Latest / Surrounded / Tim Miller vs 20 Gen Z Conservatives
Transcript
- 0:00The values that I'm talking about
- 0:02are the ones in the Constitution and the Declaration,
- 0:04as I said,
- 0:05freedom of speech,
- 0:06freedom of religion,
- 0:07rule of law,
- 0:08democracy.
- 0:09If you go down that list that we said,
- 0:11whether it's freedom of speech,
- 0:12the Declaration,
- 0:12Trump is attacking that freedom of religion.
- 0:14Trump is attacking that,
- 0:15not attacking freedom of religion.
- 0:16How is a Muslim freedom of religion.
- 0:18We had a Muslim ban in this country.
- 0:20No,
- 0:20we have never had an actual Muslim ban.
- 0:21That is an insane claim by you.
- 0:25From Jubilee Media,
- 0:25this is the surrounded podcast where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:30In the center of today's episode is Tim Miller.
- 0:32He's the host of the
- 0:34Bulwark podcast.
- 0:35He's also a liberal millennial,
- 0:36and he will be facing 20 conservative Gen Zers.
- 0:40Tim will debate them one on one until
- 0:42they're voted out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 0:45Let's get into it.
- 0:46Hey everybody,
- 0:47I'm Tim Miller.
- 0:47Uh,
- 0:48you might have seen me on the board podcast on YouTube or on MSNBC.
- 0:52Uh,
- 0:52I'm a liberal millennial,
- 0:53and today I'm surrounded by 20 Gen Z conservatives.
- 1:03My first claim is ICE has become a fascist institution
- 1:07and it should be abolished in its current form.
- 1:19What's up y'all?
- 1:23So,
- 1:23uh,
- 1:24the point that I want to make about
- 1:26immigration,
- 1:27ICE specifically that I think it's worth making is a structural one
- 1:30and one that I think you
- 1:32could respect,
- 1:33and it's the fact that democratically speaking,
- 1:36uh,
- 1:37it's been an issue that was
- 1:38not very popular before
- 1:40Trump came into power
- 1:41and it was the central issue for which he was selected for the first time.
- 1:45And then the second time he doubled down
- 1:47and it was an even stronger argument.
- 1:50Do you remember that he would like the
- 1:51people in his rallies and himself were talking about
- 1:55mass deportations
- 1:57and that idea won.
- 1:58What do you think is gonna happen in the next election?
- 2:00You know,
- 2:01do you think that sentiment's gonna disappear?
- 2:03Well,
- 2:03look,
- 2:03we live in a constitutional republic,
- 2:05so just because you get elected,
- 2:07um,
- 2:07on a certain issue doesn't mean you get to do whatever you want.
- 2:09If the next Democratic president,
- 2:11uh,
- 2:11ran on a campaign that said.
- 2:13Shut down all the evangelical churches because
- 2:15I think they're doing hate speech and
- 2:17they became president and then they tried
- 2:18to shut down all the evangelical churches.
- 2:20People would say that's fascist,
- 2:21that's wrong,
- 2:22you can't do that,
- 2:22that's illegal.
- 2:23What the president has done,
- 2:25uh,
- 2:25on the border,
- 2:25we can talk about what's happening with CBP,
- 2:27but with ICE,
- 2:28I,
- 2:28I,
- 2:28I don't,
- 2:29I don't think that a lot of people that voted for him pictured this.
- 2:31I think that if you described what they're doing in another country,
- 2:34you'd obviously say it's fascist.
- 2:35You got people coming up in unmarked cars,
- 2:38they're wearing masks.
- 2:39Masks
- 2:39they're jumping out and they're asking people for their papers.
- 2:41That's not American.
- 2:43That is not within our traditions or our rule of law.
- 2:45How should they deport them?
- 2:46Should they like just like knock on the door and be like,
- 2:48Hey,
- 2:48Mr.
- 2:48illegal,
- 2:49uh,
- 2:49can you come out?
- 2:51Do you want to have a little chat?
- 2:53You know,
- 2:53like they broke the law.
- 2:54They came here into this country illegally and we have to enforce it.
- 2:58So like
- 2:59if we're gonna call ICE fascist,
- 3:01yeah,
- 3:01you guys call everything fascist nowadays,
- 3:03uh,
- 3:03then.
- 3:04Are we going to have?
- 3:05We're not going to deport them,
- 3:06and then the people are going to be ignored.
- 3:08I don't think we need to ignore the people.
- 3:09I think if you look at deportation,
- 3:11there are a lot of Donald,
- 3:12look,
- 3:12there are a lot of Donald Trump supporters out there
- 3:14that don't like the way that ISA has been acting.
- 3:15You hear this from Joe Rogan.
- 3:17You hear it from Tim Dillon.
- 3:18What they've been doing
- 3:19is,
- 3:19is un-American.
- 3:21You should not be,
- 3:22look,
- 3:22you should not be hassling people who are American citizens
- 3:25to bring in millions of illegals into this country.
- 3:26There are people that voted for Trump.
- 3:28What are you talking about?
- 3:30Look,
- 3:30JP,
- 3:31my name's JP.
- 3:31It starts for Juan Pablo.
- 3:33I love the Latino people.
- 3:34I might look like a white boy,
- 3:36have the white boy aura,
- 3:36but I'm a Latino man,
- 3:38and I understand
- 3:39that
- 3:39they,
- 3:40it might seem like they're coming after the Latinos,
- 3:43but really
- 3:43we're,
- 3:44what we're doing is respecting our laws.
- 3:45We're a constitution Republic pause,
- 3:49pause,
- 3:49pause,
- 3:50pause,
- 3:50pause.
- 3:51I'm sorry,
- 3:51but you have to respect me when I say pause.
- 3:53You've been eliminated.
- 3:54You have to go back to your chair.
- 3:56Good to see you,
- 3:56man.
- 4:05Oh.
- 4:07As you can see,
- 4:08I'm pretty well aware of how this deportation game goes.
- 4:11A lot of relatives have to face it,
- 4:12and I gotta tell you that it's very well warranted.
- 4:15I find that with the mandate that Donald Trump got in 2024,
- 4:18he got a stronger mandate in fact,
- 4:20than he did in 2016
- 4:21and obviously in 2020.
- 4:23He,
- 4:23in particular,
- 4:24had immigration and deportations,
- 4:26by the way,
- 4:27as being one of the strongest issues.
- 4:29Yeah,
- 4:29I hear you.
- 4:29We just said this in the last one though.
- 4:30Again,
- 4:31you don't get to break the law just because you won the election.
- 4:33That's not how it works in a free country.
- 4:34We have rule of law,
- 4:35we have rules.
- 4:36Here's the thing.
- 4:37Uh,
- 4:37look,
- 4:37what ICE has been doing,
- 4:38going after American citizens,
- 4:40going after people,
- 4:41going after folks that look like you and asking for their papers is
- 4:44wrong.
- 4:44Uh,
- 4:44Here,
- 4:44here's an example.
- 4:45Do you have your passport on you right now?
- 4:47Well,
- 4:47actually,
- 4:48yeah,
- 4:48I bought it,
- 4:48but I traveled,
- 4:49but
- 4:49no,
- 4:49no,
- 4:49I'm sorry.
- 4:50Do you have it on your,
- 4:50on your person?
- 4:51Can you show it to me?
- 4:52OK,
- 4:52you don't have it on your person.
- 4:53Well,
- 4:53that's interesting because there's a guy named George here in LA
- 4:56who worked at a car wash.
- 4:57Here's what happened.
- 4:58ICE rolled up to his car wash.
- 5:00He is a dual citizen.
- 5:02He was from born in Mexico.
- 5:03He He came here,
- 5:04he became a citizen.
- 5:05He has a wife that's a citizen and two kids that are a citizen.
- 5:07They,
- 5:08he,
- 5:08they came into his car wash.
- 5:09He asked ICE.
- 5:10He's like,
- 5:11Can you,
- 5:12can,
- 5:12do you guys have a warrant?
- 5:13He showed me a warrant.
- 5:13They didn't have a warrant.
- 5:14They said,
- 5:15Can we see your dri can we see proof that you're from America?
- 5:17He showed them his driver's license.
- 5:18Then they said,
- 5:19Can we see your passport?
- 5:21He didn't have his passport on him.
- 5:22They grabbed him,
- 5:23they threw him in the back of a van,
- 5:25and he,
- 5:25they,
- 5:26he came downtown here to the detention center.
- 5:28Uh,
- 5:28George Redis is an American citizen,
- 5:30got detained by ICE.
- 5:32Just the other day,
- 5:32the New York Times was talking about this,
- 5:33that there were,
- 5:34there was,
- 5:34um,
- 5:35an unmarked car in Chicago driving down Lake Michigan.
- 5:38Two guys hopped out of the car.
- 5:40They were masked.
- 5:41They jumped out and grabbed these two joggers,
- 5:43and they're like,
- 5:44show me your papers.
- 5:45This is,
- 5:45I'm sorry,
- 5:46this is not mass deportations now.
- 5:48This is hassling American citizens.
- 5:50This is.
- 5:50Breaking the rule of law.
- 5:51This is anti-due process,
- 5:52and it's wrong.
- 5:53The anecdotes you bring up are actually relevant because I
- 5:56could do the same thing for Medicare abuse and whatnot,
- 5:58but I'm not calling for drastic reforms or even an abolishment.
- 6:01You're calling for an abolishment of ICE as we know it
- 6:03now.
- 6:04You're pointing out to fringe cases.
- 6:06The fringe cases.
- 6:06They're happening all over the country all the time,
- 6:08OK,
- 6:08so I'm,
- 6:09I'm arguing that the vast majority of the
- 6:10people that are getting deported are illegal aliens.
- 6:13You're pointing to a small percentage of folks that are
- 6:15getting deported because of obviously anything that the government does,
- 6:18that there's going to be mistakes done.
- 6:19And I feel like the majority of the people of the country
- 6:21voted more than they did for Kamala for such things to happen.
- 6:24And so what you're pointing to is,
- 6:26I think,
- 6:26to be,
- 6:26like I said,
- 6:27something that's an abstraction.
- 6:28There are many people that voted for Donald Trump
- 6:30that have already said they're upset about this.
- 6:31Prominent podcasters have said that they're upset about what he's doing.
- 6:34So just because he voted,
- 6:35it doesn't mean he gets to act in 200 illegally and act with impunity.
- 6:38All right,
- 6:38so ICE,
- 6:38ICE is about to have a bigger budget
- 6:41than the entire military of Israel.
- 6:43It's an insane way,
- 6:45thrilled about that over there.
- 6:46It's an insane way for us to be spending our resources in this country.
- 6:49They're hassling American citizens.
- 6:51They're hassling people who are here on legal visas.
- 6:54They're demanding their papers.
- 6:56Like this is East Germany in the Stasi.
- 6:58That's not how you act in a free country.
- 6:59You can do border control and you can do deportations without having masked guys
- 7:04coming and grab you because of the way you look.
- 7:06Well,
- 7:06if that's the case,
- 7:07then how come CBP and the other things
- 7:09before ICE and before Trump haven't been working,
- 7:11and that's why the people elected Donald Trump in the first place?
- 7:13So then what would be your solution that would be some sort of a middle
- 7:16ground because it seems like you just want to get rid of the whole thing.
- 7:18I mean,
- 7:18no,
- 7:19uh,
- 7:19ICE just started in 2003.
- 7:21Uh,
- 7:22we had Immigration and Naturalization Services that was inside the DOJ.
- 7:26It happened to the entire history of our country up until 9/11.
- 7:29There were plenty of ways to deal with this.
- 7:31We could have the FBI,
- 7:32uh,
- 7:32go after criminals.
- 7:33We could have the DEA go after drug dealers.
- 7:35We could have the CBP go after the border.
- 7:38Uh,
- 7:38like there is no,
- 7:39there is,
- 7:39this isn't working.
- 7:40What is happening now isn't working.
- 7:42When you are illegally detaining US veterans
- 7:45and putting them in prison for 3 days.
- 7:48That's not,
- 7:48that is not working.
- 7:49That is not a,
- 7:50that is not what happens in a free country.
- 7:53That's like when Republicans brought up death panels for Obamacare.
- 7:55And by the way,
- 7:56you say that some people like Tim Dillon don't support Trump anymore.
- 7:59Didn't Obama lose a ton of support in 2010?
- 8:01So what's your point?
- 8:02You lose some part of the coalition.
- 8:04My point is that the ball.
- 8:05My point is that,
- 8:06is that in a free country,
- 8:08just because you get elected,
- 8:09that does not mean that you can start to do illegal things.
- 8:11We still have rule of law.
- 8:12We still,
- 8:12yeah,
- 8:13they.
- 8:13You are doing illegal things all over the country.
- 8:14He's OK,
- 8:15you're saying he's doing illegal things to get rid of everybody who is illegal.
- 8:18What,
- 8:18what is,
- 8:19what,
- 8:19how,
- 8:20how do you think it makes sense for a masked person to jump out of their car
- 8:24and go and grab you?
- 8:25Well,
- 8:26how is that legal?
- 8:26So there's no unmarked police cars before I did this.
- 8:29Will they give people?
- 8:30They're not OK.
- 8:30They give people due process.
- 8:32How so as compared to people that are already not even citizens in the first place?
- 8:35I don't understand the question.
- 8:36All right,
- 8:36so you're,
- 8:37you've been eliminated.
- 8:39Good to see you.
- 8:46Hello,
- 8:47nice to meet you.
- 8:47I'm Tara.
- 8:47Hey Tara,
- 8:48nice to meet you.
- 8:49So I guess I just want to know first,
- 8:50you know,
- 8:51kind of a personal question.
- 8:52Do you know anyone who's been deported?
- 8:54Do I know anybody personally that's been deported?
- 8:56No,
- 8:56like personally,
- 8:57no.
- 8:57OK,
- 8:58I,
- 8:58I know a few.
- 8:59I mean,
- 8:59I've interviewed some people,
- 9:00but I don't have any friends.
- 9:01Oh,
- 9:01really?
- 9:01Tell me about some of the interviews.
- 9:02How long were they here for?
- 9:04Um,
- 9:05you know,
- 9:05look,
- 9:05I,
- 9:05and I think that there have been,
- 9:07um,
- 9:08people that were brought here as kids that got deported.
- 9:10Um,
- 9:11we did,
- 9:11did a big thing on MSNBC.
- 9:12Jacob Soberoff was doing it with.
- 9:14Uh,
- 9:15somebody whose mother
- 9:16had been here for decades,
- 9:18uh,
- 9:18decades you say,
- 9:19so that's interesting.
- 9:19So that's a lot of time to put off
- 9:22doing the,
- 9:23the process of becoming a citizen.
- 9:25So what do you think we should do about that?
- 9:27Um,
- 9:28I,
- 9:28I think that there are a lot of other
- 9:30punishments that we could give somebody besides deportation,
- 9:32somebody who's been in this,
- 9:33not punishment.
- 9:34I'm talking about the solution.
- 9:35Let's back up from when the law enforcement begins.
- 9:37Let's go back
- 9:38to when they realize they are here illegally.
- 9:41Maybe they turn 18 as a child or maybe they know as a child that they
- 9:44are an illegal citizen.
- 9:45What do they do next?
- 9:47Um,
- 9:47I would assume that they go to college,
- 9:49they stay in the country,
- 9:49they work,
- 9:50they go to church,
- 9:50they make friends,
- 9:51they try to do their best in a free country papers.
- 9:53When do they take the
- 9:54initiative to become a legal US citizen?
- 9:58Um,
- 9:58I don't know if your parents brought you here illegally,
- 10:01you can't take the initiative.
- 10:02You have to go back to your home country
- 10:03first before you do that unless you're under DACA,
- 10:05and I,
- 10:06you know,
- 10:06it's,
- 10:06it's complicated.
- 10:07There are a lot of different rules,
- 10:08I guess.
- 10:08My,
- 10:08my point is
- 10:09the individual choice that you're trying to get to that question.
- 10:13Uh,
- 10:13look,
- 10:14a lot of individuals break a lot of laws,
- 10:16right?
- 10:16Like,
- 10:16I,
- 10:16here's like,
- 10:17and,
- 10:17and we make decisions about how we want to punish them
- 10:20and how we want to enforce them as a society.
- 10:21Like,
- 10:22for example,
- 10:22I don't know,
- 10:23have you ever like
- 10:24borrowed somebody else's Netflix?
- 10:25Well,
- 10:26well,
- 10:26hang on,
- 10:26hang on,
- 10:26back up a second.
- 10:28So
- 10:28we're talking about like legal citizenship.
- 10:30We're not talking about a streaming platform,
- 10:32but I just wanna visit this topic curious.
- 10:34So have you ever bought.
- 10:35Well,
- 10:35hang on a second,
- 10:36I just wanna revisit this child.
- 10:38Well,
- 10:38I wanna,
- 10:38I wanna revisit this issue with the child
- 10:41whose parents are illegal,
- 10:42uh,
- 10:43uh,
- 10:43immigrants.
- 10:44Let's talk about that because this child is in America,
- 10:47right?
- 10:47Let's say they're going to a public school.
- 10:49It's probably,
- 10:50you know,
- 10:50most kids know what's happening.
- 10:52Why can't that child
- 10:53say,
- 10:54Mom,
- 10:54Dad,
- 10:55let's like get on this.
- 10:56I know I'm an illegal citizen.
- 10:58I have two kids.
- 10:58Yeah,
- 10:59you think a 7,
- 10:59a 7 year old,
- 11:00a 2nd grader is supposed to be,
- 11:01I would say let's go back to Honduras.
- 11:03OK,
- 11:03I have a friend.
- 11:04I,
- 11:04I had a friend who was 16 years old who helped her grandmother
- 11:07apply for citizenship,
- 11:08and her grandmother
- 11:09is now a legal US citizen.
- 11:11That's great.
- 11:12Why don't we have more stories like that?
- 11:13We have a ton of stories like that.
- 11:14That's the story of the whole country.
- 11:15Why don't you use your platform to encourage more of
- 11:18those stories instead of going after the law enforcement,
- 11:20no,
- 11:20we should make,
- 11:20we should make it easier for people to do that.
- 11:22It's,
- 11:22it's impossible for us to do that.
- 11:24Right now in Donald Trump's administration they've made it
- 11:26much harder to come through by legal pathways.
- 11:29The refugee program is down to 0.
- 11:30I'm getting voted off.
- 11:31I'm sorry,
- 11:32give me one people from I need to tell you about something.
- 11:34RFK Jr.
- 11:35made a documentary called Border at Midnight.
- 11:37If you haven't seen it,
- 11:38I encourage you to watch it.
- 11:39It's like 20 minutes.
- 11:39It talks about the trafficking that is happening.
- 11:41We are in a state of emergency in this country,
- 11:43OK,
- 11:44so yes,
- 11:44go after the traffickers.
- 11:45No,
- 11:46the law after the traffickers then that's easy.
- 11:48Thank you.
- 11:48Thank you.
- 11:49This one.
- 11:58Hey man,
- 11:59you're looking good.
- 12:00Thank you very much.
- 12:01You're showing me up here.
- 12:02You're looking good yourself.
- 12:03I appreciate it.
- 12:04What is your solution here to Donald Trump?
- 12:05I think that the Trump administration should follow the law,
- 12:07and I think that there's a lot of ways that we can enforce immigration.
- 12:11That doesn't include having an internal secret police that
- 12:14has a bigger budget than the military of Israel.
- 12:16We have the CBP
- 12:17that can handle the border.
- 12:18We have The Drug Enforcement Agency that can handle going after drug dealers.
- 12:22We have the FBI that can go after terrorists.
- 12:24We do not need masked people jumping out of
- 12:27cars and asking brown people for their papers,
- 12:29and I think there's a lot of elements to
- 12:32a lot of ways to enforce immigration without doing it.
- 12:34OK,
- 12:35I,
- 12:35I,
- 12:35I'd probably agree with you on that,
- 12:36but
- 12:37would,
- 12:37would you say that this is a
- 12:40I love agreeing.
- 12:41You,
- 12:41you,
- 12:42I love agreeing too,
- 12:42but would you say this is,
- 12:43this is willfully Donald Trump and ICE breaking the law,
- 12:46or that,
- 12:47that he,
- 12:47he,
- 12:47he has to
- 12:48deal with immigration?
- 12:49Of course they're willfully breaking the law.
- 12:50Let me give you one example.
- 12:51One sec,
- 12:52but do you think this is him willfully breaking the law because
- 12:53he's malicious or because things don't work out perfectly when you?
- 12:56Oh,
- 12:56no,
- 12:56no,
- 12:57they're willfully breaking the law because they're malicious.
- 12:58For starters,
- 12:59everybody's masked.
- 13:00Why are they masked?
- 13:00Every other agency,
- 13:01every other police officer,
- 13:02every other military officer,
- 13:03they put their name
- 13:04on there to protect the identity of ICE agents because why
- 13:07would they have to protect the identity of ICE agents?
- 13:08Because they're getting shot,
- 13:09because they're getting killed.
- 13:10There are people that put themselves at risk.
- 13:12Podcasters are getting shot.
- 13:13Uh,
- 13:13judges,
- 13:13how about judges or prosecutors are getting shot.
