Latest / Statecraft / Did the Courts Just Nuke Environmental Review?
Transcript
- 0:04SPEAKER_00: I'm Santi Ruiz, and this is Statecraft.
- 0:06SPEAKER_00: We interview top political appointees and civil servants about how they achieved a specific policy goal.
- 0:12SPEAKER_00: You can find the transcript for this conversation and many others at www.statecraft.pub.
- 0:20SPEAKER_00: Today, we're diving into everyone's favorite statecraft topic, administrative law.
- 0:24SPEAKER_00: Wait, wait.
- 0:26SPEAKER_00: Before you tune us out, give us a chance.
- 0:28SPEAKER_00: The two core cases we're discussing could have huge ramifications for how we build things in America.
- 0:32SPEAKER_00: To discuss the topic,
- 0:33SPEAKER_00: we brought together three of our favorite administrative law professors for an
- 0:37SPEAKER_00: admin law party.
- 0:38SPEAKER_00: Talking to them felt like opening the door to the faculty break room and overhearing today's gossip.
- 0:43SPEAKER_00: Do they agree on everything?
- 0:45SPEAKER_00: No, as you'll see.
- 0:46SPEAKER_00: Some brief intros.
- 0:47SPEAKER_00: Nicholas Bagley is a professor at the University of Michigan and was chief general
- 0:51SPEAKER_00: counsel to Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer.
- 0:53SPEAKER_00: Nicholas recently joined Statecraft to discuss how bureaucracy is breaking government.
- 0:58SPEAKER_00: And during that episode,
- 0:59SPEAKER_00: we discussed a law review article he wrote called The Procedure Fetish about the
- 1:03SPEAKER_00: problems with the procedures we've created for federal agencies.
- 1:06SPEAKER_00: James Coleman is a professor at the University of Minnesota, specializing in energy infrastructure.
- 1:11SPEAKER_00: He's testified before Congress on how to speed up energy infrastructure permits.
- 1:15SPEAKER_00: Finally,
- 1:16SPEAKER_00: Adam White is the executive director of the Gray Center for the Study of the
- 1:19SPEAKER_00: Administrative State at George Mason University.
- 1:22SPEAKER_00: He's practiced constitutional and regulatory law in D.C.
- 1:25SPEAKER_00: with a special focus on energy.
- 1:26SPEAKER_00: Full disclosure,
- 1:27SPEAKER_00: several years ago,
- 1:28SPEAKER_00: we were colleagues at the American Enterprise Institute,
- 1:31SPEAKER_00: or AEI for short.
- 1:33SPEAKER_00: Thank you all for joining.
- 1:34SPEAKER_00: We're going to be talking about a recent case before the DC Circuit Court of Appeals.
- 1:39SPEAKER_00: But I think the conversation will go a lot of places from there.
- 1:42SPEAKER_00: So the case is Marin Audubon Society, the FAA.
- 1:47SPEAKER_00: Before we get into the specific ruling in the case,
- 1:49SPEAKER_00: will you explain what the questions at stake were in Marin Audubon Society?
- 1:56SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and it's a question that has been perhaps implicit for a long time, maybe over 50 years.
- 2:02SPEAKER_02: So the National Environmental Policy Act is the United States' principal environmental review law.
- 2:09SPEAKER_02: It's the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 and was signed on January 1st, 1970.
- 2:14SPEAKER_02: So it's been in place for over 50 years,
- 2:17SPEAKER_02: and it just provides that the government is supposed to consider the environmental
- 2:21SPEAKER_02: consequences of any project that it permits or funds,
- 2:27SPEAKER_02: or major federal action.
- 2:28SPEAKER_02: Now, that law has developed over time to require more and more review.
- 2:34SPEAKER_02: At the time that it was passed,
- 2:36SPEAKER_02: it was supposed to be a relatively simple,
- 2:38SPEAKER_02: look before you leap kind of statute.
- 2:40SPEAKER_02: And keep in mind, it was passed in the context that the United States had undergone tremendous growth
- 2:47SPEAKER_02: after the end of World War Two and built really most of the infrastructure that we
- 2:51SPEAKER_02: still rely on to this day.
- 2:53SPEAKER_02: So if you look at the US interstates we use, most of them were built in that 25 year post war period.
- 2:59SPEAKER_02: If you look at the crude oil pipelines that we still use to this day,
- 3:03SPEAKER_02: most of them were built again,
- 3:05SPEAKER_02: they're more than 50 years old on average.
- 3:07SPEAKER_02: So most of them were built in that post war period.
- 3:10SPEAKER_02: period.
- 3:11SPEAKER_02: And all of that construction had often had impacts on sort of the local communities that went through.
- 3:16SPEAKER_02: So, you know, just an example, my grandmother grew up in a probably African American neighborhood in St.
- 3:22SPEAKER_02: Paul called the Rondo neighborhood, very famously,
- 3:25SPEAKER_02: was the bulldoze to bring Ina or through the middle of St.
- 3:29SPEAKER_02: Paul.
- 3:30SPEAKER_02: And so there was this concern that there had been an impact on local communities.
- 3:33SPEAKER_02: And to address that,
- 3:33SPEAKER_02: the idea was,
- 3:34SPEAKER_02: well,
- 3:35SPEAKER_02: we need some kind of look before we leave statute that says the federal government
- 3:38SPEAKER_02: has to consider these environmental impacts before it goes forward.
- 3:42SPEAKER_02: Now, over time, with a series of decisions in the season into the 80s,
- 3:46SPEAKER_02: the federal courts dramatically expanded what was required under the National Environmental Policy Act.
- 3:53SPEAKER_02: Environmental groups found that this was an amazing tool to potentially stop new infrastructure projects.
- 3:59SPEAKER_02: Because if the federal government had...
- 4:03SPEAKER_02: according to the courts,
- 4:04SPEAKER_02: not considered some environmental issue to the extent that the courts thought it
- 4:08SPEAKER_02: should be considered,
- 4:09SPEAKER_02: the court would issue an injunction and stop the whole project from going forward.
- 4:15SPEAKER_02: That could delay a project for years.
- 4:17SPEAKER_02: Not only would it have to wait for its initial environmental review,
- 4:22SPEAKER_02: it would then be stopped by the courts and have to wait for the federal government
- 4:26SPEAKER_02: to fix it,
- 4:26SPEAKER_02: for that to be fixed by the court.
- 4:28SPEAKER_02: So over time, it just took longer and longer.
- 4:31SPEAKER_02: And then the federal government, concerned about that time,
- 4:34SPEAKER_02: would started to take longer and longer with those reviews.
- 4:36SPEAKER_02: So they were initially done in a matter of months, but eventually took over five years on average.
- 4:41SPEAKER_00: And to clarify,
- 4:42SPEAKER_00: if I'm as a private citizen or as a nonprofit,
- 4:47SPEAKER_00: I could point to the NEPA review that your agency did.
- 4:51SPEAKER_00: And even though I'm not the owner of the land that's being built on, I'm a concerned citizen.
- 4:56SPEAKER_00: I could bring a case under NEPA.
- 4:58SPEAKER_02: There still isn't a standing requirement.
- 5:00SPEAKER_02: So that means that you have to show some kind of injury,
- 5:04SPEAKER_02: but that injury could be one,
- 5:05SPEAKER_02: two,
- 5:06SPEAKER_02: just an environmental benefit.
- 5:07SPEAKER_02: You enjoy birdwatching in these woods or otherwise.
- 5:12SPEAKER_02: So it could be, and those standing requirements are typically relaxed.
- 5:17SPEAKER_02: in the context of these kind of procedural statutes.
- 5:19SPEAKER_02: The idea is,
- 5:20SPEAKER_02: well,
- 5:21SPEAKER_02: Congress wanted everybody to be able to take advantage of asking for more
- 5:26SPEAKER_02: consideration of these issues.
- 5:27SPEAKER_02: And so the courts have been relatively generous in that context.
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: Keep in mind that even as the federal courts,
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: by which I mean mostly district courts and federal courts of appeals,
- 5:38SPEAKER_02: have been very generous in interpreting this statute to benefit people that want to
- 5:43SPEAKER_02: stop infrastructure projects,
- 5:45SPEAKER_02: The U.S.
- 5:45SPEAKER_02: Supreme Court has only taken 17 cases and it's about to tomorrow hear another case
- 5:52SPEAKER_02: on the National Environmental Policy Act.
- 5:54SPEAKER_02: But, you know, that's only about one case every three years, really less than one case every three years.
- 5:59SPEAKER_02: So there's been hundreds of national environmental policy cases every year in the lower courts.
- 6:03SPEAKER_02: that tend to interpret it very broadly,
- 6:06SPEAKER_02: whereas the Supreme Court,
- 6:07SPEAKER_02: in every decision,
- 6:08SPEAKER_02: the federal government has won.
- 6:10SPEAKER_02: So basically, the Supreme Court has said the federal government did plenty of review here.
- 6:14SPEAKER_02: And in fact,
- 6:14SPEAKER_02: in many of those decisions,
- 6:16SPEAKER_02: most of which were unanimous,
- 6:17SPEAKER_02: the Supreme Court has said,
- 6:18SPEAKER_02: lower courts,
- 6:19SPEAKER_02: knock it off,
- 6:20SPEAKER_02: stop requiring so much from the federal government.
- 6:25SPEAKER_02: We need some of these projects to go through.
- 6:27SPEAKER_02: There's been a little bit of a disconnect between the way the National
- 6:29SPEAKER_02: Environmental Policy Act is generally interpreted very broadly,
- 6:32SPEAKER_02: very aggressively in the district courts and circuit courts and the way it's been
- 6:36SPEAKER_02: interpreted by the Supreme Court,
- 6:38SPEAKER_02: which is probably more reasonable and aligns with the original intent of the law,
- 6:42SPEAKER_02: which was just to provide some environmental consideration before a project went forward.
- 6:48SPEAKER_00: What's the layman's explanation for why lower courts have been so much more
- 6:51SPEAKER_00: generous with their reading of the law than SCOTUS?
- 6:54SPEAKER_02: if you read those early decisions,
- 6:56SPEAKER_02: they're very clear that they want to implement the policy of the National
- 7:02SPEAKER_02: Environmental Policy Act,
- 7:03SPEAKER_02: which they say is designed to be protective.
- 7:05SPEAKER_02: And in fact,
- 7:06SPEAKER_02: if you go back and read that National Environmental Policy Act,
- 7:09SPEAKER_02: there's almost anti-civilization parts of it in the actual text of the act,
- 7:16SPEAKER_02: where it seems to have some concern with
- 7:18SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 7:19SPEAKER_02: human population and growth,
- 7:20SPEAKER_02: which is over time,
- 7:21SPEAKER_02: that's just in the sort of background findings of the law.
- 7:26SPEAKER_02: But the court seemed to want to very aggressively interpret that.
- 7:30SPEAKER_02: And that's partly about a disconnect that sort of opened up between the Supreme Court,
- 7:36SPEAKER_02: which was focusing on
- 7:37SPEAKER_02: During that time period,
- 7:38SPEAKER_02: more and more on ideas like textualism and limiting to what the law actually said.
