Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-The A.I. Debate
Transcript
- 0:02This is hashtag Channel, a podcast about discord with Ben and ste Well,
- 0:09actually, a hashtag means it's a channel. Okay, we asked Stevie,
- 0:17so which one is this? Yeah? I wondered whether you'd remember this is
- 0:21hashtag channel, Steve. Okay, I just want to let you know I
- 0:24haven't prepared for this one. I'm sorry. Do you surprise me? You
- 0:27surprise me? Luckily? I have. Luckily, I am the fucking I
- 0:31am the Atlas upon the world upon which I carry on my shoulders upon.
- 0:38So I'm the world. Yeah, you're Atlas. Yeah, who's Hercules?
- 0:42Well? Does Hercules have to do it? I think Hercules is the one
- 0:46who's like originally holding the world and he like tricks Atlas into holding it for
- 0:49him. Is it is that a thing? Actually, you're you're kind of
- 0:51like an Atlas. No, No, you're you're the Hercules character. Because
- 0:54Hercules was a trickster. Right comes along, He's like, hey, Atlas,
- 0:58can you hold this for a minute. I prefer Harry fox Off.
- 1:00I prefer Heracles to Hercules. Okay, why because I'm not a Rome couck.
- 1:03You're you're you're a Hellenist. Yeah, you like a Rome cook.
- 1:07That's super rome cock you love, but you love fucking created helmets with brushes
- 1:12on them, don't. I created a custom Google map. You know you
- 1:15can like save locations in a Google map. I created a map called Antiquities,
- 1:22and I went around the entire Mediterranean world, noting every Roman landmark I
- 1:27still want to see, and I saved it as a bookmark, as like
- 1:30a pin. When did you do this? I mean, I've kind of
- 1:33been doing it, but when I was recently in Italy, I started doing
- 1:36it because I was inspired from you. So the one, the one we
- 1:38went to, the one we went to in poetical doesn't count then. So
- 1:42I have decided if I'm going to put onto the map ones I've been to
- 1:46already, I might though, because you know I'm a completist. You are.
- 1:49I just want to collect things, Yeah, I mean you don't.
- 1:51So it's a very it's a very American no offense. It's a very American
- 1:56attitude. What's that It's about ticking a box rather than having any kind of
- 2:00you know, profound Engagement's very superficial. You're very superficial people. So you're
- 2:06saying that I don't actually enjoy myself no, I've been. I've been.
- 2:10I've been with you to these places. I just sort of I sort of
- 2:13arrive and I go on a soulless dead march through that. You put on
- 2:17your floppy hat and you sort of fucking hunch your shoulders and then you just
- 2:21fucking with your sort of weird little frog marching, just walk around making sure
- 2:25I've seen absolutely bloody everything. I don't see. I'm gonna clad. What
- 2:30are you supposed to do? Stroll around and go, oh, look at
- 2:32that mosaic? That's nice, and't it? That's lady with a top off
- 2:37there romans love? That is? What do you do? I mean,
- 2:39I don't go to these things. I just look. I just read them
- 2:42on Wikipedia. That's true, you don't. You don't want to do anything.
- 2:45I mean you you sort of like pass yourself off as this like cultured
- 2:50area. Do I do? I I guess you don't. Actually, I
- 2:53mean you sort of pass yourself off as this like like vulgar that's true,
- 2:59that's true. Correct, No, But I mean you're you're very interested in,
- 3:05like you know, in history and colts. Well I was, for
- 3:07real, you are, and yet you don't ever want to do any of
- 3:08these. I was very enthusiastic to go and see one Roman artifact on our
- 3:15walk across. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It was like one hour out
- 3:20of the way, and I told you you normally won't go fucking five minutes
- 3:23out of the way, and that's just a pub there. I'm like,
- 3:24Ben, if we literally spend an extra hour going out of our way,
- 3:29out of our way, completely out of our we can see an ancient Roman.
- 3:31Penisa loved it. What did I do? How did I? How
- 3:36did I? How did I demonstrate your appreciation appreciation for the fore bears?
- 3:43What did I do? I believe you stuck your tongue out next to the
- 3:46table. I bent down and pretend to like give it a blower. I
- 3:50think you made it your Facebook profile for ages, and I put a frame
- 3:53around it with all sparkles and that, so it looked especially romantic, right
- 3:59then archaeological enthusiast to me and the Romans. We'd get on, you know.
- 4:03So we might be going to the Pergamum Museum tomorrow. I mean,
- 4:05you're probably not gonna go because I'm not going to go, because you said
- 4:09that you might go, and then I said, well, you need to
- 4:11buy an advanced ticket. I knew in that moment that all hope is,
- 4:14oh, but what are you doing in the evening? A bit of admin
- 4:16on air, No particular plans, because I'm going to go and see Killing
- 4:20of the Flower Moon. Okay, to New Scorsese movies, it like five
- 4:24hours long. It's three and a half hours, but it starts at six
- 4:28fifteen. So I'll think about it. You're you're out by nine to forty
- 4:30five. I'll think about it because it supposed to be brilliant. I would
- 4:33go to more movies. If you would go to more ancient Roman sites,
- 4:36well, come and see Killing of the Flower Moon. Anyway, So in
- 4:40this beginning preamble to the hashtag channel bit and for the listeners, if you
- 4:45look at the hashtag channel structure, which I meticulously planned out before the first
- 4:49hashtag channel show, the intro, can you stand up a minute's Dave?
- 4:54Why they can't see it? Just I want you to read what I've written
- 4:58and read it to the audience. I've written the detailed instructions about the intro
- 5:02to the show. Coming over here to Ben's mike, I've never been this
- 5:05close to you. Oh it's attractive. Okay, intro Steve, Steve's dying.
- 5:15It says, intro, talk about something that's right. The intro says,
- 5:20talk about something. Wow. So what we're going to talk about you
- 5:24should give talk that project manage. So what we're going to do. Go
- 5:30back to your mic, now get away from me. That was it.
- 5:31That's it. I just wanted you to read it because you didn't bring it
- 5:34up on your phone. So anyway, so we're gonna talk about what you
- 5:36just gonna give a brief. I'm sorry, I'm sorry I didn't bring up
- 5:41on my phone. The carefully crafted schedule you've outlined for this episode. Hey,
- 5:46the whole show I'd hate to deviate the whole show document. The whole
- 5:49show document is like five pages long. It's just that the intro bits just
- 5:54you know. Anyway, So we're gonna give a brief, a brief for
- 5:57the talk about this year's essence. So, Ben, Ben, the Pergama
- 6:00Museum is going to close until twenty thirty seven. Yeah, you will be
- 6:05sixty years I will be sixty years old and you will be dead. Yeah,
- 6:10exactly time it reopens. I'm fucking icycle everywhere. Don't you want to
- 6:14see the ishtar Gate yeah. I mean, I suppose have you ever been
- 6:17there? Shit targate. Don't you want to see the market gate of mylitas?
- 6:23Yourlitas? Don't you want to see all of the other shit they have
- 6:28in there that I can't remember? Yeah? You can't remember? Yeah,
- 6:30I mean, what are you gonna do? You're gonna walk? No,
- 6:31I'm not going with you. No, actually I'm not going with you because
- 6:33you'll read every fucking plaque, every single and the problem is, right,
- 6:36the problem is my last chance until I'm sixty. The problem is you don't
- 6:40retain any information. So what's the point of reading all the plaques? You
- 6:45don't retain any of that. I live in the moment when I go to
- 6:47these places like you, you think that I'm not enjoying it, but I'm
- 6:51actually like I'm imagining myself there. I know you're enjoying it. I'm not
- 6:56enjoying it. That's the problem. I don't go to these things just so
- 6:58I can recollect dumbfacent, impressed my friends and chats later like you do.
- 7:01Well, well, that's the important that's the purpose of living. Anyway,
- 7:04anyway, off this topic, stop derailing the show. Anyway, We're going
- 7:09to talk about this year is Essen. So I have a statement to me.
- 7:13This is not the full name of the convention. To be fair,
- 7:17Uli Blenman presents. That's True's Essen Spiel presented by Spielworks and Uli Bleneman.
- 7:26That's true. Sorry, I do apologize the Uli Bleneman show. We're going
- 7:29to talk about the Eully Bleneman Show. So I contend that this is easily
- 7:34the best Essen for the last at least five years. So what made it
- 7:40the best for you? So, so I want to ask you a question
- 7:42first, is this the best Essence you've ever been to? No? Oh?
- 7:46Really? Oh? Come on? What was the best Essen you went
- 7:47to? The first one? Really? Why? Because it was new.
- 7:50I did not know what to expect. It was novel, it was Phantasma
- 7:54Oracle. I mean, it was quite nice staying in the house with a
- 7:57bunch of people and getting to play games. So like, if I compare
- 8:01Sen to Sen, it's it's hard to be objective because each time I go,
- 8:05I'm different to That's true. You know, I could also say the
- 8:09twenty twenty one s And was brilliant because it was sort of like smaller weird.
