Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 315. Quietly Powerful: How Introverts Can Communicate With Confidence & Impact
Transcript
- 0:06Introversion is an asset.
- 0:07Quiet leaders bring tremendous value.
- 0:08My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:11Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:13Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:17Today, I really look forward to speaking with Susan Cain.
- 0:19Susan is a former Wall Street lawyer and negotiation consultant.
- 0:23She has spent years researching how society's extrovert ideal
- 0:27dramatically shapes our workplaces, schools, and daily communication.
- 0:31Susan is a New York Times bestselling author of Quiet: The Power of
- 0:35Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking, and Bittersweet: How
- 0:39Sorrow and Longing Make Us Whole.
- 0:41She also writes The Quiet Life Substack.
- 0:44Well, welcome, Susan.
- 0:46I have looked forward to this conversation for so long.
- 0:48I really appreciate you being here and the work that you've done.
- 0:51Oh my gosh.
- 0:52I appreciate your work so much.
- 0:54There's so much overlap between what we do, so I'm really glad
- 0:57that we got to make this happen.
- 0:58Well, thank you.
- 0:59Uh, shall we get started?
- 1:01Let's do.
- 1:01All right.
- 1:02I'd love to start with one of your foundational principles, and that
- 1:05is how people show up in terms of extroversion and introversion, and
- 1:10I'd love for you to talk about what those are and also to walk us through
- 1:14what you mean by the extrovert ideal.
- 1:17Well, introversion and extroversion, your listeners have probably heard
- 1:22before of the idea of it being kind of a question of where do you get
- 1:26your energy, that introverts derive energy from a more internal source, and
- 1:32therefore like quieter settings, and extroverts are kind of the opposite.
- 1:36And there's so much we could say about what these terms really mean, but I
- 1:39think that's as good a definition as any.
- 1:41And the way I think to really ask yourself which one am I really, because
- 1:47people lose sight of it, especially many introverts do because there's so much
- 1:51pressure from the time we're very small to act extroverted that many introverts
- 1:56come to believe they actually are extroverted until they think about it.
- 2:00So a couple of questions you could ask yourself.
- 2:03One would be, imagine that you have a weekend or a vacation and you have no
- 2:09social or professional obligations.
- 2:11How do you spend that time?
- 2:13Who do you spend it with?
- 2:14How many people do you spend it with?
- 2:17And what kinds of relationships are those people?
- 2:19Like, are you choosing to spend it with the people you know really well, or do you
- 2:24prefer the novelty of meeting new people?
- 2:26So all these things, when you really lift the obligations,
- 2:29tell you a lot about who you are.
- 2:32So the extroverted ideal is basically the cultural norm, which by the
- 2:35way, we see all over the world.
- 2:37There are national and cultural differences we can talk about, but
- 2:40still, I haven't really yet encountered a country where it isn't so, that there is
- 2:46a norm for people to be bold, assertive, talkative, and socially dominant.
- 2:55And it is important to say that especially in many Confucian societies,
- 3:01in China, Korea, and so on, there are great variations to this because in a
- 3:06society where social life is organized more around group harmony, there's
- 3:11kind of like equally an imperative for people not to stand out too much and not
- 3:19to talk too much nonsense is a phrase that I often hear from these cultures.
- 3:24And so I often find in those cultures you have a kind of double consciousness
- 3:27of, on the one hand, wanting not to talk too much, and on the other hand,
- 3:32feeling that you're supposed to.
- 3:33Whereas in the United States, I think it's much more like, yeah, we all
- 3:36feel that we're supposed to be uber comfortable in social settings and so on.
- 3:42And that can really work against introverts.
- 3:45And in fact, there are all kinds of studies showing that, like
- 3:49there's one from 2024 that showed that introverts are often sort of
- 3:53outperforming on actual productivity measures, but then not doing as well
- 3:58because they're seen as less visible.
- 4:00So one of the things we should actually really talk about is how
- 4:03do you become more visible as an introvert while still being yourself?
- 4:08Absolutely.
- 4:09There's a whole bunch of research that says many of the characteristics
- 4:11associated with people who are more introverted actually are
- 4:15critically essential to how we work, how we relate, et cetera.
- 4:19The ability to do deep thinking, to have higher emotional intelligence about
- 4:24what's going on, to be able to listen deeply, those are all useful skills.
