Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP143: Selecting The Right Back Office Systems for Ecommerce, with Integration Expert & Ecommerce Thinking Co-Founder Luke Hodgson
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks for tuning in three platform.
- 0:03Podcast sponsored by airplanes in klaviyo.
- 0:05You listen to myself. James, get and my co-host Paul
- 0:07Rodgers. How you doing, buddy?
- 0:09Yeah, good thanks. How are you doing?
- 0:11Yeah, not bad. If you recovered from the
- 0:12London, Brighton bike ride. Yeah, pretty much, I think so.
- 0:16Yeah, at least getting that makes a good work.
- 0:18So before we introduce our wonderful guests, say let's just
- 0:21set up this episode and also thanks for our regular tuning
- 0:24back in and a warm welcome with. This is your first time please
- 0:27subscribe you get a new episode alert every week.
- 0:30And we'd love a like on YouTube Spotify or apple.
- 0:33So our topic today is the need for earpiece and how to manage
- 0:37back office Integrations. So really, really important
- 0:40topic, because usually, when I'm in a project with client teams
- 0:43in the word, it Erp and or the phrase Erp integration as
- 0:46mentioned, it only creates a surge of panic and fear because
- 0:50people have been burned from previous projects or people
- 0:53haven't gone through. And don't really understand the
- 0:55complexity in the data side and assume it's just simple case of
- 0:58plug into sisters together. Don't think about the potential
- 1:01complexity and impact and the time that's needed to properly
- 1:03map it out. And under estimating, it comes
- 1:05back to bite them. So these this part is such a
- 1:08huge part of any big project. And we've got a guest today is a
- 1:11specialist in managing Erp and other systems integration
- 1:14projects for a wide range of clients.
- 1:15So we're going to cover their. When does a business need an
- 1:18Erp, what the pros and cons are using one versus not, how can he
- 1:21RP project, Speedy, rest cetera? So that first of all, let's
- 1:25welcome our guest lukacs. And how you doing, sir?
- 1:27I'm very good. Thank you.
- 1:28Thanks having me on. Really looking forward to this
- 1:31one because you have bags of expertise in the area.
- 1:33That isn't my, my skill set. So I'm looking forward to
- 1:36learning as much as asking. You annoying questions before we
- 1:39start into the questions. I know that some people know you
- 1:44from from previous roles such as being a CEO and founder of
- 1:46patchworks others when I you from your current role
- 1:49co-founder of e-commerce sinking and high.
- 1:51Cohesion, can you talk people through what you do in and what
- 1:55did it what are these business? And what's your focus?
- 1:57Yeah. So I think Background and my
- 2:01career path. Is slightly unconventional in
- 2:03the, I've started to Tech businesses.
- 2:05So the first was co-founding patchworks and then the second
- 2:08was co-founding, high Cajun. And what those two, those two
- 2:14businesses did was give me and everyone around me insight into
- 2:18a wide range of different tools and a wide range of different
- 2:22business problems. And all of them were focused in
- 2:24the operational side of the business.
- 2:27So how you meet demand, how you operate?
- 2:29Efficiently, how you create a scalable business from the back
- 2:33office? Not really focused on how do you
- 2:36generate the demand and convert the demand and I think by and
- 2:39large that's a niche that is probably underserved inside of
- 2:43the the industry. So what I've done is my business
- 2:47partner Andy and I we've been working together for the best
- 2:50part of 10 years. What we've automatically done is
- 2:53like product ties the knowledge and the process that businesses
- 2:56need to go through and the things they need to be aware of
- 2:59when it Have to say, okay, we've got tons of consumer demand but
- 3:03the team and the operations can't really keep up.
- 3:07How do we address that? So that over the next 12 months,
- 3:10we can meet our growth targets and then over the next three
- 3:13years, we actually have a plan to follow.
- 3:16That says, okay, if we continue to drive top of funnel demand
- 3:20and convert loads and loads of clients and loads and loads of
- 3:22different territories however our operations and all of the
- 3:26back office going to keep up with that and support it.
- 3:29So we help people. We'll do that by building out,
- 3:31roadmaps and solving really big hairy issues that they're
- 3:35dealing with right away right now.
- 3:38Sounds that make sense. And then in terms of the Brand's
- 3:40we're doing that with, we are called e-commerce thinking, but
- 3:44I'm seriously considering dropping the E because we work
- 3:47with lots of brands that are looking Beyond e-commerce and D
- 3:52to see whether they are pure play Commerce businesses.
- 3:56Right now, that want to open a retail store or want Do more
- 4:00wholesale or more traditional brands that want to embrace
- 4:03e-commerce a little bit more. So we're working typically with
- 4:07brands that are going through some of those inflection points,
- 4:10where their existing Tech stack and their existing operational
- 4:13processes. They've outgrown them but
- 4:16they're not quite sure what to do next and typically they're
- 4:19saying, we need to choose new technology to support us or we
- 4:22need somebody who knows what good looks like and it's been
- 4:25through this growth Journey a few times to help us make those
- 4:28decisions. Great.
- 4:31Well, I'll ask the first question.
- 4:35So this is quite a big question and obviously, they'll be
- 4:37variables around it. But some for me, it kind of the
- 4:40projects that you work on what are typically the main pain
- 4:43points that trigger business to start looking at an Erp I may
- 4:49sound like I'm repeating myself throughout because there's going
- 4:51to be some recurring themes but one of the most common things is
- 4:55that the operational capacity inside of a business to handle
- 5:00the demands being placed on them by customer demand, basically
- 5:04customer demand is outstripping their operational capacity to
- 5:07meet it. Whether that be over selling on
- 5:10websites because the stock levels aren't up to date through
- 5:13two things like we cannot create more hours in the day.
