Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Earnout Agreements in Acquisitions
Transcript
- Lucas: So AMD announced this week it's acquiring ZT Systems for around $5 billion, but here's the interesting part: roughly $1.2 billion of that price is structured as an earnout tied to revenue milestones through 2027. Luna: Right, so they're not paying the full $5 billion upfront. They're basically betting that ZT Systems will hit certain numbers, and if it does, the sellers get more. Lucas: Exactly. And earnouts have become a really common tool for post ipo companies doing acquisitions. When you're a young public company with a volatile stock price—and we've seen plenty of that lately—tying part of the deal to future performance can be a way to bridge the valuation gap. Luna: Why is that especially relevant for post ipo companies versus, say, a ten-year-old public firm? Lucas: Great question. For one, many recent IPOs are still burning cash or have limited cash reserves. By using an earnout, they conserve cash and only pay more if the acquisition actually generates the expected revenue. Second, their stock might be volatile—just look at the big tech sell-off this week: Alphabet down 8 percent, Meta down 6, Amazon down 5 and a half. In that environment, all-stock deals can be risky for the seller, so earnouts offer a middle ground. Luna: So the seller gets a guaranteed base payment, plus a potential upside based on performance. That makes sense. How are these earnouts typically structured? Lucas: There are a few common models. The most straightforward is a revenue-based earnout, like in the AMD deal. The target company needs to hit a specific revenue number over, say, two or three years. If it does, the sellers get additional cash or stock. Sometimes it's based on EBITDA or user growth. Another model is a product launch milestone—for example, if the target's new product gets FDA approval, the earnout kicks in. Luna: And what about the payout formula? Is it all-or-nothing, or can it be proportional? Lucas: It's almost always proportional. There's usually a threshold, a target, and a maximum. If you hit 80 percent of the target, you might get 80 percent of the earnout. If you exceed the target, you might get a bonus up to a cap. The idea is to align incentives without creating a cliff where just missing the target wipes out the whole payout. Luna: That seems smart. But earnouts also have a reputation for causing post-deal friction. I've heard stories where the acquired team feels pressure to hit short-term numbers at the expense of long-term strategy. Lucas: That's definitely a risk. If the earnout is tied to revenue, the acquired team might push for aggressive sales tactics or cut R&D spending to boost the top line. That can hurt integration. There's also the accounting complexity—under US GAAP, earnouts are marked to market each quarter, which can create earnings volatility. For a post ipo company already under analyst scrutiny, that's not ideal. Luna: So how do companies manage that? Any best practices? Lucas: One approach is to tie the earnout to metrics that align with the acquirer's long-term strategy, not just short-term revenue. For example, if the goal is to acquire AI talent, tie it to retention of key engineers or successful product integration. Another is to keep the earnout period relatively short—12 to 24 months—so it doesn't drag out. And crucially, both sides need to be transparent about how performance will be measured. Ambiguous language leads to disputes. Luna: Speaking of disputes, what happens if the acquirer changes the target's strategy mid-way? Say they decide to kill a product that was central to the earnout. Lucas: That's a classic source of litigation. Many earnout agreements include a 'best efforts' clause, but they rarely specify what that means. Courts have landed on different outcomes. Some say the acquirer must act in 'good faith' and not deliberately sabotage the earnout. Others have held that ordinary business decisions that impact the earnout are permitted unless there's explicit language preventing it. So the devil is really in the drafting. Luna: Let's talk about the current environment. With the market down this week—the S&P 500 fell about 4 percent—are we likely to see more earnout structures in the coming months? Lucas: I think so. When stock prices are depressed, sellers are less willing to accept all-stock consideration. But buyers may not want to pay all cash either. Earnouts become a natural compromise. Plus, with interest rates still elevated—the ten-year Treasury is around 4.2 percent—borrowing for all-cash deals is expensive. So expect earnouts to feature prominently in tech M&A for the rest of the year. Luna: And for listeners who are founders considering selling to a public company, what should they watch out for in an earnout clause? Lucas: First, understand the metrics inside out. If the earnout is tied to revenue, define what 'revenue' means—is it gross revenue, net revenue, recurring revenue? Second, negotiate protections against changes in the acquirer's strategy. Third, consider the time horizon—longer earnouts increase the risk of integration drift. And finally, have a dispute resolution mechanism, like arbitration, to avoid costly litigation. Luna: Yeah, that makes sense. And one last point—earnouts can also be a signal to the market. If a public company uses an earnout, it might signal that they're disciplined about acquisitions, which investors often like. Lucas: Absolutely. It shows you're not just throwing cash at growth, but you're tying compensation to performance. That can be a positive narrative, especially for a post ipo company trying to build credibility with institutional investors. Luna: And speaking of building credibility—we should mention that this podcast is listener-supported. A small group of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's what keeps us ad-free and independent. Lucas: Yeah, it's a model we really believe in. No advertisers, no sponsors dictating topics. Just us and the audience. And if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, that support is what makes it sustainable. Luna: So thank you to those who already contribute. And now back to earnouts—one more nuance I wanted to explore: how do earnouts interact with lockup agreements? Lucas: That's a great point. If the earnout is paid in stock, the sellers might be subject to lockup restrictions on when they can sell. That adds another layer of complexity. Some deals structure the earnout in cash specifically to avoid that issue. But if it's stock, you need to align the earnout payout schedule with the lockup expiration to avoid forcing sellers to hold concentrated positions. Luna: And if the acquirer's stock drops after the deal, the earnout shares might be worth less than expected. That can create resentment. Lucas: Right. That's why some earnouts include a collar or a fixed-share number, so the number of shares is locked in regardless of the stock price. Others use a floating share count tied to the stock price. It really depends on the negotiation. Luna: Well, we could talk about this for another hour, but let's wrap it up. Lucas, any final takeaway? Lucas: Just that earnouts are a powerful tool, but they require careful design. For post ipo companies, they can be the difference between a deal that gets done and one that falls apart. And as we see more M&A activity in the second half of 2026, expect earnouts to be part of the conversation. Luna: Thanks for listening. We'll be back next week with another angle on post ipo strategy.