Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / From Awareness to Action: Confronting Physical Disability Bias in the Legal Profession
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to From Awareness to Action, Confronting
- 0:05Physical Disability, Bias in the Legal Profession.
- 0:08I'm Anthony Ross. I'm a partner at the Lewis
- 0:11Brisbane Law Firm here in Los Angeles and chair
- 0:13of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's Inclusion
- 0:15Section. I'm delighted to introduce today's speakers,
- 0:18Brandy Salovey, David Cross, and AJ Link. Brandy
- 0:22Salovey. is the legal director of Independent
- 0:26Living Resource Center of San Francisco, where
- 0:28she supervises their legal services program.
- 0:31Her experience includes social security benefit
- 0:35matters, requests for reasonable accommodations,
- 0:38pre -eviction matters, immigration matters, and
- 0:40criminal and post -conviction relief. Brandy
- 0:42is passionate about advocating for underserved
- 0:44and marginalized individuals and educating people
- 0:47about their rights. David Cross is a partner
- 0:50in Goodvin's antitrust and competition practice
- 0:52and a member of the firm's complex litigation
- 0:54and dispute resolution practice. He is a leading
- 0:57first chair trial lawyer with extensive experience
- 0:59representing both plaintiffs and defendants in
- 1:01antitrust and complex business litigation, including
- 1:04intellectual property and general commercial
- 1:06matters. David also maintains a strong pro bono
- 1:09practice focused on civil rights work. AJ Link
- 1:12will be moderating today's program and he is
- 1:14the founding president of the National Disabled
- 1:16Law Students Association and the National Disabled
- 1:19Legal Professionals Association. AJ is openly
- 1:21autistic and works as a policy analyst for the
- 1:24Autistic Self Advocacy Network. He is the inaugural
- 1:27director of the Center for Air and Space Law
- 1:29Task Force on Inclusion, Diversity, and Equity
- 1:32in aerospace and is an adjunct professor of space
- 1:35law at Howard University School of Law. AJ serves
- 1:39as a research director for the Just Add Astro
- 1:41Project, the accessibility team lead for Astro
- 1:44Access, the space law and policy chair for Black
- 1:47in Astro. And now let's get started. hands it
- 1:50over to Ajay. Thank you so much, Tony. I really
- 1:56appreciate that. Thank you all so much for being
- 1:58here with us. This is Ajay Link speaking. I am
- 2:01a black dude with a beard. I'm currently wearing
- 2:04a green Tampa Bay lightning hat with a green
- 2:07shirt and there is a gallery wall behind me.
- 2:10Before we get into the questions today, though,
- 2:12I wanted to give Brandy an opportunity to level
- 2:16set and give us kind of an introduction to some
- 2:19of the vocabulary we're going to be using today.
- 2:23Awesome. Thank you so much, AJ. So for the most
- 2:27part, these definitions have come from my wife,
- 2:29who is a disability retired civil rights attorney,
- 2:32Sandra Solovey, from a talk that she did a few
- 2:35years ago. So first, I wanted to. Talk about
- 2:39ableism a little bit. What is ableism? Ableism
- 2:42includes beliefs, prejudice, or actual discrimination
- 2:46against people who are disabled or who are perceived
- 2:50to be disabled, even if they are not. Many times
- 2:54we are aware of our prejudice. For example, like
- 2:59an old fashioned example would be hiring a male
- 3:02attorney because we assume that he will be more
- 3:05aggressive. That's an example of an explicit
- 3:09prejudice or belief that's different from an
- 3:13implicit bias. With implicit bias, we are not
- 3:18quite aware of our own beliefs or prejudice.
- 3:22We may really think we do not have prejudice.
- 3:25We may think we fully believe that all people
- 3:29are equal, but may interpret the world around
- 3:34us accordingly to these underlying beliefs. For
- 3:37example, in a healthcare situation, we may assume
- 3:42men in scrubs are doctors and women in scrubs
- 3:45are nurses. Or take my wife for example, she
- 3:48had an appointment to meet with a doctor to see
- 3:51if he would be a good expert witness for a case
- 3:53that she was trying. But because she was fat,
- 3:57he assumed that she was there to be a patient
- 4:00asking for his help. It did not occur to him
- 4:03that a lawyer he was meeting with would be a
- 4:06higher weight person. So let's talk about myth
- 4:09or truth for a second. People who are trying
- 4:12to do the right thing do not engage in ableism
- 4:16myth. Most of us are trying to do the right thing.
- 4:19And most of us in some way, at some point, will
- 4:24engage in some form of ableism. We're living
- 4:27in a culture that is saturated with ableism.
- 4:31And even more importantly, ableism is not just
- 4:35about someone's intent. It is about the impact
- 4:39of what we do. We may not mean for it to happen,
- 4:43but it still will cause harm. Ableism exists
- 4:46because of the widespread dangerous assumptions
- 4:49that lives of people with disabilities are less
- 4:54valuable than lives of non -disabled people.
- 4:58Let's use COVID as an example. COVID has been
- 5:02a turning point for disabled communities. Part
- 5:06of Part of what made this happen is because disabled
- 5:10people have been asking and begging for remote
- 5:12accommodations at work or even in recreational
- 5:16activities for years. But we have been denied
- 5:21because many disabled people, and this would
- 5:26cause many disabled people to lose their jobs
- 5:28or to lead very much more isolated and dependent
- 5:34lives than they should have to. The response
- 5:38we got as disabled people was usually that these
- 5:42accommodations were too complicated or could
- 5:45not be done. But then suddenly COVID happened.
- 5:50Everyone, meaning non -disabled folks as well,
- 5:54benefited from remote access. Many workplaces
- 5:57became remote. Many recreational activities became
- 6:00accessible for the first time. Next, we should
- 6:06talk about intersectionality. Professor Krimbley
- 6:10Crenshaw created this term, intersectionality,
- 6:13more than 30 years ago. And it may be even more
- 6:17important now. She explained the term in a Time
- 6:21Magazine interview. As we hear her words, consider
- 6:26how they apply to disabled people of color. Intersectionality
- 6:31is basically a lens, a prism, for seeing the
- 6:37way in which various forms of inequality often
- 6:42operate together and exasperate each other. We
- 6:47tend to talk about race inequality as separate
- 6:50from inequality based on gender, class, sexuality,
- 6:55or immigration status. What's often missing is
- 6:58how some people are subject to all of these.
- 7:02And the experience is not just the sum of its
- 7:06parts. Intersectionality is simply how certain
- 7:12aspects of who you are will increase your access
- 7:15to the good things or your exposure to the bad
- 7:19things in life. There is no single disabled experience.
- 7:24There are many different types of disabilities.
- 7:28And so there are many different types of experiences
- 7:32for being disabled. That will become clear as
- 7:36we share some of our personal stories today.
- 7:39Types of disabilities. So there's lots, as I
- 7:43say, there's lots of types of disabilities. Lots
- 7:46of times we think of disability and we picture
- 7:49a person using a wheelchair or maybe a deaf person
- 7:53or maybe a person like me who is blind. But disabilities
- 7:59can also impact the way people communicate, move,
- 8:03look. feel, think, act, understand the world
- 8:07and how they take in information. Some types
- 8:11of disabilities are more stigmatized than others
- 8:15or definitely stigmatized. Some people have more
- 8:20than one disability. There are also a lot of
- 8:23different ways that we become disabled. Some
- 8:26people are born disabled as I was. Some people
- 8:30become progressively disabled as they age. Some
- 8:34people may be a victim of a crime or an accident.
- 8:39Each different experience impacts how a person
- 8:42learns about and deals with their disability.
