Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Baby Reindeer - Your Emails
Transcript
- 0:00Hey is her listeners. So I didn't really expect this, but I received
- 0:05a lot of emails in response to my episodes on Baby Reindeer, and upon
- 0:10reading some of them, I thought, I have to share these emails with
- 0:16y'all. Some of these emails are extremely interesting. This first email is from
- 0:22listener Susan. She says, I stalked a therapist for years by phone.
- 0:30I stalked a therapist. I'm assuming her own therapist. I'm not sure.
- 0:34I stocked a therapist for years by phone. I was so angry with him,
- 0:39and I knew I was extremely ill, but I could do nothing about
- 0:44it. I knew I was extremely ill, but I couldn't do anything about
- 0:49it. Your video explains my behavior so well. It's providing me with another
- 0:55stepping stone of understanding towards improving myself. I stocked this poor therapist online through
- 1:03a psychology forum. I would write terrible things about him, and other people
- 1:08on the forum were responding to me with understanding. On the forum, we
- 1:15supported each other in our combined madnesses and therapy transference love. So just chiming
- 1:23in here, I think what Susan is saying is that her and everybody else
- 1:26on this forum, or a lot of the people in the forum were experiencing
- 1:30transference love for their therapists, in that we will tend to transfer our important,
- 1:40significant past relationships, often with our parents. We will transfer that relationship
- 1:45onto our therapist. We will displace and we will see our therapist as if
- 1:52they are the person in our past, even though the therapist isn't doing anything
- 1:57that would justify that. We might have an abusive parent and then we might
- 2:01feel abused by our therapist. And that's what we call transference or displacement,
- 2:07and it's confusing, but it's a part of therapy and it's normal. It
- 2:12happens all the time. Sometimes clients might fall in love with their therapists.
- 2:16So Susan is saying that they were all on this forum encouraging each other regarding
- 2:23that distortion, regarding transferring onto the therapist going on. We all had an
- 2:29addiction to our therapists, and we were all suffering at the time. My
- 2:36family and my life were literally falling apart around me, and I had one
- 2:39of those childhoods that produced my type of personality. I think she's referring to
- 2:46narcissistic personality as well as I suspect a strong genetic predisposition to borderline personality disorder
- 2:53and the associated narcissistic traits. I was so angry at the time. I
- 2:59felt like a fish caught in a net thrashing for my life. End of
- 3:04email. Yeah, well, thanks for sharing, Susan. I always appreciate
- 3:12getting emails or comments along these lines. You know, It's one thing for
- 3:15me to make a video about a stalker and a victim and have victims step
- 3:21forward, which is very, very important to me. It is literally the
- 3:24meaning of my life to help validate and inform around that. But for perpetrators
- 3:34to step forward, perpetrators of abuse, perpetrators of stalking, for them to
- 3:38step forward, well that is the icing on the cake. Because when I
- 3:45talk, I'm getting chills thinking about when I talk about these syndromes, these
- 3:51patterns, I'm not only hoping to validate the victims out there a variou different,
- 4:00but I'm also hoping that I myself can reach perpetrators people who harm others,
- 4:10because our society doesn't talk to perpetrators in a way that is inviting.
- 4:16I'm not justifying the behavior, of course, but I think I am providing
- 4:23a way of conceptualizing why a good person would do a very very bad thing,
- 4:30even if that very very bad thing lasted for years. Why would a
- 4:35good person do a very very bad thing. Well, there's various reasons.
- 4:41Of course, there are also very very bad people. I mean, what's
- 4:45good, what's bad? But you know, statistic psychopaths that are beyond repair,
- 4:49that kind of thing. You know, those people exist. I've met
- 4:53those people, I've treated some of those people. That's terrifying to be around
- 4:57them. But the vast majority of people are not that. To our society
- 5:00and the way the Internet talks about people who abuse or stock as being rotten
- 5:06to the core. They might not say that phrase, but I think they
- 5:10believe it to be true. So if we're going to actually change society for
- 5:16the better, then what better way than to help the perpetrators. And if
- 5:21we're going to help the perpetrators, then we have to reach out to them
- 5:26in a way that at the very least isn't making them out to be evil.
- 5:30So I'm glad that you are going down their path. It sounds like
- 5:36you were already on that path, and watching my videos was a small part
- 5:42of that. A stepping stone, as you say, which is just fantastic.
- 5:46All right. This next email is from anonymous annual patron and YouTube member.
