Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 10 Before you say yes, talk about money: David Koch AM uncut
Transcript
- 0:00You've used the expression financial infidelity, which I really love because it is about that
- 0:08being deceitful, I suppose.
- 0:09You're cheating.
- 0:10Yeah.
- 0:11You're cheating.
- 0:11I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick.
- 0:13I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:22This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love.
- 0:31David Kosh.
- 0:33Married 47 years, dad of four, grandfather of 10 and financial commentator.
- 0:41Excellent.
- 0:43In that priority in my life.
- 0:47So you have got a lot of life experience and professional experience to bring to this conversation.
- 0:51Thank you so much.
- 0:53I want to start with couples sharing money because most couples end up sharing money, a joint account.
- 1:01They might have a mortgage.
- 1:03They might have a car together, but they don't always think about it or talk about it together before they fall into it.
- 1:11It's not very romantic, is it, to talk about money when you're in love with somebody and all of that.
- 1:17But it's a question you've got to have.
- 1:19Yeah.
- 1:20How do we make it romantic?
- 1:21Okay.
- 1:22It's all about getting life in order before you get into a long-term relationship.
- 1:31And particularly if you're going to share financial commitments and things like that.
- 1:36And you've got to talk about it because you're a team.
- 1:41You're a team in life.
- 1:43You're a team in finance.
- 1:45You're a team in love.
- 1:46And with money, you've got to work as a team, always.
- 1:50And I always say to people, once a month,
- 1:54and spend 15 minutes.
- 1:57I call it love money.
- 1:59It's a love money session where you love your money.
- 2:03And you sit down.
- 2:04It's only half an episode of Home and Away.
- 2:06So in the overall scheme of things, it's not a lot of time.
- 2:09Liv and I usually get cheese and biscuits.
- 2:13I open a bottle of red and inevitably last longer than 15 minutes.
- 2:19But just talk about your money, not going through credit card statements and going, why did you buy this?
- 2:23Why did you buy that?
- 2:24It is, hey, anything worrying you, anything that you need to know.
- 2:31A two-way street because we've been married 47 years.
- 2:36Libby is the best household budgeter I have ever met.
- 2:40She's always looked after our household budget.
- 2:43I get an allowance every week, and that's been for 47 years.
- 2:48I do the investing, she does the household budgeting.
- 2:51And so we bring each other up to date with what we've been doing and sharing any new financial information from either of our roles in the team, in the financial team, and set our financial goals.
- 3:07How are we going?
- 3:09any stresses, financial stresses that either of us have.
- 3:13And they can be different.
- 3:15But it's just all about talking about money.
- 3:18Just 15 minutes.
- 3:19Have an agenda.
- 3:21It might be, oh, our life insurance is coming up for renewal or our income protection.
- 3:27What do you reckon?
- 3:28Should we do more?
- 3:30Should we do less?
- 3:31All that sort of thing.
- 3:32I think it's so important and how it's resonating for me is I've got kids.
- 3:36We were talking about our kids before we kicked off and they have grown up in an era where they're talking about consent when it comes to sexual relationships, right?
- 3:46What it is, how do you ask for it?
- 3:48How do you give it?
- 3:48And to me, I think this is a very similar conversation, but maybe not one, certainly wasn't a conversation I grew up with.
- 3:56so how do you money was a taboo no don't talk about money don't talk about how much you earn all that sort of stuff yeah now again you're a team you've got to share everything yeah good and the bad if you've got if you've got debts you haven't declared to your partner if you've got some money vices you know varying degrees you've got to talk about them everything's got to be open yes you can have set up your your accounts and
- 4:25have a joint account or have your own account for your own personal finances, that's fine.
- 4:34But everyone's got to know about them.
- 4:36So how do you step into that conversation if it feels uncomfortable at first?
- 4:41I think it's almost you're compatible in love, interests, friends, that sort of stuff.
- 4:49It's almost putting it in that bucket and saying, okay, let's talk about it.
- 4:54are we compatible financially?
- 4:58Are you a good saver or are you a spender?
- 5:02You know, those little things can, after a while, irritate you if you're not on the same page or you're not aware.