- 8:45With that in mind, let's turn to some more personal
- 8:48questions about our experiences and being disabled
- 8:53and practicing law. I will turn it back to AJ.
- 8:58Thank you so much, Brandi, for providing that
- 9:01grounding as we get into these questions. If
- 9:03it's okay with you, I'll ask the first question
- 9:06to David so he has an opportunity to join us
- 9:09in terms of speaking. But the first question
- 9:12is, can you share more about your journey to
- 9:16get to where you are today? I mean, all of us
- 9:18are here talking about ableism in the legal profession.
- 9:21Um, so can you talk about what you had to do
- 9:24to get here and how ableism and systemic barriers
- 9:27impacted you along your journey? So David, please.
- 9:31Sure. Thanks AJ. Uh, and Brandy, thanks for the
- 9:35setup for the conversation. That was very helpful.
- 9:37Um, and hopefully the dogs don't make too much
- 9:39noise in the background or discussion today.
- 9:43Uh, yeah, I, you know, I guess the way I would
- 9:46answer that question, AJ is, um, both positive
- 9:50and negative, I think, is the way I think about
- 9:52the experience having been born with a disability,
- 9:55born without a left hand. There have been hurdles
- 10:01to get over during the course of my journey and
- 10:05my career, both beginning as a kid and through
- 10:08education. Then ultimately, there are also ways
- 10:11that I think my circumstances and my disability
- 10:14have actually helped me in a lot of ways. For
- 10:18me, it's been a journey of ups and downs. The
- 10:23ups for me are, I think those of us who are either
- 10:26born with disabilities or develop disabilities
- 10:28later in life, there are unique challenges that
- 10:31come with that. That drives, I think, certain
- 10:34levels of persistence and creativity, for example,
- 10:37in my practice. It is incredibly important to
- 10:42be creative. I think one of the ways that I try
- 10:44to set myself apart from my clients is coming
- 10:46up with creative solutions to the problems they
- 10:48face. I spent my life doing that since the age
- 10:52of, I think I was four or five when I first learned
- 10:54how to tie my shoes and devised a way to do that
- 10:56on my own. My parents thought I'd probably wear
- 10:59Velcro shoes the rest of my life. There are these
- 11:02positive attributes that have come from the journey.
- 11:05You know, ableism has come up along the way.
- 11:08Unfortunately, as Brandy said, it's I think a
- 11:10sort of systemic part of the world in which we
- 11:12live. I think in fairness, oftentimes it comes
- 11:16up in implicit ways and unconscious ways, the
- 11:18ways that people aren't aware that they're even
- 11:21doing in the moment. Some of those can be minor,
- 11:26some of those can be major. You know, the sort
- 11:27of more minor ways that I've confronted it are.
- 11:31There are a lot of folks that I've dealt with
- 11:32over the years that I've worked with, whether
- 11:34as colleagues, folks across the aisle, different
- 11:38aspects of the profession who can't have a conversation
- 11:41with me without staring every few seconds down
- 11:45at my missing hand, at my left arm. It's minor
- 11:50in the sense that doesn't keep me from doing
- 11:52my job, but it's significant in the sense that
- 11:54it is a constant reminder in these conversations
- 11:56and these interactions that these people see
- 11:58me as something different. and they're distracted
- 12:00from a conversation I'm trying to have and something
- 12:03that's important. They can't even really focus
- 12:06on that. It's come up in more major ways where
- 12:10I can recall relatively early in my career where
- 12:14we were going to pitch something a new matter.
- 12:18The partner on it who had the relationship said
- 12:20that they thought it was better that I didn't
- 12:21join the pitch. because the client might be uncomfortable
- 12:24hiring someone with a physical disability. Instead,
- 12:27they would try to win the pitch, bring it in,
- 12:29and then they would staff me on it after. That
- 12:32was certainly a really disappointing thing to
- 12:34hear and to be able to have to sit on the sidelines
- 12:36of that opportunity. So ultimately, I feel like
- 12:41I've developed a successful practice and a successful
- 12:44career, and I'm happy with where I am. But it
- 12:46has certainly been a journey with a lot of ups
- 12:48and downs. Thank you so much for sharing that,
- 12:56David. If it's okay with you, I'd love to learn
- 12:59more about your experience navigating education,
- 13:05both primary education, collegiate education,
- 13:09law school, as someone with a very apparent disability.
- 13:13I know that in law school, for me, the ability
- 13:18to be open and communicative about being disabled
- 13:24and experiencing law school as a student with
- 13:26disability was still kind of taboo. And that's
- 13:29for someone with a non -apparent disability.
- 13:31So I would be interested to know what your experience
- 13:34was like, how that impacted your ability to kind
- 13:36of navigate school, taking the bar, those kinds
- 13:38of things. Yeah, my experience, I think, was
- 13:42similar to yours, AJ. I think one of the things
- 13:45that we've made progress on in the last, I mean,
- 13:48I've been practicing now for almost 25 years,
- 13:49I think. One of the things we've made progress
- 13:51on is that there's more dialogue around this
- 13:53and the fact that we're having this conversation
- 13:55and I've done panels, other panels for the ABA,
- 13:58for example, on this topic. I think that's good
- 14:02progress that has sort of less of a stigma around
- 14:05disabilities than there once was. I think there's
- 14:07still a pretty strong negative stigma that people
- 14:10have, again, whether conscious or unconscious.
- 14:15And so the way I navigated it, to be honest with
- 14:18you, was I didn't really address it. My disability
- 14:24is such that I can hide it at least for a while.
- 14:27I just literally put my arm in my pocket, and
- 14:30I went through most of my life in that way. To
- 14:34give you an example, when I would interview law
- 14:36firms during law school, anyone who's been through
- 14:40it obviously remembers the grueling way that
- 14:43it used to be, at least, where you would showed
- 14:45up at a hotel for two or three straight days.
- 14:48And at least my experience was that. And you
- 14:49met with a whole bunch of different folks. I
- 14:51would go into every one of those interviews with
- 14:52my hands in my pockets and really try to consciously
- 14:56not take my left arm out of my pocket so they
- 14:58didn't notice. Because my fear was if they did,
- 15:00it would certainly impact how they viewed me.
- 15:03It'd become a distraction. And whether it was
- 15:05conscious or unconscious, it would limit my opportunities.
- 15:10And I've had points in my career where I've known
- 15:14people for months before they realized that I
- 15:17was missing a left hand because I was so successful
- 15:19at hiding it. And I would say I didn't even really
- 15:22become comfortable talking about it until several
- 15:25years ago, really during the COVID pandemic,
- 15:29which I think a lot of us had time to kind of
- 15:31think slowed down for a while in the world and
- 15:32we had time to reflect. And this was one of the
- 15:34things I reflected on and realized I didn't think
- 15:36I was doing myself a good service. I thought
- 15:38I was doing the broader community a disservice
- 15:41in approaching that way. Feeling like it was
- 15:44something I always needed to hide and can talk
- 15:46about and trying to avoid the stigma that I think
- 15:49still exists unfairly rather than confronting
- 15:51it head on. I think the only way to really deal
- 15:54with it is to educate people, get people more
- 15:56comfortable with it, help people understand the
- 15:59little things that they're doing that they're
- 16:00probably not aware of, that create challenges
- 16:02and create discomfort. The bigger things that
- 16:05they're doing, sometimes that are overt, that
- 16:07can create real hurdles to success for individuals
- 16:11with disabilities. Thank you, David. I think
- 16:16you touched on a point and I'd love to come to
- 16:18Brandy with this because Brandy, I think your
- 16:20experience is a bit different than David's in
- 16:22that. David, I'm sure you experienced a lot of
- 16:27extra mental burden thinking about how am I moving
- 16:30through the world so that people do not look
- 16:33at my left hand, right? And that's a lot of extra
- 16:36mental effort that I'm sure you didn't really
- 16:39think about, but once you stop doing that, you
- 16:41realize there's so much more you know, room to
- 16:44think about things, to address things, to be
- 16:46focused and present for the conversation. Where,
- 16:49Brandy, sometimes that's not necessarily what
- 16:51your experience would be, right? It's not like
- 16:53you can put your eyes in your pocket for the
- 16:56day or something like that. So what was your
- 16:58experience and your journey like in dealing with
- 17:01ableism's systemic barriers? Yeah, so, you know,
- 17:06I graduated from law school in 2009. That was
- 17:09a terrible time in the job market in general.