- 7:44SPEAKER_02: And the lower courts,
- 7:45SPEAKER_02: which were still inspired by the Supreme Court in the 80s and 60s,
- 7:49SPEAKER_02: focusing more on the statute's purpose and trying to implement that purpose by very
- 7:54SPEAKER_02: broadly interpreting the National Environmental Policy Act.
- 7:58SPEAKER_00: Adam,
- 7:58SPEAKER_00: let me ask you to explain the Council on Environmental Quality and how that body,
- 8:04SPEAKER_00: the CEQ,
- 8:05SPEAKER_00: came up in this recent case.
- 8:08SPEAKER_03: Well, sure.
- 8:08SPEAKER_03: And I just want to commend James on his intro that I think one of the key themes
- 8:12SPEAKER_03: we'll turn to throughout this conversation is it's a very difficult balance that
- 8:16SPEAKER_03: NEPA tries to strike.
- 8:17SPEAKER_03: The NEPA's creators,
- 8:19SPEAKER_03: including one of my all-time favorite senators,
- 8:21SPEAKER_03: Scoop Jackson of Washington,
- 8:22SPEAKER_03: they tried to strike.
- 8:23SPEAKER_03: And the policymakers try to strike now.
- 8:25SPEAKER_03: I thought James's introduction was very even-handed.
- 8:28SPEAKER_03: The Council on Environmental Quality is, very broadly speaking, part of the White House.
- 8:31SPEAKER_03: I think it's actually across the street.
- 8:33SPEAKER_03: It's a nice little townhouse office in Lafayette Square in Washington, D.C.
- 8:37SPEAKER_03: But the Council on Environmental Quality has been the White House unit that's been
- 8:43SPEAKER_03: responsible for implementing NEPA for a long time.
- 8:46SPEAKER_03: I'm not actually sure when it came into existence,
- 8:49SPEAKER_03: but I've been working on these issues ever since I was an energy lawyer 20 years ago.
- 8:52SPEAKER_03: I know CEQ long predated that.
- 8:56SPEAKER_03: The crux of the case in the D.C.
- 8:57SPEAKER_03: Circuit is that CEQ's power really is not a function of statute,
- 9:01SPEAKER_03: at least not in terms of administering NEPA.
- 9:03SPEAKER_03: It really is a function of executive order in the sense that executive order gave
- 9:08SPEAKER_03: the CEQ its operative power to create binding rules.
- 9:14SPEAKER_03: One of my colleagues on the podcast pointed out, yes, it was created by NEPA itself.
- 9:18SPEAKER_03: That's true.
- 9:18SPEAKER_03: But in terms of its power to create the rules governing the implementation of
- 9:23SPEAKER_03: of NEPA by the agencies.
- 9:24SPEAKER_03: That's the product of an executive order.
- 9:28SPEAKER_03: I think it's important to put CEQ's founding in the context of its time.
- 9:33SPEAKER_03: In the mid to late 20th century,
- 9:35SPEAKER_03: right into the 1960s and 1970s,
- 9:37SPEAKER_03: you saw not just the rise of broad cross-agency environmental statutes,
- 9:42SPEAKER_03: NEPA,
- 9:43SPEAKER_03: the Clean Water Act,
- 9:44SPEAKER_03: Clean Air Act,
- 9:45SPEAKER_03: Coastal Zone Management Act.
- 9:46SPEAKER_03: You also saw a building out of the White House structure,
- 9:50SPEAKER_03: partly by the White House itself and partly by Congress.
- 9:55SPEAKER_03: You saw around the same time as a CEQ being created in 1969,
- 10:00SPEAKER_03: 1970,
- 10:00SPEAKER_03: you saw the rise of the Office of Management and Budget,
- 10:03SPEAKER_03: which had roots way back into the FDR administration,
- 10:06SPEAKER_03: but it really sort of comes into its modern form in the second half of the 20th century.
- 10:12SPEAKER_03: You saw the White House over the decades that followed building out or refining things
- 10:16SPEAKER_03: like well later,
- 10:18SPEAKER_03: the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs and things like the National
- 10:21SPEAKER_03: Security Council after World War II,
- 10:23SPEAKER_03: the National Economic Council.
- 10:25SPEAKER_03: CEQ is not quite the same as those.
- 10:27SPEAKER_03: It is, again, in its origin, a creature of statute when NEPA itself was created.
- 10:35SPEAKER_03: But you've seen its form and function change over time as more and more authority
- 10:41SPEAKER_03: was layered onto it,
- 10:42SPEAKER_03: both formally through things like executive orders,
- 10:44SPEAKER_03: but also just informally.
- 10:46SPEAKER_03: Sometimes the office holder, somebody running CEQ might have more power.
- 10:52SPEAKER_03: I remember during the Obama administrations when you had the blackouts in,
- 10:57SPEAKER_03: was it New York,
- 10:58SPEAKER_03: Brooklyn,
- 10:59SPEAKER_03: you had the sweeping blackouts.
- 11:00SPEAKER_03: Suddenly you had CEQ very much in the middle of the response to that,
- 11:05SPEAKER_03: just trying to help keep the lights on.
- 11:07SPEAKER_03: But I think above all, with the rise of
- 11:11SPEAKER_03: of climate change as a major policy subject.
- 11:14SPEAKER_03: CEQ's authority and its influence has really grown only exponentially,
- 11:20SPEAKER_03: partly because of its cross-agency power and partly because of its literal and
- 11:25SPEAKER_03: legal proximity to the presidency.
- 11:27SPEAKER_00: Will you just explain for me,
- 11:29SPEAKER_00: up until this case,
- 11:30SPEAKER_00: Marin Audubon Society,
- 11:32SPEAKER_00: which has kind of thrown CEQ's role into question,
- 11:36SPEAKER_00: up until this point,
- 11:37SPEAKER_00: what has CEQ's managerial or oversight function been of other agencies?
- 11:42SPEAKER_03: Well, I mean, formally, I'd say twofold.
- 11:45SPEAKER_03: One is the promulgation of regulations implementing NEPA in the first instance administration-wide.
- 11:52SPEAKER_03: Downstream of that,
- 11:53SPEAKER_03: NEPA has from time to time promulgated guidance or sometimes draft guidance,
- 11:58SPEAKER_03: trying to further explain and refine the application of NEPA and the NEPA regs in
- 12:03SPEAKER_03: particular contexts,
- 12:05SPEAKER_03: especially in climate.
- 12:06SPEAKER_03: And so NEPA, that's what I would consider its most important powers.
- 12:10SPEAKER_03: Although,
- 12:10SPEAKER_03: again,
- 12:10SPEAKER_03: a lot of it is the soft power of having a centralized sort of traffic cop on these
- 12:16SPEAKER_03: issues so close to the presidency.
- 12:19SPEAKER_03: That's how I think of it.
- 12:20SPEAKER_00: Can you give me an example of how I'm at work?
- 12:22SPEAKER_00: Let's say I'm an agency working on some major action in your CEQ.
- 12:28SPEAKER_00: Talk me through that dynamic.
- 12:29SPEAKER_03: Well,
- 12:30SPEAKER_03: Nick actually served in government where I just sit outside and complain,
- 12:32SPEAKER_03: but I do want it since I mentioned OIRA,
- 12:34SPEAKER_03: I want to maybe distinguish CEQ a little bit.
- 12:38SPEAKER_03: As I understand it,
- 12:40SPEAKER_03: CEQ is not as directly related in nearly as many specific concrete agency organizations.
- 12:50SPEAKER_03: actions before.
- 12:51SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 12:51SPEAKER_03: NEPA,
- 12:52SPEAKER_03: as James sort of explained earlier,
- 12:54SPEAKER_03: NEPA applies anytime an agency wants to do anything that could have a major impact,
- 12:59SPEAKER_03: a reasonably foreseeable impact on the environment,
- 13:01SPEAKER_03: or when the agency is granting or denying a permit for private infrastructure
- 13:06SPEAKER_03: projects that can have those environmental impacts.
- 13:08SPEAKER_03: So I understand that CEQ does not actually dig into every specific application the
- 13:14SPEAKER_03: way that OIRA,
- 13:15SPEAKER_03: say,
- 13:16SPEAKER_03: gets involved in or has tacit authority over so many discrete regulatory actions by
- 13:24SPEAKER_03: the agencies.
- 13:25SPEAKER_03: CEQ's role has been much more at the across-the-board lawmaking level,
- 13:30SPEAKER_03: when it is creating regulations,
- 13:33SPEAKER_03: when it's proposing guidance documents.
- 13:36SPEAKER_03: that will inform all agencies work.
- 13:39SPEAKER_03: But I don't think it gets deeply involved in discrete infrastructure issues.
- 13:44SPEAKER_03: I'm sure there's exceptions,
- 13:46SPEAKER_03: but my understanding of a CEQ is that it is more of a planning body,
- 13:51SPEAKER_03: planning the broad regulatory process and not diving into concrete permitting decisions.
- 13:57SPEAKER_03: Nick, want to kick up the ball here?
- 13:59SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean, Adam has it exactly right.
- 14:01SPEAKER_01: They're setting the rules of the road.
- 14:03SPEAKER_01: And starting in about 1977,
- 14:05SPEAKER_01: CEQ started to issue those rules of the road through what we call in administrative
- 14:12SPEAKER_01: law circles,
- 14:13SPEAKER_01: through what we call legislative rules.
- 14:15SPEAKER_01: And what that means is just that the guidance that the office issued would go
- 14:20SPEAKER_01: through notice and comment,
- 14:21SPEAKER_01: and it would be published in the Federal Register.
- 14:24SPEAKER_01: And that gave it sort of a veneer of formality.
- 14:27SPEAKER_01: These rules looked not just like, hey, this is how CEQ thinks about NEPA.
- 14:32SPEAKER_01: You know, agencies take that into account when you act.
- 14:35SPEAKER_01: Now these rules were formally binding on agencies.
- 14:38SPEAKER_01: And the big step is that courts for many years saw them as effectively binding the
- 14:44SPEAKER_01: agencies as well and as enforceable in court.
- 14:48SPEAKER_01: So CEQ regulations have grown increasingly complex over time.
- 14:53SPEAKER_01: They require, among other things, notice and comment, extensive analysis of alternatives.
- 15:00SPEAKER_01: They lay out a bunch of categorical exemptions.
- 15:02SPEAKER_01: They're also used to advance the city administration's priorities.
- 15:06SPEAKER_01: So under the Biden administration,
- 15:07SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 15:08SPEAKER_01: CEQ regulations have required agencies to take into account environmental justice
- 15:13SPEAKER_01: and indigenous knowledge.
- 15:15SPEAKER_01: And so CEQ has been blamed for...
- 15:17SPEAKER_01: for contributing to the punitive length of environmental impact statements,
- 15:21SPEAKER_01: which are now many hundreds of pages long and,
- 15:24SPEAKER_01: as James said,
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: take many years to complete.
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: Whether CEQ is in fact the primary driver of most of the sort of NEPA work that we
- 15:32SPEAKER_01: see agencies doing is contested,
- 15:35SPEAKER_01: but they certainly contributed to the burdens.
