Latest / Automotive State of The Union / 75 Day Supply, Honda's Identity Crisis, AI Bully Wanted
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning, it is Wednesday, March 11th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly, and after 1,290 episodes, we finally made it happen.
- 0:10We have the one and only Jamie Butters co-hosting the show so we can talk about some autos. 1,290 episodes. I texted him every single week, and this is the week he said yes. All right, that's mostly true.
- 0:23[laughs] It's mostly true. Well, I'm glad to have you with us this morning. Um, we're, we're talking about some day supply, talking about, uh, Honda exporting vidi- vehicles from the U.S. and importing them into Japan.
- 0:35Wild thing. And also talking about if anyone looking to be an AI bully. Well, we found a way you can actually get paid to do it. There's so much going on right now.
- 0:44Full steam ahead into ASOTU CON season, into our AutoIndustry.ai summit we're having the day before ASOTU CON. Um, look, this is the deal.
- 0:54You wanna get your tickets now so you can book your hotel rooms in the main event hotel. It will absolutely sell out. It sells out every year, and it sells out earlier every year.
- 1:02So if you wanna be at ASOTU CON, which you really should be, if you wanna be in the main event hotel, which you still can be, go to asotucon.com and make sure you get your tickets. Book your hotel room.
- 1:12Let us know you're coming. We're gonna send you all kinds of fun social posts that you can, uh, that you can post. You've probably seen some of them already.
- 1:18Also, I wanna let you know we do have a webinar coming up, our next ASOTU Edge webinar on March 25th, 2:00 PM, with Scott, uh, Traylor and Thuy Adamus from Mia.
- 1:28These are all- [laughs] these are such good friends of ours, so we always have a great, um, time on the webinar.
- 1:35Um, you know, there's, like, this friendly thing, but then we're also gonna talk a lot about, uh, the three, the three roles AI should be playing in your dealership.
- 1:42A lot of people telling you what roles AI should be playing. They have a lot of data, um, a lot of experience to back it up. Wanna thank our friends at iPacket for sponsoring today's show.
- 1:51If you want stronger appraisals, you have to start with stronger validation. iPacket Value uses 100% OEM-verified build data so that, that your team sees the exact build. Not a guess, not a decoder. The real thing.
- 2:03Then they tailor the comp sets by the CPO status, model year, distance. So when a customer says, "That seems low," which, you know, that's what the customer's supposed to say, "That seems low," you don't have to flinch.
- 2:14Instead, you can explain with the details, with the actual data, and you can move the deal forward. So you can visit ipacket.us to learn more. The wait is over.
- 2:25It is time to bring Jamie Butters into the show after 1,290 episodes. [laughs] I mean, I didn't text you that many times. Paul Jay, good to see you, my friend. Good to see you as well. No, but, uh, it's good to do this.
- 2:35You bet. And it's good to hear your voice. You sound great. You look great. You look like you have a tan. I don't know what's up with you these days. [laughs] I was out in the sun. I'm in California.
- 2:44Got to spend some time in the sun yesterday. Probably more today and tomorrow. So- Oh, man. That sounds lovely... uh, it's been a nice break after the cold winter we've had in the, uh, upper Midwest.
- 2:53Yeah, yeah, we're right- And I'm sure you have as well in New York. We're right with you- Yeah... in the northeast. Um, but before we get into the news today, um, you have a lot of new stuff going on.
- 3:00You have a radio show. Um, you have a Substack. Can you, can you just tell everybody, um, a little bit about what you're doing right now and how they can follow along?
- 3:09[laughs] It is a lot going on, uh, but it's very exciting. I started my own, uh, company, Butters Bureau LLC. Uh, doing a retail newsletter with Constellation but also looking to grow that.
- 3:20I'm doing some public speaking. As you said, trying to kick off a new, uh, radio show, podcast, newsletter business. Uh, so if you wanna be a sponsor, uh, I guess we'll find each other. [laughs] Best place? LinkedIn?
- 3:33And, um, a few other projects. Uh, LinkedIn's good. Where's the best place? Yeah, that's good for now, and then we'll move to email if we're trying to set something up. There you go. There you go.
- 3:40Um, listen, um, I, m- I can't remember what hip... I don't know if you're a big hip-hop fan. But there's, uh, who is it? He said- [laughs]... "I'm not a businessman. I'm a business, man."
- 3:49And now I feel like Jamie Butters- [laughs]... is a business man. [laughs] I'm gonna steal that. I'm gonna have to figure out who I'm stealing it from so I can give credit. But- That'll be very easy.
- 3:56Nathan will probably find it in three seconds while we're doing this first story. All right, let's get into some news. I'm gonna do a story, and I would love to get your commentary on it. U.S.
- 4:04new vehicle inventory climbed to 3.02 million units in February, which is a 75-day supply heading into spring. But a slower selling rate is doing more work than the numbers suggest.
- 4:14So total inventory's nearly identical to a year ago, but day supply jumped 10 days year over year as vehicles are just taking longer to move off lots.
