Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Film Financing: What's Hot and What's Not
Transcript
- 0:00Good afternoon to everybody.
- 0:07This is a film financing seminar.
- 0:10I'm Skylin Moore and I am honored to be here today and to give this for you.
- 0:17So let's start.
- 0:18I want to talk about what I'd like to do first is talk about the big picture issues for film
- 0:23financing, kind of the fundamental trends that affect where things are going and where
- 0:29and the industry in general.
- 0:31And the first most important lesson that I give to everybody or tell everybody is most
- 0:36films lose money.
- 0:39And that is a absolute fundamental threshold issue that everybody needs to understand.
- 0:44This industry is a losing business.
- 0:47It has been for many, many years.
- 0:49Most films lose money.
- 0:51And it's all about the law of supply and demand.
- 0:54There's just way too much money chasing this industry.
- 0:57Way too many films that are made.
- 1:01Many of them don't get a decent release at all.
- 1:03Many of them end up being sold for a pittance.
- 1:07And it's really the law of supply and demand.
- 1:09It's because the production, there's always way over funding of production and less of
- 1:20distribution because production is sexy and fun and distribution is not.
- 1:24And so whoever controls distribution controls the keys to the kingdom.
- 1:31So distribution is king.
- 1:33Content is not king.
- 1:36So then the question is film.
- 1:39What that leads to is the absolute desperate need for financing at all times.
- 1:43That is why this industry, like you're always chasing the next wave of financing.
- 1:49Or it's because whoever the last wave just got burned and had to run for the exits.
- 1:54And I have seen this over and over and over.
- 1:57I've been doing this for 40 years.
- 2:00And I've seen the US public market in the 80s.
- 2:03Then there was the foreign banks.
- 2:04And then there was Japan.
- 2:06Then there was Germany.
- 2:07Then there was India.
- 2:08Then there was China.
- 2:09And then there was insurance back financing.
- 2:11Then there was Wall Street with their brilliant Monte Carlo projections.
- 2:14All of them got burned.
- 2:15All of them ran for the exits.
- 2:17They've lost billions and billions and billions of dollars.
- 2:20And so we're always on the hunt for the next wave of financing.
- 2:26And the good news is there's always a next wave of financing, always.
- 2:30And that's the good news is because it's such a sexy industry and people love coming and
- 2:36it's like flies to light.
- 2:40And so that's the good news.
- 2:42It's wave after wave after wave.
- 2:44It'll never end.
- 2:47But when we talk about raising financing, we'll talk about the incentives.
- 2:51That's really important to understand what the incentives are, why people invest, and
- 2:55therefore how do you pitch it?
- 2:59Another kind of a fundamental shift of this, which to me is fascinating having gone through
- 3:05this, is it used to be the studios were king because studios control distribution.
- 3:10And so producers used to be on their knees to the studios and the studios had a rather
- 3:20bizarre perception of fairness.
- 3:22It's just that the affair was completely utterly totally in their direction to even ask for
- 3:27anything off of what they asked for was ridiculous because they were king, because they control
- 3:32distribution and therefore producers were weak.
- 3:37And this happened because of streaming is that many of the studios have now turned into
- 3:42production companies for the streamers.
- 3:44And the streamers now control distribution and the studios are now on their knees.
- 3:49And that's why they're consolidating and desperate.
- 3:56They are the ones now who are on their knees to the streamers.
- 3:58And so if they don't control streaming, which they really don't, other than Disney, then
- 4:05they really, really are in trouble because they're in the position of all that the producers
- 4:10used to be begging to begging to the studios.
- 4:14Another big shift is off course, been the complete 50% collapse in theatrical revenues
- 4:20over the last 10 years.
- 4:23That's been a dramatic shift from theatrical films to streaming.
- 4:28So when you're looking for financing now on your first stop now as the streamers used
- 4:34to be, of course, the studios, so that's completely changed.
- 4:39And another kind of a fundamental shift that has happened is that the streaming wars more
- 4:47or less are over.
- 4:49That is, there used to be complete brazenness from the streamers for the last several years,
- 4:54competing against each other for this of the prices when kind of bizarre, you know, off
- 4:58the roof for the last four years.
- 5:01And that really is over now.
- 5:04The competition has cooled down and the streamers are now like trying to, instead of trying
- 5:09to get product is now trying to actually make a buck.
- 5:12And that has changed the dynamics significantly in terms of what they're looking for, how
- 5:19much they'll pay.
- 5:21And we've now come kind of like full circle, which I'll talk about later about Netflix
- 5:25now trying to go to a back end model.
- 5:31And so just as we talk through the financing, you'll see that these themes keep popping
- 5:38up.
- 5:39You know, hopefully you'll see what's happening.
- 5:42The first thing I want to talk about is for film financing is equity.
- 5:48Somebody who puts in risk money, not alone, they're taking a share of profits, they're
- 5:56investing early or they're investing during production.
- 5:59That is the most hard, that is often the hardest money to find.
- 6:03But it really separates the winners from the losers.
- 6:06If you can get equity, you are 100 miles ahead of everybody that doesn't have it.
- 6:12Because otherwise, with equity, you can do development, you can do pre-production, you
- 6:18can get all the way through the magic day of commencement of principal photography.
- 6:23And even beyond that, of course, if you've got equity to go.
- 6:25Whereas, if you don't have equity, you really are stymied.
- 6:29You can't pay or play an actor, you can't put up the deposit with the agents in escrow
- 6:34which they want.
- 6:35You can't pay for pre-production because even if you pre-sell a film, you don't have money
- 6:41for pre-production.
- 6:42So you need equity.
- 6:43Where do you go?
- 6:44How do you get equity?
- 6:48My experience is it's just contacts, contacts, contacts.
- 6:53Playing with friends and family, who do you know?
- 6:56Who do they know?
- 6:57Who does everybody...
- 6:58And then just work in your way up, work in your way up, calling people, asking for further
- 7:02introductions.
- 7:03I had one client that clawed his way up and ended up with Qaddafi.
- 7:13Actually right before that great fall, he actually got like $10 million from Qaddafi
- 7:19and then we were about to get on an airplane to go get $80 million and then Qaddafi got
- 7:25kibushed.
- 7:26So how did he do it?
- 7:28I have no idea but he was calling people and he was just the terminator.
- 7:33You just wouldn't stop and that's how...
- 7:36Every time the clients show up with money, it's because they just keep going.
- 7:41Now, other sources, advertisers, advertisers, I'll talk about that later but they're a great
- 7:47source of equity if they can get behind a project where they can integrate their product
- 7:53into it.
- 7:54That's been great.
- 7:57Finders, there are people that can make introductions and they often want to fee and the...
- 8:10Oftentimes people say, oh, I want to go to a...
- 8:12I want to use an investment banking house.
- 8:14Investment banking house will never do it.
- 8:15No investment banker will actually look for financing because life is too short.
- 8:19They just won't bother.
- 8:21There are finders that will do it for a fee and that some of them do have connection and
- 8:29what you have to look out for is the SEC position is that...
- 8:32Their position is that you can't use finders for a fee period.
- 8:36That if a finder is paid, they have to be a registered investment broker and they never
- 8:41are and therefore you can't do it.
- 8:43The case law, however, is more lenient and says as long as the finder just introduces
- 8:50an investor and doesn't pitch the project, then it's okay.
- 8:55So that a finder can say, John, meet Sam and I'll let you guys talk as opposed to John
- 9:02meets Sam and, oh, look, Sam has this wonderful film project and John, you should invest in
- 9:07this film project.