- 13:15How about,
- 13:16yeah,
- 13:16how about judges or prosecutors who go after the
- 13:18gang members and who go after the criminals?
- 13:20The judges don't sit up.
- 13:21On that bench
- 13:22and hide their face because they're worried that
- 13:24the gang members are gonna come for them.
- 13:25The prosecutors don't.
- 13:26There have been tons of examples of judges and prosecutors
- 13:29and cops and other cops having people go after them.
- 13:31That's part of public service.
- 13:32You,
- 13:32in a free country,
- 13:33this is not East Germany,
- 13:35you don't get to put on a mask and go hassle people on the street.
- 13:38Here,
- 13:38talk about willful.
- 13:39This is what,
- 13:40what about what they did with El Salvador?
- 13:42What they decided to do is great,
- 13:44I'm happy you like it so we can debate that.
- 13:46They,
- 13:46what they did is they took a bunch of people that were here.
- 13:48They did not vet them.
- 13:50Uh,
- 13:50they decided that they decided they were gang members based on their tattoos
- 13:53and they sent them to a foreign country.
- 13:56Over the objections of a judge,
- 13:58where they put them in,
- 13:59where they put them in a gulag in another country.
- 14:01The people that were there,
- 14:02many of them we already know are not gang members.
- 14:04They were wrongfully sent.
- 14:05What did the administration do?
- 14:07They said FU to the judge,
- 14:09uh,
- 14:09when it,
- 14:10when it came out that many of the people that
- 14:11were sent to El Salvador were not gang members,
- 14:14they made fun of them,
- 14:15they attacked them.
- 14:16That's exactly what happened.
- 14:17The judge told him to stop the planes,
- 14:18and they kept flying the planes to El Salvador.
- 14:20The,
- 14:21the,
- 14:21this is an intentional effort
- 14:23to go around the law.
- 14:24Emile Bove said it,
- 14:26and,
- 14:27uh,
- 14:27you know,
- 14:27look,
- 14:27the head of,
- 14:28the head of,
- 14:29the head of the whole immigration enforcement effort took $50,000 in a cava bag,
- 14:32and this is not a group.
- 14:33I'm not sure that is interested,
- 14:34well,
- 14:35because it's not a group that's interested in the.
- 14:37Well,
- 14:37but I mean,
- 14:38again,
- 14:38I,
- 14:38I,
- 14:38I think that it has to be a distinction
- 14:41between what the president is trying to do
- 14:42broadly and then how that's practically applied.
- 14:45Yeah,
- 14:45I,
- 14:46I just think that you don't believe you're lying ICE and look at what they're doing
- 14:49over and over again.
- 14:49There are plenty of times how about let's go back to George.
- 14:52How many people,
- 14:52how many people have been deported?
- 14:54You've been eliminated.
- 14:55I'd love to go back to George.
- 15:03Roland now.
- 15:04Hi,
- 15:05what's up?
- 15:05I'm Tim.
- 15:06I'm Noel.
- 15:06Nice to meet you.
- 15:07So I wanted to ask you,
- 15:08could you define fascism for me?
- 15:10How would you,
- 15:11uh,
- 15:11yeah,
- 15:11sure,
- 15:12it is a government,
- 15:13uh,
- 15:14that,
- 15:14uh,
- 15:15cares more about the power,
- 15:17um,
- 15:17that they have than individual rights,
- 15:19right?
- 15:19It's basically
- 15:20subverting individual rights and service to the state.
- 15:23It's a great,
- 15:24uh,
- 15:25uh,
- 15:25book by a guy named Umberto Eco called.
- 15:27fascism,
- 15:28we kind of lists out the 14 elements of fascism,
- 15:30but that's the short of it.
- 15:31Individual rights don't matter.
- 15:33OK.
- 15:33And then also in your world,
- 15:35how would you like to see immigration,
- 15:37I guess,
- 15:38uh,
- 15:38how would you like to see immigration policies be applied then?
- 15:40Well,
- 15:41sure,
- 15:41I,
- 15:41I guess for starters,
- 15:42I'd like them to do what they said,
- 15:43which was go after the criminals first.
- 15:46Um,
- 15:46and I think that again,
- 15:47we have agencies to do that.
- 15:48We have the DEA,
- 15:48we have FBI,
- 15:49we have Border Patrol.
- 15:50I'd like to start with that.
- 15:51I think that we should,
- 15:52uh,
- 15:53give a pathway to citizenship.
- 15:54Obviously people that were brought here as kids
- 15:56think it's insane to suggest otherwise.
- 15:58I think people that have been here for a long time,
- 16:00that have been following the rules,
- 16:02paying their taxes,
- 16:03learning English,
- 16:04uh,
- 16:05should get a pathway to citizenship.
- 16:06And then I think that the other folks that are more in the gray area,
- 16:10I,
- 16:10I,
- 16:10I forget it was the first,
- 16:11it was the first guy who came up and said,
- 16:13uh,
- 16:13knock on the door and say,
- 16:14hey,
- 16:14Mr.
- 16:14illegal,
- 16:14could you get out?
- 16:16That seems like what to do kind of in a free,
- 16:18fair country,
- 16:18like go up to the door,
- 16:19knock on the door and say,
- 16:20hey,
- 16:21Mr.
- 16:21Lopez,
- 16:22sorry,
- 16:22you didn't meet these metrics.
- 16:23You have 4 months to get back to your home country,
- 16:26and then if they continue to break the law,
- 16:28or you,
- 16:28you can appeal this,
- 16:29you can go to asylum.
- 16:31If they continue to break the law,
- 16:32then sure,
- 16:33then you can send in law enforcement.
- 16:34And again,
- 16:35we have CBP and a bunch of other enforcement agencies that could do that.
- 16:37That's just a humane way to deal with this that I think probably has 80% support.
- 16:41Yeah,
- 16:41and I think sensible conservatives would actually agree with a
- 16:44lot of what you said of a pathway to citizenship.
- 16:47I guess I don't,
- 16:48I don't think some of your pals would.
- 16:50Do we have any pathway to citizenship?
- 16:51I think that's,
- 16:53I would say that a pathway to citizenship for those who
- 16:55are working here for a long time and for those who
- 16:58follow.
- 16:58The legal process because you can't cut in line because that's
- 17:00not fair to other people who have been trying to.
- 17:03I have a lot of family as well who came in right and so if you cut in line,
- 17:06it kind of devalues everyone who took out maybe loans or
- 17:09borrowed money to try to get into the country legally.
- 17:11You can't get in the country legally,
- 17:12no,
- 17:13but still,
- 17:14there's there are no legal pathways unless you're a white South African.
- 17:17That's not necessarily a South African you can get in here.
- 17:20I have family who's fine.
- 17:21I have family.
- 17:22I'm Mexican.
- 17:22during the Trump Trump administration,
- 17:24not during the they've changed the policy.
- 17:25a lot of this administration.
- 17:27We're gonna have negative net that just means that people just come in,
- 17:29that people just break the law.
- 17:30No,
- 17:30we're gonna have negative net.
- 17:32We're gonna have negative net migration in this country this year.
- 17:34The only countries that have that are like Venezuela,
- 17:37Syria,
- 17:39African countries,
- 17:39the United States.
- 17:40If I can,
- 17:40can I,
- 17:41can I address your claim specifically on fascism,
- 17:43because fascism historically has been going after
- 17:46people who politically disagree with you.
- 17:47And what we're seeing right now,
- 17:49they're doing what we're seeing right now though is we're,
- 17:51and I don't.
- 17:53I would say that everyone should be treated with human dignity,
- 17:55everyone,
- 17:56regardless of your immigration status.
- 17:58But that being said,
- 17:59I can still enforce a law and treat someone with human dignity,
- 18:03and I'm not,
- 18:03I'm not saying,
- 18:04I'm not saying that everything that ICE is doing is OK.
- 18:06That's,
- 18:07but my just generally I think that they're treating people with dignity,
- 18:09my concern about specifically,
- 18:10I'd like to address the fascism claim that you made,
- 18:13specifically the fascism,
- 18:14because we've seen even,
- 18:15for example,
- 18:16Charlie Kirk last month was shot.
- 18:18And killed.
- 18:19And so what happens when we use inflammatory flames like fascists,
- 18:22it paints people a certain way.
- 18:24But here's the thing,
- 18:25if they don't want to be that's like me saying,
- 18:26that's like me saying if you want lax border policies,
- 18:28then you're an anarchist.
- 18:29It's a false equivalency.
- 18:31It doesn't the right doesn't add up.
- 18:33Someone can communists and enemy within it all the time.
- 18:36You do this,
- 18:36then that's I'm just saying,
- 18:37look,
- 18:37look,
- 18:38that's not look,
- 18:38if they don't want to be called fascists,
- 18:39they shouldn't act like fascists.
- 18:40I just think that if this was not this country,
- 18:42if you saw.
- 18:43Cars with masked masked people hassling and all
- 18:47look at the story of Nar Narciso Branco.
- 18:50He's gardening outside an IHOP.
- 18:52A bunch of masked agents come out.
- 18:54He's an old man.
- 18:55A bunch of masked agents come out,
- 18:56hassle him,
- 18:58uh,
- 18:58uh,
- 18:59tackle him to the ground.
- 19:00He's got 3 kids who are in the Marines in a fascist.
- 19:02He gets,
- 19:03why,
- 19:03like why would we do that?
- 19:05That's obviously fascist.
- 19:06How else would you describe it?
- 19:07I'm not saying that's OK.
- 19:08What I'm saying.
- 19:08Is that in a fascist country?
- 19:10And yes,
- 19:11I would say that's not treating someone with human dignity,
- 19:12and I believe that everyone is worthy of human dignity.
- 19:15But what I am saying is that in a fascist,
- 19:18could I finish?
- 19:19In a fascist country,
- 19:20some
- 19:21political dissent is repressed,
- 19:23so all of the media is controlled by the government.
- 19:25So we still,
- 19:26even though there's polarizing rhetoric,
- 19:28rhetoric,
- 19:28we still have
- 19:29ways for people to express their opinion.
- 19:31We still have ways for people to appeal to.
- 19:34Civil systems and they can still
- 19:36appeal for
- 19:38mistreatment by ICE agents.
- 19:39And so I think that's super important
- 19:40because when we're calling people fascists blatantly,
- 19:43that's what fuels political violence.
- 19:45That's what causes people like Charlie Kirk to
- 19:47be killed because we're calling people Nazis,
- 19:49we're calling people fascists.
- 19:50That would be wrong if I went around calling every Democrat communist.
- 19:53Well,
- 19:54I agree with you that we're not a fascist country yet.
- 19:55What the claim was that is that ICE is becoming a fascist institution.
- 19:59And,
- 19:59and to that point,
- 20:00the one thing that you said in that sentence that is just not true
- 20:03is that victims of ICE cannot contest their claims.
- 20:06Uh,
- 20:06if they get deported back to Honduras,
- 20:08they don't have a legal pathway.
- 20:10They're,
- 20:10they're a US citizen.
- 20:11There were kids.
- 20:12There was a baby that had a,
- 20:14a disease,
- 20:15like a rare kidney disease.
- 20:16It was a 5 year old
- 20:17that got that is a US citizen,
- 20:19got deported with his mother back to Honduras.
- 20:21The mother wanted him to stay so he could get medicine.
- 20:24That 5 year old doesn't have a legal remedy.
- 20:26They're stuck.
- 20:27The gay hairdresser,
- 20:28I'm sorry,
- 20:28that we sent to a gulag in El Salvador,
- 20:30he doesn't have a legal remedy.
- 20:32They don't have legal remedies to the prison system in El Salvador?
- 20:34No,
- 20:34no,
- 20:34no,
- 20:35we sent like 200 Venezuelans to El Salvador,
- 20:37claims that they were gang members,
- 20:39and,
- 20:39and one of them,
- 20:40I did an interview with him,
- 20:41Andre Hernandez Romero.
- 20:42He's a gay hairdresser.
- 20:43Unless he was doing the makeup for Trendo Aragua,
- 20:46he was not in a gang.
- 20:47I don't.
- 20:48With the way that he doesn't have any redress.
- 20:50I don't agree with the way that ICE is approaching,
- 20:53approaching the immigration system.
- 20:54I'm with you there.
- 20:55I don't agree with it.
- 20:56I don't agree with sending American citizens without due process.
- 20:58I'm with you.
- 20:59My concern specifically is using the rhetoric
- 21:02of fascists because it fuels political violence.
- 21:04That is my concern.
- 21:05It's OK to disagree,
- 21:07but I don't think that that is an equivalency to Nazi Germany.
- 21:10I just don't.
- 21:11I don't either.
- 21:12Thank you so much.
- 21:13Thank you.
- 21:18My next claim is it is not worth the cost of gun deaths every year
- 21:22to have the 2nd Amendment.
- 21:28Oh,
- 21:30all right,
- 21:30well,
- 21:30first you made the claim,
- 21:32so I wanna hear your reasoning behind it.
- 21:33Well,
- 21:34yeah,
- 21:34obviously this is a reference to the,
- 21:36uh,
- 21:36Charlie Kirk quote about how it was worth,
- 21:38um,
- 21:38uh,
- 21:39some gun deaths every year to have the Second Amendment as it's currently written,
- 21:42and my view is this.
- 21:43Look,
- 21:43I'm not,
- 21:43this is not an argument to repeal the Second Amendment.
- 21:45My point is that we shouldn't have a fatalistic view about this,
- 21:48to just say we have the Second Amendment.
- 21:50Nothing we can do now.
- 21:52Some people are gonna die because of it,
- 21:53and so we've just,
- 21:55that's just the price of freedom.
- 21:56For example,
- 21:56in Canada,
- 21:58you have,
- 21:58you have a right to bear arms still,
- 21:59but it's like
- 22:00you have to get a license.
- 22:01You,
- 22:02there has to be training,
- 22:03you know,
- 22:03you have to,
- 22:04um,
- 22:05pass background checks.
- 22:06Is that not
- 22:07also in the United States too?
- 22:09No.
- 22:10You don't have,
- 22:11you don't need a gun license.
- 22:12Well,
- 22:12no,
- 22:12you do,
- 22:13but no,
- 22:13what I'm saying is it's not like a driver's license.
- 22:15Like you,
- 22:15you don't have to like go to a when you're getting a driver's license here.
- 22:18It's more akin to what you do in Canada.
- 22:20You have to go to classes.
- 22:21You have to,
- 22:21you don't have to,
- 22:22you know,
- 22:23you don't,
- 22:23you have to prove,
- 22:24you have to prove that you have to know how to use the guns.
- 22:26Like there is a process.
- 22:28There's no process in the United States.
- 22:29Well,
- 22:29in a lot of cases you don't have to go through a process.
- 22:31Sure,
- 22:32people have easy access to guns in this country without going through the process.
- 22:35There,
- 22:35um,
- 22:35is easy access for.
- 22:37Younger people to get high to get high powered weapons.
- 22:40That's definitely not true.
- 22:41But can,
- 22:42can you,
- 22:42can you name the legislation that would have
- 22:45prevented
- 22:46Charlie Kirk from,
- 22:47uh,
- 22:48being assassinated?
- 22:49Well,
- 22:49I,
- 22:49no,
- 22:50because I don't,
- 22:50there wouldn't have been a piece of legislation that
- 22:52could have prevented Charlie Kirk from being assassinated.
- 22:54My point is that his initial claim
- 22:57was in service of this idea that we have a maximalist view of the Second Amendment
- 23:00where there is nothing that we can do to limit gun deaths.
- 23:03In the United States,
- 23:04we had 46,000 just let me say this in the
- 23:07United States we had 46,000 gun deaths in 2023.
- 23:11In Japan they had 10,
- 23:13and in France they had 800 and something.
- 23:15So like
- 23:16there is obviously many things that we could do to change the cultures,
- 23:20the rules,
- 23:21the laws,
- 23:21and the mores of this country
- 23:23to not have the gun deaths that we do.
- 23:25I don't think statistics of these other countries.
- 23:27I,
- 23:27I kind of doubt that there's Japan is 1010.
- 23:30You're not giving me really any piece of legislation that would
- 23:33actually fix these things unless you're talking about the abolition.
- 23:37of the Second Amendment,
- 23:38which we can get into that,
- 23:40and the majority of these gun deaths are handguns.
- 23:42I mean,
- 23:42let's be honest here,
- 23:43they're handguns and they're suicide,
- 23:45right?
- 23:45So if we limit that number,
- 23:47if we actually take that into account,
- 23:49it,
- 23:50it's not really looking as bad as,
- 23:52well,
- 23:52it's it,
- 23:53I mean,
- 23:53no,
- 23:53it's looking pretty bad again,
- 23:5446,000 versus 10,
- 23:55is a pretty big gap.
- 23:56Um,
- 23:57OK,
- 23:57but how many,
- 23:58what percentage of,
- 23:59I think about half of them are suicides,
- 24:00and what percentage of that is handguns.
- 24:03Are you,
- 24:04are you advocating,
- 24:04no,
- 24:04a bunch of,
- 24:05a bunch of,
- 24:05a bunch of handguns.
- 24:06Can I,
- 24:06I,
- 24:06I'd like to answer this.
- 24:07I think it's an important question
- 24:09because,
- 24:09um,
- 24:10a hand,
- 24:11a suicide attempt via handgun,
- 24:13now I'm going from memory,
- 24:14so these stats might not be exactly right,
- 24:15but it's something like if you try to kill yourself with a handgun,
- 24:17you get,
- 24:18you get.
- 24:18Get it right,
- 24:18like 9 out of 10 times,
- 24:19basically,
- 24:20right?
- 24:20If you try to kill yourself using a lot of other
- 24:23methods,
- 24:24if people try to kill themselves,
- 24:25a lot of times it doesn't work,
- 24:26right?
- 24:26And so it's,
- 24:26so,
- 24:27so it increases the number of suicides in our country
- 24:29versus other countries because people have easy access to firearms.
- 24:32Our,
- 24:32in our country,
- 24:33The next,
- 24:34the amount of firearms we have in this country.
- 24:36The next closest country is Yemen.
- 24:38We have double the amount of them.
- 24:40Tell me what policy proposals are you proposing that would actually limit this?
- 24:44I,
- 24:44I,
- 24:45well,
- 24:45you can't give me a policy proposal.
- 24:47Well,
- 24:47that we don't already have.
- 24:48No,
- 24:49I can give you a bunch that I,
- 24:50that I would be for.
- 24:50I think we'd go back to the 90s assault weapons ban.
- 24:52I think we should limit high capacity magazines.
- 24:54I think.
- 24:55Assault rifle ban,
- 24:56would any of those have stopped the mass?
- 24:57Yeah,
- 24:58well,
- 24:58yes,
- 24:58I guess that's my point.
- 24:59You keep saying no,
- 25:00this is your,
- 25:01you are on the side of we should just give up.
- 25:03There's nothing we can do.
- 25:04I'm saying we're the only country where this happens.
- 25:06You haven't even asked me my position,
- 25:07so that's not true.
- 25:08All right,
- 25:08so I mean,
- 25:09you're trying to refute my.
- 25:10I,
- 25:10I can see,
- 25:10I can know,
- 25:11I can see a case.
- 25:12I can see a case for like universal background checks and things like that,
- 25:15but ultimately,
- 25:16right.
- 25:16The pros of guns,
- 25:17I would say,
- 25:18outweigh the cons of guns.
- 25:20Really?
- 25:20Yes,
- 25:21absolutely,
- 25:21you're obviously more at risk of death if you have a gun.
- 25:23We'd all be less safer if everybody had a gun right now.
- 25:25Would you feel,
- 25:26would you feel,
- 25:26would you feel more or less safe if everybody had a gun in here right now?
- 25:29I would feel plenty safe if I had a more safe.
- 25:32Yes,
- 25:32if I had a gun coming to a debating show,
- 25:34you'd feel more safe if there were 20 youth carrying guns.
- 25:39You've been eliminated by the group.
- 25:43Hey,
- 25:43Hank job.
- 25:44Thank you.
- 25:52Hey man,
- 25:53what's up?
- 25:53What's up,
- 25:54Tim,
- 25:54right?
- 25:54Yeah,
- 25:54Tim,
- 25:55Dylan,
- 25:55nice to meet you.
- 25:56You packing?
- 25:57No,
- 25:57I'm not packing right now.
- 25:58Good.
- 25:59We're in California.
- 26:00Good,
- 26:00better,
- 26:01you know,
- 26:01just making sure.
- 26:02OK,
- 26:02well,
- 26:03are,
- 26:03are
- 26:04annual car debts
- 26:05worth keeping cars in society?
- 26:07I'm glad,
- 26:07I'm glad you brought up the cars.
- 26:09Uh,
- 26:09with,
- 26:10with car deaths,
- 26:11obviously,
- 26:11you know,
- 26:11we're not going to go back to horses.
- 26:12People need cars,
- 26:14uh,
- 26:14to,
- 26:14to,
- 26:15you know,
- 26:15so they're positive to society,
- 26:17right?
- 26:17I would say the cars are,
- 26:18but here's some other things you have with cars.
- 26:20Here's some other,
- 26:21here's some other things you have with cars.
- 26:22I think they are.
- 26:22You have.
- 26:23But there's a million laws related to
- 26:25to cars to try to minimize car deaths.
