Latest / Bloomberg Law / Sam Bankman-Fried's Historic Fraud Trial
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: The Sam Bankman, freed on trial in Manhattan Federal Court
- 0:13Speaker 2: looks different from the Sam Bankman freed that presided over
- 0:16Speaker 2: a crypto empire. Gone are the thick, unkempt curls that
- 0:20Speaker 2: became his trademark and the subject of a series of memes.
- 0:24Speaker 2: The baggy cargo shorts, the T shirts and sneakers. In
- 0:28Speaker 2: their place, a neat, close cut hairstyle reportedly done by
- 0:32Speaker 2: a fellow inmate, a navy business suit, dress shirt, tie
- 0:36Speaker 2: in shoes. A jury of nine women and three men
- 0:39Speaker 2: were sworn in today along with six alternates, and the
- 0:42Speaker 2: prosecution and defense laid out their cases for the jury
- 0:46Speaker 2: in opening statements. Joining me from the courthouse is Bloomberg
- 0:50Speaker 2: Legal reporter Ava Benny Morrison, who was in the courtroom today.
- 0:55Speaker 2: Did Sam Bankman freed look different from the way we've
- 0:58Speaker 2: seen him before his arrest?
- 1:00Speaker 3: Yes, definitely. That was one of the things that first
- 1:02Speaker 3: struck me when he walked in the courtroom. He looked
- 1:05Speaker 3: a lot thinner than he has in the past several months,
- 1:08Speaker 3: and his trademark hair was no longer it was cut
- 1:12Speaker 3: a lot shorter. You might remember he's always had this
- 1:15Speaker 3: very messy, curly head of hair. And the weight loss,
- 1:18Speaker 3: I guess has happened over the past several weeks when
- 1:21Speaker 3: he's been in the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklin. His
- 1:25Speaker 3: lawyers have complained that he's only been able to eat
- 1:28Speaker 3: peanut butter and bread and water because he's a vegan
- 1:30Speaker 3: and they don't have any meals that accommodate him. In
- 1:33Speaker 3: terms of his mannerism, he seemed pretty cool, calm and collected.
- 1:37Speaker 3: He engaged a lot with his lawyers. He was keeping
- 1:39Speaker 3: notes on his own laptop in a XL spreadsheet. He
- 1:43Speaker 3: was pointing at different potential jurors during the jury selection process.
- 1:46Speaker 3: He was having jokes and smiling with his lawyers. So
- 1:49Speaker 3: he seemed to be in a pretty good spirit.
- 1:50Speaker 2: And the jury tell us about the jury that was
- 1:53Speaker 2: finally selected.
- 1:54Speaker 3: The jury that was selected was nine women and three men.
- 1:59Speaker 3: Most of them are public service jobs worked for the government.
- 2:02Speaker 3: There is a train conductor on the jury, a retired
- 2:07Speaker 3: corrections officer who used to work in a prison, a
- 2:10Speaker 3: special ed teacher, someone who works at a hospital. So
- 2:14Speaker 3: it was a real mix, but it was a very
- 2:16Speaker 3: long process to get there.
- 2:18Speaker 2: The prosecution laid out its case in opening statements and
- 2:22Speaker 2: painted this picture of Sam Bankman Freed as a calculating criminal.
- 2:28Speaker 2: Tell us what struck you?
- 2:30Speaker 4: Yes?
- 2:30Speaker 3: The theme throughout the prosecution's opening address was that Sam
- 2:33Speaker 3: Bankman Freed single handedly orchestrated this multi billion dollar forward
- 2:38Speaker 3: at FTX, and that he tricked all of his customers
- 2:41Speaker 3: and investors and people who loan money to Alameda Research,
- 2:46Speaker 3: which was the hedge fund affiliated with FTX. They painted
- 2:49Speaker 3: him as this sort of criminal mastermind who woodwinked everyone
- 2:53Speaker 3: over many many years. They said that he only told
- 2:57Speaker 3: a few people within in a circle about the secret
- 3:01Speaker 3: borrowing relationship that existed between FTX and Alameda, and those
- 3:05Speaker 3: people were Caroline Ellison and Gary Wang and Nishad Scene. Now,
- 3:09Speaker 3: the prosecution didn't mention those three witnesses by name, but
- 3:13Speaker 3: we know that they are more than likely going to
- 3:15Speaker 3: testify against them.
- 3:17Speaker 2: Bankma Free at this trial, and the defense wants the
- 3:20Speaker 2: jury to see him as a math nerd.
- 3:22Speaker 5: Yes.
- 3:23Speaker 3: So the defense's response to what the prosecution's allegations were
- 3:27Speaker 3: that this is being spun to suit their case essentially,
- 3:32Speaker 3: and that he's just a math nerd who doesn't party,
- 3:35Speaker 3: doesn't drink, worked really hard, went to MIT and built
- 3:39Speaker 3: a multi billion dollar company and was extremely successful, and
- 3:42Speaker 3: that the loss of customer funds was partly due to
- 3:46Speaker 3: market downturns last year that were outside of his control
- 3:50Speaker 3: and also poor risk management at his company. There was
- 3:54Speaker 3: a bit of a hint in the defense statement. The
- 3:56Speaker 3: defense said that Sam Batemantrey trusted and relied on Carolina,
- 4:00Speaker 3: his ex girlfriend and the CEO of al Ameter Research
- 4:03Speaker 3: to one Alameda because he had taken a backward steps
- 4:06Speaker 3: from it a couple of years ago to really concentrate
- 4:08Speaker 3: on what was happening with FTX, But in hindsight, there
- 4:12Speaker 3: was some four risk management going on at the company.