- 4:28Before we get into the actions that more introverted people can take, I,
- 4:33given the work that I do around helping people feel more comfortable and
- 4:36confident in communication, to my mind, there's a confusing of having anxiety
- 4:42in speaking and being introverted, and I'd love to hear your take on it.
- 4:46I know what I say, and I'm happy to share that with you, but I'd love
- 4:48to hear your approach to it because I believe fully it's possible to
- 4:51be a very confident introvert and to be a very anxious extrovert.
- 4:56Absolutely.
- 4:57I think what you're getting at is the overlap and the confusion
- 5:00between the difference between shyness and introversion.
- 5:03My work actually touches on both.
- 5:05Both are relevant, but shyness is much more what you were just describing.
- 5:08It's a kind of excessive social anxiety that tends to come out in situations
- 5:12where people are judged, whether that's a work meeting or a job interview or giving
- 5:18a speech, or could be going on a date.
- 5:21And many people will experience shyness and social anxiety in
- 5:24one of those settings, but not in another, so it really varies.
- 5:27And as you say, you could be an extrovert who has that kind of anxiety, and you
- 5:31could be an introvert who really doesn't.
- 5:34Although in practice, there is some overlap between the two,
- 5:37but yeah, not necessarily.
- 5:38Because introversion is much more about, it's just a preference for being in
- 5:44situations where you're less bombarded by stimulation of all kinds, like, you
- 5:48know, fewer people around, less sound, fewer inputs, and that's where introverts
- 5:53are at their best, at their most creative, at their happiest, and so on.
- 5:57So that ends up translating into the social world because if you are an
- 6:01introvert who prefers fewer inputs coming at you, you're probably not
- 6:06gonna be at your happiest when you're in a big group meeting with multiple
- 6:10social signals coming in all at once.
- 6:13But that's not necessarily shyness, it can be introversion.
- 6:16Right.
- 6:17And I really appreciate you separating those two concepts.
- 6:20And again, there are clearly relations, but there are things that people who
- 6:24are shy or people who have anxiety around communication or social anxiety
- 6:29can do that can help them, that may or may not help address some of the
- 6:33issues that they're experiencing with introversion and extroversion.
- 6:36I'm curious, what advice and guidance do you give people to help them feel more
- 6:40confident and calm in those circumstances?
- 6:43Well, I mean, it depends on the setting, and different settings are
- 6:47challenging for different people.
- 6:48But the core principle that I would say applies to all these settings is the
- 6:53kind of miracle of desensitization, which is an idea well proven in psychology,
- 6:59that if you have a fear of anything, it could be a fear of snakes or elevators
- 7:04or whatever, the best way to overcome the fear is to expose yourself to it in
- 7:09very small and very manageable doses.
- 7:12So, for example, I had a fear, like a really, really deep and
- 7:17grave fear of public speaking.
- 7:20I had it all my life.
- 7:22And the way I overcame that was, it was actually when my book Quiet
- 7:28was coming out, and I didn't want my fear to stand in the way of my
- 7:32ability to communicate about the book.
- 7:35So I went to this seminar for people with public speaking anxiety that used these
- 7:40principles of desensitization, so that on the first day, all you had to do was
- 7:45stand up, say your name, sit back down, you were finished, you declare victory.
- 7:51And then you'd come back the next week, and the exercise would be
- 7:54ever so slightly more challenging.
- 7:56Uh, maybe you'd stand up and answer a few questions about
- 7:58yourself and then sit back down.
- 8:01And what you're really doing is little by little, you are rewiring your brain.
- 8:07What happens when you have social anxiety is your brain is basically
- 8:11interpreting the social encounter as an encounter with a saber-toothed tiger,
- 8:17and you're reacting as if that were true.
- 8:20And so you're basically teaching your brain that it's not true, and that this
- 8:24kind of social encounter is actually okay.
- 8:27And if you do that enough times, it actually really works.
- 8:31Yeah, there are many, many techniques.
- 8:32Desensitization is a very powerful one, one that's been studied for a long time.
- 8:36And the cool thing is you don't actually have to do it in a situation
- 8:40like you did, where you're in front of a group of people doing it.
