Latest / AEC GrowthCast / Comfortable Being Uncomfortable: Two AEC Leaders on Succession, AI, and Growth (Ep. 10)
Transcript
- Miller Caldwell: There's this idea that, there's this dragon out there that holds treasure, right? I mean the dragons guard the treasure. But in order to get the treasure you gotta go to the dragon. And the dragon might be what you don't know or what you might be afraid of. And, you know, typically when I run into those kinds of things, the things where I'm uncomfortable or that I not necessarily fear, but make me question I'm like, ooh, that that could be something. The things that I kind of want to turn away from a little bit that are hard, I try to turn into that as hard as I can. Because then through that you find strength within yourself which I think is important. Gregory Hart: Hello and welcome to the AEC GrowthCast. This is the show for AEC Firm Leaders, where we talk about the data, the stories, and the insight behind high performance in architecture, engineering, and construction organizations. As you well know, growth isn't always just about getting bigger. It's about getting better, right? It's about getting smarter. It's about getting more intentional with a firm's future. And that's what we talk about in every episode of this podcast. My name is Greg Hart, president here at PSMJ Resources, the company behind the AEC GrowthCast, and I'm happy to have you here with us for this episode. Two great conversations, two great leaders thinking about what's next for their firms, for the industry. And we're gonna bring that to you in this episode. Before we get into that, of course, for those of you who've listened to the show in the past, we like to start things off with a metric of the month, just a quick data point that caught my attention and that has an implication for you as an AEC firm leader in some way, shape, or form. The data I want to share today is actually a tip that I saw in October in a new report from Bluebeam, developer of software and solutions for AEC firms. They release a report every year called the AEC Technology Outlook Report. So they released their 2027 Report in October, a survey of 750 US-based AEC professionals. And there was some interesting data in there. I encourage you to check it out because I'm going to share one tidbit that but there was a lot more than just that in the report. In the report, they cited that only 28% of AEC firm leaders, AEC firms, I guess, have moved AI into a production capacity. So beyond experimentation into production, 28%. Only 7% have really embedded it across multiple core workflows. So that's consistent with what we've seen over the past six months or so. More and more experimentation, but not a lot of adoption in AEC firms. What was interesting, I thought, was that only 2% cite a lack of trust in AI outputs as the significant barrier to adoption, right? A year or two years ago, that would have been far and away the number one objection is a lack of trust, security, privacy, all that kind of stuff. Now, the firms that have adopted it in the report report some pretty significant impacts in terms of cost savings or increased efficiency, but again, not a lot of adoption. When they asked about companies that are holding back, 50% cite the cost, 34% cite a lack of internal skills, AI skills, and 22% cite resistance to change among the employees. So what do you do with that data when only 28% of firms are using AI in any sort of production capacity, but that the firms who are using it are noticing a significant positive gain? I think the first thing you get to look at there is it's easy to jump into the experimentation game. And a lot of firms have found themselves in that sandbox. But you can end up in what I'd call the experimentation closed loop, closed circular reference where you just keep going over and over playing with it, but are unable organizationally to take the plunge and roll it out in any sort of workflow beyond experimentation. That's easy to say, hard to do, right? Because there are some risks, even though the report isn't mentioning it. There certainly are some risks, and it's always going to be more comfortable to keep doing things the way you've been doing it. But the most success I've seen in AEC firms is starting small, little repetitive, simple tasks. Always, always, always assign an executive sponsor to it as well. If you don't have commitment from the top down, nothing's gonna happen, even if it's a simple, small AI initiative. Set a 90-day plan. What does success look like over the next 90 days? Right? It could be things in proposal development, contact review, project documentation, quality control, financial forecasting, even. There's all sorts of little use cases like that. You've probably already been experimenting in some of those use cases. Go from experimentation to work. You can always go backwards, right? If some of the thesis that you have or some of the ideas that you have about where this is going to yield productive results don't come to fruition, but you'll never see those opportunities if you stay in that experimentation cycle. Anyway, that's our metric of the month. Some interesting data on AI adoption. We'll continue to watch that and monitor that over the next months and years to see how that evolves and how that changes as the industry gets more and more and more comfortable with AI as a valuable tool. So, with that, I said we've got a lot to cover here. So Miller Caldwell is the CEO of 35-person architecture firm, Caldwell Architects, based in Pensacola, Florida. Miller's father actually founded the firm in 1986. Miller joined me to share his journey about growing up in the family business and the pressure that that creates in his transition to eventually leading the firm, which he does today. We talk about that experience, how it shaped him as a leader in the firm, but also the importance of finding your own way, right? Of not trying to replicate somebody else's leadership style in the the shoes that you're trying to fill, which in in his case