- 15:37SPEAKER_03: CEQ isn't the only agency that's making regulations under NEPA, right?
- 15:42SPEAKER_03: So say FERC, James Coleman's favorite federal agency.
- 15:45SPEAKER_03: FERC,
- 15:45SPEAKER_03: the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission,
- 15:47SPEAKER_03: the agency that's responsible for not just regulating electricity markets,
- 15:51SPEAKER_03: but more importantly for this conversation,
- 15:53SPEAKER_03: regulating interstate natural gas pipelines,
- 15:56SPEAKER_03: certain interstate electricity corridors,
- 15:59SPEAKER_03: things like that.
- 16:00SPEAKER_03: FERC has its own body of regulations.
- 16:03SPEAKER_03: implementing NEPA at an even more granular level,
- 16:07SPEAKER_03: obviously much more tailored towards FERC's substantive jurisdiction.
- 16:10SPEAKER_03: So CEQ is not the only one making these regulations.
- 16:14SPEAKER_03: The other agencies, the Army Corps of Engineers and others, have their own body of NEPA regs.
- 16:18SPEAKER_00: So any federal agency that's dealing with NEPA has its own internal regulatory
- 16:25SPEAKER_00: system that it's working through,
- 16:26SPEAKER_00: as well as this kind of theoretically binding CEQ framework.
- 16:30SPEAKER_00: Is that right?
- 16:31SPEAKER_01: I'll turn that up a ratchet.
- 16:33SPEAKER_01: If you're an executive branch agency, the CEQ regulations are not theoretically binding.
- 16:37SPEAKER_01: They are binding on you just as a matter of executive branch internal governance.
- 16:41SPEAKER_01: It's when the White House says to all of its agencies,
- 16:43SPEAKER_01: we want you to do X,
- 16:45SPEAKER_01: Y,
- 16:45SPEAKER_01: or Z.
- 16:46SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 16:46SPEAKER_01: that's a direct order from the president.
- 16:49SPEAKER_01: And if you serve at the pleasure of the president, you follow through on that.
- 16:52SPEAKER_01: And that's true whether or not these CEQ regulations are legislative rules that apply in the courts.
- 16:59SPEAKER_01: And this is an important distinction.
- 17:00SPEAKER_00: Explain that for us,
- 17:01SPEAKER_00: because I think most of us listeners who are not lawyers will be very confused by
- 17:05SPEAKER_00: that particular sentence.
- 17:06SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 17:07SPEAKER_01: So this is this is one of the things you have to really try to wrap your head around.
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: So one of the reasons that NEPA has become so fearsome is because it is enforceable in the courts.
- 17:15SPEAKER_01: So what happens usually is that some kind of environmental group,
- 17:19SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 17:20SPEAKER_01: will sue an agency that's trying to get a development off the ground.
- 17:24SPEAKER_01: And they will say that the agency has failed to consider an alternative that would
- 17:27SPEAKER_01: have mitigated the environmental consequences or that the agency has failed to
- 17:32SPEAKER_01: examine one of those alternatives deeply enough
- 17:35SPEAKER_01: And if a court agrees that the agency has failed to take into account an important
- 17:41SPEAKER_01: aspect of the problem,
- 17:42SPEAKER_01: the court will blow up the agency action and send the agency back to the drawing board.
- 17:47SPEAKER_01: And that can be immensely disruptive to what an agency wants to do.
- 17:52SPEAKER_01: And so in response to that,
- 17:54SPEAKER_01: agencies spend a lot of time trying to kind of cover their butts,
- 17:57SPEAKER_01: trying to make sure that they can withstand eventual court review.
- 18:01SPEAKER_01: So the issue that we're sort of talking about in connection with this Marin County
- 18:05SPEAKER_01: case that kind of brought us together today is whether the CEQ regulations are
- 18:10SPEAKER_01: binding in court.
- 18:11SPEAKER_01: And what I mean by that is that when environmental groups bring these lawsuits,
- 18:15SPEAKER_01: one of the things that they sometimes do is say,
- 18:17SPEAKER_01: look,
- 18:18SPEAKER_01: the agency
- 18:19SPEAKER_01: failed to abide by the CEQ regulations.
- 18:22SPEAKER_01: They didn't adhere to what they require.
- 18:24SPEAKER_01: And that is part of the reason we think that their action should be stopped.
- 18:29SPEAKER_01: Because those CEQ regulations are on the books and because they look pretty formal,
- 18:34SPEAKER_01: courts have,
- 18:34SPEAKER_01: over the past 45 years or so,
- 18:37SPEAKER_01: looked at those and said,
- 18:38SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 18:38SPEAKER_01: we can enforce those CEQ regulations.
- 18:40SPEAKER_01: They're regulations after all.
- 18:42SPEAKER_01: And the issue in the Marin County case is,
- 18:46SPEAKER_01: Is that an appropriate rule for the courts?
- 18:48SPEAKER_01: Is it appropriate for the courts to enforce the CEQ rules?
- 18:51SPEAKER_01: But that's an entirely separate question from whether agencies must follow the CEQ
- 18:58SPEAKER_01: regulations as a matter of what the executive branch says they have to do.
- 19:03SPEAKER_01: So when the president gives you an order, you have to follow that order.
- 19:06SPEAKER_01: And that's true whether or not the courts are going to enforce it.
- 19:10SPEAKER_01: So you want to keep distinct those two things.
- 19:12SPEAKER_01: One, a set of CEQ regulations
- 19:14SPEAKER_01: That no matter what are going to bind the agencies as a matter of internal
- 19:17SPEAKER_01: executive branch governance and CEQ regulations that would be enforceable by the
- 19:23SPEAKER_01: courts if agencies fail to live up to them.
- 19:26SPEAKER_00: Fantastic context.
- 19:27SPEAKER_00: Let's go back to the Marin Audubon Society case.
- 19:30SPEAKER_00: What happened here?
- 19:31SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 19:32SPEAKER_01: So the case involves what we call air tour management plans.
- 19:36SPEAKER_01: So basically,
- 19:38SPEAKER_01: if you have like a national park,
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 19:41SPEAKER_01: you want to make sure that you're setting the appropriate rules for flights that go
- 19:46SPEAKER_01: over the park,
- 19:46SPEAKER_01: whether that's tours to kind of see parts of the park you otherwise couldn't see,
- 19:50SPEAKER_01: whether it's by airplane or by helicopter.
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: And obviously those sorts of tours have a lot of noise implications and they have pollution implications.
- 19:56SPEAKER_01: And so you don't want too many of them and you want to make sure that whenever they're
- 20:00SPEAKER_01: Going over the park,
- 20:01SPEAKER_01: they're abiding by certain rules to protect sensitive wildlife,
- 20:04SPEAKER_01: sensitive environmental areas.
- 20:06SPEAKER_01: So the particular air tour management plan in question here involves four national
- 20:11SPEAKER_01: park areas out in the West Coast in a kind of San Francisco area.
- 20:16SPEAKER_01: And this particular management plan authorized about 2,500 commercial airline and
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: helicopter flights to pass over four national park areas.
- 20:26SPEAKER_01: And when the agency, the Federal Aviation Administration developed the air tour management plan, it said,
- 20:34SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 20:34SPEAKER_01: we understand that NEPA is on the books,
- 20:36SPEAKER_01: but we actually don't need to do an environmental impact statement to consider the
- 20:41SPEAKER_01: effects of these flights.
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: Why?
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: because there's a CEQ regulation that says that any changes or amendments to an
- 20:49SPEAKER_01: existing sort of state of affairs...
- 20:52SPEAKER_01: doesn't need to go through NEPA if it only has minimal environmental impacts.
- 20:57SPEAKER_01: And so anything that has no or minimal environmental impacts,
- 21:00SPEAKER_01: CEQ regulations say agencies don't need to consider that through the whole NEPA process.
- 21:06SPEAKER_01: So a bunch of environmentalists out West sued the FAA and said,
- 21:10SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 21:11SPEAKER_01: you can't just ignore your NEPA obligations by saying,
- 21:14SPEAKER_01: well,
- 21:15SPEAKER_01: currently you've got 2,500 flights going through those areas.
- 21:18SPEAKER_01: We're not making any changes.
- 21:19SPEAKER_01: Therefore, we don't need to do an environmental impact statement.
- 21:21SPEAKER_01: They said the right baseline is sort of thinking about the question from scratch.
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: Like, what's the consequence of allowing any flights to go through those areas?
- 21:29SPEAKER_01: And how do you think about that problem?
- 21:31SPEAKER_01: And so they sued saying,
- 21:33SPEAKER_01: we don't think it was appropriate for you to use that categorical exemption to
- 21:37SPEAKER_01: avoid your NEPA obligations here.
- 21:40SPEAKER_00: And the courts rather than the DC circuit court,
- 21:43SPEAKER_00: rather than the ruling on that kind of narrow question,
- 21:46SPEAKER_00: James,
- 21:46SPEAKER_00: they,
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: as I understand it,
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: they ended up saying something very different.
- 21:50SPEAKER_00: They kind of dodged that small question and answered a much bigger question.
- 21:54SPEAKER_02: That's right.
- 21:54SPEAKER_02: And this is the question that I said has been implicit for almost 50 years,
- 21:58SPEAKER_02: which is CEQ issued these regulations in 1978,
- 22:03SPEAKER_02: and they have often been treated as binding regulations by the court.
- 22:07SPEAKER_02: So if you go back and look at all those aggressive court decisions that said,
- 22:13SPEAKER_02: now the agencies have to consider this factor,
- 22:15SPEAKER_02: now they have to consider that factor,
- 22:17SPEAKER_02: now they have to consider this other factor,
- 22:19SPEAKER_02: often they cited CEQ regulations because
- 22:22SPEAKER_02: For example,
- 22:23SPEAKER_02: some of the most prominent CEQ regulations say not only do you have to consider the
- 22:30SPEAKER_02: impacts of this federally approved or funded project,
- 22:34SPEAKER_02: but you also have to consider the indirect impacts and the cumulative impacts
- 22:40SPEAKER_02: of that project.
- 22:41SPEAKER_02: So typically,
- 22:42SPEAKER_02: CEQ regulations and all the decisions that have been based on them often cite these
- 22:46SPEAKER_02: three kinds of impacts.
- 22:47SPEAKER_02: Direct impacts,
- 22:48SPEAKER_02: which you might think about,
- 22:49SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 22:49SPEAKER_02: it's basically you're bulldozing a neighborhood for a highway product.
- 22:52SPEAKER_02: That's a very direct impact.
- 22:54SPEAKER_02: And then you have those indirect impacts and cumulative impacts.
- 22:58SPEAKER_02: Now, those indirect impacts are less well-defined.
- 23:01SPEAKER_02: Presumably, it means something beyond the actual fact
- 23:06SPEAKER_02: project or the part that is approved.
- 23:08SPEAKER_02: So maybe if you're just approving a power line to cross a specific stream,
- 23:13SPEAKER_02: maybe the indirect impact is the rest of the power line that's going to be enabled
- 23:18SPEAKER_02: by this project.
