Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Entertainment Contracts
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Nuts and Bolts of Entertainment Contracts.
- 0:09I'm Ola Poli Castro, CLE Advisor with the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:13Today, I'm happy to introduce the speakers of today's program, Neville Johnson and John
- 0:19Baldivia.
- 0:20Mr. Johnson is a distinguished entertainment and intellectual property attorney with over
- 0:25four decades of experience, having tried more than 28 jury trials, 70 non-jury trials, and
- 0:31many arbitrations.
- 0:32A member of ABOTA and a recognized super lawyer since 2006, he has been named one of Southern
- 0:38California's top 100 lawyers and honored as Hollywood Reporter's legal legend.
- 0:44Mr. Johnson has represented prominent celebrities and entertainment entities, specializing in
- 0:49net profit disputes, copyright infringement, privacy rights, and class action against
- 0:54major industry players.
- 0:56He is also an accomplished lecturer, writer, and adjunct professor, recognized for his
- 1:01precedent setting case, Sanders vs. ABC, which established workplace privacy rights.
- 1:08John Baldivia is partner at Rossi PC, specializing in negotiating contracts for major label
- 1:14artists, songwriters, and influencers with expertise in music transactions and entertainment
- 1:19litigation.
- 1:20Previously, he was a partner at Pierce Law Group, where he handled music and film contracts,
- 1:25copyright clearance, and complex litigation, securing six and seven figure judgments for
- 1:30his clients.
- 1:32Recognized as a super lawyer rising star in 2020 and 2021, John also spent a decade working
- 1:39in the music industry with major independent record labels.
- 1:43We can't wait to hear what they have to share with us today.
- 1:45And now over to you.
- 1:46Well, thank you and good morning, and we're very pleased to be here.
- 1:51We're going to be talking about stuff that you should all have on the tip of your tongue
- 1:55because there are commonplace issues that arise.
- 1:57And it's not just for entertainment, but generally in the business and life itself,
- 2:03overall, and things to think about.
- 2:05The first thing we're going to talk about is arbitration clauses.
- 2:09Every movie studio requires arbitration as to most of the major record companies and
- 2:15many other entertainment entities.
- 2:17The question is whether that's a good thing or not.
- 2:20I've done a number of indie films to fall under the IPTA International Film and Trade
- 2:28Association.
- 2:29The dispute might be over $150,000, and you might spend $40,000 on the arbitrator on top
- 2:35of which legal fees are building up.
- 2:38It doesn't necessarily pay.
- 2:41And so I'm suggesting to all of you, whether you're on the business side or not, to be
- 2:46thinking seriously about whether you want to engage in arbitration.
- 2:50People like arbitration because it's non-precedential and because it's confidential.
- 3:01And I'm not saying all arbitration is bad.
- 3:03I'm just saying the expense can be prohibitive overall.
- 3:08There is a...
- 3:09I'll give you an example.
- 3:10The LA has a requirement that if you have a claim for a million dollars, the filing
- 3:14fee is $7,700 and a later fee of $8,475.
- 3:19And then on top of that, you pay arbitrator hourly fees.
- 3:22So that may be prohibitive.
- 3:26There is authority that if a party cannot afford arbitration, the other side has to
- 3:32pay for it or it can go into the court system overall.
- 3:35And by the way, I've given you an eight-page memo that details the law on most of the stuff
- 3:42that we're going to be talking about and summarizes what we're doing.
- 3:48What jams, of course, everybody knows about.
- 3:50They're the grandfather, really, of the mediation dispute centers.
- 3:56Every single contract with majors, the studios, requires jams.
- 4:02And there is some thought that it suffers from repeat player bias.
- 4:11In other words, any arbitrator will be fearful of levying a major verdict against the studio.
- 4:20For fear he or she will not be hired again as an arbitrator or a mediator overall.
- 4:24There's a law review article written by Ron Nessum that I give you a site to that does
- 4:30an extensive analysis of this overall.
- 4:35One of the problems with arbitration is that you don't know the background of the arbitrator.
- 4:40So I want to know how is this arbitrator ruled in the past, even if I don't know the parties
- 4:45on, say, a net profits dispute, I'm not going to find out.
- 4:48Whereas in the Superior Court and the Federal Court, I can get a pretty good handle on where
- 4:51the judge is coming from.
- 4:53As I said before, I'm not against all arbitration.
- 4:57Life fee agreements provide for arbitration.
- 5:01I want arbitration in every agreement.
- 5:03Then I decided, well, wait a minute, if it's a small matter, it's under small claims court
- 5:10jurisdiction, I'll go small claims.
- 5:12If it's under $35,000, that's limited.
- 5:14I'm happy with limited.
- 5:15If it's under $150,000, I'll go with the Superior Court overall.
- 5:20What's the advantage of that?
- 5:21Well, I don't have business on the street necessarily.
- 5:24In B, it can also cover malpractice disputes, assuming one of those arises.
- 5:30A couple more things to be aware of regarding arbitration is that you might want to say
- 5:38if they're dogmatic and it's non-negotiable, and that's been my experience and I have done
- 5:44enough of these, including with majors, including on behalf of prominent people, where they just
- 5:48say it's too bad.
- 5:49That's the way it's going to go.
- 5:51No way.
- 5:52If you've got a client who's making $5 or $10 million, he or she doesn't care, really.
- 5:56It's not going to happen the years down the road, but it may happen.
- 6:01But document it and say, put something in the file, maybe it'll be useful later on to
- 6:06say, you told me this was non-negotiable overall.
- 6:11Also try and arrange.
- 6:12If you want to have arbitration, then how about we open it up to the field of whoever
- 6:17is out there, not just at jams, or how about we also require that the arbitrator, whether
- 6:23it be a retired judge or an entertainment attorney, that he or she be knowledgeable about entertainment
- 6:29matters.
- 6:30Now, arguably the most important thing I'm going to tell you today about arbitration
- 6:37is the AXTRON case, A-I-X-T-R-O-N, which came down in 2020.
- 6:44And that says, if you do not have in your agreement for arbitration the right to obtain
- 6:49third-party discovery, you will not get it.
- 6:52That could be fatal to the prosecution or defense of any case overall.
- 6:57And so you might want to be thinking about any of the clients you've had in the past
- 7:01who have arbitration agreements who before this law or this decision came down, said
- 7:07that there's arbitration.
- 7:08You might want to say, you know, you've got to revisit this and provide for third-party
- 7:12discovery.
- 7:14I'll say one more thing about arbitration is that, and I've seen this, I've seen a number
- 7:20of these reality shows which are extremely onerous and one-sided.
- 7:26And every single one of them says, you've got to go to mediation first.
- 7:31I am a great believer in early mediation as much as possible.
- 7:36Most cases settle as you know.
- 7:38A lot of times they can't be mediated or settled because enough information has not been obtained.
- 7:44But what's wrong with going to mediation, at least having a productive discussion about,
- 7:49well, what are the differences and what do we need to work out?
- 7:52I'm going to turn it over to John now, say something.
- 7:57I think my thoughts on the arbitration provision are really that oftentimes it becomes a, like
- 8:07a barrier for entry when it comes to dispute resolution, especially when you're talking
- 8:11about smaller contracts.
- 8:12Let's say you're talking about an influencer deal where at most the fee was like $1,000,
- 8:18$2,000.