- 8:15I would enjoy more. Intimately, and joy myself because I always enjoyed
- 8:18myself. But it was weird. We also had that like we're back feeling
- 8:20true. But no, I mean I thought, this is so so.
- 8:24The reason I loved it so much, I think was because you're like you're
- 8:26like a shark at Ssen. Then that's the problem. You don't stop moving
- 8:30and you have no attention span. You you just you take I dead march
- 8:35through Roman ruins, like through those halls of s and it's like from eight
- 8:37am to six pm. You don't stop walking. It's cool works and like
- 8:41nosing around cool work. I know, but I'm getting old. My feet
- 8:45hurt after like twenty minutes and so so. So again, this was an
- 8:48Essen where I definitely didn't play any games. Well you know, we didn't.
- 8:54There was there was there was no like polava right, like there's no
- 8:56transportation pilava. No. There was not even like a real like drinking too
- 9:01much polava. No, not really, no illness, I think. I
- 9:03think Wednesday I had a few drinks. Thursday I had a few drinks,
- 9:07and then after that it was fairly sedate. I thought, yeah, but
- 9:09everybody was there. I think like the relationship component was probably a bit stronger
- 9:15for me this time, but that's just growing over the years. You already
- 9:16have that because you're a bit you're a bit weird and a bit you know,
- 9:20with drawn, so you find it hard to talk to people. Just
- 9:24can't get out from under your shadow exactly. I mean what a shadow.
- 9:26It is, enveloping penis shaped shadow. But yeah, it was just it
- 9:31felt so okay. So firstly, I spent a lot of time with Martin
- 9:37Wallace this year, and he's a laugh riot. Yes, so that's always
- 9:41fun. He's here's what you refer to in the UK as a lad.
- 9:43He certainly is a lad. I thought the new hall layout was fantastic.
- 9:48Oh interesting, this this is a topic. I thought it really worked.
- 9:52I thought basically apart from a few sort of outliers like I don't know why
- 9:56Delicious Games was where they were, well, I do, because it was
- 9:58my I'm sure it was. Maybe they signed up late. No, I
- 10:01don't think it is. I think it was probably If they're there, it's
- 10:05a lot cheaper. And I don't think Delicious Games, with all due respect,
- 10:09I don't think they give them monkeys about the they're gonna sell out anywhere
- 10:15the booth experience, right, the Nerves are gonna show up on Thursday at
- 10:18eight am. They're gonna line up buy all the games. Who they don't
- 10:20even need a booth, really, I mean they love selling a game,
- 10:22don't the Vladimir Suwchi could set up a table outside of Essen, like in
- 10:28the the gruga Parky or whatever and just sells games there exactly so so,
- 10:31but but I love that. What difference did the whole lay up make to
- 10:35you? Like? Well, because all three felt like home. Yeah,
- 10:37for the first time at Essen, I think I had a home. So
- 10:43all three being the sort of nerved games, the sort of kennishpiel. Very
- 10:48crowded though, I mean very crowded, but it felt like a home.
- 10:50And that's central sort of meeting point of the game brewer place with the bar
- 10:58brilliant, having Uli just around the corner brilliant. Although I think Uli works
- 11:03too hard and he's not up for having lolls. I keep talking, I
- 11:07keep talking to him about this. I mean, maybe you should take a
- 11:09bit of the fucking strain. Look, we all work way too hard at
- 11:11spiel Works, and it's not necessary like people come to us, they want
- 11:16the games. We have a backlog of ideas through like twenty thirty. At
- 11:20least he doesn't need to pound the pavement quite so much. I mean,
- 11:22I understand he has a vision. Maybe you could take a couple of the
- 11:24meetings. I mean, I keep offering it to him. Maybe you could
- 11:28demo some of the games. He feels such a sense of personal responsibility for
- 11:31the health of the business. Every time I offer he like, he thanks
- 11:35me and passes, And you know what, I'm gonna have to get a
- 11:39little pushier with him, I think so. But yeah, and say demo
- 11:41the games. Yeah, I mean, it's not reallying my skills, because
- 11:48if you're, you know, working at spiel Works, maybe you should,
- 11:50like, you know, work in the booth or something. I mean,
- 11:52I'm working it for I'm working the whole conky for spuel Works. Like confining
- 11:56me to the booth seems. And you are a person who likes you're you're
- 12:01a box ticker, right, Well, this is how you describe me,
- 12:05and your your pride at having done all of your shopping before the convention open
- 12:11on Thursday. I'm incredible. Ah, you might you appreciated that, though,
- 12:15didn't you? Command be honest? I mean I didn't do most of
- 12:18my shopping. I didn't do most of my shopping. But but yeah,
- 12:22I mean the thing is so, without wanting to sound like an asshole,
- 12:26like Wednesday is the best day because it's you know, for us. Yeah,
- 12:31we get to go backstage and I always I'm always fascinated by that,
- 12:35and Wednesday is Wednesday. This year was great, so we had I mean,
- 12:39I wasn't there for much of it, but well, you you describe
- 12:43it. I mean I was there. So the beauty about Wednesday is everyone's
- 12:46setting up. Because I don't have a booth, I get and I get
- 12:50to do a lot of cool interviews. I get to bum around backstage say
- 12:54hello to people, and people are a lot less stressed because there's not thousands
- 12:58and thousands of people, so they can stop and have a chat for five
- 13:01minutes. You know. Me and Martin went and had all together, too
- 13:03many beers. And then the Wednesday night we ran into the guy who runs
- 13:07the whole event, that's right, Catholic Setti. And why he well,
- 13:13I was gonna say, why he's there on a Wednesday. I don't excuse
- 13:16me, but clearly it's because he runs through all event and so, and
- 13:22you know, the party was great this year. I think they made a
- 13:24change to the party. It was not a formal event. There were no
- 13:28speeches. Really great. There's a great musical actor here, great musical act,
- 13:33the poor lad. I mean, he's a good singer, he's a
- 13:35top German musical Wrong audience, maybe you no one gives a fuck. The
- 13:39problem is right if you just have a fucking average wedding band playing bangers right,
- 13:43fucking knocking out Sweet Home Alabama or whatever, that's cool. No one's
- 13:46there to dance or anything. I mean, you don't even need a band,
- 13:50honestly, just just play some low level music. People are there to
- 13:52have a chat and fucking I mean, this is an opportunity for people who
- 13:56only see each other like once or twice a year to get together. It's
- 13:58not it's not show. It's not a show. But yeah, and then
- 14:03yeah, and just the whole it just this year. And then you were
- 14:07vibing, is what you're trying. I was vibing, vibing, lack of
- 14:11I have like rather support issues were so great. The food was great.
- 14:15I loved the like all three was their own base. But then I could
- 14:20pop off into the fucking RPG hall the recess gray and yeah, it was
- 14:26just it was just I like, I like the RPG hall. I have
- 14:28mixed feelings about Hall three. On the one hand, it like really puts
- 14:33the hobby gamers like front and center. On the other hand, I sort
- 14:37of appreciated that the front halls were like the more commercial halls, and like
- 14:41my place was like in the back, hidden away. Yeah. Well,
- 14:46I mean I just I just like the so for me just getting interviews,
- 14:52the if I had interviews set up, I could just walk around basically if
- 14:56I contend square meter area and fucking get them all done. You know,
- 15:00It's just I mean, I I really enjoyed it, and I would say
- 15:03I have no issues with it. And I heard some people had some complaints.
- 15:09There was one observation, was it Stephen bonikor who said they shouldn't have
- 15:11put all the manufacturers together for some reason? Right? And I forget why.
- 15:16Maybe because they all hate each other. I don't know. Actually that
- 15:18kind of does make sense to me. I mean, if you think about,
- 15:20like the way traditionally cities were laid out in particular neighborhoods, you would
- 15:26find all of the particular cross me. It makes it much easier to like
- 15:30comparison if you're a game publisher, right, yeah, and you want to
- 15:31meet up with these Chinese producers at essen, right, you would rather they
- 15:35all be in the same place. Yeah, you'd rather go, Okay,
- 15:37I've got a panda here and then fucking bunto source here and da da da
- 15:41da. The puniters are the customer, not the exact people operating the exactly.
- 15:46And I think with with with manufacturers, they're not there expressly selling shit,
- 15:54right, and so that's specifically business, so they should be away because
- 15:58it's a consumer facing show, right. But I think that's an issue I
- 16:02had, and I think I think you want to be next to people who
- 16:06are like you in a way. So there's this commonplace in economics, right,
- 16:11like the best place to open your hot dog stand is next to the
- 16:15existing already successful hot dog stand, right, because you get like spillover benefits
- 16:18exactly. It's not like as far away as possible because you think, oh,
- 16:21this community over here is underserved, Like no, you want to be
- 16:23we're all way people want hot dogs, yes, yeah, and so and
- 16:27it's like yeah, and I enjoyed the be as in the do you think
- 16:34do you think CD Hunter is going to go on the discord now and like
- 16:38write ten paragraphs about how my economic analysis is faulty, and like, actually
- 16:42I could cite academic articles discounting it. I demand that he does, please
- 16:47do it. I quite enjoy these threads, and so yeah, I just
- 16:52it felt. It felt like the first proper one since COVID basically, and
- 16:56you know what, everything worked out, Yeah it did. It was a
- 16:59prime well almost everything apart from me losing a bag and almost everything worked out.