were quite large, right? Let's jump into that conversation with Miller. Then we'll come back out and get into Ali talking about AI and tech for AEC. All right, I'm excited to have Miller Caldwell here, Caldwell Architects. Miller, thanks for joining me. Miller Caldwell: Thanks, Greg. I'm really excited to be here. Gregory Hart: Well, one of the topics we talk about a lot in general, is kind of the friction between generations and the inability or the struggle or the challenge, I guess, to find future leaders and and create future leaders in the firm. So I thought it'd kind of fun. You've got a unique perspective and that you've grown up in the industry a little bit on some of the skills, some of your experience with becoming a leader going up to being the CEO of the firm. Kind of looking back a little bit, you know, what were the things that you'd tell yourself and and what are the lessons that you've learned and what are the skills that you think others could benefit from and insight and perspective and advice that others could benefit from. So that'd be kind of fun to dig into that a little bit if you don't mind. Miller Caldwell: Absolutely, yeah. It's a big passion of mine to help bring up the future leaders of the industry. I really think that's part of the purpose of Caldwell Architects is to help rebuild, our middle, let's say, and you know, and bringing up the young leaders to create a healthier profession. As I've watched this business since my dad started the firm in 1986. It's our 40th year. Leadership has changed incredibly, and and how we do it and what it means to do that has changed and evolved in a in a better way. Maybe a good way to think about it is we understand it better, you know, in management practices. I'm a big student of leadership and certain ways in which you know human beings respond to situations. I think that you kinda have to know that you have to lead yourself before you can lead others. And my dad always used to say, "You could read as much as you want to read, but until you've done it, you haven't done it." Being boss's son was a hard thing. Everybody kinda thinks kinda got this head. It was incredibly difficult, because you have a stigma, you know, and so I had to kind of make my own way and discover my own purpose as a leader and my own why. Be humble, know your why, and just observe what's happening around you and absorb the information, right, wrong, or indifferent, good, bad, positive, and learn from those things that happened around you. Gregory Hart: You sort of grew up in the industry, right? Your dad starts the firm. When did you decide Miller Caldwell: No. Gregory Hart: was it a foregone conclusion that you were going to be an architect, or how did that how did that happen? Miller Caldwell: No, not Yeah, not at all. Long story short is that my entire life, I wanted to be a fighter pilot and I wanted to join the Navy and that was my whole track. and in high school I was part of ROTC, get my eyes tested. And they're like, "Look, man, you don't- you're never gonna fly anything because of your eyesight." And it's like, okay, well, I gotta find something else to do. I found special forces and I went Air Force and Navy direction, also wanted to get obviously an education and so I went into college, pre-med thinking that, understanding of biology and things like that can help me from a human performance side in that avenue of things. Didn't really like it, didn't really find my purpose in it. And got home in the summer and started working at the office and I've always was called to architecture to some degree and building things also and it I think it was in my blood. And so it was like I just feel like I would miss something if I didn't at least explore this avenue for myself. Because I did enjoy it. And so that summer I really tried to explore it. And my dad always used to say, "If you don't know how to build it, you can't draw it." And I'm like, well, that makes a lot of sense. So as I started looking at colleges, Auburn was able to offer me a dual degree in building science and architecture. And I was like, okay, well I'm gonna go try that. And I tried that and and fell in love with it. So that's I was just like, okay, well this is what I think I'm supposed to be doing. My dad said, "Look, you gotta go find something to do different first. Like you can't straight come back here." I went to work for Dos (Doster Construction Company) which was the best advice. Like anybody who's going into a family business, you don't know what you're getting into, it's incredibly difficult. And so go out and get other experience so you can bring it back, So go into the unknown and observe a different things to bring new things back. Gregory Hart: And then as you've matriculated up in the firm, it seems like your dad's been quite a mentor. You often reference, things that you've learned from him. Take me through that transition and how that all works. Miller Caldwell: Yeah. My dad was probably, and I still say this to this day, he was probably the most holistic architect I've ever met, way more than I am. He knew how to draw, he knew how to produce, he knew how to project manage, he could sketch, he could present. maybe technology was kind of his, you know, his weakness, let's say. Whatever that's supposed to mean. But he understood the business, he understood the design, he understood all those things. He was very tough. He mentored in a way that he would ask you basically rhetorical questions that he already knew the answer to to see if you would try to, you know talk your way through it. and you know, and if you lied, if you tried to just make things up to justify your position, you know, he would pretty much eat your lunch. But he did it well because he always pushed you to to know different things and you knew where to push and you knew what not to push, if that makes any sense. So he knew where to be hard and then he knew where to back off, so he would push you just beyond where you were comfortable to where it it was tough. And then he and then