Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mastering Cognitive Bias in Mediation: How Mental Shortcuts Impact Settlement Outcomes
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Mastering Cognitive Bias and Mediation,
- 0:07How Mental Shortcuts Impact Settlement Outcomes.
- 0:10I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive Director and
- 0:12CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. I'm
- 0:14delighted to be here today to introduce our speaker,
- 0:17Ed Oster. Ed is a mediator with Judicate West,
- 0:20where he has handled nearly 1 ,000 insurance
- 0:22-related disputes across 36 states. He brings
- 0:2538 years of prior experience as a trial lecturer.
- 0:29Excuse me, as a trial attorney focusing on insurance
- 0:32coverage, bad faith and commercial litigation.
- 0:35He has served as a court appointed arbitrator
- 0:37and judge pro tem for the Orange County Superior
- 0:39Court and has spoken on mediation topics for
- 0:42DRI and the American Conference Institute. Now
- 0:45let's get started. All right. Well, thanks very
- 0:48much for that introduction, Belinda. And my thanks
- 0:51to all of you for joining me this afternoon.
- 0:53I appreciate the fact that you're here to improve
- 0:55your skills to get to the top. Not just to get
- 0:58a good result in mediation or a pretty good result,
- 1:01but to give 100 % of the best deal possible.
- 1:04In other words, to get everything just like the
- 1:07hero of this story. A grandmother was walking
- 1:10with her adorable grandson along a placid seashore.
- 1:14Suddenly, out of nowhere, a huge wave crashed
- 1:16upon the shore and swept the little boy away.
- 1:19Well, the poor woman was hysterical in her grief.
- 1:22Falling to her knees, she willed, God, oh God,
- 1:24why have you done this to me? Please give me
- 1:26back my grandson, and I promise I will never
- 1:29ask you for anything ever again. Just then, out
- 1:32of the calm sea, another wave crashed upon the
- 1:35shore, and there was her grandson. Stunned, but
- 1:39recovering her composure, the woman looked up
- 1:41and said he was wearing a hat. And sure enough,
- 1:45the next wave arrived with his hat. To build
- 1:49upon and improve your skills to enable you to
- 1:52get everything there is to get, today we're going
- 1:54to have a detailed conversation about cognitive
- 1:57bias, something that is present in every decision
- 2:00-making process. Then we're going to focus upon
- 2:03cognitive bias specifically in mediation, working
- 2:06with the five most prevalent biases in mediation
- 2:09and techniques for disarming them, recognizing
- 2:13them, using them to your advantage. So, let's
- 2:17begin. Think about it for a moment. In your legal
- 2:21career, you may well be involved in dozens and
- 2:23perhaps even hundreds of mediations. The facts
- 2:26of each case are going to be different. The applicable
- 2:29law will change. And you will encounter different
- 2:32parties as well as different attorneys, judges,
- 2:34and jurisdictions. The one constant that impacts
- 2:38all of these mediations is the existence and
- 2:42operation of cognitive biases. If you can master
- 2:46only one skill in mediation, utilizing cognitive
- 2:50biases to your benefit would be an excellent
- 2:52choice. The truth of the matter is, is that during
- 2:56almost all mediations, nobody is thinking about
- 2:59the concept of cognitive bias except maybe the
- 3:02mediator. If you somehow had a printout of the
- 3:05thought stream of all the participants in a mediation
- 3:07and did a word search of the tens of thousands
- 3:09of words that went through all their minds, I
- 3:12guarantee you the cognitive bias wouldn't come
- 3:14up. And yet, it's there all the time. We don't
- 3:18know about it. We don't think about it because
- 3:21we're immersed in it. It's kind of like the two
- 3:24young fish swimming in the water when an older
- 3:26fish swims by and calls out, how's the water,
- 3:29boys? The two fish look at each other with a
- 3:33blank stare and swim on. Finally, one of them
- 3:36says to the other, what's water? Well, to paraphrase
- 3:40our young fish friends, what's cognitive bias?
- 3:44So now let's talk about the nature, origin, and
- 3:48operation of cognitive biases. Simply put, cognitive
- 3:53bias is a subconscious error in the human thinking
- 3:56process that influences decision making. For
- 4:00example, confirmation bias, the tendency to only
- 4:03consider information that aligns with our preconceived
- 4:07ideas, limits information we consider when making
- 4:10decisions. Have you ever found yourself, for
- 4:13example, only reading news stories that support
- 4:16what you already think? Researchers group cognitive
- 4:20biases and negotiations into three buckets. Distortions
- 4:24about how we see ourselves, distortions about
- 4:27how we see others, and distortions of the subject
- 4:30matter, usually favoring ourselves. Because distortions
- 4:34caused by cognitive biases operate on everyone
- 4:37in negotiations. It is essential for you to perceive
- 4:41the impacts not only on your opponent, but also
- 4:44on yourself. To better comprehend and work with
- 4:49cognitive biases, it is helpful to understand
- 4:51the two systems the human brain simultaneously
- 4:54uses to process information in decision making
- 4:57and then one additional term, heuristics. Every
- 5:02time I think of the word heuristics, by the way,
- 5:05H -E -U -R -I -S -T -I -C -S I think of the extreme
- 5:09negative reaction that my wife has to it, and
- 5:12I don't know why, but she says heuristics, heuristics.
- 5:16It's such a turn off. Why are you doing this
- 5:17heuristic? Well, as you'll find out the term
- 5:21heuristics is just a fancy psychologist way of
- 5:24describing what the rest of the world would refer
- 5:26to as a mental shortcut, but it's deeply involved
- 5:30in cognitive biases. So we're going to go into
- 5:32it. Two systems of decision making. that are
- 5:37operating all the time in our brains. In the
- 5:411970s, psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel
- 5:44Kahneman conducted research in behavioral economics
- 5:47that ended up earning them the Nobel Prize in
- 5:50economics. Their experiments resulted in the
- 5:53development of the theory of two systems of decision
- 5:56making processes simultaneously at work in human
- 6:00beings during the thought process at all times.
- 6:03Kahneman authored an award -winning book on the
- 6:05topic in 2011, Thinking, Fast and Slow, in which
- 6:10he expanded upon the two systems always at work
- 6:13in decision making. System one, thinking fast,
- 6:17is the intuitive, faster thought process way
- 6:20of making decisions. It automatically and rapidly
- 6:23processes data using unconscious, innate heuristics
- 6:27to reach a decision instantly. As I mentioned
- 6:31earlier, a heuristic is a mental shortcut that
- 6:34the brain automatically uses to quickly make
- 6:37decisions based upon little information with
- 6:40minimal cognitive effort. For example, you see
- 6:44a person in a dark alley with their face concealed
- 6:46and intuitively decide to walk past just a bit
- 6:49faster. These mental shortcuts, heuristics, are
- 6:54beneficial for making the millions of decisions
- 6:56people make in daily life that don't really require
- 6:59deep thinking. Remember, the human body is hardwired
- 7:02to protect itself and to conserve resources,
- 7:06especially energy. Extensive use of heuristics
- 7:09is the primary means of conserving mental energy.
