Latest / The Lancet Planetary Health in conversation with / Plant-Based Milk and Iodine: Is the UK at Risk of Deficiency?
Transcript
- 0:00The UK has never had a supplementation policy to ensure
- 0:03its population gets enough iodine.
- 0:06For decades, it has relied largely by accident on cows.
- 0:10A new study in The Lancet Planetary Health asks what happens to that arrangement when
- 0:15we cut back on dairy for climate reasons.
- 0:19I'm Matteo, and this is The Lancet Planetary Health in conversation with Ian.
- 0:28I'm here with the journal editor-in-chief, Alistair Brown.
- 0:31Hi, Al.
- 0:32Hi, Mateo.
- 0:33How you doing?
- 0:34All good?
- 0:34Good.
- 0:34Thank you.
- 0:35So what makes this topic important for planetary health, and where does
- 0:39this paper sit in the conversation?
- 0:41Um, so planetary health is broadly interested in how people interact with
- 0:47the environment, and in particular, how those interactions affect people's health.
- 0:53And so the food system is, uh, a clear, like, point of intersection where we--
- 0:58the choices we make about the food affect the kind of environmental footprint of
- 1:02our activities, but it also affects us very directly in terms of our health
- 1:05because we- you are what you eat.
- 1:07And so if you don't eat healthy food, um, it ha- it has obvious direct
- 1:12implications of people's health.
- 1:14So the food system's a sort of a classic intersection between
- 1:17environmental considerations and health considerations, and that's why
- 1:20it's often a topic that you'll find, uh, in Lancet Country Health and- And
- 1:25researchers concerned about these issues.
- 1:27I can- I cannot say that doesn't make sense as an Italian, you know.
- 1:31We are particularly what we eat, but that's for another podcast.
- 1:36So this paper is titled The Impact of Replacing Dairy Products With Plant-Based
- 1:41Dairy Alternatives, Cheese, Yogurt, and Milk, on Iodine and Other Micronutrients:
- 1:47A Modeling Study and Evaluation of Policy Option to Support Population Intake.
- 1:52So they took some guidelines as a, a baseline for their study, and
- 1:58these guidelines were the net zero policy the UK government put in
- 2:03place and the Eat Lancet Commission.
- 2:06What are these guidelines about?
- 2:08So within food systems research, one of the most powerful, um, things
- 2:14that… You know, the evidence shows pretty strongly that one of the most
- 2:17powerful things we can do is to eat less animal-sourced foods because the
- 2:21carbon footprint, the water footprint, and just the land, uh, area requirement
- 2:26for producing these foods are all enormous compared to plant-based foods.
- 2:30So most of the guidelines which are concerned about, uh, the environment
- 2:35in some shape, manner, or form, and the climate in particular, advocate
- 2:38for some kind of reduction in the consumption of animal-based foods.
- 2:42So the UK's net zero policy is looking for a twenty percent
- 2:47reduction in animal-sourced food intake by twenty thirty,
- 2:50thirty-five percent by twenty fifty.
- 2:52And the Eat Lancet Commission, which is a commission that tried to investigate
- 2:56the extent to which you can construct a kind of a standard diet which has a
- 3:01minimal impact on the environment but, but maintains good, healthy nutrition,
- 3:05suggests a fur- a larger reduction, around a fifty percent reduction, uh, globally.
- 3:09So this paper's looking at that as some version of reductions in, um, consumption
- 3:15of animal-sourced foods, and it focuses in particular on dairy alternatives.
- 3:20So it's really looking at, you know, what happens if we substitute current
- 3:23milk, yogurt, and cheese intake with, uh, plant-based alternatives to these foods.
- 3:29To sort of align itself with these, uh, policies or recommendations,
- 3:33it looks at various scenarios.
- 3:34So twenty percent substitution, thirty-five percent substitution,
- 3:37fifty percent substitution, or a hundred percent substitution.
- 3:39So it looks at basically what would be the kind of micronutrient effects
- 3:43if we were to switch current dairy product consumption with these, uh, with
- 3:49current market plant-based alternatives.
- 3:52But there is a caveat.
- 3:54They talk about this very interesting story that in the UK in particular,
- 3:59because there are no, like in other countries, fortification of some kind
- 4:04of food with iodine, because iodine, we, we take iodine only by fo- from food.
- 4:09The UK found supplementing iodine by chance through cattles
- 4:15Yeah, that's right.
- 4:16So I probably should have made clear at the outset, this is very much a UK-based
- 4:20study, um, because different countries have kind of all kinds of different
- 4:24policies around fortification and things.