- 23:19SPEAKER_02: Or it could extend to all the new wind turbines that are going to be built as a result of this project.
- 23:26SPEAKER_02: Or it could extend to all of the industrial activity that's enabled
- 23:30SPEAKER_02: Well, the electricity produced by those wind turbines really could go to any kind of extent.
- 23:37SPEAKER_02: And then maybe this isn't the only power line that's being built.
- 23:40SPEAKER_02: And maybe we don't have some big decision to approve all of those projects that we
- 23:44SPEAKER_02: have an environmental impact statement for.
- 23:45SPEAKER_02: So maybe in this one environmental impact statement for a single water crossing,
- 23:49SPEAKER_02: we should consider all of the power lines that will ever be built over the next 10
- 23:54SPEAKER_02: years in the state and all of the wind turbines that will enable over multiple
- 23:57SPEAKER_02: states and all the power use that will enable.
- 24:00SPEAKER_02: And that's why you have thousand page NIPA review documents.
- 24:03SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
- 24:04SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
- 24:05SPEAKER_02: Those decisions are all based on these terms that CEQ just came up with in 1978.
- 24:10SPEAKER_02: And it's interesting,
- 24:11SPEAKER_02: often in the legal realm,
- 24:13SPEAKER_02: we think about what impacts are caused by some other thing.
- 24:17SPEAKER_02: And there's standards in tort law about proximate cause,
- 24:20SPEAKER_02: et cetera,
- 24:21SPEAKER_02: that if you took first year of law school,
- 24:23SPEAKER_02: you'd learn about.
- 24:24SPEAKER_02: But CEQ just came up with an entirely separate
- 24:27SPEAKER_02: series of sort of causal analysis and there are decades of analysis of that and
- 24:32SPEAKER_02: what the court here said is hold on why are we following the cq regulations as
- 24:40SPEAKER_02: binding because cq has never was never given authority to issue binding regulations
- 24:47SPEAKER_02: that would be binding in court you know and you know to nick's point
- 24:52SPEAKER_02: may well have the ability,
- 24:53SPEAKER_02: and they did issue guidelines,
- 24:54SPEAKER_02: and that's probably unproblematic to say,
- 24:56SPEAKER_02: hey,
- 24:57SPEAKER_02: agencies,
- 24:57SPEAKER_02: this is how we want you to do things.
- 24:59SPEAKER_02: Ultimately, the president doesn't like how agencies are doing their verbal reviews.
- 25:05SPEAKER_02: He can fire the head of the agency.
- 25:07SPEAKER_02: But in terms of binding in court, the courts have been treating this as binding for almost 50 years.
- 25:11SPEAKER_02: And the court here, this decision said, no, they're not binding.
- 25:18SPEAKER_02: They never had the authority to issue those regulations.
- 25:20SPEAKER_02: And since the time that those regulations were issued,
- 25:22SPEAKER_02: the courts have become more clear about when agencies have the authority to issue regulations.
- 25:30SPEAKER_02: Often it's got to be in the statute that created them.
- 25:33SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 25:33SPEAKER_02: I think over time people have realized,
- 25:35SPEAKER_02: wait a second,
- 25:36SPEAKER_02: it never was clear that CEQ had this authority.
- 25:39SPEAKER_02: And so it's become more and more of an anomaly that we continued arguing about
- 25:43SPEAKER_02: these regulations when it wasn't clear that CEQ had the authority.
- 25:46SPEAKER_02: So, you know, perhaps it's interesting.
- 25:48SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 25:48SPEAKER_02: basically,
- 25:49SPEAKER_02: I filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court case that's going to be heard tomorrow
- 25:53SPEAKER_02: that argues that
- 25:55SPEAKER_02: The Supreme Court should recognize that CEQ never had the authority to issue these regulations.
- 26:00SPEAKER_02: Now, that was was written in file before this decision came out from the D.C.
- 26:05SPEAKER_02: Circuit.
- 26:05SPEAKER_02: So we knew this issue was out there.
- 26:07SPEAKER_02: Some of us were hoping the courts might address it.
- 26:09SPEAKER_02: But the D.C.
- 26:10SPEAKER_02: Circuit is a sort of a bit of a surprise to all of us kind of address it because
- 26:14SPEAKER_02: neither of the parties to the case asked to address this issue.
- 26:17SPEAKER_02: But the D.C.
- 26:19SPEAKER_02: Circuit just said,
- 26:19SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 26:20SPEAKER_02: why are we continuing to apply these regulations if CEQ never had that authority?
- 26:25SPEAKER_00: So,
- 26:25SPEAKER_00: James,
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: this legal philosophical matter that CEQ didn't have the authority to issue binding regulation,
- 26:33SPEAKER_00: you filed an unique brief.
- 26:35SPEAKER_00: What was the context here?
- 26:36SPEAKER_02: Yeah, no, I think a lot of people had thought about it.
- 26:38SPEAKER_02: And the courts have said before,
- 26:40SPEAKER_02: wait a second,
- 26:41SPEAKER_02: well,
- 26:41SPEAKER_02: we'll just keep applying this because the parties say we should apply it.
- 26:44SPEAKER_02: Now, one thing you I mean, one thing you find if you spend a fair amount of time
- 26:49SPEAKER_02: outside of dc and then in dc appellate practice in dc appellate practice it's surprising how often
- 26:57SPEAKER_02: both sides will want to continue applying whatever roles have been applying for the
- 27:02SPEAKER_02: last decades that they both know how to apply,
- 27:04SPEAKER_02: that they are used to,
- 27:06SPEAKER_02: they say,
- 27:07SPEAKER_02: well,
- 27:07SPEAKER_02: maybe you don't like these,
- 27:08SPEAKER_02: but you know what,
- 27:09SPEAKER_02: we can argue our case for this.
- 27:11SPEAKER_02: And so,
- 27:11SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 27:12SPEAKER_02: often actually as a litigant,
- 27:13SPEAKER_02: it can be a little bit hard to get your DC lawyer to say,
- 27:17SPEAKER_02: wait a second,
- 27:18SPEAKER_02: I don't think any of this is valid.
- 27:20SPEAKER_02: And to note in this case,
- 27:22SPEAKER_02: They did, the litigants didn't ask for this anyway, but so this doesn't get raised.
- 27:27SPEAKER_02: The reason why this doesn't get raised by any party,
- 27:29SPEAKER_02: I think has a little bit to do with,
- 27:31SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 27:32SPEAKER_02: DC sort of liking to continue following the regulations that DC does.
- 27:36SPEAKER_02: And I apologize this if it's a, if it, you know, if it's a tangent, if you've ever read Anna Karenina,
- 27:42SPEAKER_02: where Levin,
- 27:43SPEAKER_02: the main characters,
- 27:44SPEAKER_02: is trying to get the agricultural workers to try a different way of doing something
- 27:49SPEAKER_02: because it's way more efficient,
- 27:51SPEAKER_02: and they won't.
- 27:51SPEAKER_02: And the same thing is true with professors.
- 27:53SPEAKER_02: If you try to get professors to teach a class the new way that they haven't taught
- 27:55SPEAKER_02: for years,
- 27:56SPEAKER_02: they will not do it.
- 27:57SPEAKER_02: So there's an inherent human conservatism that says,
- 28:02SPEAKER_02: you know what,
- 28:02SPEAKER_02: we've been doing it this way for years,
- 28:04SPEAKER_02: let's not mess with it.
- 28:06SPEAKER_02: And I think that's partially responsible
- 28:08SPEAKER_02: for why those CEQ regulations continue to be applied even after people started to
- 28:15SPEAKER_02: recognize maybe they weren't valid.
- 28:16SPEAKER_00: Adam and Nick, you're both laughing a lot.
- 28:18SPEAKER_00: I want to hear from both of you.
- 28:20SPEAKER_03: You might want to edit this part out in post-production.
- 28:22SPEAKER_03: This might get too far into the trivia,
- 28:23SPEAKER_03: but Judge Randolph,
- 28:24SPEAKER_03: who wrote the DC Circuit decision blowing this whole thing up,
- 28:28SPEAKER_03: he has a very long memory.
- 28:29SPEAKER_03: As the DC Circuit case says, this all started with an executive order from President Carter in 1977.
- 28:36SPEAKER_03: After a Supreme Court case the year before,
- 28:38SPEAKER_03: when the Justice Department basically told the Supreme Court,
- 28:41SPEAKER_03: CEQ does not have,
- 28:43SPEAKER_03: it only proposes guidelines,
- 28:45SPEAKER_03: it doesn't have rulemaking authority.
- 28:47SPEAKER_03: Judge Randolph would remember that because he was in the Solicitor General's office
- 28:51SPEAKER_03: when that case was argued.
- 28:52SPEAKER_03: More specifically,
- 28:53SPEAKER_03: Judge Randolph was the Deputy Solicitor General who argued that case and told the
- 28:58SPEAKER_03: Supreme Court in 1976,
- 29:00SPEAKER_03: no,
- 29:00SPEAKER_03: we don't have,
- 29:01SPEAKER_03: CEQ does not,
- 29:02SPEAKER_03: it only does guidelines,
- 29:03SPEAKER_03: it doesn't do rules.
- 29:04SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 29:04SPEAKER_00: So far from being a new point, this is an issue that was raised at the inception of CEQ.
- 29:12SPEAKER_01: That Randolph has cared about for a long time.
- 29:14SPEAKER_00: He's cared about for 50 years.
- 29:16SPEAKER_01: He's been trying to get this issue presented squarely.
- 29:19SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 29:19SPEAKER_01: one of the things that's super anomalous about this Marin County case is how the
- 29:23SPEAKER_01: judge reached out to decide this issue,
- 29:26SPEAKER_01: even though no party had presented it,
- 29:28SPEAKER_01: and even though it wasn't necessarily resolving the case.
- 29:31SPEAKER_01: So,
- 29:31SPEAKER_01: Santi,
- 29:31SPEAKER_01: you said earlier that the court avoided the narrow question about the proper
- 29:35SPEAKER_01: baseline against which to measure the environmental impact statement.
- 29:38SPEAKER_01: It actually didn't avoid that issue.
- 29:39SPEAKER_01: It went on to say, hey, FAA, you picked the wrong baseline.
- 29:43SPEAKER_01: You can't use the existing flights as your baseline and then decide there were no effects from that.
- 29:47SPEAKER_01: a similar plan.
- 29:48SPEAKER_01: You've got to use a baseline of zero and sort of think from there.
- 29:51SPEAKER_01: So they could have just decided the case on that basis.
- 29:53SPEAKER_01: And instead,
- 29:54SPEAKER_01: Judge Randolph,
- 29:55SPEAKER_01: joined by Judge Henderson on this,
- 29:57SPEAKER_01: reached out to decide this issue that has been irritating him for a very long time.
- 30:02SPEAKER_01: What that has done is create a vulnerability for the decision.
- 30:06SPEAKER_01: So Chief Judge Srinivasan dissented on this point, said, look, no party is raised to this.
- 30:10SPEAKER_01: There's no particular reason for us to wait in here.
