Latest / FDD Events Podcast / Assessing America’s 2023 Cyber Resiliency: A Conversation with the CSC 2.0 Co-Chairs
Transcript
- 0:04[SPEAKER_00]: Good morning, everyone.
- 0:05[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for coming to our event on Capitol Hill.
- 0:08[SPEAKER_00]: Hosted by the foundation for the defense of democracies.
- 0:11[SPEAKER_00]: It is September, nineteen, and today we are joined by representative Mike Gallagher and Senator Angus King, U.S.
- 0:18[SPEAKER_00]: cyberspace Solarium Commission co-chairs, and the former National Cyber Director Chris Inglis to discuss the twenty twenty three annual report on the implementation of the commission's recommendations.
- 0:31[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Samantha Ravich,
- 0:32[SPEAKER_00]: chair of FDD's Center on Cyber and Technology Innovation and a former Commissioner of the Cyber Space Salarium Commission.
- 0:40[SPEAKER_00]: On behalf of FDD, we're happy to welcome you both in person and on live stream for this event.
- 0:46[SPEAKER_00]: Co-hosted with CSC, two-point-o, which preserves the legacy and continues the work of the Commission.
- 0:54[SPEAKER_00]: We at FDD are honored to house CSC, two-point-o, in collaboration with my fellow commissioners of the Cyber Space Salarium Commission.
- 1:02[SPEAKER_00]: The Commission's goal was, quote, to develop a consensus on a strategic approach to defending the US in cyberspace from significant cyber attacks.
- 1:15[SPEAKER_00]: We met more than fifty times, often for two hour sessions, and we analyzed, discussed, and always in the most collegial fashions argued about the main components of that goal.
- 1:26[SPEAKER_00]: a strategic approach, defending cyberspace.
- 1:30[SPEAKER_00]: What is a significant attack?
- 1:32[SPEAKER_00]: And we reached a consensus on one hundred and sixteen distinct recommendations.
- 1:38[SPEAKER_00]: But recommendations are only truly effective once they become executive or legislative action.
- 1:43[SPEAKER_00]: And today, I'm proud to say that we have seen significant progress on that front.
- 1:48[SPEAKER_00]: While I implore you to read the assessment, I want to highlight some important figures.
- 1:53[SPEAKER_00]: Nearly seventy percent of our recommendations are either fully implemented or nearing implementation, with over twenty percent on-tracked implementation.
- 2:03[SPEAKER_00]: This shows a steady increase from the sixty percent fully or nearing implementation from last year and thirty five percent from twenty twenty one.
- 2:12[SPEAKER_00]: Today we have the privilege to be joined by the Commission's co-chairs.
- 2:15[SPEAKER_00]: Senator Angus King and Representative Mike Gallagher, former national cyber director Chris English, an executive director, rear admiral retired Mark Montgomery.
- 2:24[SPEAKER_00]: Here to assess the recommendations implementations progress.
- 2:28[SPEAKER_00]: Before I hand it over to them, let me briefly introduce our panelists.
- 2:32[SPEAKER_00]: Our first panelist is Senator Angus King, who has been serving as Maine's Independent United States Senator since the first time, before which he served two terms as Maine's governor.
- 2:42[SPEAKER_00]: He currently serves on the Armed Services Committee
- 2:45[SPEAKER_00]: the Select Committee on Intelligence, the Committee on Energy and National Resources, and the Committee on Veterans Affairs, giving him a death of experience in strengthening America's national security to promote prosperity.
- 2:57[SPEAKER_00]: Angus, I recently heard you say that strategic posture is deterrence.
- 3:03[SPEAKER_00]: Your work on the Commission was instrumental in creating that strategic posture, which will help our country and its citizenry remain secure.
- 3:12[SPEAKER_00]: Our second panelist is Congressman Mike Gallagher.
- 3:16[SPEAKER_00]: who has represented Wisconsin's eighth district in the U.S.
- 3:19[SPEAKER_00]: House of Representatives since twenty seventeen, Mike serves as the chairman of the House Armed Services subcommittee on cyber information technologies and innovation and as chairman of the select committee on the strategic competition between the United States and the Chinese Communist Party.
- 3:35[SPEAKER_00]: Prior to his time in Congress, he was an active duty in the United States Marine, learning the price of freedom at the granular level.
- 3:42[SPEAKER_00]: Mike, all of us who know you and all who are getting to know you through your work on Solarium and now on China are watching in real time, a leader emerge.
- 3:52[SPEAKER_00]: Our third panelist is Chris English, who, as many of you know, served as the inaugural National Cyber Director until February of this year.
- 4:00[SPEAKER_00]: Chris taught the US Naval Academy and served as a fellow commissioner on the Cyber Space Larium Commission.
- 4:05[SPEAKER_00]: Prior to that, he was a career national security agency leader rising to deputy director of NSA.
- 4:11[SPEAKER_00]: Our fourth panelist is Mark Montgomery, senior director of FDD's Center on Cyber and Technology Innovation, an executive director of CSE, two point out.
- 4:20[SPEAKER_00]: I got to know Mark as the unrelenting executive director of the Cyber Space Salarium Commission
- 4:26[SPEAKER_00]: Now, I've had the pleasure of working with him at FDD as well.
- 4:29[SPEAKER_00]: Our discussion will be moderated by Maggie Miller, a cybersecurity reporter at Politico.
- 4:34[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, Maggie, for guiding what will be an intriguing discussion.
- 4:37[SPEAKER_00]: One last thing before we dive in, a little about FDD.
- 4:40[SPEAKER_00]: For more than twenty years, FDD has operated as a fiercely independent nonpartisan research institute exclusively focused on national security and foreign policy.
- 4:51[SPEAKER_00]: As a point of pride and principle, we do not accept foreign funding.
- 4:54[SPEAKER_00]: Never have, never will.
- 4:56[SPEAKER_00]: For more on our work, please visit our website, FDD.org and follow us on Twitter at FDD.
- 5:02[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, that's enough for me.
- 5:03[SPEAKER_00]: Maggie, over to you.
- 5:04[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you.
- 5:05[SPEAKER_04]: All right, great.
- 5:10[SPEAKER_04]: Thank you, Samantha, for such a great introduction.
- 5:13[SPEAKER_04]: and welcome to the panelists.
- 5:14[SPEAKER_04]: Good morning on this bright, nearly day.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_04]: So we're going to just jump right into it and start talking with the National Cyber Security Strategy, which since the publication of the annual assessment last year has been put out.
- 5:29[SPEAKER_04]: and the accompanying implementation plan.
- 5:32[SPEAKER_04]: So director English, I'm going to get your response to this in a minute.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_04]: But first, Senator King, Congressman Gallagher, I want to hear from you.
- 5:40[SPEAKER_04]: You called the strategy comprehensive when it came out.
- 5:44[SPEAKER_04]: How consistent was it with your vision on the salarium?
- 5:48[SPEAKER_04]: And what's the impact you're seeing as a result of the strategy?
- 5:59[SPEAKER_08]: Okay.
- 6:02[SPEAKER_08]: First, I think the first thing I want to say is this is something that often happens to a U.S.
- 6:05[SPEAKER_08]: Senator, which is to speak to a room full of people, all of whom know more about the subject than he does, but it doesn't hold you back.
- 6:13[SPEAKER_08]: So I'm going to make my comments anyway.
- 6:15[SPEAKER_08]: No, I think the strategy was very thorough, and I'm glad you mentioned implementation.
- 6:21[SPEAKER_08]: And I think we ought to recognize Campbell Walden for the work that she did in developing the implementation plan.
- 6:26[SPEAKER_08]: My experience in public policy is that implementation is as important as vision.
- 6:32[SPEAKER_08]: You can have a great idea, a great plan.
- 6:33[SPEAKER_08]: You can pass the bill, but it's the implementation that's really important.
- 6:38[SPEAKER_08]: And I think that's why I'm so glad that the administration took both steps, not just to release the strategy.
- 6:45[SPEAKER_08]: So I like the strategy.
- 6:48[SPEAKER_08]: I remember fellow members of the Commission will not be surprised.
- 6:52[SPEAKER_08]: I still feel there needs to be greater emphasis on deterrence, because we're just not going to be able to patch and defend their way out of this.
- 7:01[SPEAKER_08]: I think our adversaries have to fear us.
- 7:04[SPEAKER_08]: They have to fear that there will be consequences for a significant cyber attack on this country.
- 7:08[SPEAKER_08]: And I'm not sure we've got the clarity of declaratory policy that we ought to have in order to develop a
- 7:18[SPEAKER_08]: a policy of deterrence that will be effective.
- 7:21[SPEAKER_08]: So I'll leave it at that.
- 7:23[SPEAKER_08]: I have some other thoughts.
- 7:24[SPEAKER_08]: I do want to thank the staff.
- 7:26[SPEAKER_08]: This is one of the most useful clear reports that I've seen.
- 7:30[SPEAKER_08]: And I love the way it's presented with the color coding.
- 7:32[SPEAKER_08]: You can tell exactly what's working, what isn't working, where the gaps are, where we need to do further work.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_08]: But the great piece of work, I attribute to Mark.
- 7:44[SPEAKER_08]: Mike and I have often said that the smartest thing we did in the whole process
- 7:47[SPEAKER_08]: was higher markment summary to be the director who has done just a fantastic job.
- 7:52[SPEAKER_02]: So I'll leave it at that.