- 4:16Speaker 3: And the defense also said that Sam had approached Caroline
- 4:21Speaker 3: in twenty twenty two when there were the market volatility
- 4:24Speaker 3: in the crypto industry and said, hey, I need you
- 4:27Speaker 3: to pedge the Alameda to protect against the possible market
- 4:32Speaker 3: downturns last year, and she didn't do that. The defense
- 4:34Speaker 3: didn't stay out right that you know, this is all
- 4:36Speaker 3: Caroline's fault, but there was certainly a flavor that she
- 4:41Speaker 3: may wear some of the blame in their case, so
- 4:44Speaker 3: you did get a little bit of a flavor of
- 4:46Speaker 3: a blank game going on here.
- 4:47Speaker 2: Did they call any witnesses today?
- 4:50Speaker 3: We heard from two witnesses. One was a customer of
- 4:53Speaker 3: FTX who lost more than one hundred thousand dollars. He
- 4:56Speaker 3: sort of explained how he signed up, what his expectation
- 5:00Speaker 3: who were in terms of what they would do with
- 5:02Speaker 3: his customer funds. And then we also heard from a
- 5:05Speaker 3: former STX developer who worked at the company for a
- 5:10Speaker 3: couple of years, was best friends with Sam growing up.
- 5:12Speaker 3: They went to MIT together and they lived in the
- 5:15Speaker 3: Bahamas with the thirty million dollar pen house together.
- 5:18Speaker 2: And finally, do you know what witnesses are coming up tomorrow?
- 5:21Speaker 3: Yes, we're going to continue hearing from the former STX
- 5:25Speaker 3: developer who testimony started today, and we're also going to
- 5:29Speaker 3: hear maybe from one of the cooperating witnesses, Gary Wong,
- 5:33Speaker 3: and the prostitution indicated this afternoon that he would be
- 5:36Speaker 3: one of two witnesses who would take the case till
- 5:39Speaker 3: the end of the week.
- 5:40Speaker 2: I know you're going to be in the courtroom tomorrow
- 5:42Speaker 2: as well, and we'll talk to you then. Thanks so much, Eva,
- 5:46Speaker 2: that's Bloomberg legal reporter Eva Benni Morrison coming up next
- 5:51Speaker 2: more analysis of the case against Sam Bankman Fried. I'm
- 5:54Speaker 2: Jim Grass when you're listening to Bloomberg. Joining me is
- 5:57Speaker 2: John George Aarres, a partner at the Warren Lage Group.
- 6:00Speaker 2: Before the prospective jurors came into the courtroom, the prosecutor
- 6:06Speaker 2: said that no plea discussions were ever held with Bankman Freed,
- 6:10Speaker 2: and no offers for a plea deal were made. They
- 6:14Speaker 2: made plea deals with three other top people at FTX
- 6:17Speaker 2: and Alameda. Do you find that odd that they didn't
- 6:20Speaker 2: offer Sam Bankman free to deal.
- 6:22Speaker 5: Typically the prosecutor's office will offer a deal, but I
- 6:28Speaker 5: think this case is unique because of the size of
- 6:31Speaker 5: the fraud. I mean, the crypto industry. This is easily
- 6:35Speaker 5: the largest fraud that's impacted it, and I think the
- 6:39Speaker 5: prosecutors have taken a very hard line position from the
- 6:42Speaker 5: first announcement of the indictment that they want to hold
- 6:47Speaker 5: Sam Bankman Freed responsible for what they're viewing as an
- 6:51Speaker 5: ady to one hundred billion dollar fraud, and the fact
- 6:56Speaker 5: that they didn't offer him a deal, and the fact
- 6:58Speaker 5: that they have three other individuals who were really at
- 7:02Speaker 5: the top of FPX, and they have Caroline Ellison who
- 7:05Speaker 5: was his former partner and also running Almata Research. They
- 7:10Speaker 5: must feel strongly that the evidence that's going to be
- 7:14Speaker 5: presented and the testimony that's going to be brought forward
- 7:17Speaker 5: is so powerful that they're going to be successful on
- 7:21Speaker 5: their claims. A prosecutor may head to their bets or
- 7:24Speaker 5: may notice some weaknesses in their case and say, what's
- 7:28Speaker 5: cut a deal? But I think a the unique nature
- 7:31Speaker 5: of this case and the size of the fraud, and
- 7:34Speaker 5: be the strength of the evidence they believe they have
- 7:37Speaker 5: has led to this result, which is no offer, no deal.
- 7:42Speaker 2: How much does the prosecution's case depend on the testimony
- 7:46Speaker 2: of those three cooperating witnesses you mentioned.