- 9:09Even under the case law, you can't do.
- 9:13People do use finders, but don't pay anybody up front.
- 9:18I'm going to talk about schemers and dreamers later, but just when you do, if you do use
- 9:22a finder, don't pay them up front.
- 9:25There's too many of those that are just, that are frauds and the way you do it, I'll talk
- 9:32later about you, you just pay them more later when they show up with money.
- 9:36There are crowdfunding sites as well that can, that purport to be able to raise equity.
- 9:42One warning I would say to them is don't pay anything up front to the crowdfunding.
- 9:46If they're looking for money up front, don't do it.
- 9:49It should only get paid on success.
- 9:52And if they do do it, you've got to make sure that they're only going to accredited investors
- 9:58due to the securities laws.
- 9:59And we'll talk about that.
- 10:01I'm going to talk to John the securities laws in a bit.
- 10:06What are, when you're looking for investors and again, who investors could be, they can
- 10:14be like family offices.
- 10:16They can be rich people.
- 10:18They can be, there are some venture capital funds every now and then that invest in, you
- 10:25know, so they're, however you end up with it, what are the incentives?
- 10:30The last thing you want to pitch is the wonderful economics of the industry because it sucks.
- 10:36And, and if they're smart, if they look, they'll know that the industry loses money and they'll,
- 10:41then so they always want the fantasy, of course, that they'll, they'll make money.
- 10:45That's wonderful.
- 10:46But that's kind of the gravy at the end.
- 10:47What you want to pitch is number one and most important credits.
- 10:52They love credits.
- 10:54I mean, they just, I sometimes I feel like I'm just brokering credits on a film.
- 10:58I feel like a big, for a main, for a big picture, I can sell a main title EP credit for $5 million.
- 11:04I'm, I'm like seriously, that's what I, in some tarot of you're going to get co-production
- 11:09credit, it's $3 million or something.
- 11:12So they love credits.
- 11:13EP and the higher, you know, executive producer, co-producer, associate producer, if you have
- 11:21to go to the end credits, fine, then you go to the end credits, but boy do they love credits.
- 11:26They love to be able to visit the set.
- 11:28They absolutely adore being able to go to the set.
- 11:31They love going to the premiere.
- 11:33They love going to the after parties.
- 11:34So you pitch the sexiness of the industry.
- 11:37Oh, look, you're going to go get to go to the set and you're going to go get to go to
- 11:41the party and bizarrely that actually sells.
- 11:44And then, oh, maybe we'll make some money.
- 11:47Hopefully.
- 11:48Haha.
- 11:49And, you know, but, but what you don't do, I never do, is boring projections.
- 11:56I never would lead with like boring projections because nobody reads them.
- 12:01No one understands them.
- 12:02No one cares.
- 12:03That's not why they're investing in the industry.
- 12:06And the projections, by the way, are always wrong.
- 12:08And the problem with like when I do a private placement offering to the industry, to investors,
- 12:15I never, ever include projections.
- 12:18Even like a summary projection, we think we'll make expires.
- 12:21I don't even, and the reason why is because if you do that, you're going to end up with
- 12:25me on the stand representing a plaintiff, you know, as the expert witness for a plaintiff
- 12:30saying, what are you doing projecting profits in an industry where the average loses money?
- 12:35Like if you were doing honest projections, it would run at a loss.
- 12:38So that's, you know, one reason not to do that because you have to disclose true facts,
- 12:44not made up facts.
- 12:46Let's talk about the structure of the, of the investments.
- 12:52What drives me absolutely crazy in this industry is that the absolute vast majority of these
- 12:57deals is done as investment contracts.
- 13:00It's done as basically an unsecured contractual obligation to pay some share of net profits.
- 13:06And I don't know why this is, I don't know why this is so prevalent in this industry.
- 13:10It's a no other industry.
- 13:12No one else does this.
- 13:14It's always done as a membership interest in an LLC every now and then stock in a corporation.
- 13:20But an equity investment should be represented by an equity instrument.
- 13:24And an equity instrument is either a partnership interest, membership interest in an LLC, stock
- 13:29in a corporation.
- 13:32And that's, it's very important for a number of reasons.
- 13:35One is so that you know what the rules are because there's a whole set of default rules
- 13:39as to what the rules are for, you know, membership interest in an LLC by law, whereas there's
- 13:48very little guidance on what these unsecured contractual obligations are for example, just
- 13:52to pick one easy example.
- 13:55The IRS says that if you use an investment contract that the producer that gets the money
- 14:00is taxable on receive because it's not an equity investment for tax purposes.
- 14:06And so you, and there's a case that holds, there's cases that have held the same thing,
- 14:11that because if you structure it as a contract, the producer that receives the money is deemed
- 14:16to have sold future profits and that's taxable.
- 14:19Whereas had you done it as an LLC, it wouldn't be taxable.
- 14:22And then similarly the investor in an LLC clearly gets to deduct, if there's a loss
- 14:28or if there's a, if there's deductible expenses, they get to deduct it.
- 14:33Whereas under a contract, they don't get to deduct it because they're not an owner of
- 14:37the LLC, they're not an owner of the film.
- 14:40It's not clear what happens with their investment.
- 14:44It might be that they have to, they don't get any deduction at all until the end and
- 14:48then it could be a capital loss.
- 14:49So, you know, so again, for, and I would make the same, I can make arguments on the state
- 14:55law, what's, what are the, what are the ambiguities?
- 14:58It's just don't do the, I don't, don't do these as contracts.
- 15:02Like what is wrong with people that they can't, you know, do an LLC and a membership?
- 15:05It's so easy.
- 15:06But it's this industry, anyway, this aspect that drives me crazy.
- 15:11Next, every time that you are raising equity, whether it's from your mom or who you're
- 15:19an investment bank or from whoever you're getting it from, you are issuing a securities.
- 15:25And you have to be aware, you'll be cognizant of the securities laws and you have to make
- 15:30sure that you comply with them.
- 15:32And it's, and in particular, you have to find what's, what's an exemption from registration
- 15:38because basically the way the securities laws work is that you either, you either have to
- 15:42register it or you have to have an exemption and registration is impossible.
- 15:47So you have to qualify for an exemption.
- 15:49And the only exemption that we permit that I permit is 506, which allows any number of
- 15:58what are called accredited investors.
- 16:00And accredited investors basically is people that have more than a million dollars of net
- 16:05worth excluding their home.
- 16:07And you can, and as long as they meet that test, there's other tests you can meet too.
- 16:11But like more than 300,000 of annual income, that's another test that they could meet.
- 16:17But as long as they're an accredited investor, you're an, and everybody, not, not just, you
- 16:23know, most everybody's accredited, then you can, you're, you're good to go.
- 16:27You can avoid registration.
- 16:29You have to file a form D with the SEC.
- 16:32It's relatively easy.
- 16:35And, and indeed, if everybody's accredited, you can even advertise your offering when
- 16:41I'm, and I, for some reason people aren't doing that, but you can, you can advertise
- 16:47the offering as long as you prove that the investors are actually accredited by getting
- 16:50a letter from their lawyer or from their accountant.
- 16:54And so that now you've dealt with the registration aspect of it.
- 16:57And the other aspect is full disclosure.
- 16:59You have to, you have to disclose, you should disclose the material facts is the, is basically
- 17:05the way the laws could, or you, you can't, the Supreme Court just literally last month
- 17:11issued an opinion that said you would date the way they interpret that is you can't,
- 17:17you just can't say falsehoods and you can't say half truths, but the better practice is
- 17:22just to disclose all material facts.
