Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Lights, Camera, Paperwork: Navigating Immigration & Entertainment Law in Hollywood
Transcript
- 0:01you I'm Keith Cooper. I'm the chair of the Beverly
- 0:06Hills Bar Association's entertainment law section.
- 0:09And today we are presenting you with Lights,
- 0:13Camera, Paperwork, Navigating, Immigration, and
- 0:16Entertainment Law. And I was mentioning to Swati
- 0:20in April who came up with the name. It's such
- 0:22a great name, because with all the glitz and
- 0:24the glamour of Hollywood, Lights, Camera, it's
- 0:27paperwork. For any entertainment law attorney,
- 0:31we push a lot of papers. not all that glamorous
- 0:35fun work, but it's a lot of paperwork. So it's
- 0:38a great title and I appreciate the fact they
- 0:40came up with that. Before we start the program
- 0:43today, let me just mention that the entertainment
- 0:46law section is sponsored by Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:48Company. Tell you a little bit about them. They've
- 0:51been around for five decades. Lawyers Mutual
- 0:53Insurance Company has been the only California
- 0:55based company to continuously provide lawyers.
- 0:58throughout the state with professional liability
- 1:00insurance coverage. Their experience and expertise
- 1:03are complemented by the fact that they are directed
- 1:06by a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:09rates and competitive premiums for a wide range
- 1:12of practice areas, including entertainment law.
- 1:15You can check them out at lawyersmutual .com.
- 1:18But as I always do, I always mention It's one
- 1:21of the valuable things that they offer in addition
- 1:24to insurance. They have an ethics hotline similar
- 1:27to the California State Bar. But with the insurance
- 1:29company, it's very handy to have some lawyers
- 1:32that you could contact if you are ever. in an
- 1:35ethical dilemma, or have just questions about
- 1:38how to proceed on something that may raise ethics.
- 1:41They have a hotline that you could contact, speak
- 1:44to them ahead of time. And that is very handy,
- 1:46as all lawyers know, to have something like that
- 1:50available to you. Meantime, I'm going to introduce
- 1:53the speakers in no particular order, starting
- 1:55with Don, I'm sorry, Dr. John Zhu. Zang, he is
- 2:00an actor known for Masters of the Universe and
- 2:02The Brother's Son. He has an extensive background
- 2:05as a former stuntman, including Marvel's Marvel
- 2:08Eternals and Fast and Furious. John is a lifelong
- 2:12martial artist and instructor, having taught
- 2:14members of law enforcement, armed forces, and
- 2:17was formerly the psychologist for Saudi Arabia
- 2:20national team. And he continues to coach athletes
- 2:23and performers. He's also the author of The Martial
- 2:27Heart. Tisha Morris is an entertainment lawyer
- 2:30and founder of Legacy Arts Law PC. She represents
- 2:35creators in film, new media, and publishing.
- 2:38She advises on contracts, deal -making, and creative
- 2:41business strategy. She is the author of multiple
- 2:44books on creativity and personal development,
- 2:47including her latest release, The Screenplay
- 2:49Book. Tisha serves on the board of the Ojai Film
- 2:52Festival and is an active member of the Beverly
- 2:55Hills Bar Association, California Lawyers for
- 2:58the Arts, Provisors, and Women in Film. Next,
- 3:03Christine Ngo, Senior Associate, and Barry Appelman.
- 3:08They're at Los Angeles office. She advises clients
- 3:10on a broad range of U .S. business immigration
- 3:13matters. Her practice focuses on employment -based
- 3:16immigration with specialization in the EB -5
- 3:20immigrant investor program and immigration solutions
- 3:23for professionals in the sports and entertainment
- 3:25industry. Christy has extensive experience representing
- 3:28individuals, families. and businesses in a wide
- 3:31range of employment -based and family -based
- 3:34immigration matters. She advises clients ranging
- 3:37from startups and emerging companies to global
- 3:40enterprise across diverse industries, including
- 3:43technology, healthcare, finance, engineering,
- 3:46and hospitality. In addition, Christie counsels
- 3:49foreign investors project developers, and regional
- 3:52centers on all facets of the EB -5 immigrant
- 3:55investor program, providing strategic guidance
- 3:58throughout the investment and immigration process.
- 4:03The two leads of the panel, semi, I guess, co
- 4:06-moderators who came up with the title that I
- 4:08mentioned earlier, April Paradis is co -owner
- 4:11and principal attorney of Ascent Legal, APLC.
- 4:15She advises entrepreneurs, startups, production
- 4:19companies, creators, and entertainment professionals
- 4:21on the legal aspects of building and growing
- 4:25their business. Her practice spans both business
- 4:27and entertainment law from company formation,
- 4:30deal structuring, and capital raising to negotiating
- 4:33production talent and licensing agreement for
- 4:36content, spanning television, film, and podcasts,
- 4:39as well as advising creators and brands. on sponsorships
- 4:43and IP matters. Finally, we have Swati Paul Katani
- 4:48is the founder and principal attorney of Paul
- 4:51Katani Global, known as PKG, a boutique immigration
- 4:54law firm based in Newport Beach, California.
- 4:57Her practice primarily focuses on employment
- 5:00-based immigration, as well as some family -based
- 5:03immigration matters. Her clients range from an
- 5:06unusually diverse range of profiles, including
- 5:08individual founders, engineers, Latin Grammy
- 5:11Award -winning artists, Olympic -level athletes,
- 5:14tattoo artists, executives, veterinarians, software
- 5:18engineers, among others. And with that, I'm going
- 5:21to turn it over to Swati in April, and I hope
- 5:23everybody enjoys the presentation today. Thank
- 5:28you so much, Keith, for that wonderful introduction.
- 5:30Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to Lights,
- 5:33Camera, Paperwork, Navigating Immigration and
- 5:36Entertainment Law in Hollywood. So here's why
- 5:40we put this panel together. Hollywood has always
- 5:43been a global industry. The actors from Soul,
- 5:47the production designer from London. the cinematographer
- 5:50from Mexico City. International talent is part
- 5:54of the business model. But when that talent works
- 5:56on a U .S. production, two legal systems collide.
