Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / The Insanity Defense & Criminal Responsibility: When Is Someone Too Mentally Ill to Be Guilty?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology undergrad. If you are
- 0:02joining us today, go ahead and grab a seat in
- 0:05the lecture hall for today's study session. Yeah,
- 0:08we've got a lot to cover. We really do. Today,
- 0:10we are doing a deep dive into the source material.
- 0:13Specifically, we are going to crack open chapter
- 0:16three of the Canadian Forensic Psychology and
- 0:19Law text. Right, which is just such a dense chapter.
- 0:22It's basically exploring this high stakes world
- 0:25where clinical psychology completely collides
- 0:28with the criminal courtroom. I mean, we were
- 0:30talking. fitness to stand trial, criminal responsibility,
- 0:34risk assessment, all that wild stuff. And, you
- 0:36know, to help you remember all this dense material
- 0:39for finals, because I know we are all cramming
- 0:41right now, I think we should structure this deep
- 0:43dive around a really simple mental timeline.
- 0:46Oh, I love a good framework. Lay it on me. So
- 0:49think of it like this. We've got the present,
- 0:51which is all about fitness to stand trial today.
- 0:54Then we look at the past. which is criminal responsibility
- 0:57at the time of the crime. Then we move to the
- 0:59future, which is risk assessment. And finally,
- 1:02we have the wild cards. The wild cards. Yeah,
- 1:05the people who are actively trying to manipulate
- 1:07the system. Yeah. You know, psychopathy and faking
- 1:10it. OK, let's unpack this. Stop number one on
- 1:12the timeline is the present. So the core concept
- 1:16here is adjudicative competency, right? Exactly.
- 1:20Or what most people just call fitness to stand
- 1:22trial. Right. And the foundational rule that
- 1:25you have to remember for the exam is that the
- 1:27courts always, always assume a person is competent
- 1:30unless proven otherwise. Right. The burden of
- 1:32truth is on whoever brings it up. But it's not
- 1:34just about being diagnosed with something. No,
- 1:37not at all. Just having a severe mental disorder
- 1:40like schizophrenia, for example, does not automatically
- 1:42make you unfit. It is a prerequisite. But to
- 1:45actually be deemed unfit, the disorder has to
- 1:48prevent you from doing one of three very specific
- 1:50things. OK, what are they? You have to be unable
- 1:53to understand the nature of the proceedings,
- 1:55unable to understand the consequences of the
- 1:57proceedings, or unable to communicate with counsel.
- 2:00That third one, communicating with counsel, that
- 2:03is where I think this gets so fascinating, because
- 2:05it's not what you think it means. I always think
- 2:08of it as... The bad translator analogy. Oh the
- 2:12translator analogy. Yeah, explain that for everyone
- 2:14So the law uses what's called a limited cognitive
- 2:17capacity test. And that basically means you do
- 2:20not have to be smart. You don't have to understand
- 2:22legal strategy. You don't even have to make choices
- 2:24that are in your own best interest. Right. You
- 2:26can make terrible choices. Exactly. You just
- 2:28have to be able to act as a basic translator.
- 2:30Like, you take the raw facts of what physically
- 2:33happened in the real world, and you translate
- 2:35those facts to your lawyer. If you can do that,
- 2:37you are fit. Because the lawyer does the heavy
- 2:40lifting with the legal strategy. Yeah. And the
- 2:42wildest example of this in the source material
- 2:44is that 1992 case, Harvey Taylor. Oh, that case
- 2:47is completely mind blowing. It really is. So
- 2:50Taylor was the suspended lawyer and he was suffering
- 2:52from pervasive delusions. I mean, severe paranoia.
- 2:56And he literally walked into Osgoode Hall and
- 2:58stabbed a law society lawyer. Just walked right
- 3:01in. Yeah. And during the process, he's firing
- 3:05his lawyers. He wants to represent himself. He
- 3:07is clearly completely incapable of perceiving
- 3:10his own best interests. Any normal person would
- 3:13look at him and say, well, he obviously shouldn't
- 3:14be standing trial. But the court said otherwise.
