Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Natalia Grace Documentary Reaction (Chapter 2)
Transcript
- 0:00Haities or listeners. This is part two of my three part audio episode series
- 0:07in which I am publishing the audio from a bunch of videos that I posted
- 0:12on YouTube about the case of Natalia Grace. I was watching the documentary on
- 0:21Max called The Curious Case of Natalia Grace. So let's get to that now.
- 0:28Maybe early twenty eleven. I can feel attention in the air walking into
- 0:33the house, I see my wife. I'll be I'll try to be as
- 0:41acturate as I can get. One of the guy's point to camera the floor.
- 0:44There's something kind of interesting the way that he talks. I don't know
- 0:47what to say about it. And of course we can't determine someone's personality by
- 0:51the way that they talk, but there's a performative nature to the way that
- 0:56he talks. I've met people like this, and certainly there's nothing wrong with
- 1:00people like this. They can be wonderful people, but there's a certain way
- 1:03that they present things. It's I don't know if I want to say histrionic,
- 1:10and I don't know what that says. It could point to some level
- 1:12of deception. It could point to just the way that he and his family
- 1:19talk about things. You know, you'll see families that tell stories in a
- 1:23certain way. It could be that he is really trying to convince the viewers
- 1:30of things because he's in a tight spot. There's a lot at stake for
- 1:34him. There's the allegations online, there's the allegations legally, there's the ongoing
- 1:40feud between him and his ex wife. And it looks like we're never going
- 1:45to be able to hear from the ex wife, from the mom Christine,
- 1:53I need right here, Rish to get understand. It's hard to have a
- 2:00lot of confidence about the truthfulness the veracity of what he's saying here. There's
- 2:06a lot at stake for him. He is going through an ongoing feud with
- 2:12his ex wife. His ex wife, according to him, has influenced his
- 2:17two sons. He doesn't have contact. He hasn't had contact with two of
- 2:22his children for eight years because of the divorce. So or at least that's
- 2:28the narrative. I guess another option it's because of him. So we just
- 2:31can't really I think he's about to demonstrate some sort of altercation or something.
- 2:38So it's just hard to know. It could all just I mean, if
- 2:42you've been through something like this, you've been close to people as they go
- 2:46through something like this. You know, if you haven't been through something like
- 2:50that, or you don't know anyone who's been through something like that, then
- 2:52you might not know that. When people go through divorces, especially if they're
- 2:57very contentious, they will not only knowingly just lie because they feel justified,
- 3:04but they will invent whole new memories. Whenever I'm watching stuff like this,
- 3:09I'm always waiting and I want to I'm waiting for that moment where I could
- 3:14be like, oh, okay, I suppose if we hear from the sun
- 3:16the oldest son, Jacob, because if he were to provide his account,
- 3:20that's similar to Michael's, and he already has to sun set. But also
- 3:23he's living with the dad, and he could just be concerned about not having
- 3:29the same story as him. The beatings we're similar to this. I mean,
- 3:50just so many things to say. One, Wow, just if that's
- 3:55true, My god, just horrible. If true, that really does change
- 4:06my list of hypotheses at the top of the list. If the mom,
- 4:13I mean, I don't know how much upper body strength the mom has,
- 4:15but Natalia is tiny, and this is an account of when Natalia would have
- 4:24been I think five or six, seven years old, and you have an
- 4:31adult, a grown woman, who is beating repeatedly as hard as she can.
- 4:40You would think that it might even kill Natalia. I mean the way
- 4:43that he's depicting this, you would think that if Christine had done this even
- 4:51once, that you couldn't hide the wounds or I don't know, I don't
- 5:00know. I mean I would have an easier time believing if it wasn't this
- 5:06severe. Not to say that this didn't actually happen, It could have happened.
- 5:13I don't know, though, I mean, what do you think?
- 5:27And then you think what sort of trauma he's exercising right now? Seems more
- 5:33than just him trying to describe something. There seems to be something else going
- 5:39on for him. Now, if any parent or anybody witnessed that, particularly
- 5:45a parent, that's going to be traumatic and you might have some pent up
- 5:50energy around it. We some heard about his childhood, really, so there
- 5:58could be something going on there. But still if this so, I don't
- 6:00know. But if this is true, If this is true, well one
- 6:09again, like I was saying in the last video, I think he's to
- 6:13blame if he didn't contact the authorities in that very second, as soon as
- 6:18he's I mean that's or at least soon after. So it's weird that he
- 6:25would. I don't know. If it's true, then it's true, and
- 6:28maybe he just didn't know what to do. And it's not common that parents
- 6:33will snitch on each other unless they're going through a divorce. I don't know.
- 6:40I just wonder if there's any sort of proof, and it'd be hard
- 6:44to find. I guess the other kids, but that's hard. I mean
- 6:47other kids, it's really hard. There are famous cases, many of them
- 6:53like this, where the kids are the only witness is the only potential witnesses.
- 6:59And that's a rough spot to be in as a child, right,
- 7:02even if you're a child and you're like, yeah, my mom's abusive.
- 7:06I don't live with my mom anymore. I'm not afraid of her, really,
- 7:12but she is my mom, and it's a lot easier for me to
- 7:16say I don't know. I wasn't there. So I can't imagine that we're
- 7:20going to get any sort of corroborating evidence around this unless Christine admitted it herself.
- 7:27I suppose how turn a camera on, turn a recorder on, and
- 7:36I pulm my phone and hide it. I start recording. How could you
- 7:43betray my trust? How could you do that right in front of me?
- 7:47Right now? You erase everything? Yeah? Yes, this, you know,
- 7:51Sky's limit in terms of what actually happened. This could have actually happened,
- 7:57and if so, then my god, my god, and then the
- 8:03other kids probably experienced similar things, least in that direction. But if he's
- 8:09making this up, then my god, I don't know. I just don't
- 8:13know what to think. Reset phone, hit Okay, don't you ever do
- 8:18anything like that again. I never got rid of the phone. I specifically
- 8:26kept it my entire life, just in case someone was ever able to do
- 8:31a data recovery off of it and pull the video back. Okay, So
- 8:39does he have that video? Because if he does, then that'll say something.
- 8:45But if he doesn't, then it all could just be a very clever,
- 8:48elaborate lie. Excerpts from actual social media exchange between Michael and Christine in
- 8:56twenty thirteen. So I'm guessing, seeing the documentarians have access to official records,
- 9:05I got one of you beating the holy freaking hell out of Natalia.
- 9:09So I got a video of you when you tried to beat the truth out
- 9:18of her. I get it. I know you're a good person. Okay,
- 9:22what does that say? Does that say he was complicit or is he
- 9:26just placating her? And that's not like you? But it got out of
- 9:35hand. She deserved it, but still so that doesn't sound like placating.
- 9:41That sounds like at least complicit in that direction. She deserved it. I
- 9:48mean, if you're horrified by your partner beating the freaking hell out of your
- 9:54child and you're trying to extract information I suppose, or you're trying to appease,
- 10:01I don't know if you would say she deserved it that wasn't necessarily necessary,
- 10:07But I don't know. And also I don't trust the documentarians to edit
- 10:11this accurately because sometimes they might take words out, or it might be of
- 10:16a different time. But I don't know. She says whatever, she was
- 10:22very evil and you know it. She's a sociopath. Okay, evil?
- 10:28What's that? Apparently you were told by a clinician that sees a sociopath.
- 10:35I think they meant psychopath. And that doesn't mean that you have the right
- 10:41or the duty to beat the freaking hel out of the child. But I
- 10:45guess what this does demonstrate is evidence that she is agreeing with what he was
- 10:52saying earlier. If we're being presented an actual account here and it wasn't doctored
- 10:58in any way, which we can't know necessarily, then she's admitting to have
- 11:05beaten the freaking hell out of Natalia. And this also seemingly illuminates a dynamic
- 11:13between the two of them, because if she had said, well, you
- 11:16know, you beat her yesterday, and maybe he did, but you would
- 11:18think if something was happening like that, she would bring that up, but
- 11:22she's not. How dare you compare yelling at me to flip out on a
- 11:33criminal in my house impersonating a three year old? Darery you compare? But
- 11:39I think the gist of what she's saying is that it's not wrong to beat
- 11:46a criminal in your house who's impersonating a three year old, So don't criticize
- 11:54me for that. With the music and the precursor to this, this seemingly
- 12:01does implicate her, but it's hard to know because we could be being manipulated.
- 12:07There could be another side of the story, but this certainly doesn't look
- 12:11good for Christine. So this certainly starts. This is potentially corroborating evidence for
- 12:16a lot of the things that Michael has been saying, which is interesting.
- 12:20You know, it's I guess you watch these videos to watch me react,
- 12:26and so this is me reacting in that I you know, my brain is
- 12:31in a mode of like, okay, that's that sounds horrible, But wait,
- 12:35this is just his account. He's going through a divorce. Who knows
- 12:37what's going on here. He also was there and he apparently never called the
- 12:43police during So what does that say? So I don't know what's going on
- 12:48here? And then I see this and although it's hard to know exactly what's
- 12:54being communicated here, it definitely starts. So I guess I'm reacting. I'm
- 13:00sifting through this right now, rewriting a lot of the past in terms of
- 13:03what I've seen. Because a lot of things Michael was saying, particularly about
- 13:07Christine, I'm like, well, it's hard to know. And I guess
- 13:11looking back to what we heard from the employees at that farm or creamery,
- 13:16and they were claiming that Christine was the one who was being violent, that
- 13:24the child was not right, and then when the child, when Natalia was
- 13:28being interviewed, Natalia was saying, well, I fell because I needed different
- 13:37shoes, and then she fell. I don't know because you But then Natalia,
- 13:43well maybe that wasn't a moment where Christine was beating Natalia, and Christine
- 13:48was just being more verbal or something. I don't know. I'm trying to
- 13:52think what else did we hear? I think Jacob. Jacob said that Christine
- 13:56was very fixated about like, tell me the truth. So seeing these texts,
- 14:01this could to me, these texts and I could be being manipulated by
- 14:07the document the documentary or whoever presented these texts to the documentary crew or whatever.
- 14:13But these texts pushed me in a direction pretty significantly to believing the story
- 14:20that Christine is indeed abusive and also hell bent on targeting Natalia. Putting up
- 14:31against the wall for eight hours, Oh my god. Yeah. A lot
- 14:35of the allegations I've been like, well, I don't know, they've been
- 14:37going through a divorce and there's a lot of questionable things here, so I
- 14:41haven't really been absorbing the possibility. It's also kind of fantastical, right,
- 14:48I've been there, and I've seen it, and I've treated and I've heard
- 14:52the stories for sure, as a therapist, we all hear those stories.
- 14:54But but my god, if all that is in the ballpark, my god,
- 15:05my god, wow, awful, awful. And maybe that's why Christine
- 15:13didn't want to be in the documentary, because she knows that there's evidence against
- 15:16her, so she's just avoiding the whole thing. And the two other boys,
- 15:22who I assume are almost adults now, they were like three and six
- 15:31ish in I think eight ish, so fifteen years ago. So yeah,
- 15:37they're adults, so hopefully they're okay now. I don't know if they were
- 15:41ever being abused in the first place. It'd be hard to imagine if Christine
- 15:45was abusive to Natalia that she wasn't abusive at least to some extent. I
- 15:48don't know. My goodness, this is interesting. I could see why people
- 15:52would want me to watch this documentary. I can also see why this is
- 15:54a popular documentary because how often do you get a story like Talia, which
- 16:00is just fascinating in and of itself, and then you get this story about
- 16:04Christine, and then you get the way that Michael talks, the way he
- 16:10describes things. You know that it's quite a combination threatening and poisoning. People
- 16:22and lying to get my husband to sleep in her room, to get my
- 16:27husband to sleep in a room. Is that related to what we saw or
- 16:33what we heard from I mean, they sort of recreated it, a recreation
- 16:40the neighbors were talking about. So one of the neighbors had heard from another
- 16:47neighbor that Natalia had propositioned him in the laundry room. This exchange between Michael
- 16:55and Christine is really an explosive revelation. Michael accuses Christine beating Natalia, and
- 17:00she doesn't deny it. Right, yeah, exactly, yeah, right now
- 17:07I can help and provide as much information about Christine as possible, and I
- 17:15don't know, I launched too many TV shows, I suppose. Now none
- 17:19of this exonerates Michael. There's a possibility that he was just as abusive.
- 17:26But because Christine isn't speaking and maybe she's speaking to lawyers or I don't know,
- 17:32so, you know, it's hard to know what was going on with
- 17:36Michael. But it's also possible that Michael never physically abused anybody. Sometimes it's
- 17:42hard for society to wrap their head around the notion that you could have a
- 17:48woman, a wife, a mother, one be that abusive and two be
- 17:53so abusive that her husband is terrified to tell anybody about it fight of his
- 18:00own wife, even though he might be bigger and stronger. And so my
- 18:04mom denied possibly doing anything wrong, and if anything, she was just operating
- 18:10under the advice of therapists. And I can assure you that no therapist would
- 18:19advise this particular action, which I'm not going to go into detail. Okay,
- 18:26so it looks like he's referring to physical violence, but we don't know
- 18:32that for sure unless he were to say that. But that does lend itself
- 18:38to the credibility of Michael's story, like if therapist did, they would lose
- 18:44their license. Interesting before a number of months ago, six months ago ish,
- 18:51Yeah, I would have totally agreed with Jacob that, of course,
- 18:55no therapist would recommend beating a child if they are out of line. But
- 19:00we saw with the Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt story that that isn't always the
- 19:07case. Is definitely not one hundred percent innocent. So I'm kind of stuck
- 19:11between like a rock and a hard place, where like, I don't hurt
- 19:15anyone, and I recognize that that might not be possible. He could toonerate
- 19:26a little girl and set the record strate. Okay, So what he has
- 19:32been saying, Jacob, he has been saying that he doesn't want to say
- 19:37what he knows happened in the house. I think, particularly regarding Christine's behavior.