- 7:13To give you an idea of how important this is,
- 7:16it has been postulated that without heuristics,
- 7:19the human brain would consume so much energy
- 7:21and generate so much heat in the process and
- 7:25making trivial everyday decisions in our daily
- 7:28lives. that our brains would literally melt by
- 7:31around 10 o 'clock in the morning. System two,
- 7:36thinking slow, is the more idealized way of decision
- 7:39making that involves critical and analytical
- 7:42thinking. But it's also much slower and requires
- 7:45a much greater expenditure of mental energy.
- 7:48It uses conscious thought processes to solve
- 7:51complex problems by analyzing, weighing, judging
- 7:55new evidence, solutions and alternatives. All
- 7:59of us have been involved in that. And that's
- 8:00why so many times at the end of the day, even
- 8:03though we're sitting at a desk, pushing paper,
- 8:05analyzing problems, we're mentally exhausted.
- 8:08Physically, I should say, and mentally exhausted.
- 8:11System one, fast thinking, using heuristics that
- 8:15warned our ancestors of danger, enabled them
- 8:18to survive because those who could not instantly
- 8:20distinguish between danger and dinner were removed
- 8:24from the gene pool. Heuristics saves time. by
- 8:28instantly drawing upon information that is already
- 8:31stored in the brain, rather than evaluating each
- 8:34decision as new and different. Unfortunately,
- 8:38this also results in creating cognitive biases,
- 8:41which causes to draw incorrect conclusions about
- 8:45new information and new circumstances, or in
- 8:48our case, new problems, new situations that have
- 8:52to be addressed. Cognitive biases influence our
- 8:56decision -making processes by drawing us to particular
- 8:59conclusions. We are predisposed to these conclusions
- 9:03by information gathered and stored in our brains.
- 9:08Our decisions are subconsciously based upon information
- 9:11our brain selects that meets our preconceived
- 9:14ideas, prior decisions on a similar issue, self
- 9:18-interest and emotional distractions, regardless
- 9:22of the existence of any new or conflicting ideas
- 9:25and information. To off, the end result is poorly
- 9:29informed and poorly reasoned decisions. And that's
- 9:33why we call it a subconscious error in the human
- 9:36decision -making process. Let's spend a little
- 9:41time now focusing on cognitive biases in mediation.
- 9:46There are hundreds of cognitive biases that impact
- 9:50analytical, rational decision -making. Among
- 9:53the most common in mediation are confirmation
- 9:56bias, reactive devaluation, anchoring bias, frequency
- 10:01bias, and optimistic overconfidence bias. I'm
- 10:06going to repeat those again because these are
- 10:08the five that you are most likely to encounter.
- 10:11Confirmation bias, reactive devaluation bias,
- 10:16anchoring bias, frequency bias, and optimistic
- 10:19overconfidence bias. Let's start with confirmation
- 10:23bias, something that most of us probably have
- 10:26a lot of experience with and you recognize readily.
- 10:30Confirmation bias causes us to seek out or consider
- 10:33only that information which supports our preconceived
- 10:37desires or conclusions. In common terms, we cherry
- 10:41-pick instead of considering all of the information
- 10:44available from all sources. It's also, by the
- 10:47way, related to the idea of cognitive dissonance,
- 10:50the psychological discomfort that results from
- 10:52having to confront data or facts or situations
- 10:56that conflict with our pre -existing viewpoint.
- 10:59We shy away from it, in other words. There are
- 11:01multiple reasons why we use confirmation bias
- 11:04when making decisions. It's easier and faster
- 11:07than carefully processing all of the information
- 11:09at hand. It relies upon information pre -stored
- 11:12in our brains, saving time and energy. And it
- 11:16protects our self -esteem when our preconceived
- 11:19ideas are validated. Now let's talk about anchoring
- 11:24bias. And this happens in mediation all the time.
- 11:28Oftentimes, parties are heavily influenced by
- 11:31expectations formed during the very beginning
- 11:34of a mediation. And the message here is that
- 11:37opening numbers are important. Anchoring bias
- 11:41operates to influence parties throughout the
- 11:43mediation based upon earlier numbers that have
- 11:46been initially put out, regardless of their merit
- 11:49or realism. It arises in mediation when the opening
- 11:53or anchoring offer is the starting point for
- 11:56negotiations. And let me stop here and make a
- 12:00word note about this. We're talking about mediations,
- 12:04which for the most part are in civil litigated
- 12:07matters and involve an exchange of money one
- 12:10way or another. But many times there are mediations
- 12:13that involve more than just money. And what you
- 12:17can do is substitute those other commodities
- 12:20that are exchanged or bargained for or bargained
- 12:23over during the course of the mediation for money
- 12:25and the outcome, the result, the application
- 12:28is the same with all of the biases that we're
- 12:31going to discuss. But to return to anchoring
- 12:34bias, anchoring bias arises because of our need
- 12:37for a starting point in our decision making,
- 12:40as well as the typical convention of demand and
- 12:43offer in negotiations. The initial anchoring
- 12:46number and have a very substantial impact on
- 12:49the outcome of mediations, even when the anchoring
- 12:52number is inaccurate or viewed by the recipient
- 12:55as extreme. It operates subconsciously. Next
- 13:01up, reactive devaluation bias. A good way to
- 13:05think of this is it can't be right if it came
- 13:07from them. The generally hostile environment
- 13:11of litigation fosters reactive devaluation. discounting
- 13:16an opponent's information or argument or position
- 13:19simply because it came from the opponent. The
- 13:23unspoken premise here is that the opponent is
- 13:25inherently manipulative and untrustworthy. Hence,
- 13:30reactions like that can't be right because it
- 13:32came from them or concerning a proposed solution.
- 13:36It's a trick if they offered it. Interestingly,
- 13:41a long time ago, as a matter of fact, A Cold
- 13:44War experiment by social psychologists Lee Ross
- 13:47and Constance Stillinger described in their 1988
- 13:51book, Psychological Bearers to Conflict Resolution,
- 13:55quantified the magnitude of this reactive devaluation
- 13:58bias. Here's the setup. The leader of the Soviet
- 14:02Union, Mikhail Gorbachev, made a proposal to
- 14:06reduce nuclear warheads by one half, followed
- 14:09by further reductions over time. Psychologists
- 14:13Ross and Stillinger took turns with control groups
- 14:17and subjects, interviewees, attributing the process
- 14:21to the U .S. President Ronald Reagan on the one
- 14:24hand, and then alternatively to Mikhail Gorbachev.
