Latest / The PR Bunker / From Journalist to Fractional CCO: The Accidental Success Story
Transcript
- Don Martelli: Welcome back down to the bunker. Appreciate you being here. Interesting guest today, because I'm not interviewing somebody from the traditional news media PR side, but somebody I would probably consider a fantastic referral partner of mine that kind of fills the skills gaps in my work. Joshua Altman, pleasure to have you down here at the PR Bunker. I can't wait to tell your story, get into your background, and let's geek out about media and everything that you're touching with your clients. Thanks for coming. Joshua: Thank you for having me. Let's go. Don Martelli: We were ⁓ where are you calling in from today? Joshua: We are in the DC area. Don Martelli: Excellent, excellent. So you like smack dab in DC on the outskirts, where exactly are you? Joshua: We're in the outskirts. Don Martelli: Okay, you go. Excellent. And so, firmly believe that folks that I have in this podcast, we all have interesting journeys and stories in terms of where we are today professionally. love to first and foremost, have you describe your business, what you do for work, the clients you work for, and then kind of back in how you got there. Joshua: We're fractional chief communications officers. That means our focus is on shaping perception and building and maintaining trust. We do that with our clients, we take a big picture view of how messaging impacts reputation, growth, and stakeholder confidence. We're fractional. That means we're contractual, we're right there with you however many hours you need us. It's not an agency. We're not there to just consult and be done. We work with agencies you already have in place. If you bring us in and you have, say, a Google Ads agency, you have a media relations firm, you, your c your ⁓ the vice president of operations are tired of managing those relationships, that's one of the reasons we come in. So you can get back to doing your job and not managing. Don Martelli: Got. What kind of clients do you work for? What what industries are your clients in? Joshua: They're across all industries. Our focus isn't on one particular industry, it's on your stage of growth. So we work with everything from solopreneur, one person, pizza startups. To anyone up to about 250 employees is the cap depending on the industry. that's because we work with startups, we work with professional services firm, we've also done government contracting. And the reason you really see that gap between, you know, some people might need this, you know, full time at higher number of people versus a lower, ⁓ is might have a hundred engineers on your team, but you've never really thought about the communications before. Meanwhile, if you're like a home services company, you're Professional services company, you might have brought on that marketing assistant when you were closer to 10 or 15 people. And that's why there's such a range, because you might not have thought about it. And we fill that gap from day one, which is when you really should be starting to think about your communications, to ⁓ you need that full-time, in-house, 40-hour a week senior communications leadership role. Don Martelli: Hm. you get into the business? Joshua: Accidentally. Don Martelli: Love that. L I love accidental successes. So tell the tell us the accident. Tell us about the story. Joshua: I started as a reporter. I went to journalism school. I thought I'd spend my career as a journalist. I was a multimedia producer doing, you know, video, photo, web, you know, front end and back end web development, all that sort of stuff. I my newsroom role. I thought I'd be a freelance reporter for a few years and then go back to a newsroom and that was more than a decade ago. While I looking for freelance reporting jobs, I found these jobs as well. And they were the same types of business. Don Martelli: ⁓ cool. Joshua: We serve now, small and medium firms, they may have had a low-level marketing assistant, what they really needed was someone to come in and look at their visuals, their video, look at their content, look at the web stuff, all of that, and really bring it all together. And I had the writing background, because I had the video background, I was able to do that. ⁓ And firms, you know, they couldn't afford a $50,000 a month big agency retainer, but that's what they needed. by doing this in that fractional way, we were able to fill that gap for these businesses. And it sort of grew organically. ⁓ Don Martelli: Mm. So would you say and I I I think I know the answer to this, but it's the same job, right? But you're just kind of doing it yeah, versus being objective. Now you are managing the relationship or the the reputation. So what what are the similarities between your your journalism start to what you're doing today and then what are the differences? Joshua: A lot of it's similar. It's all about stories. It's all about telling that good narrative. it's really all about trust. Our big focus is on trust. If you think about any purchase decision you make, both B2B, B2C, whatever it is, it comes down to trust. Do we trust your company? Now some are high trust purchases, some are lower trust purchases. But trust is at the center of all of them. And ⁓ I a political reporter. people vote are do I trust