Latest / Why Humans Lie / The Warm Laminate: How a Photograph Unmasked a Charming Con Artist

Transcript

The Warm Laminate: How a Photograph Unmasked a Charming Con Artist · Why Humans Lie

0:03
Speaker 1: January ninth, two thousand, nineteen seven, forty three in the morning,
0:09
Speaker 1: eleven degrees fahrenheit, and a utility lineman named Judith Sullivan
0:14
Speaker 1: crouches in frozen mud behind Unit seven of a Delwood
0:17
Speaker 1: apartment complex. She is there for a transformer outage. What
0:22
Speaker 1: she finds instead is a laminated wedding photograph, face up
0:25
Speaker 1: in the dirt, propped against a rear gate. She photographs
0:29
Speaker 1: it before she touches it. Then she touches it. The
0:33
Speaker 1: laminate is worn outside temperature eleven degrees. That warmth will
0:39
Speaker 1: become the first thread investigator's pull and what unravels when
0:43
Speaker 1: they pull It is not just one man's disappearance from
0:47
Speaker 1: one woman's life. It is a system. Fourteen months of
0:51
Speaker 1: engineered trust. Gail Clark was forty six years old and
0:55
Speaker 1: had been a billing coordinator in Delwood, Indiana for eleven years.
1:00
Speaker 1: He was methodical by nature. She kept her files color coated.
1:04
Speaker 1: She remembered insurance renewal dates without reminders. She had a
1:08
Speaker 1: nineteen year old daughter named Amber, a gray tabby cat
1:13
Speaker 1: named Pepper, and a Thursday morning ritual that had not
1:16
Speaker 1: changed in three years. The corner table at ELM Street
1:20
Speaker 1: Cafe seven fifteen, a m coffee before the rest of
1:24
Speaker 1: Dellwood woke up. She had been divorced since two thousand fourteen.
1:28
Speaker 1: The marriage to Dennis Clark had ended without drama, according
1:32
Speaker 1: to people who knew her, but it had left a
1:34
Speaker 1: specific kind of quietness in her. Not bitterness, something more
1:39
Speaker 1: like the careful stillness of someone who had learned to
1:42
Speaker 1: protect what remained. That detail matters because the man who
1:46
Speaker 1: would enter her life in October of two thousand seventeen
1:50
Speaker 1: did not arrive at random. According to therapist Diane Merritt,
1:54
Speaker 1: who worked with Gail after the case, he identified her
1:58
Speaker 1: specific wound first, then he built his entire persona around
2:03
Speaker 1: healing it. His name in Dellwood was David Holmes. He
2:07
Speaker 1: was forty nine. He described himself as working in real
2:10
Speaker 1: estate development, something semi independent, flexible hours, the kind of
2:16
Speaker 1: vague professional identity that sounds plausible and cannot easily be checked.
2:22
Speaker 1: He had rented an apartment near by in August, just
2:25
Speaker 1: weeks before the two of them met. The meeting, by
2:28
Speaker 1: every account, felt unremarkable. He appeared at Elm Street Cafe
2:33
Speaker 1: on a Thursday in October, then another Thursday, then he
2:37
Speaker 1: started arriving before Gale and having her coffee waiting. Patricia Ewen,
2:43
Speaker 1: who owned the cafe, watched it happen the way you
2:46
Speaker 1: watch weather move in gradually, then all at once. Gayale
2:52
Speaker 1: described him later as the first person in years who
2:55
Speaker 1: seemed genuinely curious about her. Not the performing kind of cures,
3:00
Speaker 1: the kind that remembered small things, the kind that asked
3:04
Speaker 1: follow up questions a week after a throwaway remark. By
3:08
Speaker 1: January of twenty nineteen, they were inseparable. Amber met him
3:13
Speaker 1: in March. She later said she thought he was fine,
3:16
Speaker 1: not remarkable. Nothing that triggered alarm. That absence of alarm
3:21
Speaker 1: is itself part of the record. Holmes did not move
3:24
Speaker 1: fast in ways that showed he moved fast only in
3:28
Speaker 1: the architecture of the relationship, the emotional scaffolding going up
3:32
Speaker 1: quickly while the surface remained warm and unhurried. Merritt would
3:37
Speaker 1: later describe it as learned helplessness engineered over fourteen months.
3:42
Speaker 1: The phrase sounds clinical. What it means in practice is this.
