Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Bob Free Association and Tacky Comment
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, I have some interesting short questions for you. It's really
- 0:05great when people send in long questions because sometimes questions need to be long.
- 0:09There's a lot of detail that needs to be given to us, so we
- 0:12have a context. Sometimes people don't give enough context, and we want more.
- 0:15But sometimes it's really great when people just send these really brief, one
- 0:19sentence questions because then it's easier for me to get through them. All.
- 0:23You know, how about this, I'll answer them and then you read them.
- 0:26Let's see how I do so annual patron soft noodles, She says,
- 0:31Hi, Bob, how about a little game. What is the first thing
- 0:34that comes to mind when you hear the following words love, sex, trauma,
- 0:41Donald Trump. Oh my god, I can't believe I said that.
- 0:44Jesus, it's but it's true. Childhood. Oh oh fuck, Well you
- 0:50said that people places, Kirk Honda, Bob, I don't like this game,
- 1:03Colleen, Oh, okay, soft noodles. The center of the email.
- 1:08Well, I see udon okay, udon therapy dog. One thing you
- 1:19want sexy? The experience? Oh, your experience in this exact moment.
- 1:26Oh, nervous and amused. That was awesome. Soft noodles. That was
- 1:32so great. Emma on I think YouTube commented something and there were a couple
- 1:40of other people were commenting. Maybe it was on Patreon. I'm measure.
- 1:42But on our episode where we were talking about self harm during therapy, remember
- 1:48there was like someone I think I think on a video session was digging her
- 1:55fingernails into her hands and she didn't notice. And then when she or maybe
- 2:00in office, and then she showed she at the end of the says she's
- 2:05like, oh wow, I and she the email or the client said that
- 2:09the therapists seemed kind of freaked out about it or something. We don't know.
- 2:14Yeah, the exact interaction. We talked a lot about self harm and
- 2:17non suicidal self injury and for you know, those who are triggered by this,
- 2:23I don't think we're going to get back into it again. Well maybe
- 2:27we will. Yeah, So if this is triggering for you, let's gip
- 2:30forward about fifteen minutes. Honestly, So we were talking about that and I
- 2:36was asking you if it had ever happened to you, and you give a
- 2:38story about how it. Yeah, it would because the clients that you worked
- 2:43with in the DBT class, the students that you worked with in the DBD
- 2:46class were they're you know what, like ninety percent of them had a history
- 2:51of suicidal self injury, yes, if not all of them, No,
- 2:54not all, and more at the in the research study than in my practice,
- 2:59okay, And in your practice maybe half or something or maybe maybe half
- 3:02yeah, maybe half okay. And some of those would be actively trying to
- 3:08recover from that and not engage in that, And it was a topic of
- 3:14the course. You wouldn't get into the specificity with each student, but they
- 3:20would do that with their individual client. But in the class you would talk
- 3:22about emotional regulation, and you might talk about non suicidal self injury in a
- 3:27particular module, and you would also talk about how the ground rules were such
- 3:31that they were not supposed to engage in it. They weren't supposed to talk
- 3:36about it directly, particularly if it was trying to glorify it or something.
- 3:40Oh yeah, no war stories for sure, right. So there were these
- 3:45measures in place to protect people from being triggered, to not create an environment
- 3:51that encourages it. You know, they're trying to recover. It's like trying
- 3:54to be sober from some addiction, right, And there need to be some
- 4:00some ground rules about because it would be not uncommon for someone pre recovery from
- 4:06non pseudicidal self injury to talk about it in a very positive way. You
- 4:11know, it's it's their little secret, wonderful getaway treat for themselves. You
- 4:17know, that's not uncommon. And to have that attitude and to support that
- 4:23attitude as to enable it, I'm guessing. And so for you, as
- 4:26the instructor, you had these ground rules, and as we were talking about
- 4:30it, you told this story about someone who had done it in session,
- 4:32and then I think I asked, how did she feel about it afterwards?
- 4:38How did you react to this sort of thing? And you said the word
- 4:42that it was tacky, and in the moment I listened back to it,
- 4:47and in the moment I heard that word and it was a little I mean,
- 4:56I don't want to say shocked, but I had a reaction like hunh.
- 5:00And so I tried to clarify that in the moment, and I think
- 5:04I said something like, oh, well, I can't remember what I said,
- 5:08but I was trying to soften it or something or contextualize it, because
- 5:12it didn't seem like was being communicated in the way that I think it was
- 5:17actually being carried out in class, but I don't know. Yeah, so
- 5:20some people in the comments section were like, did he say tacky and any
- 5:26thoughts on that. Yeah, that's a word Marsha Lenahan uses. Okay,
- 5:30Yeah, so I, you know, a lot of what I learned,
- 5:32I just mimic. So that's one of the ways that she's talked about it,
- 5:39the idea, right, I think the I think the comments are aimed
- 5:44at it sounds like a judgmental way to refer to something somebody has a real
- 5:46struggle with. And I can see why that is. Yeah, and probably
- 5:50if I were thinking, I probably wouldn't use that word, and I probably
- 5:55don't use that word. I probably didn't use that word. I don't think
- 5:58I maybe I did. Did we use that with a client? Did I
- 6:00say I did? I might have. Well, the very least the attitude
- 6:06that you had it was indicative of that, the way you talked about,
- 6:12the way you would talk about it in class that it was, you know,
- 6:15because it branched into another conversation that we had where I was like,
- 6:19well, for me, when people come into therapy with it, I you
- 6:25know, in summary, just treat it like anything else, and I would
- 6:28say, well, how do you want to talk about it? Do you
- 6:30want to work on it? I'm certainly not going to judge you for it,
- 6:33or they had engaged in it recently. I just had a very non
- 6:39judgment open a conversation, and even if they're in the middle of still glorifying
- 6:45it, I'm not going to try to change that immediately because that would be
- 6:48not wise. So I would just say, well, here's my thoughts on
- 6:53it, and let me know if you want to work on it. So
- 6:56it would be the same as if someone said they were using hair or they
- 7:00were engaging in relationships that I thought weren't helpful in their life. I'm not
- 7:05gonna judge them or tell them they can't or give them the impression that somehow
- 7:12I am secretly wanting them to even really necessarily change that. I'll tell them
- 7:15the truth. I'll just be like, I don't think this is helpful for
- 7:16you, but there's a lot of paths in life, and we can work
- 7:19on whatever you want to want to work on. Whereas with you, you
- 7:23were saying, even in individual therapy, you would have a more pointed approach
- 7:28of this needs to stop I'm not gonna entertain the idea that it's okay for
- 7:32you to continue to engage in non suicidal self injury something like that. Right,
- 7:38Yeah, I could see why I could land that way. You know.
- 7:42Sometimes, yeah, we do. We do have a different take on
- 7:46this. I would be I don't do this kind of work anymore. But
- 7:49when I did, my attitude was it actually does have to stop because there's
- 7:54a risk to premature death. You increase your the likelihood of premature death if
- 7:58you engage in self harm or non suicidal self injury, and that's antithetical to
- 8:03goals UM. So, so I would it's sort of it's a dialectic because
- 8:13on the one hand, it has to stop. On another hand, it's
- 8:16not just going to stop, so that the as I understand it, good
- 8:20treatment is aimed at um turning the behavior but not judging the person while you
- 8:28do it. And you know how long that takes is however, how long
- 8:30that takes. So my use of the word TACKI is just it's just a
- 8:37holdover from working with Marsha because it's the way that she would talk about it.
- 8:41But she was not judgmental about um about um non suicidal self injury.
- 8:48She she had the similar attitude that it's got a risk of premature death,
- 8:52so it's it's got to stop. It's also off putting, like it's scary
- 8:56to people, and so they people won't understand and they will alienate, they'll
- 9:05they'll you know, isolate somebody. They'll you know, that's the bad thing
- 9:11that you're doing over there. So I don't want to be associated with the
- 9:13bad thing. The role we had in the classes. You know, if
- 9:16you do it, okay, you know, right, Um, it's it's
- 9:22it's I think, yeah, now that I'm remembering, I think the way
- 9:26I talked about it is somebody I had two experiences of students doing it in
- 9:30the class, and it sets up dissonance for the other members because you know,
- 9:37presumably we're going up a particular mountain and that's going down so um in
- 9:43a way, you could say it's bad form. It's like, you know,
- 9:46the folks here are trying not to do that, so when you do
- 9:50that here, that creates a problem for them, you know, a potential
- 9:54problem. I have seen people mimic non so self self injury, and that
- 9:58was back when I I was young and starting and I didn't understand what that
- 10:03man are. And then somebody described some behavior in the class and we didn't
- 10:07put a stop to it, and somebody else over the week Mimi did.
- 10:11Now what I would, what I did most of my career, and what
- 10:16I would do if I were still doing that is, if somebody talks about
- 10:18it, I'll say, oh, you mean target behavior. That's what they
- 10:22call it in DBT land is it's a target behavior, meaning it's a behavior
- 10:24that's targeted to be eliminated, which is not a judgmental way to put it,
- 10:28but it's a way to talk about it without it being a trigger.
