Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Washington Saved The Japanese Yen
Transcript
- 0:00So in late July, there was this U.S.
- 0:04Treasury official Scott Besson, right?
- 0:06Yeah. And he was photographed walking
- 0:08into a meeting holding a notepad.
- 0:10Just a standard yellow legal pad.
- 0:12Yeah, exactly. But written on it like in plain
- 0:15sight of the cameras was this massive extremely specific To Do
- 0:19List item. It just said buy 50 to $100
- 0:22billion in Japanese yen. Which is, I mean, you just don't
- 0:27see that. No, you really don't.
- 0:29So today we're looking at the chain reaction that led to that
- 0:31moment. We're unpacking why a
- 0:32catastrophic 40 year collapse in the yen forced the US government
- 0:37to basically break a 15 year rule on market intervention.
- 0:40Dragon Europe and South Korea right into the crossfire along
- 0:43the way. Right, because that notepad
- 0:44image, it really captures the sheer panic behind the scenes.
- 0:47Oh. Absolutely.
- 0:48You don't see numbers like 50 to $100 billion scribbled casually
- 0:52like that unless standard operating procedures have just
- 0:56completely broken down because the US and institutions like the
- 0:59IMF, they have this long standing unwritten rule among G7
- 1:03nations. Right, to just let the free
- 1:04market dictate currency values. Exactly.
- 1:07Direct intervention is universally despised unless
- 1:12there is an existential threat to the broader financial system.
- 1:15And the last time the US felt that level of systemic threat
- 1:18regarding the yen was the Fukushima nuclear disaster back
- 1:21in 2011. Yeah, a literal generational
- 1:23catastrophe. Right.
- 1:25So for Washington to step in now ostensibly just to manage a
- 1:28currency fluctuation, it tells us the underlying mechanics of
- 1:31this market are flashing red. But real quick, before we get
- 1:36into those mechanics to access more advanced researches, follow
- 1:39Guru's latest movement and leverage our latest deep values
- 1:42agents. Welcome to download Deep Values
- 1:45app from App Store to track stock market temperature.
- 1:48Welcome to download iOS app Buffett Indicator from Apple App
- 1:51Store or Bubble Watch from Google Play links in the
- 1:54description. So getting back to it, for
- 1:56decades the yen was like the most predictable currency on the
- 1:59board. Right.
- 1:59Oh yeah, completely. If you look at the historical
- 2:01charts from our source material, the exchange rate moved in
- 2:04absolute lockstep with the interest rate gap between the US
- 2:07and Japan. Like a thermometer.
- 2:09Like a perfect thermometer, it was an entirely mechanical
- 2:11relationship. If the Fed raised rates to 5%
- 2:16and the Bank of Japan kept theirs at 0, the spread widened.
- 2:19Because capital naturally flows to where it gets the highest
- 2:22yield. Exactly.
- 2:23Investors would systematically sell yen and buy dollars.
- 2:26So the yen weakens, the dollar strengthens.
- 2:29The foreign exchange market just treated this interest rate
- 2:32spread as the ultimate unshakable source of truth.
- 2:36But the data shows that starting around June of last year, that
- 2:39correlation just divorced. Completely fell apart.
- 2:42Yeah, the interest rate spread kept doing its thing, but the
- 2:44yen detached and went into freefall.
- 2:46It hit 164 against the dollar. A 40 year low.
- 2:50Right, so the market stopped caring about the interest rate
- 2:53gap. What did they find to obsess
- 2:55over instead? Well, traders shifted their
- 2:57focus entirely to Japan's fiscal risk premium.
- 3:00OK. Fiscal risk.
- 3:01Yeah, specifically the bond market started zeroing in on the
- 3:05spread between Japan two year and 10 year government bond
- 3:08yields. They were no longer pricing in
- 3:11just the baseline interest rate. They were actively pricing in
- 3:14the risk of Japan's massive sovereign debt becoming
- 3:17unstable. Exactly.
- 3:18But wait, I have to challenge the logic there because Japan's
- 3:21debt to GDP ratio has been hovering around 250% for years.
- 3:26It's the highest in the developed world and the market
- 3:29has always just shrugged it off because the Bank of Japan buys
- 3:32its own debt and keeps borrowing costs pinned to the floor.