3:46
Speaker 1: By the time Gale had any reason to question him,
3:49
Speaker 1: questioning him felt like questioning herself. The engagement happened in
3:53
Speaker 1: August of twenty eighteen, back at Elm Street Cafe, White Carnations.
3:59
Speaker 1: On the tape, Patricia Ewen sighed the proposal was public,
4:04
Speaker 1: which meant it was witnessed, which meant it was real
4:07
Speaker 1: in the way that social events become real, documented by
4:10
Speaker 1: other people's memory. Two months later, in October, they opened
4:15
Speaker 1: a joint account. What Gail did not know then, and
4:18
Speaker 1: what investigators would confirm months later, was that a man
4:23
Speaker 1: matching Holmes's description had run nearly the same sequence twice before,
4:28
Speaker 1: once in Bloomington, Indiana, between two thousand nine in two
4:32
Speaker 1: thousand twelve under the name David Holt, once in Fort
4:37
Speaker 1: Wayne in two thousand fourteen under the name David Harrel.
4:41
Speaker 1: Melissa Grant and Fort Wayne had reported Harrell after losing
4:44
Speaker 1: eleven thousand dollars. That report produced no conviction. Patricia Ewen
4:49
Speaker 1: in Evansville had said nothing at the time. By December
4:52
Speaker 1: of two thousand eighteen, David Holmes was three weeks from vanishing,
4:57
Speaker 1: and Gale Clark, the woman who or coded her files
5:01
Speaker 1: and never missed an insurance date, had no idea that
5:04
Speaker 1: the man she had married on December twenty eighth was
5:07
Speaker 1: already somewhere else in his mind, waiting to leave. The
5:11
Speaker 1: joint account was open, the wedding was legal, and sometime
5:16
Speaker 1: in early December of twenty eighteen, a voice on the
5:19
Speaker 1: phone told Gail Clark it was time to consolidate. The
5:23
Speaker 1: voice belonged to a man who introduced himself as Greg,
5:27
Speaker 1: an adviser, someone Holmes had apparently arranged to walk Gail
5:32
Speaker 1: through the next step in their financial planning. Greg was calm, knowledgeable, reassuring.
5:38
Speaker 1: He explained that combining assets before the new year made
5:41
Speaker 1: practical sense. He mentioned tax efficiency, He used the word streamline,
5:47
Speaker 1: and Gail, who had spent years keeping meticulous records as
5:51
Speaker 1: a billing coordinator who color coded her files and tracked
5:55
Speaker 1: every insurance date, listened carefully and decided that Greg made scent.
6:00
Speaker 1: On approximately December seventh of two thousand eighteen, she transferred
6:05
Speaker 1: forty seven thousand dollars into the joint account. Investigators later
6:09
Speaker 1: noted that Greg was never identified as a real person,
6:13
Speaker 1: whether he was Holmes using a different voice, a confederate,
6:16
Speaker 1: or some other arrangement entirely, that question was never resolved.
6:21
Speaker 1: What the record does confirm is this, Gayle believed she
6:25
Speaker 1: was making a responsible decision that belief was the point.
6:30
Speaker 1: Three weeks later, on December twenty eighth, Gayle and Homes
6:33
Speaker 1: were married at Dellwood County court House. A clerk's assistant
6:37
Speaker 1: named Tom Varga took the photograph. It was an eight
6:41
Speaker 1: by ten print. The next day, December twenty ninth, Holmes
6:46
Speaker 1: took it to a pharmacy Kiosk and had it laminated.
6:50
Speaker 1: He paid cash. That detail sat unnoticed for weeks. Cash
6:54
Speaker 1: at a pharmacy Kiosk for a wedding photograph, A small,
6:58
Speaker 1: unremarkable transaction that meant nothing at the time and everything later.
7:03
Speaker 1: January second of two thousand nineteen, Gale logged into the
7:08
Speaker 1: joint account. The balance was four hundred twelve. She stood
7:11
Speaker 1: at the kitchen counter and read the number again. She
7:14
Speaker 1: called Holmes. He answered. He told her there had been
7:18
Speaker 1: a processing delay, that these things happened with large transfers,
7:22
Speaker 1: that she should not worry. His voice was even. She
7:25
Speaker 1: believed him. That was the last time she heard his
7:28
Speaker 1: voice with any confidence that it meant something true. January third,
7:33
Speaker 1: a notice arrived in the mail her insurance beneficiary had
7:37
Speaker 1: been changed. The new name was d. Holmes. The correspondent's
7:42
Speaker 1: address was a p O box in Carmel, Indiana, opened
7:45
Speaker 1: in November of two thousand eighteen under a variant of
7:49
Speaker 1: Holmes's name. The change had been filed during the thirty
7:52
Speaker 1: day processing window, meaning the pension designation money had not
7:56
Speaker 1: yet moved. Holmes had miscalculated by a matter a days,
8:01
Speaker 1: or the paperwork had moved slower than he expected. That
8:04
Speaker 1: margin is the only reason Gayle did not lose everything.