you? Do I trust you to make decisions on my behalf? So in that way it's very similar. In terms of the infrastructure, it works a little differently because politicians and newsrooms have, at least the ones I was working with, larger staff where I'm working with now smaller companies where they don't have that large infrastructure. We're coming in with them to help build it. Don Martelli: Got it. Excellent. Got it. growing your these days? It is a little bit of networking? Are you are you kind of doing the work you typically do for your clients, but for yourself as well? Joshua: I try not to do it for myself because and we say this to our clients because a lot of times they're already doing some of this for themselves, is you don't want to do it because this isn't your area of expertise. You are, you know, in healthcare. You are in lawn care, whatever your business is, which is why we say we are the experts at communicating your expertise. And when it comes to doing it for yourself, you're too biased. It's very hard to objectively look at that and say, sit well, what's our differentiator? What's our value property? It's very hard to objectively do Don Martelli: Mm, mm-hmm. Joshua: This for yourself. So that is why it's not something that's totally in-house. But there's a lot of networking, there's a lot of referrals, there's what we're doing now, this podcasting you know becomes social media clips that gets out for engagement to show expertise. And this is the same type of stuff we tell our clients to do all the time. Don Martelli: Fair good point. Joshua: Of course, like I said, when you're doing it for yourself, y there's bias and it's a lot harder. Don Martelli: Valid. What do you you know, clearly running a business is hard, ⁓ 'cause you're the CFO, marketing manager, the executive, the board. and are hard days and bad and bad days, good days, good days, bad days, and everything in between. But what fuels you to do what you do? 'Cause you know, you can go find another job, be a W two employee, but w as a business owner and as a small business owner, it's hard. But what drives you to to to continue to push and and to try to succeed? Joshua: Mm-hmm. I get to work with great people who are, you know, doing great things. You know, the startups are doing their niche, they're trying to change whatever it is, but also people who are in home services, professional services, they're government contractors. are trying to because we're working with smaller businesses, they're trying to do something that's already a little different than the giant firms. And that means everything we get to do can be little different. We get to take a little more risk. And actually we've talked about this a lot in our newsletters recently is having a distinctive voice, having positions on industry, having those things to say is in ways more important now than just producing the content. Because with AI, content is easy. Slop is easy to produce. You could put out thousands of words. A minute if you wanted to. But having that distinctive perspective what a big difference. ⁓ Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Love that you touch on upon upon that because oftentimes when people think about marketing communications, they always land on the channel first and they don't think about the strategy beforehand because every organization is trying to communicate to one person or another group of people in some way, shape, or form. So as you're going into a client engagement, what's that, you know, how's that sausage made, right? What what's the how's the work start? Because, you know, people want to start with, ⁓ we should be on TikTok, we should be on Substack, we should be in all these places. Joshua: Mm-hmm. Don Martelli: What's your what's your from your what's your unique process or your the process you have in general as you're working with clients to kind of get them off the channel thoughts and focus on the strategy? Joshua: We have two main frameworks that we use. The first one is story, narrative, and brand. And that's to really get you thinking about what you have, what is what you're trying to tell. a lot of people call us at the brand stage. Because they've never thought about story and narrative. You know, story is what you tell your friends at the bars, disjointed stuff. It's facts. the beginning, the middle, and the present. It's how you got here. Narrative questions. It connects the dots. ⁓ It the through line between parts of your story. ⁓ It people what we want them to think about our story, how we want them to think about it. And then is the swag. It's the stuff. It's ⁓ everything. So yeah, that's you know, actual swag. Pens and T shirts and you know decals on cars and logos and all of that. But it's also phone trees, hold music, it's email that auto-generates when someone signs up for your email list. All of those things, because people interact with it, are part of your brand. And a lot of people have brand and they haven't thought about story and narrative. So it doesn't connect as well. So we start forming those connections. And that really helps us figure out is the narrative we're telling. How are we answering these questions? How are we building trust with people? And could do this on your own. You just, you know, take a piece of paper, divide it into