Latest / The So What? / Elections Update
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplantman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:25Hello and welcome to this podcast which accompanies JP's newsletter dated 8 April 2024. It's titled
- 0:35Simply Election Update. So we have 51, 52 parties?
- 0:42Yes, indeed. In 2019, the last general election, national election, we had 48, so it's a few
- 0:51more. Plus the independents that joined the fray this time.
- 0:56And the new kid on the block is Mr Zuma's Umqonto We Siswe party, the MK party. How
- 1:02do you see their impact?
- 1:04Well, so far the impact is very, very interesting. We don't have that many opinion polls to go
- 1:09on. We only have three, but if we take the average of the three polls, then they're polling
- 1:14at the moment about 11% nationally. In the KwaZiDuna Tal province, they poll about 20
- 1:20to 24%. So they're clearly very strong there, but it also gives them a national footprint.
- 1:26Does that mean that they are the biggest party at the moment according to the polls in UKZN?
- 1:31It does suggest that, yes. It does suggest that. We can talk about the provinces later,
- 1:36but yes, they are the biggest at the moment. Now, I think what one must discount here is
- 1:41that they're having quite a nice bounce because of all the publicity surrounding the formation
- 1:46of the party. And we must see to what extent that will last. And of course, one must also
- 1:52see to what extent the party can survive the other party's machinery coming into action,
- 1:58election machinery coming into action. So, you know, one must treat these numbers with
- 2:02a little bit of caution, but clearly they're having an impact.
- 2:06Where do they find their support? Where does it come from?
- 2:09It's very interesting. It comes from the ANC. It also comes a little bit from the AFP, but
- 2:15it also looks as if they have, well, it doesn't look, they have certainly put a lid on the
- 2:20support of the EFF. So, people who in theory would have voted EFF or should vote EFF, if
- 2:26you look at profile, it looks as if they're not going to the EFF. They're rather going
- 2:30to MK. And in that sense, they're putting a lid on what the EFF can achieve. So, so
- 2:37far, we can say there are two consequences from MK entering the fray. The one is they're
- 2:41taking support away from the ANC, which I think will tilt the ANC decisively below 50%.
- 2:48And secondly, they're putting a lid on what the EFF can do. And that must make Mr. Malema
- 2:53very, very unhappy. So, if we just compare what we have now to our previous election
- 2:58note, in the previous election note, we had the average for the ANC sitting at about 45.
- 3:05It's now sitting at 40. The average for the ANC sitting, for the DA rather, sitting at
- 3:1123. It's now sitting at 24, basically the same. For the EFF, it was 13%. It's now 11.
- 3:18On counter, of course, there was nothing because they were not there yet. They also now poll
- 3:2311. So, if you take the 11 of EFF and 11 of MK, you get 22. And that sort of intuitively
- 3:30feels right. And then the IFP, according to these polls, have lost a little bit of support.
- 3:35They went from 5% to 3%. So, to answer your question, where does this support comes from?
- 3:40It comes from the ANC. It comes from the IFP. And it comes from a pool of voters that probably
- 3:46would have voted EFF, but is now preferring MK.
- 3:51Each voter will get three ballot papers this time, as opposed to two the last time. How
- 3:57exactly does it work?
- 3:59It's complicated. The change is because of independence. You will recall that there was
- 4:05a big hullabaloo, constitutional court applications and agitation and so on. And the legislation
- 4:12was changed. And now independence can stand for the national parliament and they can stand
- 4:17for provincial parliament. Now, in order to accommodate the independence, there will now
- 4:21be three ballot papers. The first one, which will elect 200 members of the National Assembly,
- 4:28you simply vote for political parties. So, the 50 odd parties will be on the list and
- 4:33you choose who's your favourite and that's it. The second ballot paper will be the same.
- 4:38It will be the list of parties participating and you choose your party. Or on the second
- 4:44list there will also be independence. So, you have to decide. Do you choose a party
- 4:48or do you choose an independent? You'll have one vote only and you'll make your choice.
- 4:53And that is the, if I can put it like that, the second 200 members.