8:08
Speaker 1: She did not open the insurance notice when it arrived
8:11
Speaker 1: on January third. She opened it two days later, on
8:15
Speaker 1: January fifth. The record notes them without drama, but they matter,
8:19
Speaker 1: two days in which the answer was sitting on her
8:22
Speaker 1: kitchen table, sealed while she made coffee and fed her
8:25
Speaker 1: cat pepper and went to work. When she opened the
8:28
Speaker 1: envelope on January fifth, she read it twice. Then she
8:32
Speaker 1: set it down. Holmes reassured her again, there was an explanation.
8:36
Speaker 1: There was always an explanation. By the evening of January seventh,
8:40
Speaker 1: his truck was gone. Gale opened the junk drawer, the
8:44
Speaker 1: one where important documents lived, the ones you keep because
8:49
Speaker 1: losing them would be catastrophic. Her passport, her Social Security card,
8:55
Speaker 1: the land deed to property in Putnam County, all of
8:58
Speaker 1: it gone. She called Holmes eleven times. He did not
9:03
Speaker 1: answer once. At some point in those hours, she sat
9:06
Speaker 1: down on the kitchen floor. Pepper came and sat beside her.
9:10
Speaker 1: She stayed there for approximately three hours, according to her
9:14
Speaker 1: later account, running through every explanation she could construct that
9:18
Speaker 1: did not mean what she already knew it meant. Her daughter,
9:22
Speaker 1: Amber was the one who finally said the word police.
9:26
Speaker 1: Amber said it at eleven p m. At eleven twenty three,
9:30
Speaker 1: Gale made the call. The photograph is where the working
9:34
Speaker 1: theories begin and where the cleaner ones fall apart. Picture
9:38
Speaker 1: the rear service corridor of the apartment complex. On the
9:41
Speaker 1: night of January eighth, Holmes moves through it carrying bags.
9:45
Speaker 1: The laminated wedding photograph is inside his coat. That is
9:49
Speaker 1: the working theory built from one physical fact. When Judith
9:53
Speaker 1: Sullivan found it the next morning at seven forty three,
9:56
Speaker 1: the laminate was warm outside. Temperature was eleven degrees fahrenheit.
10:01
Speaker 1: There was no frost on the surface, no ice at
10:04
Speaker 1: the edges. Whatever had kept that photograph warm through a
10:07
Speaker 1: subzero night, it was not the frozen mud. The underground
10:12
Speaker 1: utility conduit beneath that section of alley radiates heat that
10:17
Speaker 1: accounts for some of it. But the investigator's working theory
10:20
Speaker 1: holds that the photograph spent most of the night insulated
10:23
Speaker 1: against a human body and dropped when Holmes set a
10:26
Speaker 1: bag down at the rear gate. Holmes never confirmed this.
10:30
Speaker 1: He did not explain the photograph during either interrogation. The
10:34
Speaker 1: drop is classified as accidental in the case record, but
10:38
Speaker 1: it is labeled a working theory, not a confirmed fact.
10:41
Speaker 1: And here is where the scenario tests itself against what
10:46
Speaker 1: Holmes actually was. He was not careless. The entire fourteen
10:50
Speaker 1: month operation had been executed with patience and precision. The
10:55
Speaker 1: slow escalation, the planted urgency around the financial consolidation, the
11:00
Speaker 1: insurance beneficiary filed to a po box he had prepared
11:04
Speaker 1: two months in advance. A man that careful does not
11:08
Speaker 1: accidentally carry a wedding photograph in his coat unless it
11:11
Speaker 1: served some purpose. He had not yet finished with the
11:14
Speaker 1: second copy of the photograph found in the motel room
11:17
Speaker 1: bag in Greencastle makes the accidental drop theory more complicated.