- 7:55[SPEAKER_02]: Well, echo, Senator King's comments with one notable exception about our report on implementation, which is that the picture on the front has angus nicely in the foreground.
- 8:09[SPEAKER_02]: Clear, whereas I'm obscured and blurred out in the background.
- 8:13[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know what message Mark was trying to send with that one.
- 8:17[SPEAKER_02]: Is it if I don't exist?
- 8:18[SPEAKER_02]: No matter, which reflects the Senate's view of the House.
- 8:22[SPEAKER_02]: I think.
- 8:25[SPEAKER_02]: No, I agree with all of that.
- 8:27[SPEAKER_02]: And I should say, my general view of the world is anything that Chris Inglis had any sort of role in is usually a good thing.
- 8:36[SPEAKER_02]: And it's usually smart.
- 8:37[SPEAKER_02]: And I admire that product.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_02]: And in addition to hiring Mark Montgomery, which was a great decision we were lucky to have.
- 8:43[SPEAKER_02]: Chris English is one of our commissioners who then became the first national cyber director.
- 8:47[SPEAKER_02]: And I don't think there's anyone else who could have taken on that role in its infancy.
- 8:52[SPEAKER_02]: And I hope we have a full some discussion about the role itself and the future of the role, but Chris did a phenomenal job.
- 8:59[SPEAKER_02]: Now I think, particularly as we think about implementation, it's up to us in Congress to continue to apply productive pressure to the executive branch.
- 9:06[SPEAKER_02]: The document is one thing.
- 9:07[SPEAKER_02]: The actual actions are another.
- 9:09[SPEAKER_02]: There I say in the House at least that we do have a very good
- 9:13[SPEAKER_02]: working group that's emerged.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_02]: One of the challenges we face is that jurisdiction over cyber issues is split between numerous committees.
- 9:20[SPEAKER_02]: I have sort of the military component of it.
- 9:22[SPEAKER_02]: Intel has a component of it and then homeland has a big component of it.
- 9:26[SPEAKER_02]: And traditionally these committees don't talk to each other.
- 9:28[SPEAKER_02]: They don't work well together.
- 9:30[SPEAKER_02]: But if you look on page four of the report, probably another picture of Angus.
- 9:36[SPEAKER_02]: Oh no.
- 9:37[SPEAKER_08]: If you look on page four of the report, you'll see the least
- 9:43[SPEAKER_08]: The least implemented recommendation is to set up a special cyber committee in the Congress.
- 9:49[SPEAKER_08]: We failed utterly at that because of just what Mike said.
- 9:53[SPEAKER_08]: I think it's a red bar right across.
- 9:58[SPEAKER_08]: It says Congressional Select Committee on Cyber didn't happen.
- 10:03[SPEAKER_08]: And it is one of the real problems.
- 10:04[SPEAKER_08]: I don't mean to interrupt you.
- 10:06[SPEAKER_08]: In order to get the first forty or so provisions implemented in the Congress a couple of years ago, we had to get a hundred and eighty clearances from committees, subcommittees, minority, majority.
- 10:22[SPEAKER_08]: I mean, it was just crazy that an attribute to all the work that went into getting that done.
- 10:29[SPEAKER_08]: But that points out
- 10:31[SPEAKER_08]: how difficult it is to make, to do this kind of policy in a situation where you have divided authority and people are jealous of their authority.
- 10:39[SPEAKER_08]: They don't want to give up any at all.
- 10:41[SPEAKER_08]: And this might compromise.
- 10:43[SPEAKER_08]: Sorry, sorry, sorry.
- 10:46[SPEAKER_08]: But that was one of the biggest failures of the work of the commission.
- 10:51[SPEAKER_08]: And I'm afraid it's probably hopeless because the committee just aren't going to advocate their responsibility.
- 10:57[SPEAKER_02]: I just let it be so in light of that, we have a kind of a working group going on here in the house with all the various committees that own a piece of the jurisdiction.
- 11:06[SPEAKER_02]: And this was Chairman Green's vision, and so it's not quite as good as having a cybersecurity committee, but it's working somewhat in the House of Representatives.
- 11:17[SPEAKER_02]: And it's our job to ensure that there's implementation happening.
- 11:20[SPEAKER_04]: And before I get to your reaction, Director English, to the implementation plan, since you brought it up, Senator King Congressman Gallinger, I know the report notes that there has been drafted legislation to create these cyber committees in the case of an emergency.
- 11:34[SPEAKER_04]: Do you ever, what would you envision that case being, do you ever think that there is a potential that Congress could turn around pretty quickly on this?
- 11:41[SPEAKER_02]: Well, I mean,
- 11:43[SPEAKER_02]: Traditionally, if you look at the creation of the House Promise Club Committee on Intelligence, it took a crisis to create it or scandal.
- 11:49[SPEAKER_02]: We're hoping to avoid that.
- 11:50[SPEAKER_02]: Our mantra throughout our two years of work was we wanted to be the nine eleven commission without the nine eleven.
- 11:55[SPEAKER_02]: So we're hoping that we don't have sort of a cyber nine eleven occur and then everyone says, oh, you know, we should have created a select committee on cyber security in Congress.
- 12:02[SPEAKER_02]: So perhaps there would be a something else that would spark the conversation because I have to
- 12:09[SPEAKER_02]: I have to admit I share Senator King's dire assessment of Congress sort of willingly organizing and creating a committee at this point.
- 12:18[SPEAKER_02]: I will say every period of productive congressional reform and there's been very few in the past has involved some reorganization and consolidation of committee authority.
- 12:28[SPEAKER_02]: And I think we're at a moment now where we need such a reorganization and to read look at how the basic committees are structured.
- 12:36[SPEAKER_04]: And turning now to you, Director English, I want to give you a chance, obviously, to respond to the lawmakers' comments on the implementation plan and the strategy.
- 12:47[SPEAKER_04]: And also now that you are outside of government, how do you think your old office is doing on the implementation of the strategy?
- 12:53[SPEAKER_07]: Well, I'll answer in a reverse order.
- 12:54[SPEAKER_07]: I think they're doing great.
- 12:55[SPEAKER_07]: And I think that they're part of a much larger team that's been mobilized to actually address the needs the nation has in its dependence on cyber.
- 13:03[SPEAKER_07]: The first could describe the implementation plan.
- 13:05[SPEAKER_07]: You have to understand the strategy itself and my favorite criticism of the strategy is that it was once described as everything everywhere all at once.
- 13:12[SPEAKER_07]: Yes, it is wider than it is tall because we have to mobilize all of the efforts, all of the capabilities, all the authorities, all the talents to include private, public and multiple governments and the strategy attempts to do that.
- 13:26[SPEAKER_07]: It does that in a coherent fashion where it hangs together.
- 13:29[SPEAKER_07]: As Senator King Congressman Gallagher noted, it's really important then to have an implementation plan that instantiates that the brings action to that the spirit of what was called for in those various strategic principles in the implementation plan delivered in concert in parallel with the strategy itself delivered within three months does just that.
- 13:48[SPEAKER_07]: Sixty-five actions across eighteen agencies and departments that's actually again wider than it is tall and is work underway.
- 13:56[SPEAKER_07]: There is a life force behind it in the form of the Office of the National Cyber Director that works hand in love with the agency's departments, not least of which the Office of Management budget to make sure that we resource the things that we've committed to do.
- 14:08[SPEAKER_07]: That's a very, very important relationship.
- 14:10[SPEAKER_07]: And that life force, the Office of the National Cyber Director, reports both to the Executive Branch and to all the stakeholders in the Executive Branch and to the Congress.
- 14:17[SPEAKER_07]: That's a very important join to sustain as we go forward.
- 14:21[SPEAKER_07]: So I'm very bullish on the role that the Office of the National Cyber Director can play.
- 14:25[SPEAKER_07]: from this day forward.
- 14:27[SPEAKER_04]: And turning to you, Mark, want to get into a little bit of the nitty gritty of this third annual implementation or assessment, I should say report.
- 14:36[SPEAKER_04]: released today, which had looked at the progress on the hundred and sixteen recommendations that the Solarium has put out around that since the twenty twenty.
- 14:46[SPEAKER_04]: So how would you say that Congress and the Biden administration are doing on implementation of Solarium recommendations and what were some of the biggest changes since last year?
- 14:57[SPEAKER_05]: Well, I think we've continued to kind of persist in slow, you know, process.
- 15:01[SPEAKER_05]: You know, the first year was of getting about thirty, thirty-five percent done, and Senator King used to say, you know, if he hit three, fifty playing for the Yankees, he'd make thirty million a year, probably forty million a year now.
- 15:12[SPEAKER_05]: So that was a good year, but since then, each year we got another twenty-five percent, the next year and then ten percent this year.
- 15:18[SPEAKER_05]: I expect that kind of slowing numbers, you know, that we can get five to ten percent done.
- 15:24[SPEAKER_05]: a year over the next couple years.
- 15:25[SPEAKER_05]: So I think that kind of persistent process is good.
- 15:27[SPEAKER_05]: The big things over the last twelve months are the Cyber Diplomacy Act inside the National Defense Authorization Bill last year and the confirmation, very rapid confirmation thanks to the Senator King and Senator Hernandez of Nate Fick is the Cyber Ambassador, a very good appropriations bill.
- 15:44[SPEAKER_05]: You know that got, says a back up to about two, two point six billion and fully funded office and national cyber director.
- 15:51[SPEAKER_05]: and gave some money to the SRMA, sector risk management agencies, not all that's been inconsistent.