- 19:42I think he's been referring to the fact that Christine did in fact beat
- 19:48Natalia, but he hasn't said it directly, so we can't know, and
- 19:53he is he has been saying, look, you know, good people do
- 19:56bad things, bad people do good things, and I'm between a rock and
- 20:00a hard place here. I don't know what to say. And you could
- 20:04absolutely imagine that right from us on the outside and the producer, you don't.
- 20:11We're not in his shoes. And if you've ever been in these shoes,
- 20:15then you know. But if you haven't, then you might not know.
- 20:18We might look at him and say, like, look, you're an
- 20:21adult, now, why would you protect your mom? Why would you not
- 20:25say what actually happened, if in fact that's what he's doing. But when
- 20:29it's your parents, the parents that were good some of the time, it's
- 20:33hard to imagine. But even if Christine did do those things and more,
- 20:38there's a strong possibility that Jacob has a lot of warm, nice memories of
- 20:42his mom. Maybe a majority of memories are nice and warm. Not always,
- 20:48but even if they weren't nice and warm, all the memories are a
- 20:52lot of the memories, it's still your parent, and that's a very complicated
- 20:55relationship. I've worked with many, many clients who have had, from their
- 21:00description, some of the most horrific, abusive parents in the in the world,
- 21:06and yet they still long for love from their parents. They still have
- 21:10an affection for their parents, They still talk to their parents. So who
- 21:15are we to say that people are supposed to turn their back, that they're
- 21:18supposed to come out with the truth just because we want to know the truth.
- 21:23One of my favorite sayings from Martin Luther King Junior, Justice delayed is
- 21:26justice denied? Yeah, I need to sleep on some things. It's the
- 21:33fear that if you tell us what it is, that you know that your
- 21:37mother is going to go to prison. So they're really laying on thick and
- 21:41I don't like this. I think there's a limit to how much pressure you
- 21:47can put on some This isn't just asking someone to tell this random story that
- 21:53they heard about. This is asking a son a young man to base sickly,
- 22:00put his mother in prison and everything that if he were to admit it
- 22:03he would have to deal with in the future, that he would have the
- 22:07fallout in his family and his relationships. You know, maybe even the grandparents
- 22:11are involved in this somehow. He would have to go to trial and go
- 22:18to the witness stand, and you know, there's a lot at stake.
- 22:21It's not just this story that we consume in a documentary on a Sunday night.
- 22:26Yeah, I don't know if I wish told talk about this further.
- 22:33I'm done. Good for him, Yeah, and if he wants to come
- 22:36forward, then you know, he should be allowed to come forward on his
- 22:38own terms. He shouldn't be pressured into it. And good for him for
- 22:44just instead of trying to wiggle out of the question, he just detects that,
- 22:48I think what's happening. He detects that he has a hostile interviewer that's
- 22:53not listening to him and really being judgmental. I mean bringing up Martin Luther
- 23:00King Junior. He's Wow, she had that one in the in the chamber
- 23:07ready to fire at him. That didn't just come off the top of her
- 23:10head. I'm guessing, and instead of dancing around, he's just like,
- 23:15yeah, let's just I'm done. I detect that you're against me, and
- 23:21this is no longer viable. Somebody's hiding something someplace. No no, no,
- 23:37no, non consensual microphone if he if you think that he thinks his
- 23:42microphone is off, then you got to run to him and say, by
- 23:47the way, let's take your microphone. He's not the criminal, or at
- 23:51least I don't think he is. So this is no no. So I
- 24:02told him about my last interaction with my mom. But yeah, I guess
- 24:07the moral thing that I've been struggling with is if there's some like shred of
- 24:11hope that she can be redeemed, I don't think it's worth dragging her character
- 24:15down anymore. Okay, that's not so bad. That's basically what he was
- 24:18saying before. But I think this points in the direction of him speaking off
- 24:22the cuff, so it seems more credible. I don't think he's been lying
- 24:26at all. Really that it doesn't seem to be anything shady about his presentation.
- 24:32I can't know, but I think we might be able to trust these
- 24:34words pretty well. Since he doesn't know he's being recorded, which I'm not
- 24:38happy about. But this isn't this isn't too bad. And he's saying,
- 24:44I think more he's saying a little bit more specifically than what he was saying
- 24:47on the camera that what do you say, I guess the moral thing that
- 24:49I've been struggling with. Okay, I didn't catch that the moral thing?
- 24:53So is that referring to Look? It might be immoral for me to on
- 25:00this information because if there's some like shred of yeah, then if there's some
- 25:03shred of hope that she can be redeemed, yeah, So if you're her
- 25:08son, then you might be concerned about that. You might love her and
- 25:14wish that she can be redeemed, and also you might want her to be
- 25:17redeemed so you can have a good relationship with her. And if you out
- 25:22her, then one you might not ever see her or talk to her again,
- 25:26because she will hate you and it's your mother. And two she might
- 25:33go completely overboard and just give up on redeeming herself. Maybe he knows that
- 25:38she's trying to improve herself, she's trying to recover. He might worry about
- 25:42that hope that she can be redeemed. I don't think it's worth dragging her
- 25:48character down anymore. You didn't hear my conversation, but then yesterday I told
- 25:55the full in okay. So the father Michael is saying, oh, well,
- 26:00I already told them everything, So this is interesting. I don't feel
- 26:07good about this being the documentary, but it will be interesting if there's some
- 26:12explicit agreement from Jacob that he did witness the mother being physically violent with Natalia.
- 26:22That's a nice way of saying I put two rounds and a shotgun and
- 26:26I'm fired. It's okay. I feel like I deserve the right to tell
- 26:30my story. I could not tell them. And then this camera that they're
- 26:37you know, the camera person and maybe the producer behind them. They're trying
- 26:41to film enough to get footage so that they don't have to have just a
- 26:45blank screen, but they don't want to be seen by the people in the
- 26:49documentary because they're worried that they will not talk anymore and reveal things. So
- 26:56that's just that's not okay. And you just think about it. You get
- 27:02called by a documentary crew and they're saying, they're probably saying a lot of
- 27:06really nice things, Oh, we want to tell your story. We just
- 27:08really like you. You're a great personality, and then they just exploit them,
- 27:17especially Jacob. I mean he's a kid. I mean he's an adult
- 27:19now, but he's one of the kids. Not cool. It ruins it
- 27:23for other legit documentarians because I'm going to if anyone ever wants to, you
- 27:30know, say that I know that there's someone else that committed a crime,
- 27:34and I don't have a problem talking about that. But if I suspect or
- 27:41wonder if the documentarians are going to work against me, then I might say
- 27:45no to that is this is not a good precedent to set. And I'll
- 27:49say that I have been kind of in that situation, and that as a
- 27:56psychology expert, I will be interviewed on documentaries and other kinds of productions.
- 28:03You know, they'll have a story and then we'll have that talking head that
- 28:04you know, like that legal expert just sort of pops in and out.
- 28:07And you know, I've been asked to do that, and I have found
- 28:11it to be frankly a waste of time unless I'm passionate about the topic,
- 28:21which would justify the time and the effort and the risk. But a lot
- 28:26of the time they will take what I say, and they'll massage it to
- 28:30say what they want to say, not what I said. Also, you
- 28:34know me, when you ask me a question, there's a lot of caveats,
- 28:38there's a lot of detail how you hammer, and documentarians do not want
- 28:45that. They want that SoundBite right. So I don't appreciate that. Also,
- 28:52the filming can take forever and they'll use like literally ten seconds. There
- 29:00was this one time, maybe the last time I agreed to do something like
- 29:04this was during the pandemic for a Tiger King documentary on Discovery. I might
- 29:10even be on HBO Max now, I guess it would be right Discovery ID
- 29:14or something. They were interviewing me about the Tiger King and I told them,
- 29:18look, you probably don't want to interview me because I'm not going to
- 29:22diagnose Tiger King guy, and I'm probably just going to give a lot of
- 29:26detail about psychology and assessment and ethics. I don't think you want me.
- 29:33And we went back and forth. I was, you know, really trying
- 29:36to let them know what my shtick is, you know, and they were
- 29:41like, no, no, we still want you, you know, we
- 29:42want that sort of thing. I'm like, why do you want that?
- 29:45That's not typically what documentarians put in a documentary. It's like, okay,
- 29:49and since it was the pandemic, no one wanted to get infected, right,
- 29:55So they sent me all of the equipment, the lights and the cameras
- 30:00and the sound equipment and all, you know, just all this gear.
- 30:06And I know how to use that stuff, so it wasn't too hard for
- 30:10me. But it meant that I had to set everything up. It took
- 30:15hours and hours to I mean one just came in the mail, and these
- 30:18you know, because these cameras are like these pro cameras have these very expensive,
- 30:26gigantic cases and stuff. And I set everything up and in order to
- 30:29be interviewed, you know, normally there's someone asking me a question that's off
- 30:33camera. Well, I had to set up like a zoom meeting as if
- 30:36they were there, but they weren't there. And then I spent all the
- 30:41time. I probably spent hours in the interview. And then I had to
- 30:45break everything down. I had to ship everything back. I did get one
- 30:48thing out of it, though, I got a selfie stick. When I
- 30:52make cameos, there's this little cell phone stand, you know, because I
- 30:56was on a Zoom call on a cell phone video call. They sent this
- 31:03cell phone stand so I could watch it. I was like, how do
- 31:07I send the cell phone stand back to you because that didn't have like a
- 31:10case, and they said, I just keep it. It's like a seven
- 31:12dollars self a stamp. But whatever, idio cameo, I use that cell
- 31:15phone stand, you know, and then you watch the documentary and I'm in
- 31:18it like probably a total of twenty one seconds or something, now, you
- 31:25know whatever. But because you know, I don't know. In the old
- 31:27days, I thought of documentarians as like journalists, right, like trying to
- 31:32discover the truth. They have ethics and morals. And this is not that
- 31:37I didn't tell them about kicking the stairs, well, kicking down the stairs.
- 31:40We said we're not going to say right. My plan we're going in
- 31:44today was okay, let's rewind this. So Michael's saying, look, I
- 31:48told them about kicking down the stairs. Did we see that footage? I
- 31:51don't think we saw that. And then Jacob says, I thought we agreed
- 31:55we weren't going to talk about that. My plan going into let's ruin that
- 32:00I didn't tell them about kitting with stairs, well, kicking down the stairs,
- 32:04So he starts off. Michael starts off by saying, I didn't call.
- 32:06I didn't tell them that. What's that? Uh? And then and
- 32:10then what's the stairs? I did not tell them that. I didn't tell
- 32:15them about kitting with stairs. I didn't tell them about kicking down the stairs.
- 32:21Kicking down the stairs if we heard there's a lot of details here.
- 32:25I don't remember hearing anything about kicking down the stairs. And Jacob says,
- 32:29well, kicking down the stairs, we said we weren't gonna say that right,
- 32:32kicking down the stairs, we said we're not going to say right.
- 32:37My plan going in today was to not tell them that. And furthermore,
- 32:40I understand there to be legal rehorse or that, and you know, I'm
- 32:45not really looking forward to like being subpoened. Right. He's thinking what I
- 32:50was thinking might be thinking, which is, Look, this isn't just an
- 32:52interview. This is atomic bomb that would go off in my life, in
- 32:57my in our family. This you you, if you're Jacob, you're just
- 33:01like, look Dad, you don't care because you hate mom. But I
- 33:07still have a relationship with her, or at least I want one, So
- 33:10I don't want that relationship to blow up. Oh, okay, a child,
- 33:17and so I don't know. Maybe that's true, but that doesn't sound
- 33:23likely. He's an adult now, so there's that. Plus, children can
- 33:30be witnesses when it comes to abuse. So Michael's either making stuff up knowingly
- 33:37or or he's right. I don't know. But then Jacob says, oh
- 33:42shit, I still have my microphone on. I'm such an idiot. I'm
- 33:46such an idiot. Okay, So yeah, I mean, he didn't say
- 33:57anything that he basically wasn't saying in the interviews. I mean, he was
- 34:00basically saying in the interviews, the consensual interview, that yes, his mom
- 34:07has issues, but he doesn't want to say. And by saying I don't
- 34:13want to say, you're kind of saying it, right, because he's already
- 34:16said things about his mom. So the thing he's not saying, presumably is
- 34:21worse than the things he's already said. So, but it's not saying it.
- 34:24And in that stolen clandestine recording, you know there are laws against that,
- 34:30right, there are laws against recording people without their consent. They know
- 34:36that he doesn't know he's being recorded and they're recording it. That doesn't I
- 34:39don't, I don't like that. I do not like that. Now there's
- 34:43the famous one with Durst. What was his name, Yeah, Robert Durst.