- 7:51Speaker 5: I think from the prosecutor's view, obviously someone needs to
- 7:54Speaker 5: tell the story, so they need these individuals to talk
- 7:59Speaker 5: about the impropriety that was going on with STX, and
- 8:03Speaker 5: really at the core of this is misuse of customer
- 8:06Speaker 5: funds and mining to customers. These are individual retail investors
- 8:11Speaker 5: that put their money into FDx and believe that the
- 8:15Speaker 5: money was being held there. The reality appears to be
- 8:18Speaker 5: much different. The reality appears to be that this money
- 8:22Speaker 5: was being used for many different things, including Sam Bagminfreed
- 8:27Speaker 5: buying properties for himself as well as making political contributions
- 8:31Speaker 5: and investing in our Nator research. I think there will
- 8:35Speaker 5: be enough documents to show the flow of funds, but
- 8:40Speaker 5: I do think that it's important for the individuals to
- 8:44Speaker 5: testify to stay and give context to the jury about
- 8:49Speaker 5: what the internal conversations were and what was happening in
- 8:53Speaker 5: this ecosystem and everything around it. So could they prove
- 8:57Speaker 5: the case solely based on documents and show the flow
- 8:59Speaker 5: of funds. I think that they could make a strong
- 9:02Speaker 5: case that these funds were exiting FTX and going to
- 9:05Speaker 5: places that they shouldn't have been. But it's obviously important
- 9:09Speaker 5: to them that these three individuals, Gary wang Nischad Singh
- 9:14Speaker 5: and Caroline Ellison all give context to that, and I
- 9:18Speaker 5: think that will be very important.
- 9:20Speaker 2: Caroline Ellison had an on again, off again romantic relationship
- 9:24Speaker 2: with bankman Freed. Does that complicate her testimony well?
- 9:29Speaker 5: From the defensi's point of view, it's very typical in
- 9:33Speaker 5: a way collar case to attack the credibility of the witnesses.
- 9:40Speaker 5: That will certainly be a part of their story. Potentially
- 9:44Speaker 5: they could say she's a scorned ex lover. She has
- 9:48Speaker 5: a motivation to say negative things about Sam Bankman Freed.
- 9:53Speaker 5: But in addition to that, they also have the plea deals,
- 9:57Speaker 5: and they're going to use those plea deals. This is
- 9:59Speaker 5: the they're going to use those free deals to say, Caroline,
- 10:05Speaker 5: you got a deal that is helping you avoid the
- 10:10Speaker 5: highest level of prosecution. You struck that deal, and you're
- 10:14Speaker 5: making these statements today not because they're truthful, but because
- 10:18Speaker 5: you basically saved yourself. So I think it's really two things.
- 10:23Speaker 5: But I do believe that their relationship is something they
- 10:26Speaker 5: can mine into and that the defense will probe and
- 10:30Speaker 5: say you are saying these things because your relationship with
- 10:35Speaker 5: Sam bankmin Free did not work out.
- 10:37Speaker 2: Can you explain you know what the prosecution is alleging
- 10:41Speaker 2: happened here.
- 10:42Speaker 5: Absolutely, So there's seven criminal charges. They're pretty broad, but
- 10:47Speaker 5: it's why are fraud securities, fraud, money laundering And there's
- 10:52Speaker 5: a couple different components. The first component is lying to
- 10:58Speaker 5: the retail investors, lying to them in that the funds
- 11:03Speaker 5: that they deposit on FTX would be made available to them.
- 11:06Speaker 5: They can make withdraws and transactions with the funds that
- 11:10Speaker 5: they deposited freely and as they chose to, but in
- 11:14Speaker 5: reality the funds that they had depositive were usurped for
- 11:19Speaker 5: Almada research. There were transfers of I think around eight
- 11:24Speaker 5: billion dollars ends up, for lack of a better word,
- 11:27Speaker 5: going missing. And this goes into the political donations that
- 11:32Speaker 5: Sambang and Freed made, This goes into Almada research, and
- 11:36Speaker 5: this goes into him buying personal properties for himself. So
- 11:40Speaker 5: one component is the lying to the investors, and then
- 11:44Speaker 5: there are other components which are lying to potential creditors
- 11:49Speaker 5: and lenders of FTX stating that the financial health of
- 11:53Speaker 5: FTX is completely fine, when in reality the funds that
- 11:58Speaker 5: are supposed to be held and FTX were no longer there.
- 12:02Speaker 5: So the core conduct is the same that all stems
- 12:06Speaker 5: out of the money that were deposited were essentially misappropriated
- 12:10Speaker 5: in use for other things, and that led to defrauding investors,
- 12:15Speaker 5: that led to defrauding lenders, and that led to essentially
- 12:19Speaker 5: money laundering and misappropriating funds for something that was other
- 12:24Speaker 5: than their intended use, which is an investment in FTX.
- 12:28Speaker 2: Prosecutors have something like fifty potential witnesses and they've produced
- 12:33Speaker 2: so far thirteen hundred exhibits ahead of trial. You know, cryptocurrency,
- 12:39Speaker 2: altering code, flow of money between FTX and Alameda financial transactions.
- 12:45Speaker 2: Is it a difficult case to keep simple enough or
- 12:48Speaker 2: interesting enough for a jury.
- 12:52Speaker 5: I think that the prosecution's focus will be on exactly
- 12:56Speaker 5: that keeping it simple. At the core of this case
- 13:02Speaker 5: crypto and the fact that it was crypto and that
- 13:04Speaker 5: it involves code, and that it's a new digital asset.
- 13:09Speaker 5: I believe it's something that they're going to try and minimize,
- 13:13Speaker 5: and they're just going to focus on what is a
- 13:16Speaker 5: traditional fraud. You lied to people about what you were
- 13:20Speaker 5: going to do with the money they entrusted you with, period,
- 13:25Speaker 5: You lied to lenders about the financial viability of the company. Period.
