Latest / Film And Whiskey / West Side Story (2021) Revisited with Patrick H. Willems + Penelope Riviera Review
Transcript
- 0:01In 2021, director Steven Spielberg and star Ansel Elgort
- 0:06gave the world an adaptation of one of the most famous musicals
- 0:12of all time. In 2026, we try a whiskey that's
- 0:17in a category all its own. The film is West Side Story.
- 0:22The whiskey is Penelope Riviera. And we'll review them both.
- 0:26This is the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:48Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:51review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:54I'm Bob Book. I'm I'm Brad G.
- 0:57And Brad G, we are shaking the rust off a little bit today.
- 1:02This is not really an official podcast episode.
- 1:05This is it's kind of like the NBA play in where those stats
- 1:10don't get counted towards the regular season or the post.
- 1:13Season or the playoffs? Yeah.
- 1:15Yeah, so like we're kind of just in between seasons here, you
- 1:19know, this, this weird nether world that we're in right now, I
- 1:22feel. Like at some point 10 years from
- 1:24now, there's going to be a player that's like been on the
- 1:26Atlanta Hawks and they've been in the play in tournament for 10
- 1:29years straight. And there's going to be a stat
- 1:32on the NBA thing that was like if his play off stats included
- 1:36the play in games. Yeah.
- 1:38Oh yeah, he'd be outscoring LeBron.
- 1:41Yeah, exactly, dude. So listen, we had, we had made a
- 1:44promise to each other and to our good friend who we will intro
- 1:48here in just a second. That's when we were.
- 1:50Saying promise to each other. I just imagine like the hand,
- 1:53the muscular arms, clasping hands.
- 1:57Yeah, what movie is that from? Predator.
- 1:59Predator. Yeah, Predator.
- 2:01So we reviewed West Side Story a couple months ago, a film that
- 2:05is not just near and dear to my heart, but I think I said on the
- 2:09episode, this is a contender for Bob Book's sight and sound list.
- 2:13And during that episode, our front patch, Williams said,
- 2:17listen, I think the 21 version is better.
- 2:21And I said, look, I am happy to hear your case.
- 2:24I I hope you present your argument and prepare it in such
- 2:27a way that it is ready for the onslaught that faces you because
- 2:31I wholeheartedly disagree. And yet Patrick turned up.
- 2:36Patrick is here to talk to us about Steven Spielberg's modern
- 2:41masterpiece. Question mark the 2021 W Side
- 2:45Story. Patrick, how are you tonight,
- 2:46man? Guys, I'm doing great.
- 2:48How are you? Just doing.
- 2:51Dandy, I got to listen to the music of Stephen Sondheim once
- 2:56more. Like it's, It's always a good
- 2:58day. It's glorious.
- 2:59Guys, I got, I've got takes, I've got many takes on this
- 3:03movie and I'm prepared to hear yours.
- 3:07But I think that where I want to start today is somewhere that I
- 3:11don't actually think we talked about in the last episode, which
- 3:14is what level of familiarity do you have to the actual stage
- 3:20version of West Side Story? Because I realized zero.
- 3:25I have never seen it staged either.
- 3:27That is a big. So, so Brad and I are watching
- 3:29this version, which, you know, there's definitely been some
- 3:31adaptation by the screenwriter Tony Kushner.
- 3:34So it's like, is he rewriting lyrics or are these just the
- 3:37original lyrics from Broadway reinstituted now that there
- 3:41aren't any sensors? I can tell you about that.
- 3:45Please do please. The changes to the lyrics are
- 3:48changes that Sondheim made in between the original film and
- 3:53this one. OK.
- 3:56Yeah, those those versus. A revision from the source.
- 3:59Yes, those are are kind of like the updated lyrics.
- 4:03Those were not change like the the the movie makes changes to
- 4:06the book, as in like, you know, the the non, you know, like the
- 4:11dialogue and stuff like that. But the actual lyrical changes,
- 4:15especially in America, those were I'm, I'm, I can't tell you
- 4:20when, but I know those were Sondheim changes.
- 4:24Yep. So it's basically like George
- 4:25Lucas special editions, just, you know, little tweaks here and
- 4:29there. I I think some of them would,
- 4:32yeah. But I think a bunch of these
- 4:34were like feedback from actual like Puerto Rican people to be
- 4:39like, Hey, can we change some some of those We don't love some
- 4:43of those lyrics in in in America.
- 4:45And he's like, you know what, I hear you.
- 4:48And because these are being sung by Puerto Rican characters,
- 4:50let's let's get it right. So.
- 4:54But also it's it's really fun to go back and watch the 4K of the
- 4:5861 version now and see where Robert Wise inserted CGI like
- 5:02Gungans in the background of stuff.
- 5:04That's it's a fun Easter egg. It is, you know, for those who
- 5:07are OG. Would Maria shout in a clunky
- 5:10that that's that's what it was always missing?
- 5:17So I do know that even like in the 61 version, Rita Moreno was
- 5:21like, I am not singing some of these lyrics from the Broadway
- 5:24version for America. And so they kind of tweaked the
- 5:27intro to that song even then. So I'm not surprised to hear
- 5:30that Sondheim had additional, you know, revisions to make with
- 5:34the lyrics here. So let me just say, I'm really
- 5:37glad that all three of us who are now super familiar with the
- 5:42film versions of West Side Story have basically no understanding
- 5:47of the screen, this stage version, because that allows us
- 5:50to strictly focus on the cinematic here.
- 5:54I think we can all agree West Side Story is perhaps the kind
- 5:58of quintessential American musical and I think has been
- 6:03kind of canonized that way, especially in the last few
- 6:05decades. So we love the music, we love
- 6:09the story. Obviously Billy Shakespeare.
- 6:11Good job on that one. Attaboy.
- 6:13So let's talk about the movies themselves.
- 6:15And I want to start with Brad, because Brad, you really like
- 6:21the original. And I think now, especially
- 6:24after doing like 400 movies, revisiting it, you really
- 6:27appreciate the the cinematic elements of it.
- 6:32And yet as soon as you finished watching the Spielberg version,
- 6:35you said this is way better than the 1961 version.
- 6:41I turn it over to you. Make your opening arguments
- 6:44here, Brad, I think. I, you know, we were texting
- 6:48another friend of ours, Zach, the other day about like, how
- 6:53far we've come as movie critics, if you could call us that.
- 6:58And one of the things I've realized is that the more movies
- 7:02I watch, I kind of know what I appreciate in movies.
- 7:06And there can be elements of movies that I appreciate less
- 7:09that I can still recognize and go, yeah, like, the lighting
- 7:12here was incredible. But incredible lighting isn't
- 7:16going to move the needle on a movie for me as much as a well
- 7:20crafted story that showcases a unique element of what it means
- 7:26to be a human. Like, that's like, my that's
- 7:29what really gets me going. And I think that the script in
- 7:33this movie is just flat out better.
- 7:36I think that the big drawback for me about the original 1 and
- 7:42Bob, you and I have said this from Season 1 when we watched
- 7:45it, anytime Tony and Maria are on the screen together, I'm like
- 7:50ready to fall asleep. It's not great.
- 7:52The. Like the action?
- 7:53Is just OK The There's something about it that falls flat for me.
- 7:59Rachel Ziegler and Ansel Elgort, every time they're on screen
- 8:03together, I'm locked in and they change just enough of their
- 8:07relationship. Give it just a little bit of
- 8:10tension and it's not much. They give both of them just a
- 8:13little more background and a little more depth when they're
- 8:17with other characters. I like.
- 8:19I think the The relationship between Riff and Tony is so much
- 8:24better in this movie than it is in the original.
- 8:27I think the relationship between Anita and Maria so much better
- 8:33than in the original. So I think it's like those
- 8:35elements of the characters just being fleshed out a little bit
- 8:39that made me go like, oh, like this is so much better than the
- 8:43original. I don't know where you guys are
- 8:47at, but that's where I. Was going to say I would like to
- 8:50know where Patrick lands on the gauntlet that's been thrown
- 8:53down. The evaluation is 2021 is much
- 8:58better than 1961. I'm not going to go that far.
- 9:05So OK, what I believe what I said when I was on here before
- 9:12talking about the 1961 movie. It's 61, right?
- 9:17Yep. Yeah, exactly 60 years between
- 9:21them. I know.
- 9:23So I believe what I said and you can, you feel free to, to, you
- 9:27know, check the record, pull up the tapes and and show that I'm
- 9:31incorrect. I think I said the Spielberg
- 9:34one, which may even be better or kind of question mark.
- 9:39Like, I believe I brought it up in a way where I, I think, I
- 9:45think there are a lot of elements of the Spielberg one
- 9:48that are improvements. And but it is also, it's hard
- 9:53for me to like it. I'm never going to say the 2021
- 9:58film replaces the the original 1 because I think it is so in
- 10:04conversation with the original film.
- 10:07And they do both have their own strengths.
- 10:10And so it's one of those things where when you ask me what is
- 10:15your favorite musical movie, I do kind of have to cheat and say
- 10:20West Side Story like parentheses S it's like the two of them
- 10:25together. And because what I talked about
- 10:30in a lot in the episode about the original film is that what
- 10:35this movie does so spectacularly is just the combination of light
- 10:39and color and movement and music.
- 10:42And that is its crowning achievement to me.
- 10:45That is that it does so magnificently.
- 10:48That is like when that movie is cooking.
- 10:50It is utterly transcendent to the point where I, I, I will
- 10:57easily forgive things like, oh, yeah, the Tony Maria
- 10:59relationship is not the the most exciting thing in the world or
- 11:04whatever. And so, yeah, because the, the
- 11:08like there, there aren't parts of that movie that I think are
- 11:11bad. There's just parts that I think
- 11:12are, are OK. And then the highs are so
- 11:15stratospherically high. The Spielberg 1 is so
- 11:19interesting because it's a movie that when it was announced, I
- 11:22feel like everyone went why? Like, I, I get that you
- 11:28Spielberg making the musical felt inevitable.
- 11:32Just look, you know, his his mastery of of visual language
- 11:38and action scenes. The times that he kind of
- 11:40flirted with musicals in the was the the Lindy Hop sequence of
- 11:471941, the opening of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom.
- 11:51Like the guy can do it, obviously.
- 11:54And it just seemed odd that like, oh, so you're finally
- 11:56going to do a musical terrific, but you're, you're going to
- 11:59remake a contender for the best one ever.
- 12:04And does it need a remake? And then, but I was like, look,
- 12:08I, I trust in Steve and I showed up that I actually know.
- 12:11I, I, I this was, I remember this was a funny experience.
- 12:15Wow, this is, I'm going on such a long story.
- 12:16And you were just like, so Patrick, do you like it or do
- 12:18you not like it? But I, I promise this is all
- 12:21relevant. But I remember I, I, I went to a
- 12:24press screening of it that I, as usual, I was not invited.
- 12:27I, I, my, my friend Souvanth was invited and I was just plus one.
- 12:33But it, the press screening we were at was happening
- 12:36simultaneously with the world premiere, so no one had seen the
- 12:41movie and it was embargoed. The embargo went up I think an
- 12:45hour or so after our screening got out.
- 12:48So I remember getting out. So I had to.
- 12:51So no one had seen it. There were no reactions.
- 12:54There was no buzz or anything when I went in, which is weird
- 12:58because usually when we see movies, we're aware of what the,
- 13:01the critical consensus is, what people have been saying.
- 13:04So I had no idea. And then I remember getting out
- 13:06from the movie and I had to like to rush out like really quickly.
- 13:10So I wasn't hanging around talking with people and friends
- 13:13were texting me like, Hey, how was it?
- 13:15And I was like, I, I, I think it's maybe a masterpiece, but I
- 13:22don't know what anyone else thinks.
- 13:23I could be totally wrong. But yeah.
- 13:26But it was the thing. And I saw it multiple times in
- 13:28theaters. And I have, I have revisited it
- 13:30multiple times since then. And I do, I truly think this is
- 13:36in the upper tier of Spielberg's movies.
- 13:38And I say that as someone who recently for other projects has
- 13:41been like watch like just kind of honest Spielberg kick.
- 13:46I literally paused Empire of the Sun at the halfway point to come
- 13:49on and do this podcast. And I think it is in the upper
- 13:54tier of his filmography. And I think what's so special
- 13:59about the movie is that it retains so much of the the great
- 14:04things about the original version.
- 14:07It doesn't. It doesn't change stuff just to
- 14:09just to be different. But the way that Tony Kushner,
- 14:17like, subtly updates the script, like Brad was saying, I think
- 14:23adds so much to the entire thing and that.
- 14:27Let me interrupt you there for a second 'cause I, I do want to
- 14:29talk a little bit about like the way that specifically the film
- 14:33was updated, but I don't think iterated is the right word.
- 14:38But you kind of even said it it, it's in conversation with the 61
- 14:42version in addition to the stage play, in addition to
- 14:46Shakespeare, right? So, you know, there there is a
- 14:49sort of self consciousness about what Spielberg and Kushner are
- 14:52doing here in that they know when they have to make reference
- 14:55to the visuals we all remember and when they need to depart
- 14:59from those things or when that's a purposeful choice, I guess is
- 15:01what I should say. And I, I guess we'll start with
- 15:03Kushner because it sounds like both of you guys are like really
- 15:06on board with the script here and the changes.
- 15:08That we made Bob. You haven't told us your take on
- 15:11the movie. That's very observant, Patrick.
- 15:16Yeah, I mean, you know, I'm trying to be the impartial host
- 15:19here. I'll say this guys, I I think
- 15:24that everything prior to the rumble swings wildly between
- 15:29this is brilliant. And like, this was a choice that
- 15:31doesn't work for me. Like and it and it will change
- 15:34from scene to scene. And it that encompasses
- 15:36everything from like some of the writing choices to we'll talk
- 15:40about Kaminsky. I think some of like the, the
- 15:42color grading and lighting choices in this movie, like just
- 15:45really, really irk me. Yeah, whatever, Patrick.
- 15:50I see your face once it clicks into the rumble is like, OK.
- 15:57And and and I think maybe it's it feels to me almost like in
- 16:00watching it in sequence, like Spielberg kind of takes a
- 16:04breather, takes a break from the music for a minute and makes
- 16:09like a grown up kind of terrifying movie for 15 minutes.
- 16:15And then The thing is just sings after that like it is off to the
- 16:18races. And I think, you know, part of
- 16:20that is the way that that the script and the, you know, the
- 16:23origin story hurdles towards its climax.
- 16:26But I think that Spielberg really gets a handle on the
- 16:29material in that back, you know, half and we.
- 16:32Talked about when we did our episode about the 61 film, how
- 16:36as great as it is after the rumble, it's it it it loses some
- 16:42energy and is never as good because that's the point when
- 16:46you don't have the banger songs and it really is about Tony and
- 16:52Maria, which is the least compelling part of the movie.
- 16:56Yeah, I was bracing myself for AI think this movie is bad and
- 17:01an utter failure at which I was I was like, come on, I I was
- 17:05getting worried, but I but no, I I I think this is this is an
- 17:09interesting and totally valid take and I'm really curious to
- 17:12to hear more about your take for the like the the back stretch of
- 17:18the film. Yeah.
- 17:20Well, let's get into it a little bit.
- 17:21And and like I said, let's start with Kushner here, because I
- 17:24think that there are choices made both in the front part of
- 17:27the movie and in the back part of the movie.
- 17:30And there are things that I want to get on the table and
- 17:32acknowledge are I just think flaws with West Side Story and
- 17:37potentially Romeo and Juliet in terms of like dramatic, like
- 17:44like where you pull the dramatic momentum and the rug gets pulled
- 17:48out from under that. So like in both versions, you
- 17:52have the rumble, you have someone dead, you're like, Oh
- 17:56shit, everything just got real. And then it's like, let's do I
- 18:00feel pretty right now, Like let's let's just take a take a
- 18:03deep breath and do I feel which is first of all, a lovely song
- 18:07and a a complete ear worm. I know Sondheim didn't like the
- 18:10lyrics that he wrote for it and and really regretted it later in
- 18:13life. But also, like, I think the the
- 18:16point I'm trying to make here is like, no matter what Tony
- 18:18Kushner and Steven Spielberg did with that smash, cutting to I
- 18:22feel pretty is never going to be a great decision.
- 18:26I'm sorry, I need to go back like 3 minutes.
- 18:30Not only did you just throw four time Oscar award-winning Tony
- 18:35Kushner under the bus, you also you also ran over William Effing
- 18:43Shakespeare with what with that saying is.
- 18:45To I realized after I said it that William Shakespeare did not
- 18:49in fact, smash cut to I feel pretty in his play, so I will
- 18:53retract that bit of my argument. Read it again.
- 18:59I I feel pretty in iambic pentameter would be wonderful
- 19:02though, that's all I. I do understand the argument
- 19:05against the placement of. I feel pretty.