- 3:35Right, they've done it forever. So why would bond vigilantes
- 3:39suddenly wake up in 2024 and panic about a debt load they've
- 3:42happily ignored for a decade? Well, the catalyst was a drastic
- 3:46shift in the political winds in Tokyo.
- 3:48OK, it was spearheaded by Sanai Takaichi.
- 3:51She began aggressively pushing this policy framework.
- 3:54She called responsible active Fiscal policy.
- 3:57Which sounds very nice. That sounds great, sure, but it
- 4:00included a proposed ¥21 trillion stimulus package.
- 4:04Wow. Yeah, paired with significant
- 4:06structural tax cuts, including slashing the food consumption
- 4:10tax. Oh, I see.
- 4:11And in the old deflationary Japan, the market might have
- 4:13actually absorbed that kind of spending spree.
- 4:16Probably, yes. What?
- 4:18Takichi was demanding this massive fiscal expansion at the
- 4:21exact moment global inflation was surging.
- 4:24And central banks worldwide were scrambling to raise rates.
- 4:27Right, she was stomping on the gas pedal while the engine was
- 4:30overheating. Which just violates every modern
- 4:33macroeconomic playbook. Completely.
- 4:36The global capital markets looked at Takayechi's proposals
- 4:39and they recognize the exact same fiscal recklessness they
- 4:43saw in the UK back in 2022. The Liz Trust scenario.
- 4:47Exactly the Liz Trust scenario. Right where she proposed those
- 4:50massive unfunded tax cuts during a high inflation environment and
- 4:53the bond market just immediately called her bluff.
- 4:56They dumped British gilts, crashed the pound and forced her
- 4:59resignation in just 49 days. 49 days, yeah.
- 5:03Institutional memory is long and capital is ruthless, so
- 5:07investors anticipated a repeat of the UK disaster in Tokyo and
- 5:11they began aggressively shorting long term Japanese government
- 5:14bonds. And that immense dumping of
- 5:16bonds drove yields up and triggered a massive
- 5:18corresponding sell off of the yen.
- 5:20But the weird twist in the data here is what happened to the
- 5:23Japanese stock market. We see the yen plunging, bonds
- 5:27cratering, but the Nikki surges to record highs.
- 5:31Yeah, it sounds backward, doesn't it?
- 5:32It does, and Wall Street leaned into this divergent so hard they
- 5:36branded it the talkie trade. You know, sell Japanese bonds,
- 5:39sell the yen, buy Japanese stocks.
- 5:41But mechanically, how does a collapse in currency trigger a
- 5:45localized stock market boom? It comes down to the structural
- 5:48composition of the Japanese economy.
- 5:51The Nikkei is heavily dominated by massive multinational
- 5:54exporters. Like Toyota, Sony, Honda.
- 5:57Yeah, Mitsubishi, these conglomerates manufacture
- 6:00primarily in Japan, so they pay their labor and operational
- 6:02costs in week yen, but they sell their products globally,
- 6:06capturing revenue and strong U.S. dollars or euros.
- 6:09So when Toyota sells a fleet of vehicles in the US and
- 6:12repatriates those dollars back to Tokyo, the exchange rate acts
- 6:16like a massive profit multiplier.
- 6:18Precisely if the yen drops from 110 to 164 against the dollar,
- 6:22Toyota's revenue in yen skyrockets without them having
- 6:25to sell a single extra car. Wow, their balance sheet
- 6:29suddenly looks spectacular on paper.
- 6:31And global investors recognize that dynamic.
- 6:34They piled into the Nikkei to capture those inflated currency
- 6:37driven earnings. Which means that influx of
- 6:40foreign capital further accelerated the sell off of the
- 6:42currency to fund those stock purchases.
- 6:45Yep. Creating a self fulfilling
- 6:47feedback loop that drove the yen even lower which and to source
- 6:52those dollars they would be forced to liquidate their
- 6:54reserves. We are talking about dumping
- 6:57hundreds of billions of dollars of U.S.
- 6:59Treasuries onto the open market in a highly compressed time
- 7:02frame. Oh man, so it's like a friend
- 7:05needing cash and the only way they can get it is by selling
- 7:08shares in your business? Exactly.
- 7:10Which would tank your stock. Because flooding the market with
- 7:13U.S. Treasuries causes the price of
- 7:15those bonds to plummet. And the fundamental inverse rule
- 7:19of the bond market is that when prices fall, yields rise.
