Latest / Ego and Other Things / My Philosophy - Introduction
Transcript
- William: Alright, so I'm gonna try and begin to stumble through talking about my philosophy, which I don't really think I've ever done in a very deliberate capacity, at least when it comes to speaking. So this is somewhat new for me. And or I've really only done it in bits and pieces and maybe in conversations with people, but never in terms of a recording. But I've been encouraged recently by the experiences I've had with street evangelism. ⁓ I lead a group of street preachers essentially and we go out on Sundays and we preach the gospel ⁓ downtown in in my town here. And the one thing I've learned about preaching the gospel, especially in public, is that it's a very difficult thing to do. Or at least it's it's very nerve-wracking. And or at least it it's very nerve-wracking for me. And even though the gospel message in and of itself is quite simple, you can find yourself messing it up all the time. You can find yourself interjecting your own, I guess, biased interpretation of it a lot of the times. And it pretty much always comes out imperfectly, and you pretty much always hope that the next time you'll do better and that Jesus will enable you to do better the next time. But the point is you kinda go out there anyway, and Jesus encourages in you in this. You know, go out and and go out and make disciples, right? And you sort of just accept the humility of the fact that you're not going to do it perfectly and that but that you're you're being called to do it anyway. And I want to take that attitude to talking about my philosophy because what I noticed with the the street evangelism is that after the first couple times, you kinda just go okay with it, right? You just kinda get okay with the fact that you are not gonna be perfect out there and actually allows you to be a little bit more authentic, right? ⁓ of my philosophy has to do with that. Much of my philosophy has to do with being authentic. And I've even talked about this before, where you need to take these deliberate risks ⁓ order to develop that authenticity because ⁓ lowers that threshold of fear ⁓ comes about from ⁓ different layers of social conditioning, to put it bluntly. And so this is my attempt at that where ⁓ just gonna try and do these kind of long form ⁓ content videos with as little editing as possible and talk about my philosophy as best as I can without trying to perfect it, without trying to make it sound like super profound and world changing and world shattering, but just talking about it and getting comfortable talking about it. Because I'm okay at writing about it. Though I again I've never really done a systemic piece. I'm working on building a systemic piece right now, but or a systemic book, essentially. But I've never I guess talked about it in a systemic way. So that's what we're gonna attempt here. ⁓ And the ways that I've been thinking about introducing it is you know I guess to to kind of start frame you know frame it right frame the philosophy like what is the purpose of not just philosophy in general because that can be a a a giant wide conversation that is totally separate but what is the purpose of my philosophy? You know what is it that I'm trying to do with it? What are what what question am I trying to answer? What problem am I trying to solve? And the most succinct way that I Can think about putting it, is I am trying to answer the question, what does it mean to live a meaningfully good life? And how do you actually go about doing it? That's a simple way of putting it, and there's there's a lot in there, which is kind of what we're gonna proceed to talk about because there's the question itself, but there's also the question of okay, what actually gets in the way of a meaningful good relationshi meaningfully good life? ⁓ is it that we live in a world where meaningly a meaningfully good life is not sort of automatic? ⁓ you know, can we ⁓ we actually come to ⁓ solutions ⁓ changing ourselves and changing the world? ⁓ ⁓ so that we are able to live meaningfully good lives? And how does this whole idea stand up against just like pure nihilism, pure power? Like why isn't it that ⁓ another way of asking the question is something like, well why shouldn't I just go after power and pleasure? Right? Why shouldn't I just do whatever I can get away with As long as it's beneficial to me, right? Because that's sort of the base case. The the very natural way of being is something like, well, what what can I get away with that's going to make me happy? You know, when you're outside of the social conditioning, when you're outside of ⁓ the law, when you're outside of the the moral conditioning, when you're outside of just accepting the premises that have been given to you by the world, what is it that stops you from just A acting on what you can get away with. And so I'm gonna try and break it down like this, the structure of talking about this. Today I'm gonna introduce it. And maybe today I'm gonna introduce it and talking a little bit about the background, like why am I concerned with this question to begin with? But then afterwards I'm thinking about going right into the question, right into answering the question, what is a meaningfully good life? Just to kind of set the standard of what we're after. And that whole question, as anybody who is familiar with philosophy, is incredibly res involved, incredibly controversial, ⁓ complex in some areas. ⁓ think when you're speaking about it you naturally have to