Latest / The Make More Placements Show for Recruitment & Search Business Owners | More Placements | Higher Fees | Less Work | Fewer Headaches | / # 406 Why 2/3 Recruitment Consultants will Fail and cost your business money (and the fix)
Transcript
- speaker-0: Hello and welcome to the Make More Placements Podcast. In this episode, we're going to be talking about why recruitment consultants fail and most importantly, how to fix it. So, again, with ⁓ me and Terry here, some of the recruitment or a lot of the recruitment and presenters we speak to, one of the biggest challenges that you have right now is actually bringing consultants into your team, into your business, and then working out. And I think I read I read ⁓ a few weeks ago, and Sarah, I think I think you echoed this with the recruiters that you speak to. ⁓ two in three recruitment consultants that you bring in actually fail and don't work out. And if you look at If we look at your time in business, you look at even even your time as a as an employee at a desk, the amount of consultants you would have seen come in and not work out, you're probably one of the one of the more successful ones. ⁓ again, you th those numbers probably ring true. But Terry, I want to talk before we get into the sort of the ins and outs and the fixes, I want to talk about I guess the how, why this happens and what it can look like from an owner's point of view. speaker-1: Yeah. ⁓ I think the first thing we ought to consider is is the irony of this. A recruitment business is having trouble recruiting consultants. This is what recruiters do for a living for other people, but when it comes to building their own their own team, they have a real challenge. Because those figures that you quoted, ⁓ Drew, ⁓ most consultants that join a firm don't work out. So that that that that that's the first thing. I think also as well that a lot of recruitment business owners Bring consultants in for the wrong reason. So they bring them in. One of the b one of the saddest ones I think is what I what I call the vanity metrics, where they say, well, they say thinking, the more consultants I've got, the more successful I'm perceived to be by my peers and and and and and family. So recently I was talking to a a recruitment business. They've got five consult sorry, six consultants and they're doing two million. I spoke to one three or four months ago. He's got ten consultants in the insurance sector, but he's only doing just over a million. In fact, he's barely profitable. But one of the first things he said to me is that we're doing really well, Terry. ⁓ we've got 10 in the team now, we're looking to recruit more. I asked him the question why, before I got all the numbers, why I was looking to recruit more, said Terry, we're swamped with business at the moment. We we're not filling all the job orders. So that's the other problem. Contingent recruiters believe if they get more consultants in the business. They'll fill more of the job orders. By the way, we have no evidence to support that whatsoever. So it's another myth ⁓ that that's that's going around about the more consultants you've got, the more job orders. Because whether you've got ten consultants or you've got two consultants, on average and contingent, you're gonna fill between two, sorry, twenty to fifty percent of the roles that you work on. Regardless of the numbers. Does that make sense, Drew? speaker-0: Yeah does make sense. I d I just wanna sort of pick up on something you said there. ⁓ 'cause I think it's important, I don't I don't wanna br brush over it, is that a lot of recruitment business owners have this idea of success being having like having a big team, ⁓ and they sort of prioritize that over revenue or even over profit. I guess just to go a bit deeper into that, why do you think it happens? speaker-1: Honestly, I think part of it's naivety, Drew. ⁓ if you're at the dinner party at the golf club or, you know, at the bar with your mates, you say, Yeah, my team of ten, my team of twenty, ⁓ the perception is, ⁓ they must be doing well. ⁓ people like you and I, when we hear that number, we kind of take it with a pinch of salt 'cause the the number that really matters is is the revenue, you know. So you can have a t you can have a team of two hundred. ⁓ but if you're only doing, you know, five million a year, you're probably making a loss. speaker-0: Yeah. It's in fact not even the revenue is it, it's a profit. It's a profit. It's a profit. speaker-1: Yeah, good good points actually. Yeah. And and we know roughly what the profit's gonna be ⁓ on on t well should be on on on the consultant. Yeah, so good point. speaker-0: So I wan I want to sort of dig into the reasons, I guess, why ⁓ why recruit why consultants don't work out. And the f the first reason we've got down here is that they hired they hired a consultant to solve a solve a growth problem rather than the capacity problem. Meaning that again, like you said, Terry, look, they you know, you can they can have a recruitment business owner, they want to grow and their first thought is, ⁓ if I if I bring more people in, I can bring more clients, I can fill more of the roles I've got on my desk. ⁓ aga again, we have a sort of different view. We we believe that it should be r you should bring someone in to solve a capacity problem, meaning that once everything's optimised in the business, once you've got more business you can handle and get more exclusive or retain business you can handle, then you might need to bring consultants in. But I guess from your point of view, Terry, from that you know, we've got problem number one. They hired our consultants to solve a growth problem rather than capacity problem. I guess how do you how would you describe that and how would we get around it? speaker-1: Yeah, good one. So look, the average contingent is twenty to fifty percent of the roles they feel that that they work on, they're gonna fill. So let's say the top end, and very rarely do you get