- 7:22Yep. Japan dumping our debt would
- 7:25cause the yield on the 10 year U.S.
- 7:27Treasury to spike violently. And the 10 year Treasury yield
- 7:30is basically the foundational metric for the entire U.S.
- 7:33economy, right? It is.
- 7:35It dictates 30 year mortgage rates, auto loans, corporate
- 7:38borrowing costs. The US Treasury and the Federal
- 7:41Reserve have spent the last two years executing A delicate high
- 7:44wire Act to keep those yields from spiraling out of control
- 7:48while fighting domestic inflation.
- 7:49So a massive uncoordinated Japanese sell off would have
- 7:53shattered that domestic stability.
- 7:55So you step in to help them just to protect your own net worth.
- 7:59Washington intervened to stop Japan from selling our own debt
- 8:02back to us. It was entirely defensive.
- 8:04Purely defensive. But the way they executed this
- 8:07trade is wild, and the collateral damage it caused
- 8:10across the Atlantic. So the New York Fed stepped in
- 8:13on behalf of the Treasury, using Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley
- 8:17as their prime brokers. But they didn't sell U.S.
- 8:21dollars to buy the yen. No, they sold euros.
- 8:24Which is so weird. If the goal is to supply Japan
- 8:27with the capital it needs and you're the United States, why
- 8:30are you dumping European currency to execute the trade?
- 8:33Well, direct intervention is a blunt instrument, and the US was
- 8:36trying to perform surgery here. OK, how so?
- 8:39If the Federal Reserve starts aggressively dumping U.S.
- 8:41Dollars onto the open market to buy yen.
- 8:44It sends a flashing signal to global investors that the US is
- 8:47actively trying to devalue its own currency.
- 8:49And that could easily trigger a broader panic sell off of the
- 8:52dollar across the board, like weakening it against everything,
- 8:55not just the yen, right? The Treasury wanted to inject
- 8:59liquidity and strengthen the yen, but they needed to preserve
- 9:02the prevailing narrative of dollar strength.
- 9:04So they achieved this by exploiting cross currency pairs.
- 9:08Exactly. In the forex market, algorithmic
- 9:10trading systems constantly balance currency pairs against
- 9:13each other. You don't just have to trade USD
- 9:16to JPY, you can trade EUR to JPY.
- 9:20So by dumping EUR and buying yen, they increase global demand
- 9:24for the yen, driving its value up globally without ever
- 9:27directly touching the dollar yen pair.
- 9:29Right. Mechanically, it achieves the
- 9:31exact goal of strengthening the yen against the broader basket
- 9:35of global currencies. And politically and
- 9:37psychologically, it allows the US to keep its hands seemingly
- 9:40clean regarding the dollar specific valuation.
- 9:43Exactly. Meanwhile, the euro takes the
- 9:45hit. Europe is just lying there,
- 9:46completely innocent, dealing with its own sluggish economic
- 9:49growth. And suddenly, only their
- 9:51currency is taking collateral damage from a covert maneuver
- 9:54designed by Washington to save Tokyo.
- 9:56It's kind of funny in a dark way, but it really highlights
- 9:59the brutal reality of modern financial plumbing liquidity
- 10:03moves where it is forced to move regardless of borders.
- 10:07And Europe wasn't the only regional player swept up in
- 10:10this. South Korea saw this massive
- 10:13sudden influx of capital from the US Japan partnership and
- 10:17strategically drafted off of it. Yeah, they hailed the rideshare,
- 10:20basically. Because the South Korean one had
- 10:22just had a 17 year low around the same time they are watching
- 10:27their own currency get decimated by short sellers.
- 10:30Then they see this massive financial leviathan, the
- 10:33combined weight of the Fed and the Bank of Japan slam into the
- 10:36market to crush the yen shorts. South Korea essentially jumps
- 10:40into the slipstream. The foreign exchange market
- 10:42relies heavily on momentum and sentiment.
- 10:45When the US and Japan intervened, it created a massive
- 10:48surge of volatility. Forcing a sudden unwinding of
- 10:50short positions across Asian currencies.
- 10:52Exactly. South Korea recognized that the
- 10:54short sellers were distracted and off balance, so they
- 10:57piggybacked on that exact moment to intervene in their own
- 11:00currency markets. Propping up the one at a
- 11:02fraction of the cost it would have taken if they were fighting
- 11:05the market alone. Yeah, he was very smart.