- 17:13And I went on several interviews and I think,
- 17:16you know, I had experiences of people maybe knowing
- 17:20that there is, I don't typically walk with a
- 17:23cane. I used to, but not anymore. And I, I don't
- 17:26know if people always could tell that I had a
- 17:29visual impairment. Certainly if I, you know,
- 17:31I'm reading something in front of them, they
- 17:33would tell maybe they might say like, Oh, her
- 17:36one eye is looking different, a different direction
- 17:39or something like that. But In the beginning
- 17:42of looking for a legal job, I would actually
- 17:47tell people that I was legally blind and would
- 17:53basically say, it's not a problem. I can still
- 17:55get to work. If I need to get to court or whatever,
- 17:58it's not a problem. But I can tell you for sure
- 18:01that there was one particular family law, huge
- 18:04corporate family law firm. that I interviewed
- 18:07with that definitely did not hire me and their
- 18:11attitudes totally changed as soon as they found
- 18:14out that I was visually impaired and couldn't
- 18:17like drive. So after that experience, I actually
- 18:22stopped telling employers or potential employers
- 18:25that I had a visual disability until I was hired.
- 18:30So I eventually, you know, was hired for a position
- 18:36at a private practice, a smaller private practice,
- 18:41and didn't tell the hiring attorney that I couldn't
- 18:45drive or had a visual impairment until after
- 18:47I was hired. And that seemed to work for me.
- 18:51I mean, that's often sometimes the advice I give
- 18:53clients that, you know, need some sort of accommodation
- 18:56or service animal or something like that for
- 18:59an apartment or what have you. it's a better
- 19:04task for the accommodation later if you need
- 19:08one. That worked for me. After I worked at that
- 19:14firm, I was able to gain experience. I was a
- 19:17new attorney. When looking for future employment,
- 19:23I applied for other positions and did sometimes
- 19:26disclose my disability and was still hired. in
- 19:332009, that was not the case. And I also want
- 19:36to take a moment to bring it back a little bit
- 19:38to the intersectionality part of things that
- 19:41I was talking about, you know, earlier, because
- 19:45I am disabled, but also, I'm fat, I'm part of
- 19:50the LGBTQ community. And sometimes, discrimination,
- 19:55you know, it's not just, you know, sometimes
- 19:57people can say, okay, I can work with a lesbian,
- 19:59or I can work with a fat person, or I can work
- 20:01with a dys... But when you have all three of
- 20:04those things in one person, you know, that can
- 20:06also be a stretch for people sometimes. And I
- 20:10just want to point out, you may notice I'm using
- 20:11the word fat. I am in fat community and have
- 20:16a kind of a side pro bono. part of a law office
- 20:21called Fat Legal Advocacy Rights and Education
- 20:23Project. And so that word is just a descriptor
- 20:27word for us, just as short and tall, maybe. But
- 20:31another word you could use would be higher weight.
- 20:33And people shouldn't face discrimination based
- 20:36on their size or their disability or any characteristics
- 20:40or any combination of. those characteristics.
- 20:45And within the disabled community itself, there
- 20:48is sometimes prejudice against some people that
- 20:53are people of different size or against people's
- 20:57race or other characteristics, just like there
- 21:01is in non -disabled community. All these things
- 21:04go hand in hand. And as far as the law school
- 21:08question in my experience there, You know, I
- 21:13grew up until I was in third grade going to special
- 21:16ed classes and having large print books, which
- 21:19one textbook would be about eight large print
- 21:22books. And so by the time I got to law school,
- 21:24it's not that I was trying to hide, hide anything,
- 21:27but it was that I just wanted to use the regular
- 21:30size materials because it was much easier to
- 21:32carry, you know, one book instead of eight or
- 21:34whatever the case may be. And so. I would read
- 21:39materials close so where I would sit in the front
- 21:41of the classroom so that I could see things better.
- 21:44People definitely did know that I was disabled.
- 21:48Interestingly enough, in my law school, even
- 21:51though I did have accommodations like extra time
- 21:54for tests or things like that, I only actually
- 21:57had one professor that made my materials larger
- 22:00print for me, which was very helpful. and would
- 22:03bring them to class, which was great because
- 22:06I wasn't then carrying them all around. But it's
- 22:09just interesting that out of a large school,
- 22:12one professor my entire time, my entire law school
- 22:16career was the only person that did that. So
- 22:18that's just an interesting thing to note. Yeah,
- 22:23I can definitely relate to that. As someone who
- 22:26hated taking my textbooks home, I would try to
- 22:29do all my reading. on campus so I wouldn't have
- 22:31to lug materials back and forth. I totally understand
- 22:34not wanting to have all the the extra the books
- 22:37and reading materials but Brandy something you
- 22:40were talking about reminded me of something David
- 22:43you talked about with your experience of not
- 22:46getting not being able to pitch. And I know we
- 22:50talked about implicit bias and Brandy, you were
- 22:52talking about how people will view a person who
- 22:55maybe has various differences from what's quote
- 22:58unquote normal and judge them on that. And I'm
- 23:00wondering how each of you feels about, you know,
- 23:05the term implicit bias, but how it turns to almost
- 23:10actionable discrimination, right? Like the idea
- 23:14that you are not competent as an attorney based
- 23:17on how you look, not how you practice, how you
- 23:22prepare your materials, how you prepare for a
- 23:24case, whatever, but quite simply how you look,
- 23:28that implicit bias becomes active, right? It
- 23:31becomes active discrimination saying you are
- 23:33not competent to do your job, even though you've
- 23:35gone to school, you've passed the bar, you're
- 23:37in good standing with whatever bar association
- 23:41or jurisdiction you're in. So I'd love to...
- 23:44I don't know, just have a chat with y 'all about
- 23:47how oftentimes I think we excuse ableism as implicit
- 23:53bias when really there is active harmful discrimination
- 23:57that comes from that. And we can go to David
- 24:01first. Yeah, no, I couldn't agree more. I mean,
- 24:05one of the implicit bias, I think you've captured
- 24:08really well, right? On the one hand, it's It's
- 24:13not intended, and so it's not insidious in that
- 24:15way of where you've got someone who is being
- 24:17overtly bigoted in some way. But the consequence
- 24:21can be equally damaging. Exactly as you say,
- 24:24Ajay, because once you have the implicit bias
- 24:26and it manifests in some way, there is going
- 24:28to be some adverse consequence that comes from
- 24:30that. We see that a lot. One of the things that
- 24:35I think we struggle with in the profession, in
- 24:38particular is the impact of implicit bias on
- 24:41advancement and on positions of influence in
- 24:44law firms. I would say even in getting in the
- 24:50door, I think at the stage of hiring, when you
- 24:54look at the statistical number of individuals
- 24:56coming out of law schools who have disabilities,
- 24:58whether visible or otherwise, it is necessarily
- 25:01a substantial number of those folks. When you
- 25:05look at the number of folks who identify as disabled
- 25:08within the legal community, and particularly
- 25:11in larger law firms like mine, it is a very,
- 25:14very small, really sort of a trivial number.