- 17:25And the way you do that is a private placement memorandum, a PPM, and it can be really short.
- 17:30It can be like it should have the, what I do is the, it's the biographies of every of
- 17:36the, of whoever's involved, you know, the producers with and whatever.
- 17:41And if you've got talent, really attached, then you would tell it say that, but not,
- 17:45not fake talent, not people that are like, you hope are attached.
- 17:49And then the budget, what the anticipated budget, and then the treatment or the full
- 17:55script and the risks and the risks are that most films lose money, you know, and you've
- 18:01put that in all bold capital letters and you just, and, and we don't have, and often I
- 18:07just, you know, we don't have distribution, we don't have a completion guarantee, you
- 18:12know, but you're going to get credits and you're going to go to the party and you're
- 18:16going to have all the fun stuff.
- 18:17So we can, you can put that in there.
- 18:20But it's, you know, sometimes it's minor only like 15 pages and then that you don't
- 18:25need this massive like tax discussion.
- 18:27My tax discussion is this is not a tax shelter.
- 18:30You can't deduct anything.
- 18:32You know, I make it as bad as I can because they don't, no one really cares.
- 18:37That's not why they're investing.
- 18:38Or I'll just, you know, say, look, you, if there's a loss, you get to deduct it subject
- 18:43to the passive loss rules or something very basic.
- 18:46But I, and then I get sometimes I get these hundred page from other people, these hundred
- 18:50page PPMs are just ridiculous.
- 18:52Like no one's going to read it and they don't need to do that.
- 18:54There's no need for that.
- 18:55It can be very simple.
- 18:58So, so then you're good.
- 18:59Then you've done, as long as you've avoided registration, you filed the form D, you've
- 19:02got your full disclosure, you've at least complied with the securities laws.
- 19:07You know, otherwise it's very, if you don't comply with the securities laws, it's bad
- 19:12news.
- 19:13I had, you have two things that happened.
- 19:15One is the promoters, which is pretty broad, are personally liable for any loss of the
- 19:21investors.
- 19:22And oh, by the way, most films lose money.
- 19:24So you don't want to be personally liable for the loss to the investors.
- 19:28And then the worst case is jail.
- 19:30And I did have a client that sent me a, did some offering that I didn't handle that
- 19:36and got, literally got them subpoenaed for a criminal indictment.
- 19:40And so you don't want to go there because that's not a happy day.
- 19:46So equity, equity, equity, and that'll again separate the winners from the losers.
- 19:49Now you have, sometimes you're just raising development costs.
- 19:52Sometimes it's pre-production.
- 19:54Sometimes it's the full blown production.
- 19:55Like we're shooting for the fences here.
- 19:57Like just, we know we're not going to pre-sell this film.
- 20:00We're going to do it completely.
- 20:03And we're going to go then chase the film festival.
- 20:07That's an absolute, some people do that.
- 20:09So equity can go all the way from beginning to end.
- 20:13But at any step, all these things that I just said apply to it no matter what you're raising.
- 20:17All right, next, let's talk about doing a sale.
- 20:21You want to go sell your film.
- 20:23Streamer, streamer, streamer.
- 20:24All the sales these days is to the streamers.
- 20:28That's been my experience in the last 10, maybe eight years is just everything is sending
- 20:33soul to the streamers.
- 20:35And they've turned the world upside down.
- 20:37Of course, it's no longer going to the studio.
- 20:42They up until, and as of now, they've been, they want to do a fixed price deal.
- 20:50And the deal is usually cost of the film plus buyout or what they call it buyout or premium.
- 20:58That buyout premium has ranged all the way from something between 10% to 50% and of the
- 21:06budget of the film.
- 21:07And then of course, the question is what can you shove into the budget of the film?
- 21:11Because of course, you want to make it as high as possible so people get pretty creative
- 21:16in what kind of fees that they can shove into the budget too.
- 21:20So that the premium is higher.
- 21:21The premium has come down a lot recently because of the lack of competition.
- 21:26It's recently been like down to 10%.
- 21:32And what's happening is that the streamers now are interestingly trying to get off of
- 21:39paying those huge high amounts.
- 21:41And now very recently, you can see Netflix is trying to go to a back end model where
- 21:45they're pitching that they can, they'll give a back end and of course in exchange for a
- 21:49lower upfront.
- 21:53Upfront fee.
- 21:55So the buyout may be flat, maybe there's no buyout, but it's back end.
- 22:02But having witnessed at least a couple of the first ones that came up to bat, I can
- 22:08tell you what's happening on the ground, which is everybody is saying, oh, I love the back
- 22:12end.
- 22:13Oh, but I still want my premium.
- 22:14And so it's very hard for people to get off the concept of that they are expecting to get
- 22:23a significant premium on the buyout.
- 22:26And I do not think people are willing to come down off that in exchange for a back end at
- 22:31this point.
- 22:32They, without question view, the back end is in addition to the premium.
- 22:37So the streamers do have a battle ahead of them to change perception in the industry
- 22:43to try to get people to take less upfront because I will tell you my clients having just gone
- 22:47through this said loudly and clearly, no, we're not reducing the buyout, but oh, bye,
- 22:52we like this back end.
- 22:55So that's going to, that'll be fun.
- 22:58The streamers will do one of two models.
- 23:00They'll either pay during production, in which case they're all, you know, they're all over
- 23:06it to, and they can really effectively control it.
- 23:10And that's called the cash flow, you know, cash flow, I would call that a cash flow presale.
- 23:15Or they pay on delivery and then they expect you to go get a bank loan and you get it,
- 23:23and then you're back to the normal.
- 23:25You get a completion, you'll need a completion guarantee, you'll need a bank loan.
- 23:30You know, the student will pay on delivery and life is beautiful.
- 23:34It's just more complex, more expensive, of course, because you have to, you know, deal
- 23:38with the banks and all their fees and interest and all that.
- 23:41But so there's two different models of streamers will do.
- 23:47And but my general comment is that's your first port of call.
- 23:51I have in the just most, most of my films have gone that way.
- 23:57Even when they go to the festival circuit, they get picked up by the streamers.
- 24:01And I, you know, so that's just like 80% of what I've done literally for the last, you
- 24:09know, several years.
- 24:10Now, let's go to the old, the good old and less, less popular pre-sales, the normal,
- 24:19the old route where you would go to the Toyota can, which like just happened, and you pre-sale
- 24:25your film, you package it up, you get your actors to, you do as you attach, hopefully
- 24:32actually, but often in fantasy land, actor, director, you know, the talent and you have
- 24:40a script that you own, hopefully.
- 24:44And you go to the market and you sell that pre-sell it to the foreign distributors and
- 24:48somebody from Germany will buy it for X% of the budget and from Japan will buy it for
- 24:52Y% of the budget and you take all of those contracts and you wander back to somebody
- 25:02in the United States, a studio, and to try to find an anchor, you typically want to do
- 25:09a pre-sale, you want somebody to anchor it in the US, typically a studio, can be a streamer
- 25:15as well, but you know, if you're just selling US.
- 25:20And then you take all your contracts and you wander down to the bank and you say, dear bank
- 25:24loan, please give me a loan.
- 25:26And the bank says, wonderful, but we need a completion guarantee, so you go to the completion
- 25:30guarantee, they vet the budget, and then you go through a lot of paperwork and shenanigans
- 25:37and in the perfect world.
