Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / COP16: Greenpeace's Final Call to Save Biodiversity
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 0:07Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences, and we discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating
- 0:24the Human Side, the podcast that explores the
- 0:27people behind environmental efforts to change
- 0:30the future of our planet. Today we have the pleasure
- 0:33of presenting Estefania González, Deputy Campaign
- 0:36Director of Greenpeace Andil, who is a passionate
- 0:40advocate for biodiversity. Estefania has led
- 0:43numerous campaigns for Greenpeace Latin America,
- 0:46highlighting the urgent need to protect our ecosystems
- 0:49and confront the threats they face due to the
- 0:51climate crisis and biodiversity loss. Recently,
- 0:55the world leaders gathered in Cali, Colombia,
- 0:57for COP16. Greenpeace and Dino made a powerful
- 1:01call for nature. With a massive 17 -meter banner
- 1:04bearing the message, Action for Nature Now, Estefania
- 1:08and her team sought to remind the delegates that
- 1:11the time to act is now. Empty promises are no
- 1:14longer enough. Colombia, one of the most biodiverse
- 1:18countries globally, has a unique opportunity
- 1:21to lead with concrete actions to protect 30 %
- 1:24of terrestrial and marine ecosystems by 2030.
- 1:27A goal? agreed upon the Cumming -Montreal Global
- 1:31Biodiversity Framework. Estefania has stressed
- 1:34the importance of ensuring that the financial
- 1:37commitments agreed upon the previous Health COP15
- 1:40are honoured, with funds directed specifically
- 1:43towards diversity protection and to indigenous
- 1:46and local communities that depend on it. At this
- 1:50summit, the work of Greenpeace and leaders like
- 1:52Estefania remind us that beyond speeches, What's
- 1:56truly at stake is the future of life on the planet.
- 2:00Stefania, welcome and thank you for joining us.
- 2:02For those unfamiliar, could you explain what
- 2:05COP16 is, the UN Conference of the Paris on Biological
- 2:09Diversity, and why it is so important for the
- 2:12future of biodiversity in Latin America and globally?
- 2:16Certainly. There's a short and a long explanation.
- 2:20I'll go with the short one first. The Biodiversity
- 2:23COP is the most important international summit
- 2:26for biodiversity. And what is biodiversity? Biodiversity
- 2:30is life and all the connections and relationships
- 2:33that allow life to thrive. We are biodiversity.
- 2:36Us three talking here are biodiversity as well
- 2:39as all the flora, fauna, and even the often overlooked
- 2:42fungi that are part of the planet's fungal systems.
- 2:44This summit is where countries gather to make
- 2:47decisions on issues that an individual country
- 2:49alone cannot solve. especially given the scale
- 2:53of the challenges we're facing. The most well
- 2:55-known summits are those on climate change, so
- 2:58I'll explain a bit further. When the major Rio
- 3:00conference took place in the 1990s, it was the
- 3:03first big summit where all countries came together
- 3:05to discuss the importance of environmental issues.
- 3:08From that summit emerged three offspring, which
- 3:11were three conventions. The Framework Convention
- 3:14on Climate Change, which is the most well -known
- 3:16and has COPS, conferences of the parties, each
- 3:19year. That's why we're approaching COP29, which
- 3:22will begin in a few weeks, the Convention on
- 3:24Biological Diversity, or CBD, which is the COP
- 3:27we're currently attending in Cali and is held
- 3:30every two years, hence COP16, and the Certification
- 3:34Convention, which is much less well -known than
- 3:36the others. So, here we're making decisions on
- 3:39this important convention to protect life and
- 3:42ourselves. Perfect. That's very clear. Tell us,
- 3:46from Greenpeace and Dino perspective, what are
- 3:48your hopes for this COP16? What immediate actions
- 3:52do you consider essential to transform the environmental
- 3:55and biodiversity crisis into an opportunity for
- 3:58real change? Well, Daniel, what you mentioned
- 4:02about the crisis is perhaps the most important
- 4:04thing. We must understand today that the climate
- 4:07crisis is directly linked to the biodiversity
- 4:09crisis, which is why one of the things we hope
- 4:12to see at this summit is greater synergy between
- 4:14the work of these two conventions, which are
- 4:16separate but stem from the same place, and to
- 4:18see how we can have synergistic actions where
- 4:21climate and biodiversity agendas go hand in hand.
- 4:24Biodiversity is not only deeply affected by the
- 4:27climate and ecological crisis, but nature itself
- 4:30is also our best ally in times of crisis. So
- 4:34synergy is a very important theme. And the other
- 4:37theme we can break down bit by bit is that we
- 4:39hope for this COP in Cali to be a COP of implementation.
