Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Trader Horn (1931)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And this is our final entry
- 0:25in the 1931... Academy Award films. Correct.
- 0:29Yeah, we'll be talking about our ceremony episode,
- 0:32but this is the final nominated film for Best
- 0:35Picture that we'll be talking about. And today
- 0:36we're talking about Traitor Horn. Heavy hitter.
- 0:39Yeah, you know, so this is the... Actually, is
- 0:42this true? I think it is. The way that I watched
- 0:44these movies is the way that we covered them.
- 0:46So I watched Cimarron first, and then Eastland,
- 0:48Front Page, Skippy, Traitor Horn. Perfect. So
- 0:51I watched Traitor Horn last. In Traitor Horn,
- 0:53I was always trying to figure out what this movie
- 0:56was. I didn't really look too much into it and
- 0:58do a lot of research before the movie came out.
- 1:00I usually save that for afterwards. And Traderhorn
- 1:03was one that I was like, well, what could it
- 1:05be about? And part of me landed on it could be
- 1:09a like African jungle safari, like some kind
- 1:13of like wilderness tale. And ultimately, I was
- 1:17pretty close. Yeah. I could not have guessed
- 1:19the plot of this movie, if whatever plot you
- 1:21want to assume there is in this movie. Right.
- 1:23But yeah, this is going to be a strange one.
- 1:26100%. To kind of summarize this movie into a
- 1:30genre, I would say it's an adventure film. Sure.
- 1:33And I will say, like, the adventure genre in
- 1:37the modern day, I think it's kind of generally
- 1:41accepted that this is a genre that's disappeared
- 1:44a little bit. Sure. I mean, you've seen plenty
- 1:46of films with scale and scope like Cimarron,
- 1:49even this year, that make it into the list. But
- 1:53that has, like I mentioned, the larger scale,
- 1:57like some more drama behind it, but has some
- 1:59adventure feel. this really is almost like 100
- 2:02% adventure. Yeah. Like, if I think in recent
- 2:05years, if I had to identify an adventure film,
- 2:08like... The first thing that come to my mind
- 2:10is maybe the Jungle Cruise movie. Sure. Something
- 2:14like National Treasure. Yeah. I mean, comedy
- 2:18as well, but The Mummy. There's a lot of movies
- 2:21that stand out. See, but those are older films
- 2:24too, and that's kind of the thing. We've stepped
- 2:27away from the genre, and I think that when we
- 2:29do approach an adventure genre, it does kind
- 2:32of intermingle with other genres. Romancing the
- 2:36Stone is a perfect example. Yeah, yeah, or what
- 2:39was another one I just had in my mind? Jumanji
- 2:41is kind of like a sci -fi adventure film. Comedy,
- 2:45family, yeah, there's a lot of genres at play.
- 2:47Yeah, and it's kind of a dying breed. So in a
- 2:51way, when, I mean, this is my second time visiting
- 2:55this film, but there is that excitement of, oh,
- 2:59this is a genre we don't talk about today. That's
- 3:02exciting. But... Wish it was more exciting. Right.
- 3:06There's a lot of things wrong with this movie,
- 3:09both on screen and off. Yeah. And, you know,
- 3:13I did some research during the movie of this
- 3:15as well. And that, I don't think that's always
- 3:18a bad idea, especially with some movies like
- 3:20dramas. But with this, it was a bad idea. Because
- 3:24it just made me realize how much on screen I'm
- 3:28not liking as well. Yes. Right? Like, it really
- 3:31does kind of lead you to one belief in this movie.
- 3:34And that's that this is kind of the tone or the
- 3:37theme that I think we're going to carry throughout
- 3:38this episode. This is a cursed production. Across
- 3:40the board, I don't just necessarily mean like,
- 3:43hey, something happened. And now this is like
- 3:46everything that's happening is wrong. It's just
- 3:48more deaths have happened on here, both human
- 3:51and animal. The things that they have. done to
- 3:54get certain shots were unethical they have seen
- 3:57clear racism in the behind the scenes of some
- 4:01of these actors trying to get access into hollywood
- 4:04locations after like reshoots there's just a
- 4:07lot of reports on horrible things happening here
- 4:10there's a couple of rumors and conspiracies that
- 4:14exist about this movie that i'd love to kind
- 4:16of i don't want to say put to rest like i was
- 4:17there but like i did some more research and found
- 4:19some finality to it so i'd love to you know kind
- 4:21of touch on that a little bit but there's a lot
- 4:23happening in this movie and off screen And before
- 4:27we get there, I do think we should give the movie
- 4:29a fair shake and talk about the nomination, the
- 4:32cast, the synopsis, and a little bit about the
- 4:35beginning that I actually kind of enjoy a good
- 4:37bit. We'll get there, but I'll go ahead and start
- 4:39with the nomination. Not a very long list. This
- 4:42was nominated for Best Picture. That was on behalf
- 4:44of, well, Outstanding Production at the time.
- 4:47But that was on behalf of Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer,
- 4:49the studio MGM that released this. Is this the
- 4:52first time that we've seen... in the history
- 4:54of this show so far, 1927 to 1931, that we've
- 4:58seen the lion for MGM. Oh, I don't know. I think
- 5:02it was. Because I remember thinking, maybe it
- 5:05wasn't, but the lion looks so differently. obviously
- 5:08you know 1931 to like the many times they've
- 5:11refilmed it yeah but i thought that was very
- 5:13interesting for a movie i hadn't heard of like
- 5:15seeing mgm the logo the way that stays the same
- 5:18with the gratis you know banner above the line
- 5:20very cool almost kind of like calming a little
- 5:23bit of like ah yes a movie we've made it yeah
- 5:25yeah exactly made it so outstanding production
- 5:28was the only nomination for this uh so this actually
- 5:31joins the league of east lynn in the film that
- 5:35was nominated once or for one nomination and
- 5:38it was Best Picture. Right, yeah. Kind of crazy
- 5:40that we don't see this more often like this.
- 5:42You know, we talked about F1 in 2026 for the
- 5:45Oscars and how that was nominated three times,
- 5:48including Best Picture. But typically you will
- 5:50see some like intentionality behind the films
- 5:53that make Best Picture because of all the other
- 5:55awards they won. Clearly not the case in 1931.
- 5:58No, yeah. I wonder if in the modern landscape,
- 6:02if it is... Kind of generally accepted by the
- 6:04Academy that if you're going to make an appearance
- 6:07in the Best Picture category, you probably have
- 6:10to have something in another category to back
- 6:13up that or justify that nomination. Definitely.
- 6:16I can't say I see it. In this movie? Correct,
- 6:20yeah. Yeah. Well, I will kind of fight back on
- 6:24that a little bit. Okay. Because there is some
- 6:26historical importance to this movie. There is
- 6:29some impressiveness to this movie. It's hard
- 6:32to justify that level of impressiveness because
- 6:37of all the behind -the -scenes controversy and
- 6:39all of that. But, I mean, this was the first
- 6:41non -documentary film shot on location in Africa.
- 6:45Correct. Sure. That's a big deal. I always love
- 6:49the idea of shooting on location rather than
- 6:52green screen. Yeah. And not even on location,
- 6:54but like practical sets, right? So if you are
- 6:56filming Hollywood to appear to be Africa, fine.
- 7:00But avoiding green screen when possible. Yeah.
- 7:02Or filming in Mexico to appear in Africa, which,
- 7:06you know. Timely. Timely. We'll get there. Do
- 7:09you want to run through the cast? Sure. Would
- 7:11you like me to? No, yeah, you can. That wasn't
- 7:14like, oh, yeah, I'll do it. It was. I don't know
- 7:17if you've had it. I don't really like. Yeah.
- 7:20This whole situation with this movie. But yeah,
- 7:24let me knock it out real quick. We've got Harry
- 7:26Carey as... Is that Aloysius? Aloysius? We're
- 7:32just going to call him Trader Horn. Cool. He
- 7:33is the titular Trader Horn. His nickname is Trader
- 7:36because that's his occupation. So he'll go by
- 7:39Trader or Horn since that's his last name. Edwina
- 7:43Booth as Nina Trent, the White Goddess. If...
- 7:47That triggered your, wait a minute, this sounds
- 7:50problematic. Ding, ding, ding. Hold on tight.
- 7:54Duncan Rinaldo as Peru, and I mean, that's really,
- 7:59those are the three. Olive Carey is Edith Trent,
- 8:01Nina Trent's older sister. Mother. Mother. Yeah,
- 8:04but I mean, she's really not in this very often.
- 8:06She has maybe five lines and then a pretty traumatic
- 8:09scene on screen, but that's about it. So essentially
- 8:13it is, these three actors were the headline.