- 3:17Right. The Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that
- 3:20he actually met the standard for fitness because
- 3:23despite the delusions, he could recount the raw
- 3:26physical facts of the stabbing. He was a functioning
- 3:29translator. What's fascinating here is how that
- 3:32ruling ripples out across the whole justice system.
- 3:34Like, look at the R .V. Whittle case from 1994.
- 3:38This established the harmony of competencies.
- 3:40Wait, harmony of competencies? What does that
- 3:42mean in practice? Well, Whittle was hearing voices
- 3:45telling him he needed to unburden himself, so
- 3:48he weighs his right to a lawyer and just fully
- 3:50confesses to a robbery and a murder. And the
- 3:52courts had to decide if the cognitive standard
- 3:55for waiving your right to counsel should be higher
- 3:57than the standard for just standing trial. Oh,
- 3:59I see. Because waiving a right seems like it
- 4:01requires more, you know, brain power. Right.
- 4:05But the Supreme Court basically said no. It's
- 4:07the exact same limited cognitive capacity test.
- 4:11Whether you are standing trial, waving your right
- 4:13to a lawyer or confessing to the police, it's
- 4:15all the same standard. If you can translate facts,
- 4:19you are legally capable across the board. Wow.
- 4:22OK, so if fitness is about the present, like
- 4:24can you sit in court today and be a bad translator?
- 4:27What happens when we shift the timeline backwards?
- 4:29Then we are looking at the past. Right. The exact
- 4:31moment the crime was committed, which leads us
- 4:34into NCRMD, not criminally responsible on account
- 4:38of mental disorder. Which is such a complex legal
- 4:41standard. It is. I mean, to understand it, we
- 4:43really have to go all the way back to the 1840s,
- 4:45right? The MNOTN standard. Yeah. Daniel McKnighton
- 4:47in England, he had this profound delusion that
- 4:50the government was persecuting him. So he shot
- 4:52and killed the British. prime minister's secretary.
- 4:55And that case from the 1840s is literally the
- 4:58basis of Canadian law today. It actually is.
- 5:01The standard is that the person must be suffering
- 5:03from a mental disorder that makes them incapable
- 5:05of appreciating the nature of the act or knowing
- 5:08that it was wrong. Okay and that word wrong is
- 5:10super important here. A good memory trick for
- 5:12you guys listening is to think of it as The law
- 5:16versus the Lord. Oh, I like that. The law versus
- 5:19the Lord. Yeah, because to be found NCRMD, you
- 5:23either don't know the act is legally wrong, or,
- 5:27and this is crucial, you don't know it's morally
- 5:29wrong. Which completely shift how we view criminal
- 5:32intent. Exactly. Like, you might know murder
- 5:35is against the Canadian Criminal Code, but if
- 5:37your mental disorder has convinced you that God
- 5:39is commanding you to do it, You lack the guilty
- 5:42mind. You don't know what's morally wrong. And
- 5:44the textbook uses the R .V. Chalk case to illustrate
- 5:46this, which is just tragic. Two teenagers murdered
- 5:50someone, not for money, but because they shared
- 5:52a psychosis. They genuinely believed they needed
- 5:55to commit the murder to rule the world. Wait,
- 5:58they wanted to rule the world? Yeah, it was a
- 6:00profound delusion. They knew it was against the
- 6:02law, obviously, but they thought it was morally
- 6:05necessary. And that is sufficient for an NCRMD
- 6:08defense. Here's where it gets really interesting,
- 6:10though. When you look at the 2008 Vince Sly case
- 6:12on the Greyhound bus. Oh, absolutely. That case
- 6:16changed the entire public conversation in Canada.
- 6:19Right. It was a horrific tragedy. He killed and
- 6:21dismembered a passenger, Tim McLean, and the
- 6:25media just went wild, painting him as this real
- 6:27-life Hannibal Lecter monster. Which is such
- 6:30a damaging misconception. It really is because
- 6:32Hannibal Lecter is a fictional psychopath who
- 6:35knows exactly what he's doing. Vince Lee was
- 6:37suffering from untreated, profound schizophrenia.
- 6:41He literally believed the victim was an alien
- 6:43threat and he was acting on the voice of God.