- 8:20And for whatever reason, the influencer isn't paid or there's some kind of dispute with
- 8:23the agreement.
- 8:26Already you're talking about a barrier of entry for the influencer to come in and enforce
- 8:29the agreement when there's an arbitration provision.
- 8:31And a lot of times when you're talking about these influence agreements that have limited
- 8:37participation and limited fees, even because there's a big company on the other end of
- 8:44it, they're still going to require arbitration because they don't want these disputes to
- 8:46be public.
- 8:48And of course the brand can afford it, but the influencer who's not making a ton of
- 8:54money on this deal might not be able to.
- 8:56So you see that often in influence agreements, sometimes you see it in other contexts where
- 9:03there's an artist and a producer where the artist doesn't want any disputes to go public
- 9:09and so they have arbitration provisions.
- 9:11But again, when you're talking about a producer that's only making a couple thousand dollars,
- 9:15now the producer's got to spend all that money and then some just to enforce a contract
- 9:25that they're not really expecting all that much money to begin with.
- 9:28All right, good.
- 9:30So let's go over other things that you see in almost every contract.
- 9:35Choice of law.
- 9:37Why would anybody ever agree to the choice of law of another jurisdiction?
- 9:41You never want to be hometowned.
- 9:44Do not agree to New York or Minnesota or whatever it may be.
- 9:49What's the advantage?
- 9:50There is none.
- 9:51California's got perfectly good laws and you should not agree to them.
- 9:55If you have a dispute about it, what I say is, you know what, leave it blank or we'll
- 9:59deal with it later.
- 10:01Or you can say sometimes, all right, if you want to bring the lawsuit, then you have to
- 10:06bring it in my jurisdiction or vice versa.
- 10:11Venue.
- 10:15Venue is the internal laws, the internal counties in California and you would always want to
- 10:21be in LA County if you can, I would think.
- 10:25But you need to be aware of that and that's something they could put in the contract.
- 10:29No, selection.
- 10:30Let me chime in there.
- 10:32Just so with respect to jurisdiction and venue, and oftentimes these will get coupled together
- 10:38in a contract.
- 10:41In the entertainment industry, there's obviously a strong preference for California and New
- 10:46York and largely has to do a lot with the way the copyright cases play out in either
- 10:53of those districts.
- 10:54You want to be in a district where you know how copyright laws are going to play out or
- 11:01how the sort of procedures laws are going to play out whether in your favor or not.
- 11:09It's more or less there's a further developed area of law.
- 11:14And so as the studio or as the record label, there's going to be a stronger preference
- 11:20for it.
- 11:23As many of you know, the music industry has become largely globalized.
- 11:27There are lots of people who are making music outside of California, New York.
- 11:31Yet, you're seeing these kind of jurisdiction choices of law apply within those contracts.
- 11:41And that just becomes another barrier of entry.
- 11:45Especially when you've got independent creators who might not even be in the country, who then
- 11:51now have to bring a contract dispute in New York or California for something they may
- 11:57have recorded in Columbia or in Puerto Rico.
- 12:03Whether or not there's leverage to get those changes in there, that's just a subject of
- 12:11negotiation.
- 12:14I think it comes up a lot in influencer agreements too because the brand is always going to want
- 12:18to choose their home jurisdiction and influencers are engaged all over the country and all over
- 12:24the world really.
- 12:25And so what happens when you've got a brand that's based out in England and they're trying
- 12:30to build the presence here in the US, they're engaging influencers here and they've got
- 12:38a contract that says these are going to be governed by the laws of England or the laws
- 12:43of Wales or the laws of Ireland.
- 12:46It's one of those scenarios where you might not have the bargaining position to negotiate
- 12:51it out.
- 12:52So then what happens if there's a breach?
- 12:57You fight for it where you can, but a lot of times when you're talking about smaller
- 13:01contracts, maybe there's not a way around it.
- 13:04Yeah, and I'm saying it's happening more and more.
- 13:07We had a dispute recently with the Dutch.
- 13:09They wanted Dutch law.
- 13:12Depending on the subject of forum selection, again, you want to be in your hometown, your
- 13:19home state.
- 13:20There's an important new decision that came down on November 14th just two weeks ago.
- 13:25The Comedy Store versus Moss Adams, it's a published decision where the court said,
- 13:31we're not going to go with the state of Washington because the state of Washington does not view
- 13:35a jury trial as a fundamental right.
- 13:38So it's going to stay in California.
- 13:40So be thinking about if you're trying to get something waived, whether or not it's going
- 13:47to fly in another jurisdiction or the jurisdiction with whom your home is or you're contracting
- 13:53with overall for those of you who are representing people outside of the state of California.
- 14:00Next we're going to talk about waiver of fraud or intentional conduct.
- 14:04You see this, I mentioned before these reality show agreements in which they just say, we
- 14:10can say and do virtually anything we want and is there a limit?
- 14:14The answer is yes, there is a limit, but they habitually say, and I've had a number of people
- 14:22come to me over the years saying I just was defamed.
- 14:24And I said, yeah, well, you just consent it to it in this one-sided agreement overall.
- 14:31And maybe there's a way to get around it, but they're going to require you to go to arbitration,
- 14:37mediation, per-soc, with all the attorneys fees, et cetera.
- 14:41It's a no-win game overall.
- 14:44But California civil code 1668 states that contracts that exempt someone from responsibility
- 14:50from their own fraud, willful injury, or violation of law are against public policy.
- 14:57So I don't care if you put it in there or not, a defendant is not going to be able to
- 15:02get away from gross negligence, recklessness, or an intentional act.
- 15:06But how about this recent case from three years ago, Smith versus American Idol, unpublished,
- 15:13where the court found assumption of the risk, the guy got a perforated air drum based on
- 15:20the hearing devices they put in his ear.
- 15:24And they just said, well, that's ordinary negligence.
- 15:26That's too bad.
- 15:27You know, and it's a shame.
- 15:31Jury waiver.
- 15:32How about this?
- 15:34I have seen a number of contracts, and I've met many of you out there have as well, saying,
- 15:38well, you are waiving a jury.
- 15:40Well, guess what?
- 15:41There's a California Supreme Court case, Grafton Partners, I give you the site, that says, you
- 15:46can't do that.
- 15:48The right to a jury is a fundamental right in violent, sacred in its character.
- 15:54And so be mindful of that.
- 15:57Of course, you can say you're going to go to arbitration.
- 16:00That takes you out of the game there as well.
- 16:04Speaking of arbitration, I will say one place where I do recommend it overall is that there's
- 16:09a Supreme Court case that says, if you're a personal manager and you have an arbitration
- 16:14agreement and you want to evade or avoid the Labor Commissioner hearings, you can agree
- 16:21to go to arbitration because there's so poor arbitration at the Supreme Court.
- 16:25We just finished an arbitration before the Labor Commissioner, hey, folks, it took two
- 16:32and a half years to get the decision.
- 16:34And that's not an isolated act.
- 16:37I know that from other practitioners in the field overall.
- 16:41And I would also say, if you're on the personal manager side, you're generally going to do
- 16:45a lot better if you're in private arbitration as opposed to with the Labor Commissioner.
- 16:51Anything you want to say, John?
- 16:53I'm going to piggyback off of that point about mentioning California law and the Labor
- 17:01Commissioner.
- 17:02So this goes back to the comment about choice of law.