- 15:57[SPEAKER_05]: And then I think the executive branch has done some good things over the past year.
- 16:01[SPEAKER_05]: Starting the Zero Trust Mark program, it's consistent with our certification and labeling initiative.
- 16:09[SPEAKER_05]: The SEC rulemaking, certainly the part that has to do with governance structures inside C-suite, being responsible for cybersecurity.
- 16:17[SPEAKER_05]: That gets in our sarbans, actually.
- 16:18[SPEAKER_05]: And frankly, we were never going to be able
- 16:20[SPEAKER_05]: Serving's actually was all red, like cyber committees, because the chance of cracking open a bill that complex, it became too hard.
- 16:28[SPEAKER_05]: So having the SEC chairman against their attack it through rulemaking, I think, was the right way.
- 16:34[SPEAKER_05]: So overall, a number of good things, but we need to expect that this is about a ten percent thing each year.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_05]: What I would say is our white paper recommendations are now where we're making the most headway on workforce, on supply chain,
- 16:49[SPEAKER_05]: And then even some of the papers at CSC two-point-o is done.
- 16:52[SPEAKER_05]: I'm hoping we can make some progress on things like the water sector and the maritime transportation sector.
- 16:58[SPEAKER_05]: So there's room for growth next year.
- 17:00[SPEAKER_05]: I think that growth those as much in the white papers and the follow-on CSC two-point-o papers as it is in the original eighty-two as we're getting near the end of those.
- 17:09[SPEAKER_02]: Can I interject something?
- 17:10[SPEAKER_02]: Absolutely.
- 17:11[SPEAKER_02]: I'll interject the question for Mark.
- 17:13[SPEAKER_02]: Do any of these other commissions have this implementation or two-point-out thing like we do?
- 17:18[SPEAKER_05]: I think so you and I did an event with Eric Schmidt, the Artificial Intelligence, the NS National Security Commission and Artificial Intelligence.
- 17:27[SPEAKER_05]: They don't do what we're doing, but I do think with a generous grant from Eric Schmidt, they've kept the team in place and in fact we work pretty closely with them.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_05]: But I would say, be very helpful.
- 17:39[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, because they're legislative, they didn't have four legislators on their commission.
- 17:44[SPEAKER_05]: I think it's a little less of a kind of an implementation plan and more tackling the broader issue of artificial intelligence.
- 17:51[SPEAKER_05]: But definitely, this is unique.
- 17:53[SPEAKER_05]: I mean, you know, our famous, you know, we took briefs that the most famous commission was really Simpson Bowles.
- 17:59[SPEAKER_05]: But that track it would be zero for nineteen.
- 18:02[SPEAKER_05]: And as a result, our debt is no longer six trillion, it's thirty-three trillion as of a few days ago.
- 18:07[SPEAKER_05]: You know, this is a unique commission in that regard.
- 18:09[SPEAKER_05]: I think it started with having four congressional members as leaders.
- 18:14[SPEAKER_05]: Jim Lange was not here today.
- 18:16[SPEAKER_05]: Ben Sassas in here, but, you know, we'd be remissed that I mentioned that Jim Lange had put a lot of this legislation on his shoulders for two years, two and a half years, and really carried it on.
- 18:25[SPEAKER_02]: I'm sorry for that.
- 18:26[SPEAKER_02]: There's always interesting literature about commissions.
- 18:28[SPEAKER_02]: Do they work?
- 18:29[SPEAKER_02]: Don't they work?
- 18:30[SPEAKER_02]: How do you structure them?
- 18:31[SPEAKER_02]: Is it just show?
- 18:32[SPEAKER_02]: I'm sorry.
- 18:33[SPEAKER_04]: No, no worries.
- 18:34[SPEAKER_04]: Actually, quick follow up, Mark.
- 18:36[SPEAKER_04]: What sort of white papers should we be looking for from CSE to point out the rest of the year?
- 18:40[SPEAKER_05]: So I think that we really need to take a look at the sectors that are weak.
- 18:44[SPEAKER_05]: Like we constantly say across the sixteen critical infrastructure sectors, there's a winner like energy and losers.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_05]: I wouldn't say fifteen others, but you know,
- 18:54[SPEAKER_05]: Even on a bell curve, there's a lot of season D's in there.
- 18:58[SPEAKER_05]: We've hit water, we've hit maritime transportation security.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_05]: I think we'll hit healthcare, food, agriculture, aviation, and then there's an important one we're working on whether or not we need a cyber force.
- 19:10[SPEAKER_05]: I know that'll be well received by all the commissioners as we bring that through and a couple others like that, but that's where we're headed right now.
- 19:19[SPEAKER_04]: will be watching closely on the cyber force issue in particular.
- 19:21[SPEAKER_04]: In particular, and actually I wanted to turn to a Senator King now, something Mark just mentioned.
- 19:27[SPEAKER_04]: The cyber diplomacy act was one of your top priorities a year ago, and while the Bureau of Cyber Space and Digital Policy had begun its work last year,
- 19:37[SPEAKER_04]: you had said codification was important and you're able to get that done in last year's NDAA and since then also as Mark mentioned, Nathaniel thick has been confirmed as the ambassador.
- 19:47[SPEAKER_04]: So what are your thoughts on how the bureau was doing so far and also they're currently working on an international cyber strategy.
- 19:54[SPEAKER_04]: What all do you think should be addressed in that?
- 19:56[SPEAKER_08]: Well first I have to describe Nathan's confirmation hearing because I introduced him and I sat in front of the
- 20:05[SPEAKER_08]: at the widest table, and I looked up at the chair and said, I want to introduce Nate Fikkus, nominated for this position, and articulate his qualifications.
- 20:18[SPEAKER_08]: He's for me.
- 20:19[SPEAKER_08]: And I folded my papers up and started to stand up and walk away.
- 20:24[SPEAKER_08]: And it worked.
- 20:26[SPEAKER_08]: But no, having that position, I think, is more important than ever.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_08]: There's an old saying we brought better than we thought.
- 20:33[SPEAKER_08]: And I think we all realized there was an important international aspect of this question, but today it's even more clear than it was three or four years ago.
- 20:42[SPEAKER_08]: And so having the position, having it codified so that it's not, I give the administration credit, they appointed him and started the process before the law was passed, but it was in a kind of
- 20:58[SPEAKER_08]: It had no long-term currency.
- 21:00[SPEAKER_08]: It wasn't established in law.
- 21:02[SPEAKER_08]: Having established it in law, I think, is very important.
- 21:05[SPEAKER_08]: But also having somebody of Nate's capabilities in the office, but the conclusion is, this is an entirely international issue.
- 21:17[SPEAKER_08]: And we can do everything right here, but if there are breaches in other countries, if there are weaknesses in other places,
- 21:25[SPEAKER_08]: that's clearly a vulnerability but also we need to be working on setting international standards so that there's some clarity for countries around the world about what the rules of the game are and that's where America was lacking prior to the establishment of this position we weren't playing in the multitude of conferences and
- 21:49[SPEAKER_08]: and meetings and exchanges with other countries.
- 21:52[SPEAKER_08]: And now we're clearly in that position and natives of God that can really, I think can make a significant contribution.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_08]: So that's one that I'm really feeling good about.
- 22:05[SPEAKER_08]: And you mentioned the National Defense Authorization Act, Congress is like a train station.
- 22:10[SPEAKER_08]: And there are very few trains that go through.
- 22:14[SPEAKER_08]: But when a train is going through, you're going to put everything on it that you possibly can.
- 22:18[SPEAKER_08]: So that's why we created the position of international cyber director in the National Defense Authorization Act because that was the train that was going through the station.
- 22:27[SPEAKER_08]: And we were pretty sure it was going to get to its destination.
- 22:30[SPEAKER_08]: So I'm very pleased.
- 22:32[SPEAKER_08]: I think that was a big win last year.
- 22:34[SPEAKER_04]: And do you have any thoughts on this upcoming international cyber strategy that I know they're working on?
- 22:39[SPEAKER_04]: And if anyone else on the panel has thoughts on that as well?
- 22:44[SPEAKER_07]: Let me just want a lot of thinking about those thoughts, just say first a compliment to Nate.
- 22:50[SPEAKER_07]: There are some people that you made that are great at the podium and less so perhaps close in as they compete for kind of oxygen and space in the room.
- 22:56[SPEAKER_07]: Nate is just the opposite.
- 22:58[SPEAKER_07]: He is terrific at both of those.
- 22:59[SPEAKER_07]: He's very collaborative.
- 23:00[SPEAKER_07]: He sees the diplomacy within cyberspace as an instrument power, not the principal instrument of power, and therefore collaborates extremely well across the other instruments of power, not least in the private sector.
- 23:12[SPEAKER_07]: And I think to Senator King's point, this is a truly international issue.
- 23:15[SPEAKER_07]: If you're an individual, making use of services in cyberspace, you're reaching across national boundaries.
- 23:20[SPEAKER_07]: If you're a company doing business in cyberspace, you work across national boundaries.
- 23:24[SPEAKER_07]: You hope that the people who are actually directing policy, diplomacy, think in those same terms, Nate does the State Department does.
- 23:32[SPEAKER_07]: He's a godsend.
- 23:36[SPEAKER_02]: Great.
- 23:37[SPEAKER_02]: Someone was a remarkably effective.
- 23:40[SPEAKER_02]: He has the distinction of being better-looking than the guy you played him on TV.