- 26:27You have seat like laws you have,
- 26:30you have speed limits,
- 26:31making it illegal to,
- 26:32to do DUIs.
- 26:34So,
- 26:34so my point is
- 26:36that I think that on the right
- 26:37there are a lot of people that,
- 26:38that want to take the maximalist view of the Second Amendment.
- 26:41Should we ban supercars because they go faster or something,
- 26:44because that would be the argument for like an assault rifle.
- 26:47I don't want to ban supercars.
- 26:48I don't think.
- 26:49I don't.
- 26:49I don't know,
- 26:50but,
- 26:50um,
- 26:50uh,
- 26:50my point is that
- 26:52if we regulated guns in the manner in which we regulated cars,
- 26:55that'd be a good step.
- 26:56I,
- 26:56I think we'd probably have less than 46,000 total gun deaths next year if
- 27:00we did that and get a license for that to get a gun.
- 27:02You have to do certain things to be able to purchase firearms.
- 27:05Yeah,
- 27:05but again,
- 27:06it's,
- 27:06it is,
- 27:06it's completely incomparable to the types of things you have to
- 27:09do to get a driver's license to drive a car.
- 27:11They're,
- 27:12they're,
- 27:12well,
- 27:12actually cars have tons of driver's licenses,
- 27:15cars.
- 27:15Tons of cars have a bunch of safety checks,
- 27:18uh,
- 27:18you know,
- 27:19there are,
- 27:19there are,
- 27:19there are tons of things we do to try to mitigate deaths via cars.
- 27:23Like,
- 27:23I,
- 27:23this,
- 27:23this,
- 27:24this analogy just doesn't make any sense.
- 27:26Like what I'm trying,
- 27:26what I'm saying,
- 27:27what I'm saying is that what we're,
- 27:28what we want to do
- 27:30is figure out ways to limit the amount of gun deaths.
- 27:32I'm not happy with the fact.
- 27:34Are you happy with the number of gun deaths we have in this country?
- 27:36Do you?
- 27:37OK,
- 27:37so like,
- 27:37are you satisfied that like we have way more than any other country in the world.
- 27:41We have.
- 27:42Do,
- 27:42do people have bad hearts in other countries?
- 27:44I think they have better hearts.
- 27:46Do they have better hearts than us.
- 27:47Every person in the world is inherently bad by nature.
- 27:49OK,
- 27:50so then why do we have the most gun deaths here?
- 27:52Because
- 27:53the wrong people are getting guns.
- 27:55You don't think bad people get guns in Yemen
- 27:58or in France or in
- 27:59other places.
- 28:00I like our country is the only place where this is happening.
- 28:03Pause.
- 28:03You've been eliminated by the group.
- 28:05Well,
- 28:05thank you,
- 28:06man.
- 28:06I had to bring it up.
- 28:07Thank you.
- 28:12How's it going?
- 28:13Hi,
- 28:13my name is Hannah.
- 28:14So I want to address,
- 28:15um,
- 28:16the claim.
- 28:16First of all,
- 28:17I want to clarify,
- 28:17you are not in favor of abolishing or confiscating guns,
- 28:21correct?
- 28:22Um,
- 28:22I'm not in favor of abolishing the Second Amendment.
- 28:24I,
- 28:24I could potentially be in favor of a
- 28:26gun buyback situation where it's voluntary for sure.
- 28:28OK,
- 28:29OK,
- 28:29right.
- 28:30So I also want to talk about,
- 28:31um,
- 28:32you talked about there's other problems that are facing America,
- 28:34not only that there's more guns,
- 28:35and that's why there's more gun violence,
- 28:37correct?
- 28:38No,
- 28:38I think the problem,
- 28:39I think there's more gun violence in America because there's more guns.
- 28:41I think it's pretty simple to understand.
- 28:43Uh,
- 28:43there's not.
- 28:44Uh,
- 28:45they don't have anywhere near,
- 28:46we don't have anywhere near this level of gun death in any other country in the world,
- 28:49um,
- 28:50uh,
- 28:50any other,
- 28:51uh,
- 28:51first world country,
- 28:52basically any West Western country.
- 28:54That if you're under 18,
- 28:55the most likely way you're going to die in this country is by gun deaths.
- 28:59That is not equivalent in other in other similar Western nations,
- 29:03so I think it's basically the guns.
- 29:04Yeah,
- 29:04OK,
- 29:05so more guns equals more,
- 29:07more gun violence.
- 29:08I want,
- 29:08I,
- 29:09I want to address that claim by first of all bringing up how
- 29:12the majority,
- 29:12or at least almost 50% of all homicides caused from guns
- 29:17are in cities where the.
- 29:18Uh,
- 29:19gun per capita is much lower than the rest of the country.
- 29:24So,
- 29:25and,
- 29:25and secondly,
- 29:25I'd like to bring up that from the,
- 29:27from 1990s to the early 2000s,
- 29:30we had a major decrease in homicides by guns,
- 29:34but we had an increase of guns by nearly 50%.
- 29:37So the other thing I'd like to,
- 29:39we had an assault weapons ban during that time.
- 29:40I,
- 29:41I guess the,
- 29:41the,
- 29:42the stats in the cities,
- 29:42this is kind of a funny.
- 29:43Thing,
- 29:43um,
- 29:44and I'm glad somebody brought this up because,
- 29:46uh,
- 29:47the,
- 29:47the pro-gun side in this country is always trying to like cut
- 29:50and dissect the,
- 29:51the demographics down.
- 29:52They're like,
- 29:52OK,
- 29:53so there was a higher percentage in this city or
- 29:56among this type of person or among this demographic.
- 29:59Uh,
- 29:59the only reason you can do that kind of statistics is
- 30:02because we have so many freaking gun deaths in this country.
- 30:04Again,
- 30:04there were 10 in Japan
- 30:06in 2023.
- 30:07There were 10.
- 30:08In Australia there were 236.
- 30:10Yeah,
- 30:10I'm in,
- 30:11in,
- 30:11in,
- 30:11in France there were 887.
- 30:13We had 46,000.
- 30:14I like,
- 30:15I don't,
- 30:15so
- 30:16it seems pretty obvious.
- 30:17I,
- 30:17I,
- 30:17I don't know why we have to come up with other
- 30:19convoluted reasons why we have all these deaths in this,
- 30:21right?
- 30:21So I think that there are a few reasons.
- 30:23First of all,
- 30:23I think that fatherless homes is a big part of it.
- 30:25Um,
- 30:26in America we have
- 30:27the highest rate of any country in the world of,
- 30:31um,
- 30:31of one single parent.
- 30:33Households,
- 30:33the majority of those being without fathers.
- 30:36Also,
- 30:3676% of people who commit violent acts come from fatherless homes.
- 30:41Additionally,
- 30:41I think a second problem that we have
- 30:43is,
- 30:44is releasing criminals back into the street.
- 30:46It's our,
- 30:47it's our criminal justice system.
- 30:48The majority,
- 30:4976% of people that cause,
- 30:51that
- 30:52have violent crimes in the United States have a criminal record of some sort,
- 30:55whether that be an arrest,
- 30:56a conviction.
- 30:58Whatever,
- 30:58so it's,
- 30:59we need to stop releasing people back to the streets.
- 31:01And then third,
- 31:02I also want to
- 31:04address your claim that nothing,
- 31:05that there's this attitude that nothing else can be done.
- 31:08I,
- 31:08I disagree with that.
- 31:09So I want,
- 31:09I want to point out,
- 31:10so,
- 31:11so,
- 31:11so,
- 31:12so,
- 31:12so I wanna,
- 31:12I wanna go back to my point
- 31:14about the 76% of people having a criminal record.
- 31:18If you have a criminal record in the United States,
- 31:20you cannot leave.
- 31:20Legally purchased a gun,
- 31:21right?
- 31:21So we can agree that if you have a criminal record,
- 31:23you're not obtaining these guns legally.
- 31:25The rest of them,
- 31:26which are like the school shooters and the mass shooters,
- 31:29they are getting their guns legally.
- 31:30However,
- 31:31these are people suicides,
- 31:32is the domestic violence deaths.
- 31:34And look,
- 31:35there are a lot of other,
- 31:35again,
- 31:36but again,
- 31:36like,
- 31:36look,
- 31:3725% of the gun deaths in this country,
- 31:39you're making me do math live would still have been like 11,000 gun deaths.
- 31:43That's still
- 31:45100 times more
- 31:47than
- 31:47uh in uh in Western European countries.
- 31:49I,
- 31:50I just look,
- 31:50I hear you.
- 31:51I think that that dads should be in the homes.
- 31:53I,
- 31:53I,
- 31:54I think that we shouldn't,
- 31:55um,
- 31:55you know,
- 31:56violent criminals.
- 31:56I think we should keep behind bars,
- 31:58uh,
- 31:59but that is like that there,
- 32:01that is not
- 32:02like the reason
- 32:03that we have this problem.
- 32:04Like I,
- 32:04I'm a dad,
- 32:05I'm in the home.
- 32:06I have to worry that my kid,
- 32:08when they go to school,
- 32:09the school's gonna get shot up.
- 32:10A person that lives in the Netherlands doesn't have to have that worry,
- 32:13and it's not because of the number of fatherless homes in the country.
- 32:16I,
- 32:17well,
- 32:17OK,
- 32:18I,
- 32:18I disagree that that's still the case,
- 32:20that it's not a cultural thing
- 32:21for one.
- 32:22I'd also like to talk about the school shootings for one.
- 32:24I am
- 32:26myself 100% in favor of having armed guards at schools.
- 32:28I think that
- 32:30we need to get people,
- 32:30we need to get criminals Columbine.
- 32:32No.
- 32:33Was there an armed guard at Parkland?
- 32:34Yes,
- 32:35oh yes,
- 32:35I don't,
- 32:35yes,
- 32:36yes.
- 32:36Do you remember what happened in Uvalde?
- 32:38Do you remember what happened in Uvalde?
- 32:40The cops,
- 32:40they,
- 32:41these were the most militarized police you have ever seen in your life,
- 32:45and they showed up to the school,
- 32:46and,
- 32:47uh,
- 32:47there were cops everywhere
- 32:49and little babies were getting murdered,
- 32:51and they didn't,
- 32:52they couldn't do anything about it.
- 32:53There was an armed guard at Parkland who,
- 32:55who ran away from the school.
- 32:56Like one armed guard is not gonna do anything.
- 32:59Door locks aren't gonna do anything.
- 33:01At Columbine.
- 33:01I grew up a mile from.
- 33:02Columbine.
- 33:03The,
- 33:03the,
- 33:03the deaths that happened in Columbine,
- 33:05people talk about all these things.
- 33:06A lot of it was people were coming outside for lunch,
- 33:10you know,
- 33:10and you can't
- 33:12like put these schools all behind fortresses.
- 33:14It's just,
- 33:14it's just not realistic.
- 33:16So I'm not really,
- 33:17I'm,
- 33:17I have thought a little bit about the,
- 33:19the,
- 33:19the practical implications of this,
- 33:21right?
- 33:21I've done a little bit of mental math and the budgeting and everything.
- 33:24It's more than just one armed guard for one,
- 33:26and it's not,
- 33:27it's,
- 33:27it's,
- 33:28this could be as
- 33:29like cops sitting outside of armed guards of need.
- 33:33Mhm.
- 33:42Whoa,
- 33:43hey,
- 33:43what's up?
- 33:43Hi,
- 33:43nice to meet you,
- 33:44sir.
- 33:44Nice to meet you.
- 33:45I would disagree with your point on that,
- 33:47um,
- 33:48there isn't
- 33:49many restrictions in America for obtaining firearms.
- 33:53I just two weeks ago was in a 5 hour class regarding training of firearms,
- 33:57and I believe that those are actually required.
- 34:00Specifically in California,
- 34:01you have to obtain a CCW.
- 34:03Rules are different in California.
- 34:04Yes,
- 34:04rules are different in California.
- 34:05That's correct.
- 34:06Um,
- 34:06I lived in Texas for
- 34:08last year.
- 34:08Of my life and there are still
- 34:10a significant amount of restrictions and regulations and requirements
- 34:14for obtaining firearms in those states
- 34:16and specifically in Texas,
- 34:17where there's a lot more
- 34:19people in firearms in those more rural areas.
- 34:21I personally
- 34:22felt a lot safer.
- 34:23I understand that's different
- 34:25person to person.
- 34:25Yeah,
- 34:26I mean,
- 34:26like you can't rent a car in this country if you're 24
- 34:29and you can buy a handgun,
- 34:31in every state.
- 34:32Uh,
- 34:32you can buy,
- 34:33well,
- 34:33at 24,
- 34:33you can buy an ass.
- 34:34Weapon in every state.
- 34:35Um,
- 34:3618 year olds can buy guns in some states,
- 34:38uh,
- 34:38in this country,
- 34:39uh,
- 34:40can't buy a beer,
- 34:41can't buy a zin.
- 34:43Like they're literally states where you can't,
- 34:45you can't get a zin,
- 34:46but you can buy a weapon.
- 34:47It's crazy.
- 34:48So you just,
- 34:48I'm sorry,
- 34:48you just can't tell me that like the,
- 34:50the,
- 34:50the,
- 34:51the rules for getting guns in this country are as strict as they could be.
- 34:54Like we could obviously add some more rules.
- 34:55We can at least give,
- 34:56we can at least give the,
- 34:57you know,
- 34:58do the zin standard,
- 34:59I would say,
- 35:00um,
- 35:00I think would be fair.
- 35:02At a minimum,
- 35:03I,
- 35:03or the,
- 35:03I,
- 35:03I would go with the renting car standard.
- 35:05I,
- 35:05I don't know.
- 35:0625 you guys would not be probably thrilled about that,
- 35:08but
- 35:09I don't know.
- 35:09Yeah,
- 35:10I don't know why people need an AR-15 if they're 24.
- 35:13I,
- 35:13I,
- 35:13that's just for me.
- 35:15There's hunting rifles.
- 35:16There's a difference between hunting rifles and
- 35:17Armorite rifles that that is the case,
- 35:19and there's different reasons behind those,
- 35:21um,
- 35:22but no,
- 35:22I don't,
- 35:23I disagree with that.
- 35:24Just
- 35:24saying.
- 35:26Yeah,
- 35:27thank you.
- 35:27Thanks,
- 35:27man,
- 35:27good to meet you speak with you.
- 35:37So,
- 35:37um,
- 35:37I just wanted to bring up your claim about how you said in certain places like
- 35:41an 18 year old can own a gun,
- 35:43can't do all these things.
- 35:44Would you consider the fact that their life might,
- 35:46they might be in more dangerous places or live by themselves in which
- 35:48they feel that they need to purchase a firearm to be protected?
- 35:51I myself are a 20 year old.
- 35:52If I lived by myself
- 35:54and a 200 pound man comes in trying to rob my home,
- 35:57I feel that if I had a firearm,
- 35:58first of all,
- 35:59if.
- 36:00If
- 36:00they were to think that firearms can be owned by
- 36:04anybody,
- 36:04that reduces the
- 36:05amount of them coming into my home in the first place.
- 36:07And second of all,
- 36:08if I were to have a gun,
- 36:09that is the ultimate equalizer.
- 36:11I cannot fight a 200 pound man off.
- 36:13And
- 36:13for me it,
- 36:14it kind of braces the security.
- 36:16I might be able to.
- 36:18OK,
- 36:18look,
- 36:18here's the thing,
- 36:19I,
- 36:20I understand that some people are going to want to have guns for their protection.
- 36:23Um,
- 36:24I,
- 36:24I understand that that makes people feel safer,
- 36:27uh,
- 36:28in a free country that you want to,
- 36:30you know,
- 36:30within certain limits want people to be able to do things that they
- 36:34feel like they need to do to protect themselves.
- 36:35I,
- 36:35I get all that.
- 36:36But here's the thing,
- 36:37like,
- 36:37the facts just don't bear that out.
- 36:39Like if you have a gun in the home,
- 36:41you're 500,
- 36:42500% more likely
- 36:44to
- 36:45be killed by that gun than you,
- 36:47than than if somebody that doesn't have a gun in the home.
- 36:49much more likely if I live in a city where,
- 36:51like in here in Los Angeles,
- 36:53I could
- 36:53present you with in 10 to 12 miles from here,
- 36:55you can go and buy a 3D printed gun for cash
- 36:58anywhere.
- 36:58There are several places where you can do that.
- 36:59And in a place like this,
- 37:00I feel that I would need to protect myself individually.
- 37:02And whenever there's government outreach and they take.
- 37:05The rights away from people and they take
- 37:07the rights from guns.
- 37:08The gun violence is higher.
- 37:09It is actually not lower.
- 37:10And again,
- 37:11that's just not true.
- 37:12Like again,
- 37:13in this country,
- 37:14I know,
- 37:14in this,
- 37:14again,
- 37:15I,
- 37:15I just,
- 37:16I,
- 37:16I,
- 37:16I have one of the people,
- 37:17maybe it'll be you,
- 37:18we have 3 minutes left,
- 37:19will come up here and explain to me how Japan only had 10 gun deaths.
- 37:22Like I,
- 37:22I just,
- 37:23it isn't,
- 37:23it isn't,
- 37:24it isn't,
- 37:24it is a way bigger population density that
- 37:26is much more proportionate than Japan than Japan.
- 37:28We,
- 37:28we have a very big,
- 37:29more wide country,
- 37:3010 to 46.
- 37:32They only have really one major city rather than Australia.
- 37:34Had 236.
- 37:36Australia had 236.
- 37:38France had 800.
- 37:39So like,
- 37:39we're the only country where this happens.
- 37:41It is,
- 37:41it doesn't make people safer.
- 37:42I'm sorry.
- 37:43I understand that people might want to feel like it does.
- 37:45So what do you,
- 37:45but having all these guns in this country aren't the people safe individually.
- 37:48How,
- 37:48how,
- 37:49how do you think that people are going to
- 37:50keep themselves safe individually in their own homes?
- 37:53If,
- 37:53if I call the police and somebody is trying to attack me,
- 37:56I have no time.
- 37:57Sure,
- 37:57again,
- 37:57I have no time.
- 37:59Well,
- 37:59for starters,
- 37:59I would do education.
- 38:00I think if people want to have a gun in their home,
- 38:02want to keep it locked,
- 38:03want to keep it in a safe,
- 38:03that's.
- 38:04I'm for that.
- 38:05Again,
- 38:05I'm for you doing that if you want.
- 38:06I'm just telling you the facts is you're much
- 38:08more likely to accidentally kill yourself with a gun
- 38:10than you are to you would kill and that legislation
- 38:12in that classes and those educations to not do that.
- 38:15So that is in place.
- 38:16So if you rightfully by,
- 38:17by law,
- 38:18if you,
- 38:19if you,
- 38:20if you own lawfully,
- 38:20if you own a gun lawfully,
- 38:21you will make sure that you have the education and
- 38:23steps you need to not kill yourself with that gun.
- 38:26The claim is that we,
- 38:27so again,
- 38:28this seems a lot of us seem to agree on this stuff.
- 38:29The claim is that
- 38:31is that it's not worth the cost of some gun.
- 38:33Deaths to
- 38:34not do anything to restrict matter to the Second Amendment when you,
- 38:37when you give out freedom,
- 38:38there are going to be,
- 38:39there are going to be
- 38:40marginalized
- 38:42parts where things,
- 38:43mistakes are going to happen.
- 38:43There are going to be bad things.
- 38:44That's like it's would you consider that if you're going
- 38:46to kill yourself with that gun like you mentioned homicide,
- 38:48how about instead of trying to take guns away,
- 38:51would you
- 38:52rather give maybe that funding or some sort of
- 38:54set up some sort of mental health system that can I love mental health funding.
- 38:57Who's for more mental health funding in here?
- 38:59And uh,
- 38:59oh really?
- 39:00Everybody,
- 39:00why don't why aren't any.
- 39:02Elected officials for that.
- 39:04There,
- 39:04there are plenty.
- 39:05They're not in red states.
- 39:07In red states they're slashing mental health I'm trying to make is,
- 39:10is if we have a drunk driver that crashes because they're drunk,
- 39:12are we going to ban cars?
- 39:13No,
- 39:14we are going to focus on you're going to make drunk driving illegal,
- 39:17but you're going to make drunk driving illegal.
- 39:18Yes,
- 39:19exactly,
- 39:19and it is illegal,
- 39:20but we are not going to make guns illegal
- 39:22because certain people do certain things with them.
- 39:24Are we going to ban cars for everybody else because one
- 39:26person does one wrong you're going to make drunk driving illegal.
- 39:28I already,
- 39:28we already went through this with the other guy.
- 39:30There are a lot of restrictions that you can have.
- 39:33Thank you,
- 39:33good to meet you.
- 39:40Nice.
- 39:41What's up,
- 39:42Isaac?
- 39:42Good to meet you.
- 39:44Um,
- 39:44I wanna go back to what someone else brought up earlier that it's not a gun problem,
- 39:48it's a heart problem.
- 39:49You keep going to this fact of Japan only has 10 gun deaths.
- 39:52How many stabbing deaths do they have?
- 39:53How many car deaths do they have?
- 39:55How many suicide deaths do they have?
- 39:56They still exist,
- 39:57less,
- 39:57yeah,
- 39:57of course.
- 39:58And so we already are at a point to mitigate harm.