- 5:17How do we make all of these processes more efficient?
- 5:21And then I think a really big one is oh my God, business runs
- 5:25on spreadsheets and they're all stored on different, people's
- 5:28laptops and we don't have anything or any knowledge of how
- 5:32they all interact and thread together.
- 5:34So those are the kind of big pressing things.
- 5:36Customer demand is outstripping, operational capacity.
- 5:39We need technology to help us solve that without throwing more
- 5:43people and it all the time. We have specific issues that we
- 5:46just can't seem to solve. Rules that relate to certain
- 5:50things in the, whether it be in data, whether it be in process,
- 5:54and then third is a classic. There's just spreadsheets
- 5:56everywhere and we can't pick it. Great.
- 6:00And then I guess when people get to this point what do you think
- 6:03their first step should be. So I know you obviously run a
- 6:07consultancy. Yeah not to one side.
- 6:10The four brands that don't have kind of ctOS or see at.
- 6:14Those are kind of big. It teams have done this before.
- 6:18How do you think a brand should go around?
- 6:20Go about that kind of selection. Peace.
- 6:22And also kind of starting to build a set of requirements.
- 6:26Yeah, good question. I mean, it's probably worth
- 6:29taking a step back from that and say, when Brands and leaders
- 6:33inside of these, businesses are feeling those pain points and
- 6:37seeing those factors. What do they normally do?
- 6:41What I would do and what the vast majority of these leaders
- 6:44do is they'll asking their Network.
- 6:46I'm having these issues Did you do they'll talk to existing
- 6:51Partners? Whether that be a web agency,
- 6:54Consultants who are supporting them?
- 6:56And they'll probably do some Google searching.
- 6:58What they'll typically find is, they'll get hit by the acronym
- 7:02Erp whether that's through somebody recommending, they
- 7:05check it out or Google searches getting hit with typical names,
- 7:09like Oracle netsuite, Microsoft and sap, and the like.
- 7:14And I think what that happens, repeatedly in the same Names
- 7:18come up again and again, and again, and that unconsciously
- 7:22leads people to thinking that the only kind of option.
- 7:25They've got is Erp, it almost feels inevitable because all
- 7:29roads seem to lead to it. And what I really encourage
- 7:32people to First, really, if they can take one thing away from
- 7:35this podcast, is the fact that the notion that Erp is an
- 7:40inevitability is a fallacy that's been built up by
- 7:44marketing teams, not the reality And it's been so successfully
- 7:49marketed not challenged for so long that people feel that they
- 7:52just have to do it but some stage and you don't, I can
- 7:56guarantee that you don't have to.
- 7:58Now, that doesn't mean that Erp is always the wrong thing.
- 8:02Don't get me, I'm not anti Erp, I'm anti the default that it is
- 8:06inevitable. It Isn't So then if you need to
- 8:10go through processes and say, write what, how do we avoid
- 8:13falling into that fallacy trap? And I think the best thing you
- 8:16can do here. Respective of whether you work
- 8:19with a consultant like me or you can do this independently is
- 8:23you've got to know your operational, processes
- 8:25end-to-end. And if there is one thing you do
- 8:27over the next month, if you are thinking, should we are P or not
- 8:31Erp visualize, all of your end-to-end processes across the
- 8:35business in something like Whimsical or mirror and do it
- 8:39down to a really granular level because what this enables you to
- 8:42do is identify the main pain points in your processors or in
- 8:47your Operation or in your data and highlight the root causes.
- 8:52Well they will you to do is isolate those.
- 8:55So instead of falling into the Trap of just sort of grouping
- 8:58them all together and saying I need one system to solve all of
- 9:01these problems because we're human and we want the simplest
- 9:04route to solving as many of our problems as possible.
- 9:07The issue is that does not exist in back office, technology.
- 9:12It will be sold to you hint, hint.
- 9:14This is how we are pieces of marketed themselves.
- 9:16So successfully one system to rule the entire back office.
- 9:20It will not deliver that in reality for you.
- 9:22So we've got to do map everything out isolate, the
- 9:25individual pain points and try and identify the root causes.
- 9:29And then pair those pain points and root causes with specific
- 9:34Solutions. Now, those Solutions may be one
- 9:38of the solutions may be Erp because it helps you tick a
- 9:41couple of the boxes that you need to.
- 9:43You know, meet you need to have these particular things solved,
- 9:47but it will not. Over them all.
- 9:48That will be better fit, tooling down Erp for certain areas.
- 9:53So the biggest thing I can encourage people to do visualize
- 9:56your end-to-end operations and overlay it on the technologies
- 10:00that are being used in different parts of those processes isolate
- 10:03the problems and then choose the best fit tooling and use those
- 10:07visual tools to engage prospective vendors or Partners,
- 10:11so that you can be really clear with the most to what you need
- 10:14abstraction will lead you down a very Be risky path.
- 10:18Where you think? You can get one system to solve
- 10:21all of the problems. People will sell you that.
- 10:23And don't you really want to avoid that trap?
- 10:26I think that's, that's absolutely spot-on, a voice,
- 10:28it's amazing. Some of the projects where
- 10:29people have said, oh, you know, we're going to do an RFP now,
- 10:33for selecting its acronym, city today for erps.
- 10:37My first point, it's always been.
- 10:38What are your processes that you want?
- 10:40And what are the issues? What can you do at the moment?
- 10:42What needs to be automated? What are you?
- 10:44And it's amazing how sometimes just a small pot of money.