- 14:28The surprise was not that the individual groups
- 14:31reacted differently to the same proposal, depending
- 14:35upon its source. In other words, whether it came
- 14:37from the U .S. president or whether it came from
- 14:39the Russian. but the wide degree of difference.
- 14:42When attributed to Ronald Reagan, 90 % of the
- 14:46group reacted favorably. That favorable reaction
- 14:50dropped by over half to 44 % when attributed
- 14:54to the Soviet leader. Frequency bias. Frequency
- 15:01bias is at work when something you recently learned
- 15:04or become aware of appears to be happening more
- 15:07frequently than it actually is. In psychology
- 15:10circles, it's also known as the Bader -Meinhof
- 15:13phenomenon, named after the German terrorist
- 15:16group of the 1970s. I suspect that there are
- 15:19a few of you out there who may be familiar with
- 15:22that. And you may recall it got a lot of press
- 15:24and a lot of media attention, even though it
- 15:27was a very small terrorist group, a terrorist
- 15:30cell. But it got outsized attention and importance
- 15:35because of the operation of frequency bias. Frequency
- 15:40bias occurs because your brain becomes more attuned
- 15:43to noticing things that you've just learned about,
- 15:46leading you to perceive them as being more common
- 15:49or frequent or important in your environment.
- 15:52In reality, the frequency of occurrence remains
- 15:55unchanged. It's just that your perception has
- 15:59changed because of the influence of your new
- 16:01knowledge. For example, when people hear about
- 16:04a string of robberies or vandalism in their community,
- 16:07they are more likely to believe that there is
- 16:09a national crime wave occurring. I remember actually
- 16:12the first time that I encountered this phenomena
- 16:15when was when I bought for the first time in
- 16:17my life as a young adult, a new car, not a used
- 16:20car or a car that I had to rebuild in order to
- 16:23drive. And it was blue. It was a blue Volkswagen.
- 16:27All of a sudden, I was seeing blue Volkswagens
- 16:30everywhere. And I never realized how many blue.
- 16:33Volkswagen's there were on the road until I had
- 16:36one sitting in my own garage. Another example
- 16:39of the frequency bias that plays out at mediation
- 16:42is where plaintiffs make repeated reference to
- 16:46high dollar jury verdicts, even if it's not the
- 16:49same subject matter that you may be talking about
- 16:52in litigation, something completely different,
- 16:55or regardless of the location or the jurisdiction.
- 16:58They like to talk about high dollar jury verdicts.
- 17:01Why? in order to foster a negotiating environment
- 17:05favorable to them. Actually, it's a technique
- 17:07that works. Then we come lastly to the optimism
- 17:12over confidence bias. And again, you've encountered
- 17:16this, you just didn't have the name for it. The
- 17:20optimism element of this bias helps us to believe
- 17:22that most things will work out and we can look
- 17:25forward to a good outcome. Optimism is generally
- 17:28a good thing. motivating us to create a better
- 17:31life and a better future. At the same time, optimism
- 17:34can actually impair our ability to see a legal
- 17:38dispute accurately by overestimating strengths
- 17:42and underestimating weaknesses. The overconfidence
- 17:47aspect of this bias occurs in litigation when
- 17:50one side believes its legal skills are primarily
- 17:54the reason for or primarily account for past
- 17:57favorable outcomes they may have experienced
- 18:00instead of the fact that they were just lucky
- 18:02enough to have good facts or good law. This also
- 18:06leads to overestimating chances of prevailing
- 18:08a trial and typically downplaying success for
- 18:11the opposition. Now, I know what you're saying
- 18:14to yourself right now. Why is he talking about
- 18:17overconfidence in your opponent that you have
- 18:20never ever encountered an overconfident opponent?
- 18:23Well, just in case you ever do hear me out The
- 18:28combination of optimism and overconfidence can
- 18:31be fatal to mediated outcomes many scholars and
- 18:34scientists who have studied this believe actually
- 18:37believe that Optimism overconfidence bias is
- 18:40the major cause for the biggest breakdowns in
- 18:43the decision -making process leading to failure
- 18:45is even more of a factor when It turns out that
- 18:50attorneys know even less about their cases, which
- 18:52then has the impact resulting in even more extreme
- 18:56settlement positions based upon an unrealistic
- 18:59view of trial outcomes. In doing just a little
- 19:04bit of extra homework for today's conversation,
- 19:07I came across something referred to as the G
- 19:10.I. Joe fallacy, and the G .I. Joe fallacy is
- 19:13this. It's a mistake to believe that simply knowing
- 19:17about a bias is enough to overcome it. You actually
- 19:21have to do something to overcome it. And this
- 19:24is true whether you're talking about a bias that
- 19:27exists in your opposition or a bias that is plaguing
- 19:31you. And so now let's move our conversation into
- 19:35talking about solutions. Working with cognitive
- 19:39biases and mediation. Remember that the nature
- 19:43of cognitive biases is that they arise out of
- 19:46system one thinking, fast, intuitive, automatic,
- 19:51with little information and minimal consumption
- 19:53of effort and energy. The way to counteract cognitive
- 19:58biases is to slow things down and employ system
- 20:02two thinking, deliberate conscious processes
- 20:05that solve complex problems by analyzing, weighing,
- 20:09and judging all of the evidence. Mediation gives
- 20:14you the time and space to do this. And that really
- 20:17is one of the outstanding aspects of mediation.
- 20:20It really does give you an opportunity to slow
- 20:23the process down and to give it the time and
- 20:26attention and effort that it really deserves.
- 20:29For example, when you suspect that your opponent
- 20:32is suffering from confirmation bias through the
- 20:36medium of the mediator. Inquire whether all of
- 20:39the evidence is being considered regardless of
- 20:41its source or who it might favor and if it has
- 20:46been objectively evaluated. You will likely need
- 20:49to supply the missing evidence that is not being
- 20:52considered and articulate its objective impact.