- 4:58Correct. That's the remainder of the 400 members for the National Assembly. So, the second
- 5:03200, as you put it, that will be elected there. And then the third ballot paper is to elect
- 5:09the provincial parliament or the provincial legislature. That is a combination of political
- 5:13parties and independence and you choose who you want to have there. Now, I think I was
- 5:17just pointing out that at the moment, although we have more than 50 political parties participating,
- 5:23there are on the national list only six independents and on the various provincial lists another
- 5:28five. So, you're looking at a total of 11 independents and you must ask yourself the
- 5:33question was all this hullabaloo now really worth it? It's a very meager harvest, but
- 5:38that's a different point.
- 5:41Then of course, one of the main worries for the country as a whole, what happens if no
- 5:48one gets 50% in the first place? How will parliament then elect a president? What if
- 5:54there's a deadlock?
- 5:56Okay. The procedure is fairly straightforward. Within 14 days after the election results
- 6:02are declared. Now, the election is on Wednesday the 29th. It'll probably be the voting and
- 6:09the verification and the auditing was normally completed by Saturday. So, by Saturday the
- 6:14second of June, the electoral commission will announce the results. Then 14 days from that
- 6:20date, parliament must meet and they have to choose a president. That's their first order
- 6:25of business.
- 6:26And the chairman in that case is the Chief Justice.
- 6:31Chief Justice. Yeah. And he doesn't vote, of course. So, it's the 400 members of the
- 6:35National Assembly. You will need 201 votes to become president. If you don't get 201
- 6:41votes on the first round of voting, then the candidate with the least number of votes will
- 6:47fall away and you vote again. Candidate with the least number of votes fall away, vote
- 6:52again and you carry on until somebody has got 201. In the unlikely event after a number
- 6:59of voting rounds that nobody gets a majority, but they get the same number of votes, say
- 7:05190 each or 185 votes each. Then parliament has to adjourn for the week and then come
- 7:13back and try again. Now, obviously in that week there will then be horse trading and
- 7:17deal making and negotiation and so on. Come back after a week, vote again and hopefully
- 7:23you get somebody that'll have 201 votes and then you have a president. If again parliament
- 7:28cannot elect a president, then parliament has to be dissolved and the country must have
- 7:35new elections. Now, I don't think there's anybody that'll have the stomach for that,
- 7:40all the energy, all the money. So, the pressure on political parties will be enormous to come
- 7:46to some kind of a consensus, some kind of an agreement and elect a president.
- 7:53That's the president, but then we're back to the question of coalitions because if no
- 7:58party has 50% and for the first time really now JP, you are saying you don't think the
- 8:03ANC is going to get there. So, how do you see it?
- 8:08Yeah, if MK does as well as the polls suggest they will do, then the ANC cannot get to 50.
- 8:14I think that's just mathematically not possible. So, what will then have to happen, they will
- 8:19have to invite coalition partners. Now again, it depends by how much they miss 50. If they
- 8:24miss 50 by 2%, let's say they get 48, well then it will be very easy to make a coalition
- 8:30of the IFP. They will have 3 or 4% of the vote and you can run. And in fact, the leader
- 8:36of the IFP, Mr. Slavisa said that he is willing to do what he calls a government of national
- 8:43unity, i.e. code language for I will make a deal with the ANC because that's what we
- 8:48did in 1994. So, that door is certainly open. If they miss it by a bigger margin, say 10%,
- 8:56so the ANC only gets 40%. Now they are 10 short of 50. Then the IFP and other small
- 9:01parties won't help them. Then they will have to look at a bigger party and then their choice
- 9:06will be either the DA on the one side or the EFF and MK on the other side. I think it's
- 9:12highly unlikely that you will see a coalition with the EFF and MK at national level. I think
- 9:19it's very, very unlikely. What makes you say that?
- 9:21Well, a number of things. First of all, the fight between MK and ANC is a blood feud.
- 9:27It's a brutal threat and we all know how vicious that can be and how people just don't count
- 9:33work together around that. If you look at the EFF, a number of signals are coming from
- 9:38the political arena telling us that they are struggling to give substance to the coalition
- 9:45agreements that they have. I think the majority of people in the ANC do not want to go with
- 9:51the EFF. As I said in the last note, your support for the ANC EFF coalition is mainly
- 9:57located in the Gauteng and KwaZulu Natal provinces. That's where the push for the EFF is. The
- 10:04rest of the country, not so much. I mean the rest of the ANC in the country. So I don't
- 10:11think that will happen. I think if it comes down to a choice between EFF on the one hand
- 10:15or DA on the other hand, I think the ANC will go with the DA. Then you have a broad coalition
- 10:21of the middle. That coalition will enjoy the support of at least two thirds of South Africans.