- 10:31So instead of oh, you mean you did a target behavior, which I
- 10:35have said many, many many times, somebody say oh, yeah, right,
- 10:37Because we make that agreement upfront that we don't talk about the details of
- 10:41it. Does target behavior always refer to? It could be alcohol. For
- 10:45like, if somebody there, somebody in class had a problem with alcohol,
- 10:48like they were alcoholic or something, then that would be considered a target behavior
- 10:52for them because it's a behavior that they're targeting in therapy to eliminate. So
- 10:56if they talk about drinking, I would say, oh, you mean target
- 10:58behavior. But if somebody else didn't have a problem with alcohol, and they
- 11:01happen to be in the same class and they're talking about, you know,
- 11:03they're not with their buddies and how a beer the other day. That's not
- 11:07a target behavior for them. So I wouldn't ask them not to talk about
- 11:11it because it's you know, it's not it's normative. But but you could
- 11:18see where it's possible that somebody talking about, um, you know, non
- 11:22abusive use of alcohol could be a trigger for somebody who's got an alcohol addiction.
- 11:26It could be And occasionally that's come up, and it's sort of tricky
- 11:31because in the way you what, you don't want to I don't want to
- 11:37do anything in the class that could lead somebody to relapse on the one hand,
- 11:41and on the other hand, it's you can't you can't eliminate that from
- 11:48the world, like that potential trigger. So probably, as I understand DBT,
- 11:54what they would do an individual therapy is they would help that person get
- 11:56used to the fact that alcohol is everywhere and you still can't drink because it's
- 12:01you know, be anathetical to your goals or whatever life, you know,
- 12:03whatever. So like I know, a DBT therapist really great therapist, and
- 12:09for a couple of sessions she met her client at a bar so that that
- 12:13person could sit and not drink. She didn't drink and the client didn't drink,
- 12:18and kind of get used to this is what it smels like in here.
- 12:20This is what it's like in here. Not that it's a good idea
- 12:22for people to be hanging out in bars, maybe it's not. But if
- 12:26they're gonna then that's a way to help not relapse. Yeah, I mean
- 12:31the way that it sounds, and I didn't realize this until maybe just now,
- 12:37is that DBT has a theme that is the main theme of a lot
- 12:43of drug and alcohol treatment programs, not all, but they are often like
- 12:48this. It's similar to eating disorder treatment programs, where it's a different philosophy
- 12:54than the one that I have generally for therapy, and that it's I don't
- 13:01know the word for it, but it's a lot more directive and there are
- 13:03rules and there's a vibe of the only word that I have for it is
- 13:09judgments. You could use a different word like ground rules. But there's a
- 13:13culture around it, right. It's not just like, hey, we have
- 13:16this ground rule where that if you say you're in a drug and alcohol treat
- 13:22and program. We have this ground rule that if you relapse, and especially
- 13:26if we catch you on a drug test and you didn't tell us about it,
- 13:30then you will be terminated from this group. We have another group that
- 13:33you can go to, but for this group, we have a ground rule
- 13:37about that. And now, of course DBT wouldn't do that, but it's
- 13:41a similar attitude of you cannot do that here and here is the rule.
- 13:46That's probably just the way I'm talking about it. A good DBT therapist doesn't
- 13:50hold any judgment about this and recognizes that this behavior, it's a dialectic.
- 13:56On the one hand, it's going to happen and any other hand, it
- 13:58has to change. Both true at the same time. It has to change.
- 14:01That's it, and it also is going to happen, right. I
- 14:05don't know that you could frame the same way that relapses. How I could
- 14:07frame it as a failure, but I don't think any good therapists would frame
- 14:11it that way. But so so, like one other phrase, it was
- 14:16tacky, you know, it was okay, it was against what you should
- 14:20have done. It's against my expectations for you. I feel protective of my
- 14:26students. So if somebody self harms in the class, yeah, I'm going
- 14:31to be upset about it totally. And I can imagine for the group cohesion
- 14:35the protectiveness one hundred percent. And I don't have any judgment of the person
- 14:41that did it, Like I remember liking her very much and wanting her to
- 14:46do well in class, and um, you know, feeling an affinity for
- 14:50her, and um, not feeling a judgment of her whatsoever, as being
- 14:56at the same time being frank with her that you know you can not do
- 15:00that here because it's it's risky for the other members, and you are a
- 15:07member of this class, so I want to keep well, that's why.
- 15:11And I don't know. I might not remember this right, but that's why
- 15:15I was asking. So if an individual therapy, say outside of DBT,
- 15:20you just had a client that was talking about this, would you have a
- 15:22different attitude And my memory correct me if I'm wrong. Was you said,
- 15:26well, not really? And I also want to emphasize what you're emphasizing is
- 15:30that I have no doubt that your students, at no point quote unquote felt
- 15:33judged. I don't know that, but I don't think that that's likely given
- 15:37you. But given the DBT creed, I could imagine that some might you
- 15:45know that some might. That's why I think they heard the language. I
- 15:48think some people said, wait, did he use the word attacking? Yeah?
- 15:52I don't know that of course. Similarly, like when I worked with
- 15:56drug and alcohol folks side by side with them in you know, in the
- 16:00groups, there were moments where I thought, wow, you know, like
- 16:03the drug and alcohol folks, they just they there's a benefit to the way
- 16:07that they think, but it's not the way that I think. A given
- 16:11example, like there was a client of mine that was in the drug and
- 16:14alcohol groups. She was suffering from opiate addiction and was tasked with recovery,
- 16:22but she wasn't fully invested her parents. She was an adult, but her
- 16:26parents were the main ones who were really trying to get her to stop.
- 16:27She she wasn't there necessarily one hundred percent voluntarily, you know what I mean,
- 16:33but you know, nice person invested in stating that she wanted to quit.
- 16:38Yeah, And so an individual therapy with me, I knew the full
- 16:44her and I because therapy has a lot of different styles, my style is
- 16:48to be very open and I'm not I don't have I work with them.
- 16:53You know, I have my own thoughts, but I'm very far from any
- 16:56thought that I know what a person should do or thinking that there's only one
- 17:00way to health or something at a particular moment. So if, for example,
- 17:04she had told me that she had used I would have said, oh,
- 17:08well, what do you want to do with that? Do you want
- 17:11to talk about it or not? And if she said yeah, I don't
- 17:14really want to talk about it, I'd be like okay, and I wouldn't
- 17:15give it a second thought because that's how I'm oriented, and I believe that's
- 17:19what service. The best service that I can provide people is not only to
- 17:25do that, but to literally have that mindset and to have a vibe of
- 17:29that mindset so that they don't think, well, he's secretly judging me,
- 17:32because that's just what I think is most helpful. So I'm just imagining what
- 17:37I would do. Yeah, oh, what do you mean? Well,
- 17:40if somebody said that to me, I bet ten bucks that there's a wave
- 17:42of shame coming for them, in which case I would say how does it
- 17:47feel? Yeah, and keep most of my attention focused on what is the
- 17:51experience that's happening in between us right now, because most likely there's a sense
- 17:56of shame that's come and I would not ignore that, right like that person's
- 18:03you know me, I'm always thinking about the matrix. I love the Matrix,
- 18:06great film. Most people earn a matrix most of the time. So
- 18:11we're in our story about what is the world as opposed to what is the
- 18:12world. So someone lucky enough to land you as their therapist might not have
- 18:17a felt sense that you hold no judgment and might have their sense of matrix
- 18:22like this is how the world behaves towards me if I relapse and it's going
- 18:27to shame me, or it's going to attack me or whatever, and there's
- 18:33an anticipation of that perhaps, so there's a lovely opportunity to really dig into
- 18:41that, to just go into and join with somebody in whatever their experiences in
- 18:48this case, perhaps something like shame and care about that By your facial expression,
- 18:55I think what you're saying, and correct if I'm wrong, is that
- 18:57by completely ignoring it as at their request, I'd be ignoring something that was
- 19:03helpful. Yes, well, I don't think that you're saying that. I'm
- 19:07just extrapolating in my head, right what you're saying is it's not contradictory to
- 19:12it. But at the same time, if you are oriented towards abstinence and
- 19:19that's an important thing for you as a clinician, there's a lot of options
- 19:23in that moment. You know, a client comes in and says, I
- 19:27relapsed, and I say, did you tell your drug and alcohol people about
- 19:32that? No? I don't want to tell them about that. Do you
- 19:33want to talk about that? No? Not really? You sure, yeah,
- 19:37I want to talk about other things. Then for me, there's literally
- 19:41thousands of things I could initiate from that point or direct or encourage or something
- 19:45emphasize, one of which is what you went to, which is an option
- 19:51for sure, and I might do that, But if we always go in
- 19:55those directions, then it points to an inner drive for us as a clinician
- 19:59that there's priority, And that's fine. But for me, I reflect on
- 20:03that and I say, well, is that my priority is that the client's
- 20:06priority? Because you know, to be specific about this client, she had
- 20:08a ton of trauma and the addiction was a symptom of that, and the
- 20:15addiction priority was far lower than the trauma and the family dynamics priority. For
- 20:22me, Now, if from that point forward she just didn't want to talk
- 20:26about anything again, that would be up to her. But I would at
- 20:29some point say, so, you know, just throwing it out there.
- 20:33If you actually are here to work on things, you know, I'm going
- 20:36to suggest, you know, one of these things you should probably do anyway.
