Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Minis - Zoomers memeing 9/11 too hard?
Transcript
- 0:00How are you feeling today, Taylor? Are you feeling
- 0:02good, bad? Pretty sure this is bad. Are you feeling
- 0:06uncertain, like an update? I'm feeling good.
- 0:09You're feeling good, hey? Yeah. Okay. This isn't
- 0:12feeling good. I'm not sure why it's in feeling
- 0:15good. Maybe you were feeling good at the time
- 0:17of reading. It may again call into question my
- 0:20filing system, but I'm just going to read it
- 0:23under the assumption this will actually be feeling
- 0:25good. This is from the Rolling Stone of all places
- 0:28titled How 9 -11 Became One of the Internet's
- 0:32Most Popular Memes by David Mack, September 9th,
- 0:352024. This is old. A 21 year old college student
- 0:40was sitting in an English class at her Minnesota
- 0:42school last week when her professor began talking
- 0:45about the challenges in writing about traumatic
- 0:48events. But when he used 9 -11 as an example
- 0:51and described to the class how hectic things
- 0:53seemed that day, she realized just how she felt
- 0:56or rather didn't feel about the attacks. Being
- 0:59terminally online is wild because someone mentioned
- 1:029 -11 in my class today and I genuinely forgot
- 1:05that not everyone thinks it's funny now. She
- 1:09subsequently wrote in a post on X formerly to
- 1:12favorited more than 10 ,000 times, quote, I had
- 1:16this moment of realization within myself that
- 1:19this should be having an impact on me and it
- 1:21weirdly isn't end quote. Olivia recalled to Rolling
- 1:25Stone asking that her last name not be used due
- 1:27to the sensitivities around 9 11. She has since
- 1:30taken down the tweet, quote, I think it's been
- 1:33watered down a lot for our generation. moment
- 1:36of levity, this very heavy moment. For our generation,
- 1:40it's very almost casual." Olivia is not alone.
- 1:44To be on social media in 2024 is to be swimming
- 1:47in jokes and memes about 9 -11. Things that might
- 1:51once have been whispered among friends are now
- 1:53shared by meme accounts with hundreds of thousands
- 1:55of followers. On TikTok, videos contrasting the
- 1:59year 2024 with 2001, often ending with someone
- 2:02reacting to the plane's hitting towers, frequently
- 2:05went viral. Well on X, a famous photo of President
- 2:08George W Bush being informed by his chief of
- 2:11staff that the US was under attack is now frequently
- 2:15used to mock everything from Ozempic to JD Vance
- 2:18to the Drake Kendrick Lamar beef. Want to be
- 2:21overly dramatic about a minor event in your life?
- 2:24Why not use a video or gif of Caitlyn Jenner
- 2:27standing in a sea of American flags solemnly
- 2:30saying 9 -11? or you could keep things simple
- 2:33and just say this was my 9 -11." As the world
- 2:37marks 23 years since the attacks, the ways in
- 2:40which people talk and joke about the tragedy
- 2:42have evolved dramatically, especially on the
- 2:45internet. For some people, the passage of time
- 2:47has reduced the trauma associated with it and
- 2:49allowed them to feel more comfortable using humor
- 2:52to process the past two decades in a different
- 2:54light. For other younger Gen Z internet users,
- 2:58black comedy is a tool they use to discuss something
- 3:00they've only ever read about in history books.
- 3:04Social media, which didn't exist at the time
- 3:05of the attacks, has also given rise to a digital
- 3:08space for these jokes that is steeped in irony,
- 3:11rewards outrageous humour, and encourages others
- 3:14to join the trend. The few 9 -11 memes in the
- 3:17past decade mostly involved mocking conspiracy
- 3:20theorists such as Jetfuel, Camp Meltz, Beats…
- 3:23damn it, that was a really important quote when
- 3:26I fucked it up. Quote, jet fuel can't melt steel
- 3:29beams and quote or Bush did 9 11, both of which
- 3:32surged in usage around 2015. These gags drew
- 3:36their shock value humor by juxtaposing something
- 3:39innocent with something extreme, like when the
- 3:42words were frosted onto a cake or said by a cartoon
- 3:45pony. That's one of my favorite cartoon pony
- 3:47things. Jet fuel can't melt steel beams. I do
- 3:51like that one. It goes on and on and on. Obviously
- 3:54you get the idea of what it's talking about.
- 3:56I just thought it was kind of interesting and
- 4:00it kind of comments on the place we are culturally.
- 4:03It's an interesting space. Does it talk about
- 4:06where we are as X users culturally? Because that's
- 4:11that's where it draws back to as opposed on X.
- 4:14it does and x from what i hear about what goes
- 4:17on there is not a place that i want to be a part
- 4:19of so it could very much be that it could also
- 4:23be i don't know why the media still treat it
- 4:25as like a real place that has real things going
- 4:28on it has hit a shithole that needs to just like
- 4:33We need to stop treating it like that's where
- 4:35everybody is because it's just where the racist
- 4:37people are for the most part Oh, it's so true.
- 4:40And I don't also know if it's what are these
- 4:43gen z's? Uh, those would be gen z's. Yeah zoomers.
- 4:46I don't know. Maybe they're you know Twitter
- 4:50users to do things like this. I don't know could
- 4:53be a lot of things that the commentary is on
- 4:55but to be fair I don't think you can connect
- 4:57to the George Bush meme of him being informed
- 5:00or reading like a kid's storybook Directly to
- 5:02like this weird joke about 9 -eleven that meme
- 5:06speaks for itself. It's great No, I don't think
- 5:08it would be the same thing as like meme of like
- 5:10the plane flying into the building. Yeah, but
- 5:14I mean, you look at things that happen. No, I
- 5:18mean, there's some things I probably wouldn't
- 5:20do a meme about, but some things I might have
- 5:22happened long enough ago, depending on what it
- 5:25was. Yeah. I mean, like, yeah, the death of 3000
- 5:28people is a hard one to meme about even today.
- 5:32And you know what I think about that. And I'm
- 5:34like trying to come up with an example. And all
- 5:35of a sudden I forgotten everything I know about
- 5:37history. There's not a lot of mass killings that
- 5:40seem meme worthy later on. Yeah. No, it really
- 5:43doesn't. than even though I can't think of any
- 5:45right now. I will thoroughly stand by George
- 5:48Bush reacting to being told about it is meme
- 5:51-worthy, not the thing itself. Oh yeah, totally
- 5:53different situation, I would say. Those are different
- 5:55things. I should use that more, definitely. Maybe
- 5:57I will. It is great, yeah. Maybe I'll forget
- 5:59about it, hard to say. It's Wednesday. Anyhow,
- 6:01you guys got 48 hours, forget about it. And maybe,
- 6:04I don't know, make a good George Bush meme. Those
- 6:06are coming in like hotcakes now. Oh yeah, yeah,
- 6:08send them to us, thanks. Okay, bye. Make our
- 6:11Wednesday better, bye.