- 8:17Correct. Everybody else in this movie is just,
- 8:19they're there as supporting. But this is the
- 8:22story of Trader Horn and his companion Peru on
- 8:26a quest, on a journey through the African wilds
- 8:30in search. of Nina Trent, Edith Trent's missing
- 8:34daughter. Yes, so this is directed by W .S. Van
- 8:38Dyke, set in 1870s Africa. Trader and his companion,
- 8:43Peru, are specifically going to a local tribe,
- 8:48it's the Messiah tribe, to trade some items for
- 8:52money. And it's very clear that Trader is...
- 8:57Peru a bit in how to become a traitor. Yeah.
- 9:00Peru's a little bit of a newbie there. He takes
- 9:02the audience role of asking questions and getting
- 9:06answers, explaining to him about what's happening
- 9:07through their multiple locations, you know, the
- 9:10communications through different tribes, all
- 9:12that's being answered by a traitor from the questions
- 9:15of Peru. And once they are trading with the Messiah
- 9:19tribe, specifically, they meet the Cucuyo tribe
- 9:23that is a little more hostile. And they start
- 9:27running from them a bit. And this is when they
- 9:28run into Edith Trent. And Edith tells them about
- 9:31her daughter, Nina, who was taken very long ago.
- 9:35And she just wants to make sure she is safe.
- 9:37And Trader agrees to help her. And that sets
- 9:40forth the plot of this movie. I want to go ahead
- 9:43and start with the good. At least what I enjoyed.
- 9:45There's an opening scene in this where we see
- 9:48Trader in Peru sitting in a boat. And they're
- 9:50kind of just talking about what it is to be a
- 9:52trader and how Africa is. And they're not saying...
- 9:55some great things about Africa. But you mentioned
- 9:57that this was filmed on location in Africa. Right.
- 10:00And it is evident because there are scenes or
- 10:04moments in that scene between Trader and Peru
- 10:06where we are focusing on them. It's pretty tight
- 10:09on both of them on the back of this boat. But
- 10:12you see in the background the river that they're
- 10:15sailing in. And in that scene, you can notice
- 10:18in the background there's a hippo. that emerges
- 10:21and then submerges and it's not the focus of
- 10:24the shot you just see it in the background and
- 10:26there's tiny little details that that like that
- 10:28that just immerse you into the story and you
- 10:30feel like cool i'm in the i'm in africa i'm on
- 10:33the river i'm in this scene And it's so cool
- 10:37to see this happen, especially when there's other
- 10:39shots that happen later on in the movie that
- 10:41do favor a green screen or some kind of trickery
- 10:44to show them in front of an alligator. I think
- 10:48that's one of the funniest scenes in the movie.
- 10:49And it's probably not intentional, unfortunately,
- 10:51where you see Trader standing on a boat and he's
- 10:54reacting to an alligator or crocodile that might
- 10:56be close to them. It's a crocodile that might
- 10:58be close to them. But the camera of the crocodile
- 11:01is so close. that it looks like they're a foot
- 11:04away from each other. It looks more like a 1950s
- 11:09attack of the 50 -foot woman. where the croc
- 11:12is like three times the size of traitor. Yeah.
- 11:15Like tarantula. Exactly. And he's like reacting
- 11:18in a way of like, Oh, he's right in front of
- 11:19me. That scene doesn't work. But that earlier
- 11:22scene with the practical effects of like a hippo
- 11:24is just happens to be back there. That does a
- 11:26lot for the immersion of the, of the story. And,
- 11:28and calling it practical effects is, is one way
- 11:31of doing it. I mean, it's, they're filming a
- 11:33hippo. Yeah. But like having things actually
- 11:36on screen. Right. Very, very effective. And that
- 11:39just goes to how it pushes the. through the story.
- 11:41Now, unfortunately, what I don't want the headline
- 11:44of this episode to be is Ryan very much enjoyed
- 11:47all of the real things that happened on screen
- 11:50in this movie. We'll get there. No, I don't.
- 11:53But I do want to say that the filming on location
- 11:55at times very much helps immerse you into the
- 11:59story. Unfortunately, other things happen that
- 12:02completely take you out of that story and don't
- 12:05want you asking yourself back in. Yeah. It's
- 12:09one of those things where As I was watching it,
- 12:12the story and, like, the characters in it, any
- 12:15time they were on screen, I was just like, ah,
- 12:17yeah, I'm not into this. Yes. Let me just enjoy,
- 12:20like, they filmed this on location. It's a safari
- 12:23movie, essentially. The location, the scenery.
- 12:24Cool. I'm watching hippos exist in their natural
- 12:28habitat. I'm watching lions and alligators and
- 12:31zebras. Crocodiles, again. You've ruined me.
- 12:34Sorry. But it's, you know, I went into it saying,
- 12:37I'm going to enjoy it for that. Halfway through
- 12:40the movie, as I'm doing my research, you read
- 12:43about the controversies and how some of these
- 12:46almost like a Discovery Channel or Animal Planet
- 12:50show, like you're watching lions hunt and things
- 12:53like that. And I was like, I don't really enjoy
- 12:56watching this personally. You know, it's not
- 12:58my vibe, but cool. It's 1931 and I'm watching
- 13:01a lion take down its prey. Fine. Upon your research,
- 13:06though, you find out that they. were starving
- 13:08these animals and antagonizing these animals
- 13:11so that they would hunt and look more aggressive
- 13:13and just appear better on film. So even that,
- 13:18the enjoyment you get out of it being a safari
- 13:20film, that completely gets stripped away. And
- 13:24you're left going, I don't know what I'm supposed
- 13:26to enjoy out of this movie. It's weird because
- 13:29I feel like now if this movie came out, someone
- 13:32would say, well, what's the appeal in seeing
- 13:33this movie? And I guess technically you could
- 13:35say like, hey, there's some like pretty, I don't
- 13:38want to use the word incredible, but like insane
- 13:40shots that they get of these animals. Like a
- 13:43nature documentary almost. Like pretty crazy
- 13:46what they got out of it. Yeah. But to your point,
- 13:48that doesn't feel like a reason to watch this
- 13:51movie because it's so riddled with controversy
- 13:54of how they did this. Yeah. And it's unethical.
- 13:58That's the main word behind it. Because look,
- 14:00the truth of it is these animals are hunting
- 14:02themselves. They're hunting each other out in
- 14:05the wild. This is happening every day. If you're
- 14:07filming that, that's one thing. But when you
- 14:09are provoking them to get a more vicious attack
- 14:12out of them, so it appears more vicious on camera,
- 14:15that is unethical. Absolutely. And there are
- 14:18laws put in place, not just in film, but also
- 14:22in the US, to prevent this from happening. Yeah.
- 14:25And the production company, MGM, actually sent
- 14:28a second crew, secretly, a second unit crew,
- 14:31to Mexico. to avoid the ethical treatment, or
- 14:34the American laws for ethical treatment, specifically
- 14:36against animals. So that's where the report stemmed
- 14:40from in Mexico, of them holding back food from
- 14:45the animals to provoke a more vicious attack.
- 14:48Wow. See, and that's what's crazy. You have the
- 14:51natural world out here in Africa where you could
- 14:54set up a camera and just kind of be patient.
- 14:56Yes. But the fact that they went... passed these
- 15:00laws and these regulations and specifically did
- 15:04that with the purpose with the intention of getting
- 15:07the best shot by doing all of these unethical
- 15:09things it's like that's that's pretty gross and
- 15:14to your point when you get to the hey here's
- 15:17this film history podcast go back and watch these
- 15:20movies here's the reason this is worth watching
- 15:22here's the reason this is worth watching this
- 15:24is this might be the first movie where it really
- 15:28is hard to come up with of why you should go
- 15:31watch this movie. I completely agree. Honestly,
- 15:34it kind of stopped me, or I stopped myself, rather,
- 15:36when we first started talking about doing this
- 15:38episode, where I had to kind of stop myself and
- 15:41just be like, I don't want to just hate on this
- 15:43movie for 45 minutes to an hour. I really don't
- 15:46want to do that. But it's difficult. Because
- 15:49I don't believe that the narrative justifies,
- 15:52of the movie, justifies this experience. This
- 15:56took two years for them to film. They went to
- 15:59Africa. They, I mean, this is true. The whole
- 16:03crew contracted malaria. Yeah. And not only that,
- 16:07two cast members were actually, well, there's
- 16:10a couple of things behind that. There were flash
- 16:11floods. There were locusts. There were sunstrokes,
- 16:14insect attacks, and specifically two deaths.
- 16:18attached to this movie. One of them was a crew
- 16:22member who was actually attacked by a rhinoceros
- 16:24that happened to be filmed. There's a couple,
- 16:27and this is what I mentioned previously, there
- 16:29are some reports that the footage in the movie...