- 10:48The be a, an experienced, be a, who's very good at systems
- 10:52definitions and mapping can help to actually reduce the the
- 10:56demands that you might think need to go into a new system
- 10:59versus what can be done better with existing tools.
- 11:02Do you find it surprising? How often?
- 11:05Businesses just don't actually know their operational processes
- 11:09end-to-end and if you found that like part of the problem is that
- 11:13knowledge is silo. So departments have like these
- 11:16vertical processes And then they'd never been modeled out
- 11:19like cross-functionally. Yeah, hundred percent because a
- 11:23lot of projects when I do strategy projects and because we
- 11:25want to, we want to improve our operational capacity or improve
- 11:28operational. Efficiency.
- 11:30The first question is, what's wrong with the moment?
- 11:32How does it work? What what the process is and
- 11:34what's broken? What's broken from the business
- 11:36point of view, what's broken from a technology point of view,
- 11:38most breaker from a customer point of view.
- 11:40And if you had most of the time, we got all, we don't know,
- 11:42because you're right. There are silos, there are times
- 11:45when people are under resource therefore they just haven't Got
- 11:48to doing it. They know they want to but it's
- 11:50like you know what? I've got a trade Black Friday.
- 11:53I'm not mapping process is yeah, that reality to face as well.
- 11:58And do you know what this sounds like a really sort of basic plug
- 12:04for what we do. But the fact that that is all we
- 12:07do makes us really valuable to businesses.
- 12:10That this is something, they know, they really want to be
- 12:12able to do and they want to map these things out but it's never
- 12:15going to be the top of the priority list.
- 12:16Like when you say, you've got black Friday to prepare for.
- 12:19So, I think in many ways, if you can find people who are really
- 12:23qualified Bas and solution designers, they're worth their
- 12:26weight in gold. Not because they'll sort of,
- 12:29it's not like witchcraft. It's like just really, really
- 12:33methodical processes that get everything clear in people's
- 12:37minds. But it makes sure that you've
- 12:39you decisions that you make afterwards, you just get much
- 12:42faster, Roi much better Roi because you solving the
- 12:45problems, you actually need to solve In like, over simplifying,
- 12:49the problem and trying to find one thing that's going to fix it
- 12:52all. Yeah, I work with a guess a
- 12:55relatively inexperience e-commerce manager recently, but
- 12:59I say that just a number of years in the job, but in terms
- 13:01of knowledge and capability better than a lot of people
- 13:04who've worked in that job for five or six more years.
- 13:07Yeah she was excellent understanding the dependencies
- 13:10on other departments and teams and Technologies and how
- 13:13existing Erp worked and what the issues were and where the
- 13:15barriers were to enabling them to Scale and you know, do
- 13:19smarter CRM Etc. So there are e-commerce managers
- 13:23that have that kind of T level t-shaped thinking, but it's not
- 13:26all of them. So yeah, you're right and I
- 13:28agree, I think be a is and what sometimes the most under
- 13:32represented in a project and clients will spend tens of
- 13:36thousands and tens of thousands, even more on design.
- 13:40Yeah, yet, they won't spend a decent chunk of money on
- 13:44operational process yet. The design looks beautiful.
- 13:47And as you say, you Skylar customer demand and the
- 13:49operational processes shied. You can service them if they
- 13:52don't come back. So yeah, such a good way of
- 13:55putting it interesting. So I'm glad we flagged
- 13:57operational stuff, that's really important.
- 14:00So a question I've got linked that.
- 14:02So now I've been rambling on Paul but or love to know your
- 14:07advice there because you said, you don't the start point is you
- 14:10don't have to have an Erp, don't stop by thinking, it's a look at
- 14:13what you need is, what are the main things that dictate for you
- 14:16when a business needs and Erp. Mmm, when it needs it.
- 14:22So what are the factors that lead people to getting an Erp?
- 14:26And why that's a good decision? Yeah, exactly.
- 14:28What the common issues businesses you've seen have
- 14:31where any RPG is what they need and they should be going down
- 14:34that path. Versus you can get away with
- 14:36using other systems and Integrations.
- 14:39Yeah, it starts with Finance, it for me Erp, particularly, if you
- 14:43are a multi subsidiary international business, Selling
- 14:48in let's say North America, Europe, UK, and you have like,
- 14:53trading entities in those different territories.
- 14:55You've got a whole raft of complexities.
- 14:58When it comes to financial management, whether that be how
- 15:01you're calculating and recording tax, how you're reconciling
- 15:05transactions? All of these different things.
- 15:06Duties, Etc, Erp is like weapons-grade solving those
- 15:11sorts of problems. So for me, like, when I go into
- 15:14a business and we conclude the Erp is right, it isn't Variably
- 15:18because they have big limitations in their current
- 15:22setup and big demands in their growth forecast.
- 15:25Going forward around Finance, so sales revenues and those being
- 15:31accurate in all of the different territories with all of the
- 15:33different things that affected in their stock valuation.
- 15:37The valuation part is really key to stress there.
- 15:40Like, what is a liability in terms of the cost in lots of
- 15:44different potentially, like fulfillment locations, and
- 15:48Houses and then finally how we making our payment
- 15:51reconciliation processes as efficient as possible.
- 15:54So we can do the basic Financial work of month-end and produce
- 15:59like management reports and insights that we can analyze and
- 16:03start making decisions from rather than spending all of our
- 16:06time building the report. So we know what's actually
- 16:09happened. So for me, like Erp is a
- 16:12glorified Finance system. If you approach Erp the saying,
- 16:16I want a glorified version Asian of 0 that can scale as my
- 16:19business International risers and scales significantly, you
- 16:23will get much much better Roi of a netsuite dynamic business
- 16:29Central, Etc, then if you say I want everything.