- 4:25The story might be quite different, and obviously have different, like, dietary
- 4:29diets and, you know, typical diets.
- 4:31Uh, so it's very much a UK, uh, story, um, even though there, there will be
- 4:36lessons that can be drawn more broadly.
- 4:38But in terms of the specific findings, they're very much UK-based.
- 4:42And so, you know, it's important to understand a bit of the context
- 4:45of how things are in the UK.
- 4:47Um, lots of countries do, uh, fortify for iodine, which is one of the micronutrients
- 4:52that they're investigating in this study.
- 4:54Uh, and the WHO recommends, uh, fortification of s- uh, table salt.
- 4:59So countries, for example, like China, South Africa, Canada, Switzerland,
- 5:03Kenya, and many others already, um- Italy
- 5:05as well
- 5:06… th- and Italy as well, they already, um, sort of fortify their table
- 5:10salt to increase iodine consumption.
- 5:13But in the UK we don't, and one of the, one of the reasons, um,
- 5:16apparently is because the, there's a…
- 5:18they don't wanna have a k- kind of mixed message around salt because too much
- 5:22salt can be bad, so the idea that, you know, more salt might be good for iodine,
- 5:26but bad for, you know, blood pressure or, or whatever is one of the reasons.
- 5:29But the, perhaps the main reason in terms of, um, is just that we're
- 5:33getting that iodine from somewhere else, and in the UK, cattle have a
- 5:37iodine supplementation in their diets.
- 5:39And so, and they also historically used iodine, but as an antiseptic.
- 5:43And so it found its way into the milk that way.
- 5:45Um, in the UK, dairy products are quite high in iodine,
- 5:48and that's the main source.
- 5:50So for many people at least, that's the main source of iodine in their diets.
- 5:53So that's why it's interesting to look at, in particular, why the substitution
- 5:57of dairy products with plant-based alternatives, which might look kind
- 6:01of similar but might have a different nutrient profile, is, uh, you know,
- 6:04an interesting target of study.
- 6:06I guess we need to understand a little bit why iodine and why iodine it's,
- 6:11uh, so important as a supplement.
- 6:14Iodine, uh, it helps in the neurodevelopment, uh, regulating the
- 6:18thyroid, the hormones, uh, and is especially very important, uh, in the
- 6:23young girl and women, uh, pregnant women and child development So it looks like
- 6:29it's something dangerous to reduce.
- 6:33I mean, certainly there are micronutrients that we need in our diet, and in certain
- 6:37phase of life and certain subsections of the s- of society might require more.
- 6:42Um, and it's important to make sure that the, that we're getting sufficient
- 6:46of those micronutrients, and iodine is certainly one of those micronutrients.
- 6:49And so if we know at the outset that in the UK many people get much of their
- 6:55iodine through dairy products, then obviously substituting 20, 35, 50, or
- 7:00100% of that intake with some other source, if that has less iodine in it,
- 7:05then it's kind of obvious that if all other things are held constant, then there
- 7:09might be a reduction in iodine intake.
- 7:11And so that's exactly what this paper's trying to investigate.
- 7:14It's trying to say… It's looking at… It's a modeling study, but
- 7:16it's estimating, well, what might be the implications of making these
- 7:20switches in terms of dietary intake, and could that be problematic?
- 7:24And if so, what might be the solutions to preventing that becoming a problem?
- 7:29So they are proposing some scenarios, as we said, uh, a reduction of
- 7:3425, a reduction of 30%, 50%, or 100%, a complete reduction, and
- 7:41looked a little bit into it.
- 7:42Do we want to go to the numbers?
- 7:45But we can do, yeah, for sure.
- 7:46I think it's important to emphasize none of these, like, recommendations
- 7:50for reduced consumption of animal-source foods a-and dairy
- 7:53products are compulsory, and no one's suggesting they should be compulsory.
- 7:56So this is all through consumer choice.
- 7:59So while it might be desirable and, and people might hope that with, um, education
- 8:05that people might eat… see the benefits of eating, uh, less animal-sourced
- 8:09food, there's no suggestion that this is gonna be mandatory and that people
- 8:12are gonna be forced into these choices.
- 8:14But nevertheless, assuming that people, um, th-this paper looks at
- 8:19some different scenarios of, um, what might be the impact on micronutrient
- 8:24intake in the UK population.
- 8:26So these four different scenarios, twenty, thirty-five, fifty, and a
- 8:29hundred percent reduction in dairy products and through substitution
- 8:34with plant-based alternatives, um, and they look at the micronutrients,
- 8:38what effect might this have on iodine, calcium, riboflavin, and vitamin B12.