11:22
Speaker 1: Not less he had a duplicate, he kept one, he
11:25
Speaker 1: lost one, or left one. The record does not say
11:29
Speaker 1: which What the record does say is this Karl Christensen,
11:33
Speaker 1: fraud investigator with the Indiana Attorney General's Consumer Unit, ran
11:38
Speaker 1: the three identity profiles David Holt, David Harrell, David Harrell
11:43
Speaker 1: David Holmes against each other. A forensic document examiner confirmed
11:48
Speaker 1: all three were the same man. That work took one afternoon.
11:52
Speaker 1: The prior reports had existed for years. Melissa Grants twenty
11:57
Speaker 1: fourteen filing in Fort Wayne, Patricia Youwan silence in Eavansville
12:01
Speaker 1: in twenty ten silence. She broke only in February of
12:05
Speaker 1: twenty nineteen, when Christensen reached her. The pattern was not hidden,
12:10
Speaker 1: It was simply never assembled in one place until Gale
12:14
Speaker 1: Clark's name appeared at the end of it. Holmes was
12:17
Speaker 1: arrested on January fourteenth at a motel in Greencastle, Indiana,
12:22
Speaker 1: fifty three miles southwest of Dellwood. The stolen documents were
12:26
Speaker 1: in a bag in the room, so was the second photograph.
12:29
Speaker 1: He was cooperative, according to the arrest report, pragmatic, he
12:34
Speaker 1: did not perform distress. He confessed on January twenty second
12:38
Speaker 1: during the second interrogation. The guilty plea came in March
12:42
Speaker 1: of two thousand, nineteen wire fraud, identity theft, financial exploitation
12:49
Speaker 1: of an elder adult, two counts seven years. Holmes stood
12:53
Speaker 1: before the bench the same way he had stood everywhere else.
12:57
Speaker 1: Cooperative measured, giving the court exactly what it needed to
13:00
Speaker 1: move forward. A forensic document examiner had already confirmed in
13:04
Speaker 1: one afternoon what three separate jurisdictions had failed to connect
13:08
Speaker 1: across a decade. David Holt, David Harrell, David Harrel and
13:13
Speaker 1: David Holmes were the same man, the same posture, the
13:17
Speaker 1: same patience, the same white carnations. Most likely, though no
13:22
Speaker 1: one thought to ask. Gale recovered approximately forty three thousand
13:27
Speaker 1: of the forty seven thousand dollars. Thirty one thousand came
13:31
Speaker 1: from the joint account's accessible balance, which investigators reached before
13:36
Speaker 1: Homes could drain it entirely. The remainder came through asset
13:40
Speaker 1: forfeiture at the Greencastle Motel. Her net loss was approximately
13:44
Speaker 1: four thousand dollars. The pension beneficiary change had not yet processed.
13:49
Speaker 1: Holmes had filed it, but the thirty day window was
13:52
Speaker 1: still open when he was arrested. That detail filed to
13:56
Speaker 1: a PO box in Carmel. He had opened two months
13:59
Speaker 1: in an advance under a Holme's name. Variant expired without effect.
14:04
Speaker 1: The stolen documents, Gale's passport, her Social Security card, the
14:09
Speaker 1: Putnam County land deed were returned from the evidence back.
14:13
Speaker 1: The laminated photograph was returned to her as well. She
14:17
Speaker 1: discarded it. No ceremony, no ritual destruction. She simply set
14:22
Speaker 1: it aside and let it go. Patricia Ewen, the Evansville
14:27
Speaker 1: woman who had been silent since twenty ten, contacted Karl
14:31
Speaker 1: Christiansen's office in February of twenty nineteen. She had seen
14:36
Speaker 1: a news item. She confirmed the Holt identity. Her account
14:40
Speaker 1: added a prior layer to a pattern that now stretched
14:44
Speaker 1: nearly a decade. Bloomington, Evansville, Fort Wayne, Delwood, four cities
14:50
Speaker 1: at minimum three women. Melissa Grant's twenty fourteen report in
14:55
Speaker 1: Fort Wayne had gone nowhere at the time, no conviction,
14:59
Speaker 1: no follow through across jurisdictions. Patricia Ewan had not reported
15:03
Speaker 1: at all. The architecture was intact because no single agency
15:07
Speaker 1: had held the whole blueprint. Diane Merritt, Gayl's therapist in
15:12
Speaker 1: the months that followed, described what Holmes had built as
15:16
Speaker 1: learned helplessness engineered over fourteen months. The phrase is clinical,
15:21
Speaker 1: but the mechanics were specific. He had identified. Merritt said
15:25
Speaker 1: the precise wound Gail carried from her two thousy fourteen
15:29
Speaker 1: divorce and built his entire persona around healing it. He
15:34
Speaker 1: did not invent a character. He constructed a cure. The
15:38
Speaker 1: financial consolidation idea planted in May of twenty eighteen and
15:42
Speaker 1: dropped when Gail hesitated. That was not impulsiveness, it was measurement.