thirds, right? Story, narrative, brand, and just start answering those questions. You know, our story is what are the facts? Our narrative answers these questions. Our brand, what swag do we have? This is something really easy that you could take those first steps. Don Martelli: Love that. Joshua: I our next one that we use goes towards those channels you mentioned. And that's our four languages model. And it's what people read, see, hear, and experience. Read is probably the most intuitive. People kind of get it. It's the stuff that you read. And that's a lot of what we consume now. As we scroll through Instagram and LinkedIn and Reddit and all the other things on our phones all day, we're reading. But we're also seeing. It has pictures, it's how the it's how the text is presented. It's the layout, it's graphic All of that goes to C. Here often gets thought of as much. It's what we're doing now, it's podcasts. It's things people hear. Like I mentioned before, your hold music is something people hear that's part of your brand. It's those phone trees. It's in-store audio if you have real physical locations. And there's a lot of work being done now around optimizing in-store audio from the moment someone walks into the store as they go through aisles until they check out. what you might hear if say someone has four locations in one city. At one store at in that same aisle might be different at another location because they're really trying to optimize this. And then experience, which people think of as experiential stuff, conferences and pop-ups and events and all of that. And that is part of experience. But there's a second part of it. that's how people experience what we read, see, and hear. So I mentioned podcast, that's a great example of what we hear. We're doing it now, but we're also recording video. Some people are gonna sit and watch this and it's appointment viewing for them, and thank you, please sit and watch this as appointment viewing. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Joshua: But many people like me don't. We listen to podcasts. Podcasts are what we have on while we're driving, and please, if you're driving, do not watch it. Please listen. put your attention on the road, it's what we have on when we are walking the dog. It's we have on while we're making dinner for our families. We're getting the same information as someone in the video, watching that video, but two different experiences. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Mm, big time. Joshua: Another one we all see every day is mobile versus desktop. How we experience that. does it load fast? Does it display right? And thankfully now just a lot of you know ⁓ systems already handle that for us as opposed to 10 years ago, where optimizing for both of those was much harder. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Sure. Yeah, good point. Very good point. How about AI? I mean clearly you can't go anywhere in our business without hearing about it, using it in some way, shape, or form. What's w how how just generally for either for your business, for your clients, what tools do you're using? What edges are you bleeding towards? How are you leveraging AI and your in your in your in your flow? Joshua: We use it. It's great. It's a great tool, but that's all it is. It's a tool. You know, if you handed me a hammer, you'd be lucky if you got a bird house a bird even wants to look at. You hand a master craftsman a hammer, you're gonna get a great structure that fa looks great. Families can live in this for hundreds of years. We had the same hammer. He actually knows how to use it. the same way. Don Martelli: Ha ha ha. Yeah, ⁓ yeah. A mansion. Mm-hmm. Good analogy. Got it. Joshua: You have to know how to use it and use it responsibly. It's great for certain things. It's great for research. It's great for outlines. You know, we had to research pretty much basic demographic information for more than two dozen cities. That t it's it's really running a lot of Google searches to get vital statistics offices in a lot of cities for a client because we had to know markets. Well, you could put that list of cities into AI. Don Martelli: Yeah. Joshua: Give it restrictions. You can only do, you know, dot govs or office of vital statistics or you know city health department, whatever it was. And that saves a lot of time. Because really, all we would be doing is those same Google searches and copying those same answers. You have to check it, you have to tell it to provide all the sources, and you have to really be careful verifying all the information. You also have to make sure you put in the right inputs. If we put in Rome, it doesn't know if we want Rome, Georgia, or Rome, Italy. Does we want Paris, Texas, or Paris, France? You have to be specific with these things. So that's kind of where it can fail is we wanted Paris, Texas, it gave us Paris, France. You really do need to give yeah, you gotta give it very specific instructions. But it's great for that sort of thing. It's great for outlines. Don Martelli: Doward. Mm. Big difference. Mm-hmm. Agreed. Joshua: And if you're doing stuff yourself, it does solve that problem of staring at a blank page. If it gives you that intro paragraph, if it gives you something, okay. For a lot of people that's the hardest part. For professionals, that's the hardest part. It gives you a little bit to work with. And then you can take over and do the human part of it. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Joshua: Because we've all seen the AI slop. We know what it isn't, we know what it is, we know it when we see it. No one wants it. No one wants to consume it. And it's been getting called out a lot more. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Nope. And I'm sure it'll continue. And I'm sure as the tools get smarter and you know, I couldn't couldn't agree with you more where the tools are fantastic, but it really comes down to how you program guardrail and f you know, the project or the or the agent whatever you built out, these are the things I want, this is how I want them, this is the infrastructure to which you're gonna pull from, these are your source of truths, versus just, hey, give me a prompt and so and so and it's gonna give you, as you pointed out, a bunch of a bunch of you know what slop. Joshua: Yeah. Yeah. And it takes time to do that. I will say Don Martelli: Let me ask you this. Yeah, it it does. It well, that's the investment, right? That's that's a thousand percent I'd rather spend the time there because the outputs are gonna be much better. Yeah. Joshua: Much better. And I don't mean it takes an afternoon you're gonna spend on this. It is you do it once then you have to do it again, like, okay, this is what you gave me, AI. It likes being called you. We could discuss that at length, but it likes being called you. This is what I got. This is my correct version. And do that over period of months in some cases to really refine it. And ultimately there's a payoff. Don Martelli: Agreed. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. ⁓ yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Joshua: But you have to be very patient and invest a lot of time that training. Don Martelli: Yeah, if you just run it through it day one, expect that day one kind of result. But if it's day at one hundred and you've continued to refine it and teach it and tweak it. Nope. Never. Because today's the worst day AI will ever be. Because tomorrow will be better. It just keeps going and going and going and going. Joshua: А невесто. Or they released a new model that does things differently and the prompts you built and the restrictions you put in are now giving you worse outputs and you have to refine again. It it is always gonna be a process with it. Don Martelli: Yeah. Yeah. And then the g yeah. And then the government takes that that that diversion off the off the ⁓ off the rolls. let me ask you this. Agreed. Smart, smart. That's a good take, by the way. in of like when what what's the trigger for people to hire you and your your agency and your team? Like when and they're thinking about my business is blah, I need to get ⁓ blah. Joshua: Ha ha. Which is why you back up your instructions. Don Martelli: When do the when should they be thinking about we need help in these particular areas? What's that look like? What's a good referral? Joshua: They should be thinking about it on day one because it's a lot easier to build that foundation from the beginning than it is kind of go backwards. Like I said, we start with brand in a lot of cases because that's where people call us. But it starts a lot, it's a lot easier to start with story from the beginning. In reality, most people don't call us day one. That's not a situation we're infrequently. It's happened, but it's not the most frequent situation. People call us when they're looking to do a rebrand. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Joshua: More like likely is the owner, president, something in the leadership of a small business, small, medium-sized firm, and they're saying, I am sick of writing these weekly email blasts. I do not want to be managing our social media accounts and those, you know, marketing managers anymore. Why am I spending three hours a week on Google meetings with our firm that we've hired for this? Because that's not their job. They're VP of operations. That's their job. And then we get c called and we come in and taking that off the person's plate because it's not a 40 hour a week role at that company, which is why they've never hired someone full time. They'll do in the man say, it's taking me five to six hours a week. Well, we're not gonna spend forty hour a week employee on that. Don Martelli: Hm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Joshua: And then we fill that gap. Don Martelli: Got it. Okay. How about you know, as as a as a business owner, clearly, you know, day one's much different than day one hundred. What are what are the things you've learned, you know, at this particular stage of your business that you wish you knew going into this thing day one? Joshua: you'll pivot a lot more than you think you will. That was something that on initial plan. We didn't call ourselves ⁓ fractional communications officers from day one. We were consultants and freelancers and then we were the agency and then an unagency. And then settled on fractional chief communications officer because people really understood fractional. That was something p that made sense for people. And our model didn't fit. any of those other things. So we kept pivoting. And that's what you need to do because the world tr around us