- 17:09Remember that when you're choosing California law, you are also agreeing to subject yourself
- 17:16to the laws of California's labor code, as well as, you know, if you're talking about
- 17:22the music context, you're talking about California statutory right to a royalty audit.
- 17:28You know, that sounds like it's a preference on perhaps the talent side, but on the business
- 17:33side, maybe it's not something you're looking forward to invoking involuntarily.
- 17:39Okay, let's go on to another topic, waiver of punitive damages.
- 17:46I'm sure many of our viewers have seen that in contracts.
- 17:52Well, how about this?
- 17:54There's a court of appeal decision, Lang versus Monster Energy Corp.
- 18:002020 that's published that says a waiver of punitive damages as a remedy for all nonstatutory
- 18:07claims is substantively unconscionable, regardless of its mutuality.
- 18:13So you can put it in there if you want, but it's not necessarily going to fly overall.
- 18:18And if you think about it, when we talked about that previous clause that says you cannot
- 18:23waive willful, reckless, intentional conduct, it makes sense overall.
- 18:28When did we most recently see this played out?
- 18:32The answer is bones.
- 18:34The decision that was before the, before an arbitrator who said, where there was a clause
- 18:41that said there will be no punitive damages and the arbitrator was so incensed at the
- 18:46conduct of 20th Century Fox that he levied a very substantial award.
- 18:52I think it was about 25, 28 million and then over a hundred million dollars in punitive
- 18:58damages.
- 18:59When they tried to enforce it, the trial court said there's a waiver.
- 19:05I'm not going to enforce the punitive damage because it's a waiver and then it's settled
- 19:10on appeal overall.
- 19:11So we don't know what's going to happen, but I know that the argument that was being made
- 19:16was that it was, you cannot have a law that is grossly inappropriate given intentional
- 19:24or fraudulent conduct.
- 19:26Just a quick drafting point on that note.
- 19:29So on a lot of contracts, you're going to see this language, as I'm sure many of you
- 19:33know, and there's going to be situations where the talent buyer is refusing to review
- 19:40or remove this provision.
- 19:42But I mean, notwithstanding the California appellate precedent, another way to mitigate
- 19:52this is to limit it only in the instance where there's an absence of fraud or intentional
- 19:58discontent.
- 20:02You can talk about waiver as a punitive damage, as a waiver of equitable or injensive relief,
- 20:08but only in the context that there wasn't any fraud involved in the breach.
- 20:15And oftentimes that becomes a way to move forward in a contract because one party is
- 20:22refusing to remove this language while the other side is refusing to just waive it completely.
- 20:29You know, I was related to that issue is the topic of consequential damages.
- 20:35So many agreements say you're not going to get any more than what you were supposed to
- 20:39get paid in this contract or what money you're out overall.
- 20:44And from a business point of perspective, that's what you've got to do if you're representing
- 20:50a company.
- 20:51You want to always limit your downside as much as possible.
- 20:53As far as I know, I haven't seen a case yet that said you cannot do that overall.
- 20:58All right.
- 20:59Attorney's fees, you know, I would say my experience with that most entertainment contracts
- 21:08do not provide for the prevailing party to get attorney's fees if there's litigation.
- 21:15And I don't agree with that because I think my client's usually going to be on the right
- 21:21or I hope so.
- 21:23And secondly, and most importantly, you can't get a lawyer to work on a contingency fee
- 21:29basis if the damages do not include the attorney's fees that the lawyer might have.
- 21:36We do a lot of right of publicity cases by analogy and the Civil Code 3344 provides for
- 21:46attorney's fees.
- 21:47And a lot of times we'll take that case on because we know we're made a hole at the end
- 21:53of the day, even if there's a fire going on outside my window, fire trucks.
- 22:03So for you who are representing anybody, we think twice about why not have a fee shifting
- 22:14clause overall because otherwise you may be out in the lurch and unable to prosecute
- 22:23your case or find somebody to defend it.
- 22:26Well, I think that allows the rub, right?
- 22:29It's people omit the attorney's fees language because it makes it harder to mitigate.
- 22:34Right?
- 22:35I mean, let's be real.
- 22:36I think part of the tactic for it is to not leave an invitation for contingency attorneys
- 22:46to participate in any contract dispute.
- 22:48Absolutely.
- 22:49That's why the major studios and the big companies and everybody else, they don't want that.
- 22:55But if you're making a middle management or middle of the road kind of a company or artist
- 23:01or anybody else, I think it makes sense.
- 23:04I just did a licensing deal for a small film this weekend and the other side did not want
- 23:10to agree.
- 23:11Okay, we'll live with it overall, but I told him, you know, works your benefit as well.
- 23:18Okay, now we're going to talk about audit rights.
- 23:22So you got to make sure you always have the right to audit if there is money involved
- 23:26somewhere down the line.
- 23:27My favorite audit clause I saw on a major motion picture you would all know said, you
- 23:32can audit if the film is in profits and the film is not in profits.
- 23:36It was like a blackbuster.
- 23:39So what do you do?
- 23:42And there is a right to audit recording agreements.
- 23:44That's California's Civil Code 2501, but not for any other entertainment vehicle overall.
- 23:52And that case that I just, the deal I just mentioned to you yesterday, that's why thank
- 23:58God my client sent it to me.
- 23:59It did not have a royalty provision at all saying when or if they had to do it.
- 24:07So you got to, that's fundamental to any licensing deal overall.
- 24:13So if it's make sure you have the right to audit and to audit as necessary and oftentimes
- 24:20most agreements, many agreements, I'll say most provide, if there's a 5% or 10% discrepancy,
- 24:26they will pay the cost of the auditor.
- 24:28So that makes sense overall.
- 24:29Anything you want to say on auditing, John?
- 24:34More of a question actually.
- 24:362501, I believe would apply in any music royalty context, right?
- 24:44Not just recording contracts with publishing agreements being.
- 24:48I think it's just record companies as I recollect.
- 24:52Okay.
- 24:53Again, when you're talking about choice of law, if you've got California choice of law
- 25:01and you're representing talent, that's certainly a great benefit to have a tool to have in
- 25:07your arsenal.
- 25:09If you're someone who's on the side where you're paying royalties, it's something to
- 25:14be conscious about.
- 25:16And I don't know enough about the provision to know what the statute of limitations are
- 25:23for this.
- 25:24I think it might be three years to invoke a royalty audit under statute.
- 25:30But keep in mind that whenever you're dealing with music contracts, oftentimes you're talking
- 25:35about limiting the amount of time you have to review royalty statements.
- 25:41And it's primarily used to limit the time period shorter than the statute of limitations.
- 25:49And so when you're limiting that period under the contract to review a statement, is that
- 25:57also affecting the time that you have to review royalties if you're seeking an audit under
- 26:03statute?
- 26:04Yeah, we could do a whole program on auditing and the misery that forensic auditors are
- 26:11going through right now.
- 26:14One of the things you want to make, we'll discuss a little bit, is that they are not
- 26:22letting you go.
- 26:24The record companies are not letting the auditors take a serious look at the books.
- 26:29They're limiting them to maybe two years or so, whereas they may be holding money for
- 26:3410 or 15 years.
- 26:36And that's something that would be nice to negotiate for that you could be able to see
- 26:41these accounts overall.
- 26:43You could even take it a step further.
