Latest / Surrounded / 1 LGBTQ+ Activist vs 25 Conservatives (ft. Zander Moricz)
Transcript
- 0:00Participating in homosexual acts is inherently not loving because it's damaging.
- 0:04It violates natural damaging.
- 0:06It doesn't violate natural law.
- 0:07There are over 1000 species that are proven to have queer relationships.
- 0:15From Jubilee Media,
- 0:16this is Surrounded,
- 0:18where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:21Today's guest is an LGBTQ+ activist,
- 0:24Xander Morris.
- 0:25He is the executive director of Sea Alliance,
- 0:27and today he will be debating 25 conservatives.
- 0:30Xander will debate the conservatives one on one until
- 0:34they are voted out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 0:37Let's get into it.
- 0:39My first claim is Donald Trump and Elon Musk
- 0:41are grooming more young Americans than the LGBTQ+ community.
- 0:44Can we agree that grooming is bad and should be punished?
- 0:47Um,
- 0:47yeah,
- 0:48OK,
- 0:48what I would say is that Donald Trump and Elon Musk use
- 0:51their positions of influence over young Americans to change the way hundreds.
- 0:54Of thousands of young Americans think and behave throughout elementary,
- 0:57middle,
- 0:57and high schools,
- 0:58which has been documented,
- 0:59studied,
- 0:59and proven to increase bullying and harm,
- 1:01and it infringes on parental consent.
- 1:03I disagree.
- 1:05I think that
- 1:07what they are trying to do is.
- 1:10Not grooming,
- 1:12but
- 1:13trying to,
- 1:14let's define grooming.
- 1:15We should start by doing that.
- 1:16I would say that grooming is someone
- 1:18with a position of influence over another person
- 1:20attempting to change their thought patterns or behavior to exploit them.
- 1:23Would you agree?
- 1:24What I would say is that Donald Trump and Elon
- 1:25Musk are proven to have been doing that with elementary,
- 1:27middle,
- 1:28and high school children by sending targeted ads to youth demographics,
- 1:31accessing the rhetoric on social media,
- 1:32and what studies have shown,
- 1:34studies of tens of thousands of teachers reported incidents,
- 1:37school reports,
- 1:37hundreds.
- 1:38Of disciplinary reports sent to studies have proven that there's
- 1:42an increase in bullying in places where Donald Trump,
- 1:45I think they have a plan.
- 1:45Well,
- 1:46let me finish this really quickly.
- 1:47It's important to note that there have been thousands of cases of Donald Trump's
- 1:50rhetoric being linked specifically to bullying incidents
- 1:52that have been done by elementary schoolers,
- 1:54middle schoolers,
- 1:54and high schoolers who all said that they
- 1:56felt vindicated in their actions because Donald Trump,
- 1:58the president,
- 1:59told them that it was OK.
- 2:00And what we're also seeing is That in communities that
- 2:02have a 10 point increase in support for Donald Trump,
- 2:05there's an 8% increase in bullying.
- 2:07And the reason that this is unique is this has never happened in politics before.
- 2:10It hasn't mattered Republican or Democrat.
- 2:12It's specifically Donald Trump and Elon Musk
- 2:15working to change the minds of young Americans,
- 2:17and they're doing it for exploitative gain,
- 2:19exploitive.
- 2:21I think that we are tired.
- 2:23We're tired of
- 2:25Of the left or the LGBT community,
- 2:27we're tired of them trying to
- 2:30influence the children as well.
- 2:32No one's trying to influence the children
- 2:33except Donald Trump and Elon Musk.
- 2:35No,
- 2:35no,
- 2:35no,
- 2:35they're trying to influence the children,
- 2:37so the LGBTQ plus community is not trying to influence children.
- 2:40They're trying to save children's lives.
- 2:43I disagree.
- 2:44That's you can't disagree without facts,
- 2:46otherwise talk about castration.
- 2:47That's not saving lives.
- 2:49That's not saving lives.
- 2:50That's not saving lives break that down because it's a scary concept.
- 2:54If people were actually chemically castrating
- 2:57young Americans,
- 2:58I would also be freaking out.
- 3:00I would also have problems.
- 3:01But when we work with the medical professionals,
- 3:04when we talk to the psychologists,
- 3:05when we work with the families,
- 3:06we see that that is not happening.
- 3:08We see that that's not happening.
- 3:09There are 0.0.
- 3:101% of young Americans that are receiving non-reversible gender affirming care,
- 3:15and in 90% of those cases that was life saving care.
- 3:19That is life saving care.
- 3:20Tragedies happen.
- 3:22Medical mistakes society as a whole,
- 3:23OK.
- 3:24Do more people regret their gender affirming care,
- 3:26or do they regret knee surgery,
- 3:27hip replacement,
- 3:28LASIK eye surgery?
- 3:29OK,
- 3:29let's pause.
- 3:30You've been voted out by the majority.
- 3:33OK,
- 3:33so your claim is
- 3:35Donald Trump and Elon Musk are doing more grooming,
- 3:38right?
- 3:39Yes,
- 3:40than than LGBT activists,
- 3:42100%.
- 3:43Do you want to hear more about why?
- 3:44Um,
- 3:44sure,
- 3:44yeah,
- 3:44go ahead.
- 3:45OK,
- 3:45amazing.
- 3:45So Donald Trump's rhetoric has specifically been
- 3:47linked to bullying cases in elementary,
- 3:49middle,
- 3:49and high school.
- 3:50What we see are also that Donald Trump and Elon Musk are
- 3:52working in tandem to access young people through their phone screens.
- 3:55Donald Trump and Elon Musk worked to reduce Twitter protections,
- 3:59and we saw the firing of staff
- 4:00that worked to specifically set children's guidelines.
- 4:02We now see about one quarter of young people that are online are on.
- 4:05Twitter and they're accessing media because also
- 4:08the algorithm has been changed to make
- 4:09sure that Elon Musk's content and far-right content are boosted by about 1,000%,
- 4:12and that's been measured by a variety of studies.
- 4:14And so our young Americans while they're on
- 4:16their phones without parental supervision are absorbing rhetoric that
- 4:19psychologists have measured to be damaging not only
- 4:21to their minds but to their peers' minds.
- 4:23So we've specifically seen hundreds of cases in over 20 states that
- 4:28bullying has increased as a result of Donald Trump and Elon Musk's rhetoric.
- 4:31There was an Incident and it was heartbreaking
- 4:33where one student was bullied so severely that
- 4:35they attempted suicide because they kept being told
- 4:37Donald Trump says you need to leave.
- 4:39Donald Trump says you are illegal,
- 4:40and it is a heartbreaking,
- 4:41devastating truth because these young minds are not voters.
- 4:44This has nothing to do with the political campaign.
- 4:45It has everything to do with changing the political
- 4:47culture and working to specifically target young people.
- 4:50That's why they're banning books.
- 4:51That's why they're trying to restrict information
- 4:53that our children have access to and trying
- 4:54to give them a broken worldview so that when they continue to idolize Donald Trump.
- 4:58And Elon Musk,
- 4:59they won't know the line of when they've gone too far,
- 5:01and that's a huge problem.
- 5:03We should not have the most powerful person in the
- 5:05world who's setting an example for our young people,
- 5:07who most of our young people say they recognize
- 5:09as the most powerful person in the world,
- 5:11sharing hate speech that we see manifest in elementary school classrooms.
- 5:1590% of teachers surveyed after Donald
- 5:17Trump's first election stated that school climate
- 5:20worsened specifically due to Trump rhetoric and
- 5:23bullying that was directly linked to.
- 5:24Donald Trump's name and catchphrases.
- 5:26It's not a coincidence.
- 5:27It's not a parallel,
- 5:28and it's not something that's ever happened before.
- 5:30OK,
- 5:31OK,
- 5:31I,
- 5:31I understand what you're saying.
- 5:33Um,
- 5:34for the sake of the argument,
- 5:34I would say that,
- 5:35um,
- 5:36I agree to an extent,
- 5:38right?
- 5:38Obviously it depends on what we,
- 5:40what we're,
- 5:40what's grooming,
- 5:41right?
- 5:41Well,
- 5:42let's define grooming.
- 5:42Yeah,
- 5:43so what would you define grooming as?
- 5:44So typically in,
- 5:45I mean,
- 5:46most political circles,
- 5:47right,
- 5:47they would say grooming is any kind of act that kind of leads to like a sexual.
- 5:51That's sexual grooming.
- 5:52Grooming also works with terrorist organizations and cults,
- 5:55so I would say that grooming has a broad definition,
- 5:57but I would say that grooming is not intrinsic or exclusive to the political right,
- 6:02right?
- 6:02Grooming is,
- 6:03no,
- 6:03it's not.
- 6:03It's something that happens it happens everywhere.
- 6:05Democrats do it,
- 6:06Republicans do it,
- 6:06right.
- 6:07Some people whose favorite color is yellow do it too.
- 6:09Yes,
- 6:09but my point is,
- 6:10is that for the sake of argument,
- 6:12I would say I agree,
- 6:13but I kind of reject the initial premise
- 6:16because,
- 6:16uh,
- 6:17And even this,
- 6:18this ties into your,
- 6:19your previous point because I think what you're,
- 6:21what you're actually trying to say is that
- 6:22the agenda that LGBT activists agenda,
- 6:26everyone has an agenda.
- 6:27It doesn't matter.
- 6:28Well,
- 6:28of the LGBTQ activists make it sound like there's a coordinated agenda
- 6:31when in reality there's a bunch of people who if you're organized,
- 6:33if you're an organized group,
- 6:34you have an agenda.
- 6:35We're not organized.
- 6:36I promise we're disorganized.
- 6:37OK,
- 6:37well,
- 6:38for the sake of argument,
- 6:39let's just say
- 6:40every group has some kind of focus and things they're trying to accomplish,
- 6:44right?
- 6:44Um,
- 6:45that's not exclusive to one party,
- 6:46but the reason I,
- 6:47I think what you're trying to say is that LGBT groups aren't the issue,
- 6:50gun violence,
- 6:51stuff like that is the issue.
- 6:53But,
- 6:53but the reason why I kind of reject that premise is because
- 6:56when it comes to a lot of these medical,
- 6:58uh,
- 6:59conversations we have,
- 7:00there is actually no medical consensus.
- 7:02Like where,
- 7:03where there is a I think there is a medical consensus.
- 7:06How many doctors are in the AMA.
- 7:08Doctors who disagree,
- 7:09that by definition means that there's no medical consensus.
- 7:13Also,
- 7:13when you have when you have instances like,
- 7:16have you heard about the,
- 7:17there was a $10 million
- 7:18NIH funded study
- 7:20led by,
- 7:20I believe her name was
- 7:21uh Doctor Johanna,
- 7:23and she did a study and found that
- 7:27there were no,
- 7:28not no,
- 7:28but there weren't as much,
- 7:30uh.
- 7:31Uh,
- 7:31mental health benefits.
- 7:33I know what you're referencing,
- 7:34and that's been debunked and disproven.
- 7:35The box is gonna pop up here.
- 7:36OK,
- 7:37sure,
- 7:37but the thing is,
- 7:38when you have,
- 7:38when you have conversations,
- 7:40we have doctors
- 7:41in various groups who don't,
- 7:43there is no such thing as consensus when it comes to science.
- 7:46Like if you have people who there's
- 7:47technically no consensus that comes to everything,
- 7:49all it takes is one person in the corner of the world going like,
- 7:51I don't like french fries,
- 7:52and suddenly french fries are conservatives,
- 7:54the issues that conservatives have.
- 7:55Is the gaslighting when you say things like it's not happening,
- 7:58it's not happening,
- 7:58it's not happening
- 7:59because that is fundamentally not true and
- 8:01you can't have conversations that you're describing,
- 8:02let me clarify this because when I say it's not happening at all,
- 8:05I mean the way that you describe it because it's important for people listening
- 8:08and watching not to think that the
- 8:10care that you're describing is happening because,
- 8:12and let's break it down,
- 8:13the care that has been described throughout this episode as chemical crustration
- 8:17as these attacks on young Americans are not happening at all.
- 8:20Am I saying that any young American
- 8:21has ever regretted receiving gender affirming care?
- 8:24They have.
- 8:24It's heartbreaking,
- 8:25and I want our medical professionals to continue to learn more and do better.
- 8:29But to say what they're doing is happening is a lie,
- 8:32and I won't excuse a lie because the,
- 8:33the issue is that when you have
- 8:35other medical groups,
- 8:36I think you referenced the,
- 8:37the,
- 8:38uh,
- 8:38American Psychological Association and psychiatric,
- 8:40yeah,
- 8:41uh,
- 8:41yes,
- 8:42pediatric,
- 8:42even they have even.
- 8:43They have said that
- 8:45when it comes to gender affirming care,
- 8:47a lot of kids when they go through adolescence,
- 8:50when they go through puberty,
- 8:51no longer have that same gender dysphoria
- 8:54and it goes back to my,
- 8:55it goes back,
- 8:56but hold on,
- 8:56hold on,
- 8:57hold on,
- 8:57OK,
- 8:58you've been voted out by the majority.
- 9:00I appreciate you.
- 9:01You have a good vibe.
- 9:02OK,
- 9:03so,
- 9:03uh,
- 9:03you're saying that Elon Musk and Trump are grooming kids,
- 9:07right?
- 9:07OK,
- 9:08so,
- 9:08uh.
- 9:09You have a unique lifestyle,
- 9:11right,
- 9:11um,
- 9:12you know,
- 9:12gay,
- 9:13LGBTQ,
- 9:14to keep that lifestyle,
- 9:15we need men
- 9:17in this country to
- 9:18be in the army,
- 9:18right,
- 9:19to defend your right to have your unique unique I'm done with that,
- 9:22yeah,
- 9:22I support so
- 9:23some of the military.
- 9:24We got to stop pushing it on kids,
- 9:26pushing what on kids?
- 9:27The trans stuff,
- 9:29the
- 9:29LGBTQ stuff,
- 9:31talking about being trans
- 9:33and being queer
- 9:34made someone who is.
- 9:35Not trans and queer,
- 9:36more likely to be trans and queer,
- 9:37that would result in a lot of harm,
- 9:39but it's not happening.
- 9:40What is happening?
- 9:41It's not happening.
- 9:41Give me evidence.
- 9:42Well,
- 9:43it's,
- 9:43look at,
- 9:44look at California.
- 9:45There are more queer and trans people
- 9:46because queer and trans people feel more comfortable
- 9:48coming out and less likely that they're going to receive mass amounts of hatred.
- 9:52There's been a rise,
- 9:53there's been a rise
- 9:55in the LGBTQ,
- 9:56the trans,
- 9:57because there's more information out there.
- 9:58There's more affirmation out there.
- 10:00Because there's more media representation,
- 10:01the media loves to push it.
- 10:03It is evidenced over the last decade that the more queer people are discussed,
- 10:07why are we doing more queer people feel.
- 10:08Why are we doing drag queens are fun.
- 10:11Drag queens are,
- 10:12fun,
- 10:12but it's not for children.
- 10:13Why not for children?
- 10:14I would say a drag queen at a story hour
- 10:16is more like a birthday party clown than anything else.
- 10:18They have a fun hair,
- 10:19fun makeup,
- 10:20fun shoes,
- 10:20fun outfit.
- 10:21It's a strip drag queen.
- 10:23It's a striptease OK.
- 10:24Some drag queens are strip teases.
- 10:25If I ordered a birthday clown,
- 10:27if I ordered a birthday clown,
- 10:28and Pennywise showed up to my birthday party and started eating my children alive,
- 10:32I would be like,
- 10:33wait,
- 10:33that's the wrong clown.
- 10:34That's the wrong clown.
- 10:35No,
- 10:35no,
- 10:35no,
- 10:35no,
- 10:35no,
- 10:36no.
- 10:36Some drag queens,
- 10:37some drag queens perform at nightclubs,
- 10:39some drag queens read at bookstores.
- 10:41Some drag queens go to events,
- 10:43some drag queens go do festivals.
- 10:45There are no reported incidents.
- 10:47Hold on,
- 10:47this is important.
- 10:48Queer
- 10:48people,
- 10:49trans people,
- 10:50and drag queens.
- 10:51None of them,
- 10:52none of them have any correlation to being more likely to commit a sex crime,
- 10:56to be a groomer,
- 10:57or to do anything pedophilic.
- 10:58It's data.
- 10:59It's proven.
- 10:59The American Medical Association,
- 11:01American Psychological Association,
- 11:02the World Health Organization have proven,
- 11:04have proven that there is no more dang's going on.
- 11:07Let me tell you what's going on.
- 11:08The LGBTQ community has gone too far.
- 11:11OK,
- 11:11so I'm an ex-Democrat.
- 11:13I used to live in San Francisco,
- 11:15actually,
- 11:15yeah,
- 11:15yeah,
- 11:16so.
- 11:16Yeah,
- 11:17I,
- 11:17I went to gay pride and it was fun,
- 11:19you know,
- 11:19there's girls there,
- 11:20there's straight women,
- 11:21so obviously that's awesome.
- 11:24But,
- 11:24uh,
- 11:24uh,
- 11:25so yeah,
- 11:26when I went in 2010,
- 11:28gay pride was just San Francisco.
- 11:30Have you ever been to Mardi Gras?
- 11:31Yeah,
- 11:31yeah,
- 11:31yeah.
- 11:32So,
- 11:32but here's the thing,
- 11:33gay pride.
- 11:34Did you know Mardi Gras is labeled as family friendly?
- 11:36OK,
- 11:36but gay pride is now everywhere.