he would back off. And then so there was, just like you would anything, just like you practice anything, you push yourself to a level and come back. Gregory Hart: Yeah, that's a sign of a great coach. And we talk about that a lot in coaching and mentoring. And that's management by asking questions is a real thing, of not wanting Miller Caldwell: Right. Gregory Hart: to jump in and solve it, but asking you the questions he knows the answer to and getting you to come to that conclusion yourself. Miller Caldwell: Yeah, and I've taken that from him. even this morning when I was mentoring two younger guys, we have this project and their wall section was way off, and it was all messed up. And I didn't try to solve it for him. I didn't try to get anything, you know, just asking questions. "Okay, what do you see here? If this is the case, why is this the case?" You know? And then they would try to talk themselves through it. Even if they didn't know the answer, you know, I would try to lead them to it, you know, versus lose control of the emotion and get frustrated. That's not gonna help anybody. And so yeah, I agree. I mean, trying to push through that, know that, talk through it I think is important. Gregory Hart: You had the technical skills and and started matriculating up with that. What non technical skills did you say, "If I'm gonna run this firm, I've really gotta, build up my skill set here or there." What were the things that you don't learn in school that you had to pick up along the way? Miller Caldwell: The first thing was communication. me well enough to know that I'm pretty intense and I run really hot. I have a sign above my computer that every second counts, which it does, and I believe that. But there's also this idea that slow is smooth and smooth is fast. So I think that the intensity I had to learn how to gauge that and know when to use those certain gears because then it can start to affect communication, you know. Also communicating the why and the purpose of what we're doing. I don't think I had enough appreciation of that at the time. You know? I would say too that, you know, talking about my dad the differences, he could feel the business part of the firm. He could he just kind of knew where things were by feel. I've taken a more business approach to that versus him. And I think that that has been something that's helped us build an infrastructure to where we can grow. And so I did not know that at the time and I really spent a lot of time studying PSMJ material on project management, finance, what you know, all of those things to understand, okay, well, what does a successful business within the architecture realm look like? Gregory Hart: Tell me about that process of filling those shoes. Was that intimidating? Or did you- are people Miller Caldwell: Totally. And Gregory Hart: always comparing the two of you? Or how does that how did that work? Miller Caldwell: Yeah, I think so. I think so. I think that they did. And I think that they still do a little bit. And you know, I mean for a long time he was Big Miller and I was Little Miller. That was kind of the thing that I had to kind of not break away from...But he was always trial by fire a little bit and he was here on a Friday, and gone on a Monday. And he was like, "Good luck!" The people in the firm were like, "Can Miller do this? Like he's- you know," and they would ask me, they're like, "We're sitting here, we don't have a captain!" And I just remember at that particular moment taking charge and being like, "Look, I've got this, I'm the captain now. This is what we're gonna do." And being confident in that, but also being humble to say, I don't know what I don't know. and I think there's a balance in that being confident and being courageous towards that, maybe that's a good way to think about it, doesn't mean that you know everything. And it doesn't mean that you can't say, "You know what, I'm not so sure about that, but let's talk about it. I don't know." You still need humility. No matter how far you get, I think you still need a good dose of humility and all of it. Gregory Hart: A big part of that too, which I think has been really true with you, is you found your own way and didn't just try to replicate him. right? Miller Caldwell: Correct. Yeah, a hundred percent. That's a good way to say it. Yeah. I wanted to find my own why, my own purpose, and my own way of doing things, which was different than him in a lot of ways. I mean, took a lot of things from him, like we talked about the mentoring side, and try to polish that up a little bit, but there's a lot of things on the business side that were totally different It took me a good ten years, to switch maybe not quite, but pretty close, you know. I mean from call it 2010 to 2020. It took me most of that time to show that, you know, I can do this, I think I've proven that at this point, but it's still, you know, I think some of the older folks still, you know, look at how he did things, you know, and how I've changed things, you know. Gregory Hart: So in light of that, looking back to the Miller Caldwell that had just finished his education, or to any other young professional who's just entering the industry right now, what would you have to say to them in terms of where to go and what skills to acquire? I mean, you mentioned some of the stuff that you've picked up, but what's your advice to kind of an entry-level professional? Miller Caldwell: First I think that depending on where you want to go in your career, whether you want to lead a firm or whatever, you kinda have to decide that a little bit, like or at least be open to it. And I think that most young professionals come out and say, you know, "I want to be a leader to some degree." I don't think they know exactly what that means. But everyone that I've come in contact with, they want to lead in some way. Even outside the firm, when I coach younger professionals, I was like, you know, "You have to go into the unknown, you know, and have to push yourself beyond where you're comfortable. And