- 6:00On one side is the entertainment deal. the offer,
- 6:03the negotiation, the start date, the shooting
- 6:05schedule, and on the other hand is the immigration
- 6:07process, which has its own timeline and evidence
- 6:11requirements and doesn't move just because a
- 6:13production is ready to roll. And when those two
- 6:16tracks don't talk to each other, things can go
- 6:20wrong. The start date gets pushed, a contract
- 6:23gets signed for the work the person isn't authorized
- 6:25to do, a deal falls apart at the consulate. So
- 6:29whichever side you practice on, the other side
- 6:31affects your client. And today is about getting
- 6:34those two tracks in sync. We'll start where every
- 6:38international entertainer has to start, getting
- 6:41through the door. So we're going to lead into
- 6:44a discussion with Christie, attorney Christie
- 6:46first. Before anyone negotiates a back end point
- 6:50or billing, an international artist has one basic
- 6:54question. Can I legally work here? A great contract
- 6:58is worthless if the talent can't get on set.
- 7:01So we'll cover the main visa options, realistic
- 7:04timelines, and the mistakes we often see most
- 7:07for actors and also the people behind the camera,
- 7:11like production designers, art designers, art
- 7:13directors, and the crew who often get overlooked.
- 7:16So Christy, if you don't mind, let's get started
- 7:18with the basics. When a production calls about
- 7:21a foreign talent, what's usually on the table?
- 7:24What types of visas are we looking at? Yeah,
- 7:28first off, Spotty, thank you so much for having
- 7:29me today. So as far as immigration or entertainment
- 7:34type visas, the ones we're primarily going to
- 7:36be working with are the O -1B visas, typically
- 7:39for individuals of extraordinary ability and
- 7:42international acclaim. We also have the P -1B.
- 7:46visa, which is for the internationally recognized
- 7:49group, you know, BTS there. You got the P2s,
- 7:53which apply to entertainers or artists that are
- 7:57under a government recognized reciprocal exchange
- 8:01program. So a lot more niche. we don't often
- 8:04see these kinds of cases. And then the P3, which
- 8:07is reserved for artists or entertainers that
- 8:10will be performing, presenting, or teaching something
- 8:14culturally unique. Thank you, Christy. So oftentimes
- 8:23many people assume that the O1s are only for
- 8:25the stars. Can you talk about how a production
- 8:28designer or an art director or individuals behind
- 8:31the scenes can qualify for each of the types
- 8:34of visas that you've discussed and what types
- 8:36of evidence, what does the evidence look like
- 8:38for each of these behind the scenes individuals
- 8:42as it compares to maybe an actor? Yeah, let me
- 8:46start off by kind of discussing the O1 and a
- 8:48little more depth. The O1B specifically in media
- 8:55production is a visa for an individual who have
- 9:00extraordinary ability or also looking at international
- 9:03acclaim. It has the broadest applicability. It
- 9:08can apply to artists, entertainers, actors, of
- 9:12course, musicians, production members, social
- 9:16media content creators. But it also has the highest
- 9:20bar of proof. So there are, USAAS has certain
- 9:26evidentiary. criteria to determine whether this
- 9:31individual will qualify for an O1B visa. Among
- 9:35those criteria include awards, media coverage,
- 9:41commercial success, critical acclaim. Generally,
- 9:44it's looking at is this person internationally
- 9:47recognized? Can we show how they have extraordinary
- 9:51ability? Now, some types of evidence are going
- 9:54to be more, I would say, are weighted more heavily
- 9:58than others. Like if the individual has an Emmy,
- 10:02a Grammy, an Oscar, it's fine. We can show that
- 10:07and we don't have to spend as much time on media
- 10:10coverage or get letters from other industry experts.
- 10:14But if we don't have a major award, then we really
- 10:18have to put a thorough partition together focusing
- 10:21on how this individual does qualify for that
- 10:26high bar of the O1B. For actors, in front of
- 10:31the camera, oftentimes they will have more media
- 10:34coverage. For people behind the scenes, the challenge
- 10:39is really tying their contributions to the production
- 10:43and showing how they are recognized in the field
- 10:47and in the industry. Oftentimes that does involve
- 10:51getting expert opinions, testimonial evidence
- 10:53from industry professionals. Thank you, Christy.
- 10:58So the key point here is that the evidence, the
- 11:02supporting evidence is what qualifies both the
- 11:04actor and the behind the scenes individuals to
- 11:07build around their credits, their awards and
- 11:08industry recognition, and not just the name that's
- 11:10on the poster that's being advertised. Absolutely.
- 11:14Thank you. So then let's talk timing since that's
- 11:17where immigration and the deal collide from the
- 11:19day a client calls What's a realistic timeline
- 11:22to set for someone? How far in advance does the
- 11:26person need to plan out their immigration matters
- 11:29as it relates to the production start date? OK,
- 11:32so that's always the issue working on as many
- 11:36of these types of cases. I will say, the earlier
- 11:39you can start the process, the better. And almost
- 11:43all the time, you're already too late, or you're
- 11:47already on a crunch time. The 01 petition, as
- 11:52I mentioned, has the highest burden of proof.
- 11:55So it can take months in order to prepare, like
- 11:58one or two months to prepare the necessary documentation,
- 12:04the testimonial evidence, and submit that to
- 12:07U .S. immigration. Once the petition is filed,
- 12:11U .S. immigration can take on the short side,
- 12:15up to 15 business days to adjudicate the petition.
- 12:18They can ask for more evidence and then it goes
- 12:22to the U .S. consulate. Then we have to analyze
- 12:25where is the individual coming from? What is
- 12:28their country of nationality? What is their country
- 12:32of residence? Because each consulate has a different
- 12:35visa wait time. Additionally, you know, depending
- 12:40on the country, some are harsher than others
- 12:42and may have a higher likelihood of doing extra
- 12:47security vetting for the individual. So those
- 12:50are the things that we analyze before we start
- 12:53out the case and give a realistic expectation
- 12:55to the client. The preparation time is generally
- 12:59the same, but the individual factors, like what
- 13:02is the evidence that we can use? Where did they
- 13:04need to go to get their visa? That changes per
- 13:08person. Amazing. Thank you so much. So what are
- 13:12some of the most common reasons a visa petition
- 13:14gets delayed or denied for entertainers? And
- 13:18how can that risk be minimized? So I would say
- 13:22a common one could be potential requests for
- 13:25evidence from US immigration. Nowadays, we are
- 13:28seeing higher scrutiny for O -1 petitions and
- 13:33generally just all types of visa petitions. And
- 13:35frankly, If we request that USCAS, what is called
- 13:39premium processing, process the case, meaning
- 13:42we pay them extra money and they promise to review
- 13:45the petition in a shorter amount of time, what
- 13:48we often seen is that USC immigration will not
- 13:51have enough time to review. And so they'll just
- 13:53issue a request for more evidence to buy time.