- 11:38So Mardi Gras is just in New Orleans.
- 11:40Have you ever been to a sports party?
- 11:42Yeah,
- 11:42but it's not called a sports party.
- 11:44What's it called?
- 11:44Like when they meet out and they're like in front of the game,
- 11:47tailgates,
- 11:48tailgate.
- 11:49OK,
- 11:49that's different than gay.
- 11:50Have you ever been to a football game?
- 11:51Gay pride is everyone making out and having sex on the street.
- 11:54No,
- 11:55it's not.
- 11:55I was there.
- 11:56That's illegal.
- 11:58That's illegal.
- 11:58The vast majority of pride events,
- 12:00we're talking vast majority of San Francisco here.
- 12:02OK,
- 12:02San Francisco's extra gay,
- 12:03but the vast majority of Pride extra sexualized.
- 12:07It's a European gay city inherently.
- 12:09San Francisco is a European city.
- 12:11San Francisco is in the United States of America.
- 12:13Come on now.
- 12:15It's not a and it's the gay capital.
- 12:17And now that,
- 12:19that has gone everywhere,
- 12:21all over it.
- 12:22I would say we have gay pride in conservative cities now.
- 12:25No,
- 12:26yes,
- 12:26we do.
- 12:27But,
- 12:27but the ride dangers that you're describing,
- 12:29people having sex in the streets,
- 12:30that's illegal.
- 12:31That's illegal.
- 12:31And if,
- 12:32if someone's having sex in the streets at Pride,
- 12:33I think they should go to jail.
- 12:35But what we're saying.
- 12:35The thing is that's not happening in the vast majority of cases.
- 12:38And when it is,
- 12:38is because these are drunk adults outside,
- 12:40and that happens anytime there's drunk adults outside,
- 12:42and we need to work to prevent that and make it more safe,
- 12:45more family friendly,
- 12:46and we should differentiates the thing.
- 12:47There should be adult spaces at nightclubs and family friendly spaces and parks,
- 12:50and we should all have magical pride.
- 12:52We need men for,
- 12:53for armies.
- 12:53We need men to be men,
- 12:54right?
- 12:55I,
- 12:55you agree with that.
- 12:56I think we need anyone who wants to serve
- 12:58the American military and is qualified to do so,
- 13:00to do so.
- 13:01You do realize that.
- 13:02All men cannot
- 13:04be trans and
- 13:05no,
- 13:05we're just saying all men are,
- 13:06you're not about to become trans if I watch a bunch of trans movies in front of you.
- 13:09Why do you have to push it on children?
- 13:11There is no medical research,
- 13:12no psychological research,
- 13:13and no data anywhere in the world over any period
- 13:16of history that shows discussing queer and trans identities,
- 13:19putting queer and trans identities on TVs,
- 13:21I'm about to say it,
- 13:22change children's minds or identities.
- 13:26I feel like you're a good person,
- 13:27but that's just wrong.
- 13:29Um,
- 13:29so I think the,
- 13:30the way that the,
- 13:32the,
- 13:32uh,
- 13:33statement is phrased,
- 13:34um,
- 13:34is kind of a straw man.
- 13:36I don't disagree
- 13:37that like Elon or Trump.
- 13:39Are,
- 13:40are
- 13:41necessarily doing,
- 13:41like I'm not,
- 13:42I'm not focused on that Elon Musk and Donald Trump,
- 13:44or no,
- 13:44I would disagree,
- 13:45but I'm saying that I can agree
- 13:46that plane crashes are,
- 13:48I,
- 13:48I can agree that plane crashes are bad,
- 13:50but then also want to stop car crashes.
- 13:52Well,
- 13:52car crashes
- 13:54and plane crashes aren't originating from the same source,
- 13:56and this anti-LGBTQ plus rhetoric is originating from the
- 13:59very people who are actually grooming our children.
- 14:01So I would label this.
- 14:02Political distraction.
- 14:03Like,
- 14:04uh,
- 14:04first of all,
- 14:04I think you're gonna have to correlate that you think that
- 14:06Donald Trump and Elon Musk love queer and trans people?
- 14:08Do you think that they use rhetoric that is I
- 14:10think they're very liberal supporting queer and trans people.
- 14:12I think they're very liberal,
- 14:13and they don't think Elon Musk and Donald Trump are very liberal.
- 14:15They have a confused ontological view of this issue.
- 14:17So what I'd like to attack
- 14:19in,
- 14:19in this specific debate is
- 14:21I'd like you to make a truth claim about
- 14:23transgenderism in general because it seems that you.
- 14:25Transgenderism because transgenderism is a
- 14:27hateful word that doesn't exist and we're gonna have to unpack that.
- 14:30How is that a hateful word that doesn't exist?
- 14:32Transgenderism is do what gender is.
- 14:34OK,
- 14:34that's why it's hateful and doesn't exist,
- 14:36because men are not pretending to be women.
- 14:38Trans women are women,
- 14:39and I unders.
- 14:39OK,
- 14:40did you know there's a truth claim right there.
- 14:41So
- 14:42trans women are women.
- 14:43So there's a,
- 14:43there's,
- 14:44there's a,
- 14:44there's a thing that I would like to,
- 14:46uh,
- 14:46put forward to you.
- 14:47There's 4 things that trans.
- 14:49Transgenderism could be possibly.
- 14:52OK.
- 14:52Transgenderism isn't real,
- 14:53so I don't know how to do.
- 14:54There's 4 things that trans people could be or the causation of trans people.
- 14:58Did you know that they have brains more like their gender?
- 15:01Yeah,
- 15:01I've been through that study.
- 15:02It's obviously fraudulent,
- 15:03but I'd like to go into peer reviewed.
- 15:05Yeah,
- 15:05I know,
- 15:06uh,
- 15:06the,
- 15:06the scientific and medical establishment,
- 15:08like the study that he how many doctors are in the American Medical Association.
- 15:12I'm not sure.
- 15:13How many medical professionals are in the American Medical Association?
- 15:15I'm 270,000.
- 15:17I don't really care about credential decisions.
- 15:19I don't care about credential.
- 15:20You don't care about people being educated I'd like to,
- 15:22I'd like to make,
- 15:23I'm,
- 15:23I'm trying to attack this point ontologically.
- 15:25I'm trying to get you to make a trade.
- 15:27Truth claim about trans people.
- 15:28Let's do it.
- 15:28Uh,
- 15:29the,
- 15:29the first thing
- 15:30that trans people could be claiming to,
- 15:33could make a claim about themselves.
- 15:35There's 4 things.
- 15:36The first thing,
- 15:36and I'm gonna go through them really quick and then you could respond to them,
- 15:38that their gender doesn't master birth sex,
- 15:40period.
- 15:40So the first thing,
- 15:41yes.
- 15:42Could be a sexual perversion.
- 15:45So that has always existed.
- 15:46Men dressing up like women
- 15:48for a sexual fetish has always existed a sexual perversion.
- 15:50That is a perversion.
- 15:51Is Rudy Giuliani a pervert?
- 15:53Yeah.
- 15:53Really?
- 15:54OK,
- 15:54agreed,
- 15:55agreed,
- 15:56agreed.
- 15:56That is a weird vibe.
- 15:57So,
- 15:58um,
- 15:58let me just,
- 15:58let me just finish.
- 15:59What about Brett Kavanaugh?
- 16:00Uh,
- 16:00I don't think those claims were substantiated,
- 16:02but yeah,
- 16:03what about our vice president.
- 16:04No,
- 16:04he didn't have sex with a couch.
- 16:06That was obviously fraudulent.
- 16:07What about the fact that he dressed up as a woman?
- 16:10That was a Halloween party.
- 16:11So look,
- 16:12we're getting that dressing up as women is not always linked to pedophilia.
- 16:15And what we actually study is that transgenderism is
- 16:18not linked to any sort of any sexual misconduct.
- 16:21Dude,
- 16:21I understand you're passionate about the issue.
- 16:23I'd just like to get through these four things because other people like to talk,
- 16:26so.
- 16:27The first thing,
- 16:27I think you could admit
- 16:29that some people
- 16:30dress up like Leah Thomas,
- 16:31for example,
- 16:32she was on,
- 16:33he,
- 16:33sorry,
- 16:34he was on,
- 16:34uh,
- 16:34the Penn State swim team.
- 16:36We found his secret Instagram account and he was posting,
- 16:39no,
- 16:40this is so,
- 16:40can we just,
- 16:41OK,
- 16:41at least it's gonna pretend for the conversation,
- 16:43so I'm not gonna check you.
- 16:44I won't,
- 16:45I,
- 16:45I'm gonna have to check you because that's
- 16:46hateful and that's wrong and it's inaccurate.
- 16:48It's Leah Thomas.
- 16:50Leah Thomas lost to cisgender athletes the same year that she won.
- 16:53There's no inherent biological advantage.
- 16:55For trans athletes competing in their sport.
- 16:57Obviously there is,
- 16:58men are stronger than women.
- 16:59I don't care about that.
- 16:59It would still be care and standards.
- 17:01The NCAA sets specific biological standards of care so that you can't just be like,
- 17:06OK,
- 17:07I want to switch.
- 17:07Yeah,
- 17:08I understand,
- 17:08I understand,
- 17:09and I understand you're passionate about the issue,
- 17:10but I'm trying to just get through this information.
- 17:12Men
- 17:13pretending to be women,
- 17:14trans women,
- 17:14uh.
- 17:16Are not women,
- 17:17and the first claim that I'm making is that women are women.
- 17:19OK,
- 17:20you can keep saying it,
- 17:20it's not true.
- 17:21I feel like I have to.
- 17:22So I understand,
- 17:22I understand.
- 17:23The argument is,
- 17:25are trans women women and I'm saying no.
- 17:27So if I call her a woman,
- 17:28I'm forfeiting my entire point.
- 17:30So you understand I'm not gonna say that.
- 17:32I don't understand what,
- 17:33yeah,
- 17:33I'm gonna prove why it's valid.
- 17:35So men.
- 17:36Who pretend to be women,
- 17:37either
- 17:38it's a sexual fetish,
- 17:39which I think that you can agree a fetish,
- 17:41it's medically proven not to be.
- 17:42I think that you can agree that sometimes it can happen,
- 17:45transvestism.
- 17:46I think some men
- 17:47dress up as women.
- 17:48I think transgender women are women.
- 17:50OK,
- 17:51that's what I'm claiming the first thing,
- 17:53that's that.
- 17:53The second thing is a body dysmorphic disorder,
- 17:55right?
- 17:55That's a body and as laid out in the DSM 4,
- 17:58yeah,
- 17:59and,
- 17:59and still in the DSM 5 when they changed it,
- 18:01there's still.
- 18:01Still
- 18:02a 60,
- 18:02I think it was 65 to 7,
- 18:0475% overlay
- 18:06between people who identify as transgender
- 18:08and them having gender,
- 18:10uh,
- 18:10uh,
- 18:11dysphoria.
- 18:11So my question for you is,
- 18:13if it's a body dysmorphic disorder,
- 18:15if it does exist as a body dysmorphic disorder,
- 18:18why wouldn't you treat other body dysmorphia disorders the same way?
- 18:21We tried that with conversion therapy.
- 18:22It killed thousands of people and it was derailed by every single I'm talking about,
- 18:25that is the.
- 18:27Attempt to change,
- 18:28give a,
- 18:28why,
- 18:28why not give a tummy tuck to an anorexic person?
- 18:31You're making physical changes to an anorexic person.
- 18:33You're making physical changes.
- 18:34People make physical changes all day long.
- 18:35There's a higher rate for care for breast augmentation,
- 18:39LASIK eye surgery,
- 18:39knee replacement surgery,
- 18:40hip replacement surgery,
- 18:41and gender-affirming care because it's life-saving essential care.
- 18:44First of all,
- 18:44if you have a body dysmorphic disorder,
- 18:46which is defined in the DSM-4 and the DSM-5 as a body dysmorphic disorder,
- 18:51which is literally.
- 18:52The same thing as somebody who has like anorexia.
- 18:54They're confused.
- 18:55It's not about their self transgenderism are not the same.
- 18:57I know you don't agree with that,
- 18:58but I'm making the point.
- 18:59So just,
- 19:00just relax,
- 19:00and then I'll make the point.
- 19:01I understand you're passionate about the issue.
- 19:02You live a kind of weird perverse lifestyle.
- 19:04I understand that it's,
- 19:05I live a weird lifestyle.
- 19:06I'm a perverse one,
- 19:07and not because I'm LGBTQ plus what I'm what perversity is,
- 19:10um,
- 19:10when you
- 19:10deviate from the norm,
- 19:11right?
- 19:12And so if you deviate from the norm,
- 19:13it's perverse.
- 19:13You've perverted the end.
- 19:15So that's not the point,
- 19:15but the actual point is that
- 19:17in reality.
- 19:18A man
- 19:19who pretends to be a woman is not a woman,
- 19:21and it's the same thing if I were to go to the doctor's office as an
- 19:24anorexic and say,
- 19:25doc,
- 19:25give me a tummy tuck because my self-perception is not in,
- 19:28in,
- 19:28in line with reality.
- 19:29So go ahead,
- 19:30give me a tummy tuck.
- 19:31Yeah,
- 19:31neither is transgenderism proven to be.
- 19:34No,
- 19:34it's not.
- 19:34There was a new Oxford study that just came out in 2025.
- 19:37That proved anxiety,
- 19:38depression,
- 19:39suicidality,
- 19:40and suicide all skyrocketed,
- 19:42all skyrocketed.
- 19:44The reality of the situation,
- 19:45the reality of the affirming care and
- 19:47affirming environments reduce the rates of suiciderocketed,
- 19:51depression,
- 19:52and anxiety.
- 19:52It skyrocketed in every case,
- 19:54quoting it.
- 19:55That's time.
- 19:56Good to talk to you.
- 19:58My next claim is
- 19:59healthcare costs and gun violence harm young Americans.
- 20:02LGBTQ+ acceptance does not.
- 20:04I just want to make sure can we agree that,
- 20:06can we agree that our shared value for this debate should
- 20:08be that all young Americans have safe and healthy childhoods?
- 20:11Absolutely.
- 20:11OK,
- 20:11beautiful.
- 20:12Yeah,
- 20:12I just want to make sure I heard that right.
- 20:13Young Americans referencing children.
- 20:15So then I want to switch the focus on what the plus represents and LGBTQ plus.
- 20:19First,
- 20:19I want to state that gun violence has been the leading
- 20:21cause of death for American children for the last 4 years.
- 20:24And 6 American children die every single day from gun violence,
- 20:27and 4 million young Americans are currently uninsured,
- 20:29which makes them 60% more likely to die,
- 20:31while LGBTQ plus acceptance risks no American children's lives.
- 20:35I'm not in disagreement with that per se,
- 20:38necessarily.
- 20:38I love that,
- 20:39but where we're headed,
- 20:40right,
- 20:40that plus is a placeholder
- 20:42for maps for minor attractive persons,
- 20:44minor attractive.
- 20:45No,
- 20:45it is not.
- 20:46That would be insane.
- 20:46That's pedophilia.
- 20:47I'm glad that you think it's pedophilia and it's insane it's defined as pedophi,
- 20:50I think.
- 20:51Understand and you know that your side of the aisle does not feel that way.
- 20:54No,
- 20:55there is a large movement who commits the most
- 20:56acts of pedophilia in the United States of America.
- 20:58I'll give you a hint.
- 20:59Do you identify the LGBTQ as a political movement?
- 21:02No,
- 21:02not at all.
- 21:03See,
- 21:03we're going to fundamentally disagree right there.
- 21:04Well,
- 21:04why is why is the LGBTQ plus community a political movement?
- 21:07It's a,
- 21:08it's,
- 21:08first of all,
- 21:08it's considered a victim class.
- 21:10Let's start there.
- 21:11They have a victim class.
- 21:12They have the class.
- 21:12They have specific rights and protections.
- 21:15They have the same rights and protections as all Americans,
- 21:16or they should.
- 21:17We're working to get there because right now,
- 21:19unfortunately,
- 21:19you're right,
- 21:19it's not.
- 21:20Right now they don't.
- 21:21Right now,
- 21:21LGBTQ plus Americans have less rights and liberties than the standard American,
- 21:25than heterosexual cisgender Americans they have less rights and privileges.
- 21:29There's a variety of things.
- 21:29For example,
- 21:30there's legislation in several states that work to prevent trans women
- 21:33from accessing the bathrooms that relate to their gender identity.
- 21:35There's prevention of LGBTQ plus discussion in education.
- 21:38There's efforts right now from our president
- 21:40to work and roll back rights that have
- 21:42been guaranteed to LGBTQ plus Americans for decades.
- 21:44And it's really,
- 21:45really important that we recognize that because right now,
- 21:47LGBTQ plus Americans do not share the same liberties and rights as cisgender,
- 21:51heterosexual Americans do,
- 21:52and to pretend that it's not happening is really weird.
- 21:54I would ask you,
- 21:55what rights do you think LGBTQ plus people are asking for that are special rights?
- 21:58So this is where we're going to fundamentally disagree,
- 22:00really,
- 22:00because,
- 22:00so first and foremost,
- 22:02to be,
- 22:03to be quite honest,
- 22:04I believe,
- 22:05and that's not that I believe,
- 22:06I know that the LGBTQ movement is a Marxist movement.
- 22:10I believe in.
- 22:11I believe it was installed.
- 22:12It's not a Marxist movement.
- 22:13That's a funny thought.
- 22:13I let you finish talking.
- 22:15Let me finish.
- 22:15OK,
- 22:16but you're just saying.