- 17:06But yeah, it was a wonderful. It was a wonderful time.
- 17:07It was a great time. And I interviewed a lot of people and I
- 17:11always ask the same question, which is why should people come to Essen?
- 17:14And a lot of people said, well, you shouldn't. You don't need
- 17:17to, And I don't think I agree, Like you don't need to go
- 17:21every year, for sure, but I think if you're a gamer, and
- 17:25I understand, you know there are pressures. I mean, some people are
- 17:27Antipodean, right, But if you can give a chance to go at least
- 17:32once, I think you should, it's a flawlessly wonderful experience. Okay,
- 17:36let me see if I can come up with some reasons not to go to
- 17:37Essen and you're going to reject them. Okay, So number one, I
- 17:44don't need to get all the games. The second thing come out, they're
- 17:45going to be in the shops a couple months later. Anyway, totally agree
- 17:48with you. Fine, that's that's absolutely a valid reason you're supposed to argue
- 17:52against. Oh you're a bell end. Yeah. Second one, solid solid
- 17:56reasoning. I can just pre order them and go and pick them up and
- 18:03then leave and I don't really need to bother with having to swim around the
- 18:06crowd for four days. Totally, totally, totally fine. Oh sorry,
- 18:08sorry, you're a bell end. Okay, it's far too crowded. You
- 18:17can barely play any games. Everything is always full. You have to sign
- 18:19up, The sign up sheet is full. If you're lucky, you'll demo
- 18:22one game a day and it won't even be a game you're interested in.
- 18:26What's the point? Completely fine? Sorry, sorry, you're I'm bell end.
- 18:34I did the German one. Okay, that's that's that's three three reasons
- 18:37not to go, and you have you have you have soundly roundly rejected all
- 18:41of them. So the simple reason you go to Essen, right, the
- 18:44simple reason you go to Essen. It's why people wanted to go to Rome
- 18:48piss up in one hundred. Uh see, it's why people wanted to go
- 18:53to London in eighteen ninety. It's why people want to go to New York
- 18:57today. Piss up, I mean, obviously, but it is the center
- 19:03of this art form. So most people aren't like you. They don't care
- 19:07about the design. I'm sorry, I'm sorry. People listening to this are
- 19:11so we're talking specifically to the people who listen to them. Well, of
- 19:14course we are. So the thing is, this is why this podcast.
- 19:17I think it's undoubtedly a podcast of incredible quality, but it doesn't get the
- 19:21numbers that people think it should because it's very, very niche, and so
- 19:25the people listening like pearls before a swine. Well indeed, but the people
- 19:29listening to this are like me, are weird nerds, like they want they
- 19:32want to meet Martin Wallace. Yeah, right, exactly, And it really
- 19:36there is a buzz and an atmosphere and a feeling that you are truly at
- 19:40the center of something. If you're really into fishing, I am sure that
- 19:44there is a fucking event somewhere around the world that you feel that you want
- 19:48to attend one day. I'm sure if you're into crochet there's a similar event.
- 19:52And in board gaming it is this, it is essence, and I
- 19:56feel, you know, I don't usually like the world a privilege, but
- 20:00I do feel privileged that as soon as I got into the hobby, I
- 20:06realized I lived a four hour train journey away from the center of it.
- 20:11And so I agree with you there. I mean, as you know,
- 20:14Americans are prone to think that their country, our country, is the center
- 20:18of the world. And yet I knew about Essen twenty years ago, right,
- 20:22I never thought i'd go because, like, why the fuck would I
- 20:23go to Essen? Right? I mean, it's quite like I had no
- 20:26particular interest in going to Germany, and like Essen is not even like on
- 20:30the radar of a place you was in Germany. No disrespect to the fine
- 20:33people of the rug Beat, but you know, you really would have to
- 20:37go out of your way. And when you talk to Americans at Essen,
- 20:41people who can go to Origins and gen Con and whatever the fuck is going
- 20:45on in America on board games, they agree with you about Essen. They're
- 20:49not saying, oh, no, gen CON's actually the place America. This
- 20:53is like the one thing that America hasn't actually completely dominated it. Yeah and
- 20:57so and so and so. Vassal said on my show when I interviewed him,
- 21:00he said, you don't have to come here, and I, of
- 21:04course you don't have to come here, but I think he was implying,
- 21:07you know, if you're really into the hobby, it's not something that has
- 21:11to be on your board gaming bucket list. And I disagree. I think
- 21:14I think it is wonderful and it is still say he doesn't have to go,
- 21:17but he does. Anyway, right, it is my I think it's
- 21:22my most exciting convention. I don't think it's my favorite convention. That is
- 21:26Laracon, because I think Maria Coon is special. But it is my most
- 21:30exciting convention and I get to meet all of these wonderful people and it's it's
- 21:33brilliant. So anyway, Steve, we've talked altogether too long on this because
- 21:38you just hijack the conversation. You do nothing. My buddy's talk flap flap,
- 21:41flap flap, your bloody give me what does it say on the agenda
- 21:45talk about something? Did we not achieve that that's true? Well, let's
- 21:49move on to After altogether too much consultation with the greatest minds in the world
- 21:56of topics, we present all right, Steve, this got fiery on the
- 22:07discord the main topic this week. And I quote for the listeners, Oh,
- 22:12this is like hidden information in games memory? No, because that was
- 22:17a very interesting topic. It was an interesting topic and we've got to talk
- 22:18about this. We've got a topic for the next Hashtag Channel show. Seeing
- 22:22that the Bloody Discord listeners are just taking over the Bloody chow now, so
- 22:26we're not going to do the memory one now, No, we're doing the
- 22:29controversial one, which is that the AI one. Why is it controversial?
- 22:32Because fucking people are getting angry on Twitter X Sorry no, I mean getting
- 22:36angry on Twitter? Sorry? Sorry? What difference does it ever make?
- 22:40This is a slight sidebar. Are you beginning to get annoyed when you read
- 22:45a newspaper article and it says X comma formally Twitter? Is that starting to
- 22:51fucking knock you? Because it's beginning to knock me? I mean the formerly
- 22:52Twitter part. Yeah, it's very passive aggressive, isn't it. I mean
- 22:56I think changing the name of Twitter to x might be like the Aster's stroke
- 23:00of trolling ever accomplished in this world. I mean, Elon Musk is the
- 23:04greatest tone. I mean, I don't know, like I guess formerly Twitter,
- 23:07they feel like if you say X, like most people aren't gonna know
- 23:11what you're talking. Imagine he's a lull Elon Musk, Yeah, just like
- 23:15you go out for a couple of punts. Do you think he's a lull?
- 23:17Od you think he's a fucking night mare. I think he's probably one
- 23:18of these guys where you have to laugh at his jokes, but he doesn't
- 23:22laugh at your I mean, I'm not I'm not particularly fucking wowed by fame
- 23:26and money, so I wouldn't. I don't care about being in Musks all
- 23:30bit like I would. I would assume that he's always the center of attention.
- 23:33You know, I don't know the man, but no, I would.
- 23:37I would not think it's very enjoyable to hang out with him. So
- 23:40who would you want to kiss more if they walked into this room right now?
- 23:42Yeah, Elon Musk or Tim Cook Cook? And you want to kiss
- 23:48Tim Cook all over? I think he would be better at it. You
- 23:52be fair the glee when you said I got them from Tim Cook. You
- 23:56loved him, Cook, didn't you you love him? I thought it was
- 24:00very nice that Tim Cook responded to my email. I don't know why you
- 24:03have to bring this up. Now there's a personal kis. This was a
- 24:06personal This is personal information I shared with you. You love to cook,
- 24:10and I don't appreciate you like broadcasting it to the wage to cook, Tim
- 24:14Cook? What would you cook? Tim Cook? You know what, I
- 24:15don't even know why I tell you things about my personal life. You're just
- 24:18going to fucking go and like blab them to every fucking per to the two
- 24:22people who listen to this show. Anyway, We put it off long enough,
- 24:25Steve, we put it off long enough. You know your mission,
- 24:29should you choose to accept it. Don't make me do this to say something
- 24:32interesting on the ai R debate. Don't make me get to We'll get to
- 24:36the discorders in a bit, because they're there. They've said some very interesting
- 24:41Let's let's not have automobiles because it's gonna put the fucking horse and buggy manufacturers
- 24:45out of business. Okay, that's boom. That's that's a hot take.