you have to build habits and discipline around what you're trying to attain. And you also have to realize that there's a direct causal relationship between the things that you do and are doing in that moment to the steepness of however you grow, if that makes any sense." And so I would say that you know, first I read a lot, I'd highly recommend reading everything that you can, not only about leadership, but about all different kinds of subjects, understanding your why, why you're doing this, where you want to go, what your purpose is. And I would stop there to say that that's going to be an evolution of something for you personally that's going to evolve over time. But getting out, reading, studying, doing the extra work that nobody wants to do. You know, if you want to stand out in this business and be a leader, you have to be a leader. And first you have to lead yourself and having the discipline to do that. And then you have to say, "Okay, I'm willing to do the things that others are not willing to do." That is a huge separator, I think from most people, you know. And that might mean staying late, that might mean studying different drawings or specifications or studying PSMJ project management content or financial content. Start to observe the environment that you're in and start to write down the things, keeping a little notebook or journal, writing things down, the things that you question. "Why did this happen?" And or "This person said this and why did that?" even for the mistakes that you make, because you're gonna make a lot of them, and that's okay. We don't need to get out of over our skis because this business can be risky, right? We can make mistakes that cost a lot of money, so we need to be mindful of that. But I would say I'm a big believer in habits. "Atomic Habits" is a book that, you know, when I'm coaching young folks that I have them read. "Atomic Habits" and "Extreme Ownership." Both of those can help you really stand out and understanding what it means to be a leader because even within Caldwell, I think every position here is a leader to some degree. And I think we can all be leaders to some degree, and own the things around us as best we possibly can. And I think as so long as you do that and learn from things that happen around you, you'll stand out. Gregory Hart: On the part about always be reading, one of the things that's impressed me about you, it's a crazy time to be coming into this industry. And certainly there's a generational change that you've lived, but the AI technology piece, private equity, it's just all sorts of stuff happening at once. Miller Caldwell: Yeah. Gregory Hart: And on the AI and tech piece, you're learning it and absorbing it and testing and getting right in there and certainly not afraid of it by any means. That's a great example, I think, of just find something new and just figure it out and start playing around with it, right? Miller Caldwell: There's this idea that, there's this dragon out there that holds treasure, right? I mean the dragons guard the treasure. But in order to get the treasure you gotta go to the dragon. And the dragon might be what you don't know or what you might be afraid of. And, you know, typically when I run into those kinds of things, the things where I'm uncomfortable or that I not necessarily fear, but make me question I'm like, ooh, that that could be something. The things that I kind of want to turn away from a little bit that are hard, I try to turn into that as hard as I can. Because then through that you find strength within yourself which I think is important. It creates a situation where I'm always learning and trying to connect different things. 'Cause it's all connected, and it's a web of ideas and and I think that's been very helpful for me, I like to learn, I think everybody should always be a lifelong learner. I say that to everybody, because do we really have anything else better to do than than learn and try to make things better, I remember when my dad here in town, he bought a 286 computer and he had AutoCAD on it. He only had one machine. And everybody in town was coming to the office to see this computer. Gregory Hart: Ha ha ha. Miller Caldwell: And when I tell you there was a line out the door to see it. It was a real thing. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Miller Caldwell: And then the onset of the internet and email, it kind of, as big as a shift as that was because I worked when there was no email, and I know that there's people out there, we all worked, there was no email, there was no thing like that. And we faxed, you know, and picked up the phone. And I think that that's important, you know, that human connection is important. We shouldn't forget that. This period in time it reminds me of that. It feels the same as that did, this big technological shift is to the unknown of what's what it is, you know, and you know, so it feels the same way, you know. Gregory Hart: Yeah, you bet. Sure. Yeah. Miller, thanks so much for joining me. Lots of good lots of good insight Miller Caldwell: Absolutely. Thanks, Greg. Gregory Hart: and perspective there. Always fun talking to you. Certainly appreciate it. Miller Caldwell: Absolutely. Thanks so much for having me and yeah, I appreciate the opportunity to talk to you. Gregory Hart: Awesome. Thanks for being here. Now we're gonna shift gears. Ali Fakih is the CEO of SEG, a Phoenix-based civil engineering firm that he founded in 2009. He's also the founder of AIAEC, company focused on bringing AI to the AEC industry. How did he decide to then launch an AI company? It's because he saw an opportunity, right? He saw an opportunity to turn the industry on its ear a little bit and revolutionize how things are done. So take a listen, let's jump into our conversation with Ali. Excited to have here on the podcast Ali Fakih, who is the CEO of SEG. And I guess that wasn't enough. So he decided to found a AI firm called AIAEC as well. Wasn't busy enough doing doing SEG. Ali, welcome. thanks for joining me here. Welcome to the