Latest / Minds, Bodies, and Terawatts / The Justice Department Spent a Year Asking Whether Silicon Valley's Biggest Investor Sits on Both Sides of the AI Race

Transcript

The Justice Department Spent a Year Asking Whether Silicon Valley's Biggest Investor Sits on Both Sides of the AI Race · Minds, Bodies, and Terawatts

• 0:00
  [Host] This is Minds, Bodies, and Terawatts, the show where the referee turns out to own both teams. Bloomberg reported Monday that the Justice Department has spent nearly a year investigating Andreessen Horowitz over who sits on which boards.
• 0:15
  [Guest] Two boards. Ben Horowitz sits on Databricks, just valued at a hundred and ninety billion dollars. His partner Martin Casado sits on Fivetran.
• 0:24
  [Host] Two people, two companies. Are they even rivals?
• 0:28
  [Guest] Justice thinks so. Both sell the plumbing that moves a company's data into its AI systems. Though TechCrunch reports they weren't rivals when the firm first invested.
• 0:39
  [Host] Which law is this?
• 0:40
  [Guest] Section Eight of the Clayton Act, nineteen fourteen. It bans interlocking directorates, and Justice reads it to cover two deputies from one firm, not just one person on two boards.
• 0:53
  [Host] Nineteen fourteen. Anyone actually enforcing that?
• 0:55
  [Guest] On private equity, yes. In twenty twenty-two, Justice pushed directors off boards at firms like Thoma Bravo. Venture got a pass, because the law exempts smaller companies.
• 1:06
  [Host] And startups aren't small anymore.
• 1:08
  [Guest] Axios reports those exemptions are quietly falling away as AI companies raise billions. The law didn't change. The companies got big enough to trip it.
• 1:18
  [Host] What does the firm say?
• 1:20
  [Guest] Nothing, to any of the three outlets. Justice wouldn't confirm the probe, but a spokesperson said it will keep prioritizing, quote, affordability for all Americans.
• 1:31
  [Host] Affordability. Odd word for a boardroom fight.
• 1:34
  [Guest] It's the tell. These two sell the data layer most corporate AI projects run on. Fewer real vendors, fewer people setting what your employer pays.
• 1:44
  [Host] That's a conspiracy without conspirators. Two partners on two boards is not a cartel.
• 1:50
  [Guest] It doesn't have to be. Section Eight needs no proof of harm. The overlap itself is the violation.
• 1:57
  [Host] Does overlap actually move prices, though?
• 1:59
  [Guest] Azar, Schmalz, and Tecu tested that in "Anticompetitive Effects of Common Ownership," Journal of Finance, twenty eighteen. On American airline routes where competing carriers shared large investors, fares ran three to seven percent above what rivalry alone predicts. Nobody met. The owners just overlapped.
• 2:17
  [Host] Airlines aren't data pipelines.
• 2:19
  [Guest] The venture version is tighter. An index fund is passive. A partner sits in the room where pricing gets decided.
• 2:27
  [Host] Venture capitalists told TechCrunch they're baffled. And Marc Andreessen is one of Trump's biggest backers. This is his Justice Department.
• 2:35
  [Guest] Which is what makes it interesting. If the point were protecting friends, this file closes a year ago.
• 2:43
  [Host] So it isn't politics.
• 2:44
  [Guest] It's structure. Robert Michels, nineteen eleven, studying mass political parties. Scale forces delegation, delegates become specialists, temporary insiders turn permanent. He called it the iron law of oligarchy. A handful of firms funded most of the frontier, and the seating chart does the rest.
• 3:02
  [Host] Then force them off the boards.
• 3:05
  [Guest] Ben Horowitz's counterargument, on Jack Altman's podcast: running a company without a board, once you've sold equity to outsiders, is the most dangerous idea in the world.
• 3:16
  [Host] So the cure has a cost.
• 3:18
  [Guest] Axios lands there too. Push hard and venture firms stop taking board seats, and nobody experienced is watching at all.
• 3:26
  [Host] And for someone who owns none of this?
• 3:30
  [Guest] Building software keeps getting cheaper. Who gets it, and on what terms, stays with a small overlapping group. If your employer's AI bill climbs next year, this is a reason that never shows up on the invoice.
• 3:45
  [Host] In Unscarcity, Patrick Deglon makes decay constitutional. Power must expire unless it is re-earned, because legitimacy is a lease, not a deed.
• 3:54
  [Guest] A board seat is written the other way. It renews itself quietly, until somebody digs out a law written before the transistor. For more on why AI markets concentrate, head to unscarcity dot ai. The book is on Amazon, the audiobook is on Spotify. This has been Minds, Bodies, and Terawatts.