Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / How Warren Buffett Lower Cost Basis by Selling Options
Transcript
- 0:00Have you noticed the the absolute explosion in options
- 0:03trading this year? I mean, here we are in 2026 and
- 0:06it genuinely feels like everyone in their neighbor is trading
- 0:09zero day options while waiting in line for coffee.
- 0:12Oh absolutely. It is literally everywhere you
- 0:14look. Right.
- 0:15You pull up your phone, you see these massive AI stocks
- 0:19swinging, you know, 5, maybe 8% in a single trading session.
- 0:23And there is this flood of retail traders just diving head
- 0:26first into the volatility. Yeah, trying to make a bazillion
- 0:28dollars by tomorrow afternoon. Exactly.
- 0:30And when you look at it from the outside, it sounds exactly like
- 0:34a casino. Just pure unadulterated
- 0:37gambling. It really does.
- 0:38But what if I told you that the most disciplined, cautious value
- 0:41investors in the world, we're talking people operating
- 0:43directly in Warren Buffett's orbit, use those exact same
- 0:46financial instruments to do the complete opposite?
- 0:48They're using options to actually lower their risk.
- 0:50It is a massive paradigm shift. I mean, when most people hear
- 0:53the word options, they immediately picture someone
- 0:56leveraging their life savings to bet the farm on an earnings
- 0:58report. Yeah, a total gamble.
- 1:00But the reality of how the ultra successful value investors use
- 1:04these contracts is entirely defensive.
- 1:07It's methodical, it's risk averse, and yet it's incredibly
- 1:10lucrative. And that is exactly the mission
- 1:13of our Deep dive. Today.
- 1:14We are pulling apart a master class from Investor Fill Town,
- 1:17and we're going to look at how to flip this entire options game
- 1:20upside down. Yeah, we're going to explore how
- 1:22you can use options to get paid cold hard cash while you are
- 1:26literally just sitting around waiting to buy a stock you
- 1:28already want. Right at a price that you
- 1:30dictate. But before we get into the
- 1:32mechanics of how to do this, I have a quick heads up for you on
- 1:35where to find the tools you'll need to access more advanced
- 1:37researches. Follow Guru's latest movement
- 1:40and leverage our latest Deep Values agents.
- 1:43Welcome to download Deep Values APP from App Store to track
- 1:46stock market temperature. Welcome to download iOS app
- 1:49Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store or Bubble Watch from
- 1:53Google Play. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 1:56on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 1:59or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 2:02is for research and entertainment purposes only and
- 2:05does not constitute any investment or financial advice
- 2:07or service. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:10before making investment financial decisions.
- 2:12And you know that context is actually vital because what we
- 2:15are about to discuss requires rigorous due diligence.
- 2:18This isn't a get rich quick scheme at.
- 2:20All No, definitely not. It's a structural approach to
- 2:22capital allocation. So let's start with the reality
- 2:24check because the stats on retail options trading right now
- 2:27are just brutal. We need to look at why most
- 2:29people lose at this game. Brutal is genuinely an
- 2:31understatement. If we look at the data, and this
- 2:34is aggregated from broker regulatory data industry
- 2:36surveys, the grim reality is that only about 10% of options
- 2:41traders make money over time. Wait, only 10%?
- 2:44So 90% of the people playing this game are consistently
- 2:47bleeding out their accounts. Yes, 90%.
- 2:50And if you narrow that focus down to day trading, which is
- 2:52heavily fueled by all the short term options speculation we're
- 2:55seeing right now, the numbers get so much worse.
- 2:58I almost don't want to ask, but what are we talking about here?
- 3:00Over a five year period, only 1% of day traders make money, 99%
- 3:06lose. Oh wow.
- 3:07Yeah, and Finera, the private SEC regulator, reports that 72%
- 3:11of people lose money in year 1 alone doing this kind of
- 3:14trading. That is staggering. 72% wash out
- 3:17in just 12 months. Yes.
- 3:19And we have to ask the mechanical question, right?
- 3:20Like why? Why is the failure rate
- 3:23astronomical? Well, I guess it's the way
- 3:25they're trading. Exactly.