- 25:39On commencement of principal photography, someone shows up with a completion guarantee
- 25:42and a loan backed by all these contracts and you're able to make your film.
- 25:47What that is, how do you get to that magic day of commencement of principal photography?
- 25:57Because you, that, this massive amount of cost before then, and this is why you need
- 26:02equity and this is why winners, you know, this is what separates the winners from the
- 26:06losers.
- 26:07The loans rarely cover, they rarely cover pre-production and if you can't get equity, the next, your
- 26:14only hope is bridge lending and there are lenders that do bridge loans that prior to
- 26:22commencement, the boy, are they expensive.
- 26:25They're hard to get and they're, you know, because they're taking the risk that the film
- 26:31will get made, but they are out there, they're very expensive and you may not get it.
- 26:38So you can't bank on being able to get one of these, you know, bridge loans.
- 26:43And if there is a bridge loan there, they are clearly taking a risk because sometimes
- 26:46many films don't get to the finish line or even the start, they don't get to the start
- 26:52line, but just commencement of principal photography.
- 26:58Sometimes you don't have enough contracts to cover the whole budget, that's actually
- 27:03pretty common.
- 27:04And in that case, you need a gap loan and a gap loan is what it sounds like.
- 27:10It's the gap between really reality and fantasy, fantasy being sales of the full film and reality
- 27:19being the sales you've made.
- 27:21And so many, so for example, you might have pre-sold 50% of the budget, but you, and you're
- 27:28hoping to do sales later on for the other 50%.
- 27:31So some sales agent stands up and says, I think I can sell it for the rest of the 50%
- 27:36and a gap lender will loan on that and that's called a gap loan.
- 27:39They're more expensive than the regular loans gap that are backed by distribution contracts.
- 27:49But and many bank lenders will include a gap portion in their thing if they really think
- 27:55that it'll, that you're there, that you can cover it.
- 27:59So that's the, and that's been by the pre-sales in my world was the way we went for, for last,
- 28:06we did it for 30 years, that's how it worked.
- 28:08And then in the last 10 years, it just, it's become a trickle because of the sale to the
- 28:14streamers.
- 28:15I have seen a few in recently that I've done because can seem to be back again this year
- 28:22for the first time in several years.
- 28:24And there were actually pre-sales being made at can.
- 28:29And so it's, it may, you know, this may be back.
- 28:33Another thing that is back, which is interesting is that is that I'm doing right now is another
- 28:40way to raise financing for a film is to go to various foreign distributors and say, put
- 28:48not just, don't just pre-buy your territory, but in addition, put in equity for the film
- 28:55and all of you combine like a part, you become partners and effectively a partnership to
- 29:01make this film and putting in additional capital as equity in the film.
- 29:06And the reason why the foreign distributors are willing to do that is because they want
- 29:12big budget films and they want to get them away from the studios and the streamers.
- 29:17And the only way they can do that is by putting up more money.
- 29:20And second, they spread their risk now, it's not just their home territory, their risk
- 29:25is spread over worldwide because they get a worldwide share of profits.
- 29:29And so I used to do these a lot between maybe 20 to 10 years ago, really popular.
- 29:40And it was the whole number of what I called co-productions, consortiums, you can go by
- 29:46any different, you know, all different names, usually some kind of like co-production and
- 29:50it's back.
- 29:51And so I've now, we've now got a couple going on where distributors, foreign distributors
- 29:56are going to put in equity in order to, and it used to be to get the films away from the
- 30:00studios, it's now to get the films away from the streamers.
- 30:03And so that's, that is a possible way to do financing.
- 30:08They're rather tricky though, I will tell you that because the tax implications of a
- 30:14partnership among a number of foreign distributors, it can't get pre-Harry.
- 30:20But it's doable, it is doable.
- 30:26What else?
- 30:27Next, let's talk about local production subsidies.
- 30:33There are, so local production, this is a huge, huge source of financing.
- 30:43There is state and, first of all, in the various states in the United States, many of the states
- 30:54encouraged local production by giving subsidies based on either the total budget, a percentage
- 31:01of the total budget if you shoot there, or a percentage of the local spend.
- 31:06And so you have to look carefully and when you hear a percentage like Georgia's X percent
- 31:12and Louisiana's Y percent, you can't just look at that, you have to say X and Y of what?
- 31:17Is it of the total budget or is it of the local spend?
- 31:20Because that's a very different result.
- 31:24And foreign countries have a similar subsidies too for local production.
- 31:33Various foreign countries have, from Canada, Australia, Germany, in Europe there's things
- 31:39called European co-productions where they, where it's very similar.
- 31:44And they come, they usually come in one of two flavors, they typically come as, they
- 31:53give you, they're either assignable or they're not assignable.
- 31:59And if they're assignable, what you do is you get the, you get credits that you then
- 32:02go and sell somewhere else and somebody pays you for the credits and they go get a reduction
- 32:07of their own taxes.
- 32:09Or they're not assignable and you have to offset it against your own taxes, which is like Calif,
- 32:14California has a system that is based, other than a very limited subset, California's is
- 32:20not assignable and so it's fantastic for the studios because they do pay taxes and they,
- 32:26they can use it as a, as a credit against their own taxes.
- 32:30But California's credit system is really not viable for the independence.
- 32:36It's got a very, a limited amount that they give per year and it's other, and only those
- 32:46are assignable, the other ones, the other ones are not.
- 32:49So California really, in mice, I've not had a successful independent film made in California
- 32:54using their credits.
- 32:59If I can just berate for a bit on this whole concept of these local subsidies for the states,
- 33:05it drives, it's just, it is the, it is the, without question, the dumbest policy judgment
- 33:11of all time for states to be giving subsidies for local production.
- 33:15It is beyond stupid because the, the, the theory, what they do is they, they, they always
- 33:20get some accounting from them to say, oh, look at the multiplier effect because if we
- 33:24do, if you give, you know, $100 to these carpet, you know, to these, for a film production
- 33:31in Georgia, they'll spend it and they'll re-spend it and somebody will re-spend it.
- 33:35And if you spend it 10 times, you end up with a lot of money.
- 33:39And it's just absurd.
- 33:40The production companies are, they're carpet baggers, they take the money and they go back
- 33:44to Los Angeles.
- 33:45They don't spend it in Georgia.
- 33:47And what you're doing is you're taking money out of the local taxpayers' pockets who would
- 33:51be spending in the local area and they would be recycling.
- 33:55And so, but you're taking it out of there and giving it to, to, you know, truly to carpet
- 33:59baggers that leave.
- 34:01And the dumbest part about it is like you're subsidizing film production.
- 34:05Like I'm sorry, but film production, like really when, when you've got homeless and,
- 34:11and you've got, you know, when you could get education and health and hospitals and government
- 34:16service anything, but like film, like what is so wonderful about film production anyway?
- 34:21I digress, but that, I just think it's absurd.
- 34:26This on the foreign side, Canada has a fantastic, it's also cheaper, way cheaper production.
- 34:34And, and, and they have, and they have subsidies.
- 34:38I have a client that's very successful making, making films just nonstop in, in, like, May
- 34:44for television films in Canada store and at half the cost of the U.S. when you combine
- 34:51the subsidies and the savings.
- 34:54In Europe, you've got a quota system that, that is effectively increases the prices for
- 35:02films that are made in, excuse me, in the EU countries.
- 35:08And if you hit, if you, if you, in particular, if you can do a co-production where you hit
- 35:13in a couple of countries, you can vastly increase the amount that they will sell for, which
- 35:17is effectively a subsidy.