- 30:12SPEAKER_01: It's total dicta, which means it's like legal talk for unnecessary to the outcome of the case.
- 30:18SPEAKER_01: And now we've got two en banc petitions.
- 30:20SPEAKER_01: An en banc petition is what happens when the parties are upset about a panel decision at a circuit court.
- 30:27SPEAKER_01: The party can go to that circuit court and say,
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: the three judges who decided our case were out to lunch.
- 30:32SPEAKER_01: We think if the whole court heard this case, you'd side with us.
- 30:35SPEAKER_01: It's a really important issue.
- 30:36SPEAKER_01: So please, whole court, all the members of the court, rehear this case.
- 30:41SPEAKER_01: And both the environmental petitioners and the FAA both have gone to the D.C.
- 30:45SPEAKER_01: Circuit and said,
- 30:46SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 30:46SPEAKER_01: you know that part of Judge Randolph's opinion where he was just talking about
- 30:50SPEAKER_01: things that really bother him,
- 30:51SPEAKER_01: where nobody raised the issue?
- 30:53SPEAKER_01: Could you just
- 30:54SPEAKER_01: eliminate that part of the decision because neither of us likes it very much.
- 30:58SPEAKER_01: And I think the DC circuit's reasonably likely to take up that invitation,
- 31:01SPEAKER_01: given just how hard Judge Randolph had to work to get this issue into focus in this case.
- 31:08SPEAKER_03: Now,
- 31:08SPEAKER_03: since I brought that up,
- 31:09SPEAKER_03: let me say a word in defense of Judge Randolph now,
- 31:11SPEAKER_03: because I actually don't see it quite as negatively as Nick does.
- 31:16SPEAKER_03: I do agree neither party raised this issue.
- 31:19SPEAKER_03: say the least.
- 31:20SPEAKER_03: And as the D.C.
- 31:20SPEAKER_03: Circuit points out,
- 31:21SPEAKER_03: neither party would want this issue raised,
- 31:24SPEAKER_03: neither the environmentalists nor the federal agency.
- 31:28SPEAKER_03: But the courts are there to decide cases under law.
- 31:31SPEAKER_03: And while, and I clerked on the D.C.
- 31:32SPEAKER_03: Circuit for another good judge there,
- 31:35SPEAKER_03: they do have a long history of being very careful about sticking to the arguments
- 31:39SPEAKER_03: raised by the parties.
- 31:41SPEAKER_03: This really is a strange situation where the
- 31:45SPEAKER_03: It's not clear at all whether the agency or the parties have real law to apply here.
- 31:52SPEAKER_03: If there is an actual law there, then the court doesn't really have much to decide its case on.
- 31:57SPEAKER_03: Now, it's further complicated by the fact that the Supreme Court over the years has said in passing
- 32:02SPEAKER_03: arguably in dicta, so in a way non-binding.
- 32:06SPEAKER_03: But it's sort of said in passing that the CEQ does have binding rulemaking authority.
- 32:12SPEAKER_03: And normally the DC Circuit considers itself bound even by the dicta of the Supreme Court.
- 32:17SPEAKER_03: So this really is a mess.
- 32:20SPEAKER_03: I don't think it's entirely a mess of Judge Randolph's own making.
- 32:23SPEAKER_03: There's a lot,
- 32:24SPEAKER_03: as we've said,
- 32:24SPEAKER_03: there's a lot of history here where nobody really poked this particular regulatory bear.
- 32:30SPEAKER_03: The other part of this.
- 32:31SPEAKER_01: Adam,
- 32:31SPEAKER_01: let me interrupt you and just say,
- 32:33SPEAKER_01: I think all three of us on this call,
- 32:34SPEAKER_01: and you can correct me if I'm wrong about this,
- 32:37SPEAKER_01: on the merits,
- 32:38SPEAKER_01: I think Judge Randolph is right.
- 32:39SPEAKER_01: I don't think CEQ has rulemaking authority,
- 32:42SPEAKER_01: and I think the courts have erred in applying CEQ rules in the past.
- 32:47SPEAKER_01: I don't even think the question is that close.
- 32:48SPEAKER_01: I know that that's a controversial opinion amongst environmental lawyers and the like,
- 32:52SPEAKER_01: but I think James's amicus brief is just correct.
- 32:56SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 32:56SPEAKER_02: And the dissent doesn't even disagree.
- 32:58SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 32:58SPEAKER_02: It just it just says, well, this issue was raised.
- 33:01SPEAKER_02: And so and I do think I mean,
- 33:02SPEAKER_02: you can understand you could definitely understand why judges potentially don't
- 33:06SPEAKER_02: like the idea that they continue to apply.
- 33:07SPEAKER_02: They are just I'll keep applying this invalid law because we both asked for it.
- 33:12SPEAKER_02: But that it's a very it's a very unsatisfying sort of argument.
- 33:16SPEAKER_00: Okay, so that's this Marin Audubon Society case.
- 33:20SPEAKER_00: We're recording on Monday, December 9th.
- 33:22SPEAKER_00: On Tuesday the 10th,
- 33:24SPEAKER_00: tomorrow morning,
- 33:25SPEAKER_00: the Supreme Court is taking up oral arguments for a case that has similar NEPA ramifications.
- 33:30SPEAKER_00: What's the relationship between that case and this case?
- 33:34SPEAKER_02: So there's an issue in both the Marin Audubon Society case at the D.C.
- 33:39SPEAKER_02: Circuit and the Seven County Infrastructure case at the Supreme Court,
- 33:43SPEAKER_02: which is,
- 33:44SPEAKER_02: are these regulations valid?
- 33:46SPEAKER_02: And Nick,
- 33:48SPEAKER_02: I believe,
- 33:48SPEAKER_02: has expressed the concern that we should want to keep these regulations,
- 33:53SPEAKER_02: even if they may be invalid,
- 33:55SPEAKER_02: because they help order the environmental review process as lengthy as it is.
- 34:00SPEAKER_02: I've argued in this Supreme Court brief that instead these regulations are invalid
- 34:05SPEAKER_02: and that will help speed up the environmental review process.
- 34:08SPEAKER_02: I think it might be worth getting a little bit of back and forth on that issue.
- 34:12SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 34:13SPEAKER_01: So,
- 34:13SPEAKER_01: James,
- 34:13SPEAKER_01: I think my position is a little bit different than that,
- 34:15SPEAKER_01: which is even if you agree with Judge Randolph here and say the CEQ regulations are
- 34:20SPEAKER_01: non-binding in court,
- 34:22SPEAKER_01: they're still going to be binding on the agencies.
- 34:25SPEAKER_01: And whether that's good or bad, it just has nothing to do with this case.
- 34:29SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 34:29SPEAKER_01: the only question at issue in this case is whether the CEQ regulations ought to be
- 34:34SPEAKER_01: enforced in court.
- 34:35SPEAKER_01: On that, I think the answer is no.
- 34:37SPEAKER_01: But I do think that is not obviously a benefit for streamlining CEQ NEPA review.
- 34:44SPEAKER_01: It may be.
- 34:45SPEAKER_01: It may not be.
- 34:45SPEAKER_01: And the reason I say that is because
- 34:48SPEAKER_01: First, agencies are already going to have to abide by the CEQ regulations.
- 34:52SPEAKER_01: So they're going to have to walk through that lengthy process regardless of whether
- 34:56SPEAKER_01: it's judicially enforceable or not.
- 34:58SPEAKER_01: Second, the CEQ process, as you say, does help structure how agencies move through that NEPA process.
- 35:05SPEAKER_01: And a lot of the NEPA-specific rules that are on the books explicitly say things like, hey,
- 35:11SPEAKER_01: We're building off of CEQ regulations.
- 35:13SPEAKER_01: So if you look at the Army Corps' NEPA regulations,
- 35:16SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 35:16SPEAKER_01: they say,
- 35:17SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 35:17SPEAKER_01: this is all just sort of a riff on what CEQ has already said.
- 35:21SPEAKER_01: So the question is only about judicial enforceability.
- 35:25SPEAKER_01: On that front,
- 35:26SPEAKER_01: whether or not we apply the CEQ regulations,
- 35:29SPEAKER_01: I'm just not sure it's going to have that big of an effect on agency practice.
- 35:33SPEAKER_01: So agencies already are worried about the possibility of getting held up in court
- 35:37SPEAKER_01: because they failed to consider a particular part of the problem.
- 35:41SPEAKER_01: And you can recast all of those arguments either in terms of you failed to abide by
- 35:45SPEAKER_01: CEQ regulations or just in terms of you failed to consider an important aspect of
- 35:50SPEAKER_01: the problem under NEPA.
- 35:52SPEAKER_01: And either way, courts have proved receptive in the past to those arguments.
- 35:56SPEAKER_01: So if you're a risk averse agency,
- 35:58SPEAKER_01: you're still going to spend a lot of time chasing down every alternative because
- 36:01SPEAKER_01: you're not sure what some random judge is going to decide was an issue that you
- 36:05SPEAKER_01: needed to have considered that you failed to consider.
- 36:07SPEAKER_01: I'm not sure it changes the incentives for agencies on the ground.
- 36:12SPEAKER_03: Well, wait a second, Nick.
- 36:12SPEAKER_03: Are you talking about just cases where an agency is facing a litigation risk
- 36:18SPEAKER_03: from environmentalists or property owners who are wary of a project?
- 36:22SPEAKER_03: Or are you also talking about cases where the project proponent itself might be
- 36:27SPEAKER_03: looking to sue,
- 36:29SPEAKER_03: say the highway or a power line or a pipeline doesn't get built.
- 36:33SPEAKER_03: The project itself sues saying, no, you went beyond what you were allowed to do underneath.
- 36:38SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 36:39SPEAKER_03: I think so far we're really been thinking in terms of third parties challenging projects
- 36:45SPEAKER_03: But are you saying the same basic agency calculus would hold just in the
- 36:49SPEAKER_03: relationship between the agency and the project proponent?
- 36:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 36:53SPEAKER_01: I mean, most of these cases aren't brought by the project proponents.
- 36:56SPEAKER_01: They're brought by opponents.
- 36:57SPEAKER_01: So I'm not sure how I'd think through the proponent question.
- 37:01SPEAKER_01: But I think when you're considering the incentives of an agency when it's thinking
- 37:05SPEAKER_01: about a project,
- 37:07SPEAKER_01: what it's trying to do is make sure it doesn't get held up in court.
- 37:10SPEAKER_01: One of the ways you can try to avoid that is by abiding strictly to CEQ regulations.
- 37:14SPEAKER_01: Another is by making sure to address every concern that the parties present to you.
- 37:19SPEAKER_01: So let's say you have an environmental petitioner who,
- 37:21SPEAKER_01: during your environmental impact statement process,
- 37:24SPEAKER_01: raises a possible alternative that you should consider.
- 37:28SPEAKER_01: That's a comment, much like parties comment on agency rules all the time.
- 37:33SPEAKER_01: And if the agency fails to respond thoughtfully to that comment,
- 37:37SPEAKER_01: that could create a vulnerability for the project,
- 37:40SPEAKER_01: much in the same way that failing to respond to a comment in a rulemaking can
- 37:44SPEAKER_01: create a vulnerability for a rule.