- 22:16I,
- 22:17no,
- 22:17I'm not.
- 22:18I'm saying things that I know.
- 22:19I believe you've developed and,
- 22:20and put yourself in this sort of matrix fictional reality,
- 22:23and you feel safe there.
- 22:24I'm glad you do.
- 22:25But here's the problem.
- 22:26Where we're headed is why I'm concerned.
- 22:29Where are we headed?
- 22:29I'm not,
- 22:30I'll tell you where we're headed.
- 22:31We're headed towards maps.
- 22:32Whether or not you agree with that is,
- 22:33is regardless,
- 22:34what evidence is there that we're headed towards maps?
- 22:36I mean,
- 22:36are you kidding me?
- 22:38We,
- 22:38it's even,
- 22:39even on the conservative side,
- 22:40they're,
- 22:41they're opening up the discussion on whether or
- 22:42not this can be considered a legitimate,
- 22:45uh,
- 22:45sexual orientation.
- 22:46No one is saying that pedophilia is a legitimate sexual orientation.
- 22:49OK,
- 22:50this is important actually that you're saying this right now,
- 22:52because where we're headed,
- 22:53I'm very secure
- 22:55that we're heading in this direction where at,
- 22:57at a certain point that would be really concerning.
- 22:59I would understand,
- 22:59and I,
- 23:00I agree that we agree with that.
- 23:01But going full circle,
- 23:02OK,
- 23:02who started the gay rights movement?
- 23:04Black women.
- 23:05No,
- 23:05Harry Hay started the gay rights movement in the 1950s.
- 23:08What party did he belong to?
- 23:09You tell me.
- 23:10He belonged to the Communist Party.
- 23:12What,
- 23:12what,
- 23:12what,
- 23:13what book and what society did he start at the time the LGBTQ movement,
- 23:16because I would define it as a civil rights movement in modern history,
- 23:19whereas you're acting like we're sticking to LGBTQ plus people.
- 23:21We are still,
- 23:22but you're not talking about because
- 23:23ultimately you're leading to deconstructionism.
- 23:25You want a gray box society.
- 23:27That's the goal.
- 23:28What is a gray box society?
- 23:29The fact that you don't know that is,
- 23:30is,
- 23:31is.
- 23:31the problem.
- 23:32You are compartmentalized in society.
- 23:34I know what it is.
- 23:35It's a genderless society.
- 23:37It's where the individual is stripped from all individuality.
- 23:40That's what it is.
- 23:40I think that is where we're headed.
- 23:42The fact that you can't acknowledge that shows me that you're already in the matrix.
- 23:46You're stuck there.
- 23:47You're in this world that,
- 23:49that provides all these protections for you.
- 23:51All these,
- 23:52the fact that you can even sit here,
- 23:54the fact that this,
- 23:55what extra protections do LGBTQ plus people receive in the United States.
- 23:58Experiences or any evidence that you have.
- 24:00The fact that it even,
- 24:01you don't have that it's even a you don't have evidence,
- 24:03it's not a it's a sexual orientation doesn't mean it is a sexual orientation.
- 24:07It should be between two sexual orientation.
- 24:09What should be when it arrives about,
- 24:11what am I talking about?
- 24:12I'm talking about the fact that it's even a movement to begin with.
- 24:14It doesn't deserve there's a civil rights movement
- 24:16that doesn't deserve to be LGBT rights.
- 24:18It doesn't deserve a civil right.
- 24:20That's my whole point.
- 24:21LGBTQ+ people don't deserve civil rights.
- 24:23I would say that the majority of American pri.
- 24:25People would disagree with what you're saying right now.
- 24:27I think all people in the United States of America are equal,
- 24:30and you don't pause.
- 24:31Let's pause.
- 24:31You've been voted out by the majority.
- 24:33Please return to your seat.
- 24:34I appreciate you.
- 24:35Hello,
- 24:36nice to meet you.
- 24:36I'm Angelina.
- 24:36Nice to meet you.
- 24:37Can we agree that our shared value would
- 24:39be young Americans deserve safe and healthy childhood?
- 24:41100%.
- 24:41And I think gun violence is an issue,
- 24:43and I think healthcare is an issue.
- 24:44However,
- 24:44what I would like to talk about today is,
- 24:46um,
- 24:47children being targeted and transitioned at a young age.
- 24:50I don't believe it is children are being targeted in transition,
- 24:52so.
- 24:52Currently in the United States,
- 24:54you can start gender transitioning a child as early as they're starting puberty,
- 24:57and that's anywhere from 8 to 13.
- 24:59And so at that age,
- 25:00you can start putting them on puberty blockers,
- 25:02and which is not reversible,
- 25:03by the way,
- 25:04puberty.
- 25:04OK,
- 25:05so how many irreversible gender affirming care procedures have been done
- 25:08on ages 13 or under in the United States of America?
- 25:11Listen,
- 25:11just the idea that you even put them on puberty blockers,
- 25:13that's irreversible.
- 25:13Do you understand that?
- 25:14Not all puberty blockers are irreversible.
- 25:16New treatments are coming in every day.
- 25:17So let me break down.
- 25:17No,
- 25:17no,
- 25:17no,
- 25:17no,
- 25:17no,
- 25:18no,
- 25:18no,
- 25:18no,
- 25:18puberty blockers,
- 25:19do you know what?
- 25:19Puberty blockers are puberty blockers is Lupron.
- 25:21That is the brand name for puberty blockers,
- 25:23Lupron.
- 25:23Lupron is used on children,
- 25:258 to 13 year olds to pause their puberty.
- 25:28It is the same drug used in chemical castration for pedophiles that stops
- 25:33their sex drive.
- 25:34OK,
- 25:34if I thought 8 to 13 year olds would be chemically castrated,
- 25:36that would be horrible.
- 25:37That would be evil,
- 25:38that would be unacceptable.
- 25:39That's not what's happening.
- 25:40Well,
- 25:40no,
- 25:40let's break it down.
- 25:41I would love to break it down for you.
- 25:43No one's advocating for that.
- 25:44Let's break it down.
- 25:46So.
- 25:481%
- 25:49to 3% of the youth population in the United States of America are trans.
- 25:53About 15% of that 1 to 3%
- 25:55receive reversible or partially reversible gender affirming care only.
- 25:58I'm talking about hormone blockers.
- 26:00I'm talking about hormone replacement therapy.
- 26:02It is reversible.
- 26:03In many cases,
- 26:04so I understand some of these things are not fully reversible.
- 26:07That's why it's reversible and partially reversible.
- 26:09Some hormone blockers are not fully reversible,
- 26:11but the World Health Organization,
- 26:13the American Medical Association,
- 26:14the American Psychological Association,
- 26:16and the American Psychiatric Association work to set standards and
- 26:18to prove that all of these cares are life-saving.
- 26:20What we see is that
- 26:22the vast majority of people who receive this care never end up regretting its care.
- 26:25Do you know what the regret rate for reversible
- 26:27care is in the United States of America?
- 26:29for transgender youth.
- 26:29Any rate of it is enough to not do this to children.
- 26:32It's the targeting of children.
- 26:33Tell me the rate.
- 26:34Tell me the rate.
- 26:35Please tell me the rate is 1%.
- 26:36And do you know what the majority of that 1% rate is?
- 26:39It's due to social stigma and hatred,
- 26:41not actual regret of the care.
- 26:42And so what we see is one child decides to de-transition,
- 26:45that's enough to not do this.
- 26:47Children cannot make decisions.
- 26:48Listen,
- 26:48how can at 12 or 13 you decide you never want to have children?
- 26:51You can't.
- 26:51That's not happening.
- 26:53Hormone replacement therapy isn't sterilization.
- 26:55That's not true hormone replacement therapy.
- 26:56Then why do we give Lupron,
- 26:58the same drug we give to children,
- 26:59to pedophiles to chemically castrate them?
- 27:01That's not what's happening.
- 27:02That's not what we're doing.
- 27:03That's not Lupron to pedophiles.
- 27:04I don't think we're chemistically castrating our young American children.
- 27:07All gender-affirming care surgeries have to have a period of time between
- 27:10about 1 to 5 years in which these people are receiving treatment.
- 27:15They are working with medical professionals do not
- 27:16even have to go to a psychologist.
- 27:17That is not true.
- 27:18Blair White,
- 27:18one of the most prominent trans women in America right now,
- 27:21said she.
- 27:21To get no psychotherapy is proven to spread misinformation online and in the media.
- 27:26Blair Wright is depression is real.
- 27:28Gender dysphoria,
- 27:28I agree,
- 27:29is real,
- 27:30but I don't think the way we treat this is by just slapping on
- 27:33hormones.
- 27:33So what happens to anxiety,
- 27:34depression,
- 27:35and suicide rates after a young trans person goes through gender-affirming care?
- 27:38For about 1 year,
- 27:39it's better,
- 27:39and then after about 10 years.
- 27:41Listen,
- 27:42I don't disagree that sometimes it might be the right decision
- 27:44for someone 70% of cases but for children it's suicidality.
- 27:48down.
- 27:48No one is advocating for a child to make decisions by themselves.
- 27:51They're working with their parents to receive parental consent,
- 27:53medical supervision,
- 27:54and they're not happening under the age of 13.
- 27:56And the majority of doctors in all cases
- 27:58in the United States of America are telling people
- 28:00not to have a lot of these crucial surgeries until they do reach the age of 18.
- 28:04Do you know how many people have had surgery
- 28:06in the United States of America that is gender-affirming
- 28:08care under the age of 18 that resulted in
- 28:10any type of surgical transformation of the body?
- 28:13Tell me.
- 28:14Do you know the number?
- 28:15Tell me the number.
- 28:150.01%. So at what number do we have to get to
- 28:21to show you that this rued up their lives their mastectomies.
- 28:24How many young people have to tell you that
- 28:25this care is saving their lives before you care?
- 28:28It's saving lives every single day as a child and doing it when you turn 18.
- 28:31What's the difference?
- 28:32What's the difference?
- 28:33What's the difference?
- 28:33There's so much of a difference.
- 28:34When you go through puberty,
- 28:36so much of your body and chemical changes so drastically that it creates a
- 28:39lot of the negative experience that leads trans young people to kill themselves,
- 28:42and that is why the World Health Organization.
- 28:44The American Medical Association,
- 28:45American Psychological Association,
- 28:46American Psychiatric Association
- 28:47works to agree that they understand that gender-affirming
- 28:50care is life saving care for young adults,
- 28:53for children,
- 28:54for anyone who needs it.
- 28:55In some cases,
- 28:55and what we're not advocating for,
- 28:57but when you're a child,
- 28:58you cannot make that lifelong decision.
- 28:59You can't make it by yourself.
- 29:00And the fact alone that it sterilizes them is enough
- 29:02to say we can't do this until they're 18.
- 29:04In that it does not sterilize young children.
- 29:06You are just saying things that are scary.
- 29:08No,
- 29:08I'm that's not happening even people on your side will say that's true.
- 29:11Voted out by the majority,
- 29:12please return to your seat.
- 29:14So why are we spending so much time talking about life saving medical care when every
- 29:17single day we're losing young people to lack of medical care and to gun violence?
- 29:21OK,
- 29:21well,
- 29:21can I just backtrack?
- 29:22So you initially had said,
- 29:23I prefer to start there.
- 29:25All righty,
- 29:25um,
- 29:26well,
- 29:26I mean,
- 29:27I have a point I need to address just to,
- 29:28so you can understand kind of where I'm coming from in the argument.
- 29:30OK,
- 29:30can you answer that question and then we'll get to yours?
- 29:32Go ahead and restate it.
- 29:33Why are we spending so much time talking about life
- 29:35saving medical care when we're seeing young people die every
- 29:38single day due to a lack of medical care and
- 29:40due to gun violence in the United States of America?
- 29:42So you don't drive a car.
- 29:43Of course I drive a car,
- 29:44but what we're seeing,
- 29:45look at how many people die in car accidents every year.
- 29:48That's a really special statistic,
- 29:49but what's important about noting is that the vast majority
- 29:51of people who drive cars are choosing to drive cars.
- 29:54The vast majority of people who are being shot to death by
- 29:56guns are not choosing to be shot by death by guns.
- 29:58The 4 million children who do not have access to
- 30:00healthcare are not choosing to not have access to healthcare.
- 30:03They are more likely to die,
- 30:04however,
- 30:04because of a system that they were born into,
- 30:06and that's not fair.
- 30:07That's deadly.
- 30:08It's harming young Americans every single day.
- 30:10Life's not fair,
- 30:11so children should get shot in their classrooms and not have the medicine they need,
- 30:14but they should also have the right to protect themselves
- 30:16in their own home or in their own community.
- 30:17You should have the right when somebody comes in your being shot to
- 30:20death every single day by assault rifles designed by the home broken into,
- 30:23and they don't know how to protect themselves.
- 30:24They don't,
- 30:25they don't have the ability to.
- 30:26Tell me the statistic.
- 30:27No,
- 30:27I'm,
- 30:27I'm asking you that question.
- 30:28Gun violence in the home leads to more death in that home without burglary.
- 30:33What you're seeing is that gun violence in America
- 30:35goes up because there are more guns in America,
- 30:36there are more assault rifles in America,
- 30:38there are less restrictions that help people who should have guns have guns,
- 30:42and now we're saying,
- 30:42oh,
- 30:42you know what,
- 30:43everyone have a gun,
- 30:44let's all have guns.
- 30:44There are more guns in the United States of America than there are people.
- 30:46What there are not is people that
- 30:48are receiving chemical castrations and being sterilized,
- 30:51like other speakers in the circle are saying,
- 30:53gender-affirming care is medically proven to be life saving care,
- 30:56and they're working with psychologists,
- 30:57psychiatrists,
- 30:58doctors,
- 30:58and all the cases.
- 30:59I am saying that you and I,
- 31:00right here.
- 31:01have no idea what is best for a child in Illinois,
- 31:04in Utah,
- 31:04in Florida.
- 31:05Their parents do,
- 31:06they do,
- 31:07their medical professionals do.
- 31:08And the more that we get in the way of their choice making,
- 31:10we're infringing on parental consent.
- 31:12We're infringing on medical privacy.
- 31:13We're preventing young people from receiving life saving care.
- 31:15You said their parents have the right to make those
- 31:17kinds of choices to help them make those choices.
- 31:19So isn't your party the one that says if a kid says that they're gay at school,
- 31:22that the teacher shouldn't go and tell the parent?
- 31:25Well,
- 31:25the Democratic Party,
- 31:26I'm not a member of the Democratic Party.
- 31:28However,
- 31:28I would say that much of the Democratic.
- 31:29Party's stance versus the Republican Party's stance that makes more sense because
- 31:33it's grounded in evidence that saves young people's lives out of the picture
- 31:36when it fits the case,
- 31:37and then now all of a sudden you think the parents should have that kind of say.
- 31:40I don't understand.
- 31:41No one is I think parents should be removed from their children's lives.
- 31:43That's essentially what they argue when they the ones is arguing that they
- 31:46are a parent is a direct threat to a young person's life,
- 31:49then that needs to be evaluated.
- 31:50But that's not happening in the conversation.
- 31:52What do you consider a direct threat?
- 31:53I guess that's the thing is,
- 31:54I mean,
- 31:54there's how many people are transitioning without the support of their parents.
- 31:58In the vast majority of cases,
- 32:00trans people are supported by their parents.
- 32:02In all cases in the United States where surgery was done,
- 32:05parental consent,
- 32:06medical supervision,
- 32:07and psychological supervision were there.
- 32:09When you say all,
- 32:10I already know that's,
- 32:11that's false because nothing is a perfect 100% like that,
- 32:14that,
- 32:14that already is just that invalidates everything
- 32:16you're gonna tell me with statistics.
- 32:17When you say all,
- 32:17I know that's maybe you're right,
- 32:19maybe there's a lot,
- 32:20but when you say all,
- 32:20that's it.
- 32:21You've been voted out by the majority.
- 32:22Please return to your chair.
- 32:24I appreciate you.
- 32:24Thank you very much.
- 32:25Hi,
- 32:25how you doing,
- 32:26man?
- 32:26Ya.
- 32:27How does LGBTQ plus acceptance harm more young
- 32:30Americans than gun violence and healthcare costs?
- 32:32So
- 32:33define harm.
- 32:34What does harm mean to you?
- 32:35To me,
- 32:36harm would mean reducing quality of life or ending the life.
- 32:38OK,
- 32:39so
- 32:39the,
- 32:40the word of harm,
- 32:40it doesn't have to necessarily mean physically.
- 32:43You can harm somebody by spiritually,
- 32:44mentally.
- 32:45Entirely agree.
- 32:47And what we see is that when we support and affirm LGBTQ+ acceptance,
- 32:51depression rates,
- 32:51anxiety rates,
- 32:52and suicidity rates go down significantly.
- 32:5560%,
- 32:5760% is the rate of change in suicidality
- 32:59rates when we see LGBTQ+ people being accepted,
- 33:03suicidality.
- 33:04Honestly,
- 33:05that's not necessarily true because anxiety,
- 33:09you could say that,
- 33:09but if you really want to be,
- 33:12if you really want to go to realization,
- 33:14um,
- 33:15when they do transform to LGBTQ,
- 33:18their anxiety actually goes up
- 33:20because that's
- 33:23why it's so,
- 33:24so let's break it down because I understand that this would be horrible and it's
- 33:26very scary and the talking point gets out there a lot and it's very confusing.
- 33:29What's happening is that
- 33:30LGBTQ plus young people experience higher.