- 16:33of someone being attacked by a rhino was the
- 16:36same footage of the crew member that was killed
- 16:38by a rhino. This has been circulating for a long
- 16:41time. That has since been disproven, specifically
- 16:44when you rewatch the footage. Not that I would
- 16:46suggest you do that if you think it's real, but
- 16:48you can see the animated nature of the body after
- 16:51it falls and how it kind of disappears. So this
- 16:54was animated into it and not something that was
- 16:57filmed in person. There are reports like that
- 17:01that aren't true. Now, that doesn't change that
- 17:03two people died on set, right? Yeah. That means
- 17:05that it's, you know, great, you didn't put it
- 17:07into your movie. Good. But it is still eerie
- 17:09that someone died by the hand of a rhino. There's
- 17:11a scene in the movie of someone dying to a rhino
- 17:13in the same way. Like, it just, it feels gross.
- 17:17Yeah, it's very distasteful. Very distasteful.
- 17:19So it's hard to look at the narrative of this
- 17:21movie and say it's worth. justifying any of these
- 17:24things happening. So it's difficult, right? I
- 17:27mean, the only positive thing when you say anything
- 17:29about the unethical treatment of animals, how
- 17:33they secretly went around to Africa, Mexico,
- 17:37Hollywood, but specifically Mexico to film to
- 17:39get around the laws, the only good thing that
- 17:41comes out of it is that the reason that we have
- 17:44the laws put in place today is because of things
- 17:46like this. Sure. Yeah. Like these movies, not
- 17:50these movies, this movie specifically went out
- 17:51of its way to do these things, found those loopholes.
- 17:54And now we have laws to prevent that from happening
- 17:56again. Right. And, you know, it's so funny because
- 18:00as I'm sitting here trying to think of like,
- 18:02what is the reason for watching this outside
- 18:04of I'm a completionist or whatever. Historical.
- 18:07Yeah. My brain immediately goes to a film like
- 18:12Cannibal Holocaust. Sure. Right. Very controversial.
- 18:15Animals were. actually killed for that film and
- 18:19it said that they were given to a local village
- 18:22to be used as food but it's still very gross
- 18:24and that's a movie that came out in the 70s right
- 18:27so you know this is 40 years prior to that and
- 18:31it is true that on a larger scale this led to
- 18:34more strict laws and things and regulations but
- 18:38this is kind of something that pops up in in
- 18:40film history these unethical it's not the last
- 18:44time we'll see stuff like this no maybe hopefully
- 18:46the last time on the show i don't know but it
- 18:50is like maybe that is the importance of going
- 18:53back and watching this so that you can say oh
- 18:55this isn't right and while this does happen later
- 18:58on in history maybe this will give me a sense
- 19:02of wow i hope this never happens again yeah no
- 19:06you're right i don't know You're right. I mean,
- 19:08I think that the historical side of this is why
- 19:11we do this, right? We love movies and we want
- 19:13to make sure that we have a clear picture of
- 19:15what came before. And that's not always going
- 19:17to be pretty. In this case, this is a very good
- 19:20example of how ugly Hollywood can be in trying
- 19:23to capture some of these things in the treatment
- 19:25of animals. Treatment of people, even. I mean,
- 19:27I kind of alluded to this earlier. I confused
- 19:29my notes. But so there are two cast members in
- 19:33the film that they had to come back for reshoots.
- 19:35They didn't get everything they needed in Africa,
- 19:37so they refilmed in Hollywood, sending everyone
- 19:40out to Hollywood. And two of those cast members
- 19:42who were part of Trader Horn's crew. um ranchero
- 19:46and another individual uh they were refused into
- 19:50the hollywood hotel because of their race and
- 19:52this is another sign of the times in 1931 that
- 19:56doesn't make it right whatever by any means but
- 19:59it's another like you know it's not just the
- 20:01animals that are being treated unethically here
- 20:04it's humans as well And it's just it kind of
- 20:07lends itself to the curse production where all
- 20:10these terrible things are happening, not just
- 20:13to, you know, certain individuals, but the entire
- 20:15cast as well. And it just feels like, you know,
- 20:17I'm a believer that like when I'm doing something
- 20:20and it's not really going my way after a couple
- 20:23minutes, I'm always like, is this the should
- 20:24I be doing this? Is this not just the world kind
- 20:26of telling me like, hey, man, chill out a little
- 20:28bit. Yeah. I say all that to say that if I'm
- 20:30W .S. Van Dyke. And I'm on my second flash flood
- 20:33and the locusts are attacking. I'm going to be
- 20:35like, I wonder if this is worth it. Do we need
- 20:38to keep doing this? Two people have died. It
- 20:40feels like there has to be more to the story.
- 20:44But doing my research, this is what's reported.
- 20:46So it's almost kind of amazing that this isn't
- 20:49talked about more with how much what happened
- 20:51on the set of this. But, you know, it's one thing
- 20:55if you take that off screen. And everything that
- 20:58happens on screen is not a reminder of this.
- 21:00Like, yeah, that's behind the scenes, but you
- 21:02got to judge the movie that's on merits. I think
- 21:04that's a valid perspective to have. This movie
- 21:07is so much of what happened behind the scenes.
- 21:10Sure. That it is impossible to separate those
- 21:13two. Absolutely. Absolutely. And I think that
- 21:16even if you do manage that impossible feat and
- 21:21you do treat it as its own thing, this movie's
- 21:24not great. It's not. It's... long it's two hours
- 21:27long it's actually kind of amazing how this movie
- 21:31was nominated for best picture when it happens
- 21:32to be and i checked the runtime on this eight
- 21:34hours and five minutes long isn't that crazy
- 21:37it does seem weird it's so long man it's very
- 21:41long and i watched this last night and i was
- 21:43telling taylor like at 4 p .m i was like hey
- 21:45i gotta watch this movie and we'll we'll get
- 21:48dinner afterwards and it was 6 p .m And I checked
- 21:51like my, I was like, oh, how much longer is left
- 21:54in this movie? It was five minutes. I was like,
- 21:55has this been on for five hours? Yeah. It feels
- 21:58so long. It drags. There's a lot of, I guess
- 22:02what you would call B footage, where you're just
- 22:04seeing the African plains or the wilds, which
- 22:08again, I can see how walking into the theater
- 22:12in 1931 to catch this movie, that would be incredible
- 22:15to see. Sure. I think it's also played to kind
- 22:18of unnerve you. There's a whole sequence of once
- 22:22traitor in Peru are kidnapped by the Kikuyu tribe.
- 22:26There's a moment where they're kind of witnessing
- 22:29this ritual that they're doing. And the audio
- 22:32that's playing for almost like five minutes straight
- 22:34is just their chanting. Yeah. And it's very unnerving.
- 22:37It's supposed to make you feel uncomfortable.
- 22:40There's a similar scene that's played after that
- 22:42between a lion and some hyenas that it's like
- 22:45three minutes straight. Of just hyenas and lions
- 22:48making noises while attacking each other. And
- 22:51it was not lost on me that they're trying to
- 22:53make the comparison of like, well, look at these
- 22:55like wild animals and then this tribe and the
- 22:57noises they're making. Yep. And that makes you
- 23:00feel similarly very disgusted of like, why are
- 23:02we comparing those two things? And why is that
- 23:05audio kind of being overlaid with each other?
- 23:07It just felt very much gross. Like, this is not
- 23:11what I want to remember it by. Totally. It also
- 23:13kind of feels like a little bit of the pearl
- 23:15clutching. You're supposed to be a white audience
- 23:18clutching your pearls. The idea of like, oh,
- 23:20this tribe is scaring me. Yeah. And it just feels
- 23:23very much like, man, this is not it. No. This
- 23:26is not something you should be proud of. And
- 23:28it's very much a cliche stereotype, the way that
- 23:34this tribe behaves. Correct. It's like all of
- 23:37the worst parts of an early Looney Tunes. Right.
- 24:11Kind of the wild woman. Her hair is big and frizzy.
- 24:16And our, who is it? Peru is like immediately
- 24:20smitten with her. And the things he says about
- 24:23her is just like, oh, she's beautiful. And Trader
- 24:27Horn says something like, yes, but she's just
- 24:29as wild as these other. There's a lot of terms
- 24:34he uses. Yeah. It's just all gross. But because
- 24:37she is white, like. There's this like romanticizing
- 24:41of her immediately. Yeah, it's like, well, hold
- 24:44on. Maybe we have this all wrong. Yeah. Look
- 24:46how pretty she is. Even when they're captured,
- 24:49Traderhorn has a line. No, it's Peru talking
- 24:51to her. He's trying to convince her to help them,
- 24:54even though she doesn't speak a lick of English.