- 5:51She says, could you please discuss why you classified Martha as having narcissistic
- 5:57personality sorter rather than borderline personally sorter? So just chiming in here. Well,
- 6:00first off, I hope that I didn't classify Martha as having anything because
- 6:06I can't diagnose from afar. I hope I said that my top hypothesis would
- 6:13be narcissism, but I would need a lot more information to confidently diagnose her
- 6:17with anything, So I hope I said that. But if we go with
- 6:21that, you know didn't Why wasn't my top hypothesis borderline? The other thing
- 6:27to consider is that clinicians are going to vary regarding their opinions. I have
- 6:31seen this firsthand many many times in my life, particularly around person and I
- 6:35shorders. So why didn't I say borderline? Well, in a nutshell,
- 6:41I see borderline and narcissism to be very very similar. I've talked about this
- 6:46before that underneath every narcissistic person is a borderline person in that both in my
- 6:53conceptuization and the research points in this direction and my clinical experience shows me this
- 6:59thataristic people and borderline people both went through a lot of attachment injury when they
- 7:05were very, very young. And I could go into the nuances on this,
- 7:09and you can listen to my deep dives. But when you have significant
- 7:13attachment injury early in life, it can result in a lot of different issues,
- 7:17issues that we might label as personality shorders or attachment styles or whatever.
- 7:25Delineating between those syndromes or those reactions or those adaptations that children and then adults
- 7:32will have in response to the trauma that they went through can be hard.
- 7:38It can be hard to say is this borderline or is it narcissism, because
- 7:42the underlying issue is still the same. They went through a very very difficult
- 7:45time and they had to adapt, And might someone adapt in a way where
- 7:48they look like both depending on the day, Yeah, so could someone say
- 7:54borderline and make a case for it? Absolutely? The bottom line is,
- 7:58without going into all the details, the criteria of narcissism were closer in my
- 8:05view. Like one of the things she said when they were in the canal,
- 8:09she says something along the lines of any man who doesn't want to be
- 8:15with me, any man who wasn't attracted to me is either blind or gay.
- 8:20That's a very grandiose statement, and people with borderline don't typically have that
- 8:26grandiosity. People with borderline typically have very low self esteems contrary to evidence around
- 8:33them, whereas narcissistic people tend to have, at least on the surface.
- 8:37Their narcissistic structure is such that they believe that they're the most wonderful person depending
- 8:43on the domain that they're focusing on. In that moment, Martha's thought that
- 8:48every man would want her, that's not a borderline thing, typically narcissistic thing.
- 8:54But I see why people would think borderline because we see the vulnerability.
- 8:58But people with narcisism are vulnerable. That's why I say underneath every narcisistic person
- 9:03as a borderline person. The problem, though, is that borderline people will
- 9:07try to get attachment with others and might get some occasionally. Narcissistic people have
- 9:16avoided it their whole life, so they haven't gotten it in the same way
- 9:18that borderline people haven't gotten it, and they haven't searched for it. So
- 9:22they are really really alone and very very fragile, and very very much in
- 9:28pain. So that's that Another reason why I went with narcissism is that whenever
- 9:35someone presents with symptoms or behaviors within the realm of cluster B you know,
- 9:41histrionic, borderline, and narcissistic, if it's a woman, they will be
- 9:45categorized as borderline, and if they're a man, they'll be categorized as narcissistic.
- 9:48And I was welcoming the opportunity to talk about a narcissistic woman character in
- 9:58Martha to dispel of that stereotype because, believe me, plenty of people who
- 10:05suffer from narcissism are women. Going on with your email, you say,
- 10:09I've seen other mental health practitioners online suggest that she suffered from eroto mania,
- 10:15delusional disorder, and bipolar end of email. Yeah, well some are suggesting
- 10:20this, and I have to say I'm confused. In fact, a lot
- 10:24of people, even in the comment section where clinicians I think, saying delusion
- 10:28disorder or bipolar, and so you could make kind of an argument for delusional
- 10:35shorder, but it's better the distortion that she had that she was in a
- 10:39relationship with Donnie is better explained through narcisstic precise order, particularly because a lot
- 10:45of the other symptoms of narcissic precise order were there. Plus, when you
- 10:48actually see people with erota mania and delusional disorder, it's much more akin to
- 10:52schizophrenia. That's how it's categorized, that's how it's described. It's not schizophrenia,
- 10:58but it is much more like that, and a lot of people with
- 11:03delusional shorder will develop schizophrenia. So I didn't see that in her. The
- 11:09only scene where we saw that was when Donnie broke up with her. Right,
- 11:13they weren't in a relationship, but Donnie breaks up with her and she's
- 11:16like, oh no, don't break up with me. And you're thinking,
- 11:18huh, why do you think that you actually believe? And here's my opinion.
- 11:26When I saw that scene, I thought, even though I knew it
- 11:30was based on a true story, I thought that Richard Gadd had embellished that
- 11:35scene. I wouldn't be surprised if you would say, yeah, I kind
- 11:39of amped that scene up a little bit for drama's sake or something, or
- 11:45I condensed a bunch of things into that one scene, and that seemed like
- 11:48it fit because none of the other presentation, the way that it was written
- 11:52and presented, fit into that delusional category, like there was an earlier scene
- 11:58where he in the very beginning of episode one, after she is ramping up
- 12:05and talking and talking and talking and she brings in that picnic basket. She's
- 12:07like, oh, we could have this romantic time on my birthday. And
- 12:11he says, look, Martha, I think picnic is something that boyfriend and
- 12:16girlfriend would do, right. And the way Martha reacts is she immediately realizes
- 12:22that she has overstepped and she says, oh, well, what would friends
- 12:28do? And he says, go to a coffee shop, And then they
- 12:33go to a coffee shop. If she were delusional, she would not have
- 12:37reacted that way. When you confront a delusion, you don't get that react
- 12:43she adjusted, which pointed at the reality that for her, she knew she
- 12:48wasn't in a relationship with him, but she was hoping to be in a
- 12:52relationship with him, and she liked playing house kind of because it wasn't like
- 12:58she was going home with them or trying to kiss him or hug him everything.