- 33:33Rates of depression,
- 33:34anxiety,
- 33:34and suicidality because of the way they're treated in society.
- 33:37And that's a medical fact that's been studied for years.
- 33:39What we see is that when there is more queer and trans representation,
- 33:43more queer and trans discussion,
- 33:44more queer and trans affirmation,
- 33:46that those suicide rates,
- 33:47depression rates,
- 33:48and anxiety rates go down.
- 33:49And so,
- 33:50if it was innate within the queer and trans identity to be depressed and anxious,
- 33:54the more queer and trans discussion there were,
- 33:56the more queer trans people there were,
- 33:57the more that we would see anxiety,
- 33:59depression,
- 33:59and suicidality.
- 34:00Instead,
- 34:01what We see is that it is only when we accept,
- 34:04affirm,
- 34:04and educate about LGBTQ plus identities that these rates go down
- 34:07because it's not a symptom of being queer and trans.
- 34:10It's a symptom of hatred.
- 34:11It's a symptom of anti-LGBTQ plus policy,
- 34:13which is harming young Americans.
- 34:15Explain about the plus,
- 34:16the LGBTQ plus.
- 34:18Well,
- 34:18what do you think about what I just said?
- 34:19Yeah,
- 34:20no,
- 34:20I agree.
- 34:20I agree.
- 34:21But explain,
- 34:22but explain about the plus though with the LGBTQ plus,
- 34:24right?
- 34:24LGBTQ plus stands for the fact that,
- 34:26for example,
- 34:26intersex people,
- 34:27they don't have a letter in LGBTQ,
- 34:29asexual people,
- 34:29they don't have a letter.
- 34:30LGBTQQ
- 34:31LGBT see,
- 34:32it's hard to say.
- 34:33I would say queer and trans.
- 34:34I think queer is an all-encompassing term and trans is inclusive.
- 34:37Let's talk about intersex,
- 34:38right?
- 34:39So LGBTQ plus.
- 34:40Well,
- 34:40intersex itself,
- 34:41right,
- 34:42that still does not make a third gender.
- 34:44The chromosome itself,
- 34:45it still identifies as a male if it has a Y chromosome,
- 34:48still is a male.
- 34:49So there are many people that are born XX that would have
- 34:53what you would describe as male reproductive organs,
- 34:55right?
- 34:55There are many people who are born XY
- 34:56that actually have female reproductive organs because chromosomes.
- 34:59Themselves don't define biology.
- 35:01Sex is actually a biological characteristic that chromosomes are a part of,
- 35:04and we also see that it has to do with hormones,
- 35:07and it has to do with
- 35:08sexual organs on the inside and outside of the body.
- 35:11And so it's not a singular thing that can be defined.
- 35:13There are 40 different chromosomal structures.
- 35:15It's not just XX and not XY.
- 35:17There are so many different people that fall within the intersex category,
- 35:20and that's why gender-affirming care originally existed,
- 35:22was to help these people receive the medical care that they needed.
- 35:25What we're seeing is that it is so essential to help people.
- 35:29Be who they are and it saves their lives when you do that.
- 35:31Regardless of what you're saying let's pause.
- 35:33You've been voted out by the majority.
- 35:35Please return to your seat.
- 35:37Um,
- 35:38OK,
- 35:38so
- 35:39your original claim
- 35:40was
- 35:41that gun violence and healthcare costs harm young Americans.
- 35:44LGBTQ+ acceptance does not.
- 35:46OK,
- 35:46so I agree with the first half.
- 35:48Uh,
- 35:48what's your disagreement with LGBTQ+ acceptance and
- 35:51how it does not harm young Americans?
- 35:52So I think that first you can look at anything,
- 35:55teaching any young people something that's just fundamentally not true.
- 35:59OK,
- 35:59well,
- 36:00it is a fundamental truth.
- 36:01What we see is that intersex,
- 36:02queer and trans people have existed throughout all time,
- 36:05every continent,
- 36:06every single culture and society.
- 36:07The very first civil society,
- 36:09ancient Mesopotamia,
- 36:10had queer and intersex people.
- 36:12What we're seeing is that they existed in ancient China,
- 36:13ancient Egypt,
- 36:14they've existed everywhere throughout all time.
- 36:16It's not a matter of,
- 36:18I don't even know what you're saying.
- 36:20Well,
- 36:20that's because I didn't really say anything.
- 36:21You just kind of went off.
- 36:22You just said that they're not real.
- 36:25I know you said that they're not real,
- 36:25and that's enough to draw concern because it's like,
- 36:27what are you talking about?
- 36:28People can rewind about 25 seconds and they'll see that I didn't say that,
- 36:31but I didn't say that they're not real.
- 36:33I'm saying we're teaching people that are young people,
- 36:36things that are not true.
- 36:37For instance,
- 36:37we're teaching
- 36:38boys that they can be girls.
- 36:40That fundamentally,
- 36:41I think is.
- 36:42Boys can't be girls.
- 36:43Trans girls can be girls.
- 36:44Trans girls can be trans.
- 36:45Girls,
- 36:46right,
- 36:46and I wouldn't disagree with you that they
- 36:48don't exist.
- 36:49They're human beings.
- 36:50You're a human being.
- 36:51I love you and care about you as a human being.
- 36:53That's a dub.
- 36:53We'll take it from there.
- 36:54We agree.
- 36:54OK,
- 36:54let's take that.
- 36:55That's a dub.
- 36:55People are people.
- 36:56We see each other.
- 36:57We're human beings,
- 36:58right?
- 36:58I genuinely,
- 36:58I love that.
- 36:59OK,
- 37:00but
- 37:01within that there are still things we can teach people that can harm them.
- 37:04I think that I agree,
- 37:05teaching hatred harms people.
- 37:07Teaching people not to accept people harms people,
- 37:09but teaching about LGBTQ plus identities.
- 37:11Saves lives.
- 37:13It reduces anxiety and depression.
- 37:14I guess my only question really would be,
- 37:16if you're going to say that their suicidal rates and depression rise because people
- 37:21aren't affirming like gender,
- 37:23right?
- 37:24Where are all the tens of thousands,
- 37:25hundreds of hundreds of thousands of,
- 37:28of suicides that just went unexplained in the last
- 37:30150 years that were happening all the time.
- 37:33It's heartbreaking.
- 37:34They're happening all the time and you're saying there's a mass grave.
- 37:37Of people who weren't gender affirmed in 1920.
- 37:40Trans people don't all get together and commit suicide together
- 37:42and then say we were trans the whole time.
- 37:44These are people that never
- 37:46came out as trans because of the hatred they experienced,
- 37:48felt that they could never be themselves,
- 37:50killed themselves,
- 37:51and we're seeing this happen all the time and it's heartbreaking.
- 37:53It's getting seeing an increase in there's
- 37:55more we're seeing an increase of transphobia,
- 37:57and so we're seeing an increase
- 38:00in the rates of anxiety and depression amongst unaffirmed,
- 38:02uncared for.
- 38:03Trans individuals,
- 38:04when trans people receive gender-affirming care
- 38:06or have access to affirming environments,
- 38:08we see suicide rates go down,
- 38:09anxiety go down,
- 38:10depression go down.
- 38:11Explain that.
- 38:12I don't agree.
- 38:13It's a fact.
- 38:13OK,
- 38:13well,
- 38:14there are two studies.
- 38:15There's one from,
- 38:16uh,
- 38:16April 2024,
- 38:182 year,
- 38:1824,
- 38:19uh,
- 38:1924 month study,
- 38:21one from February 2025.
- 38:22What were the studies done by?
- 38:23I,
- 38:23they can fact check it.
- 38:25I don't remember off the top of my head cite a lot more studies.
- 38:27OK,
- 38:27but you can pause.
- 38:28That's time.
- 38:29There were studies that you should look into.
- 38:31I,
- 38:32I have.
- 38:32Thank you.
- 38:33My next claim is that anti-LGBTQ+ policies are anti-Christian and anti-American.
- 38:38So let's start with,
- 38:39uh,
- 38:40the less obvious.
- 38:40Let's go anti-American.
- 38:42What is,
- 38:42um,
- 38:43what is like your point in saying that?
- 38:44How is it,
- 38:45um,
- 38:45anti-American?
- 38:47To
- 38:47say that
- 38:49protecting our children,
- 38:50right,
- 38:50our children is our only thing we have.
- 38:52It's the future,
- 38:53right?
- 38:53How's that anti-American?
- 38:55When I'm protecting our children would not be anti-A,
- 38:57but the LGBTQ policies,
- 38:59anti those,
- 38:59right?
- 39:00You're saying it's anti-American.
- 39:01When you think.
- 39:02Children,
- 39:03right?
- 39:03You think of what?
- 39:03I have a 9 year old,
- 39:05right?
- 39:05I think of the future.
- 39:06OK,
- 39:06the future,
- 39:07right?
- 39:07Do you have a child?
- 39:08No,
- 39:08I no,
- 39:09I don't.
- 39:09Do you want children?
- 39:10Maybe.
- 39:11OK.
- 39:11All right,
- 39:11so good.
- 39:12You want to have a child,
- 39:13and you want this child to be what?
- 39:15Protected,
- 39:16correct?
- 39:16Can you agree with me on that?
- 39:17OK,
- 39:17good.
- 39:18When you think of your child being protected,
- 39:20what is an issue you don't agree with?
- 39:22What's something you don't agree with?
- 39:23I know violence and healthcare costs.
- 39:25OK,
- 39:25gun violence and healthcare costs.
- 39:26Do you come from a family that didn't have health care?
- 39:29I come from a family that struggled with healthcare access,
- 39:32but had healthcare access for me.
- 39:33That makes sense.
- 39:34OK,
- 39:34so you had it.
- 39:35So you don't want your child to be negatively influenced by gun violence,
- 39:39correct?
- 39:39Correct.
- 39:39Or by not being able to have access to healthcare.
- 39:42Absolutely.
- 39:42So if there is an agenda,
- 39:44and I know you say there's not an agenda,
- 39:45but if there is
- 39:46a mass media awareness that's pushing a narrative of saying,
- 39:50and we kind of see it,
- 39:51right?
- 39:51Guns in all the movies,
- 39:52right?
- 39:53Guns in the music videos,
- 39:55guns in this
- 39:57rap,
- 39:57hip hop songs.
- 39:58All this stuff,
- 39:59you'd probably not want your child to be exposed to that,
- 40:02correct?
- 40:02No,
- 40:02I would make sure they're educated about what guns are,
- 40:04and I would make sure they're accessing this information age appropriate age.
- 40:07That's a false comparison because why is that a false comparison?
- 40:10It's still,
- 40:11it's guns aren't people,
- 40:12and people in their intrinsic identities aren't murderous.
- 40:15Guns are designed to kill things.
- 40:17LGBTQ people are designed to exist and live and
- 40:20love and they'n money and work and be people.
- 40:22Yes,
- 40:23OK,
- 40:23they're humans.
- 40:24All right.
- 40:24So let's go with that.
- 40:25We'll,
- 40:25we'll take that angle.
- 40:26So you're talking about humans,
- 40:28and you're saying that humans are designed to be themselves,
- 40:31right?
- 40:31And intrinsically themselves.
- 40:32Yes,
- 40:32we're getting so far away from.
- 40:33No,
- 40:33no,
- 40:33no,
- 40:33we're coming back because you're talking about anti-American and
- 40:36I said I gave you that example of guns.
- 40:38So for me as a mom,
- 40:39I don't want my child,
- 40:40and I'm just gonna say the alphabet community because it's
- 40:42easier than LBGT about queer and trans queer and trans.
- 40:46All right,
- 40:47so I don't want my son exposed to queer and trans.
- 40:51You didn't say I was,
- 40:51you don't like the word agenda.
- 40:52I'm trying to be nice and queer and trans people,
- 40:54queer and trans.
- 40:55People,
- 40:55OK,
- 40:56I don't want him exposed to that.
- 40:57I'm a Christian and I'm faith based,
- 40:59and I believe I'm that my son should have his testicles intact until forever,
- 41:04not until he's 18.
- 41:05I want him to have his testicles forever.
- 41:07And he actually just asked me about that last night.
- 41:09He said,
- 41:09Mom,
- 41:10I think my testicles are dropping a little.
- 41:12I said,
- 41:12No,
- 41:12sweetheart,
- 41:13you're 9.
- 41:14Enjoy.
- 41:14You've got a long ways to go.
- 41:16Why?
- 41:16As parents,
- 41:16we want to protect our children as long as they can.
- 41:19100%,
- 41:20right?
- 41:20OK,
- 41:20you agree.
- 41:21We are in agreement with that.
- 41:22Yes,
- 41:22I love that.
- 41:22All right,
- 41:22so let's keep going.
- 41:24I would never
- 41:25in my right mind,
- 41:27let my son,
- 41:27first of all,
- 41:28attend a school,
- 41:28a public school.
- 41:29Second of all,
- 41:30attend that's a privileged choice and that's awesome they're able to make it.
- 41:33Correct.
- 41:33And I've worked very hard for that,
- 41:35where there are clowns,
- 41:36as you called them,
- 41:37drag queens there.
- 41:38No,
- 41:38no,
- 41:38no,
- 41:38I made a comparison that clowns are entertainers and drag queens are entertainers,
- 41:41but they are very much so different.
- 41:43A clown istext.
- 41:45OK,
- 41:45let,
- 41:45let me finish.
- 41:46Let me just describe it and then we'll go back so far away from the clown.
- 41:48No,
- 41:48we're not.
- 41:48We're talking about,
- 41:49we're talking about an agenda here,
- 41:51and you're talking about.
- 41:52Being anti-American,
- 41:53anti-faith,
- 41:54anti-Christian.
- 41:55I'm saying that that's not the truth.
- 41:56No,
- 41:56I'm saying anti-LGBTQ+ policies inherently contradict the
- 41:59fundamental values of Americanism and Christianity.
- 42:02It doesn't.
- 42:02What is the fundamental value of America?
- 42:04OK,
- 42:05well,
- 42:05we'll go back to Christianity,
- 42:06but let me finish my point,
- 42:07as you said you would.
- 42:08OK,
- 42:08so I'm not letting my son be exposed,
- 42:11because you,
- 42:11you're kind of in denial,
- 42:12sweetheart.
- 42:13You're saying that a clown is the same thing or same humor.
- 42:16Hold on,
- 42:16let me finish.
- 42:17Let me finish,
- 42:18please,
- 42:18dear,
- 42:18as the same as a drag queen.
- 42:21And I know for a fact what comes if you just
- 42:23Google the word drag queen and and children or kindergarten,
- 42:27you see what goes on.
- 42:28Those shows,
- 42:28the girls are in,
- 42:29or the men rather,
- 42:31are in lingerie and scantily clad,
- 42:33very,
- 42:34very sexually explicit behavior,
- 42:36crazy hair and makeup,
- 42:37and my right,
- 42:38and it happens as well as the infiltration of the books in our children's school.
- 42:43These trans books are being put into our kids' school.
- 42:46I know for a fact that's why I pulled him.
- 42:48I saw these books in there.
- 42:50You said yourself,
- 42:51if you had a child,
- 42:52you would not want him exposed to things that you didn't approve of,
- 42:55or you'd want him to be,
- 42:56quote,
- 42:56educated as to what is right.
- 42:58Why do we have to educate children
- 43:01to mental health challenges when men decide to castrate themselves
- 43:05and take off their genitals and reattach new genitals,
- 43:09and then they demand equal rights?
- 43:11That's not OK.
- 43:12And I'm not letting my child get exposed to that.
- 43:15That is anti-Christian,
- 43:16and that is anti-American.
- 43:18OK,
- 43:18so I don't find that to be a claim that addressed my claim at all.
- 43:21I would say that the fundamental value
- 43:23of Americanism is freedom and the fundamental value
- 43:25of Christianity is love and anti-LGBT policies
- 43:27are contradictory to both of those beliefs.
- 43:29But back to your point,
- 43:30because you took us there.
- 43:31The majority of drag queen book hours have never had a reported incident.
- 43:34In fact,
- 43:34there's no pattern of reported incident,
- 43:36and there are cherry-picked incidents where bad people did bad things,
- 43:39not because they're drag queens,
- 43:40but because they're bad people.
- 43:41And those incidents occur in less than 1% of places.
- 43:44So what I would say is that drag queens have no statistical.
- 43:48Correlation
- 43:49with pedophilic behavior,
- 43:51with sexual violence,
- 43:52or,
- 43:52or,
- 43:52or,
- 43:53or,
- 43:53or,
- 43:53or that is holed up in the club,
- 43:56or in sexually exposing themselves to children.
- 43:59I think clubs are.
- 44:00OK,
- 44:00we're getting so far away.
- 44:01American and faith-based values,
- 44:02let's go back to that.
- 44:03American faith-based values.
- 44:05Why the the the trans movement is not that or is,
- 44:08is antithesis of that.
- 44:09Trans people are people.
- 44:11What I'm telling you is that if your child is exposed to trans and queer individuals,
- 44:14they're no more likely to decide to become trans or queer.
- 44:16Nope,
- 44:16it is true.
- 44:17It is statistically proven.
- 44:18It is so true.
- 44:19It is data-driven.
- 44:19It is medically proven.
- 44:20It is psychologically proven.
- 44:21It is proven.
- 44:22No,
- 44:22no,
- 44:22no,
- 44:22it's proven by hundreds of thousands of people,
- 44:24and I have no idea why you believe when you're not educated on this subject,
- 44:27well,
- 44:27no,
- 44:27no,
- 44:28not in a like a you don't know what you're talking about way,
- 44:29but in a,
- 44:30you need a medical professional,
- 44:31you need a psychological professional to address this care.