- 24:56Right. And he says something along the lines
- 24:58of, white people are supposed to look out for
- 25:00each other. Dog, I almost turned the TV off when
- 25:03I heard that. Insane. Oh my God. Insane. Ugh,
- 25:06it hurts. I just watched. slanted in theaters
- 25:09the other day and that is a line that was basically
- 25:13pulled from that movie but in the most absurdist
- 25:15way well they add satire to it right yeah like
- 25:18to where clearly he's not right and like that
- 25:20kind of lends itself to like isn't it great to
- 25:22be white yeah yeah and that's the whole point
- 25:24of that comedic slash horror absurdist film this
- 25:29is played 100 straight faced yep because it's
- 25:33it's posing that question of like you know Aren't
- 25:36white people supposed to look out for each other?
- 25:39And it's asked genuinely. Yes. Of like, aren't
- 25:42we? Look at the terrible situation we're in.
- 25:44Which, by the way, the terrible situation that
- 25:45you've put yourself in. Like, this is not unfortunately
- 25:48happening to you. You've put yourself in this
- 25:51position. Yeah. It is narratively a nightmare.
- 25:54to deal with and you mentioned like you know
- 25:57there's just moments in this movie that it just
- 25:59sits in and those attacks that you watch with
- 26:01these animals there are almost i said three minutes
- 26:04i think it might be a little longer like five
- 26:06to seven where you actually watch like the scene
- 26:09setup is trader horn peru ranchero and at times
- 26:13uh nina are watching this attack happened and
- 26:17they're just more like right they're almost narrating
- 26:19it they're like yeah what look what's going on
- 26:21over there and the camera will cut and then show
- 26:23these like three minute sequences of like animals
- 26:25attacking and it just it feels pointless it feels
- 26:30pointless to be watching it doesn't lend itself
- 26:32to the story it's just more hey we happen to
- 26:34film in africa so like look at this footage that
- 26:36we captured in africa and there's ways to do
- 26:38that that don't feel as like i'm trying to find
- 26:42the best word for it but essentially white Not
- 26:44white guilt, like white pride almost. Like, isn't
- 26:47it crazy these situations these guys found themselves
- 26:50in and how they shouldn't be here? And you should
- 26:52feel sorry for them because of the color of their
- 26:54skin. Right. It just feels wrong, disgusting
- 26:58to watch. So that was very difficult. If the
- 27:00narrative puts you, or not puts you, if the narrative
- 27:05distracts you from that. and you can find yourself
- 27:07interested in the story otherwise, fine. There
- 27:10really is barely a narrative here. It really
- 27:12is just a child was taken, lost, whatever it
- 27:16might be, in the wilds, and now they are in a
- 27:19tribe, and we need to get her back home. Right.
- 27:23She seems to be thriving in the tribe, to be
- 27:25so honest with you. Sure. And this is a common
- 27:28trope across history and media. Correct. I mean,
- 27:32the Jungle Book itself. is boy gets lost in wilderness
- 27:37is raised by nature obviously the tribe element
- 27:40of that doesn't exist in there you know what
- 27:42i mean like i do it's it's a common to have a
- 27:46a person just surviving in the elements and then
- 27:49they adapt to to nature and all of that the problem
- 27:52with this is that the the villagers and the tribe
- 27:56that nina adapts to are portrayed in such a negative
- 27:59light there's a perfect example of this in the
- 28:01beginning of the movie where peru is kind of
- 28:04learning the ropes from trader and they go to
- 28:06the messiah tribe and they're starting to make
- 28:09some deals you know they brought out some tusks
- 28:11they're like yeah these are pitted out you know
- 28:13this is this is tough and while trader is doing
- 28:15all this you see peru kind of looking around
- 28:18And there's a couple of shots that I actually
- 28:19really liked here. There's a shot specifically
- 28:21of one of the women in the tribe. And she's kind
- 28:23of giving like this side profile and this look
- 28:26at the camera. And it becomes less of a narrative
- 28:28shot. And it's more like a documentary shot.
- 28:30Yeah. Of like she's not happy to be filmed. And
- 28:33she's kind of staring at the camera. And I thought
- 28:35that lent itself to like there's a perspective
- 28:36of like they don't want them here. And I thought
- 28:39that was like, okay, well, that's an interesting
- 28:41way to use this angle. of someone who's not happy
- 28:44to see this camera so like this is kind of interesting
- 28:46a little unethical but still interesting then
- 28:49that leads to peru saying traitor i think you
- 28:51got this all wrong i see like people happy laughing
- 28:55smiling like enjoying their life and that's when
- 28:58i was like oh cool like i i can take this like
- 29:01now we're kind of erasing the stereotype of like
- 29:04what it means to be you know in africa in 1870
- 29:07and if you're in a tribe and what the connotation
- 29:09is of that yeah Only to then immediately have
- 29:12Peru notice like an upside down person or a body
- 29:16corpse hanging upside down by a rack. And he
- 29:20makes this disgusted face. And Traderhorn has
- 29:22a line that might as well be, you stupid liberal.
- 29:25Like, it really was just like, man, you're that
- 29:29dumb, huh? I think the line exactly is, he's
- 29:32like, oh, no, what is that? And Treadhorn's like,
- 29:35oh, that? That's just a happy -go -lucky individual.
- 29:38Like, he's kind of using his words against him.
- 29:40To where it's not just like, hey, man, you want
- 29:42to be careful. It's dangerous out here. But it's
- 29:43more like, I knew you were too soft for the jungle.
- 29:47Yes. And it just kind of, it feels like a weird,
- 29:50like, there's a slightly political thing where
- 29:53it's like, nah, you're too awake for this. Or
- 29:55you're too sleepy for this. You're not fully
- 29:57awake and present in the moment. it just feels
- 30:00so charged and not like, you know, it's the narrative
- 30:03beat that then was like, Oh cool. I'm not like,
- 30:05this is not going to be for me. And maybe it's
- 30:08when you make that decision early on in the movie
- 30:10that I don't want to say it's a decision. The
- 30:11movie almost forces you to be like, Hey man,
- 30:13this is what we're doing. Right. And when you
- 30:16make that decision early on, that's what makes
- 30:18it feel like it's like five hours long because
- 30:21it just slowly crawls at a pace. I don't think
- 30:25there's scenes that are exciting and adventurous.
- 30:28are that common. While it doesn't look good,
- 30:31I think that river scene where they're outrunning
- 30:33the crocodiles, and I think we used the correct
- 30:36term there, where they outrun the crocodiles.
- 30:39Swinging from the vines, is that what you're
- 30:41referring to? That's later on, but specifically
- 30:42I'm talking about the green screen scene where
- 30:44it's like the 50 -foot croc in comparison to
- 30:47a trader horn. While it doesn't look good, that's
- 30:49at least exciting. And that's the kind of adventure
- 30:52scene that I'm here for. But then you're right.
- 30:54There are scenes later on that are considered
- 30:55the adventure scenes that are just footage of
- 30:58animals either attacking themselves or, even
- 31:00worse, being attacked by humans and shot and
- 31:04have spears thrown at them. Crazy that this is
- 31:08on camera. Yeah. And it feels horrible to watch.
- 31:12And it's one of those things where, again, I
- 31:15turned to... cannibal holocaust just for the
- 31:18the comparison in the animal cruelty there and
- 31:21the whole thing was that they they offered that
- 31:25the animals killed on the film to a local tribe
- 31:28for food i don't know if that's the case here
- 31:30a rhino was killed on screen a lion is killed
- 31:33on screen by the humans i don't know what was
- 31:36done with those animals. It's not said. And there's
- 31:39something in me, and it may be wrong to assume,
- 31:42but I think it's also kind of safe to assume,
- 31:44that they weren't treated with the alleged care
- 31:48that you would hope was done in a situation like
- 31:52this. So it's really weird. It's really bizarre,
- 31:54everything about this movie. It's hard to find
- 31:57something enjoyable. And then in the moments
- 32:00that you do, you read a little behind the scenes
- 32:03and you're like, oh, I don't like the way they
- 32:04did that at all. That's completely disgusting.
- 32:07Yeah. The only thing that I saw that I thought
- 32:10was kind of like a bright spot in the way of
- 32:12talking about all of this. We got to talk about
- 32:14Peru's hat, man. They're wearing hats in this
- 32:19movie, obviously, to protect themselves from
- 32:21the sun. If you look closely, actually, Trader
- 32:23Horn is wearing two hats. He's wearing kind of
- 32:26a bucket hat, but there's a hat underneath that
- 32:28to kind of help, you know, that. Hold up the
- 32:30hat. Hold up the hat. Sure. Peru. is wearing
- 32:33a hat that is almost dark helmet from Spaceballs
- 32:38adjacent. Yes. Like this is a comically large
- 32:41safari hat. And I've never been on a safari.
- 32:45Closest I've been is Animal Kingdom in Orlando,
- 32:47Florida. Kissimmee, Florida. My apologies. I
- 32:50don't, I'm not going to pretend to fully understand
- 32:52the headwear at this time. Right. I'm pretty
- 32:56sure that hat is comically large. I think so.
