Latest / Film And Whiskey / Past Lives / Jack Daniel's 12-Year Tennessee Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 2023, director Celine Song and star Greta Lee gave the
- 0:05world a quiet drama about the beauty of intertwining stories
- 0:10and fateful choices. In 2025, we take a cue from this
- 0:15movie's 12 year increments with our Whiskey for the day.
- 0:18The film is past lives. The whiskey is Jack Daniels 12
- 0:23year batch 1. And more.
- 0:25Review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:29podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:51podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:54glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:57I'm Brad G. And this week we are looking at
- 0:59one of Bob Book's favorite movies of the last God knows how
- 1:03long ever of all time. It's 2023's Past Lives.
- 1:08Bob, you have been just raving about this film since it came
- 1:13out, and I very famously watched it due to your influence on the
- 1:18back of an airplane seat as I flew to Colorado.
- 1:22Now, as I recall this story going, Brad, not only did you
- 1:24watch this movie on an airplane, which depending on the time of
- 1:28day and the fullness of the airplane, could be a good
- 1:32airplane watch. It's a very quiet movie.
- 1:34Like it's, you know, if you're on a red eye, this is a great
- 1:36movie. But you were also surrounded by
- 1:39people who were watching the film Barbie on surrounding
- 1:43screens. Is that right?
- 1:44Sure was. There was just one person a row
- 1:47in front of me to the right, so I could like see like 70% of
- 1:52their screen. And I used the soundless 70% of
- 1:57the screen, you know, occasional glances at that, that film to
- 2:02decide that I don't like Barbie. But I mean, nevertheless a
- 2:07prominent distraction given that movie's color palette and just
- 2:10general vibe. So not ideal circumstances to
- 2:14watch this movie. And I will also say on rewatch,
- 2:17for myself, at least, not ideal circumstances for watching this
- 2:21movie because we're recording this on the morning of Saturday
- 2:24the 11th. So a little over a week before
- 2:27this episode comes out, and famously for us huge Ohio State
- 2:32Buckeyes fans, it is the morning.
- 2:35The morning following Ohio State's win over Texas in the
- 2:39college football semifinals. I would say when this episode
- 2:42releases, we will know if we are the national champions once
- 2:47again. Yeah, it could be good or bad
- 2:48for us, but we're currently flying high off of that win.
- 2:51And then I immediately had to go watch this movie, which is a
- 2:54very quiet and admittedly a slow paced movie.
- 2:58So the adrenaline doesn't. Quite have the same ring as a 83
- 3:05yard scoop and score to win the game.
- 3:07Yeah, that that carryover was a little weird.
- 3:09Man the 1st 30 ish minutes of this movie.
- 3:11I had to really reorient myself to get in the zone here.
- 3:15Yeah, and this is a movie worth getting in the zone for.
- 3:19If I had to imagine, Bob, I'm going to guess that maybe 20 to
- 3:2430% of film and Whiskey Nation has seen this movie.
- 3:27Would you say that's fair? Yeah, probably less than that.
- 3:30I mean, people don't watch the quote UN quote Oscar movies
- 3:34anymore and this wasn't a lot of ways the little engine that
- 3:37could last year just to get a nomination because I think a 24
- 3:40released this movie in like March, May.
- 3:43It was really, really early on in the year and because the
- 3:46reviews were so good, it carried positive momentum.
- 3:49And it was like, I remember when the Oscar nominations came out,
- 3:52it was kind of like, will this get that 9th or 10th slot
- 3:56because it had just fallen so far out of people's memories?
- 3:58But it was a really well liked movie.
- 4:00I say all that to say, I don't know if people would have seen
- 4:04this movie in theaters. I don't know if people have
- 4:06caught it on like wherever it's streaming, Hulu, but maybe if
- 4:09you follow the Oscars, you've gone back to see this film.
- 4:12Bob This is streaming currently on the wildly popular Paramount
- 4:18Plus. Paramount Plus, baby.
- 4:20OK, but you know what's funny is like I've never, I've never
- 4:25thought to myself like I want an entire studios catalogue and
- 4:30only that studios catalogue. Sign me up.
- 4:33Like Max is the closest I've gotten cause Warner Brothers is
- 4:36really a great back catalogue. But when are you ever going to
- 4:39be like I associate this with Paramount.
- 4:42So I want to sign up for Paramount.
- 4:45The the only thing that I know that is like I do associate with
- 4:49Paramount is the Mission Impossible series.
- 4:53Well worth a Paramount Plus subscription.
- 4:56I currently have had Paramount Plus for about 4 1/2 years.
- 5:03What? Really.
- 5:04Yeah, I we paid for well. So I'll say this, we signed up
- 5:10like right when it opened for their yearly membership because
- 5:13we want to watch some survivor. Haley was pregnant with our
- 5:17first child and like that was just her go to.
- 5:21Like I'm annoyed at the world. I just want to chill and watch
- 5:25Survivor and I like Survivor as well.
- 5:27So we signed up for a year and a few months later I was like,
- 5:29man, I don't know if our credit card actually charged for that.
- 5:32And then like a year later I was like, man, we still haven't
- 5:35gotten charged for Paramount Plus.
- 5:38And here we are four years in. I have never once paid for
- 5:42Paramount Plus and yet still have full access.
- 5:45Well. They they've got you now because
- 5:47you've confessed on air, Brad. So.
- 5:49That's true. Yeah, the end of Brad's
- 5:51Paramount Plus subscription is coming soon, but it's time for
- 5:53us to talk about this movie. So in order to do that, let's
- 5:56get into our first segment of the day, which we call Brad
- 5:59Explains Brad's going to give. Us the movie plots with only 60
- 6:03seconds taken on the clock. So let's go ahead and do your
- 6:06take with this little segment that we call, Brad explains.
- 6:10Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 6:13plot of the movie that he has just seen often for the first
- 6:16time. This is, I believe, my third
- 6:19full time through with Past Lives.
- 6:22And then I caught the end of it on like we have a DIRECTV
- 6:25subscription and I think it comes with stars or one of
- 6:27those. I found the last five minutes of
- 6:30it one night and I was like, oh hell yeah, I'll watch the last
- 6:32five minutes of this. So I'm at like 3.1 viewings of
- 6:36this movie now. Brad, I think this is your
- 6:38second full viewing, first where it got your full attention.
- 6:42So I'm pretty excited to hear you explain this movie.
- 6:45Is it fair to say pretty simple plot.
- 6:48Very simple plot. All right, well, I'll give you a
- 6:50full minute. You can use it however you'd
- 6:52like. 60 seconds. Spoil this movie and go.
- 6:57Past Lives is a film that follows 3 main characters, Nora,
- 7:01Heysung, and Arthur. Nora and Haysung were childhood
- 7:05friends when Nora's parents emigrated to Canada and then she
- 7:11eventually goes to New York. Haysung is a childhood friend
- 7:15that they kind of childhood sweethearts if you will.
- 7:18They reconnect for a little bit in 2012 when they're in their
- 7:23mid 20s. They separate because distance
- 7:26is keeping them apart. And then 12 years later, they
- 7:29finally reconnect in person for the first time in 24 years,
- 7:33where Nora is married to an American author named Arthur,
- 7:38and the three of them spend a few days in town together,
- 7:41exploring what it means to live their lives, fully embracing the
- 7:47choices that they've made. Brad, I love this movie, and I
- 7:54think I've talked enough on this podcast about how much I love
- 7:56this movie that people will know.
- 7:58I've been looking forward to today.
- 8:00I want to try to make this as much about your experience with
- 8:03the film as possible. But I think that the movie is
- 8:06such a deep, aching, vulnerable exploration of longing and
- 8:15regrets and grief and commitment and affirmation that in me at
- 8:21least, it inspired me. I, I went to see this movie The
- 8:23second time I took my wife. I was like, I really want you to
- 8:26see this with me. And we had one of the best
- 8:28conversations we've ever had about the nature of marriage and
- 8:31commitment on the way home from this movie.
- 8:34I think if you engage with this movie on its terms, it brings up
- 8:40a vulnerability in yourself. And so I don't, you know, I, I
- 8:44obviously I'm not going to make you like name every sweetheart
- 8:48you've ever had in your life here, Brad, my soul.
- 8:51But I do think that we'll probably get a little bit more
- 8:56wax poetic, I guess, is what I would say today, because I think
- 8:59that's the kind of thing that this movie inspires in me.
- 9:02So if you don't enjoy that, you can get the.
- 9:05Hell out of here, yeah. You can turn a few episodes ago
- 9:10and listen to our Mad Max episode.
- 9:12It will. You will enjoy it thoroughly.
- 9:15So let's set the stage a little bit here because this is the
- 9:18directorial debut of Celine Song and this is a semi
- 9:21autobiographical movie. So in the press notes that 824
- 9:25put out, they said that she had the idea for the movie when she
- 9:29was in a very similar situation to this, where she was in a bar
- 9:32in New York City one night and she was sitting between her
- 9:35husband on one side and her childhood sweetheart who was
- 9:38visiting from Korea on the other side.