- 26:45In the contracts, it'll have language that says you can only audit and review material
- 26:50in the royalty statements for things that you have identified in your notice letter.
- 26:53And if you don't write your notice letter properly, you may have given up your right
- 26:59to review certain documents.
- 27:01I'll just say this, we're having such problems.
- 27:03Here's what's going on in auditing right now.
- 27:06In motion pictures, they say it will see in three years or four years by the time they're
- 27:10going to let you in, then they take a year to go back and forth until you finally make
- 27:15your deal.
- 27:16Same thing with the record companies, they put you in a queue that may be well over a
- 27:20year before they're going to let you in in the first place.
- 27:24And somebody ought to do something about it.
- 27:29Let me piggyback a little bit more on the audit rights point.
- 27:31So of course, we can talk about audit rights.
- 27:33We're talking about royalty statements, right?
- 27:35And certain contracts will have language that says a royalty statement is going to be deemed
- 27:39delivered on the date that it's due.
- 27:42That's something that I think a lot of us have experienced.
- 27:45You always want to look out for that.
- 27:47Make sure that the clock doesn't start running the date when it's due, especially when the
- 27:50royalty statement hasn't actually been delivered because then you're already running the clock
- 27:55at that point.
- 27:57The other thing to be wary of is contracts that say that you can't file a dispute about
- 28:06a royalty statement until after you've conducted an audit.
- 28:09When you're talking about talent who was brought on and made minimal fees but could be substantially
- 28:16owed a lot of money, had the royalties been paid through, that becomes another barrier
- 28:20of entry because here's somebody who's waiting on the royalties to come in that never came
- 28:25and they now have to seek an audit, pay $10,000, $25,000 to conduct the audit before they could
- 28:31even file a suit.
- 28:34I don't know how that plays out in the Conscionability Standard under contract review but it certainly
- 28:43comes up in a lot of entertainment agreements and something to be mindful of when you see
- 28:47it.
- 28:48It's like $50,000 or $100,000 to do a proper movie audit and that's a lot of money to put
- 28:54out.
- 28:55We find more and more that we get such pushback on audits that we just say we're going to
- 29:01file a lawsuit, we'll do a discovery through the legal system and it's much more efficient
- 29:05because they can't say no to a judge.
- 29:08On a side note, I want to mention we've seen this come up and probably ought to be talked
- 29:12about in contracts that you do.
- 29:14What happens when an income stream is sold?
- 29:17We set a law firm that was saying I want 5% of that money and ultimately the matter was
- 29:23resolved but it's going to come up more and more.
- 29:26Does the manager get a piece?
- 29:27Does the agent get a piece?
- 29:28You ought to be thinking about that.
- 29:31Also we had a case where we represented a producer on a superstar album and the talent
- 29:39settled with the record company for a lot of amount of money and nothing went to the
- 29:47record producer who ended up filing an action for and ultimately settled it but that's an
- 29:52example there.
- 29:55You should be thinking about how do I cover that, not only if there's a resolution of
- 30:00somebody who's a partner with you and the other person gets a bonus but also what happens
- 30:06when a catalog is sold?
- 30:09Let's talk about the special purpose.
- 30:12Go ahead to that point about catalog sales.
- 30:15You'll see it often in Reption warranties on the person who's selling.
- 30:20For example, an artist is selling to a fund who wants to buy catalog.
- 30:26The artist is making certain warranty with respect to any royalties that are owed that
- 30:32either the royalty recipient, aka the producer, is either paid out or is accounted for and
- 30:38has been disclosed.
- 30:39From a transactional side, that's supposed to be contemplated whether or not the buyer
- 30:45is going to take over those royalty payments, those royalty obligations or not and an issue
- 30:51arises often because the producer absolutely has no visibility on the sale between the
- 30:59artist and the buyer is well now who does the producer go to for these royalties?
- 31:08Good point.
- 31:10All right.
- 31:12Special purpose vehicles, every single television and movie production has what's called a special
- 31:20purpose vehicle, an LLC or a corporation that might be set up through which everything's
- 31:26going to be run.
- 31:27Before I go into further, somebody asked, are there handouts?
- 31:33I gave an eight page handout with this which if you go to the chat room, I think you can
- 31:37get the link to it overall.
- 31:38But anyway, special purpose vehicles, what's going to happen if there's a breach?
- 31:43You're going to sue an empty shell effectively overall.
- 31:47So you all out there need to be aware of special purpose vehicles and standby or alternate
- 31:55additional liability in the event of some sort of a breach or God forbid some tort such
- 32:01as fraud that occurs or breach of fiduciary duty overall.
- 32:05Now, you can, of course, if there is fraud or another tort, you can name an executive
- 32:14or somebody who was in a position of power that could be held liable overall.
- 32:22But again, you'll probably run up to this in a special purpose vehicle situation that
- 32:26cause I told you about before, no consequential damages overall, and which may make it totally
- 32:32unworthy.
- 32:35We've had this problem, next one we're going to talk about is collection accounts.
- 32:38And I can't tell you how frustrated I have been at my experience with collection accounts
- 32:43like vintage and freeway are two of the major ones overall.
- 32:48This is when, let's say an investor comes in and puts money in and he's supposed, or
- 32:53she is supposed to get, or is supposed to get money off of the profits and the revenue
- 32:58and they want to see what's going on.
- 33:00Well, how about the situation I had recently of a guy who wrote the script and put a hundred
- 33:04grand of his own money into it and is not on the collection accounts.
- 33:08So he has no idea what's going on with the finances and they treat him in a totally
- 33:13haunting manner overall.
- 33:15What's my point?
- 33:16My point is that if you have talent for somebody who's going to be paid based on the revenues
- 33:21coming in, whether they're an investor or talent, you want to be on that account with
- 33:27full rights to see all the money coming in and the right to audit just as anybody else
- 33:33would have such a right because there's such screwiness going on in the indie film world
- 33:39overall that you just need to pay very, very close attention to it.
- 33:46Accountings.
- 33:47John talked about internal statutes of limitation.
- 33:53I think there's every single contract I think I've ever seen provides for an internal statute
- 33:59that is shorter than, of statute of limitations, shorter than the code.
- 34:05Code is four years, two years on a normal contract, but four years or no, you're going
- 34:10to see two years overall and you have to object and there is the very difficult case that
- 34:17came down in 2017 that was very harmful to royalty payees, namely Windancer Productions
- 34:26Group versus Walt Disney in which they said, you need to object as soon as you get the
- 34:33statement and if you don't, your statute of limitations is running and you're out of
- 34:40luck.
- 34:41The problem is the conundrum that most movies and TV shows don't earn out until five through
- 34:50four years later and it doesn't pay to necessarily object or certainly to do an audit.
- 34:58What you want, the antidote at best is to object and get a total agreement if you can.
- 35:03Hopefully you have a good relationship with the payor overall, but you need to be very
- 35:10mindful of these, of this particular position.
- 35:15I'll mention also it came down, I think, I'm not sure, the Bill Nye, the Science Guy
- 35:22versus Walt Disney, this was about a year ago, six months ago.
- 35:28That is a decision where they said, the argument was that streaming monies are not the same
- 35:34as home video and we should be getting paid on 100% of the revenue.
- 35:38What happened with home video was that 25, 30 years ago they kind of concocted a methodology
- 35:47by which the talent got paid on 20% of the gross revenues and then so if you had a 5%
- 35:53of the income coming in, you got 5% and 20% and of course home video was driving the marketplace
- 35:58at that time.