- 32:58That is a hysterically large hat. Well, it's
- 33:01one of those things, too, where I kept thinking
- 33:02about that scene in Scary Movie 3 where the sheriff's
- 33:05hat just gets bigger and bigger. I swear it was
- 33:07growing as time went on. Yes. No, for sure. The
- 33:09only reason why I don't think it was is when
- 33:11I first saw him, and maybe this is why, kudos
- 33:15to the hippo that emerges and submerges immediately
- 33:17after, I was so immersed because I don't know
- 33:20anything else that could distract me from that
- 33:22hat in the opening scene. I was like, that is
- 33:24amazing. That is insane. It is honestly the equivalent.
- 33:28It's two sizes the size of his head. It's so
- 33:31big. Twice the size of his head. So big. It's
- 33:33so funny. And that's why later on in the movie
- 33:36when they're like, oh, traitor, I didn't think
- 33:37we were going to make it out of that one. That
- 33:39was traumatic. I'm like, your hat. It's hysterically
- 33:42large. Yeah. So the only thing that kind of kept
- 33:45me coming back in these horrible moments when
- 33:47you read about all these terrible things that
- 33:48happen on set is like, well, that hat is very
- 33:51funny. One of my favorite movies, John Carpenter's
- 33:53The Thing. I love that movie because there's
- 33:56so much going on. The themes are incredible.
- 33:58Practical effects are used for the aliens, designs,
- 34:02the makeup. And yet, Kurt Russell's hat in that
- 34:06movie is like Elmer Fudd level big. yosemite
- 34:11sam it is yosemite sam i'm so sorry you're right
- 34:13yeah they both wear hats but yes yosemite sam
- 34:14and i'm specifically talking about when uh for
- 34:17all of our fans of the thing out there when mcready
- 34:20uh mcready gets on his plane his helicopter yeah
- 34:23uh he has this hat attached by like a neck piece
- 34:27like around his neck so it's hanging off the
- 34:29back and you're like okay cool he has a hat but
- 34:31then the next scene is him piloting the helicopter
- 34:33with a hat on yeah And that hat is taking up
- 34:36half the space of the cockpit. Right. And it's
- 34:39so funny. Every time I'm always just like, this
- 34:42hat is so comically large. It's always going
- 34:44to get me. So the fact that Traderhorn didn't
- 34:47win me over with this comically large hat, this
- 34:50is true. And I want the pod to note this. Kyle,
- 34:52I want you to verify. I have written in all caps.
- 34:55Peru's hat on my note. It's true. I have sentences
- 34:59here of the cruelty of this film and the terrible
- 35:02things that have happened. And the only thing
- 35:04I have highlighted in all caps is Peru's hat.
- 35:07And that's because I want to make sure I noted
- 35:09how insane this is. See, that's so much more
- 35:12fun and playful. In my notes, the last thing
- 35:15I wrote is racist with six T's. OK, so hold on.
- 35:20Does that mean like you're kind of like hanging
- 35:23on it a bit like racist or like what does that
- 35:26look like to you? That's that's me talking to
- 35:30the audience and being like, hey, you guys should
- 35:32watch all the movies we cover on this film. But
- 35:34as I'm saying that, I'm like slinking out the
- 35:37back door and I'm like, yeah, yeah. That's what
- 35:40that is. I more, I more thought of it as like
- 35:42a period where it's like, yeah, this is like
- 35:44racist. Yeah. Now the problem is like, you know,
- 35:47we, we started this year talking about Cimarron
- 35:49and we talked about how that didn't have the
- 35:52best handle on race. Right. Like that was still,
- 35:55and look, look, we are aware that we're talking
- 35:58about a very different time and that doesn't
- 36:00mean it's okay. Right. But that was something
- 36:02that at the time was seen as like more acceptable,
- 36:04which is wrong. However, the way that they talk
- 36:07about in Cimarron is almost like a little bit
- 36:09of like a nudge and like a joke, which is also
- 36:11wrong. Yeah. And in Traderhorn, but it's still
- 36:14accepted as like, you know, this is commonplace
- 36:16and this is normal. As Traderhorn, this is blasted
- 36:20over like a megaphone. Right. Like this is on
- 36:22a much larger scale, both literally and figuratively
- 36:25than Cimarron was. I think it's a very interesting
- 36:31and unfortunate way to start and end this year.
- 36:35Yeah. Because in the middle of it lies exactly
- 36:37where I think I felt the most comfortable. And
- 36:39that we started with Cimarron. I was like, oh,
- 36:41this feels a little weird, but it's of its time.
- 36:43So, okay, fine, I guess. But I don't feel good
- 36:45about it. And then front page comes. And I'm
- 36:48like, oh. Well, this is wrong, but like there's
- 36:50a little bit of a satire behind it of like maybe
- 36:52that's not okay either. So you can accept that
- 36:54a bit more. But then the cap of it is probably
- 36:57the most exaggerated form of this. Yeah, 100%.
- 37:01And not even in just a morally, you know, like,
- 37:04hey, how do you feel about, you know, the way
- 37:07that we communicate to each other as people regardless
- 37:08of race, but also the way that we interact with
- 37:11animals and nature. And it's terrible. Yeah,
- 37:15it's awful. I also want to there's one thing
- 37:18we haven't talked about here. You kind of alluded
- 37:21a little bit to the connection between Peru and
- 37:24Nina. Nina. Thank you. Just make sure it wasn't
- 37:27Edith. But Nina and Peru. But there's also kind
- 37:30of a little bit of a thing between Nina and Trader.
- 37:33Like Trader has like a little bit of like a longing
- 37:35towards her, too, to a point where there's like
- 37:37a fist. Well, not even fist fight. There's a
- 37:38punch thrown between Peru and Trader. Trader
- 37:42throws a punch at Peru when he's like, you know.
- 37:45You can't look at her. That's my girl. And they
- 37:47start fighting over her or fighting each other
- 37:49over her. And this feels so tacked on, man. Like,
- 37:52you can't even say there's romance in this movie
- 37:54because it's just like, hey, I'm also white.
- 37:57Isn't that cool? Maybe we should, like, we can't
- 37:59even talk to each other, but we just look at
- 38:01each other a certain way. Right. And this happens
- 38:03after the halfway mark in the movie, so it literally
- 38:06feels tacked on. Yeah. Just added on to the end
- 38:08of it. It's so gross. Everything with Edwina
- 38:12Booth's character is just done in such poor taste.
- 38:16And it really does feel like, well, how do we
- 38:19get women to go see this movie as well? Oh, we'll
- 38:21make it a romance. But it's like, hey, you're
- 38:25white. I'm white. I think of Beavis and Butthead
- 38:28do America when he sees the president's daughter.
- 38:31And he's like, I see you have braces. I have
- 38:34braces too. And he gets thrown out a window,
- 38:37which is what should have happened to Peru. Yeah,
- 38:40it's, you know, the implications of this are
- 38:42just completely wrong because we haven't mentioned
- 38:45this yet, but when they follow Edith up the river
- 38:48to try and help her find Nina, she dies. And
- 38:51you can almost see this happening because she's
- 38:54like, hey, traitor, I just need you to promise
- 38:55that you're going to keep me safe. He's like,
- 38:57yeah, we'll do what we can. She's like, yeah,
- 38:59no, I need you to promise me that you're going
- 39:01to follow me up this river and keep me safe.
- 39:03He's like, I promise. And you're like, you're
- 39:06dead. You're so dead, man. There's no way this
- 39:09is going to happen. And she does die. And they
- 39:11have this scene where they talk about how we
- 39:13honor the death to kind of keep them from crocodiles
- 39:16attacking them. You cover their face. How did
- 39:19she die again? I believe that she drowned. The
- 39:22ship turned over, her ship specifically, that
- 39:25they were following turned over and she drowned
- 39:26because they found her washed up on the shore.
- 39:28So she dies. And then that means that any communication...
- 39:33to Nina about her past is solely from traitor
- 39:36in Peru. Right. Yeah. When we see, when we see
- 39:40Nina specifically, she doesn't have any memories
- 39:42of where she came from. She's not trying to like
- 39:45express to them, Hey, I'm not safe. This isn't
- 39:48okay. So this is quite literally two men coming
- 39:51in, kidnapping this woman from where she is currently.
- 39:54And then just saying, well, we're saving her.
- 39:56This is us saving her from where she is when
- 39:59there's nothing indicating that she isn't the
- 40:01ruler of this tribe. Right. It kind of becomes
- 40:04one of those. If she spoke English, maybe it's
- 40:05another thing where it's like, hey, yeah, I mean,
- 40:06this is weird, but like, I've kind of just gotten
- 40:08used to this. That's one thing. It's another
- 40:11when she cannot speak the language. She might
- 40:14as well be telling them like, I don't want to
- 40:15leave. Yeah. Like, let's get out of here. Like,
- 40:18it just, it feels so like white savior. Yes.