contingent recruiter fifty percent, those that measure it, because most of them don't even measure it, but that's another story. If they were just to say, let's work on the job orders that we get now, and rather than bringing another consultant, let's strive at getting our full rate to eighty percent. Financially, that would trust transform most of the ⁓ most recruitment businesses with no additional cost. Now, they will argue, yeah, but that the the problem is a is a candidate shortage. And and again, it's another one of those myths. If the role never gets filled by anybody, then it is a candidate shortage. If on the other hand there's four recruiters working on the same role, but one recruiter fills the role, well what's the shortage of the candidates? It's just that the three or four of you are working on the same role. And you would be better served working with clients either on an exclusive or or retained basis where you haven't you're not competing with the recruiters. So if you're to improve your process in the type of business that you that you took on, even on the contingent roles, if you if you're to get your consultants to qualify them better. But here's what happens, Drew. Especially for a rookie consultant or a consultant not doing too well, they get a job opportunity and on heart, they know they probably won't fit it. But they take it, knowing hand on heart they're not gonna fill it. But in their mind, if I've got let's say three or four crappy jobs, my manager's standing over me, saying, Why can you bring in business in, I'm gonna look at the manager and say to her, I'm busy filling these roles. This is where the money is. Because it it makes it easier for that consultant to be say, I'm I'm busy working on this role, even though hand on hard, they know they're no they're not gonna fill them. It convinces the ha the the the manager or the or the director of the business, 'cause I say, Well, yeah, that Consultants working on four jobs. But they probably weren't qualified. Because if a hiring manager says something like, Yeah, but if you know anybody, send them over. And they go, Yeah, I'll do that. Put the phone down and high five the colleague for getting a job order. It was kind of pointless getting it. So it's the process that they need to look at rather than let's throw another body at this and all of that. Yeah. All the expense that you're going to incur there. speaker-0: Yeah, and I think I think just what you said there in terms of like the you know, the recruitment consultant telling the the telling the director or telling the manager that. I think actually if if we if we look deeper, honestly, like I think a lot of owners tell themselves that the same thing. That's why, ⁓ I can't I can't work on business development, I can't do this because I've got these roles to fill. ⁓ and sometimes it's valid and sometimes the roles are ⁓ I guess higher quality roles that that will will get filled. But sometimes it's just just ⁓ almost almost avoiding doing what they need to do. Would you go speaker-1: A hundred percent. It's just a distraction. Because they know in the heart of hearts a problem not going to fit it. But look at it from their point of view, they're thinking, yeah, and this is what I can get. But Tara, I might get lucky. Because I've got four job orders here and I might just get lucky and get and get one of these and get a fee of ten, fifteen, twenty thousand. And quite honest, that's gonna save my day. So you can understand their thinking, but you have to acknowledge it's flawed thinking. If they just went, Well, actually, wouldn't I be better with one role? on the retained basis where get some of the money up front and the full rate fill rate on the on a retained basis is ninety percent rather than taking four roles with no exclusivity, other recruiters work on it, and I probably won't fit it. It is but the retain road road is the more complex, the more difficult one. speaker-0: 100%. So Terry, let's let's move on to num reason number two, right? So the reason number one is is more about ⁓ I guess hiring to solve a crafty problem rather than the growth problem. Number two is more about let's let's again let's say that's that's sold, right? So ⁓ I'm I've I've I've optimized my business. I've got I've got all the things in place that I need to bring someone in. And now I'm in the interview process. I'm interviewing consultants, I'm looking at CVs. I guess where does it go wrong there? Because I guess y you know, some s it's not it's not always about ⁓ timing. It's about did they say I've got the right timing but I'm just looking at the wrong C Vs or looking for the the wrong thing on C Vs, they say. Tell me tell me a bit what that can look like. speaker-1: Well I'd look at it is when I was a search form owner, I never ever met an unsuccessful search or recruitment consultant. Everyone I met was highly successful, and they implied that I would look to be talking to them. Yeah. Because what we do is this is this is human nature. When when a consultant does well, they take all the credit for it. Yeah, well, the reason I'm is I've done so well, I've worked hard at this, and you know, and you know, I'm I'm a really good consultant. However, When things are crap and we've all been there, then it's not them, it's the economic climate, it's the market they're in, it's it's everything but but them. And I know I know that's human nature. But here's what's happening. The recruitment business owner is interviewing a consultant and the cult consultant says by the way, if you're a good if you're a reasonable consultant, you're also a good communicator. So they can communicate well and they go, Yeah, over the last three years, I've averaged three hundred thousand a year or ⁓ you know for the last three years. Recruitment business owner going, fantastic. Well, look, if this guy only does two hundred thousand for us, yeah, that that would be fantastic. And they get carried away with the fantasy that the