- 9:41And this idea for a movie in which, you know, you're crossing
- 9:46the boundary of different past versions of yourself and
- 9:49bridging that gap. And what would it look like if
- 9:51there was still love involved? And then, you know, like the
- 9:53contours of the movie started to come to her in that moment.
- 9:56And I think that what if I could just set the states this way,
- 10:00Brad, what always strikes me about this movie is it's really
- 10:06specific to these three people, but it's so deeply taps into the
- 10:10universal. And I'm just curious, like, does
- 10:14that resonate with you here? Yeah, I think that, hey, my
- 10:20first question is, do you think that her childhood sweetheart
- 10:23gets residuals for this, this script because like he is the
- 10:28inspiration for the whole film? Maybe, you know what?
- 10:30Maybe let's get that out of the way first.
- 10:32So she's married to the screenwriter Justin Kuritsky's,
- 10:35I think his last name is. And it is very funny to look at
- 10:40the the way that they both analyze their relationship
- 10:43through their work. So Celine Song comes out with
- 10:46this movie and then it gets announced that Justin Kuritsky's
- 10:50is working with the director Luca Guadagnino this year.
- 10:53And they're making this movie called Challengers, which is a
- 10:56highly sexualized movie in which a domineering, manipulative,
- 11:03sexually, I guess, domineering again, Zendaya, like is
- 11:12dominatrix Zendaya, Yeah, kind of is pulling strings with these
- 11:17two guys in her life that have been part of her life for years
- 11:20and years and years. So then people are like, well,
- 11:22is this his take on this exact same story?
- 11:25And then it gets announced that her next movie that's coming
- 11:28out, I think next year. It's a movie called
- 11:30Materialists. Here's the plot line that
- 11:33they've released so far. Set in New York City, the film
- 11:36follows the story of a matchmaker, her ex-boyfriend and
- 11:40a wealthy businessman. So it's they are really plumbing
- 11:44the depths of their own Freudian psyche here, Brad.
- 11:48Yeah, I was going to say, man, whatever it takes, make that
- 11:51money. Make that money.
- 11:54Love triangles, man, people, people just enjoy love
- 11:58triangles. And I think that's like the
- 12:00fascinating thing about this film is I don't it's not the
- 12:04love triangle that you think it is.
- 12:07You know what I mean? Like the love triangle is hey
- 12:11Sung and 12 year old Nora and adult Nora trying to reclaim who
- 12:21she was as a child and experience that a little bit
- 12:24again, but also still be an adult who's married to Arthur.
- 12:28And the husband is like just honored to get a glimpse into
- 12:33who his wife was as a child in a very foreign world to him.
- 12:36It's like a really weird, almost like a time hopping love
- 12:41triangle A. 100% yeah. And I think that I've already
- 12:45compared this movie on this podcast before to Brief
- 12:48Encounter, which is a movie from the 1940s that, you know, Brad
- 12:51had never heard of until I I put it on the schedule, I think in
- 12:54our season 5 where we could just pick whatever we wanted and.
- 12:57Really leaned into that one. And it ended up being one of our
- 13:02favorite movies that we've ever watched on this podcast.
- 13:04And I think that Brief Encounter or Past Lives is a brief
- 13:08encounter for our times, Brad. It's a really mature exploration
- 13:13of the people we are, the people we have been.
- 13:17The fact that when people exit your lives, they don't
- 13:21necessarily exit your thoughts or your desires.
- 13:24That we never get a chance to reconcile with loss when it
- 13:28happens suddenly and what that looks like when it resurfaces in
- 13:31our life. And I think that both of these
- 13:34are movies for grown-ups. Like if you're going to go into
- 13:36this movie with this attitude of like, this is a movie in which a
- 13:41woman parades around her ex in front of her husband, then you
- 13:45are already looking at this movie through the the wrong
- 13:48lens. It's a super sympathetic movie
- 13:50to everyone. And I think that because it is
- 13:53equally sympathetic and empathetic to its characters, it
- 13:57forces you as an audience member to put on your big boy pants and
- 14:02take it at its own terms, which is what do mature people do when
- 14:07confronted with issues in their relationships?
- 14:10And that's the beauty of this movie.
- 14:12You know, there's an interview with director Celine Song where
- 14:16she talked about how so many dramas deal with adults acting
- 14:22like their children and making immature decisions.
- 14:25And she wanted to explore, like, what do you do when adults still
- 14:30act like adults? They still lean into their
- 14:32responsibilities and who they've chosen to be rather than like,
- 14:37second guessing the decisions that they've made, and yet also
- 14:43just engage with their emotions on an honest level.
- 14:46And like, it is easily the most mature movie I think I've seen
- 14:54ever. Like, everybody is honest about
- 14:58where they're at, honest about what's going through their heart
- 15:01at the time, and yet still, like makes good decisions.
- 15:05They're honoring to one another. Dude, when Hey Sung looks at
- 15:10Nora and says, I didn't think it would hurt so much to like your
- 15:14husband. Like what a great freaking line,
- 15:19dude. I think that if you're going to
- 15:21knock this movie, you could say that this is like a millennial's
- 15:25wet dream. Of what, you know, liberal ideas
- 15:30of like consent and openness and all.
- 15:32Like it's a very like, do people really act like this in real
- 15:36life? And yet I think because it it
- 15:40kind of makes you accepted on those terms.
- 15:42I never once thought that the movie was cloying or pandering
- 15:45or talking down to anybody. It didn't seem preachy.
- 15:48It was just these are people who have really clear, open
- 15:52communication with each other and this is how they would
- 15:55respond in a situation like this.
- 15:57And what it ultimately leads to is a movie that more than any
- 16:01other I can remember in the last, you know, 10-15 years is
- 16:05incredibly respectful of what a marriage is about.
- 16:10I think if this was the more Hollywood eyes version of this
- 16:13movie, you know, it's it's a story about her sleeping with
- 16:18him and then trying to figure out, do I want to stay with my
- 16:20husband? And there's even a great scene
- 16:22in the middle of the movie, which we'll talk about at some
- 16:24point where the two where Nora and Arthur are talking about
- 16:30what a great story this would make.
- 16:32And so they're contextualizing it there.
- 16:34But this movie doesn't go that route.
- 16:35That's the easy way out. That's the like salacious story.
- 16:39This is the story that asks like, hey, we're adults and we
- 16:42know that we're not going to kiss each other.
- 16:45We're not going to sleep with each other.
- 16:48I'm we're not going to be together.
- 16:50How do we explain the fact that we loved each other and we had
- 16:55no resolution within the context of where we are as people now?
- 16:59And that is ultimately such a more interesting question to ask
- 17:03and explore. Because it, it allows for the
- 17:08depth of the human experience to be explored more intensely and
- 17:13more honestly. Like at the end of the day at
- 17:17like, everybody loves a good drama like Rag, right?
- 17:22Where it's like, here's the terrible things that these
- 17:25people do. And even like you look at
- 17:27something like the Philadelphia Story and it's it's all about
- 17:29this socialite who finds true love in leaving her spouse at
- 17:34the altar, right? Like it's it, like you said,
- 17:37it's salacious and people love that.
- 17:39And I'm not saying it's bad to enjoy things like that, but it's
- 17:43nice to have a movie that explores it with emotionally.
- 17:48Like at the very least, they're like B minus mature that, you
- 17:52know, they're not like perfect, They're not like the most
- 17:54emotionally mature people ever to live.
- 17:57But man, they feel real. And for me, my favorite scene of
- 18:01the film is when Arthur and Nora are sitting in bed talking to
- 18:06each. Other it's mine as well.
- 18:07I would like let's let's hold off on that because I think that
- 18:10really is the crux of the movie for me.
- 18:12And to your point earlier, Brad, I mean, it might have been
- 18:15before we pressed record. I'm coming off the high of this
- 18:18Buckeyes game. I pressed play on this movie and
- 18:21it took me a minute to really get into the movie and I was
- 18:24having this like, Oh no, is this not as good as I thought it was
- 18:27moment. And I would say that lasted for
- 18:29the first twenty 30-40 minutes of the movie where it was good
- 18:33and I respected what they were doing, but I wasn't like
- 18:35emotionally clicking with it as I had.
- 18:38And it hits almost exactly the halfway point is where they
- 18:42finally meet each other face to face in the park.
- 18:45And everything following that in this movie was like, oh, this is
- 18:49like, I'm, I'm aching alongside these characters because it has
- 18:53me so gripped emotionally. But in order to talk about that
- 18:56part of the movie, I think let's let's get the first chunk of the
- 19:00movie out of the way. So it starts with these
- 19:03characters as 12 year olds in Korea very quickly moving to I'm
- 19:08moving away. You see the two of them holding
- 19:10hands and childhood sweethearts. And then she's emigrating to
- 19:14Canada. And then it jumps 12 years
- 19:16forward in time and he's doing his mandatory military service
- 19:20and she's going to college and moving to New York City.