- 11:07So South Korea gets a cheap ride out of the crisis, but Japan was
- 11:11paying full price. I mean, even before Washington
- 11:14decided to step in and save the bond market.
- 11:16Tokyo is bleeding out trying to prop up the yen organically.
- 11:20Oh, the scale of their solo intervention is staggering.
- 11:23Between 2022 and early 2025, Japan spent roughly ¥25 trillion
- 11:30in open market operations. That's about 160 billion U.S.
- 11:34dollars just incinerated in the forex markets, yeah.
- 11:38And to contextualize that figure ¥25 trillion is roughly
- 11:42equivalent to 1/3 of the Japanese government's total
- 11:45annual tax revenue. Oh wow, 1/3.
- 11:47They were emptying the National Treasury just to slow the
- 11:50descent, and they were rapidly approaching a hard mathematical
- 11:53limit. Because they couldn't sustain
- 11:54that level of capital flight. No, which is what made phase of
- 11:57the US intervention so critical. Washington didn't just throw
- 12:00cash at the problem. They deployed a highly specific,
- 12:04heavily guarded structural loophole, the FEMA.
- 12:06Hack the Foreign and International Monetary
- 12:09Authority's repo facility. It sounds like an obscure
- 12:12accounting mechanism, but the sources frame it as arguably the
- 12:16most powerful lever the Federal Reserve has in the modern era.
- 12:19It really. Is it was forged in the fire of
- 12:22the early COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020.
- 12:25Global liquidity of evaporated overnight, right?
- 12:28Everyone was panicking and. Foreign central banks were on
- 12:31the verge of fire selling U.S. Treasuries just to get their
- 12:34hands on dollars to survive. So the.
- 12:36Fed realized that if they didn't create a pressure valve, the
- 12:39entire US bond market would collapse under the weight of
- 12:42foreign selling. Exactly.
- 12:44And they later deployed it aggressively during the collapse
- 12:46of Credit Suisse in 2023, swapping $60 billion to backstop
- 12:51the Swiss National Bank. So the.
- 12:53Mechanics of a repo facility. They fundamentally changed the
- 12:56rules of the game for Japan here because the traditional
- 12:59constraint is that if Japan needs dollars, they have to sell
- 13:02their treasury bonds to a buyer on the open market, depressing
- 13:05the asset price, right? But the FEMA facility acts like
- 13:08a what? Like an exclusive high end pawn
- 13:10shop run by the Federal Reserve, that is.
- 13:12A highly accurate way to visualize a repurchase
- 13:16agreement, OK. So Japan walks into the Fed,
- 13:20hands over a massive stack of U.S.
- 13:22Treasury bonds as collateral. The Fed locks those bonds in a
- 13:26vault and hands Japan billions of newly printed U.S. dollars in
- 13:30overnight cash. So Japan gets the immediate
- 13:33liquidity they desperately need to buy yen.
- 13:36And the US bond market remains entirely undisturbed because
- 13:39those Treasuries were never actually sold on the open
- 13:41market, right? And.
- 13:42Eventually, Japan just buys the bonds back.
- 13:45It allows immense volumes of sovereign wealth to be mobilized
- 13:48across borders without triggering the traditional
- 13:51supply and demand shocks. It's a.
- 13:52Brilliant piece of financial engineering it is, but the
- 13:55detail in the data that truly defines this entire crisis is
- 13:58that Japan didn't actually use the facility.
- 14:00No, they didn't. They never pulled the trigger.
- 14:02the US simply publicized the fact that the facility was
- 14:05available to Japan, and the Bank of Japan publicly confirmed they
- 14:08were prepared to use it. The mere threat.
- 14:10Of its deployment fundamentally altered the risk calculus for
- 14:13everyone betting against the yen because a.
- 14:15Short seller makes money by assuming a central bank will
- 14:18eventually run out of foreign reserves to defend its currency.
- 14:21Exactly. But the FEMA facility
- 14:23essentially gave Japan an infinite cheat code.
- 14:28You cannot successfully short a currency into the ground when
- 14:31the central bank defending it has a direct consequence free
- 14:35pipeline to the Federal Reserve's balance sheet.
- 14:37Wow. So it was pure psychological
- 14:40warfare. Psychology.