- 13:01She just liked it's like playing house. It's like we're gonna pretend,
- 13:05and I want to pretend. Can't we just pretend? And then when he
- 13:09confronted that, she was like, oh, bummer, I guess we can't
- 13:13pretend, well, can we be friends that you know, that's not someone
- 13:16suffering from a delusion. That's someone that's making a choice. It's someone that
- 13:20is desperate, and it's not typical to narcissism, but it definitely is something
- 13:26that I've seen before. The other thing about delusion disorder is that lifetime prevalence
- 13:31of delusional disorder of all the different types, including erotomania, is something like
- 13:35zero point two percent. So that's two out of every thousand people, right
- 13:41will, according to research, suffer from delusional shorder in general, all the
- 13:46different types of delusional shorder. Erotomania is just one of the types, one
- 13:52of the several types of delusional sorder. So let's just back of the napkin,
- 13:58say, you know, this is probably too many, but let's say
- 14:01one out of every ten people who have delusional sorter have erotomania. Well,
- 14:05then that puts the lifetime prevalence rate of erotomania to be zero point zero two
- 14:09percent, two out of every ten thousand people. Right. Well, the
- 14:13prevalence lifetime prevalence rate of narcissistic person disorder is a little less than two percent,
- 14:20So that means that there are one hundred times more people with narcissistic personized
- 14:26full blown narcissistic precise story, we're not even including the people that are on
- 14:30the spectrum right, So there are one hundred times more people who suffer from
- 14:35narcisstic personal disorder than there are who suffer from erotomania. So if I see
- 14:39enough narcissistic traits and I can explain the delusion like behavior, you know,
- 14:46it's sort of like with borderline. The classic pre treatment pre awareness for someone
- 14:54with borderline is they'll text their partner while they're at work, and their partner
- 14:58won't text them BA and the individual, you know, the borderline individual will
- 15:03start spinning out of control and fast forward a few hours and without any reason
- 15:09to believe, so they believe that their husband or their partner is cheating on
- 15:13them, even though that's just not a possibility. That's you could argue a
- 15:20delusion, but we don't frame it that way. But that is why it's
- 15:22called borderline because originally, before they knew about borderline, they observed some people
- 15:28seem to have these like very specific delusions breaks from reality but it wasn't schizophrenia,
- 15:37it was something different. It's borderline schizophrenia, it's borderline psychotic. Eventually
- 15:43they figured out that these distortions were related to attachment injury, in that they're
- 15:50so paranoid about abandonment. They've been abandoned so many times that they see abandonment
- 15:54where it doesn't exist, and they will fit the facts around their feeling,
- 16:00which is that their partner is cheating on them. So for the narcissistic person,
- 16:03they also have borderline schizophrenic like distortions that they're superior, that they're wonderful,
- 16:11that everyone loves them, that anyone who hasn't attracted them is either blind
- 16:15or gay, and that someone who talks to them is secretly in love with
- 16:21them. Okay, so let's talk about bipolar because that was also something I
- 16:26saw in the comment section, and this anonymous patron and YouTube member is saying
- 16:30that she has seen other clinicians online saying that Martha has bipolar. I don't
- 16:37understand this because if you've actually met someone with bipolar, you would not think
- 16:42Martha was bipolar. For since the beginning of my career, I have seen
- 16:48people apply the label of bipolar to people that I have no idea where they
- 16:55are coming from. Bipolar is a very specific presentation. You know, there
- 17:00are variations, but the quintessential presentation, which I think is the majority of
- 17:06presentations, the vast majority, is depressed for several months and then manic for
- 17:12a few weeks, and depression most people know what that is. Mania is
- 17:18very particular. I could describe mania to you, you could hear it,
- 17:22you could read the symptoms list. You'd never really know what it is until
- 17:26you actually see it. It's so different than that, you know, I
- 17:30think everyone can kind of know what depressed, you know, because all of
- 17:33us have been a little depressed, but manic is like a whole other ball
- 17:37of axe, and it's very particular, and it's very noticeable. And there
- 17:41were zero signs of mar I mean, someone might make the argument, someone
- 17:45could make the argument that she might have suffered from bipolar, but we just
- 17:51never saw on screen because like offscreen she would have the full blown manic episodes
- 17:57or maybe she was bipolar two and you but you'd really have to shove it
- 18:02in there. And you know, if Martha were a real character, is
- 18:04it possible, Yeah, because we just don't have a lot of data,
- 18:08but in terms of the data that was presented on the show, I didn't
- 18:11see any sign. I think the only thing that people were keying in on
- 18:15it was that she talked a lot, and they just think people who talk
- 18:18a lot are manic. But a lot of different people talk a lot,
- 18:22not just manic people. Plus, when manic people are talking a lot half
- 18:26the time, particularly as they escalate in mania, they don't make any sense.
