Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / How Trauma and Culture Wire the Brain: From the Womb to Adolescence
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. We are so
- 0:02glad you're here joining us. Yeah, thanks for
- 0:04tuning in So we are basically two undergrad psychology
- 0:07students and we're just geeking out over our
- 0:10latest reading for class We're gonna take you
- 0:12on a deep dive into the psychological physical
- 0:15and well emotional development of humans Right
- 0:18covering basically all the way from conception
- 0:20right through late adolescence So roughly up
- 0:23to age 17 or so exactly and our mission today
- 0:27is to really pull apart the mechanics of how
- 0:29our earliest environments, our cultures, and,
- 0:32you know, our specific contexts physically wire
- 0:35our brains. And how that shapes our identities,
- 0:37yeah. It is, it's honestly fascinating. It really
- 0:41is. And to make this really dense material actually
- 0:44stick, we're going to use some everyday analogies,
- 0:47just common ways of thinking. Yeah, things that
- 0:49make it easier to visualize. Right. And we're
- 0:52also going to occasionally look at these developmental
- 0:54milestones through the lens of religion and morality
- 0:57to see how a society's deeply held values actually
- 1:00dictate human growth. Which is a huge factor
- 1:03that people usually just ignore. Oh, completely.
- 1:06So to understand the teenager or the adult, you
- 1:10really have to start before birth. Imagine for
- 1:13a second that a baby's brain is like physically
- 1:15adapting to survive a war zone. Or a famine or
- 1:19an economic collapse. Yeah. months before that
- 1:22baby even takes its first breath. The brain is
- 1:24literally mapping out a hostile environment while
- 1:27still inside the womb. It completely shatters
- 1:29that illusion we have of the womb being this
- 1:31ultimate, impenetrable safe space. The outside
- 1:34world is already getting in. Exactly. Let's look
- 1:37at the real -world impact of this with a case
- 1:39study from the reading. So there's this child
- 1:41named Mick Squenda. Right, the five -year -old.
- 1:44Yeah, a five -year -old assigned male at birth,
- 1:47and he's just acting out intensely. in his kindergarten
- 1:50class. We're talking throwing tantrums, having
- 1:53potty accidents. Hitting his classmates, too.
- 1:56And showing literally no apparent remorse afterward.
- 1:59Right. Which, on the surface, if you are a tired
- 2:02kindergarten teacher, that just looks like a
- 2:04straightforward behavioral issue, a discipline
- 2:06problem. Just a bad kid, right? Exactly. But
- 2:09when we trace the neurochemistry backward, the
- 2:11real story starts in utero. So Iskinda's parents
- 2:15are of Zapotec and Yaqui origin. OK. And they
- 2:19were essentially forced into this grueling migration
- 2:21because corporate agriculture was taking over
- 2:23their ancestral land. Wow. So you have pregnant
- 2:26parents dealing with the total loss of their
- 2:29community, extreme financial terror, and traveling
- 2:32north on foot. So what is actually happening
- 2:35to the fetus in that scenario? Like how does
- 2:37a mother's financial terror actually cross the
- 2:41placenta? Well, it comes down to the endocrine
- 2:43system. When a mother experiences that immense
- 2:46unrelenting level of stress and grief and maybe
- 2:49even exposure to agricultural toxins in the water
- 2:52runoff. Her body just floods with survival hormones,
- 2:55right? Yes, specifically cortisol and adrenaline.