- 16:32So yeah, finances. Where I really start to zero in
- 16:35on when it comes to Erp. Yeah.
- 16:37That resonates with, with the, the typical clients I'd work
- 16:40with ya. The the need to do something the
- 16:44cost and effort to try and customize an e-commerce platform
- 16:47or building. That is not what an e-commerce
- 16:48platforms designed to do, which is all your financial reporting
- 16:52reconciliation, and especially that.
- 16:54Yeah. The stop forecast in and stock,
- 16:57turnover existence. Yeah, I did.
- 17:00Some of the times I've seen where you've got people who are
- 17:04the finance, don't want to see, post-sales until items are
- 17:07dispatch, but any comments is taking payment on order and push
- 17:11straight through. You get all the financial
- 17:13reports or out sink and killed her in the finance team.
- 17:15Have an absolute mayor. Yeah.
- 17:18You, you're absolutely right and all of those points.
- 17:21And I think one of the big things that I'd like to stress,
- 17:24because I think, in many ways, I'm quite outspoken about the
- 17:28pitfalls associated with going with the Erp and to the extent,
- 17:32where I've written blog posts are titled, like the post Erp
- 17:35movement. So want to stress?
- 17:37That does not mean an trp. Like these are objectively
- 17:40brilliant systems with huge amounts of money.
- 17:43Spent on them widely used across the industry.
- 17:46They aren't the enemy. The enemy is like, buying into
- 17:50this fallacy that it can do everything in the back office.
- 17:53If you isolate it to those areas that it can be really good at
- 17:57and really effective at you will have a great time with it.
- 17:59And I think finances is the area that you really want to sort of
- 18:04Lodi RPMs, the key system, long-term that makes sense.
- 18:09And I guess you've talked a lot around kind of the pros of not
- 18:14going down. The IP route with some of the
- 18:17clients you I work with what might a typical equivalent
- 18:20stack. Look like that.
- 18:21What are some of the other systems should bring in and
- 18:23maybe some example vendors? Yeah.
- 18:26So I think again, like just building on that ethos of like
- 18:30Erp is like a glorified zero. So like lots of businesses will
- 18:34start when they with a Shopify instance, zero maybe a warehouse
- 18:39or a 3pl and then they'll have like an array of different apps
- 18:42that plug into Shopify and then a load of spreadsheets that sit
- 18:45around it. If you continue with that.
- 18:47Kind of methodology. And you say, okay, the next
- 18:51evolution of the finance function is going to be adopting
- 18:54Erp and having integrated to the various systems.
- 18:58That's great. But that also leaves a lot of
- 19:00other areas in the tech stack that need a system to support
- 19:04the growth and the scale. And I think some of the classic
- 19:07areas that businesses should prioritize over like a dramatic
- 19:12Erp implementation is investing in your date or an Insight
- 19:15stack. So building, a Now Tabby I
- 19:18capability inside of the business, you know, you sort of
- 19:22long-term totally scalable infrastructure will have like a
- 19:26data warehouse data modeling layer and a visualization tool
- 19:30on the top, you know, you're here Domo mentioned a lot,
- 19:33Tableau looker. So those are like the top of a
- 19:37bi stack, some of my entry level tools, are things like glue.
- 19:41You here. That's really popular at a lot
- 19:42of Shopify Brands, but I think bi and insights actually, It's
- 19:48flexibility can be a little bit intimidating because quite hot,
- 19:52you have to kind of figure out what you want from it.
- 19:55It's not like this pre-built system that you're just, you
- 19:59know, activating different functions in but that's its key
- 20:03strength is able to bend to the nuances of your business.
- 20:06So what I'm trying to encourage a lot of businesses to do is
- 20:10invest the six figures plus that you would spend on a big
- 20:15wide-ranging Erp implementation. And Actually prioritize the
- 20:19spend on bri because you will build out a lot more, like,
- 20:23intellectual property for your business and, like, tailor it to
- 20:26what you need in bi and get a lot more sort of value for
- 20:31money. Long-term out of it.
- 20:33I also think that there's just an explosion in the number of
- 20:36tools that are more fine-grained like you here, composable Tech
- 20:39stack as a phrase being used more and more.
- 20:43And I think there's just a lot more kind of composable tools
- 20:45that solve a specific problem. You know, I see Cog Z as a good
- 20:50tool and Ford eco or Predator is like a more local competitor to
- 20:56cubsy. I think those are exemplifying
- 20:59like that. There are finer grade tools that
- 21:02solve a specific thing and a need in a business without
- 21:06trying to stretch across the entirety of the business and
- 21:09build everything into one system.
- 21:11And then look it goes without saying, no code is really,
- 21:16really shaking things up zup. I think a lot of the business
- 21:20logic processors and sort of automated thinking that people
- 21:25used to build into their Erp systems are being moved into, no
- 21:30code systems. And people are actually building
- 21:32their own apps on top of no code infrastructure like a table
- 21:37retool, you know, the list goes on, but I think that's really
- 21:40shaking things up. So bi specific more fine-grain
- 21:45tools and no code or where we're seeing people.
- 21:48Innovate and find alternatives to the more traditional only Erp
- 21:53in the back office route and, you know, like no code tools are
- 21:56brilliant at starting to guzzle up some of those spreadsheet
- 21:59based processes and they're just more in more intelligent, more
- 22:03flexible. In terms of how they can
- 22:04integrate with different systems.
