Latest / The Vegan Report / The Repugnant Conclusion of Effective Animal Altruism | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, welcome to The Vegan Report.
- 0:03My name is Ryan and today is your Wednesday Science
- 0:06of Activism episode. And for today's episode,
- 0:10we are talking about the limits of effective
- 0:13animal altruism with Vera Flock. She exposes
- 0:18those limits in a recent paper published in the
- 0:21Journal of Animal Ethics titled The Repugnant
- 0:25Conclusion of Effective Animal Altruism. Vera
- 0:30has a PhD in philosophy from New York University
- 0:34and served for a few years as assistant professor
- 0:38at Indiana University. She's now the founder
- 0:41of Food Systems Stewards, which helps provide
- 0:44fundraising support to animal rights nonprofits.
- 0:49Links to connect with Vera in the episode's notes.
- 0:52You really are in for a treat. We talked about
- 0:56really deep, thought -provoking topics, like
- 1:00the tension between animal warfare and abolitionism,
- 1:04why you should or should never wish to switch
- 1:07place with an animal, or the reception Vera received
- 1:11from the effective altruism community when publishing
- 1:15her paper. Follow and or subscribe to the show
- 1:20for more thought -provoking conversations, share
- 1:23this episode with the animal advocates you know
- 1:26and please leave a 5 -star review. As always,
- 1:31thank you so much for tuning in every week. Well,
- 1:48I read the title of your paper and I was just
- 1:51so intrigued the repugnant conclusion of effective
- 1:55animal altruism. We don't hear that word often,
- 1:59you know, repugnant. To get started, I would
- 2:04love if you could give a little history of the
- 2:07effective altruism movement and how it intersected
- 2:12with the animal protection movement. Oh, great
- 2:17question. Yeah. And I should flag that I'm not
- 2:23the main expert for that, actually. I'm sure
- 2:25there are many effective algorithms out there
- 2:27who could tell that story much more effectively
- 2:30than me, much better than me. But I can say what's
- 2:34relevant from my perspective. So effective algorithm
- 2:39really rose to prominence in approximately the
- 2:42last 10 to 15 years. So starting in like the
- 2:48early 2010s, like 2012, 13, 14, I think that's
- 2:51when they started to become really active. And
- 2:57yeah, the movement really was inspired by several
- 3:02and founded, initiated by several philosophers
- 3:06doing work in that area. We had pursuit philosophical
- 3:10ideas. And that for me, from the start, was very
- 3:16exciting. So I'm a philosopher by training. I
- 3:20did my PhD in philosophy at New York University.
- 3:24And so I overlapped with a lot of these people
- 3:26during my education, during my philosophy career.
- 3:29And I always found it really exciting how they
- 3:32really were trying to use philosophical ideas
- 3:34for the greater good, for making a real change
- 3:38in the world. And from the very beginning, there
- 3:45was a strong connection with animal advocacy.
- 3:51So the main connection really is through animal
- 3:55suffering. So let me give one more disclaimer.
- 4:02So effective altruism is both a social and a
- 4:06philosophical movement. That's how Wilma Caskell
- 4:08famously characterizes it in several places.
- 4:11And when you think about effective altruism as
- 4:13a social movement, it's incredibly diverse. I
- 4:15mean, there are so many people involved in the
- 4:18movement with very diverse backgrounds, very
- 4:20diverse ideas. They don't subscribe to like one
- 4:24uniform thesis. But then there's also effective
- 4:27altruism as a philosophical movement. that has
- 4:31a specific philosophical background that was
- 4:34initially motivated and brought on specific philosophical
- 4:37ideas. And so my engagement with the movement
- 4:41really was usually more through the philosophical
- 4:44lens and through the philosophical basis of the
- 4:46movement. And so seen from that lens, effective
- 4:52altruism has a very strong connection with utilitarianism,
- 4:55where utilitarians think that your actions are
- 4:59right or wrong depending on their consequences,
- 5:04depending on how much utility you produce through
- 5:08your actions. And if you have a choice between
- 5:10two actions, A or B, you should always choose
- 5:14the action that creates more utility. And if
- 5:16you don't, you are actually doing something wrong.
- 5:18It's wrong to not maximize utility. So that's
- 5:21the basic utilitarian framework. And effective
- 5:25altruists. used that, but also changed it in
- 5:29certain ways. So they interpreted utility in
- 5:33a very specific way. From their perspective,
- 5:35utility is welfare. Meaning, if you have a choice
- 5:41between two actions, the action that produces
- 5:44more welfare is the better action. And then they
- 5:47also soften to utilitarianism in certain ways.
- 5:51So utilitarianism as a moral view, as a normative
- 5:54theory, is actually very stringent and put those
- 5:59like very strong moral requirements on agents.
- 6:02Like the view is you're doing something wrong
- 6:04when you're not maximizing utility. And most
- 6:07of us are not maximizing utility, like in almost
- 6:10any aspect of our lives. So you know, you're
- 6:12to turn and entail that we are all doing morally
- 6:15wrong most of the time. So that's a very strong
- 6:18view. And so effective interests soften that.
- 6:21And they said like, no, we don't embrace this
- 6:23very strong moral theory. What we want to say
- 6:26is that if you want to do good in the world,
- 6:30then we are providing you a framework for figuring
- 6:33out how to do the most good. So it's kind of
- 6:36a conditional claim. It's not saying you're doing
- 6:38something wrong when you are not maximizing utility,
- 6:40but more like if you choose to want to maximize
- 6:43the good that you are doing, then we show you
- 6:46how to do that. And that then very quickly led
- 6:50into animal advocacy because of the enormous
- 6:53scale of suffering in today's factory farms.