- 6:45He was completely detached from reality. They
- 6:47thought he was saving people. Yeah, he had no
- 6:49moral agency in that moment and that's what the
- 6:51insanity defense is actually for. But man, people
- 6:55get so angry about it, they think it's this giant
- 6:57loophole. Well, the public perception is just
- 7:00completely divorced from reality. There was this
- 7:02major study, Silver and colleagues, and they
- 7:06found that the public thinks people use this
- 7:08defense in like 37 % of all cases. 37%. That's
- 7:12ridiculous. I know. The reality is it's used
- 7:15in less than 1 % of cases. Less than 1%. Yeah.
- 7:18And it's rarely even successful. So the public
- 7:20is just wildly overestimating this. Yeah, by
- 7:23like 81 times. They overestimate insanity acquittals
- 7:26by 81 times. And the biggest myth is that if
- 7:29you get NCRMD... You just walk free. Right. Like
- 7:32you just go home and watch TV. Exactly. Which
- 7:34is not true at all. You're usually confined to
- 7:36a highly secure provincial psychiatric hospital
- 7:39for years, often way longer than a standard prison
- 7:42sentence. Wow. OK. So we've covered the present
- 7:45with fitness and the past with NCRMD. But once
- 7:49a trial is over or it's time for parole, the
- 7:51court stops looking backward and starts looking
- 7:53forward. Right. Yes. Which brings us to stop
- 7:56number three on our timeline, the future. And
- 7:59this is all about predicting risk and protecting
- 8:01society. Risk assessment, which seems terrifyingly
- 8:04subjective to me. Well, historically, there are
- 8:06three approaches to it. The first one is exactly
- 8:08what you just said, unstructured clinical judgment.
- 8:11The clinician just uses their subjective gut
- 8:13feeling to decide if someone is dangerous. Which
- 8:15is notoriously terrible, right? Humans are so
- 8:18biased. Oh, the track record is awful. So they
- 8:21swung the pendulum all the way to the other side
- 8:23with a second approach, actuarial decision making.
- 8:26This is purely statistical. It's no semalithetics.
- 8:29So just math. Just math. You plug in static historical
- 8:33factors like age at first arrest and it spits
- 8:36out a probability score. Okay, I have to push
- 8:38back on this because Isn't it a bit cold and
- 8:42honestly dangerous to reduce a human being's
- 8:45freedom to a rigid mathematical formula? It sounds
- 8:48like a Spotify algorithm deciding your fate.
- 8:51It does sound dystopian. Right, like it completely
- 8:53ignores their unique context today. What if they
- 8:55went to therapy? What if they got sober? The
- 8:57math doesn't care. And that is a completely valid
- 8:59concern. Actuarial models are statistically way
- 9:02more accurate than gut feelings, but they are
- 9:05incredibly rigid. So the field created the third
- 9:08approach to fix this. Structured Professional
- 9:10Judgment or SPJ? Ah, so a hybrid approach. Exactly.
- 9:15SPJ combines the best of both worlds. You use
- 9:18evidence -based risk markers, so you have the
- 9:20statistical foundation, but you blend it with
- 9:22clinical experience to account for the person's
- 9:24current context. That makes so much more sense.
- 9:27And the goal isn't just risk assessment anymore.
- 9:30It's risk management. You aren't just giving
- 9:32a score. You are figuring out why they are dangerous.
- 9:36Like dynamic factors. Are they only violent when
- 9:39they're using drugs or under extreme stress?
- 9:41Oh, I see. So instead of just saying, keep them
- 9:43locked up, you can say, they are high risk if
- 9:46they drink so we can release them, but only with
- 9:48mandatory substance abuse counseling and random
- 9:51testing. Exactly. You put conditions in place
- 9:53to reduce that specific risk. That is brilliant.
- 9:57OK, but all of this, the fitness, the NCRMD,
- 10:00the risk assessment, it all assumes the person
- 10:02is actually telling the truth, which brings us
- 10:05to the massive wrench in the gears. The wild
- 10:08cards. Stop number four. Yes. What happens when
- 10:11the person sitting across from the psychologist
- 10:13is actively manipulating the test? This is a
- 10:16huge issue. Evaluators are constantly screening
- 10:19for two major things, psychopathy and malingering.