- 8:43And they use industry-standard information about what products
- 8:46are currently available and what are their nutrient profiles.
- 8:49Some of them have some level of supplementation, but it's relatively low.
- 8:52And then they look at scenarios where with industry-standard fortification
- 8:56of these micronutrients in the plant-based milks and also in bread
- 9:01through fortified salt addition to bread, and then they look at both.
- 9:04So what would be the effect?
- 9:05So i-in a sense, you can look at, well, what might be the effect at a twenty
- 9:08percent penetration, market penetration of these alternatives with plant milk,
- 9:13cheese, and yogurt fortification or with bread fortification or with both
- 9:20and, uh- Yeah … each of the different levels of kind of, uh, replacement.
- 9:24So the results are quite complex, so I would suggest everyone to go
- 9:29and look at the paper and read them.
- 9:32But basically, some key findings, we can say that, quite unsurprisingly,
- 9:38the best result would be to have both, uh, plant-based alternatives, uh,
- 9:44fortification and, uh, a fortified bread.
- 9:48I think that we can definitely agree that the fact that substituting a food at,
- 9:52which is dairy products, which we know are quite rich in, in iodine in particular,
- 9:57for another, an alternative source of food which is less rich in iodine is, is
- 10:02unsurprising that if all other things are held steady, then people then have less
- 10:07diet, iodine in their diet, and that might be something that we need to address.
- 10:11I think that's unsurprising, like qualitatively.
- 10:14I think what's interesting here is that they tried to look at, well,
- 10:17how much of an extent, you know, tried to put some numbers on this.
- 10:20So, you know, how, uh, various different levels of substitution, how much
- 10:26effect might that have on people's intake and potentially At, you know, at
- 10:30levels that might affect their health and then what can we do about it?
- 10:33So I think that that is kind of unsurprising, but nevertheless, it's
- 10:36very interesting to look at the, you know, and estimate the, the extent to
- 10:41which it's gonna actually be a real world problem, if you like, like how much.
- 10:44And then as to whether the extent to which it can be addressed through
- 10:49fortification, I think that is the…
- 10:52If people need more of a nutrient, then fortification can help, is
- 10:57kind of conceptually obvious.
- 10:58But how much fortification and the extent to which, whether we need it
- 11:01through one type of food supplementation or two, I think that's less obvious,
- 11:04and that's where this kind of study helps, um, give us some clues about what
- 11:09might be, you know, effective policies.
- 11:11Wouldn't this go toward the ultra-processing of food, that
- 11:15we know that this is not- Is, is a controversial thing at least
- 11:21I mean, I think in the kind of current world that we live in with the kind
- 11:26of algorithm, you know, clickbait, um, misinformation world that we live in
- 11:30where, you know, in the US there's a huge amount of argument about, you know,
- 11:35there's this kind of a resurgent of ideas like raw milk and these kind of- Yes
- 11:39you know, ideas, then I'm just… I, I have no doubt that
- 11:42fortification is something that could be seen as controversial.
- 11:46Uh, but it's worth mentioning, like for example, in the UK, white flour is already
- 11:49fortified with a number of micronutrients, including calcium and iron.
- 11:52So if they were to add iodine, they would only be in line with existing
- 11:56policies which are working well and are pretty uncontroversial for most people.
- 11:59Like I haven't, you know, I'm not aware of many people who are concerned about the,
- 12:03the iron fortification in their bread.
- 12:05So I don't think that it's really… I mean, I'm, I can easily see how
- 12:10in certain circles it might be seen as something that is, you know,
- 12:13sinister and government intervention.
- 12:15But I think within kind of, uh, rational debates, I d- I think it w- it sits
- 12:20within, you know, a sensible, proven framework and, and doesn't really…
- 12:25I wouldn't consider it, uh, a movement towards m- more
- 12:28processed food, if you like.
- 12:30Uh, and that's a, that's a whole separate issue that we perhaps
- 12:33haven't got time to get into today.
- 12:34Yeah, no, of course.
- 12:34Sorry.
- 12:35I, I, I wasn't sure asking the question, but it was something that while reading
- 12:39the paper was, but wait a second, we are, uh, i- in a way trying to
- 12:45stick to a, a, a more natural diet without hyper-industrialization of
- 12:51the processes and things like that, and then we start thinking about…
- 12:55But yeah, of course, it's not like producing synthetically supplements.