- 13:57And this person could have incredible credentials,
- 13:59but it doesn't matter if the person on the other
- 14:01end. isn't looking at it, like thoroughly looking
- 14:04at the petition. And so we have to take more
- 14:07time to still respond whether or not the request
- 14:11is legitimate. Additionally, like I said, it
- 14:15is up to the consulate on how long they take.
- 14:19If this is a rush production, an important production,
- 14:21we can request an expedite, but that is completely
- 14:26discretionary to the consulate. Additionally,
- 14:30If the individual has any sort of criminal history
- 14:34or criminal issues in their background, a history
- 14:37of immigration violations, or it could be just
- 14:40what country they come from, US consulate could
- 14:44do what is called administrative processing,
- 14:47meaning they take the case aside to do extra
- 14:49security vetting. And there is no definite time
- 14:53on how long that will take. It's just they'll
- 14:56get to it when they get to it. Thank you, Christy,
- 14:59for the in -depth discussion on that topic. So
- 15:03what happens when a shoot date moves? How much
- 15:06flexibility is there once the petition has already
- 15:08been filed? Is an individual tied specifically
- 15:12to a single production or if there's multiple
- 15:14productions that they're going to be working
- 15:15on? Can you talk a little bit about how that
- 15:18works as it relates to the O -1B? Yeah, the O
- 15:21-1 can be for a single production. It could be
- 15:23for multiple productions. That all works. I think
- 15:27the part that that needs to be flexible is how
- 15:32long the petition will be valid for. So an O
- 15:35-1 visa petition will be valid for typically
- 15:38the length of the contract or the length of the
- 15:40production. So if the production moves, well,
- 15:44then the period that we requested may need to
- 15:48be extended. And that just really requires an
- 15:52additional petition before the end of their visa
- 15:54period. Individuals that have to understand like
- 15:57that does come with extra costs come with another
- 16:00filing in addition to that, you know, that petition
- 16:03late time, but at least at that point though,
- 16:06they'll likely not have to deal with the visa
- 16:09process at the consulate. Thank you. And then
- 16:13lastly, what are some things that you would like
- 16:15entertainment attorneys to keep in mind when
- 16:18preparing their clients to process through these
- 16:23immigration applications or these petitions?
- 16:26Yeah, I would say be flexible, be creative, you
- 16:30know, like, unlike a corporate immigration case,
- 16:34typically, you know, you have a start date, if
- 16:35they have to move back their start date, whatever,
- 16:37you know, the company will kind of figure it
- 16:39out. With entertainment type visas, you miss
- 16:42a start date, they can't go and it doesn't happen,
- 16:45you know, so it's very important to be flexible,
- 16:50try to get this out as soon as possible. Really
- 16:52keep in mind what is the date that they have
- 16:55to be in the U .S. and work with a consulate,
- 17:00file your expedite request, reach out to the
- 17:03USCIS premium processing unit. We've been able
- 17:07to get USCIS to. prioritize a review of the case
- 17:11just by simply emailing them. So there's a lot
- 17:14of ways that you can work around the system to
- 17:17try to expedite the case. And creativity, the
- 17:21internet is your friend. We've had a lot of clients
- 17:24that this is what they say they have, but doing
- 17:29a little online stalking of them will show just
- 17:32a lot more that they didn't even think about
- 17:35was available to buttress. their international
- 17:38claim for the petition. Thank you. And I am going
- 17:42to address this one quick question that came
- 17:44into the Q &A box. Can you talk a little bit
- 17:47about what agency or management O -1 visas, what
- 17:51the difference is between the two, having an
- 17:54agent versus an employer on an O -1 visa, and
- 17:57then what's required to obtain the same? What's
- 18:00different between having an agent versus an employer
- 18:02and vice versa? That's an excellent question.
- 18:05So the process is somewhat different for an employer
- 18:08and for an agent. So with an employer -sponsored
- 18:12petition, you can only work for that employer.
- 18:16If it is a full -time permanent role, you can
- 18:19really only have, you must have an employer -sponsored
- 18:22petition. If you are a freelancer, you have multiple
- 18:27productions, it's better off going with an agent
- 18:29-sponsored petition. The agent doesn't actually
- 18:31have to be a talent agent or what we think of
- 18:35as a professional agent. It can just be a U .S.
- 18:40citizen who is willing to sponsor the O -1 petition
- 18:44for the applicant. But an agent -sponsored petition
- 18:48does allow this individual to work on multiple
- 18:50productions at the same time. Sometimes we have
- 18:54a situation where they kind of have both. They
- 18:56have one permanent full -time role, but they
- 18:59also want to have multiple side gigs, if you
- 19:02will, in which case you have to file two petitions
- 19:05for concurrent employment. But that's all possible.
- 19:10Thank you, Christy. Thanks so much. So now we're
- 19:12going to move over to John. You have lived this.
- 19:16So can you walk us a little bit through your
- 19:18own experiences in getting work authorization
- 19:20in the US? What surprised you most about the
- 19:25process to get your work authorization in the
- 19:28US? First of all, thank you so much. And Christy,
- 19:31that was so useful to know. Just because I was
- 19:34in the dark for most of this. Um, so I auditioned
- 19:38for, um, a role on the brother's son, which was
- 19:41on Netflix, uh, at the start of April. And then
- 19:45I booked the role at the end of April. And then
- 19:48I thought, great. Okay. Smooth sailing. And then
- 19:50I got, um, an email saying, now the visa visa
- 19:53process begins. I thought, okay. Okay. Um, and
- 19:58when I was sent the forms, I knew that They would
- 20:02be extensive. I knew that would be the case,
- 20:05but what really shocked me was the specificity
- 20:08of the forms of how much they needed and took
- 20:13to how much detail they actually needed it in.
- 20:15For instance, you know, where I'd lived before.
- 20:19the schools I went to since I was a kid with
- 20:23the dates and oh gosh, there was so much, it
- 20:27was about my employment history and having to
- 20:29dig out a lot of things that I'd done as a child
- 20:32to, you know, my early thirties was kind of crazy.
- 20:38And I was certainly, we were under a lot of pressure
- 20:42because production had already began. And thankfully,
- 20:47because it was a series, I was like, okay, cool.
- 20:51Maybe they can push back my dates a little bit,
- 20:54but we very nearly didn't make it. So I, you
- 21:03know, your life is kind of on hold really, because,
- 21:07you know, I remember having to... go to bed seven
- 21:11to eight hours later, just so that I was on LA
- 21:14time. So anytime they needed something from me,
- 21:17I could get it to them as quickly as possible.