- 20:42But in the drug and alcohol group, when it was discovered that she
- 20:47had relapsed, they were very pointed about it. And the benefit to them
- 20:52is that, you know, essentially, when you're going through recovery, whether
- 20:56it's from cutting, or from opiates or from gaming, there is a benefit
- 21:03to having a social social consequence if you will to the target behavior. That
- 21:11if you're alone and you're you know, staying in the bathroom about to engage
- 21:17in the target behavior, and you think, oh, you know, I'm
- 21:21going to have to tell my fellow group members and my teacher who I like
- 21:26and respect, that I relapsed. And I don't want to have to do
- 21:30that. I don't have to disappoint them, I don't want to have to
- 21:33talk about it. I don't want to have to admit that I did this,
- 21:38you know whatever, That has a healthy benefit to the individual. Humans
- 21:45do function by accountability, right yeah, So when these individuals sign up for
- 21:51these programs, I would hope that they were told this is our approach,
- 21:55and when you are consenting to this treatment, then this is what you're signing
- 22:00up for. Yeah, for sure. And so it's a voluntary thing and
- 22:03people want that. You know, when people go to an eeniosorder treatment program,
- 22:10there's there's a similar vibe often of we're not here to just be all
- 22:15touchy feely, We're here to actually stop this behavior. You're going to recover,
- 22:22and if you're going to do that, we have some ground rules.
- 22:25And but I feel like the clinicians need to admit to themselves that they're that
- 22:30they are adopting that point of view and say to themselves there's pros and cons
- 22:34of this. Right, it can come across as judgmental at times and hurtful
- 22:40and alienating to someone, and it's a model that seems to work in Without
- 22:44it, then it doesn't seem to work as well. You know, to
- 22:48get to the drug and alcohol thing, which I'm much more familiar with.
- 22:49For example, the example that I gave of the client telling me that she
- 22:52had used didn't actually happen, but the real thing that happened was she had
- 22:56a dirty urinalysis test and it came up positive for opiates, but it was
- 23:03just it was like barely, and you know, it wasn't a lot,
- 23:07and occasionally these tests are wrong, you know, they fail false positives.
- 23:12And they confronted her about it, and she was very convincing, lee saying
- 23:18that she did not use, and a lot of the drug and alcohol folks
- 23:22believed her, but some didn't. And I didn't really know or care because
- 23:26it wasn't really my area. But I did kind of believe her, and
- 23:30I know it was a topic of our individual therapy. She'd be like,
- 23:33I can't believe they don't believe me. I didn't do what I understand,
- 23:36And it had been in months that she hadn't used, so it wasn't like
- 23:40she had just recovered, right, She had seemingly had a many months of
- 23:45not using, and there wasn't really any reason for her to every lapse,
- 23:48so it didn't really make any sense. Well, long story short, comes
- 23:51out later that she absolutely had relapsed, not only with that but with a
- 23:55whole other set of behaviors. But before I found that out, there were
- 23:57drug and alcohol folks that were my colleagues who were very I don't want to
- 24:03other word but judgmental that she had used and that she was lying about it,
- 24:08and when we would consult about the client, we just had a very
- 24:12different philosophy about how to help this person. Well, I don't want to
- 24:18presume, though, that because you had that experience of them being judgmental,
- 24:22that your thesis that DBT people are judgmental because they have an agenda is accurate.
- 24:27Bad DBT therapists are no Kenby, But well, well, my thesis
- 24:33is that it's a it's at least in that larger camp that is very different
- 24:38from the way that I operate constantly. And it was helpful though, because
- 24:42and I'm not saying that she, this colleague of mine, was a dick
- 24:45about it. She was just very good. She was a drug and alcoholic
- 24:48person and people loved her, and she was to the point and she was
- 24:52nice, strong yea. And sometimes there were conflicts between her and the clients,
- 24:59right, but ultimately they would come around if they were truly on the
- 25:02road to recovery. Whereas for me, someone could continue to engage in the
- 25:07addiction or the target behavior and I would I guess quote unquote be loose and
- 25:14quote unquote let it go. One could argue enable it because I might buy
- 25:18into a philosophy of of supporting the foundation of the behavior instead of actually confronting
- 25:26it. But I know the pros and the cons to that side of things.
- 25:30You know, the pros are that clients feel free to talk with you
- 25:32about things. The con is that with particular things, maybe I'm not particularly
- 25:37helpful in that way anyway. So might the drug and alcohol person have a
- 25:41lot of false positives herself because she she was suspicious of everybody, you know,
- 25:47every everyone was lying and everything. I mean, not really, but
- 25:49you know, she was very quick to be like, oh, she's using
- 25:52oh and and there's no way that she had that ability to see those things
- 26:00automatically. So I'm guessing that there were times when she was overly quick to
- 26:04jump to that conclusion. But what it did help is that it accelerated this
- 26:08client's process of recovery, because if they were all even just in my direction,
- 26:15then we would have all believed her that she just had a false positive
- 26:19owny ua, and she would have gone further into the addiction, and there
- 26:22would have been consequences to that, and she doesn't want that. The client,
- 26:26you know, a good part of her was actually wanting to recover.
- 26:29So in the end, I don't know if this happened, but I wouldn't
- 26:30be surprised if she thanked this other drunken alcohol counselor for not believing her bullshit.
- 26:36And you know, I'm sure the client didn't hate me, but probably
- 26:37was thinking, well, he's good for some things, but not for others,
- 26:41you know. And so I think in the in the DBT world,
- 26:47I don't know. I'm guessing it's not that far obviously, because that's not
- 26:49rarely what you're focusing on, right, you're in the DBT world. You're
- 26:52focusing on a much more familiar camp for me of bolsha, regulation and compassion
- 26:59and sending it to people in understanding. Right. But it seems just my
- 27:03observation from the outside that there's a theme of that drug and alcohol. I
- 27:07don't know what to call it, but a directive. There's a directive streak
- 27:11with DBT. Oh, yeah, for sure. That was revealed by the
- 27:15word tachie. Oh so okay, so this one's really important. My use
- 27:21of a word should not be an in martial enhancer. Use of the word.
- 27:23I guess her use of the word should not be an indicator of an
- 27:29attitude of judgment. It's not a good DBT therapist doesn't hold any judgment.
- 27:34When you have a therapy where you have a you know where somebody's going to
- 27:40subscribe if they want to do the therapy, they're subscribing to the you know,
- 27:42the structure of the thing, and you know there's is suicidal and non
- 27:47suicidal self injury have to you know, they have to go because they're going
- 27:52to lead to premature depth. And that's that's our stance, and so when
- 27:53you sign on with us, that's what you sign on for. As soon
- 27:56as you have a scar, excuse me, soon as you have a priority
- 28:02or an agenda, you have to let it go at the same time because
- 28:07there will be people, meaning the counselor yeah, because there will be people
- 28:11who cannot be helped. We don't have a therapy that helps everybody. That's
- 28:18just just think about it for a sec We don't have we don't have medical
- 28:21treatment that helps everybody. We don't have psychotherapy that helps everybody. So so,
- 28:25but the minute, so, the minute you put in a structure,
- 28:29you set yourself up for this kind of sense of frustration and futility and potential
- 28:37for judgment depending on how a therapist processes their own countertransference, meaning that you
- 28:41should be expected at some point to terminate with clients on the basis that this
- 28:48model isn't going to help them. Well, yeah, I'm saying it poorly.
- 28:51No, what I think a good therapist is going to have to be
- 28:56able to tolerate frustration because you won't. You won't be able to shift everybody's
- 29:00behavior, so somebody you might lose, somebody to suicide. And that doesn't
- 29:06mean that what you're doing is garbage, or it doesn't mean that the client
- 29:08failed. In fact, in DBT they talk about this very specifically part of
- 29:12me. They say, clients cannot fail in therapy. It's impossible. What
- 29:21can fail is therapy meaning we don't have a therapy that helps everybody, or
- 29:25a therapists meaning that therapist didn't apply the principles and protocols of the of the
- 29:32therapy in order to help the client. But the client cannot fail. It's
- 29:36sort of like when you go to the surgeon because you have appendicitis and they
- 29:41take your penis out and you die on the table. That ain't your fault.
- 29:44You just you have this problem. You showed up and either the surgeon
- 29:48failed because you know, they nicked an artery, or maybe we don't have
- 29:52a surgery that helps everybody because everybody's anatomy is a little bit different, and
- 29:56maybe we haven't captured how to do appendectomy for you know, this particular kind
- 30:02of anatomy. I don't know how that works. But but nobody says,
- 30:04oh, well, yeah, the patient patient failed because they died. So
- 30:08same same, same with therapy. So in aketo, aketo is fascinating.
- 30:15It doesn't matter. A keto has no offensive moves, and they have this
- 30:18saying. They say, whoever grabs loses. So the minute I reach out
- 30:23and grab your arm, I have now attached myself to a particular agenda.
- 30:27You haven't grabbed me. You're gonna win this one because I am giving you
- 30:32my energy and all you have to do is dance with it, and you
- 30:34dance with it properly. I'll be on the floor in just a couple of
- 30:37seconds. So it's the one who grabs. So if a therapist grabs,
- 30:44they're gonna lose. So you gotta hold loosely. You got to hold.
- 30:48I mean, if this is what you believe, you believe, well,
- 30:49we've got to get an SSI off the table because because you know, it
- 30:55leads to premature to the fine, and you won't get it off the table
- 30:59in the in the timeframe that you want for all people, or for some
- 31:03you won't get it off at all. And that has to be okay.