- 10:23I like to use a memory aid for this one. I call
- 10:25it the void versus the actor. The void versus
- 10:27the actor. OK, break that down. So the psychopath
- 10:30is the void. Their emotional hardware is genuinely
- 10:34just missing. They are glib, they are grandiose,
- 10:38they lack emotional depth, and they are naturally
- 10:40callous. And heavily linked to a high risk of
- 10:43violence, yes. Right. And psychologists measure
- 10:46this using Hare's PCLR tool, right? But the key
- 10:49is they aren't faking a lack of empathy. It's
- 10:51a genuine void, which makes them so dangerous.
- 10:54Right. Whereas the actor has perfectly normal
- 10:56hardware. Exactly. The actor is the malingerer.
- 10:59They're intentionally faking or exaggerating
- 11:02psychiatric symptoms just to evade prosecution
- 11:04or get an easier sentence. They are putting on
- 11:07a show for secondary gain. And catching them
- 11:09is an art form. Psychologists use specific tools
- 11:12to catch them breaking character, like the MFAST
- 11:15or the TOM -M. The TOM -M, the test of memory
- 11:18malingering. I love the math behind this test.
- 11:20It is so clever. It looks like a really difficult
- 11:22memory test, but it is engineered to be incredibly
- 11:25easy, even for people with genuine severe brain
- 11:28damage. Because it's a forced choice recognition
- 11:30test, right? So you show them a picture and then
- 11:32later you give them two pictures and say, which
- 11:34one did you see? Right, there are only two choices.
- 11:36So it's literally a coin flip. Even if you were
- 11:38completely blindfolded mathematically, you would
- 11:40get 50 % right just by guessing. Exactly. So
- 11:43if a defendant is sitting there claiming they
- 11:45have severe memory loss and they score like 20
- 11:48% on the TomM? The math traps them. To score
- 11:5220%, you have to actually know the right answer
- 11:54and then actively choose the wrong one on purpose.
- 11:57It statistically proves you are faking it. It's
- 11:59so wild. They literally prove you're playing
- 12:01a role just using probability. It's a fascinating
- 12:04cat and mouse game in the evaluation room. Okay,
- 12:07so what does this all mean for us? Let's quickly
- 12:10recap the timeline framework that will save everyone
- 12:13on exam day. Please do. So we have the present,
- 12:16which is fitness to stand trial, and the limited
- 12:18cognitive capacity test. We have the past, which
- 12:21is NCRMD and the whole law versus the Lord concept.
- 12:24We have the future, which is SPJ and managing
- 12:27dynamic risk factors. And finally, we have the
- 12:31wild cards, dealing with psychopathy and malingering
- 12:34using tools like the TomM. That is the perfect
- 12:36But, you know, before we wrap up this deep dive,
- 12:39there was one last philosophical puzzle that
- 12:42we didn't really discuss today, but it stems
- 12:44directly from all this material. Oh, lay it on
- 12:46me. I love a good puzzle. Think about the entire
- 12:49basis of our criminal justice system. It is built
- 12:52on the concept of free will and moral agency,
- 12:55right? We punish people who choose to do wrong.
- 12:58Right, the mens re. Exactly. Yeah. But what happens
- 13:01if someone is found permanently unfit to stand
- 13:03trial? Say they have a profound, untreatable,
- 13:06organic brain condition. Okay, so they can never
- 13:08be tried. Right. But... If a risk assessment
- 13:12determines they are a danger to society, the
- 13:15state can hold them in a secure psychiatric hospital
- 13:17indefinitely without ever proving their guilt
- 13:20in a trial. Wait, really? Just indefinitely?
- 13:22Yes. So the question I want everyone to think
- 13:25about is this. At what point does a system designed
- 13:27to protect society cross a moral line? Where
- 13:30does justice actually live if we are indefinitely
- 13:33punishing a brain that simply cannot understand
- 13:35the rules of the game? Wow. That is a heavy thought
- 13:39to end on. It really forces you to question the
- 13:41absolute limits of the law when it comes up against
- 13:44biology. It's the ultimate gray area. It really
- 13:46is. Well, thank you guys so much for tuning into
- 13:48this study session on the Psychology Undergrad.
- 13:51We hope this helps you crush your exams, keep
- 13:53questioning the mind, and we will catch you on
- 13:56the next deep dive into the source material.