- 4:42As you mentioned at the beginning, at the previous
- 4:44COP, COP 15, a framework was agreed upon which
- 4:47would be our direction. So to speak, which is
- 4:50the Can Ming Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework,
- 4:52the equivalent of the Paris Agreement in the
- 4:54case of climate. But here, in biodiversity, it
- 4:58set the goal to protect 30 % of our ecosystems
- 5:00by 2030. This is the first COP held since that
- 5:04framework was agreed upon, and what we hope to
- 5:06achieve here in Cali is its implementation. This
- 5:09requires many important actions that are being
- 5:12negotiated as we speak. Fantastic. And it is
- 5:15also important to highlight that, according to
- 5:17the Living Planet report, 73 % of the biodiversity
- 5:21on the planet has been lost over the past 50
- 5:24years. What remains is only the 27 % of the biodiversity.
- 5:29including vertebrates, not even counting invertebrates.
- 5:33So, as you said, we have this synergy with all
- 5:36biodiversity, but it's also critical to remember
- 5:40that we depend entirely on it, right? As you
- 5:43said, we are part of this. And to clarify, what
- 5:47are the main commitments Greenpeace hopes countries
- 5:50will make at COP16? How could these commitments
- 5:53impact the daily lives of people and all of us?
- 5:57Yes, well... the numbers are extremely alarming.
- 6:00What this study has done is that scientists have
- 6:03been studying vertebrate populations on the planet,
- 6:05and these populations are decreasing. This 73
- 6:09% is the average on a global level, but if we
- 6:11zoom in on Latin America, the percentage rises
- 6:14above 90 % in terms of population decline. Out
- 6:17of over 8 million species today, 1 million species
- 6:20are at risk of extinction. That's why action
- 6:23has to be taken now. That's why we arrived here
- 6:26before the summit started and put up an 80 -meter
- 6:29banner reading, Action for Nature Now. What does
- 6:31this action look like? First, countries needed
- 6:34to come here with updated biodiversity action
- 6:37plans and strategies aligned with this global
- 6:39biodiversity framework, which aims to protect
- 6:4230 % of terrestrial, marine, and coastal ecosystems,
- 6:46but also to restore them. This is not just about
- 6:49protecting what's left and letting the rest go.
- 6:52No. We also need to restore our ecosystems. Unfortunately,
- 6:56only 36 countries presented these biodiversity
- 6:59action plans, Colombia being one of them as the
- 7:02host, which sends a very important signal to
- 7:04our region, but it's still a very low percentage
- 7:07considering that the protection actions are set
- 7:09for 2030, and 2030, as they say in many places,
- 7:13is just around the corner. Another issue involves
- 7:16financing, which is frequently discussed and
- 7:18remains a stumbling block for climate action.
- 7:21You'll hear about it again this year, when the
- 7:23climate change COP begins next week in Baku,
- 7:26Azerbaijan. Financing is a point of contention
- 7:29for both climate and biodiversity. Developed
- 7:32countries have financial commitments. For climate
- 7:34change, it's the mobilization of $100 billion
- 7:37per year, and for biodiversity, they committed
- 7:40$20 billion by 2025 for developing countries.
- 7:44Larger, wealthier countries are largely responsible
- 7:48for the climate ecological, and biodiversity
- 7:51crises we're facing and have generated immense
- 7:54wealth from this destruction. So, they now have
- 7:57a responsibility, not just a commitment, but
- 8:00a responsibility, and this principle is recognized
- 8:03in international law, particularly within these
- 8:05conventions, to mobilize these resources. What's
- 8:09happening now is that the $20 billion is not
- 8:12the full amount of financing needed, and even
- 8:14so, we've only reached 55 % of this financing.
- 8:18So, one of the current discussions is about how
- 8:21countries can mobilize these resources and reach
- 8:23financing agreements that will allow many countries,
- 8:26which are not the main culprits of the climate,
- 8:28ecological and biodiversity crisis we're facing,
- 8:31to act in ways that protect biodiversity for
- 8:34everyone's benefit. Here's an important message
- 8:37from Greenpeace. When a developed country, a
- 8:40northern country, allocates a certain amount
- 8:42of euros or dollars to southern countries, it's
- 8:45not doing them a favor. Instead, It's an investment
- 8:48in the health of its own citizens and in the
- 8:51stability of something that is planetary in scale.
- 8:53That's very true. And you mentioned earlier about
- 8:57installing this large banner. Can you tell us
- 9:00more about why these impactful installations
- 9:01are important across different media? Yes. Well,
- 9:05something very important. And maybe people start
- 9:08to feel a bit discouraged or eco -anxious seeing
- 9:10governments here discussing these issues. I mean,
- 9:13as we speak now, my colleagues and I are planning
- 9:16who will cover the negotiation sessions, which
- 9:18may go on until 1, 2, or 3 in the morning. We're
- 9:22all tired, but it's also about giving people
- 9:25a sense of hope, carrying people's voices into
- 9:28the negotiation halls. For example, we achieved
- 9:31the Paris Agreement on Climate, where countries
- 9:34committed to keeping global temperatures below
- 9:361 .5 degrees and the Comming -Montreal Framework.
- 9:40which aims to protect 30 % by 2030. These agreements
- 9:44give us tools within our countries to hold our
- 9:46governments accountable, and this is thanks to
- 9:48the people, to civil society, to indigenous communities,
- 9:52to various tribal groups, and to local communities
- 9:54present in these spaces. That's why communicating
- 9:57this to people and helping them feel their voices
- 10:00have influence in these negotiations is so important.