- 2:58And the placenta is an incredible organ, but
- 3:00it is not a magical force field. Right. Can't
- 3:03block everything. No. Prolonged high concentrations
- 3:06of those neurochemical distress signals cross
- 3:08the placental barrier and soak directly into
- 3:11the developing fetus. I like to use a common
- 3:13way of thinking to picture this. Think of the
- 3:17developing fetus as a stress sponge. Oh, that's
- 3:21a great way to put it. Yeah. The fetus is just
- 3:23soaking up whatever the mother's nervous system
- 3:25is swimming in. If she is swimming in stress
- 3:27hormones or grief, the baby absorbs that into
- 3:30its very neural architecture. That imagery captures
- 3:33the biology perfectly. The prolonged exposure
- 3:36to cortisol literally inflames the reptilian
- 3:39brain of the fetus. The amygdala and the brainstem,
- 3:41right? Exactly. The parts that handle our most
- 3:44basic survival instincts. The brain is highly
- 3:47plastic, meaning it adapts to whatever environment
- 3:49it anticipates being born into. So because of
- 3:52those chemical signals, Exquenda's brain assumes
- 3:55he is going to be born into a highly dangerous
- 3:57hostile world. Yes. His lower brain layers actually
- 4:00develop to take up more functional real estate
- 4:02just to handle that anticipated threat. So his
- 4:05baseline is just wired for panic. Basically,
- 4:08he is born in a constant state of sympathetic
- 4:11arousal. that classic fight, flight, freeze,
- 4:14fawn response. Wait. I have to push back on how
- 4:17society handles this, then. OK. Go for it. If
- 4:20a baby's baseline is set to panic before they're
- 4:22even born, isn't it an incredibly unfair moral
- 4:26expectation for society to demand that they just
- 4:29sit perfectly still on a kindergarten carpet?
- 4:31Oh, absolutely. We are basically punishing a
- 4:34biological survival mechanism. We call it bad
- 4:37behavior when it's actually just its brain doing
- 4:39exactly what it was programmed to do to keep
- 4:41them alive. That tension you're pointing out
- 4:43is actually central to developmental psychology.
- 4:45We often pathologize survival skills when they
- 4:48show up in polite society. Because they're inconvenient.
- 4:51Exactly. And this leads directly into a concept
- 4:54by the psychoanalyst Wilhelm Reich. He called
- 4:56it character armor. Character armor? Yeah, Reich
- 5:00theorized that early unresolved trauma and chronic
- 5:03stress don't just stay in the mind. They lead
- 5:05to actual physical rigidity in the musculature
- 5:09of the body. Meaning the body literally armors
- 5:12itself against the world? Like, how does that
- 5:15actually look in a child? Well, the text gives
- 5:17the clinical observations of babies born addicted
- 5:20to crack cocaine. When caregivers try to hold
- 5:22these infants to soothe them, the babies arch
- 5:24their backs. Oh, wow. Yeah, their bellies go
- 5:27completely rigid and then clench their fists.
- 5:30They physically cannot melt or relax into a caregiver's
- 5:33hold. That is just heartbreaking. So the very
- 5:36act of being comforted feels like an attack to
- 5:38them? Precisely. Their nervous systems are so
- 5:41highly reactive, so flooded with sensory input,
- 5:44that a gentle touch is processed by the brain
- 5:46as a threat. So that physical bracing, the arched
- 5:50back, the tight fists, that is the character
- 5:53armor? Yes. It is the muscular system's way of
- 5:56protecting a deeply dysregulated nervous system.
- 6:00The psychological defense becomes a physical
- 6:02wall. Okay, let's unpack this. We have this biological
- 6:06baseline, the body armoring itself or wiring
- 6:09itself for panic. But how do we move from the
- 6:12sheer biological stress of the body into the
- 6:15psychological needs of a growing infant? Right,
- 6:17because eventually that armored baby has to figure
- 6:20out how to get their basic survival needs met
- 6:22by the giant adults in the room. Exactly. Which
- 6:26brings us to Freud. We have to talk about Freud's
- 6:29psychosexual stages. Oh boy, here we go. I know,
- 6:33I know. The moment people hear Freud, they roll
- 6:35their eyes or think it's all incredibly weird
- 6:37and taboo. It definitely gets a bad rap. But
- 6:39to help remember this, just think of Freud's
- 6:42stages simply as the body's very first interaction
- 6:44points with the outside world. That is a much
- 6:47better way to look at it. It removes the taboo
- 6:49and gets to the mechanical function. Right. So
- 6:52think about the oral stage. A newborn's only
- 6:54real interaction with the world is eating. So
- 6:57the oral stage is fundamentally about trust.
- 7:00Is the world going to feed me when I cry? Makes
- 7:02perfect sense. Then you move to the anal stage,
- 7:05which is potty training. Again, it sounds weird,
- 7:08but developmentally, sphincter control is the
- 7:11very first time a human being realizes they have
- 7:13power. It's about control and autonomy. Exactly.
- 7:17A toddler realizes, I control my waist. I can
- 7:20tell these giant adults no by withholding this.