- 19:09I think the the purpose of it has always been, and you know,
- 19:18this is its purpose. You you might just think its
- 19:20purpose doesn't work, which is totally fair.
- 19:23But it is I feel pretty, which could just be a sort of like
- 19:30nice throwaway little song suddenly is now laced with all
- 19:34of this dramatic irony that like for sure, man, she is, she is
- 19:39she is a feeling on top of the world.
- 19:41Because then immediately after that, that that song Chino shows
- 19:45up and delivers this news. So she goes from like her
- 19:48highest high to her absolute lowest point.
- 19:51And, and, and that's what, and it's the thing where like,
- 19:54that's what I think is, is that's what I like about having
- 19:56the song there, because you're getting into the song, but
- 19:58you're just like, oh. Oh, oh Maria, oh you, you have,
- 20:01you have no idea. Oh oh, you're not going to feel
- 20:04very pretty in like 5. Minutes.
- 20:06Yeah, it's a real oh honey kind of moment for her, for sure.
- 20:09It it feels like something Tarantino would do to one of his
- 20:12characters like. It feels.
- 20:15Like, like, granted, if this is a Tarantino movie, Chino would
- 20:18show up and actually shoot Maria, right?
- 20:24But it feels like that level of tension between what you're
- 20:29seeing on the screen and what you know as a viewer.
- 20:32I like, I freaking love the placement of the song, where
- 20:36it's at in the film. I will say in terms of that back
- 20:39half, I think, and I I believe this, this change actually
- 20:43originated in some versions of the the stage show, because
- 20:50again, you know, like any Broadway show from back then,
- 20:53it's been revived multiple times.
- 20:55Every revival has changes. I think one of the best cool
- 21:01cool moving, moving cool to pre rumble and also having cool be
- 21:08Tony and riff, not action and the other guys.
- 21:14I and and also, of course, just like the staging of cool.
- 21:17I I think is pretty spectacular, But but also that is moving cool
- 21:23also shortens that like the the the last stretch of the movie
- 21:29and and and it's just I think it works so much better in this
- 21:32version. And and here's the thing.
- 21:33And I know. It's funny too, because.
- 21:35Like, I like the song cool, but it's it's just like there,
- 21:38there's no competition. Yeah.
- 21:40I think that like the I I kind of break all the changes up in
- 21:42my mind and like changes that I definitely think are
- 21:45improvements, changes that I'm neutral about, changes that I
- 21:48don't like and cool falls in the middle camp for me.
- 21:52But I think that might actually be like the best thing I can say
- 21:56about it because I I went to bat for cool in our last episode.
- 22:00I think that like it's probably the thing that gets laughed at
- 22:03the most when you show that movie in like high school to to,
- 22:06you know, they're like, Oh, this is really dumb.
- 22:09But when you can get on its wavelength and see the way that
- 22:12those kids are like literally exploding inside having seen one
- 22:18of their own just get murdered, I love the and I love that it's
- 22:21in that parking garage and you get the bright lights and it's,
- 22:23it's just, it's staged so well. And so to move it pre rumble,
- 22:27like you said, it's now between Tony and Riff.
- 22:30And so you get that great moment at the end where instead of like
- 22:33a direct address to camera where they're all saying pow at the
- 22:37audience in the 61 version, you now get Riff saying pow at Tony,
- 22:44which is just a you're dead to me.
- 22:46And it is like, it's heartbreaking.
- 22:48It cut back to Tony. There's a tear going down his
- 22:50face. Like it's there's so much more
- 22:52emotional resonance between those two characters now.
- 22:55And Brad, you even mentioned this, like the relationship
- 22:58between Tony and Riff in this one is so much more fleshed out.
- 23:03And, and I don't think that that's a reflection for me
- 23:05necessarily. You know, I tried to go through
- 23:07my mind who's better in their role between the 61 and and 21.
- 23:13And we'll get to the cast. I love Russ Tamblyn in the
- 23:16original, and I don't think that I can hold it against him that,
- 23:20you know, Mike Feist got way meatier dialogue in this
- 23:23version, right? Like, they're both excellent for
- 23:26for what they're supposed to be. I will say at this juncture, I'm
- 23:30still pissed off that Mike Feist didn't get nominated for this.
- 23:33Because it's like, you watch a movie like this and you watch
- 23:36that role and you say like, that's a star, that dude's going
- 23:39to be a *. And he completely, even in like
- 23:42the opening ballet, you know, down the street, this is like a
- 23:46very wide canvas, the cameras constantly moving and your eyes
- 23:50are locked on Mike Feist. Like, he's just so good in this
- 23:54movie, you guys. And thankfully, you know, even
- 23:58though he didn't get the Oscar nomination, he still got
- 24:00challengers after this. As as opposed to poor Ariana
- 24:05Dubose, who is great in this movie, won an Oscar and then has
- 24:09not been in a single good movie since.
- 24:13No, it's like she's. A fun thing now is Angela
- 24:16Bassett does the thing right. That's like, that's what she's
- 24:19known for. Right.
- 24:20It, it's, it is like her post West Side Story career is rough.
- 24:26But like, this was the the thing of with, with this movie of
- 24:31obviously it's introducing Rachel's Rachel Zeigler.
- 24:34She was like the this is her first film.
- 24:37She was a total unknown. But there are a bunch of like
- 24:41really exciting finds in this. And like Mike Feist, he he, he
- 24:47walks out of that like, you know, construction machine where
- 24:51he's just like making out with his girlfriend.
- 24:52And it's just like, you know, this guy is a star.
- 24:55Yeah. Yeah.
- 24:56That's all he was doing, making out, just making making out with
- 25:00his girlfriend. I don't see him pulling up his
- 25:04pants. No.
- 25:06This is a PG13 movie if you didn't.
- 25:08See it? It definitely didn't happen.
- 25:11That's all I'm saying. Brad and Patrick, I want to
- 25:14continue down this thread of like structural changes for the
- 25:18better in this movie or for the worse.
- 25:20Like what were some changes that you noticed specifically that
- 25:25that stood out to you? I loved the usage of Rita Moreno
- 25:30as a married to the original doc, but now she's the doc
- 25:36running the store. I love that change.
- 25:39I like it gave it a little more depth.
- 25:41And once again, it gave Tony as a character a little more depth
- 25:46for the motherly role that she has in his life.
- 25:49And like the little moments of her teaching him Spanish because
- 25:54he's so head over heels puppy in love with Maria.
- 25:58That little moment is like, OK, like this is the logic behind it
- 26:03that happens without us thinking about it.
- 26:05It's like, OK, if this is his mom and she believes that he's
- 26:10in love with Maria enough that she's going to help him get her,
- 26:15then I can believe that their relationship is for real.
- 26:19Yeah. And so it's like little things
- 26:21like that, that I, I really found myself believing the whole
- 26:26premise of the entire story so much more than the original 1,
- 26:30but that, that one. That's also like way it's way
- 26:33closer to the role of the apothecary in Romeo and Juliet.
- 26:36Yes, right. Like the apothecary helps them
- 26:39out and then also makes the poison for them, right?
- 26:41Like so, because in the original, like Doc, at every
- 26:45juncture is like, I don't understand you kids.
- 26:48Get out of my candy. Shop the whole time basically
- 26:50isn't like a person. Yeah.
- 26:53Like he just he's he's the old guy who owns the place where
- 26:57they hang out. And and yeah, it's one of those
- 27:00things where, you know, I when they announced that Rita Moreno
- 27:03would be in this movie, it feels like like a lot of times in like
- 27:07whether you know, it's a remake or whatever, they're like, oh,
- 27:11right. We'll give an original cast
- 27:13number, like a little roll. They'll have a cameo.
- 27:16So you can all you can do the Leo point the screen and be
- 27:18like, oh, there they are. And then then making her a real
- 27:23character who I think deepens so many things about the story
- 27:28where first of all, like, you know, the the doc figure is now
- 27:31an actual human being who even gets a song.
- 27:35But but suddenly just like the fact that like she's Puerto
- 27:37Rican and was married to a white man.
- 27:39And so she has experienced what Tony's experiencing.
- 27:44And Tony can look to her to be like, hey, see, see, this can
- 27:48work out. It worked out with you.
- 27:51And, you know, so much work, I think very suddenly is, is done
- 27:56to make Tony a way more interesting character, whether
- 27:58it's the fact that, you know, he was in prison because he almost
- 28:01killed a guy in a fight. Just, you know, like, even even
- 28:05just like the stuff with like with him and Riff and like the
- 28:09like, you know, birth to earth, sperm to worm the thing.
- 28:12It's like, oh, right, this feels like a friendship that they
- 28:15have. And, and again, this is what I
- 28:17think is so smart about Kushner's script, where it's not
- 28:20like a radical rewrite. It's it's almost like a really,
- 28:24really smart Polish that just basically goes through.
- 28:27And it's like, let's deepen every character.
- 28:30Like, let's make anybody's like an actual character who's now
- 28:34like, explicitly like a trans woman or sorry, trans man.
- 28:38You know, like, like there in the script, rather than just
- 28:41kind of like the annoying tomboy who shows up every so often and
- 28:44yells a little bit and then runs away.
- 28:46Yeah, no, 100%. And I, I don't want to gloss
- 28:49over the fact that they have the doc character Rita Moreno
- 28:54singing the song somewhere and nobody else.
- 28:57It's like it's just a solo for her and it's so much more
- 29:01touching. And I think to our recurring
- 29:03theme here, it speeds up the end of the movie a little bit.
- 29:06So because you don't have the awkwardness of hey, I killed
- 29:10your brother, let's have sex and then sing a song about it.
- 29:13Like it, it's there's still the the fundamental flaw of like,
- 29:17hey, I killed your brother, let's have sex.
- 29:19But we kind of cut away from that.
- 29:20But at least we can have Rita Moreno singing.
- 29:23Yeah, it's I just think that it it really does help that back
- 29:26half of the movie. And you know, you, you mentioned
- 29:29the oh, how does it start the sperm to worm line?
- 29:34Birth to. Earth womb to tomb, womb to tomb
- 29:36to sperm to worm. Yeah, they bring that back in
- 29:40tonight where in the original, you know, they're they're
- 29:44walking down the street and he's, I think he's talking to
- 29:46Arab and they're just counting out how they're going to punch
- 29:48the guy and he goes 123. Well, and in this one you have
- 29:52Mike Feist asking a different person, womb to tomb question
- 29:58mark and then sperm to worm is like the response because he's
- 30:02just told Tony like you're dead to me.
- 30:06And it really it, it continually deepens like the tragedy of Riff
- 30:10as a character that he is like so desperate for that connection
- 30:14and to feel like there is someone who understands him and
- 30:17will go with him to the end of the line that he'll just like
- 30:20dangle that out in front of whoever else is in his vicinity
- 30:24at that moment. I just, I think little subtle
- 30:26things like that are, if not necessarily improvements, are
- 30:30just like they are earned moments for me.
- 30:33Yeah. Well, it's what I think all of
- 30:36these feed into is that the, you know, while these are both, you
- 30:42know, big extravagant musicals and also, and obviously the the
- 30:49original 1 was it was a big deal because it was like the first,
- 30:53not the first first, but it was, it was rare for for for musicals
- 30:58to be shot on location. And this was actually doing like
- 31:01location filming in New York. But the original is so stylized.
- 31:07It is it is big bold colours. It is it it it does not feel
- 31:11like it really exists in in real New York as much as they have
- 31:16like the aerial helicopter photography at the beginning
- 31:19going over New York as much as especially the prologue, what is
- 31:24largely child and location. It does not like it.
- 31:28It feels like kind of like a fantastical universe, New York
- 31:31and I, the 2021 film is so much more rooted in the actual
- 31:39reality of real New York of that specific era, right from the
- 31:43very from the first shot, which I think is is so incredible of
- 31:47especially being, you know, someone who lives in New York
- 31:50when they show the sign of being like Lincoln Center coming soon.
- 31:55And that's like I, I have, you know, truly, I saw this movie in
- 32:00theaters 2 blocks north of that. Like I've walked past that a
- 32:04million times. And so being like, this is where
- 32:07this is and, and like this is, this is a real place.
- 32:11And, and, and it just, it does feel like, you know, again, it,
- 32:17it's, it's lit there in a very glossy, colorful way, but it
- 32:21feels like more like an actual cohesive reality populated by
- 32:25real human beings in a way that the original 1 wasn't even
- 32:29really trying to do. But that to me is, is the
- 32:33biggest difference. Like there, there is actually
- 32:34like a community here. There are people on the street
- 32:38there that like the Puerto Rican characters have a like a culture
- 32:43here. And, and, and so and yeah, and,
- 32:47and just all these little changes to make this feel like
- 32:49a, a believable world populated by human beings.
- 32:53I think is is so effective and really adds so much power to
- 32:58this version. Yeah, even the way that, I mean,
- 33:01I, you know, I lived in Philadelphia for a while and
- 33:03there is an element of like you crossover a certain St. and all
- 33:08of a sudden you're like, things are different here.
- 33:11Like there's a different population of people that live
- 33:14past this street than the ones that lived previous to it.
- 33:17And you see that like when The Jets first crossover and they're
- 33:20going to paint on the Puerto Rican flag.
- 33:22Like you feel that as they move in and it feels real and
- 33:26populated. Patrick, I think what you're
- 33:28talking about for me, I texted Bob at some point and I was
- 33:33like, I think that the 1961 version feels like a musical.
- 33:40The 2021 version feels like a movie.
- 33:45And I don't know quite how to fully say it more than that
- 33:49other than it's like the first one feels like it's on a sound
- 33:52stage and it feels like it is it's contained and bright and
- 33:59vibrant and all these things. This one felt like a, a lived in
- 34:03world that feels more like a film.
- 34:06And I and that just man, it got me this time.
- 34:10Now, Bob, I think it's time. Are you ready?
- 34:15I'm ready. Let's do it.
- 34:16I because I perked up Patrick when I heard you say that you
- 34:21have been going on a Spielberg experience, an extravaganza of
- 34:28enjoying everything he has to offer us.
- 34:32Bob has a very hot take about Yanis Kaminsky and I Bob, I,
- 34:38I'll give you the floor because I, I'm not going to try to say
- 34:41it for you, but I really want to hear Patrick's thoughts on this.
- 34:46I've been dying to hear it. All right.
- 34:49Now I will say apparently I am not alone in this take on Janusz
- 34:56Kaminsky because there was like a very small vocal minority of
- 34:59people on Twitter a couple months ago that were like, I
- 35:02don't vibe with Janusz and then got pilloried.
- 35:05So I cut my mouth shut, but but I stand with them silently.
- 35:10So I think that the majority of Spielberg's films post like AI
- 35:19or especially post Minority Report, when you really started
- 35:23to see Janusz bring in those like heavily diffused lights and
- 35:29integrate the lens flares in ways that he hadn't prior to
- 35:33that. And then especially like, I know
- 35:35Patrick, you corrected me on the last episode that was like,
- 35:37Spielberg only has Kaminski's shoot on film.
- 35:40Like that's it's not digital, but I mean, I would I, I'm
- 35:44assuming that we're at least using like digital color grading
- 35:47and things like that on these films now.
- 35:49So like I there's something about the way that 2010's
- 35:55Spielberg into 2020 Spielberg is shot and graded that it gives
- 36:01everything such a plastic look that like there's a milkiness to
- 36:07the lights and you know, like there's no such thing as like a
- 36:10pure white, like it's always tinted, especially in this
- 36:14movie. There's like tons of Blues, tons
- 36:16of green filters on everything. And, and ironically, I think
- 36:19towards the end of the film, it's like filtered less.
- 36:21You actually get much more natural tones on people's skin,
- 36:24but it's dark outside so you don't notice it as much.
- 36:27But. It it.
- 36:28Pulled me out of the movie and I remember it in the theater.
- 36:32It was during the America number, which they've updated
- 36:35now to happen during broad daylight, not at night time, you
- 36:39know, which again, we'll talk about some of these purposeful
- 36:41changes that I don't think work. And I just remember like I
- 36:45looked at the background kind of like behind the sets and I'm
- 36:47like, I think some of those buildings off in the background
- 36:50are CGII can't know for sure, but I think there's some CGI at
- 36:54play here. And it was, it was seamless in
- 36:59the way that like a lot of modern ILM stuff is kind of
- 37:04seamless where like I think ILM stuff just doesn't stack up the
- 37:09way it used to. And so it, it seemed to me like
- 37:14what we had actually created wasn't a seamless blend of like
- 37:17well done CGI and live action stuff in front of it.
- 37:21It ended up having the effect of like everything kind of looks
- 37:25computer animated to me. Everybody's skin looks a little
- 37:28bit too plastic. Everything is a little bit too
- 37:31Milky for me. And it's an issue that I've had
- 37:34with Spielberg for years and years and years.