- 35:19So the, the subsidy works by, by require, by a quota system that requires distributors
- 35:24to, to acquire local content.
- 35:27And that means the prices go up and that effectively becomes, becomes a subsidy.
- 35:31They also have direct subsidies where they, where they, you know, give financing for a,
- 35:38you know, cash, cash for local production.
- 35:41Next, next source of financing these days.
- 35:46Barbie from advertisers, that's like for me, one of the first places to think about.
- 35:52If you look at the Barbie film in particular, let's just, you know, think about that from
- 35:58an advertiser's perspective, what a home run.
- 36:01You're, you've got, you get money, forget, you know, you've, your toy sales go crazy,
- 36:07your, your, your, you get, you also have the opportunity for profits from the film.
- 36:11You've got Lego that was wildly successful, Transformers.
- 36:15I mean, it's, you've got incredible opportunities for average.
- 36:18So I have had, no, usually advertisers contribute the rights, excuse me, whatever the property
- 36:27is, they don't typically put in money, but they, but some did.
- 36:30I, I had in a film called a trilogy called goal, which is a soccer film, soccer trilogy
- 36:36and, and Adidas put in literally the entire budget for the three films and it got to $100
- 36:43million.
- 36:44It was a hard cash equity investment and it was just fantastic.
- 36:49So, so advert and, you know, we had, take goal, for example, we agreed that we would
- 36:54have a certain level of, you would see there, either the players they sponsored or their
- 36:59shoes or the, someone wearing their shirt or in the background of the soccer thing.
- 37:04So you can integrate the product or Barbie just make it the, you know, the movie is the
- 37:08Barbie.
- 37:10And so equity from advertisers, the, the, I've done it with, with a number, number,
- 37:17all different kinds of, you know, companies from, anyway, all different kinds.
- 37:24The one problem you have to look out for is that sometimes they want to turn the film
- 37:29into like one big advertisement and you have to save them from themselves and say, look,
- 37:34if you do that, no one's going to watch it.
- 37:36And that becomes a very real problem that it's often, when the, when the product isn't
- 37:42a, you know, isn't a bar, when it's, when you're trying to integrate a product, take
- 37:46anything like, you know, laundry soap and you, you obviously don't want it to turn
- 37:52into a laundry soap commercial, but they want laundry soap to appear somewhere in the commercial
- 37:57and they're willing to pay for it.
- 37:59And you just have to kind of walk them back from turning it into a big, big commercial.
- 38:04And I just, it's the one warning I would give to everybody.
- 38:10Next, more fun financing.
- 38:12Like, because I, as I hear it all the time, I hear it all the time, oh, section 181.
- 38:19Section 181 is not a great source of financing.
- 38:21No, it's not a great source of financing.
- 38:24It just doesn't work.
- 38:25It really doesn't.
- 38:27And what, here's the theory and then the reality.
- 38:29The theory is you get to deduct the first $15 million of the cost of making a film in the
- 38:37United States, including development cost and, and including production costs.
- 38:44Isn't that wonderful?
- 38:45But it's, but it's not a credit.
- 38:47The 15 million is a deduction against your taxes.
- 38:50Again, sorry, deduction against your income.
- 38:53It's not a credit.
- 38:54So you don't go and offset your taxes, dollar for dollar.
- 38:57It's, it's like, if you lose the money, just for starters, you've lost your money.
- 39:02So it's like giving $100 to charity.
- 39:05Maybe it's not as painful as it would otherwise be because you get a 50% deduction against
- 39:11your taxes.
- 39:12But you're, so you're still out 50 bucks.
- 39:14You know, if you, and if you do a hundred million, a hundred dollars on an 81 81 and
- 39:18you lose it.
- 39:19All right.
- 39:20So you've, you maybe get to deduct it, but you've still lost the 50.
- 39:25That's not, you know, so that's kind of one myth.
- 39:29Second, and the biggest problem is that it's a passive.
- 39:33It's what's called a passive loss, which is a, it's a, it's not for most individual investors,
- 39:40it's only deductible against passive income.
- 39:43And most people, passive income is not what you think.
- 39:45It's not dividends and interest.
- 39:47It's a very limited subset that basically is limited to, to income from real property.
- 39:54There's a couple of other small categories, but for most people, if they have it at all,
- 40:00it's from real property.
- 40:01Well, if you have real property, number one is real property is the biggest tax shelter
- 40:05of all.
- 40:06So usually they're, they have too many deductions.
- 40:08They don't have income.
- 40:10And second, if they're smart enough to be investing in real property, they're not dumb enough
- 40:15to invest in films.
- 40:17And so you narrow down significantly people who give a hoot about 181.
- 40:24And then, and then even, even if they've got, so now even if you, you found your investors
- 40:30with passive income, that can offset this, you know, the law of the deductions against
- 40:36their passive income.
- 40:38It's a, it's like no big deal because you get to deduct during production wonderful,
- 40:43but on the, on the, on release of the film in most cases, that's when the income comes
- 40:48back.
- 40:49And so yet most it is a one year deferral, an absolute most it's a one year deferral.
- 40:54And it's like big deal, like really, like a one year deferral is like so wonderful.
- 40:59You're not, no, you're not going to raise financing off that.
- 41:02No one's going to write home to their mother and say, oh my God, I got a, I got a one year
- 41:06deferral.
- 41:11With that said, there are two companies out there that are pitching 181 and they are absolutely
- 41:18committing outright fraud.
- 41:20All right.
- 41:21Just there's no question about it.
- 41:22Have you hear the 181, if you hear a leveraged 181 deal, I know who they are and that are
- 41:27doing it.
- 41:28And I can tell you without question, they're committing fraud.
- 41:32Now, what, if you're the producer and you're, and somebody's offering you 181 to giving
- 41:41you money from 181, the way to play it is don't ask any questions because you don't want
- 41:47to be aiding in a betting requires knowledge and assistance.
- 41:50So the last thing you want to do is start asking questions and you let them go commit
- 41:54their fraud and they will actually sometimes show up with real money and take the money.
- 41:59But the one thing, if you aren't going to take the money, make absolutely sure that
- 42:04the rights are coming back to you right then and there, that there's a loop, that the rights
- 42:09are coming back and let them go commit their fraud and you get the money and make sure that
- 42:14you get the rights back.
- 42:15Because the problem, the paperwork is really ugly and often doesn't connect the loop.
- 42:21And so you can end up, yeah, you've got some money, but you lose the rights and you don't
- 42:25want that to happen.
- 42:26So if you are going to, if you are going to take money from them, don't ask questions,
- 42:31make sure you get the rights back.
- 42:33If you're being asked to invest in them, forget about it, man.
- 42:36That's just, I mean, if you're, if somebody comes to you and says, oh, I can never 181
- 42:40and you're going to deduct four times your investment, one, because it's absolute nonsense.
- 42:45It's absolute fraud and they will get hammered and they, and prior ones that did this did
- 42:49get hammered.
- 42:50It's just, it's just a matter of time.
- 42:54I would say the exact same thing for section 168K and that is, that's what that says is
- 43:05you can deduct the full cost of the film with not a $15 million limit on, on when the film
- 43:11is released to the public, if it's made in the United States.
- 43:15So if you've got a film produced in the US and you release it and so every now and then
- 43:20all, instead of 181, I'll hear 160 AK and there's two problems with that.
- 43:26One is, one is it's being phased out.
- 43:28It's now, you can only deduct in 2024, only 60% of the cost of the film, not the, not
- 43:34the 100%, which it used to be a couple of years ago.