- 21:20But it was the letters of recommendation that
- 21:22were really difficult to get. Thanks, John. That
- 21:28sounds very strenuous on your end. So was there
- 21:32ever a moment in a visa timeline that may have
- 21:35cost you a particular role with the production,
- 21:38whether it was Brothers Sons or a different production?
- 21:43Absolutely. So I was informed that as production
- 21:49had began on Brothers Sons and they wanted to
- 21:52get me in as soon as possible, but I can't get
- 21:55there until... everything sorted and um but back
- 21:59to the whole specificity uh element it was like
- 22:03with the letters of recommendation it was very
- 22:05much um the brother some was my first mainstream
- 22:09acting role but all of my previous mainstream
- 22:12credits were stunt credits um so when i got uh
- 22:17people i'd work with to write me a letter of
- 22:19recommendation uh it was about me as a stunt
- 22:22performer and about me and my character. So I
- 22:26did get a lot of feedback saying, we can't have
- 22:29that. It needs to be you specific as an actor.
- 22:31I thought, oh, gosh. Oh, gosh. So it's having
- 22:34to dig out more contacts and chase people up,
- 22:37getting them to amend the letters as well as
- 22:40finding people that I'd worked with years ago
- 22:43who'd since gone to win more awards. But there
- 22:46was definitely a lot of pressure with the timeline
- 22:49because the interview at the British, well, in
- 22:56the US Embassy in the in the London had no vacancies
- 23:00for interviews. So I would have had to fly to
- 23:02Ireland to have the interview. And as I was about
- 23:07to book my flights to Ireland, they told me that
- 23:11somebody had cancelled their London interview.
- 23:14I thought, oh, thank goodness, please book me
- 23:15in. Had it not been for that, I think we may
- 23:20we may have been delayed. a fair bit, and I may
- 23:23not have made it because Brother Son, Netflix,
- 23:26they wanted a local hire. Thank you. So suffice
- 23:34it to say there was a lot of induced anxiety
- 23:36through the process, yeah? Absolutely. It was
- 23:40very much just being in the dark, not knowing
- 23:43what was happening. I was saying no to a lot
- 23:45of other jobs because I had to prioritize this
- 23:48one. So your life is on hold, and you just want
- 23:52to make sure that any information that is requested
- 23:55of you, you can get it over as soon as possible.
- 23:59But another thing that surprised me was media
- 24:03coverage as well, which actually makes sense,
- 24:05makes a lot of sense. And because I don't have
- 24:08a publicist, I manage all of my publicity myself.
- 24:13Okay, it's finding out all these old interviews
- 24:16that I'd done and sending them over and gosh,
- 24:19it was quite shocking to see how much of you
- 24:23is actually on the internet as well. Nothing
- 24:27incriminating. I sure hope not. So that leads
- 24:33me to my next question. What do you wish production...
- 24:36reps understood better about what performers
- 24:39go through on the immigration side that might
- 24:41have helped you in your own situation? I think
- 24:45more communication because in all fairness, the
- 24:51whole process from start to finish took six weeks,
- 24:54which is good going. But when you have to adjust
- 24:57your your sleep patterns to L .A. time and your
- 25:01life is on hold here and I think, and you're
- 25:05saying no to jobs, so I think it's addressing
- 25:08the uncertainty. Like, can you let me know where
- 25:10we're at? Is there anything more that I can do?
- 25:13Is there anything that I can, you know, maybe
- 25:16not do? If my social media presence is being
- 25:19monitored or watched somewhat, okay, what do
- 25:25I need to be conscious of? So maybe some kind
- 25:28of media training as well. I mean, I think that
- 25:30would have really helped, but... I was nocturnal
- 25:34for the most part, so I couldn't get up to much
- 25:37trouble. Thank you so much, John, for sharing
- 25:40your experiences and what you've gone through.
- 25:43So once the visa process is approved, the question
- 25:45then becomes, what did we just agree to and when?
- 25:48And that's where the entertainment side comes
- 25:50in. So I'm going to pass it over to April and
- 25:53Tisha for how contract timing and immigration
- 25:55strategy have to work together. Sounds good.
- 25:59Thank you, Swati. So now that we've laid out
- 26:01the immigration side, I want to turn to what
- 26:04actually happens on the entertainment side because
- 26:08productions are usually negotiating deals, setting
- 26:11schedules while all of this is happening, right?
- 26:15So Tisha, thank you again for being on this panel
- 26:17and sharing your input. So at what point does
- 26:21contract negotiation, would you say typically
- 26:23start relative to the immigration process? parallel,
- 26:28or does one weight on the other? How is that
- 26:31process like? Yeah, thanks. Thanks for having
- 26:34me everyone. And thanks for everyone for watching.
- 26:35And if anyone's looking for a documentary topic,
- 26:38I think following John during his immigration
- 26:40papers would be great material. So to your question,
- 26:46April, it's important that they run parallel
- 26:50from what you're getting from what Christie said,
- 26:55the timing. Is so important and the entertainment
- 27:00contract actually becomes part of the evidentiary
- 27:03record for the process and so the communication
- 27:07between immigration council and entertainment
- 27:09council is a very collaborative. We have to work
- 27:14very collaboratively and so what I see is kind
- 27:17of the ideal. sequence of events, so to speak,
- 27:22is that production identifies the foreign talent
- 27:25and then immigration counsel kicks in with determining
- 27:30the classification, the timing, and the evidence
- 27:34requirements that are going to be needed. And
- 27:37then on the entertainment side, a deal memo or
- 27:40short form contract is negotiated between the
- 27:43parties. And then as the petition timing gets
- 27:48more clarified as the same with the production
- 27:53timeline as well. The long form is in negotiation
- 27:57and they all magically come together and the
- 27:59timing works out perfect. So that's kind of how
- 28:03I see the timing working out. I think it's a
- 28:06part science and a part art and a part prayer
- 28:10perhaps. No, definitely. And I could definitely
- 28:14agree with what you're saying, because as transactional
- 28:17attorneys, when we are dealing with foreign talent,
- 28:22it is so important that, like you said, they
- 28:25have to run in parallel. Immigration counsel
- 28:27and entertainment counsel both have to communicate,
- 28:31especially when there's different moving parts
- 28:34to the transaction. So definitely appreciate
- 28:37your input on that point. Do entertainers need
- 28:41to set up their own loan out company or entity?