- 34:49The Jinx was the documentary, and from my memory, Robert Durst was
- 34:55implicated, implicated in a murder, but because of his riches and his lawyers
- 35:00or something. I could be getting this wrong, he wasn't convicted. And
- 35:07the documentarians were interviewing him and they concluded an interview and he stood up and
- 35:15walked out. I think they really confronted him on something and he just wheeled
- 35:20out of it. And then he goes to the bathroom and he still has
- 35:22a lapelm icon and he says something under his breath. He whispers something something
- 35:28like I did it or yes, I did kill that person. And it
- 35:31was shocking, obviously. Now at first when I saw that scene, and
- 35:37it's got to be out there somewhere, it's like it looks like it's on
- 35:40YouTube, or at least the ending is that it looks like, oh my
- 35:45god, he just admitted it. So done deal. But there's a lot
- 35:49of reasons why someone would mutter something to themselves. And I'm not making excuses.
- 35:53I think there was a lot of circumstantial evidence pointing in his direction,
- 35:59and I don't even know if it's murder. I think it was anyway,
- 36:00but it's not a slam dunk, you know, someone muttering. Now if
- 36:05he had muttered a lot of stuff. You know, he's like, Okay,
- 36:07yesterday I lied, but I really did it, you know, he
- 36:10kind of mutters a phrase anyway. The point is is that in that one,
- 36:15I'm just very skeptical. Can you tell? I'm just like eh.
- 36:21So that's what being a scientist does too, is that when you actually study
- 36:28science, you study data, you study research, you study how people interpret
- 36:31research. Even researchers scientists will jump to conclusions. And it's one of the
- 36:37pitfalls of science is jumping to conclusions or wording things too confidently or too strongly.
- 36:45You know, I hope you hear in my language, I'll say,
- 36:46well, the data suggests that the data suggests that when this happens, it's
- 36:52associated with this, and even that word associated with it doesn't mean that they
- 36:55always coincide or that it's causal. Correlation doesn't equal causation. So there's just
- 37:02a lot of things about life and nature that it's hard to determine. And
- 37:07so I'm just very very skeptical a lot of things. I'm guessing no lawyer
- 37:14would want me on their jury unless it was the defense. I suppose I
- 37:19was on a jury for a drunk driving charge. It was an accident.
- 37:24No one was hurt, but it was a very interesting trial. And me
- 37:31I and the rest of the jury very very quickly as soon as the trial
- 37:37was over, deliberated for five minutes and said yep, guilty because the defendants
- 37:45were There were three defendants and they had I'll just tell you the story.
- 37:50So the three guys they go to Hooters in Seattle, and they had drinks
- 37:57and they got on the VIADUCTLI was Seattle, the old ninety nine Viaduct downtown,
- 38:02and they were going south and something happened. They were sitting, you
- 38:07know, three abreast in a truck, in a little truck, and I
- 38:10don't know how or why, but because of drunkenness or something, he the
- 38:15guy driving, had smashed his car into the you know, the barrier and
- 38:21then went and had shot across and somehow missed all the traffic because there's usually
- 38:25a lot of traffic. And then they pulled off on First Avenue. Police
- 38:30had seen or a parking a tenant parking meter person seen him, and then
- 38:35the police show up because their car was undrivable, otherwise I think they would
- 38:39have driven off. And then the police investigated and determined who the driver was
- 38:45because the three guys, it's hard to you know, they were outside the
- 38:47truck. And then the police officers determined who the driver was and then did
- 38:52a breathalyzer and determined that that person was above the limit and then had charged
- 38:58the person. But then the three guys were I think kind of rich or
- 39:02something and had really good lawyers who figured out a way to get out of
- 39:07it. And what they said was the person that was identified as a driver
- 39:13was not the driver. The real driver was another guy, but you didn't
- 39:15do a breathalyzer on him, so you can't know if he was drunk driving.
- 39:20So case closed. They're innocent. But so the whole defense came down
- 39:27to the story that the three fellas were saying, and each of the fellas
- 39:34were saying a different story, and one of the guys seemed to be quite
- 39:38tortured as he was trying to defend seemingly his friend's So the fact that the
- 39:45three of the guys didn't even and this was months later. They hadn't coordinated
- 39:51their story and so it was not hard to convict. And also the guys
- 39:58they just had a certain you know. So it was the Roxbury What's that?
- 40:05That skit on SNL and that movie with Will Ferrell and the other guy,
- 40:10you know, the What Is Love? They were those kind of guys
- 40:16and you know, God bless but uh, you know, not the sort
- 40:21of guys that I'm cheering for. And they had these really like I always
- 40:28think of coloring bad if you're familiar with the eighties, So I think he
- 40:31had this. It's like this. It's you know, like when you go
- 40:36to a golf course, the grass is beautiful, but the greens you know
- 40:40where the where the hole is, where you put that grass is pristine.
- 40:46It's it's unnatural how they can get this natural grass to just be perfectly shaven
- 40:53if you wealthy, you know. And these guys had just these perfect roomed
- 41:00pencil beard things and they all had the same one. I think on purpose,
- 41:07because the idea was that they were easily mixed up visually. I don't
- 41:13know, see color me bad? That guy that guy? Do you do
- 41:17you hear a song? I just I just thought of those the three guys
- 41:22looked like him. He's abusive. I couldn't stand up to that woman.
- 41:45So if it is credible, and if he is legitimately a victim, then
- 41:54there's a possibility that he hasn't had treatment for this and hasn't been given sufficient
- 42:02space to express or talk about or explore what had happened to him. So
- 42:09in the interview, if this is the first time he's really getting into it,
- 42:15then there's going to be some emotionality. I guess the question is do
- 42:19we think that this is a legit emotional expression. He's a little bit of
- 42:22an odd duck the way he expresses himself. But if we look past that,
- 42:28yeah, this is what would happen if you were to recall a story,
- 42:32even if you had been through some therapy. But I'm guessing he hasn't.
- 42:36I couldn't stand up to that woman. I could today, I could
- 42:45now with distance in space and clarity, I could now. I couldn't.
- 42:52I just couldn't. Still something kind of odd the way he talks. I
- 42:59don't know, it seems like it's a little exaggerated. You know. If
- 43:04I was to take a guess, I would say that the tears and the
- 43:07emotion is legit and that he isn't lying. And yet when he talks,
- 43:14I think he feels like he has to amp it up a little bit to
- 43:17be more convincing or something. That's the way it feels to me. What
- 43:22does it feel like to you. It's also possible that he's tamping it down
- 43:27because he's trying to hold together. I mean, if if we're using it
- 43:30as a jumping off point and when people go through these kinds of traumas and
- 43:32they talk about him, yeah, it's it's rough. Now. Some people
- 43:37will avoid the feelings and distance themselves from the details and just talk about it
- 43:42intellectually. You know that can happen too, But if people are feeling the
- 43:46feelings, then yeah, it's it's it's going to be it's gonna be tough.
- 43:50And you just imagine what it would be like to be him if he
- 43:53is a legit victim being interviewed and going over all the stories or an organ
- 44:00over and over again, you know, because we see how many hours of
- 44:02him being interviewed, but you know they typically will interview for for every hour,
- 44:07you're probably being interviewed in another ten hours or at least in the process
- 44:10of making the documentary. So just imagine, you know, it really start
- 44:15to take a toll and you would start to see evidence of that toll.
- 44:19What else well he is talking about? Oh no, that's that's just all
- 44:22I wanted to talk about. But now I feel like a moron because I
- 44:25have my microphone on. First off, even if they couldn't ask you,
- 44:29but I can't. I luck, howe, we'll talk about it. Gone.
- 44:35Secondly, you are non beetle true. Yeah, okay, so we're
- 44:39hearing more of the clandestine recording. He knows he's being recorded. Now Michael
- 44:46knows he's potentially being recorded. Now let's rewind us what else is talking about?
- 44:52Oh no, that's that's just all I wanted to talk about. But
- 44:54now I feel like a moron because I have my microphone on. First off,
- 44:59even they go and ask you. But so this makes Michael look good
- 45:07in that he is telling his son. Look, just straw a boundary.
- 45:12You don't have to say anything, because if Michael is lying or exaggerating,
- 45:17and he's the sort of person that would do that, then that would be
- 45:21in the direction of someone that would try to manipulate your adult son to disclose
- 45:27information along the lines that would corroborate and bolster your your case, particularly because
- 45:34I think Michael is being charged with things right. I don't know if he's
- 45:37being charged at this point, but but you know, who knows. He
- 45:39could just be doing this for the microphone. The little boys, they can't
- 45:43You're no danger whatsoever. So then he thinks that if he talks quietly,
- 45:51they can't hear him. There's there's a there's a volume. There's a game
- 45:57you can you can get in. There were you the Quinn by Christina and
- 46:00Mike. Okay, tell me about that they didn't like really like whoop me
- 46:06or none like that? Okay? Did anyone ever put their hands on you?
- 46:08Okay? So now we hear from Natalia that she was never whooped?
- 46:15And what does that say? And is Natalia lying? Is Michael lying?
- 46:22Is Jacob lying? I don't know that means like physically did anyone physically harm
- 46:28you? No? But I know they did? Well? Actually did I
- 46:31say they initially? Natalia? So then she says, wait, did I
- 46:37say? Now It's possible that Natalia her memory is spotty because of not only
- 46:45the abuse she went through, if she did in fact go through abuse,
- 46:49but also if she went through abuse or very difficult situations prior to even coming
- 46:55to the United States, then it will create dissociative tendencies that can cause people
- 47:02to dissociate in moments of terror that will make it more difficult to recall the
- 47:08memories. It doesn't make it impossible, but when people develop what we might
- 47:13call pathological lying or compulsive lying, it's also possible that she's used to lying.
- 47:17When people develop what we might call pathological lying or compulsive lying, they
- 47:22will lie when they don't want to lie, because it's better if you want
- 47:28to be believed, if you want to be if you want your lies to
- 47:30be believed, the faster and more convincingly you lie, the more believable it
- 47:35is. Right If someone asks you were you there last night and you say
- 47:42no, then people don't believe you, right, But if you say were
- 47:45you there last night, no, I wasn't there, then it's much more
- 47:49believable. So it creates this habit for people. Often because they're being abused
- 47:55and they have to lie that they will bid to fault lie, particularly when
- 48:01it's a tension question that's weird, but especially when the question has a lot
- 48:09of weight to it, like did your parents beat you? And they'll just
- 48:14be this automatic, without any thought, just lie. And some of you
- 48:16have even said of the comment section that you have this condition. And it
- 48:22might not be all the time, but you'll notice that sometimes someone will ask
- 48:27you, like what time is it, and you'll lie, and you'll think,
- 48:30why did I just lie? It's often it's because of this adaptation that
- 48:34you needed to develop when you were younger in order to avoid being abused or
- 48:39harmed or terrified or something. And so it's possible that through that pathological lying
- 48:45mechanism, she just lied. In her interview with the forensic interviewer with the
- 48:50Prosecutor's office, she's made a lot of conflicting statements, and they are memorialized
- 48:54in police reports. They will be like, you know, like sometimes a
- 48:59parents they whoop you with the belt. They did whoop me. She literally
- 49:02let the boys whoop me. She let the three boys. What is so
- 49:08hard to believe her? Right? But we can if we're acting like we're
- 49:14a jury. I suppose that's kind of how I'm That's why it feels to
- 49:17me. It feels like I don't know, if I've watched something that made
- 49:22me feel so much like a jury member. But so if she had said
- 49:27just a general statement, yeah, I know they would beat me with a
- 49:29belt, but we hear this language going towards the mom and then this detail
- 49:34of yeah, she would let the boys beat me, which isn't uncommon.
- 49:39We've seen that on some of these abusive family vloggers on YouTube. The Family
- 49:47O five I think it was called. There was documentation of this. Yeah,
- 49:52it's it's horrific, right, It's horrific to abuse your child. It's
- 49:58even more horrific to abuse your other children. To abuse your child, because
- 50:02you know, the children that are coerced or influenced to abuse one of their
- 50:08siblings, they don't come out of that unscathed. Jacob, you just dropped
- 50:13me. When you say he just dropped you, what does that mean?
- 50:16Like he just dropped you, so do you like pick you up? It's
- 50:22also hard hard to know the circumstances. It's possible that she was the initiator
- 50:28of the altercation and then Jacob responded or something. But it's also possible,
- 50:36I guess I hadn't thought about this directly anyway, that Jacob might be hesitant
- 50:40to get into it because he knows that he did things. Now, he
- 50:45could absolutely make a case that he was a victim too and was only doing
- 50:52things to her and maybe the other boys because the mom was influencing and or
- 50:58coercing him to doing it. When the three boys were whooping you, who
- 51:01is in the room, Christine, She was sitting her at a moment.