simplify things and again, ⁓ don't have ⁓ a whole bunch of experience ⁓ verbally talking about it and again most people who are familiar with the differences between writing and and talking about it, they're two different kinds of skill sets. But I'm gonna do my best and we're gonna talk about w ⁓ what is a meaningfully good life, at least what I've discovered or what I think the best that I can the best that I can articulate about what it means to live a meaningfully good life. And then from there we're gonna move on to the question of c of sort of like what went wrong, which is two questions. One, you know, what prevents us from living a meaningfully good life now? What prevents us from reaching that standard? And then secondly, what created these conditions? I mean, what what is it that why isn't it that you know, we don't just automatically live in a world that's meaningfully good. Which is worth asking because It's not it's I would say it's we kinda come with the assumption that the world is is has sort of this innate suffering to it or this innate pain to it or this innate brokenness. You know, I like that I like that term a lot. and But why is it the case? You know, why is it the case that it's broken? Why is it the case that there's misery and suffering? Why isn't it just s sort of na why why why would any of these things come about in the first place? Why isn't it just sort of naturally paradise, naturally meaningful and good, you might say, right? ⁓ and there's some we'll get into history, we'll g we'll talk about childhood, we'll talk about social dynamics, power, the state, markets, economy. There's a whole bunch of stuff that's involved in there too. And again, it's it's large, it is complex, and of course in philosophy it's controversial. Even if you get to the standard of what is good and meaningful, the question of what went wrong itself is a whole other can of worms. And then lastly, we'll talk about okay or thirdly, we'll talk about Well, now that we know what the g the the standard of the good is and we know what went wrong, how can we overcome what went wrong? How can we overcome the obstacles that have been put in our way? What are the actual practical strategies going forward to kind of get us individually and as a society towards a meaningfully good life? And again, you know that's that's ⁓ Big area, lots of controversy. And then lastly, we'll talk about okay, does all of this stand up to scrutiny? It's something like I'm going to take everything that I have talked about up until that point in terms of my philosophy and do my best to critique it, do my best to kind of destroy it as much as possible and see if it stands up to my best attempt at scrutinizing it. And especially testing it against nihilism, testing it against the philosophy of why not just get as much as I can get away with in life, rather than commit myself to any sort of moral principles or etc. etc. ⁓ and that's that's the plan so far. That's just a general structure. Maybe it'll change, maybe things will come up, maybe other things will happen, but this is gonna be just my attempt at articulating it and getting over the hump of doing it, right? ⁓ so for the rest of this recording I'm just gonna talk about a little bit about why this is important to me, because of course, a philosophy doesn't really just come out of nowhere. It comes out of a particular context. And what I like to say is that philosophy is always inevitably individual, in the sense that, you know different philosophers might be part of the same school, they might be engaged in similar ideas, they may use similar concepts in similar ways, but people are attracted to ideas because of the context in which they've grown up in. And people are invested in certain parts of philosophy because of what they're after. You can never really get away from the individual and his valuation in understanding of philosophy. And sometimes you can even analyze one's motivations for philosophizing, which a person may or may not be explicitly aware of, and not necessarily dismiss the entire philosophy, but ask yourself whether or not it's worth pursuing. Because you might just not be interested in that that area whatsoever. And I'm gonna try to be brief about this. Because it it involves some personal hardship, but I don't want it to I don't want this to just become about like an autobiography if that makes sense. I just sort of want to give a little bit of the context for why this is important to me in the first place. And so I'll try to be brief about it while still providing the relevant context. And it essentially goes something like this. when I grew up I experienced ⁓ a like a a significant degree of abuse, both verbally and physically. And abuse and neglect. And again, I'm not gonna get into much details, but essentially my experience as a child was very painful and confusing at the same time. So I was experiencing a lot of suffering, but that suffering didn't you know, bring me any meaning or significance. It just seemed to be painful. And not only that, but that suffering and pain and confusion was because there wasn't given much explanation, was often in conjunction with explicit or implicit moral standards that were often, again, confusing or incredibly hypocritical. And so the justifications for the kind of suffering that I was going through, or the suffering that I was seeing in my family in general, was giving me explanations and justifications that made absolutely no sense. And it was and at the same time I wasn't