- 13:30Speaker 5: The defense will certainly try to put forward the story
- 13:35Speaker 5: that the terms in use of FTX gave them broad
- 13:38Speaker 5: latitude to move funds as they chose to fit, and
- 13:41Speaker 5: that maybe they didn't have proper risk management tools, but
- 13:45Speaker 5: it didn't arise to the level of fraud. So I
- 13:48Speaker 5: think the government has an interesting story from the perspective
- 13:52Speaker 5: of this is a huge sum of money, This is
- 13:55Speaker 5: a very public figure, and I believe that they'll be
- 13:58Speaker 5: able to boil it down to the base level of
- 14:01Speaker 5: the conduct that occurred here. However, that is a complication
- 14:04Speaker 5: that they faced. You know, I do believe that the
- 14:07Speaker 5: defense is going to put the spotlight on the complexity
- 14:11Speaker 5: of crypto and how maybe the jury should not treat
- 14:14Speaker 5: this as just a typical, normal financial transaction. But in
- 14:19Speaker 5: some I do think that the government will be able
- 14:22Speaker 5: to boil this down to a base level where a
- 14:24Speaker 5: jury can really understand what happened.
- 14:27Speaker 2: The judge has issued a number of pre trial rulings
- 14:30Speaker 2: that were setbacks for SBF, including revoking his bail and
- 14:35Speaker 2: jailing him. He ruled that bankmin Freed couldn't call seven
- 14:38Speaker 2: expert witnesses, and he made a decision this week that
- 14:42Speaker 2: his lawyers couldn't refer in the opening statements to the
- 14:45Speaker 2: advice of counsel defense, which they wanted to use to
- 14:49Speaker 2: show that bankman Freed didn't have criminal intent here and
- 14:53Speaker 2: was relying on the advice of his attorneys. How serious
- 14:57Speaker 2: are these setbacks?
- 14:58Speaker 5: These are fairly serious facts, the first one being revoking
- 15:02Speaker 5: bailn being put in prison, and that was because there
- 15:06Speaker 5: was alleged tampering of witnesses occurring in advance of trial.
- 15:11Speaker 5: So that shows that SBS is a bad actor trying
- 15:14Speaker 5: to influence the tropil ahead of time. And SDS has been,
- 15:18Speaker 5: probably much to his lawyers this day, very public about
- 15:22Speaker 5: saying things, very public about saying I messed up, that
- 15:26Speaker 5: people need to know the truth. He did, I believe,
- 15:29Speaker 5: a sixty minute interview on this. He really went out
- 15:33Speaker 5: and put himself in the public sphere and already made
- 15:35Speaker 5: a ton of statements that I'm sure the government is
- 15:39Speaker 5: going to use against him. But as for the pre
- 15:41Speaker 5: trial rulings, the judge is narrowing the case down to
- 15:45Speaker 5: what the relevant defenses are that can be presented, and
- 15:49Speaker 5: the fact that the judge struck down the reliance on
- 15:52Speaker 5: council defense. It's a very very powerful defense if you
- 15:56Speaker 5: are able to show that an individual well fully disclosed
- 16:01Speaker 5: what was happening to an attorney and that an attorney
- 16:04Speaker 5: rendered advice, and then the individual who gave him the
- 16:09Speaker 5: advice followed that punctiliously and went along with what the
- 16:13Speaker 5: lawyer said. What the judge's ruling indicates to me is
- 16:17Speaker 5: that there were likely some communications about what was happening,
- 16:22Speaker 5: but it didn't rise to the formal level of an
- 16:26Speaker 5: advice of council defense, which is very formulaic and it
- 16:30Speaker 5: has to be laid out clearly with evidence otherwise, you know,
- 16:34Speaker 5: anyone that had a passing conversation with an attorney would say,
- 16:37Speaker 5: or even an accountant would say, oh, well, I relied
- 16:40Speaker 5: on their advice, and that should exonerate me completely. It's
- 16:44Speaker 5: a blow for the defense because their story is getting
- 16:50Speaker 5: narrowed in advance of trial, and what they're going to
- 16:52Speaker 5: have to focus on most likely is that, yes, things
- 16:58Speaker 5: happen that may have been in proper from a business perspective,
- 17:02Speaker 5: but it did not rise to the level of criminal intent.
- 17:07Speaker 5: And looping back on one of our earlier questions, I
- 17:10Speaker 5: believe that's where the three witnesses that were formerly at
- 17:14Speaker 5: the top of SPX and Almeta, we'll be able to
- 17:17Speaker 5: give a lot of context into what those conversations were
- 17:20Speaker 5: between themselves and SBS.
- 17:23Speaker 2: The judge has left it open they can't refer to
- 17:26Speaker 2: the advice of council defense and opening statements, but later
- 17:30Speaker 2: on in the trial he may allow them to use it.