- 51:06First she woke to me. And then, of course we understand that as
- 51:09a child, if you witness your mother beating other people, then you often
- 51:15will have that model to you and will mimic that behavior. It's told to
- 51:22you and taught to you very viscerally, that when you're frustrated and you can
- 51:28overpower someone, then that's what you do. Then she had the boys,
- 51:31and then Michael walked, and then Michael walked you. And then we hear
- 51:38that Michael would also beat her, which seems likely to me. So there's
- 51:45a number of possibilities. One is that I think what Michael is saying is
- 51:49I tried to do something about it, but I was terrified, and he
- 51:53used language of a victim. He could have adopted it. He could have
- 51:58you know, he could be faking it, but that is the language of
- 52:00a legit victim that will say I didn't feel strong enough to do anything against
- 52:06the abuser. Today I would, but back then I couldn't because get broken
- 52:13down over time. So also, when you're in a marriage and you're trying
- 52:16to make it work, there's a lot of reasons to not say something,
- 52:22to not call the police, right, to try to influence from within.
- 52:25It's like, well, if I really want to affect change, I need
- 52:29to get her on my side. So I can't you know the way that
- 52:31Jacob basically seemingly was saying, Right, if I'm really gonna help my mom,
- 52:37I can't tell the truth. And that's really the conundrum of the victim,
- 52:40right, And that's what abusers want you to think, right, They
- 52:45want you to be in that position. Right. So it's possible that Michael
- 52:51was terrified and didn't contact the authorities or anybody. I mean, that is
- 52:55common, by the way, And he didn't be her at all, didn't
- 53:00beat Natalia at all, and Natalia is just lying or misremembering or something.
- 53:06You know, she's pretty young at the time. She's a lot older now.
- 53:08So that's one possibility. The other possibility is that he did absolutely participate
- 53:15in the abuse, and that Natalia is telling the truth right now, it
- 53:20kind of sounds like truth because the story that she's telling has a lot of
- 53:25details, is pretty quickly told to the evaluator, and I don't know,
- 53:34it doesn't unless she has had this lie frequently. But it doesn't seem exaggeratory.
- 53:39So there's that. Because the reason I guess, Okay, this is
- 53:45what I want to say is that it's it's very likely. It's very believable.
- 53:49I'll say, I don't know the likely, but it's very believable that
- 53:52Michael would also physically harm Natalia, maybe not as much, maybe as much,
- 53:59but it's not hard to imagine. Although I don't know when I say
- 54:02that out loud, is that just throwing victims under the bus, because what
- 54:07am I basing that on. I don't know. We'll wait from and of
- 54:10course we're not hearing from Christine, and I'm guessing that Christine, whether it's
- 54:15true or not, would also say so. We would have to hear from
- 54:17the kids, which is hard to depend on them, you know, like
- 54:22with Jacob, he seems to be against Christine and not against Michael. But
- 54:30the other kids, if you talk to them, they probably would be the
- 54:34opposite, and both of them saw everything that happened, or a lot of
- 54:37things that happened, right, So what does that say? Well, what
- 54:40that says is that us humans are influenceable, and our conscious minds are influenceable,
- 54:47and our fears will dictate the kinds of things will allow ourselves to say
- 54:52or even believe, or know or remember. So it's hard to know.
- 54:59It's just one of those things. They haven't revealed if the cell phone is
- 55:02going to work or not regarding a file, I have a feeling it won't.
- 55:07But if it does, but all that would do would help us to
- 55:13know that Christine was abusive. It wouldn't tell us if Michael was or was
- 55:15not abusive. One of Natalia's problematic behaviors was that she would frequently soil urinate
- 55:24in places where she shouldn't. So we heard earlier allegations from Michael. I
- 55:30believe that Natalia would purposely urinate on her brothers and smear her own feces on
- 55:38her brothers in the car. So we're also hearing that she would have trouble
- 55:44controlling herself, which is also very very normal for kids who have been through
- 55:49those experiences, you know, potty training. If you've helped a child to
- 55:53go to the bathroom in the toilet, it's a thing, you know,
- 55:57it takes a while. It's not something that kids just automatically do right.
- 56:02Other things you don't necessarily have to teach them, right, like you don't
- 56:06have to teach children how to use nouns and verbs and adjectives. They just
- 56:10learn by watching. But with potty training, you know, there's a lot
- 56:15of details to it. I can kind of remember being pottied. I do
- 56:20remember being potty trained by my dad. Actually, I'm pretty sure both my
- 56:23parents participated, but I remember my dad in particularly me and my siblings.
- 56:28My three siblings have a joke in our family that with most of us,
- 56:31if not all of us, we distinctly remember my dad telling us that we
- 56:36should only use two squares of toilet paper, which is absurd. Now,
- 56:42when you're very small, you have small amounts of things to wipe up,
- 56:46and so you don't need that much. And my dad was concerned with us
- 56:52kids just going zing on the toilet paper, you know, using way too
- 56:57much and clogging the pipes or whatever. So no, I don't know if
- 57:00he was saying us two and he knew that that meant that we would use
- 57:05four or five, but all of us still will ras my dad for he'll
- 57:14come out of the bathroom and be like two squares dad, you know that
- 57:15kind of thing, and you know he likes to do that kind of thing.
- 57:19So my dad takes it well, but I remember it. Do you
- 57:22remember it? Anyway? It's a thing. So the point is is that
- 57:28for a child that is completely abandoned left alone also very consistently parented. We
- 57:34heard from the aunt that she was with the bio mom, then another family,
- 57:38then another family than the orphanage. And we also know that potty training
- 57:44takes some time and if one family was working on that for a bit,
- 57:50but the next family would have to pick up where the old family had left
- 57:52off, and maybe that wasn't coordinated. Also, it's not unusual for neglected
- 57:59kids with neglectful parents or caregivers just to leave kids in diapers because it's just
- 58:04it's easier in the short term, you know, because you have to actually
- 58:07pay attention to a kid to potty train them. So that's that angle.
- 58:10But even kids that are potty trained, they can still have issues with control
- 58:17because it's a common expression of trauma. It's hard to know this, but
- 58:22it could be an adaptation that we evolved to signal to others that we're not
- 58:30doing okay. You know. It's similar to crying. Actually, there's not
- 58:34a lot of ways that we can determine why we evolved to shoot water out
- 58:39of our eyes when we're sad or happy, or nostalgic or you know,
- 58:45there's a lot of different emotions that produce that prideful when we you know,
- 58:50when our kids do great on the soccer field, we might cry out of
- 58:54joy. So it's hard for us to figure out why we do that.
- 59:00A lot of people online and some scientists will say, well, we're trying
- 59:02to get rid of certain neurochemicals. And I can't say that that's inherently wrong,
- 59:07but that doesn't make a lot of sense to me. It's not coherent
- 59:12with the way that it's the way that tears work in our species. The
- 59:16way that tears work on our species is that it's not just tears too.
- 59:20It's like it's not and potentially convulsion like this, you know, and the
- 59:24wailing. It's a it's an expression just like laughing. You know, Why
- 59:29do we have an uncontrollable, like haha, because we one are telling other
- 59:35people how we are feeling, right, and there's facial expressions, you know,
- 59:38there's like hundreds, I don't know how many muscles are involved, and
- 59:42our facial expressions and our vocalizations. You know, it's a lot of wasted
- 59:45effort to do something just to get rid of a neurochemical. You know,
- 59:50it is a lot of effort to specifically signal to everyone around us how we're
- 59:54feeling. And because we're extremely social and very dependent on each other and no
- 1:00:00knowing what other people are thinking. Because in order to survive in a group
- 1:00:05a tribe, you have to gain their acceptance, because if you don't have
- 1:00:07their acceptance, then you're left to the wolves, literally and you will die.
- 1:00:10So there's a lot of attention, and our species is very good at
- 1:00:15communicating what's going on in our hearts and on our minds, and so we
- 1:00:21cry to signal how we feel. Well, it's possible, it's kind of
- 1:00:24a leap that we have other ways of excreting things to signal that we're not
- 1:00:31doing okay right, and we might have benefited by having that mechanism to alert
- 1:00:38caregivers or kin to come to the young child and figure out what's going on.
- 1:00:45Is the child scared, are they hungry, are they suffering, are
- 1:00:49they lonely or something? And once that has been corrected for, the incontinence
- 1:00:54goes away. An additional hypothesis as to why kids will do this after being
- 1:01:00traumatized is that due to PTSD developing complex PTSD developing, the child is at
- 1:01:07baseline anxious. So if we have anxiety from zero to ten, and for
- 1:01:14most people, if everything is going okay in their life, they're a zero
- 1:01:17or one. For people who have been chronically terrorized, and abandonment can result
- 1:01:23in that chronic terror. But it's highly likely that she was also physically and
- 1:01:30or sexually abused in addition to being abandoned before she came to the States and
- 1:01:35after maybe, but when children go through those kinds of things for the rest
- 1:01:39of their life. You can have people that at baseline are a five and
- 1:01:44they won't look like they're you know, if I'm at a five, you'll
- 1:01:46probably know, But for someone that's always at a five, you won't necessarily
- 1:01:52know because they have learned to just act like everything's fine. Plus they might
- 1:01:58think everything is fine because they're the least anxious they've ever been. It's one
- 1:02:02of the tragedies of there's many tragedies, but it's one of the tragedies of
- 1:02:06early childhood abuse that it's the gift that keeps on gifting, giving for the
- 1:02:09rest of you know, you'll have people that are sixty years old and have
- 1:02:13never been below a five. Now, with treatment, there's optimism in terms
- 1:02:16of a prognosis. For sure, it can take time, but they're not
- 1:02:21doomed. But a lot of people don't get treatment or not effective treatment or
- 1:02:23something but anyway, or they don't have access to treatment. So another hypothesis
- 1:02:30is that when we are anxious, we adapt it and we see this in
- 1:02:36other animals too, to get rid of dead weight so we can run right,
- 1:02:39And so that's another possibility. Another hypothesis is that when we're terrified or
- 1:02:46threatened, you know, because when you have PTSD, complex PTSD and other
- 1:02:50kinds of conditions related to trauma, you are more likely to consider things that
- 1:02:55aren't dangerous to be dangerous, right, And so you have a child that
- 1:02:59is in a non dangerous situation, but there's something threatening and their body thinks
- 1:03:04of it as a massive threat, and the child might regress to an earlier
- 1:03:08phase that was before they were potty trained, and then that results in that
- 1:03:13behavior. There are other hypotheses as well, but I just thought i'd throw
- 1:03:17it out out there. So he's saying that she did have problems, which,
- 1:03:22again, like I said, I would just assume that has to do
- 1:03:24with the trauma. Unfortunate. It's just a really this whole thing is just
- 1:03:30one big heartbreak to me, honestly, this whole, this whole thing is
- 1:03:34one big heartbreak, such as for example, on blanket or on furniture such
- 1:03:38as a couch or a bed. And I think he's building up to why
- 1:03:44his mom would go after her mother was trying to do to address the situation
- 1:03:50wasn't working on. Solution my mom came up with was for me to urinate
- 1:03:54in Natalia's bed, all right, gag. So that's shocking and awful and
- 1:04:04horrible. But parents who do this, they don't just stop there, right
- 1:04:11a parent, just think of what you would have to go through as a
- 1:04:14parent to even just come up with that idea, just let alone just having
- 1:04:19that brainstorm in your mind. And then even if you did, you think
- 1:04:25the vast majority of parents, even many abusive parents. Well that's ridiculous.
- 1:04:29What no, But for a parent to then say, yes, I'm going
- 1:04:33to do this, I'm going to implement the plan. Wow, I'm going
- 1:04:39to ask my other child to do it. I'm going to rope in,
- 1:04:45I'm going to make another child do this. It's also out there in the
- 1:04:50family that you're doing it, right, So that says a lot that he
- 1:04:56is saying that to me. That is uh, that's that. Actually,
- 1:05:01that says way more than even what that is, because this is the first
- 1:05:06time that he has affirmed that she is abusive, because he's been alluding to
- 1:05:15it. You know, Michael has given a lot of descriptions, but beyond
- 1:05:17that, it's that's that's all that we have. We had Natalia saying that
- 1:05:24the mom was abusive and Michael and her brothers, but we can't really know.
- 1:05:29It looked like a moment of honesty for Natalia, but that's hard to
- 1:05:35bank on. Jacob though, he does, I think have potential coercion happening
- 1:05:42around him by father. It's you know, it could be happening, or
- 1:05:45at least he's trying to please his dad or something. But the specificity you
- 1:05:49know, you think if he was just trying to please his dad, he
- 1:05:51just say Blank's yeah, you know, mom was abusive. I don't want
- 1:05:54to get to it, but to give this specific story. And I think
- 1:05:57the reason why he's telling a story is that he thinks this isn't as bad
- 1:06:00as the actual stories that he doesn't want to get into. It's also traumatic
- 1:06:05for him for Jacob, right, these are not pleasant memories for him.
- 1:06:11And that's another tragedy of these sorts of situations is that you'll have kids that
- 1:06:15are roped into the abuse and they walk away feeling like they're a monster,
- 1:06:21right, that they're part of the problem when they were children and they were
- 1:06:29being told to do something and they were being modeled to behavior. We often
- 1:06:34talk about victimization of abuse regarding the person who was being attacked, but we
- 1:06:42don't often talk about and some of you might know situations like this. Some
- 1:06:45of you might have been in situations like this where you were made or coerced
- 1:06:51as a child to be a secondary abuser. And the shame of that because
- 1:06:59victims often blame themselves anyway, if not universally, But if you actually did
- 1:07:03it and you tell people about it, they're likely to say, how come
- 1:07:10you did that? How come you didn't say no? Right? But of
- 1:07:12course those people don't understand how reality works. I don't blame them because we
- 1:07:16don't talk about it very much and it's complicated. But so yeah, Jesus,
- 1:07:21wow, wow, she had pink blankets. The vivid part is just
- 1:07:26like basically the action. I remember feeling anger while I was doing it,
- 1:07:31like like experiencing a thought like, oh, this will this will show her.
