Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Always Says They Are Too Busy
Transcript
- Lucas: You're in your weekly one-on-one, and you ask a team member to take the lead on a new project. Before you finish the sentence, they say, 'I'd love to, but I'm just too busy right now.' Luna: Classic. And if you're a first-time manager, that can be a real conversation-stopper. You don't want to pile on, but you also need the work done. Lucas: Exactly. Today we're looking at the employee who always says they're too busy. It's one of the most common deflection tactics — and it's also one of the trickiest to handle because sometimes they really are overloaded. Luna: Right, you don't want to be the manager who dismisses their workload. But if it becomes a pattern, it's a problem. Lucas: I want to start with a specific case. At a mid-size SaaS company — about 300 employees — there was a senior engineer named Priya. She was great technically, but over about six months, she turned down three straight project assignments citing capacity. Her manager, a first-time manager named Dan, initially backed off. He didn't want to burn her out. Luna: I bet that created a resentment spiral. Other team members had to pick up the slack, right? Lucas: Exactly. And Dan started to notice that Priya still had time for interesting side tasks — she'd volunteer for a cool proof of concept, but not for the routine maintenance work. So the 'too busy' wasn't universal. It was selective. Luna: That's a huge clue. It's not about total hours — it's about what she prioritized. Lucas: Right. So Dan decided to try a different approach. Instead of accepting the 'too busy' at face value, he scheduled a dedicated thirty-minute conversation — just about capacity. He called it the capacity conversation. Luna: I love that framing. It's not a confrontation. It's a joint problem-solving session. Lucas: Exactly. Dan started by saying, 'I hear you that you're stretched. Help me understand what you're working on so we can figure out what to reprioritize.' He asked Priya to bring a list of everything on her plate — including estimated hours per week. Luna: That's a smart move. It moves the conversation from subjective feeling to data. Lucas: And what Priya brought was revealing. She had about forty-five hours of work listed — but when they looked closer, about ten of those hours were on low-impact tasks that didn't align with the team's top priorities. Things like perfecting internal documentation that nobody used. Luna: So the capacity wasn't the real issue. It was about autonomy. She was choosing the work she liked. Lucas: Bingo. And Dan didn't call her out. He said, 'Okay, if we drop these three low-impact items, that frees up about ten hours. Could you then take on the new project?' And she agreed. Luna: But what about cases where the employee genuinely is overwhelmed? I had a situation once where a direct report was working sixty-hour weeks, and when I asked for a time log, it showed she was doing work that belonged to another team. Lucas: That's a different animal. In that case, 'too busy' is a cry for help. The capacity conversation can still work, but the solution is different — you need to protect them from external demands, not reprioritize internal ones. Luna: Right. So how do you tell the difference between selective busy and genuine overload? Lucas: Look for patterns. Selective busy people say no to certain types of work — usually the boring or difficult stuff. Genuinely overloaded people say no to everything, including things they enjoy. Also, overloaded people often show signs of stress — missed deadlines, lower quality, fatigue. The selective busy employee still delivers on the work they choose. Luna: That's a good diagnostic. And I think the capacity conversation forces that diagnosis naturally. If they can't produce a time log, or if the log reveals a lot of low-value work, you know it's a prioritization issue. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the key: as the manager, you have the authority to say, 'I'm making these tasks your priority, and these other tasks can wait or be dropped.' That's the trade-off conversation. Luna: I've seen managers shy away from that because they don't want to dictate someone's day. But it's actually empowering. You're giving permission to stop doing low-value work. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the real job of a manager — to help people focus on what matters. If an employee says they're too busy, your job isn't to just accept it. It's to figure out if they're working on the right things. Luna: You know, this topic reminds me of something. A lot of listeners have told us that these episodes genuinely help them navigate tough Monday mornings. And I think if today's conversation has been useful to you in that way, there's a simple way to keep this show ad-free and going. Lucas: Yeah. If this episode was worth a coffee to you, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure — just a way for listeners who value the show to support it directly. Luna: And honestly, even just knowing that people find this stuff useful keeps us going. So thanks for that. Lucas: Alright, back to Priya and Dan. After that capacity conversation, Dan started using a simple tool: every time he assigned new work, he'd also explicitly say, 'If this conflicts with something on your plate, let's talk trade-offs.' Luna: That preempts the 'too busy' reflex. It frames it as a negotiation, not a refusal. Lucas: And it worked. Priya stopped defaulting to 'I'm too busy.' She started saying, 'I have X on my plate, but if Y can wait, I can do this.' That's a much healthier dynamic. Luna: So the takeaway for managers is: don't let 'I'm too busy' be the end of the conversation. Use the capacity conversation to dig into what's really going on. Lucas: And then act on what you find. If it's selective busy, reprioritize. If it's genuine overload, protect them. Either way, you're leading, not just accepting. Luna: I think the hardest part for new managers is having that first conversation. They're afraid of seeming unsympathetic. Lucas: That's why I like the framing of it as a joint problem-solving session. You're not saying, 'I don't believe you.' You're saying, 'Help me understand so I can help.' That's empathy with action. Luna: And if they resist even that? What if they say, 'I don't have time to log my hours'? Lucas: Then you have a different problem. That's a trust or engagement issue. But you still need to address it. You can say, 'I understand you're busy. Let's use the next week as a test — just jot down major tasks. It doesn't have to be perfect.' If they still refuse, that tells you something important. Luna: Right. At that point, it's not about capacity anymore. It's about willingness. Lucas: And that's a conversation for another day — or another episode. For now, try the capacity conversation. It'll change how you manage the 'too busy' employee.