- 20:55Open -ended questions you can formulate for the
- 20:58mediator work very well to that end. And remember
- 21:02that cognitive bias is not selective. It operates
- 21:06on everyone. This means that while investigating
- 21:09cognitive bias impacting your opposition and
- 21:12what you can do to overcome any biases you detect,
- 21:16you should also conduct the same analysis on
- 21:18yourself. So how do you go about doing it? Well,
- 21:21beginning with yourself, use the five cognitive
- 21:24biases discussed previously, the five that I've
- 21:27outlined, and use this as a checklist or a grid
- 21:30and run your positions and valuations through
- 21:33them. Are you sure that you are not unwittingly
- 21:37employing unwarranted thinking shortcuts? Are
- 21:41your positions and valuations the product of
- 21:43system two thinking? If your answer to either
- 21:47question is anything other than an unqualified
- 21:49yes, you probably have some distortions about
- 21:53how you see yourself, how you see your opponent,
- 21:56and or how you see the subject matter. If you
- 21:59detect the presence of cognitive bias in yourself,
- 22:03engage in your own system two process. Now, do
- 22:08the same thing with positions and valuations
- 22:11of your opponent, because, and let's get real
- 22:13for a moment, it's your opponent who is the real
- 22:16problem, right? Okay, so if you detect the presence
- 22:19of cognitive bias in your opponent, and it's
- 22:22highly likely that you will, what do you do?
- 22:26Well, you could try a baseball bat, or you could
- 22:30try a snuckles. But that doesn't work at all
- 22:33when we're in a Zoom context as we are right
- 22:35now. And frankly, that's about 90 percent of
- 22:37the mediations in civil litigate civil litigated
- 22:40cases these days. But joking aside, there are
- 22:44these really are serious concerns and there are
- 22:47real solutions. But I implore you again, remember
- 22:50the GI Joe fallacy. It is a mistake to believe
- 22:53that simply knowing about a bias is enough to
- 22:56overcome it. It isn't. You actually have to do
- 22:59something. So, here are a few tested suggestions
- 23:03for addressing specific biases you perceive to
- 23:07be affecting your opponent. Let's start with
- 23:10the first one, confirmation bias. In addition
- 23:15to bringing the slower system to thinking into
- 23:18play through the mediator and through open -ended
- 23:21questions, try to ascertain what information
- 23:24is not being considered and focus on that. And
- 23:27again, through the mediator, bring in new information
- 23:31from objective sources? Are there comparable
- 23:34verdicts or analogous situations to draw upon?
- 23:38And here I want to make a point, a pitch for
- 23:41a little bit of pre -mediation preparation, because
- 23:45it's almost a certainty that there is going to
- 23:48be confirmation bias rampant in the mediation
- 23:52in the other room and very likely, honestly,
- 23:55in your own room as well. So you might consider
- 23:58before the mediation even begins coming up with
- 24:02doing a little research and coming up with the
- 24:04type of information that you think can help counter
- 24:07this and that you can supply to the Mediator
- 24:10not just the kinds of things that you would put
- 24:13in an advocacy brief or a mediation brief But
- 24:16things that may come up in the moment Now I know
- 24:19that during most mediations, it's wonderful.
- 24:22You've got downtime, we've got the internet,
- 24:24and you can do all kinds of Googling, chat, GPT,
- 24:28and so forth to find information. That didn't
- 24:30exist 10 or 15 years ago. The internet was there,
- 24:33but AI wasn't really robust then as it is becoming
- 24:36today. Nonetheless, do a little preparation in
- 24:40advance. You'll not only advance your own cause,
- 24:43but very likely you're going to impress your
- 24:45client as well. about how seriously and thoughtfully
- 24:49you prepared for the mediation. You make it look
- 24:52easy, and of course that's a real good thing
- 24:54to exhibit all the time. Okay, let's consider
- 24:57another one now, frequency bias. This is a circumstance
- 25:02where you encounter something and the other side
- 25:04keeps bringing it up and bringing it up, and
- 25:06all of a sudden you're worried about it happening
- 25:08all the time, everywhere, including in your case.
- 25:12Well, be prepared to distinguish your case from
- 25:16the verdicts or other information that you think
- 25:18it's likely that your opposition will be providing.
- 25:22And here it's important to remember to check
- 25:24the ultimate disposition on appeal or the post
- 25:28-trial history, post -trial motions of any verdict
- 25:31that is being cited. We all have experience with
- 25:34the fact that you can see a big splashy verdict
- 25:37that appears in the newspapers. And then two
- 25:39or three years later, not on page 1, but on page
- 25:4316, there's a small little paragraph about it
- 25:46being overturned on appeal or reduced or remitted
- 25:49or something like that. Even in a situation where
- 25:55your opponent does not present isolated occurrences
- 25:59to argue for a trend that might be worrisome
- 26:02for you, you should nonetheless consider coming
- 26:05to the mediation with your own recent data or
- 26:07examples for the very reason Already mentioned
- 26:11you want to create the negotiating atmosphere
- 26:14and the frame of mind that you want during the
- 26:17course of the mediation Good to have this information
- 26:20in your saddlebags Okay, let's talk now about
- 26:24anchoring bias. This is another one that I mentioned
- 26:28I think is present in just about every single
- 26:31mediation If you suspect in advance if you suspect
- 26:36that your opponent will present an unworkable,
- 26:40outrageous demand. Consider being the first one
- 26:43to set out a number and explaining its basis.
- 26:46You can not only help create a reasonable framework
- 26:50for negotiations, you also create a good first
- 26:53impression. If you're going to do this, by the
- 26:55way, and you're on the defense, I suggest that
- 26:58you thoroughly discuss this with your client
- 27:00in advance. And if the response that you get
- 27:04is still an outrageous demand, All is not lost.
- 27:09You can simply make a very, very small move the
- 27:12second time around. If your opponent is going
- 27:16to put out the first number and you know that
- 27:19it is going to be absurd, plan your response
- 27:22now. One of the things that you can do is to
- 27:26refuse to participate until the other side comes
- 27:28up with a reasonable number. But truthfully,
- 27:30that rarely works. Consider instead coming back
- 27:34with your own reasonable number or what appears
- 27:36to be reasonable under the circumstances and
- 27:39explain why it is what it is. And if there is
- 27:43no good response from the other side in its next
- 27:46move, then you can continue with a much, much
- 27:49smaller move the second time around. In this
- 27:53regard, I think it's very important for us all
- 27:56to remember. I mean, it really is worth recalling
- 27:59that in most cases, no matter how far apart the
- 28:03parties are, real bargaining and interest cannot
- 28:06begin until both sides are at a reasonable bargaining
- 28:10position. Typically, this means dollar a mile
- 28:14for the case that you are all mediating. And
- 28:17so it's actually to your interest for the other
- 28:20side to get to a reasonable point and for you
- 28:23to be at a reasonable point as well, because
- 28:26as we've just been discussing, only then can
- 28:28The real negotiation began in earnest. Then there
- 28:33is reactive evaluation bias, and this is kind
- 28:37of a tough one. But here is where you really
- 28:39need the help of your mediator, because the truth
- 28:42of the matter is trying to convince your adversary
- 28:45during the course of a mediation that you are
- 28:48not inherently manipulative or untrustworthy,
- 28:52if that is their view, is a big hill to climb.