- 37:46SPEAKER_01: And so saying that CEQ regulations are no longer enforceable in court
- 37:51SPEAKER_01: I'm not sure that really changes your risk-averse analysis if you're an agency
- 37:55SPEAKER_01: who's thinking through how to respond to input that it gets from environmental
- 38:00SPEAKER_01: groups about what it ought to consider.
- 38:01SPEAKER_02: Okay, so I think this is exactly where maybe there is some disagreement.
- 38:06SPEAKER_02: I agree with Nick that it's possible that
- 38:12SPEAKER_02: striking down these CEQ regulations, at least for purposes of court, might not do very much.
- 38:17SPEAKER_02: And it might not do very much for a couple of reasons.
- 38:19SPEAKER_02: One is if the president continues to insist that the agencies follow those regulations,
- 38:28SPEAKER_02: then ultimately the reviews are going to be very similar.
- 38:32SPEAKER_02: Also,
- 38:33SPEAKER_02: if the courts continue to follow all the same decisions requiring more and more
- 38:38SPEAKER_02: environmental review,
- 38:39SPEAKER_02: and they just say,
- 38:40SPEAKER_02: although we said that we were doing that under these CEQ regulations,
- 38:45SPEAKER_02: which are no longer valid,
- 38:47SPEAKER_02: we were actually applying the statute,
- 38:49SPEAKER_02: which of course continues to apply.
- 38:51SPEAKER_02: And so therefore,
- 38:53SPEAKER_02: we're going to require all the same,
- 38:55SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 38:55SPEAKER_02: jump through all the same groups to approve a project.
- 38:58SPEAKER_02: If those two things happen,
- 39:00SPEAKER_02: then striking down the CEQ regulations doesn't do much except for maybe make it a
- 39:03SPEAKER_02: little bit more difficult to figure out how to argue in court,
- 39:07SPEAKER_02: right?
- 39:07SPEAKER_02: With that said,
- 39:08SPEAKER_02: I do think it sort of presents that opportunity,
- 39:11SPEAKER_02: that,
- 39:12SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 39:12SPEAKER_02: that etch-a-sketch opportunity to potentially change things.
- 39:16SPEAKER_02: And in fact, our environmental reviews have gotten so long and there's increasing bipartisan
- 39:21SPEAKER_02: recognition that they have gotten too long,
- 39:24SPEAKER_02: then I think there might be some momentum to use this opportunity to speed up the
- 39:28SPEAKER_02: environmental reviews.
- 39:29SPEAKER_02: And I could take two forms.
- 39:30SPEAKER_02: One is the president could not require so much of the agency.
- 39:36SPEAKER_02: And we've had a lot of back and forth about what things should be required under
- 39:40SPEAKER_02: the CEQ regulations going back and forth between the Trump administration and the
- 39:44SPEAKER_02: Biden administration with the Trump administration requiring less.
- 39:46SPEAKER_02: Biden administration requiring more,
- 39:49SPEAKER_02: and then the Congress asking for some changes to the CEQ regulations.
- 39:54SPEAKER_02: And so we might see, so we might, you know, I think we'll continue to see that.
- 39:59SPEAKER_02: I anticipate that the new administration with its focus on building new infrastructure in the U.S.
- 40:04SPEAKER_02: will likely not impose similar requirements that would have been required under the CEQ regulations.
- 40:11SPEAKER_02: which, you know, at least currently are struck down, might in theory be addressed by the Supreme Court.
- 40:16SPEAKER_02: Who knows what's going to happen with Anbonk's petition.
- 40:17SPEAKER_02: So there's a lot of uncertainty for what kind of COQ regulations we're going to have going forward.
- 40:21SPEAKER_02: Secondly, I think, you know, the reality is over time, we're getting new judges on the courts.
- 40:28SPEAKER_02: And even if
- 40:30SPEAKER_02: the judges from 10 years ago might still want to apply the same cases that they've
- 40:36SPEAKER_02: been applying for decades and say,
- 40:38SPEAKER_02: well,
- 40:38SPEAKER_02: although the CEQ regulations are struck down,
- 40:41SPEAKER_02: we're gonna continue to apply that as a matter of the statute of the National
- 40:44SPEAKER_02: Environmental Policy Act.
- 40:46SPEAKER_02: It gives judges an opportunity to say,
- 40:48SPEAKER_02: wait a second,
- 40:49SPEAKER_02: this old case was based on CEQ regulations that were no longer supposed to apply.
- 40:54SPEAKER_02: I'm going to address this as a matter of first impression.
- 40:59SPEAKER_02: And so basically it gives circuit courts like the DC Circuit the opportunity to
- 41:05SPEAKER_02: basically make their jurisprudence on the National Environmental Policy Act more
- 41:09SPEAKER_02: aligned with the Supreme Court jurisprudence
- 41:11SPEAKER_02: which has been much more forgiving of basically shorter,
- 41:15SPEAKER_02: less and less formal reviews than we've seen from the circuit course.
- 41:19SPEAKER_02: So that's the reason that I'm optimistic that it creates an opportunity for change,
- 41:22SPEAKER_02: but I do agree with Nick that it doesn't necessarily mean that we will see faster reviews.
- 41:29SPEAKER_01: James, you and I are on pretty much the same page.
- 41:32SPEAKER_01: I'm a little more skeptical,
- 41:33SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 41:34SPEAKER_01: that the effects of the decision by itself will prompt enough reconsideration in
- 41:38SPEAKER_01: the courts or enough uniform reconsideration in the courts.
- 41:41SPEAKER_01: So as to adjust agency incentives,
- 41:43SPEAKER_01: right,
- 41:44SPEAKER_01: agencies are still going to be afraid that maybe those judges that you talk about
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: who are newer,
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: who might be less inclined to apply NEPA to the hilt,
- 41:52SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 41:53SPEAKER_01: would be receptive to a thinner EIS, they're just not going to know.
- 41:56SPEAKER_01: The broader point that this decision provides an etch-a-sketch moment,
- 41:59SPEAKER_01: a chance for everybody to take a deep breath,
- 42:01SPEAKER_01: look at what we've been doing and maybe take a different path.
- 42:04SPEAKER_01: I think that's exactly right.
- 42:05SPEAKER_01: And I think the Trump administration has an opportunity here,
- 42:08SPEAKER_01: potentially working with Congress to really adjust meaningfully how NEPA is
- 42:15SPEAKER_01: practiced in the agencies and how the courts go about reviewing NEPA compliance.
- 42:19SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think that's crucial in terms of Congress.
- 42:22SPEAKER_03: There either has to be a conversation about NEPA itself and whether it's time to
- 42:25SPEAKER_03: modernize terms,
- 42:27SPEAKER_03: clarify terms like reasonable,
- 42:29SPEAKER_03: foreseeable environmental impacts,
- 42:31SPEAKER_03: reasonable alternatives,
- 42:32SPEAKER_03: or maybe both.
- 42:33SPEAKER_03: Or we will have to consider project-specific statutes or issue-specific statutes.
- 42:39SPEAKER_03: And sometimes this is a benefit.
- 42:41SPEAKER_03: It's easier to sort of say to agencies,
- 42:43SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 42:43SPEAKER_03: we're going to reduce the regulatory load for this one particular project because
- 42:47SPEAKER_03: we think it's particularly important.
- 42:49SPEAKER_03: But the more projects you see like that that get a fast pass through the NEPA
- 42:55SPEAKER_03: regulatory process,
- 42:56SPEAKER_03: I think the more questions it raises about the quality and the burdens of the NEPA
- 43:01SPEAKER_03: process for all the other projects.
- 43:03SPEAKER_03: But I completely agree.
- 43:04SPEAKER_03: This is going to have this new decision in the D.C.
- 43:06SPEAKER_03: Circuit.
- 43:07SPEAKER_03: And whatever we see out of the Supreme Court in the next case,
- 43:10SPEAKER_03: in the Utah case,
- 43:12SPEAKER_03: it's going to be an at-a-sketch moment in all three branches,
- 43:14SPEAKER_03: in the executive branch,
- 43:15SPEAKER_03: in the courts,
- 43:16SPEAKER_03: and in Congress.
- 43:18SPEAKER_00: What are the possible verdicts the Supreme Court could provide on this question?
- 43:22SPEAKER_00: As I understand it, they give the decision next summer, right?
- 43:25SPEAKER_00: They hear oral arguments now and we don't hear for a while.
- 43:28SPEAKER_00: What's kind of the range of possibility here?
- 43:31SPEAKER_03: Well, I'll jump in.
- 43:32SPEAKER_03: One possibility,
- 43:33SPEAKER_03: and going back to James's taxonomy,
- 43:36SPEAKER_03: the taxonomy that James noted of direct environmental impacts,
- 43:39SPEAKER_03: indirect environmental impacts,
- 43:40SPEAKER_03: and cumulative impacts.
- 43:41SPEAKER_03: You could see,
- 43:42SPEAKER_03: I think,
- 43:42SPEAKER_03: the Supreme Court drawing a harder line between,
- 43:46SPEAKER_03: say,
- 43:47SPEAKER_03: direct impacts and indirect impacts.
- 43:50SPEAKER_03: This would be a significant decision.
- 43:52SPEAKER_03: I don't know if the Supreme Court would go all the way,
- 43:54SPEAKER_03: but you could,
- 43:55SPEAKER_03: in theory,
- 43:56SPEAKER_03: see the Supreme Court say NEPA was only created to deal with the direct impacts,
- 44:02SPEAKER_03: the second and third order effects of a project.
- 44:08SPEAKER_03: That would have enormous effects itself on how agencies think about climate impacts and so on.
- 44:15SPEAKER_03: But it would be of a piece with the Supreme Court's recent decisions under,
- 44:19SPEAKER_03: I hate to throw more jargon out,
- 44:20SPEAKER_03: but under headings such as the major questions doctrine and other areas where the
- 44:25SPEAKER_03: Supreme Court has basically said to agencies,
- 44:27SPEAKER_03: Agency, you're in charge of a discrete, limited issue.
- 44:31SPEAKER_03: You are not sort of the free-floating macro policymaker for the economy or our politics at large.
- 44:39SPEAKER_03: An interpretation of NEPA that really limits the agency's purview to what's
- 44:44SPEAKER_03: happening on the ground and in the air in the specific vicinity of a given project
- 44:49SPEAKER_03: would be one way to significantly limit the regulatory burdens of NEPA,
- 44:53SPEAKER_03: but that would be an extremely consequential decision.
- 44:56SPEAKER_01: I think the likeliest outcome is that the D.C.
- 44:59SPEAKER_01: Circuit will strip the portion of Judge Randolph's opinion saying that CEQ
- 45:04SPEAKER_01: regulations are non-binding and that the Supreme Court won't weigh in on the question.
- 45:08SPEAKER_01: And we're going to kind of proceed with some judicial uncertainty on that on that precise issue.
- 45:14SPEAKER_01: All that said,
- 45:15SPEAKER_01: I think James's point about the Etch-A-Sketch moment,
- 45:18SPEAKER_01: all of that still applies even if the decision is overturned.