- 4:22Mid-range vehicles, 30 to $50,000 range, are sitting an average of 73 days. Luxury units above 80,000 are aging even slower, 80 days on lot.
- 4:32EV supply dropped to 109 days from 132 days the prior month, so they're falling very quickly. Sedans remain the leanest segment at 60 days, while pickups and SUVs are hovering around 75 to 76 days.
- 4:47Toyota continues to run the tightest ship in the industry at just 27 days supply. The only eight major automaker who is under 40, uh, day supply. Jamie, you probably have some thoughts on this. Well, I do.
- 5:01And I think what's really, really interesting, because I'm a nerd for transparency and compliance, you know, back when I started covering the industry, everybody reported their sales every month. Um, U.S.
- 5:14sales every month on the first or second or whatever, the first Monday or Tuesday after the month started. Clockwork. And then companies started going away from it. They started going to just quarterly.
- 5:24You know, Tesla only reported quarterly and only reports globally. So then, of course, everyone's trying to be like Tesla 'cause they want the trillion-dollar market cap. Yeah.
- 5:32General Motors and others started going to quarterly reporting. Um, and you know, it was a hassle for them, big headache for them to always report and often be losing market share. Mm-hmm.
- 5:42So month after month, they're like, "I hate sales stories," and they don't wanna do them. So they wanna go back to quarterly. Well, here's the thing. The companies that report monthly have, like, a 50-day supply. Ah.
- 5:55[laughs] So there's seven companies that still report monthly, and I think part of it is, of course, one of them is Toyota, which has been since COVID, they're the, the ones that have really stuck to that COVID model- That's right...
- 6:06of super lean inventory and super fast turns. Um, butThey all-- I think they all had less inventory this month than a month ago. Mm-hmm.
- 6:17And it just shows, I think it shows, I think it's a really good proof point for the value of transparency. It holds companies accountable.
- 6:26And whether you're talking about the industry or a company that you're investing in or working with, there's more credibility in reporting more often and more thoroughly.
- 6:36You know, I think that one, one of the reasons that people switch to quarterly is, like, you can, you can hide a little bit more, like you said, and, and you have a little more time to, like, play the field.
- 6:46But it doesn't- Mm-hmm... actually help dealers make better decisions.
- 6:49It doesn't help dealers prepare more because when you do quarterly reporting, right, it's-- Reporting anyway is always a history lesson, but now it's a history lesson- [laughs]... 90 days ago, right?
- 6:58Like, what are we gonna do now? Mm-hmm. We're living in the result of what happened 90 days ago. So I, I love the take on transparency. Uh, it's just something, uh, we've kind of seen less and less.
- 7:07And speaking of things we've seen less of. Stop. Segway. This is pretty wild. [upbeat music] Honda, a bit of a brand problem in Japan, and its solution is becoming one of the country's biggest auto importers.
- 7:20Shipping vehicles from the US, China, and Thailand, and India in, back in to lose- [laughs]... uh, to gain market share while buyers are chasing some mini cars.
- 7:30Honda went all in on domestic mini cars like the N-Box, which became their top-selling mini car.
- 7:35But it left buyers wanting larger Honda nameplates like the Accord, the Odyssey, and the CR-V that the company had quietly stopped making at home in Japan.
- 7:44To course correct, they are importing four new nameplates this year: the Acura Integra Type S, the Honda Passport from the US to Japan, a new electric Insight from China, and the CR-V from Thailand.
- 7:56The US-built models will ship left-hand drive despite Japan's right-hand drive norm. This is crazy. Limiting their volume- Yeah... but the move is more about the brand signal, uh, than scale.
- 8:05So Honda's now Japan's third largest importer behind Mercedes and Suzuki. Uh, so now they're, they're looking at being number one. They literally just imported 39 vehicles into J- in Japan back in 2015.
- 8:18[laughs] So, uh, here's a quote from, uh, their domestic sales manager who says, "We drifted a bit towards being seen as a mass-market car maker. We needed to reestablish our brand." So, um, not, a little added context.
- 8:32In 2025, US-Japan trade agreement requires Japan to accept American-manufactured US safety-certified vehicles without any additional testing. So a little barrier's been removed to make that happen.
- 8:44So, uh, Jamie, have you seen, ever seen this in your career?
- 8:49Um, we've always seen a few go back and forth, and sometimes for symbolic purposes, you know, the Japanese would take an American-made car and, and take it back to the home market.
- 8:59Uh, I think the ones we're seeing here from the US are very much symbolic.
- 9:03As you said, they're the wrong, they're, the steering wheel's on the wrong side of the car, so it's gonna be only a very select handful of enthusiasts that would want to buy this.
- 9:11It's more about showing President Trump, "Hey, we're, we're not unwilling to send some cars from the US to Japan."
- 9:18I think the thing that's gonna move the needle that moves them from number three to number two is those CR-Vs and maybe the Insights coming from China.
- 9:26But those CR-Vs from Thailand, that's a huge, uh, segment for them to not be in. I do think it's funny, you know, to misread the market this way.