- 10:27That can then have interesting consequences in the longer term, medium to longer term,
- 10:33largely around a reconfiguration of our politics. What I think we're going to see in the short
- 10:38term after the election is that the parties on the left, that's the EFF, it's Mr. Zuma's
- 10:44party, it's ACMK, it's Ace Machashula's party, ACT, African Congress of Transformation, and
- 10:51a few other, call them left-wing parties. I think they will come together in some kind
- 10:55of an arrangement. What we have at the moment is the MPC, the multi-party charter or the
- 11:00Moonshot coalition. You have them on the right of the ANC. I think you're going to see a
- 11:05similar Moonshot developing on the left of the ANC, quite soon after the election. If
- 11:12they're excluded from power, they're excluded from government, these left-wing parties will
- 11:18have an incentive to come together. Mr. Zuma has already alluded to that. You'll then have
- 11:23a left-wing Moonshot coalition. You will have a right-wing Moonshot coalition. You will
- 11:28have the ANC and the DA in the middle. Then you can have over a period of time, five years
- 11:34or more, you can have a reconfiguration. That reconfiguration, I think, conceptually will
- 11:40come down to the following. You will have on the right, people with free market thinking.
- 11:45That's the DA and that group of people. In the middle, you will have the ANC and parts
- 11:53of the DA working with what I would call a social democratic value system. On the left,
- 11:59you will have RET, radical economic transformation. That's a nice little division, certainly in
- 12:05terms of ideas between the main political groupings.
- 12:08You've described that as a healthy development. I think it's very healthy. In South Africa
- 12:13and in the Anglo-Saxon world where our political tradition was formed, we're not used to coalitions
- 12:20or the idea of social democracy. Americans, for example, don't understand it at all. Neither
- 12:26do the English. In Europe, it's a standard thing. It's a very, very standard thing. Germany,
- 12:31most successful economy on the continent, has been run by a social democratic value
- 12:36system ever since the Second World War. I think for South Africa, in our circumstances,
- 12:43a social democratic solution is quite a good one and appealing one. You will then have
- 12:50free markets, social democratic, radical economic transformation.
- 12:54That can be, I'm now really going speculating wild here and I'm talking long term, but that
- 13:00can help to replace identity politics. Then you move from the current regime of identity
- 13:08politics to a regime where you have identity politics, but also a value based system that
- 13:15underlies your choice. That's why I think it will be a healthy development.
- 13:20In summary, so what? First, the MK Party?
- 13:24Yeah, first, the MK Party is affecting the ANC quite clearly. If they survive the ANC's
- 13:30counter campaign, they can get the numbers that the polls suggest and they will take
- 13:364 or 5% away nationally from the ANC. Paradoxically, the second impact of the MK is that they are
- 13:43putting a lid on the growth of the EFF. I think that'll be a bitter pill for Mr. Malema
- 13:48to swallow and he'll be very disappointed, but that's the way the cookie is scrambling
- 13:53at the moment.
- 13:54So what for the multi-party charter?
- 13:57The multi-party charter has got no chance of realizing their ambition, their public
- 14:03ambition of replacing the government. They're polling at about 34% at the moment, 33, 34.
- 14:11Even if they go up to 40% by election day, there's still a hell of a distance from 40%
- 14:16to 50%. So they're not going to replace the new government, not going to happen. The fact
- 14:21that people claim that I think is a bit of a misrepresentation. But constituents of the
- 14:26multi-party charter can indeed join up with the ANC. The DA, for example, the IFP, those
- 14:33are very real possibilities. Yeah, and I think what we're going to see, as I've said, is
- 14:39a national, on a national level, the ANC-IFP coalition. And you may also see that in the
- 14:45provinces, but the provincial situation becomes more difficult, more interests, more parties.
- 14:51So let's see what the final vote count is before we pronounce.
- 14:55So then the only thing to say is happy voting.
- 14:59Absolutely. Go and vote and happy voting.
- 15:02Thank you very much. Goodbye.
- 15:04Thank you.
- 15:06Thank you for listening to the So What podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 15:11to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 15:16future episodes. Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written version of
- 15:22all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.