- 5:10Oh, can't believe they go shopping for this and that while the other partner just loves to see their account balance go up in their savings account.
- 5:21You've got to talk about those sort of things because...
- 5:25breakups divorces you know 50 of them are because of financial stress or financial incompatibility um and so right from the very start you've got just in a fun way cheese and crackers glass of wine oh you're savor or what do you do just set yourself financial goals you know lead as one partner if you want to open the subject oh
- 5:52I love to save.
- 5:53You know, this is my financial goal.
- 5:55I learnt this from mum and dad or an uncle or auntie or whatever.
- 5:59You know, this is how I run my life.
- 6:03What about you?
- 6:04And just ease into it rather than say, do you have any credit card debt?
- 6:09How many credit cards do you have?
- 6:10That comes further down the line.
- 6:12But the icebreaker is, oh, what are your goals?
- 6:16Yeah, I had dinner with a bunch of girlfriends the other night and we started talking about our superannuation balances.
- 6:23and how everyone's done that.
- 6:25And one, she's done an amazing job, I have to say, and I was a bit jealous of her.
- 6:30But I walked away thinking, I haven't had that conversation with my friends even, you know, recently or growing up, and it was really liberating to hear where everybody was at.
- 6:42So it does open the pathway then to have other conversations too that are really important.
- 6:48Exactly right.
- 6:49And it is that...
- 6:53Be aware of anything.
- 6:57You might love your partner.
- 6:59Obviously you do if you're a team.
- 7:02But any little warning flags of money that disappears or they want to control their money very secretively or worst cases they want to then control yours because you're a team.
- 7:20They're real red flags for me.
- 7:24Everyone's just got to be so transparent.
- 7:26There should be no money issue at all that shouldn't be talked about.
- 7:33And if an answer comes back, oh, don't you trust me?
- 7:38Well, then you've got to be thinking in your own mind, well, maybe I shouldn't.
- 7:43Yeah.
- 7:44Don't you love me?
- 7:46Don't you trust me?
- 7:47You know, it's not about that.
- 7:50It's about being honest and protecting yourself.
- 7:54You've used the expression financial infidelity.
- 7:57Oh, yeah.
- 7:58Which I really love because it is about that being deceitful, I suppose.
- 8:03Yeah, you're cheating.
- 8:04Yeah.
- 8:05You're cheating.
- 8:05If you're, you know, you might have something as, you know, you might have $100 sports bet account.
- 8:15Okay.
- 8:16and just declare it.
- 8:18Because if it's a $100,000 sports bet account, then that could be a warning for your partner and they need to know about it.
- 8:28If you've got secret credit cards that only you know about, or debts that only you know about, then you've got to declare it.
- 8:39And particularly in this day and age of
- 8:45going to the bank of mum and dad, if you want to get help getting into property, I always say to mum and dad, be a bank.
- 8:57Never give the money, lend the money, because if your child's partner walks out,
- 9:05I'd rather them walk out with half of a debt to me than half an asset that they're just going to take away.
- 9:15So it is a big responsibility.
- 9:20And you'll be amazed, absolutely amazed.
- 9:24how many people fall for the traps and find themselves in all sorts of problems.
- 9:30And joint accounts is one of those areas that's really tricky.
- 9:33Yeah, or joint credit cards.
- 9:35You know, sounds really lovely.
- 9:38And joint accounts are great as well.
- 9:41Liv and I have always had a joint account, but...
- 9:45above certain limits.
- 9:46We both got to agree.
- 9:49We both have passwords to them all.
- 9:53We set limits on decisions that the two of us can make.
- 9:57And a joint credit card, you've got to understand, a joint credit card doesn't mean if your partner is a partner.
- 10:07walks out that you're only liable for half of the debt on it.
- 10:13You could be liable for the whole thing.
- 10:15If the bank can't track down your partner, or it's too hard, they will go after the easiest person.
- 10:23and you're responsible for their half as well.
- 10:27Don't think it's only half.
- 10:28So this is going into what I've been calling my feminird territory because I love reading terms and conditions.
- 10:36Catherine, you are a very special person.
- 10:38If you love reading terms and conditions.
