Latest / No Stress Web Success / Accessibility for Humans: WCAG 1.4.1 or Don't Let Color Do All the Talking | 11
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to No Stress Web Success. This is Accessibility for Humans.
- 0:05I'm your host, Lisa Bowers, founder of 5Penny Web Studio, and this is episode 11.
- 0:11If you're new here, this show is for the person who is responsible for the website
- 0:16and doesn't have a big team behind them.
- 0:18Maybe you're an executive director who also approves a newsletter.
- 0:22Maybe you're the entire marketing department. You didn't train as a web designer,
- 0:27and you shouldn't have to.
- 0:28You just want a site that works for the people you serve Last time in our two-part
- 0:33series on info and relationships I mentioned that meaning can hide in color,
- 0:38Over the next few weeks, we'll be exploring some of the critical rules that
- 0:42apply to color Today, we start with another common problem.
- 0:47The rule is WCAG 1.4.1 and it's called use of color The plain English version is this Color can help,
- 0:56but it can't be the only way you say something.
- 0:59So let's start with what the rule actually asks. The rule says that color shouldn't
- 1:04be the only visual way you do anything, whether it's share information,
- 1:09show that something can be clicked, ask someone to respond, or tell one thing apart from another.
- 1:15That's a mouthful. Here's the everyday version. If someone took the color away,
- 1:20would they still understand the page?
- 1:23Think about who that affects. A lot of people, roughly 1 in 12 men and about
- 1:291 in 200 women, have some form of colorblindness.
- 1:33That's a good number of your donors, your volunteers, and your board members.
- 1:37Now, add people with low vision, people looking at a phone screen in bright
- 1:43sunlight, people with an old monitor, and people who print your page in black and white.
- 1:49Now, let's add people who use a screen reader, because screen readers don't announce color at all.
- 1:55So when your page says the red items are urgent or the green dates are open, a lot of people miss it.
- 2:03Not because they didn't read carefully, because the information was never in a form they could get.
- 2:09Now, I want to be clear about this rule and what it does not say.
- 2:14It does not say you can't use color. Color is wonderful. It's a part of your
- 2:19brand. It helps a lot of people.
- 2:21The rule just says that color can't be doing the job alone.
- 2:25Give it a partner. A word, an underline, an icon, a pattern, a label.
- 2:31Color plus something. That's the whole idea.
- 2:34So let's walk through the places I see this go wrong. The first place is the
- 2:39links inside your text Picture a paragraph on your about us page,
- 2:44A few words in the middle are blue and those are links Everything else is dark
- 2:49gray or black If the only thing that tells you this is a link is the color blue,
- 2:55A person who can't tell blue from gray can't find your links,
- 2:59They read right past the donate here and the download the application,
- 3:05The simplest fix is the oldest one Underline your links It's a clear signal
- 3:10that works for nearly everyone And it needs no explanation,
- 3:13Now, I know some designers feel underlines look dated And there are other ways
- 3:18to do it For example, making things,
- 3:21bold Or having a clear visual change that isn't only color But if you're not
- 3:26sure, underline it It's the safest choice,
- 3:29A useful exception Menus and buttons are a little different because it's clear
- 3:34from the layout that those things are things you click.
- 3:39What this mostly matters for links is that they sit in the middle of a sentence
- 3:43or a paragraph, where color is the only clue.
- 3:46And here's a place you can check yourself right now. Open up your homepage.
- 3:51Find a link in the middle of a paragraph. Does it have anything besides color
- 3:55to tell you that it's a link?
- 3:58So the next place is your forms, your donation form, your volunteer sign up,
- 4:03your event registration.
- 4:05These are the pages where someone is trying to give or join.
- 4:09So a color problem here costs you real people.
- 4:12The classic example is the red error. Someone fills out your form and leaves out their email.
- 4:19Your form box turns red. A person who can't see red knows something's wrong.
- 4:26A person who is colorblind or using a screen reader or looking at a washed out
- 4:30screen may see nothing at all.
- 4:32The form just won't submit, and they don't know why.
- 4:36The fix is easy. Say it in words. Right next to the field, write something like,
- 4:42please enter your email address.
- 4:44The red can still be there. It helps the people who can see it.
- 4:48But the words are what make sure everybody gets the message.
- 4:52It's even better if you add a small icon, like a warning symbol next to words.
- 4:57Words plus a symbol plus color. Now you've got three ways to get the message across.
- 5:02Same goes for required fields. A lot of forms put a red asterisk next to a field and say nothing else.
- 5:10If it's the only clue that a field is required, that's color doing the job alone.
- 5:16Add the words required to the label, or put a note at the top of the form that
- 5:20says fields marked with a star are required and keep the star too,
- 5:26and one more success messages after someone donates do you show a green box,
- 5:32great make sure it also says in words thank you your gift was received the green
- 5:38is a nice touch the words carry the meaning,
- 5:41so try this on your own donation form leave a field empty on purpose and submit it.