- 43:38And it's got the same problems as 181, which is it's a passive loss.
- 43:43And it's, and, and, and usually on the date of release, usually is the date you get income.
- 43:48So usually it, to wash.
- 43:50So you, because you've, if you've pre-sold it or you sold it to a studio or you delivered
- 43:54it to, you know, a student, to a streamer, they're paying you right, right up front.
- 44:00And or on delivery or on release particularly.
- 44:03And that, so you have a deduction in it offsets.
- 44:05It's the same as like 181.
- 44:06It's a one year deferral like at that.
- 44:08And if for what, for 168K, it's not even a one year.
- 44:11It's like a nothing deferral.
- 44:12So like, it was the same day.
- 44:14So forget about it.
- 44:16Next, ways I source of financing.
- 44:24Schemers and dreamers.
- 44:25I've just got to warn you about schemers and dreamers.
- 44:28You, they're, they're all over the place.
- 44:31And let's start with the dreamers, right?
- 44:34The dreamers are people that honesty God believe that they can raise bazillions of dollars from,
- 44:42from some, and that usually you'll hear like, oh, I've got in this and that and then I know
- 44:47somebody who knows somebody and, and we're going to leverage up something or other and
- 44:52we're going to sell cookies in Europe and raise gold bars and then we'll come back to
- 44:57you.
- 44:58It's like, and they really believe it.
- 45:00And so they're not asking for money up front and they waste your time and they, and boy,
- 45:06I have had clients that actually commits, commits principal photography relying on dreamers.
- 45:12And that is just a disaster, of course.
- 45:14I mean, you'll just you, because it'll fall.
- 45:16Yeah, they don't come through.
- 45:17You'll fall apart and you'll look like you've got mud on your face and you're the one taking
- 45:21the hit.
- 45:22So you got to vet these people.
- 45:24You've got to, you've got to, you've got to ask the tough questions and they will always
- 45:28tell you, oh, you're being so rude, Sky.
- 45:30How dare you ask for bank statements?
- 45:32Like how, you know, you don't trust us and you don't, whatever.
- 45:36You, our investors will be insulted if you ask them, whatever, or it's confidential.
- 45:41I, oh, I can't do that.
- 45:42It's private.
- 45:43It's confidential.
- 45:44Bologna, just press, press, press, get the, you know, what have you done?
- 45:50What have you closed?
- 45:51Where are your investors?
- 45:52Want, tell me to just do the normal due diligence that you wouldn't.
- 45:55Don't be put off by this nonsense of it's confidential and it's this and it's, you're
- 45:59insulting them.
- 46:00I'm glad to insult them because there's, and they're all over the place.
- 46:04Damn dreamers are just all, they're just like, they breed like rabbits, man.
- 46:08They're just so many of them.
- 46:11So anyway, all you have to do is do diligence, due diligence, due diligence.
- 46:15Then the next one, the schemers.
- 46:16Oh God, the schemers, man.
- 46:20They come by every imaginable flavor, every imaginable way, and it always, always boils
- 46:26down to you give them some money now and they're magically going to show up with a whole lot
- 46:31of money later on.
- 46:33It always boils down to that.
- 46:35And I've seen it as low as $400 and then up to several million.
- 46:40And they walk and talk a good game.
- 46:48They've, sadly, sadly, they've even, they've pulled it off where they even get money in
- 46:55escrow.
- 46:56So I've had a client, not them, I didn't represent them on this, but they put up a million dollars
- 47:01into an quote escrow and with a real escrow company, by the way, with a real honesty,
- 47:06got escrow company.
- 47:08And then the schemers sent in false instructions and got the money out of it, stole the million
- 47:15dollars right out of escrow.
- 47:16So they can go even that far.
- 47:18Often it's that they don't even use an escrow.
- 47:20They just, people are willing to, because most films use money, because it's so hard
- 47:25to raise money, producers are desperate and they were willing to pay anybody, anything
- 47:30to try to, on the hope that they'll raise money and they all get taken to the cleaners.
- 47:35I always tell them, don't pay upfront.
- 47:38If somebody says to you that they can raise all the money in the world, great.
- 47:42And you'll pay them double whatever they're asking for when they show up with the money
- 47:47in your bank account and it's closed.
- 47:49And I have vetted it.
- 47:51And that will, that will drive the, the schemers away immediately.
- 47:55The moment you say, well, pay you on close, they'll disappear.
- 47:58You gotta look out, I always ask for all the normal stuff through diligence bank statements.
- 48:04And I have been sent fake bank statements.
- 48:06And thank God I called the bank and verified that it was, I found out that they were fraud.
- 48:11And I mean, you just got to look hard and the games come in all different flavors.
- 48:19Oh, I've got all this money just, but it's locked up in a trust.
- 48:23If you can loan me this, I can release all of it.
- 48:27And often you'll hear, I've got it.
- 48:29And if you give, put money here, you'll be in escrow there and it will release.
- 48:34We can, we can leverage it up and then we can come back with more money.
- 48:37It's always some kind of leveraged like mousetrap game.
- 48:40You put money here and then all kinds of things happen and somebody shows up with more money.
- 48:44So don't do that.
- 48:46Don't do that.
- 48:50I always say the real trick to film financing is I've got clients that just don't stop.
- 48:57And they're just, they're the determinator.
- 48:59They're, I mean, again, the one that raised money from Gaddafi.
- 49:03I've got one client that's just been unbelievably successful in selling films, but they effectively
- 49:09stand in the middle and broker deals get people to get the rights and then they go to, they
- 49:15have relationships with the studios.
- 49:17Another thing important, and I should mention this.
- 49:22The all the streamers and studios have people that I call the anointed ones that they will
- 49:26listen to and fortunately I have clients that are, that are the anointed ones partner with
- 49:33them.
- 49:34If you're, if you're not an anointed one and you're trying to get traction at a studio
- 49:38or a streamer, all you got to do is figure out who are the anointed ones for your type
- 49:45of content at that particular studio or streamer.
- 49:49For example, if you've got a horror film, all you have to do is look at the credits
- 49:52on the horror films that are playing on the recent horror films that are playing on that
- 49:56streamer to see who are the anointed ones for horror for, for that stream or whatever
- 50:02it is.
- 50:03You can, you can pick out the producers really fast looking at the credits on the recent
- 50:06films.
- 50:08Partner with those people, give them half your joint, you know, tenants and com joint, joint
- 50:14ownership of the project.
- 50:16Be happy if they'll, if they'll do it because those people, the agents will take their calls
- 50:22the studios and the streamers will take their calls and, and it's unbelievable what they
- 50:27can get done.
- 50:28I mean, and, and that you, that, that people that don't, you know, aren't an anointed one
- 50:32can't get done.
- 50:34So, you know, be glad if somebody will, will partner with you and take half, you know,
- 50:40you give them half ownership.
- 50:41I'm absolutely the, that's the best way to go.
- 50:46So again, to the, to the final, final few, few thoughts.
- 50:52I always tell clients, Churchill's refrain was never give in, never give in, never, never,
- 50:58never.
- 50:59There's always new financing coming in.
- 51:02You can always find a way.
- 51:03You can always, if you just, you know, don't give up and, and, and keep plugging and just
- 51:09keep plugging.
- 51:12Speaking of plugs, let me give you a plug for a few things.
- 51:16One is, if, if my background is, I'm a partner at Greenberg Glusker.
- 51:23I am the author of a book called The Biz and with luck, I'm going to be able to share my
- 51:31screen and show that it's not, it's a very popular book.