- 44:34No,
- 44:35to address this care.
- 44:36What I'm saying is that your child is
- 44:38not endangered by witnessing queer and trans existences.
- 44:41It is true.
- 44:42That is not true.
- 44:42Let me give you an example.
- 44:43I'll give you one.
- 44:44Let's pause.
- 44:44You've been voted out by the majority.
- 44:46Please return to this year.
- 44:46Thank you.
- 44:47Hope you don't hear me.
- 44:48First off,
- 44:49I would like to say that your question,
- 44:50I think is worded very,
- 44:51uh.
- 44:53How do I put it?
- 44:53It's not a question,
- 44:54but I'm saying anti-LGBTQ plus policies are anti-Christian and anti-American.
- 44:57Which would you like to start with?
- 44:58So
- 44:59can you define for me what anti-LGBTQ is?
- 45:01Yes,
- 45:02policies that are against the LGBTQ plus community,
- 45:04hence anti,
- 45:05anti.
- 45:05OK,
- 45:05so could you tell me what it means by against it?
- 45:07Like,
- 45:08could you give me an example of legislation that is anti-Christian,
- 45:10that is also anti-LGBTQ?
- 45:12Can you give me examples?
- 45:13I would say because I am a Christian and I'm LGBTQ,
- 45:16policies that go against me are anti-Christian,
- 45:18and I would say because they contradict the fundamental.
- 45:20Values that we were taught as Christians,
- 45:22that they are anti-Christians.
- 45:23So a couple of things.
- 45:24One,
- 45:25we were told to follow the Holy Spirit beyond the text.
- 45:28We were told that throughout life,
- 45:30while God's word is perfect and true,
- 45:32man's interpretation and understanding of it is not.
- 45:34For example,
- 45:34slavery,
- 45:35can we agree that's wrong?
- 45:36Interracial marriage,
- 45:37can we agree that's beautiful?
- 45:38Yes.
- 45:39Fantastic.
- 45:40Can we agree that we both should be able to eat shellfish and pork?
- 45:42Yes.
- 45:42Fantastic.
- 45:43We continue to evolve our understanding when
- 45:45we have new information and perspectives.
- 45:47Jesus Christ incarnated.
- 45:48Not to tell us,
- 45:49follow the Bible,
- 45:50but to help us understand it better.
- 45:51We once understood eye for an eye,
- 45:53now we know it's turned cheek for cheek,
- 45:55and we were also told to measure people by their fruits.
- 45:57LGBTQ plus people bring love into the world,
- 46:00they benefit the economy,
- 46:01they bring safety into the world,
- 46:02while anti-LGBTQ plus policies are proven to bring more death,
- 46:05more anxiety,
- 46:06and more depression.
- 46:07I'm not saying I don't understand your fear and concern.
- 46:10I'm saying when I rely on the data,
- 46:11the evidence,
- 46:12and the professionals,
- 46:13these policies kill children.
- 46:16I do not believe so.
- 46:17So if they do,
- 46:18so looking at Christianity,
- 46:19because you're the one who brought it up
- 46:20in Matthew 18:6,
- 46:22Christ says,
- 46:22if any of you causes one of these little ones to stumble,
- 46:24it is better that a millstone is tied around your
- 46:26neck and you drown in the depths of the ocean.
- 46:27Yes,
- 46:28absolutely.
- 46:28Not that they should be,
- 46:29but it's that they,
- 46:30it's better off that they would be.
- 46:31So what I'm trying to say is that,
- 46:33but you can't say that people are misguiding children
- 46:36by informing them about people that exist
- 46:38when there is no data that that information
- 46:40causes young people to become queer and trans.
- 46:42The rise of young people identifying as queer and
- 46:45trans people comes from more affirmation and safety.
- 46:47No one becomes gay,
- 46:48it's medically proven and it's been backed by data that you cannot,
- 46:52no matter what you do,
- 46:53turn someone gay.
- 46:55You can't do it,
- 46:55how are they gay then?
- 46:56It is a biological characteristic.
- 46:58So it's like something that's in their genetics essentially.
- 47:01Yeah.
- 47:01OK,
- 47:01so how can you spread the genes of being gay if you're gay?
- 47:04Like I'm straight because my dad and my mom are not genetics,
- 47:06it's in the biochemical reality of human existence.
- 47:09It's not something that's taught,
- 47:10it's not something that can be changed in an experience,
- 47:12and that has been proven throughout time,
- 47:14so the only thing that we're born with essentially is going to be our genetic code,
- 47:17which our parents passed down from us,
- 47:19and then after that we have a blank slate.
- 47:20Mind
- 47:21and whatever is put into that blank state of
- 47:22mind will alter our personality and our person.
- 47:25So you're right,
- 47:26there is no gaying because it's non-existent.
- 47:27It's an inferior genetic.
- 47:28You cannot pass down
- 47:30the genetics of being gay if you're gay,
- 47:32which is why I believe that people are being groomed to become gay,
- 47:35whether it happens when they're 2 years old,
- 47:3610 years old,
- 47:3713 years old,
- 47:38whether it's from the LGBTQ agenda,
- 47:40which I believe you and your allies are pushing,
- 47:42or if it's my allies
- 47:43who are.
- 47:44Allies,
- 47:44I mean,
- 47:45I mean,
- 47:45I'm not very familiar with your work,
- 47:47but I understand that you're an LGBTQ activist,
- 47:49so I would say your allies are people who align with your values,
- 47:52at least a 90%.
- 47:52So I'm an activist
- 47:54and I work on political reform in the
- 47:55state of Florida focused primarily on school boards because
- 47:58they are currently attacking our children and they hold
- 48:00massive political opportunity to actually revolutionize the state,
- 48:03and I'm LGBTQ plus.
- 48:05So how are these school boards attacking children in Florida?
- 48:08You wanna go there?
- 48:09I,
- 48:09I would like to hear your claim on this do it.
- 48:10OK,
- 48:11bet.
- 48:11So school boards in the state of Florida and all throughout
- 48:13the country have actually been a listed part of Project 2025,
- 48:16as they stated,
- 48:17because they are politically vulnerable spaces that have low voter turnout,
- 48:21low community awareness,
- 48:22low investment that is disproportionately easy when you take lots of
- 48:25money and invest them into the elections to change the results.
- 48:27So a couple of years ago we saw a massive sweep
- 48:29from candidates from Moms for Liberty and far-right hate groups.
- 48:32We also.
- 48:32Rhonda Santos become the very first governor in
- 48:34our state's history to endorse these candidates.
- 48:36These candidates pushed anti-LGBTQ plus policies,
- 48:39which are anti-Christian and anti-American.
- 48:41They banned books.
- 48:42They banned books throughout the state.
- 48:43They told people they could not use restrooms.
- 48:45No,
- 48:45no,
- 48:45no.
- 48:46OK,
- 48:46we always should ban pornography in our schools.
- 48:48Pornography in our schools would be evil.
- 48:49Erotica in our schools is not acceptable.
- 48:51What we see is age-appropriate leveled reading
- 48:54that discusses topics that some might find uncomfortable.
- 48:57In our school,
- 48:57but that is measured by psychology,
- 48:59which includes being gay,
- 49:00which is,
- 49:00well,
- 49:00I would say you would find being gay uncomfortable,
- 49:02whereas I would say it's a reality,
- 49:03and I would say that someone should be able to homosexual,
- 49:05which is a sexual thing
- 49:07that is erotica,
- 49:08because you're talking about being queer isn't inherently sexual.
- 49:10I'm not having sex with you right now because I'm LGBTQ plus.
- 49:13I'm sitting at a table having a conversation with you.
- 49:15OK,
- 49:15so earlier you tried to claim that gay pride parades
- 49:17were not inherently sexual.
- 49:19So let's pause there.
- 49:20They're not.
- 49:20We've been voted out.
- 49:22Hi,
- 49:22nice to meet you.
- 49:24OK,
- 49:25so
- 49:25I wanna talk a little bit more about the anti-Christian
- 49:29thing that you were saying.
- 49:30So I know that you said that
- 49:32Jesus,
- 49:32this is what you said,
- 49:33Jesus said that
- 49:35basically we follow the Holy Spirit.
- 49:37Does that mean that we can do whatever we want or what,
- 49:39what,
- 49:40what are the rules?
- 49:41Because
- 49:41within Christianity.
- 49:43There are a set of rules.
- 49:44Obviously
- 49:45we're sinners,
- 49:45we're not going to follow them.
- 49:47The most important one I would say is to love others around you,
- 49:50but there's a lot of other ones that are important as well,
- 49:52such as,
- 49:53such as the sinning,
- 49:55like no LGBTQ.
- 49:56That's a rule.
- 49:57Where does it say that in the Bible?
- 49:58lust.
- 49:59It does say that a man cannot be with a man.
- 50:01Did you know that that was actually mistranslated
- 50:03and had to do with sexual violence,
- 50:04grooming,
- 50:05and ritualistic relationships?
- 50:06No,
- 50:06in the New Testament,
- 50:07it says that a man and a woman shall be together for the very first time,
- 50:11a man.
- 50:12The word homosexual to the Bible,
- 50:14that was never a part of God's word or God's choice.
- 50:16God
- 50:17gives perfect word and truth to man who
- 50:19has imperfect ear and an imperfect understanding.
- 50:21And so that's how we have things like slavery,
- 50:23which is never in God's vision,
- 50:25is not a part of love,
- 50:26is not a graceful practice.
- 50:28There's lots of things in the Old Testament that don't pertain to today,
- 50:30OK?
- 50:31The New Testament,
- 50:32now you're saying that it was misinterpreted.
- 50:34There's a lot of other things within that same sentence,
- 50:36such as you shall not murder,
- 50:38you shall not commit adultery,
- 50:40you shall not,
- 50:40man shall not be with man.
- 50:42So you're saying the only.
- 50:42The part within that sentence that was misinterpreted
- 50:45was man should not be with man.
- 50:46What about murder?
- 50:47Is that OK?
- 50:48No,
- 50:48I'm saying that one was thatlationterpreted as well?
- 50:51No,
- 50:51I'm saying that one mistranslation contradicts what Jesus
- 50:54told us is the most important rule.
- 50:55He came to earth and said,
- 50:56do not follow the Bible like a law.
- 50:58Use it as a loving,
- 50:59graceful practice and follow my word about the 10 Commandments?
- 51:02Those are laws,
- 51:02and the word of God says that
- 51:04these commandments are written on the tablets of your hearts.
- 51:07These are what the laws that us shall through John 16:12
- 51:09is that I cannot bestow all knowledge upon you now.
- 51:12You will learn more.
- 51:12You will experience more and you will develop.
- 51:14Women have rights now and even in the New Testament,
- 51:16they were disrespected,
- 51:17belittled,
- 51:18and they were not given these rights.
- 51:19And so what we're seeing is that we as people are imperfect beings.
- 51:22And the more that we develop our understanding,
- 51:24educate ourselves,
- 51:25meet new people,
- 51:26and follow the most important law,
- 51:27which is to love one another.
- 51:30What about we should not commit murder?
- 51:31Is that OK?
- 51:32Because you're you're disregarding the other laws.
- 51:35I have a can I just say something?
- 51:36I think it's great that you're Christian.
- 51:38I think,
- 51:38I don't think that,
- 51:39oh,
- 51:39if you're a sinner,
- 51:40you can't be Christian because that's not what the Bible says.
- 51:42said to come as you are and you can be a Christian,
- 51:44but I don't believe that you're following Christ as you should be.
- 51:47You may be a Christian,
- 51:48but the thing is that you're hindering your walk with God.
- 51:51You're hindering your relationship with.
- 51:52First of all,
- 51:52my walk with God is between me and God,
- 51:54and second of all,
- 51:55no,
- 51:55the important point is I see the flag going up from a Christian perspective.
- 51:58I do want to say that when we speak about LGBTQ,
- 52:01I know that it comes off as hatred,
- 52:03but it comes from a place of caring,
- 52:05as we can see that love is an action word,
- 52:07care is an action word,
- 52:08and the reason that one country is going downhill
- 52:11when we look back from the beginning.
- 52:12time till now,
- 52:13it's going downhill,
- 52:14and what's changing,
- 52:15we're,
- 52:16and people are affirming transgenderism.
- 52:17People are affirming the gay people.
- 52:19So what is changing,
- 52:21that's changing.
- 52:21And as we see that happening,
- 52:23we see less suicide,
- 52:24less depression,
- 52:24less anxiety is going up queer and trans
- 52:26people who are affirmed and receive gender-affirming care,
- 52:28suicide rates don't go up.
- 52:30Amongst young people in a failing country with a
- 52:32failing healthcare system that denies them mental care,
- 52:34then we see.
- 52:35No,
- 52:35mental health care is the reason suicide rates are going up.
- 52:38There's no access to it in the United States.
- 52:40Gender-affirming care is proven to lower suicide.
- 52:42What you said about that one sentence in the Bible that we have to go back to,
- 52:45the reason
- 52:46I believe we shouldn't murder people is because
- 52:48it's in clear alignment with God's greatest rule,
- 52:50love everyone.
- 52:51Hating LGBTQ plus people is in clear contradiction.
- 52:54And so because of that,
- 52:56because of that,
- 52:56hold on,
- 52:57I am continuing to follow the Holy Spirit and learn new things and extend grace,
- 53:01faith,
- 53:02and love to all.
- 53:03And that is how we concluded more rights for more people throughout history.
- 53:07Why would we stop if LGBT is living in a life that is leading to destruction,
- 53:11and we applaud.
- 53:12Them,
- 53:12do you think that's love?
- 53:13And we accept them and say this is good,
- 53:15even though we know for a fact if someone's leading a life of destruction,
- 53:18we need to help.
- 53:18Your life is going to lead to destruction them out now.
- 53:20Your life is going to lead to depression.
- 53:22Love is telling the truth even when it's hard to hear.
- 53:24If your house is on fire.
- 53:26I need to tell you to get out.
- 53:27The truth is the number one place queer and
- 53:30trans people experience the hatred that causes their suicide,
- 53:33depression,
- 53:33and anxiety rates to increase is actually
- 53:35hateful rhetoric from the Christian church.
- 53:37The number 1
- 53:39population that is
- 53:40homeless in the state of New York City.
- 53:42In the state of New York
- 53:43are queer and trans young people who
- 53:45have been disavowed by their Christian families.
- 53:47Jesus Christ would go to those people the number and help them.
- 53:50He would let's pause there.
- 53:52You've been voted out.
- 53:53OK,
- 53:54thank you.
- 53:54I appreciate you.
- 53:56So I'm assuming from everything you're telling me that you think
- 53:59that God is OK with you practicing sodomy with other men.
- 54:02I am saying that God always acts in accordance with love,
- 54:05and the sodomy that was written about in the Bible has nothing to do with loving queer
- 54:08and trans relationships because there was no frame
- 54:10of reference for the phrases who created it.
- 54:12Man is imperfect,
- 54:13God's word is perfect,
- 54:14God would support queer and trans existence.
- 54:16Do you want to talk about why it's also anti-American?
- 54:18You don't think that
- 54:19sodomy existed 2000 years ago?
- 54:22I do think it existed 2000 years ago and the way
- 54:24that it was written about in the Bible was about hateful,
- 54:27unconsensual,
- 54:28pedophilic,
- 54:29ritualistic acts of sodomy.
- 54:31There have been healthy queer and trans relationships all throughout the history,
- 54:33and they were not included in the Bible,
- 54:35the same way women's rights were not included in the Bible.
- 54:38God did not intend us to treat that like a law that we never move on from.
- 54:41He entreated us to use it like a way to learn love and practice it better.
- 54:45It is not an instruction manual.
- 54:46It is one tool that we can use to live our lives.
- 54:48You do think,
- 54:49but to clarify,
- 54:50so you do think that God is OK with you having sex with other men?
- 54:53Yes,
- 54:54OK.
- 54:55So I feel particularly close to God when I have sex with other men.
- 54:59That's literally,
- 55:00OK.
- 55:02So I think that your definition of love is basically
- 55:05what feels good for you and also being nice to other people.
- 55:09Um,
- 55:09I think love is more complicated than that.
- 55:11For example,
- 55:11you can have a sexual relationship with someone that you might not love,
- 55:14whereas love is a deeper emotion of care.
- 55:16But
- 55:16basically it's just like this like fluffy feeling of like,
- 55:19oh,
- 55:20like I like you,
- 55:20I'm treating you well,
- 55:21whatever.
- 55:22I think that love is willing.
- 55:23The good of another person.
- 55:25So you can,
- 55:25you can have
- 55:27consensual sex with someone,
- 55:29and that's not loving them because participating in homosexual
- 55:32acts is inherently not loving because it's damaging.
- 55:35It violates inherently damaging.
- 55:37It violates naturally damaging.
- 55:38It doesn't violate natural law.
- 55:39There are over 1000 species that are proven to have queer relationships.
- 55:44God designed Why does the G-spot exist?
- 55:46I don't know.
- 55:47God literally designed male and female bodies to know God's vision.
- 55:50How about this?
- 55:51Let's not pretend to know God's
- 55:52How come 12% of men who have sex with other men
- 55:55one or more times a week
- 55:57have problems where they are not able to control their bowel movements?
- 56:02Because when
- 56:04you.
- 56:05Well,
- 56:05why?
- 56:06If it's healthy,
- 56:07if it's perfectly healthy,
- 56:10and you know that's true,
- 56:11that doesn't mean that doesn't mean that I hate you.
