Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #79🎙️ |Public Inquiry Blasting Week Beginning 29th June 2026 Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:04Unknown: It's hard to know where to begin with this episode. If
- 0:08you had told me this time last year that the podcast will be
- 0:12rebuked and a warning issued from the PAC, I think that's
- 0:16what they were saying today, and it was more or less that if
- 0:19there are any more so-called defamatory podcasts, it appears
- 0:24I too will be banned, and there might be legal consequences.
- 0:29It's become rather a badge of honour to be excluded from the
- 0:32public inquiry. You're patently not a player unless you've been
- 0:35evicted. It would be funny if it wasn't quite so serious. Now,
- 0:40not only are the PAC tightly controlling everything within
- 0:44the room, which sometimes extends the whole building, but
- 0:48I believe they are now endeavouring to control the
- 0:50narrative outside the room as well. I suppose they've been
- 0:54doing that all along, from the exclusion of the media in the
- 0:58first phase of the public inquiry to the refusal to allow
- 1:02real-time viewing of the proceedings, to the switching
- 1:05off of mobile phones in the room, it's an unusual
- 1:08interpretation of the word public, but perhaps I'm missing
- 1:12something. And to finish this part of today's proceedings, I
- 1:19also recognise when someone is trying to silence me. I want to
- 1:24make one thing absolutely clear. I am not afraid. If you'd taken
- 1:28the time to find out who I am, you would know that I own very
- 1:31little, and I have never measured my life by what I
- 1:34possess. If speaking the truth as I see it were ever to come at
- 1:39a personal cost, then so be it. What matters most to me has
- 1:43never been what money can buy. That conviction comes from
- 1:49something that happened years ago. I once witnessed a dog
- 1:52being half beaten to death, and I did nothing. I stood there in
- 1:56silence. I have carried that moment with me ever since on
- 2:02that day, I made a declaration to myself, never again would I
- 2:05remain silent in the face of what I believed to be an
- 2:08injustice. I've tried to live by that promise ever since, and
- 2:13have no intention of breaking it now, just so you know. To return
- 2:18to the proceedings of today, there was another announcement
- 2:22that Cormac would remain banned for the rest of the public
- 2:24inquiry. We had been informed by the PAC during the week that
- 2:29this was the case, but still hearing it again today was
- 2:33painful, to say the least. Ah, well, onwards and upwards, as we
- 2:40moved on to the next topic. Blasting was the usual ceremony
- 2:44of introducing everyone who would be speaking. Some were
- 2:48familiar faces, veterans of the inquiry by now, others were
- 2:53entirely new people coming and going as they have throughout
- 2:58the public inquiry. As I waited for the introductions to end, a
- 3:03line from the love song of J. Alfred Prufrock drifted into my
- 3:07mind. In the room, the women come and go, talking of
- 3:12Michelangelo. We are straight in to an explosive conversation.
- 3:18Apologies, I could not resist the pun. Dr. John Player,
- 3:23batting on behalf of Delraydian, was hard put to answer most of
- 3:26the questions fielded by the Commissioner. Mostly he didn't,
- 3:30but what we learned early in the day is that there will be 16
- 3:36separate blasts in 24 hours, eight in the morning and eight
- 3:41in the evening, which is different from the twice a day
- 3:44blasting on the original plan over the course of the morning,
- 3:50again and again new oral evidence was being presented on
- 3:55behalf of Delradion, but I'll come back to this later. The
- 3:59second question asked, was there any explosives alternative
- 4:03assessment, and the and the answer to this by the applicant
- 4:07was no. During the course conversation, we find out that
- 4:13bulk emulsions are the names been used for specific
- 4:16explosives, that the daily quantities of explosives cannot
- 4:22be determined, because apparently this is based on the
- 4:26mine schedule. It was ascertained by third parties
- 4:32that the data set produced by the applicant is too small to be
- 4:35reliable, that there is too little information for us to
- 4:38independently assess the predicted impacts, and therefore
- 4:42independent verification of their modelling was impossible.
- 4:47Again, during this conversation, we heard yet more new
- 4:51information from the applicant. Fagan Council for FODC said that
- 4:57the information is needed to assess the vibrant.
- 5:00Operational impact at the point of consent, that the applicant
- 5:04keep reiterating that the detail is not really known, but it's
- 5:08okay, we'll sort it out in the conditions, and with mitigation.