show. Ali Fakih: Thanks, Greg. Thanks for having me. Appreciate you. Gregory Hart: So first to paint the picture a little bit, just tell me a little bit about SEG was it 2009 when you founded the engineering firm? Ali Fakih: February 2009, I started SEG. So SEG planning, entitlement, and civil engineering firm. At the beginning of the worst real estate crash ever, end of 2008 and beginning of 2009. And it's been an amazing journey. Seven offices. Our focus is a lot on land development, tons of entitlement, a lot of planning. We do a lot of work in Arizona, California. We have our headquarters in Phoenix. We have an office in Dallas as well focused on land development. Gregory Hart: AIAEC, that was a couple of years ago, right, that you started that? Ali Fakih: Yeah, Yeah, we started this almost three years ago. I go back to it. Obviously, you know, like I'm your typical nerd civil engineer. I mean, have mastered the PhD. I've been studying all my life and different aspects to it. And three years ago, when AI start taking more, space in all of our lives, I was one of the people who believe us matter experts and professionals in our field has to be the one figuring out how we incorporate AI into our workflow and how we get it to be working with us and for us to kind of like address similar challenge and similar pain that our professional have. And this is exactly what we did. My focus always been, Greg, since the beginning, I've seen our engineer, our planner, including myself have worked hours and hours on research and, know, like tracking information and following up on information. So my focus from the beginning is I want to reduce the entitlement process by reducing at least the resource part. How can we do this? How can we get to point where early on on property acquisition or early on on due diligence, how can we reduce this? And we literally, with what we built, we have a client that literally hired us to do due diligence report that usually take our guys about 200 to 220 hours at the SEG site. Now we're able to run the first draft in six minutes. But this discrepancy in time is insane. And then the other thing which we hear a lot is permitting. Everyone complained about permitting. Municipal complained about permitting. Politician complained about permitting. Developer as professional complained about permitting. So there is a huge pain in the permitting process. So this is the other tool where we're focusing, okay, what can we do to reduce the permitting pain? And you know, it's funny what we learned throughout the process, know, especially looking into it more from municipal side, their goal align exactly with our goal because the perception is, well, municipal is dragging the permitting. Municipal would love to have these quickest permitting, agency and the whole state or the whole, 50 states, right? But the challenge is way beyond what they're controlling. It's like between private and public. So what we focus on our other tool, QPoint, is like, okay, how can we reduce the pain on the permitting? Before even you have a solid professional making the last call on a plan, there is 70% of it that goes in through administration, which is insane. Gregory Hart: What made you decide to kind of build an AI company and what was the first step? How did this come about? Ali Fakih: In July 2023, I would be sitting in a room and they're talking about model training, AI, you know, like computer visioning and how you get into the right model and guardrails and things honestly, I had no idea what it is. It was way beyond my head. And I will sit there and they're so smart. And at one point of time, you start figuring out the business side and start figuring out what's your added value, which my added value was more as a product guy, someone who's seen a pain and I envision how I want to fix the pain. And now today I know a lot more about the technicals than I knew three years ago. But when I hired our first engineer, I had no clue, truly no clue. Since I immigrated to the US, I'm big, believer [in] you have to be comfortable to be uncomfortable a little bit. have to, and if you don't, you're stuck. We've done really well in SEG and the last three years is kind of like, okay, I want to get into the AI world because I could see the opportunity for us. Took me a while just to finalize the vision of what I want to build and where we want to take it. I built the strategy in the first six to eight months while I'm learning through it. Gregory Hart: Fast forward to today, so how's it going with AIAEC today? Ali Fakih: It's been awesome. So we have two products on the market now. Actually three, but the two main ones that we're seeing a lot of traction that we're focusing our marketing effort on, it's called ChatAEC. And this product focus on due diligence for properties early on. And it's a chatbot and due diligence report. You're putting an address for a property. You're able to know exactly what you could do on this property. You could, okay, from this address it's pulling your zoning, your general plan. You're pulling every information you need to build a performer early on. How long is it going to take me? Time is money. So we're changing the way you search on properties where it's always been based on financial and end user, right? We're taking it and to look more on how can we look, make entitlement that is real pain part of your performance. Let's talk about timing, schedule, fees, impact fees. What's all your allowed use? What's the highest and best use you could and from this early on through ChatAEC you like the property? Let's build it full due diligence report for you. Let's create a schedule. And this is all takes minutes I mean we're talking about items that usually takes hours and days that we're doing that in minutes. Gregory Hart: Was there a part of you at some point that was like, "Wait a minute here, I'm biting the hand that feeds me, I'm in a time based business model?" Ali Fakih: It It is, so I have one of our clients, call us like, "Hey man, I'm using the tool. I