- 22:06You know, like product management is being transformed
- 22:10by no code because it's so easy to then pump that data into
- 22:14Shopify, a warehouse system, the financial An system.
- 22:18So yeah, I think that's the biggest shift I've seen in the
- 22:21last 5-10 years. Actually, What is amply?
- 22:24INS in a word, it's Freedom, the freedom to build a digital
- 22:29experience as Limitless as your vision create preview schedule,
- 22:34and manage. All your content in one easy
- 22:36place. Find out more at a lien.
- 22:39Start calm and plants experience freedom.
- 22:46Great. And I guess, um, when compared
- 22:49to the initial question here is more focused on erps, but I
- 22:53actually think it'd be quite interesting to talk about some
- 22:56of the other systems. So when you're starting to kind
- 22:58of build out that stack and let's say, you're looking like
- 23:00an inventory management system and maybe like something for
- 23:04finance, what should people be looking for?
- 23:08And like, what are some of the variables around kind of
- 23:10selecting systems are kind of best suited for your business?
- 23:15Mangal question. I mean talking to people who've
- 23:17used them before is always really helpful.
- 23:20It's a bit like why e-commerce thinking exist, you know, like,
- 23:23there's a lot of insecurity around selecting new tools, you
- 23:27know, a lot of brand leaders and Business Leaders, particularly
- 23:31in like the d2c space. A lot of the senior teams are
- 23:34inherently like creative products, Brands type people.
- 23:37Like that's what gets their juices flowing and the whole
- 23:40idea of data and Tack and making those decisions it's quite It's
- 23:44like quite insecure about it and it makes sense.
- 23:47So genuinely talking to people and using your network
- 23:50effectively would do. The first thing I would do,
- 23:52who's done this before, who's chosen something, who seems to
- 23:55be pretty happy with it. Can I, you know, take what
- 23:58they've done and tweak it for my own business.
- 24:01The second is and one of the sort of Base rules that I would
- 24:05enforce in any business that I'm involved in is you just don't
- 24:09choose tools that don't have really flexible either pre-built
- 24:13Integrations. School really flexible.
- 24:15Apis that enable you to plumb and move the data around.
- 24:19You will get so much more value for money.
- 24:22Out of the system that has a like a really well-built well,
- 24:26documented API than something that's like a black box.
- 24:29So I'm mindful that's quite abstract advice and I've not
- 24:32given you like a list of, here's the tools I would choose is the
- 24:35ones I wouldn't but this is the field is so vast that it's
- 24:38almost impossible to do that because you need to know the
- 24:41situation in the business and then pair it with the A'right,
- 24:44so willing so talk to you network and never choose
- 24:48systems. Don't talk to other things.
- 24:50Now, I can now make sense, I am a massive advocate of kind of.
- 24:53Yeah, I hope that more product. I really well, documented,
- 24:57standardized connected to pick cetera.
- 25:01Yeah. And Sophia, and then a sub
- 25:03question off the back of that. So if a business was to, you
- 25:08know, like a bigger business, they've got some, you know, big
- 25:10stakeholders that maybe have worked VIPs in the past and
- 25:14they've Decided to go down that road if you were in a market and
- 25:17even you know looking at and maybe the sap is the next week's
- 25:21the Microsoft Dynamics. Like what typically would be
- 25:26look like what should be the main criteria and kind of how
- 25:29would you differentiate between Man, big big question.
- 25:36I'm going to try not to be too controversial here, but I think
- 25:42there's very little that differentiates them.
- 25:46You know, base, an Erp is a general ledger, and then,
- 25:50they've got lots and lots of different things that have been
- 25:52stacked on top. And if you did a direct
- 25:55comparison between the major players that have got the most
- 25:57money behind them, the vast majority would come out pretty,
- 26:01even in terms of the core functionality and the level to,
- 26:04which you can customize them. If you either work with their
- 26:07own, Professional Services teams, or you work with one of
- 26:11their Partners, whether that's a Microsoft reseller partner, Or a
- 26:15specialist next week agency. So I think it's actually quite
- 26:19hard to differentiate between them at like just base
- 26:22functionality level. I think, where you start to see
- 26:26some differentiation is in the methodologies, IE, how they are
- 26:29implemented and what process, they go through.
- 26:33And then I think also how much they've worked with brands that
- 26:36are like yours. So whether that be vertical,
- 26:40whether it be complexity and nuances in your operating model
- 26:44or your customer promise. So I think if people are trying
- 26:48to split hairs between the different functions in the
- 26:50business in these systems, the probably going down a bit of a
- 26:53blind alley. There's still value in it but I
- 26:56wouldn't sweat that as much as I would.
- 26:58What is the methodology? How are these businesses?
- 27:01Or these people proposing? This solution, interpreting my
- 27:04business and my unique needs and that links back to model out
- 27:08your operational processes. So that you can explore tickle,
- 27:11ate it, and show it to these people.
- 27:14When are they done? Done this before, with a
- 27:16business that resembles me or very closely to me, and my
- 27:20operation. And then in terms of ongoing, I
- 27:24think, like I said before, I really, really encourage
- 27:28businesses to reduce the scope of what they're expecting from
- 27:31the Erp so that they don't get build themselves into a corner
- 27:35for the down the line. You know, erps are very flexible
- 27:38and custom development can be done extensively on top of them.
- 27:42If it should just because you can do that doesn't mean you
- 27:45should And I think the biggest thing is to avoid building too
- 27:48much on top of the Erp and therefore, you kind of reduce
- 27:52the need for ongoing development, forever, and ever,
- 27:56and ever on top of the system that may sound like I'm still
- 28:00sitting on the fence. So to be a little bit more
- 28:03opinionated on it Paul because I can tell you about to ask me,
- 28:07the biggest tip I can advise people is, do not fall into the
- 28:14kind of The Allure of working with.