- 10:03At Greenpeace, we achieve this through non -violent
- 10:06direct actions that bring these messages to the
- 10:09streets. That's why we displayed this giant banner
- 10:12with climbers with our activists to bring activism
- 10:14to the center of this so -called People's Cop
- 10:17with a call to action for nature. This week,
- 10:19we were also in negotiations with a piggy bank,
- 10:22an actual little piggy bank, demanding action
- 10:24for nature from the countries, especially from
- 10:27the developed countries, which, as you mentioned,
- 10:29are the ones with the most impact on biodiversity
- 10:31and emissions. Which of these countries have
- 10:34presented proposals? Or do you see any making
- 10:37tangible changes beyond just words? Because,
- 10:42well, anything can look good on paper. Yes, Linda,
- 10:46what you mentioned is absolutely true, that anything
- 10:49can look good on paper. What we need here is
- 10:52for developed countries as a group to stop blocking
- 10:55the agreements. We've been in negotiations for
- 10:58almost two weeks. and we still don't have an
- 11:00agreed -upon resource mobilization strategy.
- 11:03It's not enough for, say, Germany to contribute
- 11:06part of the resources toward the $20 billion
- 11:08goal, even though that's very important. Developed
- 11:12countries as a whole must meet their commitments
- 11:15to build trust. Many countries, especially in
- 11:18the southern hemisphere, are dealing with significant
- 11:20challenges in terms of vulnerability, poverty
- 11:23reduction, and facing the impacts of the climate
- 11:26crisis. such as severe droughts and extreme weather
- 11:29events. There must be a fair and equitable resource
- 11:32mobilization strategy. But it's also true that
- 11:35countries in the southern hemisphere can't condition
- 11:37their biodiversity or climate action solely on
- 11:41financing from the north. Let me give concrete
- 11:43examples from our region, Latin America. For
- 11:47example, in Chile, coal production creates so
- 11:49much pollution that today, children in areas
- 11:52like Quintero and Pachincavi, where there is
- 11:55coal mining, can't attend school because they
- 11:57get sick, feel dizzy, or end up in hospitals.
- 12:00So, when we talk about climate action, about
- 12:03protecting the Amazon, halting the expansion
- 12:06of the agricultural frontier, or stopping illegal
- 12:09and legal mining, a major issue in Colombia,
- 12:12it's because the Amazon is reaching a critical
- 12:14point where climate change could alter rainfall
- 12:16patterns, making it unsuitable for the type of
- 12:19rainforest currently there, which would have
- 12:21tangible effects on the communities that live
- 12:23there. So, Southern countries also need to understand
- 12:26that biodiversity ambition should not be solely
- 12:29conditioned by financing. It's also a responsibility
- 12:32toward their own citizens who are already experiencing
- 12:35the daily and very real impacts of the climate
- 12:38and ecological crises. Unfortunately, these impacts
- 12:42will only increase. If we do everything right,
- 12:45we'll prevent extreme changes, but we're still
- 12:48heading toward a future with more extreme weather
- 12:50events, reduced rainfall, and less predictable
- 12:53rainfall patterns. It might rain only two days
- 12:56instead of over four months, affecting how we
- 12:59use our natural resources like water. We must
- 13:02take this challenge seriously. We're past that
- 13:0590s -era dichotomy of choosing between economic
- 13:08progress and environmental protection. Protecting
- 13:12the environment isn't just for people who can
- 13:14afford to vacation in pristine forests or those
- 13:16who like to hug trees. Today, it's about survival.
- 13:20There's no possible economic development without
- 13:23protecting our biodiversity and ecosystems, because
- 13:26even economic activities cannot develop predictably
- 13:29into the future without it. Our economic stability
- 13:32is directly impacted by the triple planetary
- 13:35crisis of climate change, biodiversity loss and
- 13:38pollution. Yes, absolutely. And earlier, we discussed
- 13:42the ambitious goal of protecting 30 % of ecosystems
- 13:45and biodiversity by 2030. Why was this particular
- 13:50goal set? What does achieving it mean for communities?
- 13:54And you already explained some of its importance
- 13:57for humanity overall. But specifically, why this
- 14:01particular goal? Yes, well, what we must understand
- 14:04is that when we talk about ecosystems, they don't
- 14:07recognize the political and administrative boundaries
- 14:09we've set, like national borders, or in the case
- 14:12of oceans, national versus international waters.
- 14:16Ecosystems operate differently. What's happening
- 14:18now is that we're not only losing large amounts
- 14:21of biodiversity, but we're also fragmenting habitats.