- 6:59And that was both characterized or visible in
- 7:03the personal lives of early effective altruists.
- 7:07So many of them that I interacted with over the
- 7:10years were vegetarian or vegan or strongly leaning
- 7:14in that direction. And then it also was like
- 7:16quickly reflected in the initiatives that Maya
- 7:21started to create. And so I'm sure I'm not going
- 7:25to get the dates exactly right now off the cuff,
- 7:28but it's in my article if you want to look it
- 7:30up. So there was an early initiative specifically
- 7:34focused on animal welfare and that then over
- 7:38time or a relatively short period of time morphed
- 7:41into what is now known as ACE, Animal Charity
- 7:43Evaluators. So an initiative that that evaluates
- 7:50other non -profit organizations according to
- 7:55their effectiveness. There's a lot more that
- 7:58I could say, but I feel like I've already said
- 8:02quite a lot. So let me pause and see where the
- 8:05next question will guide us. Well, I was thinking
- 8:10about the trolley problem and how to bring this
- 8:14home, you know, the definition of effective altruism.
- 8:19And I guess the trolley problem is a perfect
- 8:21way to illustrate what effective altruism is
- 8:24all about. So I guess an effective altruist will
- 8:28go with the road with the less people, you know,
- 8:33on the railway. So that would be obvious for
- 8:36an effective altruist. Yeah, yeah, nice illustration.
- 8:41So The trolley problem, roughly, is the problem.
- 8:44Imagine there is a runaway train, a runaway trolley,
- 8:48and it is set to run over five people that are
- 8:51sitting or standing on a track. And you have
- 8:55a choice. You can flip a switch. And if you flip
- 8:59the switch, then the trolley gets redirected
- 9:02to a different track that has only one person
- 9:04on it. So whichever way you go, someone is going
- 9:08to die. The question is, is it going to be five
- 9:10people, or is it going to be one person? And
- 9:14then there's also a big question about your involvement.
- 9:18So if you flip the switch, then in a way, you
- 9:21caused the death of the one person. Whereas if
- 9:24you didn't or don't flip the switch, you were
- 9:27not causally involved in causing the death of
- 9:29the five people. And so for effective altruists
- 9:33or consequentialists more generally, the question
- 9:35is very clear. They don't care about my culpability
- 9:41or your causal involvement in it. For them, the
- 9:45main question about what you ought to do really
- 9:46boils down to what are the better consequences
- 9:49here. And so they would say, well, one person
- 9:52dying definitely is better than five people dying.
- 9:55So you should flip the switch and redirect the
- 9:58train so that it kills only one person. You mentioned
- 10:03animal charity evaluators, and they have now
- 10:07such a big place in the animal protection movement,
- 10:11and it happened only recently. Relatively speaking,
- 10:16I welcomed them on my show and they presented
- 10:18their top 10 charities, recommended charities.
- 10:22And then I went through that list interviewing
- 10:25leaders from every one of those charities. interviewed,
- 10:30I think five out of the 10 recommended charities
- 10:34on the list. Looking forward to interviewing
- 10:37the rest. But yeah, please tell us more about
- 10:42the place that animal charity evaluators has
- 10:45taken in the animal protection space. Yeah. Yeah.
- 10:52Let me first say also that I have enormous respect
- 10:55for the work that animal charity evaluators is
- 10:57doing. I think all the critical doubtful thoughts
- 11:06that I have about the philosophical basis of
- 11:10effective altruism are compatible with an enormous
- 11:14amount of respect and appreciation for the really
- 11:17vital and important work that these people are
- 11:19doing, that effective altruists are doing in
- 11:23the space and that animal charity evaluators
- 11:25in particular is doing. So yeah, animal charity
- 11:30evaluators entered the scene as kind of the gift
- 11:35well of the animal space. So the thought was
- 11:41that they wanted to give donors reliable guidance
- 11:46on where their dollars would do the most good.
- 11:52Similar to how gift well is doing that for charities
- 11:55across the board, but just restricted to the
- 11:58animal advocacy space. And I think one plausible
- 12:05condition to that is that it would also motivate
- 12:09donors to give more. So I would ask that question
- 12:15Steen or other people at ACE directly since I'm
- 12:19sure they could describe it better. But looking
- 12:21at it from the outside, a very plausible outcome
- 12:23of what they are doing is not simply to redirect
- 12:27funds that are anyways going into the movement,
- 12:29but to overall increase donor confidence in the
- 12:33effectiveness and the value of the work that
- 12:36animal advocacy charities are doing. So that's
- 12:41how I would characterize the role of ACE. A few
- 12:49years ago, they had a very specific philosophical
- 12:52framing on their website that they publicly descended
- 12:55where they said, our goal is to maximize net
- 13:00aggregate wealth here. I'm actually not sure
- 13:06whether that is universally embraced by people
- 13:09working at ACE. I doubt it, since that's a diverse
- 13:13group of people. And they also have since then
- 13:16taken that specific framing down from their website.
- 13:20So there's definitely been some distancing and
- 13:23some moving away from this very specific framing.