- 25:18I don't think that happens by accident. And I
- 25:20think the same is true as you look over time
- 25:23for other disadvantaged communities. Brandy's
- 25:27talked about some, right? The gay and LGBTQ plus
- 25:30community, certainly racial communities. maybe
- 25:37confess my own bias, I think we as a profession
- 25:40have done better with some communities than we
- 25:42have with others, which is not to say that we
- 25:45don't have a long ways to go. I think we still
- 25:46have a long ways to go with a lot of folks that
- 25:48are still disadvantaged disproportionately and
- 25:50unfairly today. But I often think of those of
- 25:53us with disabilities as the somewhat forgotten
- 25:57community that just has not gotten the same focus
- 25:59over the last 20 to 30 years. And I will confess,
- 26:05I think part of that is we're also, I think we're
- 26:08not as organized as a community. I think we're
- 26:09often not as vocal as a community. And I myself
- 26:11am perfect examples, something I really didn't
- 26:14want to talk about for the last first 20 years
- 26:17of my career because I was so concerned about
- 26:19the stigma. And it often reminds me of when I
- 26:22started my career, at that point, the LGBTQ plus
- 26:27community had not made the strides that had been
- 26:30made over the last 25 years. And I can remember
- 26:33friends early in their career who faced the difficult
- 26:38decision of, do they identify as gay or lesbian
- 26:43in the workplace? Because they were very worried
- 26:45about the statement at that time, what that might
- 26:47mean for their work opportunities. I think we've
- 26:50come a long ways, still have a long ways to go.
- 26:54But today, with disabilities, the folks that
- 26:58I hear from and the folks I talk to, both at
- 27:01prior firms and beyond. I've had a lot of folks
- 27:04reach out to me, particularly as I've gotten
- 27:05more vocal on this from lots of other law firms,
- 27:09have coffee and Zoom calls, a lot of folks. One
- 27:12thing that comes across with every single one
- 27:14of them is they are very, very nervous about
- 27:16identifying as disabled. And if they can hide
- 27:18it, they're gonna hide it. And I think it just
- 27:21creates such an unhealthy environment. As you
- 27:24pointed out, AJ, there is sort of this... additional
- 27:26kind of mental burden that comes along when you're
- 27:28trying to do that. But there's also just the
- 27:30stress that comes with that and sort of negative
- 27:33self images that come along with that, where
- 27:35it's this sort of reinforcing kind of toxic mentality
- 27:40that I have to hide something that's a core component
- 27:43of who I am, who affects who I am, because others
- 27:46may have a negative reaction to that, whether
- 27:48it's implicit or not. And to your point, AJ,
- 27:50even implicit bias, once that negative reaction
- 27:53manifests, It is very much real discrimination
- 27:57in the workplace. So I think you hit the nail
- 28:01on the head. It's a good point to emphasize.
- 28:04And I don't quite have a solution for it, other
- 28:06than having these types of conversations. And
- 28:08hopefully, people listen and learn, and we all
- 28:12do better. Yeah. And Brandy, I want to come to
- 28:16you. I think, David, you brought up a really
- 28:20good point of how because as part of the National
- 28:24Disabled Legal Professionals Association, I keep
- 28:27up with these numbers a little bit, but there's
- 28:29such a huge gap between the number of students
- 28:32who volunteer that they're disabled versus the
- 28:35number of students who are actually getting accommodations
- 28:38versus the number of students who applied to
- 28:41the law school and said they were disabled versus
- 28:43changing that once they're accepted for fear
- 28:45that they won't get accepted. versus students
- 28:49who ask for accommodations on the LSAT to get
- 28:51into law school, compared to law school graduates
- 28:54that ask for accommodations on the bar, bar exams,
- 28:58refusing to grant accommodations for whatever
- 29:00reason. And then to your point, people who are
- 29:03openly volunteering as disabled, as practitioners,
- 29:06but then moving up, you know, as partners and
- 29:08things like that. All of these numbers are very
- 29:11disparate. It's not like... One is 10 % and one
- 29:14is 14%. It's like, oh, there's a gap or understandable.
- 29:17The numbers are all over the place. I think the
- 29:19number of openly identified disabled partners
- 29:21in the legal profession is something like under
- 29:243%, maybe even lower than that. Whereas the last
- 29:28numbers that I saw for privately identifying
- 29:32law students, and even then people have the stigma,
- 29:34is close to 15 % of law students identify as
- 29:38having a disability privately. So that's a huge
- 29:41gap. Right? Brandy, I'd love your input on why
- 29:47you think there's still that stigma, the gap
- 29:51in numbers, how the implicit bias and discrimination
- 29:55plays a role. David kind of mentioned that internalized
- 29:58ableism that people have that are impacting their
- 30:00ability to be their full selves in the workplace.
- 30:03I think I'm just rambling about all the factors,
- 30:05but I'd love to hear your thoughts about why
- 30:08there's such that big gap between people who
- 30:10are comfortable identifying as disabled legal
- 30:13professionals. Yeah, I mean, I think that's interesting.
- 30:16I think that, you know, it goes back to sort
- 30:19of what I was saying before about, you know,
- 30:23me choosing not to tell one of my first employers
- 30:27that I finally got hired at that, you know, not
- 30:30to tell them about my disability because. I wasn't
- 30:34being hired as someone saying that they had a
- 30:36disability. And I had the experience that was
- 30:39needed for the job posting. So I do think that's
- 30:44interesting. I think that, as David said, I agree
- 30:50that also peep, you know, we also have our own
- 30:53internalized ableism. I mean, I'm sure I also,
- 30:56you know, I didn't want to carry large books
- 30:58for law school, but, you know, I also wanted
- 31:02to read the like books that everybody else was
- 31:04reading, you know, or, you know, we all have
- 31:07our own internalized ableism as well. And it
- 31:11probably does make it so we just want to not
- 31:15mention it or pretend it's not there. But I think
- 31:17the more that we do mention it or that we are
- 31:23seen as disabled, and the more times you are
- 31:27passed up for the job promotion or you're passed
- 31:29up for getting the job, the more you're going
- 31:32to decide not to share that anymore. I think
- 31:37my experience is a little bit different, because
- 31:40as I mentioned earlier, all disabilities are
- 31:42different, and so all people's experiences are
- 31:46different. And me being blind, I think that's
- 31:51sort of seen as like a good disability in disability
- 31:55community. And so for me specifically, I think
- 32:03the stigma of being blind is probably less than
- 32:06it is in some cases for some other disabilities.
- 32:09And I've actually found that in some situations,
- 32:13it's actually helped me in some ways. I think
- 32:15it makes me a little bit more memorable. So I've
- 32:19actually had really great relationships with
- 32:22judges or opposing counsel that knew. And I think
- 32:28that in some ways, you know, it sort of humanizes
- 32:33me. It would humanize my client in some cases.