- 31:06So nobody can get kicked out of There's only one way out of a DBT
- 31:10skills class. They have a specific rule about this, and that's if you
- 31:12miss coming four times in a row, that's it. You do self harm
- 31:17in the class. No, not a grounds for getting kicked out. Yeah,
- 31:19that's the student who had done the target behavior in the middle of the
- 31:23class was not kicked out. Hell no, no, she's mostly a most
- 31:26welcome person in the class. If you miss four in a row, that's
- 31:30it. If you quit, you're not out unless you missed four in a
- 31:33row. So I've had people quit and then show up two weeks later and
- 31:36like, okay, welcome back. That's it. But you can't get kicked
- 31:38out for doing a target behavior ever. You just can't because that would just
- 31:44be just being a dick. He kicked somebody out because they had the behavior
- 31:49that they should have been therapy to try to get a hold of. That's
- 31:52just crazy, and it's a belief in the individual that they can recover from
- 31:57the behavior. It's a hey, you know, I know you can do
- 32:01it, and so let's let's do this and we'll give you the tools,
- 32:06and the expectation is is that there's going to be abstinence from that behavior.
- 32:10Well, it's been a little long, but let's take a break here,
- 32:14we get back, let's continue the conversation. What do you say, Yes,
- 32:21okay, we're back from the break. Another field that I worked in
- 32:24that it had this element was in domestic violence treatment the perpetrators. It wasn't
- 32:30I don't know if we had it explicitly stated, but it was obvious that
- 32:34if they were violent with their spouse, then we were not going to just
- 32:38let that go for example, right, And we had a very pointed,
- 32:45I would argue, even judgmental in that in that instance directive that violence and
- 32:50control and abuse of anyone, particularly their spouse, because that was usually what
- 32:55landed them in the group to begin with, was off the table and they
- 32:59were going to do that. I don't think they would have been kicked out
- 33:01of the group, but we would have absolutely carved out time to talk about
- 33:06it. If it happened, we would have been very pointed. You know,
- 33:09if they justified it or said I didn't start it or something would we
- 33:15would say that doesn't fly with us. Or if they said I don't want
- 33:19to talk about it, we'd say fuck you were going to talk about it.
- 33:22The other group members would join in because the more advanced participants had recovered
- 33:27sufficiently personality why such that they were on the other side of the rubicon and
- 33:31could speak more plainly to the other participants. And it's for the good of
- 33:38the client themselves, of course, it's good for the people around them.
- 33:43And I get that. Yeah, And it's I think it needs to be
- 33:46recognized, and it was recognized to me at the time that it's that it's
- 33:51a choice. It's not necessarily and it doesn't naturally emerge from the work.
- 33:54It's a decision that you're making clinically that you believe to be the right move
- 33:59for that person. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, So that's all I'm saying
- 34:02is that I hadn't realized that about the DBT thing, Like when when we
- 34:06brought that up in the last episode. I thought you would be and DBT
- 34:10in general, because I think of DBT as a therapy technique. But and
- 34:15it is, but it has this this element of directiveness. I suppose that
- 34:22I just didn't know that it was there. Yeah, I didn't. I
- 34:24didn't especially I didn't know that you would actually do anything like that. But
- 34:28I absolutely understand the utility of it, and overall, ninety nine percent of
- 34:31time, I'm sure that it's it's extremely helpful. And to have you know,
- 34:36for example, my attitude general attitude about cutting would be terrible in a
- 34:40group like that, just be like, well, you know whatever, you
- 34:43know, it would would not be helpful to the group. You would I
- 34:47can't imagine you being glibly dismissive about such a thing. No, But if
- 34:52say a client came in and said that they had cut the night before and
- 34:55they just set it flippantly or even in a glorify way, and I said,
- 35:01huh, well do you want to talk about that and they said no,
- 35:05I'm good. It would just go right past me and I'll be like,
- 35:07okay, well, what is the group when I talk about Like if
- 35:09I were running right right, it wasn't That's what I would do, right,
- 35:15And you could argue that isn't ultimately helpful. You know, this was
- 35:17really good feedback for me because I've been had that word in my lexicon for
- 35:22years just because you know, I just I'm a great mimic. I just
- 35:27mimic what I've heard. Um. So the feedback that that word, it
- 35:32has a judgy edge to it. It's like it's not something I would have
- 35:37recognized. But I'm glad to have gotten the feedback. A little embarrassed by
- 35:39it. But wow, when when does not wish to be um? Um,
- 35:47it's a yeah, dis yeah, Well that's why when you said it,
- 35:52I thought, well, that doesn't fit with what that word beads to
- 35:57me. And I think, to some of the listeners, what does not
- 36:00fit with the way I see you? And so that's when I said,
- 36:05well, but you know, and then you clarified it from that point,
- 36:08but you know, maybe not maybe not sufficiently. Yeah, but it is
- 36:14a good discussion, and I think for just for clinicians out there, it's
- 36:17important to understand because I've you know, like another I'll just say this one
- 36:22last asterisk is that people will sometimes talk about motivational interviewing and solution focused therapy
- 36:30and think of them as the same, And they do look very similar,
- 36:34but they're fundamentally completely at opposite ends of the spectrum. And it's sort of
- 36:38in this camp and I and I and I totally value motivational interview So just
- 36:44to give a short primer on it is with motivational interviewings maybe a little easier
- 36:47to describe. Essentially, it emerged out of drug and alcohol treatment and instead
- 36:52of you know, if someone sits down and in terms of stage of change,
- 36:57they're pre contemplative, meaning that they haven't identified fully or even even halfway
- 37:01that they have a problem with alcohol. For example. Yeah, but you
- 37:06know, quote unquote as a clinician that the person is drinking every day throughout
- 37:12the day. It absolutely is a problem for them, and you can see
- 37:15all the all the consequences of their chronic drinking. They've lost their job,
- 37:19their relationships, their health is falling apart, their sleep is bad, you
- 37:22know, And so you know in quotes that the client isn't denial and that
- 37:28what would be best for the client is if they stop drinking. But you
- 37:30can't just yell at them and say stop drinking that isn't helpful. It's more
- 37:34helpful to lead them down a road where they can make that choice themselves and
- 37:37can realize it themselves. So they call this thing motivational interviewing, where you
- 37:42interview in a way that will promote motivation. And you will say okay,
- 37:45well, and they teach you how not to be judgmental or to push back.
- 37:52You accept with an asterisk, and you will say okay, so how
- 37:58is your drinking? Well, yeah, I drink all day yesterday. Okay,
- 38:00how do you feel about it? And the client says, I feel
- 38:02fine about it, And as the clinician, you say, okay, so
- 38:06you feel fine about it? Every everything's good? Yeah, everything's good.
- 38:08Okay, Well, let me ask you some questions and totally up to you
- 38:12know, you're very, very tentative, but you know where you're heading.
- 38:15So you ask the client, well, so, how are things going in
- 38:19your life? Let's not even talk about alcohol, like how are things And
- 38:22then eventually you get the client they will say, well, yeah, you
- 38:25know, my life is kind of falling apart, and as a clinician you
- 38:29say, okay, well, what do you think the factors are in that?
- 38:31And in the back of your mind. You know what the main factor
- 38:35is is that they're drinking, but you ask it in a way that's very
- 38:38curious and it doesn't have anything that you're assuming. You're you're coming across like
- 38:44you're not assuming, and so the client feels free to explore without judgment,
- 38:50because the idea is that if a client is given the space, they will
- 38:52lead themselves to that because it's logical, it's obvious. It's they know they
- 38:58have everyone on the planet is that their alcohol's problem, but they maybe I've
- 39:01never had a non judgmental, non shaming space to actually have the freedom to
- 39:06fully go there and to discover that for themselves. So that's the idea with
- 39:09motivational interviewing. With solution focused it can look like that, but the major
- 39:15difference is that with susan focused therapy, the therapist has no idea where the
- 39:21client will end up and has no agenda. With the motivational interviewing folks,
- 39:24they absolutely know quote unquote where the client should end up, and they know
- 39:30exactly what the client should be motivated to eventually realize and take action on the
- 39:36solution focused person. It is fundamental to that form of therapy that they drill
- 39:42it into their head and divorce themselves from any notion that they know it's best.
- 39:45For example, with a solution focused person, it's not likely, but
- 39:49they could work with an alcoholic and that person could eventually come to the conclusion
- 39:53that alcohol is not the factor that is in the way of them changing their
- 39:59life, and in fact it's their job or something else or their relationships.
- 40:04And so the client learns that they need or think differently or something like that.
- 40:07And the solution focused person not only on the surface, but deep down,
- 40:13they have conditioned themselves to believe that or to you know, go with
- 40:19where the client is, because the belief is is that if you do that,
- 40:22the client will eventually gravitate towards what is best for them. To belief
- 40:28in the innate capacity of a human to find their pathway to well being in
- 40:32welfare, yeah, it's an innate belief like that's a that's Rogers has a
- 40:37similar attitude exactly, and in innate belief that you know nothing about what a
- 40:43client should or should not do that and to believe that is hubrious and counter
- 40:49to therapy, counter to help. So you really have to demote yourself in
- 40:55that that assumption and it's hard for any human to douar therapists. Oh yeah,
- 41:00So social focus is a is a very different philosophy and I've played in
- 41:07that space a lot, and it's very it's very freeing. It really liberates.