- 7:23It's the birthplace of willpower. And then the
- 7:26phallic stage is simply body awareness. Yeah,
- 7:29noticing physical differences, which lays the
- 7:31very first brick in the foundation of identity.
- 7:34So Freud gave us a framework for internal drives,
- 7:38but psychologists like John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth
- 7:41realize you can't just study the baby in a vacuum.
- 7:44You have to study the relationship between the
- 7:46baby and the caregiver. Exactly. And that gave
- 7:49birth to attachment theory. A brilliant way to
- 7:52conceptualize this from our reading is to imagine
- 7:55that human babies are born as if they are completely
- 7:57covered in glue. The glue mnemonic. Yes, I love
- 8:00that one. They are basically biologically primed
- 8:04to stick to someone. They have to be. A human
- 8:07infant is completely helpless for years. They
- 8:10don't have the cognitive capacity to judge whether
- 8:12their caregiver has the moral or emotional capacity
- 8:15to care for them. They just stick to whomever
- 8:17is there. Right. Their survival depends entirely
- 8:20on the strength of that glue. But the way that
- 8:24glue dries... or the way cultures value that
- 8:27attachment varies wildly, like Ainsworth traveling
- 8:30to Uganda for naturalistic observations. Which
- 8:33eventually led to her famous strange situation
- 8:36experiment. Let me make sure I have the mechanics
- 8:39of that experiment right. You put a mother and
- 8:41a baby in a room, the mother leaves, a stranger
- 8:44walks in, and then the researchers just watch
- 8:46how the baby reacts when the mother finally comes
- 8:48back. That is the core of it, yeah. It measures
- 8:52how the child uses the caregiver as a secure
- 8:54base and how quickly they can be soothed upon
- 8:56reunion. But the fascinating part isn't just
- 8:59the experiment itself, right? No, it's the cultural
- 9:02divergence it exposed. Because what looks healthy
- 9:05in one culture might look completely dysfunctional
- 9:07in another. Exactly. Consider Western industrialized
- 9:10cultures. We are highly individualistic. We value
- 9:13independence and self -reliance above almost
- 9:15everything else. Right. So in the West, a secure
- 9:18attachment often looks like a child who might
- 9:20cry when the mother leaves, but when she returns,
- 9:23the child is quickly soothed and then confidently
- 9:25turns away to play independently. The ultimate
- 9:27goal is separation. Yes. But in collectivistic
- 9:30cultures, the goal isn't independence at all.
- 9:33The research highlights the concept of ame. Ame,
- 9:36yeah. That loosely translates to maternal do,
- 9:40right, or emotional interdependence. Right. The
- 9:43cultural goal is to stay close, to remain an
- 9:46integrated part of the whole. So in a collectivistic
- 9:49culture, after that same distressful separation,
- 9:52the mother is far more likely to maintain continuous
- 9:54physical proximity, even after the child stops
- 9:57crying. They stay merged. They stay merged. Whereas
- 9:59a Western mother might physically turn the child
- 10:01toward the toy, signaling, you're okay now, go
- 10:03be independent. Exactly. This connects so deeply
- 10:06to religion and morality, too. Think about Western
- 10:09moral frameworks. We idolize the rugged individual.
- 10:13The self -made person. Yeah, the lone pioneer
- 10:15who doesn't need anyone's help. That is treated
- 10:17as a moral high ground. But if you look at so
- 10:20many global religious traditions, the moral highest
- 10:23good is communal interdependence. You're ethically
- 10:27bound to your neighbor. Which forces us to ask
- 10:29a difficult question about the lens of psychology
- 10:31itself. Exactly. When a Western psychologist
- 10:34assesses a non -Western child who clings to their
- 10:37mother, do they misdiagnose beautiful cultural
- 10:41interdependence as anxious enmeshment? We risk
- 10:44pathologizing a cultural strength just because
- 10:46it doesn't fit our specific moral blueprint.
- 10:49Which is wild to think about. It is. The context
- 10:52is the only thing that gives the behavior meaning.
- 10:55And that contextual importance skyrockets as
- 10:58the child grows out of toddlerhood and enters
- 11:01middle childhood. So roughly ages 6 to 11. Right.
- 11:04The primary influence shifts away from that family
- 11:07glue and outward into the broader society, the
- 11:11school system and their peers. Which brings us
- 11:13to Lev Vygotsky and his sociocultural theory.