- 14:24What does this mean? Human activities are cutting
- 14:27apart essential relationships that allow certain
- 14:30groups of animals, forests, or ocean cycles to
- 14:33function healthily. It's not just about protecting
- 14:36individual species, an outdated perspective of,
- 14:39say, saving elephants or a specific tree, but
- 14:42about protecting these relationships. I love
- 14:44this concept of biodiversity because, as one
- 14:47of my colleagues specializing in this field always
- 14:49says, we are all biodiversity. Protecting these
- 14:52relationships is essential because nature operates
- 14:56much like us. Alone in our homes, like during
- 14:59the pandemic, we find it hard to survive. We
- 15:02need to socialize, see family and friends, engage
- 15:05in various activities. All those relationships
- 15:08are vital, and it's the same in nature. there
- 15:12are many vital relationships. So, when scientists
- 15:15study ecosystems, they say we need to protect
- 15:18a portion of our ecosystems that allows these
- 15:20natural cycles to be preserved and protected
- 15:23in different ways. One of the best -known methods
- 15:26is protected areas, national park systems, marine
- 15:29protected areas. But there are also protections
- 15:32that involve indigenous territories. Many well
- 15:35-preserved ecosystems are indigenous reserves
- 15:38Areas managed by indigenous communities with
- 15:41a worldview different from ours, one that doesn't
- 15:43separate humans from nature. This is something
- 15:46I've learned a lot about, for example, working
- 15:48with the Toscar community in Chile or the Mapuche
- 15:51and Yagin communities in southern Chile. This
- 15:54idea of dividing humans from nature doesn't make
- 15:56sense to them. They see themselves as part of
- 15:59nature, part of these cycles, recognizing that
- 16:02an essential portion of the ecosystems on our
- 16:05planet and really 30 % is small. I'd like it
- 16:08to be much more, must be preserved, so that these
- 16:10relationships can continue and life can thrive
- 16:13is crucial. And everything you mentioned ties
- 16:16into another topic you brought up, restoration.
- 16:19Restoration today is discussed in terms of functionality.
- 16:22We have had other guests who explain this as
- 16:27not being able to restore individual species
- 16:29or recreate a past state of an ecosystem, but
- 16:32rather restoring the functions of natural systems.
- 16:36And Daniel, you used a key word here, functions.
- 16:39But I want to challenge it because when we talk
- 16:42about ecosystems, ecosystem services are a trendy
- 16:45term, a way of monetizing nature. How do we put
- 16:49a price on the role phytoplankton plays for a
- 16:51whale? Or on the rock where a mother jaguar rests
- 16:55with her cubs? Perhaps that doesn't have a value
- 16:57as an ecosystem service, but it's still an ecosystem
- 17:00function that doesn't depend on what we humans
- 17:03need. It's important to start thinking about
- 17:05this planet as something we share with other
- 17:07species, and ecosystems are very wise. Sometimes
- 17:11the first step to restoration is to leave that
- 17:14ecosystem alone, to give it the space to recover
- 17:16its functions, as you mentioned, Daniel. And
- 17:19sometimes it's amazing. I've seen it, for instance,
- 17:23in burned native forests after intense wildfires,
- 17:26which are now affecting all of Latin America
- 17:28and have also impacted Australia. Often, Forestry
- 17:32management will say, well, let's cut down this
- 17:35burnt tree and repurpose the land. I've been
- 17:38in forests where you'd think the ecosystem was
- 17:40lost, but if you leave it alone, the next year
- 17:43you'll see that charred trunk sprouting green
- 17:45leaves everywhere and insects returning. And
- 17:49I find that wonderful. I encourage everyone to
- 17:52visit places that have been heavily polluted
- 17:53or abandoned, even areas full of trash, and you'll
- 17:57see how life finds its way back. This idea of
- 18:00restoration involves allowing nature to reclaim
- 18:03its cycles and functions. Something that gives
- 18:06me hope in a time when it's sometimes hard to
- 18:08be optimistic is going to these devastated areas
- 18:11and witnessing the resilience of life. It's like
- 18:14the blooming desert, where even a little rain
- 18:17brings unexpected bursts of life. Life wins out.
- 18:21The force of life against death is incredibly
- 18:24powerful. This is why we need to give nature
- 18:26a chance to restore itself and to marvel at our
- 18:29planet and its ecosystems. We have seen many
- 18:32examples of this, like an insurmountable disaster,
- 18:35where they completely isolated the area and no
- 18:38humans could enter due to the radiation. Yet,
- 18:41the animals and forests completely restored themselves.
- 18:44A species reappeared that hadn't been seen in
- 18:47many years, and it was simply left untouched.
- 18:50It didn't revert to exactly what it once was.
- 18:54as one of our other guests mentioned, but it
- 18:57regains its functionality, which is the most
- 19:02essential part. Some countries might think the
- 19:04climate crisis is a distant problem, only affecting
- 19:07certain areas. But why biodiversity laws matter
- 19:10to all of us, regardless where we live? Often
- 19:14people say, ah, it's snowing. What climate change?
- 19:18In a TED Talk, a climatologist compared the weather
- 19:22with our... day -to -day swing moods. Happy,
- 19:26sad, anxious. But climate is more like personality,
- 19:31which is more stable over time. So why we should
- 19:35all care about this? You mentioned earlier that
- 19:38we are interconnected, that we belong to this
- 19:41biodiversity. What is it not something distant?