- 10:41You know, I know it's really... You're a nerd.
- 10:44I am a nerd.
- 10:45I like to say I'm a femi-nerd.
- 10:46I think there's a hashtag.
- 10:48But I've been trying to explain to people, if you take a look, say, in your mortgage or any other account where there's a debt, there's that expression joint and several liability, and it's exactly like you've talked about.
- 11:00It doesn't mean you're only on the hook for 50%.
- 11:03You're actually on the hook for the whole 100%.
- 11:05Why do you think people don't quite understand that?
- 11:08Is it...
- 11:09The banks are not telling us enough about it or is it we just we go in a little bit blindly?
- 11:15I think we go in a bit blindly.
- 11:18Reading terms and conditions is boring and can take a fair bit of time.
- 11:25They should be advised.
- 11:27with the lender and the lender often says you need to get your own independent advice to each of the borrowers.
- 11:36I reckon that rarely ever happens.
- 11:40Now with AI and if you subscribe to Claude or one of those, you can put the terms and conditions into Claude and say, what do I need to watch out for in these terms and conditions?
- 11:53And Claude very quickly,
- 11:55So I think AI is going to be an absolute boom for financial literacy and risk of management in financials.
- 12:03And I have this saying, you can delegate some financial responsibility to the other member of the team.
- 12:12Like I delegate the household budget to Lib, but you can never surrender responsibility.
- 12:19And you've always got to be aware there is no excuse.
- 12:22And none of this, I find it too complicated, I'm not interested, it takes too much time, whatever.
- 12:29I don't care.
- 12:30It's your money.
- 12:32You've got to spend a bit of time looking at it and understanding what you're in for, because it will pay off into the future.
- 12:41Yeah, and like insurance too.
- 12:44What are you really being insured for as well?
- 12:47What are those conditions around that?
- 12:49Obviously, I'm doing this podcast because I have seen, unfortunately, the impacts of financial abuse.
- 12:56And that's when someone tries to control you through your access to money.
- 13:01So what happens if your best endeavours to find out what's going on, to have those conversations, if actually you can't because somebody is trying to abuse you and conceal that from you, that information?
- 13:14Just walk away.
- 13:15Simple as that.
- 13:16It is just not worth it.
- 13:18You may love the person, but if you don't walk away,
- 13:25you run the risk of losing everything if they walk away.
- 13:29I know I'm sounding harsh with this, but that's the reality of it all.
- 13:34And, you know, we've had, Lib and I have had friends and, you know, particularly women are vulnerable more than blokes in this, have just been left destitute.
- 13:47It is heartbreaking to see it.
- 13:51And it's because they trust it.
- 13:54their partner way too much.
- 13:56And it's not a trust thing.
- 13:59It's a...
- 14:01have I got into a relationship with a decent person who we're looking after each other's interests?
- 14:07That's a two-way street.
- 14:08That's in everything we do.
- 14:09That's in parenting.
- 14:10That's in looking after each other and health-wise, all that sort of stuff.
- 14:16It is just the fundamental of a relationship to be completely open and honest.
- 14:21And as I said before, if you've got a partner that says, don't you love me, don't you trust me,
- 14:27Well, you say, what if you drop dead?
- 14:31Where are the insurance policies?
- 14:34Who's our financial planner or accountant?
- 14:37If you've got one, if not, who do we deal with at the bank?
- 14:42Where is everything?
- 14:43It should all be in one easily accessible place that you all know about.
- 14:50And have that 15 minutes?
- 14:51Yes.
- 14:53at least every month talk about money together.
- 14:56And if there's pushback from a partner on anything, it's just not acceptable.
- 15:01Yeah.
- 15:01You talked it before we started about a book you wrote about some time ago with Lib.
- 15:07Yeah, with Lib about 20 years ago.
- 15:09And the book was basically if your partner walks out, the 10 steps you must take,
- 15:19before you get emotional, before you cry.
- 15:22And again, it was pretty blunt, but it was, hey, if they walk out, you change your passwords.
- 15:30You let your bank know.
- 15:32You make sure you've got access and you go and get copies of wills, of insurance policies, everything.