- 51:33It's up to its sixth edition and it's sold like 50,000 copies.
- 51:39It's pretty widely used in Hollywood.
- 51:41So let me see if I can do that.
- 51:45There it is.
- 51:46It's on Amazon and it's, it covers everything I've talked about today and a whole lot more.
- 51:53So I would, I'd strongly recommend it if anybody that's interested in that.
- 51:58I also have a YouTube channel.
- 52:01If you search my name under Skymore, SKYmore Attorney and The Biz.
- 52:08I think if you put in The Biz, you'll find like I have a whole course that I used to
- 52:12teach at the UCLA Law School and the UCLA Business School that I record, effectively recorded
- 52:17or did it separately, put it online.
- 52:19So it covers everything in the world, you know, A to Z for, for, for films.
- 52:25And I have a Forbes, I have a monthly Forbes column that is, that's, I cover everything
- 52:34that's going on, you know, whatever is happening recently.
- 52:37And I have a newsletter and if you're interested in the newsletter, you just pop me an email
- 52:43that says add, the word add, and I will add you to the newsletter.
- 52:48And it's just my email is smore at ggfirm.com.
- 52:55Again, smore at ggfirm.com.
- 53:00And so you can easily follow me or, you know, get hold of my emails from now.
- 53:06And so with that, I'm glad to take questions.
- 53:11And I see Q&A and I also see something under chat.
- 53:15But I'm going to do Q&A first because I see more there.
- 53:18And, and again, if you keep, if you keep the questions relatively short, I will actually
- 53:23be able to read them and, and be able to answer them.
- 53:27Okay, question one.
- 53:30I love this.
- 53:33Okay.
- 53:35I have been perplexed in some producer clients want to offer safe SAFE notes to investors.
- 53:41Have you seen such?
- 53:42If so, why and why and what is the conversion event for a safe note?
- 53:49Okay.
- 53:52This is a short agreement for future equity.
- 53:58Short agreement for future equity is what's called a safe and they are absurd.
- 54:03They are not safe.
- 54:04They are idiotic.
- 54:05They are half-baked.
- 54:06They are ridiculous.
- 54:07They are stupid.
- 54:08Don't use them.
- 54:09So the answer to your question is they are ridiculous.
- 54:10Don't use a safe.
- 54:12What a safe is is some, it's like it's equivalent of a Hollywood term sheet deal memo, something
- 54:18napkin deal, which are again half-baked, you know, ambiguous.
- 54:23There's no reason why you shouldn't go to a, to whatever the final agreement is.
- 54:27And the final agreement can be short.
- 54:29It can be, but it should be comprehensive.
- 54:32All you have to think about is for any deal is money in, money out and control.
- 54:39And if you cover those issues and you think about the default rules and you do it correctly,
- 54:44you can be, you can be covered, but don't use a safe.
- 54:47A safe is saying, at some point I'll give you something, but it's completely, it's
- 54:52not clear what it is for tax purposes.
- 54:53It's not clear what it is for corporate purposes and it's not clear what you're going to finally
- 54:57get.
- 54:58So the, the, the answer to your question, the conversion is supposedly the first funding
- 55:02of the, of the entity, but you don't, you don't control that.
- 55:05You don't know really what you're getting.
- 55:07Okay.
- 55:08Next.
- 55:09What are your thoughts on equity crowdfunding sites that try to standardize the investment
- 55:12process?
- 55:13I don't, I don't like the crowdfunding sites.
- 55:17I, I'm, I'm sorry.
- 55:19I'm just not a fan of them.
- 55:21They often ask for money up front.
- 55:22I don't, I don't trust the documents.
- 55:26I don't trust the process.
- 55:27I don't like it.
- 55:29How often do I use 506C, which allows general solicitation?
- 55:33I have 506C allows you to advertise your, your offering for equity and it lets you go out
- 55:40and I don't understand why nobody's using that.
- 55:43So the answer is I've never used it because no one has, I don't know why no one has done
- 55:49it.
- 55:50And so, you know, I'm perplexed.
- 55:52I would be glad to do a 506C.
- 55:55I don't see why people aren't advertising, but I haven't seen it.
- 56:00Are finders that aren't SEC licensed brokers legal?
- 56:03And if so, I think I've answered that one, which is there's the SEC says finders that
- 56:08get paid a fee are not legal at all.
- 56:11The case law has said as long as they don't pitch the product, then, then you're, you're
- 56:16okay.
- 56:17So I tell clients it's okay to use finders as long as they don't pitch it, as long as
- 56:23they literally just make the introduction.
- 56:25I try to stay within the case law.
- 56:27Okay.
- 56:28I a couple of questions.
- 56:30I touched on 506, not 504 yet.
- 56:33Don't use 504.
- 56:36Clashen Ray, who met you take on an equity?
- 56:40Yeah.
- 56:41Okay.
- 56:42I don't do 504.
- 56:43I only do 506.
- 56:44I like accredited investors and I just, just too many.
- 56:48If you go out and this is obviously a lawyer discussion, but if you do 504, you got to comply
- 56:53with state law and if you make one, you just, you run into problems.
- 56:59And I don't want to be in a litigation with a widow and orphan on a 504.
- 57:03I'd rather be in a litigation with an accredited investor that's a big boy that can afford
- 57:08losing their money.
- 57:09So that's, that's the short answer to that.
- 57:13Okay.
- 57:14Advertisers.
- 57:15Oh, now someone's already doing.
- 57:18How much money can I get?
- 57:20I got a hundred percent.
- 57:21I got a hundred million dollars from Adidas for goal.
- 57:26It's it all, it ranges the board.
- 57:27So Ann Marie Gillan, the answer is nice to see you, hear you.
- 57:32It ranges the board from zero, from zero to, you know, go use the rights to, to literally
- 57:38the full budget, which was a happy day.
- 57:43Are streamers only buying worldwide or can you retain streamers?
- 57:47They prefer worldwide.
- 57:49They will even step on, I've had to undo foreign deal several times now for the streamers
- 57:55because they weren't worldwide.
- 57:57So I've had, I've sold foreign, then got a streamer sale that said, I don't really
- 58:02don't care about your foreign, go get rid of it.
- 58:04Even in territory, bizarrely that they don't own like China.
- 58:07They made me unwind even, even territories that because they just want to theoretically
- 58:11own worldwide and if and when it ever comes up.
- 58:15But yes, you can do streamer deals on a domestic only deal.
- 58:20But they often, they do, they often do want world, what worldwide.
- 58:24Can I speak in more detail about the emerging streamers back in definition?
- 58:30What are they including in gross?
- 58:31What are they?
- 58:32Okay, what is Netflix proposing?
- 58:33We're not clear yet.
- 58:36And I'm I short answer is we really don't know.
- 58:42We're not clear on what exactly their definition is, whether it's tied to subscribers, new
- 58:48subscribers, views, hours watched, minutes watched.
- 58:52Stay tuned to this station.
- 58:54We are not entirely clear on what is being offered.
- 59:00What are the concerns about foreign equity investment?
- 59:02On foreign equity, you've got to worry about foreign securities laws.
- 59:06And that's often people overlook that.
- 59:08You know, say it's not if you're raising money from Germany or France, you got to worry what
- 59:15are their securities laws and do you have to comply with it?
- 59:17So I would definitely work.
- 59:18Are my books are my books on Kindle?
- 59:20I don't know.
- 59:21I don't think so, but I don't own.
- 59:23I don't know.