- 41:13I liberated myself. You know. Narrative therapies, like all the quote
- 41:16unquote postmodern therapist cloud roo therapies are in this camp. And it's a wonderful
- 41:22place to be. For some of you who watch my reality TV reaction videos,
- 41:27you might have you know, complimented me or something that it's like wow,
- 41:32you know, you really just don't judge people. And a lot of
- 41:36it actually comes from that. It's not a people will label me as being
- 41:39wholesome, as if I'm nice. I don't think I'm particularly nice. I
- 41:44just have a philosophy that I have been demoting myself and realizing for myself that
- 41:51it's actually and there's many instances points of learning, right, because when you're
- 41:55a therapist, there's a lot of opportunity to start inserting yourself and start saying,
- 42:00well, I think you should do this, and when you have thirty
- 42:02years of practice, you know, it's almost like mindfulness, where you just
- 42:07get good at the at the mental process over time, where it's like you
- 42:12and I know what it feels like when I have that emerging thought of like,
- 42:15well, they're in a marriage that looks like it should break up.
- 42:20And I've had thousands of instances of being able to learn what that impulse feels
- 42:24like internally and to have effective ways of philosophically within half a second negating it.
- 42:30Not just pushing it back, but I literally just eliminating it from being
- 42:35a possible thought that I would. I was like, that's stupid, like
- 42:37and all these memories come into to focus in that half a second that are
- 42:42memories of me being wrong about stuff like that. It's like, remember,
- 42:45you've been wrong, and you've you've you've stored those away, So in this
- 42:50moment, you're you might not be wrong, but there's no way to know
- 42:53if you're right, and there's a lot of reasons to believe that you're wrong,
- 42:58and it does no good to focus on that thought. It doesn't even
- 43:01help the client, even if you are right, to believe you're right and
- 43:05to tell them they're wrong or to have that vibe in your questions is definitely
- 43:09not going to help them. You know so so with social focus and motivational
- 43:15interviewing, look can look similar but be very different. And the problem that
- 43:19I have this is this is where I was leaded. What headed was motivational
- 43:22interviewing. People will think they are I've heard this before. They will say
- 43:27they are like social focused, and they're not. You know, when you
- 43:31talk to social focus people, when they look at motivational interviewing people, they're
- 43:35like, you're not like us. You're you're fine, do your thing,
- 43:39but do not think that you are like us. You are fundamentally different from
- 43:44us because of the reasons I laid out, and that lack of self awareness
- 43:47is the problem that as a clinician, you have to understand where you are
- 43:52and instead of just believing that you're right or that you are in the philosophically
- 43:57sound area, you just have to know you're in an area and you have
- 44:00to be able to reflect on that and know the pros and the cons.
- 44:02Like for me, I could have a story that being non judgmental is the
- 44:07right way to be, but I understand that that might not always be the
- 44:09right thing given what I'm what I'm saying, and the word non judgment is
- 44:14is a you know, catch all but non directive or not having it within
- 44:19my within my set of beliefs that a particular behavior needs to change or something
- 44:23like that. And so uh, to not reflect on that and to not
- 44:28understand that you're making a choice to believe a certain thing based on the pros
- 44:31and the cons I believe to be can present some problems because it can produce
- 44:38for the clinician this notion that they have a natural belief as as opposed to
- 44:43a chosen belief for a reason, do you know what I mean? Y?
- 44:46Yeah, yeah. And so for the DBT folks um I would hope,
- 44:51or the drug and alcohol folks, or for folks like me, the
- 44:54risiian uh, I don't know what you call me, but whatever you call
- 44:59me. For the every theory of every profession, every place has comes with
- 45:05it a certain set of philosophies. And you know, they're pros and cons
- 45:08and that's great and it should be utilized in that way. But because I
- 45:14worry that people who don't know how to younger or more novice people that don't
- 45:17know how to navigate this will be brainwashed into that area, oh yeah,
- 45:23as the best area as opposed to just an area. I remember when I
- 45:29read Lenahan's book on It's called Cognitive Behavioral Therapy from Borderline Personally disturb its DBT.
- 45:37Right, I had this overlay that I could not see back then.
- 45:44When I would read, I would distort what I was reading to kind of
- 45:46match something in my worldview that had really way too much to do with my
- 45:53relationship with my father and my sense about doing the right thing, like half
- 46:00like rules, you know whatever, meaning that when you were reading it it
- 46:02felt mean or something. Um, it almost seemed like a license to be
- 46:07mean. So there's one passage in there that has to do with it's clients.
- 46:12It's in a client's interest for a therapist to want to work with them.
- 46:15You could really distort that. We'll say it again, it's in a
- 46:20client's interest for the therapist to want to work with them. It's you know
- 46:25meaning that Yeah, that's a yeah right. I think I see what you're
- 46:29saying. That. It is a way of justifying when a client is pushing
- 46:34back that regardless of what I'm doing to you, you need to appreciate what
- 46:37I'm doing to you, yeah, which is you know, that was a
- 46:40big distortion that I took me a long time to kind of even just see
- 46:45that I had it um because in the most literal sense it is true,
- 46:51in the most basic sense, depending on the therapist. Though, what do
- 46:55you mean, Well, it's not within the interest of every client to to
- 47:00give in to the therapist treatment. Oh yeah, No, No, I'm
- 47:02not saying that. I'm not saying that. The actual sentence is a client's
- 47:07going to get better therapy if the therapist wants to work with them, then
- 47:10if the therapist doesn't, Oh, I see, But this is not meant
- 47:15to be a bludgeon. It's just a basically true statement. Yeah, but
- 47:21it's very easy to distort. Yeah, it's very easy to to the other
- 47:24Well, what does she mean by that statement. I think she means that
- 47:28basically, clients are going to get better outcomes if therapists want to do that
- 47:30kind of want to want to work with them, and if client's behave in
- 47:32a way that there's more of a message to therapists, like you need to
- 47:37try to have a positive attitude about your work. Well no, that's not
- 47:43least as I remember it. That's not how she wrote it, though.
- 47:46She would say it's in your interest to love your clients. Yeah, like
- 47:51she's she's pretty warm person to her peeps, to her clients. Um um.
- 47:59But if if if like let's say, oh, this is back in
- 48:02the days of pagers, if every time my pager goes off, I'm having
- 48:06a freak out because oh shit, this might be another suicidal crisis, and
- 48:10um, that's going to affect how I interact with the person. Whether maybe
- 48:16they just want to tell me, hey, it's my kid's birthday, who
- 48:20knows, I mean, you know whatever. But if my body goes into
- 48:22fight or flight when I'm interacting with my client and that makes me kind of
- 48:27like brittle and not want to be there, my client's not going to get
- 48:30as good therapy. Now. It's not my client's job to manage me,
- 48:34that's mine. Yeah. And you know, one, that's one thing that
- 48:38probably we're always you know, honing or managing our own feelings. Um or
- 48:45I should just speak for myself, I'm always honing. Um um. So
- 48:52so well, boy, actually, let me think about this for a sec.
- 49:01I noticed that I don't want to talk about it any further because I
- 49:05will say in such a way that will be interpreted as clients have to accommodate
- 49:13therapists, and I don't mean that, so I probably can't talk about it.
- 49:15Well, but your intention was to say what exactly that it's actually clients
- 49:22get better outcomes of therapists like working with them. Yeah. Right, So
- 49:25you're saying that when you were reading the book that it can come across in
- 49:30a way that isn't representative of what the work is actually like or even what
- 49:37Marshall Lenahanna's really like. And then if you actually go through them that's what
- 49:39I'm saying the whole thing, then you see like, well, there's language
- 49:43in there that you could interpret it, but when you actually know what she's
- 49:46referring to you in the culture of it all, it's it's it's it's not
- 49:50it's not it's not mean, it's not just mental. I that was the
- 49:54biggest benefit I got from working for her is a re a re learning of
- 50:02what the heck she's trying to do. Because what she's trying to do and
- 50:07what I told myself she was trying to do when I read that book,
- 50:09don't even they're not they're not very close. So and I just attribute that
- 50:15to either you know, maybe it's not the best of writers. That was
- 50:16a hard book to get through, but also I have it. Well,
- 50:22you know, bad breath, hard to smell your own, so am I
- 50:27get a chance to smell mine? I feel like I'm the first person that
- 50:30smells my own bad breath. Don't you smell your bad breath? Now?
- 50:35Man? When I was see, I was about thirty one thirty two,
- 50:39went to work. David Kurzy, my good friend. Oh no, it
- 50:44comes into my office and he's like, you remember the other day when you
- 50:45said friends tell friends tough stuff, like because I think I told him me
- 50:49it's a book or something, and he said, oh, thanks, thanks
- 50:52for telling me. I'm like, well, friends tell He's like, you
- 50:54often have very bad breath often? Yeah, yes, Now I have lots
- 51:00of dental work, very bad breath. Oh yeah, he was not kidding.
- 51:04And I mean, I've never known you to have a better h Yeah,
- 51:07so um, I didn't know. And I have a lot of dental
- 51:13work that, you know, like lends itself to that as a possibility.
- 51:16So occasionally calling him be like, oh, could you brush him floss?
- 51:22And I may have just brushed him floss that morning and it's five in the
- 51:24afternoon, and things that fermented a bit in my face. So so you
- 51:31know, I'll just go brush in floss because I know this and almost I
- 51:34take it mead that gives me a bit of dry mouth, so oh really
- 51:37yeah, so um, it's it's fine. I mean I get it,
- 51:42and it's I was really glad to get the advice. That was mortifying to
- 51:45be told. Yeah, but thank god someone so so yeah. I mean
- 51:50I would sit in a very small room and sometimes have two people, like
- 51:52a client and an interpreter, because I worked with a lot of foreign language,
- 51:57non English speaking folk and I don't know how I put them both through
- 52:01it. Like, but one time I remember the interpreter. Oh she's lovely
- 52:06where you never forget her. She's a model. She's on the cover of
- 52:09Time magazine. Like, if you look up Time magazine, they did an
- 52:14article on Migraine. That's her face on the cover it she looks very a
- 52:17lot of distressed anyways. Actually, so for a Migraine, she's just a
- 52:20model. She's just a model that they used for Yeah that's funny, but
- 52:23lovely, lovely, lovely. Um. Anyways, she would be like Bob,
- 52:29you would a mint and I'd say, oh, no thanks, I
- 52:32said no thanks. I didn't know I had bad breath at the time,
- 52:36And then I'm like, oh, she wasn't. But that's classic that.