- 13:00It's just something that it-
- 13:02I do think that I'm sure that there, for many people, there would be a temptation
- 13:06to see this as a story of we have a natural food which is providing what
- 13:11we need, and now we're gonna replace it with a, like a less natural food- Yeah
- 13:14and it's not providing what we need.
- 13:16That's not really what the evidence says in this case.
- 13:19Like firstly, these, uh, you know, these, this is, uh, intensive
- 13:22agricultural practices that where we g- we're getting these products from.
- 13:26It's not, you know, one cow in a water meadow.
- 13:29And secondly, they, m- most of the iodine that they're getting, they're
- 13:33getting from fortification of their diets in th- these agricultural settings.
- 13:39So it's not really, even though I can see the appeal a- and the kind
- 13:43of intuitive sense of that idea, it doesn't, it's not really what the
- 13:48ev- you know, shows is happening.
- 13:49You know, we're, we're having one type of food which is fortified in its
- 13:53own way, and then there's a question about do we need… If we're gonna
- 13:56replace that type of food, do we maybe need to fortify in another way?
- 14:00I think it's also worth saying there are other ways that you can
- 14:03get, uh, iodine into your diet.
- 14:05So if you're… So, you know, as Educated, intelligent people, you can look at,
- 14:10oh, well, I've made this choice to substitute this with this, and I know
- 14:12that that's lower in iodine, uh, so I need to get more sources of iodine.
- 14:16Yeah, eat more fish, for example.
- 14:17Exactly.
- 14:18And I think it's also just really important to point out that many
- 14:21people are, currently don't get enough micronutrients in their existing
- 14:25diet because many people don't have particularly great diets already- Exactly
- 14:28… for all kinds of complicated reasons.
- 14:30Uh, yeah.
- 14:31And so it's not the case that everyone is currently getting all
- 14:35of the micronutrients they need.
- 14:36And if we were to make this switch, suddenly a whole load of people would
- 14:38not be getting the micronutrients.
- 14:40You know, it's already a complicated picture.
- 14:42But w- I think what this, probably if I wanted to kind of try and
- 14:46really summarize, I think what this paper shows is that when you make a
- 14:49substitution, obviously it has the potential to have implications on the
- 14:53nutrient profi- profile of those foods.
- 14:55And if within your broader diet, that could have implications for
- 15:00your overall nutrient intake.
- 15:02And, um, in this case, it seems like it's relatively easy to address through
- 15:07alternative fortification profiles, you know, which are existing proven policies
- 15:12which are used already in the UK and already around the world, specifically
- 15:15for, um, iodine around the world and, and for other micronutrients in the UK.
- 15:20So I think from my point of view, as someone who doesn't entirely substitute
- 15:26dairy products, but certainly substitutes some dairy products some of the time,
- 15:30it's quite reassuring that, you know, okay, I c- I need to be aware that
- 15:34this might have some implications, but it's quite easy for me to manage.
- 15:38And in the wider population, it could be probably managed w-
- 15:42through fortification without people really giving it much thought.
- 15:46Yeah.
- 15:47I really like this paper because, uh, it proposes a, a, a very simple
- 15:51solution to something that could have an effect, but actually with a
- 15:55little help from a fortification of a, of a product, the benefit on the
- 16:02planet, and so by consequence also on people's health, it's just there.
- 16:08And it doesn't take much to achieve, just one cow at a time.
- 16:14I think that the… One of the interesting things about these kind of substitutes
- 16:18is that there, there's a, um… And we, we talked about this a little bit in
- 16:22our preamble about whether, you know, whether making change just requires a
- 16:26substitution of one product for another.
- 16:28So, and I think that for many people, if they were to eat less animal-sourced
- 16:33foods, they would be making much broader changes in their dietary composition.
- 16:38For example, eating, you know, a wider variety of, um, vegetables
- 16:42and pulses and things like that.
- 16:44Um, and so substituting milk would only be one of the choices
- 16:49that they've made in, y-you know, changing their kind of dietary mix.
- 16:52And in that case, obviously, it's a much more complicated
- 16:54situation, and it's more…
- 16:56It's harder to assess.
- 16:57But the way that these, uh, milk and dairy substitutes are marketed is sort of pretty
- 17:03much as a direct replacement, right?
- 17:05I can go and buy some, um, soy milk, or I can go and buy some oat milk, and I can
- 17:09just put that in my fridge and replace it.
- 17:11Milk, essentially, in terms of functionally, in terms of my daily habits.
- 17:15But it, it is important to understand that just because it looks a little
- 17:18bit similar and because it's having a similar function in terms of your daily
- 17:22habits, it doesn't necessarily mean it has the same nutrient qualities,
- 17:25and that might require, you know, people to think a little differently.