- 28:17For me, let me rephrase that you might want to edit a bit.
- 28:21But for me to be opinionated I would say I've never had a very
- 28:26good experience since I've been client side with the really,
- 28:31really generic delivery methodologies of these vendors.
- 28:36So, classic example is like, Oracle netsuite.
- 28:39Have a fantastic business in terms of generating demand and
- 28:43converting, that demand Reputation and actually
- 28:46delivering what the business needs and delivering
- 28:50satisfaction at the other side of it isn't.
- 28:53As effective as those other elements, they tend to need a
- 28:56lot of their projects rescuing. So I think that there's
- 28:59something to be learned from. I think actually some of these
- 29:02more sort of Niche, specialist partners that work with specific
- 29:06businesses, with specific needs and our experience that like,
- 29:09flexing the system to those do requirements.
- 29:12I'd go with the smaller team that have worked with you.
- 29:15You and businesses just like, you over the big like Behemoth
- 29:19team that looks massive and like they could do everything.
- 29:22The reality is that they just don't tend to be able to deliver
- 29:25the same way as a crack more Specialist Team that works
- 29:29closely with you when you talk about like a smaller more Niche.
- 29:33Peso would like an example, be like we've obviously looked at
- 29:36the dunk with a couple of clients recently who have
- 29:38already used, they seem to be broadening.
- 29:40So, with that, be like an example for fashion?
- 29:43Yeah, definitely definitely. I mean, we think zedonk has a
- 29:47really strong place in the market.
- 29:49I also think there's like examples of businesses who are
- 29:52deploying these bigger Erp systems better.
- 29:56So like we're, we know Greg and Chris at ACS, like, they're a
- 29:59common concept of you and I pull, we work really closely
- 30:03with those guys, on some netsuite projects, because
- 30:06they're able to get right under the skin of the business, and
- 30:09understand the new ones, and then have enough experience and
- 30:12expertise inside of the business to then, Model netsuite to the
- 30:17requirements of the business. So I think there's a few
- 30:20different flavors right there. Is the more Niche Focus systems
- 30:23like as a donk in fashion and then there are these Niche
- 30:27agencies or partners that sit on top of these huge very, very
- 30:32Advanced systems, but they're tailoring them and personalizing
- 30:35them to the users at the other side.
- 30:37And I would always default to those over working directly with
- 30:41the vendor. Yeah, that's I I typically would
- 30:44and for a couple of reasons the second.
- 30:47So whenever it's about the second one being cost, they will
- 30:51incur a lot of fats in your project fees because all the
- 30:55additional Consultants who wrapped around it and I'm not
- 30:58denigrating the approach to the big can big companies that's how
- 31:01their business model works. But if you want to de-risk a
- 31:04project you want to reduce the costs as well to give yourself
- 31:07more contingencies, should you get problems later on down the
- 31:10line? So yeah, great.
- 31:11I've got a Want to extend that question on D risk in please,
- 31:14because you talked about the about some of the key issues you
- 31:18talk about projects over running.
- 31:19I've seen so many so many times where I started an e-commerce
- 31:22re-platforming and said to the client, your biggest risk of
- 31:24going live. Is your Erp integration and even
- 31:28higher. If then putting in a new Erp
- 31:30alongside a new e-commerce platform and a lot of people
- 31:32don't get it. They don't know, we've got a
- 31:34project timeline, it's due to go live in.
- 31:36September's I add 3 months if you're lucky.
- 31:40So apart from the the Scope control.
- 31:44Yes, is an obvious thing of don't try and buy everything off
- 31:47at once. What other advice can you give
- 31:49to? What have you learned in the
- 31:50process of? How can people be rest of the
- 31:51projects? This could be down to resource
- 31:53in. It could be down to managing
- 31:55Partners. Like, what advice can you give
- 31:57people? Yeah, I'll go really practical,
- 32:00right? Like, what would I do?
- 32:02And what do I do when I'm involved in these sorts of
- 32:05projects from the client side? So I think you've made it the
- 32:09point. Clear around like limiting the
- 32:11scope and Making your requirements really, really
- 32:14clear. So that means visualizing it and
- 32:17documenting it in flows, you know?
- 32:19Remember that the people delivering these systems are
- 32:22probably working on three, four, five, maybe more projects at any
- 32:26one time. Every time they stopped working
- 32:29in your project, they're working on something else, they then
- 32:31return to your project and their memory of what you need will be
- 32:36distorted slightly. So make it really, really,
- 32:39really really clear what your processes need to be.
- 32:42Keep-keep like re-emphasizing those and returning to those
- 32:45visuals. Sound pedantic it works.
- 32:48So use those visuals is like a weapon to speed up the whole
- 32:52process. Integration is Mega you know
- 32:55integration means that like when some of these deploying an Erp
- 32:59system, they're working with a team that is typically a
- 33:02specialist in the Erp and in that domain they don't a have
- 33:06the experience of the other systems that they perhaps need
- 33:09in order to be able to isolate problems like Pacify like
- 33:13Warehouse, like all the other systems that sit around your
- 33:15business. So really making sure that
- 33:18somebody is handling the integration now that will
- 33:21involve like a technology. So I can integration platform
- 33:25like a high cohesion, but also somebody internally who can
- 33:30answer all of those in Project questions about how to Shopify
- 33:34deal with these situations. How does your 3pl or your
- 33:38warehouse management system deal with these situations?