- 28:56So the quick fix here is to have the mediator
- 28:59present your argument in a neutral fashion or
- 29:02your suggestion or offer as coming from the mediator
- 29:05in exploratory fashion and in this regard I want
- 29:08to stop for a moment really stick a pin in this
- 29:11because I think we all have Experience with the
- 29:14desirability of having something come from the
- 29:17mediator instead of a party during the course
- 29:19of a negotiation I know my own practice is to
- 29:26depending upon the room that I'm in saying, well,
- 29:28they argue this or their position in response
- 29:32to your argument is such as that sometimes that
- 29:34comes from the other party. Sometimes it doesn't.
- 29:38But it's very, very important for them to have
- 29:41all this information. One of the things that
- 29:44I think is very important, the service that the
- 29:47mediator can provide and something that you should
- 29:49insist upon with the mediator is for the mediator
- 29:53to help both sides. explore and know not only
- 29:57what their strengths are, but what their weaknesses
- 30:00are. And this brings into several of the biases
- 30:03that we've talked about already today. But the
- 30:06overall point here that I want to make is you've
- 30:10hired a mediator and hopefully a very good mediator
- 30:14who is well -asserted to your purposes, and you
- 30:16ought to get the most out of that mediator. And
- 30:18you'll find that mediators are very compliant
- 30:21in this regard. They want to help you in every
- 30:23way they can. So you can ask a lot of questions
- 30:27of the mediator, not only about the other side
- 30:29or presenting something to the other side, but
- 30:31you can ask about your own position as well.
- 30:35Be careful, of course, because the mediator is
- 30:37not going to want to alienate anybody. And the
- 30:41mediator is there to facilitate an agreement
- 30:43amongst the parties. But I really think that
- 30:45that direct dialogue with the mediator is something
- 30:48that is missing in a lot of mediations and that
- 30:51you ought to take advantage of. We'll talk about
- 30:53that a little bit more later on. OK, of the five
- 30:57primary biases that we've been working with today,
- 31:02the last one is the optimism overconfidence bias.
- 31:09An antidote for you to consider for your opponent's
- 31:11unhelpful optimism is a very strong dose of pessimism
- 31:16in the form of realistic projection. Actively
- 31:20discuss what all of the potential outcomes are.
- 31:24And again, you need to work with your mediator
- 31:26in this regard. All kinds of things can happen
- 31:29during the course of a trial and litigation process.
- 31:35And all of those things ought to be potentially
- 31:38considered. There's no guarantee whatsoever that
- 31:42the one party is going to have its position and
- 31:45it's relying on heavily be the prevailing position
- 31:48at time of trial. And when pressed, the truth
- 31:51of the matter is that parties and attorneys admit
- 31:54that there are no guarantees. And while good
- 31:57cases should win, they don't always win. Even
- 32:01very good or very, very good cases don't always
- 32:04win. And it's important that your opponent and
- 32:07parenthetically you as well, it's really important
- 32:11for both of you to consider the whole gamut,
- 32:14the whole range of possibilities. But right now
- 32:17we're talking about your opponent. having really
- 32:20unhelpful optimism, and that needs to be put
- 32:25in the proper context. And you can do it by setting
- 32:28out positions or possibilities and work through
- 32:31the mediator and getting this done. On the other
- 32:35hand, recall this is called the optimism overconfidence
- 32:38bias. Now I want to talk about the overconfidence
- 32:41part. For opponents suffering from overconfidence
- 32:45in their own legal ability, as the reason for
- 32:48their prior success, instead of being fortunate
- 32:52enough to have very good facts and or very good
- 32:55law. It's a mistake to attack their abilities.
- 32:59Do not do it however much it might be justified,
- 33:04warranted, or you just really want to do it.
- 33:07Instead, hold back, pour over the facts and the
- 33:12story that the facts tell, keeping the focus
- 33:14there. Making an ad hominem attack against your
- 33:17opponent is not the road to success. Keep the
- 33:21focus on the facts, and many times this will
- 33:24involve bringing in facts of which your overconfident
- 33:27opponent was not aware, as we discussed a little
- 33:31bit earlier. Beyond the world of mediation, acquiring
- 33:37expertise in recognizing and working with cognitive
- 33:40bias offers additional benefits. Just as cognitive
- 33:45bias is not selective in terms of who it influences,
- 33:50its impact on the decision -making process is
- 33:53not limited to mediation or to business pursuits.
- 33:56It is at work in every situation where decision
- 33:59-making is occurring. Becoming better at meeting
- 34:03cognitive bias challenges in your professional
- 34:06life honestly will likely do the same for your
- 34:08personal life. Now, I want to pause here for
- 34:12just a moment because I have some additional
- 34:15things that I'd like to go over with you. But
- 34:17I want, because I'm not the most adept tech person,
- 34:19I want to stop and check the questions to see
- 34:24where we are at. And if I can appropriately open
- 34:29this up, I hope, to get to the questions. And
- 34:37all right. So the questions that are appearing
- 34:47so far have to do primarily with the program
- 34:51materials. If there are any questions that any
- 34:55of you would like to pose now as your opportunity,
- 34:58please feel free. And I will come back to this
- 35:01later before we are concluded for today. So with
- 35:06some of the time remaining, I mean, well, in
- 35:09brief summary, what we have, let me just kind
- 35:12of round things up for a moment. You start with
- 35:15the idea that constantly, every time there is
- 35:18a decision to be made, the human brain operates
- 35:21on two parallel tracks. There's the system one,
- 35:25fast thinking, intuitive process that considers
- 35:27little and moves very quickly, relies upon information
- 35:31already stored in the brain. Great for everyday
- 35:33trivial decisions that you don't have to re -decide
- 35:36over and over again. Then there is the system
- 35:38two, thinking, which is much more deliberative,
- 35:41much more analytical. It's conscious. It considers
- 35:45all of the information and in the process consumes
- 35:48more time and of course more energy. Both of
- 35:52these are going on simultaneously at any given
- 35:55time. And with respect to the operation on and
- 35:59how cognitive biases arise, you'll recall that
- 36:03little word for mental shortcuts, heuristics.