- 3:27It's because the vast majority of retail traders are buying
- 3:30options. When you buy an option, as Phil
- 3:33Tom points out in his material, you are placing a very specific,
- 3:36very difficult bet. You're betting on direction.
- 3:39Right correction, yes, but also timing options are essentially
- 3:43melting ice cubes. They expire.
- 3:46So they don't just have to be right about the stock going up
- 3:49or down, they have to be right. And they have to be right right
- 3:52now, before the ice cube melts. Precisely.
- 3:54You are paying money upfront for the privilege of hoping the
- 3:57stock moves exactly how you predicted before a literal clock
- 4:01runs out. And if it doesn't?
- 4:02If the stock stays flat, the ice cube melts and you lose.
- 4:05If the stock moves the right way, but it takes a month longer
- 4:08than you thought it would, you still lose the element of time
- 4:11decay, what options traders call Theta.
- 4:14It just eats you alive. OK, let's unpack this.
- 4:16Because retail traders buying these out of the money options
- 4:19are essentially buying expensive lottery tickets with hard
- 4:22expiration dates. Yes, exactly.
- 4:24So to stop losing, the answer isn't to spend all our time
- 4:27researching how to buy slightly better lottery tickets.
- 4:29We need to become the gas stations selling them right?
- 4:32That is precisely the shift the Warren Buffett or Rule hashtag.
- 4:36One strategy, as Phil Towne calls it, is to always be the
- 4:40seller. You want to be the casino.
- 4:42You want to be the insurance company.
- 4:43Because the casino doesn't fight the clock.
- 4:45Right when you sell an option, you aren't the one fighting
- 4:49time. You are the one collecting the
- 4:50premium upfront. The person buying the lottery
- 4:53ticket hands you cash immediately.
- 4:55I mean, I like the sound of immediate cash in my pocket, but
- 4:58there has to be a catch. What am I giving them in return?
- 5:01Well, in exchange for that cash, you take on a contractual
- 5:04obligation. You promise to do something.
- 5:07OK, that sounds a little risky. It does, but the secret sauce,
- 5:10the reason this works for value investors, is that you only ever
- 5:14take on an obligation that you actively want to take on.
- 5:17You are getting paid to promise to do something you are already
- 5:20planning to do for free. I see how this works in theory,
- 5:23but to really grasp how we become the casino, we need to
- 5:26translate this Wall Street jargon into plain English.
- 5:30Absolutely. The source material uses this
- 5:32incredible metaphor about a golf course house to explain a call
- 5:36option, and it just makes the mechanics click so perfectly.
- 5:40It's a brilliant way to visualize it without getting
- 5:42bogged down in stock tickers and strike prices, right?
- 5:45So imagine you own a house sitting right on a beautiful
- 5:47golf course. It's worth about $1 million.
- 5:50You're just chilling in your living room.
- 5:51And one day, some guy in a sharp suit knocks on your front door.
- 5:55OK, I'm picturing it. He says I'd like the right to
- 5:58buy your house sometime in the next year for $1.5 million and
- 6:03to secure that right, I'll pay you $20,000 in cash today.
- 6:07Now you have to ask why is he doing that?
- 6:09He isn't being charitable. Right.
- 6:11What's his angle? He's an investor betting that a
- 6:13commercial developer is going to come in, plow over the golf
- 6:16course, build a massive luxury shopping center, and suddenly
- 6:19your house will be worth 2.5 million.
- 6:22He wants to lock in the right to buy it from you at 1.5 million
- 6:25so he can flip it. OK, So what does this all mean
- 6:27for you, the homeowner? Let's say you like your house,
- 6:30but for 1.5 million you happily pack your bags.
- 6:34You take the deal. Yep, you sign the paper.
- 6:36You put that 20 grand in your pocket today.
- 6:38Fast forward a year. If the developer comes and the
- 6:42guy exercises his right to buy your house for 1.5 million, you
- 6:45win. You got half a million over your
- 6:48current value, plus the 20 grand you already pocketed.
- 6:50Exactly but. What if the developer never
- 6:52shows up and the guy in the suit just walks away?
- 6:54The contract just expired. Right.
- 6:56You still have your $1,000,000 house, you don't have to move,
- 6:59and you still have that extra 20 grand in your pocket.