- 13:27But this framing that Ace put forward actually
- 13:32was a core aspect of what motivated me to write
- 13:36my article, The Repugnant Conclusion of Effective
- 13:38Animal Algorithm, since it very directly criticizes
- 13:43this. feel us that we ought to maximize net aggregate
- 13:47wealth here. And ACE, you know, we focused on
- 13:53ACE right now, but there are so many other animal
- 13:57protection funders and nonprofits that are totally
- 14:01aligned with effective altruism. name a couple
- 14:05of them in your paper, the Animal Welfare Observatory,
- 14:09we had Louis, the CEO of that organization on
- 14:13the show, the Humane League, we had also the
- 14:17CEO of the Humane League on the show, you mentioned
- 14:20in the Thunder Lane coefficient giving, which
- 14:24is, I think the biggest donor in the space of
- 14:28animal protection, also very much aligned with
- 14:32animal effective altruism values and philosophy.
- 14:36So this philosophy is truly shaping the way we
- 14:41are leading this movement. It's truly stunning.
- 14:45And again, it has happened in a matter of a few
- 14:50years. And because of that, I think because of
- 14:54the recency of of all of this, there is still
- 14:58friction. There are still vegans out there calling
- 15:01themselves abolitionist, calling themselves whatever,
- 15:04who are not very sympathetic to the ideas of
- 15:08effective altruism. What do you make of them?
- 15:15People sometimes tend to think in like a broad
- 15:20kind of dichotomy where they think you can either
- 15:24work towards eliminating animal agriculture,
- 15:28eliminating factory farms, or alternatively,
- 15:33you can work towards increasing welfare standards
- 15:35in factory farms. So that's kind of a common
- 15:39fork in the road that many people see. And if
- 15:45you think of it, if you think of animal advocacy
- 15:48in terms of this dichotomy, in terms of this
- 15:50fork in the road, then effective altruists are
- 15:53very clearly on the side of wanting to increase
- 15:58welfare within factory farms. So they are very
- 16:00clearly positioned as people who don't oppose
- 16:03factory farms themselves but aim to increase
- 16:06welfare standards within those facilities. So
- 16:14many of them have become famous and have been
- 16:16very, very successful. For example, at implementing
- 16:20cage -free campaigns that convince corporations,
- 16:24say, to source only cat cage -free acts and so
- 16:27on, where a cage -free poultry system still is
- 16:30a factory farming system. It doesn't move away
- 16:36from factory farming even though it implements
- 16:38higher welfare standards. Now, I think this kind
- 16:43of fork where you think you need to choose and
- 16:45either do the one or the other, I think that's
- 16:47a somewhat short -sighted way of looking at it.
- 16:52And the reason is because people with a common
- 16:55goal, people wanting to reduce the suffering
- 16:58of animals, can go either one of these two directions
- 17:04based on different views on tractability, on
- 17:10the probability of success, say. So if you think,
- 17:15for example, that it's highly unlikely that we
- 17:19will end factory farming. And you also have the
- 17:22goal to reduce suffering. Then it makes a lot
- 17:27of sense to want to increase welfare standards
- 17:30in those factory farms. However, if you think
- 17:35that it is absolutely in our capacity to end
- 17:38factory farming, and you also want to reduce
- 17:41suffering of animals, then that's where your
- 17:45efforts would go, you know, you wouldn't work
- 17:47towards higher welfare standards. You would want
- 17:50to work towards eliminating these facilities
- 17:53once and for all. So what I'm trying to say is
- 17:57advocates with a common goal, advocates wanting
- 17:59to reduce suffering can end on different sides
- 18:06of this fork simply based on their views about
- 18:10tractability and chances of success with regards
- 18:12to ending factory farming. And furthermore, I
- 18:18believe that if we are honest, if we pay careful
- 18:25attention to our evidence, then none of us can
- 18:29be certain on this. None of us can be certain
- 18:33how likely it is that we are going to be ending
- 18:37factory farming. So we are all engaging in a
- 18:40bit of guesswork here. We are all engaging in
- 18:43a bit of following your instincts, following
- 18:45your basic impulses, your gut. And that then
- 18:52gives me a lot of respect and also a lot of humility
- 19:00with regards to people who end up on the other
- 19:04side of that fork, who end up with different
- 19:07views about tractability and for that reason
- 19:09end up on a different answer to the like abolitionism
- 19:13versus welfareism debate. Yeah. That's really
- 19:20interesting and a great way of presenting this
- 19:23tension in the movement. You know, the first
- 19:26time that this came on my radar was through a
- 19:32conversation with I think his name is Jacob.
- 19:35You might know him, he's an attorney working
- 19:39for Animal Outlook and he published a paper talking
- 19:44about how animal welfareism and abolitionism
- 19:49could in many ways be compatible or work in synergy
- 19:56with each other to end factory farming, which
- 19:59is a goal that even the staunchest animal welfareist
- 20:04I think would would accept as a success. And,
- 20:10and yeah, one argument that he presented was,
- 20:15well, in implementing animal welfare reforms,
- 20:19you are eating away from the profit margins of
- 20:24big corporations that have to spend more money
- 20:27on heating space for laying hands, for example.