fact consultants told them the truth. One of the things they should be doing is challenging those numbers. One of the things they should be look doing is looking at P forty five to see what they actually earned. Can it give you some indication? But they take low recruiters recruitment business owners take things on face value. Yeah, I did one million last year and ⁓ You're lucky to be talking to me 'cause I'll probably do about two million this year and he only gets excited at the prospect of something that's never gonna happen. speaker-0: And I think I think even to go deeper into that, even if you look at the the pay sips or whatever, ⁓ you you you can be a consultant that does well, like build well, and it not be again I don't want to take away from the consultant to say that they're they're not then they're not contributing anything, but it could just be that you've got one in that b ⁓ in that previous business, you've got one good client that gave you lots of roles that were easy to fill or that that you that were exclusive terms. So you feel you filled it and you can't bring that client with you to the new company anyway. So it's almost That's right. Almost becomes irrelevant. Like you were success yes, you were successful. Yes, don't want to take any w anything away from that success. But can it be transferred to another business for that point? No. speaker-1: Yeah, and I and you have great example. Drew, I was guilty as that as a as a search consultant. One year I did just over three hundred thousand. It was with one client. Yeah. One client and one client only. You know, and we worked on retainer for the whole year. It was fantastic. speaker-0: So you've got in situations like that, there's no there's no, I guess from the consultant point there's no, I guess, proof that they can win new clients. They can't bring that old client across anyway. And even if even if they were able to bring that old client across, there's no guarantee that that client's gonna hire as much the following year. So it's almost absolutely almost success built on built on el built on elements that you can't control, but it built on elements that the recruitment c consultant can't can't control. So I guess don't know if you know the answer to this story, but how if I'm if I'm if I'm a business owner and I'm interviewing and I'm and I'm seeing this and I'm on or I'm thinking that could be a concern of mine, right? How do I know that this yes, this this recruiter's build, but how do I know how that building was split? Was it was it with one client, within multiple clients? Did they bring the were they w the one that brought the client in or were they just the one filling the roles? Get all these details that actually make a difference to how good the or how good the person might be or how suited the person might be to my firm. How do I spot for that in an interview process? speaker-1: Magnetic identity can. And I think I think we're looking all the recruitment business owners look at the wrong thing. I want to bring a consultant in that stunned 300,000 of the previous firm. Does that hindsight I'm going to go, why they leaving? If they're so good, why are they leaving? By the way, here's the thing I have to consider. When the consultants ever got made redundant, you and I have been around long enough to know that even when recruitment firms are struggling, if a good consultant's billing, you don't make them redundant. Your consultants just don't get made redundant. There's no logic to that, is there? ⁓ you're building three hundred thousand, we're gonna have to get rid of you. Are you kidding me? It's not gonna happen. So I t I think it's actually looking at the wrong thing. So rather than looking at I need to bring in a ⁓ high performing consultant, it may be worth looking at your own business and saying, look, to bring in a top performing consultant who's also the other one people always ask for is who's entrepreneurial. Because if they're top performing and entrepreneurial, Why would they join you? Why not go then go off on their own and do and do their own thing? Wouldn't it be better to have a process in your business where you say, I don't need to bring in a top-billing consultant. I need to have a process in my business that when a consultant this is what our clients are doing. Come and join us. You'll never ever have to cold call, but we'll show you how to generate leads and get meetings. And you know, if you use some of the the Apex pro ⁓ services that that we provide, you can say to your consultant, you'll get twenty meetings of burns, one meeting a day, every day with a hiring manager in the market to what you do. Yeah. Now you've got a process. And by the way, it's now easier to recruit ⁓ consultants if you if you can say that and guarantee that. That's what you should be looking at, rather than let me find that top ⁓ that top billing consultant. speaker-0: And that that that brings us on to reason number three is that you they a lot of recruitment business owners hire for talent and not hire for a system, right? So again, Terry, what you touched on it there, like to to increase the chances of a recruitment consultant having success in any business, there needs to be a system for them to follow. And I think sometimes a lot of owners can have the owner the owner can be successful with them themselves, but it's all it's all up here. What they do, the process they follow, how they win clients, how they how they deliver candidates, whatever it is, it's all it's all in the in the mind. And they bring in consult ⁓ bring in another consultant and sort of leave it down to them. Sort of a si it's almost like a single swim. And I've I've you know, and almost ⁓ wr wrongly maybe the bigger the firm the the more I guess susceptible they are to this, where they'll like they'll they'll overhire. They'll they'll they'll know these numbers that we're talking about. ⁓ two and three are gonna fail, therefore I'm gonna bring in three or I'm gonna