- 33:41There is like low. It's in loads of micro decisions
- 33:44as you're implementing an Erp. And if there is a lag period
- 33:47between the question being asked and the answer being provided,
- 33:51your timelines are going to consistently expand, that always
- 33:54going to get pushed out. So what you need to create is a
- 33:57really really Dynamic like question and response like, and
- 34:01that really comes down to resourcing.
- 34:04You need somebody sat in the project, all of the time with
- 34:08the awareness of what your process is our awareness of how
- 34:11those systems work. Work.
- 34:12And then the ability to answer those questions as they coming
- 34:15up in a really Dynamic and fast-moving way.
- 34:18And then the third area is data migration.
- 34:22Data migration is one of the, if not the biggest cause of delays
- 34:26early in the project because ultimately nobody wants to take
- 34:30control of it. Then the providing the Erp is
- 34:34usually pretty hands-off when it comes to migrating and
- 34:37transforming your legacy data, the system that you're moving
- 34:40from or Thing to has no vested interest in your new Erp system,
- 34:46somebody either internally or a designated resource that you're
- 34:50going to work with has to take the rather Harry and often quite
- 34:55unforgiving. Job of getting the data migrated
- 34:58and transformed to get the right people in it isn't actually a
- 35:02big issue if you don't it, literally they, it can delay
- 35:05projects for months because people just cannot get their
- 35:08heads around. Our, I'm going to migrate and a
- 35:1010,000 skews or Fifty thousand orders or 75 thousand customers
- 35:15from its source format into this new format.
- 35:18How, how do I do that? Like get somebody in, who can
- 35:21handle the data migration, and it will speed everything.
- 35:24So, yeah, three areas really, make it clear what your
- 35:28requirements are in a visual way and just keep returning back to
- 35:31it and update it as it changes going through the project.
- 35:36Get somebody who is like really integration Savvy who can answer
- 35:40those integration questions and then Make sure that what
- 35:43ramifications that has on the config of the Erp system is
- 35:47clear and understood to everyone and then the third area is data
- 35:51migration. Just get somebody to handle
- 35:53that. Yeah, really, really nicely put,
- 35:55yeah, we just did an episode mean, pool of data.
- 35:57Migration an area that's often underestimated, and everything
- 36:00else in it. And then people who all, we've
- 36:02got no product data, it doesn't work in this new system.
- 36:07Okay, cool. So it this is, this is, this is
- 36:10a bit of a, like, a feature gays.
- 36:12As in or conceptual questions. So this one goes.
- 36:15So we've talked, we've talked about some of the Legacy
- 36:17platforms over there are some massive players, you've got big
- 36:20track record, especially with in certain verticals like
- 36:24manufacturing, Etc. So sap is oracle's ETC.
- 36:28There are newer players and I pull mentions me Summer.
- 36:32I do as I do do or Belgian company.
- 36:35What's your view on where the technology is going for trp?
- 36:39What a, what a modern Erp should look?
- 36:42Like, yeah. Okay.
- 36:45Let me think of my feet here. Oracle sap, Microsoft have so so
- 36:55much strength. They're not going to lose the
- 36:57Erp, Crown, the new emerging Erp in inverted.
- 37:01Commas, won't beat those. So there's a splintering.
- 37:06So the new emerging players are going to be more fine-grained.
- 37:10They're going to be issue or problem, or feature specific.
- 37:14And then the big players will likely start acquiring them,
- 37:18which is happening in the Planner got bought by was it's
- 37:21age or it may have been one of the other bigger players.
- 37:25I think we're going to see finer grain systems being acquired by
- 37:29the bigger software houses. I think we're also going to
- 37:33start seeing a wave of Acquisitions in no code tools.
- 37:36I think Microsoft is either going to buy or build their own
- 37:39Google of started building their own, no code application
- 37:42Builder. It's inevitable that Oracle will
- 37:45start doing that as well. So I think what, I think the
- 37:48future will hold Old is that Erp may stop being used as an
- 37:56acronym in the next 10 years. I think we may move Beyond Erp
- 38:01and doesn't mean we'll move beyond the businesses that own
- 38:04and ruin and have these Erp systems.
- 38:07I think it's just going to Splinter and maybe we'll
- 38:10continue to use the Erp phrase for certain factors of it.
- 38:13But I think we'll start to sort of supplement it with other
- 38:16things and I suspect, that most of them are going to exist.
- 38:19Of The Umbrellas of some of these big companies.
- 38:23It's quite a cynical slightly depressing view on the future,
- 38:27sorry for that. But you know, I mean II, think I
- 38:29think we are moving into a phase where our current conception of
- 38:33what Erp is inside of a retail business or a manufacturing
- 38:38business will evolve. And I think it will evolve with
- 38:42the major players being two or three years ahead of all of us
- 38:45and realizing that the Acquisitions.
- 38:47They need to make or the way they split.
- 38:49Up their products or position, their products will start to
- 38:53change and morph. And that's how the the
- 38:56ecosystem. I think we'll continue to
- 38:58develop. Okay.
- 39:00So slightly open last question and you have any parting
- 39:05suggestions for brands are currently looking at investing
- 39:09in their kind of back office. So stuck record time don't buy
- 39:14another back-office tool until you've modeled out your
- 39:17operational processes in detail. In a visual way and then
- 39:21interrogate them with different stakeholders in different
- 39:24Departments of the business that you do, really understand how
- 39:27the business operates end to end, and where the root causes
- 39:30of your problems. Are, don't buy anything until
- 39:33you've done that and then buy stuff that solves the problems.