- 56:13It means I don't want you doing something that's not natural and
- 56:15it's not healthy and it's not good for you or for society.
- 56:18There's a reason gay men can't reproduce with each other.
- 56:21There's a reason why gay women can't reproduce with each other.
- 56:24Our bodies are not an essential factor of love and care.
- 56:28It is not the essential factor of a relationship,
- 56:30and the things that you're saying are nasty,
- 56:33evil pieces of rhetoric that aren't grounded in science.
- 56:36Absolutely not evil.
- 56:36You don't think it's scientific that it's more
- 56:38harmful to have gay sex than straight sex?
- 56:40It's not more harmful.
- 56:41It obviously is.
- 56:42That's why there's more STD rates.
- 56:44So,
- 56:44OK,
- 56:44that's time.
- 56:48My last claim is politicians banning books is
- 56:50more dangerous than drag queens reading them.
- 56:53Hey,
- 56:53hello,
- 56:53hello.
- 56:54Get a little more time this time.
- 56:55Let's do it.
- 56:55All righty,
- 56:56um,
- 56:57first I,
- 56:57I guess I wanna say,
- 56:58um,
- 56:59wouldn't both,
- 57:00I guess from the arguments that I've heard,
- 57:01I could be wrong,
- 57:02feel free to correct me if I'm wrong,
- 57:03are they not both propaganda,
- 57:04kind of like going back to that question where we went to grooming,
- 57:06right?
- 57:07We go to grooming.
- 57:07I think
- 57:08when it came to that argument.
- 57:10In my opinion,
- 57:10I think where you were getting confused was
- 57:12that you were getting propaganda and grooming.
- 57:14I've said that's why I said in my opinion,
- 57:16how I interpreted your responses.
- 57:17Yeah,
- 57:18how I interpreted is that when you were phrasing things,
- 57:20it was in my head,
- 57:21you,
- 57:21you should have been substituting propaganda.
- 57:24There's nothing inherently wrong with that.
- 57:25Like grooming is
- 57:26like forcing
- 57:27a belief upon somebody.
- 57:28I believe that's how I,
- 57:30yeah.
- 57:31And propaganda is political communication involuntary.
- 57:33Now these kids are being given us uh
- 57:35information at a young age,
- 57:36and they're just making the choice.
- 57:37It's just more appealing to those kids.
- 57:39It's also about the impact.
- 57:40A lot of this information is lies and it leads to
- 57:42direct harm for those children and other children around them,
- 57:44and it is meant to be done to change their thinking and patterns of behavior
- 57:48such that
- 57:49Donald Trump and Elon Musk are able to exploit them for.
- 57:51Power,
- 57:51but right now we're discussing book bans and drag queens.
- 57:54Would you agree that politicians banning books,
- 57:56which has only ever in human history led to authoritarianism,
- 58:00is more dangerous than drag queens reading books,
- 58:02which is proven to have no correlation to sexual violence whatsoever.
- 58:07Well,
- 58:08I guess it,
- 58:08it's,
- 58:09I think we should admit
- 58:10that a drag queen.
- 58:12Which is
- 58:13almost always
- 58:14a man
- 58:15in a fun woman's costume.
- 58:17Fun is relative,
- 58:18fun is that's that's a relative in adult spaces,
- 58:21it is often
- 58:22more sexy.
- 58:23So what we're saying is,
- 58:25I think it's just a hard piece of imagery for people who don't want
- 58:29diverse gender expression to swallow,
- 58:30and so we're like,
- 58:31oh,
- 58:31that's sexual violence,
- 58:32oh,
- 58:32they're trying to sexualize their children,
- 58:33but psychologists and medical doctors have actually
- 58:37evaluated those events because of how many horrible claims that have been made on a.
- 58:40Baseless,
- 58:41baseless amount of hatred,
- 58:43and what we found
- 58:44is that there is no sexual violence,
- 58:46there is no sexual perversion,
- 58:49and there is no increase in sexual confusion.
- 58:51That's the most important part,
- 58:52because I can understand someone saying,
- 58:53oh,
- 58:53the drag queen has the best of intention,
- 58:55but now my child is confused.
- 58:57They measured it,
- 58:57they tracked it,
- 58:58they studied it,
- 58:59the child doesn't get confused.
- 59:00The child sees someone in a fun costume,
- 59:02they're like,
- 59:02that is fun,
- 59:03and suddenly reading,
- 59:04which is very boring for many young children,
- 59:06they're willing to pay attention.
- 59:07They're willing to be there.
- 59:08And what we also see is.
- 59:08Queer and trans children in those cases are less likely to be depressed and anxious
- 59:13when they witness someone
- 59:14who is experiencing diverse gender expression
- 59:17in their space.
- 59:17Yes,
- 59:18OK,
- 59:18so,
- 59:18um,
- 59:19once again,
- 59:20so
- 59:20I'm gonna go back to propaganda because I
- 59:22really think that's what this question is about.
- 59:24There are two ways to do that propaganda,
- 59:26which again
- 59:26every we'll say agenda as we've established before.
- 59:28I'm not saying that
- 59:29LGBT has an agenda,
- 59:30but it's got a title.
- 59:31Therefore it probably has a group that has an agenda.
- 59:33If it's got a title,
- 59:34clearly
- 59:35you guys agreed on something,
- 59:36right?
- 59:36I think that's fair to say.
- 59:37I,
- 59:38uh,
- 59:38I'm gonna keep,
- 59:38I'm,
- 59:38I'm just,
- 59:39I think everything that would have a title,
- 59:40clearly there's a group that women have a coordinated political agenda.
- 59:44Do white people have,
- 59:45are they,
- 59:45are they feminists?
- 59:46Are they,
- 59:46I mean,
- 59:47I think everybody does,
- 59:47as somebody else said,
- 59:49everyone has an agenda.
- 59:49You can't say that you don't have,
- 59:50you're describing people fighting for their human rights.
- 59:53Well,
- 59:53human rights,
- 59:54well,
- 59:54I guess that's a whole another debate in itself,
- 59:55but point being,
- 59:56human rights are not up for point being propaganda can be done in two ways.
- 59:59You can remove certain things or you can heavily promote certain things.
- 1:00:03Why do we?
- 1:00:04In so many shows and movies nowadays
- 1:00:06that
- 1:00:07there's usually a gay character or some form of LGBT representation,
- 1:00:10right?
- 1:00:10OK,
- 1:00:10that's one thing that's proven to save lives.
- 1:00:12Let me just see,
- 1:00:13I know,
- 1:00:13I know,
- 1:00:13I'm just,
- 1:00:13I'm gonna respect the context,
- 1:00:16yet you don't have a positive conservative character.
- 1:00:18There are far more conservative people than gay people.
- 1:00:20So I'm just saying like it's all propaganda.
- 1:00:22Both sides can do it.
- 1:00:23Don't say it's not.
- 1:00:25So I think
- 1:00:26neither is worse than the other.
- 1:00:27I think it's just one side using agree that book bans are worse than drag queens.
- 1:00:30No,
- 1:00:31not at all.
- 1:00:31I think,
- 1:00:31I think they're,
- 1:00:32I mean,
- 1:00:32I think they're,
- 1:00:33they're a way that one side
- 1:00:35chooses to promote their argument or dissuad the
- 1:00:37other about where the wild things are.
- 1:00:39What's wrong about Charlotte's Web?
- 1:00:40I mean,
- 1:00:41is it the context or the actual,
- 1:00:42I mean,
- 1:00:42because you can read between the lines and things that people say.
- 1:00:44No,
- 1:00:45no,
- 1:00:45no,
- 1:00:45no.
- 1:00:45See,
- 1:00:45Charlotte's Web is banned because animals were speaking
- 1:00:47and one parent decided that was witchcraft.
- 1:00:49Now none of the parents in the district get to make the child's.
- 1:00:52Should a city council have to pass a law that allowed them to,
- 1:00:54that allowed them to ban those books?
- 1:00:55Did some state,
- 1:00:56wait,
- 1:00:56then how did they?
- 1:00:57In many instances,
- 1:00:58school boards hire a singular professional who
- 1:01:00accepts singular complaints and ban any books
- 1:01:02based off the singular complaints elect people that we trust to make decisions.
- 1:01:05We did not elect the person they paid to go into our schools.
- 1:01:08We elect tarp our libraries,
- 1:01:09remove our power to choose an independent person to do that.
- 1:01:12We allow those people were elected,
- 1:01:14and now people,
- 1:01:15the majority chose those people to then pick somebody else on their behalf.
- 1:01:19It's the same with electors and elections.
- 1:01:20We don't pick the electors,
- 1:01:21but we pick the people who picked them.
- 1:01:22They've been voted out.
- 1:01:24Hello,
- 1:01:25hello.
- 1:01:25Doing well.
- 1:01:26Hi,
- 1:01:26Will.
- 1:01:26All right,
- 1:01:27so you said like Charlotte's Web is getting banned.
- 1:01:29That's silly.
- 1:01:29I also think it's silly if one parent runs the whole thing.
- 1:01:32But,
- 1:01:32um,
- 1:01:33for sure,
- 1:01:33that's not every book being banned.
- 1:01:35Like,
- 1:01:35you know,
- 1:01:36I'm sure you've heard of gender queer,
- 1:01:37stuff like that should not be in schools.
- 1:01:39It's pornographic.
- 1:01:40I think it should be available at an age-appropriate level.
- 1:01:41Do I think elementary schoolers need to be reading gender queer?
- 1:01:44No.
- 1:01:44And in terms of like,
- 1:01:45uh,
- 1:01:45you know,
- 1:01:46Republican bills in Florida,
- 1:01:47like,
- 1:01:47uh,
- 1:01:47you know,
- 1:01:48I don't think,
- 1:01:48especially K through 3.
- 1:01:49There should be any official curriculum being taught to kids
- 1:01:52that is telling them about
- 1:01:53sexual orientation.
- 1:01:55However,
- 1:01:55I wouldn't go the extra mile and say like
- 1:01:57we should get rid of every book that just mentions a gay character in the library.
- 1:02:00That's not a part of the official I love that we're inching there.
- 1:02:02What I would say is that there has never been
- 1:02:04a democracy that lasted when it started banning books.
- 1:02:07Every single civilization that has ever started
- 1:02:09banning books turned into a fascist regime,
- 1:02:11and to me that's very frightening and to me the justifications of it
- 1:02:14being rooted in.
- 1:02:15Marginalized communities and their identities.
- 1:02:17The majority of banned books discuss queer,
- 1:02:19trans,
- 1:02:19black,
- 1:02:19and brown identities.
- 1:02:21That feels to me like a very quick trend towards fascism.
- 1:02:23And so when that's being perpetuated by someone
- 1:02:25who's saying,
- 1:02:26I want to be king,
- 1:02:27there's gonna be a third term for president,
- 1:02:28I'm like,
- 1:02:28uh oh,
- 1:02:29fascist recipe coming together very quickly.
- 1:02:31I know,
- 1:02:31I don't agree with the 3rd term bullshit,
- 1:02:33right?
- 1:02:33What are we talking about?
- 1:02:34George W.
- 1:02:35did a lot of work just for him to be like,
- 1:02:36no,
- 1:02:37sorry,
- 1:02:37backtrack.
- 1:02:38What were we just talking about just before you mentioned Trump,
- 1:02:39book bans,
- 1:02:40book bans.
- 1:02:41Um,
- 1:02:42and how they're worse than drag queens reading books.
- 1:02:44OK,
- 1:02:45well,
- 1:02:45uh,
- 1:02:45first of all,
- 1:02:46they're not being banned in the sense that none of
- 1:02:47these books are banned in the state of Florida.
- 1:02:50They're being banned in like local school boards like you're saying.
- 1:02:52So there's no actual government law that's being written to ban books.
- 1:02:55What are school boards?
- 1:02:56Uh,
- 1:02:56they're,
- 1:02:57you know,
- 1:02:57forms of government,
- 1:02:58and they're banning books as a part of a
- 1:03:00national coordinated strategy that was written in Project 2025
- 1:03:03as a part.
- 1:03:04Of a fascist plan to overtake the stated intention is
- 1:03:07overtake the government.
- 1:03:08OK,
- 1:03:08but you know,
- 1:03:09you know,
- 1:03:09I could say I don't,
- 1:03:11I think it should be more than just one complaint,
- 1:03:12but I think parents coming forward to school boards
- 1:03:15and local government levels because local politics is good.
- 1:03:18I'm not a fan of local politics.
- 1:03:19I like local politics.
- 1:03:20So it's,
- 1:03:21it's,
- 1:03:21it's,
- 1:03:22it's different than a statewide ban on books in Florida,
- 1:03:24which is not happening.
- 1:03:25Yeah,
- 1:03:25I agree that.
- 1:03:26Local governments are banning books and that is bad.
- 1:03:28OK.
- 1:03:28And in terms of the drag queen Story Hour,
- 1:03:30what is the upside to that?
- 1:03:32Why don't we have firefighters or veterans?
- 1:03:33That's a good question.
- 1:03:34It actually creates safety and new gender experiences for
- 1:03:37queer and trans children who don't feel safe.
- 1:03:39And so we've actually found is queer and trans
- 1:03:40children who do have drag queen story hours,
- 1:03:43they actually have higher rates of affirmation,
- 1:03:46less suicide,
- 1:03:46depression,
- 1:03:47anxiety,
- 1:03:47and I think that matters.
- 1:03:49OK,
- 1:03:50I've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:03:52Hi Cameron,
- 1:03:53nice to meet you.
- 1:03:54So,
- 1:03:55um,
- 1:03:56I would like to start off by,
- 1:03:58uh,
- 1:03:58saying that
- 1:03:59I'm not anti-gay
- 1:04:01as a Republican,
- 1:04:02I believe in freedom,
- 1:04:04you know,
- 1:04:04less regulations,
- 1:04:06less laws,
- 1:04:06and the freedom to be gay.
- 1:04:09However,
- 1:04:10um,
- 1:04:10when
- 1:04:11you're saying banning books,
- 1:04:12I do believe that there needs to be some age restrictions on certain books.
- 1:04:16Um,
- 1:04:17we shouldn't be teaching children about sexuality so early.
- 1:04:22Um,
- 1:04:23or being transgender,
- 1:04:24changing your gender,
- 1:04:25they can't even
- 1:04:26learn to drive a car yet.
- 1:04:27That makes lots of sense,
- 1:04:28and I think
- 1:04:29what we should teach people about is diverse identities.
- 1:04:31I don't think we need to be talking about graphic
- 1:04:33sex with elementary schoolers on that we'd entirely agree.
- 1:04:35I think saying,
- 1:04:36hey,
- 1:04:36some gay people exist,
- 1:04:37make sure you don't spit at them.
- 1:04:39I think that's a great thing to do because young people
- 1:04:40are most able to learn that information at a young age.
- 1:04:43And so what the psychology and the data shows us is that when they have.
- 1:04:46Those discussions,
- 1:04:47it actually not only benefits queer and trans students,
- 1:04:49but all students,
- 1:04:50including straight cis students,
- 1:04:52become safer,
- 1:04:53more productive members of society,
- 1:04:55and it actually,
- 1:04:55and this is my fun crazy statistic,
- 1:04:57it actually benefits the economy.
- 1:04:59OK,
- 1:04:59I do see what you mean.
- 1:05:00Um,
- 1:05:01that being said,
- 1:05:01I just,
- 1:05:02I just feel like we shouldn't be talking about that around children.
- 1:05:05I think that's something,
- 1:05:06um,
- 1:05:06they should figure out for themselves whether they agree
- 1:05:09with or not.
- 1:05:10Um,
- 1:05:10obviously,
- 1:05:11we also shouldn't have hateful books towards,
- 1:05:14you know,
- 1:05:15the gay community,
- 1:05:16uh,
- 1:05:16for them to read.
- 1:05:17I,
- 1:05:18I don't think any sort of hate
- 1:05:21teaching to children is OK.
- 1:05:23Um,
- 1:05:23also,
- 1:05:23the drag queen thing.
- 1:05:25That's just weird to me.
- 1:05:26Why are you having a,
- 1:05:28a
- 1:05:28person that's
- 1:05:30dressed up as a different gender,
- 1:05:32um,
- 1:05:32reading to children?
- 1:05:34Like,
- 1:05:34I wouldn't
- 1:05:35bring my kid to something like that.
- 1:05:37I think it's just strange.
- 1:05:38And I think that if you don't want to,
- 1:05:39you definitely shouldn't.
- 1:05:40I think that it should be an option for parents who do want to,
- 1:05:42because what we see is that many parents who are raising queer and trans
- 1:05:45children or children that they believe might
- 1:05:47be questioning their sexuality or gender,
- 1:05:48the word queer children.
- 1:05:50Shouldn't even be a thing,
- 1:05:51but people,
- 1:05:51that's weird.
- 1:05:52Queer children doesn't mean sexualized children or children who are having sex.
- 1:05:56It means people who have a queer id don't even know how to be straight yet.
- 1:05:59Why are we teaching them
- 1:06:00to be queer?
- 1:06:01As young as 2nd grade,
- 1:06:03there are reports of people feeling like they have crushes on people and
- 1:06:06blowing kisses because we are all in a society where relationships are disgusting.
- 1:06:09er,
- 1:06:10like,
- 1:06:10but queer,
- 1:06:11queer just means not straight.
- 1:06:13It doesn't mean like.
- 1:06:15Devil.
- 1:06:16OK,
- 1:06:16so it just means not straight because
- 1:06:18from my understanding,
- 1:06:19from what I've heard,
- 1:06:20queer means you like everybody no matter what.