- 19:45Why we should everyone should listen and feel
- 19:47that this matters. For those listening, I think
- 19:51if there's one emotion shared by all humans,
- 19:54it's the awe and wonder of being in nature. It
- 19:57can be anything. Some love the beach, others
- 20:00the mountains, urban trees outside their windows,
- 20:03or birdsong. The connection with life, I think,
- 20:06is what biodiversity is all about. Often, we
- 20:10make a big effort to scientifically prove how
- 20:12biodiversity provides a function, like the Amazon
- 20:15giving us oxygen, but that's a very rational
- 20:18perspective. I invite everyone to remember how
- 20:21they felt the first time they saw a wild animal
- 20:23they'd never seen before, the first time they
- 20:25saw a colorful bird, or the first time they entered
- 20:28the sea and felt the ocean. The joy of being
- 20:31in contact with life is something that unites
- 20:34us. I don't know anyone who hasn't felt happy,
- 20:37even for a moment, in nature. And that's something
- 20:40the pandemic taught us too. In confinement, many
- 20:43people realized that even with all the technology
- 20:46and streaming services available, it wasn't enough.
- 20:49We all long for two things, fresh air and time
- 20:53with loved ones. That's biodiversity. That's
- 20:56what we need to protect. And on a practical level,
- 20:59the impacts of biodiversity loss are something
- 21:01we experience every day, extreme heat, sudden
- 21:04cold. As you mentioned, Linda, the climate crisis
- 21:08doesn't mean an increase in temperature everywhere,
- 21:10but the rise in global temperature affects different
- 21:13regions differently. More rain in some. drought
- 21:16in others more extreme weather in some places
- 21:19and extreme lows in others in antarctica for
- 21:22instance certain conditions are making it harder
- 21:25for penguins to return to feeding areas leading
- 21:27to chicks being unable to survive after their
- 21:30parents search for food in general these kinds
- 21:33of things can happen and sometimes there's more
- 21:35ice not less because the system becomes unpredictable
- 21:38and unstable this accelerated pace of change
- 21:42means species lack time needed to develop resilience
- 21:46I hear a lot, especially in this era of climate
- 21:48denial, about how, yes, we've had glacial and
- 21:52deglacial periods before. And of course we did.
- 21:55But those cycles took much longer, giving species
- 21:58the time to adapt. It's one thing to know a storm
- 22:01comes every year at a certain time and to prepare
- 22:04for it, but it's another to experience it without
- 22:06warning in a place with no history of such weather.
- 22:09The speed of these changes makes it hard for
- 22:12ecosystems to build resilience. And we're seeing
- 22:15this play out daily. Yes, absolutely. I have
- 22:17a question that might give us a global perspective.
- 22:19In countries like Colombia, we have a fiscal
- 22:22control agency that monitors and enforces environmental
- 22:25policies and regulations, including the ability
- 22:29to impose penalties for violations. On an international
- 22:32level, who is responsible for monitoring biodiversity
- 22:35and ecosystem loss? Your organization acts as
- 22:39an advocate in such cases. Do you report findings
- 22:43to international bodies, or do you collaborate
- 22:46on tracking events like ecocide deforestation
- 22:49or ecosystem dysfunction? Who takes on this oversight
- 22:55role for critical biodiversity issues? Yes, well,
- 22:59honestly, I'd say that there isn't a single international
- 23:02body for this, and it's still very difficult
- 23:04for most countries to recognize damage to ecosystems
- 23:07and biodiversity as equivalent to a criminal
- 23:10offense. You mentioned ecocide, and today only
- 23:13a few countries have environmental harm classified
- 23:15as a criminal offense. It's something that's
- 23:18progressing, but very slowly. We're currently
- 23:21involved in an important case in Argentina. A
- 23:24few years ago, in a place called Puntitambo,
- 23:27which is home to a large part of the world's
- 23:29Magellanic penguin population, a neighboring
- 23:32landowner decided to construct a fence and drove
- 23:35machinery over the nests, killing dozens of penguins.
- 23:38This case has taken a long time but with two
- 23:41other organizations an Argentinian group called
- 23:43Patagonia Natural and the Association of Environmental
- 23:46Lawyers of Argentina we went forward and declared
- 23:49it an environmental crime. This is the first
- 23:52time it's reached an oral trial which is ongoing
- 23:55and we invite everyone to follow Greenpeace Argentina
- 23:58for updates. We managed to prosecute those responsible
- 24:01for this ecocide on two charges animal abuse
- 24:04which allows us to classify this act under criminal
- 24:07law and aggravated environmental damage. But
- 24:11we'll see how the trial ends, as these types
- 24:13of offenses are still treated differently. Imagine
- 24:17dozens of penguins and their nests destroyed
- 24:19during a critical reproductive period. It shouldn't
- 24:22even be a question. The public authorities should
- 24:25have taken action, but it was left to us in civil
- 24:27society to pursue the case with local prosecutors.