- 36:06And the idea is that what the brain automatically
- 36:10does without us even considering it kind of subconsciously,
- 36:14it goes ahead and makes a mental shortcut and
- 36:18doesn't necessarily consider all of the new information
- 36:21or the new situation you're in. But your brain
- 36:24automatically recalls similar and other circumstances
- 36:27and relies very heavily on that to make an instantaneous
- 36:30decision in the moment. And the problem is, of
- 36:33course, that overlooks a number of things that
- 36:38can lead to the various biases that we discussed,
- 36:42the five most important being the most prevalent
- 36:44being the confirmation bias, frequency bias,
- 36:48anchoring bias, reactive devaluation bias, and
- 36:52finally the optimism and overconfidence bias.
- 36:56And I want to suggest to you that when you Just
- 37:00make a little list of these. And I think you've
- 37:03got an outline. I tried to keep it very short,
- 37:05a two -page outline that you can even just bring
- 37:10with you to a mediation. And during the course
- 37:13of the mediation, go through that and see if
- 37:15there's anything that can help you in the mediation
- 37:18that day. But really, as I've said before, I
- 37:21think you ought to try to engage in this process.
- 37:24well before the mediation ever begins. And in
- 37:26some circumstances, particularly when you're
- 37:28talking about making a preemptive opening offer,
- 37:30if you're on the defense side of things, knowing
- 37:33typically that the opening demand comes from
- 37:35a plaintiff. You might want to discuss that.
- 37:37You really should discuss that with your client
- 37:39in advance. And even if you decide not to, I
- 37:43suggest to you that you very likely get a few
- 37:45brownie points from your client for even thinking
- 37:48of the idea in the first place and bringing it
- 37:50up. So with the time remaining here, I want to
- 37:56turn to an additional topic that I think is really
- 38:00vital for excellence in mediation. And let me
- 38:04set it up with this brief story. A young woman
- 38:08brought her boyfriend home to meet her parents.
- 38:11After dinner, the father invited the young man
- 38:15to his study for a drink and to talk. So what
- 38:18are your plans? The father asked him. Well, plans,
- 38:21the young man said. I plan to marry her, he answered.
- 38:25Oh, the father said, well, what do you currently
- 38:28do? He knew he was a student. The young man says,
- 38:31I'm a student. A student. Hmm. Well, how are
- 38:36you going to buy her a ring? I will study, the
- 38:38young man replied, and as it says in the Bible,
- 38:41God will provide. Well, how will you keep a roof
- 38:45over my daughter's head? The father asked. God
- 38:48will provide. The young man replied, and children,
- 38:51asked the father, how will you support your children?
- 38:54Don't worry, sir. God will provide. Well, you
- 38:58know where this is going. At every question,
- 39:00the young man insisted God will provide. Later
- 39:04on, the mother asked the father, well, how did
- 39:07it go, honey? Well, he has no job and no plans,
- 39:12the father answered. But the good news is he
- 39:15thinks I'm God. Now. None of you has any illusion
- 39:19about mediators being God, but the point remains
- 39:23that mediators can't do it all alone. You need
- 39:27to help them, and you definitely help yourself
- 39:29by helping the mediator. This is a question I
- 39:33get a lot, honestly, I think by better practitioners.
- 39:36What can I do to help you help me? There are
- 39:42four things that readily come to mind. One of
- 39:46the first things you can do is come prepared
- 39:48to the mediation. And I mentioned this a little
- 39:51bit earlier. And by this, I mean have a plan
- 39:54in advance to deal with an outrageous demand
- 39:58or offer from your opponent. It's almost certainly
- 40:01going to happen in most of the mediations that
- 40:03you attend. Not all, I hope, but it will happen.
- 40:07And remembering the operation of the anchoring
- 40:10bias. This is what you're trying to overcome.
- 40:14So do some research in advance. Do some planning
- 40:17in advance of how you were going to counter the
- 40:20outrageous demand or offer. And I gave a few
- 40:23suggestions of positions that you might take.
- 40:27Remember also the frequency bias. Somebody bringing
- 40:30up verdicts or occurrences or front page articles
- 40:34that they want to have an outsized influence
- 40:36on during the mediation. Do your own research
- 40:40in advance. so that you can provide information
- 40:42to the mediator during the mediation to employ
- 40:47anti -frequency bias techniques. And this is
- 40:50information about other verdicts or distinctions
- 40:53between the cases they're going to play up and
- 40:56yours, or simply just cases that you want to
- 40:59discuss. And remember that a verdict while splashing
- 41:04and gets the front page news is not a final disposition
- 41:07of the case. Find out what happened on appeal.
- 41:10If it went to appeal, find out what happened
- 41:12to the post -trial motions. There's another bias
- 41:17that we talked about a lot. For reactive devaluation,
- 41:21this is a it can't be right if it came from them.
- 41:24It's a trick. Use the mediator to present your
- 41:28position as though it was coming from the mediator.
- 41:34And I want to stress again, although I know I
- 41:36said it earlier, I think that really there ought
- 41:39to be a constant dialogue between you and the
- 41:41mediator. Ask questions, ask questions of the
- 41:44mediator. You can suggest that the mediator ask
- 41:48questions of the other side. This will help open
- 41:51things up and take things beyond the immediate
- 41:54focus, the immediate points that your opponent
- 41:57is relying on or wants to hammer on. Generally,
- 42:00you'll do better if the lens is opened up and
- 42:02you have a broader playing field. Next on the
- 42:07list of helping the mediator help you is achieving
- 42:10clarity and communication. And please remember
- 42:13this cardinal principle, all moves in mediation
- 42:18are messages. And that's so important, I'm going
- 42:21to repeat it. All moves in mediation are messages.
- 42:27Now, typically in most mediations, you are going
- 42:30back and forth with just dollar numbers. It might
- 42:34be demand, it might be an offer. At some point,
- 42:38you might get into ranges, you might get into
- 42:41brackets and so forth. But you are using dollars
- 42:45to express what you really think about the case,
- 42:50not only your opinion, but the other sides. And
- 42:53the dollars and what you mean by it are also
- 42:56helping you to get to that place where both parties
- 42:59have to be in order for you to have a successful
- 43:02mediation that results in a settlement. both
- 43:05sides have to be at a reasonable point. So you
- 43:09want to indicate through your moves flexibility
- 43:12or what you are willing to do. You want to encourage
- 43:15good moves and discourage bad moves and so forth.