- 18:32Also, the kinds of things that manic people will talk about. I
- 18:36don't know. I don't want to get in the weeds. I just want
- 18:37to say, to me, it didn't look like bipolar at all. And
- 18:42it's just another example of how sometimes I wonder if I'm stupid, or we
- 18:48all learned from different professors, or I don't know, I just don't understand
- 18:53why. Because I had a client who had borderline and he went to the
- 18:59hospital, you went to the mercy room and he was diagnosed with bipolar within
- 19:06twenty minutes and given lithium. And he came into session and he's like,
- 19:10yeah, so I had sort of a bad weekend because of this and that,
- 19:14And I went to the mercy room and they diagnosed with me with bipolar
- 19:18and they gave me lithium. Do I have bipolar? And I've been treating
- 19:22this client for years and I was like, no, you don't have bipolar.
- 19:27Presumably my client was assessed by a very qualified individual, hopefully, and
- 19:34yet how could they miss the mark? I don't know a fad. I've
- 19:38seen people just throw bipolar like you'll have. I once had a six year
- 19:44old client who had a huge anger problem and he was diagnosed with bipolar,
- 19:49and I didn't see any cycles. Now, I will mention that there are
- 19:55mixed cycles and rapid cycling. That's a very complicated area to get into.
- 20:00You could make an argument I suppose that Martha had some sort of mixed rapid
- 20:06cycle version of bipolar, But I don't know. To me, it just
- 20:10feels like it's really stretching it. I'm willing to be proven wrong. I'm
- 20:14willing for people to make a case for it. I'd love to hear it,
- 20:18honestly. But let's go on to another email anonymous long term annual patron.
- 20:32She says, I was initially put on the defensive while listening to your
- 20:37Baby Reindeer episodes because of my own disorganized and preoccupied attachment. I was initially
- 20:44put on the defensive while listening to Your Baby Reindeer episodes because of my own
- 20:49disorganized and preoccupied attachment. Okay, in dating, I've always moved on quickly
- 20:56when it didn't work out, and dating I've always moved drawn quickly when it
- 21:00didn't work out. But with my most recent breakup, I was very in
- 21:03love with him in a way i'd never experienced before, and I had a
- 21:07really hard time letting go. So it sounds like the patron is saying that
- 21:14she felt the urge similar to what Martha was doing. I'm not sure I'll
- 21:22continue reading. I've always felt a bit resentful when you talk about the risk
- 21:29for preoccupied people to hold their avoidant counterparts hostage. I've always felt a bit
- 21:34resentful when you talking to me, when you talk about the risk for preoccupied
- 21:41people to hold their avoidant counterparts hostage chiming in. I hope I never used
- 21:45that term that they would hold avoidant people hostage. I mean, I guess,
- 21:53depending on what I was saying or the context, I don't think I
- 21:57would word it that way. But yeah, there's a risk for preoccupied people
- 22:03to deal with the pain and the anxiety by becoming controlling. That's just a
- 22:11fact. Do they all do that? No? Can avoidant people be controlling?
- 22:15Yeah? Can secure people be controlling? Yeah? But preoccupied people.
- 22:22But I wouldn't ever say seriously that preoccupied people hold their avoidant counterparts hostage.
- 22:30I mean, that is extreme, and that's not how I think. If
- 22:34I said that, I apologize. Why is it seen as such a violation
- 22:41to want to be with someone intensely but not to completely rip a person's heart
- 22:47out? Why is it seen as such a violation to want to be with
- 22:51someone intensely but not to completely rip a person's heart out? Just chime me
- 22:56in, yeah, I mean anonymous, long term, a manual patron.
- 22:59If you know you were for the first time, you're saying very much in
- 23:03love with someone, and when you went through the breakup, you had a
- 23:07really hard time letting go, and you didn't want to say goodbye, and
- 23:15you say, you know, you want to be with them intensely, and
- 23:18you might have pursued them intensely. You know, that's not a violation.
- 23:23That's just normal. I mean it's normal for anyone. If you're secure and
- 23:27you go through a rough breakup, then You're probably going to have moments of
- 23:33intense desire to Even if you were the one breaking up with someone, you
- 23:37might have an intense desire to get back with them. You know, it's
- 23:40just normal you miss them or you don't want to say goodbye, particularly if
- 23:42you're the one being broken up with. Going on, it's totally fine to
- 23:48tell someone they're safe with you, only to disappear and make them feel very
- 23:52unsafe. It's totally fine. I'm not sure that so all of this was
- 23:57swirling around in my head when I was listening to Your Baby Reindeer episodes,
- 24:03but I think your episodes, coupled with watching the show Baby Reindeer finally helped
- 24:07it click for me. Obviously, I understand logically that it wasn't okay to
- 24:14stalk him, but I was able to empathize with the avoidant person a lot
- 24:18more than I have in the past. I think she's referring to Donnie.
