Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Are Pivoting Careers
Transcript
- Lucas: So Dana wrote in with what I think is one of the most stressful salary questions we've gotten in a while. She's a marketing coordinator with four years of experience, and she's been asked to take on a product manager role on her team. It's a promotion on paper, but her company is framing it as a lateral move. No raise, just 'new responsibilities, same pay.' And she's worried that if she pushes back, they'll think she's not serious about the pivot. Luna: Oof. That is a classic catch-22. You want the title change but you're afraid to negotiate for fear of looking ungrateful. Lucas: Exactly. And the thing is, this isn't just Dana's problem. We keep seeing versions of this in the listener mail — people moving from marketing to product, from teaching to instructional design, from sales to customer success. The pattern is always the same: the role is a step toward something bigger, but the compensation doesn't reflect the new responsibilities. Luna: So what's the fix? Is there a way to ask for a raise when you're pivoting without sounding like you don't get the opportunity? Lucas: I think there is. And it starts with a reframe. When you're pivoting, you're not just asking for a raise — you're asking the company to invest in your future contribution. That's a different conversation than 'I've been doing this job at a high level and I deserve more.' Luna: Right, but how do you actually have that conversation without sounding like you're asking for a favor? Lucas: You prepare. You come in with data, and you separate the two arguments: what you're worth now, and what you'll be worth to them as you ramp up. Let's break it down with Dana's case. Luna: Please. I want to hear how this actually works in practice. Lucas: So first, she needs to research what a product manager at her level actually earns. She's in Austin, so I'd point her to Payscale and Levels.fyi. For a mid-level PM in a mid-sized tech company, the market range is roughly ninety-five to one hundred twenty-five thousand. She's currently at seventy-eight as a marketing coordinator. Luna: That's a big jump. But she's not a PM yet, right? She's being asked to take on the role. Lucas: Right, and that's where the nuance comes in. She's not asking to be paid like a seasoned PM on day one. But the job description they're handing her? That's the PM job description. And the market rate for that job is what it is. Luna: So you're saying she should anchor her ask to the market rate for the new role, not her current salary? Lucas: Yes, but with a strategic twist. She says to her manager, 'I'm excited about this transition, and I'm committed to ramping up. I know there's a learning curve. But the responsibilities you're describing are the same as a product manager at the market rate of one-ten. I'm not asking for that immediately. I'm asking for a fair progression — maybe a bump to eighty-five or ninety now, with a clear review at six months to reassess.' Luna: Hmm. That's interesting. So you're acknowledging the learning curve but still asking for something above your current pay. Lucas: Exactly. And the key is to be explicit about the long-term plan. You're not asking them to take a leap of faith on your current skills. You're asking them to bet on your trajectory. And you're giving them a structured way to do it. Luna: And if they say 'we don't have budget' or 'this is a growth opportunity'? Lucas: Then you pivot to the internal equity argument. You say, 'I understand that. But I'd like to understand how our company values this role internally. Could you share the salary band for this position?' And if they've hired externally for this role before, or if there are other PMs on the team, you compare. Luna: That's a good move. Because if they've hired a PM from outside at ninety, they can't really say the role is worth less when you're doing it internally. Lucas: Right. And that's the moment to say, 'I want my compensation to reflect the value of the role, not the path I took to get here.' That's a strong line because it's fair. Luna: I love that. But let's be honest — not every company has a clear band. What if they say 'we don't have bands'? Lucas: Then you ask what they'd budget for an external hire. That's a sharper question. Because if they'd pay ninety to hire someone from the outside, they can't argue that the role is worth less when you're doing it internally. And if they say, 'we'd pay the same for external,' then you have your answer — maybe the role really is a lateral move in terms of comp, but then you know that going in. Luna: So you're saying the conversation is as much about information gathering as it is about the ask. Lucas: Absolutely. You're not just asking for money; you're asking for transparency. And that transparency helps you make an informed decision about whether to take the role at all. Luna: That's a powerful way to think about it. And it's actually a theme we hear a lot on the show — the value of asking questions to understand the frame. Lucas: And speaking of value — if this episode is helping you think through a career move, the way we keep it ad-free is listener support. If you've got something out of these conversations, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It genuinely keeps the lights on. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple way to keep us going. And back to the topic — you were saying the conversation is about gathering info. So what's the next step after that? Lucas: Once you've asked for the band and they've given you a number or a range, you can decide whether to push for a midpoint. Let's say they say the band is seventy-five to ninety-five, and they offer seventy-eight — which is your current salary. You can say, 'I'd like to be at the midpoint, which is eighty-five, given that I'm taking on the full scope of the PM role. And I'm willing to be evaluated at the six-month mark to earn the top of the band.' Luna: That's a great script. It shows you're being reasonable and performance-based. Lucas: And it also protects you if they say no. If they refuse to budge and won't even commit to a review, then you've learned something important about how they value you. That's data for your next move. Luna: Which is a great segue to the other scenario we see a lot: the pivot where you're moving to a completely different function, like a teacher going into instructional design. Lucas: Right. That's a different beast because the skills are transferable but not identical. So the salary research is even more critical. You can't anchor to your current role because it's not comparable. Luna: So what do you do in that case? You don't have an internal equity argument because there's no internal role to compare to. Lucas: You become an external hire in your own negotiation. You say, 'I know I'm coming in without direct experience, but I bring these specific skills: curriculum design, classroom management, assessment creation. The market rate for an instructional designer at this level is seventy to eighty-five. I'd like to be at the lower end of that, given my ramp-up, but I want to be in that range.' Luna: That's smart. You're acknowledging the gap but still anchoring to the market, not to your previous salary. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the thing — when you're pivoting, your previous salary is almost irrelevant. It's a historical data point, not a fair market value for the new role. And the fact that you're willing to take a conservative entry point shows good judgment. Luna: And I'm guessing that six-month review is a recurring theme. Does it actually work? Lucas: It works if you get it in writing. And if you set clear, measurable goals for what 'success' looks like at the six-month mark. So maybe you say, 'I'll have these three projects shipped, and I'll have hit the key performance indicators we agree on. Then we revisit comp.' If they agree to that, you've got a plan. Luna: So the ask isn't just for a raise now — it's for a structured path to one. Lucas: Yes. And that's actually a stronger ask because it's more credible. You're saying, 'I understand this is a bet, and I want to earn my way up.' That's the kind of attitude most managers respect. Luna: I think that's the takeaway for Dana and for anyone else in this spot. Don't just ask for money — ask for a plan. Lucas: And if they won't even do that, then you have your answer about whether this company is the right place for your pivot. Sometimes the best raise is the one you get by moving on. Luna: That's a hard truth. But it's also liberating — it means you're not stuck. Lucas: Right. So, to sum up: research the market rate, anchor to the new role, acknowledge the ramp, ask for a structured review, and get it in writing. And if they won't budge, you have your answer. Luna: And if you're the listener who's been putting this off, maybe today's the day to start that research. Lucas: Yeah. Because the worst they can say is no, and if they do, you'll know more than you did before.