- 1:07:38Do we need more on this topic or are we good? Or I
- 1:07:43talked a while back about the trauma effects of recalling these memories, particularly speaking
- 1:07:50them out loud to people in detail, and how it can be re traumatizing
- 1:07:56or the very least create a lot of emotion that can be difficult. And
- 1:08:00I don't know if he's been through treatment about this. I'm guessing he hasn't.
- 1:08:04They haven't been alluding to any of that sort of treatment, So for
- 1:08:11him, this could be really rough for all that traumatized individuals, and really
- 1:08:15maybe everyone might be traumatized, even the mom who knows they as they tell
- 1:08:21these stories so very briefly. When someone comes into my office, say first
- 1:08:28session, and I asked them whether they want to talk about and they say,
- 1:08:30I want to talk about my childhood trauma, or even if it's the
- 1:08:32fiftieth session, but I haven't heard anything about it before, and I don't
- 1:08:38know their emotional regulation abilities and the extent of their trauma reactivity. What I
- 1:08:45will say to them is, Okay, I want to hear this story and
- 1:08:48I want you to talk about that for sure. That's partly why I became
- 1:08:53a therapist was to be there for people as they tell me their stories of
- 1:08:57trauma that they've perhaps never told anybody before. And I've had a number of
- 1:09:00clients trust me and honor me with that role in their life, and I
- 1:09:08want to be there for you. However, if you just head into telling
- 1:09:13that story and you have a trauma condition that is triggered in that moment or
- 1:09:18after the session, overall, you could be harmed by that disclosure by telling
- 1:09:24me that story. And so there are a number of things we have to
- 1:09:26do to make sure that we can monitor your distress level as you tell me
- 1:09:30the story, and you have ways to regulate that distress whether you're in session
- 1:09:35or out of session, So we just have to be careful. So how
- 1:09:41do you feel about that then we But for the documentarians, I don't know
- 1:09:45if they care about that. So there's a possibility that Jacob is actually causing
- 1:09:51himself a lot of psychological and physical symptoms now and in the future because he
- 1:09:57is now talking about things he might not have ever talked about. She shouldn't
- 1:10:00give me instructions, man, like she shouldn't like, oh, let's aim
- 1:10:06that way, like I was never How were you feeling about it now?
- 1:10:15So this will be interesting. But I also wonder if he's telling this story
- 1:10:18because he wonders if, well, I should say something. I don't know
- 1:10:24exactly. Maybe it's the moral dilemma he was referring to earlier. But he
- 1:10:28surmises that if he tells this story this, this more implicates him. He
- 1:10:31thinks it doesn't implicate him at all at all. It implicates the mom.
- 1:10:38So he might think, well, I'm telling a story, but it's more
- 1:10:42about me, And if my mom gets angry at me, I will say
- 1:10:45I was throwing myself out of the bus, because you know, he's sure
- 1:10:47to say she didn't tell me where to aim, she didn't tell me which
- 1:10:53I did those things, But no one in their right mind would say that
- 1:11:00was him doing it, that was his fault. That's the mom I had
- 1:11:05performed this action of urinating in Italia's bed. And Yeah, to this day,
- 1:11:13I feel horrible that I actually did that. It's one of those things
- 1:11:17that keeps me up at night. Yeah, I don't doubt that that.
- 1:11:21I don't think it's just an expression that he says for emphasis. I think
- 1:11:26it might literally keep them up at night. That's what I was talking about
- 1:11:29earlier, about the children or others who get roped in to the abuse,
- 1:11:35perpetration against their will, so to speak. You know, they're highly influenced.
- 1:11:41It's a similar trauma for cult members. You know, you have a
- 1:11:46high control organization and you might have a few people the top, maybe one
- 1:11:53person at the top, and then they brainwash people, and those people are
- 1:11:59brain washed to maybe harm others, you know, like with Keith Ranieri in
- 1:12:01the Nexium cult. I don't know this specifically, but I'm guessing that there
- 1:12:09were lieutenants to him. I know there was one in particular, but they
- 1:12:14were all told to do things and then eventually they just do it on their
- 1:12:19own right. Eventually, you're so brainwashed you don't need to be told you
- 1:12:23just you just do the plan because you've been brainwashed and scared into adopting someone
- 1:12:29else's mind, and then you walk away from the cult. And well,
- 1:12:32actually, like when I was watching Twin Flames, right, there was that
- 1:12:38one woman who was one of the lieutenants, so to speak, you know,
- 1:12:42one of the top employees, and she had been coaching some of the
- 1:12:48other couples and was forcing them to do things that she now knows was very
- 1:12:56harmful, and she was crying about it. And you know, case by
- 1:13:00case basis, we might be able to say you should have known better even
- 1:13:05though you were sort of brainwashed. That doesn't release you from responsibility. But
- 1:13:13a child, a child, no, like, I kind of feel like
- 1:13:16a Nazi following words in a way. It's very smart. Actually, that's
- 1:13:23that's that's very that's very apt. I mean, depends on what sort of
- 1:13:27Nazi you're talking about. But for the rank and file in Germany, a
- 1:13:32lot of them did horrific, horrible, horrible things, but they would never
- 1:13:36have done those things normally, right, So yeah, yeah, that's a
- 1:13:43And I hope that comforts him a little bit, right, because you have
- 1:13:45millions upon millions of Germans that did horrific things, So maybe that that is
- 1:13:53Maybe that's him saying like, look, it was horrible and I should feel
- 1:13:57guilty, but I was all so in a high control situation. I don't
- 1:14:06know if I wish to talk about this further. I mean, I've gotten
- 1:14:09a lot of stuff off my chest, but I haven't really had a chance
- 1:14:12to speak about publicly. Yeah, I'm good. Yeah, I don't think
- 1:14:15I have anything else to add. Take your mic off, Remember to take
- 1:14:26the mic off. Christine made Jacob peel all over in Italia's Things. Jacob's
- 1:14:33words to me, his mom explained it to him as it is therapeutic.
- 1:14:40It is something that a therapist told her to be done. Oh no,
- 1:14:45is it heading in that direction? You know an earlier video. I was
- 1:14:48like, well, we knew from Jody Hilda Brandt that sometimes that, But
- 1:14:54in that moment I figured that if that did indeed happen, that Christine was
- 1:14:58just claiming that a therapist had told her when a therapist had not told her
- 1:15:02to do that, or a therapist had told her you know, you need
- 1:15:04to have consistent boundaries or something. And then Christine ran away with that and
- 1:15:10took it to some bizarre extreme. But now are we learning that it actually
- 1:15:15was told her. Now, on one hand, you'd say, well,
- 1:15:19was the therapist the ringleader? If there's something like that, it's probably,
- 1:15:26you know, because the sort of people that followed Jody Hildebrant are not your
- 1:15:30average parent. Now, maybe an average parent would be routed to her by
- 1:15:34other Mormons or people in the community and then they were influenced by her.
- 1:15:39But you just imagined that for the Jody Hildebrandts of the world, because there
- 1:15:43are a lot of them, they attract a certain kind of parent that is
- 1:15:46looking for a justification or a system or something. So but are we going
- 1:15:53to hear that, Wow, boy, that's going to boil my blood.
- 1:16:00If someone in my field had something to do with this, that is going
- 1:16:04to boil my blood. Christine told Jake that it's okay, And my wife
- 1:16:11made my twelve year old son he all over to Italia's things. Wow twelve,
- 1:16:17So yeah, I didn't know the age. In my head, he
- 1:16:21would have been a little older because but she was only in the house for
- 1:16:25a certain amount of times. So yeah, that if he were eighteen or
- 1:16:29seventeen, And think, well, it's starting to get into a realm where
- 1:16:31he has a little bit more possibility of pushing back on that and knowing better
- 1:16:36or something. Even then, though I would not hold a seventeen year accountable
- 1:16:41for this story, but twelve, I mean, come on, as a
- 1:16:45get you back, give me a second. Yeah, and it's not just
- 1:16:54the urine, right. Imagine you're Innatalia and your bed is now soaked and
- 1:17:00you don't do the laundry. You can't do the laundry. You're you just
- 1:17:05have to live with it for whatever, until it just dries. You know.
- 1:17:12That's that's I think what we're hearing. I don't know. I don't
- 1:17:15know what Jacob needs from me. In that moment. I tried to put
- 1:17:17my arm on him as he was telling me, and he slacked me away.
- 1:17:21Yeah. Again, the way he describes things, it's woman. Jacob
- 1:17:27was abused by that woman. My other two sons are abused by that woman
- 1:17:30right now today. That woman is a controlling, lying, manipulating woman.
- 1:17:36We were all abused. Yeah. I sort of wish that he had a
- 1:17:44more typical presentation because I think it would be more believed by people. I
- 1:17:49worry that because I don't know. Maybe he's very convincing to people. If
- 1:17:55true, which there's a seemingly a lot of corroborating evidence from a number of
- 1:17:59individuals pointing in this direction that Christine is in fact as much of a monster
- 1:18:04I mean truly as the way that Michael has been describing this whole series,
- 1:18:11then yeah, you could imagine not only just the normal victim blaming that happens
- 1:18:17and stigma and people avoiding you, but also if you're a man, if
- 1:18:23you're a husband, maybe particularly in his region, I don't know, you
- 1:18:29could imagine someone just being continually even if people do believe you, there's like,
- 1:18:32yeah, but it couldn't been that bad. Even in their head,
- 1:18:33they don't really treat you with the care and love and compassion that you deserve.
- 1:18:41You can imagine someone getting continually frustrated with that and just feeling like I
- 1:18:47need to what do I need to do? I need to scream, I
- 1:18:50just need to yell. I need to be more convincing. I need to
- 1:18:54be more demonstrative to convince people. Because people don't leave me, or they
- 1:19:00even when they believe me, they don't really grasp the gravity of what's happening
- 1:19:04here and what has happened Christine's a monster and one time she yelled at me.
- 1:19:13Okay, so Michael's mother is saying that Christine is a monster, so
- 1:19:17we're gonna hear a story here. But started to take her word for this
- 1:19:23sort of thing, because going through a divorce, you know, typically if
- 1:19:28you love your kid, you're you're gonna be biased, and you're also going
- 1:19:31to be influenced by a lot of things that you're a lot of things your
- 1:19:34kids are saying. You know, the average divorcing family, the parents will
- 1:19:41be very biased against their former in law child, right, So we just
- 1:19:46have to take this with a grain of salt. But it is another account.
- 1:19:49So let's hear this. Because she was standing on a on a chair
- 1:19:53to change a light bulb and I wanted to get off the chair because she
- 1:19:57was pregnant. And do the next day and she's up on a yelling because
- 1:20:00Michael had changed a light bulb and I said, Christine, you need to
- 1:20:04come down. She told everybody I hit her, and then she told me
- 1:20:09I had to leave their house. I wasn't welcome there anymore. Okay,
- 1:20:14that's her side of the story. But given everything else we've heard, you
- 1:20:17know, it's sort of like when you hear allegations against people like Bill Cosby
- 1:20:23or Harvey Weinstein. The first allegation says something, but the second allegation that's
- 1:20:30very similar to the first allegation that says something, The third, the fourth,
- 1:20:34the fifth that says something. So when we hear so many different people,
- 1:20:41well, I guess regarding Christine, we're hearing well, I guess we
- 1:20:45heard from Atalia. That's hard to know how to take that. But we're
- 1:20:49hearing from Michael's mother, but it's Michael's mother. We're hearing from Michael,
- 1:20:53but that's Michael. We're hearing from Jacob, but Jacob is perhaps partial to
- 1:20:57Michael. Who else have we heard from about Christine? I think, oh,
- 1:21:02well, the people at the creamery were saying, there's at least two
- 1:21:10people. I think that we're saying things like, I don't know. It
- 1:21:13didn't look like Natalia was the aggressor, that's for sure, but that's pretty
- 1:21:19minor in terms of a witness. But anyway, Yeah, so if we
- 1:21:24just heard Michael Let's saying something, then we hear Jacob Let's saying something,
- 1:21:28we hear the mom saying something. You know, and visual and you can
- 1:21:32see it and you can know it. And then there's what I went through.
- 1:21:39Did she sexually abuse me by physically violating my body, No she did
- 1:21:45not. Did she sexually abuse me by using it as a tool, Yes
- 1:21:53she did. Okay, this is interesting. At the very least, it's
- 1:21:57going to be an account of actual abuse that might be different from the way
- 1:22:02people will hear about the stories. So this will be interesting if we believe
- 1:22:10a lot of the stories about Christine. Is it possible. Yeah, absolutely,
- 1:22:15people who are abusive in the way that we have heard, it's pervasive
- 1:22:20in their personality. You know, for all of us, we've all been
- 1:22:26debatably abusive, even the best person on the planet when we get upset at
- 1:22:30our partner and we say things like you never listen to me, or you're
- 1:22:39the most sensitive person on the planet, or I don't know. I'm just
- 1:22:42trying to think of like common phrases i'll hear from couples that are pretty healthy.