- 24:22I identified with Martha when I watched the show. Identified with Martha in a
- 24:30way that I hated, and identified with Martha in a way that I hated.
- 24:33I would never do anything so extreme as what she did, but I
- 24:40did text my ex twelve times with no response after he abruptly ended it.
- 24:48At first I employed apologies and pathos to get him to answer. Then overtext,
- 24:53I was short of working out how I felt about him. I was
- 24:59sort of sorry. Then over text, I was sort of working out how
- 25:02I felt about him and the relationship. Then eventually I got angry in the
- 25:04text, and then he blocked me unsurprisingly. Okay, I just want to
- 25:07go over this. So you say that he abruptly ended it, and then
- 25:15you texted him twelve times with no response. So the first four texts you
- 25:22were apologizing and expressing pathos, you know, feelings, You're like, hey,
- 25:26please just please answer me. Then there were four more texts of you
- 25:32saying you're trying to work out how you felt about him in the relationship,
- 25:37so maybe something like well maybe this is for the best or whatever. But
- 25:41then there's four more texts where you're angry, like fuck you, how dare
- 25:45you you're not responding or whatever? Are you always were a jerk face?
- 25:51Or I don't know? And then you say that he blocked you unsurprising,
- 25:55And you know, I don't know the situation, but I wouldn't be surprised
- 26:00if we saw the texts or if we talked to him, would he say
- 26:06that he abruptly ended it? But maybe he did, you know, maybe
- 26:07maybe he did. Maybe he just everything was cruised along and all of a
- 26:11sudden he's like, yeah, I'm breaking up and then boom he blocks you,
- 26:14Like yeah, it's gonna cut. So I could be hearing a very
- 26:18normal response from you, patron, but we'd have to hear the full story
- 26:23going on with the email. So he blocked me. Unsurprisingly. All I
- 26:27really wanted, short of getting back together or even just being friends, was
- 26:32some sort of closure, some recognition from him that I'm human and that he
- 26:37hurt me. But I also understand it probably made him feel unsafe and smothered.
- 26:41Okay, end of email. You're saying that you feel resentful of me
- 26:51when I characterize preoccupied people as holding avoidant people hostage. You know, I
- 26:56don't know what went on with you and your boyfriend. I do know me,
- 27:00and I apologize to you if I said that or hinted at that or
- 27:06something. You know, In all the content that I make, there's a
- 27:10lot of different contexts, Like there will be times when I'm speaking to a
- 27:15preoccupied person and I'll have a particular vibe. Another time, I might be
- 27:18talking to someone who was abused by someone that we would characterize as preoccupied,
- 27:26and I'll speak in a different way. Or I might be watching a reality
- 27:30TV show in which someone is being preoccupied and I feel bad for them,
- 27:33And in another moment, I might be watching a reality TV show and seeing
- 27:37someone that's acting preoccupied, that is being extremely abusive and annoying, and I'll
- 27:42be talking about preoccupied in a different vibe. So you know, there's probably
- 27:45a lot of vibes. And you know I have been a dick at some
- 27:48point along the line along the way, Yeah, and I apologize for that,
- 27:53if that's true, all right. The sex emails from patron Emily from
- 27:56Denver. She asked a lot of questions about projective identification, which I very
- 28:03much love because that's one of my favorite things to talk about. But I
- 28:07don't want to get bogged down too much in theory. You can listen to
- 28:11my other episodes on that. But to answer your questions directly, yes,
- 28:15you can internalize both an outside relationship and you can also internalize a relationship that
- 28:22you're in. You internalize the object, your perception of the object. You
- 28:27also internalize your perception of the self, and that becomes a stable diad internalization.
- 28:33And then you also say does it apply to events later in life or
- 28:37only a child that yes, we're always internalizing, but we're more of a
- 28:41sponge when we're young. In fact, therapy in my model, is an
- 28:47internalization in a positive way. You're internalizing yourself, a version of yourself and
- 28:53your therapist, and that's becoming a stronger. You're bolstering a positive interject inside
- 29:00of you. So there's that. Let's go into another email. All right,
- 29:03this is another great email. Anonymous listener. She says, I just
- 29:07started watching your Baby Reindeer episodes and you were talking about a corrective experience and
- 29:15how most of us have this compulsion to rewrite the past. For example,
- 29:22you talked about getting involved romantically with people that have similar traits to a parent
- 29:26so that we can rework the past. You said that sometimes it can be
- 29:30successful, but more often than that, we choose someone who won't change because
- 29:36we kind of need it to be that way. Would you be able to
- 29:38expand on that, Why do we need it to be that way? You
- 29:41did not elaborate, but I was really curious to know what you meant.