- 17:33Speaker 5: So what the judge is signaling is that formal defense
- 17:37Speaker 5: in order for it to be advanced. It's going to
- 17:40Speaker 5: have to be laid out through witnesses, through documents. Right,
- 17:43Speaker 5: there has to be an attorney client relationship in the
- 17:46Speaker 5: first instance. Then there has to be disclosure of what's
- 17:49Speaker 5: happening at STX. Then there has to be advice, and
- 17:53Speaker 5: then following that advice. So at this point, the judge
- 17:58Speaker 5: is likely not wanting to cloud the jury's mind with
- 18:03Speaker 5: evidence that has yet to come forward, and a defense counsel,
- 18:08Speaker 5: especially in a criminal trial, you want to be flexible
- 18:12Speaker 5: and you also want to play your cards close to
- 18:15Speaker 5: your chest. When it's time to reveal the evidence, you
- 18:19Speaker 5: start revealing it because burden in all these cases, right,
- 18:22Speaker 5: the burden of proof for a criminal prosecution is on
- 18:26Speaker 5: the government and they have to meet that burden of proof.
- 18:29Speaker 5: So when it comes time for the defense to lay
- 18:33Speaker 5: out what their narrative is, what their defenses are, the
- 18:37Speaker 5: judge appears to be giving them the opportunity to do that,
- 18:41Speaker 5: but they're saying, we haven't seen any of that. At
- 18:43Speaker 5: this stage, you don't get to just baldly refer to
- 18:47Speaker 5: an advice of counsel of defense without making the proper
- 18:50Speaker 5: evidentiary show.
- 18:52Speaker 2: Most defendants don't testify at their own trials. But how
- 18:55Speaker 2: likely do you think it is that he will take
- 18:57Speaker 2: the stand.
- 18:58Speaker 5: It's a very difficult question because he does have so
- 19:02Speaker 5: many prior statements out there, and he may need to
- 19:06Speaker 5: give them some context. He may need to make certain
- 19:10Speaker 5: things clear that when he was saying he messed up,
- 19:13Speaker 5: that he didn't have the intent to mess up. It
- 19:17Speaker 5: was just that he didn't have the proper risk controls
- 19:20Speaker 5: in place, you know, given the stakes that we have here,
- 19:23Speaker 5: right if SBS is convicted of these charges, the sentencing
- 19:27Speaker 5: guidelines provide that he could be in jail for I
- 19:30Speaker 5: mean over one hundred years, so with his life on
- 19:34Speaker 5: the line. Essentially, it may come a time after the
- 19:37Speaker 5: government presents their case, which it appears it's going to
- 19:40Speaker 5: take them about a month in total. You had mentioned
- 19:44Speaker 5: the amount of documents that are out there, the amount
- 19:46Speaker 5: of witnesses that they might profer for the hearing, It'll
- 19:49Speaker 5: take them about a month to lay it out, and
- 19:52Speaker 5: then based on the nature of that testimony, if they
- 19:56Speaker 5: feel the defense Council feels that they can put SBF
- 20:01Speaker 5: on the stand and have him contextualize or explain some
- 20:06Speaker 5: things in a better way. They may call him, but
- 20:09Speaker 5: there's a huge risk in doing that, because if you
- 20:12Speaker 5: call the defendant as a witness, you are opening up
- 20:16Speaker 5: them to cross examination on everything that they testified about,
- 20:20Speaker 5: and that might be a moment for the government to
- 20:23Speaker 5: really go at SBF and damage him and put the
- 20:27Speaker 5: nail on the proverbial caulsin.
- 20:29Speaker 6: For his case.
- 20:31Speaker 5: So it's a very very difficult question, and you've rightly
- 20:34Speaker 5: pointed out that a defendant rarely testifies in their own case.
- 20:41Speaker 2: For SBS, this is freedom on the line for the prosecutors.
- 20:46Speaker 2: What's at stake.
- 20:47Speaker 5: It's extremely important because they are staking their credibility. They
- 20:54Speaker 5: are staking the regulatory environment of the crypto industry. On
- 20:59Speaker 5: this case, FTX before the collapse was the darling of
- 21:05Speaker 5: the crypto industry. We have individual celebrities like Tom Brady
- 21:11Speaker 5: endorsing them. They were all over Super Bowl at they
- 21:15Speaker 5: were very had a huge public profile. So when the
- 21:19Speaker 5: government takes on a case like this, it's a heavy
- 21:22Speaker 5: burden for them. They have shown to the public, or
- 21:25Speaker 5: made allegations to the public that this was a resoundingly
- 21:29Speaker 5: large fraud and that there are issues with the crypto
- 21:32Speaker 5: industry and the people that are operating it. And this
- 21:35Speaker 5: also sends a message to the crypto industry in general,
- 21:38Speaker 5: which is you will be prosecuted under the laws that
- 21:41Speaker 5: we have in place if you do not follow them.
- 21:44Speaker 5: So this is a major pressure for the government to
- 21:48Speaker 5: get this right, which is why I think they're going
- 21:51Speaker 5: to go through an extremely detailed and lengthy presentation. Four
- 21:56Speaker 5: weeks of putting on evidence in and of itself showed
- 22:00Speaker 5: how much evidence that they have and how seriously they're
- 22:03Speaker 5: taking this. So it is a big task for the government.
- 22:07Speaker 5: I'm not sure that it's a huge risk because they
- 22:10Speaker 5: seem fairly comfortable with the evidence that they have, but
- 22:14Speaker 5: obviously if SBF is exonerated and he's found not guilty
- 22:19Speaker 5: on these charges, it is a major blow to the government.
- 22:22Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show. That's John
- 22:24Speaker 2: George Aris, a partner at the Warren Law Group. Coming
- 22:27Speaker 2: up next, the Supreme Court appears ready to reject a
- 22:31Speaker 2: challenge to the Consumer Financial Protection Board. You're listening to Bloomberg.