- 15:41You tell the bank,
- 15:43This account, this joint account cannot be used from now on without both agreement on money going out just to protect yourself.
- 15:54Yeah.
- 15:55What would you say if you were going to write the book now instead of it being the 10 things you do before you get emotional after they leave, what about the 10 things you do as you're running them throes of emotion?
- 16:08Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 16:09Or the 10 things you do when you're...
- 16:13about to commit to a long-term relationship.
- 16:15Yeah.
- 16:15What would be on that list?
- 16:17Oh, it would be having the conversation.
- 16:20It would be setting the ground rules of how our money is going to be managed.
- 16:26It might be a joint account where – and –
- 16:29kick off in the early stages of a relationship while you're building that trust because you really don't know someone unless you've lived with them for a fair amount of time, I don't think.
- 16:40Because the romance
- 16:47the short-term romance will go and you become friends and you become partners and you become a team.
- 16:53That's a big step forward and that's where it all, you get to really know the person going forward.
- 17:00So it is, okay, how do we sort out our banking?
- 17:04How do we sort out the income we both earn?
- 17:07How do we divvy it up?
- 17:08What are the financial goals?
- 17:10What are each of our responsibilities?
- 17:12in terms of managing different parts of the household budget or just our financial relationship and getting that all done quickly.
- 17:21Our estate planning, what are we going to do with wills?
- 17:24Insurances, do we add each other as beneficiaries?
- 17:29Do you become my designated beneficiary on the super?
- 17:33Yeah.
- 17:34Today, that's a big commitment.
- 17:35That's a big sign of a relationship.
- 17:39So it's all of those issues I think you need to discuss.
- 17:44And that's just part of having a healthy relationship.
- 17:48It shouldn't be intimidating.
- 17:50No, of course not.
- 17:52As you talk about, it is a partnership.
- 17:54What about the conversations with the providers of those?
- 17:57Are there things that, like, you know,
- 18:00Quite often, you know, you move into a house, it's like, oh, I've set up the electricity, my name's on it.
- 18:05Yes.
- 18:06Or I've put both of our names on it.
- 18:09Should you be also talking about whose name is on things?
- 18:14It depends.
- 18:16Sometimes for...
- 18:18you know, incidentally, they are big bills, okay, that particularly with the cost of living crisis we've got at the moment and managing their household budget.
- 18:29But they're...
- 18:31I think they're reasonably minor compared with the big issues of estate planning, loans, debts, all of that.
- 18:41The household budget commitments should always be in both names.
- 18:48You might need to wait for renewals or changeover to do it, but that should be on your list, your financial health checklist.
- 18:57before you make a big commitment and in the early stages of it to get it sorted.
- 19:03And then what about as you're moving through life and you've got some of those other things that are happening?
- 19:09We don't always talk also about the things that might go wrong.
- 19:13So when you're doing the planning, so you're walking in, it's all hunky-dory, but what about when life happens?
- 19:19And life does happen, and particularly...
- 19:22If you're part of a small business, that's another layer of responsibility.
- 19:30I've had family businesses virtually live my whole married life.
- 19:36And it is if you're a director of a small business, if you're in a relationship with a tradie or married to a tradie or...
- 19:47and you're a director of their small business.
- 19:51It is understanding your responsibilities there.
- 19:55The golden rule is you never sign anything.
- 19:58Never sign anything until you understand it and it's explained to you.
- 20:03Never.
- 20:04And I know it can be really easy because life's very busy for everyone.
- 20:09Hey, can you just sign this for the accountant?
- 20:12Well, no.
- 20:14No, you stop.
- 20:15Even though you're busy, you stop and go, I'm not going to sign that now.
- 20:20Let's set that aside where in tonight or in two days' time or when we catch up for our monthly, talking about money, you explain to me what I'm signing here.
- 20:33Yeah.
- 20:34And leave the document with me so I can read it.
- 20:37And let's talk about it.
- 20:39And you tell me why it's so important.
- 20:40I need it.
- 20:41And, you know, it could be an asset document.
- 20:43It could be anything.
- 20:45It could be administrative bureaucratic.
- 20:50And the answer is pretty simple to give you.
- 20:53But it could be something different as well.