- 19:24Go ahead the. Shot of him marching and then
- 19:26sitting there eating and like, you talk about expressive
- 19:32filmmaking where you know that he's thinking about her without
- 19:35there being any indication that he's thinking about her.
- 19:39Dude, yeah. Teo Teo you I believe is his
- 19:43name. Just freaking nails it.
- 19:47So I think this is the the part of that first chunk I really
- 19:50want to talk about is them as early 20 somethings because they
- 19:53do such a good job of playing young adults, even though the
- 19:57both of these actors are in their 30s.
- 19:59And it's it's very much posture and body language and having
- 20:04that sort of youthful exuberance.
- 20:06And you get this moment where they finally reconnect via
- 20:10Skype. Remember Skype, They were they
- 20:13connect via Skype. And she at one point she
- 20:16mentioned Eternal Sunshine and they kind of have this eternal
- 20:20Sunshine like montage that lasts 10 minutes in the movie of.
- 20:25Their relationship unfolding, all the conversations they have,
- 20:28them deepening their bond with each other, the missing calls
- 20:32from each other. And you can kind of see the
- 20:33rhythm get thrown off and how it ultimately ends with them
- 20:37because their lives are going in different directions and she has
- 20:40to cut it off. I'm wondering, Brad, of that
- 20:43whole first section, childhood and young adulthood, what worked
- 20:47best for you and what didn't work for you?
- 20:49Oh. Dude, I'm about to bring up the
- 20:51greatest movie of all time. Do you remember our discussion
- 20:58about how perfectly Elizabethtown captures the like
- 21:04boyfriend girlfriend late night self of conversation of 2006 a.
- 21:08100%. Dude, like, and I know that part
- 21:11of this is my experience, but when I was in college, I dated a
- 21:16girl who studied abroad in Italy for, you know, four months.
- 21:20And we would Skype like that at those sounds, the beeping sounds
- 21:26that Skype made when it started and ended and lost connection
- 21:29and all the things I was like in my fields, just hearing those
- 21:34sounds. And I like this time through, I
- 21:37was like, man, they're not really capturing the shoddy
- 21:42connection of the early 2000 tens.
- 21:45And then they had a montage of like 9 missed calls in a row
- 21:49where her going, hey son, are you there?
- 21:52Like where, where'd you go? And and he's on the other end
- 21:55doing the same thing. And I was like, Yep, that's it.
- 21:58That's it. Like it is the most perfect
- 22:02cinematic illustration of like a very specific time period where
- 22:07Skype was the only way to video chat with people and it was
- 22:10unreliable. And it was awesome.
- 22:12And like, I still vividly remember the first time I used
- 22:15Skype. I, I was like talking to an old
- 22:17friend from summer camp that I hadn't seen in like 3 years.
- 22:20And we get on a Skype call that I had never heard of.
- 22:23And she told me like, we'll download this Skype thing.
- 22:26It'll let U.S. chat on video. And I'm, I know I'm making
- 22:28myself sound really old right now, but I remember literally
- 22:32thinking to myself as a freshman in college, like what do you
- 22:35mean chat on video? Like like that's wild.
- 22:41I understand phone calls but the idea of talking to you live on a
- 22:44video feed was insane to me. That's funny, dude.
- 22:48Yeah, yeah. I think that's part of why I say
- 22:50that it's Brief Encounter for our times, is that it is
- 22:54nostalgic for things that only millennials will feel nostalgia
- 22:57for. But I think that because there
- 23:00are such universal themes here, you could absolutely tap into
- 23:03it, whether you're a boomer or, you know, Gen.
- 23:05Z or whatever you might be. I think that the whole movie's
- 23:09kind of slow paced on purpose. It's very meditative and kind of
- 23:11dreamlike in the way that the camera just kind of glides in
- 23:14and out of scenes. But it's paced really well
- 23:17because that that early section of them as children is like 8
- 23:21minutes long. And then you get maybe, you
- 23:23know, 2025 minutes of them as young adults.
- 23:27And then it's immediately dropping you another 12 years
- 23:30forward in time to when they're in their mid 30s.
- 23:33And so the whole second-half of the movie is this conundrum that
- 23:38comes up when he makes contact with her to let her know he's
- 23:41coming to visit New York City. Secretly, she's worried, and her
- 23:46husband is worried that he's coming because he's still in
- 23:49love with her. And will they or won't they?
- 23:52Will it be confirmed that he's still in love with her?
- 23:54That's where the dramatic tension of this movie rises.
- 23:57But even saying dramatic tension doesn't quite feel right.
- 24:00It doesn't feel like this movie is ever really making you think
- 24:06that she's going to cheat on her husband or, like, is there going
- 24:09to be this passionate moment where they both break and make
- 24:12out with each other? The tension arises from like,
- 24:15what's going to happen to this relationship?
- 24:18Like, are are they going to blow it?
- 24:20Is he going to blow it with her in such a way that it like,
- 24:22ruins everything? You know, it, it comes from a
- 24:24much more human place than a like, horny place, if I can be
- 24:29that frank about it. And I think that's what makes
- 24:31the movie work. Absolutely.
- 24:33The the moment when they first see each other and like you
- 24:39could, you could just see it in the actor's eyes and bodies and
- 24:43the the tension is so thick you can cut it with a knife that
- 24:47like she enters back into the physical.
- 24:52I'm around you again for the first time in 24 years
- 24:54relationship with the bright bubbliness of a 12 year old.
- 24:59And you can tell that that's what she's looking to get out of
- 25:01this of like, oh man, I like I have an opportunity to like
- 25:05capture a little bit of my youth and remember who I was when I
- 25:08lived in Korea for the final time.
- 25:10And and like this is an opportunity to engage with that.
- 25:13And she becomes a little bit of a 12 year old again.
- 25:16And he is entering into that space as a 30 something year old
- 25:20man who's not necessarily like trying to win the girl back, but
- 25:25he's trying to explore like, what does this relationship mean
- 25:29to me today, here and now and then?
- 25:33And like, the way she hugs him is so powerful.
- 25:36And then you juxtaposition that with when they leave and she
- 25:39can't hug him because she doesn't want to see her 12 year
- 25:42old self disappear. And he leans in and gives her a
- 25:45massive hug. I'm almost like embracing who
- 25:48she's become now. Yes.
- 25:50I am so glad that you're catching on to those things
- 25:52because there are so many callbacks.
- 25:54And it's something that like, I didn't even notice how many
- 25:57callbacks there are to the early scenes of the movie, whether
- 26:00it's them as 20 somethings or as children.
- 26:02But they're sowing seeds that they come back to harvest later
- 26:06on in the movie in such profound ways.
- 26:09You know, going back to that scene where they first meet each
- 26:12other in person. You have Hey Sung coming to New
- 26:16York City. It's like a rainstorm.
- 26:18They show him in his hotel room and he just, he doesn't know
- 26:22what to do. He opens the curtains, he's
- 26:23looking out on New York City, and he's just sitting alone on
- 26:25the bed. And to that point in the movie,
- 26:28and even later in the movie, every single time you see that
- 26:31character by himself, he is in the middle of a big city,
- 26:37whether it's when he goes to China or whether he's in Seoul
- 26:41or whether he's in New York City.
- 26:43And there is nightlife happening outside his window.
- 26:46And there's like the bustling culture of wherever he is.
- 26:50And he is just trapped in in this room by himself.
- 26:54And it's such a great representation of where he's at
- 26:56emotionally. Not can.
- 26:57I get really quickly. Oh please.
- 26:59They also often in those scenes trap him in a frame within a
- 27:03frame. Did you notice that we're like,
- 27:06you see him from the kitchen area of the the hotel suite and
- 27:11he's like, you see through the little window in the wall and
- 27:14then he's sitting in front of a window full of rain with like
- 27:17one light shining on him. And you're just like, this is
- 27:21like every cinema part of me is just like, I don't know if this
- 27:26is like overboard and doing it too much, but it's working for
- 27:29me. Oh.
- 27:30No, I love, I think the cinematography in this movie is
- 27:32super underrated. There's this scene where they go
- 27:35to ride the ferry to Ellis Island together.
- 27:39And the way that it's shot like you're watching them in line,
- 27:42but it's shot from like outside of the queue and like under some
- 27:45sort of an overhang. And so the top and bottom of the
- 27:48screen are all blacked out. And so it almost looks like
- 27:51they've changed aspect ratios for a minute.
- 27:53It's. A natural aspect ratio, yeah,
- 27:56but it's also like, what's it called?
- 27:58What's it called when the the music is diegetic?
- 28:02Yeah, it's like diegetic screen. But once again, it's like
- 28:07putting them in this frame within a frame, almost
- 28:10suggesting that like, his idea of spending time with her is
- 28:13like this, you know, romanticized painting that
- 28:17you're going to hang up somewhere.
- 28:18It's not real life. And I they never do that with
- 28:21Arthur and Nora. No, never, ever.
- 28:23Except for there's one moment. There's one moment at the end of
- 28:26the movie when she says that she's going to go walk him down
- 28:28to his Uber and they leave the camera on him.