- 11:17Vygotsky basically argued that we do not develop
- 11:19in a vacuum. No, our cognitive development is
- 11:22entirely dictated by what our specific culture
- 11:25demands that we learn. To make Vygotsky's theory
- 11:28memorable, we have to use the shoelace analogy
- 11:30from the text. I use this way of thinking all
- 11:33the time now. It's so helpful. If your culture
- 11:35doesn't wear laced shoes, you're never going
- 11:38to learn how to tie them. It's not because you
- 11:40have a cognitive delay. And it's not a moral
- 11:42failing. Right. You simply only develop the cognitive
- 11:45skills that your specific environment requires
- 11:47for you to function. So we have to examine the
- 11:49specific environments, the modern shoelaces,
- 11:52so to speak, that children are being forced to
- 11:54learn today. And some of those are really tough.
- 11:57Yeah. We are looking at several highly toxic
- 12:00context that are fundamentally altering childhood
- 12:03cognitive development. We have the trauma of
- 12:06the COVID -19 pandemic, the foster care system,
- 12:09and the profound burden of systemic discrimination.
- 12:13So what does this all mean when you look at the
- 12:14actual numbers? Well, just looking impartially
- 12:17at the data presented in our sources. Black children
- 12:20are currently six times more likely to be killed
- 12:22by police than white children. Wow. This is a
- 12:24statistical reality that requires BIPOC parents
- 12:27to have the talk. with their children very early
- 12:31on, teaching them how to survive police interactions.
- 12:34Right. Furthermore, the text notes that gun violence
- 12:37is the second leading cause of death for U .S.
- 12:39children, and 85 % of kids aged 0 to 12 who are
- 12:43killed by guns are killed in their own homes.
- 12:46OK, so mechanically, what does this actually
- 12:48do to the brain? If Vygotsky is right, and we
- 12:52only learn what our environment teaches us, Are
- 12:54we saying that children growing up in these high
- 12:56stress contexts are neurologically adapting to
- 12:59survive a war zone? Yes. And as a result, they
- 13:03literally lose the cognitive bandwidth to learn
- 13:05math or reading. That is the exact mechanism
- 13:08at play. Human cognitive bandwidth is finite.
- 13:11If the shoelace your society demands you learn
- 13:14to tie is how to scan a room for physical danger.
- 13:17Right. Or how to read the emotional volatility
- 13:19of an unstable foster parent just to avoid being
- 13:22hit. Exactly. Your brain is going to divert all
- 13:25its resources to the amygdala. The prefrontal
- 13:27cortex just gets shut off. It gets deprioritized.
- 13:31The context dictates the resilience required.
- 13:34The child isn't failing to learn. Their brain
- 13:37is succeeding at prioritizing survival over academics.
- 13:41That is just... It changes how you see everything.
- 13:44It looks like a failure on a standardized test,
- 13:46but it's actually a biological success. Exactly.
- 13:50Okay, so... Let's pull all these threads together.
- 13:53We've seen how the biological stress sponge sets
- 13:56the baseline. We've seen how the caregivers provide
- 13:59the attachment glue. And how society dictates
- 14:02the cognitive shoelaces. Right. Now, what happens
- 14:05when puberty hits? The teenager is suddenly forced
- 14:08to take all of these wildly conflicting forces
- 14:11and integrate them into one identity. To explore
- 14:14this, we have the second case study, Dev. Dev
- 14:17is an adolescent from a first -generation South
- 14:19Asian immigrant family raised Muslim. Okay. And
- 14:22he's currently questioning his gender identity,
- 14:25ultimately identifying as transgender. Here's
- 14:28where it gets really interesting. Dev is walking
- 14:31into an absolute hurricane of identity collision.
- 14:34He really is. If we map Dev's experience using
- 14:36Aaron DeVore's 14 -stage model of transsexual
- 14:39identity formation, we can see the hidden psychological
- 14:42weight he's carrying. Because he's isolated at
- 14:44school, right? Right. And he knows it isn't safe
- 14:47to come out at home. Right. He is finding his
- 14:49community and expressing his gender online, but
- 14:52hiding his true self in his living room to maintain
- 14:55safety. So how does psychology even categorize
- 14:58that? Is he just stuck between stages? Well,
- 15:02Dvor's model helps explain this. The early stages
- 15:05involve profound anxiety and confusion about
- 15:07gender, followed by comparing oneself to others.