- 24:48Now boom, Now I wish you to expand. Uh well, I think
- 24:53what's less interesting than the debate itself is like the the substantive topic of the
- 25:00be like should we or shouldn't we? Then why people who aren't even involved
- 25:03get so exercised about it, Like all of these people who aren't artists coming
- 25:07out of the word work suddenly to defend other people who are artists. But
- 25:11shouldn't you invent shouldn't you defend injustice? I don't know. I mean it
- 25:15seems like cherry picking to me, Like why this particular topic is so motivating
- 25:19for people I don't understand, Like nobody cares about the fact that the board
- 25:23games that they play are manufactured in China, which is like a totalitarian regime,
- 25:27the fact that they have to be shipped all across the planet, that
- 25:30they use like countless resources. I mean, you talk about this sometimes,
- 25:33but you know it exercises a few people to some extent. But like the
- 25:37AI is now like I think it's just trendy. I think it's just hype.
- 25:41So so okay, I'll address this and then we'll talk about sort of
- 25:45something a bit more substantive about this. But you are right, there are
- 25:48causes dou jure and the nature of social media. There is a particular person
- 25:55on Twitter who's been particularly animated about this, and they public a list of
- 26:00content creators who will not review staff using ai R. And do we have
- 26:07actual proof that it is well like casting people like jobs. We'll move move
- 26:12away. We'll talk about that in a second. But you are right,
- 26:15this seems very much to be a cause to zure. And so you can
- 26:22say your argument often is on social issues. Well, the planet's dying,
- 26:27so why the fuck are we talking about this? It is often your argument.
- 26:30And while of course to some degree, you're right, people do care
- 26:37about other things, and people can care about multiple things at the same time,
- 26:41right, Yeah, absolutely absolutely, and the board game industry is so
- 26:45I think I think part of the I don't think I assume you wanted me
- 26:49to be provocative here. It's just a sure, But I don't think it's
- 26:52entirely performative. I don't think people's concern is entirely performative. I think there
- 26:56are a lot of people on Twitter who are being performative and tends to be
- 27:00performative because I think they think it gives them social Q dots. But there's
- 27:07something about this hobby that is different from other hobbies that are similar. There
- 27:14is something different about board gaming as opposed to video gaming. There is more
- 27:19of a feeling. You may not like the term, but nevertheless, lots
- 27:23of people, lots of people are into it. There was a feeling of
- 27:27being in a community. I know lots of people who do art for board
- 27:33games, right, and I don't want to see my friends. So it's
- 27:37personal for you. I mean to a degree, I don't want to see
- 27:41my friends who have managed to develop a career that gives them dignity in an
- 27:48area that they like having that taken from them due to ease. I mean,
- 27:55I think you know, to All probably has like twenty more years than
- 27:59an does he? AI is going to be does he? Though? I
- 28:03mean, this is the point if it so. I mean, I don't
- 28:07know Moore's law, all of this sort of stuff. What is it not
- 28:10his name? That's partly a selling point now. I mean they put it
- 28:11on the box right like you can get a I mean, this is like
- 28:15a very sort of narrow way of looking at the argument, but you see,
- 28:18like whatever whatever sort of like pilarva of a game by vital aserta art
- 28:22by einotool true, it is attractive that the game art is by Eino tool
- 28:26if you have AI generating it, like, that's not going to be part
- 28:29of the value proposition anymore. True. But in his case, I wonder
- 28:33though, Yeah, so I because gamers are aquisitive, right, it is
- 28:38part of the nature of this hobby is acquisition, right. I wonder if
- 28:42you have those Eagle Griffin games. I wonder whether gamers are willing to sacrifice
- 28:47the ian o'tool art for a game that is similar in all other aspects,
- 28:52with componentry of that level thirty quid cheaper. I wonder. I wonder how
- 28:59long Ian's has currency. I mean, publishing sounds like a tough business,
- 29:03so it's hard to criticize them, the publishers, for wanting to cut costs.
- 29:07However they can. It depends though, no, if you want these
- 29:10games to exist, well, it depends if cutting costs. So, so
- 29:17this is the question. This is the thing. It's the stealing part that's
- 29:19the issue, not the generation of the images that's the issue. Right,
- 29:22Yes, so, I guess I think that is a problem. I guess
- 29:26because I'm not because I'm a bit of a lefty, right, I think
- 29:33society has society, and by extension, businesses I think have an obligation to
- 29:41not be purely money making ventures. I think there is an aspect of broader
- 29:47sociological duty to give people work. To do that, we should value the
- 29:53dignity of human beings, and we should value that more than simple numbers.
- 30:00And the board game industry up until this point has been able to survive wonderfully
- 30:06using human beings to generate the artworking games. Just because it makes you more
- 30:11money doesn't mean you should abandon your duty to give people work in which they
- 30:22feel pride and dignity. Right, Well, it's got that like Homie sitting
- 30:25around the dinner table playing a board game vibe. It sort of extends to
- 30:29how we feel about the hobby. I don't want I think that, you
- 30:32know, I legitimately think that is nice. But like, how many named
- 30:37artists are we talking about who might have worked taken away from them? I
- 30:41would guess a lot of these games, Well that's that's it. The companies
- 30:44have like art departments, and they will they will generate art for their games
- 30:47in one way or another. The thing is, we don't that's not a
- 30:48question we asked, But I think so I guess. I guess part of
- 30:52the reason, so part of the reason I still continued to be a part
- 30:56of this hobby twelve years down the line is because I don't feel like a
- 31:07consumer. I feel like a participant within the industry. Now that may be
- 31:12complete fucking delusion on my partner, Nevertheless, I feel that, and I
- 31:22worry something like AI art takes away from that sense of us all having a
- 31:30role in the sense that this is something that has been fashioned by human hands.
- 31:36Board gaming is willfully analogue in a way that everything else isn't. And
- 31:42I guess, I guess, I guess that is why people are appalled by
- 31:45this as much as the theft. I think there is an unsubstantiated concern and
- 31:52I think it's this feeling. And this is why when Asthma Dae started buying
- 31:56everything, I think people were uneasy, and I think think what it is,
- 32:00broadly speaking, is people are thinking, wow this. I think board
- 32:07gamers are more Steve Wosneyak than Steve Jobs, I guess, is what I'm
- 32:10saying, right, what do you mean Steve wo Wassniak is the cool hippie
- 32:15in the garage building the computers. Steve Jobs is the ruthless capitalist who makes
- 32:20apple products an addictive substance. He's also the one who wanted to make them
- 32:24beautiful, that thought that a computer could be kind of a work of art.
- 32:28I don't think Steve Wisniak cared about design, right, so Steve Jobs
- 32:31would be the one hiring the artist, not Steve Wisniak. But the point
- 32:36is, I think the point I'm making is that we kind of most of
- 32:42us kind that don't want board games to be this ruthless triple a capitalist venture.
- 32:49We don't want to live in a situation in which companies are hiding hiding
- 32:54their playtest copies from other publishers in case they steal them. That X publisher
- 33:00is suing why publisher over and there probably always will be publishers that you can
- 33:06support who won't behave like that. I mean, you know, look look
- 33:08at the greatest living hero in board game publishing today. I don't think that
- 33:14there is any danger that Uli Blenneman is going to start using AAR because the
- 33:19man does not know how to use computers. This is very true. Okay,
- 33:22So you can like rest assured if you buy from if you buy from
- 33:25any number of publishers, they will probably take either they will take a stand
- 33:30similar to yours or they're just going to remain like very small craft producers,
- 33:34but like the larger corporations they especially if they're I don't know if Asthmade is
- 33:37publicly traded, or that some of them may even be part of publicly traded
- 33:40companies like Hasbro or whatever. They don't have the luxury to put the needs
- 33:45of like Embracer is publicly traded. I think who Embracer? Who's that?
- 33:50They're the people who own Asthmade? Okay, but so they have a fooduciary
- 33:53responsibility to their shareholders to maximize profit. I mean, I'm not saying that's
- 33:58a good thing, but they they probably don't have the option to put the
- 34:00needs of the livelihoods of artists ahead of their commercial responsibility. But the smaller
- 34:06independent publishers that we all we mostly support and can continue to support, they
- 34:10probably will, and they and they do so. I think board gaming has
- 34:15a particular I think board game has a particular usp in this. This is
- 34:21like a special pleading argument, right yeah, And I think this justified.
- 34:24It's justified because I think essentially board games are a pilava. Right, What
- 34:32do you mean they're a pilava. There is a reason board games don't sell
- 34:37as well as computer games, right, is because look, with a computer
- 34:39game, you get it. If you've got a console, you get it.