- 1:06:22OK,
- 1:06:22that's a,
- 1:06:23that's a misconception.
- 1:06:24So,
- 1:06:24so instead of saying LGBTQ plus,
- 1:06:26which everyone in this room said they wouldn't be willing to say,
- 1:06:28I was like,
- 1:06:29let's switch it to queer.
- 1:06:30Queer used to be a long time ago,
- 1:06:31a horrible word.
- 1:06:32Exactly.
- 1:06:33And then the LGBTQ plus community reclaimed it
- 1:06:36and basically said,
- 1:06:36if you are not straight,
- 1:06:38let queer be an umbrella term that serves you,
- 1:06:39because if we do keep adding letters,
- 1:06:41no one's gonna say anything.
- 1:06:42Anything,
- 1:06:42no one's going to be respectful.
- 1:06:43So queer encompasses all of the identities,
- 1:06:46and it's you're gay,
- 1:06:47you're lesbian,
- 1:06:47you're bisexual.
- 1:06:48Why can't you just be one of those?
- 1:06:50Why do you have to be queer in terms of just
- 1:06:52language that encompasses and includes everyone in the LGBTQ+ community,
- 1:06:56and like I said there,
- 1:06:57that already doesn't have an I,
- 1:06:58it doesn't have the A,
- 1:06:59it's already not fully inclusive,
- 1:07:01and so instead of
- 1:07:02continuing to add letters,
- 1:07:03we say queer and trans.
- 1:07:04But I have an issue with that because gay and trans are two totally different things.
- 1:07:07Why are you grouping them within the same thing?
- 1:07:09Some gay people don't like trans people.
- 1:07:12We entirely agree that sex and gender are different things.
- 1:07:14What I am saying is that the LGBTQ plus,
- 1:07:18it is what you said,
- 1:07:19but the LGBTQ plus community is called a
- 1:07:22community because these are people that have been
- 1:07:24pushed out of societal norm and persecuted in the same ways by the same people for
- 1:07:29differences in their innate characteristic of who they are as a human being
- 1:07:33and because it is so similar in the styles of persecution
- 1:07:35and because we shouldn't.
- 1:07:36Further divide marginalized communities.
- 1:07:38The queer and trans community are a community.
- 1:07:40Our struggles are interlinked.
- 1:07:41Stonewall,
- 1:07:42the first protest,
- 1:07:42what is known to start the LGBTQ plus movement,
- 1:07:44is an interlinked movement of resistance between queer and trans people.
- 1:07:48And so the community and trans are two totally different topics.
- 1:07:51They're different things.
- 1:07:52They are,
- 1:07:52and they're
- 1:07:53trans and being gay,
- 1:07:55liking a certain gender and wanting to change,
- 1:07:58mutilatestinctualize the two,
- 1:08:00because why are,
- 1:08:00why are we grouping them?
- 1:08:01Why is it important for you to make those two communities distinct?
- 1:08:04You just named them all queer.
- 1:08:05They're not all queer.
- 1:08:06Who's not all queer?
- 1:08:07Gay
- 1:08:08is not the same thing.
- 1:08:09You're putting them under one umbrella.
- 1:08:11No,
- 1:08:11no,
- 1:08:11I said queer and trans.
- 1:08:13Huh?
- 1:08:13I said queer and trans.
- 1:08:14Queer is a term that describes difference in sexuality.
- 1:08:17OK,
- 1:08:18or sexual orientation.
- 1:08:18That's fine.
- 1:08:19But as I said,
- 1:08:20I'm not getting anywhere with this with you.
- 1:08:22Gay and trans are two different things.
- 1:08:25Yes.
- 1:08:25They shouldn't be put under the same umbrella.
- 1:08:27No.
- 1:08:28OK,
- 1:08:29so you just voted out by the majority.
- 1:08:30Thank you.
- 1:08:31Um,
- 1:08:32so quick question,
- 1:08:33do you think people are born gay or trans?
- 1:08:35So you think kids are born trans?
- 1:08:37I think they're born trans.
- 1:08:38Yes,
- 1:08:38OK,
- 1:08:39so you would be,
- 1:08:40uh,
- 1:08:40OK with them getting any type of either brain scans
- 1:08:43or anything before they go through medical transition then,
- 1:08:45right?
- 1:08:46That way,
- 1:08:46that way,
- 1:08:47because you know,
- 1:08:4713%,
- 1:08:48which you stated was 1%,
- 1:08:49but actually 13% of people do de-transition.
- 1:08:52So to avoid that,
- 1:08:53no,
- 1:08:53they could bring up,
- 1:08:54I'll even show the study on my phone to you right now.
- 1:08:56Well,
- 1:08:56I'm sure you have things that say that,
- 1:08:57but it doesn't make it true.
- 1:08:59So this you're just invalidating the entire study you're invalidating the entire
- 1:09:03study let me let me ask you this are you OK with uh
- 1:09:05this medical transition if
- 1:09:07they get brain scans before the medical transition?
- 1:09:09What are you talking about?
- 1:09:10OK,
- 1:09:10so how,
- 1:09:11how do you know someone's born trans?
- 1:09:12Give me the,
- 1:09:13the definition.
- 1:09:14How do you know they're born trans?
- 1:09:15So
- 1:09:16transgender is when your gender
- 1:09:19is not the same as your birth sex.
- 1:09:21And so when someone says I'm transgender,
- 1:09:23then I'm like,
- 1:09:24OK,
- 1:09:25so you're transgender.
- 1:09:26OK,
- 1:09:26so how do you know they're born that way?
- 1:09:28They know and they tell us,
- 1:09:30and then we see that when we affirm their gender,
- 1:09:32their lifespan and their quality of life increases.
- 1:09:35So you and there's no objective way to measure it.
- 1:09:37It's all subjective,
- 1:09:38right?
- 1:09:39No.
- 1:09:39OK,
- 1:09:40so what's the objective measurement that someone's born trans?
- 1:09:42An objective measurement that someone is born trans.
- 1:09:44When they say that they are born trans,
- 1:09:46that is deeply important,
- 1:09:47but also
- 1:09:47there's differences in the actual brain of
- 1:09:50trans people that correlates to their gender.
- 1:09:52Like
- 1:09:53they are more similar to that of their gender
- 1:09:56than.
- 1:09:56Their birth sex.
- 1:09:57OK,
- 1:09:58so that's an objective way to measure in your opinion,
- 1:10:00correct?
- 1:10:00Well,
- 1:10:01it is a factually objective way to measure it.
- 1:10:02So then we could agree that kids should have this,
- 1:10:05uh,
- 1:10:05brain scan before they medically transition,
- 1:10:07correct?
- 1:10:07Wouldn't that be a good middle ground?
- 1:10:09Um,
- 1:10:09I would say because you say there's an objective way to measure it,
- 1:10:11correct?
- 1:10:12I am saying.
- 1:10:13That that is one objective reality of the trans existence.
- 1:10:16What I am saying is that because
- 1:10:19all queer and trans people who are transitioning as young people in
- 1:10:22the United States do so with about 3 to 5 medical professionals,
- 1:10:25I trust that those medical professionals know more about that individual than I do.
- 1:10:29Someone is not just saying,
- 1:10:30oh,
- 1:10:31this kid says they're trans,
- 1:10:32let's go.
- 1:10:33Let's give them hormones.
- 1:10:34What actually happens is a young person feels
- 1:10:36a deep amount of distress in who they are
- 1:10:39based on something they had no control over.
- 1:10:41They share that with their parents.
- 1:10:42In the majority of cases,
- 1:10:43the parent who wants to keep their child alive,
- 1:10:45brings them to a psychologist or a psychiatrist.
- 1:10:47They work with that medical professional for many
- 1:10:50years.
- 1:10:51They bring in endocrine specialists and they work together for
- 1:10:53years to decide what is the right path of treatment,
- 1:10:56when,
- 1:10:57how,
- 1:10:57and with who.
- 1:10:58And they have over time
- 1:11:00over being trans.
- 1:11:01Yeah,
- 1:11:01you have no control over it,
- 1:11:02correct.
- 1:11:02So the de-transition rate shouldn't be 13%,
- 1:11:04right?
- 1:11:05So the majority of people who detranuber anxiety,
- 1:11:07why do the majority of people detran
- 1:11:09anxiety and someone suffering from gender dysphoria?
- 1:11:11What's the distinct difference?
- 1:11:13So puberty anxiety is,
- 1:11:14oh my gosh,
- 1:11:15I'm very worried that my characteristics are going to change who I am as a person.
- 1:11:19Other people are,
- 1:11:20oh my God,
- 1:11:21I'm worrying that puberty is going to permanently lock
- 1:11:24me into a body that is not mine,
- 1:11:27and I will never be able to prevent the changes that I go through with puberty.
- 1:11:31And so,
- 1:11:32A partially reversible option
- 1:11:34is puberty blockers that is actually proven to save lives.
- 1:11:38That's what matters to me is lives saved of young people.
- 1:11:41So if you care about lives saved,
- 1:11:42then why do you dismiss the Oxford study of 108,000 patients when their depression,
- 1:11:47anxiety,
- 1:11:47substance use,
- 1:11:48and suicide suicidal talk about the Oxford study.
- 1:11:51Talk about the methodology.
- 1:11:52Why do you talk about the people who ran the study?
- 1:11:53Talk about the peer review process,
- 1:11:54so you just don't like the study because it doesn't,
- 1:11:56it doesn't,
- 1:11:57it doesn't affirm your belief though,
- 1:11:58right?
- 1:11:58No,
- 1:11:58no,
- 1:11:58I'm saying it's a broken study in one study
- 1:12:01that you.
- 1:12:02You think is good.
- 1:12:02OK,
- 1:12:03I would say the study is done by the 270,000 doctors.
- 1:12:05OK,
- 1:12:06which one?
- 1:12:07it's the same thing,
- 1:12:08but you'd have to talk about the same thing because it doesn't affirm,
- 1:12:10you're not,
- 1:12:11you don't know anything about your study,
- 1:12:12whereas I know everything about the American Medical Association study,
- 1:12:15the American Psychological Association study,
- 1:12:17the American Psychiatric Association study,
- 1:12:19the American Pediatric Association study,
- 1:12:21the World Health Organization study,
- 1:12:23and countless global doctors who have referred and peer reviewed those studies.
- 1:12:26Your study,
- 1:12:27I would like you to talk about the methodology,
- 1:12:29how it was peer reviewed,
- 1:12:30and how you're citing it,
- 1:12:31because what I do.
- 1:12:31about your study is not only are you manipulating it,
- 1:12:34but it's broken in its process.
- 1:12:36OK,
- 1:12:36so the Cas review study is bad.
- 1:12:37The Swedish study about puberty blockers is bad is proven UK,
- 1:12:40the UK Health,
- 1:12:41the Finland,
- 1:12:42the Denmark,
- 1:12:43all their health departments that say puberty blockers are aren't safe.
- 1:12:46Not all studies are run well,
- 1:12:47because some studies can be broken,
- 1:12:49some studies aren't accurate,
- 1:12:50and some studies aren't well done.
- 1:12:52And so I'm not saying I don't like your facts.
- 1:12:54I'm saying
- 1:12:55the conversation we're having
- 1:12:56about the studies you're referencing
- 1:12:58don't attribute to the greater conversation we're having about LGBT.
- 1:13:01To you plus people because of the ideologies
- 1:13:03and methodologies and practice of those studies.
- 1:13:05What I'm saying is the largest global medical organizations
- 1:13:09unanimously agree that queer and transgender affirming care,
- 1:13:13it is unanimous.
- 1:13:13That's what makes it special.
- 1:13:14It's not a medical.
- 1:13:15That's why it's so important.
- 1:13:16I didn't say medical consensus.
- 1:13:18I said the majority
- 1:13:19of health organizations that are the largest in the world
- 1:13:21and in the country all unanimously agree that queer,
- 1:13:25it is true.
- 1:13:26You just don't want to believe it because it doesn't affirm your reality.
- 1:13:28That's the,
- 1:13:28that's the problem.
- 1:13:29You want to believe it because it does,
- 1:13:30but when it.
- 1:13:30Peer reviewed when it's fact check and when people actually look into your studies,
- 1:13:33they realize that they're false.
- 1:13:35You would be able to reference more,
- 1:13:36you'd be able to reference peer reviewed sources,
- 1:13:38you'd be able to reference medically established institutions,
- 1:13:41you'd be able to reference things that
- 1:13:42are respected in the greater medical community.
- 1:13:44He's a perfect middle ground for you.
- 1:13:45Here's your perfect.
- 1:13:46He's a perfect middle ground.
- 1:13:47You don't want to reach a middle ground.
- 1:13:48Here's the middle ground.
- 1:13:49I would like to do so.
- 1:13:50If people are born trans and we could see in their brain scans,
- 1:13:53then you'd be OK with a,
- 1:13:54with a brain scan before they medically transition.
- 1:13:56That's a really good middle ground.
- 1:13:58That's a really good middle ground.
- 1:13:59The information there.
- 1:14:00Is new.
- 1:14:01So you don't want to reach the middle ground of it.
- 1:14:02No,
- 1:14:03what I'm saying is I trust the medical
- 1:14:05professionals who found that information to continue to
- 1:14:08study it and decide what is the best practice to apply it to life saving healthcare.
- 1:14:12If I see medical practices that put young people in harm's way,
- 1:14:15I would advocate against it's life saving to stop the natural biology of someone,
- 1:14:18inject them with synthetic hormones,
- 1:14:20and then do gender reassignment surgery.
- 1:14:21That's life saving to you say it,
- 1:14:23isn't that correct?
- 1:14:24No,
- 1:14:24I'm just saying,
- 1:14:24I'm just saying life saving to take a scalpel,
- 1:14:26cut someone open,
- 1:14:28go into their heart,
- 1:14:29remove a part of their heart.
- 1:14:30Zip them back up,
- 1:14:31that's also life.
- 1:14:31Let me ask you this.
- 1:14:32How do they know they're in the wrong body if they
- 1:14:33haven't even hit puberty where the body is fully developed yet?
- 1:14:36It is not about the physical characteristic of
- 1:14:38me feeling my fingernails and being like,
- 1:14:40wow,
- 1:14:40these are my fingernails.
- 1:14:42It is having to do with who you are as a human being,
- 1:14:44your innate human identity,
- 1:14:46which is gender,
- 1:14:48not aligning with your birth sex.
- 1:14:51If you go through puberty,
- 1:14:52the majority of changes,
- 1:14:54how long do they go on puberty blockers?
- 1:14:55It depends on the individual.
- 1:14:57How long?
- 1:14:57OK,
- 1:14:57let's pause there.
- 1:14:58That's time.
- 1:15:02Xander will now choose a conservative to debate for
- 1:15:0510 minutes on a claim of their choosing.
- 1:15:07I'm gonna choose Mike.
- 1:15:08I feel like we're gonna have a productive conversation.
- 1:15:10All right,
- 1:15:11so
- 1:15:11my claim is,
- 1:15:13uh,
- 1:15:13Xander,
- 1:15:14correct?
- 1:15:14OK.
- 1:15:15My claim is Xander and LGBTQ+ people
- 1:15:18have a fundamental misunderstanding of Christianity.
- 1:15:22OK,
- 1:15:23what is the point of your claim?
- 1:15:24OK,
- 1:15:25so,
- 1:15:25um,
- 1:15:26back when you were talking earlier,
- 1:15:27a lot of presuppositions.
- 1:15:29So you made the claim that you are a Christian.
- 1:15:31I am also
- 1:15:32a Bible believing,
- 1:15:32uh,
- 1:15:33uh,
- 1:15:33Jesus follower.
- 1:15:34Contrary to popular belief,
- 1:15:35the Bible says once you claim to be a Christian,
- 1:15:37it's free game as far as like judgment.
- 1:15:39So if I'm a Christian,
- 1:15:40like people can judge me.
- 1:15:41I can judge you.
- 1:15:42Like it's like non-believers,
- 1:15:44pagans,
- 1:15:44not really,
- 1:15:45you know,
- 1:15:45concerned about them,
- 1:15:46but if you're a Christian,
- 1:15:47there are certain standards.
- 1:15:49So we.
- 1:15:49Kind of uh made a lot of claims,
- 1:15:51especially,
- 1:15:52um,
- 1:15:52in the totality of our conversation as far as like,
- 1:15:55OK,
- 1:15:55medical consensus,
- 1:15:56we kind of like
- 1:15:57we're throwing out specific terms,
- 1:15:59but when it comes to the Christian
- 1:16:01faith,
- 1:16:01when it comes to the Christian religion,
- 1:16:02there is a,
- 1:16:03I mean,
- 1:16:04depending if you're Orthodox,
- 1:16:05Catholic or Protestant,
- 1:16:06there is a centralized authority,
- 1:16:07there is historical,
- 1:16:09biblical traditional teachings,
- 1:16:10um,
- 1:16:11things that have been practiced and understood for 2,000s,
- 1:16:13thousands of years,
- 1:16:14right?
- 1:16:15So when it comes to things.
- 1:16:16Like progressive ideologies,
- 1:16:18specifically what we're seeing in the 21st century,
- 1:16:20a lot of progressive Christian beliefs are very specific political beliefs.
- 1:16:25They're not,
- 1:16:25they're not faith beliefs,
- 1:16:27they're political.
- 1:16:27Who does Christ tell us has the right to judge Christians?
- 1:16:30Other Christians.
- 1:16:31No,
- 1:16:32Christ actually tells Christians that they should not judge
- 1:16:33other Christians and that instead he says God,
- 1:16:35he says you will know them by their fruits.