- 20:33And so that costs Money and even when I talked
- 20:37with I think Dan Shan and CEO of the Humane League
- 20:42he said we're aware of that and We do desire
- 20:47an outcome where there is no more factory farming
- 20:51and we do think that by implementing cage -free
- 20:54policies we are also eating away from the profit
- 20:59margins of big corporations and it's Maybe at
- 21:03the end what will work is a like a debt by a
- 21:06thousand cuts with all of those well first reforms
- 21:10Yeah, I think that that probably resonates with
- 21:15me that makes that makes a lot of sense to me
- 21:18I'm not sure exactly How much welfare reforms
- 21:23really cut into profit margins? I think that
- 21:26depends on a number of factors. So sometimes
- 21:30subsidies just make up for any difference in
- 21:34profit revenues. And other times, farmers can
- 21:39just command higher prices for higher welfare
- 21:41products. Yeah, I mean, I have very direct experience
- 21:46with this. I actually have hawk farmers in my
- 21:49extended family. My sisters -in -law are hawk
- 21:53farmers. And they shifted to a higher welfare
- 21:56system. And they did that. absolutely incentivized
- 22:00and motivated by financial consideration. So
- 22:04they got government, it wasn't Germany, not in
- 22:06the United States, that they got government subsidies
- 22:09for doing that. And then they were also able
- 22:11to command higher prices. And so just made financial
- 22:14sense for them to do it. That's really interesting.
- 22:21Yeah, I mean, that's why we need to have those
- 22:23conversations, like internally. And that's why
- 22:27I command your paper, because you are critical
- 22:31of this effective altruism philosophy without
- 22:36altruism dismissing it. But by examining it,
- 22:40examining it and engaging with it with a high
- 22:44level of understanding. So what is this repugnant
- 22:48conclusion that you came to? Yeah, great. So
- 22:57where to start? The Repugnant conclusion is actually
- 23:00a very famous and old argument in philosophy.
- 23:05And it targets utilitarian population ethics.
- 23:09So it targets any view according to which a population
- 23:13with higher welfare is better than a population
- 23:16with lower welfare. And the basic argument is
- 23:22that for any population with a relatively small
- 23:30number of individuals with relatively high welfare,
- 23:35there is another possible much larger population
- 23:39of individuals whose individual welfare is much
- 23:45lower, but whose net aggregate welfare is higher.
- 23:50And so if you think that net aggregate welfare
- 23:53is what makes for the goodness of a population
- 23:56or what makes one population better than another,
- 23:58then you are forced to say that this latter population,
- 24:01the large population with individual nodes, each
- 24:04of which are worse off, is better than the first
- 24:07population of individuals, each of which is better
- 24:11off. And that in itself seems seems like the
- 24:17wrong conclusion. It seems like the wrong axiology
- 24:19or the wrong ordering of possible populations.
- 24:23Most people, myself included, have the intuition
- 24:25that a small population with a small number of
- 24:30individuals that are all very well off is much
- 24:32better than a very large population of individuals
- 24:35that are much worse off. So that's the basic
- 24:40philosophical argument. It's originally due to
- 24:44Derek Passage, one of the, if not the most influential
- 24:49and important moral philosopher, maybe ever.
- 24:54And it has made big waves. I mean, there are
- 24:58hundreds of papers written on this. It's a famous
- 25:02influential argument. And so what I did in my
- 25:06article is actually just pointing out the consequences
- 25:10of this argument for animal advocacy, where I
- 25:16point out that if you think our goal as animal
- 25:19advocates is to maximize net aggregate welfare,
- 25:24then that entails that we would consider a large
- 25:28population of, say, chickens with relatively
- 25:33low welfare better than a small population of
- 25:37blissful chickens provided that the net aggregate
- 25:41welfare of the large population is larger than
- 25:44the net aggregate welfare of the small population.
- 25:47And that seems like the wrong conclusion. And
- 25:50to make matters worse, if that's what's action
- 25:52guiding for us, so if we want to bring about
- 25:55and create the population with the higher net
- 26:00aggregate welfare, then that means we should
- 26:03actually take even the active steps for making
- 26:06this happen. And so that means we should actually
- 26:08build more factory farms as long as the individuals
- 26:12in these farms have net or have on average above
- 26:17zero or net positive welfare. And that's that
- 26:23to my mind is just a clearly wrong conclusion.
- 26:26I mean, the so the basic disagreement is with
- 26:29the axiology. So I just don't believe that a
- 26:32large population of of chickens that are not
- 26:36very well off but have net positive welfare is
- 26:39better than a small population of blissful chickens.
- 26:42So I don't agree with that basic axiology, but
- 26:45then the action guiding consequences that utilitarians
- 26:50and with them effective altruists are forced
- 26:52to draw from this sit even worse with me. I do
- 26:57not believe that we ought to build additional
- 27:00factory farms, even if the individuals in those
- 27:03farms have net positive welfare. And so the conclusion
- 27:10that I want to draw is that we need to reconsider
- 27:14the basic starting point. So we need to reconsider
- 27:16whether maximizing net aggregate welfare really
- 27:19is a plausible goal that we as animal advocates
- 27:23should pursue. Let me take a few step backs and
- 27:30talk about how to measure welfare in animal populations
- 27:35So you again you go through that in the article.
- 27:39I highly recommend people to read it But yeah,
- 27:44so how exactly do we determine what is good?
- 27:47What is bad in terms of welfare? Yeah I think
- 27:52this is a fast -moving field where many insights
- 27:55are still generated and where we have an incomplete
- 27:59picture. There are no final answers on this.
- 28:04I think the best, and to my knowledge, most detailed
- 28:08work in this area is due to the Welser Footprint
- 28:13Institute, Cynthia Chuck Payne and her team,
- 28:20yeah, published several studies, some of them
- 28:23book -length studies on the topic. And so their
- 28:27approach uses the so -called cumulative pain
- 28:30framework. And they focused on chickens in this
- 28:37research, though by now they may have expanded
- 28:39to other species. But they focused on layer hens
- 28:43and then also on broiler chickens and used the
- 28:46so -called cumulative pain framework. to measure
- 28:49the amount of pain that these chickens experience.