- 40:01OK,
- 40:01yes,
- 40:02we're at a point in this country where there are more guns than people.
- 40:03We can't go backwards.
- 40:04We can only go forward.
- 40:05These are the cards that we've been dealt with
- 40:07and so you can look at
- 40:08Japan,
- 40:09you can look at Germany,
- 40:10which has
- 40:11a lot of gun deaths and stabbing deaths,
- 40:13uh,
- 40:13France,
- 40:13the UK,
- 40:14uh,
- 40:14Nicaragua,
- 40:15tens of thousands of people are getting slaughtered.
- 40:16Are you trying to be Nicaragua?
- 40:18No,
- 40:18um,
- 40:18what I'm getting to the point is it's not a gun problem,
- 40:21it's a heart problem,
- 40:21and frankly it's a lack of having
- 40:23Jesus in your heart problem because
- 40:25we as a society,
- 40:26yes.
- 40:27We as a society and globally
- 40:29have gotten rid of the moral givers,
- 40:31so there's no morals behind what we do.
- 40:33There's a lot of violence and there's a lot of
- 40:34reason for someone to do something if they don't see
- 40:37each other in the Imago day that were fearfully and wonderfully made.
- 40:40When we eliminate that from the picture,
- 40:41violence
- 40:43increases,
- 40:43and you can see that everywhere around the country.
- 40:45Yes,
- 40:45in the US I'll give it to you.
- 40:46There's more gun deaths,
- 40:47but if you look at anywhere else in the country,
- 40:49there's a lot.
- 40:50A lot of death and a lot of violence
- 40:51and that ultimately is what we're both agreeing with
- 40:53that there needs to be a reduction in violence
- 40:56and frankly getting rid of guns doesn't do that lessening guns doesn't do that.
- 40:59Fixing people's hearts and allowing them to know that they're saved
- 41:02through Jesus is what gets them to that.
- 41:04Look,
- 41:04I,
- 41:04I would,
- 41:05I want people to try to become their best selves whether that's through Jesus,
- 41:09through the church,
- 41:10or otherwise.
- 41:10I'm for that.
- 41:11I'm just like there are.
- 41:12Um,
- 41:13other countries
- 41:14that have,
- 41:15uh,
- 41:15smaller populations of Christians that have greater populations of Christians,
- 41:19and they all have way less gun deaths than us.
- 41:21Like it,
- 41:22it isn't that the,
- 41:22the
- 41:23the fact
- 41:24we eliminate gun deaths.
- 41:25Just talk about violent.
- 41:26Violent crime is higher in this country than it
- 41:29is in any other first world Western country.
- 41:31It's lower than,
- 41:32sure,
- 41:32like Nicaragua
- 41:34and some other countries,
- 41:35but of the first world Western countries,
- 41:36violent crime.
- 41:37And death is higher here
- 41:39and a lot of it is because we have so such easy access
- 41:42to firearms and all I'm saying is that we should try to fix that
- 41:45and I think that policy wise,
- 41:46uh,
- 41:47you know,
- 41:47I appreciate what you're saying about people finding,
- 41:48finding,
- 41:49uh,
- 41:50finding Christ.
- 41:50I,
- 41:50I think this administration
- 41:52and their policies are about as un-Christian as imaginable.
- 41:54I'm not talking about this policy or this administration.
- 41:56I'm talking about people,
- 41:57OK,
- 41:57right,
- 41:57well,
- 41:58no,
- 41:58but so that's what I'm saying.
- 41:59I think that like if we're gonna do this,
- 42:00it should be a um.
- 42:03Uh,
- 42:03uh,
- 42:03it should be unified across the board,
- 42:05and,
- 42:05and if we're trying to encourage people
- 42:07to,
- 42:08you know,
- 42:08improve their hearts,
- 42:09I'm for that.
- 42:09But,
- 42:10but there's,
- 42:10but we still,
- 42:11people are still gonna have demons.
- 42:13There's still sin.
- 42:14People,
- 42:14and if they have easy access to deadly guns the effort into fixing that,
- 42:18then trying to eliminate guns.
- 42:19And if you look at the gun deaths,
- 42:21they're suicide.
- 42:22That is a personal problem that is not a mass shooting.
- 42:25How would you,
- 42:25how you,
- 42:25how would you suggest that we go into,
- 42:27uh,
- 42:28helping more people find Jesus in their hearts by allowing them to.
- 42:31Understand that we are flawed,
- 42:32that we need to as a government,
- 42:34how,
- 42:34how would we do that?
- 42:35Well,
- 42:35as a government,
- 42:35it's not the government's responsibility,
- 42:37it's the Holy Spirit's responsibility,
- 42:38and we are the seed planters.
- 42:40We're here debating about what the government's policy should be.
- 42:42Yeah,
- 42:42exactly.
- 42:42And so the government's policy is not going to solve
- 42:44the problem because we're both trying to reduce the violence.
- 42:46That's the problem at hand.
- 42:47Yeah,
- 42:48and I,
- 42:48well,
- 42:49I think that obviously you could reduce the violence because there are many
- 42:51other governments and many other places
- 42:53that have successfully reduced the violence.
- 42:54And I think that
- 42:55it would be best for all of us.
- 42:57Yeah,
- 42:57look,
- 42:58everybody wants,
- 42:58yeah,
- 42:59all,
- 43:00everybody in Europe,
- 43:00we have a higher,
- 43:01we have a higher violent crime rate than every country in Europe.
- 43:05Uh,
- 43:05it,
- 43:05it,
- 43:05it is,
- 43:06it is just true,
- 43:06except maybe like Belarus and Ukraine,
- 43:08some of the Eastern Europe,
- 43:09Western Europe,
- 43:09of course.
- 43:10Does that have to do with guns?
- 43:11Yes,
- 43:11yes,
- 43:11it has to do with guns.
- 43:12No,
- 43:12it doesn't.
- 43:13Yes,
- 43:13it does.
- 43:13That we're that we're the only out we're the only outlier on this,
- 43:17on this front.
- 43:18And look,
- 43:18the people that die of the gun deaths in this country,
- 43:21that's terrible.
- 43:21Yeah,
- 43:22absolutely.
- 43:22I mean,
- 43:23uh,
- 43:23they did not,
- 43:24they did not deserve to be
- 43:25snuffed out.
- 43:26They did not deserve that,
- 43:27and they,
- 43:27and they're only at risk of that in this country.
- 43:29They should have an opportunity to live a full life of purpose and meaning,
- 43:32whether that's with,
- 43:33with Christ or otherwise.
- 43:35That's not how things should go in a free country.
- 43:37Pause,
- 43:37pause,
- 43:37pause.
- 43:38Time's been out.
- 43:39Thank you.
- 43:39Thank you,
- 43:40thank you.
- 43:40Nice to meet you.
- 43:44We are releasing episodes of the Surrounded podcast every Sunday,
- 43:48so subscribe wherever you get your podcasts
- 43:50and consider leaving us a positive review.
- 43:52Thank you.
- 43:53My next claim is the Trump administration is an attack on American values.
- 44:02Tim,
- 44:02nice to meet you,
- 44:03Scotty.
- 44:03What's happening,
- 44:03man?
- 44:04You've been ready.
- 44:04I've been watching you.
- 44:05I've been ready.
- 44:06I've been,
- 44:06this has been so much fun.
- 44:08Let's talk about what are the American values.
- 44:10Let's find some common ground first,
- 44:11OK?
- 44:12Would you consider hard work pursuing the American dream and American value?
- 44:17Um,
- 44:17sure,
- 44:17awesome.
- 44:18We agree right there.
- 44:19Would you say
- 44:21That
- 44:22all men are created equal,
- 44:24of course,
- 44:24yeah,
- 44:24of course.
- 44:25OK,
- 44:25great.
- 44:26Then where do you get that from in your liberal perspective,
- 44:28right?
- 44:29Because in the Declaration of Independence,
- 44:30right,
- 44:30it says that it's,
- 44:31it's bestowed by our
- 44:33Creator,
- 44:33right?
- 44:34Where do you get those values?
- 44:35Yeah,
- 44:35well,
- 44:35look,
- 44:35the Declaration of Independence is
- 44:37probably the classic
- 44:39document representing liberal values,
- 44:42liberal democracy,
- 44:43like liberal democracy,
- 44:44small l liberalism is something that
- 44:46Um,
- 44:46has
- 44:48basically began here in this country and proliferated into Europe
- 44:51and around the world a lot because we promoted it.
- 44:53Uh,
- 44:54those liberal values are basically,
- 44:57uh,
- 44:57freedom of speech,
- 44:58freedom of religion,
- 44:58pluralism,
- 44:59tolerance,
- 45:00rule of law.
- 45:00But where do you get those values?
- 45:02Because when you're saying the Trump administration,
- 45:03right,
- 45:03I believe the Trump administration actually protects American values,
- 45:06right?
- 45:07It protects the American values of the unborn,
- 45:09right?
- 45:09Those are things that us as Gen Z,
- 45:11we are passionate about,
- 45:12right,
- 45:13because it has killed.
- 45:15Martin just said 28% of us.
- 45:17Abortion has killed 28% of us Gen Z,
- 45:19so that's something that we're
- 45:20very
- 45:21passionate about,
- 45:21and you can only find that when you find your value in a creator.
- 45:26I mean,
- 45:26we,
- 45:26you know,
- 45:26we could go back to the Enlightenment.
- 45:28I don't know that we need to do a bunch of John Locke talk here,
- 45:30but,
- 45:30um,
- 45:31you know,
- 45:31essentially the,
- 45:32the values that I'm talking about
- 45:34are the ones in the Constitution and the Declaration,
- 45:37as I said,
- 45:37freedom of speech,
- 45:38freedom of religion,
- 45:39rule of law.
- 45:40Democracy,
- 45:41pluralism,
- 45:42that is,
- 45:42that is the foundation of what America was founded on.
- 45:44That's what the founders wrote about.
- 45:45You can go read about it in the Federalists and all
- 45:47of those Judeo-Christian values that were instilled from the beginning.
- 45:51I hear you,
- 45:51man,
- 45:52but you're,
- 45:52you're trying to make this about faith,
- 45:54and,
- 45:54and what,
- 45:55and what the founders were explicit about was that
- 45:57this country was not founded based on religion.
- 46:00A lot of them were religious,
- 46:01of course,
- 46:01but we have freedom of religion,
- 46:03excuse me.
- 46:04Excuse me,
- 46:04we have freedom of religion in this country.
- 46:05So,
- 46:05uh,
- 46:05so if you go down that list that we said,
- 46:07whether it's freedom of speech is the Declaration,
- 46:09Trump is attacking that freedom of religion.
- 46:11Trump is attacking that.
- 46:12He's not attacking freedom of religion.
- 46:13How is he had a Muslim freedom of religion?
- 46:15We had a Muslim ban in this country.
- 46:16No,
- 46:17we have never had an actual Muslim ban.
- 46:18That is an insane claim by you.
- 46:21That is an insane.
- 46:22It had to be overturned by the Supreme Court.
- 46:24Boss,
- 46:24pause,
- 46:24boss,
- 46:24you've been eliminated by
- 46:26a lot.
- 46:26Good to meet you,
- 46:26man.
- 46:35Let's go.
- 46:35What's up,
- 46:36man?
- 46:36Tim,
- 46:37that's good,
- 46:39man.
- 46:40Nice job.
- 46:41Little Clementine there.
- 46:42We're ready.
- 46:43It's sweet talk.
- 46:44OK,
- 46:45I hope so.
- 46:46I would like to know what you mean by American values.
- 46:49Again,
- 46:49so like,
- 46:50obviously there are a lot,
- 46:51but I'm thinking about the values that were promoted
- 46:52in the Declaration of the Constitution by the founders,
- 46:54the things that make America unique.
- 46:56So just going through them,
- 46:57I would say freedom of speech,
- 46:59freedom of religion,
- 47:00free markets,
- 47:01uh,
- 47:01democracy,
- 47:02pluralism,
- 47:03and the rule of law.
- 47:04Those are the things that come to mind.
- 47:05Obviously there could be other American values that you
- 47:07think Trump is going against all of them.
- 47:09I,
- 47:09I mean when it comes.
- 47:10It comes to freedom of speech,
- 47:11um,
- 47:11right now,
- 47:12uh,
- 47:12you're getting cracked down on this country.
- 47:14If you wrote an op ed criticizing Israel,
- 47:16you got jailed.
- 47:17That was Remeza Ozturk.
- 47:18Uh,
- 47:19there are 60 Minute,
- 47:20uh,
- 47:20there are media organizations that are getting attacked if they're,
- 47:23uh,
- 47:23mean to Mr.
- 47:23Trump.
- 47:24Uh,
- 47:24JD Vance said that if you said something mean about Charlie Kirk,
- 47:27the people should call your boss.
- 47:29So they're going after freedom of speech.
- 47:30They're shutting down the ICE block apps now real quick with the criticism on stuff.
- 47:33I,
- 47:34there's a lot that you're throwing at me right now,
- 47:35so I'm trying to keep up,
- 47:36but,
- 47:36um,
- 47:37with the criticism on Trump,
- 47:38I actually agree that there can be a lot of criticism on Trump.
- 47:40I think there's a lot of things that he,
- 47:41that he does that are not reflective of traditional Christian values.
- 47:45So
- 47:45I would wanna know,
- 47:46like,
- 47:47just because he,
- 47:48so we can agree on that on the Christian values.
- 47:50That wasn't really the claim,
- 47:50but let's just do it for fun.
- 47:51He is terrible and when it comes to just basic Christian values,
- 47:54terrible.
- 47:55I just,
- 47:55I haven't seen him really like say like,
- 47:57OK.
- 47:57Some press like can't say certain stuff or whatever.
- 47:59Like he's not exactly well the Department of Defense um had a press room
- 48:03where people get to go in and ask questions to the press secretary.
- 48:06Uh,
- 48:07they made them sign a pledge that they
- 48:08were not going to report unapproved information,
- 48:11and now the only people in there are like the turkey
- 48:14newspaper.
- 48:15That's something that I have to
- 48:16to myself.
- 48:16I haven't heard of that.
- 48:17OK,
- 48:17but traditional Christian values.
- 48:18I'm interested in what
- 48:19what you mean by traditional Christian values though.
- 48:21Um,
- 48:22well,
- 48:22sure,
- 48:22like loving your neighbor as yourself,
- 48:24I think that Donald Trump is pretty bad on that,
- 48:26and I think if you go down the list of,
- 48:28uh,
- 48:28of Christian,
- 48:29of,
- 48:29uh,
- 48:30of American values,
- 48:31obviously,
- 48:31but Judeo-Christian values,
- 48:34this administration has a disrespect
- 48:35for all of them.
- 48:36I mean,
- 48:36again,
- 48:36we talked in the first claim or we talked earlier about the,
- 48:39the deportation regime.
- 48:40I think that's very un-Christian.
- 48:42Um,
- 48:42I think that canceling Medicaid so that people
- 48:45don't have healthcare services is pretty un-Christian,
- 48:47the way Trump talks to people and treats people,
- 48:48I mean.
- 48:49There's,
- 48:49I mean,
- 48:50there's a whole lot of people.
- 48:51He's nasty.
- 48:52Like he's nasty.
- 48:53That's un-Christian,
- 48:53but it's also un-American.
- 48:54But anyway,
- 48:55so would you agree with that?
- 48:56He is anti-Christian values?
- 48:57You know,
- 48:57I wouldn't,
- 48:58that's the thing,
- 48:58right?
- 48:58Like there's a lot of things that I don't
- 49:00agree that Trump like reflects Christian values on.
- 49:03But at the same time,
- 49:05to claim that he's going against the founding of this country,
- 49:08I just don't think is
- 49:09completely fair because I haven't seen any actual by
- 49:11definition fascistic behavior unless you were trying to,
- 49:14of course,
- 49:14get to the other points that we talked about.
- 49:16Yeah,
- 49:16sure.
- 49:16Well,
- 49:16I mean we could go.
- 49:17Through them again,
- 49:19obviously free markets,
- 49:20he's attacking with the tear-ups with the way
- 49:22that we're now taking over certain countries,
- 49:25the rule of law.
- 49:26He's going after his political opponents to the DOJ,
- 49:28democracy,
- 49:28and he did try to overturn the election.
- 49:30I don't think there's stormed the Capitol.
- 49:31We haven't,
- 49:31we have,
- 49:32I don't think there's enough concrete.
- 49:33Well,
- 49:33you saw people storming the Capitol though,
- 49:34right?
- 49:34Yeah,
- 49:35but there's more,
- 49:35there's a lot of context regarding that stuff that
- 49:37like I obviously don't support any sort of political,
- 49:40oh sorry,
- 49:40I said,
- 49:41my bad,
- 49:42sorry.
- 49:43All right,
- 49:43you may get back to your chair.
- 49:44Thank you.
- 49:45Appreciate it.
- 49:53Hello,
- 49:55my name is Bethlehem.
- 49:56Bethlehem,
- 49:57great,
- 49:57I love that name.
- 49:57Nice to meet you.
- 49:58Um,
- 49:59so your claim that the Trump administration,
- 50:02um,
- 50:02is against,
- 50:04um,
- 50:04the founding principles of American values in general,
- 50:07I like to
- 50:08kind of establish that American values are
- 50:10inherently Christian while they're not explicitly.
- 50:12Um,
- 50:13because they're built on natural law and natural law is essentially a theology
- 50:16that's based on Christian values and Christian principles.
- 50:18So I think in that regard,
- 50:19I think you are kind of off there that
- 50:22America is inherently built on those Christian principles being
- 50:25right to life,
- 50:25liberty,
- 50:26pursuit of happiness,
- 50:27those all coming from Jesus Christ,
- 50:29and I'm not saying that.
- 50:33Yeah,
- 50:33again,
- 50:34this isn't the claim a lot of,
- 50:35a lot of folks wanna talk about this here.
- 50:36I,
- 50:36I,
- 50:36I guess I'll,
- 50:37I'll play this game if we want to.
- 50:38I,
- 50:39I don't,
- 50:39I think that Trump is
- 50:41like maybe the most anti-Christian president that we've
- 50:44had that I can think of in his,
- 50:45in his personal comportment
- 50:47and in,
- 50:47and in the policies that he put forth,
- 50:49but I,
- 50:49I,
- 50:49I think that the,
- 50:50um,
- 50:51you know,
- 50:51the founding principles of the country again,
- 50:52obviously they were Judeo-Christian values,
- 50:54but like they,
- 50:55you know,
- 50:55they're agnostics,
- 50:56Thomas Jefferson,
- 50:57like they,
- 50:58they were,
- 50:58they,
- 50:59they,
- 50:59they're explicit in,
- 51:00in respecting.
- 51:02Many different religions and they came to the
- 51:03country so people could have freedom of religion,
- 51:05but I,
- 51:05I guess I would say that Trump
- 51:06is both anti-Christian values and anti-American values.
- 51:09Well,
- 51:10I think,
- 51:10I mean,
- 51:11we're not here to assess Trump's sins,
- 51:12you know,
- 51:12we're not priests,
- 51:13we're not God Himself.
- 51:15So I,
- 51:15I don't think you guys keep bringing,
- 51:17bringing up.
- 51:17No,
- 51:17no,
- 51:18I mean,
- 51:18my,
- 51:18my point is that
- 51:20while he doesn't particularly reflect Christian values because I mean he's,
- 51:23I mean,
- 51:24he,
- 51:24he,
- 51:25he's sinned like the rest of us and things like that,
- 51:27but my point is that he has,
- 51:29he sinned a little more than you probably.
- 51:31He's a little older,
- 51:32so he has more,
- 51:32I think probably at your age,
- 51:34even at your age,
- 51:35he's probably sinned a little more than you.
- 51:36I think we could agree.
- 51:37OK,
- 51:37um,
- 51:38OK,
- 51:38I,
- 51:38OK.
- 51:40But my point is,
- 51:41OK,
- 51:41yeah,
- 51:42uh,
- 51:42my point is that that he has lowered unemployment,
- 51:45right?
- 51:45He has given child
- 51:47child
- 51:48credit tax,
- 51:49uh,
- 51:49tax cuts,
- 51:50huh?
- 51:51Well,
- 51:51I mean,
- 51:52I'm,
- 51:52I'm sure,
- 51:52no,
- 51:53he,
- 51:53well,
- 51:53I guess that was in 2017,
- 51:55right?
- 51:55Planned Parenthood has now been officially defunded protecting
- 51:58life,
- 51:59liberty,
- 51:59and pursuit of happiness,
- 52:00the part of life where America was founded upon.
- 52:03Liberty is the key one in there,
- 52:04right,
- 52:05which is people should have the liberty to act as they please,
- 52:07even if they oppose this administration.
- 52:09This administration is targeting political foes across the board.
- 52:12He calls them the enemy within.
- 52:13They're investigating political foes through the DOJ.
- 52:16This is fundamentally un-American.
- 52:18It's the type of thing that happens in banana republics,
- 52:20and Donald Trump is the only one that has participated in this in my,
- 52:23in my lifetime.
- 52:24I may be going back to Nixon.
- 52:27Thank
- 52:27you.
- 52:27Good to meet you.
- 52:36How you doing,
- 52:37Tim?
- 52:37Charlie,
- 52:38what up?