- 29:45Yeah, well, anonymous listener in a nutshell, And this is largely psychobabble
- 29:51and unprovable, but it's a model of understanding weird human behavior. Psychodynamic theory
- 29:56is good for that. And this is my way of putting it. How
- 30:00do I say this very briefly, this'll just go with abandon it.
- 30:03So you have an abandoning father and you learn a lesson that you are not
- 30:11worth sticking around for. And so you grow up in life and you're struggling
- 30:18with that internally, and you're not super aware of it. I mean,
- 30:19you know your dad abandoned you, but you don't really know you're carrying it
- 30:22with you. You don't know how it affects you. You have this assumption
- 30:26that you're not a good person, you're not lovable, You have this assumption
- 30:30that other people can't really be trusted, and that other people are always trying
- 30:36to get away from you whatever. You know, it depends on the manifestation.
- 30:38But get my point. And you're starting to date and there's a subconscious
- 30:45need to try to recreate that past relationship because there's this desire to try to
- 30:52go back in time and make your dad not abandon you. And if you
- 30:56can date someone that kind of looks like your dad and has abandoning hints and
- 31:02qualities, and I can get him to not abandon me, then at least
- 31:07that's a vicarious solution to that problem that I want to correct for in the
- 31:11past. It's not actually taking a time machine, but I'm you know,
- 31:15it's it's close enough. This is a subconscious compulsion. Another reason for this
- 31:22is that we're just used to it. You know, we loved our dad
- 31:25and we will subconsciously look for qualities that we predict will produce that love feeling,
- 31:32and if we're not careful, we'll just sniff out the guy in the
- 31:34room who actually has the signs of someone who would abandon you. So some
- 31:41of it is just the devil, you know, that kind of thing.
- 31:44Also, we might recreate it because we believe deep down that we're abandonable,
- 31:49and why fight it. We should just be with someone who abandons people,
- 31:55because it's going to happen anyway, you know, that kind of thing going
- 31:57on With another email anonymous long term middle tier patron, they say, watching
- 32:01Baby Reindeer triggered me pretty hard in an unexpected way. I related, so
- 32:07thoroughly to Donnie. The part where he realizes he's part of the problem and
- 32:10he realizes that he's complicit in his own abuse. I remember realizing that too.
- 32:15Yeah, yeah, that. I don't know if there's anything that I've
- 32:19ever seen that shows that element at all, let alone that Well, yeah,
- 32:24you say, the part he realized he's part of the problem and he
- 32:28realizes that he's complicit in his own I mean, he's not complicit in his
- 32:31own abuse. That that's how he felt about it. He's not to blame,
- 32:35he's not complicit. He's he's just trying to survive. But you could
- 32:39see how someone would think that going on. I remember realizing that too,
- 32:46and the shame and the defeat I felt at the time. Yeah, just
- 32:50shemming in here. I don't air situation anonymous long term military patron. But
- 32:54there's it's not black or white. It's not I wasn't complicit or I was
- 33:01complicit. There's a third option, which is I was struggling to such a
- 33:07degree and looking for a solution under various rocks, and occasionally the rocks that
- 33:12I would overturn involved me leaning into the abuse and maybe trying to get a
- 33:16control of it by trying to create it or something that's not complicit with the
- 33:22abuse. That's a desperate act by a desperate person, you know, sort
- 33:25of be like you're a hostage. Someone's got you at gunpoint, and you
- 33:30try very different things to avoid being shot, and one of the things you
- 33:34do is you start kissing up to the guy with the gun. Well,
- 33:37you're not complicit in the gun being in your face. You're just desperately looking
- 33:43for a way to survive. And that's the way it looked to me.
- 33:46And I actually felt bad for Donnie that the way the character was written,
- 33:52he was concluding that he was to blame. All I saw was someone that
- 33:55was just scrambling for solutions to very difficult situation, and everyone does that.
- 34:05Going on. It's been almost a year since that revelation, and I'm still
- 34:08working with a therapist. I've been kind of hybernating because I don't trust myself.
- 34:14I see that I'm my worst enemy. Even with therapy, I'm not
- 34:17so confident. I'm like Donnie going out every day pretending to be fine,
- 34:22strong and normal. Any email, Yeah, well, Patroon, I'm so
- 34:25sorry that you went through this. You're better off now than you were before.