- 52:40Yeah, never turned down a mint, that's what they're saying. I Yeah,
- 52:44one time I offered him into a client because I was having one,
- 52:49and she's like, do I have bad breath? And I'm like, no,
- 52:50no, pretty sure it's me. Yeah, So anyways, how do
- 52:54we get on this? Oh, bad breath? It's hard to smell your
- 52:58own, it was. I didn't know. I was really glad to find
- 53:00out, because you know, who wants to come near that? Yeah,
- 53:05so kind of in theme. I don't think you actually meant it this way.
- 53:08I don't think maybe did. Was that when you are indoctrinated into a
- 53:14philosophy of therapy and a treatment model, that it's hard to see the woods
- 53:20for the trees because you're in the woods or whatever, right, And when
- 53:22an outsider actually goes, huh, well that's an interesting word, let's talk
- 53:28about it. Yeah, it gives one an opportunity to reflect on the foundation.
- 53:35Not a bad one, but it's an area that you're in, right.
- 53:37And Two, Yeah, that what I've seen and I'm not saying it
- 53:42about you and I don't even know if i'd know anyone from DBT that's like
- 53:45this, But I have seen people within social focused folks. I've seen people
- 53:49within motivational interviewing folks, within drug and alcohol groups that when you're outside pointing
- 53:54out the bad breath or just the breath, it's let you say it's bad,
- 54:00and you're saying and you're saying, you're in an area. You know
- 54:04you're in an area, and there are other areas that are that are valid
- 54:07and their own pros and const and you get pushback from those individuals saying that
- 54:14you're wrong, no other area is valid. Then you're talking about a cult
- 54:19member. But I mean, to be frank, you're talking about a brainwashed
- 54:22person who either is insecure or they've been brainwashed by other insecure breaks. And
- 54:29if you can't reflect and criticize your own model and see it, then you're
- 54:34lost, truly. So the fact that you can do that is healthy.
- 54:38A good rule of thumb for me is if it doesn't have compassion and humility
- 54:45embedded in it, it's probably missing something important. Yeah, all right,
- 54:49take a break, we get back more questions. Would you say, yep,
- 54:55okay, Bob, we're back from the break Anonymous from Ireland. She
- 55:00says, Hi, Kirk and Bob, I'm a big fan. I'm a
- 55:04fairly new clinician. I'm finding that I tend to be more anxious before sessions
- 55:07with clients that I have a good relationship with. It's like, I'm afraid
- 55:12I will mess things up. Please, can you share your thoughts? So
- 55:15I want to punt on this one and give my self a chance. Can
- 55:20you just say your thoughts and I'll chime in when I have some Uh okay,
- 55:25Well, yeah, so you're saying, Anonymous from Ireland that with when
- 55:30you think of all your clients, you get the most anxious with clients that
- 55:35you have the best relationship with, people that you feel comfortable with, or
- 55:39people that you have a deeper relationship with. And I don't know, but
- 55:44yeah, it sounds like for these folks you understand the weight of the matter,
- 55:50you actually well, I don't know. I guess you'd really have to
- 55:52think about what it is that is causing the fear. Is it that you
- 55:57are now in a place where you actually can help help and you don't feel
- 56:00like you know what you're doing. Maybe with these other folks, the people
- 56:06you don't have a good relationship with I'll give an example for me. When
- 56:10I was a wrestler, I was not good at the first step of wrestling,
- 56:16which was the takedown, but I was good at everything else. I
- 56:19was good at reversals, I was good at I was good at pinning people.
- 56:22I was good at scorming my way out of things. I was good
- 56:25at escapes, but I was not good at takedowns. And when we had
- 56:30a tournament where I went up against my nemesis in the league, he was
- 56:36the one guy that was difficult for me, and it was really embarrassing because
- 56:42it was the one time when a bunch of people came to the match.
- 56:45Usually people didn't come to wrestling matches, but this one was, like,
- 56:47I think, on like a Friday night, and like almost everyone in the
- 56:51school showed up, and I went up against my nemesis and I lost to
- 56:54him because he was very good at takedowns, but he wasn't good at the
- 56:57rest. So it was sort of like this opportunity for me to shine athletic
- 57:01prowess, but because the whole tournament was organized around his skills, I lost
- 57:07miserably. At the end of the season, I ended up beating him in
- 57:09the championship. It was hard. But the point is is that for you,
- 57:14you might be like my nemesis. You're good at the beginning, but
- 57:16then once you get the good relationship, you don't feel as confident or something
- 57:20like that. And so maybe you have a general insecurity. But there's one
- 57:25thing you know what to do, which is actually to develop a close relationship,
- 57:30to be able to listen or something. You know. The possibility is
- 57:32that the bad quote unquote bad relationship or the neutral relationship clients they are not
- 57:38in therapy because they want to be necessarily or you just kind of feel like,
- 57:43well, they're kind of phoning it in, so I don't really need
- 57:46to worry. It's not really my fault or something. Anyway, I had
- 57:50that thought too, like maybe what happens is we fragilize the good relationship.
- 57:53We treat it like, oh, it's gonna go to heck, and the
- 57:59relationship that you know is the neutral and the bad one we're not afraid of.
- 58:04You know. It's sort of like, I ain't got nothing to lose
- 58:06here. I'm going to leave it all on the mat, so to speak,
- 58:08and show up with my full self, but maybe one one gets stuck
- 58:15in being worried about maintaining and loses focus on, you know, whatever good
- 58:21therapy happens to be, you know, in favor of what's to maintain the
- 58:25good relationship. Yeah, so it's also just possible that you're still learning and
- 58:34you're recognizing what's at stake, and that you know who knows. But I'm
- 58:39guessing if someone were to work with you, and obviously talk with your supervisor
- 58:43and mentor about this, but the likelihood is pretty high that the best thing
- 58:49you can do is to return to fundamentals of listening and of caring for your
- 58:53clients and having compassion and creating a space for them to explore. And you
- 58:59might be over thinking it. A lot of novice therapists do. There's this
- 59:02notion that somehow the word I would always use was tinkering. I'd be like,
- 59:07stop trying to tinker. There's nothing to tinker, and there's no method
- 59:10of tinkering, you know, there's I think people think of therapy as the
- 59:15you know, to use a metaphor, it's like they're opening up like Siler
- 59:19did and the Heroes the TV show where he'd open up someone's skull and he
- 59:22would he would figure out the brain and then he would adopt things. And
- 59:28so there's this notion of like, Okay, I'm gonna I'm gonna use this
- 59:31one sentence or I'm gonna I'm gonna create this one intervention and then that will
- 59:37turn everything around. And you know, there's some mild truth to that,
- 59:39but to focus on that as a therapist is uh is misguided and a set
- 59:45up for failure and anxiety. UM. You know, so I would say,
- 59:49you know, stop stop tinkering and start listening. Stop tinkering, stopless
- 59:53um annual patron Moira. She says, I want to be a therapist.
- 59:58I'm completing my undergrad at at the moment, I'm currently in therapy. My
- 1:00:01biggest problem at the moment it is having disorganized attachment. I worry that it
- 1:00:05skews my perspective and that I won't be able to provide the help I want
- 1:00:09because of my own baggage. Do you have any advice? Yeah, great
- 1:00:15place to start. It will at times skew your perspective because that's the that's
- 1:00:22just the nature of the thing. So the good thing you got going for
- 1:00:24you is you got awareness that that does indeed happen. It will happen,
- 1:00:29So keep keep at it. It's going to follow you into graduate school and
- 1:00:32then into your clinical work. And your job isn't to try to prevent that.
- 1:00:37Your job is to learn from it. Each time it does, have
- 1:00:39some humility and talk to your supervisor, your mentor whoever is in your corner
- 1:00:45so that you can well, that's like that autobiography in five short chapters by
- 1:00:53Porsche Nelson. Do you know this poem? Well? I won't be able
- 1:00:58to remember it all of it, but basically it's Chapter one. I walked
- 1:01:01down the street. There's a deep hole in the sidewalk. I fall in.
- 1:01:05I'm lost, I'm there. It takes a long time to get out.
- 1:01:08Chapter two, I walked down the sidewalk. There's a deep hole in
- 1:01:10the sidewalk. I fall in. I'm here again. It's not my fault.
- 1:01:15I takes forever to get out. Chapter three is I walk down the
- 1:01:19sidewalk, there's a deep hole. I fall in. I know this place.