- 59:24What is the state of foreign pre-sales for foreign?
- 59:30Bad.
- 59:31I can tell you it's bad.
- 59:35Very bad.
- 59:36I just had I just give an example.
- 59:37I just went to a client, just go pre-sale a can.
- 59:40They got offers for half the total foreign sales was half the budget.
- 59:45And they then went to get a Netflix deal for more than, of course, more than 100% of the
- 59:49budget.
- 59:50So they tried and failed on foreign.
- 59:53So I think the foreign, then I've got another one though, they're putting in equity and
- 59:57we're going to, we're going to, they are going to fund, it's a bigger budget film.
- 1:00:03They want to take it away from a streamer and so they're willing to put in real equity,
- 1:00:07but generally the market's very bad for foreign, for foreign sales.
- 1:00:12What distributors are financing co-productions?
- 1:00:14The one that I'm doing is Germany, France, England, Japan and Scandinavia, Scandinavian
- 1:00:24countries, which is pretty common.
- 1:00:27That's kind of the general, sometimes Korea is in, China is out.
- 1:00:32China is gone, by the way, China is just gone.
- 1:00:39If we give, if equity investor, look, someone got lost, if I miss them.
- 1:00:45If you give equity, if you give equity investor shares, can that be reconciled with other
- 1:00:50financiers taking control?
- 1:00:52Yes.
- 1:00:53Even if you've got some people getting contractual, you can mesh that with people who are getting
- 1:00:58done, being done properly with an equity investment in the entity.
- 1:01:02So it can be combined.
- 1:01:04Although why would you do that?
- 1:01:10If you rely heavily on sponsor, like advertiser funding, how badly does that harm your international
- 1:01:15sales?
- 1:01:16Depends on the film.
- 1:01:17It totally depends on the film.
- 1:01:19Look at Barbie.
- 1:01:20I mean, that's, look at goal.
- 1:01:24So it depends.
- 1:01:27Would I advise setting up a film LLC until there is some type of funding available?
- 1:01:32Well, yeah.
- 1:01:35You don't have to form the LLC until there's some funding.
- 1:01:37Yes.
- 1:01:38Correct.
- 1:01:39No reason to do it upfront other than if you think you're going to close it.
- 1:01:42It's not pretty easy to do.
- 1:01:43So it's why not.
- 1:01:48I'm going to drop down.
- 1:01:49What about if you're doing a slate of 10 to 12 films and your investors putting up equity
- 1:01:52year on year, effectively they could write off their basis year on year, effectively
- 1:01:56deferring below, you know, baloney, baloney, baloney.
- 1:02:00I don't believe it.
- 1:02:02I don't think investors are going to want to be investing in 10 to 12 films very rarely
- 1:02:08and the rollover, it's like big deal like this.
- 1:02:16People don't invest for tax deductions.
- 1:02:17They invest for fun and sex and take credits and everything else.
- 1:02:21They don't invest for tax reasons.
- 1:02:27What's the best way to structure an executive producer, a private financier who would like
- 1:02:30the best return on investment and give them a credit and invite them to the party and
- 1:02:36invite them to the premiere?
- 1:02:37That's what you tell them.
- 1:02:39That's your return on investment.
- 1:02:42How are investors in hybrid investment, treating their investment and any money they would,
- 1:02:48yeah, good.
- 1:02:49You know, it's all over the, oh, okay, Sally, that's funny.
- 1:02:53Sally, we'll talk about that later.
- 1:02:56It's a complex question what people are doing because it's all over the board.
- 1:03:00They're all over the board.
- 1:03:05Some people are treating it as though they're a partner.
- 1:03:07Some people are treating it as though they are invested in stock in the company.
- 1:03:14So they treat it as though they've got an investment that they capitalize.
- 1:03:18So it totally depends.
- 1:03:20I understand the case law says, finders are okay if they do not pitch, but can the finders
- 1:03:24get paid on a percentage of the deal?
- 1:03:29If the SEC says no, no payment at all.
- 1:03:35You can pay, in my opinion, you can pay them anyway you want to as long as they don't pitch
- 1:03:40the project.
- 1:03:41Okay?
- 1:03:42So that's how we treat it.
- 1:03:44Whatever you agree to.
- 1:03:45Upfront, whatever you agree to.
- 1:03:49All right.
- 1:03:51What is this last one?
- 1:03:52Am I seeing foreign presale deals without clauses so you can sell worldwide to the streamers?
- 1:03:58No, I haven't seen that up front.
- 1:04:02Most foreign distributors won't do that.
- 1:04:03We usually have to go back to the foreign distributors and get on our knees and say,
- 1:04:07please give us a, we'll pay you to get out of this deal.
- 1:04:12And they're usually happy to get out of the deal if you pay them enough.
- 1:04:16And usually the streamers are willing to pay them enough to get out of those foreign deals.
- 1:04:25Do I have any different ideas for faith-based projects?
- 1:04:28Yes.
- 1:04:29Go to the faith-based distributors.
- 1:04:31There are several and they, so if I had a faith-based project, that's where I would
- 1:04:36go.
- 1:04:37It's very clear who they are.
- 1:04:41One wrote the question that's too long.
- 1:04:44Should you maintain the underlying IP rights in the same entity being used as the investment
- 1:04:50vehicle?
- 1:04:51Yes.
- 1:04:52I use the LLC.
- 1:04:54When I do the LLC, I combine production, distribution, and ownership.
- 1:05:02For a one-off film, I prefer simplicity.
- 1:05:06I don't see the need for having a special purpose vehicle that is doing production only.
- 1:05:11I have the rights all owned by the same LLC.
- 1:05:15That's what I do.
- 1:05:20And if I have a mothership company that's going to, that really is going to stay in
- 1:05:24existence, then I'll use an SBV, but the rights will be owned by the mothership.
- 1:05:28The SBV will just be for production.
- 1:05:30I will have the rights owned by the mothership.
- 1:05:32And that's like, if you've got an ongoing company, and then you want to, I'll have
- 1:05:35to isolate production risk and also just for credit, I mean, for guild purposes and
- 1:05:41stuff.
- 1:05:45For finders, is it better to pay them as producers on the picture if their fee is tied to what
- 1:05:49they find?
- 1:05:50To me, it doesn't matter what you call them.
- 1:05:52Again, I'm taking, I will warn you, the SEC takes the contrary view to what I'm telling
- 1:05:57you because the SEC says you can't pay finders at all no matter what you call them.
- 1:06:01So I don't even, I just face it up front and I say, look, we're relying on the case
- 1:06:05law.
- 1:06:08Do I have experience with financing films in other countries, Indian films?
- 1:06:13No, I'll minor, minor, I have certainly films produced in foreign countries, but they're
- 1:06:19always US, English language, so they're always US language.
- 1:06:25Can tax credits be as used as collateral?
- 1:06:27Absolutely.
- 1:06:28Tax credits are all the time used as collateral.
- 1:06:30There are very specialized lenders that lend on them and they often are separated out from
- 1:06:37the other collateral and you have a lender that often just does exactly that.
- 1:06:46And so with that, I am going to end this thing and say, and I've got, although I've got chats
- 1:06:52though, I don't know if that is, no, they were good.
- 1:06:54Okay, so I've answered the questions and I am honored to have done this for everybody.
- 1:06:59And again, if you have any, if you want to follow up with me with my email, I'm glad
- 1:07:03to take questions there and it has been an honor to be with you.
- 1:07:07So thank you.
- 1:07:10You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:07:13Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.