- 8:43You can actually, there's a whole bunch of research on visualization, where you
- 8:46can do it just inside your own head, almost like a flight simulator for pilots.
- 8:50So for some people, it's just too much to go to that initial meeting, so you
- 8:55can do some of that desensitization through visualization, and it helps.
- 8:58I love that technique.
- 9:00I want to switch to what we all can do, but leaders play a role in this as well.
- 9:04And you talk about quiet leaders.
- 9:06Can you define what that is?
- 9:08And then I want to ask about how we can set up environments to support
- 9:12people who are more introverted.
- 9:15I think hopefully many of us can think of quiet leaders we know.
- 9:18They're often people who listen a little bit more than they talk.
- 9:22They maybe reflect a little more than is typical before making a decision.
- 9:27They might lead through asking a lot of questions and understanding inputs from
- 9:33their team and then going off to process and then coming up with their decision.
- 9:38They often are building those deep one-on-one relationships.
- 9:41So quiet leaders show up in these forms, and there's actually quite
- 9:45a bit of data showing that quiet leaders deliver outcomes that are as
- 9:51strong, and in some cases stronger, than those of extroverted leaders.
- 9:55So it's a real paradox because the problem is that people who have
- 9:59these characteristics tend not to be cultivated as much for leadership
- 10:03positions, but that leads to a colossal waste of talent because
- 10:07they actually deliver great results.
- 10:11And I think there has to be a, a mindset shift over what good leaders are.
- 10:15As you were describing the characteristics of an effective quiet leader, for
- 10:19me, that was quite aspirational.
- 10:20I would love in the leading I do to exhibit some of those.
- 10:24If you were a manager, leader in an organization and you wanted to build
- 10:29in practices, procedures that would really allow introverts to feel more
- 10:37engaged or more comfortable, what might be some things you would do?
- 10:41I could imagine, for example, having updates where people might write
- 10:46the updates rather than have to stand up and share their updates.
- 10:48I'm just curious if there's some very specific tactics that you would put in
- 10:51place if you could set up an environment in the workplace for introverts.
- 10:56Well, I think the first thing that I would do is evaluate the evaluation
- 11:00system to make sure that when hiring and when promoting, when identifying
- 11:07candidates for leadership within the organization, to make sure you're
- 11:10using the right criteria so that you're actually getting in your net the
- 11:15talented, committed introverts, because I can tell you, you're probably not.
- 11:20You're probably letting a lot of talented people slide through if
- 11:24the criteria look like coding for sort of conventional visibility.
- 11:29So that's the first thing.
- 11:30I would give a lot of thought to how do I structure meetings and making
- 11:34sure that there are times within each person's workday where they get to put
- 11:41their head down and enter a state of flow and know that they're not gonna
- 11:44be called into a spontaneous meeting.
- 11:47You know, and maybe that looks like setting aside times in the
- 11:50workday where it's head down time.
- 11:52And then within meetings themselves, there are so many different things one
- 11:55can do, like make sure that you hear from everybody when making a group
- 12:01decision, but also building in time for each person to be able to think.
- 12:07And that benefits everybody because what tends to happen in meetings is there's
- 12:12not really much thought given in advance to what you're going to be talking about.
- 12:17And then the loudest or most dominant people come in and hog up the microphone.
- 12:22And we know from the Kellogg School that three people do 70% of the
- 12:25talking in your typical meeting.
- 12:27So how do you avoid that?
- 12:30One of my favorite techniques comes from the world of education.
- 12:33It's called think-pair-share.
- 12:35And what you do is you, let's say you're trying to make a decision,
- 12:39you have everybody sit quietly and think about their ideas.
- 12:42Then you have people talk about it in pairs just with one other
- 12:45person, and only then do you start sharing out with a group.
- 12:48And you end up getting not only more participation, not only
- 12:53broader, but also more thoughtful participation from everybody, the
- 12:56extroverts as well as the introverts.
- 12:59Think-pair-share is a technique I have always adored and in my
- 13:02teaching use it repeatedly for all the reasons you talked about.
- 13:05It's also a wonderful tool if you have people who perhaps
- 13:09are newer to a language.
- 13:11It gives that same opportunity.
- 13:13Wonderful specific advice on how to structure the meetings.