- 43:18But everything that you do, even though expressed
- 43:21through numbers, is a message. And here's the
- 43:25key point. You want to be sure that the message
- 43:27that you convey is understood by the other side,
- 43:32whether it's a bracket or a number, or something
- 43:35else. So, for example, when you are giving a
- 43:38new number, you can tell the mediator that the
- 43:42mediator can tell the other side why you moved
- 43:45the way that you did. Go ahead, put it in an
- 43:48envelope, remove all that, give it context, and
- 43:52the same thing applies in reverse. If you're
- 43:54unclear about what is meant by one of your opponent's
- 43:58moves, ask the mediator what he or she thinks
- 44:01it means. or ask the media otherwise to find
- 44:04out. And you can do this even before you respond.
- 44:08You can have communication with the other room,
- 44:11not just through your messages and moves, but
- 44:13you can have that communication through the mediator.
- 44:17And most mediators are very adept at avoiding
- 44:22any of the biases that we've talked about today
- 44:24in their own dealings. They don't have a dog
- 44:27in the hunt. They're not in the fight. And so
- 44:31they have the opportunity to be neutral and stay
- 44:34above it and look at the whole playing field.
- 44:36And after all, that's what you're hiring a mediator
- 44:38for, at least in part. But the important thing
- 44:41here and the key takeaway is, however you accomplish
- 44:44it, make sure that your message is understood.
- 44:48It's not my story, but I remember being told
- 44:51about a circumstance years and years ago that
- 44:54involved the Dodger. Great the Dodger legend
- 44:57Sandy Koufax and it was actually not about Sandy
- 45:01Koufax but about an autographed baseball that
- 45:03he baseball that he had autographed and this
- 45:06you can imagine was a very valuable baseball
- 45:09and The circumstances that there was a young
- 45:15a young boy really actually I think about eight
- 45:18or nine years old who came into his father's
- 45:21study one Saturday morning and said, Hey, dad,
- 45:24you know, let's play catch here. I got the gloves
- 45:27and I've got a ball. And what the young boy done
- 45:29is taken this Sandy Kofax autographed baseball
- 45:33and was going to use it to play catch. Obviously,
- 45:36he had no idea of the value of it. And the father
- 45:40was just shocked. And he said, No, no, no, no,
- 45:42no. We can't use this ball. You know, we can't
- 45:45use this one. It has writing on it here. See,
- 45:48do you see this? It has this writing on it. We
- 45:51can't use this baseball. So go and put it back
- 45:54where you got it. Well, five, 10 minutes later,
- 45:59the young man comes back and says, hey, Dad,
- 46:02we can play catch now. And Dad says, what? He
- 46:05said, look, here's the ball. I erased all the
- 46:08writing on it. The boy understood what the father
- 46:13said. but he didn't really get the message of
- 46:16what the father was saying. It wasn't just that
- 46:19the ball had writing on it, of course, that it
- 46:22was a very, very special and very valuable baseball.
- 46:25And I tell you this story in the hopes that it
- 46:28will just jog your memory at some point. You'll
- 46:31remember the Sandy Koufax autographed baseball
- 46:34when you are thinking about the messages that
- 46:36you were shooting back and forth during the mediation.
- 46:41Third. You can help the mediator help you by
- 46:45overcoming your own cognitive biases We talked
- 46:49about this earlier, but I there's a few additional
- 46:52points that I want to emphasize Use the five
- 46:55biases we discussed today as a grid to see if
- 46:59you are having One of these biases work on you
- 47:03and interfering with your judgment and decision
- 47:05-making Let me give you an example of this occasionally
- 47:09it happens in disability cases disability insurance
- 47:13policies, although it's not limited to those
- 47:15kinds of cases, that there is a feeling that
- 47:18the plaintiff is a fraud. They're not really
- 47:20disabled, but they're asking for all this money
- 47:22regardless. And typically there are all kinds
- 47:25of cases where this occurs in personal injury
- 47:27and otherwise. And I can tell you from personal
- 47:30experience and what I witnessed dozens and dozens
- 47:34of times, it's really hard for attorneys and
- 47:38most importantly, their insurance company clients
- 47:43to pay money, much less pay a lot of money to
- 47:47somebody that they feel in their bones is a fraud.
- 47:51You can reverse the situation here. But the point
- 47:55overall, it's just very, very hard for them to
- 47:59do that. You have to overcome those feelings
- 48:04of, in my bones, I think that somebody is a fraud
- 48:07or they're wrong, or that this is a very bad
- 48:10defendant. And they did this intentionally and
- 48:14wrongfully, and I'm the one who is suffering
- 48:16as a result if you're a plaintiff or if you're
- 48:18a plaintiff's attorney. Those gut feelings and
- 48:22those emotions often have way too much influence
- 48:26in mediation. Because the truth of the matter
- 48:29is, I mean, you've really got to overcome them,
- 48:31because what matters is not how you feel or how
- 48:35your client feels. It's really what the decision
- 48:39maker thinks. The trier of fact may not share
- 48:42your gut feelings, and especially if the decision
- 48:45maker is a judge. The judge, and even more especially
- 48:50a federal judge, certainly does not care about
- 48:53how you feel or what your gut instincts are.
- 48:56The judge may even think that there's some exaggeration
- 48:59on the part of this disability plan, if I was
- 49:01talking about, or some potentially bad conduct
- 49:05by a defendant, but they might ignore it. I mean,
- 49:08honestly, when the judge is a decision maker,
- 49:11especially a federal judge, they can do whatever
- 49:12they want. And that's really true in the case
- 49:14of federal judges. And in this regard, I'm reminded
- 49:17of a story that I was told many years ago when
- 49:20I was a brand new lawyer. In fact, it was the
- 49:22right home from getting sworn into federal court
- 49:24in the central district. And it's a story told
- 49:29to me by one of the people who was present there
- 49:31about the psychiatrist who died and wanted to
- 49:34get into heaven, knocking on the pearly gates.
- 49:37St. Peter called out Who are you? What do you
- 49:40do? And the reply came, I'm a psychiatrist. Whereupon
- 49:44St. Peter said, come on in. And as he was giving
- 49:47the psychiatrist a tour, St. Peter said, you
- 49:50know, we can really use your shrink around here.
- 49:54The psychiatrist said, no, really? Here in heaven?
- 49:57How can that be? St. Peter whispered to him,
- 50:01it's the boss. He thinks he's a federal judge.