- 28:31And they have like, the whole border of the outside of the
- 28:35frame is all blacked out because they've just gotten back to
- 28:37their apartment and he's there and like, standing facing the
- 28:40door, like by himself. Oh they do such a great job with
- 28:43those frames within frames in this movie.
- 28:46Yeah, just absolutely beautiful. I know you were talking about
- 28:50other things but when they're walking past the carousel and
- 28:54it's like life is moving faster around them than their pace
- 28:58together. Like the dude the the
- 29:02cinematography in this movie is just absolutely beautiful.
- 29:07That scene is where I started clicking again with the movie,
- 29:09and I was like, Oh yeah, this is a freaking masterpiece.
- 29:12It's, you know, they've been kind of hinting, not even
- 29:16hinting. What's great about the way they
- 29:17talk to each other is they both know exactly what's going on and
- 29:21nobody wants to be the one to say it.
- 29:23And it's not because they think they're crossing lines, it's
- 29:26because they're both terrified of what it means if they confess
- 29:29that. Not that they have feelings for
- 29:31each other even, but just like, I missed you, I don't know where
- 29:35this puts us. There is no closure here.
- 29:37And so they get in front of this carousel and they're just
- 29:40sitting. And for a while, they're sitting
- 29:42absolutely still as the carousel spins behind them.
- 29:45And Brad, that's where the dialogue in this movie for me
- 29:48took off. And I wrote down.
- 29:50When you get to the back half of this movie, it reminds me a lot
- 29:53of ET, one of my favorite movies, where, like every moment
- 29:57is kind of surface level but also metaphorical.
- 30:00Like there's a double meaning to everything at the end of that
- 30:03movie. And I think every single line in
- 30:06this movie almost from that point to the end, has some sort
- 30:10of a double meaning. You know, like, she's asking
- 30:14him, why did you come here? He's kind of confessing to her,
- 30:17but not really. There's no I love you that comes
- 30:19out of his mouth. And then you hear her just kind
- 30:22of look at him. She leans in a little bit.
- 30:25She says, we were babies then. We're not babies anymore.
- 30:29And you can tell from the way she's saying it that like, she
- 30:33looks legitimately concerned. It's the first time that she's
- 30:37let that sort of smiling, reassuring posture go and she's
- 30:41leaning into him and she's like, you can see with her eyes, she's
- 30:44like pleading with him, but you don't know what she's pleading
- 30:47for. It's this portrayal of I need to
- 30:50hear you say it And at the same time, please God, don't say it
- 30:55because I don't know where that will put us and I don't know
- 30:57where that will put me. And there's so much unspoken and
- 31:01I just think it's a master class in posture and body language and
- 31:05non verbal acting there. Well, and it speaks the, the
- 31:08reason you talked earlier about this feeling like a universal
- 31:12movie that anybody can like access emotionally.
- 31:17And I think the reason is, you know, the, there's all sorts of
- 31:21research into the brain. And one guy, Dan Siegel, writes
- 31:25about how there are 9 domains of the brain, like 9 places that it
- 31:30works within our lives. And one of the domains is in
- 31:34storytelling that, like humans are naturally storytelling
- 31:40creatures. We are trying to make meaning of
- 31:43our lives. And I think that's the reason
- 31:46this movie is so universal is that you're watching these two
- 31:49people dance around the social standards of Nora is married, He
- 31:56is not the their childhood sweethearts, and yet he doesn't
- 32:00want to be a home wrecker. But he's trying to seek
- 32:04validation for what his story was with her.
- 32:09And she is trying to seek validation for what her story
- 32:12was with him, even though they're in vastly different
- 32:15places now. And I think that is why this
- 32:18movie is so beautiful is that it honors the reality that we are
- 32:23storytelling creatures and our stories don't die the moment we
- 32:29move on from the present moment. A. 100% they.
- 32:33Live on in our imagination, they live on in our memory.
- 32:38And when they are never acknowledged, it can become
- 32:43something dangerous that that like ferments in the back corner
- 32:47of your mind and grows into something it shouldn't be.
- 32:50But there is that catharsis of just being honest to say we can
- 32:55get through this. Like, this was real.
- 32:57And the cool thing is that moment of catharsis doesn't
- 33:01truly come until after Heysung meets Arthur.
- 33:07And like, once they've met, once they've spent a little time
- 33:10together and he's like, oh, crap.
- 33:12I actually like, really like this husband.
- 33:15I like, I think he's really good for Nora.
- 33:19That's when he's finally able to say, yeah, our, our relationship
- 33:23meant so much to me. And she is able to say it back
- 33:27to him. And there's something about
- 33:28honoring the present that allows them to go back and validate the
- 33:32past. Yeah.
- 33:33I think what I love about the movie is that there's a sense of
- 33:35inevitability, Like everyone knows this is not going to end
- 33:39with her running away with him. And she says that out loud at
- 33:41one point, you know? And so there's no dramatic
- 33:44tension in that regard. But because you care so much
- 33:47about these characters, all three of them and their
- 33:50emotional fragility, I think that's where it comes is that
- 33:53you you access that sort of longing and yearning.
- 33:57You access the grief, you access the loss.
- 34:00It all comes flooding back. And and Brad, before we go to
- 34:03break, I think that I do want to talk really briefly about Greta
- 34:06Lee in this role as Nora. I think all three of these main
- 34:11actors should have been nominated for Oscars, and I'm
- 34:13pissed off that not one of them did.
- 34:15But her character, I think, is really difficult to play
- 34:20because, you know, it's written from Celine Song's perspective
- 34:23at least somewhat. And I think that in the wrong
- 34:27hands, an actress could make this character seem like really
- 34:32evil, kind of bitchy, you know what I mean?
- 34:34And the fact that A, they're able to avoid any of that.
- 34:37But it's such a tough character to play because if she seems
- 34:42overly flirty with Hey Sung, then we as an audience will turn
- 34:47on her. Like, you are abandoning your
- 34:49husband. You're leading this guy on.
- 34:51But if she seems overly aloof in the way that she treats him,
- 34:55then we'll think she's being too cold to him.
- 34:57And you know, we won't be on her side then too.
- 35:00So because. Heysung is so likable.
- 35:03Oh yeah, and, and also so obviously, like I am in love
- 35:07with you. Please don't hurt me in my puppy
- 35:09dog eyes. Like, I don't know if I could
- 35:11entirely say that the way he he behaves all the time is super
- 35:15appropriate. Like it's not, it's not
- 35:17disrespectful. He's always respectful.
- 35:19But like, from the moment they meet each other, he's like, hey,
- 35:23you want you want to, you want to be with me now.
- 35:25You know what I mean? Yeah.
- 35:26You want to choose me? And so in every situation, she
- 35:29actually has to be the most knowing person and you can see
- 35:33her processing other people's emotions in real time.
- 35:38And like she instantly recognizes he's still in love
- 35:41with me. How do I make him feel
- 35:44comfortable? How do I reassure him, but also
- 35:47keep proper boundaries without coming across as manipulative or
- 35:51bitchy? And I think that as a person,
- 35:54Nora has a really tough balancing act.
- 35:56But as a character, Greta Lee has a really difficult job to do
- 36:01to make you be on her side. Because on top of all of that,
- 36:04they also have to get us on board with her and we have to
- 36:08believe that she too wants and deserves closure in this
- 36:13situation. And I think she manages it
- 36:17because, you know, the whole character is about like
- 36:20balancing 2 worlds, the world of her past, the world of her
- 36:23present. The moment that her character
- 36:26completely clicks for me is when she's done hanging out with
- 36:30Hasan on the first day and she sits down on the couch.
- 36:34Arthur takes off his gaming headset and she goes, you were
- 36:39right. And he goes, what, what do you
- 36:41mean? And she's like, he he came here
- 36:43to see me. And it's not he came here
- 36:47because he's in love with me. It's not he came here to steal
- 36:50me away. It's not he's a dirty scumbag.
- 36:52It's just an acknowledgement of like, yeah, you were right.
- 36:55Like, he came here to see me. He's not here on vacation.
- 37:01And the way she delivers that line, you feel the honesty of
- 37:08who she is here in the present versus who she's trying to
- 37:12figure out who she is when she's around this person.
- 37:15And once again, talk about a universal feeling.
- 37:19Bob, you were known as Bobby Book back in the day, right way.
- 37:24Back in the day, yeah. And in your, in your modern day
- 37:272025 adult life, you go by Bob. And yet there are still some
- 37:33people that you hang out around that might call you Bobby that
- 37:36all of a sudden you feel like I'm 1314 years old again.
- 37:41And like I, I think all of us have that experience when you're
- 37:44around people from your childhood that you're like I, I,
- 37:47there's a tension. I don't know who I am here
- 37:49because I'm not 12 anymore, but the 12 year old that I was is
- 37:54still in me because it's a part of my story and who I am.
- 37:58But the, you know, 20 years that have passed since then are also
- 38:02a part of me and I'm different. And it's that war within
- 38:06yourself that you're trying to figure out.