- 24:30Many countries are advocating for environmental
- 24:33crime laws. In Argentina, we're also pushing
- 24:36to make forest destruction a crime. Otherwise,
- 24:39what happens is that companies find it cheaper
- 24:41to pay fines for biodiversity damage, factoring
- 24:45these costs into production rather than complying
- 24:47with the law. We also have many illegal activities,
- 24:51like illegal mining in Colombia, where control
- 24:53is very difficult. One positive step in our region
- 24:57is the Escazu Agreement, which recognizes the
- 25:00role of environmental defenders and urges countries
- 25:03to enact legislation in this area. It also establishes
- 25:07principles of participation and prior consultation
- 25:10for affected communities, which can help with
- 25:12prevention. But it's still hard for people to
- 25:15understand that destroying an ecosystem is equivalent
- 25:17to a crime because you're taking life, not just
- 25:20one, but many forms of life. Yes, and that's
- 25:24a big problem, for instance, with migratory species.
- 25:27In some countries like Japan, where there are
- 25:29dolphin massacres, or in the Faroe Islands of
- 25:34Denmark, there is no regulation. There is nothing
- 25:36we can do. It is disheartening to see these migratory
- 25:40species under protection elsewhere, but lacking
- 25:43cultural importance in these countries. My question
- 25:46touches on this complex part, that there should
- 25:49be an entity above national legislation, as this
- 25:53impacts the entire world, all people, all countries,
- 25:56as it threatens both nature and other species'
- 26:00existence. Yes, this is where these conventions
- 26:03come in, these sometimes tedious spaces where
- 26:06people wonder, why bother gathering at the UN
- 26:09to waste time? But individual actions by each
- 26:11country aren't enough. Suppose, hypothetically,
- 26:14that Chile could protect all its whales. They'd
- 26:18be safe in Chilean waters, in a healthy ecosystem.
- 26:21But these are migratory species that will eventually
- 26:24leave Chile, maybe head close to Colombia's waters,
- 26:27where they might not be protected. or pass through
- 26:30international waters outside any country's jurisdiction.
- 26:34Conventions like the CBD allow us to set collective
- 26:37goals and provide civil society tools to hold
- 26:40governments accountable. So, for example, when
- 26:43we talk about the 30 % biodiversity protection
- 26:46target, this gives us a tool. There's also an
- 26:49important new instrument for oceans, the High
- 26:52Seas Treaty, achieved after 20 years of effort
- 26:54led by Greenpeace and many organizations. I also
- 26:58had the chance to participate in these negotiations.
- 27:01This treaty sets rules for all countries on the
- 27:04high seas. Approved after two decades of negotiations,
- 27:08it lets us create protected marine areas and
- 27:11international waters, assess environmental impacts,
- 27:14and more. But this treaty needs ratification
- 27:16by 60 countries. It hasn't been ratified yet,
- 27:20which is why at COP16 we're calling on countries
- 27:22to ratify the Oceans Treaty, a concrete tool
- 27:25that's legally binding. This treaty creates obligations
- 27:29for states covering protected marine areas, marine
- 27:32genetic resources, capacity building, and environmental
- 27:36assessments. We need to bring it into force,
- 27:39hold COPS under this treaty, and make progress
- 27:41on each point. But I want to emphasize that there
- 27:44have been key moments when the world has come
- 27:46together to set minimum standards for collective
- 27:49action, understanding these interconnections
- 27:51that go beyond individual actions. Yes, it's
- 27:54essential to highlight these legally binding
- 27:56advances in these conventions and initiatives.
- 27:59You also mentioned the significant role given
- 28:02to indigenous communities at this COP. Could
- 28:05you tell us more about why the knowledge of indigenous
- 28:08and ancestral communities are crucial for biodiversity
- 28:11conservation? Certainly, indigenous communities,
- 28:15especially different indigenous peoples, have
- 28:17a place in our negotiations, along with youth,
- 28:20women's groups, civil society organizations,
- 28:22and local communities. They're not only guardians
- 28:25of biodiversity, but can also offer many solutions
- 28:28for improving biodiversity protection. Recognizing
- 28:32their ancestral territorial rights is also crucial.