- 45:21SPEAKER_01: I think that's why it's such an interesting moment is that you can,
- 45:25SPEAKER_01: you kind of put,
- 45:26SPEAKER_01: Judge Randolph put this argument on the radar screen of people who are thinking
- 45:30SPEAKER_01: about NEPA going forward.
- 45:31SPEAKER_01: And it's kind of a moment where NEPA compliance is
- 45:34SPEAKER_01: is kind of a contested and up-in-the-air sort of question where there is bipartisan
- 45:39SPEAKER_01: interest in trying to reduce the burdens on agencies of environmental compliance review.
- 45:44SPEAKER_01: And if that's the case,
- 45:45SPEAKER_01: then I almost don't think it matters all that much what the courts decide in the
- 45:50SPEAKER_01: near term about the binding status of CEQ regulations.
- 45:53SPEAKER_01: It's just an opportunity to revisit a set of conventions that have hardened over
- 45:58SPEAKER_01: time and that really ought to be reconsidered.
- 46:01SPEAKER_00: Can I add, how can something like this be practiced by the courts for 50 years?
- 46:05SPEAKER_00: Everyone kind of understands that the CEQ doesn't necessarily have statutory authority,
- 46:10SPEAKER_00: but it takes 50 years for someone like Judge Randolph to say,
- 46:13SPEAKER_00: wait a minute,
- 46:15SPEAKER_00: just as a matter of kind of legal culture.
- 46:17SPEAKER_01: So some of it has to do with the way that these cases normally get presented.
- 46:22SPEAKER_01: So usually you've got an outside challenger who says the agency did not do enough.
- 46:27SPEAKER_01: And then the agency defends by saying we did do enough.
- 46:31SPEAKER_01: Sometimes the challengers say you didn't do enough because you failed to abide by CEQ regulations.
- 46:36SPEAKER_01: Well, the agency can't come back and say, those regulations don't bind us.
- 46:40SPEAKER_01: Those regulations are irrelevant, those regulations.
- 46:43SPEAKER_01: And so they tend not to make that argument.
- 46:45SPEAKER_01: And because the argument is never squarely presented,
- 46:48SPEAKER_01: the courts generally don't have an opportunity to address it.
- 46:51SPEAKER_01: When NEPA was adopted, it was kind of before the Chevron era of strong Chevron deference.
- 46:56SPEAKER_01: It was a kind of loosier,
- 46:57SPEAKER_01: goosier time of administrative law where the question about whether CEQ got some
- 47:03SPEAKER_01: measure of deference on its regulations,
- 47:06SPEAKER_01: the other court said,
- 47:06SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 47:07SPEAKER_01: sure.
- 47:07SPEAKER_01: You know, CEQ thinks about these questions.
- 47:08SPEAKER_01: We'll listen to what it has to say.
- 47:11SPEAKER_01: And it didn't harden into the rule that what CEQ says is the law until the Chevron
- 47:17SPEAKER_01: revolution really took hold and agencies with responsibility over statutes were
- 47:22SPEAKER_01: given a great deal more deference than they had before,
- 47:25SPEAKER_01: kind of strict binding deference.
- 47:27SPEAKER_01: So there's been sort of an underlying shift in the way we think about deference
- 47:31SPEAKER_01: that I think,
- 47:31SPEAKER_01: and a sort of lack of incentives to raise the question just the right way,
- 47:36SPEAKER_01: that I think has contributed to this sort of weird lurking issue.
- 47:40SPEAKER_01: That's my best guess, at least.
- 47:41SPEAKER_03: And I would add to that,
- 47:42SPEAKER_03: just again,
- 47:43SPEAKER_03: from the private sector side of this,
- 47:45SPEAKER_03: when a big project is getting built up,
- 47:48SPEAKER_03: an infrastructure project,
- 47:49SPEAKER_03: you have the agency in a conversation first and foremost with the project proponent,
- 47:53SPEAKER_03: like
- 47:54SPEAKER_03: So when I was an energy infrastructure lawyer a long time ago,
- 47:58SPEAKER_03: my office was basically a library of environmental impact statements from old projects.
- 48:04SPEAKER_03: And for each new project, I'd create a binder.
- 48:07SPEAKER_03: Back in the days,
- 48:07SPEAKER_03: we had binders with all of the rules,
- 48:11SPEAKER_03: the CEQ rules,
- 48:12SPEAKER_03: FERC's NEPA rules,
- 48:14SPEAKER_03: FERC's rules under all the other statutes that would apply.
- 48:17SPEAKER_03: The EPA and Army Corps of Engineers rules,
- 48:19SPEAKER_03: the Department of Commerce's rules for the Coastal Zone Management Act and on and
- 48:22SPEAKER_03: on and on and all the state regulations.
- 48:25SPEAKER_03: And this is with any big project.
- 48:27SPEAKER_03: It becomes a project of checklists and and sort of structuring a procedure to just
- 48:33SPEAKER_03: go through and cover everything.
- 48:35SPEAKER_03: And not not even just like in a cynical way of, oh, we need to paper up this project.
- 48:40SPEAKER_03: You know, in a good faith way of what's the way these projects are done and reviewed?
- 48:45SPEAKER_03: How do we make sure the project succeeds and is also safe?
- 48:49SPEAKER_03: And of course, when push comes to shove, there's a lot of negotiation around where to draw lines.
- 48:54SPEAKER_03: But over and over again, the projects in each of these things starts by just taking for granted
- 48:59SPEAKER_03: the entire body of rules and so on, and just trying to get the project done under those rules.
- 49:05SPEAKER_03: Maybe at some point you might start pushing back against a specific rule or interpretation,
- 49:10SPEAKER_03: but for the most part,
- 49:11SPEAKER_03: you've got the agency and the environmental groups
- 49:15SPEAKER_03: and even the private sector taking for granted that the legal infrastructure around
- 49:20SPEAKER_03: all of this is sound and taken for granted.
- 49:22SPEAKER_03: We're in a different era now.
- 49:24SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 49:24SPEAKER_03: in other areas of law,
- 49:25SPEAKER_03: you see things like the financial industry pushing back against their regulators in
- 49:29SPEAKER_03: a way that they never did before.
- 49:31SPEAKER_03: Maybe you'll see a similar dynamic in the energy industry.
- 49:35SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 49:36SPEAKER_03: But for the most part,
- 49:37SPEAKER_03: the private sector would take these things for granted as well and just try to get
- 49:41SPEAKER_03: the project done under existing rules.
- 49:44SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 49:44SPEAKER_02: and I could say that if you have a client that says,
- 49:48SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 49:49SPEAKER_02: I wanna build this power line,
- 49:51SPEAKER_02: how do I get my federal approvals for the water crossing?
- 49:55SPEAKER_02: If you say,
- 49:55SPEAKER_02: well,
- 49:56SPEAKER_02: here's the whole CEQ process,
- 49:57SPEAKER_02: but I've got this great legal theory that's been mentioned in a lot of concurrences
- 50:03SPEAKER_02: about why we actually could completely rip up this process and start fresh.
- 50:08SPEAKER_02: Most clients are going to say, let's just stick to the checklist.
- 50:12SPEAKER_02: And ultimately, as lawyers and as law professors, we know that law students...
- 50:18SPEAKER_02: They wanna hear what's the rules.
- 50:19SPEAKER_02: They wanna hear what are the rules.
- 50:20SPEAKER_02: And if you start giving them, well, here's the theoretical reasons why maybe the rules are invalid.
- 50:25SPEAKER_02: They get very frustrated.
- 50:26SPEAKER_02: So yeah,
- 50:27SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 50:27SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 50:27SPEAKER_02: clients like law students,
- 50:28SPEAKER_02: everybody just wants to know what the process is and follow it.
- 50:32SPEAKER_02: And so,
- 50:33SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 50:33SPEAKER_02: I do think there's a,
- 50:34SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 50:34SPEAKER_02: if there's gonna be a reform,
- 50:36SPEAKER_02: if there's gonna be a reform moment,
- 50:37SPEAKER_02: we're gonna wanna pretty quickly get through to that new process because there's
- 50:42SPEAKER_02: only a limited amount of tolerance for having the rules in flux.
- 50:46SPEAKER_02: I did wanna just say two things that I think haven't been said so far.
- 50:50SPEAKER_02: So one is this seven county infrastructure case.
- 50:53SPEAKER_02: It's important to understand the context of it.
- 50:55SPEAKER_02: So this is why we keep talking about, and it was quite right, upstream and downstream impacts.
- 51:00SPEAKER_02: This is a case about a piece of railroad in Utah
- 51:05SPEAKER_02: that the courts have required that when the federal government approve this,
- 51:11SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 51:11SPEAKER_02: little railroad in Utah,
- 51:12SPEAKER_02: it also analyze all the oil production that might happen across Utah.
- 51:17SPEAKER_02: It's not a lot of oil production in Utah,
- 51:19SPEAKER_02: but they said,
- 51:19SPEAKER_02: well,
- 51:20SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 51:20SPEAKER_02: in theory,
- 51:21SPEAKER_02: this railroad would enable it
- 51:23SPEAKER_02: you should consider all of that.
- 51:24SPEAKER_02: And then secondly,
- 51:25SPEAKER_02: you should consider all of the impact of if there is a new oil that comes in this railroad,
- 51:31SPEAKER_02: then maybe that would eventually reach the Gulf Coast and go to refineries there.
- 51:36SPEAKER_02: And what would happen at the refineries there?
- 51:37SPEAKER_02: So it really is this sort of butterfly beats its wings idea that you should consider all those
- 51:42SPEAKER_02: And the court did say it was upstream and downstream or uprail and downrail impacts,
- 51:48SPEAKER_02: although I used all those terms,
- 51:49SPEAKER_02: those projects.
- 51:50SPEAKER_02: And so, you know, again, it really pursued all these ideas sort of out to the end of the week.
- 51:54SPEAKER_02: So that's what's that issue there.
- 51:55SPEAKER_02: And the final thing that we've been talking about that we probably should mention
- 51:59SPEAKER_02: is an Etch-a-Sketch is a toy that you do a picture on and then you just shake it
- 52:05SPEAKER_02: and the picture goes completely away.
- 52:06SPEAKER_02: You can draw something different.
- 52:07SPEAKER_02: So when we say Etch-a-Sketch moment, I know that has entered the political lexicon through
- 52:12SPEAKER_02: uh you know governor senator romney's campaign but you know he's he's gonna you
- 52:17SPEAKER_02: know maybe there are folks who weren't around for that jave are you calling us old
- 52:21SPEAKER_00: yeah i'm not sure everybody knows what i actually i actually do remember that that
- 52:25SPEAKER_02: was a part of my political awakening yeah exactly exactly so that's what an edge of
- 52:28SPEAKER_02: sketch is it's basically an opportunity to sort of reconsider to reconsider things
- 52:33SPEAKER_02: that we're taking for granted for some period of time
- 52:36SPEAKER_03: Sure.
- 52:37SPEAKER_03: I think it's important to see this.