- 35:59Well, now there's no more home video, there's no distribution, there's no block clusters
- 36:05and it's a different world entirely, there's no physical product and so the argument was
- 36:10that I should get paid on streaming at the 100% rate and three product court judges
- 36:17said no, Disney says this is our policy and this is, we say it's home video, they put
- 36:25up some internal executives who said that's what we think and Bill Nye's people came up
- 36:30with some other people and the court went with Disney overall.
- 36:34That's an example where they just interpreted their contract the way they wanted to interpret
- 36:40in the face of new technology that came in.
- 36:44Speaking of which, you always want to be thinking about new technology and I don't even know
- 36:48where to go right now when it comes to AI.
- 36:52It's so chaotic overall but everybody's scratching their head and trying to figure it out right
- 36:58now just like everybody's scratching their head for the last 10, 15 years on how do you
- 37:03get paid and streaming?
- 37:04What was the result?
- 37:05The result was that you don't get back in anymore, maybe you're just going to get paid
- 37:10a big profit if you're lucky when the deal goes down and now Netflix is pulling back
- 37:16and saying well, we don't know if we like that model anymore and you look at the Disney
- 37:21and other places and they say well, if you have awards, if you have a good opening in
- 37:27the movie theaters, good critics, other things like that, you will get bonuses but you are
- 37:34not going to get back in.
- 37:35It looks like it's the depth of back end.
- 37:38John?
- 37:39With regards to accounting, I think it's always important to pay attention to who do you actually
- 37:48have the right to receive the accountings from and to conduct the audits from.
- 37:52If you're a producer, oftentimes your rights are against the artist but the artist is often
- 37:59passing on the obligation of providing the accounting to the record labels.
- 38:04As a producer, you're often not going to have the right to audit the record label directly
- 38:11and so you're reliant upon the intermediary to maintain accurate books and records in
- 38:18order to provide an accounting in the first place.
- 38:21It becomes an even bigger issue when the artists themselves haven't received their royalties
- 38:26and then you as a producer, you're stuck second in line where you can't even get the statements
- 38:34until the artist gets the statement first.
- 38:38You want to have the right to see any audits the artist does and to participate in the
- 38:43resolution of any such audits overall.
- 38:46Otherwise, you're just hanging out on an aluminum.
- 38:50A couple other points for accountings which aren't necessarily related to audits but there's
- 38:55this concept of windowing when it comes to accountings.
- 39:01Let's say that at the end of Q4 of 2024, the royalty account is in a payable position.
- 39:08In January 1st, you take an advance or incur a significant cost where you now receive a
- 39:19large sum of money from either the label or the production studio where the account with
- 39:25then be in the red.
- 39:28Well, the Q4 accountings won't come in until, let's say, February or March.
- 39:36Sometimes you'll see record companies apply the January 1st advance against the royalties
- 39:43that should have been paid at the end of Q4.
- 39:48You want to make sure that there's at least clear language that says that the practice
- 39:54isn't allowed or that there's no way to read the contract that says you can apply advances
- 39:59to monies that have not yet been paid yet.
- 40:03So, the little thing to pay attention to with accounting, the other thing with respect to
- 40:09accountings is who is the one that's actually receiving the accounting royalties statements?
- 40:16Are they the ones receiving the accounting?
- 40:25And at what?
- 40:29Soon as they receive the accountings, your statute is running.
- 40:34And if you don't wise it up until two or three years later down the line that the middle
- 40:37man is the one screwing you over, you can't do anything about those statements that have
- 40:44already been rendered.
- 40:46Okay, let's talk about fiduciary duties.
- 40:52Plain employers are always looking for consequential damages and fiduciary duties.
- 41:01Is there a fiduciary duty to pay royalties?
- 41:04Arguably, I think a good case can be made, yes.
- 41:06However, the courts have gone the other way.
- 41:09And I give you the city of Hope case from 2008, and I give you the New York site as
- 41:15well and it says there's no fiduciary duty overall.
- 41:19So sometimes, lawyers have been clever enough to find a fiduciary duty that happened in
- 41:26the Don Johnson case some years ago on Nash Bridges when they gave him a part of the copyright.
- 41:32And he said, you owed me a fiduciary duty.
- 41:34It paid me fairly.
- 41:35He said, no, that was just window dressing.
- 41:37Now, Port went the other way in the jury and he did just fine.
- 41:42But another case, Roger Rabbit, was another case where McDonald's paid a boatload of
- 41:49money to the producer and the writer said, I should get a piece of that.
- 41:57And he lost.
- 41:58They said, no fiduciary duty there overall.
- 42:01So if you can find a way to, there should be a fiduciary, if you can find a way, go
- 42:07ahead and get it.
- 42:09But every agreement I've virtually I've ever seen says there's no fiduciary duty, but
- 42:12I would say this.
- 42:14I don't care if you're in a partnership with somebody overall, you owe fiduciary duties.
- 42:19That's full disclosure and put their interests ahead of your own particular interest overall.
- 42:24But that's a battle that's been going on a long time and will go on for time and memorial.
- 42:30And to piggyback off of the fiduciary duty point, there's, I think a lot of us are familiar
- 42:35with the fiduciary duties that say a lawyer or an agent owes to talent.
- 42:42And there's always this question of does the manager, does the talent manager owe fiduciary
- 42:47duty to the talent?
- 42:49And generally, the law is no, except in certain situations where the manager is controlling
- 43:00the money of the talent.
- 43:02And so you've got to be, you've got to pay attention to situations like that.
- 43:07Is the manager doing something that might be screwing over the talent, like controlling
- 43:11the money, negotiating business, negotiating when the artist actually receives the money?
- 43:17Has the manager then invoked a fiduciary duty to a talent where there otherwise would not
- 43:27have been?
- 43:28You know, what you say is that you don't think there's a fiduciary duty that managers have.
- 43:33And I beg to differ.
- 43:34I think they do absolutely under traditional agency principles.
- 43:38But now thinking out of the box for the first time on that subject, I'm yet to see a manager
- 43:44agreement, and I've been looking at them for over 40 years, that said there's no fiduciary
- 43:48duty between us.
- 43:49But I don't see why you couldn't put that in anyway.
- 43:52I mean, they advise and counsel, and they can book gigs, some gigs on behalf of the
- 43:58artist and certainly in conjunction with an agent, and they're the artist's face out
- 44:02there whose job is to advise them on the best way of promoting their careers.
- 44:09All right, let's talk to the good, talk to the subject of injunctive relief.
- 44:14Virtually every entertainment contract says you cannot, even if I breach this contract,
- 44:22I'll pay you, you can't stop the release of my film.
- 44:25That's a very typical clause overall.
- 44:29Query, whether that would work in the face of an intentional tort such as fraud or something
- 44:37like that, I don't know.
- 44:39But it's basically a non-negotiable term, and you're going to see it in every agreement
- 44:45happening.
- 44:47I put in the handout, I actually quoted section, Civil Code 3423, which says you cannot get
- 44:57an injunction against somebody in a personal services contract unless you've guaranteed
- 45:03them a minimal amount of money, which is $9,000 in the first year, $12,000 in the second,
- 45:10$15,000 in the third and on, and that, you know, I don't know how many contracts there
- 45:19are these days that provide for those kinds of guarantees, but this has been around for
- 45:24a long time.