- 28:35I always try to be respectful and avoid speaking
- 28:38on behalf of indigenous communities because I
- 28:41believe it's important for these communities
- 28:42to have their own voice. So, I prefer to speak
- 28:46about my direct experiences such as the work
- 28:48we've done with the witchy communities in northern
- 28:50Argentina to protect the Chaco Forest. For indigenous
- 28:54communities, the Chaco Forest is a place of medicine,
- 28:57spirituality, life, and territory. In the case
- 29:01of the Canoe peoples with whom I've worked in
- 29:04Chile and Patagonia, they have a different understanding
- 29:06of territory. We're often more accustomed to
- 29:09sedentary peoples, with well -defined territorial
- 29:12limits, so we think, let's create a reserve from
- 29:15point A to point B. But with the Canoe peoples,
- 29:17their territory is vast, practically all of Chile's
- 29:21Patagonian fjords and channels, where various
- 29:24peoples coexist. So, how do we create territorial
- 29:28management systems that allow proper use of these
- 29:30areas by these communities? It's not the same
- 29:33for a factory ship to extract resources indiscriminately
- 29:36as it is for an indigenous community to use its
- 29:39ancestral territory, where they don't see fish,
- 29:41for example, as a resource to exploit but as
- 29:44a relationship with nature that ensures mutual
- 29:47survival. So, when I would ask them, what's it
- 29:50like when you harvest an animal, they would describe
- 29:52it as a mutual care relationship. We care for
- 29:56this species, for this population because it's
- 29:58vital. When we need food, We respectfully take
- 30:01only what we need, honoring the animal's life
- 30:04in that moment. It's a relationship vastly different
- 30:07from our industrialized food systems, where even
- 30:10the vegetables we consume contribute to environmental
- 30:13degradation. Understanding this role, this way
- 30:16of connecting with nature, which reminds us that
- 30:19it's possible to live in respect with our environment,
- 30:22is vital. It's also important to acknowledge
- 30:24these ancestral territorial rights. Indigenous
- 30:27communities have been on these lands for thousands
- 30:30of years, yet they're being displaced by extractive
- 30:33industries and tourism, even though they want
- 30:35to continue their small -scale agriculture and
- 30:38other activities. Recognizing indigenous territorial
- 30:41rights is crucial, as the places left in the
- 30:44world with the most intact ecosystems are often
- 30:47under indigenous stewardship. These lands have
- 30:50often been degraded by state policies that prioritize
- 30:52short -term gains, especially in Latin America.
- 30:56This reminds me of something one of our guests,
- 30:59Professor Sean Olm, highlighted. He's an anthropologist
- 31:02who works closely with indigenous communities.
- 31:06He talked about the colonialist view that often
- 31:10devalues indigenous knowledge compared to the
- 31:12Western knowledge, as if ancestral knowledge
- 31:15has less validity or less value. Yet, these communities
- 31:19have coexisted with their ecosystems for thousands
- 31:22of years, and their knowledge is profound. integrated,
- 31:26and perfectly adapted to the environment. How
- 31:28does Greenpeace support these indigenous communities
- 31:31and amplify their voices, for instance, at COP16?
- 31:35It's a great starting point you've raised, Linda,
- 31:38because it's about epistemologies about the narratives
- 31:41we use. Science, of course, is incredibly important,
- 31:44but it's only one knowledge system, and other
- 31:47knowledge systems operate under entirely different
- 31:50logic. This debate about scientifically validating
- 31:53indigenous knowledge is noble, but we also need
- 31:56to understand indigenous knowledge systems on
- 31:58their own terms, rooted in unique epistemologies,
- 32:01narratives, and dynamics distinct from Western
- 32:04science. For example, I've had the privilege
- 32:07of sailing with Mapuche -Wilish communities in
- 32:10southern Chile, and it's impressive how they
- 32:12navigate with no instruments, no GPS. They know
- 32:16exactly when storms will come, how the sea will
- 32:18behave. because they're constantly reading the
- 32:21land. And this skill, this knowledge, is now
- 32:24at risk because of regulations on what's required
- 32:27for navigation permits, limiting a grandparent's
- 32:30ability to take a grandchild on such journeys.
- 32:33All these seemingly small issues play a huge
- 32:35role in passing down these forms of knowledge,
- 32:38which are deeply territorial, knowledge rooted
- 32:41in the land. Once, I spoke with a leader from
- 32:44the Khosgar community who mentioned that when
- 32:46someone claimed to speak Khosgar on Chilean TV,
- 32:49she thought, but Khosgar is learned in the land
- 32:51itself. You can't just learn it because each
- 32:54word has meaning tied to specific places. Imagine
- 32:57a language tied directly to territorial knowledge.
- 33:00When we discuss indigenous participation, it's
- 33:03essential for building solutions. While technology
- 33:06is often touted as the solution to everything,
- 33:09we have more access to technology than ever before,
- 33:12yet we're still facing severe climate, biodiversity,
- 33:15and pollution challenges. We're seeing some of
- 33:18the highest rates of biodiversity loss and rising
- 33:22temperatures in history. While technology helps,
- 33:25it's not the only answer. So why not ask, why
- 33:28not listen to those with different knowledge
- 33:30systems? Indigenous communities are here with
- 33:33us at COP. We've organized side events, and discussions
- 33:37have centered on financing mechanisms that ensure
- 33:40funds not only reach vulnerable countries, but
- 33:43also the people within those countries actively
- 33:45protecting biodiversity. Discussions are ongoing
- 33:48about direct access to financing for indigenous
- 33:51communities. In many of our regional campaigns,
- 33:54we work closely with indigenous communities,
- 33:57sometimes presenting joint legal actions, supporting
- 34:00with scientific knowledge when needed to complement
- 34:02ancestral wisdom, as courts often operate within
- 34:05a Western framework. We strive to balance scientific
- 34:08knowledge with traditional knowledge. Truthfully,
- 34:12I'd say I've learned much more from indigenous
- 34:14communities than they've learned from me, and
- 34:17I want to express my deep gratitude to them.