- 52:38God bless you.
- 52:39How's it going?
- 52:40Whoa,
- 52:40fantastic.
- 52:41Thank you.
- 52:42We're good.
- 52:42We're good.
- 52:43All right,
- 52:43I wanna start with,
- 52:44uh,
- 52:45freedom of speech.
- 52:46It was during the COVID times that the Biden
- 52:49administration was very agree we can move on.
- 52:50I think Biden is well,
- 52:51I think that was horrible.
- 52:52Biden did on freedom of speech during COVID,
- 52:54I think,
- 52:54well,
- 52:54and I don't think that's something that we should just move.
- 52:56On from because we're saying that Donald Trump is against American values.
- 53:00I think the freedom of speech in this country is the strongest it's ever been,
- 53:03and I think it's the freest it's ever been.
- 53:04In fact,
- 53:05maybe it's to a detrimental point because so many people
- 53:08are able to say so many things without being blocked,
- 53:11without being censored.
- 53:12Their accounts aren't being banned anymore.
- 53:14They were being banned,
- 53:15so,
- 53:15so.
- 53:16More so during the Biden administration than they were during,
- 53:19let's talk about the tech companies then if you want to.
- 53:21So the thing that we both agree on that the Biden administration was doing,
- 53:24uh,
- 53:25was they're going to the tech companies and saying,
- 53:26hey,
- 53:27you should censor misinformation about COVID,
- 53:29whether it's ivermectin or whatever,
- 53:31and that they were,
- 53:31and,
- 53:31uh,
- 53:32tech companies were doing it voluntarily.
- 53:33The government wasn't making them do it,
- 53:35uh,
- 53:35but it still was bad,
- 53:36I think.
- 53:37I,
- 53:37I still don't think they should have done it.
- 53:38The Trump administration is doing the exact same
- 53:40thing right now with information about ICE.
- 53:43Uh,
- 53:43they've gone to Facebook and Apple and told them to stop.
- 53:47Uh,
- 53:47Apple got rid of their app called ICE Block,
- 53:49and Facebook,
- 53:50uh,
- 53:50shut down Facebook groups where people were going on there and saying,
- 53:53hey,
- 53:54you know,
- 53:54I live in this neighborhood.
- 53:55ICE has been doing raids in the neighborhood,
- 53:57FYI,
- 53:58just so you know,
- 53:59ICE is in your community.
- 54:00In a free country,
- 54:01I think people should be able to post on the internet and say,
- 54:03hey,
- 54:04uh,
- 54:04there are folks in my neighborhood,
- 54:05and without the government coming in and shutting it down,
- 54:07the government.
- 54:08Came in and shut it down.
- 54:09So,
- 54:09so if you were mad about that during the Biden administration,
- 54:12to me,
- 54:12what's happening now,
- 54:13the Trump administration's worse on that front.
- 54:14They're also doing the same thing on a speech about Charlie Kirk,
- 54:16Israel,
- 54:16and other things.
- 54:17The Biden administration actually paid Facebook
- 54:20to
- 54:21go against what the Republican Party was doing and consider their values,
- 54:25whereas the Trump administration,
- 54:27I believe,
- 54:28with Twitter and with Facebook and all the social media that we have right now,
- 54:31it's actually been a lot again more freer and more,
- 54:35more concise,
- 54:36and we're able to talk about things.
- 54:38Without being banned and censored,
- 54:39I don't know how many people's accounts got censored during the COVID years.
- 54:42I mean,
- 54:42Elon's still censoring people.
- 54:44Zuckerber was still like that censoring is still happening,
- 54:46but that's in the free market.
- 54:47I'm fine with that.
- 54:47But my problem is when the government,
- 54:49when Donald Trump is coming in and saying you can't post about ICE,
- 54:51you can't.
- 54:52If you did that op ed,
- 54:53what do you think about Remeza Obsturk?
- 54:54You know that story?
- 54:55She wrote,
- 54:55she was a tough student.
- 54:56She co-wrote an op ed,
- 54:58uh,
- 54:58basically calling for divestment from Israel.
- 55:01Uh,
- 55:01she was,
- 55:02uh,
- 55:02uh,
- 55:03detained,
- 55:03imprisoned
- 55:04by the Trump administration
- 55:06for co-writing
- 55:07an op ed.
- 55:08That didn't happen during the Biden years or the Obama years or the Bush years.
- 55:12That's crazy,
- 55:13isn't it?
- 55:14I would,
- 55:14yeah,
- 55:14I would say that is pretty crazy.
- 55:15But again,
- 55:16your claim is that Donald Trump is against values,
- 55:19against American values.
- 55:20Free speech is one of those American.
- 55:21I've been trying to get through the whole list,
- 55:23but you guys are,
- 55:23you know,
- 55:23want to talk about Christian values and other stuff,
- 55:25uh,
- 55:25again,
- 55:26freedom of religion,
- 55:27free markets,
- 55:27rules.
- 55:29Of law against freedom of religion.
- 55:30Again,
- 55:30we talked about the Muslim ban.
- 55:31With free markets,
- 55:32you've got the tariffs where Donald Trump is bullying companies to come in and,
- 55:36and force them to bend the knee to him,
- 55:38free market companies,
- 55:39or else he's,
- 55:40he's not gonna,
- 55:41he's not going to tariff them.
- 55:42It's crazy.
- 55:42It would be,
- 55:43you guys would be talking about how socialist it was if Kamala Harris said,
- 55:46hey,
- 55:46Tim Cook.
- 55:47You gotta come in here for me not to add a tax to you.
- 55:51And what you're gonna have to do is you're gonna have to compliment me.
- 55:53You can,
- 55:54you're gonna bring me a little trophy
- 55:55that says that,
- 55:56hey,
- 55:57you know,
- 55:57this staffer that we have who's a non-binary indigenous,
- 56:00really appreciates your work.
- 56:02He wants to honor you,
- 56:03Kamala Harris,
- 56:04uh,
- 56:04and if we,
- 56:05if we give this to you,
- 56:06then you won't tariff us.
- 56:08Everybody would call that socialism because that's what it is.
- 56:10That's what's happening in this administration.
- 56:11Tim Cook came to the White House and gave Trump
- 56:13a trophy from a MAGA person.
- 56:15He's like,
- 56:15please don't tariff my iPhone
- 56:17components.
- 56:18And Donald Trump gave him an out on that.
- 56:20But then he's tariffing other things.
- 56:21This is not the free market.
- 56:22Donald Trump's running a socialist
- 56:24regime straight out of the out of the White House.
- 56:27He just is.
- 56:28Pause.
- 56:28You've been eliminated.
- 56:29Thank you.
- 56:30Thank you,
- 56:30man.
- 56:30Good to see you.
- 56:38Clock down.
- 56:40Tim,
- 56:41Timothy,
- 56:41Tim,
- 56:41pleasure.
- 56:42You're Timothy.
- 56:43You the full name.
- 56:44I go by Timothy.
- 56:45OK,
- 56:45my parents called me Timo actually,
- 56:46so I've never been Timothy.
- 56:47Yeah,
- 56:47it's OK.
- 56:48It comes from the Greek which is Timotheos.
- 56:50It means honoring God.
- 56:52God.
- 56:52Yeah,
- 56:52very cool.
- 56:53I want to address your claim about the rule of law and being a Western value,
- 56:57specifically about ICE and everything.
- 56:59I think what the Trump administration is doing
- 57:01with ICE is actually protecting his constituents.
- 57:04He's doing exactly what I elected him for,
- 57:07specifically the family of Lake and O'Reilly.
- 57:10Yeah,
- 57:10who's protecting them?
- 57:13Well,
- 57:13let me,
- 57:13let me just,
- 57:13let me just ask you this.
- 57:15Do you agree that we have an immigration problem in this country?
- 57:17Or we did.
- 57:18We don't anymore.
- 57:19Yeah,
- 57:19well,
- 57:20I,
- 57:20I guess I would say this.
- 57:21We did during the Biden administration.
- 57:22They let in too many people,
- 57:23and that's why the claim,
- 57:24the original claim was not about border patrol.
- 57:26I think we obviously need border patrol.
- 57:28And so I think that Biden is Biden failed rule of law.
- 57:30Yeah,
- 57:30I'm talking about addressing the rule of law here and how the government.
- 57:33The rule of law is not just
- 57:35part of it is protecting innocent people from being attacked,
- 57:38right?
- 57:38Totally.
- 57:38But another part of it is protecting all of our rights
- 57:41from being infringed by the government.
- 57:43Let me tell you about a guy named George Reddis.
- 57:44He lived right,
- 57:45he lives right up here.
- 57:45He's a security guard outside a marijuana farm.
- 57:48OK.
- 57:48He's a veteran.
- 57:49He's a US citizen.
- 57:50He was driving to work.
- 57:52They were raiding the marijuana farm because.
- 57:54I guess there are undocumented people working there.
- 57:56George
- 57:57is American.
- 57:57He's,
- 57:58he's a Marine.
- 57:58He's trying to get to work.
- 58:00Uh,
- 58:00the ICE agents broke into his car by ICE,
- 58:03yeah,
- 58:03arrested.
- 58:04They sent him to prison.
- 58:05He did not get a phone call.
- 58:06He was there for,
- 58:07he missed his child's 3rd birthday.
- 58:09He was there for 3 days.
- 58:10They put him in solitary confinement for 48 hours.
- 58:13He's an American citizen.
- 58:14He can sue.
- 58:16Of course he can,
- 58:16but the administration hasn't said anything about it.
- 58:18But,
- 58:18OK,
- 58:18then let's talk about you people can sue and you can get restitution for that.
- 58:21But if you're an illegal alien year old in Honduras,
- 58:23can't,
- 58:23you know,
- 58:24can't sue.
- 58:24But no,
- 58:25but if you're an illegal alien,
- 58:26you don't have the rights guaranteed to you by the Constitution
- 58:29because you already broke the law coming in here.
- 58:31Now,
- 58:32secondly,
- 58:32what I also wanna talk about is the freedom of religion and the Muslim ban.
- 58:36Uh,
- 58:37the Muslim ban,
- 58:38you're talking about in the very first Trump administration
- 58:40when he said the Muslims can't come in.
- 58:42That was a safety threat.
- 58:45That was a safety threat.
- 58:46Yes,
- 58:47it was.
- 58:47We were at war.
- 58:48Everybody was at war during that ban terrorists.
- 58:50You don't have to ban Muslims.
- 58:51I was at during that first,
- 58:53you understand that they don't come over saying,
- 58:55hey,
- 58:55I'm a terrorist.
- 58:56Well,
- 58:56yeah,
- 58:56sure,
- 58:56that's why they have come over and they say,
- 58:58guys,
- 58:58that's why we have a CIA.
- 58:59This is why you keep being like,
- 59:01look,
- 59:01there,
- 59:02there are ways to go after bad people.
- 59:04We've done this in every administration besides Trump.
- 59:05There's a way to go.
- 59:06I mean,
- 59:06there's a way to go after terrorists,
- 59:07there's a way to go after drug dealers without
- 59:10hassling.
- 59:10People
- 59:11and having a secret and having a,
- 59:13a,
- 59:13a,
- 59:13uh,
- 59:13you know,
- 59:14internal police that's masked going after people.
- 59:1811 more thing I have to address democracy.
- 59:20I hope none of you guys have chosen to go after the democracy point,
- 59:22which I think is interesting.
- 59:24Well,
- 59:24we live in a republic,
- 59:25but
- 59:25the claim that you say that ISIS like ISIS into the secret police is ridiculous,
- 59:31is laughable
- 59:32and everything.
- 59:33But
- 59:34yes,
- 59:34it is.
- 59:35Yeah,
- 59:35it is their secret.
- 59:37They're acting in secret
- 59:38and it's Donald Trump's internal police force.
- 59:40They are acting they don't have a warrant by a judge for each person they do.
- 59:43Yes,
- 59:44no,
- 59:44they do.
- 59:44No,
- 59:45they don't.
- 59:45You're just wrong.
- 59:46Have you ever interviewed somebody from ICE on your show?
- 59:48You could read ProPublica.
- 59:49Have you interviewed someone from I actually I interviewed Dean Kane,
- 59:52who is a,
- 59:53uh,
- 59:53who is a Superman actor that has joined ICE.
- 59:56Uh,
- 59:56he is not the smartest tool in the shed,
- 59:58but he's decided that he wants to join ICE
- 59:59now even though he has no experience doing that.
- 1:00:01Look,
- 1:00:01man,
- 1:00:01you're wrong,
- 1:00:02they don't have warrants.
- 1:00:03Read,
- 1:00:03read ProPublica.
- 1:00:04Read your local news here.
- 1:00:05Read the Los Angeles Times.
- 1:00:07Many,
- 1:00:08many people have been detained by ICE.
- 1:00:10American citizens undocumented,
- 1:00:11I think ProPublica recently said it was like 170,
- 1:00:14hundreds of American citizens have been detained by ICE without a warrant.
- 1:00:18No,
- 1:00:18you're wrong.
- 1:00:18That just isn't happening.
- 1:00:19That maybe those things do happen,
- 1:00:21but when you have
- 1:00:2210 million people that have come in,
- 1:00:24there's gonna be things that fall through the cracks.
- 1:00:26Let me ask you this,
- 1:00:27you believe that bad things happen with the police also,
- 1:00:29right?
- 1:00:30Do you agree that they should be abolished as well?
- 1:00:31Well,
- 1:00:31no,
- 1:00:32they're,
- 1:00:32no,
- 1:00:32because,
- 1:00:33exactly,
- 1:00:33well,
- 1:00:33no,
- 1:00:34right,
- 1:00:34so maybe they should be reformed.
- 1:00:35Maybe there should be some other things I reply to
- 1:00:36that because I do think there's a key difference,
- 1:00:38exactly it's to me.
- 1:00:39Police
- 1:00:40have unions.
- 1:00:41They have accountability to their people.
- 1:00:42When the police mess up,
- 1:00:44uh,
- 1:00:44as you mentioned earlier,
- 1:00:45people can sue the police.
- 1:00:46Police,
- 1:00:46but also police acknowledge their mistakes.
- 1:00:48We can sue I.
- 1:00:49We can sue the federal government.
- 1:00:50That's why we have lawyers.
- 1:00:51That is not happening with ICE right now.
- 1:00:53ICE has wrongly detained
- 1:00:55a bunch of people.
- 1:00:55They wrongly sent a bunch of people to El Salvador,
- 1:00:57by the way.
- 1:00:58Uh,
- 1:00:58the Department of Homeland Security has not acknowledged a single mistake,
- 1:01:01by the way.
- 1:01:02Oh,
- 1:01:02really?
- 1:01:03Tell me about that.
- 1:01:04So I wanna talk.
- 1:01:04So the,
- 1:01:05the guy that was the makeup artist that got sent to El Salvador,
- 1:01:07you're cool with that?
- 1:01:08I don't know about that guy.
- 1:01:09I'm just saying about the El Salvador?
- 1:01:11What about the president is amazing.
- 1:01:13OK,
- 1:01:13well,
- 1:01:13we sent 200 people to El Salvador.
- 1:01:15We said that they were,
- 1:01:16well,
- 1:01:16if they're an American citizen,
- 1:01:18they're gonna have passports.
- 1:01:19They're gonna have documentation,
- 1:01:20and so they won't,
- 1:01:21they're not gonna be ending up in jail.
- 1:01:23Well,
- 1:01:23yeah,
- 1:01:23we sent 200 Venezuelans to El Salvador.
- 1:01:27We claim,
- 1:01:27no,
- 1:01:27no,
- 1:01:27no,
- 1:01:27not American citizens.
- 1:01:28We claim that they're not American citizens.
- 1:01:30You think that we can.
- 1:01:31Just send people to foreign gulags even if they're not American.
- 1:01:34They're not they're not American citizens.
- 1:01:35We can do whatever we want.
- 1:01:36Well,
- 1:01:36that they broke the law coming in.
- 1:01:38If who doesn't want them?
- 1:01:39If Honduras doesn't want them,
- 1:01:41if anybody else doesn't want them,
- 1:01:42where are they gonna take them?
- 1:01:42Well,
- 1:01:43no,
- 1:01:43no,
- 1:01:43several of them because we told,
- 1:01:45we told,
- 1:01:45we told the president of Colombia to say,
- 1:01:47hey,
- 1:01:47take your guys back,
- 1:01:48and he said,
- 1:01:48no.
- 1:01:49Several of the Venezuelans that came to
- 1:01:50the country did come through legal pathways,
- 1:01:53and we deported.
- 1:01:54Them to an El Salvador prison
- 1:01:56because they had tattoos
- 1:01:57that that looked like they were trend to Arragua like MS-13 trend to Arragua.
- 1:02:01Several of them you think the cartels operate
- 1:02:03in other countries besides just El Salva.
- 1:02:06My question is,
- 1:02:06do you think that somebody is,
- 1:02:08no,
- 1:02:08my question is to you.
- 1:02:09Do you think someone that's a legal resident in this country that came the right way
- 1:02:12from Venezuela
- 1:02:13can without due process be sent to a foreign prison in El Salvador?
- 1:02:17Do you think that that's what the government should be doing?
- 1:02:19Are you talking about an American citizen?
- 1:02:21No,
- 1:02:21they're Venezuelans that came to the country through a legal process.
- 1:02:23They're working through legal pathways.
- 1:02:25They were refugees path,
- 1:02:26or asylums in regards to,
- 1:02:28and they came to this country and we sent them
- 1:02:30to an El Salvador gulag.
- 1:02:33Did they break any other laws?
- 1:02:34No.
- 1:02:35No,
- 1:02:35and the administration has not acknowledged it,
- 1:02:37has not apologized to them.
- 1:02:38One of them is a guy I interviewed.
- 1:02:39His name was Andre Hernandez Romero.
- 1:02:41He is a makeup artist and a hairdresser.
- 1:02:44He came to this country,
- 1:02:46and he,
- 1:02:46he,
- 1:02:46he went through the CBP one app just like you were supposed to do.
- 1:02:50He tried to do it the right way,
- 1:02:51and what we did is we picked him up,
- 1:02:53put him on a plane,
- 1:02:54and we sent him to that El Salvador hellhole.
- 1:02:56Is he still?
- 1:02:57There
- 1:02:584 months later,
- 1:02:58the Bukele and Maduro cut a deal to get him out of there.
- 1:03:02He was in there for 4 months.
- 1:03:03We did that to him.
- 1:03:04He came to this country.
- 1:03:06He tried to do it the right way,
- 1:03:07and we sent him to a foreign country.
- 1:03:08I'm sorry,
- 1:03:09that is against American values.
- 1:03:10This was a country where people wanted to come here.
- 1:03:12It was a shining city on a hill.
- 1:03:14Gotta be a lot.
- 1:03:14We were welcoming people throughout the world.
- 1:03:15I understand that,
- 1:03:16but there's gotta be a lot more to the story than you're saying.
- 1:03:19There isn't.
- 1:03:20You've been eliminated by the group.
- 1:03:23Good.
- 1:03:29That's,
- 1:03:29Whoa,
- 1:03:30we rolling.
- 1:03:32Oh,
- 1:03:32buddy,
- 1:03:33that's time out.
- 1:03:36These people who crossed into this this country
- 1:03:39they broke a law
- 1:03:41and so
- 1:03:42there are
- 1:03:43sort of asylum seeking processes that you do when you're outside of the country.
- 1:03:47What I don't appreciate is the cutting in line aspect of this
- 1:03:51because
- 1:03:52it's almost like you're at a grocery store,
- 1:03:54you cut someone in line.
- 1:03:56I don't appreciate that because there were Venezuelan individuals
- 1:03:59who were criminals being housed in New York City
- 1:04:01and that was coming out of our taxpayer dollars.
- 1:04:03Now we're talking about American values.
- 1:04:06I voted for Donald Trump not because of a mutually exclusive interest.
- 1:04:10I voted for him despite it.
- 1:04:13I wanted to
- 1:04:14see closed borders and I wanted to see things like gender ideology diminished.
- 1:04:19I,
- 1:04:20I wanted to go back to a time where we
- 1:04:22weren't self IDing in bathrooms and we
- 1:04:24could actually vote legally instead of having
- 1:04:26things like legal aliens voting.
- 1:04:29The issue that I have and what we need to actually fix.
- 1:04:32Immigration is,
- 1:04:33is,
- 1:04:34it's been thrown around like a poker chip.
- 1:04:36We've,
- 1:04:36we've seen both sides utilize it,
- 1:04:38but I think what Republicans have actually done,
- 1:04:40and,
- 1:04:40and we can look at this through the DREAM Act bill which
- 1:04:43was actually voted against by a lot of Democrats including AOC.
- 1:04:46So this DREAM Act bill was going to
- 1:04:48create a process for citizenship for DACA individuals.
- 1:04:51I consider parents
- 1:04:52who are smuggling their children into this country as terrorists,
- 1:04:55domestic terrorists,
- 1:04:57because,
- 1:04:57yes,
- 1:04:57I do,
- 1:04:58because these individuals,
- 1:04:59they're,
- 1:04:59they're not having a decision on being in this country.
- 1:05:02They're sort of foregoing out of our taxpayer dollars education,
- 1:05:05right?
- 1:05:06And we're paying over $9 billion
- 1:05:09federally.