changes all the time. Don Martelli: Very true. Very true. How about this? this is one of the kind of random questions I always throw to people that are on my podcast. If you weren't doing what you're doing now, nor being a journalist, what would your profession be? Joshua: dogs, working with dogs. Don Martelli: Working with dogs, got it like training dogs or doing grooming. What what's that look like? Joshua: work with dog rescue. I'm a volunteer with local dog rescue ⁓ all the different things we do there, coordinating dogs, you know, I was a foster for a long time. So something in that space. Probably not in veterinary care, that wouldn't be for me. Don Martelli: ⁓ that's cool. Nice. Nice. ⁓ cool. So how do Got it. Do you have do I'm assuming you have a dog now or dogs now or no? What kind of dogs do you have? There you go. Cool. I've I've got a white ⁓ Shepherd's about a hundred and ish pounds. it's the first dog I've had for quite some time, but we'd we'd love to get another one down the line. I see those see those rescue videos all the time, and and I think those that are marketing those shelters do a fantastic job, especially like on the social media channels, because you see these dogs and all they want to do is rescue every single one of them. Joshua: I do. Yes. Yes. ⁓ a street map. Yeah. Yes. Don Martelli: I wanna I want a three thousand, three million square foot home, get all the dogs and let ⁓ run around, let ⁓ do their thing. Joshua: Yeah. And that's what I would do if I didn't have this. Don Martelli: That's cool. That's cool. What's what ⁓ what what's the what kind of breeds do you like? All the all the breeds, so it just doesn't matter. Yeah, ⁓ That's cool. Joshua: ⁓ all of I mean w I work with a shelter ⁓ it's a so we get a mix of everything. Don Martelli: Yeah. I like big, loofy, like big headed dogs. Big clumsy ones that drool all over the place that just, you know, are silly and want their belly rubbed all the time. the little ones are pretty cool too, 'cause I I like the little ones 'cause they're pretty feisty. You know, they're like this big, but they've got an attitude as like a German shepherd. You know? Yeah, that's cool. ⁓ Joshua: Yeah. I I have my dog's not a hundred pounds, but I yeah, he's bigger. Don Martelli: Yeah, mine that my dog's name is Daisy. ⁓ I I love I I love the she's getting up there. She'll be thirteen this December, so she's an old lady, but we we try to I walk her every ⁓ at least twice, if not sometimes three times a day and up and down the block and she's it's funny, as as the dogs have gotten older, it's it's it's about it's about the the smells and the sniffing versus the distance know, now she wants to sniff every corner, every brick, every tree. I'm like, all let's go. Good stuff. Well, how about this? Where if ⁓ you know, if if people are in that stage where they need that fractional work, what's the best way they can find you? Joshua: Email me jayaltman at beltway.media. You can also visit our website, beltway.media no dot com. there's a link right there to book a meeting. You could also find me on LinkedIn, ⁓ Joshua dash I dash Altman. Don Martelli: Okay. Excellent. Cool. Excellent. Do you guys have a YouTube channel? Are you doing your own podcast and stuff like that too? Okay. Joshua: We do, so we don't host a podcast. ⁓ you can find us on YouTube, Instagram, and elsewhere as The Comms Chief. Don Martelli: Excellent. What's what's your thoughts on Substack these days? You Substack at all? Yeah, got it. Joshua: We have it, yeah. We have it, we use it. is a great channel that provides a lot of opportunities. I know for people who host podcasts, it has a built-in podcasting platform, it has newsletters, it makes it easy to monetize, but also easy to ⁓ do something free ⁓ also balance that. We recommend it to a lot of clients because it does provide a great place for both short and long engagements. Don Martelli: Mm. Mm-hmm. Mm. Mm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, that's the cool thing about our business, man. never know in in a a month or six months from now, some cool kid's gonna develop some channel that we're gonna have to balance at some point. You know, TikTok before that, Substack now, and there'll be some other tool ⁓ that we'll be contending with. Joshua: Yeah. Di s the ones we have today won't be the ones in fifteen years something new's always gonna come along. Don Martelli: No. Yeah. I mean, there's there's a long graveyard. Remember like Plerk Four Square? I mean, you could go I mean I I remember ⁓ geez, I mean a long time. and it's been a long time since I would ⁓ I would text message in my tweet to Twitter at that time. You know, four ⁓ four ⁓ four ⁓ Crazy, man. Crazy, good stuff. So one more time on your website. So if people need to find you, they can find you there. What's the website address? Joshua: When was the last time you checked your MySpace? Yeah. Yeah. Beltway dot media. Don Martelli: Excellent, Joshua. This has been a great conversation. Appreciate you stopping by the PR bunker. looking forward to getting to know you even more. So when I got clients that need your services, I'm happy to send them your way. But keep grinding down there in DC and keep saving those puppies and those dogs. That's a great mission. I appreciate the work there too. No problem. Joshua: Thank you.