- 38:08And then it's just magnified by the fact that you haven't seen
- 38:10this person since you were 12. And I, we could talk for three
- 38:14hours, Bob. Yeah.
- 38:15Man, this is a great movie. Let's press pause here.
- 38:18Let's drink some whiskey. When we come back, I want to
- 38:20talk about the other two actors, Tail, you and John Magaro,
- 38:24because I think they also knock it out of the park.
- 38:26And their characters are obviously crucial to the movie,
- 38:29but they're what really gives the movie it's color for me.
- 38:31So let's try this. Jack Daniels 12.
- 38:34What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 38:42All right, so today we are checking out Jack Daniels 12
- 38:46year batch one Last week we had Jack Daniels 10 year.
- 38:50This week, Brad, I, I wish we could have found a Korean
- 38:53whiskey to drink for this episode, but in doing some
- 38:56research, I only found one major distillery in Korea.
- 38:59And even then saying major, it's a, it's a minor distillery, but
- 39:02it's really the only one that's importing to America wasn't able
- 39:06to secure a sample for us. So we said let's keep rolling
- 39:08with Jack Daniels. And here we are man.
- 39:11What did you think of last week's 10 year?
- 39:14I think it was good, not great, like not enough to make me want
- 39:19to buy it. It was intriguing and fun and
- 39:21and like you know, I like trying new whiskeys but nothing that I
- 39:25would like write home about. So the nice thing with these
- 39:29Jack Daniels well aged versions that we've been drinking is
- 39:32there's really not a ton of variance from what's in the mash
- 39:36bill. Like this is 80% corn, 8% rye,
- 39:3812% malted barley. You guys know what Jack Daniels
- 39:41is? It's 107 proof, which is nice.
- 39:44I think that's like a perfect proof point for you and I, Brad,
- 39:47we always talk about how we want just slightly more proof.
- 39:50But when you start getting into the teens and 20s, it can be a
- 39:53little harsh. So this is really nice, man.
- 39:55I, I just poured it out in my glass and even sitting, you
- 39:58know, 6-8 inches away from the glass, I'm getting immediate
- 40:02notes of banana pudding on this. Way more than I got on the 10
- 40:05last week, to be frank. Yeah, the banana here is the
- 40:09most pleasant version of Jack banana that I have ever gotten.
- 40:15It's Okie. It's like the fruitiness I get
- 40:18from it is like a artificial mixed Berry that I actually
- 40:22really enjoy. But there is like some caramel
- 40:27and brown sugar and it it it feels like sitting in the barrel
- 40:30long enough has imparted some of those bourbon Y notes that
- 40:34really round out the experience. I'm sitting at an 8 out of 10 on
- 40:38the nose. I'm.
- 40:39Going to give this an 8.5 and it's because your boy likes
- 40:42banana. I do think there's a sense of
- 40:44artificiality to the banana a little bit.
- 40:46That's why I said banana pudding.
- 40:48It reminds me of like those really great southern style
- 40:50layered banana puddings with the vanilla wafers in them and like
- 40:54the the vanilla or banana pudding that actually goes into
- 40:58them. So I get the artificial and the
- 41:00slices of banana. It's really beautiful.
- 41:03I actually think that I like it way better than last week's 10
- 41:07year. And I'm wondering if there's
- 41:08some weird alchemy going on between 10 seemed over oaked.
- 41:12Is it going to come back around and bring out new notes in the
- 41:15flavor we're going to see? I haven't tried it yet.
- 41:17So why don't you give us your tasting notes, Brad?
- 41:20Bob this palette is incredible. For me, the caramel turns into
- 41:25like a really beautiful butterscotch note.
- 41:29The vanilla really comes through here.
- 41:31There's brown sugar, the the banana is there, but it's not
- 41:35overpowering it. It really does remind me of a
- 41:37banana pudding that that's a good note.
- 41:39And for me, the the mixed Berry turned into like a Berry blast
- 41:44crunch, which is like easily the best version of Cap'n Crunch.
- 41:48I think this is a delicious, delicious whiskey.
- 41:51I'm going to give it an 8 1/2 out of 10.
- 41:54Yeah, Brad, I think this is a really good whiskey.
- 41:56I think the banana is like almost absent for me on the
- 41:59palate, though, And it may be just because I was expecting so
- 42:02much of it, but we always talk about that banana note on Jack,
- 42:06and it's always more present on the nose than it is on a palate.
- 42:08And I'm just waiting for the one that is going to be a banana
- 42:12bomb for me. It hasn't happened yet.
- 42:14This is super oaky. There's a lot of oak.
- 42:17There's a lot of like tobacco and leather notes, like really
- 42:21earthy kind of notes going on here.
- 42:24It's complemented by like a black cherry note for me and
- 42:28some classic bourboni brown sugar notes.
- 42:31I just wish there was a little more complexity here.
- 42:34So I'm going to come down to an 8 out of 10.
- 42:36Still a very good whiskey, but not as good as the nose for me.
- 42:40The finish definitely falls off a little bit.
- 42:43Still really delicious. The caramel and banana sit
- 42:46there. It definitely gets oaky on the
- 42:48back end. Doesn't turn into the bitterness
- 42:51that you get from some higher age stated bourbons and, you
- 42:55know, American whiskies. But I'm, I'm going to say it,
- 42:59man, this is a really solid experience.
- 43:01There's a little bit of black pepper.
- 43:03I like the finish a lot. I'm coming down from my palate,
- 43:07but I'll still give it an 8 out of 10 here.
- 43:09Yeah, I think I'm just going to be slightly below you on almost
- 43:11everything today. I'm at a 7 1/2 on the finish,
- 43:14really nice. I think it kind of continues to
- 43:17get simplified the longer I go into the tasting process.
- 43:22The nose was more complex, the taste less so, the finish even
- 43:25less. It's just kind of like vanilla
- 43:27extract and oak for me, which is nice, but again, kind of lacking
- 43:32that complexity that I think would make this a really special
- 43:35whiskey. So I'm going to be at a 7.5 and
- 43:37on balance, I think I'm also just going to give it a 7.5.
- 43:41I'm slightly let down. It's probably because your boy
- 43:44loves banana so much and it's just not there.
- 43:47So I need to reset my expectations, but they were set
- 43:51at a very specific point with the nose and then those notes
- 43:54weren't carried through. So I'm at a 7.5 here.
- 43:58I'm actually at a nine out of 10 Bob.
- 44:00Like I think that the each individual part isn't perfect,
- 44:05but it, it works together to make something that is a really
- 44:09cohesive, delicious experience. So I, I'm, I'm coming up from
- 44:14any of my tasting scores to give it a nine out of 10 on balance.
- 44:18I'm very fascinated. As far as value goes, this is
- 44:24MSRP, a $95 bottle of whiskey, so not quite triple digits, but
- 44:29still something you are going to drop a very pretty penny on.
- 44:34Where are you at on value? This is hard because I think
- 44:39just given that it's 12 years age stated $90.00 is not asking
- 44:43a ton for this. The market on this is fair.
- 44:46I would need to try more than just this one batch to determine
- 44:49if some of it, some of them will be more complex.
- 44:53Because when you're approaching $100, I want something that is
- 44:56like I'm putting on my smoking jacket and smoking my pipe next
- 45:00to my fire. Like I want a good, sturdy,
- 45:04complex sipping whiskey. And this one hasn't hit that for
- 45:07me. Good whiskey.
- 45:09Would I spend $90.00 on it? Probably not.
- 45:12I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10, Brad.
- 45:14I'm at a 7 1/2. I think this is good value. 7
- 45:181/2 for me on value is is the point where I have to think of
- 45:22whiskey is well worth the price tag to give it a 7 1/2 or
- 45:27higher. I think that this is priced
- 45:30properly as well as being worth the money you're spending.
- 45:33So I'm at a 7 1/2 Bob. I'm coming out to a relatively
- 45:37high 41 out of 50. Oh wow.
- 45:40OK, yeah, I'm at a 38.5 out of 50.
- 45:43So that takes us to a 39.75 out of 50 on average, just below
- 45:48that 40 mark. So this is a soft recommend just
- 45:52judging on the score, but it hasn't quite hit that like this
- 45:56is a no brainer recommendation that a 40 would indicate.
- 46:00I do think it's worth picking up.
- 46:01I'm just slightly let down and I think it could be a little bit
- 46:04better. It's like a.
- 46:05It's like AB plus A minus version of what I think this
- 46:09could be. See, that's the thing for me,
- 46:11Bob. I think this is the best version
- 46:13of Jack Daniels I've ever had. I.
- 46:15Like it's not a perfect whiskey. I don't think Jack Daniels is my
- 46:19favorite flavour wheelhouse. It's never going to hit a 45
- 46:24plus for me, at least what I've had of them, which we've, we've
- 46:27drank a decent amount of Jack on this, on this podcast.
- 46:29Bob, I think this is the best version of Jack I've had.
- 46:33I I I think it is a really rich and flavourful experience that I
- 46:38would recommend bottle or bar. I love it, man.