- 20:54It could be, hey, you're guaranteed for an overdraft that we're going in for the bank, understanding what that means for you.
- 21:02Yeah, what exactly that means.
- 21:03So I think what I'm really taking away from this conversation is eyes wide open and the curiosity to have the conversation together.
- 21:13And you're not loving your partner.
- 21:18You're not distrusting them.
- 21:21And they shouldn't take it that way either.
- 21:25It is...
- 21:27You want to satisfy yourself.
- 21:29You want to understand what you... You want to be involved in the financial side of the relationship.
- 21:36And you should be because it's your money.
- 21:38It's your commitment.
- 21:40It's...
- 21:41your risk in terms of any loans that you might have.
- 21:48And that's just part of a healthy relationship.
- 21:52People that say to me, oh, really uncomfortable talking about it.
- 21:55Why?
- 21:57We all talk about our family.
- 21:59We talk about our sex lives with each other.
- 22:02Why can't you talk about money?
- 22:04It's just part of life.
- 22:06It's part of a relationship.
- 22:08But everyone goes this taboo thing, I don't want to upset anybody or think that I don't trust them.
- 22:15No, you're just protecting yourself.
- 22:19Yeah.
- 22:20Maybe that's part of what we need to do next is how do we get that conversation really out there?
- 22:25I mean, it's more taboo to talk about money than it is about mental health, for example.
- 22:30We're having a much better conversation about mental health.
- 22:33Absolutely.
- 22:33Yeah.
- 22:33Absolutely.
- 22:34We hear the term joint account all the time and you've talked about that, but what do people think it means and what does it actually mean?
- 22:42Okay.
- 22:42I think joint accounts, joint loans, the whole thing, everybody goes...
- 22:50Oh, it's joint, it's fair.
- 22:52I'm responsible or am entitled to 50% of the joint savings account or I'm responsible for half the joint debt on a credit card or a mortgage.
- 23:08But what it really means is, no, no, no, no, you are responsible for the entire debt.
- 23:15if your partner walks out and won't pay their share.
- 23:19And with your joint savings account, you are responsible for the entire balance as your partner is.
- 23:29Now, in a joint savings account,
- 23:33Your partner's just not limited to taking out their half of the joint.
- 23:38They're entitled to take the whole lot.
- 23:40And there have been lots of stories where a partner has walked out and said, see you later.
- 23:46Then the other partner has gone to their joint savings account and it has been cleaned out.
- 23:51Yeah.
- 23:52So, yeah, joint is you.
- 23:55Yeah, I've seen that as well in the cases of financial abuse where there might be two people putting into the offset account or having the redraw in the mortgage.
- 24:07That's also cleaned out as well.
- 24:10So there is a risk there when you've got that.
- 24:13And the double risk is if you lose all the entire savings account
- 24:22but then you also inherit an entire debt.
- 24:26Yeah.
- 24:26And that's a nightmare for anyone involved in that.
- 24:32Yeah, absolutely.
- 24:33And if a partner is going to leave and leave you in the lurch, you may not see it coming.
- 24:39They may have been planning it for quite a while and have taken the steps to clean you out.
- 24:46So what about when the team does it really well?
- 24:49How does that feel?
- 24:51I know.
- 24:51We've been sounding very serious, haven't we, with all of the pitfalls you've got to watch out for.
- 24:58But if you're working well as a team financially,
- 25:02It's just a wonderful experience.
- 25:04So all that financial stress lifts off your shoulders because you're talking to someone about it.
- 25:10You're sharing issues.
- 25:12You're sharing goals.
- 25:13You're achieving goals because you're on the same financial page.
- 25:17So it can be a wonderful, liberating experience
- 25:22when you get it right, and so many people do.
- 25:25Thank you very much for your time.
- 25:27I really appreciate it.
- 25:27Sure, I am.
- 25:28Thanks for having me.
- 25:29I'm asking every guest to finish up the podcast by finishing this sentence, before you say yes.
- 25:38Before you say yes, have an honest and transparent conversation about everything to do with your finances and your partner's finances.
- 25:50Thank you very much, Koshi.
- 25:51Really appreciate your time.