- 37:36And I think this movie is one of my, I guess least favorite
- 37:41examples of that. And so I like, and it may also
- 37:46be just because I'm so partial to the look of the original that
- 37:51there are elements of this one where I'm like, I, I know that
- 37:54you're trying to be different. It just doesn't, and it's
- 37:59sludge. By far my biggest detraction
- 38:02from the film. Sludge was the word he used to
- 38:05describe this. There's some sludginess there
- 38:07is. So Bob, you are bringing up the
- 38:13America sequence as your example of this.
- 38:18Well, and I, I bring it up especially because that is
- 38:21purposely the most vibrant number in the movie.
- 38:26And so like, if that is like the apex of where we're going with
- 38:29how we're rendering colors and kind of like the crispness of
- 38:33things and everything else besides that is a more muted
- 38:37version of that. Then like I, I bring up America
- 38:39because it's like, if that's the most heightened we're getting
- 38:42with our, our colors and saturation and things like that,
- 38:45you know, let's compare that to the original.
- 38:47I just wish I had a bowl of popcorn right now to watch
- 38:49Patrick. This is May I ask how did you
- 38:56watch the movie? What do you mean?
- 38:59Oh, like I watched it on Blu-ray.
- 39:01I. Thought.
- 39:03I thought you were going to say, may I ask how many films have
- 39:07you colour graded Bob? Yeah, right.
- 39:10Well, that's part part of why I wanted to bring this up with
- 39:12Patrick is that like I am obviously not a film maker and I
- 39:15don't have a lot of the technical terminology for this.
- 39:18And so even yesterday, I'm like, who out there is like me and and
- 39:22has this complaint about Janusz Kaminsky.
- 39:24And I'm like Googling like I hate Janusz Kaminsky just to see
- 39:27like what comes up. And I don't hate the guy.
- 39:29I think especially like Schindler's List is amazing.
- 39:32Saving Private Ryan. No other cinematographer could
- 39:35have made that movie look like that.
- 39:36But it's it's really this 21st century Kaminsky stuff.
- 39:39So, and I kept seeing this complaint of like, it was Milky,
- 39:45comma desaturated color. And I'm like, Milky is the word
- 39:49I've been looking for. There's like this weird
- 39:51creaminess to everybody's skin tones that it, it just, it loses
- 39:56definition and it looks a little smudgy and it it has the effect
- 40:00of making everything look artificial to me.
- 40:05OK, so I'm. About to get schooled.
- 40:10I can see it in this man's face. I OK Kaminsky has shot every
- 40:15Spielberg movie from night from 93 onward.
- 40:20There are different eras of Kaminsky. 90s Kaminsky, of which
- 40:25there's only a handful of movies, does not look like
- 40:28current Kaminsky. There is then the early 2000s
- 40:33Kaminsky era where you've got where especially the diffusion
- 40:39filters really come out like like he isn't he's going really
- 40:45strong on especially look, I just saw a 35 millimetre print
- 40:48of minority Report last Saturday and Minority Report AI is where
- 40:54he's real as when those movies are just fucking glowing in a
- 40:59way that like the they're they are really strong looks that I
- 41:06and that I really like a lot. And and then you've got you got
- 41:10some of this into though, right there.
- 41:14Those two are kind of their own thing.
- 41:16But then you still like got especially like Munich War of
- 41:20the Worlds in 2005. He is getting more desaturated
- 41:24there. But still, you know, it's look,
- 41:29even even before Yanish, Steve loved backlighting everything
- 41:36again. I have Empire of the Sun paused
- 41:38in my living room, shot by Alan Daviao, who also shot ETI and
- 41:45and look, it's just again, people in rooms with light
- 41:49pouring in through the windows. That's how Spielberg has always
- 41:53liked to shoot things. But Kaminsky gets he he gets
- 41:57glowier than than anyone had before.
- 42:02And then you do get into the the 20 tens where it does feel like
- 42:07the the movie is do get grayer and they are moving a more
- 42:11desaturated. It's also an era where we should
- 42:14point out Spielberg is making a lot of like drama period pieces.
- 42:20You know, it's like Lincoln and Bridge of Spies and stuff like
- 42:24that. You know, movies where it's
- 42:25like, oh, it's like the Civil War are like Berlin during the
- 42:29Cold War and stuff like that where it's like, Oh yeah,
- 42:31Honestly, being kind of Gray does sort of make sense.
- 42:36And I am are like, you know, the Post.
- 42:38And here's the thing. I like the way all those movies
- 42:40look. I completely understand not
- 42:44vibing with the 20 tens era of Kaminsky Spielberg, because it
- 42:50is obviously it's they're all shot on film.
- 42:53The only exception is the BFG is the only Spielberg movie shot
- 42:56digitally because I think they had to just because so much of
- 42:59the movie is animated right. And I believe even ready player
- 43:031 the like real world sequences are shot on film and but I get
- 43:09not clicking with those. But like they're shot on film,
- 43:11but it's still very high speed film.
- 43:14So it like you, you you barely see film grain, but it's still
- 43:17all shot on film. I get not being into that.
- 43:23I I have always felt and even noticed among people I've I I've
- 43:26spoken with is just anecdotal that even Kaminsky haters have
- 43:33to give it up for West Side Story being like, you know what?
- 43:37This is an exception. Yanish just brought it so
- 43:42fucking hard on this film that that I'll like, I'll give him
- 43:48this one. And genuinely, I think this is
- 43:53like for me, the the like of of the the the Jonner Spielberg
- 43:59collaboration. It's like for me, it's like AI
- 44:05Minority Report, Schindler and this if we need if we need a 5
- 44:11Munich also. I've, I've and I'm, I'm making a
- 44:17video about the, about the filmmaking in Munich soon.
- 44:21And so I I'm going to be talking a lot more about that movie.
- 44:24But so here's the thing here, Bob, here's why your take is
- 44:27psychotic to me. Yeah, I love it because you're
- 44:32talking about it being Milky. We are living in an era that is
- 44:38while there are still plenty of great looking movies made every
- 44:41year, we are living in an absolute low point of visual
- 44:47quality of like cinematography in cinema.
- 44:51Because look plenty of great movies that are shot digitally.
- 44:54But the, I think the, the average level of like visual
- 44:58quality of talking purely aesthetics of, of average movies
- 45:02has really plummeted. And and because just so just
- 45:08whether it's like flat color grading, especially terrible
- 45:12looking exterior day scenes. It is just like so many movies
- 45:16just look like trash and it drives me insane.
- 45:21And here's the thing. A movie that I I I really like
- 45:25that I think is quite good that came out the same year as West
- 45:29Side Story and was shot in the same neighborhood is John M
- 45:31Chews in the Heights. I think I think a very good
- 45:35movie. You put these two movies side by
- 45:39side in terms of like how they look.
- 45:41And it's like, yeah, that is that is a that is a movie that
- 45:45is very grey and very flat and has some some good visuals in
- 45:48there. But like, but but truly it's
- 45:51just like there is a lack of contrast and a lack of
- 45:53definition to so much of it. And and obviously it gets way
- 45:56worse and wicked. But West Side Story has such
- 46:02contrast and, and the, the images are so rich and so
- 46:08vibrant and America is just like, again, America is 1 where
- 46:12what I talked about when I was on the last time where I am like
- 46:16almost tearing up just because of like the like the, the power
- 46:22of the, the movement and the color and the music on on screen
- 46:26with when there's that shot near the end of the sequence when
- 46:30like everyone like rushes by the camera and, and then, and then
- 46:34it cranes up and like, the like the color of Anita's yellow
- 46:38dress with like the red under like like lining to it is so
- 46:43like those are colors that we don't see in movies anymore.
- 46:47And the for instance. And The thing is, there are
- 46:49parts of West Side Story like the prologue that are very Gray
- 46:53and very desaturated. And those, and I think there
- 46:57that is used so deliberately where it's like, or, or like in
- 47:02Jet Song, where it's like, this is the rubble of this
- 47:06neighborhood. This place is being levelled to
- 47:09being built up into a fancy like Art Center for like for rich
- 47:14people. And these losers are fighting
- 47:18over piles of of like, you know, of, of rubble.
- 47:22This is like, like this is what this is like a like a burnt out
- 47:27like war zone basically. And then there are sequences
- 47:31like like the dance at the gym or America or, or any scene in
- 47:38Maria and Anita's apartment with all of you know, like the, the
- 47:42fabrics and sheets hang there that are so colorful.
- 47:46And these people have like, really rich lives that with
- 47:49like, you know, actual, like, like passion and excitement and
- 47:52love there. And And so I think colour is
- 47:55deployed so smartly in this movie.
- 47:58I think this is like a staggering work of visual
- 48:02storytelling and of cinematography.
- 48:04And I think I think this is one of the best looking movies ever
- 48:06made. And so, so, yeah, so, so
- 48:10disagree. So equating this to like it is
- 48:15just so outrageously beautiful and and and so equating this to
- 48:20like, I don't know, some like fucking Netflix movie with with
- 48:25just like shitty streaming cinematography.
- 48:28But you're when you're saying, oh, it's Milky and and doesn't
- 48:31look good. I'm like, well that's how a
- 48:33sludge again. I just watched first of all, 20.
- 48:35One you said sludge. But last night I watched the
- 48:382021 Mortal Kombat movie and that is Sludge.
- 48:43Yeah, well, like, first of all, I'm not going to argue sludge
- 48:45with Patrick. He made a whole video, like
- 48:47specifically about Marvel sludge.
- 48:49So like, no. Like I built my career on
- 48:53talking about shitty, desaturated, bland
- 48:57cinematography. West Side Story is the cure that
- 49:01that was like that when I saw this in theaters, I'm like the
- 49:06like, I, I felt like I was breathing oxygen for the first
- 49:10time in a year. I'm like, God damn it, like
- 49:12movies can look like this. And so all I'm saying is, Bob,
- 49:17you, you are not appreciating beautiful things.
- 49:21And it sounds like you, you have a, a really sad life.
- 49:24And I'm, I'm just sorry for you now.
- 49:27You know, the The funny thing too is like this is one of those
- 49:28areas where I'm like, I also know that Patrick can talk
- 49:32technically about this in a way that I cannot, But like I have a
- 49:36very strong opinion about it. And I think that like there are
- 49:40still moments in this movie where like, I will never argue
- 49:44that Janusz is not a master of his craft, right?
- 49:48Like the compositions in this movie.
- 49:50You know, I I love the look of the 61 Maria song where it's
- 49:56like these insane over saturated neon lights on Tony as he goes
- 50:02down the street in with the rear projection behind him.
- 50:06And then you get this burst of the like green, almost like
- 50:09stained glass that he comes across.
- 50:12And you get a moment like that in this one where he walks into
- 50:15the puddle. And if you it's, it's.
- 50:18So. Subtle because it's supposed to
- 50:20represent like the ripples of the water.
- 50:23But if you look really closely, there's actually a rig above
- 50:26that shot that's like gently rotating.
- 50:29And it's like, oh, dude, Giannis, you got that one right.
- 50:31Like there's moments, I think. Towards the end, the the puddle
- 50:35shot as it like a, a staggering like the, the, the, the, the
- 50:42scene when they're at the cloisters with like the, the
- 50:45light and the colours coming in through the stained glass and
- 50:49like changing colour on their faces.
- 50:51Like this is this is stuff that we do not see in movies anymore.
- 50:58I think there there have been moments where I've shared an
- 51:00opinion and like Brad has said something that like cut me to
- 51:04the core and it's been like really hurtful.
- 51:07And I feel like you probably took me down harder than Brad
- 51:12ever did. But I don't feel like I just
- 51:15feel so convinced of my own rightness about this topic that
- 51:18I'm like, that's fine. Like I.
- 51:19Here's the things of opinion. What we are discussing right
- 51:22here is pretty much like aesthetic taste.
- 51:25And so this is not even like, again, there's no right or
- 51:30wrong, but this isn't even like, it's a storytelling thing that
- 51:34will like, that's easier to argue about.
- 51:37Like is like, it's easier to like, like, you know, like argue
- 51:43or like change your mind about things.
- 51:45But it's like, look, if it's like when it comes to like
- 51:47colours, it's like, yeah, you like it or you don't like it,
- 51:51It's there's, you know, you can't be convinced to change
- 51:55your mind. Is there some sort of technical
- 51:59term though? And I'm not asking you to
- 52:01strengthen my argument for me, but like, do you understand what
- 52:04I'm talking about when I say that?
- 52:05There's like something about the way he's either diffusing light
- 52:09or adding filters or grading where it it almost makes like
- 52:14human skin look plastic at moments for me.
- 52:18No. OK.
- 52:19Well, here's what I can say. It's there's elements of just
- 52:23like the color grade that are simply manipulated in the
- 52:26colors. But it's also so much of this,
- 52:31it's not as simple as being like, oh, it's this one thing
- 52:33because what Kaminsky is doing is so complicated where so much
- 52:37of it is also like the light where all of the exterior day
- 52:41scenes like it. You look at the behind the
- 52:44scenes photos and stuff and they have giant lights rigged up on
- 52:50cranes to basically create extra sun.
- 52:54And so that's so that, yeah, that's why you, you know, you
- 52:58look at like you look at America and it's like, oh, this is,
- 53:02there is still, even though this is the middle of the day, there
- 53:06is perfect edge lighting on everybody.
- 53:09This is because again, also they just have a ton of money and
- 53:11like unlimited resources, but this is they, they can light
- 53:16exterior day scenes so immaculately and, and well,
- 53:21we've just been used to. So again, with digitally shot
- 53:26movies, exterior day is what they always have the most
- 53:30trouble with. That is all.
- 53:31Again, you, you look at, look at anything in, in Wicked or a
- 53:36Marvel movie or whatever. And it's like, even if it has
- 53:39good looking interior scenes, it just falls apart when they go
- 53:43outside. It just looks like, 'cause it's
- 53:45just, they just light it really, really softly and grate it in a
- 53:50really low contrast way. And it's, that's become the
- 53:53norm. And so West Side Story isn't
- 53:56trying to look realistic. It's, it's, it's, it's still
- 54:00doing like a magical movie lighting, but it's just like,
- 54:03oh, look, you can actually have magical movie lighting when
- 54:07they're outside as well. And so, so, yeah, it, it's, so
- 54:12you have, so it's the lighting, it's the color grade.
- 54:16It is. I, I will say he's not going as
- 54:19hard on diffusion filters and like netting the lens as he did
- 54:24on Minority Report. So the, the, the movie is not
- 54:29glowing as much as other Kaminsky films have glowed.
- 54:33I but yeah, but it, it, it's look the Yonnish has it's I, I'm
- 54:42not even an expert on, on how he does what he does, but it is the
- 54:45thing of like, look, he, he almost only works with Spielberg
- 54:48and has such total mastery of what he is doing that he can
- 54:54that, that he, you know, the entire process from start all
- 54:58the way through post production, he can basically manipulate
- 55:01everything to get exactly what he's looking for.
- 55:04And so I can't tell you what he does where, but but yeah, I, I,
- 55:10I, I sort of know what you're talking about in terms of some
- 55:13skin tones, but in general. But yeah, but I'm, I'm like,
- 55:17well, when you talk about the America sequence, I'm like,
- 55:20you've, you've lost me there because that's where you've lost
- 55:22me. Because, because, Because that
- 55:24is that does not look like the prologue does.
- 55:27Yeah, yeah, I get that. All right.
- 55:29So you can understand where I'm coming from, but I'm still
- 55:32generally wrong is what I'm getting here.
- 55:35No, no, I'm there, there. There's no right or wrong.
- 55:38It is. It is just simply, to me, a
- 55:41truly deranged opinion you should go to jail for.
- 55:45Yeah, love it. Love.
- 55:46It, but it's not wrong. I can agree with you on that and
- 55:50still say like it's not. You could have.
- 55:52Captured like the dull grayness of what, the first scene Jet
- 55:57song, whatever, without also adding like that cheap looking
- 56:01blue ass filter on top of it. Like there's just some decisions
- 56:05in the color grade that bothered me.
- 56:07I can't believe we've been talking about this for 15
- 56:09minutes. Brad, it's important you opened
- 56:11the floodgates here and this is clearly we have lost listeners
- 56:14at a staggering rate. No, they're, they're joining
- 56:17just for this. Part.
- 56:19That's what I'm saying. It's.
- 56:21Like a live broadcast, people are being like, yo, you got to
- 56:23listen to film and whiskey. Willem's this is is screaming at
- 56:27Kaminski. Kaminski Well, Brad, let me
- 56:31pause us here because we are almost an hour in.
- 56:34I think we need to drink this whiskey.
- 56:36We'll come back and I will continue.
- 56:38My I have so many hot takes on this.