- 13:16The point about how we are assessing people and what those criteria are
- 13:21in looking at how they are perhaps negatively impacting introverts
- 13:26and finding the, the talent.
- 13:27Thank you for sharing that.
- 13:29I want to switch to your other book, Bittersweet.
- 13:31And in that, you explore the power of embracing emotional complexity,
- 13:35such as longing and sorrow.
- 13:37In a business world that heavily indexes on positivity, crushing it,
- 13:42just moving forward, how can leaders and all of us effectively communicate
- 13:46vulnerability and to be, you know, emotionally whole when we show up at work?
- 13:52Any ideas about how to do that in the way we relate and communicate?
- 13:56It's a tricky thing because there can be a risk to being too vulnerable,
- 14:01especially if you're in a leadership position, because people want to know
- 14:04that their boss has got it together and that their leader knows what's
- 14:07happening and that they can rely on them.
- 14:09And at the same time, they also want to know the truth.
- 14:12And the truth involves vulnerability because the truth involves, "Well, I
- 14:19don't know if we're going to be able to make our shipment. I don't know if we're
- 14:21going to be able to make our numbers." So you want to find a way to share that
- 14:26information truthfully while at the same time communicating that you have a plan.
- 14:33But kind of the broader perspective for all that, I would offer a, a
- 14:36different example, which is a case study that I wrote about in Bittersweet.
- 14:40This is a Harvard business case study of an oil rig off the coast
- 14:45of Texas and the Gulf of Mexico.
- 14:48And they profiled the leader of this oil rig, who was a very classical
- 14:53sort of dominant type of guy.
- 14:55And he started to feel that things were not working the way they should.
- 15:00And he did a really introspective deep dive and realized that the
- 15:04problem was that he wasn't being truthful with the people in his
- 15:09workplace, with members of his family.
- 15:11He wasn't really being truthful about what he was experiencing.
- 15:15And he went through this process of learning to do that and of encouraging
- 15:19other workers to do that as well, to really show up and talk about what
- 15:24was going on in their personal lives.
- 15:26And as a result of this, the accident rates at this oil rig went way
- 15:31down because suddenly people were comfortable saying, "You know what?
- 15:35I think this system might not work, and I'm worried that
- 15:39there could be an accident.
- 15:40So how about if we try doing such and such thing?" Whereas before, there had
- 15:43been a culture where it was a quite macho culture, and you never would
- 15:46have wanted to do that because it would have made you look too uncertain.
- 15:49So accident rates went down and their productivity went way up.
- 15:54So the takeaway is there are ways to express what you are truly experiencing.
- 16:01But if you pair it by offering a plan and an idea and a belief of what we
- 16:09can do with this uncertainty, what we can do with this vulnerability,
- 16:13then people will trust it.
- 16:14Setting up psychological safety and role modeling, I think are two things
- 16:20I took away from what you said, and the result of it can be really positive.
- 16:24I appreciate that, and clearly there are benefits to that.
- 16:27I see a thread across your work is trying to find ways to bring power and
- 16:33motivation and the full strength of the people in organizations when there might
- 16:37be biases against some of those ways.
- 16:40Well, Susan, this has been lovely.
- 16:42I knew that we would learn a lot from you, and I personally am
- 16:45really enjoying the conversation.
- 16:47Before we end, I always ask the guests three questions.
- 16:50One I make up just for you, and the others I've been asking everybody.
- 16:53Are you up for that?
- 16:54Yes, absolutely.
- 16:56So I was delighted to learn something.
- 16:58As we were arranging for this meeting, I came to learn from your team
- 17:04that you encourage people to take time away from work and technology.
- 17:09Can you share a little bit about what motivates this, and what
- 17:11purpose does it fulfill for you and for those on your team?
- 17:15I guess beyond the obvious answer to that question is the fact that I personally
- 17:21have experienced burnout in my life.
- 17:25I know what it feels like, and I know what causes it.
- 17:27And I've experienced it in situations where I didn't like my job so much, and
- 17:32I've also experienced it with my current work, and I adore my current work.
- 17:37And there's still such a thing as burnout, even with work that you really love.
- 17:41We're especially prone to it in the age of technology, where we are so tethered
- 17:46to our phones and to our laptops.
- 17:49And like now people don't even say, "Let's get on a phone call."