- 39:37As you've isolated them, not in this kind of like abstract
- 39:40sweeping way going down, the abstract street, sweeping way
- 39:44will cost you more money, waste, you a load of time and reduce
- 39:48the ROI on what you Eventually spend being really specific
- 39:52really clear and really confident in what you know, is
- 39:56the problem inside of the business will get you much
- 39:58faster Roi, you'll spend less money and you'll make
- 40:01improvements much quicker, sounds simple.
- 40:04But it's like that's the most sort of effective advice I can
- 40:08give I like that. I think we've, I think there's
- 40:13been a lot of really good advice during this this process, I
- 40:15really like the fact that you're starting point is not you need
- 40:18an Erp, but do you and make sure that the key Point I've taken
- 40:23from this, which, which I wholeheartedly believe in is, is
- 40:27map your operational processes and look at where your issues
- 40:30are and what you, how you can best achieve these things.
- 40:34And if you don't understand technically how you knit them
- 40:36together, you don't know if something's got that Enterprise
- 40:39solution architecture. Your knowledge base within the
- 40:41business, it's worth the weight in gold to have because I don't
- 40:45like yourself an agency partner. Whoever is the technical
- 40:48Specialists to help you get the right solution so that you're
- 40:51not sold something that you don't need.
- 40:53I think that's the most important by sometimes by
- 40:55spending 5, to 10K up front on the device, you can save
- 40:58yourself. Okay, tens, and tens.
- 41:01Hundreds of thousands in future pain 100%, And it's hard to
- 41:05quantify the risks involved in rushing into something like
- 41:10this. Because it's not just the
- 41:12monetary outlay, which is always going to be six figures if you
- 41:15go down an Erp in the traditional way.
- 41:18But it's also the loss of time and energy.
- 41:23These are really a traditional projects.
- 41:25When you go through these like big Erp, implementations, you
- 41:28don't want to do it on a whim. You want to be 100% certain that
- 41:33you you're going to get out of it.
- 41:35What you need from the other side?
- 41:37I think just as a kind of closing statement like Really
- 41:41making sure that, you know, your operational processes.
- 41:44We've started to use the phrase operator experience, you know,
- 41:48like ux is like, the idea of what is the customers end-to-end
- 41:52experience of our brand? Our product, our customer
- 41:55service? Like how are we set up to
- 41:57Delight the customer? And to end there is another part
- 42:01to the same discipline. It's like, just underneath,
- 42:04which is operator experience. And it's like, what is your
- 42:07team's experience of delivering? That end-to-end customer
- 42:11experience. How efficient is it?
- 42:14How manual are the processes? How much time are your team
- 42:17spending actually? Doing really low value,
- 42:21unrewarding work to support that customer experience versus.
- 42:25How much, are they doing? Really high value work?
- 42:27Because they've got systems and tools that talk to each other,
- 42:30that are set up properly, the automate most of the grunt work
- 42:34that sits underneath the surface.
- 42:35So yeah, we're trying to really like really promote this idea of
- 42:39operator. Earrings is being a discipline
- 42:42that deserves Like Oxygen and time inside of a business and
- 42:46focus. Now that could just be time that
- 42:49your own team spend thinking about what is it, like to
- 42:52deliver this service and how could it be more effective or it
- 42:55could be investing in external help, which is where e-commerce
- 42:59thinking sits, but I think that's a nice sort of title to
- 43:02sort of encapsulate, all of the things and the discipline that
- 43:05we're talking about here eggs and going to Nick that one.
- 43:08Yeah, dude, go for it. Like it, I will Give you credit,
- 43:11don't worry. Yeah, I think that's a really
- 43:12good way because in the the if you try to deliver a new
- 43:17e-commerce website without think about customer experience
- 43:20businesses and bright light, especially creators and Brands
- 43:23and heads of customers transferred, Lafayette town.
- 43:26But so many times, people people happy to compromise on the
- 43:29operational experience and the things that impact their staff
- 43:33day-to-day on their ability to execute.
- 43:35So, I hundred percent agree. It's really important.
- 43:38Luke really appreciate you. Taking time.
- 43:39I really enjoyed that. I think people listening would
- 43:42have learnt a stack as well. If anybody wants to grow your
- 43:46bit more in terms of what your skills and what you can do, or
- 43:49they want to discuss a project, how do they reach out?
- 43:51They can reach out on e-commerce, thinking.com.
- 43:55And then I am at LinkedIn. If you Google or LinkedIn, Luke
- 43:59Hodgson. I will likely come up as one of
- 44:02the top few hits. So yeah, reach out to me, direct
- 44:05message me on LinkedIn or get in touch with us through the
- 44:07website. And also on the website, you can
- 44:09find out assess how how we do what we do and what kind of
- 44:15impact we can have inside of the brands?
- 44:17Oh, I love love in the glasses. They give me the Thunderbirds
- 44:19Vibe today. Yeah, and that's these are
- 44:22cubits. So someone we work very very
- 44:24closely with after you pour. Yeah.
- 44:27Cool by an excellent time and thanks everyone for listening.
- 44:30As always, we hope you enjoyed it as much as we did, keep an
- 44:32ear open for the next step. So that drops every Tuesday do
- 44:35subscribe. And please do give us a rating
- 44:37on Apple Spotify or YouTube. Thanks very much until next time
- 44:40I'm More information on this topic, head over to re-platform
- 44:50dot. F m, for our audio podcasts to
- 44:52discuss a project or if you like to chat about any of the topics
- 44:55covered in this episode in more detail.
- 44:57Please reach out to myself. James, scared and my co-host,
- 44:59Paul Rodgers via LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 45:01Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 45:03next episode.