- 56:40I'll get into Spielberg and what I think he did poorly in this
- 56:43movie. After our whiskey break, Brad,
- 56:45let's hit pause. Let's drink some Penelope
- 56:48Riviera. What do you say?
- 56:49That was everything I could have ever hoped it would be.
- 56:54I knew I was hoping in a can. I didn't know quite what was in
- 56:58it, but that was a can of whoop ass.
- 57:00And and I think we need to drink whiskey.
- 57:05Let's get to it, Bob. All right, everybody, we kicked
- 57:14Patrick out so that we could come do a whiskey review today.
- 57:17And we've got a brand that we haven't talked about in a while.
- 57:19It's the Penelope brand, which Brad, we have a great history
- 57:24with Penelope. So I'm very excited to dive into
- 57:26today's whiskey, which is called Riviera.
- 57:30Now Riviera is an interesting blend of whiskeys and I'm going
- 57:34to pull up the spec sheet just to make sure I say it all
- 57:36correctly. So Riviera blends 8 year
- 57:40American light whiskey with straight bourbon and is then
- 57:44finished in rose wine casks from Southern France.
- 57:48Now there's two things to note here.
- 57:49Number one, we have had the Penelope rose finish before and
- 57:53it is freaking phenomenal. So I'm very excited to return to
- 57:58anything finished in Rose from Penelope.
- 58:01The other thing is American Light whiskey, which is a
- 58:04category that we've only dipped into maybe once before, It has a
- 58:08very different set of rules from bourbon or rye, kind of similar
- 58:12to what we have when we drink corn whiskey on the podcast.
- 58:15So American Light whiskey was developed kind of as a response
- 58:19to the growing trends through the 60s of people moving away
- 58:23from brown liquors and towards like vodka's.
- 58:26And so like, you know, a while back we did a review, gosh, this
- 58:29was back in like maybe season 3 Seagram's 7.
- 58:33And so one Ave. that some whiskeys took, like Seagram's 7
- 58:37was to just basically cut their whiskey with what's called
- 58:41neutral grain spirits, basically vodka.
- 58:43We're just blending vodka and whiskey.
- 58:46And hopefully people who like vodka will drink, drink this
- 58:48whiskey. The other route that they went
- 58:50was what's called light whiskey, which is you basically make it
- 58:53the same way you make whiskey, but you distill it to a way
- 58:57higher proof point. So like 160 to 190 proof.
- 59:01It basically strips a lot of the grain character out of it and
- 59:04then they age it in used barrel so that it doesn't get some of
- 59:07those like harsh tannins from the the barrel itself.
- 59:10So it's aged for much longer, similar to corn whiskey.
- 59:13And the resulting whiskey ends up tasting like this very
- 59:16wonderful matured whiskey. It's just made a completely
- 59:20different way. So this is 8 year light whiskey
- 59:23that's blended with straight bourbon.
- 59:24I've been talking for two minutes straight.
- 59:26Brad. I'd love to hear your thoughts
- 59:28before we dive into this, Penelope.
- 59:30Yeah, I'm always fascinated when people take different
- 59:35experiences of whiskey and blend it together into something new.
- 59:39So I'm I'm intrigued. I have good feelings and vibes
- 59:42towards Penelope already. So yeah, I'm excited to get in,
- 59:46man. All right, now, you just
- 59:47finished drinking this before we jumped on the horn here, so
- 59:50you've got notes ready to go. I'm drinking it live.
- 59:53This is how we do it, folks. I'm going to start nosing this
- 59:55while Brad gives his notes and I'll tell him whether he's right
- 59:58or wrong. Yeah, as I got into the nose on
- 1:00:01this, it really had a ton of floralness.
- 1:00:05There was like a, it lacked the Tang of a traditional Peach.
- 1:00:09It reminded me more of like a white Peach.
- 1:00:11There was table grapes. It had some citrusy kind of
- 1:00:14orange peel vibes. It's a really pleasant nose, but
- 1:00:18it's not anything that like makes me super excited.
- 1:00:22So I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10 here.
- 1:00:24I I think it's good. I'm curious to see where we go
- 1:00:27on the palate. Yeah, I actually share a lot of
- 1:00:29notes with you on this one. I'm going to give it a 7.5.
- 1:00:32But so with light whiskey, we've been finding it increasingly
- 1:00:36more popular in the market. I think during the whiskey boom
- 1:00:39when people just had nothing else to make, they were like,
- 1:00:41let's do light whiskey. And so now we're getting 1518
- 1:00:45year aged light whiskey being released and that stuff is
- 1:00:48phenomenal. eight-year light whiskey.
- 1:00:50That's nothing to sneeze at. But because it doesn't pick up
- 1:00:53as much of that wood character as a charred or a new charred
- 1:00:57barrel would have it, it just takes a lot older to really get
- 1:01:01that maturity. And the fact that they're
- 1:01:03blending this with straight bourbon, it doesn't say how old.
- 1:01:06So maybe four years, but I mean, it only has to legally be two
- 1:01:11years to be called straight bourbon.
- 1:01:13I don't know how old the actual balance of this whiskey is, and
- 1:01:18I think it smells a little bit youthful to me now.
- 1:01:21It's what's kind of masking that.
- 1:01:23Are these citrusy, bright notes that you're getting?
- 1:01:26There's a ton of like lemon peel, orange zest.
- 1:01:29There's just a ton going on here that keep it in that like bright
- 1:01:33floral headspace. I do kind of wonder though, if
- 1:01:36that youthful sense I'm getting on the nose is going to creep up
- 1:01:40in the taste. But for now, 7 1/2 on the nose.
- 1:01:43Yeah, I think that the. Palate as I got into drinking
- 1:01:47it, it reminded me a lot of of of rum almost.
- 1:01:51It has a very cane sugar vibe going on.
- 1:01:54There's vanilla bean that white Peach sticks around for me.
- 1:01:58It's got a nice soft peachy tone without much of the tanginess.
- 1:02:02I it's a really pleasant whiskey.
- 1:02:05I once again, there's nothing that like makes me get out of my
- 1:02:08chair and get excited, but it's a solid experience to drink.
- 1:02:12I'll come up a little bit here. I'll give it a 7 1/2.
- 1:02:16Yeah, I'm going to stick right in the same realm that I was
- 1:02:18before. I'm going to beat a 7 out of 10
- 1:02:19on this one. I think you're on point today,
- 1:02:21man. It, there is a lot of rum
- 1:02:23character to it because even an aged rum, you know, if you get
- 1:02:26like a three-year, 4 year aged rum, it's like, wow, they left
- 1:02:30this rum in the barrel for four years and it it stays in that
- 1:02:33kind of like simplistic sugar note.
- 1:02:37This has that. And I will say, like part of the
- 1:02:41reason you use light whiskey is because it's supposed to be a
- 1:02:44lot softer and not carry those like tannic flavors with it.
- 1:02:48This definitely has a lot of like it has that kind of toasted
- 1:02:51barrel char ashiness to me, coupled with like a black tea
- 1:02:57tannic kind of quality, which if they were trying to avoid that,
- 1:03:01like it's it's definitely here for me.
- 1:03:03I don't think it's a bad whiskey, but I'm going to give
- 1:03:05it a 7 out of 10. The tea notes is right where I
- 1:03:09was going on the finish. To me, it's almost like you took
- 1:03:12a Peach tea and added like legitimate black tea to it and
- 1:03:16you get a little bit of that bitterness that comes through on
- 1:03:20the back end. The vanilla turns into like a
- 1:03:22vanilla protein powder more than like fresh vanilla, and the
- 1:03:27orangeiness turns into like an orange rind on the back end.
- 1:03:31I don't dislike the finish. It definitely drops off a little
- 1:03:34bit for me. I'm going to give it a 6 1/2
- 1:03:36here. I mean, I don't think that it is
- 1:03:39a mistake that they released this in the spring.
- 1:03:41This is definitely like a springtime floral kind of summer
- 1:03:45sipper. For me it's 94 proof, which I
- 1:03:49think is a perfect proof point if you do want to mix it with
- 1:03:51something and if you threw this into like an iced Peach tea in
- 1:03:55the summer. It'd be great.
- 1:03:57This is like a great porch sipper.
- 1:04:00Again, we're we're drinking it neat though.
- 1:04:02So those finished notes, everything I got on the pallet
- 1:04:04is sticking around on the finish there.
- 1:04:06You know, I don't know if they used used charred barrels or
- 1:04:09uncharred barrels for the light whiskey, but there's definitely
- 1:04:12some of that kind of tannic charred note going on in the
- 1:04:14back of my pallet. The vanilla is there, but like
- 1:04:18you said, Brad, it doesn't like overwhelm anything and the
- 1:04:21orange becomes more of like an orange pith rather than orange
- 1:04:24zest. So once again, I'm going to be
- 1:04:26at a 7 out of 10 here. I think I will give it a 7.5 on
- 1:04:29balance. It's a it's a perfect like 3 out
- 1:04:32of four-star whiskey for me. Where where you falling on the
- 1:04:36balance bread? I think I'll come down a little
- 1:04:38bit. I, I don't think there's enough
- 1:04:40complexity here for me to give it over A7 or even add a 7.
- 1:04:44I'll give it a 6 1/2 out of 10. I I think it's relatively well
- 1:04:48balanced. There's nothing that like comes
- 1:04:50out of left field, but but there's nothing about the
- 1:04:53experience that I'm like really passionate about.
- 1:04:56S 6 1/2 now value in the illustrious state of Ohio.
- 1:05:01This will set you back $79.99. So it's an $80 whiskey.
- 1:05:07And that for me, Bob is, is kind of the breaking point on this.
- 1:05:12I feel like it's a 45 to $50 quality.
- 1:05:17You know. $87.00 with with tax I I'm going to give it a 4 1/2 on
- 1:05:23value Bob. Yeah, I'm at a 5 out of 10 on
- 1:05:26value I. Think this is for like a
- 1:05:27Penelope completest. Like if this is your brand, try
- 1:05:31it out. I will say, you know, this is
- 1:05:33the first thing we've had from Penelope in a while.
- 1:05:35Thankfully, we have another bottle of something coming in
- 1:05:37the mail or they might cut us off after this review.
- 1:05:40But we really like Penelope and I especially like the Rose
- 1:05:44finish. If you just get the regular
- 1:05:45Penelope rose. I do think that that is because
- 1:05:49of the sweet notes of the bourbon.
- 1:05:51It's it's leagues better than this one is.
- 1:05:54Now, is this a fun summertime mixer?
- 1:05:56Absolutely. I don't know that would ever
- 1:05:58recommend paying $80.00 for it. So if Penelope is your thing,
- 1:06:02maybe you want to shell out for it.
- 1:06:04I'm going to give it a 5 out of 10 on value.
- 1:06:06And that brings me to a 34 out of 50.
- 1:06:09Brad, where are you falling on this one?
- 1:06:11Just a little bit lower at a 32 out of 50.
- 1:06:15All right. So we're averaging A33.
- 1:06:17Or a 66 out of 100 and that puts us just shy of the 35 mark where
- 1:06:22we typically start recommending. I will say like, I don't think
- 1:06:26that this is a, if you just said like in a vacuum, good whiskey,
- 1:06:29bad whiskey, this is not a bad whiskey.
- 1:06:32I think the the price point is probably the biggest detractor
- 1:06:36from me giving it a thumbs up if we're just talking about the
- 1:06:39juice. Like, yeah, I would give this a
- 1:06:41hesitant kind of thumbs up if you find a pour at the bar or if
- 1:06:45you see it on a friend's shelf. It's definitely worth trying.
- 1:06:48Just can't recommend $80.00 for it.
- 1:06:50Yeah, the $80.00 is a little bit of a deal breaker.
- 1:06:52For me, everything you said is where I'm at, Bob.
- 1:06:55So yeah, look, look at us, man, on the same page.
- 1:06:59We may not be on the same page about.
- 1:07:00West Side Story or Yanish Kaminsky.
- 1:07:03But we are on the same page about Penelope Riviera.
- 1:07:06That's right. I love it.
- 1:07:08All right, man, let's. Get back to talking to.
- 1:07:09Patrick Williams about West Side Story.
- 1:07:11What do you say? Let's get to.
- 1:07:13Let's get to it. All right, everybody, that was
- 1:07:19Penelope. Riviera, a whiskey that feels
- 1:07:24pretty similar to Bob's take on on a boy Janusz.
- 1:07:31Now I I thought it was a pretty. Good whiskey, Brad.
- 1:07:33I just don't. Think it was worth 80 something
- 1:07:35dollars is where we landed on that one.
- 1:07:38Now I will, I will get down off of my apparently wrong high
- 1:07:42horse about Yanis Kaminsky and his weird plasticine people in
- 1:07:47these movies. But you know what it is?
- 1:07:50It's that the the people in Spielberg movies recently have
- 1:07:54looked like the characters in Robert Zemeckis's Welcome to
- 1:07:57Marwin, and that's out of here. Just get out of here, Bob.
- 1:08:01I just sort of like, don't know what you're talking about, Bob
- 1:08:05there. Are movies where I would agree
- 1:08:08with you and and I'm just like like that that that would be, I
- 1:08:13think a good observation on some films.
- 1:08:16But to be like West Side Story, I'm like, what, What are you
- 1:08:20talking about? Have I, I know you have glasses
- 1:08:23on right now, but I think maybe you need to like go check your
- 1:08:27prescription and update perhaps. I have glaucoma as well and
- 1:08:30that's what I'm starting. To realize, oh, are there any
- 1:08:33scenes you thought looked? Good, yes, and actually.
- 1:08:38That's a thank you for. Teeing me up with that, I think
- 1:08:41one of the areas that I really loved what Spielberg did this
- 1:08:45time around is the sort of like the balcony, wherefore art thou
- 1:08:50Romeo scene. Because in the original, and I
- 1:08:53mentioned this then Brad, it's the first instance of like Tony
- 1:08:56and Maria where the movie freaking grinds to a halt
- 1:08:59because it's not the dance and it's not the cool little like
- 1:09:01ballet at the dance. It's the next scene and they
- 1:09:04have that shitty song and like it's just it's so bad where
- 1:09:08she's going like Tony, Tony. I hate that song.
- 1:09:11And in this version, it's like, Hey, let's pull out some great
- 1:09:16Spielberg wonners. And at one point they're like,
- 1:09:20you know, he's he dollies in across like the face of that
- 1:09:26grating to frame them even closer.
- 1:09:29And I'm like, this is when you get Spielberg to move the
- 1:09:32camera. A scene like this, which has
- 1:09:33absolutely no forward momentum. He creates it.
- 1:09:37And I will also give points to Kaminsky because they for being
- 1:09:42a a much more lifelike set in that scene.
- 1:09:48They just straight up go stage lighting.
- 1:09:50And when she comes out on the balcony, it's like, let's just
- 1:09:53throw a spotlight on her. You know?
- 1:09:54It's like, let's just do that. Why not?
- 1:09:56And it's you don't. You don't even question, like,
- 1:09:58where's the spotlight coming from?
- 1:09:59Because it just makes sense for the dramatic stakes of that
- 1:10:03scene. So I thought that that was like
- 1:10:05a clear upgrade from the 61 version.
- 1:10:08Yeah. How about the dance of the?
- 1:10:10Gym that's I am neutral on that. I thought that like.
- 1:10:17How in terms of like, is it an improvement or is it like worse?
- 1:10:22I think I'm in the nude. Like they're both they both
- 1:10:24serve their own purpose. And I love when they drop all
- 1:10:28the lighting out from behind them in the 61 version.
- 1:10:30And they kind of exist in this dreamlike state.
- 1:10:34Whereas in this one, it's like, let's physically remove them
- 1:10:37from the dance and put them behind the bleachers so that
- 1:10:39they can have that moment with each other.
- 1:10:40But they but they still both work.
- 1:10:42But they still. When they go into the.
- 1:10:43Bleachers like you can. See through the bleachers and
- 1:10:46nobody else exists. I thought that was like a really
- 1:10:49nice call back to the original and also in that sequence of the
- 1:10:53original when everyone. Else kind of fades out and they
- 1:10:55have kind of have just like these sort of like glowy lights
- 1:10:58appear. They do a similar thing here,
- 1:11:01but the and and they really use like Spielberg doesn't often
- 1:11:04shoot on anamorphic lenses and he does on this and but he kind
- 1:11:11of waits until until Tony and Maria see each other.
- 1:11:15Then the anamorphic lens flares come in really hard.
- 1:11:20As in like it's, it's basically like stars appearing when these
- 1:11:25two see each other and then and, and like the light pouring in
- 1:11:29when they're under the bleachers.