bring in ten, knowing that most are gonna fail and I'm gonna are gonna be left with the with the gems. Which aga again, I'm not not saying doesn't work. Obviously, you you can speak to lot of successful business owners, well, that has worked. It's just that it's just very high risk. very high staff staff turnover. The you the way to get around that is is to build a system and and to tr hire people based on their ability to follow a system rather than based on their past success. Terry, what what guess what are your thoughts on that and and how would you speaker-1: Yeah, hundred hundred percent. And then y you made a good point there. Because you and I both know businesses who do that. Yeah, well Terry, what we do is we bring six in at a time and we know that four, maybe even five, won't work out, but we're spending our time with six consultants at the same time rather than try you know, trying to coach six at six different times. So it's the same amount of time for us. I think the thing that they they don't or maybe must consider, I don't know, I've changed them enough on this is that's quite a cost bringing in six consultants. ⁓ and they give them you know, three, four months. Yeah. They get rid. But they they they're argumentative. We'll work in the numbers territory. We know the numbers. We know if we bring in six, we're gonna get one or two each time. And that's what we're striving for. It seems a really expensive way of doing it. And and in fairness, a lot of them have b have got training or whatever they're providing that. But again, it always makes me smile that the the the the amount of small recruitment business owners who then complain about the performance of their consultants. I mean, I say, well what's all the training does them? Well, I don't do any training. Well are you not going to take any responsibility for this? You brought this consultant in, they're not delivering. Is it possible they could perform better with a bit more support? Well no, I expect my consultants to come and hit the ground running. speaker-0: Well, I s I think that's part of the problem, so like again, training is one thing because I think it's probably more common that they train them on the recruitment process itself, like the delivery. Yeah. But if you're expecting someone to come in the B three sixty and actually bring in clients, a lot of the time these owners don't have a system for bringing in clients themselves, right? They sort of they don't they don't know how to get clients or don't have to get clients consistently. ⁓ so they they bring someone in hoping that okay, what whatever that person is bringing clients in, they can bring into my business and we can we can both do what we we do. But again, neither of them really have system in fact I'll go as far as to say the recruitment industry as a whole, the the attracting client side, attracting quality clients, this is, is probably a a weak area, right? So they they have systems bringing in clients and and and very very little systems for delivery, right? Delivery is probably the bit where they they have got solved, right? But if they can't if you can't win the clients in the first place, or can't win clients on the right terms and what I'm talking about exclusive exclusivity yeah ideally retained, then then aga again it's it's an uphill battle from day one. Again, I remember reading I guess you may you maybe read it when I was probably about twenty one, ⁓ the EMIF book. By Michael E. Gabba? Yeah. One of the quotes in that book I was really looking at the other day is like let let systems run the business and let people run the systems. So let systems run the business and let people run the systems. And I think so many recruitment business owners we speak to do not have the systems in place or any systems they do have are up here and it's not a transferable skill to give to another consultant coming in. So does that make sense? speaker-1: Hundred percent. And when you ask the owner, well, so how do you go about business? ⁓ Terry, don't understand. I've been in this business for a year, they've got a great network and you know, I I can I can just make a few calls and that's great for you. But it's it's not it's not it's not a it's not it's not a process, it's not a system. Yeah. And if you bring in a consultancy, you've got to have a system that you can share with your consultants, say, if you do this, example, if you use the Apex ⁓ client attraction ⁓ process, you should average about twenty meetings a month every month with interested hiring managers. And you you want to stack the numbers in your favor. So twenty, thirty meters a month, should you know, you should be able to win two retainers a month every month by doing that. But most owners kinda fingers crossed all being well. So there's this it creates that uncertainty in the business because they just don't know when the next piece of business is is coming from and how they're gonna get it. speaker-0: And Terry, just talking about the Apex system, we've got a shorter ten minute video that runs through these whole Apex system, how to how to bring clients in, how to deliver, how to retain clients. ⁓ if you go to makemoreplacements.com forward slash V S L. That's V S L. ⁓ MakeMore Placement dot com slash V S L. There's short video there that'll run through the whole system. ⁓ Terry, that's it for today. Anything you wanna add? Any last words? Yeah, speaker-1: Just just go to make more placements and that and that and have a look at that. There's no costs, there's no obligation. If you're having trouble right now either building a team or getting getting clients, just get this free ⁓ this free free free training and see what some of your competitors are doing right now when it comes to winning new clients and and growing their business. But that's it for me, Drew. Thanks for the invite and ⁓ look forward to next time. Awesome. speaker-0: We'll speak to you soon. Until then, take care, take action and be relentless.