- 22:35Speaker 2: The fate of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau was at
- 22:39Speaker 2: stake in a case asking the Supreme Court to declare
- 22:42Speaker 2: its funding system unconstitutional. But justice is across the ideological
- 22:47Speaker 2: Spectrum seemed to be struggling with that argument.
- 22:51Speaker 7: Is there not in the Constitution? Where do we get
- 22:53Speaker 7: I don't understand.
- 22:53Speaker 2: We can't just suddenly decide that things are troubling without
- 22:57Speaker 2: some kind of legal reference point.
- 23:00Speaker 7: Well, I'm trying to understand your argument that I'm a
- 23:04Speaker 7: total loss.
- 23:05Speaker 8: The word perpetual I'm having trouble with because it implies
- 23:10Speaker 8: that it's entrenched and that a future Congress couldn't change it,
- 23:14Speaker 8: but Congress could change it tomorrow.
- 23:17Speaker 1: This is the standard be Is it like an intelligible
- 23:20Speaker 1: principle of money spent? I mean, I think we're all
- 23:23Speaker 1: struggling to figure out, then, what's the standard that you
- 23:26Speaker 1: would use and just assuming that you're right.
- 23:28Speaker 2: Unlike most federal agencies, the CFPB, the federal government's consumer
- 23:34Speaker 2: financial watchdog, doesn't rely on the annual budget process in Congress. Instead,
- 23:40Speaker 2: it's funded directly by the Federal Reserve. But the Solicitor
- 23:43Speaker 2: General told the justices that the CFPB was indistinguishable from
- 23:48Speaker 2: many other federal agencies, including ones that date back to
- 23:52Speaker 2: the country's founding, and both liberal and conservative justices seem
- 23:57Speaker 2: to agree. Here are Justices Elena Kagan, Clarence Thomas.
- 24:01Speaker 7: Annual line item appropriations. We're some appropriations, but massively not
- 24:08Speaker 7: all appropriations, and so you're just flying in the face
- 24:11Speaker 7: of two hundred and fifty years of history.
- 24:14Speaker 4: I get your point that this is different, that it's unique,
- 24:17Speaker 4: that it's odd that they've never gone this far, but
- 24:21Speaker 4: that's not having gone as far is not a constitutional problem?
- 24:26Speaker 2: Joining me is Harold Krant, a professor at the Chicago
- 24:28Speaker 2: Kent College of Law, tell us about the question in
- 24:31Speaker 2: the case. It's based on the appropriations clause of the Constitution.
- 24:36Speaker 6: The propation clause in the Constitution is situated in Article one.
- 24:40Speaker 6: It's one of Congress's great powers to conteract any kind
- 24:44Speaker 6: of presidential overreach, because the president can't do anything or
- 24:48Speaker 6: the exectu bridge can't do anything unless Congress gives it
- 24:51Speaker 6: the money to perform certain functions. And the clause itself
- 24:55Speaker 6: says that no money shall be drawn from the treasury
- 24:57Speaker 6: but in consequence of appropriations by law law. And the
- 25:01Speaker 6: question that was raised in the case is does appropriations
- 25:04Speaker 6: by loss imply every year appropriations does it imply a
- 25:09Speaker 6: strict amount of money? Because in this case, under the
- 25:13Speaker 6: twenty ten law that created the agency, Congress gave it
- 25:18Speaker 6: an open ended funding mechanism which should actually be drawn
- 25:22Speaker 6: from another agency, the FED and the FED and the
- 25:26Speaker 6: amount of money that the CFPB could use the maximums
- 25:30Speaker 6: twelve percent of the Fed's budget. So the argument was
- 25:35Speaker 6: this is somewhat of an unusual appropriations decision. The fact
- 25:39Speaker 6: that Congress decided what the funding mechanism means is that enough.
- 25:44Speaker 6: And that's what the debate really was about in the
- 25:47Speaker 6: Supreme Court, and both sides had a hard time finding
- 25:50Speaker 6: some kind of line to draw to distinguish permissible congressional
- 25:54Speaker 6: appropriations from impermissible ones.
- 25:57Speaker 2: Justices on both sides seemed to be generally confused by
- 26:02Speaker 2: the arguments by former US Listener General Noel Francisco on
- 26:06Speaker 2: behalf of the trade associations, and.
- 26:08Speaker 6: Understandably because they were searching for some kind of intelligible
- 26:13Speaker 6: principle to use that term that they could use in
- 26:16Speaker 6: order to side with those attacking the CSPB, and there
- 26:21Speaker 6: was no intelligible principle. I mean, the former Stalist general
- 26:24Speaker 6: reached out for some factors that there's no real cap
- 26:27Speaker 6: in this case, no real cap of how much money
- 26:29Speaker 6: that can be spent. I mean that's not exactly true,
- 26:32Speaker 6: but I understand what he was saying. There's also no
- 26:34Speaker 6: time duration, meaning that with Congress doesn't act, the agency
- 26:39Speaker 6: bcves this money year after year. And finally, it's true
- 26:42Speaker 6: that this case is different is because another agency distributes
- 26:46Speaker 6: the money as opposed to Congress directly. But this former
- 26:50Speaker 6: Salister General couldn't say which one of these factors was
- 26:53Speaker 6: the most important. He basically said, well, this is sweet, generous.
- 26:57Speaker 6: All three of these things are going on in this case.