- 32:40And in some cases, when I didn't feel like it
- 32:43would help the situation or I didn't want opposing
- 32:45counsel to know, then I didn't mention it. Oftentimes,
- 32:48I'd communicate with trying to negotiate settlements
- 32:52or whatever via phone. Oftentimes, opposing counsel
- 32:55wouldn't realize. And yeah, I wasn't going to
- 32:58volunteer it if I thought that it would not benefit
- 33:02my client in some way. The interesting thing
- 33:09is I've actually been discriminated against based
- 33:13on being a woman from a client. I had a client
- 33:17once, I was representing her son actually in
- 33:23a juvenile matter and she wanted the other partner
- 33:27of the firm. to be the person that would actually
- 33:31go to court with her son, not me, even though
- 33:34I was the one working on all the case and knowing
- 33:36all the details, because she thought the female
- 33:38judge would listen to a man more than another
- 33:41woman. So, you know, it's interesting, like we're
- 33:44here today talking about implicit bias and disability,
- 33:49but she had a very explicit prejudice towards
- 33:53women. So yeah, it's interesting. One thing I
- 34:00would add on that topic, Gigi, picking up on
- 34:02a point that Brandy was making is I do think
- 34:04there is a spectrum of disabilities in terms
- 34:08of how it affects people's reactions and the
- 34:11biases and the hurdles that come up. I think
- 34:14what it comes back to is do folks who are in
- 34:18decision -making positions, whether it's over
- 34:20hiring, advancement, some influence over a lawyer's
- 34:25career, Do they feel like at some level, whether
- 34:29conscious or unconscious, that the disability
- 34:31is going to affect them and make their lives
- 34:33harder in some way? I think that is a challenge
- 34:36that we face. Fortunately for me, I don't think
- 34:40anybody thinks my disability makes their lives
- 34:42harder. There are other disabilities that I think
- 34:44they do think that. I can remember sitting at
- 34:47a table with a bunch of lawyers once who were
- 34:49complaining after COVID about an associate at
- 34:52a firm who had long haul COVID. and the consequence
- 34:58was this person would get these bouts of exhaustion
- 35:00that came out of nowhere, and they would have
- 35:03to just go and rest, take a nap for an hour.
- 35:08The lawyers who were talking about it were complaining
- 35:12and bemoaning how this made their lives harder
- 35:15because they didn't know if this person might
- 35:17disappear for an hour. It struck me as not something
- 35:20that would be that hard to manage as a supervising
- 35:23partner. They were really unhappy with it, and
- 35:27the conversation quickly became, well, we should
- 35:29steer work to someone else because then we don't
- 35:31have to deal with us. And there is some level
- 35:36where I kind of get that instinct that as lawyers,
- 35:41our lives are difficult and stressful to begin
- 35:42with. We want things to be simple, and we want
- 35:46to work with people who make our lives simple.
- 35:48In fact, that's often what we will tell junior
- 35:49lawyers, right? The best way to be successful
- 35:51is to make yourself an asset to make things easier
- 35:54for the people who are relying on you. But at
- 35:57some point, I think we also have to be human
- 35:58beings. We have to be empathetic and compassionate
- 36:00and recognize that people have challenges that
- 36:03manifest in all manner of different ways. That
- 36:06one person had one particular challenge that
- 36:08created a disability for them that I think probably
- 36:11had a pretty trivial impact on the people relying
- 36:13on that person. And in my mind, that was certainly
- 36:17wasn't the way to deal with it. And the last
- 36:19point I'll make is It really struck me that I
- 36:22was sitting at this table with all these lawyers
- 36:24complaining about this, and it never once entered
- 36:26their mind that it might be offensive to someone
- 36:29else who was sitting there with a disability,
- 36:31which, again, gets to the implicit bias, which
- 36:32is I think it's so unconscious with some folks
- 36:36that in their mind, they think they're just having
- 36:38a normal conversation about someone who's created
- 36:40some challenge for them, and they're talking
- 36:41about how they're going to navigate that. and
- 36:44it never enters their mind that one, the conversation
- 36:46is unfair and the way that they're thinking about
- 36:48it and talking about it and the action plan that
- 36:49they have in mind, which is to take work away
- 36:52from this person, which ultimately will limit
- 36:53that person's career opportunities. And then
- 36:56also not thinking about the person who's sitting
- 36:58at the table with disability and how it might
- 37:00be insulting in the way that they're having this
- 37:02conversation. And all really good people, I know
- 37:05those people well, they're genuinely good people.
- 37:08And I think if I had said something to them about
- 37:10it and I decided in the moment, not to, because
- 37:13it was just a context in which I didn't think
- 37:14it was going to be the right time to bring that
- 37:16up. I think they would have felt really bad.
- 37:21But the reality is that they go through their
- 37:23lives making those types of decisions and having
- 37:25those conversations all the time. And folks with
- 37:27disabilities pay the price for it. And so, again,
- 37:31it comes back to what I made before. We've got
- 37:33to educate people. We've got to enlighten people
- 37:35on how they're thinking about these things, how
- 37:37it's impacting them, and then ultimately how
- 37:38it's impacting others. Yeah. I agree. I agree,
- 37:43David. AJ, is it okay if I go off of that for
- 37:46a second? Please feel free. I think trainings
- 37:50like what David was saying and talking about
- 37:51and trainings like this one are super helpful.
- 37:58I also think making sure the environment for
- 38:02people is accessible. If you think back to law
- 38:07school and the attached desks and chairs, those
- 38:11chairs do not work for everyone. They don't work
- 38:15for a lot of people. And so you're automatically
- 38:18excluding and telling disabled people that there's
- 38:22not room for them there. There's not room for
- 38:23them in their own like legal classroom. So trying
- 38:29to make, you know, places that have like work
- 38:33environments accessible will actually make the
- 38:37life of everyone easier in the end. So not having
- 38:41conference rooms that you have to go upstairs
- 38:43to get to without having an elevator or having
- 38:46different types of seating in like waiting rooms
- 38:49that can be chairs with arms, chairs with no
- 38:52arms, couches, chairs that have higher weight
- 38:56capacities or having conference rooms that have
- 39:01room for a wheelchair to go through without everybody
- 39:04having to move their chair. If you have the environment
- 39:08set up so it's accessible for everyone, that
- 39:12will automatically make it easier for everyone,
- 39:16accessible for everyone. And it should just be
- 39:19thought about at the beginning, at the planning
- 39:22stage, so that a disabled person doesn't have
- 39:25to come and ask for that. So it's just already
- 39:27there. If our environment's changed, that would
- 39:31be very helpful. Yeah, and I would just say,
- 39:35you know, those fixes can be so easy sometimes.
- 39:38I mean, one of my favorite stories is there's
- 39:41a famous story about Mr. Rogers from many years
- 39:44ago. For those who watch Mr. Rogers, he would
- 39:49often begin his show feeding a fish and he would
- 39:51just walk in and he would talk about what he
- 39:53was talking about that day and feed the fish
- 39:54and not say anything about it. And occasionally
- 39:56he would mention feeding the fish. There was
- 39:58a little blind girl that watched the show. And
- 40:02on the days when he didn't mention that he was
- 40:03feeding the fish, she'd be very concerned that
- 40:05the fish was not getting fed. And so she sent
- 40:08him a letter. And apparently the letter made
- 40:11it to him. He read it. He was very troubled that
- 40:14he had upset this young girl. And so from that
- 40:17point forward on every episode, he would make
- 40:19sure to talk about feeding the fish. And so it
- 40:22was just the smallest little thing, right, where
- 40:24he just added literally seconds to his dialogue
- 40:26that he ensured was there every day. So people
- 40:29who were blind, children who were blind would
- 40:31know, fish got fed. And he internalized it in
- 40:34other ways that he could be more descriptive
- 40:36on what he was doing. And so much as you introduce
- 40:39yourself, AJ, the way you did at the start of
- 40:41the panel today. And so there's very simple little
- 40:46things that might take just seconds of thought
- 40:48and energy that we can do that make the environment
- 40:51more conducive to success for folks who have
- 40:54these disabilities. And the more we do that,
- 40:58we also send a message that we are supportive.