- 34:43You put it in the console, you flip it on, you start
- 34:45playing. Two minutes, you're fucking playing your game. Right, You don't
- 34:50need other people, you can just do it. Blah blah blah blah blah
- 34:52boof right, board games are a pilava. So they're physical products. You
- 34:58need to un box them, punch them, and then it's why we don't
- 35:01play them. Basically, get them on the table, learn the fucking rule,
- 35:06deal with the other human names, get other people with all of the
- 35:08fucking issues, oh my god, get around the table with you. Then
- 35:13you've got to sit with those other people and deal with their fucking issues for
- 35:16ninety minutes. And then you've got to pack the fucking thing away. Then
- 35:20you've got to put it in a bag and fucking lug it around. Board
- 35:22games are a plava. And this I think is a massive positive for this
- 35:28industry because I think it makes this it limits the insane growth that this industry
- 35:35can have. Therefore, I think by its very nature, it is always
- 35:40going to feel a bit ad hoc, and that's a great thing. I
- 35:45think this whole AI debate, though, I mean a little bit, it's
- 35:47catastrophizing. I mean, it's funny how well it mirrors every other major technological
- 35:53revolution that has come along where people have legitimate concerns. We don't know anything,
- 36:00that's the point. But it's very likely that in fifty years it will
- 36:02just be like part of the state of play and nobody will say anything or
- 36:05think anything about it. And I mean, for real, if we want
- 36:07to take it seriously, we're completely missing the point about AI. AI art
- 36:13could be a problem. I mean, artists have been exploited by companies for
- 36:16since time immemorial, right, Like this has always been the case in the
- 36:20music industry, and you know people complain about it. But I mean,
- 36:22did you read that interview? Ug? Oh yeah, like the Australia chee
- 36:27Company. No, Ug, it's ug. Do you know how much he
- 36:30got paid for those fucking caws in that cave? Like half a bulls I'm
- 36:34trying half point half a bull scrot he got for that, Trying to make
- 36:37a fucking fair half a bull scroke for those I'm trying to say twas Ever,
- 36:40Thus, but AI is hot right now, people are uncertain about it,
- 36:44and they're they've seen like too many Terminator movies. The real controversy is
- 36:49not going to be over AI art. What's going to happen when the AI
- 36:52becomes good enough that it can just generate the entire game. Right, because
- 36:57board games are like they're like computer programs. Computer programs, they're very algorithmic,
- 37:01they're very spreadsheety, they're very mathematical. Many of them are developed by
- 37:06people who used to be in software or or have some kind of like scientific
- 37:09background or very logical bent of mind. Right, if that kind of analytical
- 37:15competency is what is generally producing games, then you just put like a scrim
- 37:21of art on top. There's going to be no stopping a computer from just
- 37:23being able to like generate from a few prompts an entire game with the engine,
- 37:29with a design, with probably the art as well. Maybe it will
- 37:31require a little bit of tweaking and editing, but I wouldn't be surprised if
- 37:36you could do this. I wouldn't be surprised if you could do this already.
- 37:38It doesn't mean that it will be attractive to people that you still won't
- 37:42want to buy games from actual human beings that you know design them, that
- 37:45have humanity in them. It could also mean that we won't be able to
- 37:49tell the difference after a certain point, and then beyond a certain point,
- 37:52beyond that it won't matter, all right, So we'll move on to the
- 37:55contributors. Suck, I thought I just had a really good including remark,
- 38:00and you you've got nothing to say in response. No, because I'm moving
- 38:04on. This is my job as the host. That's just mind. I
- 38:07move on, Just move on. Why do I need to comment on your
- 38:09beautifully concise speech? It was wonderful. I actually my comments. I value
- 38:15you as an interilock eat and what you have to think my comment will only
- 38:17devalue the beauty of your elocution. So you agree with me? Moving on?
- 38:24Bonzo says, Okay, this is this is the fucking world I'm in
- 38:30right now. I'm having serious conversations. And then we have to move on
- 38:32to Bonzo. Oh my god, I used to be a fucking PhD student.
- 38:37Bonzo. What does Bonzo have to say? It's it's clever, he
- 38:40says, it isn't even art. It's AI generated content, and in its
- 38:45current form it's nothing more than theft. How do I know Bonzo is an
- 38:50AI generated content? Well, it could be could be a bot. I
- 38:52don't think he's a bot, though, I don't know that anybody's not a
- 38:54bot anymore. How do I know that you're not a bot? Because I'm
- 38:58I'm real, I'm here, are very real. I'll just weed myself on
- 39:00this chat smell. If there's if there's a word I would use to describe
- 39:05you that captures your essence, it would be visceral. Indeed, So this
- 39:09is the I think this is so the problem with new technology. Technology always
- 39:15goes fast to the legislation because legislation, by its very nature plays catch up,
- 39:21right, because you can't we don't even have a Speaker of the House
- 39:22right now in my country. You can't legislate against something if you can't even
- 39:27conceive of it, right, And so I understand the copyright and theft issue.
- 39:35It's the ultimate sort of reductio ad absurdum, of like the remix philosophy,
- 39:42right, because, as we often talk about, all culture is some
- 39:45kind of cultural appropriation. You are always taking elements that already exist in order
- 39:49to produce something new. Sure, this is simply that at the level of
- 39:52computation, and it's like the human mind can't comprehend like exponential growth. Right,
- 39:59So we have gone from a world in which you actually had to do
- 40:00the work over a long period of time of like assimilating knowledge and influence into
- 40:06producing new things, and just turned that into like something a computer can do
- 40:09in a split second based on everything that has ever been created. So it's
- 40:15like, you know, terrifying, and it is terrifying. So I'm not
- 40:17a great believer in copyright copy left well, yeah, to an extent.
- 40:24I think my issue with copyright is that it has got out of hand after
- 40:31the George Harrison ruling in the seventies. Copyright is meant to protect commercial interests.
- 40:37Sure, and so after the George Harrison ruling in the seventies where My
- 40:40Sweet Lord was proven to have been a copy of a Cherelle's song, I
- 40:47believe even though George Harrison hadn't heard the Charelle song, I think that was
- 40:52probably a lie because it's a very sair song. But the judge ruled it
- 40:55doesn't matter the similarity of these means that you should pay royalties. Right,
- 41:01that was not fair use No, and so that crushes creativity because there's only
- 41:07a certain amount of notes, there are only a certain amount of ideas,
- 41:10right and so and so someone someone else that I haven't put in here because
- 41:16we've organized our entire society around the need to like make money to survive.
- 41:22This is the problem, right, So so someone else, God, we're
- 41:24going to create a fucking amazing new world one day, a fucking utopia,
- 41:28I'll tell you so. So one of the people further in the further down
- 41:31in the thread said was Newly hasn't commented on this. I think he's I
- 41:37think he's saving his powder for Minor ULI's new podcast. But we'll get onto
- 41:42that line. You need to save your powder right now. On that topic,
- 41:44So someone said, so, should we pay Donald Xvacherino every time a
- 41:51deck builds made? Should we pay Mine Wallace every time a worker placement's made?
- 41:57So? So the point is, did Martin Wallace invent worker places?
- 42:00No? Actually, we spoke about this at Essen he said it was Richard
- 42:04Breeze who invented it. Because he Martin Wallace is often cited as the person
- 42:07who invented it, but he says he number one most underrated game designer in
- 42:13the hobby. I agree anyway, So Richard Breeze, not Martin Wallace.
- 42:15So the point is it's special pleading. Could it be could it be said
- 42:19it's special pleading? What that What we're talking about AIAR being theft actually is
- 42:28just like taking someone's game mechanism and using it in the game. And yet
- 42:31we don't accuse people doing that of theft, but we do accuse aar.
- 42:37Is it because aiart is new? I think yes, and I think we're
- 42:39all overreacting. And the thing is, like you were saying something about my
- 42:44hot it's all hot takes. It's hot takes all the way down. It
- 42:45is because it's social media, right, Like we're not having, like to
- 42:50generally real conversations based on complete knowledge of the subject, right, do people
- 42:55actually know what they're talking about? Like? Probably not. I mean,
- 42:58you want to take a side and then not you. People always want to
- 43:00take aside and then denounce anyone who doesn't agree. See, this is a
- 43:02problem with English. We've stopped using the term one to mean generally, and
- 43:08so you have that ambiguity when you say you sometimes you think you are accusing
- 43:13someone. German still has this, it does man, Yeah, exactly.
- 43:17So, I mean, and I think this is the problem. We don't
- 43:22really understand what we're dealing with here, and then it does end up becoming
- 43:24a form of special pleading, like this is not like anything else that's happened
- 43:28before. I'm like, well, actually, it's quite a lot like things
- 43:30that have happened before. Maybe it's just different in magnitude, or maybe we
- 43:32are going to be confronted with like the actual consequences for for once, right,
- 43:37right, Like you add computation to something and you magnify the consequences.
- 43:43Like, look what social media has already done to the world. What is
- 43:46it done to our politics? What has it been to our political discourse,
- 43:50our ability to relate to one another? What is technology done to human relationships?
- 43:54I mean great gifts though, I mean there's a lot of benefit as
- 43:59well. I mean what you say, do you say jiff like a twat
- 44:01GIF? Yeah? No, I say Giff good. I mean there is
- 44:05there is one great thing I'm always saying about this hobby is like it forces
- 44:08people to come together. Indeed, and it's one of the reasons I'm not
- 44:10that into like tabletop Utopia online, yeah normally, and I'm not even into
- 44:15games that require you to use apps. Now that's a debate i'd like to
- 44:19have, all right, So the Bruce, former post of the work Post
- 44:22of the Month says, general AI under duress was he posted? Fuck me?
- 44:28Can I get through a fucking sentence? Why is it every time I
- 44:30start reading the fucking thing that you fucking jump in? Why do you have
- 44:36to do this on the air? The Bruce says, general, AI for
- 44:40Better or Worse is a new no generative? I think east put gen AI?