- 46:42Yeah. Usually you're not preaching the
- 46:44gospel of Jack Daniel. So this is a this is a big deal.
- 46:48Yeah. Good job Jack Daniels, you did
- 46:50it. Also I I went to sample this and
- 46:54my 4 year old Sadie asked me what I was drinking and I was
- 46:59like oh it's Jack Daniels 12 year and she goes oh is Jack
- 47:03Daniels friends with Daniel Tiger?
- 47:08And you said? Yes, he is.
- 47:09I was like, yeah, honey, I think they're cousins.
- 47:13Jack, Daniel, Tiger, you've got it from us here first, folks.
- 47:17Brad, let's jump back into talking about past lives.
- 47:19What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 47:25All right, everybody, That was Jack Daniels 12 Year batch #1A
- 47:30whiskey that answered a vitally important question for us, Bob.
- 47:35And do you know what that question is?
- 47:37I don't what's the question? How much does Bob love bananas?
- 47:43So. Much he just he just loves him a
- 47:45good banana. Listen, we're talking about
- 47:47Freudian stuff today. I'm going to ask that you guys
- 47:50don't read into that too much. You know what you should read
- 47:52into. Is it 2 facts and a falsehood
- 47:55the. Fact that Bob is
- 47:57overcompensating and two facts and a falsehood.
- 48:01Brad is going to try to stump you.
- 48:03Bob 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 48:092 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 48:12the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 48:16the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 48:20Brad, I am doing pretty darn well.
- 48:22What am I sitting at now? Like 10 and 4 maybe?
- 48:26Yeah, you've been killing it, man.
- 48:27This is this is your season. You are like the Cleveland
- 48:30Cavaliers of two facts in a false Oh.
- 48:33No, I lost last week. I'm nine and five right now.
- 48:37You you lost last week. I lost last week on The Big
- 48:39Short. I thought you, I'm pretty sure
- 48:42you won last week, Bob. Well.
- 48:43Good. Then I'm going to change this L
- 48:45to AW. We're just going to say I won.
- 48:48Yeah, 'cause you picked out the Easter egg of the the Monopoly.
- 48:52Pieces. Oh yeah.
- 48:53All right, cool. So I'm 10 and four.
- 48:54Got it, man. Let's freaking go.
- 48:57I don't know a lot about the making of this movie except for
- 49:00like what has been widely reported about Celine Song and
- 49:03her weird marriage, so you might get me.
- 49:07The IMDb fact list for this movie, normally there's like you
- 49:12know, for big budget movies like End Game there is literally like
- 49:15200. Most movies have anywhere from
- 49:17like 30 to 70 facts written on their IMDb trivia page.
- 49:23This one had like 8. See, what you should have done
- 49:26is written 2 falsehoods and had me pick out the one that's true.
- 49:30In that sort of. Scenario, you know.
- 49:32What I should start doing? I should start writing the
- 49:35trivia things on the IMDb page because then I can say that they
- 49:40are true based on our standards. Just start submitting
- 49:43falsehoods. I love it.
- 49:45All right man, hit me with your two facts and a falsehood.
- 49:48Fact number One In preparation for the film, director and
- 49:51writer Celine Song took Greta Lee TOU and John Magaro to a
- 49:56house similar to the Artisan Residence home in the movie and
- 49:59conducted a Past Lives workshop for each actor to explore the
- 50:04hypothetical past lives that each of their characters may
- 50:07have had. Fact #2 To enhance the emotional
- 50:11authenticity of the reunion scenes, director and writer
- 50:14Celine Song revealed in a New York Times profile of Greta Lee
- 50:18that she deliberately kept Lee and Tail You apart during
- 50:22production, mirroring the prolonged separation their
- 50:24characters experience in the film.
- 50:27In fact #3 the Skype scenes between Nora and Hey Sung were
- 50:32filmed at the same time in two different sets, connected by a
- 50:35cable with built in throttle on the connection, meaning that the
- 50:39delay could be adjusted or paused to get authentic
- 50:42reactions from the actors. All right, Brad, I think #3
- 50:47sounds the most plausible to me. You may have made that up, but
- 50:50it just sounds it's a good fact. 1 and 2 are striking me as
- 50:55potential falsehoods here and #1 strikes me as a potential
- 50:59falsehood because I'm wondering how pretentious the film makers
- 51:03of this movie are. If you're a pretentious artist
- 51:06that is absolutely something you would do.
- 51:08You're a non pretentious artist then.
- 51:10That's a falsehood. I mean, consider, consider how
- 51:13we started the episode, Bob, when you talked about
- 51:16Challengers. Yeah, yeah, yeah #2 like
- 51:22physically distancing the actor is like, yeah, maybe you could
- 51:25do that. I don't know how effective that
- 51:27would be. So I, I think it's one of those
- 51:29two, my gut says #1 is the falsehood.
- 51:32And I think that for the sake of time here, I'm just going to go
- 51:36with one as the falsehood. Brad, Bob.
- 51:39You should listen to your gut more often.
- 51:42It has not steered you wrong this season.
- 51:44You are just like a true cavalanche of correct answers
- 51:50this season. What Cavs player would you say
- 51:54that I fill the role for on this podcast?
- 51:58Tristan Thompson. Fuck you man.
- 52:03Married to a Kardashian? Divorced from a Kardashian?
- 52:06A little. Past such time but but still
- 52:09just, you know, a great guy to be around.
- 52:12Whatever, whatever man, let's get back into talking about past
- 52:15lives, Brad. And we left off by saying that
- 52:18we're going to revisit tail you and John Magaro.
- 52:21John Magaro we just talked about last week on The Big Short.
- 52:24Here he is again. Akron, OH native, my guy John
- 52:28Magaro. I'm so excited to be talking
- 52:29about him. Can I just say, like, out of all
- 52:33the actors to randomly have to never have had in 9 1/2 seasons
- 52:40of this podcast and then he's on two weeks in a row freaking
- 52:44killing it? Yeah.
- 52:46Listen, this dude is going to be nominated for an Oscar within
- 52:48the next 5 years. Like mark it down, book it.
- 52:51How much? How much do you want to bet on
- 52:52that $50.00? I will short you that bet.
- 52:59Put put it in a CDO squared that's.
- 53:02Right, 'cause I'm jacked to the tits.
- 53:05So the key piece of this movie for me, the key scene is one
- 53:09that you mentioned and it's the one where the two of them are in
- 53:12bed together, Greta Lee and John Magaro.
- 53:14And it's his perspective on this whole thing.
- 53:19And it's not just that it's the best written and potentially the
- 53:22best acted scene in the whole movie.
- 53:24It's that it is the most narratively necessary scene in
- 53:28the movie. Because without that, he has a
- 53:30nothing character. He is literally just a guy
- 53:33that's getting cucked by his wife.
- 53:35And I think the fact that they give him so much deep,
- 53:41vulnerable fear in that moment is what makes this movie have
- 53:45deeper meaning. Because without it, it's just
- 53:47the story of these two people. And he's a bystander.
- 53:52And with that scene, it's a movie about three people with an
- 53:55equal amount of emphasis and empathy on all of them.
- 54:00And what it captures so beautifully.
- 54:02And, you know, this isn't something I've experienced, so
- 54:05I, I can't speak fully into it, but I would imagine that for any
- 54:10marriage or like, you know, partnership of two people who
- 54:15specifically spoke different languages from one another
- 54:19growing up that lived in different countries from one
- 54:22another growing up. I have to imagine that like what
- 54:25he says about her speaking in Korean in her dreams, it like
- 54:31it's got to be true where there's a part of you that
- 54:33always wonders, like, am I missing a part of you?
- 54:40Do I have full access to your soul?
- 54:43And, and it's a question that he's probably been pondering
- 54:47since the moment he met her and was attracted to her.
- 54:52It's a question that is like, am I enough?
- 54:57Like, am I enough for this woman who I deeply love and respect
- 55:03and want to make her better? Like, am I keeping her from
- 55:07something, from a true part of herself?
- 55:10And in a culture where we, in my opinion, unfortunately place so
- 55:16much stock in our inner feelings and like being true to
- 55:21ourselves, there's this place where he basically tells her,
- 55:25like, if you were just quote UN quote, being true to yourself,
- 55:30like this is the greatest story. Like you fall in love and you
- 55:33run off with your childhood sweetheart.
- 55:35And I'm just the dumb American that stood in the way.
- 55:38And and she just lovingly, gently is honest with him and
- 55:46says, yeah, there was something there.
- 55:47Like she's not trying to gaslight him and yet reassures
- 55:53him. But what we have is real too.
- 55:57And we can't live in a fantasy world.
- 56:00We have to live in the world of the choices we've made.
- 56:02And it's just one of the best scripted scenes of any movie
- 56:08I've ever seen. As if the goal is to represent
- 56:12the honest human experience well.
- 56:14And I talked earlier about how I think so many lines in that back
- 56:17half of the movie have multiple meanings.
- 56:19And so he's going on and on about like how frightened he is.