- 1:01:22It's my fault. I get out immediately. Chapter four, Oh no,
- 1:01:27that's chapter three. Chapter four is what I just said, and then
- 1:01:30chapter five is oh oh no. Chapter four I walked down the sidewalk,
- 1:01:34there's a deep hole. I walk around it. In chapter five, is
- 1:01:37I walk down a different sidewalk where there will be another deep hole, and
- 1:01:42that we will fall in, Because that's just the nature of learning. The
- 1:01:45things I struggled with now aren't the things I struggled with five years ago,
- 1:01:49or fifteen years ago or twenty five years ago. And the things that I
- 1:01:52struggle with ten years from now I won't be the same as the things that
- 1:01:55are here now. And that's one of the great things about being a therapist
- 1:02:01is this perpetual opportunity to grow. It's really quite lovely and profound thing to
- 1:02:10I'm quite privileged to have that as my profession. So it's going to happen,
- 1:02:16Moira, That's okay. You can just keep learning and you'll be all
- 1:02:22right. When you say you you're not struggling with the same things today as
- 1:02:25you were before. What do you mean by that, Well, in the
- 1:02:30old days, I would say that I was not clear about some things that
- 1:02:37are I'm really glad I'm glad to know about now. Like I didn't understand
- 1:02:40compassion and I didn't understand its utility, and so there was a I have
- 1:02:46an edge. I can have an edge. There was an edge in my
- 1:02:50work back then that wouldn't be now. And then later I didn't understand attachment
- 1:02:55and actually had opportunity to learn about that, but didn't understand that learning about
- 1:03:00that was absolutely fundamental, and so didn't And then they did and they're like,
- 1:03:06oh, yeah, that's going to change. That changes a lot about
- 1:03:08how I work. And am I answering your question? I forget? Oh
- 1:03:20shit, Well, I also wonder I think what I was wondering about is
- 1:03:27do you the things you when you refer to things that you struggle with?
- 1:03:30Are you saying things in clinical work or things in your personal life? Oh?
- 1:03:35I was thinking about clinical work, though there clearly are personal things too,
- 1:03:37Okay, So so clinically, in the past you would struggle with compassion,
- 1:03:43whereas today you don't not so much. Yeah and yeah, yeah,
- 1:03:47I mean organized attachment to any attachment, any sort of issue. There's two
- 1:03:52things at play. Often would people ask these questions. One is that there's
- 1:03:57a stigma or some kind of expect that therapists are perfect or something like this,
- 1:04:01and yeah, and then you'll also have the opposite belief that all therapists
- 1:04:05are screwed up or something, And it's just like, you know, therapists,
- 1:04:11and what do we mean by a spectrum of being screwed up? Exactly
- 1:04:15right? It doesn't really hold water to think about life like that, you
- 1:04:18know, because for example, for you, on a one scale in terms
- 1:04:23of attachment and abuse syndromes within your personality, you're you're at the high end,
- 1:04:30but you're also one of the most healthy, self aware, compassionate people
- 1:04:35on the planet. So which one is it? You know, are you
- 1:04:41in terms of when they say you will all therapists are crazy? Are you
- 1:04:44one of the crazy people? Are you one of the non crazy people?
- 1:04:46So it's it's nonsensical. The way that I look at it is that I
- 1:04:51rather recently, I think I've said this on the podcast when I figured it
- 1:04:55out. I rather recently figured out that no one is not on a personality
- 1:05:00sort of spectrum. No one is not prone to insecure attachment feelings and behaviors.
- 1:05:08You know, there's also and it took me a long time to kind
- 1:05:11of figure that out. And I think about a few years ago I just
- 1:05:14did a mental inventory of everyone that I know, because you know, client
- 1:05:17wise, that's one population, right, But if I were to think about
- 1:05:23everyone in my life, every coworker, every family member, every friend,
- 1:05:29I just you know, over time, especially if I have enough time with
- 1:05:33people, I just passively note, oh that's a trauma for that person,
- 1:05:38or oh that's a schema, or oh that's a personally sort of trait right
- 1:05:42there. I don't people say, oh, I'm analyzing everyone. It's like,
- 1:05:45well, that's not really how I look at it. It's it's just
- 1:05:47noticing the humanity if and sometimes it's explicitly discussed, you know, it's like,
- 1:05:53quote unquote, I've diagnosed you with disorganized attachment. No, we've just
- 1:05:57had conversations that have led us in that natural direction. Right. So people
- 1:06:01that study birds can look at a bird and know what bird it is,
- 1:06:04Right, They're not analyzing the bird, they just write. They just note
- 1:06:08it. Yeah, it's just something you notice, because why would you not.
- 1:06:12Plus it's a big part of getting to know someone. It's a way
- 1:06:15that I will experience people. Of course I'm not thinking about it consciously usually,
- 1:06:20but anyway, you're conversant, influent in therapy. Yeah, we're going
- 1:06:26back, you know. And so with everyone that I that I know,
- 1:06:30I'm like, wow, I can't think of really anyone who is that sort
- 1:06:34of person that I thought existed in the past, which was always sure themselves,
- 1:06:42never overreactive, just this light as a feather walking through life, and
- 1:06:49and everything is happy, go lucky. You know, when you talk to
- 1:06:53the gurus that are actually good, you know, the like people like the
- 1:06:57Dalai Lama, these f folks, when you present this attitude to them,
- 1:07:00because a lot of people think of them like that, and they will dispel
- 1:07:03it. Often it doesn't go over well with the population because they don't really
- 1:07:08hear it. They don't want to believe it. But they'll say, I'm
- 1:07:11not any better than you. I'm just as prone to anger and to sadness
- 1:07:15and to attachments and to being upset about things. I overreact. There's a
- 1:07:21bad part of my personality. I you know, I just engage in a
- 1:07:27practice that is I believe helpful to me and others around me. When I
- 1:07:31speak, I speak from that place of a lot of time thinking and talking
- 1:07:36about this sort of thing. But I'm not any healthier than you. If
- 1:07:41you knew me, you would know that that I just, you know,
- 1:07:44I have bad moods and you know, of all these stories, and I
- 1:07:47feel like a lot of people they're just like, oh, he's just being
- 1:07:49graceful, you know, he's just being gracist. He's gracious, He's being
- 1:07:54gracist, and it's such a gracist. And but the more older I get,
- 1:08:00the more I believe them. Yeah, I think, yeah, they're
- 1:08:03probably massive dicks sometimes and they have rigid beliefs that are unattractive and not in
- 1:08:14line with what we think of them to be. The you know, these
- 1:08:16these these elevated holy you know, above it all kind of people that no
- 1:08:21one like that exists. And so thus, when you have a self awareness
- 1:08:28around disorganized attachment, Moira doesn't set You're not separate from the rest. You
- 1:08:34are. You are just aware of how common you are, you know what
- 1:08:41I mean. It's it's your thing. Disorganized attachment is your thing. But
- 1:08:45for someone else, they have a different thing. Now, some things can
- 1:08:48present perhaps more reactivity and more distortions, sure, but it's not it's not
- 1:08:55unusual, it's not strange. The other thing that I think people are operating
- 1:08:59from is that some how, when you have issues like this, it will
- 1:09:02you know, it's tempting before you become a therapist to look at your close
- 1:09:06relationships with your partners or your friends as the way a therapeutic relationship will feel
- 1:09:14like, right, But a therapeutic relationship can be very deep and can be
- 1:09:17very compassionate, it can be very involved. There are clients that I've worked
- 1:09:23with for many years who I know very very well, and sometimes I'm like,
- 1:09:30how come I can't have conversations like this with my friends or something you
- 1:09:32know, or my family members. It's it's deep, you know, but
- 1:09:36it's different, and I my personality is not really called upon. It's not
- 1:09:44really involved as much as when I'm here talking to you about I am there
- 1:09:50to provide a service. I'm there as a professional. It's a deep relationship,
- 1:09:55but I'm not There's a mode that I think practiced therapist will go into
- 1:10:00where your own insecurities aren't triggered as often, in your own issues aren't at
- 1:10:04play as often. You know, the amount of times in a regular relationship
- 1:10:10with a friend or a family member my wife, where my more unfortunate qualities
- 1:10:15of my personality will will emerge is pretty much constant. But with my clients
- 1:10:21it's it's actually kind of rare. So because you know, you keep your
- 1:10:27eye on the ball. When you're a therapist, you listen, You're in
- 1:10:30their world. You're trying to help them. A lot of therapy as the
- 1:10:33client talking, so you are free to sit back and relax and observe and
- 1:10:40care. There's not a lot of responsibility for you as a therapist to somehow
- 1:10:45fill the room with your own personality. So it's not uncommon, for example,
- 1:10:49to have a really hard time with close relationships but not have a hard
- 1:10:53time with close clients. And I've seen that before. Yeah, I've seen
- 1:10:58in fact for something. Well you tell me, Bob, like, is
- 1:11:00there souless than that for you where you will go through a tough couple of
- 1:11:05weeks with close relationships, but then with your clients. I feel like,
- 1:11:11oh, this feels like a reprieve from the difficulties of by actual in personal
- 1:11:19relationships with people. Yeah, how so, Well, it's often the case.
- 1:11:25I'm in my marriage. The edges of my insecurity are I went constants,
- 1:11:34a bit dramatic, but frequent. And that's, as you say,
- 1:11:39rare in my professional life, not unheard of, but rare, rare.
- 1:11:45And that is those experiences I have, I mean, I probably have twenty
- 1:11:51to twenty five clinical hours a week. That's a big chunk of my attention
- 1:11:55in time, and most of the time that's going pretty well. And so
- 1:12:00it's a great comfort and solace to me that, um that that's the case.