- 1:22:46You know, those are arguably abusive things. You're just painting them with
- 1:22:50a broad brush. You're accusing them of something. You're being semi aggressive in
- 1:22:56your tone, or something you're purposely trying to hurt their feelings or semi purposely
- 1:23:00or something you know, but it's not constructive, right, it's not healthy
- 1:23:04communication, it's not useful depending on the situation. Right. So we've all
- 1:23:11been like that, But for someone to be that far down that road,
- 1:23:15you know, that far over on the spectrum of the things that we've heard,
- 1:23:19there's something different about their personality. There's something fundamentally different about their perceptions,
- 1:23:28their sense of fairness, Their distortions are particular such that they often depending
- 1:23:34on I don't know what if Christine did in any of those things, but
- 1:23:38if she did, I don't know what the foundation would be. But a
- 1:23:41lot of the foundations involve a lot of entitlement and a lot of distorting what
- 1:23:46is happening, where internally they will feel completely justified in what they're doing,
- 1:23:54not always, but often, and they will they'll pass a light detector test
- 1:23:58if one existed, by a straining the question was it fair what you did?
- 1:24:02To Natalia? And she would say yes potentially, and she and she
- 1:24:06would not be lying. No one would agree with her, but she would
- 1:24:11feel it would be true because of the way she perceives and processes information and
- 1:24:17data. It's all filtered through her schema, and there's a lot of transference
- 1:24:23from the past, a lot of displacement from the past that just completely clouds
- 1:24:26one judgment. So my point in saying all that is that that personality problem
- 1:24:32doesn't just stop with parenting. It's everywhere, particularly in attachments, and will
- 1:24:38likely show up with sex. And or another way of looking at it is
- 1:24:44that your desire to overpower and your desire to harm, or your desire to
- 1:24:48be in control, your desire to get back at people to you know,
- 1:24:54I don't know what the particular motivation was. It likely doesn't just stop the
- 1:25:00talia. It goes in all directions that are relationally close to you, and
- 1:25:04he would potentially get it as well. And one of the ways that you
- 1:25:09can abuse someone and harm them is through sexy. You ask anyone who's been
- 1:25:13a victim of intimate partner violence, and the vast majority of them will talk
- 1:25:18about how the abuse didn't and outside the bath, outside the bedroom, you
- 1:25:25know it was. It was definitely in the sexual relationship as well, not
- 1:25:30always but almost always, you know, very frequently, and that can be
- 1:25:35really you know, you can just imagine that's pretty insidious because your whole body
- 1:25:40is involved, your sexuality is involved. So Christine's sexual things to manipulate me
- 1:25:45was basically holding it from me, keeping it from me. She knew I
- 1:25:49was attracted to her. There were many years that the number of times that
- 1:25:54she permitted it to happen with single digits. She never came on to me.
- 1:26:00She never told me I was attractive. She's so, I don't know
- 1:26:04if I'm hearing something that I would characterize as abusive. Now could it be
- 1:26:12all part of the same ballo acts for him? That it was a way
- 1:26:17to control him, a way to make him feel bad the attractive one.
- 1:26:23I'm the ugly one. So invariably I get we've been addicted to pornography.
- 1:26:30Pornography is not going to tell me I'm ugly. It's not going to reject
- 1:26:34me. So Christine would use the pornography stuff against me. It made it
- 1:26:43worse. Okay, again, it's hard to know what he means by against
- 1:26:45him. Maybe he'll give some more detail. Again, it's his word.
- 1:26:50We don't have any other story. Only Christine would know in no likelihood any
- 1:26:56other details. But he's saying addicted to pornography. A lot of people.
- 1:27:00I plan on doing a deep dive on porn addiction. I have a number
- 1:27:04of notes about it because I get asked about it a lot, and it
- 1:27:08comes up a lot in the kinds of content that I make, and the
- 1:27:14you know, the very brief thing that I'll say is that whenever I hear
- 1:27:16someone saying that someone, including themselves has a porn addiction, I will find
- 1:27:24out once I get more information, that they did not have. What we
- 1:27:27would call now addiction isn't necessarily a super precise clinical word because we don't use
- 1:27:32that term. You might hear me use that term because that's a common language
- 1:27:35term, but we like in the DSM, we don't say alcohol addiction.
- 1:27:41We say alcohol used disorder, and it's more precise. It's you know,
- 1:27:46the word addiction has a lot of meanings to it. But another word that
- 1:27:50is, I think even better is compulsion. So if one we're you know,
- 1:27:57like a lot of people will because they're horny and they want to masturbate,
- 1:28:03they will look at porn. And he describes it interestingly as well,
- 1:28:08that pornography never shunned him. Pornography was always there for him. Pornography made
- 1:28:14him feel, you know, he could fantasize or something you know, it
- 1:28:16was just a holdover or something for the real thing. And it can be
- 1:28:25an outlet. It can be a very positive thing, it can be a
- 1:28:27healthy thing, it can be an unhealthy thing. Also, there's different pornography.
- 1:28:30There's ethical preography and unethical pornography, harmful abusive pornography, meaning the performers
- 1:28:36are being deeply harmed, but there are many performers who are doing it consensually
- 1:28:42and being treated fairly anyway. The point is that for some people, they
- 1:28:46will feel this need for sexuality masturbation, and they involve pornography, and it's
- 1:28:55this little, you know, solitary oasis away from the world. And for
- 1:29:00some people that can be a functional thing, it's just like getting away from
- 1:29:02the stress at work or something. But for some people that are an abusive
- 1:29:06relationship, it can be a very important aspect of their life, a very
- 1:29:14meaningful part. It's like, this is just for me, No one can
- 1:29:16tell me not to do it. I am I'm taking care of myself.
- 1:29:21But then afterwards the shame, particularly with culture and religion and society, maybe
- 1:29:27even spouses. Now I'm not saying everyone should be looking important, but I'm
- 1:29:30just sort of giving the broad strokes of the landscape. But what I'll say
- 1:29:35is this, I've treated actual people who have a compulsive porn use problem disorder,
- 1:29:42and these people the way that it manifests, the symptoms are the same
- 1:29:46way that an addiction to heroin or an addiction to alcohol or cigarettes or caffeine
- 1:29:51would manifest, in that there's this uncontrollable itch, and it gets worse over
- 1:29:57time and more frequent over time, and there are a lot of consequences over
- 1:30:00time. So a common person that I would see with porn addiction was looking
- 1:30:05at pornography pretty much all day long, every day, and they were trying
- 1:30:11to hide it, but they couldn't hide it because they were so compulsive about
- 1:30:15it, right, They couldn't control it. You know. They would say,
- 1:30:17Okay, I'm at Thanksgiving, I need to not look at porn,
- 1:30:20and they would do everything in their power to refrain, but this itch would
- 1:30:27just be happening. Okay, So that's addiction, right. It's the same
- 1:30:29as if you're addicted to cigarettes. It's like, Okay, I'm I'm going
- 1:30:31to Thanksgiving with my family. I don't want them to know I'm smoking,
- 1:30:34so I'm gonna not smoke okay, but then you know, the itch just
- 1:30:39builds it. You're just just like, oh, you can think about it,
- 1:30:41and you end up smoking cigarette. Now, you know, we can
- 1:30:44talk about the differences between a chemical addiction and a behavioral compulsion, but the
- 1:30:50itch is the same. The brain seems to work similarly in both compulsions.
- 1:30:55So with pornography addiction, that's what it'll look like. With pornography, you
- 1:31:00have a problem with pornography, or you wish you wouldn't look at pornography,
- 1:31:06particularly afterwards, you're like, oh, I'm ashamed of that. And then
- 1:31:10you have this build up of motivation over time, and then you use pornography
- 1:31:14and masturbate, and then you feel ashamed. You know that cycle. Do
- 1:31:16we call that an addiction? Do we call that a problem? Do we
- 1:31:20call it something that you shouldn't be ashamed of? And it's fine, and
- 1:31:26you're just manifesting internalizations from society or your wife or something. You know,
- 1:31:32there's a lot of different specifics that I need to know. So I would
- 1:31:36have some clients come to me claiming to have a porn addiction, and I
- 1:31:41would look into it, and I would start throwing out these ideas. After
- 1:31:45hearing stories, and I would say, well, you know, I wouldn't
- 1:31:49call that an addiction. I wouldn't call it a compulsion. If you tell
- 1:31:53me it's a problem for you, then that that's all I need to know.
- 1:31:57I would want to know why it's a problem for you and what we
- 1:32:00need to do, because I need to understand the problem before I'm going to
- 1:32:03treat the problem, you know. And sometimes people are being oppressed, you
- 1:32:09know today, but particularly in the past, some people would come into therapy
- 1:32:14because they thought that they had a problem because they were attracted to same sex
- 1:32:17people, and they said, there's something wrong with me, something wrong with
- 1:32:23my head. I need treatment. I need you to convert me to being
- 1:32:26a head or sexual or something. And there was a lot of treatment,
- 1:32:30conversion therapy, and homosexuality was even in the DSM for a while decades ago
- 1:32:35as a disorder. So we can't trust the DSM necessarily. We can't even
- 1:32:41necessarily trust culture or our sense, or even other clinicians and their sense of
- 1:32:46what is and what is not a problem. And we know that we have
- 1:32:50a sex negative society. It might be more sex positive than other societies,
- 1:32:56but not as sex positive as some other societies and their pockets with in our
- 1:33:00society, of course, but we know that we live in a sex negative
- 1:33:03culture and a shaming culture about this, and we have to be skeptical about
- 1:33:10our assessment of this, and particularly lay individuals and their labels about their own
- 1:33:15porn addiction. But anyway, I just feel compelled to say that look out
- 1:33:20for the deep dive because it'll be a lot more yammoring than that. October
- 1:33:26twenty thirteen, I leave Canada. We were not yet divorced at this time,
- 1:33:32and Christine decides to start using sex as a weapon to make me come
- 1:33:38back and get back in role and serve, so she would start sending naughty
- 1:33:45pictures to me. That's interesting, This isn't. At the beginning of this,
- 1:33:48Ti'm like, this might be interesting. We might hear some presentations of
- 1:33:51abuse that we don't usually get to see or hear about. And this is
- 1:33:56absolutely something that is common enough that I have seen it before. That you
- 1:34:00have an abusive person who you know might be characterized as having lower libido than
- 1:34:08the victim, and that might seem kind of strange. It's like, well,
- 1:34:11if you're a victim of abuse, why would you want to have sex
- 1:34:13with the perpetrator. Well, it's it's really complicated. When you're being abused.
- 1:34:16You're not like one hundred percent against your spouse. A big part of
- 1:34:20your heart and your mind is in love with this person and wants to be
- 1:34:24with them and has good times with them and might be attracted to them,
- 1:34:28right, so that those things are not mutually exclusive, And there can be
- 1:34:31a lot of shame around that, right, and a lot of victim blaming
- 1:34:34around that. It's like, why would you want to have sex with you?
- 1:34:36Must not be a victim? Right? That kind of stupa talk,
- 1:34:40so, and we don't know if he's telling the truth, so just using
- 1:34:43it as jumping off point. He's saying that when he would be transitioning away
- 1:34:46from her, she was trying to seduce him back, trying to use what
- 1:34:51she could. And abusive people, high control people, you know, whether
- 1:34:55you call him abusive or just high control or controlling people will do a version
- 1:35:00of this very frequently. Whether it's this or say you have a boss that
- 1:35:05is abusive to you or high control and you're asking for a raise and they're
- 1:35:11like no, no, no, and then they're abusing you. And then
- 1:35:14finally it's just a breaking point, and you you resign, and then the
- 1:35:19boss starts to come around, starts to be a little nicer. Hey,
- 1:35:24you know, we got some extra funds, and I really do appreciate you,
- 1:35:27and I really think that you're worth five dollars more an hour. So
- 1:35:30how does that sound to you? And they will use that because they're trying
- 1:35:35to get you back, and they will use whatever they can to get you
- 1:35:41back, and since they have been beating you down, you know, like
- 1:35:45in that scenario, you'll have an employee that, because of the abuse,
- 1:35:47will believe that they're not very worthy of a worker and will be stuck in
- 1:35:54this world where they could actually leave and get a better job somewhere else with
- 1:35:59a non abusive and actually get paid more at least the same because of all
- 1:36:02the emotional abuse, the person leaves and thinks, well, I'm probably not
- 1:36:06going to get a job, and then five dollars more and you get sucked
- 1:36:09back in. Right. We don't know if this is true, but this
- 1:36:11is a good opportunity for us to talk about these these kinds of ways to
- 1:36:16eliminate the victim's power to get away. You know, other kinds of things
- 1:36:21might be going to therapy. Now, I'm not going to say going to
- 1:36:26therapy is a bad thing necessarily, but perpetrators absolutely will do this. Sometimes
- 1:36:30they will, I mean typically, more typically what will happen is they will
- 1:36:35promise to go to therapy and they'll show all the evidence. Look, I'm
- 1:36:39calling all these places. They won't actually go though, but they're doing a
- 1:36:42lot of the motive that. You know, they're going through a lot of
- 1:36:44emotions, and the victim will be like, oh well, maybe maybe a
- 1:36:46nast time, or they'll enter recovery, you know, they'll quit drinking or
- 1:36:50something or now, sometimes people are not only victimizers abusers, and they legitimately
- 1:37:00will be wanting to change something. So it could be both me teasing me,
- 1:37:04tempting me. If you just come back, you'll get this. This
- 1:37:13documentary is I don't know if we need to see these pictures. It's a
- 1:37:18little Jerry Springer ish, you know. I mean, I guess the question
- 1:37:23is do we care about Christie? But you know we haven't. We don't
- 1:37:26have definitive proof. I don't know we have enough to go off of.