- 28:53And so the framework distinguishes between four
- 28:55different layers of pain. I think it was excruciating
- 29:00pain is the worst. Then there's disabling pain,
- 29:04I think. And then annoying is another level.
- 29:09I'm forgetting a fourth level now. But they're
- 29:11basically like four different layers of pain.
- 29:15Yes, I have it here, excruciating, disabling,
- 29:19hurtful and annoying. Yeah, great. Thank you
- 29:23so much. And then they had estimates about what
- 29:27the different kinds of conditions that chickens
- 29:29can experience, what level of pain they would
- 29:33cause. And this estimate is based on behavioral
- 29:38indicators. So for example, excruciating pain
- 29:41makes it impossible for the chicken to pursue
- 29:44any other interests, like their entire existence
- 29:48is focused on this pain that they are experiencing.
- 29:51They cannot pursue other joyful interests or
- 29:54activities while they are experiencing this pain.
- 29:57And so chickens can typically often undergo different
- 30:02types of injuries and illnesses in factory farms,
- 30:05for example, keel bone fractures. And then the
- 30:08Welfare Footprint Institute basically measured
- 30:11Like how often do these various illnesses and
- 30:15injuries happen? What level of pain do they typically
- 30:18generate? And then how much time do chickens
- 30:21on average spend in pain? And yeah, and the results
- 30:29are very sad. I think one of the biggest takeaways
- 30:35is that the that the switch from caged to cage
- 30:41-free systems for layer hands brings a huge relief
- 30:45in terms of reducing the amount of pain that
- 30:49birds experience. Yeah, I think that's the main
- 30:54takeaway. I think the research is still incomplete
- 30:57because, for example, we don't have research
- 30:59on joyful stage that these birds may also experience.
- 31:06So we know how much pain. We don't know how much
- 31:09actually enjoyable periods they also may undergo.
- 31:14And that just was a limit to then calculating
- 31:17net aggregate welfare. If you want to calculate
- 31:19net aggregate welfare, you somehow need to weigh
- 31:21pain against pleasure or painful states against
- 31:24joyful states. And we just don't have data on
- 31:28the joyful part of this equation. So we actually
- 31:30don't really have a handle on the net aggregate
- 31:33welfare calculation. Yeah, I mean, there's this
- 31:38tendency of focusing on, you know, eliminating
- 31:43sources of pain and eliminating pain as a welfarist
- 31:47approach instead of maximizing joy, which is,
- 31:52you know, it reminds me of Epicurus, the Greek
- 31:56philosopher. I read the few lines that are still
- 32:02with us that he wrote and taught. And in there,
- 32:06that's what he promotes, basically, that a good
- 32:10life pleasurable life is not necessarily a life
- 32:13where we invest in our joys, but a life where
- 32:18we limit our pains. Now, I take that for the
- 32:23modern mind doesn't doesn't sound very appealing.
- 32:29But how do you explain this tendency we have
- 32:32of focusing on limiting the pain of the animals
- 32:36instead of maximizing their joy factor or pleasure
- 32:40factor. We always talk about eliminating causes
- 32:47of suffering and not so much talking about how
- 32:50to make their life and what that would entail.
- 32:55Maybe it's because of a lack of understanding
- 32:58of the animals. fascinating conversation I've
- 33:03had with many sanctuary owners is how we know
- 33:07so little about the animals that have been with
- 33:13humans since the dawn of time. Like one sanctuary
- 33:17owner of a fish sanctuary made the point that
- 33:21she had to learn a lot of things about taking
- 33:25care of a fish through experience and exchanging
- 33:29with other fish caretakers, because we don't
- 33:34have any real real studies about what makes a
- 33:39fish happy and how to maximize that. Mm hmm.
- 33:45Yeah. Yeah, that's fair. I mean, I think there
- 33:49were some initiatives in that direction, so -called
- 33:51enriched cages, I guess, were designed to provide
- 33:55animals with a greater source of enjoyment. And
- 33:59I believe the conclusion that advocates and ultimately
- 34:03also the industry drew was that we can increase
- 34:07welfare of chickens more by just eliminating
- 34:11cages rather than enriching the cages. Yeah.
- 34:18I mean, I think we as humans, I think we often
- 34:20in our own lives, we often tend to just focus
- 34:24on reducing our suffering rather than increasing
- 34:27our enjoyment. I mean, I think it often takes
- 34:31a little bit of mental effort, a little bit of
- 34:34a cognitive shift to encourage yourself to seek
- 34:38out joyful opportunities, pleasurable opportunities,
- 34:43things that are fun. Oftentimes, we are more
- 34:46focused on, oh, gee, how can I get out of this
- 34:48assignment that I don't want to do? You know,
- 34:51how can I make my foot stop to hurt? How can
- 34:54I get some food while I'm hungry? Like often
- 34:58we are just kind of dominated by trying to tap
- 35:02out all the flames of our little pieces of suffering
- 35:05here and there, you know, rather than rather
- 35:08than embracing the bigger picture and seeking
- 35:10out sources of joy. Let's go back to your paper.