allowed to kind of ask questions or to challenge things or to really think for myself at least explicitly or externally. Like the the very idea of challenging ⁓ ideas that were being given to me, no matter how ⁓ they seemed, no matter how literally seemed to justify the kind of suffering and abuse that I was going through, ⁓ themselves would be punished, right? So challenging the ideas ⁓ intellectually or practically ⁓ punished, right? So it was just kind of this ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ appeared to me ⁓ painful and confusing, basically, which you might expect, right? And it wasn't until later, about in my teens, I say fifteen or sixteen, that I think really as a consequence I started to you know, put a lot of my anger and resentment and anxiety and depression and all the different kinds of emotional catastrophes that I was experiencing but had no way to understand and I started s projecting them on to to politics and I got really interested in ⁓ in ⁓ In politics, which, as those who are familiar with it, we know this is the most kind of superficial branch of philosophical inquiry. It's often where most of the conclusions end up resting, is somewhere in in the political realm, or at least in the ethical realm. and luckily enough, or I I would say by fate, or I'd say, you know, by the guidance of Jesus at that moment. I had I I I was able to stumble from politics into philosophy more generally. I started asking questions in and debating people about philosoph ⁓ and debating people about political ideas, I very quickly came to understand that, you know, it was the ideas underneath politics, around ethics, around notions of reality, under notions of ⁓ ⁓ self and mind and power, like there were all these deeper concepts that were ⁓ ⁓ I happened to be exposed to thinkers and to writers and to philosophers ultimately ⁓ ⁓ Helped me to start thinking about that kind of stuff, and I became very much interested in philosophy. And I don't think that was a mistake because philosophy was that thing which helped me to make sense of the world around me, ⁓ which I had desperately needed when I was a child, and gave me the tools and the training to make sense of the world around me. But more than this, philosophy was was the one of the only realms. ⁓ where ethical questions were were asked and not only that, but questioning in and of itself and challenging assumptions and morality and ideas was not only possible, but greatly encouraged by other thinkers, right? And I think that was that was very attractive to me because that was what I was missing I was a kid, right? And so I started to dive deeply into that and philosophy sort of naturally brought me into other areas more superficially. I mean, ⁓ so I I got interested in economics and I got interested in sociology and I got interested in psychology and ⁓ eventually I was able to go to therapy and and flo both a combination of philosophy, Therapy and just life events in general allowed me to kind of diagnose a lot of the things that happened to me as a child, work through it, ⁓ with all the sort of natural ups and downs and bumps and and you know, two steps forward, three steps back kind of thing that happens when you're trying to heal from a particularly traumatic childhood. And and all the while I sort of developed this understanding of philosophy and and and and I was always centered around ethics. I was always centered around the question of meaning and the question of ⁓ what it means to live a good life or what it means to be a hero or what it means to I don't know, do the right thing. Questions of morality, of ethics You know, politics still kind of interested me, but it was always like an extension of ethics. You know, it it was never about politics. And metaphysics and epistemology were I understood to be necessary foundations for understanding questions of human nature and society and and and in individual life. But again, they were never like this massive interest. The in the center of interest was always ethics. The center of interest was always the individual life. And everything else with I was either a premise to that or a consequence of that, if that makes sense. And that's been true r I would say right up into the present moment. ⁓ And that's sort of where the philosophy came out of. That's where the motivation of the philosophy came out. And and despite all these other things happening in my life, and despite ⁓ you know, all these influences from other branches ⁓ coming in to in to inform my understanding of philosophy, I never really lost philosophy as a central interest. And then I began a at the beginning of my interest in philosophy, I kind of had this idea of trying to find the philosophy out there that would answer all my questions and would leave me sort of satisfied in all of my inquiry. Like I never really thought about early on, I would say from like 18 to 22, I never really thought about the question of developing my own framework, I guess. And I but I would go out and I would read philosophers hoping that they would have the answer. Because I thought, you know, the answer's gotta be out there somewhere already. Someone's already figured it out, right? And I just have to find that philosopher and basically become a syphil sycophant, right? Basically become a champion for that philosophy. And that kind of happened a little bit with you know with with different thinkers that I ran into. But inevitably Every single philosophy I ran into, every single philosopher I ran into, they