- 34:19There's often this somewhat patronizing idea
- 34:21that NGOs have to go and make indigenous communities
- 34:24visible, but sometimes they know exactly how
- 34:27to make themselves visible and how to influence
- 34:29change. I'm often amazed by the level of organization
- 34:33within Colombian indigenous communities. They're
- 34:36incredibly strong and know exactly how to find
- 34:39those spaces. So from civil society's perspective,
- 34:42it's often about giving these spaces and letting
- 34:45the right people take the lead. It's not just
- 34:47about delivering something to them. I am profoundly
- 34:50grateful to all the indigenous communities I've
- 34:53worked with. They've taught me so much and have
- 34:56completely shifted my worldview. I was educated
- 34:59within a highly colonial, scientific paradigm,
- 35:02and working with them has been like a reset.
- 35:04It's like they've shaken my understanding of
- 35:06the world, turned it upside down. Wonderful.
- 35:10Thank you for sharing. Many of our guests have
- 35:12shared similar reflections from working with
- 35:14indigenous communities. It's essential to keep
- 35:17this in mind. Finally, Estefania, you have shared
- 35:20many important messages today, but if you had
- 35:23to choose one final message for our audience,
- 35:25what would you want to leave them with? I think
- 35:29the most important message is to say that working
- 35:31for nature, biodiversity, and socio -environmental
- 35:34issues is worth it, no matter the outcome. We're
- 35:37in a challenging moment globally. and within
- 35:39each country. It's easy to feel hopeless, to
- 35:43think. It's all over. Why bother if we won't
- 35:46achieve anything? My message is that getting
- 35:49involved is valuable in and of itself, even if
- 35:52we don't reach our goals. I don't know if we'll
- 35:55succeed. I can't say with certainty that we will.
- 35:58Deep down, I think we will, but I don't know.
- 36:01What I do know is that it's worth living every
- 36:03day working toward a better world. whether it's
- 36:06through our relationships, how we treat nature
- 36:08around us, how we communicate and think about
- 36:11nature. It's worth it. The richness of living
- 36:14a life connected to what's around us is unparalleled.
- 36:18It changed my life, and it continues to do so
- 36:22every day. For instance, we've been fighting
- 36:25a large salmon company in Chile alongside indigenous
- 36:28communities after a whale, which was endangered,
- 36:30got entangled and died. And then, nothing happens.
- 36:35the authorities let it go, and we feel like we've
- 36:38lost. But along the way, we've gained so much,
- 36:41relationships, experiences, connections with
- 36:44incredible places, and inspiring others. When
- 36:48a company loses millions, they lose, but when
- 36:51we win, we win, and even when we lose, we still
- 36:54gain something. So I want to encourage people
- 36:56to get involved, to know that it's worth it,
- 36:59and to keep talking about these issues. It's
- 37:01up to us. Even if sometimes we're led to believe
- 37:04that the power lies solely with big companies
- 37:06or governments, we are not the same, and we can
- 37:09make a difference. We invite people to join us.
- 37:12Greenpeace has a platform in Argentina, Chile,
- 37:15Colombia, and globally with many actions where
- 37:18people can get involved, from sharing a video
- 37:20to signing a petition, to sometimes messaging
- 37:23a minister to prevent something from happening.
- 37:25Join Greenpeace .com's call to action for nature
- 37:28at COP. But also remember, there are countless
- 37:31ways to contribute. Even just talking with neighbors
- 37:34and caring for the trees around us. It's worth
- 37:37it. The journey is absolutely worth it. Yes,
- 37:40that's a beautiful message. I completely agree.
- 37:43A friend we interview, who is the director of
- 37:45Kathnex, who was here in Australia, said that
- 37:48we don't need people doing this perfectly. We
- 37:51need more people doing it imperfectly, but being
- 37:54involved. Because every action counts. Perfection
- 37:58isn't necessary. We just need more people taking
- 38:00part. Thank you so much, Estefania. Thank you
- 38:03all for the invitation and for the incredible
- 38:06work you're doing in raising awareness. Most
- 38:09of my interviews are 10, maybe 15 minutes long,
- 38:12not because I want to talk, but because it shows
- 38:14the importance placed on these topics. So gathering,
- 38:17reflecting together, and talking about environmental
- 38:20issues is invaluable, and I'm grateful for the
- 38:23space. It's been one of the highlights of my
- 38:25week. And I'm leaving here very happy. Of course.
- 38:29Thank you very much. This podcast is fully self
- 38:32-funded and self -edited by your dedicated hosts.
- 38:35And we rely on your support to grow. You can
- 38:38help us spread the word by subscribing, sharing,
- 38:42and leaving a review. Find us on YouTube, Spotify,
- 38:46and our official website, www .sciencebehindtheglass
- 38:50.com. Follow us on X, Facebook, and Instagram
- 38:53for the latest updates. A special thanks to our
- 38:57friend Bernardo Avila for the original music
- 38:59and to our promotions manager Rafael Giordano
- 39:02for his invaluable technical support. Let's keep
- 39:06the conversation going.