- 17:29You know, there's a kind of a two, like, schools of thought about that.
- 17:32You know, one is that people need to just be aware of their, their choices
- 17:37and think about the kind of mix of dietary intake, and the other is, oh,
- 17:41well, they shouldn't have to worry about that, so we can just sort it all out
- 17:45without them worrying about it, right?
- 17:46So the fortification solution is one that j-you know, just means
- 17:49that people don't need to engage with any of these questions.
- 17:52It's also, of course, I think worth reiterating, we're not
- 17:55talking a-about, uh, new policies that weren't already in place.
- 17:59You know, food is already fortified in multiple ways.
- 18:01So this is an addit- the potential value in one additional fortification for a
- 18:06certain type of food, which is very much in line with, you know, existing policies.
- 18:10And I think that's perhaps what makes it quite appealing, because
- 18:13often with sustainability, there's this kind of idea that it's quite
- 18:16hard, and it might require, you know, maybe undesirable life choices.
- 18:21Whereas, you know, when you can just substitute, I think that's
- 18:24wrong, but that's, uh, definitely a conversation for another day.
- 18:27But, uh, but that's nevertheless a kind of a message that people
- 18:29get, and I think that- Yeah.
- 18:31Um-
- 18:31I agree.
- 18:32I think the idea that you can just substitute one product for another,
- 18:36at least in the short term, and that it's not gonna have a big impact, or
- 18:40at least if government takes simple action, there's no need for it to
- 18:43have any kind of significant impact on your micronutrient intake profile.
- 18:48You know, that's a… It's quite a neat solution, uh, without requiring
- 18:53people to kind of be interested or engaged, particularly with, you know,
- 18:58sustainability as an ideological, um-
- 19:01Yeah
- 19:02… initiative.
- 19:03Yeah, that's, that's something that it's worth noting.
- 19:05It's a personal choice, but doesn't need to be a, a kind of a moral, uh, dilemma.
- 19:11It's something that is working well for the environment.
- 19:14It's something that it working well for you, for your health, and so why not?
- 19:19To the paper.
- 19:21I think it would be fair to note if there are, like, any limitation to the study.
- 19:26So I mean, I, I think the purpose of our kind of, like, conversations
- 19:30is mostly around setting some context around the papers.
- 19:33And so, as you have already said several times, I always encourage
- 19:36people to go and read the paper itself.
- 19:38There's invariably I've skipped over or missed some, you know,
- 19:41important detail, and, uh, when you're understanding a study, it's
- 19:45obviously important to understand some of the limitations and assumptions.
- 19:48In, in a paper like this, a modeling paper like this, is often to do with
- 19:50kind of simplifying assumptions.
- 19:52So, you know, for example, they assume, like, a population-wide shift
- 19:56in dietary behavior, which isn't, you know, very realistic, but it
- 19:58allows you to get a sense of how it might change the kind of the overall
- 20:02state of things in the population.
- 20:04The plant-based dairy alternatives were based on current offerings, but
- 20:09because they didn't have data about the kind of market share of each of
- 20:12them, they used kind of standardized products, if you like, not necessarily
- 20:16reflecting any, any one or the ratio of the different products out there.
- 20:20And, um, perhaps the, one of the most kind of important things is that the
- 20:26bioavailability was not assessed, so just looking at how much was in the food
- 20:30rather than, you know, whether your body can extract those nutrients effectively.
- 20:34Uh, and they didn't look at, at whether there was any impact on nutrient,
- 20:37nutrient int-interactions within the diet.
- 20:40They just assumed that if they were there, then that was okay.
- 20:43So lots of simplifying assumptions, but nevertheless, reasonable assumptions
- 20:48that allow you to say something useful about the possible effects of these
- 20:52choices at a population level, which is what the, the study's trying to do.
- 20:55Fantastic.
- 20:56Thank you very much.
- 20:57I think we can wrap it up by saying…
- 21:01Um, that what the study shows is that, uh, the micronutrient intake effects
- 21:07of changing to plant-based dairy alternatives are relatively small, but
- 21:13they are there, and that in the short term, absent some kind of government
- 21:18policy, people who are making that choice might want to look at how they
- 21:22can find alternative sources of iodine in their diet, iodine in particular.
- 21:26But that it would be relatively easy if the, if this did become, you know,
- 21:30a large change in dietary preference within the country, it would be
- 21:33relatively easy for the government to address that with, um, supplementation.