- 1:11:30I'm just like this, like this is like as good as cinema gets
- 1:11:34right here. And like, this is like the light
- 1:11:36and color in that sequence again, I'm just like, this is so
- 1:11:41rich and vibrant and just. And the way that they are
- 1:11:45manipulating the lighting in an unrealistic way where it's like,
- 1:11:49it makes emotional sense, but there isn't really a real
- 1:11:54tangible diegetic reason for why the light is suddenly changing
- 1:12:00like at this moment, other than that they're feeling something.
- 1:12:03I think that is staggering. And it like, I get kind of like
- 1:12:09choked up just by like how good the filmmaking is.
- 1:12:13And also, again, I feel something about this
- 1:12:16relationship because of the work being done.
- 1:12:21The the one thing I I'm. With you Patrick.
- 1:12:24I love the dance scene in the 2021 version.
- 1:12:27Love it in the original as well. The one change, Bob, you asked
- 1:12:31earlier, like what are some changes that we might not have
- 1:12:33liked? I know that.
- 1:12:36Spielberg was going for a little bit more.
- 1:12:38Of a movie feel. And so the moment that Tony and
- 1:12:42Maria see each other it it makes more sense in a movie for it to
- 1:12:47be a little more subtle, a little more like, OK, the
- 1:12:51clearly they notice each other, but nothing really changes.
- 1:12:53The whole scene is still happening.
- 1:12:55I freaking love in the original when they see each other and it
- 1:13:00it's not immediate that everybody else disappears, but
- 1:13:04the way it's like this kind of radial blur.
- 1:13:07Where they like there's only focus in one part of the shot
- 1:13:10and everything else is out of focus.
- 1:13:12I freaking love that in this version.
- 1:13:13I like what they did though because.
- 1:13:14They they have. Like he films a lot of the dance
- 1:13:17scene with long lenses. And so you you have almost this
- 1:13:21kind of like observational documentary, like when Tony and
- 1:13:24Maria see each other, there's like layers of people between
- 1:13:28the camera and Tony and they're all walking by while these two.
- 1:13:32Figures like are are remain standing in place.
- 1:13:35Yeah, yeah. I thought.
- 1:13:37I thought it was a really. Elegant way of kind of solving
- 1:13:40what is admittedly like a cheesy look in the original.
- 1:13:44That kind of like smudgy focal thing.
- 1:13:46It was cheesy but I freaking loved it.
- 1:13:49I don't know what it is, but that's like one of the things
- 1:13:51from the original I loved the most.
- 1:13:55All right. Do I get into my Spielberg hot?
- 1:13:58Take. Or do we save that for the end
- 1:14:00of the episode? No, now let's RIP that Band-Aid.
- 1:14:03Off do it. OK.
- 1:14:08My overarching complaints about. Musicals in the 21st century
- 1:14:12Brad this is well documented on our podcast is that I think
- 1:14:16generally speaking this does not apply to Spielberg but like
- 1:14:19generally speaking, film makers have forgotten that the best
- 1:14:25tool in their. Like.
- 1:14:28Arsenal the best weapon? In their arsenal is putting the
- 1:14:32camera down in a fixed spot and simply panning back in.
- 1:14:37Like just swinging the camera back and forth as Fred Astaire
- 1:14:41or Gene Kelly moves along a horizontal plane in one space
- 1:14:46because you get the the camera stops being a distraction and
- 1:14:50you get the full effect of that person's kinetic dynamism.
- 1:14:56And I think that like when you watch classic MGM musicals.
- 1:15:00So I mean, unless you're doing like Busby.
- 1:15:02Berkeley stuff like. So much of it is just like,
- 1:15:05here's the camera, we're going to go this way, we're going to
- 1:15:08go this way. We're not even tracking really.
- 1:15:10We're just kind of like panning back and forth and it creates an
- 1:15:14incredibly dynamic moment because the performers are so
- 1:15:19dynamic now. I think we've also lost like
- 1:15:22really, really great triple threat actor singer dancers in
- 1:15:26cinema like since the studio system collapsed.
- 1:15:29But I think that so much of what film makers have done to try to
- 1:15:33compensate for that is like, we're going to get really.
- 1:15:37Inventive with the. Camera and how we move the
- 1:15:39camera within musical numbers. And I think a lot of times it
- 1:15:43has the opposite effect where it's like, this would have been
- 1:15:45better if I had more of a sense of the movement of the dancers
- 1:15:51and the camera wasn't taking away from that.
- 1:15:54So enter Spielberg. Perhaps.
- 1:15:57The greatest mover of the camera we have ever had.
- 1:16:02There are moments in this movie where it's like, that's an
- 1:16:05awesome touch. I just talked about the balcony
- 1:16:07scene. The way he moves the camera in
- 1:16:09that scene gives it a forward momentum that it never had
- 1:16:12before. Even in like the the dance at
- 1:16:14the gym, there's a moment where like Riff swings Graziella like
- 1:16:21head first towards the Sharks girls and you get this like whip
- 1:16:27pan and like immediate push in as she almost like smacks her in
- 1:16:31the face. And it's like, that was a really
- 1:16:34cool shot. You know, the moment in cool
- 1:16:36where they're fighting over the gun and they slam their hands on
- 1:16:39the ground with the gun and you get the like tilt down.
- 1:16:42It's it's a really cool and dynamic shot.
- 1:16:45There are other times in this movie, and I guess this is the
- 1:16:47furthest I'll go with the criticism where I'm like, I wish
- 1:16:51Spielberg would kind of just like put the camera on a tripod
- 1:16:55once in a while and let the kinetic energy of the dance tell
- 1:17:00the story without him feeling the need to assist with the
- 1:17:04camera movements. That's like, that's the farthest
- 1:17:07I'll go with it. I still think that like he moves
- 1:17:11the camera in incredible ways in this movie.
- 1:17:14I just kind of wonder sometimes, like is he overly cocky in the
- 1:17:19way? That he moves the.
- 1:17:20Camera or do you think that maybe he didn't trust himself
- 1:17:22enough because this is his first musical, to kind of leave it
- 1:17:25alone? Sometimes it just feels like
- 1:17:27there are moments in this movie where the camera's a little busy
- 1:17:30for me. That's as far as I'll go with
- 1:17:32it, Brad. Maybe not as hot as I wanted it
- 1:17:34to be. I would say at this point, Bob,
- 1:17:36I think you. Do need to keep it cool?
- 1:17:42I think that a world where. You know, David tried to kill 2
- 1:17:47Goliaths in a row, we wouldn't know who David was anymore.
- 1:17:51So it's probably wise. You've slung your stones at
- 1:17:55Kaminsky. Hold back on Spielberg a little
- 1:17:58bit. I I will say to.
- 1:18:02Mildly defend Bob here. I can understand this take even
- 1:18:10if I don't really agree with it. While the commit while like the
- 1:18:14lighting and color take, I just thought was like deranged.
- 1:18:19Yeah, just just. Deranged stuff.
- 1:18:21Just like like that's like you, that's that should be illegal to
- 1:18:24say. Like like I'm adapting in real
- 1:18:27time. That's what we're, Yeah, but no.
- 1:18:29We need to suspend. Bob's First Amendment.
- 1:18:32Rights because of that take, I mean, we.
- 1:18:36Probably should have done that a long time ago, but sure I but it
- 1:18:40is the thing like the camera does move a lot in this movie
- 1:18:46and I, I I can again, I don't agree, but I understand the
- 1:18:51argument for maybe chill out a bit more.
- 1:18:54I, I I will say that. So I, I, I.
- 1:19:01Think this movie. Contains several of the most.
- 1:19:04Staggering musical numbers ever put on film just once I I
- 1:19:09rewatch frequently because I just again, it's that you know
- 1:19:15the it's it's that West Side Story combo of some of the
- 1:19:18greatest music ever written. Shout out Leonard Bernstein.
- 1:19:22And then just you know, our our greatest living visual
- 1:19:27storyteller on knowing how to just how to capture movement to
- 1:19:35In Sync with with this music to just an astounding degree there,
- 1:19:42especially when you look at 21st century musicals.
- 1:19:46It is amazing how long the shots.
- 1:19:51Are. In this compared to literally
- 1:19:53everything else you look at like, I mean, especially, you
- 1:19:57know, Rob Marshall, one of the only people allowed to make
- 1:20:01Hollywood musicals because he made Chicago 1st and won an
- 1:20:04Oscar. And then they're like, well, now
- 1:20:06you make half the musicals that exist.
- 1:20:08But it's like, yeah, it's, it's, you know.
- 1:20:12It's weird looking at Chicago now and it's like, Jesus Christ,
- 1:20:15this guy came from the theater and he's cutting like every
- 1:20:17second on like just like like the body parts of the dancing.
- 1:20:22And and then you, you look at the sort of like there, there
- 1:20:26are parts in America and the, the dance, the gym where he just
- 1:20:32the camera basically stops moving and he just holds on a
- 1:20:35really wide shot that lasts for like sometimes up to a minute.
- 1:20:42And it is and, and like, and constantly it is the shots are
- 1:20:46wide. You can see not just a body, but
- 1:20:49many, many human bodies all moving together.
- 1:20:52You can see the choreography. And I think it's this, look,
- 1:20:57what I will say about Spielberg's musical numbers is
- 1:20:59the same thing I'll say for his action scenes where the guy just
- 1:21:04like knows when the. Camera should move.
- 1:21:07When to cut, He just has this innate savant, like,
- 1:21:11understanding of this medium better than basically anybody.
- 1:21:15And so, yeah, So all these musical numbers, like, even
- 1:21:20though the camera is very active and it's doing a lot, there's
- 1:21:24never a point where I can't tell what's going on for me.
- 1:21:27There's again, for sure, this is just me.
- 1:21:30There's never a point where what the camera is doing does not
- 1:21:37connect with with what the. Music is doing.
- 1:21:40And in general, it's something where I think the he makes the
- 1:21:43camera a really incredible part of the choreography, as if it is
- 1:21:49another dancer. And I think it is so beautifully
- 1:21:52In Sync with what the dancers are doing.
- 1:21:56And of course, you've got something like tonight, tonight.
- 1:21:59Is it tonight tonight or just tonight?
- 1:22:02I think it's just tonight, OK? I yeah, don't.
- 1:22:04Write. Write tonight.
- 1:22:05Tonight, tonight is the smashing pumpkin song and with, with,
- 1:22:12with a great music video. But I but tonight, because that
- 1:22:17that song, it obviously it it does, it's not a dance number.
- 1:22:21And so the camera there is doing so much storytelling, especially
- 1:22:25in that sequence where, yeah, Tony and Maria are separated by
- 1:22:30like like the grading and the fire escape for so long until
- 1:22:32finally like Tony vaults over the the side and they are like,
- 1:22:38like together there. And it is just, it's so elegant
- 1:22:40and so impressive. But then you just, you've just
- 1:22:43got like America, you just have this, you know, this huge group
- 1:22:48of people in brightly colored clothing just dancing in in the
- 1:22:53middle of the street as the camera elegantly, you know,
- 1:22:56cranes up and that and I'm like almost reduced to tears because
- 1:23:00it's, it's just so beautiful. Or you got I look, I could do
- 1:23:04this all day. I, I, I promise I will, I will
- 1:23:07limit myself. But you've got the beginning of
- 1:23:10the dance, the gym where you have this insane shot.
- 1:23:14I where it fought like it. It's got Tony, sorry, not Tony
- 1:23:22Bernardo and Anita and Mariardo and and and and Chino as they're
- 1:23:25walking down the hall and then and it's like on a steady Cam
- 1:23:30and it follow goes back to them and then pans with them.
- 1:23:33And then they go through the doors into the gym.
- 1:23:35And then it turns into a crane shot that swoops up over
- 1:23:39everyone there and then lands down on almost like on the floor
- 1:23:44right as the dancers like, land perfectly into frame.
- 1:23:48And then it like dollies left and like, like, it keeps it it
- 1:23:52it is what he's doing here. Is just like again.
- 1:23:56In the 21st century, there are no musical numbers on this
- 1:24:02level. You know, almost all of cinema,
- 1:24:04this is this is really like, this is some of the best shit
- 1:24:09ever. And and I, I again, I could go
- 1:24:15on about it all day. And again, because it's like,
- 1:24:16look, if you're going to do West Side Story, if you're going to
- 1:24:19do these songs that have already been executed so well, you'd
- 1:24:22better, you'd better. It's you know, it's like, it's
- 1:24:27like the, the, the the seat on The Simpsons where, you know,
- 1:24:30where Barney picks up the, the glass of beer that's come out of
- 1:24:33a bowling ball and goes, this is better be the best beer I've
- 1:24:37ever had. You got lucky and it's it's just
- 1:24:42that it's. Like, yeah, OK, OK.
- 1:24:44Good job. You made the best musical
- 1:24:46numbers of all time. OK, OK, We'll, we'll we'll allow
- 1:24:49it. I think that this highlights
- 1:24:51like. For me it's it's the difference.
- 1:24:53Between two film makers and I, I really did feel the need in our
- 1:24:56last episode to kind of go to bat for Robert Wise as a person
- 1:25:01with a visual sensibility because I don't think he gets
- 1:25:03credit for that enough. And so like, you know, this is
- 1:25:06really simplistic and this is not the correct terminology, but
- 1:25:10when I think about like shot composition, I think about if
- 1:25:15we're imagining a shot like a still frame, how are we
- 1:25:19composing it within the frame without the movement of the
- 1:25:22camera involved? Now I know that that is part of
- 1:25:24what we consider shot composition.
- 1:25:25But like, I think when I'm talking about Spielberg, I think
- 1:25:28I think of it almost as like shot choreography versus what
- 1:25:32wise was doing a lot, which was stationary camera.
- 1:25:36The whole background of the frame is a gigantic tenement
- 1:25:40building. We will see, you know, coming up
- 1:25:44from behind a mound of rubble, 3 sharks.
- 1:25:47And it will be the coolest framed shot you'll ever see.
- 1:25:50And I think that there's like, there are moments in this movie
- 1:25:53where I'm like, I'm with you. Like he does stop moving the
- 1:25:56camera and it adds it adds weight to those moments because
- 1:26:00you almost notice that we have stopped for it's like we've been
- 1:26:03hurtling through this thing. Why are we stopping right now?
- 1:26:05What do I need to pay attention to?
- 1:26:07I also think that there's like a level of confidence that someone
- 1:26:10like a Robert Wise doesn't typically get credited for to
- 1:26:15just be like, you know what, we're going to make the coolest
- 1:26:18shot of all time. It's going to be inside of this
- 1:26:20tree line in the Sound of Music with Maria just weaving through
- 1:26:24these trees. Like it's just, it's freaking
- 1:26:25gorgeous. And the the level, like the
- 1:26:28interplay between what's stationary and what's moving, I
- 1:26:32think is just as dynamic as what Spielberg does by, like, moving
- 1:26:37the camera through a crowd of people.
- 1:26:39Yeah, This is why. I'm, I'm not coming in here
- 1:26:43being like, oh, the original or sorry, the, the Spielberg 1 is
- 1:26:47better because it wouldn't exist without the original.
- 1:26:51And I don't, I don't think it replaces it.
- 1:26:53But then there are things that you look at where I'm like, Oh
- 1:26:57yeah, I like the Spielberg. Version of G Officer Krupke is.
- 1:27:05Just like I I think so much better and so much more fun than
- 1:27:10the original 1. Yeah, it's.
- 1:27:14It's that's. Dude and and I.
- 1:27:16Will you know what? I have one person on my side
- 1:27:18with this, Your friend Sidant. I read his review because I was
- 1:27:23like, I want to see what he said about this.
- 1:27:25He also agreed with me that like something gets lost in the
- 1:27:28Officer Krupke number here and I don't and and you know, in his
- 1:27:31review, this is something that like, I don't know if it's a
- 1:27:34casting thing or if it's a Spielberg thing.
- 1:27:37He makes great note of the fact that there's not a level of
- 1:27:41individuality to The Jets and Sharks the way there are the way
- 1:27:45there is in the 61 version where those guys have very distinct
- 1:27:49faces. I know what every single one of
- 1:27:51those people looks like. And so by the time you get to
- 1:27:54like cool or whatever it is, you fully know each of their
- 1:27:58personalities. And I felt like this time
- 1:28:00around, Officer Krupke was just like it.
- 1:28:03It was just missing something to me.
- 1:28:06And Brad, I'd like to hear your take 'cause I think you actually
- 1:28:08mentioned Officer Krupke to me when we were talking about it
- 1:28:11yesterday. I think Officer Krupke and I.
- 1:28:14Am not as familiar with the original 61 film.
- 1:28:18To me it felt like they tweaked it just a little bit so that
- 1:28:23rather than in the original where it feels like all the
- 1:28:26different characters they introduce themselves to, you
- 1:28:30know, there's the judge and the psychologist and the social
- 1:28:32worker and so on, in the 61 version it feels like they are.