- 28:44And if so, when should that happen relative to
- 28:47the visa process from your experience? It's certainly
- 28:51not required for the immigration process. And
- 28:55in fact, if they do, then it needs to be at the
- 28:59outset because the immigration papers and The
- 29:04the loan out company all the paperwork needs
- 29:07to be in the same the same names so to speak
- 29:10and so that needs to be determined. Probably
- 29:13at the probably christy can probably about probably
- 29:17at the very very. Beginning of what what names
- 29:20need to go on the paperwork i imagine they can
- 29:23probably be a minute i'm not quite sure on that
- 29:25side of things but so it's a it's more of a consideration
- 29:28a bigger consideration business consideration
- 29:30of where they're alone out company is. Is advantageous
- 29:34for the for the talent or not. But would you
- 29:38agree that it's better to get, like, immigration
- 29:41council involved before deciding how that company
- 29:44you will interact with that petition? Because
- 29:46sometimes from the outset, right? They know that
- 29:48they're going to use and a loan out company before
- 29:52before engaging in type of agreements that they
- 29:55will. Right? And so it's better to loop in an
- 30:00immigration attorney prior to that. Yes, 100%.
- 30:05Let's see what contract terms would you say are
- 30:08unique to foreign entertainers how do you handle
- 30:12terms like condition presidents termination rights
- 30:16pay or play force majeure and if a visa is delayed
- 30:22or denied. Yeah all those that you just mentioned
- 30:25become that much more important for conditions
- 30:29precedent that's. Pretty like paramount to the
- 30:34contract that it be conditioned on that the talent
- 30:41can that their petition gets approved i mean
- 30:44you need to specify what that condition is not
- 30:46just that they. they're able to you know be united
- 30:49states it's if their petition got approved or
- 30:52do you want to make it on their their actual
- 30:54admission into united states being very specific
- 30:58on what that what that is conditioned upon and
- 31:02very similar with with pay or play if there's
- 31:05a pair play provision at play then that needs
- 31:09to be very clear on what those triggers are and.
- 31:15If it falls on the talent as far as what if they
- 31:19if they fail to do something on their end as
- 31:22far as their paperwork or if it's something that
- 31:25fell through on the production side maybe it
- 31:28got postponed you know six months making things
- 31:31you know near impossible to pull off or with
- 31:34it was the government you know you can always
- 31:37blame the government for for things going sideways.
- 31:40So the pay or play provision needs to have a
- 31:44lot more specificity than a typical entertainment
- 31:47contract. And then similar with a termination,
- 31:52these are all considerations separate from a
- 31:54typical termination provision. With GPF, a strong
- 31:58conditions precedent provision, then the termination
- 32:02provision as it relates to the immigration process
- 32:06will not be that. Different than a typical entertainment
- 32:11contract, but if you want to have it instead
- 32:15of the conditions president have it all on the
- 32:17termination provision that is an option as well
- 32:19as a drafter to make that that choice and then
- 32:23also with a force majeure provision telling not.
- 32:29fulfilling their immigration status is not really
- 32:34grounds for force majeure because that is something
- 32:36that is foreseeable and within the party's control
- 32:40to an extent. What might be more applicable for
- 32:44force majeure that would be applicable, that
- 32:46would be at play perhaps would be a government
- 32:49border shut down or something that makes it impossible
- 32:53on a bigger global scale that's not specific
- 32:59to the parties in the agreement. So don't rely
- 33:02on the force majeure provision. Really hone in
- 33:08on the conditions precedent. And then if there's
- 33:11a pay or play, be super specific on what those
- 33:14conditions are based on. No, definitely. And
- 33:18something I want to emphasize from what you said
- 33:20is a specificity, right? In terms of how we're
- 33:23drafting. As transactional attorneys, our goal
- 33:26is always to allocate the risk in advance so
- 33:30everybody knows what happens in that situation,
- 33:32right? So even when whose fault matters, right?
- 33:36If the actor timely provided everything and the
- 33:38delay is simply processing related, that is a
- 33:42different situation, I would say, from where
- 33:44the talent failed to provide required information.
- 33:46Um, or waited to the last minute. So, you know,
- 33:49putting the burden on on who, right? Um, so thank
- 33:53you definitely for, um, highlighting, um, in
- 33:56terms of, like, drafting, um, those, um, specific
- 33:59provisions that we want to highlight. Which I'll
- 34:02just get back real quick on that. Like most contracts
- 34:05that's a lot of that is going to depend on leverage.
- 34:07Um, if it is a. Difficult to replace performer
- 34:11or someone who's you know, a big high profile
- 34:13name that the production is that is relying on
- 34:17then perhaps the production shoulders more of
- 34:20those burdens. Whereas if it is a emerging talent
- 34:23with less leverage, perhaps the contracts are
- 34:26more putting more of those burdens and on them
- 34:30to fulfill. Definitely in moving on to, like,
- 34:35another question I have, who typically bears
- 34:38the financial risk if a visa doesn't come through
- 34:40in time? Would that be on the production side
- 34:44or on the talent? Yeah, great question. So that
- 34:47piggyback or that ties into what I'm just saying.
- 34:50But first of all, those those specifics do need
- 34:54to be in the contract of who is shouldering those
- 34:56those not just the. The of what happens if it
- 35:02all falls through is that on the town or on the
- 35:05production, but also who is paying for those
- 35:08immigration costs and that really comes down
- 35:11to a negotiating point and then negotiating points
- 35:13always come down to leverage. So there is no
- 35:16right or wrong way to do it. It is just a negotiating
- 35:19point of how to how to balance out those those
- 35:24leverages. No, definitely. I mean, you have on
- 35:28the one hand, right? A production who knowingly
- 35:31hires international talent, chooses immigration
- 35:35lawyer, controls when the petition is initiated,
- 35:38and sets that production schedule. And then on
- 35:41the other hand, if the talent fails to cooperate,
- 35:43doesn't provide documents, or there's an issue
- 35:45personal to the talent, then production is going
- 35:48to want a different result, you know? So, yeah,
- 35:51like you, like you mentioned, it just depends
- 35:53on so like leverage has a lot of input on how
- 35:58it's going to play out ultimately. So if a foreign
- 36:03entertainer is required to participate in premieres,
- 36:07festivals, press junkets, should those obligations
- 36:10be addressed in the immigration planning as well
- 36:13as the contract? Yes, those are if they're part
- 36:17of the services that the talent will be performing
- 36:20or even at their discretion going to be performing
- 36:24then for sure and it needs to be part of the
- 36:28schedule the time the timing schedule that of
- 36:31the production sets out for you know pre -production
- 36:35production post -production what that timeline
- 36:38is so if that is included in their talent agreement
- 36:43then that time needs to be Somehow set forth
- 36:48as well now most most entertainment talent contracts
- 36:52will have promotional activities at the subject
- 36:56to professional availability. I would suggest
- 36:59adding subject to immigration status and authorization
- 37:04is also a condition for their for those types
- 37:10of services. So that's something that's obviously
- 37:13different than a most most. talent contracts.