- 45:27So you need to be aware of it.
- 45:29If something that's really important used to be used against recording artists all
- 45:33the time.
- 45:34What is, what you also need to think about though, and maybe you don't necessarily need
- 45:40it, is that, and I've seen this happen in my practice, is that company, artists walks
- 45:48away from company A signs with company B.
- 45:50Just takes one letter to company B saying, I'm going to sue you for interference with
- 45:55contractual relations.
- 45:56So I'd be mighty careful if you put on any product by this particular talent.
- 46:01To kind of piggyback off of that and drug to believe provision.
- 46:07So there's certainly language and entertainment contracts, especially when there's copyrights
- 46:13involved saying that, you know, as you're, as you're further up the line of the chain
- 46:19title that you're waiving the right to, to enjoying the copyright.
- 46:26There's also language that you'll see sometimes when there's, when there's a talent providing
- 46:31services that says that the buyer of the talent will, will have, will, will require the talent
- 46:40to, to recognize and acknowledge that their services are unique and that the buyer would
- 46:48be entitled to injure the relief.
- 46:51I don't know how enforceable that is in court, especially in light of the language that
- 46:56that Neville had brought up about minimum, minimum payments.
- 47:00But as a drafting note, oftentimes what we'll do is we'll, we'll say that the, the buyer
- 47:06has the right to seek injure to relieve only because in many cases of the, the buyer won't
- 47:15agree to waive a provision that, that, that allows for them to, to, to injure through
- 47:23relief.
- 47:24The middle ground there is, okay, you'll have a right to seek constructive relief, but
- 47:28we won't automatically give it to you.
- 47:30All right, we're going to go into what I call general rules.
- 47:34General rule number one, get to the top of the financial waterfall as soon as possible.
- 47:39More middlemen there are, the more opportunity there is for you, your, your, your client
- 47:46to be cheated in some way overall.
- 47:49And that's tough.
- 47:50It's tough to do when you, like so, if you sign to a production, you're going to have
- 47:53a production company, which for a motion picture or invest in one, which then makes a deal
- 48:00with one of the majors, you have no privity to go after the major overall.
- 48:06So you should be getting copies at least of the financial statements when and as they
- 48:10are delivered to the production company or the other intermediate person.
- 48:19You can also agree to have a joint account.
- 48:22I mean, commonly in, in, in a manager, personal managers agreement, since we will mutually
- 48:28designate a third party to be the business manager or accountant for us.
- 48:33Well, that, that would work for me if I was a manager.
- 48:36And then I know I don't have to rely on a, on a musician who might get mad at me and
- 48:41don't want to pay me.
- 48:43All right, set up a tickler system for your clients.
- 48:46We, we had a case where you'll love this, where our client was a major EP executive
- 48:54producer for a company with a hit shows.
- 48:57And then the company kind of dissolved the head guy died and our client didn't get paid.
- 49:04And we said, where's the money?
- 49:06And they said, we forgot.
- 49:09I just, that's my favorite experience, dogging my homework.
- 49:13And what we'd also discover was that it was, we were past the limitations for the business
- 49:17manager who should have been involved and acknowledged and understood that their monthly
- 49:22or I mean, semi-annual payments were coming through and do.
- 49:25And so we went after the business manager for not having adequate safeguards.
- 49:31So we get, in my firm, I know we get, countings on several, a number of things for work that
- 49:38we've done overall.
- 49:39And I know when that money is due.
- 49:40And if it doesn't come in, I call or my client calls and we, we check into it.
- 49:46But that just means you have to have a tickler system.
- 49:48And in today's modern age, there's no difficulty having that.
- 49:53Loan out corporations.
- 49:55Boy, were they in over the last 30 years used a lot, especially in motion pictures for actors,
- 50:06writers, directors, producers, oftentimes utilized for tax purposes.
- 50:11You can get a better, better depreciation and tax, and tax benefits overall.
- 50:16Well, there's no problem.
- 50:17There's a problem with that, which is that if it involves a copyright, you may not be
- 50:23able to terminate the copyright.
- 50:24When you signed over on your line, your loan out corporation, the copyright in the script
- 50:31that you wrote or the song, the copyright act only recognizes a human being can get
- 50:39the reversion area right.
- 50:41And that's how it backfired for John Wade against UMG recordings because they said,
- 50:46well, you had to work for hire, et cetera.
- 50:49And your corporation on the copyright, you don't have the right to get it back overall.
- 50:55So be very, very careful about engaging in loan out corporations where there's a potential
- 51:01for a revolutionary copyrights somewhere down the line.
- 51:04As a drafting note on that point, I think what we're seeing a lot now is that when there's
- 51:11a particular talent who's both a recording artist and a songwriter, you'll see on the
- 51:16recording contract that the artist will be signing the recording contract under the loan
- 51:21out.
- 51:23Whereas when the talent is entering into deals with a music publisher, either for a co-publishing
- 51:30situation or administration where the songwriter is contracting with the publisher in their
- 51:41personal capacity and just directing money is to be paid to the law rather than having
- 51:46to contract you with a loan out directly.
- 51:49Related to this is Bozio versus E.M. Light Group 2016.
- 51:56I give you the site to a daily journal article I wrote about this.
- 52:01That was Nobody Walks in LA.
- 52:04What's the name of that group?
- 52:07Anyway, carrying Bozio.
- 52:09She owed taxes and the corporation had lapsed.
- 52:15That's another reason, motivation against not having a corporation or an LLC is you've
- 52:20got to keep it up every year with $1,000 in minimum taxes.
- 52:23So Bozio owed money and was able to get the federal court to say, you know what, you still
- 52:30have standing not with standing or a suspended corporation because it looks like there's
- 52:34money there at the end of the line.
- 52:36But I tried that gambit in the last year or two and the state tax authority said, we don't
- 52:42really need to hear from you, Mr. Johnson.
- 52:44Thank you.
- 52:45We've got a number of people.
- 52:48Just pay the back taxes if you would.
- 52:53Another thing I talk about are foreign sales agents for independent films.
- 52:57As I've told you, I've had a number of situations with indie films and I'm very unhappy with
- 53:05the general state of affairs overall.
- 53:07They all just live it up and can and charge expensive marketing fees, et cetera.
- 53:16And I'm hard pressed to think of any indie films that ever make a profit overall.
- 53:20So what you're doing, particularly when you're making these deals with these foreign sales
- 53:25agents or indie distributors is to say, you're limited as to what you can charge.
- 53:32I want to see a copy of all of your deals.
- 53:35I have the right to terminate.
- 53:37I have the right to audit, that will, et cetera.
- 53:39You've got to be harsh.
- 53:41They're not putting up any money.
- 53:43If you think about it, overall, you have a $5 million film.
- 53:46They're not putting up the money.
- 53:48What they can do sometimes is they can sell it off.
- 53:51I'll tell you another trick that we've seen.
- 53:54They'll go get advances from foreign distributors and then they set up a sub-distribution company
- 53:59in these foreign countries and suck out all the earnings that are coming out from those
- 54:05people overall.
- 54:06But so number one rule is marketing expenses.
- 54:11Limit those as much as possible.
- 54:13Make sure you're, as I said before, make sure you're in on the investor corporation that
- 54:23is collecting all of the money, the collection agent, et cetera, and monitor it.