- 40:21And it just kind of in a movie that didn't absolutely
- 40:24needed no further investigating into what it
- 40:28means to like have race relations. Yeah. Just
- 40:31absolutely. Buggled it completely. Yeah. Let's
- 40:35talk about Edwina Booth. Let's talk about Edwina
- 40:37Booth. So, obviously, everything that's happened
- 40:40in this movie is awful and a huge controversy.
- 40:43The deaths that occurred. The crocodile death.
- 40:46The rhino death. Peru's hat. Peru's hat. R .I
- 40:49.P. Oh, it didn't make it. Did it not? No, he's
- 40:52not wearing it at the end. You're right. So,
- 40:54actual R .I .P. You know what I think it is?
- 40:57You know how the whole thing is Indiana Jones
- 40:59never loses his hat. And he does the whole thing
- 41:01where it's on the other side of the door that's
- 41:04about to close and he reaches out with one hand
- 41:05and grabs it. You need two hands for Peru's hat.
- 41:09And sometimes both your hands are full. So he
- 41:13probably had to leave it because he couldn't
- 41:14drag it through the African plains. I do like
- 41:18the idea of like if Nina fell out of the boat
- 41:21and his hat fell out of the boat, you have like
- 41:23a scene of him like. yeah like in indiana jones
- 41:25when it's it's elsa and uh the grail yes he's
- 41:29like pull me up he's like but the girl yeah same
- 41:32thing with the hat where he comes what a great
- 41:35final scene that would be in the movie if uh
- 41:37if trader's about to leave on the boat and he
- 41:39just sees all of a sudden peru comes in and he's
- 41:42got his hat but he's like where's nina he's like
- 41:44yeah my hat's fun But yes. And they high five
- 41:49because they're like, yeah, good choice. They
- 41:52shook hands. That's what they did. Oh, makes
- 41:54sense. But yes, Edwina Booth. Yeah. So production
- 41:57riddled with just tragedy. And we mentioned at
- 42:00the top that most of the crew and the cast contracted
- 42:04malaria. Correct. Edwina Booth was mishandled
- 42:07completely during the making of this. She was
- 42:11sent out on the boat while they were traveling
- 42:14to Africa. to sunbathe by the director because
- 42:17she had to have a certain look. And she was meant
- 42:21to sit out there for hours. And she ended up
- 42:24with like serious burns. But on top of that,
- 42:27she also contracted malaria and did not recover
- 42:31from this for six years. So this destroyed her
- 42:35career. This was like the last movie she was
- 42:38in until much later in her life where she had
- 42:41kind of like a soft return to acting. But there
- 42:44was like a lawsuit involved in all of this because
- 42:46of how she was treated on the set. And, you know,
- 42:49you don't really get a good feel of her acting
- 42:52abilities in this movie. So you don't know like
- 42:55what could her career have been. But either way,
- 42:58we talked about Skippy last episode and the way
- 43:02the children were kind of mistreated. and expected
- 43:05to not only deliver very physical and dangerous
- 43:09performances, but were emotionally traumatized.
- 43:13And this is a reoccurring theme now, where Edwina
- 43:16Booth and other members of the cast were just
- 43:19kind of put through it in a very serious way.
- 43:23How did you feel when you started researching
- 43:26this? Like I was kind of watching the ring tape.
- 43:30Yeah. Like, this is, don't. don't you put that
- 43:34evil on me, to quote Michael Clarke Duncan on
- 43:37that. It felt wrong. And it just, you know, I
- 43:40recently saw Undertone, a movie that talks about
- 43:43like the idea of like feeling cursed or like,
- 43:45you know, something following you because of
- 43:46what you've listened to or read. That's kind
- 43:48of what I felt like researching this, where it
- 43:51felt like an evil spirit kind of like dawned
- 43:53on this movie. And it goes across the board.
- 43:56You know, it's not even like, well, this movie
- 43:57was seen as successful, so ultimately it's in
- 43:59the right. No. To your point, Edwina Booth's
- 44:01trial. resulted in MGM having to pay her like
- 44:04a million dollars. Yeah. I actually noted on
- 44:07this when I read it's in a million bucks. I thought
- 44:09that was a little strange. Oh, did it? I think
- 44:10when I read the conversion rate, it was like
- 44:12$600 ,000, which is... Oh, so like a million
- 44:15bucks today, but at that point it was $600 ,000?
- 44:18Maybe. I don't know. Interesting. But I remember
- 44:20it being like $600 ,000 and saying, that's not
- 44:24enough. Yeah. Well, I mean, no amount of money
- 44:26is enough of it. permanently changed your life
- 44:29right like but i mean it said a million dollars
- 44:31on there i guess we'll have to do the research
- 44:33on that well it said a million bucks but um a
- 44:36million buckaroonies yeah like look she almost
- 44:39died what are we doing like people literally
- 44:41died on set and we're like 100 smackaroos yeah
- 44:44but no it felt awful like doing the research
- 44:46on this like it was it's a testament to you know
- 44:49the work that we want to do here to where we
- 44:51want it to be historically accurate even in the
- 44:54even in the face of like morally wrong yeah and
- 44:58it feels awful to be talking about some of these
- 45:00things that shouldn't have ever happened and
- 45:01shouldn't exist and thankfully it led to some
- 45:04scenarios where there are laws in place to where
- 45:06this can't happen again yeah and i guess that's
- 45:08good but it shouldn't happen in the first place
- 45:10right did you ever watch that series on shutter
- 45:13cursed films i did and i actually one of my double
- 45:17features one of my double features i'm going
- 45:19to be talking about plays prominently into that
- 45:21okay for that exact reason yeah it's just that
- 45:25talked about obviously very mainstream movies,
- 45:27but I would be very interested if this got some
- 45:32kind of like documentary treatment or even if
- 45:35they did like a biographical narrative of how
- 45:38this was made, because it is one of the most
- 45:40insane production stories I've ever heard of.
- 45:44It is. You know, I think I read that there was,
- 45:46and I can't say this with my full chest, but
- 45:49I think I read that there was like a remake in
- 45:51the 70s of Traderhorn. And there was a documentary
- 45:54about that and how the original could have been
- 45:57made. But my understanding is from taking the
- 46:00title or taking the movie that they probably
- 46:02did not want to highlight a lot of what happened
- 46:04in the original. So it was more, how did we make
- 46:07this one? So in that eye. Or in that sense, unfortunately,
- 46:10more of a revisionist thing of like, well, hey,
- 46:13if you look in the making of Traderhorn, you're
- 46:15going to find the 1970 documentary. Interesting.
- 46:18Instead of what happened in 1931 on this. So,
- 46:21I mean, you know, there's a lot that's happened
- 46:24with cursed films or films that have been deemed
- 46:26as cursed productions in the past. And specifically,
- 46:29you know, one of the films that's talked about
- 46:31on that excellent special, you talked about cursed
- 46:34films on Shudder. One of them is Poltergeist.
- 46:37And Poltergeist is the idea of like, you know,
- 46:39that you actually used human skeletons for the
- 46:42pool scene in Poltergeist. You move the tombstones,
- 46:45we didn't move the bodies, like a lot of that.
- 46:47And ultimately, yeah, that's very difficult,
- 46:50moral gray area of how to handle that. Probably
- 46:53shouldn't use real bodies for that. But then
- 46:55you talk about something like this, where in
- 46:58retrospect, and certainly I do not really want
- 47:01to see anything that beats this record. Yeah.
- 47:04one of the more like tragic backgrounds behind,
- 47:07even in the movie. And so much of that makes
- 47:10its way into the movie, which is what makes it
- 47:12so difficult to watch. So it's really hard to
- 47:15recommend because of the very troubled background
- 47:18of it. But also the movie itself just does not,
- 47:21no movie warrants that happening, but it doesn't
- 47:24warrant a watch in spite of that. No, absolutely
- 47:28not. We've said it a million times now. There's...
- 47:31Really nothing redeeming in this movie. The most
- 47:34interesting thing, I think, are the nature scenes
- 47:39and like the animals. But the problem with that
- 47:41is the way these animals were antagonized to
- 47:44get those shots. So you can't even find enjoyment
- 47:46in that. You're better off just popping on a
- 47:49Discovery Channel or whatever, National Geographic.
- 47:54whatever anything is better than this well you
- 47:56know a lot of it is reportedly right because
- 47:59there's not a lot of confirmations that came
- 48:00out of this unfortunately i'm sure a lot of it's
- 48:02being kept under wraps but specifically when
- 48:04you have a scenario where mgm is mgm is secretly
- 48:08sending out a second unit crew to mexico to avoid
- 48:12the american laws around ethical treatment of
- 48:14animals you have to assume that the reports that
- 48:17you're hearing Are also correct. Right. About
- 48:20them antagonizing the animals. Yeah. So specifically
- 48:23I'd read it was the lions that they were antagonizing.