- 27:00Speaker 6: He also added sort of a subsidiary point that there's
- 27:04Speaker 6: no sort of market check on what the CFPB does.
- 27:08Speaker 6: They can just keep getting more and more money and
- 27:10Speaker 6: nobody will be upset by it because it's hidden through
- 27:13Speaker 6: the FED. And what the Justice is said, well, well,
- 27:17Speaker 6: where's the line. How do we apply this in the future.
- 27:20Speaker 6: Give us some kind of understanding about which is the
- 27:22Speaker 6: most important point, because if we take one and strictly,
- 27:26Speaker 6: the entire country fall apart. Because Congress has been giving
- 27:30Speaker 6: this kind of appropriation to one form or another. One
- 27:33Speaker 6: of these factors has been present in countless appropriations throughout history.
- 27:38Speaker 2: The decision came out of the ultra conservative Fifth Circuit
- 27:43Speaker 2: from a panel of three Trump appointed judges, and that
- 27:47Speaker 2: Circuit seems to be trying to push the envelope in
- 27:52Speaker 2: many cases that the Supreme Court is taking this term.
- 27:55Speaker 2: In other words, here this was a novel argument to
- 27:57Speaker 2: bas this on the appropriations clause.
- 28:00Speaker 6: I sense that the Court may be moderating slightly and
- 28:05Speaker 6: that it sort of understands that because of the signals
- 28:08Speaker 6: that is given in past cases, there are lower court
- 28:11Speaker 6: judges who are becoming more and more adventurous as the
- 28:14Speaker 6: ones in the Fifth Circuit. And there may be a
- 28:17Speaker 6: residual feeling not in all the justices, but in some
- 28:20Speaker 6: that that just goes too far, that you have to
- 28:23Speaker 6: have some kind of principled decision backed by history, which
- 28:27Speaker 6: in other context is very important to the court, and
- 28:30Speaker 6: this simply doesn't exist in this case. So it seems
- 28:34Speaker 6: relatively clear, though not for sure, of course, that the
- 28:37Speaker 6: Court will rebuff the Fifth Circuit saying that it went
- 28:40Speaker 6: just too far, because it'd be incredibly difficult to craft
- 28:43Speaker 6: an opinion that wouldn't jeopardize countless other agencies. I mean,
- 28:48Speaker 6: just give a couple of examples. The Post Office gets
- 28:51Speaker 6: to enlarge its budget depending upon what it brings in
- 28:54Speaker 6: with postal fees, as does any federal agency that relies
- 28:57Speaker 6: upon permit systems, and the Custom's Office was structured that
- 29:02Speaker 6: way as well. And the Congress has made sort of
- 29:05Speaker 6: perpetual delegations to fill Social Security checks every year, and
- 29:10Speaker 6: it doesn't have to re up those every year. So
- 29:12Speaker 6: each of these factors that the challengers raised exist in
- 29:18Speaker 6: many fundamental statutes. So it's very difficult, and the Court
- 29:21Speaker 6: is aware that if they try to draw aline it
- 29:24Speaker 6: may jeopardize very basics of executive branch government.
- 29:28Speaker 2: At stake is really every regulation and enforcement action the
- 29:33Speaker 2: CFPB has taken since its beginning, and organizations representing the
- 29:37Speaker 2: mortgage industry, housing industry, and realtors warn the court of
- 29:41Speaker 2: the potentially catastrophic consequences of a broad decision, saying that
- 29:46Speaker 2: it could set off a wave of challenges and the
- 29:48Speaker 2: housing market could descend into chaos to the detriment of
- 29:52Speaker 2: all mortgage borrowers.
- 29:54Speaker 6: The actual challenge was to a payday loan, and if
- 29:57Speaker 6: the Court focused only on knocking on the payday loan rule,
- 30:02Speaker 6: then the markets would not be rattled. But the concern
- 30:05Speaker 6: is realist. What's the remedy's going to be? It's hard
- 30:08Speaker 6: to conceive of what the Court could do if it
- 30:12Speaker 6: found this appropriation's defect. Would it make up an appropriation
- 30:16Speaker 6: from Congress? Would it say the entire statues unconstitutional and
- 30:20Speaker 6: send it back to Congress to decide what to do.
- 30:22Speaker 6: And if they did that, what's going to govern the
- 30:24Speaker 6: mortgage industry and their interim? And that was the concern. Now.
- 30:27Speaker 6: The good news is that no Justice during the Soter
- 30:31Speaker 6: General's argument, asked her what she thought about the appropriate remedy.
- 30:35Speaker 6: That might be another signal that the Court is not
- 30:38Speaker 6: going to hold this unconstitutional. There was some discussion later
- 30:42Speaker 6: with the challengers about what remedy they seek, but it's
- 30:46Speaker 6: very difficult to craft a remedy without roiling both the
- 30:50Speaker 6: mortgage and the credit markets, not to mention jeopardizing lump
- 30:53Speaker 6: sum appropriations to other industries and so forth.
- 30:56Speaker 2: Even Justice Clarence Thomas made a state meant that it
- 31:00Speaker 2: didn't seem unconstitutional. Defenders of the CFPB were worried about
- 31:05Speaker 2: this case. It was seen as the most significant test
- 31:09Speaker 2: of the agency's thirteen year existence. It's been before the
- 31:13Speaker 2: Court before in twenty twenty. Tell us what happened then?