- 37:18Right, and something that I've heard from other
- 37:19like immigration attorneys that handle this type
- 37:22of work, and I'm sure Christy can speak more
- 37:25to it, is that entertainment lawyers only tend
- 37:28to give only shoot dates or just bare minimum
- 37:31information, which makes it difficult for them
- 37:35to get a scope of the entirety of the production,
- 37:38right, the production schedule. everything that
- 37:41it's going to entail. So that creates more issues
- 37:43in the long run. And let's see another question
- 37:49that I have is when negotiating start dates,
- 37:52exclusivity periods, hold periods or other option
- 37:54periods, how much flexibility should entertainment
- 37:58council build in for possible immigration delays,
- 38:03probably as much as Christy lets us. Those windows
- 38:10are important to I mean there's it's like the
- 38:14Goldilocks specificity and also latitude and
- 38:19getting that right. So that's definitely something
- 38:21you that the entertainment council would want
- 38:23to collaborate and discuss with immigration council
- 38:27to get those those windows. Matching number 1
- 38:33and the most importantly, but also. Determining
- 38:37what that with that immigration window and production
- 38:40window and having those match up. Need to be
- 38:42so I think that's a collaborative decision. Obviously
- 38:46production production is production. They need
- 38:48what they need to make the make the project.
- 38:52So the feasible the practical feasibility, it
- 38:55really is a reality check for product for. production
- 39:00to to get these windows right so that the immigration
- 39:03can can align no exactly and i mean as entertainment
- 39:09council we're thinking about how long production
- 39:12can keep my client unavailable, right? Based
- 39:16like on what John was sharing about his experience,
- 39:18a 30 -day immigration delay is one thing, but
- 39:21an indefinite hold preventing the actor from
- 39:23accepting other work is another. That is often,
- 39:26you know, like you're living it, right? Tisha,
- 39:29you're working on these transactions, so you
- 39:31can definitely talk more about experiencing this
- 39:36type of experience. Can a foreign person form
- 39:42a U .S. production entity? Short answer, yes.
- 39:50So when we start talking about business entities,
- 39:53we go to state business formation laws, which
- 39:56is obviously different than federal immigration
- 39:59laws. And so forming an entity is outside of
- 40:03immigration. um in fact in California and Delaware
- 40:06and probably most other states um at least for
- 40:09an LLC it defines um a person eligible as someone
- 40:13domestic or foreign so it's actually explicitly
- 40:16um stated in in the business formation laws that
- 40:19um a foreign owner foreign owner can or foreign
- 40:22person can own um an LLC um and so that they
- 40:28where so forming owning investing LLC um it doesn't
- 40:31authorize um the person to actually work in the
- 40:35United States. It's when they step foot and start
- 40:37working in the United States when immigration
- 40:39kicks in. So that's an important distinction.
- 40:42And so you can own an LLC, but if you come to
- 40:46the United States to start obviously producing
- 40:50day -to -day operations that's when immigration
- 40:54kicks in. Now if you're coming to the United
- 40:58States for for limited business activities such
- 41:01as meeting with associates or attending a conference
- 41:05and stuff like that a business visa may need
- 41:07to be applied for and that's where Christy comes
- 41:12in. Well, thank you so much, Tisha. This was
- 41:15very valuable information. I'm going to turn
- 41:19over to John. John, you're an actor. You're living
- 41:24this day in and day out. As attorneys, we are
- 41:29advising talent constantly, but cannot imagine
- 41:34being in your shoes. So I want to learn more
- 41:37about your experience in terms of navigating
- 41:42this entire situation. So from the talent side,
- 41:45how much say do you have in your own immigration
- 41:48process versus how much is handled by your team?
- 41:52I think the only real say that I have in the
- 41:55whole process is what I submit in terms of the
- 41:59forms, the letters. But aside from that, there's
- 42:04not much I don't have much too much freedom here,
- 42:09besides what I submit. So it can be a little
- 42:12bit, you can feel a little bit overwhelmed with
- 42:17how much is required of you. And it's like, and
- 42:20you have to be patient as well. That's something
- 42:22that I'll always say to other performers. If
- 42:24you're applying for a visa, you need to be patient
- 42:26and you kind of have to trust the process. But
- 42:30yeah, I think just regular communication would
- 42:33just really... be really helpful. I work with
- 42:36a really great team but sometimes it would go
- 42:39quiet for days on end and sometimes weeks and
- 42:43ah and of course I'm not too sure what's happening
- 42:46and you're always wondering is there any more
- 42:50that I could do? Could I submit more things?
- 42:52Would that hurt my application? Maybe I'll just
- 42:55sit back and wait. Right and I mean I've heard
- 43:00that from other talent as well that Waiting and
- 43:04just especially right now with how immigration
- 43:07is right the delays and uncertainty Can really
- 43:12add to the anxiety and stress of the talent?
- 43:16I know you talked to us about a situation that
- 43:19you've experienced before or you were in limbo
- 43:22of whether or not If you're going to do the project,
- 43:28you were not. Can you walk us through how an
- 43:34immigration time? Like, basically, did you have
- 43:38to put off another deal that you were working
- 43:41on and had to take on a certain project? But
- 43:46you didn't know if you were actually going to
- 43:49be able to get the immigration process in time,
- 43:51and then you had to forgo other opportunities.
- 43:55I had to say no to quite a few opportunities,
- 44:00which so it meant living out of my savings for
- 44:02the duration of of the visa process, really.
- 44:05And it was there was so much uncertainty around
- 44:10this because, OK, I've booked the job, which
- 44:14is amazing, you know, but I need to actually
- 44:18get the visa to actually do the job. And. You
- 44:23know, I did say no to a fair few jobs, which
- 44:25could have really helped at the time. I think
- 44:27in retrospect, there's a couple that I could
- 44:29have done, but you just don't know at the time.