- 48:26Starving. Starving the lions, exactly. So I can't
- 48:30say that with 100 % certainty, but unfortunately
- 48:32it's extremely believable with all the other
- 48:34reports. Oh yeah, absolutely. Of what did happen
- 48:36here. Now, I will say, I talk about how this
- 48:39was like a dying genre and things. Yes. This
- 48:42was very successful at the time. It was. And
- 48:45this ended up. creating a trend of these like
- 48:49adventure safari films that pushed out the gangster
- 48:54genre as the most prominent genre of the time
- 48:57i think that's really interesting it's unfortunate
- 49:00that it came out of this movie with all of its
- 49:03controversies but that's that's a big deal because
- 49:06obviously when you think about the 30s you think
- 49:10about gangster films so Success? Are you excited
- 49:13for more adventure films like this? Totally.
- 49:15Yeah. No, I mean, I love the adventure genre.
- 49:18And that's why it's like, I would love to just
- 49:20say this episode is, you know, wow, look at the
- 49:22first real entry that lent itself to that genre
- 49:25being lifted up. How cool that would be. But
- 49:28it's difficult to do that when what happened
- 49:31has happened. The thing that I will say is that
- 49:34when it comes to adventure. I am excited to see
- 49:38where it goes from here. And I'm excited to see
- 49:41what we've learned not to do. Yeah. And hopefully
- 49:44we don't see a lot of the retreading of what
- 49:46happened here. And I don't just necessarily mean
- 49:48behind the scenes because I'm sure like you can't
- 49:51kind of replicate that. Thank God. But I'm talking
- 49:53more about the way that like. we talk about race
- 49:56and talk about tribes in Africa, a lot of the
- 50:00dialogue that's used in the screenplay here is
- 50:03pretty reprehensible. Yes. And it's kind of thrown
- 50:06away. I mentioned how in Cimarron it feels, or
- 50:09in Front Page, it feels a little bit more like
- 50:10a satire. Like we're kind of mocking the idea
- 50:13that this person is saying it this way. At least,
- 50:15you know, that's my hope. In this, it's delivered
- 50:18very straight. Specifically, Traitor is using
- 50:22a lot of this dialogue that is pretty... I mean,
- 50:25I can't think of another word for wrong. Just
- 50:27objectively wrong. It's pretty gross. So I hope
- 50:31to see more adventure films in the future, and
- 50:34we will. But I also hope that in the near future,
- 50:36in the 30s, we don't see a replication of that
- 50:40screenplay and that writing style. Yeah. And
- 50:43speaking of that writing style, a little fun
- 50:45fact. This was based on a novel by Ethel Rita
- 50:49Lewis. Correct. So there was one time there was
- 50:52a... book event going on and i found cimarron
- 50:55as a novel and i i purchased it because i was
- 50:57like oh what a what a cool little thing to have
- 50:59for like a buck i was at a thrift store and i
- 51:04actually came across trader horn and i was like
- 51:07oh what a cool little thing to and then i thought
- 51:09about the first time i watched it and i was like
- 51:11i'm good i'm just gonna put that one back but
- 51:14walk up do you guys need me to throw this out
- 51:16for you or yeah yeah do you guys know you have
- 51:19this It's dangerous. Have you read this? You
- 51:22basically have Jumanji the board game. Don't
- 51:26open it. Oh, God, please don't. Yeah, look, it's
- 51:29such a weird thing to talk about. And I mean,
- 51:33well, do you want to get into ratings? Oh, absolutely.
- 51:36This is clearly obvious in the rating that I
- 51:38gave it. I kind of danced back and forth on what
- 51:41to do with this. But I ultimately did end up
- 51:44giving this two stars. Or no, wow, wrong. Sorry,
- 51:47I was looking at Skippy. Wrong, incorrect. I
- 51:49gave it a star. One star. Yeah. And I went star
- 51:52and a half. I just changed it to one. I thought
- 51:55about it more. And normally I don't like to do
- 51:57that. Like when I watch it, I want to go with
- 51:58what I went there. Right. But talking more about
- 52:02it, it's like this, this doesn't deserve much.
- 52:04I agree. And, you know, one thing that I like
- 52:06pointing out is when you look at Letterboxd,
- 52:09you have the ability to kind of see a rough idea
- 52:12of what people are rating this. And while it
- 52:14stands at a 2 .5, that doesn't sound terribly
- 52:16low. It's worth noting that the highest or the
- 52:19most common rating this is given is one star.
- 52:22Yeah. The second, I think, is two and the third
- 52:24is half. of one star. So this is trending in
- 52:28that direction of people are looking back with
- 52:31a not great point of view with this. Yeah. And
- 52:35I think that's the correct way to do this. I
- 52:37mean, and from like an Academy standpoint too,
- 52:40just like East Lynn, this was nominated for outstanding
- 52:43production. And I think that a majority of that
- 52:45comes from, Hey, this was filmed in Africa. Look
- 52:48at all the animals. It's. It's kind of funny,
- 52:51though, that they use the term outstanding production
- 52:53and not best picture. Because I could see you
- 52:55trying to say this is the best picture. It's
- 52:57not. But I could see you trying to make that
- 52:59argument. To look at everything that's happened
- 53:01in this and say, is this the most outstanding
- 53:03production? Sure. Absolutely not. I mean, it
- 53:07stands out. I would say it is the most upstanding.
- 53:10Well, that's not even the right word. The most
- 53:12standing out production. The most upsetting production.
- 53:15Yeah. But yeah, just like easily the most cursed.
- 53:18That's a very good point. You know, and to talk
- 53:21on the cursed films documentary, I think with
- 53:23a lot of that, anytime a film is considered cursed
- 53:27and there's a death involved, that death isn't
- 53:30connected to the film itself. Correct. It's just
- 53:33something that happened on set. Yeah. Or after
- 53:35set. Right. Like Poltergeist is the good example
- 53:39there. There you go. But with this, it's just
- 53:41like, hey, we did things that were really kind
- 53:43of taboo and dangerous and we paid for it. Correct.
- 53:48So it's like a self -inflicted curse. What are
- 53:50you guys doing? Yeah, like, you could have left
- 53:52at any time. And that's why it's hard for me
- 53:54to kind of be like, well, what did you do to
- 53:55the animals to provoke them? You were on their
- 53:58land? Like, you went up to them? Like, you were
- 54:01filming near them? Yeah. They don't know what
- 54:03movies are. They can't, like, they don't know
- 54:05behaviors and, like, you know, well, hey, it's
- 54:07uncouth for me to kill you on camera right now.
- 54:09They are just surviving. And, like, it's the
- 54:12law of the jungle, quite literally. But then
- 54:14when you look at the production, if the animal
- 54:16is like, hey, it's not cool for me to kill you
- 54:18on camera right now, but I'm going to do it anyway.
- 54:20And then the director says, that's great. We're
- 54:22going to use that. Yes. It's just crazy. What
- 54:25are we doing? Crazy. So wrong. Well, look, you
- 54:28mentioned cursed films. We'll go ahead and go
- 54:30into our double features. So my double feature
- 54:33is part of that cursed films. It's the Twilight
- 54:36Zone. Oh, yeah. Twilight Zone, the movie. I want
- 54:40to go ahead and say. I picking a double feature
- 54:42for the trader horn was very difficult because
- 54:45the double feature inherently means that you
- 54:47are recommending this. Right. I wouldn't recommend
- 54:50this double feature. In fact, I would recommend
- 54:52this double feature. Skip the first one. Only
- 54:54watch the second one. Yeah. And that's Twilight
- 54:56Zone, the movie. A similar situation filmed in
- 54:591983. Also a cursed production. Obviously, there's
- 55:02a lot happened there. We don't have to get into
- 55:03too much of it. But it is deaths that resulted
- 55:06from this filming. So there's a lot that's involved
- 55:09in it. I just gave the example of... oh yeah,
- 55:12these movies didn't involve like actual deaths
- 55:14on film. And then you're like, except this one.
- 55:16Except this one. Let me recommend it. It did.
- 55:18And you know, obviously there's a lot of controversy
- 55:20around it, but watching the film, there is a
- 55:23way to kind of see this and not be reminded of
- 55:26the horrible, horrible things that happened as
- 55:29a result of that. Yeah. So I would suggest Twilight
- 55:32Zone, the movie, in spite of that. The other
- 55:34reason too, is that Twilight Zone, the movie,
- 55:37his... did lead to industry changes. Sure. There
- 55:41were changes that came from the filming of The
- 55:43Twilight Zone, much like they came from Traderhorn,
- 55:47from the lawsuits from, I mean, not just the
- 55:50lawsuits with Edwina Booth, but specifically
- 55:52the mishandling of the animal scenes. Right.