- 54:28And I know there are some good distributors out there overall, but it's the Wild West.
- 54:34And I have a client who's a big actor.
- 54:40And he was saying, how come there's never any profits?
- 54:43And the answer is because there's never going to be any profits.
- 54:46The advances that come in go to the producer and they never make enough to pay anybody
- 54:52else.
- 54:53But if the client, as I said before, is making many, many millions, there aren't too many
- 55:00crocodile tears.
- 55:03Copyright notes.
- 55:04Here's four things to be aware of that are important.
- 55:09You've got to register a copyright within three months of publication before the defendant
- 55:14first infringes upon the work to get the certain benefits, mostly attorney's fees or if you
- 55:19want to go for what are called statutory fees overall.
- 55:23So what does it pay?
- 55:24It pays always to register your copyright as soon as possible.
- 55:28If you've registered within five years of publication, there's a prima facia presumption
- 55:33of validity regarding the information included in the registration.
- 55:38This is super important.
- 55:40Now you should all be aware of it.
- 55:43Recent case from the Supreme Court, you can't file a copyright claim unless you have a certificate
- 55:50of registration from the copyright office.
- 55:53And ordinarily it takes, as I understand, two, three months to get a copyright certificate
- 55:57back.
- 55:58If you've got to go after it, you can pay more recently.
- 56:02We've paid, I think, $750 and we can get it within a few days overall.
- 56:06Finally, we had a decision this year that made a lot of people happy, which was that
- 56:12the statute of limitations for breach of copyright, for copyright infringement, runs from the
- 56:17date of reasonable discovery.
- 56:20That's the Warner Chapel Music versus Neely case.
- 56:24So those are many of the topics that I wanted to talk about.
- 56:28I know John has more.
- 56:30So just to piggyback off the copyright note, there is one concept that floats around in
- 56:34the music industry context, and that's the idea of copyrights in musical compositions.
- 56:43By default, if you're a co-author of a composition, you all share equally in 100% of the copyright
- 56:50of the song.
- 56:52However, in the music industry practice, what we see is that writers through contractual
- 56:58vehicles will have language that says, well, each writer gets to administer their respective
- 57:06share of the composition exclusively.
- 57:10It's a provision that is very necessary in order for the publishing industry to survive
- 57:18in the manner that it does.
- 57:19The question comes up is what happens if there isn't an actual split sheet signed or any
- 57:24agreement that contains this language, that the writer controls and administers their
- 57:28work exclusively, and one writer decides to threaten a takedown notice.
- 57:37I don't know that that case has actually gone to court, at least I'm not personally aware
- 57:43of it, but you see threats of takedowns all the time, oftentimes with producers that haven't
- 57:50paid who say, you know what, I'm going to enjoy the use of my sound recording and the
- 57:58use of my composition because you haven't paid me, I haven't given you the right to
- 58:04use my song that I co-wrote.
- 58:07Well, technically, I don't think the artist needs that right.
- 58:13As a co-writer, anyone has the right to exploit the composition as long as they're properly
- 58:18accounting the respective shares.
- 58:20Now we're out of time, but I'm going to rattle off a few other points.
- 58:25We'll go into too much detail, but there are certain points that will come up.
- 58:33Sometimes you'll see an entertainment contract, and I'm not talking about settlement agreements,
- 58:38I'm talking about regular service agreements, where it has a waiver of rights under California
- 58:44CID Code 1542.
- 58:45For those of you who aren't familiar, that's a waiver of your right to release claims that
- 58:54are known or unknown.
- 58:57I don't know why that exists in a transactional context, other than the tell-on buyer might
- 59:02be saying, you know what, if I've hired you in the past, you can't sue me for it anymore.
- 59:07But if you see that in a transactional setting, that's very quickly going to be one of the
- 59:14first things you strike out.
- 59:19Other things you need to be mindful of is certain contracts will have language that
- 59:23says you're going to consent to service a process by mail, and it'll be effective service
- 59:28in the jurisdiction of the choice of law that's chosen in agreement.
- 59:35Now, of course, the practical issue there is, well, what happens if you've changed addresses
- 59:41or you've changed attorneys or you've changed representation and they just mail it.
- 59:46Now you're being sued and you're at risk of getting defaulted because you didn't even
- 59:51know the lawsuit was filed against you in the first place.
- 59:57There are other provisions with regard to influencer agreements.
- 1:00:08There's this concept of sequential liability.
- 1:00:12Oftentimes, major brands will go through an agent to employ talent to do these influencer
- 1:00:20agreements, where the contractual privity is between the talent and the hiring agent.
- 1:00:26And you'll see a provision in there that calls for sequential liability in that the brand
- 1:00:32will not be liable for paying the talent's fees unless and until the agent has actually
- 1:00:42received the money from the brand.
- 1:00:46Now that becomes an issue, obviously, because from a contractual standpoint, the talent
- 1:00:50doesn't have privity with the brand itself.
- 1:00:53Now, of course, there's claims of whether there's unjust enrichment from the brand
- 1:01:02and the agent with services, but from a contract standpoint, the talent can only go after the
- 1:01:10agent and the agent's not on the hook until the agent has actually received the money.
- 1:01:15Well, if the agent hasn't received the money, then what relief does the talent actually
- 1:01:22have there?
- 1:01:26With respect to independent contractor language, it shows up all the time in entertainment
- 1:01:32contracts, regardless of what the relationship is.
- 1:01:35Just be mindful that when you're in California, there's California employment laws that really
- 1:01:40bust up what you want to call yourself.
- 1:01:43Certain states will allow you to be an independent contractor, as long as you call yourself an
- 1:01:46independent contractor.
- 1:01:47But California is a lot more stringent.
- 1:01:52You've got to satisfy the ABC test in order to prove that someone is an actual independent
- 1:01:58contractor.
- 1:02:01In the music context, you'll often be faced with insurance obligations in contracts involving
- 1:02:13live performance.
- 1:02:14Let's say that you're a talent and you're doing a small show or you're a DJ, you're
- 1:02:19performing at a festival, and there's a requirement that you as the talent are providing general
- 1:02:25liability insurance and naming the talent buyer as additional insured.
- 1:02:30If you're a smaller talent, you're making a small fee, and then you're required to pay
- 1:02:36insurance just to get that fee.
- 1:02:40That's already eating into your small earnings to begin with.
- 1:02:44The other thing with respect to those contracts or festivals in particular is when you're
- 1:02:50a smaller talent, local talent, let's say you're a DJ in LA, and you want to perform
- 1:02:56at Coachella.
- 1:02:58But there's a radius clause that says you can't perform any shows from time period,
- 1:03:05six months leading up to the performance.
- 1:03:08But the performance is still four months away.
- 1:03:12We're in January and the show is in April.
- 1:03:17Are you then expected to not work in LA up until the date of your performance at Coachella?
- 1:03:24Especially when you're not even a headlight act, something to be mindful of that shows
- 1:03:28up in those types of movements, particularly with small artists.
- 1:03:34Right to use AI.
- 1:03:36This has been a developing fight, and I know that this area of law is really unknown quite
- 1:03:45yet, but there's always this fight where if you're the talent, and particularly in situations
- 1:03:54where the talents works are considered work for hire, does the buyer have the right to
- 1:03:58use the results and proceeds of your services for AI?