had flaws. They had either biographical flaws in which their lives weren't really a reflection of their philosophy, or otherwise their philosophy was contradictory, full of holes, ⁓ left me unsatisfied in my questions, wanted it left me wanting to go deeper. And so sort of ⁓ subconsciously I guess I I I just started to develop my own system, my own perspective, my own philosophy, my own understanding of life. And more and more of my philosophical effort went into that. Trying to understand my own answer to the question of what does it mean to live a meaningfully good life. And again this the philosophical interests for me it started around 15. I'm about I'm 29 right now. And so this is the culmination. of that or this is the the extent of that and I can't I certainly can't claim it to have all the answers, right? I can only claim this to be my understanding of philosophy and my understanding of what it means to live a meaningfully good life. But my goal has always been to understand the truth of that. Not to just have my own system, not to just rigorously defend my own prejudices, though of course I have my prejudices, I have my opinions, I have my, you know, things I want to be true. I mean, no philosophical system is perfect, no philosophical system is separate from the individual who has created it. But this has been the culmination of my attempt to answer that question and and it's something that I will probably pursue for the rest of my life because I just have such an intense interest in it now and I have I have such it's kinda the thing I've wanted to do my whole life. I the the older I get with philosophy, the more I start to lean towards not so much developing it myself, but encouraging others to develop their own philosophy and having that kind of exchange, because that exchange is where so much of the growth happens. And if it wasn't for the philosophies of other people whom I didn't agree with or, you know, I felt were unsatisfactory, or I felt maybe were naive in certain points, or incomplete, or you know, whatever it was, if it wasn't for those people putting out their thoughts in a way that certainly wasn't perfect, right? And sort of courageously putting their thought on display, then I would have never really caught that passion for philosophy. I wouldn't have caught the framework that helped me in a lot of ways navigate my twenties and helps to navigate my life even today. And that honestly I think helped me to avoid some of the worst outcomes that could have happened ⁓ from the kind of ⁓ child early childhood that I experienced, right? And so th that's really the purpose of what I'm doing right now. Is, you know, I know I know that my mu my philosophy is mistaken in some ways that I can't see, right? I know that it is probably naive in areas that I don't understand. I know for sure it's incomplete, it's imperfect, it's Prejudiced and biased, I'm sure, in some ways. There are things that I don't see or don't understand, and that's the case with every philosophy and every philosopher. But nonetheless, I want to put it out there. Nonetheless, I want to make a public record of it. Nonetheless, I want to use it as a platform to engage and encourage with other people. if anything, if anything, it forces other people to argue against what I'm saying, right? And that helps them to ⁓ create an understanding of the world themselves and create an understanding of what it means to live a good a meaningful life themselves. And if that's all my philosophy ever does, if it never if none of its actual content actually goes on to help anybody, but just the reaction against the content goes on to help people, you know, create their own understanding of framework, then I'm perfectly content with that because Because the philosophy for you know, I mean, it was created out of me. I mean it was created out of or at least my understanding of the the philosophers I read. I don't want to claim that it's totally unique or something like that. I mean it's if anything, it's eclectic, but ⁓ and it's a cobbled together version of many different philosophies and things that I picked through. So I I I certainly don't wanna the claim that it's in any way original, but ⁓ I guess what I'm saying is that even if the value is just in people reacting against it, that's good enough for me, right? In terms of a a public utility. But I just don't wanna hide it anymore. I don't wanna like wait to put it out until it's perfect, right? I don't wait 'cause it's never gonna be that way. It's it's never gonna be perfect, it's never gonna be complete. And not only that, but you know, like I'm a Christian and and that's a r a recent conversion for me. about two years or so. But especially in the light of Christ, I know that philosophy isn't perfect. I think it has some value. This is what my last video was talking about, to an extent, and me wrestling with the value of philosophy. ⁓ but I think it has some value. And Much like, you know, even though Christ even though Christ is the path to eternal life, medicine still has some value, right? And even though Christ is what overcomes evil in the world, I think philosophy still has some value. So any that that's the background. ⁓ I'm not gonna do too much longer on today. I just wanna give that kind of introduction. I wanted to lead into the structure that I'm gonna be attempting to follow as I go forward ⁓ with these videos and with this subsack and with this with this channel. So ⁓ So yeah, I think that's where we're gonna end it today.