- 9:36Uh, obviously in America, generally for, uh, decades and decades, the rule is go bigger, go bigger. [laughs] Give people more, raise the prices, sell them for more. Since Lee Iacocca's day- Yeah. [laughs]...
- 9:47I mean, that's been the rule, right? Um, and Japan or Toyo- Honda sometimes makes these strategic missteps.
- 9:53Coming out of COVID, or coming out of the great financial crisis, they stripped down their car models, tried, felt like, "Oh, consumers are gonna be really, um, ca- cautious- Yeah... and conservative.
- 10:05Let's give them a lower priced vehicle." Well, they didn't want that. They wanted, you know, adaptive cruise control, and lane keep assist, and leather seats, and heated seats.
- 10:13And so they quickly retooled, changed course. Here they are again. They made another mistake. But one of the things Honda does really well is acknowledge their mistakes- Oh, yeah... and correct course.
- 10:25Yeah, I mean, that-that's a great point because you do see some automakers never acknowledge mistakes, and they just keep plowing forward. So I think it's one of the reasons Honda's is just a highly trusted brand.
- 10:35Like Honda dealers and OEMs have a high ch- high trust relationship. I think consumers have a high trust relationship with Honda, and maybe that's part of it, that they're just willing to say, "Hey, we did this.
- 10:45We need to course correct. Here's how we're gonna do it." Um, I'll tell you what, though. If... I- I'm, I'm trying to think, like, would I ever buy a vehicle with a steering wheel on the other side, like here in the US?
- 10:56I don't think I would. You know, maybe when I was younger, I was cocky enough. I would just think, "I can, I can drive from the wrong side of the road." Yeah. Uh, you know, sitting on the...
- 11:06Uh, but now I'd, I wouldn't, I totally wouldn't trust myself- Yeah. Not worth it... [laughs] to do that. Not worth it. Unless very special cases- Yeah... would I want to be riding in, driving from the right-hand side.
- 11:14Uh, speaking of a very special case. Stop. Segway. This one's so much fun.
- 11:18[upbeat music] I can't wait to see what you think about this because you and I have been forced into a world, especially in media, where we are literally forced to use AI in, in so many areas of our life because the media landscape's changing so quickly.
- 11:31But a startup is paying $800 a person to hire a professional AI bully for a day. No tech skills required, uh, just a long memory for every time AI forgot what you told it.
- 11:44The gig pays $100 an hour for an eight-hour shift spent stress testing the memory of popular AI chatbots, asking them to remember things, seeing what they forgot, and documenting that frustration.
- 11:55The role is meant to highlight a major issue that we've all dealt with in AI development, memory and cog- context loss. Like, "Why did you forget what I just told you? I told you to do this. We've talked about it.
- 12:05You apologized, and you did it again." So you don't need a degree or experience. Um, you basically [laughs] they say, quote, "You need an extensive personal history of being let down by technology."
- 12:16I think there's quite a few people that'll sign up for that.
- 12:18Candidates are signing up, lining up actually, including one recent grad paying nearly $300 a month in AI subscriptions, who sent a full rant about memory failures across every platform. Uh, the company's called Memvid.
- 12:30CEO, uh, Mohammed Omar said, "People constantly have to repeat themselves to chatbots. We want to turn that everyday frustration into something viable."
- 12:39Jamie, has AI ever forgotten what you told it?Uh, I've had a few problems, more with hallucinations, but it's all interrelated. Uh, I don't use it that much.
- 12:49I'm starting to use it more, especially in my new, uh, entrepreneurial role- Mm-hmm... trying to- Need it... uh, have some, uh, virtual colleagues since I don't have as many, uh- [laughs]... coworkers as I used to.
- 13:01Uh, now, now I picture you with virtual, virtual colleagues and, like, Jamie's probably an expert at setting up his, his, like, water cooler buddies, right? [laughs] Like, "Oh, this one's really into sports.
- 13:11That one always has relationship issues," right? "This one's a complainer." [laughs] Can you imagine that? That would actually be a pretty fun product to set up. You know, it is- It really could be...
- 13:19definitely something... We, we use AI pretty extensively here, and one of the constant frustrations is when you ask it for something and later it gives you the opposite information, or it gives you, um...
- 13:31It, it forgets you specifically told it to do this or not do this. And, um, you know, this, this company's trying to get to the bottom of it.
- 13:38Um, but I, I think even, like, the hallucinations you mentioned, I don't think anybody would be friends with someone who either hallucinated this much or was this forgetful. Yet- [laughs]...
- 13:46yet we are forced to be because of society. [laughs] Oh, man. Well, Jamie, it has been so much fun spending some time with you. Enjoy your time in California. Happy birthday to your dad, by the way. 76 years young.
- 13:58I'll pass that along. Thank you so much. Thanks, Paul. [laughs] We'll see you. Great seeing you. [upbeat music] Keep running. Keep running. Keep running. And move to the right. Keep running. Keep running. Keep running.
- 14:02And move to the right. [upbeat music]