- 35:16So Now that you have described the conclusion
- 35:20of this philosophy, what are the practical implications
- 35:24of that? So I think part of it goes back to actually
- 35:29earlier parts of our conversation. So I mean,
- 35:35I'm hoping that it will lead to a bit of a softening
- 35:37of the lines between welfarist and abolitionist
- 35:41approaches because My goal was to invite animal
- 35:48advocates to think about the philosophical foundations
- 35:51of their advocacy and to think about what they,
- 35:56what we really want to achieve by advocating
- 36:00for animals. And I hope that one thing that my
- 36:06paper makes clear is that maximizing that aggregate
- 36:09welfare in all likelihood is not a good goal.
- 36:12We need a different goal. And so what are these
- 36:16alternative goals? I think some of these other
- 36:21goals are able to provide for a much bigger tent,
- 36:26actually. So for example, if you have aimed to
- 36:29reduce suffering rather than maximizing that
- 36:32aggregate welfare, that is open to a broader
- 36:37spectrum of tactics and interventions. directed
- 36:42at achieving that goal. So K3 campaigns is one
- 36:48initiative that you could pursue in furtherance
- 36:53of this goal. But shutting down factory farms
- 36:57or eliminating and preventing new permits from
- 37:00being issued for factory farms actually is also
- 37:03a good initiative in furtherance of this goal,
- 37:07in furtherance of reducing suffering rather than
- 37:09maximizing that aggregate welfare. So that's
- 37:14one practical upshot. In short, I'm hoping that
- 37:20the argument will make people, make advocates
- 37:24critically question whether maximizing that aggregate
- 37:28welfare really is the goal that their advocacy
- 37:32stands for. Yeah. And what was the reception?
- 37:38to your paper because I saw you published the
- 37:41paper on the effective altruism forum. I tried
- 37:45not to look at the comments before this conversation,
- 37:50just not to get to be biased. But what was the
- 37:54reception to your paper? Yeah, great question.
- 38:01Yeah, I mean, I think there were a number of
- 38:03really good conversations that I really appreciated.
- 38:07So I really enjoyed all the conversations that
- 38:10came out of this paper. I will say I regret somewhat
- 38:16the choice of the title, The Repugnant Contribution
- 38:19of Not -Effective Animal Adversance. It refers
- 38:23to this very well -known philosophical argument,
- 38:25and so the title is very effective at positioning
- 38:27my paper in this philosophical tradition as responding
- 38:30to this literature. But it is also quite polarizing,
- 38:34and I think it puts some effective altruists
- 38:36on the defensive. I think some of them had a
- 38:40quite defensive reaction. And that wasn't my
- 38:43goal. I didn't want to put people on the defensive.
- 38:48I wanted to invite conversation and reflection.
- 38:51So I think in that regard, the choice of title
- 38:53was maybe a little counterproductive. Yeah, what
- 38:59was the reception like? I mean, I think the one
- 39:02big strand of discussion focused on whether animals
- 39:08and factory farms ever have net positive welfare
- 39:13because that's really what the argument turns
- 39:17on. So the argument says that if our goal is
- 39:22to maximize net aggregate wealth, we need to
- 39:24figure out what system makes for minimally positive
- 39:27welfare and then the more systems of that kind
- 39:31to maximize the product of the number of animals
- 39:34in those systems and the average welfare of those
- 39:37animals. And so some people responded by saying,
- 39:41well, but animals and factory farms never have
- 39:44net positive welfare. They always have net negative
- 39:48welfare. And that kind of that raises a whole
- 39:52host of issues, a whole host of questions. So
- 40:00I think for effective altruists, their view on
- 40:04what makes for net positive welfare should be
- 40:08constrained by empirical evidence and logical
- 40:13reasoning as much as possible, because that's
- 40:15what the movement stands for. They say, we use
- 40:18evidence and reason to figure out what to do.
- 40:21So it wouldn't serve them and their agenda well
- 40:24to just say, well, we have an intuition that
- 40:26this is not that this is net negative welfare
- 40:29that would very much run against the spirit of
- 40:32effective altruism. So they are really required
- 40:35to come up with a very empirically grounded and
- 40:41well -reasoned explanation of what kind of system
- 40:44would make for net positive welfare. And so I
- 40:49think as I earlier pointed to the best empirical
- 40:53evidence that we have in that area. At this point
- 40:56is the evidence developed by the WellSafe Footprint
- 40:59Institute. And my reading of this research really
- 41:05is that we do not have evidence that the lives
- 41:10of chickens in cage -free factory farms would
- 41:14make for net negative welfare. So my reading
- 41:17of this research really is that these chickens,
- 41:19for all we know, may have net positive welfare.
- 41:22And that is not in contradiction of the fact
- 41:26that they experience a lot of pain. I mean, they
- 41:28do. They endure hours and hours of pain. However,
- 41:35they also have opportunities for enjoyment. They
- 41:38also have opportunities to scratch, for example,
- 41:40to move around, to spread their wings and so
- 41:42on. And so overall, the balance of evidence in
- 41:46my reading doesn't show that these birds necessarily
- 41:51have nice with net negative welfare. It's not
- 41:57conclusively answered. More research in this
- 41:59area could make more progress to what's actually
- 42:02answering the question, what kind of system would
- 42:05make for net positive welfare. But overall, this
- 42:11whole strand of argument also doesn't question
- 42:14my main conclusion, actually. So it calls into
- 42:18question what type of poultry system, say, would
- 42:25make for the highest product of the number of
- 42:32animals and their average welfare. But it doesn't
- 42:35really put into question the main conclusion
- 42:37of the paper, which was that whichever system
- 42:40that is, we should build more of those facilities.