- 56:23And, and to his credit, he's the only character in the movie to
- 56:26that point that has like completely verbalized out loud
- 56:30what he's thinking. Everything else has been non
- 56:33verbal or communicated through body language.
- 56:36And the fact that he says, like, I'm really afraid in this moment
- 56:40and the story that you guys are writing is a really good story.
- 56:44And in that story, I am not the hero.
- 56:46And that concerns me. And the way she shuts him down
- 56:50is by being the realist in that moment.
- 56:52At first she says she just says that's not how life works.
- 56:55And then he pushes back and says, like, yeah, but what if
- 56:57you met somebody else at that artist residency?
- 57:00What if you were living with him?
- 57:01And. And then all she says is this is
- 57:04my life and I'm living it with you.
- 57:08And on the surface level, it just seems like almost a cold
- 57:12thing to say. But the way she says it, like I,
- 57:15I wrote down 5 or 6 different meanings, Brad.
- 57:18Like she's shutting him down, She's reassuring him, she's
- 57:23shutting herself down from fantasizing about something
- 57:26else. She's mourning the sacrifices
- 57:31and the compromises that she had to make to be in this moment by
- 57:35just telling herself, this is this is who I am.
- 57:37And she's reaffirming her own commitment to him all in one
- 57:41line. It's an incredible moment of
- 57:43acting and writing and not overwriting.
- 57:46That's the great part of this movie is like, there is so much
- 57:49between the lines, both spoken and unspoken in this movie that
- 57:55it doesn't pander to you as an audience member.
- 57:57You have to fill in those blanks.
- 57:59Absolutely. I could go on and on and on
- 58:05about this movie. I I'm curious, is there anything
- 58:09about this movie that you're like, I can't get out of this
- 58:13episode without making sure filming Whiskey Nation
- 58:17understands this about the movie?
- 58:19Because at the end of the day, I feel like we are making a pitch
- 58:21for more people to see this movie, which I think we're doing
- 58:24successfully. You'll have to let us know.
- 58:26Jump on our Discord, jump on our socials, let us know if you have
- 58:29watched the movie because of this episode.
- 58:31But Bob, what, like give your pitch?
- 58:34What, like beyond everything we've already said, Like, what's
- 58:38something about this film that just makes it so daggone special
- 58:41to you? I think it's the avenues that it
- 58:43opened up for honest conversation in real life for
- 58:46me, Like it accessed a part of me that I felt seen by this
- 58:51movie. This movie understands.
- 58:54And you and I come from a background where we, you know,
- 58:57you grew up this way. I came to it in high school of,
- 58:59of evangelical Christianity and dating culture in evangelical
- 59:04Christianity is real messed up because, you know, at the very
- 59:09least it was from like 98 through like 2015, correct?
- 59:14Our experience of it was like dating is not so much you
- 59:19figuring out who you are, what you want in a partner.
- 59:22It was like identifying your spouse and then immediately
- 59:26committing to that person and you are locked in for life.
- 59:29And that is just that. A that's not, that's why it
- 59:32didn't ever work when you were dating in the evangelical world.
- 59:35That's also why so many evangelicals, I think, have
- 59:38horrible foundations in their marriage.
- 59:39Brad And like this movie sparked a conversation between me and my
- 59:44wife where for the first time we kind of felt permission to talk
- 59:46about the fact that like, yes, like you, we both know we have.
- 59:51We had other relationships in life, but we never really talk
- 59:54about the fact that there was real love there or that
- 59:58sometimes you miss seeing people that you had to cut out of your
- 1:00:01life because that's who you are as a person now.
- 1:00:04And it is OK to admit that sometimes you miss a person.
- 1:00:10Or to say, like, yes, there have been times where after we've
- 1:00:13gotten in an argument, I've sat down and wondered, like, how
- 1:00:16could my life be different in this moment?
- 1:00:18Like, that is a human emotion. It doesn't make you a bad person
- 1:00:22to experience that thought. And in fact, it is significantly
- 1:00:26healthier to talk about those things than to push them to the
- 1:00:28side and ignore them. And I think for people of a
- 1:00:31certain culture like you and I, Brad, this movie was not just a
- 1:00:36wake up call, but a really necessary text for me to see.
- 1:00:40Yeah, At the end of the day, the human experience is inherently
- 1:00:46an emotional one. And our our emotions are like
- 1:00:50messengers from the front line of a war.
- 1:00:52Like they come to us to let us know this is what's happening in
- 1:00:56your world. This is how your story interacts
- 1:01:00with it. This is how your body is is
- 1:01:03responding to the things happening around you, the people
- 1:01:06who are talking to you, the relationships that you've had.
- 1:01:10And if you kill the messenger, it doesn't mean that the war
- 1:01:13isn't still being fought on the front lines.
- 1:01:16And so the ability to honestly express our emotions in a place
- 1:01:21that is safe and where you can be seen and secure in who you
- 1:01:26are in that moment and soothed and like cared for is so
- 1:01:33evidently powerful in the human experience.
- 1:01:36And this movie captures that. And I think it captures it
- 1:01:40throughout the whole film, but most perfectly in the final
- 1:01:45three minutes of the movie. Like Nora and Haysung walk off
- 1:01:51to his Uber. One of the facts that I learned
- 1:01:54was that Celine Song sends them off to get the Uber in the scene
- 1:02:00and didn't tell them how long it would be.
- 1:02:02Like like they truly were waiting for a car to come and
- 1:02:05they didn't know when it was going to come.
- 1:02:08And so they're sitting there waiting.
- 1:02:10They finally, the car finally arrives.
- 1:02:13He initiates the hug with her because he has found validation
- 1:02:19throughout the film and she is the one who's struggling now and
- 1:02:23she she hugs him and they talk about in yon, which we didn't
- 1:02:28even touch on this. But it's essentially the idea
- 1:02:30that in all of our past lives in in a karmic Buddhist sense, like
- 1:02:36people who get married are ones whose past lives have touched at
- 1:02:41least 8000 times. And they just have a little like
- 1:02:45beautiful conversation about like, I wonder what this life
- 1:02:50like what in yon it is leading to where we are married, or
- 1:02:54maybe we were married in the past in yon and and it's a
- 1:02:57really beautiful moment. She walks back and it's the
- 1:03:00moment I love Arthur the most because he didn't sit up in the
- 1:03:04apartment and sulk and he didn't He also didn't go down to creep
- 1:03:08on her. Like he's just sitting on the
- 1:03:10stoop. He's not like craning his neck
- 1:03:13to see if his wife is making out with another dude.
- 1:03:16He's just sitting there smoking a cigarette.
- 1:03:18He knows what this weekend or few days as meant to her and as
- 1:03:23she weeps he gets to experience her as the crybaby 12 year old
- 1:03:28who is feeling her feelings and he just loves her.
- 1:03:32Dude, I have seen this movie 3 full Times Now and I did not
- 1:03:36make that connection until this time because they do it so
- 1:03:39subtly in the opening parts of the movie when they first
- 1:03:43reconnect as 20 year olds or whatever they are.
- 1:03:47He asks her, are you still a crybaby?
- 1:03:49Do you cry anymore? And she says no.
- 1:03:51Like I, I moved to America and I felt like nobody cared about me
- 1:03:54crying. And she said you used to be
- 1:03:56there with me and you would stay with me when I was crying.
- 1:04:00And they say it one more time when she's first talking to John
- 1:04:04Magaro about him. And they really sow this seed
- 1:04:06and you don't see that emotional damn break.
- 1:04:09And I think that moment has always been really impactful for
- 1:04:11me because you do see her breakdown finally.
- 1:04:13She doesn't have to be, you know, playing a role to support
- 1:04:17him and and not let tail you down.
- 1:04:20But more than that, it's this affirmation that like he has now
- 1:04:25fully become that person for her.
- 1:04:27Her husband is the person now who is there for her when she is
- 1:04:30crying and who stays with her. And it is like, dude, it's just
- 1:04:34such a beautiful picture of that relationship.
- 1:04:37It's incredible. And it's that moment where he
- 1:04:41has been honest about who he is in this story between the three
- 1:04:46of them. She has been honest about her
- 1:04:48role. Like she tells it, you know, he
- 1:04:50asks, is he attractive? And.
- 1:04:52And she goes, yeah, like, he's really masculine in this weird
- 1:04:55Korean way that makes sense if you're born in Korea.
- 1:04:59And and like, they're honest with each other throughout.
- 1:05:02And because of all that, that honesty, the payoff is the fact
- 1:05:07that their marriage is deeper than it ever could have been.
- 1:05:12If T OU doesn't come back into her life.
- 1:05:16And you know, I said it earlier, Arthur gets to experience a
- 1:05:22fuller, more integrated version of his wife that her story now
- 1:05:29includes 12 year old crybaby Nora instead of just being adult
- 1:05:37Nora that he's known for the last 12 years.
- 1:05:41All right, man, we've we have really gone on with this movie.