- 41:00And the more we send a message we're supportive,
- 41:01the more people feel comfortable being who they
- 41:04are, being open about themselves if they need
- 41:08help, asking for help because they aren't worried
- 41:09about the negative consequences of that. That
- 41:12hopefully makes them more successful. It makes
- 41:14the enterprise more successful. And so everybody
- 41:16benefits from it if we can figure out the right
- 41:19way to do it. Yeah, I really. fully agree with
- 41:26that and embrace the principles of universal
- 41:28design Brandy was talking about. David, I'm thinking
- 41:31about the anecdote that you gave and how oftentimes
- 41:38people without the disability are concerned about
- 41:41the disabled worker's ability to do the work
- 41:44without realizing, and you talked about this
- 41:47at the beginning, David, that disabled people
- 41:49have already thought about the creative solutions
- 41:51that they need in order to practice and to not
- 41:54be deemed as inferior or bad college or things
- 41:58like that. And I don't know that antidote just
- 42:01really got me thinking like lawyers have a lot
- 42:05of hours in their day. And oftentimes they have
- 42:08to be creative with planning those hours. And
- 42:10to your point, I think taking an hour to rest,
- 42:13which all of us do, it may not be rest because
- 42:16of COVID or long COVID or things like that, but
- 42:21every legal professional does take an hour. However
- 42:24they do it, whatever they do, because they have
- 42:27extended days and that's just how it is and they
- 42:29have families and things like that, but we find
- 42:31that hour. And I think to your point about implicit
- 42:34bias, people don't think about how oftentimes
- 42:37disabled folks are living their lives and practicing
- 42:40just like other people do. It's just the situation
- 42:43is different. The scheduling is different. The
- 42:46way they go about the day is different, but the
- 42:48actual work is the same. And I think, you know,
- 42:52panels like this where we kind of merge two questions,
- 42:55which was specific instances where you've experienced
- 42:57ableism and tips. Brandi gave a nice list of
- 43:01tips. But I think being able to educate people
- 43:04about how, you know, disabled people are more
- 43:10than competent to be attorneys. You're often,
- 43:12and again, David, to your example, surrounded
- 43:14by people, whether or not you know they're disabled
- 43:17or view them as disabled, you are surrounded
- 43:19by disabled colleagues who are quite good at
- 43:22their jobs. And I think it's really important
- 43:26that we can continue to communicate that. So
- 43:29we have 17 minutes. I want to leave time for
- 43:32audience questions if there are any. We've already
- 43:35combined the specific instances of ableism while
- 43:38practicing. I don't know if either of you want
- 43:39to talk more about that, whether it's from clients,
- 43:42judges, opposing counsel, or court staff. But
- 43:45then I also want to move more into the suggestions.
- 43:47I know Brandy gave a great list. But if there
- 43:49were suggestions for the legal community, that
- 43:53can make the profession more accessible and less
- 43:55hostile. to disabled practitioners and what role
- 43:59do organizations like the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 44:01play in advocating for the disabled members,
- 44:04especially when, you know, again, to use David's
- 44:08example because it's so visceral, they're probably
- 44:09not in the room knowing that they're being discriminated
- 44:11against. How can we educate folks and not put
- 44:14that burden on the disabled practitioners? So
- 44:17I know that was a lot of rambling from me, but
- 44:19Brandy, if you want to answer any of that or
- 44:22just go off on your own. Yeah, I think I'm doing
- 44:26trainings like this one as David had said earlier
- 44:29I think try to set everyone up for success if
- 44:32an employer if an employee tells you That they
- 44:36need a certain accommodation. For example, if
- 44:38an employee says like they need a desk in a quiet
- 44:41corner try to make that work out for them without
- 44:44trying to like, you know, make it a big deal
- 44:48and be generous when a disabled person points
- 44:53out like an access problem, not defensive because
- 44:56the disabled person is not trying to like make
- 44:58your life more difficult. They're actually trying
- 45:01to help and improve things. So I think, you know,
- 45:06Just listening to people coming with an open
- 45:10mind, knowing that access is important for everyone,
- 45:20for all of us. And just, yeah, basically do the
- 45:26right thing and try to give accommodations when
- 45:31they're reasonable and things of that nature.
- 45:33That's what I would say for the legal community.
- 45:36And then obviously like these types of trainings
- 45:39and the anti -bias trainings and all of that
- 45:42stuff is so important so that this is in conversation
- 45:46so that people are thinking about it more because
- 45:49yeah, it definitely doesn't help like if we're
- 45:52not talking about this stuff and if it's not
- 45:54on folks' minds. Yeah, I would pick up on the
- 46:04point that Brandy was making about, if somebody
- 46:11has some sort of request, if they need help,
- 46:13not getting defensive, one of the things I have
- 46:16heard from a lot of folks over the last several
- 46:18years is I've spoken on this and people have
- 46:21reached out to talk about their experiences is
- 46:25a sort of running theme is that folks reached
- 46:30out internal to their firms. and didn't really
- 46:33get the receptivity that they had hoped for.
- 46:37And sometimes those asks are fairly small. And
- 46:40my sense is it's not that folks are trying to
- 46:45be difficult in responding. My sense of having
- 46:51worked professionally for a long time now is
- 46:54that folks in HR often just don't like to make
- 46:58exceptions. And there are lots of good reasons
- 47:00for that, because when you make one exception,
- 47:03it creates the concern, well, now we've done
- 47:05this, and now other people are going to ask for
- 47:07something else, and they're going to ask for
- 47:08something else. And so I understand the logic
- 47:10behind it. But the reality is that you have folks
- 47:15who need exceptions, folks with disabilities
- 47:17in particular. And so being more empathetic,
- 47:22and I think more understanding and more accommodating
- 47:23is really important. And also doing it in a way
- 47:26that doesn't require people to share deeply personal
- 47:30information that they may not want to have to
- 47:31share. Because one of the reasons folks often
- 47:34will not ask for accommodations is not just the
- 47:36negative stigma that they're worried about, but
- 47:38they're also worried they're going to get lots
- 47:39of questions on, well, why do you need this?