- 44:33So it's being conscious and smart with your money
- 44:38as well. But like I said, I work with a really
- 44:41fantastic team basically because I didn't have
- 44:44a talent agent at the time. The it was the casting
- 44:49department that was my intermediary with with
- 44:52immigration with that side of things. So they
- 44:56would send things to the casting department who
- 44:58would then send me more information and more
- 45:01requirements. And, you know, I did get a few
- 45:05non -updates saying. We don't know yet, but yeah,
- 45:09there were few and far between. So I think it
- 45:11would have been good to know more regularly where
- 45:14we were at. Yeah, just yeah, it was it was only
- 45:19six weeks, I must say, but it was a long six
- 45:23weeks. Well, thank you so much for sharing your
- 45:30perspective as the talent and going through the
- 45:34struggles that you go through while we're still
- 45:36managing the process, the contracts, and everything
- 45:39in between. It looks like we're up for time,
- 45:45so any last parting thoughts that any of the
- 45:49panelists would like to share? I think we go
- 45:56to 1 .30. Oh, I thought it was 1 15th. Yeah,
- 46:01we're we'll see if at least like 5 10 minutes
- 46:04for Q and a at the end. There is 1 thing that
- 46:07I did want to touch on with Christie or the deal
- 46:09memos and how that correlates into like the itinerary
- 46:12that that you're creating for the 0 1 applicant.
- 46:16When did the deal memos come in? How does the.
- 46:19How does the deal memos create the itinerary
- 46:21for this individual as it relates to the length
- 46:24of time that they're going to receive on that
- 46:26O -1 petition? If it's just a one -year project,
- 46:28do they only get that one year? Or if they have
- 46:31several deal memos, are they getting a full three
- 46:33-year period? And then can you touch a little
- 46:35bit on the consultations that are required for
- 46:37the O -1 applications if they're working under,
- 46:40say, SAG -AFTRA, the Producers Guild, how that
- 46:44plays into the application as well? Very good
- 46:47questions. Okay. That really gets into the nitty
- 46:50gritty of the 01 process and is a possible reason
- 46:54for delays. As far as the deal memos, typically,
- 46:58you can either have the actual contract or you
- 47:00could have the deal memo that is laying out the
- 47:04terms of the contract with production. We can
- 47:09only request the validity period as supported
- 47:13by the evidence, so the actual contracts or the
- 47:17deal memos. If the production is supposedly only
- 47:20one year, we can only request one year. If we
- 47:23have multiple productions and you have multiple
- 47:26deal memos, then we can request pretty much from
- 47:28the start of the first production all the way
- 47:31until the end of the last production, up to three
- 47:35years. The 01 can only be for a three -year period.
- 47:39When you extend the 01 visa, typically it's for
- 47:43a one -year period unless you can show that this
- 47:45is a new role, a new event production that they're
- 47:52involved in, and then you can request an additional
- 47:55three -year period. As far as the consultation
- 47:58letters, we can request those pretty much when
- 48:02the petition is primarily done, when we can show
- 48:06that they meet the threshold for the 01 eligibility.
- 48:12because the management organizations, the talent
- 48:18organization can only confirm whether or not
- 48:20they believe that this individual qualifies for
- 48:22the 01. So that's usually the last bit in the
- 48:26process and how long they take, who we're requesting
- 48:29the letter from. That's a little bit outside
- 48:32of our control. And that timeline does need to
- 48:35be considered when you look at the overall petition
- 48:39preparation time. Now for productions in media
- 48:43and in TV and media, you actually have to get
- 48:46two consultation letters, one from the management
- 48:49agency and one from the labor organization. So
- 48:54that's also involved with the process. Now you
- 48:57have two. organizations that you have to rely
- 49:00on to provide you the letter in time. Sometimes
- 49:03there are multiple organizations that you can
- 49:05pick and choose from. And based on your immigration
- 49:08attorney, they can, you know, if they've had
- 49:09experience, they can say, Oh, this one takes
- 49:11forever, or this one's a little bit faster. Oh,
- 49:14this one charges a lot more money. Oh, is this
- 49:17is the production company or whoever the employer
- 49:20that you're working for already a member of that
- 49:24organization, and we can get it for free or faster.
- 49:27Those are all things that It will have to be
- 49:29analyzed at that time. Thank you. So what I'm
- 49:32hearing is there needs to be substantial amount
- 49:34of flexibility to allow for these immigration
- 49:38visas to come in as approved and then allow flexibility
- 49:42for the applicant to go to the consulate and
- 49:44finally get their visa. Yes. Absolutely. I think
- 49:47it was asked like, what are the kind of like
- 49:50lasting thoughts that I have? to be transparent,
- 49:54and I think John can attest to this, the immigration
- 49:57process is going to be more complicated and frankly
- 50:00frustrating than you will expect. You know, especially
- 50:06in this immigration climate, the policies and
- 50:09the processes are changing fairly rapidly. And
- 50:12so whether you're the entertainer, whether you're
- 50:15part of the production crew, whether you're the
- 50:17attorney, we're all often having to be flexible,
- 50:22having to adapt to, like, hey, this new policy
- 50:25dropped, these new forms dropped, these consulates
- 50:28are now not taking any applications, you know,
- 50:31at the time that maybe John applied for his visa,
- 50:34he could go to another country, go to Ireland
- 50:37to apply for a visa because he can't get an appointment
- 50:40in the UK. That may not be an option anymore
- 50:44because now they can only apply for a visa in
- 50:47your country of nationality or residence. So
- 50:50these are the things that working with someone
- 50:54who has a lot of experience can help you navigate.
- 50:59And I had a question for you, Christy. Given
- 51:02the current climate right now, the new administration,
- 51:05in terms of approval rates, how many, like, have
- 51:08you seen it being difficult to actually have
- 51:10an O -1 petition approved? Is it, like, difficult,
- 51:14or are you seeing a lot of RFEs coming in? Okay.
- 51:19You know, not just your own, you know, or anything,
- 51:21but I haven't had any denials, knock on wood.
- 51:25So I think the approval rates are still fairly
- 51:27good, but The rates are certainly skyrocketing
- 51:32and this is across all immigration types. So,
- 51:38because the RFP, even if, like I said earlier,
- 51:41if the RFP is not legitimate, you still have
- 51:43to provide a substantive response. And that,
- 51:47especially if you need additional reference letters
- 51:50could take a lot more time in preparing the response.