- 7:01Where's the downside? Well, that's the beauty of it.
- 7:03But let me push back here for a second, because this sounds a
- 7:05little too perfect. What if the housing market
- 7:08completely crashes? What if a giant sinkhole opens
- 7:11up on the golf course and the house is suddenly worth
- 7:14$500,000? That is the crucial distinction.
- 7:17If a sinkhole opens up, yes, your house loses value.
- 7:20But that was going to happen whether you sold the option or
- 7:22not. That is the risk of ownership,
- 7:25not the risk of the option strategy.
- 7:27Oh, I see. In fact, if the sinkhole opens,
- 7:29you are actually $20,000 richer than you would have been if you
- 7:32hadn't talked to the guy in the suit.
- 7:34The premium you collected acted as a small buffer against your
- 7:38losses. That makes total sense.
- 7:40The option didn't create the risk.
- 7:43The asset itself holds the risk and by selling the option I
- 7:47actually reduced my downside by 20 grand.
- 7:49Precisely in this scenario, the guy in the suit is the option
- 7:52buyer. He's making that highly
- 7:53leveraged, time sensitive bet on the developer showing up.
- 7:57And you, the homeowner, are the option seller.
- 8:00Right, you collected the premium.
- 8:02In Wall Street terms, this is a call option because the guy is
- 8:05paying for the right to call the asset away from you.
- 8:07And the crazy thing is, you don't have to wait for a guy in
- 8:10a suit to knock on your door. You can just do this online.
- 8:12Yeah, you can log into your brokerage and execute this exact
- 8:15deal all day, every day for almost any stock you currently
- 8:18own. The core philosophy is
- 8:20structuring situations where every outcome is a win based on
- 8:24your intrinsic valuation of the asset.
- 8:26OK, I see how this works to squeeze extra cash out of a
- 8:29neighborhood I already live in. If I own the stock, I can sell a
- 8:33call option to generate income while setting a sale price I'd
- 8:36be thrilled to get anyway. Exactly.
- 8:39But what if I'm trying to buy into a neighborhood I don't live
- 8:42in yet? Say you found a great company,
- 8:44it's a little too expensive, and you want to buy it on a
- 8:46discount. This is where we shift from
- 8:48being a homeowner to becoming an insurance company and this
- 8:52involves the other side of the options market which are put
- 8:55options. Put options.
- 8:56OK, a put option works mechanically very much like a
- 8:58car insurance policy. Right.
- 9:00But Phil Town stresses that the way the Buffett disciples handle
- 9:04this is that we never buy the insurance.
- 9:06We are the insurance company. We are GEICO.
- 9:09Exactly. Imagine someone out there owns a
- 9:11stock. Let's call it the car in this
- 9:13metaphor. They just bought it.
- 9:15They are nervous about the market and they are terrified
- 9:17the value of their car might crash.
- 9:19So they want protection. Right.
- 9:21So they come to you, they pay you an insurance premium upfront
- 9:23in cash. In exchange, you sign a contract
- 9:27saying if your car drops in value to this specific agreed
- 9:31upon price, I am obligated to step in and buy it from you at
- 9:33that price. Because they are paying for the
- 9:36right to put their shares onto you.
- 9:38Yes, wait, let me stop you there.
- 9:39Because here is where it gets really interesting, but also a
- 9:43little scary for the average investor.
- 9:45If the stock is tanking hard enough that this guy wants to
- 9:48trigger his insurance policy and force me to buy it, aren't I
- 9:51just catching a falling knife? It looks that way, but.
- 9:54I mean, the market is panicking, there's blood in the streets,
- 9:56the stock is plummeting, and I am legally bound to step in and
- 9:59buy a sinking ship. Why on earth would I obligate
- 10:03myself to do that? That right there is the absolute
- 10:05crux of why this works for value investors and utterly ruins
- 10:08gamblers. You do not do this blindly.
- 10:10You don't do this for speculative tech startups or
- 10:12meme stocks. You only do this for a company
- 10:14that you have exhaustively researched.
- 10:17You are looking for a business with an impenetrable competitive
- 10:19Moat and exceptional management. So you're doing the deep rule
- 10:23half tag one analysis first. Right.