- 1:37:30I guess so, but still, I just I don't think this is necessary.
- 1:37:35We can just hear the stories. Okay, so she's using puns,
- 1:37:51the asterisks. I have to sort of fill in, if you will,
- 1:37:56so to speak. And then he's saying, this is so wrong. You're
- 1:38:00my ex, You've moved on wrong. Need to something? You need to
- 1:38:10This is on HBO? Why can't they have and plus like, okay,
- 1:38:15so we live in a world in which the powers that be say that,
- 1:38:19sure, kids can watch this documentary, but don't have a swear word,
- 1:38:26particularly if it has to do with sex. What which would you rather have
- 1:38:31your kids exposed to the word shit because they actually would beep and use asterisk
- 1:38:35for shit. Would you rather have your kids hear the word shit on the
- 1:38:41television or watch this documentary? You know the rest of the documentary, all
- 1:38:46the content. So what a weird situation. Okay, so he's saying,
- 1:38:56no, don't do this to me. And then at least the way it's
- 1:39:11edited, who knows if that's accurate as soon as and this is very telling.
- 1:39:17It's just that's bringing back a lot of memories. It's so manipulative.
- 1:39:21Everything's fun in games. It's there's a lot of energy, right, It's
- 1:39:26like, hey, you know pictures and innuendos and all the asterisks, and
- 1:39:31then as soon as he turns the corner and says, yeah, I'm me
- 1:39:38too, then she drops in the control of court, which I think is
- 1:39:43referring to I don't want you to divorce me, or I don't want you
- 1:39:46to take me to court. I don't want you to out me, or
- 1:39:49something like that. I don't know that, but that that seems like what
- 1:39:54might be happening, and that is the pattern, And to the victim,
- 1:39:58it's this whiplash of like, because you know, if you want, you're
- 1:40:01being beaten down in gas lit for ten years. You finally leave, but
- 1:40:06you're not entirely sure because there's no certainty in life, and your support system
- 1:40:12might be pretty fragmented because of the control of the abusive person. You've been
- 1:40:15gas that you don't really trust yourself and maybe you're wrong about everything, but
- 1:40:20I don't know, and you leave, plus like it's going to tear your
- 1:40:25family apart. The kids are going to suffer, finances are going to suck
- 1:40:28for a while or maybe forever, and I don't know, maybe I'm making
- 1:40:32the wrong choice. And then you know, they start to suck you back
- 1:40:35in and then you are like resisting, You're like no, but then eventually
- 1:40:40you said, well, wait, I guess he is turning around. So
- 1:40:44that was what I wanted. And I don't know. I'll play it safe.
- 1:40:49You know, I won't say no, but I won't say yes.
- 1:40:51And you know I'm not going back. I'm not going back. But I
- 1:40:57don't want to discourage him from doing this because that's mean. Plus what if
- 1:41:01he does turn around and we can I can have my old husband back from
- 1:41:05the old days. But I won't say yes. And then even more effort
- 1:41:10and just a full court press of all the things that you always wanted.
- 1:41:15I finally got those plane tickets to Aruba. You always wanted to go there,
- 1:41:20and you're like, oh wow, you've I thought that was never possible.
- 1:41:25I'm in therapy right now. You know. Now, maybe those are
- 1:41:27legit things, but maybe they're not. And then, so the key,
- 1:41:31if I were to say something very briefly as to how to know the difference
- 1:41:36is if you, as a victim, and it's hard to notice say this
- 1:41:42or go on a campaign, and to get at this, you tell the
- 1:41:45abusive person, Okay, great, I'm glad you're doing all these things.
- 1:41:49But can you tell me why you're doing these things? Or or can you
- 1:41:56admit you were abusive to me? Or I want to re engage with you,
- 1:42:01but I need to see the pudding. I need to see proofs in
- 1:42:05the pudding. I need to see at least six months, if not twelve,
- 1:42:10eighteen months of you actually in therapy and I'm actually getting to talk to
- 1:42:15your therapist about your progress and what you're working on. Not because I'm keeping
- 1:42:18tabs on controlling you. I just I don't know. I'm sorry, I
- 1:42:20just don't necessarily trust the situation. But if you're legitimately doing it, then
- 1:42:26that would help. I'm not saying yes, but I'm not saying no.
- 1:42:30And once I see eighteen months and it looks like things are actually helping and
- 1:42:36you're actually changing, then I'll make a determination. Then if you tell an
- 1:42:41abusive person that, in all likelihood, if they're manipulating, they won't like
- 1:42:45that. If they're legit they'll take it because they have changed, right,
- 1:42:49So something along those lines, But people don't often know to do that.
- 1:42:55Plus when you're getting this full court press from them, especially if they start
- 1:42:59making threats, subtle threats of just you know, I'm gonna get you,
- 1:43:01and I'm gonna get I'm gonna I'm gonna ruin your life. So this is
- 1:43:06a good representation of the subtlety of how that can work. I don't know
- 1:43:11if that's what we're seeing. Christine was leveraging her body, her sex to
- 1:43:21get what she wanted in the divorce. You can have this, but give
- 1:43:26me what I want, which is custody of the boys, and he agrees.
- 1:43:30Now there's a possibility that it is sexual satisfaction that he's seeking, but
- 1:43:38maybe mostly what he's seeking is physical warmth and approval. I don't know,
- 1:43:44but I have this hypothesis without much data that well, I guess I'll say
- 1:43:50this. I'm curious as to what personality and schema foundations he had before he
- 1:44:00ever met Christine, because in all likelihood, there was something going on with
- 1:44:05him and that can be exploited by an abusive person and also used during the
- 1:44:14breakup. So he told my kids over and over and over and over and
- 1:44:17over, your father's going to kill you. I'm going to protect you.
- 1:44:24And for a young developing mind, how often do you need your mom to
- 1:44:30repeat to you the dad's going to kill you? Until you start buying it.
- 1:44:38Yeah, it's possible. It's also potentially Michael getting out ahead of allegations
- 1:44:44that he knows or thinks might be coming down the pike because he was threatening
- 1:44:49or something. I don't know. It doesn't seem super likely, but it
- 1:44:54is a possibility. But yeah, if the stories and the piction of Christine
- 1:45:00is somewhat accurate, then yeah, I would not doubt that she would brainwash
- 1:45:08the children for sure, and that she wouldn't use extreme tactics to do so.
- 1:45:14I mean, anybody who is upset at their child who's been traumatized because
- 1:45:19of incontinence, you know, they've been traumatized, and you're upset at the
- 1:45:25child for having normal incontinence as maybe just a medical issue. I mean sometimes
- 1:45:30it just happens to be upset about that at all, right, and then
- 1:45:32to get so upset and then you want to be vengeful, and then you
- 1:45:36grope your older boy into it, like anyone who would do that. And
- 1:45:41we don't know if that happened, but that's what we're being told. Then
- 1:45:44Yeah, the constant manipulation and brainwashing and potential gas lighting and need for total
- 1:45:51control would in all likelihood manifest in the way that Michael is depicting it right
- 1:45:57now, saying it right now, my middle son and my youngest son.
- 1:45:59I've not seen them in over eight years, and they want nothing to do
- 1:46:04with seeing me evil. She's earned it, She's earned every single letter of
- 1:46:12it evil. Now, I guess I understand why Christine wouldn't be in the
- 1:46:20documentary even if none of this is true, although anyway, if even a
- 1:46:30little bit of this is true, you would, I guess understand why she
- 1:46:32would say no. I only stand to lose by that amazing clarity. I
- 1:46:38could know. I couldn't. Couldn't when she told me that she had tried
- 1:46:48to kill her mom, was like, why was that? And I felt
- 1:46:53like either she was coached to say that and those things didn't happen. Okay,
- 1:46:59So I'm a bit confused. Clearly, I think the documentarians are trying
- 1:47:05to convince us, at least in this moment, that the mother Christine coached
- 1:47:12Natalia to claim and to tell others that she is dangerous since she tried to
- 1:47:18kill people, her family and her mom, when she hadn't tried to do
- 1:47:24that. Okay, So, given what we've heard about Christine is that possible.
- 1:47:29Yeah, absolutely, I'm just trying to piece everything together. Now.
- 1:47:34Yeah, I don't know what the document the documentarians are trying to tell us.
- 1:47:40Are they trying to tell us that none of it was true? Was
- 1:47:43all Christine or a combination? What would have happened if you wouldn't have gone?
- 1:47:47Along with Natalia being hed up? Oh my god, I would have
- 1:47:54lost my kids. Then that's for sure, never seen my kids again.
- 1:47:58Okay, So the detective is interviewing Michael. The visual is a recreation with
- 1:48:03actors, and the detective asked what would happen if you wouldn't have gone,
- 1:48:09along with the notion that Natalia was older than what the paperwork was saying,
- 1:48:15and Michael was saying, I would have lost my kids. Okay, So
- 1:48:19that is consistent with what a victim would say. Is he a victim?
- 1:48:25I don't know, but that is absolutely possible, right, So that's interesting.
- 1:48:30The other thing I want to point out is that this documentary will interview
- 1:48:32Michael over a span of time at least a year, if not longer spans
- 1:48:39of time, and it's possible that the earlier interviews he was still under the
- 1:48:46thumb of his ex wife either internally or externally or both. So the things
- 1:48:53he was saying earlier either he knew he was fabricating because he was scared,
- 1:49:00or he was still brainwashed to some extent because the inconsistencies that we see might
- 1:49:10make him less credible. And this is one of the things. I'll just
- 1:49:13use this as a jumping off point. When victims come forward after being brainwashed
- 1:49:17for twenty years or maybe even a shorter period of time five years, five
- 1:49:21years is a long time. I mean a month is a long time,
- 1:49:24honestly, but you say five years, and they finally come forward, they
- 1:49:30find a therapist or a police officer or the public, Twitter or something.
- 1:49:34The problem that they face, among many is that because they're confused and discombobulated
- 1:49:43and brainwashed and gaslet, they don't really trust themselves very much, and they're
- 1:49:48struggling with a lot of trauma. They of course have an urge to know
- 1:49:54the truth and to tell the truth, and they're also struggling with a lot
- 1:49:58of pushback and victim blain, and they also have their own trauma even before
- 1:50:02they met their abusive partner potentially, and so they can often come across They
- 1:50:09can often come across in a number of ways that will make the victim look
- 1:50:13like an unreliable narrator. In particular, they might actually have completely different stories
- 1:50:19over time, which is a hallmark commonly of lying or fabricating or something.
- 1:50:25But that is absolutely almost always the case when it comes to someone emerging from
- 1:50:30a high control relationship, and it can take years, it can potentially take
- 1:50:32decades, depending on how much recovery. You know, you take a cult
- 1:50:35member who was fully brainwashed for ten years, they leave for whatever reason,
- 1:50:41and they get no treatment, no effective treatment, for twenty years. You
- 1:50:45talk to them twenty years later, they would it would be as though they
- 1:50:47had just left the cult. They might be barely mentally out of the cult.
- 1:50:53So it could take a long time ticked that out of my house,
- 1:50:57and she would have done what she did. I mean, you say that
- 1:51:01Christina was a mass manipulator. Yep. What if I told you Natalia has
- 1:51:06never had a period. I'd what if I told you that Natalia really just
- 1:51:14started developing breast to your go, Okay, wow, I hadn't thought about
- 1:51:17that, but yeah, given everything else we've heard about Christine, then yeah,
- 1:51:25but Christine apparently, according to Michael in his memory was shocked about pubic
- 1:51:34hair the day they got Natalia. So why would Christine so quickly be trying
- 1:51:45to throw doubt about the age unless, I mean, this would truly be
- 1:51:54monstrous, the pinnacle of monstrous, that Christine actually adopted a child, knowing
- 1:52:00before she adopted the child that she was going to abuse that child and the
- 1:52:05tact. This is pure fantasy world here. It's it's ridiculous, it's possible,
- 1:52:13but that she would adopt a child and then immediately try to make it
- 1:52:19seem as though she's a lot older the child so that she Christine can get
- 1:52:25away with mistreating her more because there are different protections for children than adults.
- 1:52:30Right, So that would be so. But anyway, is it possible that
- 1:52:36Christine just claimed markers of post puberty and Michael just believed it? Right?
- 1:52:46She the mother Christine screamed when she was bathing Natalia, and then according to
- 1:52:54him, he went into the bathroom. Christine, if I remember right,
- 1:53:00is looked down and then Michael looks down and sees pubic care. It's possible
- 1:53:05that that's not what happened, but that's how he remembers it. That she
- 1:53:10came out of the bathroom and said what she supposedly had seen, and then,
- 1:53:15over time retelling the story, he just put himself into the narrative that
- 1:53:20he actually saw. That's very, very common that people will do that say
- 1:53:25that I go into the other room and I go whoa, and I come
- 1:53:29back out. I shut the door and I say, oh my god.