- 1:05:44It's freaking phenomenal. It's time for us to get to our
- 1:05:46last segment of the day, which we call let's make it a double
- 1:05:50we're. Near the end of the episode.
- 1:05:52So thanks listening to the film and whiskey show.
- 1:05:55Let's pair another film with this one.
- 1:05:56Even if it's struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:05:59day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:06:00Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:06:03movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:06:06feature, right? There's a million movies I can
- 1:06:08pair this with. You know, I've talked about
- 1:06:10Brief Encounter, I've talked about ET.
- 1:06:12I'd like to hear from you first. What's your pair with past
- 1:06:16lives? Oh this is such a tough one.
- 1:06:21I'm kind of in between 2 movies. I want to pick one because I
- 1:06:24like it more. I think the other one's tone and
- 1:06:29pacing fits this movie better. I think I'm going to pair it
- 1:06:35with the movie I like less, but I'm going to pair it with Lost
- 1:06:38in Translation. Oh, interesting.
- 1:06:40I. I think there's a place where
- 1:06:43you get the characters of Lost in Translation asking very
- 1:06:47similar questions, and they answer it in very different
- 1:06:51ways, right? Like that film involves an
- 1:06:54affair and this one does not. But I think both of them are
- 1:06:58paced in similar ways. They ask similar questions, they
- 1:07:02both have quietly funny moments throughout the film, and I I
- 1:07:06think it would make for a really interesting evening to watch
- 1:07:08Lost in Translation and Past Lives.
- 1:07:11So what was your other movie, The one you like more?
- 1:07:14I think La La land I. Knew it.
- 1:07:16Yeah, I wrote down La La Land. Yeah.
- 1:07:18I think La La Land has a lot of similarities, but it's just so
- 1:07:22much more vibrant of a film it it like it's hard to pair it
- 1:07:26although. If you watch La La Land 1st and
- 1:07:28then immediately jumped into this movie, you'd be in the
- 1:07:31perfect headspace for this movie.
- 1:07:33Yeah, I, I, I would actually agree with you there.
- 1:07:35Because we didn't even talk about this.
- 1:07:37I think this movie does a really good job of subtly also
- 1:07:41underscoring her character with the immigrant experience and how
- 1:07:45when she's first talking to John Magaro, she's like, he's so
- 1:07:48Korean and it makes me feel like I'm less Korean and should I be
- 1:07:51more Korean and so like her. Her infatuation with him is also
- 1:07:55trying to figure out, like who? Like, am I Korean still?
- 1:07:59Should I be more Korean? Like, what does this mean for
- 1:08:01me? I've given up on a lot of hopes
- 1:08:04and dreams to be where I am here.
- 1:08:05Or I've pursued a dream and given up on a past life.
- 1:08:08And that's like, literally the plot of La La Land.
- 1:08:10So yeah, I think that would be a great pairing, Brad.
- 1:08:13I think I'm going to go ahead and pair it with a movie that is
- 1:08:16even more tonally wild than La La Land would be, but it's
- 1:08:22because not too far off. It's a movie called Everything
- 1:08:26Everywhere All at Once. It's a movie that I I don't like
- 1:08:30as much as this movie and I think that I'll, I'll under
- 1:08:33score that when we get to it in a few weeks here.
- 1:08:35There's this line that John Magaro says to her when they're
- 1:08:38sitting in bed and he has 2 great lines.
- 1:08:40One of them is my favorite line in the movie where he tells her
- 1:08:43you dream in a language I can't understand which.
- 1:08:45Is what a great line, dude. Oh.
- 1:08:48My gosh. But he tells her, you make my
- 1:08:51life so much bigger. And I just wonder if I do the
- 1:08:54same thing for you. And that moment hit me.
- 1:08:56There's this moment in Everything Everywhere All at
- 1:08:58Once where Kiwi Kwan's character says, like, you know, even
- 1:09:04though I know that you're going to break my heart again, I just
- 1:09:07want you to know that in another life, I would have really liked
- 1:09:11just doing taxes and laundry with you.
- 1:09:14And it's and they're in the rain behind the Opera House.
- 1:09:17It is unbelievable. And I think that those like
- 1:09:22supportive husband characters helping their like Asian wives
- 1:09:27go through an emotional journey. It's like that's the connective
- 1:09:31tissue here. It's it's a wild pairing, but
- 1:09:34I'm going to pair it with Everything Everywhere All at
- 1:09:36once, just. Based on that scene, I'm with
- 1:09:39you man. Like, yeah, we'll talk about
- 1:09:42Everything Everywhere All at Once in a few weeks.
- 1:09:44I freaking love that movie. I've seen it since I saw it in
- 1:09:47theaters, and I definitely came down a little bit.
- 1:09:50But man, it's moments like that that make me understand why that
- 1:09:55film did so well at the Oscars. Let's Make It a Double was
- 1:09:58brought to you by Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 1:10:01No matter what movie you choose to pair this with, you can
- 1:10:03always make it a double with Blackwood Distilling Co.
- 1:10:07Blackwood will expand your horizons, Bob.
- 1:10:11It'll never hold you back. We need to get Zach Johnston
- 1:10:13back on here. He seems like a guy that would
- 1:10:15like past lives. He really does seem like a guy
- 1:10:18that like past lives, although based on your history of like.
- 1:10:23Predicting movies I would like. Who knows, man?
- 1:10:26He he might be he'll just he'll come in here and like knowing
- 1:10:30his his journeys over the years, he'll be like, I lived in Korea
- 1:10:33for eight years. This this movie does not
- 1:10:35accurately represent the Korean experience, you know Yeah.
- 1:10:38And then he'll like. Start speaking in Korean.
- 1:10:42Yeah, sure, Zach. Zach, come back on, man, we miss
- 1:10:44you. Brad.
- 1:10:45It's time for us to give final scores.
- 1:10:47This is a 10 out of 10. This is this is like every time
- 1:10:50I see it, I think I'm going to go down a little bit on this
- 1:10:52movie. And I put it number one over
- 1:10:55Oppenheimer last year and over the holdovers.
- 1:10:58And I watched both of those movies again in the last, what,
- 1:11:01four months? And I was like, oh man, past
- 1:11:03lives has a lot to live up to. This is one of the best movies
- 1:11:06of the 21st century. It is an all timer for me and it
- 1:11:10is 10 plus out of 10. I so this movie is like from
- 1:11:16opening to credits rolling, it's an hour and 39 minutes.
- 1:11:20So First off, I'll call it because it is in that hour.
- 1:11:25It's like an hour and 39 and like 42 seconds, but I'm still
- 1:11:29going to call it a 90 minute film, so perfect amount of time.
- 1:11:32Secondly, the first like 45 minutes of this movie to to an
- 1:11:38hour, it's around the hour mark that things really shift for me
- 1:11:42is like a nine, maybe 9 1/2 out of 10.
- 1:11:46But the last 40 or so minutes of this movie are so perfect.
- 1:11:52And, and everything that you said, Bob, about the seeds that
- 1:11:56have been sown, they all are harvested in the most beautiful,
- 1:12:00perfect, meaningful ways. I'm with you, man.
- 1:12:04This movie is a 10 out of 10 yes.
- 1:12:07Oh, I'm so happy. Do you know how hard it is for
- 1:12:10both of us to hit on a 10 out of 10, Brad?
- 1:12:13We might disagree on ET. We might disagree on the
- 1:12:18assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford.
- 1:12:21But Brief Encounter and Past lives, baby.
- 1:12:25Folks, I cannot recommend this movie highly enough.
- 1:12:27It is one of only 3 movies so far this season that have
- 1:12:31received a perfect 10 out of 10, and it's joining Oppenheimer and
- 1:12:34Whiplash in that club. And I will say I'm glad it is
- 1:12:37because those are two very like Broy manly movies.
- 1:12:41And this is not necessarily a feminine movie, but it is a very
- 1:12:44different kind of movie. And I think you need that
- 1:12:46represented here as well, Brad. Absolutely.
- 1:12:49Go watch Past Lives. This movie is absolutely
- 1:12:53incredible. And like you said, Bob, it's
- 1:12:56incredible because it speaks to the human and soul at a really
- 1:13:00meaningful level. All right, so it's definitely a
- 1:13:02modern classic, it sounds like from both of us, Brad.
- 1:13:06I think that's it for today. We want to know what you guys
- 1:13:08think of past lives. Will you go watch it as a result
- 1:13:10of us talking about it for so long?
- 1:13:12You can let us know and sing poetically.
- 1:13:14Yes, you can let us know on all of our social medias, Facebook,
- 1:13:18Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:13:23Or you can join the conversation on our Discord server.
- 1:13:25You can find a link to it at the end of every single one of our
- 1:13:28show notes. Next week, we're taking kind of
- 1:13:31a hard turn from a movie about, you know, confronting your past
- 1:13:35through nonviolent means to confronting your past with
- 1:13:38extremely violent means. We're watching the modern day
- 1:13:41boxing classic Creed. So join us for that one next
- 1:13:45week. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:13:47I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.
- 1:14:14Music.