- 34:30But you're in that zone where Donnie was. There's another zone where you
- 34:36don't conclude, you know, you say it like I realized it too,
- 34:39you know, I remember when I realized that I was complicently abused. That's
- 34:44just another version of internalized abuse for yourself. You weren't complicit, and to
- 34:51conclude that and stay in that place, and it's fine if that's just a
- 34:54stage, but to stay in that place that you're to blame essentially for the
- 34:59abuse will lead to what you're talking about, where you believe you're your own
- 35:04worst enemy. You were harmed by somebody else. That this is very important
- 35:09and there's no way to completely convince oneself of this over time, but you
- 35:15got to work on it. The abuser did something to you and you were
- 35:21innocent. You've always been innocent and you were just trying to survive. Maybe
- 35:27there were times when, you know, like with Donnie, you created it
- 35:31somehow, But that's how trauma is, you know, that's what it does
- 35:36to us. So the fact that you feel defeated and that you don't trust
- 35:40yourself, that you're not confident, you know, keep going to therapy,
- 35:45keep working on it. But The place that you deserve to be is a
- 35:49place where you look back and say, like, oh my god, I
- 35:52was I was trying my best, and I didn't have particularly good guidance or
- 35:58I didn't have the time to think or to ask for help, and I
- 36:05was scrambling because I was suffering like anyone else would have in that position.
- 36:10And I regret doing X, Y, and Z, But I don't think
- 36:15I was a bad person, because what else are you gonna do when you
- 36:20got a gun point out your face, You're gonna do some weird shit.
- 36:24The bottom line is is that I was targeted by someone who was abusive and
- 36:30they harmed me, and I was just trying anything to get out of it.
- 36:34You know, That's what Donnie was going through. Donnie was one of
- 36:37the most abused people we've ever seen any kind of show or movie. And
- 36:42if he's going to have a few weird reactions, it's understandable, right,
- 36:47And he had a lot of healthy reactions, including if this is a true
- 36:51story? Making the TV show all right? Last email here page trans Sarah
- 37:00in France. She says, I watched Baby Reindeer on Netflix and found it
- 37:06extremely triggering due to my preview experience of having been sexually abused of my teens.
- 37:09Yeah, Honestly, if I had known it was that dark, I
- 37:14probably wouldn't have watched it. Just chiming in. Yeah, I think I
- 37:17said at the very beginning of my first video that people should be very careful
- 37:22watching this show. If ever, I think I said, if ever there's
- 37:25a show that requires a trigger warning for people with PTSD, this is that
- 37:30show. So yeah, So going on with the email, However, I
- 37:35almost immediately segued from Netflix into your podcast episode, and I found it to
- 37:40be very soothing to relive the experience of watching the show with your commentary.
- 37:45Hearing your voice and how you unpacked the characters was very insightful and healing for
- 37:51me and helped me to ground myself. I'm not sure if you make reaction
- 37:55content with the express purpose with this express purpose in mind, but in this
- 38:01instance, I found it really helpful and it made me feel able to carry
- 38:06on going about my day rather than collapsing in on myself. So thank you
- 38:10for sharing your perspective and for all the hard work you put into the podcast.
- 38:15You're truly a good person. Wow. Sarah France thinks that's that last
- 38:20sentence is the nicest thing anyone can say to me, honestly. But anyway,
- 38:25yeah, sorry you went through that. I'm sorry you went through the
- 38:29original PTSD, the original traumas. I'm sorry that you got triggered. I'm
- 38:34glad that I was able to help in my small way. And I don't
- 38:42make my reaction content specifically for that, but I have heard that from people
- 38:46before because it's weird. You know, It's like, well, watching this
- 38:52show by myself makes me feel this bad way, but then when I watch
- 38:57it and then Kirk interrupts and then yamors for a while, it doesn't feel
- 39:02as bad if I you know, I guess if I said I had an
- 39:07overarching reason why I make reaction videos, is that, well, I guess
- 39:12there are two things. One is, I'm trying to increase compassion for self
- 39:19and others through modeling and understanding, you know, conceptualizing people in a way
- 39:24that will drive compassion and thus drive compassion for the self. But I also
- 39:30am trying to validate people's experiences. I'm trying to say that right there,
- 39:37I've seen many times and that or I've been through that myself. You know,
- 39:44I think a lot of content makers will have that as a purpose,
- 39:49right, And that's why I turn to stuff, you know, Like I
- 39:54watched Rebel Moon two the other day and I couldn't believe how bad that movie
- 40:00was. I wanted to like it. I actually kind of liked Rebel Moon
- 40:04ie, contrary to everyone around me. Everyone hated, they hate everything that
- 40:09Zack Snyder does. Right, but Rebel Moon the movie on Netflix one,
- 40:15I you know, I tried to be as open as possible and I was
- 40:17like, yeah, it wasn't that bad. Six out of ten. It's
- 40:21watchable, it's fine. It's not as bad as everyone says it. And
- 40:23I had to defend it to everybody, but like, hey, you know,
- 40:27Rebel Moon. Hating Rebel Moon isn't a personality. And then I watched
- 40:32Rebel Moon two and I'm thinking, you know, it's a continuation of the
- 40:36story. It's probably just as good as the last one. Right, No,
- 40:38Rebel Moon two, I can't even especially if you've seen Rebel Moon one.