- 5:47Look at the error. If you removed all the color, would you still know what went wrong and where?
- 5:54Now, the places where non-profits use color the most. Charts,
- 5:58calendars, and status labels.
- 6:01Start with charts and graphs. Maybe your annual report has a pie chart showing where your money goes.
- 6:08Four slices, four colors, and a color key off to the side.
- 6:12If two of those colors look the same to someone, they can't tell which slice is which.
- 6:18The fix is to label the slices directly, with the name and the number written on or next to each one.
- 6:26Skip the key if you can. If you do need a key, you can add patterns like stripes
- 6:32and dots so the slices differ by more than just color.
- 6:36Line charts can use different line styles such as solid and dash or use direct
- 6:41labels at the end of each line.
- 6:44Next, calendars. A lot of event calendars color code programs.
- 6:50Blue for youth programs Orange for adult classes Green for fundraisers It looks
- 6:56nice But if the only thing that says
- 6:58youth program is the blue Then that information is lost for many people,
- 7:04The fix is easy Put a word in the event title or label like Youth Homework help,
- 7:10The colors become a bonus,
- 7:12Then status labels Think of spots available in green And full in red Or a fundraising
- 7:20thermometer, where the color shows how close you are to your goal,
- 7:24If the color is the whole message, it's gone for some people Write it out Spots
- 7:29available, full 72% of our goal Numbers and words do the heavy lifting The color
- 7:36is decoration See the pattern?
- 7:39Every fix is the same Add a word, a label, a symbol, or a pattern You're not
- 7:45removing anything You're adding a second way to say it.
- 7:49Here's a small one that sneaks in through your own writing. Have you ever written
- 7:54something like, click the green button to register?
- 7:57Or, see the red text below for the deadline?
- 8:01Almost all of us have. It's natural. But it relies on color,
- 8:05and a person who can't see the color has no idea which button you mean.
- 8:10The fix is to name the thing by its words or what it does.
- 8:15Click the register button now. See the note below that begins with deadline,
- 8:20Same instruction, no color needed,
- 8:23This is one you can fix just by being thoughtful when you write It's also a
- 8:27great habit to share with your staff and volunteers Who write for your site and your emails.
- 8:33So, one quick note, because this one confuses almost everyone.
- 8:37People often mix up two different rules.
- 8:40There's this one, use of color, which asks, is color the only way you're sharing something?
- 8:47And then there's a separate rule about color contrast, which asks,
- 8:51is your text easy enough to read against its background?
- 8:55Light gray text on a white background is a contrast problem.
- 8:59A red error message that has no words is a use of color problem Both matter,
- 9:05They're cousins, not twins You can pass one and fail the other We'll cover contrast
- 9:11in another episode soon So if you hear contrast and wonder, just know it's a different check,
- 9:18So let's make this practical Here's a test that takes about 5 minutes and requires
- 9:23no technical skill Step 1, go gray Most phones have a grayscale or black and
- 9:30white display setting in the accessibility settings.
- 9:33Turn it on and open your website.
- 9:35Or in your computer's print preview, choose black and white.
- 9:39Now look at your key pages. Home, donate, volunteer, events.
- 9:46Can you still tell what's a link? Can you still find the errors?
- 9:50Can you still tell your chart slices apart?
- 9:54Wherever you get stuck, that's a place where color is doing the work alone.
- 9:58Step two, use a free tool. I've put two Chrome extensions in the show notes,
- 10:04Wave and the Silk Tide Accessibility Checker. Both are free.
- 10:09They can point out accessibility issues on a page, and Silk Tide can also show
- 10:14you how a page looks to people with different kinds of vision.
- 10:17They're a good way to see your site through someone else's eyes.
- 10:21Step three, ask the question. Whenever someone on your team makes a design choice,
- 10:27ask, if someone couldn't see the color, would they still know what this means?
- 10:32That one question will catch most of these problems before they ever go live.
- 10:36And you don't have to fix everything at once. Start with the pages where people
- 10:41give, join, and ask for help.
- 10:44And as always, definitely your homepage.
- 10:48So let's land this thing. Color is a gift. Use it. Make your site beautiful and true to your brand.
- 10:56Just don't let color carry the whole message.
- 10:58Pair it with words, underlines, icons, or patterns so that everyone gets the
- 11:05same information whether they can see the color or not.
- 11:09Links, errors, required fields, charts, calendars, status labels,
- 11:16and even the way we write our instructions.
- 11:19Color plus something, that's the rule. Before you go, I'd love to hear from you.
- 11:25If you have questions or feedback or a page on your own site that you're wrestling
- 11:28with, head over to 5pennyweb.com and send me a note.
- 11:33And if this episode helped, please take a minute to leave feedback on the podcast,
- 11:37a rating or review wherever you listen.
- 11:40It helps other nonprofit and small team leaders find the show.
- 11:44Once again, this has been Accessibility for Humans, part of the No Stress Web
- 11:48Success. I'm Lisa, and I will see you next time.