mean, due diligence you charge us for, it's kind of like at the other side, it's making life a lot easier." And, but they still use us on the other side. And here's the trick. It's-there is a lot of analysis and work get to be done early on, right? You always want to have a human making the final decision. So even if they run a due diligence, they want this touch of a professional to confirm and, take it in. And I say this kind of like I had a developer that, you know, using our tool and the question is like, "How much I could trust it?" And I say, hey, you have two approaches here. If you hire someone fresh out of school to help you, you're going to put them in analysis, due diligence or whatnot. And if you put them on a task, and they just email it to you and you're the type of person will just forward this without even opening it and look at it. This is not for you. If you open it and check what they did, it means you still add this second set of eyes that needed early on, right? And if you set this expectation time by time, you start building a trust with your tool and you will know when you don't need to open and just forward or you see, okay, you know what, you're double checking everything is good. And yeah, this is good. Saving me tons of time and looking into it. Our QPoint, this is where we work. It's mainly on plan review and it's quality control and municipal facing. And this is what make it really intriguing. And this is live already now with local municipality in Arizona as well. And they just gave us six permit to start with. This is another thing I learned. We all see like, those a huge permit, like those big mixed use project. But by city, how many of those projects are doing compared to the other majority of the project from single family home and. pool permit and tenant improvement or whatnot. These are where, the majority is, right? So you like, you have to focus on their pain today, which is majority of the amount of work before it come to them. It's like, I want to do your most important project through AI. No, let's start, get you trust where you need to, and then we can go from there. And this is the approach and it's been working really well for us. Gregory Hart: You bet. Yeah. And it seems like on the engineering side, what you're doing is exactly what we would suggest you do. You're swimming upstream. You're looking at the higher value work for the human piece and pushing more of the lower value stuff. Well, in some cases, it's honestly high value, but into the AI model. So you're justifying the value prop of the engineering firm at a much higher level, right? Ali Fakih: 100%. I have not met a single professional engineer, planner, architect who'd sit down with you, you know, like, "I'm so bored. I mean, I wish I Gregory Hart: Yeah. Ali Fakih: have, I wish I have a little bit more to do." I have not met a single person, Gregory Hart: Yeah. Ali Fakih: especially in the last eight, nine years. What I hear is "There is a lot to do. We have every day they're changing priority every day. There is a new priority because they could receive an email about any item or planning item or projects that could change their priority today. And things are need to be prioritized to be done. Otherwise they can't, have so many on their plate, We all have a lot going on. There is no way to replace what the people doing. Let's figure out how we can at least reduce some of these to-do list to dos that AI could help with, right? And this has been... the pitch that really worked and the honest truth about it because AI will not replace a human on what you do. I mean, even if you forget about the license and whatnot, you know, like put this on the side, you still have some touch where us human will have to have in our field. There is a lot of liabilities, there is public health, there is tons of creativity that occur. So our part is so important, but there is a lot of things we do today that easily we could reduce to make us more productive on the things that we like and enjoy the most. Gregory Hart: How did you what were some of the early objections? You're probably still getting some objections and how do you deal with that? How do you make sure it's not just putting out AI slop? Ali Fakih: It's, they have to go back to trust and training, right? And it's all about the data, right? I give you that now, it's not the perfect analogy, but I'm going to use it. Let's say you have [a] nine year old and you give them two books. One has all the wrong ideas in the whole world and they keep them reading, or you give them one with truly the right ideas on whatever learning experience I want [them] to have, whatever the topic is, right? If the data is good, they're going to be able to, you know, like, use it and build on it. Like sometimes I have some people it's like, "Well, hey, we could use Claude and ChatGPT to get what you do." It's like- and sometimes we do a demo and we ask the question for those people exactly "Pull the general AI and ask the question. Is it going to pull information from everyone?" So you could be lucky to get information specific to the parcel, but you may have a Reddit opinion about the zoning that you will be able to pull, right? And this is a go back to how you can set up your model with the right guardrail to only focus on the items that is related to the vision of the product. And this is the most part of it that we've been spending so much time on, even in due diligence when you're putting a report, how you create a flow to it and how it's all connected to it. So this is what makes a difference between the general LLM and what we do. I was in conference, I think 18 months ago, and I don't know if you know Zach Kass. He's one of the guys who started OpenAI. And I was like, "Hey, I would like to spend a couple of minutes with you." And Doug is like, "I've spent a lot of money on this tool. I mean, I'm so excited about it. And I just like, I'm all in. Will you guys ever come and take this from us? I mean, are you guys going to get into our field?" And