- 1:04:04You as a talent rapper are always going to fight that you can't use it for AI without
- 1:04:10my permission, or you'll even take a heart of sense and say, no, you don't get to use
- 1:04:14it at all.
- 1:04:16And we saw these with NFTs earlier, whether or not you can use the results and proceeds
- 1:04:21as part of NFTs, whereas the buyer is going to try and push for the right to include it
- 1:04:26in AI for whatever purposes they need, because I bought the copyright, so it's mine to do
- 1:04:32whatever I want.
- 1:04:35And I think the middle ground, or at least the approach right now is that if a company
- 1:04:40doesn't want to address the AI issue, they just leave it out of the copyright.
- 1:04:46And even if you try to insert language that says, you know what, I don't want you to use
- 1:04:51my works in AI context, and I'm going to put it in there, oftentimes the response will
- 1:04:57be, you know what, we're not going to address it right now.
- 1:04:59So I'm not agreeing to your comment.
- 1:05:02I'm not saying that we'll do it.
- 1:05:03Not saying that we won't, but we're just not going to address it.
- 1:05:06And so it kind of potentially leaves this gray area in contract.
- 1:05:11Again, the music contracts context, you're talking about language that when you're delivering
- 1:05:19a work, it's going to be technically and commercially satisfactory.
- 1:05:23Technically satisfactory, I think we kind of understand that, you know what, if you
- 1:05:29turn in something and we're not even able to distribute it and use it, then clearly
- 1:05:39it makes sense why we can't count it as delivered.
- 1:05:42But when you're talking about a commercially satisfactory standpoint, now you're talking
- 1:05:48about what does the label have the right to decide whether or not your music is even good
- 1:05:55enough?
- 1:05:56You know, say you turn in a full album and the label says internally, you know what,
- 1:06:01this album sucks.
- 1:06:03And now you go up in the door for them to say, you know what, it's not commercially satisfactory.
- 1:06:07We're not going to deem this record as delivered.
- 1:06:11There's certain language you put in there that says, you know what, if it's consistent
- 1:06:14with, you know, with works that the artist has produced in the past, then it'll be deemed
- 1:06:21commercially satisfactory.
- 1:06:22But there's often a fight about what commercially satisfactory even constitutes.
- 1:06:29And the last point I'm going to bring up is kind of related to that.
- 1:06:34This idea of what happens when an album is delivered, right?
- 1:06:45Or you're trying to terminate a recording agreement.
- 1:06:50When as a talent, you deliver works and either the label doesn't want to put it out or decides,
- 1:06:58you know, what halfway through the project, we're kind of done with this artist.
- 1:07:02They want to drop now in the, you know, in the normal setting, anything that was created
- 1:07:11by the artist during the term of that agreement before the artist was dropped, all those works
- 1:07:16belong to the record label.
- 1:07:20But what happens if the artist is really just upset at the label and wants to get out of
- 1:07:26the contract and the label says no, right?
- 1:07:28We're just going to hold you hostage forever because you don't want to comply with us.
- 1:07:31We don't want to comply with you.
- 1:07:33And so as punishment, we're just not going to release you.
- 1:07:35Well, you know, there's certain vehicles that you could put in there that say, you know
- 1:07:40what, you have to release an album within a certain amount of timeframe or, you know,
- 1:07:47you might have pay or play language that says, you know what, if you don't want to put my
- 1:07:50stuff out within a certain amount of time, then pay me, buy me out.
- 1:07:56And you know, you could even have, you can even try to put a language that says, you
- 1:07:59know what, if you're not going to work my album, at least give me those rights back.
- 1:08:04And it becomes a negotiation of, okay, fine, we'll give it back to you, but who paid for
- 1:08:07those recordings?
- 1:08:08If we're the ones to pay for it, then give us an override royalty on the subsequent contract.
- 1:08:14Oh, and by the way, we paid you in advance.
- 1:08:17Since you want to terminate, you pay us back the advance.
- 1:08:21That becomes a fight that you then have to deal with because, you know what, you probably
- 1:08:26don't have that money anymore.
- 1:08:29And in order to get out, you can, you know, you're being asked to pay it back.
- 1:08:33But you know, you can mitigate that by adding pay or play language also saying, you know
- 1:08:38what, fine.
- 1:08:41At least if the pay or play language is sufficient to cover the advance that's already been paid
- 1:08:48out, then I don't have to pay anything back because that's my outclass.
- 1:08:53And I think, you know, that's as much as I'm going to provide today.
- 1:08:57Give you a couple of, we have one thing I want to mention, and I think there's one or
- 1:09:01two questions.
- 1:09:03Stems, I am in litigation right now over stems and I'm in settling another case involving
- 1:09:08the same thing.
- 1:09:09Stems are where the individual tracks that the record producer uses.
- 1:09:15And now what's happening is people, the talent or the record company or the entity placing
- 1:09:24music into film and TV wants all the ability to remix it and do it themselves.
- 1:09:29And in the case I represent producers and they're saying, I'm not giving you my toolbox.
- 1:09:34I'll give you some of the stuff, but not all of it.
- 1:09:37And it's unsettled overall.
- 1:09:38So that's something to be aware of at percolating.
- 1:09:43It says, do I have an opinion?
- 1:09:45Do we have an opinion of the Jams Entertainment and Sports Group?
- 1:09:47I think everybody at Jams is pretty talented.
- 1:09:50No, I have nothing negative to say about them.
- 1:09:54But again, there is the concern that they may be overly biased when it comes to situations
- 1:10:04involving major studios.
- 1:10:08Somebody mentions the Limp Bizkit versus UMG lawsuit where they didn't get royalties and
- 1:10:13the band is saying they should have gotten three million agreed.
- 1:10:18One person said it was missing persons that I referenced.
- 1:10:22That's absolutely right.
- 1:10:23Another person says, will there be any viable future musical copyright infringement cases
- 1:10:28in the wake of the Sharon decision?
- 1:10:30Yeah, sure.
- 1:10:31There always are going to be some and they can go both ways and you never really know.
- 1:10:36But he did, he was found or settled out on other cases overall.
- 1:10:41And I would say in my experience over the years, there's theft of idea, theft of music
- 1:10:46is commonplace.
- 1:10:48That's people who are executives don't advance and they get fired if they don't come up with
- 1:10:52good shows or good songs, etc.
- 1:10:57Now, there's even that case at UNI, where there's a writer that's trying to claim copyright
- 1:11:05infringement of an entire genre of music.
- 1:11:08So there's going to be cases out there.
- 1:11:12John, on the service of process by mail, I would add it's advisable to include a clause
- 1:11:19requiring courtesy copy sent by email, but should explicitly state that they do not constitute
- 1:11:25legal service.
- 1:11:26That's right.
- 1:11:27For AI point of possible resolution as if it will be used in AI, the parties have the
- 1:11:32right to revisit and negotiate the AI use.
- 1:11:35I say absolutely right.
- 1:11:37What's the best way for a law student to reach out with follow up questions after the seminar?
- 1:11:44I don't know, send them to John or me.
- 1:11:49All right, ladies and gentlemen, that was a very gratified week to do that.
- 1:11:56I hope you all appreciated it.
- 1:11:58And we look forward to seeing you down the line.
- 1:12:01Thanks John.
- 1:12:02Thanks BHBA.
- 1:12:03All the best.
- 1:12:04Thanks all.
- 1:12:06You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:12:08Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.