- 1:12:04And um my when when my when things in my personal life are bumpier,
- 1:12:10Yeah, for sure, it's not a substitute. It's just you know,
- 1:12:15like there are other people, you know, like I'm thinking of somebody
- 1:12:17I know who's an accountant, and when they go to work, it's a
- 1:12:21nice distraction from the problems in their life. They're just immersed in whatever it
- 1:12:26is. And then you know, they finished their day and they return home
- 1:12:28and whatever's there, you know, it waits and whatever edges that has to
- 1:12:34do that come up for them come up, and it's nice to have a
- 1:12:40break from it. Yeah. Does your disorganized attachment get triggered with your clients?
- 1:12:45Yeah? Is it very often? It was more often before, and
- 1:12:51um, is it very often? I'd say it's um every one to two
- 1:12:58months. Okay, thing will get triggered in me. Not let's let it's
- 1:13:02my older than it used to be. But it's definitely significant and it's there.
- 1:13:06Yeah, And in the past, correct me if I'm wrong. When
- 1:13:09it was triggered, the common response from you internally was judgment and anger at
- 1:13:15a client, Oh for sure, and then it would sort of shine through
- 1:13:17and your intervention or without question, it couldn't not and then maybe even become
- 1:13:24a rupture that you have to repair with a guid And when you first started
- 1:13:27out, was that true as well? When I first started out as a
- 1:13:30therapist, yeah, the first five years, oh yeah, yeah, more
- 1:13:33frequent. And one of the things that also true is I worked in a
- 1:13:39place that was highly stressful, and I was had colleagues who dedicated but also
- 1:13:50prone to burnt out and talking shit about their clients. Yeah, and then
- 1:13:55you get the attitude about what is And that's why I'm glad that when I
- 1:13:59left. I'm glad. I mean I'm glad I did leave because I found
- 1:14:01other colleagues who didn't have that kind of attitude. And I'm you know,
- 1:14:06I'm prone and vulnerable to well probably no more name well maybe a little more
- 1:14:11now other people, to absorbing my environment and observing the attitudes of those around
- 1:14:15me. So if I hadn't met people that practice in the way that I
- 1:14:21believe we ought to practice. I don't think I would have developed much.
- 1:14:25Yeah, and what would have helped you back then? What did help me
- 1:14:30was supervision and mentorship. David Taylor saved my ass. Yeah, someone that
- 1:14:36could model for you how to have compassion and not engage in the toxic work
- 1:14:43environment against clients us versus them. Yeah, and and but um and and
- 1:14:47folks who believed believed in me and supported me and guided me. I don't
- 1:14:57think he ever judged me, But I don't think he was. He no
- 1:15:00shrinking Violet either. He wasn't gonna you know, he gave me feedback and
- 1:15:05he helped me. Yeah. So for you, Moira, having someone or
- 1:15:14a group of people like that, well, for anyone would help, but
- 1:15:17particularly around things like that. And you know, maybe for you, Moira,
- 1:15:23the vulnerability would be similar. And all therapists are vulnerable to this.
- 1:15:27But yeah, if you have disorganized attachment, as a good chance you were
- 1:15:30abused growing up and have some triggers there around that, certain attitudes or statements
- 1:15:39or vibes from a client that might remind you of your abusive parents, and
- 1:15:42the way you navigate that is, you know, the way you navigate it.
- 1:15:46There's no, everything, every mistake we make as a therapist is a
- 1:15:50potential opportunity for an apology and therapy for the client. Yeah, and frankly,
- 1:15:58I guess as a side effect, therapy for ourselves to have the compassion,
- 1:16:01the self compassion, the humility, the self awareness to say, well,
- 1:16:08that was triggered and that's not my fault that it was triggered. And
- 1:16:13it's really hard to rein that in for anyone. And I'm going to absorb
- 1:16:16this and accept it and take responsibility and apologize while still retaining the foundation that
- 1:16:24I'm a good person and people make mistakes and then to apologize. So do
- 1:16:29you think that's why people have such a hard time with apology is if they
- 1:16:31say they're sorry, it means that they're a bad person. Yeah, it
- 1:16:36secks, Yeah it does. It's a big part of this awareness for me
- 1:16:42is watching reality TV and also analyzing people's apologies, is that the more insecure
- 1:16:48you are. And I guess myself as well. When I am insecure about
- 1:16:56who I am, I'm the most rigid internally in my brain that I was
- 1:17:00right right and when I you know, like I learned this in part a
- 1:17:06long time ago watching my parents actually, because when I noticed, so there
- 1:17:15were six people in my family, so in a small house. So there's
- 1:17:17a lot of communication. There's a lot of things happening. You know,
- 1:17:20you grew up in a similar house and you just can't not have moments with
- 1:17:26everyone for various purposes and reasons. And did you live in a small on
- 1:17:30the smaller end of a house. Yeah, I shared a room with my
- 1:17:32two brothers your whole childhood. Oh yeah, my god, that is actually
- 1:17:36and then we had a foster kid, so it was four of us in
- 1:17:41that room. So there was a pretty small room. It's like a third
- 1:17:45of the size of this room. So you shared a room with your two
- 1:17:47brothers the entire time of your of your childhood, h two bunk beds and
- 1:17:51a single and even you're seventeen years old, you're sharing a room with your
- 1:17:56younger brother. Yeah, my whole growing up life, Danny and I I
- 1:18:00did not know that we slept together for that sucks man. And I have
- 1:18:06your own room. I never did have my own room till I was in
- 1:18:10college and I was in ra A. That was the first time. I
- 1:18:14golly, you did live at a small house. I mean, our house
- 1:18:16is pretty small too, but not that small. Did you have your own
- 1:18:23room? Yeah? I had my own room. So the house had five
- 1:18:27I mean well had four bedrooms plus like another room that they converted into a
- 1:18:30bedroom. So yeah, you could say like they were five bedrooms. So
- 1:18:33my parents and then the four of us each had our own room. Yet
- 1:18:35three bedroom house, one bath. My sister had our own room, makes
- 1:18:39sense. My parents and then me and my my umbrellas. Yeah, we
- 1:18:45had three bathrooms, which is kind of shocking to me when I think about
- 1:18:48it. I mean, one of the bathrooms was real drankie and that was
- 1:18:51mine. But bathroom. Yeah. When we were young, I would notice
- 1:18:59that, For example, people when I would ask would so there are a
- 1:19:02lot of moments where people are trying to find things, and so I'd be
- 1:19:05like, mom, where's the peanut butter or something, or where's the broom?
- 1:19:09And she'd be like, well, I think that it's in the garage
- 1:19:13in this one place. And then I'd looked there and it was there.
- 1:19:15And then when I would be asked a question, people be like, where's
- 1:19:18the broom, I'd be like, it's in the garage, or I'd say
- 1:19:23like, definitively it's in the garage. And what I noticed was that some
- 1:19:28of the times I was wrong, it wasn't in the garage. But I
- 1:19:31was so sure of myself, and I was so definitive, there was no
- 1:19:38tentativeness. And I noticed that my parents were almost always right and I was
- 1:19:44far less often right. So I noticed as a kid that why am I
- 1:19:49so sure of myself when I say things? Because I had this initial perspective
- 1:19:58that my parents weren't act really sure, that they were actually extremely unaware of
- 1:20:04things, or they just didn't whenever they answered questions, they just like,
- 1:20:09you know, I'm just taking a wild guess that it's you know, the
- 1:20:12way they said it, because I didn't understand gray zone, you know,
- 1:20:15or and I remember really respecting that and thinking, Okay, I'm going to
- 1:20:19turn a new leaf and try to try to be more like that. Even
- 1:20:24when I'm pretty sure, I need to recognize I might be wrong too.
- 1:20:28It just comes across better to other people when you're more tentative about things,
- 1:20:31you know, instead of annoyed and sure about yourself. And so, you
- 1:20:36know, over the years, I've developed I suppose a little bit more in
- 1:20:42that direction of tom Yeah to just be humble about that. So we're talking
- 1:20:47about that because as a therapist, is that what we're saying? What were
- 1:20:51we saying? I think we were talking about being humble of the therapist,
- 1:20:54but I could be wrong. Okay, Well, be extremely tentative about why
- 1:21:00we got to this place. I have no I have no idea where the
- 1:21:02broom is, and I have no idea how we got to this point.
- 1:21:04Peanut Butter, it's lost. It's the end of the episode. So wait
- 1:21:08a minute before we ring off. Last year, when we were in Italy,
- 1:21:12we were sitting at the dinner table. It was like the first or
- 1:21:14second night there, so we were learning people's names. We didn't know anybody,
- 1:21:16and they were eighteen nineteen people there, right, So I'm sitting there
- 1:21:19with this woman, Nancy. She was really cool, and she's like,
- 1:21:23well, what's her name? And I said, someone said it's Devorah,
- 1:21:26like Deborah but with the V Devorah. And I'm like, I think it's
- 1:21:29Devora. And Nancy looks at me and she goes, are you sure,
- 1:21:32And I said yeah, and that might be a problem. Her name is
- 1:21:38Devorah. I was really like. It was a really cool moment of saying
- 1:21:45yes, and then realizing I don't know if I it no, yeah,
- 1:21:47so and so it was nice to say and that that might be a point.
- 1:21:50Well, what you're saying is you have enough self awareness to know that
- 1:21:54when you're sure of something, that's a red flag. Yeah, it's a
- 1:21:57red flag. It was just a good moment. So we had to laugh
- 1:21:59about it. Then we had a laugh when I was wrong, and that
- 1:22:02was good. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, Well that is over that episode,
- 1:22:06and everyone please take care of yourself because you deserve it.