- 5:12Fagan went on to emphasise that these matters need to be dealt
- 5:16with upfront, not at a later date. Emmett spoke up about the
- 5:21human rights violations in relation to volume, quantity,
- 5:24and timing of blastings over decades, all adding up to a
- 5:28human situation that would be intolerable. FODC has concerns
- 5:35about 2014 data being used, saying you need to do a trial
- 5:40blasting, it hasn't been done, and how can small trials provide
- 5:45for the much greater size of the mine? He also went on to say
- 5:50that there was little evidence provided that the proposed work
- 5:53will be completed within the recommended vibrational levels,
- 5:59that was not obvious that it had been screened out, and here was
- 6:03yet another example of what has not been included in the
- 6:08environmental impact statement. He went on to explain that trial
- 6:15blasting should be undertaken prior to consent, that it was
- 6:20important not to be imposing conditions that they may not
- 6:24possibly meet or comply with, saying that the commissioners
- 6:30were missing large tranches of information about blast
- 6:33vibration timing, etc. And at some point, Dr. Player from
- 6:39Dalradion said, over time our vibrations will get more
- 6:43beneficial to the community, whatever that means. Mary
- 6:48Brawley pointed out that primary vibrations were also dependent
- 6:51on the rock, as well as the primary source, i.e. the
- 6:54explosives themselves, that vibrations would come from heavy
- 6:58machinery also, and we also learned from our esteemed
- 7:03colleague Dr. Player that minds make more waste than they do, or
- 7:09we could have told him that just before lunch Emmett received
- 7:13another informal warning. I genuinely can't remember what it
- 7:17was about, it seemed that inconsequential. My toddler
- 7:22grandson carries a little teddy bear everywhere because it gives
- 7:25him comfort. Listening to the steady stream of warnings over
- 7:29the past few weeks at the inquiry, I couldn't help
- 7:31thinking they seem to have acquired a similar role in the
- 7:34proceedings. After lunch, Barbara Ward spoke movingly
- 7:40about where she lives on the Gortacashel Road, from where she
- 7:44can see the Dalrydian compound and the explosive store. She
- 7:49explained that she lived in an old stone house built at the
- 7:53start of the 20th century, walls more than two feet thick, and
- 7:57when the blasting was being carried out in 2014 2016
- 8:03Firstly, they were not issued with any warnings, and when the
- 8:06first blast came, the noise nearly put her off her feet, so
- 8:10much so that she thought the house was coming down around
- 8:13her, and that she could most certainly feel the vibration of
- 8:17the blasting, and she went on to say how she lived in one of the
- 8:21most beautiful parts of Tyrone, and all she wanted to do was to
- 8:24continue to live a quiet life. Later on the afternoon, Sean
- 8:29Kelly spoke as a resident of Navin, and how he lived less
- 8:33than a kilometre from Tara Mine, and that he was never impacted
- 8:37by the mine in any way at all. Neither was his home, but he
- 8:41would say that, wouldn't he, being a lifetime employee of
- 8:44Blyden Tara Connor Fagan for FODC, returned once again to the
- 8:50subject of the amount of new information being raised orally,
- 8:53and that third parties ought to be given a chance to respond.
- 8:58Towards the end of the afternoon, the subject of St.
- 9:00Mary's Church in Ruski came up again, and DFI said that a
- 9:04watching brief would have to be kept on the mine as it crept
- 9:07closer to the church, due to the fact that the church was quite
- 9:10ancient and has no foundations, particularly in the case where
- 9:15there are undisclosed tunnels, which are expected to undermine
- 9:18the whole area. One other new piece of information that we
- 9:23heard today was that there would be 42 00 tonnes of ammonium
- 9:27nitrate used for explosive purposes over the life of the
- 9:29mine. The quantity of ammonium nitrate proposed for explosive
- 9:34use could amount in crude t and t equivalent terms to more than
- 9:39the explosive yield of Hiroshima and Nagasaki individually, but
- 9:44unlike these bombs, this would not be one single explosion.
- 9:48It would be distributed across repeated blasting events for
- 9:52many years to come. Isn't that something to look forward to?
- 9:56And on that note, I leave it here for this evening. If you
- 10:01have any thoughts on what you've just heard, we'd genuinely love
- 10:05to hear from you. Whether you agree, disagree, or have
- 10:08something to add, please leave a comment. We read every one of
- 10:11them. Thanks very much for listening, and we'll see you all
- 10:16again soon.
- 10:20Bye.