- 23:43[SPEAKER_02]: Which is true.
- 23:47[SPEAKER_02]: Great Marines, so it may have been fantastic.
- 23:49[SPEAKER_02]: You know, sort of, I sort of thought we had remarkably with Nate, Chris, with Jenny Strilly, who was, you know, did some red teaming for us on the Slam Commission.
- 24:00[SPEAKER_02]: All these incredibly talented and collaborative people, which, you know, is obviously very rare in government.
- 24:10[SPEAKER_02]: Just sort of provide the support necessary to those talented players, iterate based on some experiences we had with the creation of the National Cyber Director, I think we'd be in a very, very good position.
- 24:23[SPEAKER_02]: So it's incumbent upon Congress to make sure that folks like Nate, you know, future national cyber directors, and Jenny's truly have the resources and support they need in order to advance the objectives that we all agree upon.
- 24:36[SPEAKER_05]: So on the International Cyber Strategy,
- 24:38[SPEAKER_05]: I'd be excited if they have it done by December, like Congress asked, I think it'll probably be late.
- 24:44[SPEAKER_05]: But I am excited to see it really emphasized building partner capacity building.
- 24:48[SPEAKER_05]: The CSC did a paper on this a few months ago, and it's our strong belief that we need to get, particularly the non-military aspects of cyber capacity building of our international partners, organized, make sure that we've examined it, removed any redundancies, but also addressed any gaps.
- 25:07[SPEAKER_05]: And then give state department the funding line they need to lead this.
- 25:12[SPEAKER_05]: And then make sure we're helping them.
- 25:14[SPEAKER_05]: And we should definitely prioritize those countries whose national critical infrastructure is critical to our military and our economic security.
- 25:22[SPEAKER_05]: In other words, the countries through which we may have to move through and over our U.S.
- 25:26[SPEAKER_05]: forces.
- 25:27[SPEAKER_05]: And the countries upon whom we're really dependent for supply chain parts during a crisis or
- 25:34[SPEAKER_05]: or contingency.
- 25:35[SPEAKER_05]: And then, you know, get those out there and build a cyber resilience of those partners.
- 25:40[SPEAKER_02]: I just make a quick point on that.
- 25:41[SPEAKER_02]: Like, if you're considering the most stressing NASCAR to scenario, let's say Chinese invasion of Taiwan, my view is that the only short war for Taiwan would be a quick Chinese victory.
- 25:53[SPEAKER_02]: And therefore, you have to assume that we are going to need to surge men and material forward to the end of Pacific theater, which is not an easy thing to do in any circumstance, but that
- 26:02[SPEAKER_02]: Surging would be contested in cyberspace and our airports of de-barcation or C ports of de-barcation are incredibly vulnerable to cybertax.
- 26:10[SPEAKER_02]: Some of that's on domestic U.S.
- 26:12[SPEAKER_02]: oil, but some just in our own neighborhood, then places that we've neglected.
- 26:17[SPEAKER_02]: And putting on my hat is Chairman of the Select Committee on China to see the amount of investment, diplomatic, economic, military.
- 26:25[SPEAKER_02]: That China is putting in our own hemisphere is incredibly troubling, and it's just something we've neglected for far too long.
- 26:32[SPEAKER_04]: Now, actually, that tease us up perfectly for the next question, Congressman, which we're going to stay with you.
- 26:36[SPEAKER_04]: Of course, you are also the chair of the House Armed Services Cyber Subcommittee in charge of the cyber elements in the House of the NDAA.
- 26:46[SPEAKER_04]: It's approved on a bipartisan basis, dozens of provisions to strengthen U.S.
- 26:51[SPEAKER_04]: and partner cyber resilience.
- 26:54[SPEAKER_04]: looking at that from that position and also from your position as you mentioned as Chair of the Select Committee on China.
- 27:01[SPEAKER_04]: How are you hoping that the NDAA will shake out once it gets through conference on cyber issues and how are you using both of those leadership positions to push forward provisions on cyber?
- 27:10[SPEAKER_02]: Well, if you leave our first report was called ten for Taiwan, which was focused on things we could do in the hundred and eighteenth Congress to enhance near-term deterrence across the Taiwan straight.
- 27:18[SPEAKER_02]: Of our ten recommendations,
- 27:21[SPEAKER_02]: Seven, I think it last count got into NDA.
- 27:23[SPEAKER_02]: I should recognize the great work of James Mespash over there, my MLA and Defense Guru with an assist from Brigitte, of course, my Marine fellow.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_02]: By the way, I have former Gallagher fellow, Ali King in the back there.
- 27:36[SPEAKER_02]: So, you should remember, you may escape the office, but you always work for me still, as Mark has found out.
- 27:42[SPEAKER_08]: We call it staff for life.
- 27:43[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, exactly.
- 27:46[SPEAKER_02]: Probably the most important one for this discussion of the seven and NAAs, a provision to turbo charge, our cyber collaboration with Taiwan, building off some of the best practices we've learned in other parts of the world and having a conversation with them about how they can improve the resiliency of their grid, their critical infrastructure.
- 28:08[SPEAKER_02]: One comment that the now vice president and likely future president made to me when I was in Taiwan that
- 28:15[SPEAKER_02]: that suck with me, as we had this conversation about how do we turn Taiwan into a porcupine, is that, okay, you can't swallow a porcupine, but you can starve it.
- 28:25[SPEAKER_02]: And I left my last visit to Taiwan thinking that we need to be, we, I, e, those of us who come at this with a military conventional military lens need to be paying far more attention to a different scenario, a blockade scenario, or a scenario in which China tries to weaponize, or a scenario in which they
- 28:44[SPEAKER_02]: expand the cyber war that I would suggest has already begun for Taiwan.
- 28:49[SPEAKER_02]: So that's the provision I'm most closely tracking.
- 28:51[SPEAKER_02]: Another thing that I think is going to be important is a report we have evaluating the need for or the precise nature of a cyber force.
- 29:00[SPEAKER_02]: We're going to have that debate in the city subcommittee as well as a report on the how can we we can improve occupational resiliency in the cyber mission force and that brings to mind a related issue that we've
- 29:13[SPEAKER_02]: It's sort of having legislated NDA, but it's conversations that we've had with the Pentagon.
- 29:18[SPEAKER_02]: Are we making the best use of things like cyber-accepted service?
- 29:23[SPEAKER_02]: Are we making use of the creative authorities we've given to the Pentagon so they can hire some of the best and the brightest from the private sector who wouldn't traditionally be interested in a job in the five-sided building?
- 29:34[SPEAKER_02]: So that's what comes to mind right now, but I know Chris has something.
- 29:38[SPEAKER_04]: I was just going to answer that.
- 29:39[SPEAKER_07]: But I think we can take some lessons from our Ukrainian experience.
- 29:41[SPEAKER_07]: The Ukrainians have acquitted themselves quite well, not just on the physical battlefield, but in cyberspace, against what most of us would have said were very long odds.
- 29:50[SPEAKER_07]: And in cyberspace, I think what they've shown is technology matters, but expertise matters more in coalitions, matter still more, that coalition that they've built matters most of all.
- 30:00[SPEAKER_07]: Where the Russians now find themselves having to beat more of us, if not all of us, to beat the one thing that they want to beat.
- 30:05[SPEAKER_07]: That's a lesson for us in terms of our material disadvantages, as we attempt to defend something that's kind of on the backside of the planet.
- 30:12[SPEAKER_07]: Expertise and coalitions will matter more than that physical reality or the technology that's in play.
- 30:19[SPEAKER_05]: If I can add a few, I think this year's NDA is another thick, good cybersecurity list, NDA both the House and Senate versions.
- 30:27[SPEAKER_05]: They have a total of about forty-seven, forty-eight in there.
- 30:30[SPEAKER_05]: There's twenty-five provisions that we're tracking
- 30:33[SPEAKER_05]: having a tie-back to our initial reports.
- 30:35[SPEAKER_05]: Some of those support what's going from the Senate are a nuclear command and control continuing to make sure that our NC-free system has the proper security.
- 30:43[SPEAKER_05]: Senator King was emphasizing that repeatedly last few years as an important part of our strategic returns is actually having a secure system for controlling our nuclear weapons.
- 30:53[SPEAKER_05]: Another one that there's a continuity economy pilot program in the Senate version, and I think it'll be critical for moving that along, studying how secure are
- 31:03[SPEAKER_05]: are we, once we leave the bases?
- 31:06[SPEAKER_05]: Can we transition our supplies, our equipment, our personnel from the bases to the aviation points that are part and sea ports that are larger, that the Representative Galagher mentioned.
- 31:18[SPEAKER_05]: And I find out what I'd mentioned is there's a lot there on cyber command readiness.
- 31:23[SPEAKER_05]: How do we get the metrics, right?
- 31:24[SPEAKER_05]: We were always interested in metrics.
- 31:26[SPEAKER_05]: And I was glad to see both the House and Senate versions, those staffers are continuing to push
- 31:31[SPEAKER_05]: the issues into the NDAA.
- 31:35[SPEAKER_04]: And Senator King, do you have thoughts on the Senate side in the NDAA?
- 31:38[SPEAKER_08]: Well, I want to change this subject slightly and we talked about continuity of economy.
- 31:45[SPEAKER_08]: I'm still worried about the private sector.
- 31:49[SPEAKER_08]: Not only in a security sense of the compromise of a smaller facility that is a sub to a larger defense contractor and they get in that way.