- 1:05:09Well,
- 1:05:09I gotta tell you,
- 1:05:10um,
- 1:05:10I,
- 1:05:11I just think that this is gonna be an area where,
- 1:05:12where we aren't gonna find much common ground because I think that,
- 1:05:16I think that somebody fleeing communism in Venezuela,
- 1:05:19somebody fleeing oppression
- 1:05:21that is looking for freedom,
- 1:05:22that wants to come to this country
- 1:05:24and,
- 1:05:24and is doing so through an asylee process or
- 1:05:27through the refugee process or through the TPS process,
- 1:05:29somebody that wants to come to this country
- 1:05:31because they wanna give their kid an opportunity,
- 1:05:33I think.
- 1:05:33I think finding a way to make that happen is the Central American value.
- 1:05:37It is what made America what it was.
- 1:05:39This is,
- 1:05:39this is a have them wait in line.
- 1:05:41No,
- 1:05:41please.
- 1:05:42Some of them were able to get in through,
- 1:05:43through temporary protected status or through asylum status,
- 1:05:46and they're able to.
- 1:05:47I'm sorry,
- 1:05:48and they're,
- 1:05:48yeah,
- 1:05:48and they're able to come into this country to give their kid a chance,
- 1:05:51which we did not want.
- 1:05:51And
- 1:05:52can you just let me finish?
- 1:05:53They're able to come to this country,
- 1:05:53give their kid a chance.
- 1:05:55And to me that is the American story.
- 1:05:56Like the,
- 1:05:57the,
- 1:05:57the,
- 1:05:57our country
- 1:05:58is
- 1:05:59the,
- 1:05:59as Ronald Reagan said,
- 1:06:00the shining.
- 1:06:01City on the hill,
- 1:06:01we want to give people fleeing oppression a possibility here
- 1:06:05and what you said is that if a parent,
- 1:06:07uh,
- 1:06:07tried to come as an asylee and bring their kids into this country,
- 1:06:10and I've worked with some of these kids,
- 1:06:11um,
- 1:06:12that they are a terrorist and a child trafficker.
- 1:06:15No,
- 1:06:15they're a parent that loves their child that wants to give them an opportunity
- 1:06:18that they could not have in the communist hellhole where they came from,
- 1:06:21and we should not,
- 1:06:22we should not treat them bad.
- 1:06:24We should not taxpayers,
- 1:06:25a lot of them pay taxes.
- 1:06:26They come,
- 1:06:27they work,
- 1:06:27obviously.
- 1:06:29American values.
- 1:06:29This is what this American values value.
- 1:06:31We should not be sending people all of us actually voted for Trump
- 1:06:35because we wanted what was happening right now.
- 1:06:37We want people to finally be in line with,
- 1:06:40and that's the final American value which actually none of,
- 1:06:43none of you wanted to talk about,
- 1:06:44which is fine.
- 1:06:44We can agree on that,
- 1:06:45but no,
- 1:06:45we can't actually because Donald Trump lost
- 1:06:48democracy because Donald Trump lost the 2020.
- 1:06:50If I could,
- 1:06:51Donald Trump lost the 2020 election.
- 1:06:53He lost the 2020 election.
- 1:06:54He won this election by the popular.
- 1:06:56And then he pretended like he won and then people stormed
- 1:06:59the Capitol and attacked police because they don't respect democracy.
- 1:07:02Excuse me,
- 1:07:02let me finish,
- 1:07:03and you guys and maybe all of you,
- 1:07:04I don't know,
- 1:07:05you're speaking for everybody,
- 1:07:06but many of you voted for him
- 1:07:07after democracy,
- 1:07:09after he,
- 1:07:10after he instituted an attack on our democracy,
- 1:07:13on the Capitol,
- 1:07:13a violent attack the attack?
- 1:07:15The people that were attacking the Nancy Pelosi one that was
- 1:07:18a stunt to actually look like it was Donald Trump,
- 1:07:21but it wasn't.
- 1:07:22Yeah,
- 1:07:22that's not what happened.
- 1:07:23It,
- 1:07:24it did.
- 1:07:24It was on record.
- 1:07:26No,
- 1:07:26you can watch the tape.
- 1:07:27You should talk to the police.
- 1:07:31The last claim is that the reddest states are governed worse than the bluest cities.
- 1:07:39Oh,
- 1:07:40there we go.
- 1:07:41What up,
- 1:07:41man?
- 1:07:42Good to see you.
- 1:07:43So obviously,
- 1:07:44in order for us to understand your claim,
- 1:07:46I would love to understand why you say that.
- 1:07:48What specifically about
- 1:07:50red states makes them govern worse than cities?
- 1:07:52Um,
- 1:07:54well,
- 1:07:54I think that there are kind of two ways to look at that.
- 1:07:56One is just in a technocratic sense,
- 1:07:58like the outcomes are worse,
- 1:07:59right?
- 1:07:59Um,
- 1:07:59poverty rates are higher.
- 1:08:01Uh,
- 1:08:01violent crime is higher,
- 1:08:03uh,
- 1:08:03divorce rates are higher,
- 1:08:05uh,
- 1:08:05economic
- 1:08:06dynamism and opportunities is lower,
- 1:08:08schools,
- 1:08:09school scores are lower,
- 1:08:10uh,
- 1:08:10violent crime is higher.
- 1:08:12Um,
- 1:08:13I mean,
- 1:08:13but per capita,
- 1:08:14the highest violent crime state,
- 1:08:16red state,
- 1:08:16uh,
- 1:08:17states are,
- 1:08:17I think almost all red states except North New Mexico.
- 1:08:19I think it's Alaska,
- 1:08:20Louisiana,
- 1:08:21Mississippi,
- 1:08:22uh,
- 1:08:22those are the highest violence,
- 1:08:23violent states when it comes to violent crime,
- 1:08:24yeah,
- 1:08:25OK,
- 1:08:26so
- 1:08:27the blue cities that have
- 1:08:30overwhelmingly
- 1:08:32more regulation on guns,
- 1:08:34they have more gun violence.
- 1:08:35Why do you think that that is?
- 1:08:38Um,
- 1:08:39well,
- 1:08:39I mean,
- 1:08:39I don't think that's exactly true.
- 1:08:41There are some cities that have really high,
- 1:08:43it's not true,
- 1:08:43um,
- 1:08:44well,
- 1:08:44there's some cities that have a lot of gun violence like Chicago,
- 1:08:46and a lot of the guns are coming in from,
- 1:08:48they have some of the strictest gun regulations in the,
- 1:08:50yeah,
- 1:08:50but again,
- 1:08:51you have more violent crime in places like Tennessee
- 1:08:54than you do
- 1:08:55in places like Massachusetts and New York,
- 1:08:57but that's true.
- 1:08:57No,
- 1:08:58it is not even New York.
- 1:08:59Let's take Chicago and New York who have some of the strictest gun violence.
- 1:09:02Chicago is a horrific example of those coming in from Indiana,
- 1:09:05yeah,
- 1:09:05um,
- 1:09:06OK.
- 1:09:06And how are they coming in?
- 1:09:08They're
- 1:09:08people are trafficking them in from Indiana and they should be stopped them.
- 1:09:11OK,
- 1:09:12so they're coming in illegally.
- 1:09:13I don't know why you're whispering it.
- 1:09:15Well,
- 1:09:15they're,
- 1:09:15they're coming in illegally,
- 1:09:16right?
- 1:09:18But they have the regulations
- 1:09:20to crack down on the guns.
- 1:09:21So you're telling me that
- 1:09:23regulation doesn't work?
- 1:09:25Well,
- 1:09:25no,
- 1:09:25regulation certainly does work in,
- 1:09:27in certain cases.
- 1:09:27There are ways to why does it work in Chicago?
- 1:09:29Yeah,
- 1:09:29but again,
- 1:09:30because they have it is working problems,
- 1:09:31I guess they have strict gun reg you're trying to,
- 1:09:32uh,
- 1:09:33you're trying to do the debate bro thing with me,
- 1:09:34like,
- 1:09:35uh,
- 1:09:35where it's just,
- 1:09:36but it just isn't working because the facts are not right.
- 1:09:37Like
- 1:09:38in the,
- 1:09:39the states that have the least gun violence
- 1:09:41are blue states.
- 1:09:42There's places like Vermont and Massachusetts,
- 1:09:44uh,
- 1:09:44gun I'm,
- 1:09:45I'm just,
- 1:09:45I'm sorry,
- 1:09:46the gun violence,
- 1:09:47yeah,
- 1:09:47I'm just sorry,
- 1:09:48you know why?
- 1:09:48Here's why.
- 1:09:49Because the gun violence,
- 1:09:50like you hear about like the street crime gun violence,
- 1:09:53and,
- 1:09:53and there certainly is some of that,
- 1:09:55particularly in Chicago where,
- 1:09:56where it's,
- 1:09:56where it's really bad.
- 1:09:57But
- 1:09:58there is a ton of gun violence that's happening across rural America,
- 1:10:02uh,
- 1:10:03related to domestic violence,
- 1:10:04and,
- 1:10:05and having guns in your home just leads to suicides,
- 1:10:07leads to,
- 1:10:08uh,
- 1:10:08uh,
- 1:10:09leads to wives being menaced and killed,
- 1:10:11and like that is happening all over the country.
- 1:10:13But there's a lot of other factors that that go into the fact.
- 1:10:15For example,
- 1:10:16in the rural areas,
- 1:10:17they're going to have less deterrence from the community.
- 1:10:19Not everybody lives together,
- 1:10:20so they don't have the threat of their neighbors shooting at a robber,
- 1:10:23for example,
- 1:10:23they have less,
- 1:10:25um,
- 1:10:25law enforcement,
- 1:10:26um,
- 1:10:27the time that it takes for law enforcement to get to these,
- 1:10:29um,
- 1:10:30crimes that would be happening,
- 1:10:31like,
- 1:10:31for example,
- 1:10:31all of the things that you're mentioning,
- 1:10:33um,
- 1:10:33is a lot higher than it would be in blue cities,
- 1:10:36but that still doesn't.
- 1:10:37Away from the fact that you even agreed
- 1:10:39Chicago has the highest
- 1:10:41gun regulation in the country and they have the most amount of gun violence.
- 1:10:44How does that work?
- 1:10:45And what OK,
- 1:10:46again,
- 1:10:46because we live in a free country and Chicago is not like a fortified
- 1:10:49environment where nobody can come in and out.
- 1:10:51But I,
- 1:10:51but I,
- 1:10:52my,
- 1:10:52my,
- 1:10:52I guess my point is that
- 1:10:53I,
- 1:10:54I don't think that,
- 1:10:54I think that Chicago's governed awfully actually.
- 1:10:57The mayor,
- 1:10:57the mayor of Chicago is terrible,
- 1:10:59um,
- 1:11:00but,
- 1:11:00uh,
- 1:11:01my.
- 1:11:01The point is that there's a lot of conversation about that,
- 1:11:03that the mayor of Chicago is terrible.
- 1:11:04A lot,
- 1:11:04like a lot of this is in the news.
- 1:11:05People talk about this all the time.
- 1:11:06There's not a lot of conversation about the fact that
- 1:11:08that in West Virginia,
- 1:11:10in Tennessee,
- 1:11:11in Louisiana,
- 1:11:12and Mississippi,
- 1:11:13there is greater violent crime than there is in Charcot.
- 1:11:15It's just not as in condensed of an area.
- 1:11:16People don't talk about it,
- 1:11:17and they're not doing anything to solve it,
- 1:11:19and they're the,
- 1:11:20the govern,
- 1:11:20the governors in those states are actually making it worse,
- 1:11:23exacerbating the problem.
- 1:11:24You make this claim.
- 1:11:25That on average,
- 1:11:27the blue cities are governed worse than red states,
- 1:11:29but when we talk about Chicago,
- 1:11:30which happens to be the one of the biggest country
- 1:11:32or one of the biggest cities in the country,
- 1:11:35the most populous,
- 1:11:36they have the strictest gun regulation.
- 1:11:37It's like,
- 1:11:37oh well,
- 1:11:38we can't talk about that.
- 1:11:39We have to talk about the rural red.
- 1:11:40I'm happy to talk.
- 1:11:41No,
- 1:11:41I'm happy to talk about it.
- 1:11:42I'm just saying I think that Chicago,
- 1:11:44objectively Chicago is,
- 1:11:45is governed not well,
- 1:11:47and I think that it should be governed better.
- 1:11:48What do you think,
- 1:11:49but objectively it's governed better than.
- 1:11:51West Virginia.
- 1:11:52What,
- 1:11:52what do you think about like if you wanna,
- 1:11:54if you live Los Angeles is objectively governed better
- 1:11:56than West Virginia or Oklahoma on every score,
- 1:11:58where would you,
- 1:11:58where would you want to send your kids to what policy differences?
- 1:12:01Sure,
- 1:12:02sure.
- 1:12:02Again,
- 1:12:03education,
- 1:12:04access to healthcare,
- 1:12:05uh,
- 1:12:05services,
- 1:12:06uh,
- 1:12:07transportation,
- 1:12:08uh,
- 1:12:08poverty levels.
- 1:12:09Poverty levels are way higher,
- 1:12:11but the affordability is also higher in those states as well
- 1:12:14because nobody,
- 1:12:15yeah.
- 1:12:22Hi,
- 1:12:23hey,
- 1:12:23it's Noel again.
- 1:12:24Good to see you.
- 1:12:25Good to see you again.
- 1:12:26So,
- 1:12:27uh,
- 1:12:27I know a lot of things were mentioned and just to
- 1:12:29kind of level the playing field and find common ground,
- 1:12:33um,
- 1:12:33you mentioned,
- 1:12:34you know,
- 1:12:34kids dying because of school shootings.
- 1:12:36I'm with you there.
- 1:12:37My heart breaks every time I hear something and I want something done about that.
- 1:12:40Same when we look at,
- 1:12:41you know,
- 1:12:42immigration and we're seeing human trafficking,
- 1:12:44kids being trafficked at the border by the cartel,
- 1:12:46horrible.
- 1:12:47So all of,
- 1:12:48all of the violence against children,
- 1:12:49I want something done by that,
- 1:12:50and I think it's horr.
- 1:12:51Horrible.
- 1:12:51That being said,
- 1:12:52and I think we can agree on that.
- 1:12:54When we look at blue cities,
- 1:12:55they have some of the most extreme abortion policies.
- 1:12:58Um,
- 1:12:58for example,
- 1:12:59Cesar Santangelo in Washington DC,
- 1:13:02they were,
- 1:13:02uh,
- 1:13:02justice for the 5,
- 1:13:03and they still haven't received justice,
- 1:13:05but they were 5 babies that were aborted at the 3rd trimester.
- 1:13:09Um,
- 1:13:09and so we see these cases happening in blue cities,
- 1:13:12and I think that's super problematic.
- 1:13:14Do you think that that is?
- 1:13:15I'm against 3rd trimester abortions.
- 1:13:17Um,
- 1:13:17I,
- 1:13:18I,
- 1:13:18I'm like quasi pro-life.
- 1:13:19Um,
- 1:13:20I would say I,
- 1:13:20I,
- 1:13:21I'm where a lot of people are in the country,
- 1:13:22uh,
- 1:13:22which is in the middle on that issue.
- 1:13:24I think you get a lot of times it gets,
- 1:13:26um,
- 1:13:26bifurcated into,
- 1:13:27um,
- 1:13:28extremes,
- 1:13:29uh,
- 1:13:29but now that.
- 1:13:30Uh,
- 1:13:31Dobbs has been overturned,
- 1:13:32um,
- 1:13:32uh,
- 1:13:32you know,
- 1:13:33kind of like the dynamics has changed a lot and what the,
- 1:13:35what the laws are in a lot of those cities,
- 1:13:37but I,
- 1:13:37I agree,
- 1:13:37and I think that
- 1:13:38the Kermit Gosnell thing,
- 1:13:39whatever in Philadelphia,
- 1:13:40horrible,
- 1:13:41uh,
- 1:13:41a horrible story.
- 1:13:42Uh,
- 1:13:42here's the problem though
- 1:13:43is that
- 1:13:44again,
- 1:13:45on average,
- 1:13:46like.
- 1:13:47The red states do a horrible job of,
- 1:13:50of protecting
- 1:13:51young people.
- 1:13:52Uh,
- 1:13:52you mentioned gun deaths,
- 1:13:53but it's also,
- 1:13:54uh,
- 1:13:54child poverty is higher in the red states.
- 1:13:57Infant mortality is much higher in the red states because they,
- 1:13:59they aren't funding
- 1:14:00healthcare,
- 1:14:01uh,
- 1:14:01to,
- 1:14:02to the,
- 1:14:02to the same degree.
- 1:14:03And my view is,
- 1:14:04look,
- 1:14:04when I think about
- 1:14:06what I'm looking for in,
- 1:14:07in a governor,
- 1:14:08and,
- 1:14:08and somebody who's governed the state or the country,
- 1:14:10um,
- 1:14:11I used to work for Jeb Bush.
- 1:14:12One of his lines was that he wants people to
- 1:14:13be able to live a life of purpose and meaning.
- 1:14:15And that's kind of what I judge everything by.
- 1:14:17I want people to be able to have an opportunity to live a life of purpose and meaning.
- 1:14:20What does that mean?
- 1:14:21That means that when they,
- 1:14:22when they're born,
- 1:14:23they get to stay born,
- 1:14:24right?
- 1:14:25Uh,
- 1:14:25and then it means when then they grow up and they go to school,
- 1:14:28then they have good schools where they have a chance to learn and,
- 1:14:31and do well.
- 1:14:32And then if they get out of school and they have like financial,
- 1:14:35uh,
- 1:14:36issues like that there's a safety net,
- 1:14:38so they at least have a chance to go out and find a job.
- 1:14:41On,
- 1:14:42on that metric,
- 1:14:43like red states are doing terrible.
- 1:14:44Like infant mortality is high,
- 1:14:46the schools are terrible,
- 1:14:48and,
- 1:14:48um,
- 1:14:49and the safety net is,
- 1:14:50is,
- 1:14:50uh,
- 1:14:50has holes in it.
- 1:14:51And,
- 1:14:52and I just,
- 1:14:52I,
- 1:14:52I think that,
- 1:14:53you know,
- 1:14:54I agree with you that there have been some extreme abortion laws in blue states,
- 1:14:57cities,
- 1:14:58but I just don't think that matches up to the
- 1:15:00just horrible way that red states are governing on that metric.
- 1:15:03I,
- 1:15:03I agree that the education system is a mess and I.
- 1:15:06I think we need to change that.
- 1:15:07I think homeschooling should be a more popular
- 1:15:10option and people should have education choice,
- 1:15:12um,
- 1:15:12and unfortunately we don't see that a lot in blue states.
- 1:15:15We see that in red states to allow more freedoms of education of choice,
- 1:15:18but I do want to say,
- 1:15:19you know,
- 1:15:19you mentioned,
- 1:15:20um,
- 1:15:22that we should protect life after the child is born,
- 1:15:24so do you agree that we should protect the life
- 1:15:28allow the child to be born because,
- 1:15:30um,
- 1:15:31so you're pro-life then.
- 1:15:32Again,
- 1:15:33I mean,
- 1:15:33I think that this is a complicated issue,
- 1:15:35right?
- 1:15:35Like I,
- 1:15:35I definitely am not for 3rd trimester elective abortions,
- 1:15:38right?
- 1:15:38I think that there are exceptions to the life of the mother.
- 1:15:40I think that some of the red state laws are really terrible,
- 1:15:42like bounty laws in,
- 1:15:44in some of these cases.
- 1:15:45I think it's a little different,
- 1:15:46you know.
- 1:15:47The abortion isn't the issue.
- 1:15:48Like we could probably sit here and debate the 6 week and 8 week,
- 1:15:50you know what I mean?
- 1:15:51Like I think that there are different lines,
- 1:15:52um,
- 1:15:53on there,
- 1:15:53but
- 1:15:54I,
- 1:15:54I guess my point is that,
- 1:15:55um,
- 1:15:55I'm for that.
- 1:15:56Uh,
- 1:15:57again,
- 1:15:57I think that people should have an opportunity to live a life of purpose and meaning.
- 1:16:00That means getting born,
- 1:16:00but that means staying born,
- 1:16:01right?
- 1:16:02You don't want infant mortality when they're deaf.
- 1:16:03You wanna make sure they have good,
- 1:16:05good hospitals,
- 1:16:06and I,
- 1:16:06and I just think they're,
- 1:16:07they're failing on this front.
- 1:16:08I live in Louisiana.
- 1:16:09I live in New Orleans.
- 1:16:09We have school choice.
- 1:16:10I'm for school choice too,
- 1:16:11actually,
- 1:16:12but like.
- 1:16:13They,
- 1:16:14they don't fund the schools.
- 1:16:15So it's like there are 3 really great schools.
- 1:16:17And so if you have great parents
- 1:16:19that,
- 1:16:19that work hard to get you on the lists and make sure that you
- 1:16:21get the tests and you get to go to the good public schools,
- 1:16:23then you're great.
- 1:16:24If you have
- 1:16:25absentee parents or bad parents,
- 1:16:27then you end up in these crappy schools.