- 47:41And they may not want to explain in detail about
- 47:43why they need this. And they shouldn't have to
- 47:46explain in detail why they need this. And so
- 47:49I think part of it is making sure the folks who
- 47:52are making these decisions, whether it's in HR
- 47:55or more broadly supervisors, have the requisite
- 47:58training so that they're sensitive to it. They
- 48:00understand when requests come in, how to handle
- 48:02it, how to be supportive, how to ask questions
- 48:05in the right ways, and not to take things too
- 48:07far. I think that's critically important. Another
- 48:09thing I would say as decision makers, and it
- 48:11gets back to the point I was making earlier,
- 48:13again, I think we as a profession, and I don't
- 48:15think it's unique to our profession, I think
- 48:16it's probably true of just about every industry
- 48:18that exists today. We do not have a lot of leaders
- 48:21with disabilities. We certainly don't have a
- 48:24lot of leaders with physical disabilities or
- 48:26visible disabilities. And I think that's a real
- 48:30problem. I mean, we have accepted for a long
- 48:34time, because the studies show that it's true,
- 48:38that when you have a group of folks who are making
- 48:40decisions affecting the lives of others, particularly
- 48:41within a business environment, you want that
- 48:44group to have a level of diversity that reflects
- 48:48the people that they are responsible for so that
- 48:50they really understand the lives and the journey
- 48:53and the challenges of the people that they're
- 48:56responsible for. Generally, we probably would
- 49:03not accept that if you were to point a board
- 49:06of a dozen people and everybody on it was the
- 49:10exact same gender, race, and sexuality, I think
- 49:14we'd probably look at that and think, Hm, that
- 49:16seems kind of odd. Are they really going to have
- 49:18a deep understanding with lots of people who
- 49:19are not reflected there? But the reality is,
- 49:22if you look at leadership positions across the
- 49:24legal profession, particularly large law firms,
- 49:27mid -size firms and others, there are not a lot
- 49:30of us with disabilities. And I think that really
- 49:31has an impact on decisions get made in terms
- 49:35of how we think about hiring and promotion and
- 49:39down to the level of training. And if you don't
- 49:41have the right people that are thinking about
- 49:42these issues and they're not doing maybe as much
- 49:44as they need to do on training people internally,
- 49:46which then has a negative repercussion. And then
- 49:49it becomes this cycle that becomes impossible
- 49:51to break until you get people in a position of
- 49:54influence and authority that they can break that
- 49:57cycle. And I think we've still got a ways to
- 49:59go to do that, unfortunately. And so that's one
- 50:02of the things that I try to emphasize is look
- 50:04around the room and who's making decisions and
- 50:07make sure that those people are a group that
- 50:11really deeply across the group understands what
- 50:17life is like for the people that they're responsible
- 50:19for. Yeah, I totally agree with what you're saying,
- 50:24David. And I think to sort of go off of that
- 50:28too, to center disabled people and plan for access
- 50:33for disabled people from the beginning of whatever
- 50:36project. like including disabled people for access
- 50:42rather than like seeing it as extra is important.
- 50:46Access is part of basically the cost of doing
- 50:50business. And when you truly realize that disabled
- 50:54people are as valuable as non -disabled people,
- 50:57and you realize that building stairs instead
- 51:00of a ramp or building a classroom that has fixed
- 51:04seating is a problem with the design, not a problem
- 51:08with the disabled person or them needing something
- 51:11extra. And I totally agree with David, you should
- 51:15never put a disabled person on the spot or put
- 51:22them in the position where they feel pressured
- 51:23to disclose their disability, to be included,
- 51:27but do value the disclosure if they choose to
- 51:31share. And I think a very basic thing, David
- 51:34was talking about that meeting earlier and he
- 51:36was around the table, a very basic thing is always
- 51:40avoid um ableist language and I think to remember
- 51:45that you know accessibility um is an antidote
- 51:49to ableism and it's an important part of equality.
- 51:55Yeah that's a good point. Yeah and I think I've
- 51:59been in the profession um not that long but long
- 52:02enough where I've seen the cycle where There
- 52:05was a big focus on mental health and well -being,
- 52:09especially in the late 2010s, where there was
- 52:12a huge focus on addiction among legal professionals,
- 52:17which is under the disability umbrella. And we've
- 52:20moved now more recently to a lot of firms really
- 52:23focusing on neurodiversity, whatever that means
- 52:27in a particular company and their initiative.
- 52:30those two things have been on the bookends of
- 52:32the past decade or whatever in the legal profession.
- 52:35But the legal profession hasn't connected that
- 52:37those things are disability inclusion. And I
- 52:39think David, you brought up a great point about.
- 52:41you know, physical disability, where they're
- 52:44doing all this work around disability, whether
- 52:46or not they know it, but there's never that explicit
- 52:49intention to make sure that we are being inclusive.
- 52:52And Brandy, you talk about this accessible to
- 52:54people with physical disabilities, disabilities
- 52:56complex. We already talked about that, but I
- 52:58think it's so interesting how To use your point,
- 53:03David, the people in the room are focusing on
- 53:04the struggles they're going through with, you
- 53:07know, being neurodivergent or having neurodivergent
- 53:09children or going through the stress and addiction
- 53:12that comes with that. And that's what they focus
- 53:14on rather than being completely inclusive across
- 53:17all disabilities. We have at least seven minutes
- 53:20left because we have to go to the hour. I was
- 53:22instructed that I have one more question for
- 53:25David and Brandy, which we can get short answers.
- 53:27And then I will go to the Q &A because we do
- 53:29have a few questions. So David and Brandy, what
- 53:32is one thing you would like folks to take away
- 53:35from today's session? I know we've talked a lot
- 53:36about a lot of different things, but the one
- 53:38thing you would like people to take away? Brandy,
- 53:41why don't you go first? Sure. I think that not
- 53:46including disabled people in these management
- 53:52positions and leadership, as David was talking
- 53:55about, is a real, real disservice. And then also
- 54:00not hiring disabled people in general, because
- 54:03you're losing a whole different perspective of
- 54:05brilliant ideas and ways of looking at the world.
- 54:11I think AJ had mentioned, it's a problem if you
- 54:15look around the room, or maybe David mentioned,
- 54:17and everybody looks the same. You need diversity
- 54:22to be successful and to have different ideas
- 54:26and different thoughts. Um, yeah, so I would,
- 54:31I would encourage folks to want to have a, you
- 54:35know, a diverse team in all aspects, not just
- 54:38disabled people, but in, you know, all characteristics.
- 54:45Yeah, I think I would say the most important
- 54:48takeaway to me is that maybe sort of two sides
- 54:52of the same coin. I think folks have to recognize
- 54:56one that no matter how good we are as people
- 55:00and how conscious we are of trying to be supportive
- 55:03and trying to build a supportive environment,
- 55:07we necessarily fall short all the time. Where
- 55:10I think we mostly fall short, in my experience
- 55:13at least, is folks with disabilities, whether
- 55:16it's physical, visible or not visible, neurodivergence.
- 55:21I think we're just so far from where we need
- 55:24to be. for folks to be able to be successful.
- 55:27And so I would say just being very, very conscious
- 55:29of the little things that you can do that make
- 55:32a much more supportive environment for folks.
- 55:39And then sort of the flip side of that coin,
- 55:41I would say, is recognizing that there is some
- 55:43non -trivial number of people around you who
- 55:46probably work with you every day, whether as
- 55:48lawyers, paralegals, professional staff who are
- 55:52suffering silently at work. because they don't
- 55:55want to be vocal about what they're dealing with
- 55:58and what they're struggling with because they're
- 55:59worried it'll affect their jobs, whether they
- 56:01keep their job, what opportunities they get,
- 56:04what work they get, what advancement they have,
- 56:07or just how people view them, right? There's
- 56:09a concern that if you say, I'm struggling with
- 56:12X because I have some sort of disability again,
- 56:15whether it's physical or otherwise, There's just
- 56:17a worry that someone who you think really respects
- 56:20you, a mentor, someone who's a champion for your
- 56:22career, that may just suddenly affect how they
- 56:24view you and their support, Wayne's, even if
- 56:27it's on an unconscious level. And so that to
- 56:30me is, I think, the most important takeaway from
- 56:32these discussions is just recognize there are
- 56:36people who are just quietly going about through
- 56:38their day. And they're navigating in ways that
- 56:41they shouldn't have to that take so much extra
- 56:43energy, so much extra time, makes their lives
- 56:46so much harder. And they're not sharing that
- 56:48with anyone. And just a small little fix from
- 56:51some supportive person or an environment that
- 56:54tells them it's OK to speak up and ask for help
- 56:57and be who you are fundamentally changes things
- 57:00for everyone. Thank you both so much. That leads
- 57:07into a question, which I'm going to redirect.
- 57:12But one of the questions was, can a law firm
- 57:14get sued by not forcing a disagreeing client
- 57:17to not discriminate? But differently, was the
- 57:20firm required to not follow the client misdirection?