- 44:44Does that mean generative AI? Generative? AI? Okay, jen AI
- 44:47for Better or Worse is a new tool available to humans and they are going
- 44:51to use it. Students will have it right their essays. Corporations will use
- 44:53it to not pay artists. On the plus side, will will be more
- 44:57productive. The AI does a lot of g werk. On the negative side,
- 45:00we were about to go through the second great and shittification of the Internet.
- 45:06The first was social media in sertification, he may have just earned himself
- 45:08Poster of the Month again. Certification is a good word. Yeah, I
- 45:13mean so was social media. So you know, what human beings are very
- 45:17bad at doing the meat? Then do you know human beings are very bad
- 45:21at doing what's that? Predicting anything and having any perspective? It's true,
- 45:27do you think so? He talks about the first great in shitification of the
- 45:31Internet being social the Internet itself. My question, I don't know about product.
- 45:37My question, My question to you is did the Internet really exist before
- 45:42social media? It was some fucking weird thing nerds did, But did it
- 45:45really exist before fucking Facebook and Twitter? And I don't know what you mean?
- 45:50It existed from me then in the nineties, yeah, I think my
- 45:52previous time. So let's let's take a brief trip down memory lane, like
- 46:00basement using the internet. Oh, this fucking JPEG's gonna come up in three
- 46:06and a half hours that I could have a lank. So I can't believe
- 46:09that that that actual recording was preserved for all these years. I can't believe
- 46:14in the nineties. I don't know why I recorded that. By the way,
- 46:16I can't believe in the nineties. You're a West Country accents. Yeah,
- 46:20So I don't know what he means about being more productive. I don't
- 46:23think we'll be like as productive as we always have been and just have like
- 46:28produce more shit and sittification is a good word actually, all right, So
- 46:30next one, like we'll just we'll just find different forms of grunt work.
- 46:34I mean, like using the IAI will become grunt work. Like what the
- 46:37question is, like what value does it add? Like does it add value
- 46:40to use the AI? And if it's gonna automate some things like the promise
- 46:44of technology of the internet of whatever. The fuck has always been free up
- 46:47our time so that we don't have to work, not so that we could
- 46:51be more productive, Like how much more fucking productive do we need to be?
- 46:54Right? I'm gonna get back to the environment in a second. I
- 46:57mean the growth and the fucking economy does is further a pollute and destroy our
- 47:00world. So I was watching I was watching a video. I was watching
- 47:04a video the other day and they were talking about somebody as a normal job
- 47:07like mine. Yeah, and you know how they referred to the normal job.
- 47:12How job job as an eight to five job. Didn't it used to
- 47:17be a nine to five jobs. I would fucking kill for an eight to
- 47:21five job, I mean, Christ, So they've added that it's just people
- 47:25say eight to five job nine not nine to five. Just accept it,
- 47:30and just accept it. Like the computers, the AI will be no different.
- 47:34It will not like reduce the amount of work that we have to do.
- 47:37Like more productive simply means you'll be able to like unlock more value for
- 47:40somebody else, for whom you're working. I don't think it's gonna mean we
- 47:43work fewer hours. Listen, if they come out with some kind of like
- 47:46AI and like accompanying legislation, we go through some societal transformation. I don't
- 47:51know how to articulate it such that all of us can just work like four
- 47:54hours a day thanks to AI. Right, fuck the board game artists,
- 47:59I take that deal. So famed game designer Isaac Shalev says the claim that
- 48:07AI is I agree. I hate collaborative overlap. It makes me want to
- 48:12kill. I don't want to argue with themed word game designer Isaac Shallev than
- 48:14anything, because then you can fucking respond and have to listen to him.
- 48:16So the claim AI is theft is a weak one, and it sort of
- 48:20misses the point. AI can be created using public images or using art that
- 48:24is owned or licensed. There are already a few options doing so. Available
- 48:29similarly claims that AI isn't really art, ring hollow. For one, much
- 48:34of the commercial illustration and graphics work that AI will be used for isn't exactly
- 48:37art either. That's that's being rather denigrated industry. What depends on define art?
- 48:44I suppose, for two, humans and machines are both quite bad at
- 48:47differentiating, by the way aar AI and human images of many types. Yes,
- 48:52it's got its hands, you can probably tell it's it's got hands,
- 48:59you can probably tell well. But those areas are shrinking as the AI improved.
- 49:02Okay, so that didn't make much sense the last bit that I read
- 49:06because I can't read, but so I guess the broad sweep of what he
- 49:12says. Then now, Isaac, please came on the discord and tell me
- 49:14I'm wrong. Will is that? Well, it's just fucking illustration. So
- 49:20who gives a fuck? It's worthless anyway? Am I being overly harsh on
- 49:24what he said there? I think that is what he's saying, kind of
- 49:29right, I mean, like it's it's not art. Much of the commercial
- 49:32illustration graphics work that AI will be useful isn't exactly art either. I mean,
- 49:36that's to say art in the sense that you're not going to stick it
- 49:37on a museum one. I don't think it. I don't, I don't
- 49:40like it. Therefore, fuck the people who produced well, like I was
- 49:44saying before, a lot of the I mean to lose the Trek was considered
- 49:46a shitty commercial artist back in the day. I don't know, was he
- 49:50He did a lot of these like posters for the Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 49:52I mean sure. I mean we have now decided to go back and
- 49:57recover these things and call them art and stick them on the wall. Could
- 49:59that happened with board games? Maybe? But I guess it's doubtful. I
- 50:04mean, I think I think Weberson Santiago. So for the listeners, I'm
- 50:06just going to show Steve my I mean, I think a lot of the
- 50:08art produced for board games, it's probably I think I think Weberson Santiago is
- 50:14incredibly it is incredibly idiosyncratic and interesting and emotional, and yeah, I think
- 50:22it's I think it's valuable work. Yeah, it's it's it's nice. But
- 50:28you could say the same thing about like graphic novels and comic books. I
- 50:30don't know how people do people argue that these things are or are not art,
- 50:35so I think it's probably in the same genre. But but like this
- 50:38has a name on the box, Okay, that person produced that art.
- 50:43There are probably a lot of games that the art is produced by, like
- 50:46you know, commercial graphics departments, where a bunch of people contributed and there's
- 50:51like no one person responsible for it. It's simply like a function of the
- 50:53company to produce these illustrations or this content or whatever. Maybe we're not quite
- 51:00worried as much about them as we are about this person's webson Santiago. Are
- 51:06you familiar with their work on other games? Yeah, the Bloody In for
- 51:08instance, is one of his Okay, I mean I would go back to
- 51:10my like you know, tool argument. I mean, if we value this
- 51:13sort of idiosyncratic take on things, I think there will still be a place
- 51:15for artists. It could be that AI gets to be so good that you
- 51:21can just generate this stuff. So it's fascinating, fascinating. This isn't the
- 51:24criticism of you what I'm about to say, but I think it's indicative of
- 51:30the way our society is. Is that the way you are, the way
- 51:37you are framing your argument is essentially an argument for market economics if there's a
- 51:44market that exists for it, therefore it has value. I think rather fatalistic
- 51:49about market economics, okay, in the world in which we live. So
- 51:51so I'm going to ask you a question. You haven't asked me an ethical
- 51:53question about it yet, So I'm going to ask you a question because I
- 51:57actually, to be honest, I think a lot of the argument essentially boiled
- 52:00out to mark economics. But is there Can you frame these things not as
- 52:07commodities? Can you frame them outside of market economics? Or because of the
- 52:13nature of our society? Are we forever are we forever doomed to come back
- 52:19to this idea of value i e. Money I E. Markets? I
- 52:25mean, I think a lot of art over the centuries has been produced in
- 52:30a kind of market economics context. Not necessarily, but all of it in
- 52:35fact, I mean, unless you have the gentleman artists who doesn't care about
- 52:37money. I mean, if you're looking at fucking Titian or people like this,
- 52:43how do you pronounce his name Titian? Titian, Yeah, Titian,
- 52:46Yeah, Titian, Not Titian, No, Titian. I think it's Titian,
- 52:51It's Titian, But Titian's funnier Titian like he was a he was a
- 52:59businessman, right, All of these sort of renaissance artists were business people seen
- 53:04through the frame of market economics. Yeah, they're not like capitalists per se,
- 53:07like well proto capitalists. Yeah. Maybe. I mean we're like living
- 53:10in this like late capitalist society where it seems like qualitatively different than people who
- 53:16happen to create art and sell it for money in the past. Are we
- 53:20naive to think that art is anything other than crude fucking market value. Is
- 53:25this a naive folly, a symptom of a privileged society. I think this
- 53:32is exactly the kind of conversation that you would have in like a philosophy of
- 53:38esthetics class. I mean, there's a there's a book by Arthur C.