- 55:56And circumventing the law by going to Mexico.
- 55:59Totally. Just a lot going on there. But while
- 56:02I wouldn't recommend celebrating any death in
- 56:05any film, it's hard to not look at something
- 56:08like a cursed production of, I would say it's
- 56:11much more cursed with Traderhorn, but certainly
- 56:14the horrible events that happened on Twilight
- 56:16Zone, the movie, where they still somehow didn't
- 56:18make that the point of the movie. Right. Yeah.
- 56:21So I would recommend, nope, I wouldn't, but I
- 56:24would compare those two movies. Yes, I totally
- 56:26understand. I had thought about also doing a
- 56:28cursed film. Went against that. Not that I think
- 56:31Twilight Zone is a bad one. What I do like about
- 56:33Twilight Zone 2, that sequence doesn't take place
- 56:36in the film, right? They got rid of it. Correct.
- 56:39Awesome. Yeah, that's correct. As they should.
- 56:41Yeah. Something that Traderhorn could have learned
- 56:44from retroactively. And I don't want to say that
- 56:48this is how you do it because it shouldn't happen
- 56:50in the first place. Yes, right. But inherently
- 56:52that is the right mindset of, well, what do we
- 56:54do now to honor that? Yeah. And not just, well,
- 56:58that's the jungle, baby. Yeah. That makes no
- 57:01sense. Yeah. My film is all fictional. So there
- 57:06is that. However, it is the story of a director
- 57:09who is willing to go to any length to get what
- 57:13he needs for his movie. And that comes at the
- 57:16expense of much of his crew, some of his cast,
- 57:21and really like a majority of New York City even.
- 57:25And that is 2005's King Kong. Yeah. So Jack Black's
- 57:31character, Jack, is it Jack? I forget his name.
- 57:34I really like his character's name. Carl Denham,
- 57:37of course. Carl Denham goes on this expedition
- 57:39to find Skull Island and film a movie there.
- 57:43And they come into contact with just some of
- 57:46the most dangerous creatures and scenarios known
- 57:51to mankind with giant bugs and dinosaurs. And
- 57:54of course, Kong himself. And every time someone
- 57:59dies in this movie, Carl Denham has a moment
- 58:03where he says, we're going to continue on with
- 58:06this movie and we're going to do it for so -and
- 58:09-so. They would have wanted us to finish this
- 58:11and we're going to donate the proceeds to his
- 58:14wife and kids. And then he continues to make
- 58:17the movie and people die. And it just keeps happening.
- 58:20And I think that is a more lighthearted, comical,
- 58:24maybe not while you're watching the movie. Well,
- 58:26a little bit. It's played for laughs. A little
- 58:27bit, yeah. Yeah. A fictional counterpart to the
- 58:31real tragedies that occurred on the filming of
- 58:33Traitor Horn. Well, I mean, one, it's fictional,
- 58:37right? But two, the greed is like baked into
- 58:39the character. Yes. So when a real director,
- 58:43assuming he was fully on board with this, which,
- 58:45you know, you have to assume, W .S. Van Dyke,
- 58:47he... That's just who he is at that point. That
- 58:51greed is baked into his character. So yeah, I
- 58:54think that's a fantastic comparison. I'm actually
- 58:56very upset I didn't think of that as well. It's
- 58:59also a great adventure movie. So good. Especially
- 59:01Peter Jackson's version. He did a great job with
- 59:04that. That kind of has the curse of the sophomore
- 59:06slump of like, hey man, you did Lord of the Rings.
- 59:08What are you going to do next? He's like, um,
- 59:10this. Everyone's like, oh, it's not as good.
- 59:13Oh, I loved it. It is very good. It's great to
- 59:15revisit now. I do think it's funny. That everything
- 59:19you mentioned about how it was, what was his
- 59:22name, Carl? Carl Denham. Carl Denham. Carl Denham
- 59:24kind of like brought this into New York. Like
- 59:27he made this New York's problem. Yeah. And then
- 59:29King Kong dies. And someone's like, oh, the bullets
- 59:32killed him. He's like, no, it's not the bullets.
- 59:34It was the beauty that killed the beast. And
- 59:37someone's like, hey, didn't you bring him here?
- 59:38Yeah. Like, I like the idea of him saying this.
- 59:41Like, yeah, yeah, it was the beauty that killed
- 59:43him. Not me bringing him here. Right. Yeah. Great.
- 59:47Good job, Carl. Yeah. I like that one. Great
- 59:51double feature. Great double feature. Try just
- 59:53watching King Kong. Yeah. I recommend that. You
- 59:56know what? Watch the original King Kong and then
- 59:58watch this one. My double feature for you for
- 1:00:01Trader Horn is to not watch Trader Horn and instead
- 1:00:03watch both versions of King Kong. Yeah. Maybe
- 1:00:05skip the Jessica Lange one. Okay. I was wondering
- 1:00:08if you were going to go the Jessica Lange or
- 1:00:09is it Faye Dunway? Faye Dunway. Yeah. Yeah. No.
- 1:00:12Faye Ray. Faye Ray. Yeah. Sorry. I got the first
- 1:00:14name right. Yeah. No, I like the how, hey, I'm
- 1:00:19going to get this movie done. Jack Black is in
- 1:00:222005. That's true. Crazy Adrian Brody's in that
- 1:00:25movie. Isn't it? Yeah. Fully in acceptance speech
- 1:00:28for it. Some say it's still happening. Just as
- 1:00:30long as King Kong was. But yes, that is Traitor
- 1:00:34Horn. I'm really curious if anybody watched this.
- 1:00:37If you did go into this without like any type
- 1:00:39of warning, I do apologize because it is. Pretty
- 1:00:44triggering. That being said, if you did watch
- 1:00:46it and you have thoughts, which how could you
- 1:00:48not? Shoot us an email at OUTAOPodcast at gmail
- 1:00:52.com. Be sure to check out the Patreon, patreon
- 1:00:55.com slash OUTAOPodcast for access to the community
- 1:00:59Discord. Watch parties, which we will be doing
- 1:01:02tonight. Nope, March 27th. You're so close. I
- 1:01:07know. One day I won't stumble. We're covering
- 1:01:09a film. We haven't announced it yet. Maybe we
- 1:01:12have. I don't know. It's a good time to announce
- 1:01:14we'll be watching Traderhorn. And everybody drops
- 1:01:18their backing. We won't be watching Traderhorn.
- 1:01:20No. No, it will be a film from 1931 that was
- 1:01:23not nominated for an Oscar. So looking forward
- 1:01:26to watching that with you all tonight. Yeah,
- 1:01:28absolutely. Rate and review the show on whatever
- 1:01:31podcast platform you listen to. Beyond that,
- 1:01:34that's all I got. Next episode is going to be
- 1:01:36our ceremony episode where we talk about the
- 1:01:381931 Academy Awards, winners, losers, sleepy
- 1:01:42little Jackie Cooper, and everything in between.
- 1:01:45You'll understand that reference when the episode
- 1:01:47comes out. Absolutely. Do you have anything you
- 1:01:50want to add? No. No? We're recording this the
- 1:01:54day of the Oscars, so it's a little peek behind
- 1:01:57the curtains. What a nice way to end this otherwise
- 1:01:59very difficult episode to talk about. It's such
- 1:02:03a funny peek behind the curtain of we're two
- 1:02:07weeks past the Oscars now, but... in real time
- 1:02:10we're just about to sit down for him yeah and
- 1:02:13honestly it's such a nice high and it's a nice
- 1:02:15thing to mention because i think it's such a
- 1:02:17it's such a nice culmination of all the research
- 1:02:19we've done yeah and work that we've done to kind
- 1:02:22of like get to this point and it is riding that
- 1:02:24high So, very excited about tonight. Love the
- 1:02:28Oscars. Love the Academy Awards. And, you know,
- 1:02:30sometimes they don't always get it right. Yeah.
- 1:02:32It happens. Not talking about the 2026 Oscars.
- 1:02:35Whatever happened there, I'm very proud of it,
- 1:02:37I'm sure. But more so talking about Trader Horn
- 1:02:40and this being nominated. Again, to kind of cap
- 1:02:42it. crazy that like there's one nomination and
- 1:02:46it's like the highest award you can get for seen
- 1:02:49as the highest award you can get for the oscars
- 1:02:50so very strange wild movie wild well wild wild
- 1:02:54year really so crazy year can't wait to like
- 1:02:58break it all down next episode we will and then
- 1:03:01welcome in 1932 really excited for that i'll
- 1:03:03yeah we'll talk about it next episode but that's
- 1:03:06gonna do it for this episode thanks for listening
- 1:03:09I'm your host, Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 1:03:12you at the movies.