- 1:16:28And my point is you can have school choice,
- 1:16:30but you also gotta,
- 1:16:31you also gotta invest to make sure kids have opportunities.
- 1:16:33They're doing that in blue.
- 1:16:34Cities that are not doing it in red states,
- 1:16:35sure,
- 1:16:36but we have to allow people to have that option,
- 1:16:38and I,
- 1:16:38we're seeing a lot of restrictions in,
- 1:16:40in blue cities towards school choice.
- 1:16:42And so people should be able to choose because then
- 1:16:44they're not going to be able to even have.
- 1:16:45I agree.
- 1:16:45I just think on balance,
- 1:16:46like if you wanted to send your kid to school and you were just like,
- 1:16:49would I go to in San Francisco
- 1:16:51or would I send them to school in Shreveport
- 1:16:53if you want to give them the best chance to succeed.
- 1:16:55I think pretty much everybody would say San Francisco.
- 1:16:57There'd be some weird woke stuff that they'd learn,
- 1:17:00but like
- 1:17:00they would have a,
- 1:17:01they would get a good education and like
- 1:17:03there is not that investment happening in red states.
- 1:17:05But what we're seeing in blue states is we're seeing a lot
- 1:17:07of governors and we're seeing a lot of mayors be very adamantly.
- 1:17:11Pro-choice.
- 1:17:12Like they're not advocating for any sort of restrictions on abortion.
- 1:17:16I think that's super problematic,
- 1:17:17and I think we can agree on that.
- 1:17:18And so if you have governors and you have
- 1:17:21mayors who are saying it's OK to kill children,
- 1:17:24I don't really trust their judgment if they think murder's OK.
- 1:17:27Yeah,
- 1:17:28um,
- 1:17:28again,
- 1:17:28and I think that there are different,
- 1:17:29difference of opinions on,
- 1:17:31on abortion.
- 1:17:33Thanks so much.
- 1:17:34Good job.
- 1:17:34Thank you.
- 1:17:43We rolling.
- 1:17:44All right,
- 1:17:44here we go.
- 1:17:46So I think
- 1:17:47when you look at blue states,
- 1:17:48blue cities and red states,
- 1:17:50one of the things you see a major difference in is like
- 1:17:52investment in terms of what,
- 1:17:54uh,
- 1:17:54private companies are investing in,
- 1:17:56you know,
- 1:17:56like
- 1:17:57New York City,
- 1:17:57San Francisco,
- 1:17:58you have a lot of these tech companies that
- 1:18:00are also hiring a lot of white collar workers,
- 1:18:02right,
- 1:18:03whereas some of these blue or red states you're talking about Mississippi,
- 1:18:06Louisiana.
- 1:18:08Used to be blue collar states that are now blue
- 1:18:10collar jobs have dissipated from and gone overseas because of,
- 1:18:14you know,
- 1:18:14free trade
- 1:18:15and stuff.
- 1:18:16Let me,
- 1:18:16let me object to it.
- 1:18:17Just let me give you one example.
- 1:18:18So I,
- 1:18:19I again,
- 1:18:19as I mentioned,
- 1:18:19I live in New Orleans.
- 1:18:20I was thinking about this as I was trying to come up with a good example.
- 1:18:23If you just go up the Mississippi River,
- 1:18:24right,
- 1:18:24so let's take out the coastal states because I do agree
- 1:18:26they're kind of different in the kind of economy it is.
- 1:18:28If you just go up the river,
- 1:18:29you got
- 1:18:30New Orleans,
- 1:18:31Memphis,
- 1:18:31Saint Louis that are all in red states,
- 1:18:33and then you got Minneapolis,
- 1:18:34Saint Paul,
- 1:18:35that's in a blue state at the top.
- 1:18:37Minneapolis-S Saint Paul is thriving.
- 1:18:39A lot of people wanna move there.
- 1:18:40There's a lot of economic opportunity.
- 1:18:42There is,
- 1:18:43um,
- 1:18:44a has a lot more private companies investing in,
- 1:18:47well,
- 1:18:47right,
- 1:18:47but why?
- 1:18:48It's because the governance there has been attractive.
- 1:18:51People wanna move there.
- 1:18:52A lot of tampon access in,
- 1:18:53in,
- 1:18:54uh,
- 1:18:54Minneapolis thanks to Tim Walls,
- 1:18:55you know,
- 1:18:56any bathroom you go into,
- 1:18:57you can get a tampon.
- 1:18:58A lot of people
- 1:19:00wanna go to Minneapolis.
- 1:19:02It's a liberal state
- 1:19:03that has been governed well,
- 1:19:04where the education is good.
- 1:19:06The Healthcare is good,
- 1:19:06so no wonder companies want to go there because,
- 1:19:08uh,
- 1:19:08diverse,
- 1:19:09diverse communities are welcome.
- 1:19:10And then you go down the red states.
- 1:19:12Saint Louis was once one of the biggest cities in the country.
- 1:19:15Memphis was once one of the biggest cities in the country.
- 1:19:16New Orleans,
- 1:19:17where I lived,
- 1:19:17used to be very dynamic.
- 1:19:18They have hollowed out and people don't want to move there because they're governed
- 1:19:22like crap.
- 1:19:23OK,
- 1:19:23when you're talking about moving somewhere,
- 1:19:25where are you primarily going to move for a job,
- 1:19:27right?
- 1:19:28You're not,
- 1:19:28you're,
- 1:19:29yes.
- 1:19:29And so,
- 1:19:30OK,
- 1:19:31so it's the job of the states to try to attract the good jobs.
- 1:19:33The states have been doing that.
- 1:19:34It's not about geography.
- 1:19:35It's not like randomly it's because of the
- 1:19:37coast or because of the certain industries.
- 1:19:39So,
- 1:19:39I mean,
- 1:19:39Tennessee,
- 1:19:40Tennessee,
- 1:19:41Tennessee has had a lot of companies move their tech companies,
- 1:19:44right?
- 1:19:45The thing is,
- 1:19:46I think it's a false equivalency here because,
- 1:19:48OK,
- 1:19:48so a lot of the jobs have left from the Rust Belt and everything.
- 1:19:51These are the states that you're,
- 1:19:53you're saying are,
- 1:19:54you know,
- 1:19:55worse than on average being governed great.
- 1:19:57Josh Shapiro is doing a great job,
- 1:19:58but Michigan is being governor.
- 1:19:59Detroit is having a renaissance right now.
- 1:20:01They have a Democratic governor.
- 1:20:02Wisconsin is being governed.
- 1:20:04Milwaukee's having a renaissance.
- 1:20:05There's no reason that New Orleans,
- 1:20:06but it's Memphis
- 1:20:08or like any of these other cities could be like,
- 1:20:10could be like states you're talking about,
- 1:20:11the cities you're talking about have white collar jobs.
- 1:20:14So obviously those people are gonna
- 1:20:16better on average because they have better income.
- 1:20:18Pittsburgh,
- 1:20:19Detroit,
- 1:20:19Wisconsin,
- 1:20:20that was the rest of them.
- 1:20:20They look at Ohio and Indiana,
- 1:20:23not as many white collar people live there.
- 1:20:25And so of course outcomes are gonna be worse on average.
- 1:20:28And now I want to go back to your,
- 1:20:29your,
- 1:20:31thanks,
- 1:20:31man.
- 1:20:32Good to see you.
- 1:20:40Welcome back.
- 1:20:41What was it?
- 1:20:41JP,
- 1:20:42JP,
- 1:20:42yeah,
- 1:20:43good to see you,
- 1:20:43man.
- 1:20:43Yeah,
- 1:20:44nice to see you again,
- 1:20:45um.
- 1:20:47I don't really wanna talk about like states cities because I see what you're doing.
- 1:20:50You're mentioning the states,
- 1:20:51we're mentioning the cities,
- 1:20:52uh,
- 1:20:53but again,
- 1:20:53like we all know like.
- 1:20:55It's no surprise that people are
- 1:20:57always talking about LA and New York.
- 1:21:00I come to the city for the first time with my little sister.
- 1:21:02It's beautiful.
- 1:21:03It,
- 1:21:03it attracts
- 1:21:04eccentrics.
- 1:21:05It's a wonderful city.
- 1:21:06It represents America.
- 1:21:07I'm from Miami,
- 1:21:08Florida,
- 1:21:08where you don't see all this homelessness,
- 1:21:10right?
- 1:21:10But you see it here.
- 1:21:12You,
- 1:21:12no,
- 1:21:12you don't see it like here,
- 1:21:14and it's no surprise that it's on the news all the time.
- 1:21:16So I wanna move away from that because I know you're gonna do.
- 1:21:18You're gonna mention specific states and you're gonna ignore.
- 1:21:21Uh,
- 1:21:21the social conditions here,
- 1:21:22the poverty rates,
- 1:21:23etc.
- 1:21:24I'm not gonna do that.
- 1:21:25Um,
- 1:21:25I wanna talk about the word Morris that you mentioned.
- 1:21:28Uh,
- 1:21:28I assume you're a big,
- 1:21:29uh,
- 1:21:29Togville guy,
- 1:21:31Alexa Tovill,
- 1:21:31and it's,
- 1:21:32I'm getting old since I'm a dad,
- 1:21:33so it's been,
- 1:21:34it's been a decade since I've read the Tocqueville.
- 1:21:35But yeah,
- 1:21:36for,
- 1:21:36for,
- 1:21:36for the normies,
- 1:21:37Alexa Tocville loved to talk about
- 1:21:39inclinations,
- 1:21:40right,
- 1:21:41about Morris.
- 1:21:42Uh,
- 1:21:42I think that today
- 1:21:43liberal cities have an issue that's not really about government.
- 1:21:46It's about hyper individualism,
- 1:21:49right,
- 1:21:50and we're losing,
- 1:21:51uh,
- 1:21:51let's say the Moors,
- 1:21:53you know,
- 1:21:53the inclinations to make America great.
- 1:21:55Some of those are represented
- 1:21:57in,
- 1:21:57you know,
- 1:21:58rural America,
- 1:21:59and it's,
- 1:22:00it's imperfect,
- 1:22:01perfect,
- 1:22:01you know,
- 1:22:02hard to compare these places,
- 1:22:03but.
- 1:22:04I think that
- 1:22:05you sometimes uh
- 1:22:07make things so much about identity about hyperactive individuality you mentioned
- 1:22:11gay Latino,
- 1:22:12black you're,
- 1:22:13you brought demographics many times today
- 1:22:15and one thing that Trump does and Republicans do
- 1:22:18is they talk about nationhood
- 1:22:20they talk about being an American and right now
- 1:22:21with liberals a lot of times they're like,
- 1:22:23why do all these like people have American flags in their house?
- 1:22:25What are you proud of,
- 1:22:26you know,
- 1:22:26uh,
- 1:22:27have you,
- 1:22:27did you watch the protest,
- 1:22:28the no kings protests,
- 1:22:29uh,
- 1:22:29it was all liberals,
- 1:22:30a lot of American flags,
- 1:22:31a lot of American.
- 1:22:32Flags out there,
- 1:22:33a lot of American flag,
- 1:22:34a lot of them,
- 1:22:34you know,
- 1:22:35saying
- 1:22:35things that,
- 1:22:36and Donald Trump did the thing where he called them the enemy of the people,
- 1:22:40but the enemy within,
- 1:22:41the enemy from within,
- 1:22:42the people that were protesting him,
- 1:22:43he called them the enemy from within.
- 1:22:44He has very kind things to say about foreign despots that like him,
- 1:22:48you know,
- 1:22:48if you're a Sharia laws and dictator,
- 1:22:51you are confusing foreign policymaking.
- 1:22:53Like he's trying to negotiate and get a deal,
- 1:22:55and you're trying to make like,
- 1:22:56oh,
- 1:22:56Maduro loves like Putin,
- 1:22:58and that's what's been eliminated.
- 1:23:00I,
- 1:23:00I wanted to talk about some traditional values stuff,
- 1:23:03but I appreciate it,
- 1:23:03man.
- 1:23:03It's OK.
- 1:23:10All right,
- 1:23:10what's up?
- 1:23:11Good,
- 1:23:11Martin.
- 1:23:12Nice to meet you,
- 1:23:12Martin.
- 1:23:12Nice to meet you,
- 1:23:13man.
- 1:23:13So I think that the whole framing of kind of red states versus blue cities,
- 1:23:16it's,
- 1:23:17it's,
- 1:23:17it's kind of a bad framing because
- 1:23:18we're talking about different levels of analysis.
- 1:23:19I think the best way of looking at this would be
- 1:23:22what happens when a state goes from blue leadership
- 1:23:24to red leadership,
- 1:23:25and I think the best example of that is the
- 1:23:26state of Florida under the leadership of Ron DeSantiss.
- 1:23:29So
- 1:23:29under the leadership of Ron DeSantiss,
- 1:23:30has the poverty rate of Florida gone up or down?
- 1:23:33Um,
- 1:23:33and I don't have all of the Florida stats in front of me,
- 1:23:36um,
- 1:23:36but,
- 1:23:36uh,
- 1:23:37I will say,
- 1:23:37well,
- 1:23:37do you want me to do a little Florida talk?
- 1:23:39I'll,
- 1:23:39I'll give you the,
- 1:23:39the downside of Florida.
- 1:23:41Um,
- 1:23:41I,
- 1:23:41I think that,
- 1:23:42uh,
- 1:23:43right now what you're seeing in Florida is a big rise
- 1:23:46in,
- 1:23:46uh,
- 1:23:47in cost of living because people don't wanna move there.
- 1:23:49I get that there's a lot of,
- 1:23:50there's a lot of,
- 1:23:51there's a supply and poverty,
- 1:23:52but the poverty rate of Florida has gone down.
- 1:23:53Yeah,
- 1:23:53there's supply and demand.
- 1:23:54There's an Adam Smith.
- 1:23:55Yeah,
- 1:23:55why,
- 1:23:55why has it gone down to Florida,
- 1:23:56um.
- 1:23:58You know,
- 1:23:59I think,
- 1:23:59because,
- 1:23:59I think probably because of economic development
- 1:24:01opportunity that's come to the state,
- 1:24:02I guess,
- 1:24:02yeah,
- 1:24:02the main reason why is because when you lower state taxes,
- 1:24:05you attract more businesses.
- 1:24:06Businesses come in that creates more jobs and opportunity for people,
- 1:24:08which is what you see
- 1:24:09on a Republican leadership.
- 1:24:11And that's really why you're seeing,
- 1:24:12you know,
- 1:24:12major companies and people leave states like California in
- 1:24:15droves to go to states like Texas and Florida
- 1:24:18with preferable business.
- 1:24:19California is doing better than the poverty rate.
- 1:24:20Than Florida is though,
- 1:24:21but look,
- 1:24:21Florida has big,
- 1:24:23because,
- 1:24:23because Florida because Florida was Florida has a big insurance rate crisis.
- 1:24:26So look,
- 1:24:26if you're,
- 1:24:27you're,
- 1:24:27you're right,
- 1:24:28if you're doing well in Florida right now,
- 1:24:30if you're like one of the tech bros that moved from San Francisco to Miami,
- 1:24:32you're,
- 1:24:32you're doing well.
- 1:24:33It's more than the health insurance.
- 1:24:34It's,
- 1:24:35it's had record job growth most under the leadership on DeSantis,
- 1:24:38mainly because when you have pro-business policies,
- 1:24:40you're going to have more job growth in your states.
- 1:24:42You love DeSantis.
- 1:24:43That's great.
- 1:24:44I mean,
- 1:24:44are you for him in the primary?
- 1:24:45I,
- 1:24:45I didn't think he's,
- 1:24:46I know,
- 1:24:46I voted for President Trump,
- 1:24:47but I think that why,
- 1:24:49why did I vote for Rhonda Santos,
- 1:24:50the primary,
- 1:24:50that seems like a crazy thing to do.
- 1:24:51Um,
- 1:24:52I think that President Trump's leadership was great in his first term,
- 1:24:54and I think we're seeing it again in his second term.
- 1:24:56But I think let's,
- 1:24:57let's say on the topic of Florida here.
- 1:24:58Um,
- 1:24:59so in,
- 1:24:59in Florida,
- 1:25:00you've seen,
- 1:25:00like I said,
- 1:25:01you've seen record job growth,
- 1:25:02you've seen record,
- 1:25:03record number of poverty the other way.
- 1:25:05Yeah.
- 1:25:06What was that?
- 1:25:07I mean,
- 1:25:07Florida is starting to hit tough times.
- 1:25:08There was definitely a boom with Rhonda Santos,
- 1:25:10and right now they're in a huge insurance crisis,
- 1:25:11right?
- 1:25:12Getting home insurance in Florida is a nightmare in part because of climate change.
- 1:25:15Yeah,
- 1:25:15that's part of hurricanes,
- 1:25:17that's not the fault of Rhonda Santos.
- 1:25:19Well,
- 1:25:19it certainly as a governor,
- 1:25:20it is,
- 1:25:21it is your obligation to try to make sure people can live
- 1:25:23affordable lives in your state and like there's a major insurance crisis.
- 1:25:27Hurricanes that are coming into the state,
- 1:25:28I,
- 1:25:28I mean,
- 1:25:29again,
- 1:25:29yeah,
- 1:25:30I mean there is,
- 1:25:30it is making it unaffordable to live there,
- 1:25:32obviously.
- 1:25:33I think we should focus on things that are actually within the country.
- 1:25:35OK,
- 1:25:35well,
- 1:25:35how about health insurance?
- 1:25:36That's what I was gonna say,
- 1:25:37second,
- 1:25:37lowering taxes,
- 1:25:38businesses to come in,
- 1:25:39getting people to move to your state,
- 1:25:41which is why we've seen a record number of people who've moved to Florida,
- 1:25:43especially since it's come under Republican leadership.
- 1:25:45Second amount of,
- 1:25:46uh.
- 1:25:47Uh,
- 1:25:47uninsured in Florida.
- 1:25:48Uh,
- 1:25:48look,
- 1:25:48here's my thing,
- 1:25:49I,
- 1:25:49and I didn't use Florida as an example because I think
- 1:25:51Ron's done an OK job compared to some of the worst
- 1:25:53red states,
- 1:25:54right?
- 1:25:54But if,
- 1:25:54if we're gonna talk about it,
- 1:25:55I,
- 1:25:56I don't,
- 1:25:56uh,
- 1:25:56you know,
- 1:25:57look,
- 1:25:57I,
- 1:25:57we haven't,
- 1:25:58I,
- 1:25:58I intentionally didn't wanna do like
- 1:26:00gay stuff as a gay here so I just kind of all,
- 1:26:03all,
- 1:26:03uh,
- 1:26:04you know,
- 1:26:04kind of focus on that issue,
- 1:26:05but as,
- 1:26:05as a,
- 1:26:06as a gay parent.
- 1:26:07I wouldn't move to Florida,
- 1:26:09uh,
- 1:26:09because,
- 1:26:09because Rhonda Santos put in a law.
- 1:26:11Well,
- 1:26:11you,
- 1:26:11you disagree with the vast majority of Americans
- 1:26:13who are moving there from blue states.
- 1:26:15I'd,
- 1:26:15I'd like to explain why I would.
- 1:26:16I'd like to explain why I would move there
- 1:26:17because Rhonda Santos put in a law
- 1:26:20where any.
- 1:26:21Any Karen
- 1:26:22could sue a school if a teacher
- 1:26:25is,
- 1:26:26uh,
- 1:26:26has Antango Makes 3,
- 1:26:28the Book of Gay Penguins.
- 1:26:29If,
- 1:26:29if,
- 1:26:29if they have to read that in porn in our schools,
- 1:26:32absolutely you should be able to.
- 1:26:33Is that a penguin porn book?
- 1:26:34Um,
- 1:26:34there are
- 1:26:36the have you seen a gay penguin or porn book?
- 1:26:37The amount of soft porn in our libraries is.
- 1:26:39No,
- 1:26:39I'm against porn.
- 1:26:40Uh,
- 1:26:40I'm also against porn.
- 1:26:41So then you're,
- 1:26:41so then you're against the vast majority of the books
- 1:26:43that have been banned in the state of Florida.
- 1:26:44Um,
- 1:26:44well,
- 1:26:44no.
- 1:26:45But,
- 1:26:45uh,
- 1:26:45I guess my point is that you could sue a teacher
- 1:26:47for having a picture of them and their spouse in Florida.
- 1:26:50That's like something that's legal now.
- 1:26:51They,
- 1:26:51they had a bill.
- 1:26:52Yeah,
- 1:26:52I don't think gender ideology and these
- 1:26:54other weird sexual orientation ideology pushed on kids.
- 1:26:57So that's an interesting question.
- 1:26:58So,
- 1:26:58so my kid's 7,
- 1:26:59she's got two dads.
- 1:27:00So she went to school and the assignment was,
- 1:27:03OK,
- 1:27:03we've kind of strayed a little bit away here from the original,
- 1:27:05no,
- 1:27:05it isn't.
- 1:27:05This is about can you agree that governance?
- 1:27:07Yeah,
- 1:27:07can you agree that the economics of a red.
- 1:27:09I has gotten better since coming from Blue.