- 1:28:39All saying the same. Thing about the kids the teens
- 1:28:43whereas in this one in the 2021 version it feels more accurate
- 1:28:47to real life the the real life justice foster you know, teen
- 1:28:56legal. System, if you will.
- 1:28:59Where? You know, the judge says, oh,
- 1:29:01well, they don't need to be in jail.
- 1:29:02They need to see a psychologist. And the psychologist says, oh,
- 1:29:05well, they they need to see a social worker.
- 1:29:07And the social worker says, oh, no, they need to go to jail.
- 1:29:10And and it feels way more accurate to the dysfunction of
- 1:29:15our governmental system in trying to help kids.
- 1:29:19And so I I really thought that that small change paired with
- 1:29:24the a little more dynamism in the movement of the camera in
- 1:29:29the in the dance. I also don't as soon as you said
- 1:29:33that the characters in the original. 1.
- 1:29:35Felt more distinct. I was like, yeah, because I
- 1:29:37don't care about the main characters in the movie, whereas
- 1:29:41in this one I care so much about the classic problem.
- 1:29:45Too. Like, you know, I think we had
- 1:29:47this. Conversation, Brad, even.
- 1:29:49With like Beauty and the Beast, there are just certain stories
- 1:29:52where your main characters are kind of fundamentally the most
- 1:29:55boring characters in the movie. And like it, it's the, it's the
- 1:29:59supporting characters that make the movie.
- 1:30:01And that was especially true in the 61 version.
- 1:30:03I think to some extent it's true here.
- 1:30:05I I cannot allow you to. Impugn my favorite 90s Disney
- 1:30:12film I I have never once. Said.
- 1:30:16That the main characters of Beauty and the Beast are
- 1:30:19extraordinarily boring. You might have said that, and I
- 1:30:22will allow you to have your own wrong opinions.
- 1:30:25I just needed to be known that I did not say.
- 1:30:28All right. Well, for the record, yeah, Brad
- 1:30:32prefers to spend time. With the beasts whining
- 1:30:35throughout that whole film. But let let me let me steer us
- 1:30:38into this. I think it's time to think 1.
- 1:30:40Can I say 1 brief thing? About Officer Krupke, please.
- 1:30:44I do. Agree.
- 1:30:46That by the other members of The Jets and the Sharks do feel a
- 1:30:52little more they they pop a bit more in the 60s version.
- 1:30:56I totally feel they feel a little sludgy in this.
- 1:30:59Version they they they do as much as like there are.
- 1:31:02Some like good faces there. I can't tell you most of their
- 1:31:05names. I, I will say, and I think this
- 1:31:11ties into what Brad was saying about Officer Krupke is that
- 1:31:16they just feel. More.
- 1:31:18Believably, like actual gangs in this one, like this, like this
- 1:31:25sequence is set in a police station.
- 1:31:27It's like, yeah, like, yeah, like even just little things
- 1:31:30like, oh, Riff has a couple tattoos, stuff like that where
- 1:31:34I'm like, you know, oh, I believe that these guys actually
- 1:31:39now, you know, have, you know, have been arrested multiple
- 1:31:46times. Actually, again, these are not
- 1:31:48just like dancing, like, you know, colourfully costumed,
- 1:31:54quote UN quote like gang members.
- 1:31:56It's like, Oh no, these are actually people who have like,
- 1:31:58you know, who are like, like, you know, like been like, you
- 1:32:02know, falling through the system and stuff like that.
- 1:32:04And so the stuff that that that G Officer Krupke like is about
- 1:32:10like it does actually feel like it's more directly connected to
- 1:32:13these characters as as they're presented here, even though I
- 1:32:17don't feel like I know these guys as well as the ones in the
- 1:32:2160s film. But also, and maybe it's just
- 1:32:24that I've watched the movie a bunch of times and I was just
- 1:32:25noticing it like on this rewatch.
- 1:32:27I just think the choreography of that number here and the way
- 1:32:32it's shot and the way it uses just the set of the police
- 1:32:36station is just so fun. Dude when they lift up the
- 1:32:40bench. And use the bottom of the bench
- 1:32:42as the bars. It's so freaking good dude.
- 1:32:45It's great. And and also that one part where
- 1:32:47there's the one. Woman who is also just holding
- 1:32:50there what is cuts to her just watching them like what I do
- 1:32:55like the thing of without ever like drawing a lot of attention
- 1:32:58to it. It's a rare thing in a musical,
- 1:33:01but it is almost as if like like.
- 1:33:05A bystander is there being. Like, are they singing and
- 1:33:09dancing right now? Yeah, like it.
- 1:33:12Well, and early in the. Movie there's a there's like a.
- 1:33:14Diegetic moment where Bernardo is singing and he, he, and is it
- 1:33:20Krupke or what's the lieutenant's name?
- 1:33:24Shrank. Shrank.
- 1:33:25Sorry, I think it's Shrank. He goes, Oh, he's a boxer and a
- 1:33:28crooner, and you're like, oh, like this is a this is a
- 1:33:31diagenic moment. He's really singing in a
- 1:33:33musical. Is that?
- 1:33:35Is that the part after? The prologue when they just
- 1:33:37start and I, I don't know what the name of the song is, but
- 1:33:39when they're just sort of like singing the the song in Spanish
- 1:33:42national anthem, yeah and which. Again, is just.
- 1:33:46One of those little touches where it's like, oh, right,
- 1:33:48yeah, these, these do. These are believably immigrants.
- 1:33:51And The Jets are explicitly presented here as they are
- 1:33:55racist in a way where in the 60s one, it is much more like, oh,
- 1:33:59right. It's just it's two rival gangs.
- 1:34:01It's like, no, these guys are just harassing immigrants.
- 1:34:05Yeah, Yep. Can I 100% I I?
- 1:34:09Want to talk? More about that later.
- 1:34:10Bob I. Don't want to interrupt you
- 1:34:11though. I know you.
- 1:34:12You wanted to go. No, Brad, I I think that's the
- 1:34:15perfect thing to do 'cause I, I. Have something to say on that as
- 1:34:17well. Let's let's make sure we talk
- 1:34:19about the cast though, because I feel like we're running a little
- 1:34:21bit long because of my Yanish takes.
- 1:34:24I I will shut up, I promise. No, no, it's not.
- 1:34:28It's not you. It's me.
- 1:34:29Triggering. You I I think that maybe the
- 1:34:33most. Fun.
- 1:34:34Way to do this is like, yes, let's give some small notes on
- 1:34:36each person, but I want to just say like, are we picking the 61
- 1:34:40person who played this character or the 21 person who played this
- 1:34:43character? And I think we have to have the
- 1:34:46the briefest of disclaimers about the Ansel Elgort stuff.
- 1:34:50We've talked about it before with Baby Driver.
- 1:34:52Ansel Elgort seems like a real creep, which is in many ways a
- 1:34:57bummer because I think a lot of people now, now that he is like
- 1:35:01an established creep, want to kind of crap on his sometimes
- 1:35:06wooden seeming acting style. I've always liked Ansel Elgort.
- 1:35:10I will, I will go out on a limb and say I like him in this
- 1:35:13movie. I think that hey, Tony's given
- 1:35:14much more to do in this movie, but it's it's not a secret that
- 1:35:18Richard Baymer in the original is just not really that good of
- 1:35:22an actor. He's a pretty face and he is
- 1:35:24he's a gorgeous man, but like, you know, that's about all he
- 1:35:27is. He's also not even doing his his
- 1:35:29singing in that. Movie No.
- 1:35:32So like, I think this is a pretty easy Ansel Elgort
- 1:35:35victory, especially when you consider like I, I, I watched
- 1:35:40Cool and then paused it and rewatched the entire number
- 1:35:45again because he is basically having a dance battle with Mike
- 1:35:49Feist, who is a trained Broadway performer.
- 1:35:53Ansel Elgort, Not a singer, but does a great job singing well.
- 1:35:57He went to La Guardia High School.
- 1:36:00He's from Manhattan. But no, Elgort has been a like
- 1:36:05musical theatre like trained guy for he wasn't like a Broadway
- 1:36:09star, but I but it is the thing of like in cool.
- 1:36:14I think he and and you, you see some of it in baby driver as
- 1:36:17well. He moves so well.
- 1:36:19He's also very tall, has long limbs.
- 1:36:22But then I'm like, damn, I I wish he got another dance
- 1:36:26sequence because he is and and and you know, he has like he
- 1:36:30gets to to move in something's coming.
- 1:36:32But I do think he he's just a he's a he's a physically.
- 1:36:38I think he's very good on screen and I wish he got to do more of
- 1:36:41it because I think he's very good and cool.
- 1:36:43It is something again, putting aside, you know, allegations or
- 1:36:48whatever, just looking at his performance, I feel like he's so
- 1:36:50often brought up in this movie is like, Oh, everyone's great,
- 1:36:53Just a bummer. L Gord is there like sucking in
- 1:36:57the middle of I'm like, I think, I think he's maybe like.
- 1:37:05Of the of the principles I. Think he's maybe by default the
- 1:37:09weakest, and I think he is totally so I think he's pretty
- 1:37:13good in this movie. I think Tony is the nature of
- 1:37:17the character, always the least interesting character in the
- 1:37:20movie. And and I think I think he's
- 1:37:23pretty good. I think look, you know, he has
- 1:37:25several big songs. I I think he hits them all.
- 1:37:28I believe the Tony Maria relationship.
- 1:37:31He he works for me and I I you know, like, like you just said,
- 1:37:35Bob, I think he has an upgrade over Richard Beamer.
- 1:37:37Yeah, IA 100% He I would put him at.
- 1:37:40Like AB, like he's a really strong B.
- 1:37:44Nothing about his performance draws me out of the experience
- 1:37:49of the film. Also a quick Fact Check, both
- 1:37:53Timmy C and Ansel Algort LaGuardia High School.
- 1:37:58Very good. Patrick, Hey, you know I'm here
- 1:38:01to. Give New York trivia.
- 1:38:03That's right. Rachel Zeigler is an
- 1:38:07interesting. One for me.
- 1:38:08She's also now become the subject of like way too much
- 1:38:11online hate for seemingly no reason, just for existing and
- 1:38:14being Snow White. And I will say that I would
- 1:38:17choose Rachel Zegler over Natalie Wood for 95% of this
- 1:38:22movie. Obviously Natalie Wood didn't do
- 1:38:24her own singing. Rachel Zegler is a phenomenal
- 1:38:26talent and I think a a better actress for most of the movie
- 1:38:32except for the key final scene when Tony dies.
- 1:38:37I think that like, she's a little green still.
- 1:38:40And I think it shows in that moment where, you know, I came
- 1:38:44on the last episode and I raved about Natalie Wood where I was
- 1:38:47like, I, I kind of didn't like her until that last scene.
- 1:38:49She freaking nailed it. And so like, that's the only
- 1:38:52part where I would say I think Natalie Wood actually kind of
- 1:38:54beat Rachel Zeigler for me. You can probably just CGI her
- 1:38:58in. Just kind of scrub it in.
- 1:39:00Yeah, like deep fake, right? Yeah, there's also the thing
- 1:39:03worth pointing out. And we'll.
- 1:39:05We'll bring it up when we discuss Bernardo as well, where
- 1:39:08it's like, you know, 1 is like a Latina actress and and 1 is a a
- 1:39:14white person basically for sure. So there's that as well.
- 1:39:18But like, I, I think, look, I, I also, I don't know Rachel at
- 1:39:23all, but we have some mutual friends.
- 1:39:25And so by all accounts, like, I'll just say really lovely
- 1:39:29person. But I, I, and I actually, I, I
- 1:39:32became a fan of her before this movie came out because she
- 1:39:36appeared as a guest on, on my friends have a comedy show
- 1:39:40called the George Lucas Talk Show.
- 1:39:42And she was a guest, She's a recurring guest on that show.
- 1:39:46And I I was like, Oh my, she's so cool and like she hasn't even
- 1:39:50and like I haven't even seen her act yet, but I think it like
- 1:39:53what? Just watching this again
- 1:39:55yesterday. I'm just like, I think she's
- 1:39:57like, this is like. Kind of a.
- 1:40:00Revelatory like debut performance.
- 1:40:03I think I I she like you, you love to see an introducing
- 1:40:09credit, which we don't get very often.
- 1:40:12And I'm just like, right. This is just like an instant
- 1:40:15star. She just nails it and is so
- 1:40:19good. And I, I, I do agree that I, I
- 1:40:22think the one, the one places I think Natalie Wood is stronger
- 1:40:27in that final scene. But in general, I'm like, yeah,
- 1:40:30I'm, I'm giving it to Ziegler Absolutely, for sure.
- 1:40:35Brad any. Any Ziegler comment you guys?
- 1:40:37You guys nailed it. I I can't add anything.
- 1:40:40I truly I as I was watching it so many times throughout.
- 1:40:45I thought that. Her and Al Gore's chemistry was
- 1:40:47great, brought a brought the relationship to life, but also
- 1:40:53her and Anita, Ariana Dubose, like them two together, just had
- 1:40:59an electricity to the way that they had this sisterly
- 1:41:03relationship that I I thought Zeigler really was incredible.
- 1:41:10OK, we've talked. About Riff quite a bit, so I.
- 1:41:13Think this is this could be a very quick who you picking
- 1:41:16Tamblin or Feist? Go Feist.
- 1:41:20Feist. I take.
- 1:41:23Feist as well, but it's close like I don't.
- 1:41:25I don't hold it against Tamblyn. He was really good.
- 1:41:27If Tamblyn had some tattoos, would you pick him it?
- 1:41:32Is. I I, I think, I think.
- 1:41:33Bobby, you said it. Earlier that just Like Tamblyn
- 1:41:36just didn't have as meaty material to play.
- 1:41:41And So what? Feist has more to work with, but
- 1:41:44Riff is just so much more compelling as a character.
- 1:41:49Like Tamblyn is great to watch. He's a great dancer, love to see
- 1:41:52him and anything and it it's just like like Feist is like a
- 1:41:55fully realized character who is just like, he's like electric in
- 1:42:00this movie. Yeah.
- 1:42:02Now Bernardo is a really tough one for me and.
- 1:42:05We obviously are getting back to the like George Shakiris, a very
- 1:42:09white person in very brown face in the original, right?
- 1:42:13Like he played riff on the West End, was found there and then
- 1:42:17offered Bernardo. And so like, yes, I, I, I get
- 1:42:21that. What is the difficult thing for
- 1:42:23me is that they play this character in 2 completely
- 1:42:27different ways. And it's because Kushner gives
- 1:42:29Bernardo like the boxing back story where Shakira says
- 1:42:34Bernardo is like a, he's a charmer.
- 1:42:36Like he's just, he, he wins you over.
- 1:42:39And he is so charismatic. He's and this version of
- 1:42:43Bernardo is like he's a hot head, but you also like you
- 1:42:47completely understand why he feels so defensive about the
- 1:42:52people that he loves. And so I think they're both
- 1:42:54really excellent. And and Brad, I'd love to hear
- 1:42:57if you had to pick. 1. Who would you go with?
- 1:42:59Because I really do think there's an argument for both of
- 1:43:01them. Yeah, I think that 2021.
- 1:43:06Bernardo has a little more umph to his character there.
- 1:43:11I think he I think the character works better as a charmer.
- 1:43:16And so I like I think that's why I would lean towards Shakira's,
- 1:43:21but I I don't have a that's not a strong take from me.
- 1:43:26But I yeah, I do think that the character just works better as a
- 1:43:30smooth talking when people over with his charm kind of guy than
- 1:43:35this stocky like I'm going to beat the crap out of you now.
- 1:43:40I will say the one place where that like is lights out when
- 1:43:47Ansel Al Gore is standing at the at the brawl and he just takes
- 1:43:53the punches and he takes like 8 or 9 punches in a row.
- 1:43:58You feel that because of who is playing Bernardo.
- 1:44:02And I do think that that adds to the the elements at the end of
- 1:44:06the film there. Patrick who we going with
- 1:44:08Alvarez or Shakira. This is tough.
- 1:44:10I I. Think I'm I think I have to go
- 1:44:13Alvarez. It also again, it just, it just
- 1:44:16feels wrong to me to be like, I'm gonna pick a guy in brown
- 1:44:20face. I just like, I I don't want to
- 1:44:23get cancelled for that look. I despite the problematic nature
- 1:44:27of the casting, I love Shakira's in the original and especially
- 1:44:31like as a dancer like in in America, which I think is, is I
- 1:44:37think my favorite number in both films.
- 1:44:39I just the way Shakira's moves, it's just one of my favorite
- 1:44:44things in cinema. I love that.