- 1:16:38Exactly,
- 1:16:38exactly,
- 1:16:39and that if you cast the first stone and if you use the biblic
- 1:16:41text or the word of God to tell other people what to do or.
- 1:16:44Live their lives,
- 1:16:44you within yourself are casting sin and sitting within it.
- 1:16:47And so what we know,
- 1:16:48what we know,
- 1:16:48what we know is that God Himself is the judge,
- 1:16:51and what we are to do is to hold our relationship with God,
- 1:16:54let others hold their relationships with God and prevent harm.
- 1:16:57What I am saying is that LGBTQ plus existences and relationships do not create harm.
- 1:17:01Murder creates harm.
- 1:17:02I would say Christians have an obligation to call
- 1:17:04out and stop murderous policies when they see them,
- 1:17:07because there is not a correlation of harm that would call out the word of Christ.
- 1:17:11That is what we're seeing there.
- 1:17:12I am going to have to have a very hard conversation about the fact
- 1:17:16that the original biblic text
- 1:17:18would have destroyed life for millions of good Christian Americans.
- 1:17:22So what we did
- 1:17:23is we listened to the Bible and we listened to the word of Christ,
- 1:17:25who said,
- 1:17:26you do not know everything yet,
- 1:17:27do not treat the Bible like a law.
- 1:17:29Follow the Holy Spirit,
- 1:17:30be inspired by it and follow it through grace.
- 1:17:32And because we do so,
- 1:17:33we learn to bring in new people into the Christian faith,
- 1:17:36support them,
- 1:17:37occlude them.
- 1:17:39A lot you're saying a lot of presuppositions and
- 1:17:40you're saying a lot of things that like back,
- 1:17:43back when you were making the claim,
- 1:17:44right,
- 1:17:44when everyone was bringing up,
- 1:17:45uh,
- 1:17:46different studies and things that were happening,
- 1:17:48you're saying that's fundamentally not true.
- 1:17:49The things that you're saying right now are fundamentally not
- 1:17:52true specifically because of what it's written in scripture,
- 1:17:54right?
- 1:17:54So there's people who like I'm not gonna get
- 1:17:56into the the uh debate of like sola scriptura
- 1:17:59and whether or not like Christians only look at
- 1:18:01the text or tradition and stuff like that,
- 1:18:03but the word of God says we shouldn't do that.
- 1:18:05But the point I'm making,
- 1:18:06so even,
- 1:18:06so again,
- 1:18:07the reason why I said.
- 1:18:08The Fundamental misunderstanding
- 1:18:09is because when it comes to
- 1:18:11reading the text and understanding the text,
- 1:18:14there's no form of like exegesis,
- 1:18:15there's no form of understanding context,
- 1:18:17there's no form of looking at the text and saying,
- 1:18:19hey,
- 1:18:20what is actually happening here?
- 1:18:21There is a word in the text from Christ that says,
- 1:18:24do not treat this like a law,
- 1:18:25and I haven't told you everything yet.
- 1:18:27John 16:12 literally says
- 1:18:30you do not have all the information now.
- 1:18:32I have not burdened you with all of the throw the Bible verse.
- 1:18:34They'll throw the Bible verse on there,
- 1:18:35but so,
- 1:18:36and I said it less pretty I'll give you.
- 1:18:37I'll give you one example.
- 1:18:38I'll give you one example,
- 1:18:39uh,
- 1:18:39based off a point I,
- 1:18:40I believe you're trying to make.
- 1:18:41So when the Bible talks about,
- 1:18:43um,
- 1:18:43uh,
- 1:18:43don't judge others when you have a plank in your eye,
- 1:18:46you're looking at the speck in your brother's eye when you have a plank in your eye.
- 1:18:48That's not saying that you cannot judge.
- 1:18:50It's saying that when you do judge,
- 1:18:52make sure that you
- 1:18:54are holding yourself to a specific standard,
- 1:18:56right?
- 1:18:56We read it in Timothy and James when it calls when it,
- 1:18:58uh,
- 1:18:58when it talks about holding yourself to a certain standard
- 1:19:01as an elder and harmful practices and to offer grace,
- 1:19:04to offer faith,
- 1:19:05to offer love.
- 1:19:05It also says that if you use the.
- 1:19:07Text he'll tell other people how to live their lives,
- 1:19:09then that is not Christ.
- 1:19:10You're,
- 1:19:10you're,
- 1:19:11you're vehemently misquoting Christ.
- 1:19:13So do you believe women should have rights?
- 1:19:15Yes.
- 1:19:15Then if we were to follow this lane of thinking,
- 1:19:18women would not have rights for more who
- 1:19:20fundamentally pushed for better positions for women?
- 1:19:23Christians,
- 1:19:23Christians,
- 1:19:24yes,
- 1:19:24historically,
- 1:19:25right?
- 1:19:25So if you talk,
- 1:19:26and now good Christians throughout the world are pushing to
- 1:19:28include LGBTQ plus people in the name of the Holy.
- 1:19:29What does it mean to be a Christian?
- 1:19:30What is a Christian?
- 1:19:31A Christian is someone who acts with love and the word of God.
- 1:19:33What is love?
- 1:19:34What is love?
- 1:19:35Love is an action word.
- 1:19:36Love.
- 1:19:36Is showing care for other human beings in a sustainable true way.
- 1:19:39OK,
- 1:19:39so I would say that is a very watered down
- 1:19:42understanding of what love is.
- 1:19:43So love in,
- 1:19:44in my,
- 1:19:45and I've actually been thinking about this,
- 1:19:46love is the obligation
- 1:19:49to encourage others
- 1:19:51to pursue a life that will abundantly
- 1:19:53reconcile them with God.
- 1:19:56That is,
- 1:19:56that's your definition of love,
- 1:19:57half of loving relationships in the world wouldn't fit within that.
- 1:20:00So my definition works way better.
- 1:20:02And,
- 1:20:02and Christian,
- 1:20:03a man and a wife don't fit under the role of holding.
- 1:20:06Each other exclusively accountable.
- 1:20:07It's also about care.
- 1:20:08It's about compassion.
- 1:20:09It's about grace.
- 1:20:10See,
- 1:20:10again,
- 1:20:11you're misunderstanding
- 1:20:12marriage is a specific institution that God put in place
- 1:20:15as an example for our heavenly marriage to Him,
- 1:20:18to Christ.
- 1:20:19That that is the purpose.
- 1:20:19That is the purpose of originally marriage as discussed in the original
- 1:20:22text was not like a loving marriage that we see today.
- 1:20:25What we see today is a new version of that
- 1:20:27because we continue to follow the Holy Spirit's deliberation.
- 1:20:30Today it's perverted.
- 1:20:30People marry for love.
- 1:20:31People marry for very superficial things and not for property,
- 1:20:34which I would say is great.
- 1:20:36Uh,
- 1:20:36I would say for power.
- 1:20:37People in the past married for power.
- 1:20:39Marriage is a power play and also property.
- 1:20:40I'm not just like
- 1:20:42saying that sure,
- 1:20:42and historically,
- 1:20:43right,
- 1:20:44yes,
- 1:20:45um,
- 1:20:45so
- 1:20:46again,
- 1:20:46my point is there's a fundamental misunderstanding of the text
- 1:20:50because you said,
- 1:20:51because you,
- 1:20:52because you said
- 1:20:53Christianity means to love.
- 1:20:54Um,
- 1:20:55people always say things like,
- 1:20:56oh,
- 1:20:56the greatest commandment is to love.
- 1:20:58When I talked about context,
- 1:21:00the greatest commandment is love in the context of the 10 Commandments.
- 1:21:03So in that conversation,
- 1:21:05uh,
- 1:21:05where they're talking about the 10 Commandments,
- 1:21:07uh,
- 1:21:07the 10 Commandments is,
- 1:21:08first of all,
- 1:21:09the 10 Commandments is a summary
- 1:21:10of like more than 600 laws,
- 1:21:12right,
- 1:21:12that the,
- 1:21:13that,
- 1:21:13that were in place,
- 1:21:14not just in Old Testament Israel,
- 1:21:16but also in he fulfilled those laws,
- 1:21:18hold on,
- 1:21:18hold on,
- 1:21:18hold on,
- 1:21:18he added new meaning to them because there's a.
- 1:21:21Because God's word is perfect,
- 1:21:22but man's understanding of it is not.
- 1:21:23No,
- 1:21:23no,
- 1:21:23no,
- 1:21:24uh,
- 1:21:24man's understanding is not,
- 1:21:25and that's why Christ came and corrected us.
- 1:21:27So my,
- 1:21:27my point is
- 1:21:29the context of the 10 Commandments,
- 1:21:31right,
- 1:21:31is in the context of there was more than 600 laws,
- 1:21:35it boiled down to 10,
- 1:21:36and then Jesus boiled it down to 2,
- 1:21:37which people like to quote,
- 1:21:38love your neighbor.
- 1:21:39The first is actually love the Lord your God,
- 1:21:41right?
- 1:21:41In the context of the 10 Commandments.
- 1:21:44It is my is my theological
- 1:21:47opinion
- 1:21:47that the greatest commandment is when God says,
- 1:21:50be holy,
- 1:21:50for I am holy,
- 1:21:51right?
- 1:21:52The reason why is because,
- 1:21:53again,
- 1:21:54my point is the fundamental misunderstanding of Christianity.
- 1:21:57Your position is that Christianity means
- 1:22:00that come as you are,
- 1:22:01stay as you are.
- 1:22:02That is fundamentally not true.
- 1:22:04You are saying it because I think that Christians like you,
- 1:22:07Christians use the Bible and the word of God to hate
- 1:22:09others need to reflect on that and become more Christ-like.
- 1:22:12So you agree with my point when I said that your,
- 1:22:14your,
- 1:22:14your,
- 1:22:14your understanding of love
- 1:22:16is to affirm.
- 1:22:17That is not a biblical definition of love.
- 1:22:19I'm not telling you you need to change your faith.
- 1:22:20I'm saying that,
- 1:22:21no,
- 1:22:21no,
- 1:22:21I'm not talking about faith.
- 1:22:22I'm not I'm not,
- 1:22:23I'm not talking about faith.
- 1:22:23I'm saying that I'm saying that if a Christian believes.
- 1:22:26That if I have a child and I believe that child is made in
- 1:22:29the image of God and God made them male or God made them female,
- 1:22:33and then someone comes along and says that they're not male or they're not female,
- 1:22:36that is contrary,
- 1:22:38that that it comes as a divide between what God is you thinking
- 1:22:42that you know that person's relationship with God better than they do.
- 1:22:46It's not I trust that their relationship with God showed them who they were and
- 1:22:49it is our duty to love and support
- 1:22:51them as Jesus Christ was fundamental misunderstanding.
- 1:22:53I'm not talking about.
- 1:22:55Their relationship with God.
- 1:22:56I'm not talking about,
- 1:22:56I'm not talking about their relationship with God.
- 1:22:58So you brought up sex workers,
- 1:22:59right?
- 1:23:00The adulterous woman comes,
- 1:23:01the,
- 1:23:01the Pharisees brought the adulterous woman to Jesus,
- 1:23:04and we caught her in the act,
- 1:23:05right?
- 1:23:05Some people say it's like,
- 1:23:06why,
- 1:23:06how did the Pharisees catch her in the act,
- 1:23:07right?
- 1:23:07It's like what were they doing,
- 1:23:08right?
- 1:23:09Jesus,
- 1:23:10in his
- 1:23:11proper context of love,
- 1:23:13criticized them,
- 1:23:14says he,
- 1:23:15uh,
- 1:23:16um,
- 1:23:16he without sin cast the first stone,
- 1:23:18you're bringing LGBTQ plus people to
- 1:23:20Jesus and saying
- 1:23:21they're bad,
- 1:23:22and he would say it's not their bad.
- 1:23:24Mind your business,
- 1:23:25and he would affirm the love of us and even beyond that example,
- 1:23:28I don't think he would tell us to do
- 1:23:29anything differently because there is nothing harmful being done.
- 1:23:32I even think in today's worldview,
- 1:23:34sex work would be respected by Christ and this is why
- 1:23:36I think it's a fundamental misunderstanding and this isn't just a
- 1:23:38a progressive LGBT issue.
- 1:23:40I think there are people in general who
- 1:23:41have a misunderstanding of what Christianity is about.
- 1:23:43Christianity isn't good guys and and
- 1:23:45and bad guys.
- 1:23:46Christianity is we're all bad guys.
- 1:23:48We're all bad guys and we're all perfect we,
- 1:23:50no,
- 1:23:50we're all fundamentally sinful.
- 1:23:52It's not we're imperfect.
- 1:23:53We are all fundamentally
- 1:23:55in I think it's unhealthy to think we're all bad people.
- 1:23:57I think we all sin.
- 1:23:58I think we're all are.
- 1:23:59We are bad in the context of we are not God.
- 1:24:01So the way I kind of define sin,
- 1:24:03it's not a matter of you did this,
- 1:24:04you did that.
- 1:24:05Sin is basically means to miss the mark,
- 1:24:08right?
- 1:24:08It means that God is the standard
- 1:24:10and we will never meet that standard.
- 1:24:12So to me sin is sin simply means I am not God and I'm not capable of being God.
- 1:24:16And because I'm not God,
- 1:24:17I am not holy and because of that,
- 1:24:19I,
- 1:24:19Bible says I'm born into sin,
- 1:24:21right?
- 1:24:21So.
- 1:24:22When I say fundamental misunderstanding of Christianity,
- 1:24:25when it comes to specifically progressives LGBT groups,
- 1:24:28is that they think it's like,
- 1:24:30OK,
- 1:24:30yeah,
- 1:24:30we're imperfect,
- 1:24:32right,
- 1:24:32but it's more of a Gnostic understanding.
- 1:24:34It's like,
- 1:24:34well,
- 1:24:35we strive each day and as we gain more knowledge,
- 1:24:37as we read more studies,
- 1:24:39we'll we'll we'll somehow attain some kind of like
- 1:24:42understanding that we'll get closer to God by the fruit.
- 1:24:46And I would say that when we view LGBTQ plus people,
- 1:24:49the fruit,
- 1:24:50I'm about to describe it in the context of our conversation,
- 1:24:52if we measure LGBTQ plus people in their fruit and what they produce for this
- 1:24:56world and how they contribute and how they show up and how they exemplify,
- 1:25:00it is positive,
- 1:25:00it is good,
- 1:25:01and it adds value to our experience.
- 1:25:03When we think about anti-LGBTQ plus policies,
- 1:25:06we see harmful.
- 1:25:07The fruit of the spirit,
- 1:25:08I think that's.
- 1:25:09For interpretation.
- 1:25:10For me,
- 1:25:10it's what we bring to the world.
- 1:25:11The Bible literally says what the fruit of the Spirit is.
- 1:25:13I know,
- 1:25:14but the Bible also says a variety of things that Jesus
- 1:25:16Christ tells us to interpret in a more graceful manner.
- 1:25:19I would say the fruit of the Spirit is how we bring value to this world.
- 1:25:22If you love me,
- 1:25:22you will keep my commandments,
- 1:25:24right?
- 1:25:24And you will know them by their fruit.
- 1:25:26The fruit of the Spirit is a myriad of things,
- 1:25:28and there's one,
- 1:25:28there's one fruit of the Spirit.
- 1:25:30I like to call it the forgotten fruit of the spirit.
- 1:25:31It's the last one mentioned,
- 1:25:32it's self.
- 1:25:33Control.
- 1:25:33It's self-control,
- 1:25:35right?
- 1:25:35It means that in this imperfect world we're gonna have struggles.
- 1:25:38If it,
- 1:25:39if in the context of LGBT people,
- 1:25:41that is
- 1:25:42their struggle and the fruit of the spirit is self-control.
- 1:25:45I would say that self-control applies to eating junk food or drinking alcohol.
- 1:25:49I say to all things in the in the context
- 1:25:51not about limiting who you are as a human being.
- 1:25:54OK,
- 1:25:54that's time.
- 1:25:55Thank you.
- 1:25:59Those are nice?
- 1:26:00Yeah,
- 1:26:01I think so.
- 1:26:01I think so.
- 1:26:03I did a lot of reflection before I decided to come today.
- 1:26:05I think sometimes when it's platforming negative views that are really harmful,
- 1:26:09it can just be harmful,
- 1:26:10but I really thought that this conversation could be productive,
- 1:26:13and I think in many ways it was really the,
- 1:26:15the most important reason why I wanted to come on here is because these,
- 1:26:17these discussions are,
- 1:26:18are very important regardless of what the topic may be,
- 1:26:22finding a middle ground,
- 1:26:22meeting with people that you don't agree with is something that we don't do.
- 1:26:25I'm glad that this is a.
- 1:26:26Space where we can all come together and share our opinions without
- 1:26:30fear of violence because unfortunately that's something we see a lot of nowadays.
- 1:26:33I didn't feel surrounded by the enemy and I think that that's so important.
- 1:26:37These people didn't hate me.
- 1:26:38I didn't hate them.
- 1:26:39We want the same things we're using different information and that's why it feels
- 1:26:43like we're in different realities and so we just have to close the gap.
- 1:26:45I'm a community organizer and my job is to find commonalities that.
- 1:26:49People have and shared goals that we have and
- 1:26:51successful ways to work towards them so that we can
- 1:26:53build a better quality of life for ourselves and a
- 1:26:55better future for the incoming generations and I think that
- 1:26:58every single person here today wants that
- 1:27:00and I think that there's a broken idea of how we get there.
- 1:27:03Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:27:06your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:27:08And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:27:10subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.