15:47
Speaker 1: He waited until the ground was ready. The one question
15:50
Speaker 1: the record leaves open is the photograph. Why he carried
15:54
Speaker 1: it when he left on the night of January eighth.
15:57
Speaker 1: Why a man who had prepared a po box two
16:00
Speaker 1: months in advance and filed an insurance form to a
16:03
Speaker 1: false address would keep a wedding photograph inside his coat
16:07
Speaker 1: during an exit. The working theory is that it fell
16:10
Speaker 1: when he set his bag down at the rear gate.
16:13
Speaker 1: The mud beneath the gate was warmed by an underground conduit.
16:17
Speaker 1: The laminate held heat from his body. Judith Sullivan found
16:21
Speaker 1: it face up at seven forty three in the morning
16:23
Speaker 1: in eleven degree air, no frost on the surface. He
16:27
Speaker 1: had a duplicate in the motel room bag. So he
16:30
Speaker 1: kept one, he lost one, or left one. The record
16:34
Speaker 1: does not resolve which, and the record is all that
16:38
Speaker 1: remains of whatever David Holmes, of whatever David Holmes believed
16:42
Speaker 1: the photograph was four. There is something that resists clean
16:46
Speaker 1: summary in a case like this one, not because the
16:49
Speaker 1: facts are murky, but because the facts are precise and
16:52
Speaker 1: the damage is still hard to measure exactly. Gaiale Clark
16:57
Speaker 1: was forty six years old when Holmes arrived at Dellwood.
17:01
Speaker 1: She had rebuilt a life after a divorce that had
17:04
Speaker 1: cost her more than money. She had a Thursday table
17:07
Speaker 1: at the Elm Street Cafe. She had a cat named Pepper.
17:10
Speaker 1: She had a daughter named Amber, who, on the night
17:13
Speaker 1: of January seventh, twenty nineteen, sat with her on the
17:17
Speaker 1: kitchen floor and said call the police. Holmes chose Gale,
17:21
Speaker 1: not randomly, but specifically. Diane Merritt's word identified Carrie's weight.
17:27
Speaker 1: He found the exact shape of what she needed and
17:29
Speaker 1: became it. Over fourteen months. He moved at a pace
17:32
Speaker 1: calibrated to her trust, not to his impatience. Every step
17:37
Speaker 1: the cafe appearances, the engagement with White carnations at the
17:40
Speaker 1: same table where Patricia Ewen had watched them fall in love.
17:44
Speaker 1: The joint account, the phone only adviser named Greg, the
17:48
Speaker 1: insurance beneficiary filed to a mailbox in Carmel. Every step
17:52
Speaker 1: was placed where her guard was lowest. That is what
17:55
Speaker 1: makes this case worth sitting with. Not the money, not
17:58
Speaker 1: the seven year sentence, which is a number, a legal outcome,
18:02
Speaker 1: a box checked. What makes it worth sitting with is
18:06
Speaker 1: the mechanism. The way one person can study another person's
18:10
Speaker 1: grief and build a structure out of it, and how
18:14
Speaker 1: long that structure can stand before anything shows a crack.
18:18
Speaker 1: Gayle returned to her Thursday table at the Elm Street
18:21
Speaker 1: Cafe in the first week of February two thousand nineteen.
18:25
Speaker 1: Patricia Ewen was behind the counter, the table was available.
18:29
Speaker 1: Gail sat down. That is not a small thing after
18:33
Speaker 1: fourteen months of having her reality quietly methodically dismantled. After
18:38
Speaker 1: the kitchen floor, after the eleven unanswered calls, after the
18:43
Speaker 1: passport missing from the drawer, she walked back into the
18:46
Speaker 1: room where it began and ordered her coffee. The photograph
18:50
Speaker 1: is gone now, she did not need to burn it.
18:53
Speaker 1: This show is made by OBA media,