- 10:25You've looked at the 10 year revenue growth, the return on
- 10:28invested capital, the free cash flow.
- 10:30You've stress tested every assumption about their debt, and
- 10:34through that rigorous process you have calculated A precise
- 10:38conservative intrinsic value for the company.
- 10:40You know exactly what the business is genuinely worth.
- 10:42Exactly. Once you know that number, you
- 10:44demand a massive margin of safety.
- 10:47You set your strike price, the price you agree to buy the stock
- 10:50at in your insurance contract, at a huge discount to its true
- 10:54value. So I'm not catching a falling
- 10:57knife out of nowhere, I've calculated exactly where gravity
- 11:00is going to take the apple, and I'm placing a basket exactly
- 11:03where I wanted it to fall in the first place.
- 11:04That's a perfect visual. You are getting paid a premium
- 11:08to promise to buy a stock that you were secretly praying would
- 11:10drop to that price anyway. Wow.
- 11:12You want the stock. You want it at that bargain
- 11:14basement price and because the market is fearful someone is
- 11:17literally handing you cash to force you to buy it at your
- 11:20dream price. The logic is sound, but I really
- 11:23want to see the actual mechanics of this compounding magic.
- 11:27Let's connect these theoretical metaphors to the real world Math
- 11:30Philtown walkthrough in his master class.
- 11:32Yeah, let's do it. He used Sprouts Farmers Market
- 11:34as a case study, right? Let's walk through that math
- 11:37because honestly, that's where my jaw hit the floor.
- 11:40It is impressive, and I should note, as the source material
- 11:43emphasized, this is just an illustrative example to show the
- 11:45math. It's not a current declaration
- 11:47of Sprouts exact value today. Right?
- 11:49Of course, but let's set the stage with his numbers.
- 11:52At the time of this example, Sprouts stock is trading on the
- 11:55open market at $76 a share. OK.
- 11:58So it's at 76 and let's imagine we've done all that extensive
- 12:01research. We determine the intrinsic value
- 12:03of strouts. What the business is actually
- 12:06worth is $140 a share. Right.
- 12:08So we have a highly confident intrinsic value of 140, but we
- 12:12are conservative value investors, so we demand a 50%
- 12:15margin of safety. Which means we don't want to pay
- 12:17140, we want to pay half of that.
- 12:20That puts our target by price at exactly $70.
- 12:23Exactly. Now the stock is at 76, we want
- 12:26it at 70. The traditional advice here is
- 12:29to just place a limit order at $70 and sit on your hands for
- 12:32free, checking your app everyday hoping the market dips.
- 12:35Which is incredibly capital and efficient, right?
- 12:37Your money just sits there doing nothing.
- 12:39Totally. But because we are the casino,
- 12:41we aren't just going to wait. We're going to sell a one month
- 12:45put option with a $70 strike price.
- 12:48We are officially telling the market I will happily act as
- 12:51your insurance company. I promised to buy Sprouts at $70
- 12:54anytime in the next. Month, yes.
- 12:56And because there is fear and volatility in the market, let's
- 12:59say a buyer pays US $1.50 per share immediately to take on
- 13:04that obligation. Cash clears into your account
- 13:06today. Today.
- 13:07Now, structurally, this leads to two very distinct outcomes over
- 13:11the next month. Oh, come one, the stock never
- 13:14drops to $70. It stays at 76 or it goes up,
- 13:17the month passes, the ice cube melts, and the option contract
- 13:19expires. Worthless and.
- 13:21What happens to us? You keep the $1.50, it's yours.
- 13:24You log back in and you just sell another one month put
- 13:27option for the next month. You just keep renewing the
- 13:29insurance. Policy.
- 13:30Let me do the math on that because this is where the
- 13:32capital efficiency blew my mind. If I collect $1.50 every month
- 13:37for 12 months, that is $18.00 in premium collected over the year.
- 13:41Right now I have to keep $70.00 of capital sitting in my
- 13:45brokerage account to cover my obligation just in case I am
- 13:47forced to buy the stock. But generating $18.00 of cash on
- 13:52a $70.00 cash pile 18 / 70, That is a 25.7% annualized return.