- 53:42Dante. I think it's just called what is Art? Ye? So I
- 53:45don't know that there's an answer to this question. It's just something that we
- 53:46should consider and talk about. And you know, AAI has added another nuance
- 53:52to the conversation. I don't think there's going to be a definitive answer,
- 53:55much as I would agree that Isaac Shalev famed Board Game does, though he
- 54:00is knows everything about the world, has all the right answers, and is
- 54:04always correct. I think there's probably going to be a lot of debate and
- 54:08no real answers, and we're just gonna have to make choices about the kind
- 54:12of world we want to live in. Do we want to be Do we
- 54:15want to live in a world in which computers can just generate all of our
- 54:19creative output for us, Like probably today you could find an AI that can
- 54:23take all of the recordings of your podcast and generate new podcast episodes in your
- 54:30voice that maybe you would not be able to. Hello, Steve, You're
- 54:35a balance, You're ballance Steve. So that what we just played for you?
- 54:40There was an actual clip from a real episode of Five Games. I
- 54:44just went on GPT. That was the real one. Now do AI generated?
- 54:47Sorry, I'll do the generated one. Your belland Steve, Hi,
- 54:52I'm fucking band from five Games for vulgain boom bay. So that sounded pretty
- 54:58fake, I mean you and I the first one sounded very genuine. Yeah,
- 55:00like you can tell the differences, but eventually they're going to sound so
- 55:04similar you won't know the difference. So then, but do we want to
- 55:07live in that world? Like that's the question, Like, yeah, market
- 55:09economics could drive us inexorably in that direction, but we don't have to choose
- 55:15to go in that direction. All right, So the last one I'm going
- 55:19to look at because you said, love these phenomenological conversations we have though so
- 55:22I haven't asked you about ethics. You say, I'm not sure that that's
- 55:25true. But anyway, I'm going to go on to the final contribution.
- 55:29That's CD Hunter, and by what I want to know is why does he
- 55:31go on for another hour? Now? Why does he why does he have
- 55:35it's a CD hunter fucking inverted Comma's Gladiator. Was that the nickname we gave
- 55:43him, That's what it is. It's the it's the nickname we gave him.
- 55:46That's why. Okay, so they're all doing that. It's like the
- 55:49thing to do on the discord it is, which you can join by going
- 55:52to www dot five games redoomsday dot com, clicking on the pinned post at
- 55:55the top of the page, which will lead you to the discord because it's
- 56:00an invite link. Then you're in. Then you leave a comment in a
- 56:04hashtag channel. Then we give you a nickname. No, you get a
- 56:06nickname. By becoming a patron, you go to patreon dot com slash five
- 56:09G for D. You can x Ben, you can blue sky him,
- 56:14you can master it on him. You can you can master it on me.
- 56:16But I don't even know if I can log into master do you can
- 56:19email him? Just just try every possible combination of five G for D,
- 56:22five games for roomsday spelled out with the numbers. Maybe you can get actually
- 56:27ask chat g ept to like generate all the permutations send messages to if you
- 56:31If you ask chat gibt to do that, it just comes up with one
- 56:34sentence, what's that Ben is a twat weird, doesn't it so? And
- 56:37you'll get a nickname, C Day Hunt, C Day C Day Hunter.
- 56:40Sadey Hunter says, I have to say focusing on legality is largely a bad
- 56:45argument. And this is coming from a lawyer. Yeah, I feel very
- 56:49shaky waiting into these waters here. Whether the law considers something as theft or
- 56:52not is not isn't relevant to the ethical issue. The ability of law to
- 56:57regulate something or not isn't the point. It might be legal or illegal,
- 57:01that isn't the issue. He writes beautiful sentences equally The idea that the criticism
- 57:06of ai Art is reliant on capitalism as a precondition is also a completely legitimate
- 57:12concern. Since we live in a capitalist world, that is the precondition.
- 57:16So I don't like the phrase we live in a capitalist world. Well,
- 57:21we don't live in a capitalist world. Demonstrably, we live in a Western
- 57:24capitalist society. I think there are other places where capitalism pertain, but center
- 57:29not Island, for example. But so essentially he's saying the law is an
- 57:34ass and there is a grander consideration, which is the ethical one. To
- 57:38what extent do you agree with that? Yeah? Completely? I mean I
- 57:43think you sometimes can make it sound like I'm a capitalist myself and a defender
- 57:47of the capitalist mindset. I suppose I would be. You know, I
- 57:52am along the lines of what you're saying, like we live in a capitalist
- 57:54world. I just I don't like the idea of that, as if I
- 57:55don't necessarily think the capitalist get to sort of infect all of our minds.
- 58:00I don't necessarily think you are. I think often you're framing I think quite
- 58:05legitimately is through that lens. Though. Yeah, it's the sort of like
- 58:09we interface with the systems that we have to deal with and the power that
- 58:16controls the systems, which which is like capitalist in nature, whatever our personal
- 58:22sentiments are about it. Also also this is a phrase I came up with,
- 58:27maybe someone else came up with it, and I'm trying to think of
- 58:29the phrase now, which is the chauvinism of the present moment, right,
- 58:36So it's good. So the thing is, we live in a capitalist society
- 58:39and we can never conceive of anything other than a capitalist society because of the
- 58:43chauvinism of the present moment. Back in the feudal system, you spoke to
- 58:46a peasant, they probably wouldn't have been able to conceive of the feudal system
- 58:52being completely irrelevant. It's because of the chauvinism of the present moment. It's
- 58:55like such a lack of imagination. I mean here, I think I can
- 58:59paraphrase famous uh Slovenian philosopher psychologists Slavoy Jijia, Yeah, who always points out
- 59:07that we have such an incredible imaginative potential at our disposal. We can imagine
- 59:13all kinds of scenarios for for the end of the world, cats with monkeys,
- 59:16yes, we have. We have genitive AI and and and social media
- 59:20like there, there are no no limbit. We're gonna Spanish. Yeah,
- 59:23We're literally gonna send like a probe to visit the moons of Jupiter in the
- 59:30next week. Longestein, who can dunce the camcan? Yeah? There,
- 59:34as you and I are both indicating in our various ways, there are no
- 59:37limits to what human ingenuity is able to come up with, except for an
- 59:38alternative to capitalism. Right, it's crazy, all right? So with that,
- 59:44I hope that was edifying for the listeners. I hope they enjoyed it.
- 59:46Steve, I think you really outdid yourself down with the system. Ben
- 59:50may I may I say, Steve not cribbing from another podcast, But that
- 59:53was a tool de force. And uh, let's move on to in an
- 1:00:00act of wilful competition, we present our all right, Stevie, what is
- 1:00:07this section? Christ? Is this the one I was just about to introduce
- 1:00:12it? Do we talk bollocks in this section? No? No, no,
- 1:00:14no no no. I have to, like, like Ajust my I
- 1:00:16want to know stedhetorical pasture, who you think is this month's poster of the
- 1:00:22month, because the listeners know it, because there's a bumper that says it.
- 1:00:24But come on, oh, okay, I'm prepared for this one.
- 1:00:27Actually, yeah, poster of the month. Okay, okay, it can't
- 1:00:30be. So I didn't mention Jertsy's Yertzy's one, but he can't be Poster
- 1:00:35of the month. I don't know why. Why because he prefaced his comment
- 1:00:39with a dictionary definition. If anyone ever makes a comment and they preface it
- 1:00:45with a dictionary definition, you instantly make yourself non eligible, because that is
- 1:00:51the But he didn't know that going into it. No he didn't, but
- 1:00:52still he should know that it's trite to do that. What does like every
- 1:00:58best man speech saying defined by the Cambridge Dictionary as putting your thumb up your
- 1:01:04wrecker? So if you had tried, if you can't be trite? If
- 1:01:07you had given the best man's speech at my wedding, yeap, like,
- 1:01:10like, what would it have been? I fucking just shipped myself. Did
- 1:01:17you see that? Earl hang On? I spoke to the cat and he
- 1:01:22said, oh, oh fucking ll low fucking hell, have you seen it?
- 1:01:28I am fucking sinate. Have you seen it? What you're fucking looking
- 1:01:30at? What you're fucking looking at me? Like that? Before you fucking
- 1:01:32come I'm gonna fucking kill you, you twat fucking look at me like,
- 1:01:37no, I won't fucking go. Don't take that fucking microphone on my head,
- 1:01:39you fucking asshole. That would have been the speech. Sorry I meant.
- 1:01:44I meant if you hadn't had anything to drink, I wouldn't have been
- 1:01:47at you. Like, let's see, you're going through one of your like,
- 1:01:50you know, sober periods, which which I currently am. Yes,
- 1:01:52yeah, so then what would the speech be It was a wedding, yeah,
- 1:01:55but like you know, you're not drinking and you're it just how happens
- 1:01:59the wedding falls than the sober period I don't understand. And then you're giving
- 1:02:01the speech all right, Uh fucking hell, drink for a month. So
- 1:02:07I've had like two glasses a while. Fucking did you see it? You
- 1:02:12say a thing on the telly the other day? Fuck you know. Anyways,
- 1:02:15I having a wank and what what are you fucking looking at. I'm
- 1:02:20just telling you a fucking story. Fucking no, I won't fucking give you
- 1:02:23the fucking microphone. Fuck off. So that's the sober version exactly. Okay,
- 1:02:29great, So what was the least of the month the dictionary word that
- 1:02:32he defined art. That so he posted a dictionary I don't think he should
- 1:02:37ever get to win Post of the Month for that ship. I'm sorry.