- 32:02[SPEAKER_08]: there can't be any holes in the system supply chain.
- 32:06[SPEAKER_08]: But I'm also, I just, I don't know whether, I don't know quite how to say this, but I'm worried that in many places in the private sector, they're just still not taking this a series as it should be.
- 32:22[SPEAKER_08]: And I don't know what it's going to take because smaller, a lot of smaller entities are grappling with these ransomware attacks and those kind of things.
- 32:32[SPEAKER_08]: I think the energy sector is taking it very seriously.
- 32:36[SPEAKER_08]: Probably the best of any of the private sector entities.
- 32:41[SPEAKER_08]: The health care sector, I'm very worried about.
- 32:43[SPEAKER_08]: Water, there are seventy thousand water systems in America.
- 32:47[SPEAKER_08]: Now, that's good news in a sense that it means you can't compromise them all at once.
- 32:51[SPEAKER_08]: It's bad news in a sense that
- 32:53[SPEAKER_08]: Very few of them have the capability to have a serious cyber protection.
- 32:57[SPEAKER_08]: You know, they don't have a person on staff.
- 33:00[SPEAKER_08]: They're four or five people that run the system.
- 33:02[SPEAKER_08]: So I just think there's still an enormous amount of vulnerability out there in the private sector.
- 33:09[SPEAKER_08]: I don't, you know, we just keep talking about it.
- 33:12[SPEAKER_08]: But I'm glad that the SEC took the step that they did
- 33:18[SPEAKER_08]: I think corporate executives are going to have to view this as if they view financial risks and weather risks and those kinds of things.
- 33:28[SPEAKER_08]: This has to be, I believe, one of the highest priorities.
- 33:31[SPEAKER_08]: And in a case of a major cyber conflict, there's going to be no distinction between private and government.
- 33:37[SPEAKER_08]: I mean, it's all we're all in one way or the other.
- 33:41[SPEAKER_08]: And a compromise at a major
- 33:44[SPEAKER_08]: a major industry is going to compromise the country.
- 33:47[SPEAKER_08]: So I just, I want to get that in.
- 33:49[SPEAKER_08]: I think that's where there's built plenty of work to be done.
- 33:53[SPEAKER_04]: And to quickly follow up with you, Senator King, I know Congressman Gallagher mentioned cyber force and the support to Taiwan.
- 34:00[SPEAKER_04]: Do you think those are both issues that the Senate kind of agree on and that will get through conference on your side?
- 34:05[SPEAKER_08]: Yes.
- 34:07[SPEAKER_08]: for the shortest answer you have heard from a senator.
- 34:10[SPEAKER_04]: That's great.
- 34:10[SPEAKER_08]: We're probably both conference.
- 34:13[SPEAKER_02]: We'll jam it with our immense power.
- 34:16[SPEAKER_02]: It's right.
- 34:17[SPEAKER_04]: On cyber, the leaders.
- 34:19[SPEAKER_04]: And I want to turn to you, Director English.
- 34:22[SPEAKER_04]: The Commission focused on operationalizing public private collaboration.
- 34:26[SPEAKER_04]: Of course, that's a big focus of
- 34:28[SPEAKER_04]: the defense departments, cyber strategy, they just released.
- 34:32[SPEAKER_04]: And in your time in office and since, what do you think have been some of the big gains, what are the remaining hurdles in this space?
- 34:41[SPEAKER_04]: And then after Director English, very quickly perhaps Congressman Gallagher Senator King, you can comment on views from Capitol Hill and whether sector risk management agencies and others are making the right investments to advance this public private collaboration.
- 34:54[SPEAKER_04]: But we'll start with you, Director English.
- 34:55[SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, it's a great question.
- 34:56[SPEAKER_07]: I think that the Salarian Commission took care to use the word collaboration as opposed to division of effort or perhaps just kind of the same way same day terms.
- 35:05[SPEAKER_07]: Because collaboration is materially different than what we've been doing.
- 35:08[SPEAKER_07]: For very long time, various parties in this space, cyberspace had been defending in their own silos, as if they could defend their patch with the limited expertise, limited insights, limited powers, authorities that they might have that's simply not true.
- 35:22[SPEAKER_07]: We're not trying to solve the same or a similar problem in those very stout pipes.
- 35:26[SPEAKER_07]: We're trying to solve the same problem that ruthlessly cuts across those stout pipes.
- 35:30[SPEAKER_07]: So first and foremost, I think we finally understand what collaboration is.
- 35:34[SPEAKER_07]: combining our resources so that we can observe, understand, discover things together that know one of us could discover alone, and then together solve those.
- 35:42[SPEAKER_07]: To that extent, things like the JCDC, the Joint Cyber Defense Collaborative, which is built on a cyberspace solarium provision, essentially is a place where it's not policy experts to show up.
- 35:53[SPEAKER_07]: It's subject matter experts to show up, so that they can compare their shards, their shreds, their hunches, and cyberspace to say,
- 35:59[SPEAKER_07]: is the half of the thing that I'm looking at line up with the half of the thing you're looking at so that we might then together discover something and do something that no one of us could have done alone.
- 36:08[SPEAKER_07]: I think that's the material advance that we've made.
- 36:10[SPEAKER_07]: And that exists in the sector risk management agencies as well.
- 36:13[SPEAKER_07]: The Department of Defense is doing that.
- 36:15[SPEAKER_07]: It's something they call the cyber collaboration center.
- 36:17[SPEAKER_07]: Department of Energy proposes to do that and something called the Energy threat analysis center.
- 36:22[SPEAKER_07]: This can work broadly across the system.
- 36:25[SPEAKER_07]: And there can be something that then synthesizes, pulls all that together so that we benefit collectively from what we discover in the collaboration across that broad front.
- 36:34[SPEAKER_04]: And Congressman Gallagher, Senator King, thoughts on sector risk management agencies very quickly?
- 36:38[SPEAKER_02]: Well, I think it's fair to say, I mean, there's been inconsistency across the sector risk management agencies.
- 36:45[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, it's says what?
- 36:47[SPEAKER_02]: The sector risk management agency for eight out of the sixteen.
- 36:51[SPEAKER_02]: critical sectors, but each of them have different needs.
- 36:56[SPEAKER_02]: So even I think it's very, even scissors performance has been inconsistent across the different sectors.
- 37:04[SPEAKER_02]: So that's an area where I think we have more work that needs to be done.
- 37:07[SPEAKER_02]: I guess the given scissors, outside the role, it gets to something we try to do in our initial report, which is to elevate an empower system.
- 37:16[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, that was one of the bigger themes that came out of our initial
- 37:20[SPEAKER_02]: report was how do you make this is a sexy for lack of a better term and I think he's really done a great job but I think there's more work that needs to be done on elevating and empowering says they're going forward.
- 37:35[SPEAKER_08]: I think one of the failures that we've had is the we haven't gotten the joint collaborative environment established which is something
- 37:44[SPEAKER_08]: that we've been working on and we get close and it doesn't quite happen in the Congress.
- 37:49[SPEAKER_08]: SZA has developed, it's working in that direction.
- 37:53[SPEAKER_08]: Anyway, I do, I think we're talking all about policy here, but we ought to be also talking about people.
- 38:01[SPEAKER_08]: We talked about Chris's role in getting establishing the National Cyber Director
- 38:05[SPEAKER_08]: Jenny Sterley, Chris Krebs before, and Jenny Sterley, it says, I think it's done an extraordinary job.
- 38:11[SPEAKER_08]: I want to thank and compliment a new burger at the National Security Council for the work on the labeling initiative, which is also one of our recommendations, and they had a very thoughtful process and have come out with basically it's a labeling system for consumer electronics.
- 38:29[SPEAKER_08]: I mean, now we've got the Internet of Things,
- 38:32[SPEAKER_08]: And we need to talk about the cybersecurity of your router or probably even your microwave or your car.
- 38:38[SPEAKER_08]: And so that we're moved toward a voluntary labeling situation like UL on electronic devices.
- 38:46[SPEAKER_08]: I think it's big progress.
- 38:47[SPEAKER_08]: So I want to thank those individuals.
- 38:50[SPEAKER_08]: And of course, Chris for establishing the office in Kemba for continuing his work.
- 38:55[SPEAKER_08]: You can't separate policy from people.
- 38:58[SPEAKER_08]: And we've had some really good people that have been involved in these issues.
- 39:02[SPEAKER_08]: But again, I think the joint collaborative environment is something that has been lacking.
- 39:08[SPEAKER_08]: We've got to build a situation where the private sector and the government can work together harmoniously, seamlessly, in real time.
- 39:17[SPEAKER_08]: And that doesn't come naturally to either of those entities.
- 39:23[SPEAKER_08]: It has to be, I think we have to set up a structure before the crisis, so that's as trust is established, which can then lead to positive outcomes during some kind of crisis or confrontation.
- 39:39[SPEAKER_08]: It doesn't work.
- 39:39[SPEAKER_08]: I used to say to my friends at the main legislature, the relationship has to come before the ask.
- 39:46[SPEAKER_08]: And I think setting up a structure that will enable a kind of ongoing communication between private sector entities and CISO or whatever agency is involved, whether it's a sector risk management agency, you've got to do that first rather than when the world is falling down around.
- 40:04[SPEAKER_08]: So that's, I think, something that I'm hoping we're going to be able to continue to pursue actively.