- 1:44:47But Jakiris is my favorite stuff that he has in the in that movie
- 1:44:52is mostly when he's not talking. It's mostly just him as a
- 1:44:56physical presence and just like his his really like his great
- 1:45:01eyes and his dancing. And in the 2021 film with
- 1:45:07Alvarez, I'm like, I believe his relation, his protectiveness of
- 1:45:12his little sister and his relationship with Anita like
- 1:45:18more and and his protectiveness for his whole community that
- 1:45:22comes through so strongly there, which I think just again deepens
- 1:45:26the entire film. And so I've got to go Alvarez.
- 1:45:30There you go. All right, last one and then we
- 1:45:33can kind of touch on. Minor characters, if we want to,
- 1:45:36is Anita. Now, this is an incredibly
- 1:45:38difficult one because we're talking about two people who
- 1:45:41both won the Oscar for their performances.
- 1:45:46I think that I will throw the gauntlet down by saying.
- 1:45:48Ariana Dubose. Is incredibly good in this
- 1:45:53movie, but I think the most revelatory thing about
- 1:45:57revisiting. 61. West Side Story for me was
- 1:46:01watching the ways that Rita Moreno as an actress, whether
- 1:46:06it's within a song or during dialogue, is given a very tied
- 1:46:14to its moment written character and adds so much color to that
- 1:46:20character that it's like I I know for a fact that if Tony
- 1:46:24Kushner handed Rita Moreno this script in 61, we would have
- 1:46:28gotten a performance that is equivalent to what Ariana Dubose
- 1:46:31gave in this movie. I don't know if I put Ariana
- 1:46:35Dubose in the 61 version if she could have made a character that
- 1:46:41had less to do on the page as compelling as Rita Moreno did.
- 1:46:45So I'm I'm going to have to go with the OG on this one.
- 1:46:50Same. Yeah, they're both.
- 1:46:53Fantastic, they're both. Stand outs in each movie.
- 1:46:56But Moreno is the stand out in the 61 film, like hands down.
- 1:47:02And also, you know, bonus points for be being so good as a
- 1:47:07completely different character, like in her 90s in the 2021
- 1:47:11film, right. Yeah, Rita Bruno, just great,
- 1:47:17really great. Yeah, in in both films she is
- 1:47:20better than the person. In the other film, that's true.
- 1:47:25She she, she is way. Better than Doc, I'll give her
- 1:47:28that much. For sure.
- 1:47:31Yeah. Rita Moreno Is Doc better than
- 1:47:33Doc? Rita Moreno is.
- 1:47:34Anita better than Anita? I'll take it.
- 1:47:40I I will say I. Was very happy to see Corey
- 1:47:42Stahl. Show up as Lieutenant Shrink.
- 1:47:45He is a super underutilized actor who I fell in love with as
- 1:47:49an actor when he was on House of Cards.
- 1:47:51I thought he was just freaking phenomenal on that show.
- 1:47:54And then all he's really done in Hollywood seems to be shitty Ant
- 1:47:57man movies and I just wish that we gave my guy more more
- 1:48:00chances. I I love Corey Stoll he should
- 1:48:03be in way more stuff. He's he's an alum of the college
- 1:48:07I went to. And so, OK, no shout out guy who
- 1:48:11went to College in Ohio. That's right.
- 1:48:13But I all of us. But yeah, I, I actually, when I
- 1:48:16rewatched it for this, I was like, I forgot he was in it and
- 1:48:20I was like, hey there, there he is with hair.
- 1:48:24He kind of feels a great hairpiece.
- 1:48:26I have never seen him in. Anything he kind.
- 1:48:28Of reminded me of like a. Slightly taller.
- 1:48:31A little bit like lankier Tom Hardy.
- 1:48:35Interesting. I don't know if that vibes.
- 1:48:37With you guys, but. That's like I found myself a
- 1:48:39few. Times being like.
- 1:48:41Wait, that's not Tom Hardy. Well, come on, Brad, I Corey
- 1:48:47soul is great. Does your?
- 1:48:48Deranged take Yeah, does. I mean, he's, he's like a.
- 1:48:51Great. Like.
- 1:48:53You know, New York actor does a lot of theatre.
- 1:48:56He's on a lot of TV shows. He is I he's never not good.
- 1:49:04Love it. Brian Darcy James shows up.
- 1:49:06In a thankless role as Officer Krepke.
- 1:49:08Good to see him again. We've only talked about him in
- 1:49:11in his supporting turn in Spotlight on this.
- 1:49:14He's so good in Spotlight. Nice to see him again.
- 1:49:17He's real good, Real good in Spotlight.
- 1:49:19Guys, I think that we've arrived at the point Brad wanted to
- 1:49:22touch on something before we get out of here.
- 1:49:24Brad, you, you told me to hit pause on a conversation earlier.
- 1:49:27I'd like to hear you get up on your soapbox.
- 1:49:31Both Patrick and I have done it, so it's your turn now.
- 1:49:34Well, here's it kind of happened, Patrick, when you were
- 1:49:37just. Railing Bob about Kaminsky?
- 1:49:44Is that what I was doing? I mean, you know, wow.
- 1:49:49I feel. Violated what?
- 1:49:53What I. Realized and I I don't totally
- 1:49:55know how I made the connection. It but as you were talking about
- 1:49:59the color and the lighting that that's what it was you're
- 1:50:02talking about the color in the America scene.
- 1:50:06It made me It made me think about the.
- 1:50:09Jets. And it made me think about how
- 1:50:12The Jets are consistently portrayed and, and blacks and
- 1:50:15Grays and jeans and right, they're just kind of dirty and
- 1:50:19they look like the concrete rubble that they're trying to
- 1:50:23protect. And it, it got me starting to
- 1:50:26think about the overall messaging of this movie
- 1:50:29specifically. And what I really love about
- 1:50:33this movie is that when you think about who The Jets are,
- 1:50:37like, The Jets are the final children, the final generation
- 1:50:44of a bunch of poor Irish, Italian immigrants that came to
- 1:50:50the country 100 years before, right?
- 1:50:55The Puerto Ricans are new to America.
- 1:50:58They are bright and vibrant and hopeful.
- 1:51:02And they? Have this deep desire to claim
- 1:51:05all that America has to offer. And the women see all the hope.
- 1:51:11And in America you see them with their brightness and vibrancy
- 1:51:15and they want to buy things on credit and they want to get
- 1:51:17these apartments and and all these things.
- 1:51:20And yet the men see the danger of America.
- 1:51:25They are fighting The Jets. They're on the streets scrapping
- 1:51:30for a living. And so they are afraid that if
- 1:51:34they stay here in America, they're going to end up like The
- 1:51:37Jets. That's what their ultimate
- 1:51:39outcome is. And I think that.
- 1:51:42The movie takes on this fascinating reflection of like
- 1:51:48you are seeing the end stage of white immigration in America.
- 1:51:53And it's very clear that some white immigration has gone on to
- 1:51:57have power and money and prestige and all the things.
- 1:52:00And yet some elements of white immigration has ended up in the
- 1:52:04slums in under the rubble of of the city.
- 1:52:10And now we get to look at it from the new immigrants to.
- 1:52:13America. And what they are trying to get
- 1:52:16out of it and what they're afraid of and what they're
- 1:52:19hopeful for. And I just, I just found myself
- 1:52:21appreciating the movie even more.
- 1:52:24So to say that it's it's not just The Jets being racist.
- 1:52:29Was that like they are? That is very clear, but it's
- 1:52:33also like they are a mirror that the.
- 1:52:38Sharks and. The Puerto Rican community as a
- 1:52:40whole are looking into to say man like, like, we don't want to
- 1:52:45become like them. How do we avoid that?
- 1:52:48And like, I don't, I don't know if I'm just completely off my
- 1:52:50rocker with this take, but that's been like noodling around
- 1:52:55in my brain ever since you were talking about Kaminsky and
- 1:52:58America and color, color schemes for the movie.
- 1:53:01Yeah. I mean, I think that for me the
- 1:53:04the biggest win. That you get by Kushner kind of
- 1:53:08adding stakes right from the beginning is that he immediately
- 1:53:13establishes not not just that like this is a a zone under
- 1:53:18construction, but that like this entire neighborhood is going to
- 1:53:21be leveled. We are fighting over like this
- 1:53:24is the last gasp of what you know for The Jets like what my
- 1:53:29parents and grandparents were here for like I'm fighting this
- 1:53:32to the death and for the Sharks it's like this is the first
- 1:53:37place we've been able to call home.
- 1:53:38We have nothing else we want to be able to say that like this is
- 1:53:41our territory now. And so it it almost has this
- 1:53:44sort of like, you know, doomed who's going to be the last one
- 1:53:48off of the planet before the asteroid crashes into it kind of
- 1:53:52a thing. Like there there is this this
- 1:53:54weightiness that's added to it in a way that the 61 version
- 1:53:57doesn't have. And it also helps explain
- 1:54:01everybody's hot headedness and why they're so it like so
- 1:54:04volatile all the time. It's because there's this sort
- 1:54:07of like ticking time bomb situation happening apart from
- 1:54:11their tension with each other, it's their tension with like the
- 1:54:14city around them that's crumbling.
- 1:54:16I just I think that like adding that it, it really does remind
- 1:54:20me in a lot of ways. You know, we talked about the
- 1:54:22color palette of the original mirroring like do the right
- 1:54:25thing. But I think in terms of like
- 1:54:28dramatically, this one kind of mirrors do the right thing
- 1:54:31because you have that sort of like there's, you know, it's the
- 1:54:34hottest day of the year. There's a ticking time bomb.
- 1:54:36This is going to explode eventually.
- 1:54:38You get that sort of same dramatic stakes from the fact
- 1:54:41that like we're leveling this to build Lincoln Center and I think
- 1:54:44once again, that is what gives more.
- 1:54:47Depth to Tony and Maria's relationship is that this isn't
- 1:54:51just about two kids who fell in love.
- 1:54:54Like because of how Riff and Tony are situated, you can
- 1:54:58actually tell that Tony is trying to lift himself up beyond
- 1:55:04the place that he came from, which is what all of the whole
- 1:55:07Puerto Rican community is trying to do as well.
- 1:55:10And so the the idea that we could work together and fall in
- 1:55:16love in order to better both of our lives it it.
- 1:55:20Mimics this. Idea that if The Jets, if The
- 1:55:23Jets and the Sharks were willing to work together, that they
- 1:55:27could all work together to lift themselves up.
- 1:55:30And yet what do they get brought down by?
- 1:55:33Well, petty jealousy and evil racism and this territorialness
- 1:55:39that sinks the entire ship, the, the 2 standard bearers of the
- 1:55:45two communities are dead at the end of the movie.
- 1:55:48And it's their hatred that also sinks the rising ship of Tony
- 1:55:54and Maria, a partnership that could have represented
- 1:55:59cooperation between two racially diverse communities.
- 1:56:03And I'm, I'm just like, I, I don't know.
- 1:56:06I'm just like geeking out about this.
- 1:56:07I think it's a fascinating subtext to the movie that I I
- 1:56:11like I didn't think about before until we sat down and talked
- 1:56:14about it today. Yeah, a thing that I was
- 1:56:16thinking about on this re watch is.
- 1:56:19Also, I feel like everything I'm about to say is like really
- 1:56:21obvious stuff, but whatever, I was thinking about it anyway.
- 1:56:25But I'm like, I look, this has several of the best songs like
- 1:56:29ever written in it. But I really think the most
- 1:56:36important song in the whole thing is Somewhere, because
- 1:56:40fundamentally West Side Story is basically just about a whole
- 1:56:46bunch of people who all they really.
- 1:56:48Want is to belong. Somewhere and that's it, whether
- 1:56:53it's the the The Jets who are just desperately trying to hold
- 1:56:56on to like the only thing they have as it's as they that they
- 1:56:59think is being taken away from them.
- 1:57:01Obviously the Puerto Rican just want a, a, a new home.
- 1:57:05It's why I, I think the like the, the, the changes to to
- 1:57:10anybody is, is one of the like, like the smartest changes, like
- 1:57:13in this version, because they just want to belong like in a
- 1:57:20group. And, and so and like somewhere
- 1:57:23basically just like lays out like this.
- 1:57:26This is like this is just what the the entire story is about.
- 1:57:31Just like there's a place for us and and and I think all of these
- 1:57:36beyond truly beyond just like, you know, I think, you know,
- 1:57:41Spielberg and Yanish's like staggering work here and a
- 1:57:45really extraordinary cast. I think what makes this movie
- 1:57:49like really special and the the places where it does, I think
- 1:57:55exceed the original R Kushner's changes like two of these
- 1:58:00scripts that just deepen that central idea even more.
- 1:58:08All right, guys, I think it's time for us.
- 1:58:10To get into our final segment. Of the day which?
- 1:58:12We call Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:58:16episode, so thanks listening to the film and.
- 1:58:19Whiskey Show. Let's have another film with
- 1:58:21this one, even if it's struggling.
- 1:58:22It's the final segment of the day now.
- 1:58:24Let's make it a double now. I've been thinking through this
- 1:58:28whole episode. What would I pair West Side
- 1:58:31Story 21 up with? You know that's not the obvious
- 1:58:34OG 61 version. I'll kick us off because,
- 1:58:38Patrick, I can see you have forgotten that we do this every
- 1:58:40time. So I'm gonna give you.
- 1:58:42I've got my answer. You got it.
- 1:58:45You know what? Let's do this, then let's give
- 1:58:46Patrick. I don't know if you.
- 1:58:48Wanna first dibs here? I don't know if you wanna keep
- 1:58:50poking Patrick, man. It's.
- 1:58:54OK, it's OK. We.
- 1:58:56Like all of our animosity is in the past.
- 1:59:00Yeah, we're we're like The Jets to the shots at the very end.
- 1:59:02After several people have died. We're walking together down the
- 1:59:06street, holding the corks as Brad's as Brad's dead arm.
- 1:59:11Flops over, you come. Over and grab his arm next to me
- 1:59:15as we March him down the street. Yeah, Patrick, go right ahead.
- 1:59:19What's your Let's make it a double here, Mad Max Fury Rd.
- 1:59:27If my children were not sleeping immediately above.
- 1:59:31Me right now I would be screaming witness me as loud as
- 1:59:35I can Brad I I I'm honored to hear that I.
- 1:59:41The The only thing that could have made the ending of this
- 1:59:43movie better is if. Right before shooting, Tony
- 1:59:47Chino just like sprayed silver all over his face, then came out
- 1:59:52in the street. It is.
- 1:59:54It is truly in terms of like. Major studio films in the 21st
- 1:59:59century. I I really think those are, at
- 2:00:03least for me the 2 like most, purely thrilling.
- 2:00:09Films on just. On a film making level and
- 2:00:12especially just in terms of like like pure cinema, like I said a
- 2:00:18million times, movement and light and colour.
- 2:00:23And music. And all of those things that
- 2:00:25these. Movies are so different, but
- 2:00:27they are like, I really struggle to think of two films that that
- 2:00:33offer such transcendent, just cinematic experiences.
- 2:00:37And I'm like, if I, if I spent like, I don't know, like 4 1/2
- 2:00:41hours watching the two of those back-to-back, I'd, I, I'd feel
- 2:00:45like I could just run through a brick wall.
- 2:00:47Yep, Patrick I so I did not see Fury.
- 2:00:51Road in theaters. I'm have.
- 2:00:54Have you had a chance yet? I have it.
- 2:00:57Trust me when I say the moment I see it.
- 2:01:00Showing anywhere you got to come to New York, a place here like
- 2:01:03every year. That might be our next trip,
- 2:01:06Bob, so just to see. Fury Rd.
- 2:01:10I sometimes just. Based on life scheduling, I can
- 2:01:14only watch a. Movie at like 5:30 AM before I
- 2:01:16start the work day and all that, right?
- 2:01:19I love that Patrick appreciates that.
- 2:01:21I'm sure that Patrick has watched a movie at 5:30 AM at
- 2:01:23some point in his life. So I got up one day and I
- 2:01:27watched Mad. Packs.
- 2:01:29Fury Road for the first time in my life from like 5:30 to 7:30
- 2:01:34and no joke this is the only time this has ever happened in
- 2:01:37my life. I texted my buddy Steven, who I
- 2:01:39know loves Fury Rd. It was like, bro, I, I need you
- 2:01:43to come watch Fury Rd. with me tonight.
- 2:01:45I literally have not been able to stop thinking about it.
- 2:01:48Like, I'm like doing dishes, like just immersed in the world.
- 2:01:53And he came over that night and I watched that movie twice in
- 2:01:57one day. Let's go.
- 2:02:02I love it, dude. Oh.
- 2:02:03My gosh. I.
- 2:02:06Well, I guess I'll come. Down off of that mountaintop for
- 2:02:09my let's make it a. Double unless Brad, do you want
- 2:02:11to go first? Yeah, I'll go.
- 2:02:12I I think did last time when we did the.
- 2:02:16OG did I? Choose.
- 2:02:18Do the right thing. I don't know.