- 17:52They say, "Let's have a Zoom." So, like just to have a conversation,
- 17:55you're often staring into a screen.
- 17:57It's terrible.
- 17:58So I think we really need to be getting away from all that as much as possible,
- 18:03not only to stay sane, but to stay, you know, creative and activated and happy.
- 18:08Right.
- 18:08And I just thought it was great to see that it was a policy, and it was
- 18:11a policy that was being dictated from the person running the organization.
- 18:15Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 18:20Well, you know, my favorite communicator of all time, to whom
- 18:24I dedicated my book Bittersweet, is Leonard Cohen, the musician.
- 18:29And I love him, and many people do, because he is telling the
- 18:35truth, and you know he is.
- 18:38He's not the best singer.
- 18:40He wasn't the best-looking man.
- 18:41He often wasn't happy.
- 18:43He suffered from depression throughout much of his life.
- 18:47And he told the truth about all of it.
- 18:49And in so doing, he became incredibly charismatic in his own way, and you felt
- 18:55like you were getting the real thing.
- 18:57Absolutely.
- 18:58That authenticity, that truthfulness, very important, and I appreciate you sharing.
- 19:02Final question for you.
- 19:04What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:10Well, I mean, I guess the first one is what we were just talking
- 19:13about and have been talking about throughout, and I would say sincerity.
- 19:18We are evolutionarily designed to be able to read all kinds of cues from the people
- 19:23we're speaking to and make all kinds of unconscious conclusions about them
- 19:29without even knowing how we got there.
- 19:31And so whatever mode you are speaking in, people are going to know it.
- 19:37And so it is true that there are people like, you know, your classic con
- 19:40man, let's say, who gets by by making people feel really good and believing
- 19:47something that isn't true, by promising things that the people want to hear.
- 19:51But that doesn't work over time.
- 19:53That kind of person is really good in a first meeting, maybe
- 19:57a second meeting, maybe a third.
- 19:59Doesn't work over time.
- 20:01Over time, what works is truly showing up in a way where you actually care,
- 20:07you're actually trying to give value.
- 20:09People will know it.
- 20:10So maybe I'm saying two things.
- 20:12One is to attend to your inner state, knowing that it's your inner state that
- 20:17people are going to be reacting to.
- 20:19And number two is to be sincere.
- 20:21And then I would say number three is to find the place in you that truly
- 20:28enjoys other people and enjoys the world, and try to tap into that aspect
- 20:34of yourself when you're going into difficult communication settings.
- 20:39Because we all have the more pessimistic sides or more despairing sides or
- 20:43whatever, and then we have the hopeful and positive energy sides of ourselves.
- 20:48Both those sides are okay and great, but it can be helpful to
- 20:52just sort of mindfully shift from one to the other as you need to.
- 20:56Yeah, and the ability to toggle between those is really important.
- 20:59So understand your inner state, where you're coming from, how you are in the
- 21:03world, be sincere, and look for the external opportunities where you really
- 21:08find joy and connection in others.
- 21:10Those are really powerful and important ingredients.
- 21:14And this has been a really important conversation.
- 21:16I know many people listening and watching to this, and just many
- 21:19people in the world feel in some ways inadequate or deficient because of
- 21:24their introversion or their shyness.
- 21:26And in fact, the contributions and opportunities that they have to help
- 21:30everybody are very positive and strong.
- 21:32And I appreciate you highlighting what those are and ways in
- 21:35which we can enable that.
- 21:36So thank you for your time, and thank you for your insight.
- 21:39Oh my gosh.
- 21:40Thank you so much for having me and for the work you do in the world.
- 21:43I think it's so, so important, so thank you.
- 21:47Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 21:49Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 21:52To learn more about confidence building, please listen to
- 21:54episode 69 with Kelly McGonigal.
- 21:57This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me,
- 22:01Matt Abrahams, with special thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 22:05Our music is by Floyd Wonder.
- 22:07Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 22:10Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 22:13Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 22:16And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 22:20learning content, and our newsletter.
- 22:22Please consider joining our Think Fast, Talk Smart Learning Community
- 22:25at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 22:28You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, an AI
- 22:31coach, and book club opportunities.
- 22:34Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast,
- 22:39Talk Smart Learning Community.