- 40:11[SPEAKER_07]: So Megan, I know you want to go to questions from the audience, but can I just follow on that to say that I couldn't agree more that form will follow function.
- 40:19[SPEAKER_07]: And the mechanisms will follow the life forces.
- 40:22[SPEAKER_07]: And you can see no better example that than what you saw in Solarium where Republicans and Democrats combined their efforts to come up with something that was a consensus report.
- 40:30[SPEAKER_07]: The only tension I recall in that room across those two years, when the Green Bay Packers got into the finals,
- 40:36[SPEAKER_07]: And it was suddenly kind of apparent that not everybody was a fan of the Green Bay Packers.
- 40:40[SPEAKER_07]: I don't know who might be, but all the same.
- 40:42[SPEAKER_02]: Those people were similarly dismissed.
- 40:45[SPEAKER_07]: But I think that having kind of put down ideology and put the nation's kind of, you know, fortunes first in the Solarium Commission and then what then follows, we will figure out how to get the mechanisms and the structure and the
- 40:56[SPEAKER_07]: the JCE, the collaborative environment, which is really a response to how do we actually equip that light force?
- 41:02[SPEAKER_07]: How do we actually sustain that light force?
- 41:04[SPEAKER_07]: I think we'll get that right.
- 41:06[SPEAKER_04]: And I could, I literally have a list of questions that I could sit here and ask all four of you all day, but that would be rather selfish.
- 41:13[SPEAKER_02]: So we're going to... Mark's got an off easy.
- 41:15[SPEAKER_02]: I think Mark needs a heart.
- 41:16[SPEAKER_04]: I think he has.
- 41:17[SPEAKER_04]: So we're going to turn to...
- 41:21[SPEAKER_04]: Well, if anyone in the audience has a question for Mark that's more difficult, we're going to turn to an audience Q&A.
- 41:26[SPEAKER_04]: Take a few questions for the next few minutes.
- 41:29[SPEAKER_04]: So, if anyone has a question, absolutely.
- 41:33[SPEAKER_04]: Here in the, yes.
- 41:37[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you.
- 41:38[SPEAKER_01]: My name's Kelsey Richie Fierce and I'm a Technology Fellow in Cinder Thunes Office with the background in AI and cyber.
- 41:43[SPEAKER_01]: So really appreciative of the event today and of the report.
- 41:46[SPEAKER_01]: My question kind of combines the AI and cyber piece of this.
- 41:49[SPEAKER_01]: I know you mentioned the NSEI.
- 41:52[SPEAKER_01]: How does kind of emerging technology, especially kind of in this boom of AI, impact the way that you're thinking about kind of the implementation of the cyber strategy and how does it change the way that we need to be thinking about the cyber domain in general?
- 42:07[SPEAKER_02]: Well, set first of all, Senator Thin, Packers fan, let the writer chat.
- 42:12[SPEAKER_05]: I'll take a first one.
- 42:13[SPEAKER_05]: I could just say one of the things that AI is doing is forcing even more.
- 42:17[SPEAKER_05]: We noticed we were pretty dumb-struck by the slow process of updating documents of getting regulation, right?
- 42:25[SPEAKER_05]: Getting provisions in legislation, right?
- 42:27[SPEAKER_05]: In cyber security.
- 42:28[SPEAKER_05]: Now you add an artificial intelligence and you're going to need a lot more agility than we're used to in both the executive and legislative branches.
- 42:36[SPEAKER_05]: And you're going to actually have to, one of the things we've avoided Chris said it gently, I think, is that
- 42:41[SPEAKER_05]: You know, we've had twenty-three years of following a pretty poor, you know, voluntary partnership program.
- 42:47[SPEAKER_05]: And we've allowed that to persist.
- 42:49[SPEAKER_05]: I think artificial intelligence is going to remove our ability to be slow, and it's going to require agility, and it's going to remove our ability to not make sharp decisions.
- 42:57[SPEAKER_05]: I mean, we really do have to make decisions, and we really do have to do it in a speedy way.
- 43:02[SPEAKER_05]: And I think, you know, I'm not saying it's going to help us in that regard.
- 43:05[SPEAKER_05]: It's going to force us in that regard.
- 43:07[SPEAKER_05]: So that's what area.
- 43:08[SPEAKER_05]: And I do think artificial intelligence
- 43:11[SPEAKER_05]: You know, what people say is a good or bad for cybersecurity.
- 43:13[SPEAKER_05]: It can be answers both, you know, and it's just what they see.
- 43:16[SPEAKER_05]: So we're going to have to take advantage of the opportunities and manage the risk.
- 43:20[SPEAKER_05]: But we're going to have to do it at much more rapid fashion.
- 43:24[SPEAKER_07]: I just too thanks to that, I agree.
- 43:25[SPEAKER_07]: I would just say that from the dawn of the internet, there were kind of two driving factors that essentially characterize the technology, innovation and market efficiency.
- 43:34[SPEAKER_07]: For too long safety has not been that kind of third leg under the stool.
- 43:37[SPEAKER_07]: We need to make sure that safety or reliability pick your term.
- 43:40[SPEAKER_07]: But we need to make sure that's the third leg under the stool.
- 43:42[SPEAKER_07]: That needs to be a cultural norm that needs to be an expectation.
- 43:45[SPEAKER_07]: We need to develop and deploy technology.
- 43:46[SPEAKER_07]: That's the game.
- 43:48[SPEAKER_07]: Two, this technology is moving so fast that we can't actually get our arms around stop kind of focus on a given technology.
- 43:55[SPEAKER_07]: We need to prepare the human being to actually be resilient and robust kind of in the face of that technology.
- 44:00[SPEAKER_07]: For those of you who was old as me, you might remember a Bose speaker commercial with his person sitting in front and the speaker is blowing a hair kind of to the far quarter.
- 44:08[SPEAKER_07]: That's where we are in terms of technology.
- 44:10[SPEAKER_07]: What's next is quantum computing.
- 44:12[SPEAKER_07]: What's next is kind of gene splicing at home.
- 44:14[SPEAKER_07]: I'm just making that up.
- 44:15[SPEAKER_07]: But the technology is moving so fast.
- 44:17[SPEAKER_07]: We have to make sure that we double down on actually the resilience of the human being and place them at the center of the frame.
- 44:24[SPEAKER_08]: I want to touch on that because and broaden the discussion.
- 44:28[SPEAKER_08]: We're in a, we're in a competition with, with China, particularly, but also with Russia and with other regimes around the world about who system is better democracy or some kind of authoritarianism.
- 44:40[SPEAKER_08]: And Xi Jinping believes in his discuss this explicitly that
- 44:45[SPEAKER_08]: The democracy can't work in the twenty-first century because of the speed of decision making that's necessary.
- 44:51[SPEAKER_08]: And so we have to be responsive to that.
- 44:53[SPEAKER_08]: We have to show that our system can work and be responsive and not take years and years and years and years because the reality of our current life in both in technology and generally is speed.
- 45:08[SPEAKER_08]: And speed is not a word that you generally use in applicability to the U.S.
- 45:13[SPEAKER_08]: Congress.
- 45:15[SPEAKER_08]: Our system was designed to be cumbersome and slow, and the framers succeeded beyond their wildest imaginations.
- 45:24[SPEAKER_08]: But we have to be thinking about that, not to trample the checks and balances and all those kinds of things.
- 45:30[SPEAKER_08]: But I really think we need to understand that there's an underlying competition going on in the world today.
- 45:36[SPEAKER_08]: between visions of how you govern.
- 45:39[SPEAKER_08]: And we have, I think, the best system, but we have to realize that speed and agility, which aren't, qualities normally associated with our governmental system, are values and imperatives as we move into an age of accelerating change.
- 45:56[SPEAKER_08]: That's my sort of constitutional speech this morning.
- 46:00[SPEAKER_02]: I'll just quickly say, finally we're wearing our, we got the Constitution tie.
- 46:04[SPEAKER_02]: I got the Declaration of Independence tie.
- 46:06[SPEAKER_02]: It's part of our uniform that Angus and I have to wear it together.
- 46:11[SPEAKER_02]: If you read our initial report, you see the tension between the demands of speed
- 46:17[SPEAKER_02]: and let's say the demands of safety, right?
- 46:20[SPEAKER_02]: Or the desire to incentivize or force the private sector to step up and prioritize cyber security while not saddling them with counterproductive onerous regulations from the federal government.
- 46:31[SPEAKER_02]: That was really attention that persisted throughout our work and it's sort of a
- 46:36[SPEAKER_02]: attention that's impossible to resolve perfectly.
- 46:38[SPEAKER_02]: I think that tension is even greater as Congress turns to this question of how to deal with AI, right?
- 46:45[SPEAKER_02]: Because we can't pause.
- 46:47[SPEAKER_02]: We can't pause for six months because that hands of victory to the Chinese Communist Party and the only thing I know is that if they command the heights of AI technology, they will use this technology for evil purposes.
- 46:58[SPEAKER_02]: So we have to simultaneously keep
- 47:01[SPEAKER_02]: innovating within the free world while also trying to slow them down.
- 47:05[SPEAKER_02]: There's some obvious steps there in my opinion.
- 47:07[SPEAKER_02]: We have massive loopholes in our export controls related to advanced semiconductors that are necessary for AI that should be short up.
- 47:13[SPEAKER_02]: We should not allow private investors in America to invest in Chinese AI companies.
- 47:18[SPEAKER_02]: I'm speaking just for Mike Gallagher, not for the Solarium Commission.