- 40:43Rebel Moon two is quite possibly the dumbest script. And I've seen some
- 40:46dumb scripts. I've seen The Room, I've seen episode nine, and Rebel
- 40:54Moon two is I I just can't even believe how bad is. And I
- 41:00wasn't traumatized, but I did want to feel not alone, and so I
- 41:07went to YouTube and I'm not alone, and you're not alone. And I
- 41:13don't know if I'll do any more episodes about Baby Reindeer. I somehow I
- 41:16dot it. But what a journey, right, well, maybe something will
- 41:22come up. I don't know. It's not on the docket. But if
- 41:27you're still listening to this or watching this, what a journey this show has
- 41:31taken us on and all the things that have happened, It's quite a thing.
- 41:37It's like the Tiger King moment or the Love is Blind Season one moment,
- 41:43you know, these TV events often on Netflix that just you know,
- 41:50get us going, get us talking, get us thinking. Now, think
- 41:55about all the emotions that everyone has been through, just even in these emas
- 42:00in response to the show. And yeah, I'm getting chills thinking about when
- 42:07I was watching that first episode and I was like, oh my god,
- 42:10this show is so good. I mean, regardless of the of the topic,
- 42:15which also is very engaging, just the style and the story and the
- 42:21acting and the directing. And I can't believe that Richard Gadd directed this.
- 42:27I can understand why he wrote it, because he was already a playwright,
- 42:30right, I understand why he wasn't why he is a good actor, because
- 42:35again he was on stage. But directing with camera is, you know,
- 42:39it's a whole other world. And there are very specific directing choices. I
- 42:45mean, nothing mind blowing, but very specific directing choices that aren't obvious and
- 42:52cheesy, but extremely effective. Like there's this one scene early on I think
- 42:57episode one, where Donnie comes around the corner of the bar and he sees
- 43:00Martha sitting at the bar, and Martha is looking very very sad. When
- 43:06Donnie is around, Martha's very animated and happy. But when Donnie kind of
- 43:09sneaks a look at her when he's not around and she's just left to herself
- 43:15and she's just staring at eyes cast down, she looks miserable. And the
- 43:22way that scene is shot and the voiceover and the lighting changes and the zoom
- 43:29and I don't know, it's not mind blowing, but it's very very effective.
- 43:32And when the first time I watched the show, I didn't really recognize
- 43:36any of those things. Upon rewatching it, I recognized these edits and these
- 43:42shots and these sequences and the choreography or the staging, like that scene in
- 43:46the Canal, it's just so specific. That scene where I'm getting chills,
- 43:52where they're joking around is later on and she says she's hugging him, and
- 43:59she says, I just wish I could unzip you all the way down through
- 44:02your belly and I could just crawl inside you. And the line that Richard
- 44:07Gad the writer, director, actor rides in between because you know it's hinting
- 44:14at like Science of the Lambs, right, but it's not going completely in
- 44:17that direction. There's another part where you at the same time you feel the
- 44:23pain and the innocence in Martha's desire to crawl inside someone. It sounds like,
- 44:30at least to me, the way a child would long to be held
- 44:35to be taken care of. So in the same expression, which is just
- 44:40masterful really and fits these kinds of scenarios of stalking where you have, in
- 44:49the same moment in the same person someone is being fragile and childlike and you
- 44:57feel bad for them. At the same time they're talking about skinning you alive
- 45:02and getting inside of your skin and walking around with your skin on like a
- 45:06skin suit. And it's terrifying the fact that Richard Gadd several times in the
- 45:13series could have these scenes that could hold all of that, and that's so
- 45:19hard to do. It's just so incredibly hard to do. Like that scene
- 45:22where he makes the joke about the curtains and the way the voiceover is and
- 45:28the sequence and everything, like he's got a keen eye for how people interact
- 45:36and the way things feel and why people do things. It was you know,
- 45:43there's so many reasons why the show works, and it's numerous things.
- 45:50You know, it's not just the show isn't a one trick pony. I
- 45:52worry that people will just characterize it as, oh, that's the show about
- 45:55the Stalkers. That show could have been about anything. That show could have
- 46:00been about anything, and it still would have been entertaining. It wouldn't have
- 46:04been as compelling in all like the good, but it was just a good
- 46:08show. I could you know that first half of that first episode of the
- 46:15actress Jessica Something and Richard Goad and the way it was written everything. I
- 46:21could have watched that forever, The way that they were interacting, the believability
- 46:24of it, and the empathy that I'm having for the characters, and I
- 46:30don't know. Yeah, there are historical moments sometimes centering around a TV show,
- 46:36and I think we just witnessed one which is and I'm glad to have
- 46:40been swept up by that thing. Maybe more things will happen. Maybe in
- 46:47the future it'll come out that Richard Goad was lying about the whole thing and
- 46:52Fiona is completely innocent. Well, I mean, maybe it doesn't seem likely,
- 46:57but all right, well that does for that episode of Psychology Seattle.
- 47:00Everyone out there, please please please take care of yourself because you deserve it,
- 47:05you really really do. And thanks for the emails. Supper. OHI
- 49:30oh boy, Why I oh boy? Why? I oh boy. Uh