- 14:00A 25.7% return on cash that is literally just sitting in my
- 14:05account just for publicly stating I'm willing to buy a
- 14:07stock I already desperately wanted to buy at 70.
- 14:09Exactly. You are generating a massive
- 14:11yield on idle cash while you wait for your perfect pitch.
- 14:14That is outcome one. But let's look at outcome 2.
- 14:17Because the market isn't always stable and eventually the stock
- 14:19might actually drop. Right.
- 14:21So sometime during that year, let's say we're in the 12th
- 14:23month of doing this, the market has a bad week and Sprouts drops
- 14:27to $65. It crosses below our $70 strike
- 14:31price. Right.
- 14:32So the person who bought the put option from us panics and they
- 14:35exercise their contract. We are now assigned the shares.
- 14:39We are legally forced to buy them at $70.
- 14:42Which again we are thrilled about.
- 14:44Our intrinsic value was 140. We just bought a dollar for
- 14:47$0.50. But wait, this is the part that
- 14:49takes a second to wrap your head around.
- 14:51We didn't actually pay $70.00 out of pocket for those shares,
- 14:54did we? Well, no, because we have to
- 14:56factor in the premiums we've been collecting all year.
- 14:58Exactly. In finance this is called your
- 15:00cost basis. The actual net amount of money
- 15:03that left your pocket to acquire the asset.
- 15:06You handed over $70.00 to buy the shares, yes, but over the
- 15:09last year the options market had already handed you $18.00 in
- 15:12cash. So my true out of pocket cost,
- 15:14the my effective cost basis is 70 -, 18, it's $52.
- 15:18That is the magic number. That is wild.
- 15:21We just acquired a business we firmly believe is worth $140 and
- 15:24our effective purchase price is $52.
- 15:28We engineered a massive discount that is way larger than our
- 15:31original 50% margin of safety. And you didn't have to predict
- 15:34market momentum to do it. You didn't rely on a stock
- 15:37Screener to time a breakout. You relied on absolute valuation
- 15:41discipline. And you let the fear in the
- 15:43options market subsidized your entry point.
- 15:45But the strategy doesn't end with buying the stock.
- 15:47Eventually the market recognizes the value of the stock goes up
- 15:50and you're going to want to exit the position.
- 15:53So let's talk about the final phase.
- 15:54Yeah, the exit. Fast forward a couple of years.
- 15:57Sprouts has executed their business plan perfectly.
- 15:59Earnings are up. The market loves it.
- 16:01The stock rockets up to $300 a share.
- 16:04It happens all the time. The market violently reprices a
- 16:07good business once the fear subsides.
- 16:09But as a value investor, you don't just hold forever blindly.
- 16:11You have to recalculate. OK.
- 16:13So Phil Towns suggests in this scenario, based on their new
- 16:16earnings, the new intrinsic value has grown to $220 a share.
- 16:21Right. So the business is actually
- 16:22worth 220, but the euphoric market is trading it at 300.
- 16:27It is severely overpriced. It's time to sell.
- 16:30Now a normal investor would just login, hit the sell button at
- 16:33300 and take your profits. But we are still playing the
- 16:36casino side of the table. How do we exit using options?
- 16:40We use the exact strategy from the very beginning of the show,
- 16:42but in reverse. You own the shares.
- 16:44Now you are the homeowner on the golf course.
- 16:46So you sell a call option. You sell a six month call option
- 16:49with a strike price of say $310. I am telling the market I will
- 16:53happily sell you my shares for $310 anytime in the next 6
- 16:58months. Right.
- 16:58And because the stock is flying high, it's highly volatile and
- 17:02greedy speculators are absolutely desperate to leverage
- 17:04up. Someone pays you a massive
- 17:06premium for that, right? Let's say you collect $30 a
- 17:08share in premium right now. OK, let me walk through the
- 17:10staggering final math here. Yeah.
- 17:12We were assigned the shares at $70.00, but we had collected 18
- 17:16and put premiums. So our effective entry price was
- 17:18a net of 52. Then two years later, we collect
- 17:21another $30 in premium by selling the call option.
- 17:24That cash goes straight into our pocket, which lowers our cost
- 17:26basis again, 52 -, 30. Our total absolute net cost
- 17:31basis is down to $22.00 a share. Keep going, Walk through the
- 17:34final execution. Stock hits 310.