- 42:44So yeah, it was a really interesting discussion
- 42:46that raised many questions and was very animating.
- 42:49And at the same time, it didn't really cast the
- 42:51doubt on the main conclusion of the article,
- 42:54to my mind. And then there was a second strand
- 43:00of response where people wanted to diverge to
- 43:05nearby views, like we want to minimize suffering.
- 43:11And that, again, I understand the impulse, but
- 43:18it also raises many questions for me because
- 43:23suffering is an inevitable fact of life. We all
- 43:27suffer. And if you want to minimize suffering,
- 43:31that means we ought to eliminate all sentient
- 43:34life. And that again is not a conclusion that
- 43:39I find plausible, that I could stand behind.
- 43:47So those were the two main strands of response.
- 43:52There were a few less productive discussions
- 43:54about, I don't know, some... some issues here
- 43:58and there, but those were the two main and most
- 44:00productive lines of argument I think that developed
- 44:03from the article. Such tricky business to talk
- 44:08about. And yeah, this might be a bit controversial,
- 44:14but from my perspective, when I look at the chicken,
- 44:18even a happy chicken, for me as a human, this
- 44:24looks like suffering. I would not want to trade
- 44:27place with that chicken. I hear some animal activists
- 44:30say sometimes I wish I was an animal. I don't,
- 44:33I don't wish to exchange my cognitive abilities
- 44:37as a human. My, the way I relate to the world
- 44:40through my senses and all of the advantages of
- 44:44being a human being. Um, it's an enjoyable life
- 44:47with that of a, of an animal, uh, even a happy
- 44:51animal. Um, although there are I'm sure some
- 44:56humans that are living some horrible lives that
- 44:59might not agree with me. Um, but yeah, there's
- 45:04an existential aspect to that, that for me, this
- 45:08life is, is more happier than the life of, um,
- 45:13any kind of animal. And there's a basis of suffering
- 45:16to being a chicken or a horse or whatever animal
- 45:22you can name that is not human. At the same time,
- 45:27maybe there's there's some alien species out
- 45:30there who are much smarter and have evolved into
- 45:35I don't know what higher consciousness and look
- 45:39at humans the way we look at chickens and think
- 45:42I would never trade place with a human. I mean,
- 45:46this looks like like a terrible existence. What
- 45:49I find fascinating is that people have such different
- 45:52intuitions about this, about the kinds of lives
- 45:55that they would consider worth living. Really,
- 46:01when you talk to people, we are all over the
- 46:05spectrum on that. I mean, I personally am actually,
- 46:08I think, on the opposite end of the spectrum
- 46:09from you. I think I would be excited to explore
- 46:12basically any kind of life. Like, yeah, let me
- 46:16be an earthworm and see what that's like. I think
- 46:19that would be very interesting. And then I know
- 46:23that there are other people like you who are
- 46:25like, no way, no way. And then even, I mean,
- 46:31there are antinatalists who think that Existence
- 46:37itself is a problem and shouldn't be inflicted
- 46:41on anyone. So yeah, I don't have any conclusions
- 46:46to draw here except for the just appreciation
- 46:50on the fact that people are so all over the spectrum
- 46:53on the question of what kind of life they consider
- 46:56worth living. Yes, definitely. That resonates
- 47:00with with me because I'm a Buddhist and that's
- 47:04like a core precept of Buddhism. Life is suffering,
- 47:07life itself, whatever life it is, there's so
- 47:11much truth in that. When deciding what is the
- 47:22level of suffering that a chicken goes through
- 47:25and you talk about it in your text, You talk
- 47:30about the hours that the chicken spends in pain
- 47:34versus the hours where it's okay. But do the
- 47:38people that are thinking full time about this,
- 47:42and I'm not immersed in that world like you are,
- 47:45are they thinking about the fact that their life
- 47:50arrives at an end precociously? And that there
- 47:55are there are hundreds of hours, thousands of
- 47:58hours that those chickens don't get to live.
- 48:00How do you classify those those hours that have
- 48:06not been lived? Is that can we value that as
- 48:11suffering? Oh, interesting. Interesting. Yeah,
- 48:17I mean, A sector of altruists would look at it
- 48:21and consider, well, with these additional hours,
- 48:24would they have brought more pain or would they
- 48:27have brought more enjoyable states? And then
- 48:32so it's all about the balance between pleasure
- 48:35and pain. And that really then answers the question
- 48:41of whether we did something wrong by cutting
- 48:43their lives short. If we shifted the balance
- 48:48of net aggregate welfare downward, then we did
- 48:50something wrong by cutting the lives short. I
- 48:52mean, there are different approaches to think
- 48:55about this as well. I mean, you might think that
- 48:57animals have rights, that they have a right to
- 49:02not have their lives cut short. And so from that
- 49:11perspective, the questions about their welfare
- 49:15and how net aggregate welfare is shifted by in
- 49:18virtue of killing them is irrelevant. I mean,
- 49:21you would wrong them if you kill them. Yeah,
- 49:26so that's an alternative perspective to take
- 49:29on that. Interesting. Do you think you'll be
- 49:35successful at making the effective altruist crowd
- 49:41more flexible in their openness to other ideas
- 49:45in the world of advocacy? Oh, yeah, great question.
- 49:51I would actually absolutely love to hear from
- 49:53effective altruists on that question, whether
- 49:55they feel like it made them feel more more open.