- 47:22[SPEAKER_02]: And then on the positive front, I do think DOD's ethical framework for the use of AI is pretty good.
- 47:28[SPEAKER_02]: And it's a framework we could build upon and expand across
- 47:31[SPEAKER_02]: The federal government, and then if we were really smart, we would start to build out in the concentric circles that our alliances and get our allies on the same page with us in terms of striking that balance, starting with Ocas, expanding to five eyes and then to certain NATO countries or technological advanced countries.
- 47:47[SPEAKER_07]: I want to go ahead, Chris.
- 47:49[SPEAKER_07]: I think the really good thing about what Congressman Gallagher just said about that tension in American society is that it's always been a feature.
- 47:56[SPEAKER_07]: We don't have the word or the preamble of the Constitution.
- 47:58[SPEAKER_07]: We intend to do all of these things.
- 48:00[SPEAKER_07]: that sometimes means we have to work harder to deliver those, but we can deliver innovation, market efficiency, and safety.
- 48:06[SPEAKER_07]: We've done that in other systems of interest.
- 48:08[SPEAKER_07]: We just have to make sure that the Senator King's point that agility is one of those things that actually is a common property across those three dimensions.
- 48:16[SPEAKER_05]: I think as we address artificial intelligence, there's two things that we looked at in the commission that have not gotten done that have to get done.
- 48:23[SPEAKER_05]: The first is understanding how we secure data properly so that it can't be misused in artificial intelligence.
- 48:30[SPEAKER_05]: gathering, and the second is the security of our cloud service providers.
- 48:35[SPEAKER_05]: That's, to me, that's critical.
- 48:38[SPEAKER_05]: You know, one of the big obvious flaws and presidential policy direct to twenty-one is it doesn't, it doesn't, doesn't, doesn't, doesn't, doesn't recognize their cloud service providers.
- 48:51[SPEAKER_05]: The cloud service providers, or at least the cloud computing industry, needs to be a critical infrastructure.
- 48:57[SPEAKER_05]: and needs to have a sectorist management agency, and we need to figure out some baseline standard for cybersecurity in there, or we're really going to be exploited heavily by artificial intelligence.
- 49:07[SPEAKER_05]: So those, those two things need to happen, securing data, and securing the cloud.
- 49:12[SPEAKER_04]: Any other questions?
- 49:15[SPEAKER_10]: Yes.
- 49:16[SPEAKER_10]: Hi, I'm Christian Vasquez.
- 49:18[SPEAKER_10]: I'm a reporter from cybersecurity group.
- 49:19[SPEAKER_10]: Thank you for doing this.
- 49:20[SPEAKER_10]: I have two questions.
- 49:24[SPEAKER_10]: So on SRMA, I'm thinking about funding and resources which areas or which agencies are most concerned about.
- 49:30[SPEAKER_10]: I mean there's been historically TSA EPA haven't had much funding TSA after colonial was like a skeleton group.
- 49:36[SPEAKER_10]: I think
- 49:37[SPEAKER_10]: A one report had EPA similar kind of things going on.
- 49:40[SPEAKER_10]: I'm kind of curious which agencies don't you think currently have enough?
- 49:43[SPEAKER_10]: What is enough and where does CISA fit in?
- 49:45[SPEAKER_10]: And on new tech, where are the regulations for distributed energy resources, which is going to be a huge energy supply space, like you just mentioned, cloud service providers.
- 49:57[SPEAKER_10]: I'm just kind of curious as we're kind of going through these rapid accelerations on these different areas of tech.
- 50:02[SPEAKER_10]: Where does regulation fit in?
- 50:04[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you.
- 50:05[SPEAKER_10]: First question was a human resources.
- 50:07[SPEAKER_02]: What agencies don't have enough?
- 50:09[SPEAKER_04]: Which, yes, which SRMA is doing a free source is how can we increase that?
- 50:13[SPEAKER_08]: The two agencies that I'm most worried about are HHS and EPA.
- 50:18[SPEAKER_08]: HHS because of its relationship and CMS, the healthcare sector generally, and then EPA, water sector as I mentioned.
- 50:29[SPEAKER_08]: of those are two areas that I think are particularly vulnerable, and they need more resources and more focus, frankly.
- 50:38[SPEAKER_05]: And if you want bad news and threes, I agree totally with those two.
- 50:40[SPEAKER_05]: It'll throw in food and agriculture, which is the Department of Agriculture.
- 50:46[SPEAKER_05]: It's going to need a lot more investment as an SRMA.
- 50:49[SPEAKER_05]: I think those three, and those are kind of our health.
- 50:52[SPEAKER_05]: You know, those are your health and public safety, you know, your key along with energy,
- 50:59[SPEAKER_05]: key to, you know, to survive a personal survivability.
- 51:02[SPEAKER_05]: So we really need to tackle all three of those.
- 51:04[SPEAKER_02]: I said a hospital shut down in my district because of a cyber issue.
- 51:08[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, just offline for, I mean, catastrophic consequences at the local level.
- 51:15[SPEAKER_07]: No, I think your second question was about regulation, writ large, and that's the word Voldemort in the room finally.
- 51:21[SPEAKER_07]: So I think the new and novel part of the strategy, the national cybersecurity strategy, was it introduced the prospect of regulation?
- 51:28[SPEAKER_07]: I think that that's been something that we've used in other kind of systems of interest, whether that's transportation systems, drug therapeutics, and it's time that we actually consider the possibility that there are things that are so important in terms of our dependence on cyberspace for health and critical and life safety issues that we need to at on occasion specify that.
- 51:46[SPEAKER_07]: However, it needs to work the way this way.
- 51:48[SPEAKER_07]: We need to make sure that market forces have had their full opportunity to kind of play through and deliver the goods.
- 51:54[SPEAKER_07]: And when they fall short, and we need to actually extend what market forces have done, we do so.
- 51:59[SPEAKER_07]: But we do it with the latest possible touch and no later, and we harmonize the result.
- 52:03[SPEAKER_07]: So all the would be regulators are not actually kind of smothering the baby and it's crib, but we blanket after blanket after blanket.
- 52:09[SPEAKER_07]: That's hard to do, but we've done it before, and we must do it again.
- 52:13[SPEAKER_04]: Yes, another question over here.
- 52:16[SPEAKER_06]: I'm John Sacklary, Otisett, Lidico, so a little bit of an inside job.
- 52:20[SPEAKER_06]: I'm sorry.
- 52:22[SPEAKER_06]: I wanted to ask the middle three panelists whether you've been in conversation with Harry Coker about his pending confirmation process and then what your hopes and perhaps concerns might be in particular on the timeline of his confirmation.
- 52:38[SPEAKER_08]: Mike and I are meeting with him this afternoon.
- 52:41[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 52:42[SPEAKER_02]: I'm not in the confirmation business, so I'm taking a pass on that.
- 52:46[SPEAKER_02]: question.
- 52:47[SPEAKER_02]: Very much looking forward to the conversation.
- 52:49[SPEAKER_08]: I would never take a job that requires confirmation.
- 52:54[SPEAKER_08]: Although I guess I have to do that every six years.
- 52:57[SPEAKER_08]: That's validation.
- 52:58[SPEAKER_08]: Yeah.
- 53:00[SPEAKER_04]: And I'm going to quickly follow up and say Senator King, what do you think in terms of pace for getting him through the Senate is nomination?
- 53:12[SPEAKER_08]: Who knows?
- 53:14[SPEAKER_08]: What was the English standard?
- 53:15[SPEAKER_08]: As long as the title doesn't involve general, we may be able to do it.
- 53:21[SPEAKER_08]: No, we are moving some nominations.
- 53:24[SPEAKER_08]: The budget bill is in limbo right now, so I just absolutely can't give you a time, I'm sorry.
- 53:34[SPEAKER_04]: OK.
- 53:36[SPEAKER_04]: Any other questions, yes?
- 53:37[SPEAKER_03]: Hello, I'm John Co.
- 53:38[SPEAKER_03]: Francesco.
- 53:38[SPEAKER_03]: I'm the founder of the Applied AI Company.
- 53:41[SPEAKER_03]: I'm curious to what provisions have been made and should we be making in light of a cyber nine eleven?
- 53:47[SPEAKER_03]: It's pretty likely that we're going to have something kick off in Taiwan, the majority of our critical infrastructure.
- 53:53[SPEAKER_03]: It remains unprotected.
- 53:54[SPEAKER_03]: For example, if you were to turn off a couple of substations, we don't have supply in this country to replace the components in those facilities so you'll leave large measures of the country without power for months.
- 54:07[SPEAKER_02]: Let me just click on it with it.
- 54:08[SPEAKER_02]: So putting off the Sellerium hat, putting on China, Committee hat, we just, we were just in New York and we did a war game with major asset managers and financial executives to examine for the non-kinetic aspects of a Taiwan scenario.
- 54:26[SPEAKER_02]: And the results were troubling.
- 54:28[SPEAKER_02]: This was a twenty-twenty-eight scenario, but then we hopped in the delorean, we went back in time to twenty-twenty-three to see what choices could we make now to expand the range of options a president would have
- 54:37[SPEAKER_02]: non-kinetic options in twenty- twenty-eight to diffuse the crisis.
- 54:40[SPEAKER_02]: To me, it hammered home the point that at least in key areas, we are going to have to strategically or selectively decouple.
- 54:47[SPEAKER_02]: Otherwise, you're going to find yourself allowing the CCP to weaponize key supply chains or to your point sort of attacking various vulnerabilities we have.