- 31:16Speaker 6: Yeah, the earlier case challenged in some ways, the very
- 31:20Speaker 6: existence of the agency is on the ground that it
- 31:23Speaker 6: had an unconstitutional structure in that there was only one
- 31:26Speaker 6: director of this agency, and the Court felt that because
- 31:31Speaker 6: it was just a single member at the head of
- 31:33Speaker 6: the agency, that the agency would be too independent of
- 31:36Speaker 6: presidential supervision. And even though there are some agencies also
- 31:42Speaker 6: having only one head, most of our independent agencies have
- 31:46Speaker 6: three or five people at the head, which dilutes the authority,
- 31:50Speaker 6: according to the Court, of any one individual commissioner or
- 31:54Speaker 6: director of an agency. So in the former case, in
- 31:57Speaker 6: some of law case, the Court also had a remedial question.
- 32:02Speaker 6: It could have punted the whole thing back to Congress,
- 32:05Speaker 6: and the Congress restructure the CFPB as it chose fit.
- 32:09Speaker 6: What it did was it gave the President the power
- 32:11Speaker 6: to remove the head of the agency at will as
- 32:14Speaker 6: a remedy. But the remedy that would have been just
- 32:16Speaker 6: as logical would have been to say that there are
- 32:19Speaker 6: now three members on the CFPB and then allow the
- 32:22Speaker 6: President to appoint two others, because that would have gotten
- 32:26Speaker 6: rid of the constitutional flaw that the Court identified.
- 32:30Speaker 2: What was the Fifth Circuit's remedy. Would the remedy have
- 32:33Speaker 2: been to dismantle the CFPB because there wouldn't have been funding.
- 32:37Speaker 6: So the remedy wasn't clear under the Fifth Circuit's decision. Certainly,
- 32:43Speaker 6: what the Court indicated was that the payday loan rules,
- 32:47Speaker 6: which were challenged in this case, they would have been
- 32:49Speaker 6: held unconstitutional. The question that, of course, would have been,
- 32:52Speaker 6: if just the payday loans rules were held unconstitutional, well,
- 32:56Speaker 6: what would happen to every other rule that was issued
- 32:59Speaker 6: by the agency With this is just ushered the stampede
- 33:02Speaker 6: to the court that no matter what kind of action
- 33:04Speaker 6: there was challenging enforcement action, a rule or whatever that
- 33:08Speaker 6: the agency issued, that the courts then falling fascifred president
- 33:12Speaker 6: would have had to knock those down as unconstitutional as well.
- 33:16Speaker 2: This is one of several cases coming before the Court
- 33:18Speaker 2: this term that challenge agency authority attack on the administrative state.
- 33:25Speaker 2: Do these CFPB arguments indicate that the conservative justices might
- 33:30Speaker 2: not go as far as conservatives who are against big
- 33:34Speaker 2: government might want, or is it just based on the
- 33:37Speaker 2: facts of this case?
- 33:38Speaker 6: Well, the Court ushered in all of these cases by
- 33:42Speaker 6: signaling that it was re examining the very sort of
- 33:45Speaker 6: accepted basis of the administrative state that's existed for in
- 33:48Speaker 6: some ways for seventy five years, in some ways since
- 33:50Speaker 6: our nation's history. So the Court has invited these kinds
- 33:53Speaker 6: of challenges, and I think now that so many challenges
- 33:56Speaker 6: are taking place, and course, like the Fifth Circuit or
- 33:59Speaker 6: chopping at the bid to pare down the authority of
- 34:02Speaker 6: executive branch officials, the Court is going to have to
- 34:05Speaker 6: make a tough call about where to draw the line.
- 34:08Speaker 6: Even though this case would have had tremendous significance and
- 34:11Speaker 6: still could if the agency loses. There's another case that's
- 34:15Speaker 6: penning and hasn't been set for a argument yet, the
- 34:17Speaker 6: Jocracy case, which itself has incredible seeds of doing great
- 34:23Speaker 6: mischief to the administrative state because they're both raised and
- 34:26Speaker 6: non delegation argument, which would limit the authority of agencies
- 34:31Speaker 6: to interpret broad congressional statutes in ways that they have
- 34:35Speaker 6: to as an everyday basis. But the other argument is
- 34:38Speaker 6: given is that agencies can no longer go before agencies
- 34:42Speaker 6: to bring most enforcement actions, but rather have to proceed
- 34:46Speaker 6: in court with a jury trial, which would take an
- 34:49Speaker 6: immense amount of time and money and lose the ability
- 34:53Speaker 6: of an expert tribunal to understand the facts of the case.
- 34:57Speaker 6: So if those arguments are held by the court, and
- 35:00Speaker 6: that's this circuit challenge, that would be again a shoe
- 35:04Speaker 6: tectonic shift in terms of a loss of agency, flexibility
- 35:08Speaker 6: and power.
- 35:09Speaker 2: Thanks for joining me, Hal. That's Professor Harold Krant of
- 35:11Speaker 2: the Chicago Kent College of Law. And that's it for
- 35:14Speaker 2: this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can
- 35:17Speaker 2: always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 35:20Speaker 2: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 35:24Speaker 2: www dot bloomberg dot com slash podcast Slash Law, And
- 35:29Speaker 2: remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight
- 35:32Speaker 2: at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and
- 35:35Speaker 2: you're listening to Bloomberg