- 57:24Brandy, I think that was directed towards you
- 57:27and your story. But I just wanted to use an opportunity
- 57:31because I wanted to say this and forgot. But
- 57:34oftentimes, HR, I think both of you kind of talked
- 57:37about this, views the ADA as adversarial when
- 57:41if you talk to a lot of disabled workers, if
- 57:44they can get the accommodation without having
- 57:46to go through that formal process and have to
- 57:49get those formal legal protections, which a lot
- 57:51of people need because of discrimination, it's
- 57:53a lot easier on both ends. You both kind of talked
- 57:56about there are really small things you can do
- 57:57to make someone a better, more effective employee
- 58:01without necessarily have to go through the formal
- 58:03legal process. And I think the legal process
- 58:07of getting accommodations is what scares HR rather
- 58:11than understanding that you can just make accommodations
- 58:15to people's work environment to make it more
- 58:17accessible. But Brandy, I don't know if you wanted
- 58:21to answer that question. It seems like that is
- 58:26for you. Yeah, I mean, a client can hire whatever
- 58:31attorney they want to hire. So I believe if you
- 58:37can do the job and a firm doesn't hire you because
- 58:39of your disability, then that's a problem, clearly,
- 58:44legally for the firm. But a client, you know,
- 58:49I can't go sue the client because they don't
- 58:51want me to be the attorney representing them.
- 58:53um they have like no fiduciary duty to me of
- 58:57any kind or any duty like you know if anything
- 59:00an attorney has a duty to their clients so there's
- 59:02not going to be like a course of action that
- 59:05you can take on a client not wanting you to represent
- 59:09them they can you know fire and hire whatever
- 59:11attorney they want to thank you and then We have
- 59:17another question. As a mobility disabled senior
- 59:21paralegal participating in an AM law firm, I'm
- 59:24so glad to hear these conversations among the
- 59:26attorneys and for the openness. Any thoughts
- 59:29on work social opportunities eg walking to a
- 59:33lunch place. where a person cannot walk? I think
- 59:36this is actually a great question. I do a lot
- 59:38of work around this. These are kind of like the
- 59:41soft career ladder steps where you are excluded
- 59:44from the golf outing or the happy hour because
- 59:48of stairs and you miss that opportunity to socialize
- 59:51and make bonds to further your career potentially
- 59:54if that's something you want. So, David, I'll
- 59:57let you go first and then Brandy, you can wrap
- 59:59us up on that question. But any thoughts on that?
- 1:00:03Again, it gets back to the point I was making
- 1:00:04earlier. I think we all just have to be really
- 1:00:06thoughtful about those things. I think one challenge
- 1:00:11that we have to confront and confess as folks
- 1:00:15with disabilities is there is attention because
- 1:00:18on the one hand, we say we don't always want
- 1:00:20to talk about our disabilities and we don't want
- 1:00:22to have to share a lot about them, but at the
- 1:00:24same time, we want you to accommodate them. That's
- 1:00:26why I think it's so important to have an environment
- 1:00:29that is just unequivocally supportive so that
- 1:00:35folks know that they can share what they want
- 1:00:37to share. They don't have to share more. And
- 1:00:39so if I have a mobility disability and someone
- 1:00:44invites me to someplace that's really going to
- 1:00:46be difficult for me to walk to, I want to know
- 1:00:48that I'm in an environment where I can share
- 1:00:50that. And I don't have to share anything more.
- 1:00:52I can just say, look, that's going to be difficult
- 1:00:54for me to get to. And that's the end of it. That's
- 1:00:56the conversation. And so the two people work
- 1:00:58together to find someplace that's closer. And
- 1:01:01so on both sides of that, I think we've got to
- 1:01:04be conscious of how we deal with those issues.
- 1:01:07But it all starts with what's the environment
- 1:01:10in that office? What's the environment in the
- 1:01:11business place? Do people feel comfortable having
- 1:01:14that dialogue? Because without that dialogue,
- 1:01:16then things get challenging and uncomfortable
- 1:01:18for everyone. And that's where we have to start.
- 1:01:22Yeah. And based on that, David, I think that,
- 1:01:25you know, Creating an environment in disability
- 1:01:29community. Sometimes we talk about this of centering
- 1:01:31the needs of the most marginalized person in
- 1:01:35that environment. And so, you know, thinking
- 1:01:38about that in like, you know, who's the like.
- 1:01:42the most disabled person, the fattest person,
- 1:01:46you know, whatever, like if you can just start
- 1:01:50off by censoring the needs of the most disabled
- 1:01:54person and basing things on that, like, okay,
- 1:01:57well, then this activity will work for everybody,
- 1:02:00including the person that's the most marginalized
- 1:02:03is like a really important concept in like disability
- 1:02:08justice movements. And I think it's important
- 1:02:13for workplaces too. I mean, myself, you know,
- 1:02:16one of the jobs I've had, you know, they had
- 1:02:18like... What was it? It was, I believe like a
- 1:02:22marathon or something that they were running.
- 1:02:24And obviously I couldn't do that. I cannot run
- 1:02:27a marathon without like tripping on something
- 1:02:28or not seeing something. And so yeah, it was
- 1:02:31difficult. Like I wanted to go. I wanted to be
- 1:02:34a part of the, you know, team. And as you mentioned,
- 1:02:37AJ, which also helps to interact with people
- 1:02:40and to get, you know, those promotions and to
- 1:02:43show that you're a member of the team. but I
- 1:02:46wasn't able to do that. Or I've actually had
- 1:02:49clients in my pro bono practice that haven't
- 1:02:53been able to, they wanna be on the team, the
- 1:02:57work soccer team, and there's team shirts, but
- 1:03:00maybe the team shirts only go up to a 2X and
- 1:03:03they need a 4X. And so they can show up, but
- 1:03:06now they're not wearing the team shirt. So they're
- 1:03:08not showing team spirit. And that also gets in
- 1:03:11the way of their advancement. So I think like,
- 1:03:15you know, being as accessible to all people is
- 1:03:20definitely the key. Thank you so much. We have
- 1:03:26made it past an hour, so I've officially accomplished
- 1:03:29my job. I don't know if there are any other questions
- 1:03:33from the audience or if Brandy, you or David
- 1:03:38have any last things you want to share. I don't
- 1:03:43think I have any last things to share. Do you,
- 1:03:46David? I just would say thank you, certainly
- 1:03:49to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for organizing
- 1:03:52this, putting it on. It was their idea. They
- 1:03:54reached out, and it's fantastic that they're
- 1:03:56being proactive on this particular topic. And
- 1:03:59thanks, Brandy, and thanks, AJ, for jumping in
- 1:04:01to facilitate what I think is a good discussion.
- 1:04:03So thank you. Yeah, I agree. Thank you, AJ. Thank
- 1:04:06you, David. Thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:04:09Association as well. I agree and I think these
- 1:04:12topics and the more people that can have these
- 1:04:15topics and learn, the better. So thank you. I
- 1:04:20want to thank both of you so much. I also want
- 1:04:22to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 1:04:24hosting. If folks are looking for resources or
- 1:04:26community, there exists the National Disabled
- 1:04:30Lawson's Association and the National Disabled
- 1:04:33Legal Professionals Association. If folks are
- 1:04:36are looking for other legal professionals with
- 1:04:38disabilities or resources or community or things
- 1:04:40like that. Both of those organizations exist
- 1:04:43and are there for you to reach out to them if
- 1:04:45need be. And I think we are done. So thank everyone
- 1:04:49so much for being here and enjoy the rest of
- 1:04:51your Mondays and the rest of your weeks.