- 50:07Please remember the point. Many times it's very
- 50:11hard for you to overcome emotions and gut instincts
- 50:17that you have. But you have to think outside
- 50:20of yourself. You have to overcome cognitive biases
- 50:23that are otherwise impairing your decision -making
- 50:27process and your judgment so that you make the
- 50:30best decision possible and can advise your clients
- 50:33accordingly. Finally, great mediation practice
- 50:39is to consciously cultivate a relationship of
- 50:42trust with your mediator, as this will open all
- 50:45kinds of doors for you. It's almost impossible
- 50:48to overstate the importance of this. You absolutely
- 50:52want a mediator who has your back vis -a -vis
- 50:55your own client and when the mediator is in the
- 50:58other room. A mediator who trusts you, to be
- 51:01honest, is going to be a much better advocate
- 51:03for your position, like everyone else. Mediators
- 51:07find that when they trust someone and can rely
- 51:09on their word, it is such a welcome breath of
- 51:12fresh air that they naturally gravitate towards
- 51:15that person or their position, most of the time
- 51:18without even knowing. Now, there are many ways
- 51:21to put deposits in the trust account, but in
- 51:24things big and small, it boils down to saying
- 51:29what you mean and doing what you say you will
- 51:33do. It's that simple. It's been said that parties
- 51:38make the settlement, and I suppose that that's
- 51:41mostly true. More often than not, though, the
- 51:44heroes that I see in mediation are the attorneys
- 51:47who act on behalf of their clients, like the
- 51:50grandmother who was strolling with her grandson
- 51:52along the seashore who wanted it all. If you
- 51:56come to the mediation, well aware of the op -creation
- 52:00of cognitive biases and their antidotes, you
- 52:04do your pre -mediation preparation And during
- 52:07the course of the mediation, use the techniques
- 52:09that we've discussed today. You will be fully
- 52:12engaged like she was. And if there is a settlement
- 52:15to be had, you will get more than a settlement.
- 52:18You will get the best deal possible. Thank you
- 52:23all for your attention. What I'd like to do right
- 52:25now is to briefly check to see what kind of questions
- 52:28we have, if any, that might be addressed. And
- 52:33if you'll give me just brief moment and an opportunity
- 52:36to do that. All right, we have a handful here.
- 52:45The first question has to do with dealing with
- 52:49an opponent who is launching ad hominem, that
- 52:54is to say personal attacks against you with the
- 52:59court and This is not taking place necessarily
- 53:07in the context of mediation, I gather. It's something
- 53:11that can happen just about any time. And I don't
- 53:16know that there is a particular technique about
- 53:19this that has to do necessarily with cognitive
- 53:21bias. But I will share this experience. Most
- 53:25of the time when there's a personal attack, judges
- 53:28don't want to see this. They want very much to
- 53:31see opponents disagree and strenuously disagree,
- 53:36even very aggressively disagree with one another,
- 53:39but still treat each other as professionals.
- 53:42They don't like to see personal attacks taking
- 53:44place. And my suggestion would be to take advantage
- 53:49of that orientation bias, if you want to call
- 53:52it that, but that orientation of the court and
- 53:56try to rise above the situation. And you can
- 54:00say something like, however much it might be
- 54:06appropriate to respond to that attack, Your Honor,
- 54:08or whatever, instead, I will concentrate on the
- 54:12reason why we are here and then go ahead and
- 54:15talk about the specific legal issue or process
- 54:18that you're involved in. But many times when
- 54:21there's a personal ad hominem attack like that,
- 54:24It's kind of bait that the other side is putting
- 54:26out there and hoping that you will pick up because
- 54:29there's some larger issue or subject matter that
- 54:32perhaps they want to distract against. Let me
- 54:36take a look at another question here. This is
- 54:42a pretty good question here. This one says, it's
- 54:44a lot to juggle and to move against your biases
- 54:48in the moment. How can you practice it? You have
- 54:58in mediation substantial downtime when the mediator
- 55:01is out of the room in the other room And that
- 55:06is the time to do it mediation really is Unique
- 55:10in that it gives you the time and space to slow
- 55:13things down Rarely are you gonna have a mediator
- 55:17who's gonna come and say I've got a number for
- 55:19the other side You've got 30 seconds to give
- 55:22me a response Nobody's gonna do that So you have
- 55:26the opportunity, I think, virtually just about
- 55:30every time, even with just these five that I've
- 55:34mentioned to you to say, is this in operation?
- 55:37Is this in effect? And so forth. And it is a
- 55:41lot. But what I can tell you is this. If you
- 55:44try it a handful of times and even put it down,
- 55:48on one or two three by five cards and have you
- 55:51with it during the mediation. It gets easier
- 55:54and easier each time to do it. It sounds like
- 55:57a lot at first, but you'll get used to it. And
- 56:01hopefully some of the stories that I told today
- 56:03will help you remember these things. Let me take
- 56:06a look briefly at the other questions we have.
- 56:17Okay, here is the question. As a mediator, what
- 56:21do you do to counter these referring to the five
- 56:25biases? When you see them in play, both sides
- 56:29overconfident, reactive practicing blatant confirmation
- 56:32and frequency bias. The number one technique
- 56:36is to ask genuine neutral questions. And we all
- 56:43are aware of the practice of somebody asking
- 56:47a question, which isn't really a question. It's
- 56:50more of a statement or there is some other approbation
- 56:54that they are engaging in. So sometimes when
- 56:57you're walking in an area and somebody comes
- 56:59up to you say, can I help you? They're not really
- 57:03there to help you. They don't want you to be
- 57:05there. That's a statement. The statement is I
- 57:06don't want you to be here. During the course
- 57:09of the mediation, I try in circumstances like
- 57:13this, and even when these circumstances aren't
- 57:15present. to ask genuine questions in a non -threatening
- 57:19way where I'm not trying to push them into a
- 57:22particular direction, but they're wide open questions
- 57:25that are genuine questions like, why do you think
- 57:29that they feel that way? What do you think would
- 57:31motivate them? What do you think they are basing
- 57:34that on? And is that accurate? What can we do?
- 57:39Real big open -ended. What can we do to counter
- 57:42this thought process? In my library, there's
- 57:47at least three books that are all about asking
- 57:50questions in mediations, and most good manuals
- 57:54refer to it. So as long as it's not a question
- 57:58that is really a statement, particularly a critical
- 58:02statement in disguise, I think open -ended, genuine
- 58:06questions are one of the very best ways to bring
- 58:09that out and get a discussion going. You say,
- 58:12well, if they really think that, well, why do
- 58:14they think that? And what are they basing that
- 58:16on? Or do you really think this? What might you
- 58:20do? What are you basing it on? Those are the
- 58:22kind of things that readily come to mind. That
- 58:26brings us to a close for today. Again, I want
- 58:30to thank all of you for taking the time to be
- 58:32with me. This is a topic that I love. I think
- 58:35it's fascinating. And I think that it's a real
- 58:38good shortcut from proving your mediation outcomes
- 58:41substantially. To each of you, I wish you all
- 58:44the very best, and thanks very much for your
- 58:46time.