- 49:59I mean, I think some of the conversations I had
- 50:00were very promising and very interesting, so
- 50:03I'm feeling optimistic. I should also say that
- 50:09I think in philosophy as elsewhere in life, I
- 50:14think it's always more interesting and more productive
- 50:18to actually stand for something than to position
- 50:22yourself as being against something. So that's
- 50:26a second misgiving that I have about my paper.
- 50:28I sketch an alternative view like in the very
- 50:31end of the paper. But overall, the paper is very
- 50:35much like arguing against a view rather than
- 50:38developing a new view. And so what I want to
- 50:41do in my future work really is to lean more in
- 50:44the positive work and lean more into like positively
- 50:48developing an alternative framework. Yeah, because
- 50:53I think that's that's ultimately more productive
- 50:55and also more interesting for for me as a philosopher.
- 51:01So you are in looking for new ideas to, you know,
- 51:06feed your worldview right now. Oh, I always have
- 51:10I always have more than enough ideas. And more
- 51:14looking for the time. Yeah, the time and the
- 51:19mental composer, I guess, or the inner piece
- 51:22for actually putting these ideas to paper. Amazing.
- 51:28Okay, I guess my last question for you, Vera,
- 51:32is are there any organizations, and feel free
- 51:37to say I don't want to answer that question,
- 51:40but are there any organizations out there that
- 51:43you feel are truly effective in the way they
- 51:49approach animal advocacy. Oh, great. Great question.
- 51:55I mean, it goes to the heart of what we mean
- 51:56by effective. So let me actually say some words
- 52:01about that, even if it doesn't quite answer your
- 52:04question. So one misgiving that I have about
- 52:09effective altruism is just the choice of the
- 52:11name effective altruism because it casts everybody
- 52:15who is not part of the camp as ineffective. So
- 52:20the basic framing is we are effective, other
- 52:22people are not effective. Where I think the reality
- 52:26is that reasonable people can have very different
- 52:31views on effectiveness. And so rather than casting
- 52:35effectiveness that's effective and other people
- 52:38as non -effective, I think the better framing
- 52:40would be that they stand for a particular type
- 52:43of effectiveness and other organizations may
- 52:46pursue other forms of, yeah, other forms of effective
- 52:50work. Yeah, I think, I mean, there are so many
- 52:56incredible organizations out there doing very
- 52:59valuable work. Yeah, I think I'm, yeah. You can
- 53:05mention your own, that's okay. Oh, my mind actually
- 53:09wasn't going there, no. I mean, yes, I'm a fan
- 53:13of my own organization, but let me speak about
- 53:17other organizations. I mean, I'm a huge fan of
- 53:20the work that New Roots Institute does, for example,
- 53:23because I think they do really admirable work,
- 53:27I think, in terms of leadership development,
- 53:30in terms of cultivating the kind of virtues and
- 53:39the kind of mindsets and communication techniques
- 53:42that make us successful advocates in whatever
- 53:47role we may pursue later. So I think that is
- 53:52a very impactful approach. because I think it
- 54:01goes at some of the root causes or some of the
- 54:04root mechanisms that is holding us back as a
- 54:07movement, which are, for example, ineffective
- 54:10communication strategies and unnecessarily antagonizing
- 54:16campaigns and things like that. a huge fan of
- 54:26different initiatives for bringing advocates
- 54:29into high impact positions. I think animal advocacy
- 54:34careers is doing really promising work in that
- 54:36area in placing people in impactful positions,
- 54:40not just in the nonprofit sector, but also in
- 54:43the for -profit sector. I think food policy pathways
- 54:49under Rachel Atchison also does really important
- 54:54and promising work in that direction. I'm really
- 54:57inspired by the work that Taylor Quinn is doing
- 55:00with Taylor Foods, where his long -term goal
- 55:05is to shift development funding away from being
- 55:10invested into factory farms and towards being
- 55:12invested in plant -based food systems. Yeah,
- 55:17I mean, I should flag that these are also all
- 55:19organizations that I have collaborated with or
- 55:21am collaborating with in one way or another.
- 55:24So I feel like the list would probably go on.
- 55:33There are many, many very interesting, impactful
- 55:36and inspiring organizations out there. Yeah,
- 55:40you practice what you preach. You admire them.
- 55:44And so of course you want to collaborate and
- 55:46offer your time and expertise to advance their
- 55:50mission. So yes, it's available. Wonderful Vera.
- 55:55So did you have anything more to add before we
- 55:58stop the conversation? Thank you. Thank you for
- 56:05your interest. Thank you for this conversation.
- 56:08I mean, I find it also fascinating how my own
- 56:13thinking is evolving and developing on these
- 56:15topics and issues. So for me, it's a very welcome
- 56:20occasion to further develop in my own thinking
- 56:24as well. So thank you for that. Well, thank you
- 56:28for thinking seriously and intelligently about
- 56:34this movement and the philosophies that we that
- 56:39guides us. Your paper was really clarifying for
- 56:44me, who is a bit new to this whole effective
- 56:49altruism philosophy. I discovered them through
- 56:54Sam Harris, his podcast, and since then I have
- 56:59been more and more hearing about them and how
- 57:05much they progressed as a social movement. Um,
- 57:09so yeah, this is, uh, very appreciated. Thank
- 57:12you so much. Thank you again. Thank you everyone
- 57:17for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 57:20podcast with the vegans, you know, let's encourage
- 57:23more people to take action again. Thank you so
- 57:27much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 57:30for a new episode.