- 54:55[SPEAKER_02]: And I do think energy policy is a big part of this.
- 54:57[SPEAKER_02]: Improve in the resiliency of our grid here domestically.
- 55:01[SPEAKER_02]: is a key priority.
- 55:02[SPEAKER_02]: And you assume, final point I'm going to make, sorry to go on, you assume there are people in treasury and commerce that are doing this, right, that are going through the financial and economic escalation in the way we sort of rigorously do that and have a well thought out multi-decade theory of the case on the conventional and certainly on the strategic side, but it's not happening unless you've been part of something, I'm unaware of.
- 55:22[SPEAKER_02]: And they need to be doing it with the military people.
- 55:25[SPEAKER_02]: We need to have that, our theory of the case in place prior to the crisis happening, so we're not making it up on the fly.
- 55:31[SPEAKER_08]: And to your point, we should be learning from Ukraine.
- 55:33[SPEAKER_08]: The Russian attack on the Ukrainian electrical system has been substations.
- 55:38[SPEAKER_08]: That's what they're, that's what they're, and transformers.
- 55:41[SPEAKER_08]: That's what they're taking out.
- 55:43[SPEAKER_08]: And they're hard to replace.
- 55:44[SPEAKER_08]: And there's a shortage of them.
- 55:45[SPEAKER_08]: Then we couldn't replace them in this country if there were
- 55:48[SPEAKER_08]: And we've learned in some cases that you can take them out with a rifle with a scope site.
- 55:52[SPEAKER_08]: So this is, again, a serious vulnerability.
- 55:57[SPEAKER_08]: As I said before, I think the energy sector is ahead of it.
- 56:00[SPEAKER_08]: But in this case, it's sort of a combination of cyber and physical risk.
- 56:06[SPEAKER_08]: And the system is just very vulnerable.
- 56:11[SPEAKER_08]: Bridges, fiberlines, all of those things.
- 56:14[SPEAKER_08]: I remember after
- 56:17[SPEAKER_08]: September eleventh, I assigned the state police in Maine to assess where the risk were.
- 56:23[SPEAKER_08]: And I think it's time to keep doing that.
- 56:26[SPEAKER_08]: If you were a terrorist, where would you go?
- 56:28[SPEAKER_08]: If you were a adversary on a cyber mission, where would you attack?
- 56:32[SPEAKER_08]: And that's why I have a big believer of red teaming.
- 56:34[SPEAKER_08]: We should be red teaming the whole country on these issues.
- 56:38[SPEAKER_08]: You know the mark on the mark.
- 56:39[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, so we had two thoughts on this in the commission.
- 56:42[SPEAKER_05]: One was that we needed exactly, we needed to have a fund for recovery.
- 56:46[SPEAKER_05]: And that's actually a recovery fund.
- 56:47[SPEAKER_05]: That one we got through in the bipartisan infrastructure act, a lot of it.
- 56:51[SPEAKER_05]: And there was money put aside against it, appropriate against it.
- 56:55[SPEAKER_05]: But we also recommended a national critical infrastructure resilience fund to identify, you know, an process to identify single points of failure at a time.
- 57:05[SPEAKER_05]: Electrical power grid was a big area there.
- 57:08[SPEAKER_05]: Some industries in electrical power is one that does do some investment in buying excess capacity, transfers and things, but not enough.
- 57:17[SPEAKER_05]: But many other areas have nothing.
- 57:18[SPEAKER_05]: And you can think back to position, navigation, and timing, where we actually gave up our backup system.
- 57:23[SPEAKER_05]: The DOD said they didn't need it anymore.
- 57:25[SPEAKER_05]: We retired it.
- 57:26[SPEAKER_05]: And the rest of the group said, hey, that was our backup.
- 57:29[SPEAKER_05]: And it's gone.
- 57:30[SPEAKER_05]: So we absolutely have to do that preventative mitigation work.
- 57:34[SPEAKER_05]: And then do some investments.
- 57:35[SPEAKER_05]: The government's going to have to help pay for some of that procurement, which is not going to go over well with everybody.
- 57:41[SPEAKER_05]: But you've got to have that beforehand.
- 57:43[SPEAKER_05]: And we do have the recovery fund for after.
- 57:46[SPEAKER_05]: fifty percent of the way there, but that's not good enough.
- 57:49[SPEAKER_07]: I've just had all that agree, but all of those are appropriate responses to a cyber nine eleven that is already happening.
- 57:56[SPEAKER_07]: It's happening as we speak.
- 57:57[SPEAKER_07]: It's just diffused in time and space.
- 57:59[SPEAKER_07]: We haven't seen it for what it is.
- 58:00[SPEAKER_07]: There's too much proactive ambivalence.
- 58:03[SPEAKER_07]: Nancy term that says, there are a whole lot of folks that say they're smoke in the room, but I hope to God somebody puts that fire out, not realizing they're a part of the solution.
- 58:10[SPEAKER_07]: All of us need to mobilize our time, our talent, our authorities, individuals, organizations, sectors, plural, governments, plural.
- 58:17[SPEAKER_07]: And I think there are three things that are particularly frail at the moment.
- 58:20[SPEAKER_07]: We're addressing these, but the three things are the material, the hardware, the software, the systems, the collaboration that essentially is what delivers those in useful form critical functions.
- 58:30[SPEAKER_07]: So we need to make it such that we have coalitions that collaborate in the defense of those systems, the way the Ukrainians have shown us that you can and confidence.
- 58:38[SPEAKER_07]: That's the third thing that's particularly frail.
- 58:40[SPEAKER_07]: We think back to the colonial pipeline event when there was plenty of petroleum and those pipelines up and down the eastern sea board, but people believing that cyber held that at risk in some absolute way panicked, and essentially then rushed the gates.
- 58:54[SPEAKER_07]: In a way that we could not at that moment in time properly allocate those supplies so that we could just weather that storm.
- 59:00[SPEAKER_07]: We need to get to a place where we're confident that we can weather the storm because we've got robustness built in.
- 59:05[SPEAKER_07]: We actually are on the front balls of our feet defending that space.
- 59:08[SPEAKER_07]: We do that collaboratively.
- 59:09[SPEAKER_07]: They're going to have to beat all of us to beat any one of us.
- 59:11[SPEAKER_07]: We need to get to that place.
- 59:13[SPEAKER_04]: And as we begin to wrap up, I'm going to ask you to give a very quick rapid fire start at the end of the line with Mark response as we start a new year.
- 59:25[SPEAKER_04]: What is the one outstanding recommendation you want to move forward?
- 59:28[SPEAKER_04]: And yeah, try to keep it under ten seconds.
- 59:30[SPEAKER_04]: We're running out of time.
- 59:31[SPEAKER_04]: Mark.
- 59:31[SPEAKER_04]: Mark.
- 59:32[SPEAKER_05]: Mark.
- 59:32[SPEAKER_05]: Well, I'm just going to be good PP-D-D-Twenty-One rewritten.
- 59:36[SPEAKER_05]: And in a mature way that adds critical infrastructure such as cloud computing and
- 59:42[SPEAKER_05]: and space support infrastructure.
- 59:45[SPEAKER_05]: And I will make sure for next year's front piece, instead of lowering Representative Gallagher, we'll give them the trotsky treatment and just wipe him out of the photo.
- 59:54[SPEAKER_04]: Is that okay?
- 59:57[SPEAKER_08]: Join collaborative environment.
- 59:59[UNKNOWN]: Okay.
- 1:00:00[SPEAKER_02]: We got a response on continuity economy from the administration that was a joke.
- 1:00:05[SPEAKER_02]: So turning it into something real, that's not a joke.
- 1:00:08[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's a priority.
- 1:00:10[SPEAKER_02]: Sorry, was that too harsh?
- 1:00:13[SPEAKER_07]: What gets measured gets done, so I continue with the implementation plan.
- 1:00:16[SPEAKER_07]: It's broad-based.
- 1:00:17[SPEAKER_07]: It's wider than it is to all of us just continue a pace.
- 1:00:21[SPEAKER_04]: Well, with that, I want to thank all four of you for your continued leadership on cybersecurity and for being here today.
- 1:00:28[SPEAKER_04]: We'll be watching this space closely and using the Solarium's recommendations as benchmarks to judge if our country is moving in the right direction on national cyber resilience.
- 1:00:38[SPEAKER_04]: And with that, I want to thank all of you in the room and those of us watching on live stream for joining us for this conversation.
- 1:00:45[SPEAKER_04]: Thank you so much, and I take care.
- 1:00:46[SPEAKER_08]: Could I add one thing?
- 1:00:48[SPEAKER_08]: There's so much expertise in this room.
- 1:00:49[SPEAKER_08]: If you have ideas or thoughts, the things that we could work on, let us know.
- 1:00:54[SPEAKER_08]: Let Mark know.
- 1:00:54[SPEAKER_08]: It's a, it's a, it's a, Mark Tolerian.org, and we're still at it.
- 1:00:59[SPEAKER_08]: So let's share what your thoughts are.
- 1:01:02[SPEAKER_08]: Reaction, things that we're missing, please.
- 1:01:05[SPEAKER_08]: We need your help.
- 1:01:06[SPEAKER_02]: And I'll give you Senator King's personal number if you want to call any hour of the day.
- 1:01:11[SPEAKER_04]: Thank you.
- 1:01:24[UNKNOWN]: Thank you.