- 17:36The guy in the suit knocks on our door and calls the shares
- 17:39away. We are forced to sell our shares
- 17:43for $310.00. So we essentially paid a net of
- 17:46$22.00 out of pocket and we sold for three 10310 / 22.
- 17:51That is a 1400% return in three years.
- 17:54How is that even mathematically possible without using massive
- 17:57margin debt? It's possible because of cost
- 18:00basis reduction. You aren't borrowing money to
- 18:02multiply your gains. You are using the continuous
- 18:05income from selling options to systematically drain the risk
- 18:08out of your original investment. Yeah, let's compare that 1400%
- 18:11to the traditional approach. Let's say you just placed a
- 18:13normal limit order, bought the stock at $70, held it and sold
- 18:16it straight up at 300. Buying at 70 and selling at 300,
- 18:19that's a little over a 400% return, which is amazing.
- 18:23Anyone would be thrilled with 400%.
- 18:25Absolutely. But compared to 1400%, we
- 18:28literally use the options market to generate an additional 1000%
- 18:32return on the exact same stock over the exact same time frame,
- 18:36simply by changing the mechanics of how we entered and exited the
- 18:39position. And I want you to think about
- 18:41the alternative if the stock didn't get called away.
- 18:44What if the stock hovered at 300 and never quite hit 310 before
- 18:48the six month contract expired? Well, your ice cube melts.
- 18:51The guy in the suit walks away. Right.
- 18:52You keep the $30 premium you already collected.
- 18:55Your cost basis remains at $22.00.
- 18:57And what do you do the next day? You just sell another call
- 18:58option. A few months later, maybe you
- 19:00collect another $25. Wait, if my basis is 22 and I
- 19:04collect another 25 in premium, I would wipe out my cost basis
- 19:08entirely? I would actually be negative,
- 19:10yes. I would have 0 original capital
- 19:12in the trade and I would have pulled out more cash than I ever
- 19:14put in and I still own the shares.
- 19:16Yeah, I would be playing with pure house money.
- 19:18That is the ultimate definition of compounding capital.
- 19:21That is why Warren Buffett was historically one of the largest
- 19:24option sellers in the world. It's not about taking crazy
- 19:28leverage risks, it's about systematically reducing your
- 19:31cost basis until your risk is practically 0.
- 19:35Let's recap this because it is a complete inversion of how the
- 19:38media portrays options. The vast majority of retail
- 19:42investors, 90% of them, use options to gamble.
- 19:45They buy melting ice cube. Yeah, they.
- 19:47Bet on direction, they bet on timing, they try to hit a home
- 19:50run by next Tuesday, and they dramatically increase their risk
- 19:52of losing everything but. Disciplined value investors look
- 19:56at that same market and flip the script.
- 19:58They act as the casino. They facilitate the gamblers.
- 20:00Exactly. They sell options to enforce
- 20:03their own buying and selling discipline.
- 20:04They use the premiums to drastically lower their cost
- 20:06basis, they generate double digit returns on idle cash.
- 20:10And they do it all while patiently waiting for the
- 20:12perfect pitch. They literally get paid to wait.
- 20:14It completely changed changes how you view a static portfolio,
- 20:18which leads to a thought I think everyone listening should really
- 20:20Mull over tonight. Oh, I like a good thought to
- 20:23Mull over. Let's hear it.
- 20:24We are so deeply conditioned by Wall Street, by financial media,
- 20:28and by our own instincts to believe that in investing, high
- 20:31returns must inherently require taking on massive stomach
- 20:35turning risks, right? But what if the ultimate
- 20:37competitive advantage isn't predicting what the
- 20:39unpredictable market will do tomorrow?
- 20:42What if the real advantage is structurally designing a
- 20:44portfolio where you are financially compensated simply
- 20:48for your patience? What if you finally stop buying
- 20:50the lottery tickets and become the gas station selling them?
- 20:54That is a brilliant question to end on.
- 20:56Thank you all for joining us on this deep dive.
- 20:57Stay curious out there, keep analyzing those businesses, and
- 21:00we'll see you next time.