- 52:38SPEAKER_03: It is just a result of 50 years of technological progress and scientific expertise.
- 52:44SPEAKER_03: It was one thing to say in 1970, think about the environmental impacts of a project.
- 52:49SPEAKER_03: You're building 88 miles of rail line in Utah.
- 52:53SPEAKER_03: You would look around and say, like, what are we bulldozing here?
- 52:56SPEAKER_03: What's the runoff?
- 52:58SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 52:58SPEAKER_03: even 50 years ago,
- 52:59SPEAKER_03: you come up with theories about,
- 53:00SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 53:00SPEAKER_03: railroad might cause,
- 53:02SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 53:02SPEAKER_03: might throw some sparks that cause fires and so on,
- 53:05SPEAKER_03: that kind of thing.
- 53:06SPEAKER_03: That's still a pretty limited set of impacts.
- 53:10SPEAKER_03: But now because of our scientific expertise and our technology,
- 53:15SPEAKER_03: we can in many ways project far into the future.
- 53:20SPEAKER_03: and at great distances,
- 53:21SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 53:22SPEAKER_03: the butterfly effects of these things,
- 53:24SPEAKER_03: butterfly flaps its wings and a storm brews in the Gulf of Mexico or something.
- 53:30SPEAKER_03: Also,
- 53:31SPEAKER_03: over the last 50 years,
- 53:32SPEAKER_03: we've become aware of the fact that sometimes you do have just low probability,
- 53:38SPEAKER_03: high impact effects due to complex energy infrastructure projects.
- 53:43SPEAKER_03: I think time and time again of the Gulf of Mexico well blowout,
- 53:47SPEAKER_03: the Macondo well blowout.
- 53:49SPEAKER_03: I think I was still an energy lawyer those days working on these issues.
- 53:53SPEAKER_03: You get this Deepwater Horizon oil well blowout in the Gulf of Mexico, spilling oil everywhere.
- 53:59SPEAKER_03: And an executive says, well, that was practically unthinkable.
- 54:03SPEAKER_03: And when you go through any time you have a complex energy infrastructure project
- 54:07SPEAKER_03: go bad,
- 54:08SPEAKER_03: some very low probability thing that goes wrong,
- 54:10SPEAKER_03: there's always going to be someone who says,
- 54:13SPEAKER_03: well,
- 54:14SPEAKER_03: no one could have seen that coming.
- 54:15SPEAKER_03: Now we can actually project out a lot more of what could possibly go wrong.
- 54:20SPEAKER_03: in a very complex energy infrastructure project.
- 54:24SPEAKER_03: The old book on the 80s about NEPA by Serge Taylor was called Making Bureaucracies Think.
- 54:28SPEAKER_03: And I've always kind of admired just that headline on a book.
- 54:32SPEAKER_03: At the end of the day,
- 54:32SPEAKER_03: you do need a process to help force decision makers,
- 54:38SPEAKER_03: both in the private sector and in the public sector,
- 54:40SPEAKER_03: to think hard and think creatively
- 54:43SPEAKER_03: about extremely hard to imagine consequences.
- 54:47SPEAKER_03: And now we have technology that allows us to do more and more of that.
- 54:51SPEAKER_03: The downside of that,
- 54:52SPEAKER_03: though,
- 54:52SPEAKER_03: is that when it all gets bogged down into court and people are just sort of
- 54:56SPEAKER_03: spitballing alternatives and possible effects,
- 54:59SPEAKER_03: and there's no clear line between what's reasonable and unreasonable when you're
- 55:03SPEAKER_03: sketching it out,
- 55:04SPEAKER_03: We've seen over 50 years, this has become more and more complex.
- 55:07SPEAKER_03: And in many ways, the complexity is a good thing.
- 55:09SPEAKER_03: It reflects our experience and our technology.
- 55:12SPEAKER_03: But it does actually make this basic, simple statute from 1969 much, much harder to administer.
- 55:19SPEAKER_00: It's ironic that you talk about the role of NEPA in making agencies think about
- 55:25SPEAKER_00: unintended consequences,
- 55:26SPEAKER_00: because one of the through lines in this conversation seems to be that NEPA itself
- 55:30SPEAKER_00: has all these unintended consequences and agencies.
- 55:33SPEAKER_00: The original architects did not foresee this outcome.
- 55:37SPEAKER_03: Oh, I have a story about that.
- 55:38SPEAKER_03: I promise I'll be quick.
- 55:39SPEAKER_03: Years ago when I was still a lawyer,
- 55:41SPEAKER_03: I was meeting with a favorite law professor of mine and he was asking what I was
- 55:44SPEAKER_03: doing and I described NEPA stuff.
- 55:47SPEAKER_03: And he says, oh, when I was a clerk on the DC circuit, I worked on a NEPA case.
- 55:50SPEAKER_03: It was kind of interesting.
- 55:51SPEAKER_03: And I thought to myself, I said,
- 55:53SPEAKER_03: Richard, you clerked for Judge Skelly Wright in like 1970.
- 55:57SPEAKER_03: So you were the clerk on this case that's famous among lawyers called Calvert-Cliffs.
- 56:01SPEAKER_03: That's the case that really made NEPA a big judicially enforceable thing.
- 56:06SPEAKER_03: I said, did you work on the Calvert-Cliffs case?
- 56:08SPEAKER_03: And he goes, yeah, that was it, the nuclear regulatory case.
- 56:11SPEAKER_03: He said, it seemed like a pretty straightforward case to me.
- 56:14SPEAKER_03: How did it work out?
- 56:15SPEAKER_03: And I open up again.
- 56:16SPEAKER_03: These are the olden days.
- 56:17SPEAKER_03: I open up my briefcase and I pull out four volumes of EIS,
- 56:20SPEAKER_03: environmental impact statements that I was traveling with for work.
- 56:23SPEAKER_03: And I dump it on the table.
- 56:25SPEAKER_03: The table shakes.
- 56:26SPEAKER_03: And I said, well, Richard, it's no way to run a country, but it's the Adam White full employment plan.
- 56:30SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 56:31SPEAKER_03: the judges,
- 56:33SPEAKER_03: 1970,
- 56:33SPEAKER_03: well-intentioned judges who are looking at a specific thing,
- 56:37SPEAKER_03: a nuclear reactor in what was it,
- 56:41SPEAKER_03: Maryland.
- 56:42SPEAKER_03: Of course you want to bend over backwards and think as creatively as possible and
- 56:47SPEAKER_03: force the government to think creatively about this.
- 56:50SPEAKER_03: But it's no way to run a country when you can't build anything anymore,
- 56:54SPEAKER_03: such to the point that it's so hard to build power lines that we might recommission
- 56:58SPEAKER_03: the Three Mile Island reactor.
- 57:00SPEAKER_03: to fund or to power these data centers.
- 57:04SPEAKER_03: We're going to see so many fights now in the next,
- 57:07SPEAKER_03: well,
- 57:07SPEAKER_03: this presidential administration,
- 57:08SPEAKER_03: regardless of whether Trump or Harris would have won,
- 57:11SPEAKER_03: especially under Trump,
- 57:12SPEAKER_03: and for years to follow,
- 57:14SPEAKER_03: so much need for power in the mid-Atlantic.
- 57:17SPEAKER_03: So many hard questions about environmental impacts and property rights for these power lines.
- 57:21SPEAKER_03: The kind of thing that judges in the 1970s,
- 57:23SPEAKER_03: let alone even Senator Scoop Jackson in 1969,
- 57:26SPEAKER_03: could never have foreseen.
- 57:28SPEAKER_03: All of it because of our great,
- 57:30SPEAKER_03: vast technological progress that makes both these projects more complex and the
- 57:34SPEAKER_03: regulatory process more complex.
- 57:36SPEAKER_00: That's a great place to wrap up.
- 57:38SPEAKER_00: Thank you all three for joining.
- 57:40SPEAKER_02: Thank you so much.
- 57:41SPEAKER_00: It's great to be here.
- 57:43SPEAKER_02: Thanks, Santi.
- 57:44SPEAKER_01: Santi, that I wanted you to tell that story on the podcast, Adam.
- 57:47SPEAKER_01: So I'm glad you got to it.
- 57:48SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I can't.
- 57:50SPEAKER_03: Again, with the roadshow, he has to hear this story over and over.
- 57:52SPEAKER_01: I love it.
- 57:52SPEAKER_01: I'll hear it.
- 57:53SPEAKER_01: I'll hear it every day.
- 57:53SPEAKER_01: So Richard Leiser, one of the ironies of NEPA is that it doesn't even mention judicial review.
- 57:59SPEAKER_01: And it was meant originally as an internal executive branch management tool.
- 58:03SPEAKER_01: It was adopted kind of the late 1960s before the court's
- 58:07SPEAKER_01: took a really hard look at what agencies did.
- 58:09SPEAKER_01: And so when Congress adopted it, there was no expectation that the courts would change their practice.
- 58:13SPEAKER_01: But it was adopted right as the D.C.
- 58:16SPEAKER_01: Circuit was intensifying the level of judicial scrutiny way past what it had been before.
- 58:21SPEAKER_01: And so the D.C.
- 58:22SPEAKER_01: Circuit takes this law that was really meant just about internal executive branch
- 58:26SPEAKER_01: management and retrofits it to suit the felt needs of the time.
- 58:30SPEAKER_01: But it was it was really not the original understanding of what NEPA was all about.
- 58:35SPEAKER_02: When you look at some of the proposals for reform that Nick mentioned,
- 58:40SPEAKER_02: the president working with Congress may be looking to make some changes so that
- 58:44SPEAKER_02: NEPA doesn't hold up infrastructure projects so much.
- 58:47SPEAKER_02: A lot of the most important proposals will focus specifically on judicial review.
- 58:52SPEAKER_02: And we've seen a number of them where they've said, hey, maybe we will get rid of the use of injunctions.
- 58:59SPEAKER_02: for judicial review so that even if there's a dispute between the opponents of the
- 59:04SPEAKER_02: project and the government about how much review has been done,
- 59:07SPEAKER_02: the government can go do its review.
- 59:08SPEAKER_02: But in the meantime, the project will be allowed to go ahead and be maybe there needs to be some kind of
- 59:15SPEAKER_02: stronger time limits for when you can judicially challenge a project.
- 59:19SPEAKER_02: So if you look at some of the previous reforms that have been used,
- 59:23SPEAKER_02: a lot of times projects that Congress really has wanted to be built and been
- 59:27SPEAKER_02: exempted from judicial review.
- 59:29SPEAKER_02: So you can think about the Trans-Alaska pipeline or the Mountain Valley pipeline.
- 59:34SPEAKER_02: And I think
- 59:35SPEAKER_02: To the extent that Congress is really serious about addressing this challenge of
- 59:40SPEAKER_02: National Environmental Policy Act holding up needed infrastructure,
- 59:43SPEAKER_02: you'll see them focus on limiting judicial review.
- 59:47SPEAKER_02: And as Nick said,
- 59:47SPEAKER_02: maybe that goes back more to the original meaning of the National Environmental
- 59:52SPEAKER_02: Policy Act.