- 1:02:42That's supposed to be illuminating that you posted the dictionary definition of the world art.
- 1:02:45What what is the dictionary definition? Well, it comes from a Latin
- 1:02:49word that simply means like a thing that has been done or made, which
- 1:02:53is like just about the most Britannica Britannica for anything you can come up with
- 1:02:59Britannica dictionary definition of art. What's the Britannica dictionary That sounds like a fucking
- 1:03:02Britannica. Yeah, I mean, I know the Encyclopedia Britannica. There's a
- 1:03:07dictionary something that is created with imagination and skilling, that is beautiful or that
- 1:03:10expresses important ideas and feelings. Well, there you have it. That's saith
- 1:03:15the dictionary and you're to see whoever the fuck anyway, so who's post of
- 1:03:19the month. You can't have fucking uli he didn't post? Why not because
- 1:03:25he didn't post? Why can I just have what I want? I want?
- 1:03:30You can't have what you want in this case? What are my options?
- 1:03:34So you got I don't have many options though, yeah, you have
- 1:03:37when you're going with the memory topic like thirty people, Bonzo, it's nothing
- 1:03:40more than theft the Bruce right generative a R. He's in certification, right
- 1:03:45people and be the Bruce? Isn't it? Famed going James and Isaac Shalev.
- 1:03:51It's a bad argument. And you've got Jersey Dictionary definition about the c
- 1:03:55D hunter. The law is an ass Which one you going for? Yeah,
- 1:04:00I mean I'm quite partial to the CD hunter. We have to reward
- 1:04:03the use of the term the coinage and citification, right. I don't know
- 1:04:08if it's a coinage, but I've never heard it before. I think we're
- 1:04:10going for the Bruce again. All right, So that's first two months in
- 1:04:14a row. It's a tufa in a row even, I think. So
- 1:04:16he's on fire. This guy's on fire anyway. So that was this month's
- 1:04:21post of the month. That was our all right, Steve, we've gotta
- 1:04:31wrap this up because it's been a long show. I got are we still?
- 1:04:35Are we still in the hashtag channel show? Yeah? Yeah? I
- 1:04:38never know like which show I'm in, you know, yeah, because because
- 1:04:42you're just the freewheeling artist and I'm the down to a fucking you're the logistical
- 1:04:47person. You're like the business guy exactly. The thing is, you just
- 1:04:50stick a mic' the Steve. I'm the Steve Jobs. You just stick a
- 1:04:54mic in front of me and ask me inane questions and then later tell me
- 1:04:58like, oh, this was for this and this is Steve Jobs. Rucky.
- 1:05:00He got cancer and he said, I'll drink fruit juice. It'll kill
- 1:05:01my cancer. Right. Yeah, you know when he realized it didn't work,
- 1:05:05by the way, when he realized that he was gonna die because it
- 1:05:09didn't fucking work anyway. When he realized that he was going to die,
- 1:05:12right and the dog said, sorry, mate, it's over. Why didn't
- 1:05:15he just for Lulls changed his first name to Blow. That's what I would
- 1:05:19have done, you know what I mean. God, Ben Maddock's always asking
- 1:05:23the hard questions anyway, So how do they join the discord? You've done
- 1:05:26it before, but let's do it again. So you need to you need
- 1:05:30to put the concept of numbers out of your mind right now. Okay,
- 1:05:33when I say a number, you're going to think about how you would spell
- 1:05:36that number out in letters. Okay, you're gonna go do five Games four
- 1:05:41Doomsday Calm. At the top of the page, there is a pinned post
- 1:05:45with a link. That link is actually an invite link to the discord.
- 1:05:50Now, I notice every time I open up the discord app on my phone,
- 1:05:55ten new people have joined. I don't know who you. People are
- 1:05:59great, but we love you and we want to see you start contributing to
- 1:06:01the conversation because this thing is like self sustaining, its sustaining. It's great,
- 1:06:05Like it's what I wanted. You're you're You're giving us a lot to
- 1:06:08talk about, a lot to think about. I'm actually like lulls aside,
- 1:06:12legitimately astounded by like the breadth and quality of the conversations happening on your discord,
- 1:06:16probably because you're not involved in this. Absolutely so okay, that's how
- 1:06:19you do that. If you wanted to support the show but not with financial
- 1:06:25remuneration, how would you go by doing that? Steve? You could send
- 1:06:28an email to Ben five games for day at five Games through doomsday dot com
- 1:06:31that Gmail dot com. Anyway, that's not what I meant, and you
- 1:06:35could tell Ben like that you enjoy his work. If that's that doesn't mean
- 1:06:39anything. If you wanted people in non remunerative appreciate its non immunistry. But
- 1:06:44if if you wanted the public to see you're got to x and you could
- 1:06:48x Ben. Yeah, or you could also go to you could go to
- 1:06:51like iTunes or whatever the fuck and and give what a five star review?
- 1:06:57So I've decided, Steve, Yeah, I'm past all the bullshit. Pretend
- 1:07:00go five star review? What you want? No fucking five stars, lads?
- 1:07:04Five? How many games for Doomsday? Five? How many stars?
- 1:07:09Fucking five? We just did the work for you. And then you could
- 1:07:12write a review as well. Can you write a review? For example?
- 1:07:15You could get chat gpt to do it? Can you? Actually? You
- 1:07:16could? Should? I should? I? I could generate one right now?
- 1:07:19Ben is great. I think he's sexy. That blow jobs joke was
- 1:07:26really great? Shall I write? Shall I have chat GPT write a review
- 1:07:30of five games? Right? You need to vamp for a minute, though,
- 1:07:32Yeah, I got a vamp. I So listeners, come on with
- 1:07:35discord and tell me what you thought of the blow jobs joke. I thought
- 1:07:40that was great. I thought it was really funny, and I'm sure no
- 1:07:43one has ever made that joke before. I think I'm highly original Steve Jobs
- 1:07:48blow jobs. You know what I mean? Because blow jobs is funny,
- 1:07:51because rude stuff is funny. Sixty nine is funny, still funny after all
- 1:07:56these years. Here we go by the way chat GPT, I'm going to
- 1:07:59show you gave you five stars? Coolse it did. Five Games for Doomsday
- 1:08:03offers an engrossing blend of tabletop gaming insights and the larger existential ponderings we all
- 1:08:09grapple with. Each episode is a journey where the games serve as a lens
- 1:08:14to explore human nature, passions, fears, and hopes. The conversations flow
- 1:08:18naturally, giving listeners an intimate glimpse into the minds of industry insiders and enthusiasts.
- 1:08:24Whether you're a diehard gamer or someone looking to understand the allure of board
- 1:08:27games, this podcast offers both depth and accessibility. The host's skill in weaving
- 1:08:32together the world of games with broader life themes makes for an engaging, thoughtful
- 1:08:38listen. Highly recommend, highly recommend, highly recommended. Okay, good,
- 1:08:44So how do you feel about AI now? Ben? Love it anyway?
- 1:08:46So if you wanted to financially remunerate the show, how would you go by
- 1:08:50doing that? Stevie. So there's a website that some of you may have
- 1:08:54heard of. It's called patreon dot com, and you can go there and
- 1:09:00for your patronage. Much like in the Italian Renaissance, Ben is an artist
- 1:09:03and he needs supporters so that he can continue creating this art, which I
- 1:09:08believe this is art no matter what hears he thinks. And you know,
- 1:09:12we're in a world of rising inflation, so you know, don't be stingy
- 1:09:14as I'm trying to say. So, I just want to say thank you
- 1:09:16to everybody who contributed on the discord for this show. Without you, this
- 1:09:21show doesn't exist without you. Quite frankly, this whole venture doesn't exist.
- 1:09:27So thank you ever so much. And yet I just want to say,
- 1:09:30like personal note, personal note, when you contribute to this podcast, to
- 1:09:33the Patreon, you help me too. So let's be honest with the listeners
- 1:09:41here, like this is a Ben Maddox venture. I'm just here as a
- 1:09:44kind of like fellow traveler so to speak. You know, I help out,
- 1:09:46I pitch in. It's fun for me. I really love that I'm
- 1:09:48part of it. But like the more successful it is, the less likely
- 1:09:54I'm going to have to deal with Ben's moaning and complaining and like unhinged sort
- 1:10:00of personality works. You know, it's really tough, like I have to
- 1:10:04deal with that. You're helping me not have to deal with that, and
- 1:10:08I really appreciate it. Yeah, well, enough of that, calm me
- 1:10:11shit, and I'll see you next month for more Hashtag Channel. Without you,
- 1:10:23this show wouldn't exist, so really, you're to blame, so thank
- 1:10:27you for listening and oil up your ears for the next Hashtag Channel.