- 1:27:11I,
- 1:27:11I would like to finish my hypothetical,
- 1:27:12um,
- 1:27:13and,
- 1:27:14and,
- 1:27:14and so
- 1:27:15if they are gonna get an assignment which is give us your family tree,
- 1:27:17my daughter's given an assignment says give us your family tree in Florida,
- 1:27:20and she,
- 1:27:21uh,
- 1:27:22does that assignment and it includes,
- 1:27:24uh,
- 1:27:24two dads,
- 1:27:25and that some other kid in the class doesn't like
- 1:27:28that and goes home and tells their mom or dad,
- 1:27:30and then that dad in Florida now can sue the school.
- 1:27:33Um,
- 1:27:34well,
- 1:27:34the kid,
- 1:27:35the American people feel.
- 1:27:36I also,
- 1:27:37I also like to note real quick that you didn't answer my,
- 1:27:38you didn't answer my question on the economics part
- 1:27:40because you know that Florida has gotten better and the
- 1:27:42red states get better and that states get better
- 1:27:44when they go from blue leadership to red leadership.
- 1:27:46Well,
- 1:27:46that's on your hypothetical.
- 1:27:47No,
- 1:27:47look at Colorado.
- 1:27:48We did,
- 1:27:48I just did this,
- 1:27:50uh,
- 1:27:50Pennsylvania,
- 1:27:50Josh Spiro,
- 1:27:51it's gotten much better.
- 1:27:52Uh,
- 1:27:52Colorado,
- 1:27:53Jared Polis is doing a great job.
- 1:27:55Um,
- 1:27:55I think that Kentucky has gotten far worse than the leadership of any machine.
- 1:27:57That is totally not true.
- 1:27:59Yes,
- 1:27:59it absolutely is.
- 1:28:00So I,
- 1:28:00I,
- 1:28:00yeah,
- 1:28:00I think that this is kind of crazy.
- 1:28:01I think they're trying to do an outlier.
- 1:28:03We can argue.
- 1:28:03About Florida,
- 1:28:04I don't think that Florida has gotten better,
- 1:28:06actually.
- 1:28:06That's gonna be just,
- 1:28:07I mean me,
- 1:28:07the stats would just flat out disagree with you.
- 1:28:09The poverty rate would disagree with you.
- 1:28:10The job to disagree with you,
- 1:28:11trying to see if the amount of people who moved there had disagree with you.
- 1:28:13Yeah,
- 1:28:14I do think Ron DeSantiss would have been a better president than Donald Trump.
- 1:28:16That's not really what we're debating.
- 1:28:17I wish you,
- 1:28:18I wish,
- 1:28:19I wish you would have been for that.
- 1:28:20I don't think,
- 1:28:20I don't think,
- 1:28:21I definitely don't think you would have seen people storming the Capitol
- 1:28:24with Ron de sanctimonious flags,
- 1:28:26beating up cops.
- 1:28:27Ron,
- 1:28:27I think,
- 1:28:28I think that's very safe.
- 1:28:29Pause,
- 1:28:30pause,
- 1:28:30pause.
- 1:28:30Time's up.
- 1:28:31Thanks.
- 1:28:32Good to see you,
- 1:28:32man.
- 1:28:39Tim will now choose someone from the circle to come back
- 1:28:41to the center and debate a claim of their choosing.
- 1:28:47I think I will go with the gentleman that's been taking notes over here.
- 1:28:49I felt like we have some unfinished business.
- 1:28:55My claim is from the moment of conception,
- 1:28:59abortion is a grave moral evil.
- 1:29:02From the moment of conception,
- 1:29:04I guess I would disagree with you,
- 1:29:05um,
- 1:29:06but I think that,
- 1:29:07um,
- 1:29:08that abortion reaches a point where it is a grave moral evil,
- 1:29:12and I would agree with you on that.
- 1:29:13I think it's something that I fall
- 1:29:15on,
- 1:29:15uh,
- 1:29:15a disparate side with a lot of people on the left on.
- 1:29:18I'm curious where you put the line.
- 1:29:20You know,
- 1:29:20I think that's,
- 1:29:21I think it's complicated,
- 1:29:22um,
- 1:29:23but I'm pretty,
- 1:29:24um,
- 1:29:24compelled
- 1:29:25by,
- 1:29:26uh,
- 1:29:26arguments related to the heartbeat,
- 1:29:28and I'll tell you this,
- 1:29:29I,
- 1:29:29so I,
- 1:29:30I,
- 1:29:30um,
- 1:29:30adopted my child.
- 1:29:31Um,
- 1:29:32I've been,
- 1:29:33uh,
- 1:29:33we had a couple of adoptions that went south,
- 1:29:35uh,
- 1:29:35where I went and sat with,
- 1:29:38uh,
- 1:29:38mothers that were trying to make this hard choice what to do,
- 1:29:41whether to have their child or whether to,
- 1:29:43uh,
- 1:29:44terminate the pregnancy,
- 1:29:45whether to parent the child,
- 1:29:47whether to give the child up for adoption.
- 1:29:48And so I get to sit there with them,
- 1:29:50um,
- 1:29:51uh,
- 1:29:51in the hospital room,
- 1:29:52uh,
- 1:29:53where you can,
- 1:29:53you know,
- 1:29:54look at the,
- 1:29:55uh,
- 1:29:55monitor,
- 1:29:56you can see the heartbeat,
- 1:29:57you can see the little fingers,
- 1:29:59and,
- 1:29:59and in those rooms like you can feel a grave moral weight like you can just feel it,
- 1:30:04like you can feel that the decision is a big decision.
- 1:30:07I,
- 1:30:07I think that,
- 1:30:08um.
- 1:30:09You know,
- 1:30:10when you get into now the nitty gritty of like how the government remediates that,
- 1:30:14like I think that there are different questions,
- 1:30:16the different this is obviously a really important thing just given the numbers,
- 1:30:21right?
- 1:30:21And so I think someone said earlier,
- 1:30:23it's almost like a third of Gen Z is not here because of abortion.
- 1:30:27And so
- 1:30:28whether,
- 1:30:29you know,
- 1:30:30where we But the line is actually a huge thing that we need to
- 1:30:34get right on because
- 1:30:35human rights,
- 1:30:36right,
- 1:30:36the,
- 1:30:37the right to life is at stake.
- 1:30:38And so
- 1:30:39I think this is something very important that we need to think about.
- 1:30:42And so you said you're persuaded by heartbeat arguments.
- 1:30:45I'm,
- 1:30:46I'm,
- 1:30:46I'm uh just
- 1:30:47curious,
- 1:30:48what about a heartbeat makes you a human being,
- 1:30:52a valuable human being?
- 1:30:53That's worth protecting.
- 1:30:54Well,
- 1:30:54I think,
- 1:30:55um,
- 1:30:55well,
- 1:30:56I think every human being has value,
- 1:30:58and I guess this is where I get into,
- 1:30:59uh,
- 1:30:59if,
- 1:30:59if I,
- 1:31:00I'm not trying to do it like debate trick where I duck your question because I'm,
- 1:31:03I'm happy to come back to this,
- 1:31:05um,
- 1:31:05but like,
- 1:31:06uh,
- 1:31:06this is where I do get frustrated with people on the right,
- 1:31:09like,
- 1:31:09and,
- 1:31:09and people in particularly that have supported Donald Trump
- 1:31:12to talk who,
- 1:31:12who talk about the fact that,
- 1:31:14uh,
- 1:31:14they believe that every human has value and has dignity
- 1:31:18because I,
- 1:31:18I just,
- 1:31:18I can't think
- 1:31:20of a
- 1:31:21public figure
- 1:31:22in my entire.
- 1:31:23Life who's had less respect for human dignity
- 1:31:27and human life than this president.
- 1:31:28Well,
- 1:31:28maybe Joe Biden that advocates for abortion.
- 1:31:32Well,
- 1:31:32no,
- 1:31:32no,
- 1:31:33again,
- 1:31:33you're talking about,
- 1:31:34OK,
- 1:31:34again,
- 1:31:35you're talking,
- 1:31:36you're talking about just abortion.
- 1:31:37And again,
- 1:31:38we can look,
- 1:31:38look,
- 1:31:39I,
- 1:31:39I'm not,
- 1:31:40I'm not an expert.
- 1:31:40We didn't,
- 1:31:41I didn't know.
- 1:31:41Well,
- 1:31:42no,
- 1:31:42of course it's a huge issue.
- 1:31:43And like I said,
- 1:31:43I think that,
- 1:31:44look,
- 1:31:44I think that European countries handle it well,
- 1:31:46so let me just go your whole argument is you haven't heard my argument.
- 1:31:50Well,
- 1:31:51I know what you're gonna say is Donald Trump.
- 1:31:52Has has done all these terrible things,
- 1:31:55right?
- 1:31:55But
- 1:31:56all the conclusion is from your argument is
- 1:31:59that Trump supporters that are pro-life are hypocrites.
- 1:32:01That's it.
- 1:32:02It has nothing to do with their,
- 1:32:04their life.
- 1:32:05I'm actually,
- 1:32:05we're doing this.
- 1:32:06I love that we're doing this.
- 1:32:07I'm hoping a lot of young,
- 1:32:08uh,
- 1:32:09MAGA and young conservatives are,
- 1:32:10are,
- 1:32:10are watching this,
- 1:32:11particularly young Christians.
- 1:32:12I want them to watch this and,
- 1:32:14and I want,
- 1:32:15I'm hoping to try to compel them to the arguments that
- 1:32:17that like that human life having value,
- 1:32:19if you believe that in the unborn,
- 1:32:21which I.
- 1:32:22Again,
- 1:32:22which I do,
- 1:32:23and I think there's some questions about like what 3 weeks and 4 weeks,
- 1:32:26but like I believe that every human life has value.
- 1:32:28If you believe that,
- 1:32:30then it's not about hypocrisy,
- 1:32:31it's about manifesting that same
- 1:32:34view of life
- 1:32:36once the kid is born.
- 1:32:37And in this country
- 1:32:38we are eradicating support
- 1:32:41for mothers,
- 1:32:41for single mothers who need support to help their kids.
- 1:32:44Can I,
- 1:32:44can I finish?
- 1:32:45We are menacing,
- 1:32:46we are no,
- 1:32:47no,
- 1:32:47we,
- 1:32:47no,
- 1:32:47we are menacing.
- 1:32:48No,
- 1:32:49no,
- 1:32:49it doesn't,
- 1:32:49it has everything to do with it.
- 1:32:51Why?
- 1:32:52Abortion a grave moral evil from the moment
- 1:32:53of conception because every human life has dignity,
- 1:32:56right?
- 1:32:56Well,
- 1:32:56right,
- 1:32:57because it's literally the murder of an innocent.
- 1:32:59OK,
- 1:32:59great.
- 1:32:59And so if every human life has dignity,
- 1:33:02then we have to treat each other as such.
- 1:33:05We cannot,
- 1:33:06and,
- 1:33:06and,
- 1:33:06and,
- 1:33:07and that,
- 1:33:07and that child when they're born,
- 1:33:08that little baby when they're born,
- 1:33:10they need to be able to survive.
- 1:33:12So we need to make sure that they have the medical treatment to survive.
- 1:33:14No,
- 1:33:14the mothers need to have support.
- 1:33:19Uh,
- 1:33:19the kids need to be able to go to good organizations.
- 1:33:19The kids,
- 1:33:20the kids don't want to be scared.
- 1:33:21That they're going to die by a mass shooter in their schools.
- 1:33:24But Tim,
- 1:33:25Tim,
- 1:33:25our differences,
- 1:33:26our different country doesn't want to be deported.
- 1:33:28I'm sorry,
- 1:33:29no,
- 1:33:29no,
- 1:33:29no,
- 1:33:30Tim,
- 1:33:30our differences in opinion on what constitutes human flourishing when it comes to
- 1:33:35immigration or wealth,
- 1:33:37the welfare state or or healthcare or all these different things,
- 1:33:40dignity.
- 1:33:41OK,
- 1:33:41human dignity.
- 1:33:42What our differences in our views with that have nothing to do
- 1:33:46with whether it's a human being at the moment of conception.
- 1:33:50It has to do,
- 1:33:50no,
- 1:33:50it doesn't.
- 1:33:51Tim,
- 1:33:51how?
- 1:33:53How?
- 1:33:53What is the argument that a heartbeat is what makes a human being
- 1:33:57a valuable person?
- 1:33:58I came from a background of pro-life,
- 1:34:00as I said,
- 1:34:00and I,
- 1:34:01I came as a Republican.
- 1:34:02I came from a Catholic family,
- 1:34:04and I,
- 1:34:04and I believe
- 1:34:06that that unborn life has value.
- 1:34:08But human life having value,
- 1:34:10being pro-life
- 1:34:11means instituting a culture of life.
- 1:34:12And when I was growing up
- 1:34:14in the Republican Party and in the pro-life movement,
- 1:34:17this was something that people talked about,
- 1:34:18about the culture of life.
- 1:34:19It it all,
- 1:34:20it meant all the way.
- 1:34:21Life until death.
- 1:34:22It meant not having the death penalty.
- 1:34:23It meant not sending people to foreign gulags.
- 1:34:25It meant being compassionate conservatism.
- 1:34:27It meant giving mothers treatment.
- 1:34:29No,
- 1:34:30no,
- 1:34:30no,
- 1:34:30it means all of those things,
- 1:34:31man,
- 1:34:32and I want a culture of life in the human being is
- 1:34:35completely different from a criminal who
- 1:34:38has raped and murdered innocent individuals.
- 1:34:41OK,
- 1:34:41well,
- 1:34:41sure they're completely different cases.
- 1:34:43No,
- 1:34:43we live in a society where you're gonna have to make laws.
- 1:34:46You have to understand the rights,
- 1:34:48because in a,
- 1:34:48in a situation of an abortion,
- 1:34:49as you know.
- 1:34:50Um,
- 1:34:51we are also,
- 1:34:52we're talking about two human lives,
- 1:34:53two human lives,
- 1:34:54excuse me,
- 1:34:55like the life of the mother has value
- 1:34:57in addition to,
- 1:34:58in addition to the unborn life,
- 1:34:59right?
- 1:35:00And so,
- 1:35:01uh,
- 1:35:01you have to respect the rights of the mother to be able to make,
- 1:35:04um,
- 1:35:04uh,
- 1:35:05to,
- 1:35:05they'll make judgments based on their health,
- 1:35:07um,
- 1:35:08the rights of the mother to,
- 1:35:09uh,
- 1:35:10you know,
- 1:35:10make judgments based on,
- 1:35:12but we don't,
- 1:35:12we don't allow
- 1:35:14mothers right to murder
- 1:35:16their newborns,
- 1:35:17right,
- 1:35:17or their two year olds,
- 1:35:19right?
- 1:35:20So we went,
- 1:35:20right,
- 1:35:20right,
- 1:35:21exactly.
- 1:35:21I'm against 2nd and 3rd trimester abortion.
- 1:35:23I know,
- 1:35:23but you brought it up as an argument.
- 1:35:24And so,
- 1:35:25you know,
- 1:35:26we don't do that.
- 1:35:26Why is that?
- 1:35:27It's because the newborn
- 1:35:29and the 2 year old are human beings that we need to protect,
- 1:35:32right?
- 1:35:33And so let's get back to the actual question.
- 1:35:36Let's,
- 1:35:36no,
- 1:35:36no,
- 1:35:36now you're bringing it back up.
- 1:35:37Let's protect the newborns.
- 1:35:39Let's protect the people that are fleeing and want to
- 1:35:42come to this country to have a life for themselves.
- 1:35:44Let's protect,
- 1:35:45uh,
- 1:35:45people,
- 1:35:46uh,
- 1:35:46mothers,
- 1:35:47uh,
- 1:35:47who.
- 1:35:48disproportionately in red states who are dying in childbirth,
- 1:35:52let's protect the kids let's protect infant mortality.
- 1:35:56You have a single argument for why the unborn before a heartbeat is not a human being,
- 1:36:01and we can kill it.
- 1:36:03Yeah,
- 1:36:03you have a single argument.
- 1:36:04Yeah,
- 1:36:04no,
- 1:36:04my argument is basically that it's a tough judgment call,
- 1:36:06and I think that if you're making laws in a country that is not a Christian country,
- 1:36:09how is it a tough judgment call?
- 1:36:11The science of embryology is extremely clear from the moment of conception.
- 1:36:15This is when a
- 1:36:17new distinct human being comes into existence.
- 1:36:20So that would make IVF illegal in a lot of cases because they're,
- 1:36:23you know,
- 1:36:23right,
- 1:36:23a lot of pro-lifers are against IVF.
- 1:36:26Actually,
- 1:36:26you,
- 1:36:27Trump actually rescinded some of his
- 1:36:29statements and policies about IVF because he
- 1:36:31got so much pushback from the pro-life.
- 1:36:33Yeah,
- 1:36:33and so that's,
- 1:36:34and so that's what I'm saying.
- 1:36:35I think that,
- 1:36:35I think that those are really tough moral questions.
- 1:36:37Look,
- 1:36:37we live,
- 1:36:37we don't live in a Christian,
- 1:36:39but like a Christian this is,
- 1:36:40this is jubilee.
- 1:36:41Like this is where we're supposed to have these tough moral questions,
- 1:36:44and I'm telling you.
- 1:36:45And I'm telling you,
- 1:36:46I think that there's some clear,
- 1:36:47there's some areas where it's clear.
- 1:36:49I think we're not living in a Christian nationalist country.
- 1:36:51We are not living in a,
- 1:36:52in a,
- 1:36:53and so
- 1:36:54if you're gonna live in a pluralistic society where people have different views,
- 1:36:57you have to respect the rights of the mother and the baby,
- 1:36:59like I,
- 1:37:00I just think that early on in,
- 1:37:02in a pregnancy,
- 1:37:04like you have to make laws that that are gonna be the equivalent of,
- 1:37:08of going back to like when slavery was around and saying,
- 1:37:11oh well,
- 1:37:11slavery is a very complicated issue.
- 1:37:13You know,
- 1:37:14these farms,
- 1:37:15these plantations are hiring people,
- 1:37:18right?
- 1:37:18And so exactly,
- 1:37:19that's,
- 1:37:20that's what you're saying,
- 1:37:21and I'm saying it's actually really not that complicated of an issue.
- 1:37:25It is a human life worth protecting.
- 1:37:27And in the same way of slavery was wrong,
- 1:37:31passion for
- 1:37:33life
- 1:37:34from the life of the 1 week old zygote.
- 1:37:37I wish we had that passion for the 2 year olds that are dying of my generation is gone.
- 1:37:43They are gone because of abortion,
- 1:37:45Tim.
- 1:37:47This,
- 1:37:48this is the greatest moral tragedy,
- 1:37:50I would say even greater than the Holocaust.
- 1:37:53As far as millions of lives are being killed,
- 1:37:57if I am correct.
- 1:37:58I absolutely,
- 1:38:00I am very passionate about that issue because of the implications.
- 1:38:04And so Tim,
- 1:38:05I,
- 1:38:06I,
- 1:38:06I love your heart.
- 1:38:07I really see your heart behind it.
- 1:38:09All I'm saying is
- 1:38:10please come up with some arguments
- 1:38:13that
- 1:38:13will actually define the view or become pro-life
- 1:38:16or from the moment of conception,
- 1:38:18defend the unborn.
- 1:38:22I appreciate your passion on this issue and like you said to me,
- 1:38:24I,
- 1:38:25I,
- 1:38:25I,
- 1:38:26my wish for you back and for folks that have this view is that
- 1:38:29that they
- 1:38:30would have the same passion
- 1:38:33about for the human dignity
- 1:38:34of the people
- 1:38:35that are being badly,
- 1:38:37badly mistreated
- 1:38:39by this administration,
- 1:38:40um,
- 1:38:41that they do for unborn kids.
- 1:38:43I will have that passion when abortion is completely ended in this country.
- 1:38:47Appreciate it.
- 1:38:48All right,
- 1:38:49great to see you.
- 1:38:50Good talking to you.
- 1:38:54I think we've all gotten in our own silos so much,
- 1:38:56uh,
- 1:38:57when we're talking,
- 1:38:58particularly those of us who are like in the media.
- 1:39:00And um after the last election and Trump won,
- 1:39:03I really wanted to commit myself to at least trying
- 1:39:06to communicate with people kind of outside the anti-Trump bubble
- 1:39:10and uh and and particularly talk to younger people
- 1:39:12who I think feel very polarized right now.
- 1:39:15I think Tim Miller is a great millennial debater.
- 1:39:18I think his stances come from a place of compassion
- 1:39:21of just wanting the world to be a better place.
- 1:39:23I think that was something when we were talking about
- 1:39:26immigration or abortion or just children in.
- 1:39:29General,
- 1:39:29something we could all agree on is
- 1:39:31we really want those demographics to be protected and
- 1:39:34we may have different ways of going about that,
- 1:39:36but we care about them.
- 1:39:37There's a deeper conversation that needs to be had in this country and it's
- 1:39:40not about guns or abortion or these issues that are important to have,
- 1:39:45but also some deeper conversations about
- 1:39:48social cohesion.
- 1:39:49What does it mean to be an American?
- 1:39:51How do we move forward?
- 1:39:52The main thing you do as an individual to bridge the partisan divide is to
- 1:39:56see people from the other side as humans.
- 1:39:59Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:40:01your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:40:04And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:40:06subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.