- 14:41The Market. Realized Japan didn't have to
- 14:43sell bonds to get dollars anymore, they could just pawn
- 14:46them at the Fed endlessly. And just the realization of that
- 14:50structural backstop caused the yen to spike nearly 4% in a
- 14:54single week completely. Crushing the short sellers
- 14:57without a single dollar. Changing hands the largest
- 14:59single week gain in years, achieved almost entirely through
- 15:02signaling and market psychology it's.
- 15:04Incredible. And you look at the US and Japan
- 15:07coordinating policy this aggressively utilizing secret
- 15:09notes, collateral currency trades and offshore repo
- 15:12facilities and it immediately begs the historical comparison
- 15:16the Plaza. Accord, right?
- 15:17Are we looking at a modern iteration of the Plaza Accord?
- 15:21But the sources suggest the structural realities of 1985
- 15:24clearly do not map to today's market.
- 15:27No, they. Don't.
- 15:27The optics are similar, yeah, major economic powers
- 15:30coordinating to manipulate exchange rates.
- 15:32But the motivations are entirely inverted because.
- 15:35In 1985, the US was the core of the problem.
- 15:38A super strong dollar was decimating American
- 15:40manufacturing and widening the trade deficit to unsustainable
- 15:44levels right it. Was in Washington's direct
- 15:47primary interest to force a global devaluation of the
- 15:50dollar, but. Today, the crisis originates
- 15:53with Japan's fiscal policy. Fixing the yen is a defensive
- 15:56side quest for the US. Exactly.
- 15:58The US is far more consumed with tariffs, AI, supply chains, and
- 16:02broader geopolitical tensions right now and the.
- 16:04Most profound difference highlighted in the sources is
- 16:07simply the scale of the battlefield.
- 16:09The foreign exchange market today is 40 times larger than it
- 16:12was during the Plaza Accord. It's.
- 16:13Massive. We are talking about over $7
- 16:16trillion changing hands every single day 7.
- 16:19Trillion a day. The source.
- 16:20Material uses an excellent analogy to capture this shift in
- 16:24scale. 40 years ago, the global financial market was effectively
- 16:28a small pond. OK, if the central banks wanted
- 16:31to change the water level, they could coordinate, build a small
- 16:35dam and exert complete control over the environment.
- 16:38But. Today, the market isn't a pond,
- 16:40no. Today it's the Yellow River.
- 16:42It is a raging, massive, uncontrollable force of
- 16:46aggregate global capital. So.
- 16:48Central banks, even institutions with the limitless balance
- 16:52sheets of the Fed and the Bank of Japan, simply cannot build a
- 16:56dam large enough to stop the flow.
- 16:58They can. Throw pebbles in the water.
- 16:59They can temporarily redirect a small tributary with a
- 17:02coordinated intervention or a FEMA threat, but they cannot
- 17:06overpower the current, so the. Only way to permanently alter
- 17:09the course of the river is to address the underlying
- 17:11topography exactly. Meaning Japan actually has to
- 17:14change its monetary policy, they have to raise interest rates
- 17:16significantly or abandoned Chuck E Cheese's aggressive fiscal
- 17:20expansion, everything. Else is just buying time just.
- 17:23Buying time. It's a stark realization in
- 17:26today's hyper connected world. The traditional macroeconomic
- 17:29indicators are breaking down. Even global superpowers are
- 17:33reduced to relying on psychological Bluffs and obscure
- 17:36repo facilities just to survive the currents of a market that
- 17:41has completely outgrown their control.
- 17:43The. Market has become the ultimate
- 17:45arbiter. Yeah, policy.
- 17:46Makers are no longer dictating terms, they are managing the
- 17:49fallout. Which leaves.
- 17:50Us with this thought, If central banks are now just throwing
- 17:53pebbles into a raging river and their ultimate weapon is a
- 17:57psychological bluff backed by a FEMA pawn shop, it makes you
- 18:00wonder what happens the day a massive financial shock actually
- 18:03forces their hand right. If the bluff gets called and
- 18:07they are forced to actually liquidate those treasuries into
- 18:09a panicked market, who absorbs that hit?
- 18:12Who actually has their hands on the steering wheel, that is.
- 18:14The ultimate question disclaimer.
- 18:16All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 18:19may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 18:22All contents from this channel is for research and
- 18:24entertainment purposes only and does not constitute any
- 18:27investment or financial advice or service.
- 18:30Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 18:32financial decisions.