- 2:02:21I'm trying. I don't know what I mean, but
- 2:02:23you can. Do it again if you want to.
- 2:02:24Well, I was thinking about. Do the right.
- 2:02:26Thing and I was. Like I think I picked that
- 2:02:28before. So I'll pick another one.
- 2:02:29I think that I want to pair this with if Beale Street could.
- 2:02:33Talk. I thought nice.
- 2:02:36I think that there's. Something about the way.
- 2:02:39That they shoot a couple being in love when all the odds are
- 2:02:44against them that like the vibe of if Beale Street could talk is
- 2:02:49like very different than West Side Story and the kineticism of
- 2:02:53it. But like, there's still that
- 2:02:55same thrust of a of a story and, and what they're trying to do.
- 2:03:03And it's a very beautiful movie. So there you go.
- 2:03:06I'll give you if Beale Street could talk a good answer.
- 2:03:09Yeah, dude, I. Well, and Brad knows.
- 2:03:12If Beale Street could talk is. Like one of my top 10 movies of
- 2:03:14the century. So I think he's trying to coax
- 2:03:17my score on this up a little bit by comparing it to Beale Street.
- 2:03:21I would never do something, Bob. I'm gonna go with a movie.
- 2:03:25That's pretty recent here. And it's because one of my.
- 2:03:28Favorite additions by Kushner in this version is this random
- 2:03:33scene of Rif procuring a gun for the rumble where they go in this
- 2:03:39bar and you get this great, like you remind me of your dad and
- 2:03:43you get the the kind of unwritten rules of like
- 2:03:45illegally buying a gun of him just being like, leave it on the
- 2:03:48counter. Don't hand it to me, you know?
- 2:03:50And it reminded me so much of this really vivid bar fight
- 2:03:55scene in the 2023 movie The Bike Riders, which is an incredibly
- 2:04:02underrated kind of study of 1960s, you know, biker gangs
- 2:04:09that I think was just, like, way overlooked.
- 2:04:12And the more I thought about it, it's not just the bar scene, but
- 2:04:16it's this study of a group of men who do not know how to
- 2:04:20express their feelings, who are violent people because they are
- 2:04:24like emotionally immature and scared.
- 2:04:27And I think that there's like way more parallels to it,
- 2:04:30especially this version of West Side Story, you know, than the
- 2:04:3361 version. I really cannot recommend the
- 2:04:36bike riders highly enough. It was one of my favorite movies
- 2:04:38of 2023. And I don't think I've ever
- 2:04:40gotten a chance to talk about it on this podcast.
- 2:04:42Brad, I, I've never heard you mention it.
- 2:04:44So I appreciate it. I really like that movie.
- 2:04:47I agree it's underrated. Real.
- 2:04:49Also, Really. Good answer, thank you.
- 2:04:52I I redeemed myself a little bit.
- 2:04:53Mad Max Fury Rd. Is the right answer to every
- 2:04:57Let's make it a double yeah you know The Sound of Music, Mad Max
- 2:05:03Fury Rd. there's. Some reason that you can.
- 2:05:05Justify that it pairs with everything whether.
- 2:05:08It's like a similar vibe or whether it's being like, you
- 2:05:10know what, I enjoyed that Tarkovsky film, but it was, you
- 2:05:14know, like slow. When let's get some energy going
- 2:05:16after this, it's like, yeah, there wasn't enough fat men with
- 2:05:19nipple rings. Exactly.
- 2:05:21Exactly, Brad, The Sound of Music is one of the.
- 2:05:24Easiest things to pair with Fury Rd. because.
- 2:05:26Then you have the sound and the fury, and that's just like,
- 2:05:28that's an obvious one, guys. Let us give this film some final
- 2:05:33scores. I will go.
- 2:05:34First here because. I'm pretty sure I'm going to be
- 2:05:35the low man here. I didn't really get a chance to
- 2:05:39talk about this because Brad your your soapbox moment was
- 2:05:42very elegant. My My biggest overall gripe with
- 2:05:46this movie, aside from the Janusz of it all, is I actually
- 2:05:50kind of disliked the extent to which both gangs.
- 2:05:58Are. Accepted by and.
- 2:05:59Have connection. To their communities, like the
- 2:06:02America number. For me, it becomes this this
- 2:06:06kind of neighborhood celebration where it goes beyond just like
- 2:06:10the Sharks and their girls having a friendly argument with
- 2:06:14each other that's kind of like sassy back and forth.
- 2:06:16And it it kind of spills into the street and becomes both like
- 2:06:19a celebration of Puerto Rican culture and their own
- 2:06:22frustrations. And it's an interesting choice.
- 2:06:25And you have moments like that with The Jets as well,
- 2:06:28especially the way that they interact with like, Lieutenant
- 2:06:30Shrink, who very much paints himself as like, I'm one of you
- 2:06:33guys in a way that he doesn't do in the original.
- 2:06:37And I actually think that's my least favorite change about this
- 2:06:39version, because there's something about the 61 version
- 2:06:42that captures the fact that both of these gangs are completely
- 2:06:48misunderstood and rejected. By.
- 2:06:51Everybody else, even like of their own ethnic background,
- 2:06:55everyone is constantly looking at The Jets and being like you
- 2:06:58guys are idiots, you guys are stupid, you're going to amount
- 2:07:01to nothing. Doc is constantly telling them
- 2:07:03that the America number, you know, in the 61 version is this
- 2:07:07very kind of insulated, insular thing.
- 2:07:10And I think that what that version does better is it
- 2:07:13captures that the only people that understand each of the
- 2:07:16gangs is their mirror image in the rival gang, which is why you
- 2:07:20have that great moment after the opening, like ballet where
- 2:07:24they're given Officer Krupke and Lieutenant Shrank a bunch of
- 2:07:27shit and they're like giggling with each other.
- 2:07:29It works so much better because it immediately underscores these
- 2:07:33guys all understand each other and the tragedies that they hate
- 2:07:37each other, but they're the only ones that get each other.
- 2:07:39So I think that that for me, that kind of brought this
- 2:07:42adaptation down just a little bit.
- 2:07:44I also like, I have canonized and lionized the 61 version.
- 2:07:50I'm watching this version and I get to the rumble and I'm like,
- 2:07:52this is like a 7 out of 10 movie for me so far.
- 2:07:56And I, it pains me to say it because I think that Spielberg's
- 2:07:59floor is kind of a 7 out of 10 movie.
- 2:08:03And he, I think, I think he's got some lower than that.
- 2:08:08I mean, from a technical standpoint, it's hard for him to
- 2:08:10do. Worse than A7?
- 2:08:12Behind the camera, but then the rumble happened and then the
- 2:08:16rest of the movie happened and it really took off for me.
- 2:08:19Hey, remember that shot at the bathing of the rumble where it's
- 2:08:22like. Overhead and all the shadows
- 2:08:24come in. Yeah, freaking amazing, guys.
- 2:08:29As much crap as I've given this movie, I am going to.
- 2:08:31Come all the way up to an. 8.5 out of 10 on this film it it
- 2:08:36does not approach the heights of 61 for me, which I think is like
- 2:08:42I really might put that on like my ten all time put it in a
- 2:08:46vault movies just from a cinematic language standpoint.
- 2:08:49But this is still a damn good movie.
- 2:08:51Brad. Isn't it funny when you think a
- 2:08:55movie is? Really good and just because.
- 2:08:58The other people are even higher on it.
- 2:08:59You end up having to, like, be the bad guy.
- 2:09:02Yeah, yeah, I I've been in that position before and it's
- 2:09:06annoying. Patrick.
- 2:09:08Episode Season 1 episode. One of the film and fucking
- 2:09:13Whiskey podcast. We watch a movie called
- 2:09:17Goodfellas. Little old Brad here.
- 2:09:22Little old Brad here liked the movie A.
- 2:09:24Lot but had some quibbles and qualms with it and I gave it an
- 2:09:288.5 and I thought Pop was going to come across the table and
- 2:09:34strangle me forgiving it an 8.5. How dare you.
- 2:09:39Good fellas, dude. It's a great movie.
- 2:09:42It's just. Not.
- 2:09:44Perfect. It's not.
- 2:09:46Or is it or right? Or is it I don't?
- 2:09:50Know. I think this is a 10 out of 10.
- 2:09:55Movie Bob. Wow.
- 2:09:58This is. Like I got done with this movie.
- 2:10:02And I got done crying and I just started like 5, you know, the
- 2:10:08little like Rolodex of my musicals that I love.
- 2:10:14And I'm like, it's this in La La Land.
- 2:10:17And even like, as you were talking about how Steven needed
- 2:10:21to put it on a on a tripod and just kind of do a little thing
- 2:10:25here and there, I was thinking about La La Land.
- 2:10:28And I'm like, he does that for the majority of the dance
- 2:10:32sequences and it doesn't work because he doesn't have Gene
- 2:10:37Kelly dancing. He has Ryan Gosling.
- 2:10:40And I'm like, I, I'm sure that Ansel Elgort is a great dancer,
- 2:10:44probably better than Ryan Gosling.
- 2:10:46He he went to LaGuardia after all.
- 2:10:48But at the end of the day, he's not Fred Astaire.
- 2:10:52And I, I think I like, I love La La Land.
- 2:10:56It remains up there for me. This is one of the greatest
- 2:11:02musicals that's ever been made and I freaking love West Side
- 2:11:07Story 2020. One I like and love. 61 I
- 2:11:13started this episode by saying I think this is much better and
- 2:11:17I'm sticking with that with my final score.
- 2:11:20There you go, I'm. Trying to remember.
- 2:11:24What I. Gave the. 61 film.
- 2:11:28I'm like did I give it a 9.5 or did I give it a 10?
- 2:11:33Do you write these down? I think you and I both gave it
- 2:11:36A10 and Brad gave it a 9.5. If I.
- 2:11:38Remember correctly. That sounds right.
- 2:11:42Yeah, I gave it a 9.5. Bob gave it a 10.
- 2:11:45We didn't write down what you gave it, but I I think you gave
- 2:11:47it a 10 as well. Then I'm giving this A10 as
- 2:11:50well. It's again.
- 2:11:52I think I, I, I, I'm not even saying 1 is better than the
- 2:11:56other. I, I again, I, I love these two
- 2:12:01movies so much. And again for for what seemed
- 2:12:08like a doomed. Mission.
- 2:12:10The gall to be like I'm gonna remake this.
- 2:12:15All right, I know, I know, you can say like it's not a remake.
- 2:12:17It's just like a re adaptation of the same source material.
- 2:12:20Whatever it's it's calling your own shot.
- 2:12:23It really is it really? Is and the fact that it.
- 2:12:26Actually delivers to this degree.
- 2:12:30And you know, I've, I've seen this thing, you know, multiple
- 2:12:33times. And each time I'm just like, I I
- 2:12:35think this is like, I think decades from now we're going to
- 2:12:41especially for a movie that, even though it was very well
- 2:12:44received, got like a best picture nomination, it was not a
- 2:12:48huge box office success. It kind of disappointed and it
- 2:12:53was also marketed weird, but whatever.
- 2:12:56But like. Yeah.
- 2:12:57I I think a lot of people just kind of slept on this movie.
- 2:13:02Which feels crazy. But I think decades from now,
- 2:13:05people will look at this and be like, oh, that actually maybe is
- 2:13:10one of the great movies of the 21st century.
- 2:13:14And if nothing else, it's probably like the best musical
- 2:13:17that's been made. And, and I, and I, I think 11 of
- 2:13:21Spielberg's best. So, yeah, I'm, I'm going 10 out
- 2:13:25of 10, baby. Let's go.
- 2:13:28There you go. All right, Patrick.
- 2:13:30Thank. You for joining.
- 2:13:31Us thank you for. Putting me in my.
- 2:13:33Place about Mr. Kaminsky. My pleasure.
- 2:13:36I, I will. I will turn it over to you.
- 2:13:40Tell us what you're working on. Where can we find you?
- 2:13:43Just all the things, Patrick. I mean, New York City, obviously
- 2:13:46that's where you I'm in the greatest.
- 2:13:48City in the. World New York City, although I
- 2:13:53live in Brooklyn, not Manhattan, where The Jets and the Sharks
- 2:13:56live but but you know, I make it where they still live to be
- 2:14:00clear, they still oh, oh, oh, oh true well, there's the.
- 2:14:03The new incarnations of The Jets.
- 2:14:04And the Sharks that we're all familiar with.
- 2:14:06Sure. Yeah, exactly.
- 2:14:08Yeah. The obviously, you know, the the
- 2:14:10Sharks, you know, they campaigned for Zoran.
- 2:14:13You know, The Jets were iffier about him, as they would be.
- 2:14:18But no. Anyway, so I I make videos about
- 2:14:21movies. They are available on YouTube
- 2:14:23and Nebula. And I got to say the timing is
- 2:14:26great because I am currently writing and shooting next week a
- 2:14:32video that I have been promising for a year now and I'm finally
- 2:14:36doing it. A video about a Spielberg movie
- 2:14:41that I have extremely complicated feelings about.
- 2:14:45Cult hook. Oh, there it is.
- 2:14:51Less than a seven out of. 10 But is it?
- 2:14:55It is a it is a bizarre, fascinating thing that is a real
- 2:15:00like a expensive therapy session for Steve as he is trying to
- 2:15:05figure a lot of stuff out in that one movie.
- 2:15:08And I am, I I I'm, I'm I'm, I'm spending a lot of time thinking
- 2:15:13about this movie and wait, when did this episode drop?
- 2:15:18Sometime next week. So you will be.
- 2:15:20Knee deep in recording it and I, I, I'm.
- 2:15:22Just even gonna say it. I haven't announced this
- 2:15:23anywhere else. I'm doing I'm doing the
- 2:15:26Spielberg doubleheader after the hook video because I feel kind
- 2:15:32of bad kind of ragging on Steve a bunch in the movie.
- 2:15:36To be clear, it's not like an like an anti hook video, but
- 2:15:38it's like it it is critical of it.
- 2:15:41After that I'm doing a video about Munich which I think
- 2:15:46contains some of the some of the, if not the very best
- 2:15:51directing Spielberg has ever done.
- 2:15:54Just one. Of his most underrated.
- 2:15:57Movies and really like a staggering piece of film making
- 2:16:02that is under discussed and so I'm going to discuss it and
- 2:16:07crucially maybe. Yanish's crowning achievement.
- 2:16:10Just a great, I mean the technical mastery is it is what
- 2:16:15what they do with the camera and.
- 2:16:18Zoom lenses and light and reflections.
- 2:16:21Last time I watched that movie, about every 5 minutes I would
- 2:16:24have to pause it and rewind to be like, wait, wait, wait, what
- 2:16:27did I, what did I just see that that's not possible.
- 2:16:30Yeah. If you ever want to feel like
- 2:16:32that's the movie that makes you feel bad about yourself as a
- 2:16:36film maker because you watch it and it's like, well, I could
- 2:16:39never do this. No one can do this.
- 2:16:41This. What?
- 2:16:43The fuck? So yeah, anyway, I got 2 so if
- 2:16:46you want me talking about Spielberg more, that's the next.
- 2:16:50Like, I don't know, month and a half of my life.
- 2:16:55Love it. I cannot wait.
- 2:16:56You could have a worse. Episode you could.
- 2:16:58Have a worse. Sorry, Brad, Go ahead.
- 2:17:01Yeah, It's, it's it's really. Not too bad.
- 2:17:03Again, like I'm I'm watching. Empire of the Sun.
- 2:17:05Like for research just 'cause it's like, you know, it came out
- 2:17:09like shortly before hook and and you know what?
- 2:17:13Really good movie. I got to say man, weird
- 2:17:18cultural. Moment there in what?
- 2:17:19What was a 90? One, because that's also like
- 2:17:22that's around the time that Michael Jackson kind of founds
- 2:17:25the Neverland Ranch too. So there was just some weird
- 2:17:28Peter Pan stuff happening in our culture at least in 91.
- 2:17:32We can all be glad that Michael. Jackson did not star in
- 2:17:36Spielberg Peter Pan movie as he had wanted to.
- 2:17:40He really wanted to. Yep.
- 2:17:42All right, Patrick Williams. Thank you again for joining us
- 2:17:45man. It's always good to see you.
- 2:17:47We will be back next week as we preview season #11 this is going
- 2:17:51to be a really fun season. I'm sure Patrick will be joining
- 2:17:54us again for one of these upcoming films.
- 2:17:57Brad, final thoughts? I I'm just overwhelmed I think.
- 2:18:03Guys, I think. This was the best Patrick
- 2:18:07episode of any. I'm just happy that he he tore
- 2:18:10me a new one 1000%. 1000%. Well, see if I can recover my
- 2:18:17dignity next week on film and whiskey until then.
- 2:18:19I am Bob Book, I'm Brad G and we'll see you next time.