he [Kass] starts laughing and is just like, "Listen, there is a lot of expert matter stuff, like things that professionals are doing... We won't be able to get to it. we'd have to hire all, you know, like type of professionals that would to go after. This is it's focused by itself, right?" So he sees it exactly as that! The general LLM will exist and how each one of us tap into it and how we can manage the workflow to it to make it specific to our field. This is where the future is. And I'm so lucky to be in, you know, like where we are today through the timing. Gregory Hart: Sure! In a lot of ways, AI is what's going to allow architects and engineers to do what they do best, right? And Ali Fakih: 100%. Gregory Hart: in so much of the work, not just in the permitting, but in other parts of the business are documentation, administration, things like that. So absolutely. And it which is a perfect segue into the other thing I want to talk to about. So you as a CEO of an engineering firm, obviously really, really AI kind of forward thinking. When you look around the competition at other CEOs of engineering firms or architecture firms, what do you see them getting wrong about AI? Ali Fakih: I think skepticism there is sometimes mistrust. I think I hear sometimes that, "I don't trust AI or AI will never do what we do." You know, it's a lot of skepticism exists out there and sometimes not trusting on not knowing how to use it. I used to spend probably 50% of my time on email. Okay. I probably spend it more now in AI. Because I could get in a lot more done and getting in, you could send an LOI, you could do whatever you want to do from business side by creating this workflow. So the skepticism, the lack of understanding how to use it, I think the two keys for it. And it depends on which take you take, right? Because you're leading the company, right? If you have a skepticism, it goes all the way from up to down because you're not going to let anyone use it, right? You're going to have concern if anyone uses it. If you're open to figure out how to use it and train it and create guardrailing for it, it will affect the whole organization as well. So we see both of it. Unfortunately, more on the skepticism part than the, you know, more taking it into the next level. But I think this has changed. I think this will change really quick and it has to. Gregory Hart: It has to because as we continue to go through both growth and expansion of firms, but also generational change, the knowledge transfer or knowledge management piece I think is huge. But how do you get over that hump? If you were talking to a CEO right now saying, "I love what you're doing, Ali, I think it's great, but I just don't trust it. I don't think that's the best thing for the client or I don't think it does as good of a job as human..." so on and so forth. How do you get over that skepticism? Ali Fakih: When we do demo for our product, there is some people that loves the product, but they never make it into even use it, try it, right? Even for free to try it yet. Right. So what we discover is the more exposure we do, the more demo we do, the more presentation we do. It could be, you know, like they're looking at the property. I would choose them and note about it. Right. And then the more we align with what the research is and our answer align with what they're doing on a daily basis. This is building trust. You know, like, "Okay, I could see how this helped me." And this is what we're focusing on right now, how we can get them to try it. It has to have value for them, right? Because as we mentioned earlier, everyone is overwhelmed. Everyone has tons of stuff going on and sometimes, and they're all bombarded with tons of AI things. I mean, if we, I don't know how many emails you receive daily about a new AI tool, right? So for them to focus on one is really tough too. Gregory Hart: Yeah. You bet and in the past and decades to come, finding talent, especially in the engineering side, continues to be the huge challenge. So the more you can leverage some of these tools, right, to free up resources and free up bandwidth, seems like a no-brainer. You must see some pretty interesting reactions when you take folks through this and kind of calm some of these trust, skepticism issues, things like that that are going in kinda looking for the fault. It must be kinda gratifying when they see the output and see what it can do, right? And see that that real power here. Ali Fakih: For sure. For sure. I have people who use our tools sometimes ask me questions about something and I will just go into my account and I will send them the answer from the tool. Like just literally take me 30 seconds and Gregory Hart: Yeah. Ali Fakih: copy and paste it, Send it in "Hey, by the way, this what you could do." And this is like a base from the chat because they have access to it. And we see so much fun when they get quick answer. And especially when it come into them making like from different ICP, different excitement. Like developer, when I presented to developers, they want to know "How does this affect help us in this competitive market to tie a property earlier and finish entitlement earlier? Okay. What's the dollar value to it? How can we find a property that we could do what we want to do on it? How can you help us to find this property? Right. And this is our criteria." And by us start helping them with this and them seeing the filter, it's been a huge win for them. Right. A lot of the brokers, like we have CBRE, some people here local, Phoenix, what they love about early on, they came across the property. They don't need to have a call to land use attorney, to architect engineer, sometimes asking favor, sometimes paying for it. They will just want to know what could be done here. What's the height restriction? What type of use could be here so they can know who to send this property to and start going after it. Architect designer different, right? they're looking into the code section. I have one of our architect user love searching the