- 15:10Which he has moved past, because he found that
- 15:13online community. Exactly. He knows who he is,
- 15:16so he is likely oscillating between stages eight
- 15:19and nine. What defines those two stages specifically?
- 15:22Stage eight is the delay before acceptance. This
- 15:25is where a person is reality testing their identity
- 15:27or waiting for circumstances to change, like
- 15:30waiting until they turn 18 to move out, before
- 15:33fully expressing themselves. And stage nine?
- 15:36Stage nine is the acceptance of the transgender
- 15:38identity, where it becomes internally established,
- 15:41even if it isn't externally visible to everyone
- 15:43in their life. The moral and religious friction
- 15:47Dev is facing has to be excruciating. I mean,
- 15:50his parents have a very strong ethnic and racial
- 15:52identity, or ERI. Right. As first -generation
- 15:56immigrants, their Islamic faith and South Asian
- 15:58heritage carry specific cultural expectations
- 16:00for gender roles in marriage. And teenagers still
- 16:03desperately need their parents' psychological
- 16:05support. Dev is caught in a profound moral crossfire.
- 16:09It really is a crossfire. It's the ethical desire
- 16:12to honor his parents and his family's faith,
- 16:14colliding head on with the psychological imperative
- 16:17to be his authentic self. How do you tie those
- 16:20shoelaces together when they belong to two completely
- 16:22different pairs of shoes? It's incredibly difficult.
- 16:25And the mechanism that makes Dev's situation
- 16:27unique to this generation is the role of social
- 16:30media. Oh, yeah. The text highlighted that. For
- 16:33previous generations, an isolated teen in Dev's
- 16:36position might have genuinely believed they were
- 16:38the only person on Earth feeling this way. The
- 16:41isolation would have been total. But social media
- 16:43provides a literal lifeline. It offers connection,
- 16:46peer validation, and a shared vocabulary that
- 16:49bypasses his physical geography. It's a whole
- 16:51new cultural context that Vygotsky or Freud couldn't
- 16:54have ever imagined. Dev is getting one set of
- 16:57glue and shoelaces from the internet and a completely
- 17:00contradictory set from his living room. And as
- 17:03a mental health professional or just an empathetic
- 17:06human, you have to look at Dev not as a cluster
- 17:08of diagnostic symptoms, but as a composite of
- 17:11all these cultural collisions. The goal isn't
- 17:14to pathologize his anxiety. No, the goal is to
- 17:17understand that his anxiety is a functional adaptation
- 17:20to the incredible pressures he is forced to navigate
- 17:23every single day. It's just breathtaking when
- 17:26you zoom out. When we trace this journey today,
- 17:29Starting with the neurochemical stress -flooding
- 17:32exquentes developing brain in the womb. Watching
- 17:34how trauma physically builds character armor.
- 17:37Right. And understanding the sticky attachment
- 17:40glue we use to survive our caregivers. Learning
- 17:42the specific shoelaces our society demands we
- 17:45tie. All the way to Dev trying to integrate massive
- 17:48cultural and moral forces into one identity.
- 17:51Human development is clearly not a clean, straight
- 17:54line. It's a messy, brilliant adaptation to whatever
- 17:57the world throws at us. It is a constant negotiation
- 18:01between biology and environment. So when you
- 18:04look at your own traits, your specific anxieties,
- 18:07your fierce independence, your moral compass.
- 18:10Or even the physical way your body reacts to
- 18:12stress. Exactly. Remember that you are the product
- 18:16of the glue you were handed and the shoelaces
- 18:19your culture taught you to tie. Which leaves
- 18:21us with a final lingering thought to chew on.
- 18:25If our deepest psychological wiring, the thickness
- 18:28of our character armor, the baseline of our nervous
- 18:30system and our attachment style is largely set
- 18:34in motion when we are way too young to ever choose
- 18:36our environment. Yeah. How much of you is actually
- 18:40you and how much is just the echoed history of
- 18:43the people who held you? Unraveling that is the
- 18:46work of a lifetime. It really is. Thanks for
- 18:48joining us for this deep dive on the psychology
- 18:50undergrad. We'll catch you next time.