- 51:55Thank you. All right, so we'll open it up to
- 52:00Tisha April or John if you guys have any closing
- 52:03thoughts on your specific area of expertise Things
- 52:08that you wish people understood a little bit
- 52:10better John as it relates on the actors part
- 52:13or the performers part Tisha April as it relates
- 52:16to the entertainment as the entertainment attorneys
- 52:19part In collaboration with the immigration side.
- 52:23Go ahead. The floor is yours Yeah, I'll just
- 52:26add real quick that You know you can't rely on
- 52:29just a template a talent template because of
- 52:35so many of the specifics have to be well specific
- 52:38and so even with with pre -production activity
- 52:41number one you can't require the talent to be
- 52:44on camera unless until their authorization is
- 52:49approved and that needs to be really explicit
- 52:51in the contract but. things the typical things
- 52:55that you kind of take for granted of wardrobe
- 52:57fittings or you know the pre -production activities
- 52:59those need to be timed out with um with specificity
- 53:03and a lot of productions kind of take those dates
- 53:07for granted and they can't when you have a foreign
- 53:10talent so pre -production dates production dates
- 53:14post -production dates need to be need to be
- 53:17really ironed out. I would say going off a little
- 53:22bit of what Tisha said, I would leave everyone
- 53:25with is that immigration and entertainment contracts
- 53:28cannot be treated as separate conversations.
- 53:31The immigration process determines what an artist
- 53:34may be able to do and the entertainment agreement
- 53:36determines the business expectations around the
- 53:39work, right? The scope of the work, what will
- 53:41they be doing? If those two pieces are not coordinated
- 53:45early on, you can have a great deal that the
- 53:48artist cannot ultimately perform due to immigration
- 53:52issues, right? So the best outcome I believe
- 53:55happens when immigration council, entertainment
- 53:58council, the talent and the production team are
- 54:00all communicating from the beginning. Thank you
- 54:05so much, everyone. I'm going to go over into
- 54:08the Q &A. So this one I'm going to go over to
- 54:12Christy. You have previously talked about Agency
- 54:17versus employers sponsoring for the one. Would
- 54:21you suggest that it's still the same case for
- 54:25tour for musicians who are touring in having
- 54:28to apply for a new petition every single time
- 54:30they're going to a new to a new venue to perform
- 54:33or if it's a new production that they're performing
- 54:35for as a touring group, do they have to apply
- 54:38for a new one or. My personal opinion would be
- 54:43apply. under a single agent and then have that
- 54:46itinerary long term so that you can at least
- 54:49secure those three years and you have each of
- 54:51the performances secured under that same O1.
- 54:55But I'll open the floor to you. Yeah, I think
- 54:57I agree with you completely. File under an agent
- 55:01O1. In the petition, the language should be very
- 55:05specific, that it's more open -ended. In that
- 55:08case, you could ask you could have additional
- 55:12events that you're tackling on without having
- 55:15to file an O -1 amendment or a new petition,
- 55:18so long as you're still doing the same activity,
- 55:21performing the same role as your O -1 petition.
- 55:24But if in your petition, it's narrowly tailored
- 55:27to a specific event or just a specific production,
- 55:32you may have shot yourself in the foot and it
- 55:34doesn't have that flexibility. Thank you. And
- 55:38then I'm going to open this up to everyone that's
- 55:40here. Are there advantages to being both an immigration
- 55:44attorney and an entertainment attorney? And if
- 55:47so, what do you see as those advantages? I can
- 55:55start. I think there are certainly advantages.
- 55:59You can understand the process from both sides.
- 56:03Right. Like certainly as an immigration attorney,
- 56:06I don't have the expertise from the entertainment
- 56:09side. I don't know what's going to be important
- 56:11in the contracts and how that will involve the
- 56:14timeline of the production and the actor's needs.
- 56:19On the other hand, gosh, like just being an immigration
- 56:23attorney is already hard enough on its own. I
- 56:27have a hard time imagining someone being so having
- 56:32the knowledge needed to, you know, adequately
- 56:38or exceptionally, you know, work on both sides.
- 56:43But that could just be me. No, I agree with that.
- 56:48I think with both industries being in such an
- 56:52evolving space with new rulings, and it would
- 56:58be a lot to Keep up with all the changes and
- 57:02yet if anyone's willing wanting to do that, then
- 57:05I say go for it. Now, definitely it's a huge
- 57:09undertaking. I would say, but. yeah I mean from
- 57:13the entertainment side you're able to anticipate
- 57:15issues that may come up in the like in the immigration
- 57:19process right and then I feel like I don't know
- 57:21they go hand in hand I think and so even when
- 57:25drafting contracts you're anticipating things
- 57:27that you know being on the immigration side but
- 57:32as just working in entertainment I'm constantly
- 57:35reaching out to the immigration attorney and
- 57:38trying to see, okay, what else should I anticipate,
- 57:40what delays, what things can go wrong, right?
- 57:43Because I'm not in that field of practice, but
- 57:45I feel that there's definitely advantages to
- 57:48becoming both. I agree with all of your sentiments
- 57:53and especially Christie's, it's already hard
- 57:55enough being an immigration attorney under this
- 57:57climate and keeping up to date with each of the
- 57:59changes that come out almost every day is tough.
- 58:02So I can only imagine having the wealth of knowledge
- 58:05of both sides. And then we do have two more minutes.
- 58:09So the last question I'll go over is DUIs and
- 58:12how they impact, you know, you can address those
- 58:16head on with the USCIS petition, but once you're
- 58:19at the consulate, you can only prepare your client
- 58:21on how to address that issue if it does come
- 58:24up at the interview, right? So if a visa is denied
- 58:27for any reason due to criminal background issue,
- 58:30how do you prepare your clients for that, Christy?
- 58:32And how can you be proactive about? about something
- 58:37like a DUI or an issue of such a thought? Have
- 58:42all the documents with you. It takes a long time
- 58:44to get them through the criminal courts. Be prepared.
- 58:49A DUI or something minor may not preclude you
- 58:54from getting a visa, but the consulate will want
- 58:58to see those documentation. Additionally, it
- 59:01does increase the risk of administrative processing,
- 59:04meaning that security check. So keep in mind
- 59:07that it could could add delays. With that, we
- 59:11have no additional questions. So thank you so
- 59:14much to the Beverly Hills Bar Association, the
- 59:16Orange County Bar Association, each of our panelists
- 59:19and Dr. John Zhang for joining our panel. We
- 59:24are so appreciative of all of you. And thanks
- 59:28for joining our panel.