building code early on because we have the ICC collaboration. It's like want to ask question about the whole building code or ask question about the whole ordinance, right? One thing they told me is like, we will be with a client on a phone call that potential client, it's not, we're just talking about potential properties are working on and we go and put the address. And while we're talking in this 30 seconds, we're able to pull in zoning information. What's his parking requirement? Is he able to do what he needs to do? Average, you know, like entitlement process. And he said, just source information within 30 seconds, position us to be knowing the city so well and knowing the project so well that 90% of the time we're closing the deal just based on this little information. So it's all every persona and every ACP completely different excitement how they could use it and how they can tag into it. Gregory Hart: And it's amazing to me how much it'll continue when we look twelve, twenty-four, thirty-six months out, how it's gonna continue to evolve very quickly. What's your take on what firm leaders should be doing to prepare the next generation to be living in a world like this where the whole value prop of the industry is getting turned upside down? Ali Fakih: It's, it's, they have to embrace it, embrace it Gregory Hart: Yeah. Ali Fakih: all the way from the top, all the way to the young engineer. The young engineers have been using it in their college for their preparation and examination and figuring out how to study. They study through AI today. I know that for a fact. I've seen it. I mean, we mentor some engineers. We've seen it. They study through AI. So for them to start a company and the leader doesn't embrace AI or the being in a skepticism about it, it's a challenge. Right. Our job is to help them figuring out how to use it in a way where it's useful for them. Like I get, I give you an example. We onboard some planner, part of our onboarding process is to, you know, like onboard them on our tools as well. One of them is ChatAEC early on. Right. So when it come in out of school, they spent so many time looking at website and finding information. How much is added value is this to them down line in their career? I, never heard anyone. "I'm so glad I did all of these research for website," because it changed every day. And what happened today, it changed, could change six months from now. So to have this early on, it elevated their game where they're getting the information and now they're working with the architect on the site plan based on the requirement and they're understanding the whole workflow. But it all goes in from leadership. I tell everyone, I encourage everyone dealing with me to using AI. I don't care if they get email from AI as long as they're prompting it correctly and they understand what it is and how to put it together. We have to all embrace it. It's a matter of time. My daughter is 10 years old. She did the business plan and flyers for school through ChatGPT. It took her 10 minutes to put a business plan and create a marketing flyer, printed 20 of them, took it to school. Yeah. I mean, this This is happening. This is happening all around us, right? So we cannot deny it. Gregory Hart: No, we can't. And by the time she enters the workforce or your son, it it's gonna be next level for sure. We'll put a link to AIAEC in the show notes, as well as SEG. But tell me a little bit about kind of what's coming next with AIAEC, what's in the future, new products, what's going on? Ali Fakih: So, ChatAEC will be going in nationwide soon here. So, plan before the end of the year, we'll be nationwide, or probably way before the end of the year. QPoint currently, which is the plan review, is getting piloted. We're going through a pilot for three months. Town of Gilbert is using our chat tool, ChatAEC today, for the park and recreation, for different departments, just economic development to get quick answer. We're getting so much amazing, good feedback from municipal. And when I started Greg, by the way, municipal wasn't the ICP I'm going after. That was more, I was focused more on the private because this is where our majority of our relationship and going after. So municipal is doing really well, showing a lot of interest and we're going in by end of the month. We're going to have an application will be released for ChatAEC. So it's not just a web app. And on QPoint, we'll be releasing our developer facing platform where now any developer. could come into us, have a site plan or have a preliminary package or even have a submittal that go into the city. They could use our tool, we'll pull all the information they need, we'll review their plan and we'll give them a report on what they should be fixed before they submit to the city. And this will be coming here by end of the month. So it's really exciting. QPoint only Gregory Hart: Awesome. Ali Fakih: been live for 10 days, by the way. The other one, couple of months, but all of this happening Gregory Hart: Yeah. Ali Fakih: so quick. It's amazing. Gregory Hart: That's awesome. Yeah, it seems like you're keeping pretty busy and it's going well. So that's good to hear. Well, Ali, thanks so much for joining me here. This has been fantastic. We'll have to have you on again. We could probably go so much deeper on the the business model implications in particular of AI, because you were in a unique perspective of you're on the AI side and the engineering firm side. So you see both. Thanks so much, Ali. Take care. Ali Fakih: Thanks, thank you, thank you very much! Gregory Hart: Okay, that brings us to the end of this episode of the AEC GrowthCast. Hope you enjoyed it. If you liked what you heard, go out and implement some of these ideas in your own firm. But first, be sure to like and subscribe to the AEC GrowthCast wherever you get your podcasts. If you have any questions, comments, ideas, things that you want to share with us for a future episode, aecgrowthcast@psmj.com. We'd love to hear from you. Thanks for joining us.