- 1:53:31So I'm in there and there's this guy and he's big and he's got big
- 1:53:35muscles, and he looks at me and he gives me his blue hat,
- 1:53:43and I'm like, what are you doing? And so I dropped the hat
- 1:53:45and I came in here. Okay, So I'm telling you it's a weird
- 1:53:47story. As I'm telling you that story, you're likely visualizing it. Maybe
- 1:53:53not everybody, and there's people actually have a hard time visualizing things in a
- 1:53:57movie pictorial way. But for those of you who can, you might have
- 1:54:00a vision in your head. I described a muscley man as big, handsome
- 1:54:04blue hat, and I take it driving. Well, when a year from
- 1:54:09now, if I were to repeat this story and you think about it every
- 1:54:13once in a while, you not only remember me telling you the story,
- 1:54:15but you remember the visualization that you created in your mind about my description of
- 1:54:19the story. And so ten years later, when it all gets kind of
- 1:54:25smeared the memory, you remember it, but you remember the visualization, not
- 1:54:30that I told you what had happened, And so you remember the visualization as
- 1:54:35the actual event, and you say, and so you think, well,
- 1:54:39I must have been in the room because I can see it. I can
- 1:54:41see the blue hat. So did the dad do that? I don't know,
- 1:54:45But the very least the allegation, I think from the detective or the
- 1:54:49implication, is that she was Christine was trying to manipulate situation to make it
- 1:54:57so that Natalia would be seen as older, that she could abuse her more
- 1:55:01easily. There it might be over well said I'm not guilty. People like
- 1:55:15everybody knows. It took two strangers about an hour and a half. So
- 1:55:25there's that odd presentation. Again. I don't know about you, but it
- 1:55:29just comes across as amped up. Do I think he legitimately has emotion right
- 1:55:33now? Yeah? To catch up. So this final episode, there was
- 1:55:38just a lot of reality TV fluff and many several people saying very adamantly,
- 1:55:46this changes everything. I feel like that should be the name. Is that
- 1:55:50the name of this episode? No, this is not the name of this
- 1:55:55episode, but I was an appreciative of the drawing it out and making it
- 1:56:03all suspenseful, just like, get to the story. I don't want to
- 1:56:06see a bunch of fluff and a bunch of upswelling of music and people walking
- 1:56:12around and I don't know. It's just not my favorite episode in this series.
- 1:56:17But anyway, so let's rewind it, but you can. It just
- 1:56:23looks like he legitimately has emotion because he was found not guilty, and he
- 1:56:28is having an emotional expression, and then there's like there's like a doubling of
- 1:56:32the expression. Oh, everybody knows. It took twelve strangers about an hour
- 1:56:44and a alf figure out I wasn't guilty. Unform I don't know. I
- 1:56:48say this sometimes that I am a professional listener of crying people because as a
- 1:56:55therapist, of course, a lot of people will cry in therapy. I
- 1:56:59might cry as a therapist and therapy I will also see a lot of students
- 1:57:03cry in a lot of my classes. You know, being a therapist is
- 1:57:08hard. One. Two. A lot of the courses that we teach in
- 1:57:12our program involve self investigation and trauma awareness, kind of transference awareness. For
- 1:57:18the therapist, because the therapist needs to know their own issues, their own
- 1:57:24traumas, their own reactivity, their biases, and that can be hard.
- 1:57:28It's not necessarily super hard, but it can be super hard, but even
- 1:57:33mildly hard things, especially when you have people who are toward the spectrum,
- 1:57:40toward one end of the spectrum in terms of emotional expression. You know,
- 1:57:43therapists are more likely to not have the stigma around having and expressing emotions.
- 1:57:49So maybe even little things might cause a lot of people to cry in my
- 1:57:53field, So I'll see a lot of therapists cry as I'm supervising or teaching.
- 1:57:57And then I know, of course in my personal life there might be
- 1:58:00occasional tears or something. So you know, there would be times when by
- 1:58:02the end of the day, I would just be thinking back on the day.
- 1:58:05I think, I remember there was this one day, and it wasn't
- 1:58:09super uncommon for this to happen. But I said to myself, for I
- 1:58:13might have said to Stacy, I said, literally, everyone I interacted with
- 1:58:17today cried. I mean, not everyone I passed in the hallway or something,
- 1:58:21but everyone I had an interaction with longer than a few sentences cried today,
- 1:58:28And that doesn't necessarily mean that the world is falling apart or everyone's falling
- 1:58:32apart. Is just just a normal part of life anyway. So I,
- 1:58:36over a long period of time throughout the day, will see a lot of
- 1:58:42different types of crying, a lot of different emotions that are being expressed through
- 1:58:46crying at various different intensities, with various different situations. You know, a
- 1:58:51little bit of trauma and fusion, a little bit of excitement and fusion,
- 1:58:56nervousness and fusion. You know, there's a lot of different colors of crying.
- 1:58:59I fancy myself someone that can see the nuances of crying. So when
- 1:59:03I see people on these shows, and sometimes I will have some alarm go
- 1:59:10up. I don't know if that says anything. I can't know if it
- 1:59:13says anything. And of course, people who claim to have some sort of
- 1:59:17radar of any sort will believe that their radar is correct. And I know
- 1:59:24enough to know that that's silly. But what do you think. I mean,
- 1:59:26there's just something about and I'm trying to figure out why he would do
- 1:59:30this, why he would shoot himself in the foot, really, because of
- 1:59:32course he is having an emotional reaction. He just was found not guilty.
- 1:59:36Does he feel like he needs to perform. There's some interviews where he was
- 1:59:41histrionically getting angry and through the bat and then he's like, he's just very
- 1:59:46demonstrative. Does it point to something about his personality? My initial hypothesis was
- 1:59:53someone like this, because of course you might see this in a therapy office.
- 1:59:58You know, I might see a client, they tell me what's going
- 2:00:00on with them. They might actually do the stuff like this. And the
- 2:00:03first hypothesis I would explore is that they learned when they were young that they
- 2:00:09had to amp it up in order to get any attention. That's what historyonic
- 2:00:13personality disorder is, and I suppose that's what one category of histrionics would would
- 2:00:19be caused by, in that as a child, you have an emotional expression
- 2:00:24laughter, crying, upset, inness anger, and you're perpetually being ignored or
- 2:00:30inconsistently being attended to, and you learn that you have to be extra with
- 2:00:34your expressions and it becomes neurological, it becomes automatic, habitual, and you
- 2:00:39don't think about it anymore, that you just that's just how you express yourself.
- 2:00:43But it's not inherent to the person. They can potentially unlearn it if
- 2:00:46they are made to feel safe enough to just have normal, spontaneous expressions that
- 2:00:51are attended to most of the time. So that'd be my guess. I'm
- 2:00:56not saying that he's fake or he's always lying, but that would be my
- 2:01:01first guess. Everybody knows it took twelve strangers about an hour and a half
- 2:01:15figure out I wasn't guilty on fourfiloy might now is it normal that he's crying?
- 2:01:23Yeah, the stress involved is enormous and I can't even imagine. I've
- 2:01:31never been in a situation like that. I've been in a lot of stressful
- 2:01:33situation. I've never been in a stressold situation like that would just be I
- 2:01:38can't even imagine the amount of stress. So there's that. Now, just
- 2:01:41because the jury found him not guilty doesn't mean that he isn't guilty, right.
- 2:01:46I took some notes while I was watching this episode, So number one
- 2:01:51is that, Yeah, there's a lot of silly reality TV tropes in this.
- 2:01:56If I were to give a note of feedback to the editors of this
- 2:02:00episode, is just like, stop with the history onics. Really, just
- 2:02:04the story is that's always the thing to meet with reality TV. Often the
- 2:02:09story is dramatic, you know in ninety day Fiance Love is Blind. There
- 2:02:13are real stakes. These are people and their lives and their marriages and their
- 2:02:16kids and everything. You don't have to fake it. You don't have to
- 2:02:21trump it up. You don't have to switch scenes around like with Jackie and
- 2:02:26Marshall. There's enough story there. You don't have to fake. You just
- 2:02:30tell the story. It's a good story. The other number two is that
- 2:02:33he's a little strange. The other thing that he was presenting kind of oddly
- 2:02:40to me anyway, was during the legal meetings that he was having with his
- 2:02:45legal team. He had three lawyers, and although it was interesting to kind
- 2:02:48of see those scenes behind the scenes because they were having these long strategy meetings
- 2:02:55about how to win the trial, and they were coaching him on and how
- 2:03:00to present himself, how to smile, how to respond, and looked at
- 2:03:05one way, it's like, oh, well, he can't act naturally because
- 2:03:09he knows that he's guilty or something like that. But of course, if
- 2:03:14you are a legal team, you are going to spend some time, hopefully
- 2:03:18coaching the defendant on what to do in court, because when people act naturally,
- 2:03:25sometimes they do things that shoot themselves in the foot and the eyes of
- 2:03:29the jury. So that all was normal, I thought. The other thing
- 2:03:33that we saw was that during discovery of the trial, the Facebook messages of
- 2:03:40Christine had to be handed over every Facebook I think it was literally every message
- 2:03:45she had ever sent or Facebook. Just imagine that just everything right, and
- 2:03:50so all that was handed over seemingly, and then it's just available to each
- 2:03:56legal team, including the defendant. So now as co defendants, I'm not
- 2:04:00quite sure. Maybe they'll tell us what happened to Christine. But he was
- 2:04:03given all of her Facebook messages, which included to him evidence of affair affairs,
- 2:04:11not just evidence, but like depictions of affairs that she was having sexual
- 2:04:15affairs, sexting and meeting up with other men. Then they actually met with
- 2:04:19one of the partners that Christine had been cheating with a little person, and
- 2:04:27he was a character. He was nonchalantly disclosing there back and forth. Yeah,
- 2:04:32here's where I talked about my penis and how it's bigger than average,
- 2:04:36and you know she liked that one, like, yeah, so you don't
- 2:04:42need to edit that. That's just a good story, and so there was
- 2:04:46that. But he's learning about all these affairs and that was obviously upsetting to
- 2:04:51him. So if we add that, because that's seemingly factual, it's not
- 2:04:57just hearsay or speculation circumstantial. We have evidence now he might have cheated to
- 2:05:04and having an affair. Cheating isn't evidence of anything really, because it's common
- 2:05:10enough anyway, especially toward the end of a relationship. We don't know when
- 2:05:14exactly she was having She might have had those affairs after they had both strongly
- 2:05:18said to each other that divorce was likely, you know, so we didn't
- 2:05:23get much detail about that. So that's all say about that. But it
- 2:05:27also could be evidence of some global personality for Christine, or pattern of behavior,
- 2:05:32of lack of remorse, lack of empathy, or someone who knows.
- 2:05:35It's just hard to say. The other thing that we learned is that he
- 2:05:41has a new partner. It's the woman that he's hugging right now, Jennifer.
- 2:05:45They seem to be getting along well, but who knows. He disclosed
- 2:05:47that he had a mental breakdown in which he was overwhelmed with the stress of
- 2:05:53the trial, which of course makes sense. He think by mental breakdown meant
- 2:06:00that he was at risk of killing himself. He said that he almost had
- 2:06:04a third attempt at suicide, So then I'm wondering when were the other attempts,
- 2:06:09And he said the second attempt was eighteen years ago. So that's evidence
- 2:06:15that points to the possibility that I was wondering about regarding his early childhood.
- 2:06:20People who have suicide attempts don't necessarily have difficult childhoods, but they often do
- 2:06:26because there's a lot of arrows pointing at some kind of trauma or neglect or
- 2:06:30something that he went through. It might just be mundane, like his parents
- 2:06:33went through a difficult divorce, or it could be more severe than that or
- 2:06:38something. I don't know, but the fact that he in his younger life
- 2:06:43was attempting, you know, that says something. They showed some clips of
- 2:06:47Doctor Phil. Apparently Natalia had gone on Doctor Phil. The way that they
- 2:06:54made it seem from the clip, and it was just a short clip,
- 2:06:56it seemed as though doctor Phil was on Natalia's side or something, and everyone
- 2:07:00was against the parents, And that makes me wonder if the whole news cycle
- 2:07:04story was mainly against the parents. Now, of course, Christine if the
- 2:07:11evidence is compelling enough, absolutely does deserve a huge backlash. Now, I
- 2:07:15will say that the trial, the prosecution was hindered by the judge ruling that
- 2:07:21because legally the Natalia the victim, had been determined to have been born in
- 2:07:28nineteen eighty nine, when everyone basically agrees that she was born in two thousand
- 2:07:33and three or two thousand and four or something. Because of that discrepancy and
- 2:07:39that hadn't been changed officially, that hadn't been changed, then the judge is
- 2:07:44saying, you can't charge these people with child abuse because legally speaking, she
- 2:07:50was an adult at the time that you are claiming that the parents should be
- 2:07:55neglected, so neglectful. So the only charge or prosecut you can go after
- 2:08:01is that they were neglectful of a dependent adult. I don't know, but
- 2:08:05I'm going to take a guess and say that that's a much higher bar to
- 2:08:09demonstrate from a prosecution side of things. So there's that, And yeah,
- 2:08:16it just seems like in terms of the documentary, there's really no evidence or
- 2:08:22very limited evidence that she was Natalia was older than what was told to them
- 2:08:31at first. So it's frustrating to think that because of a clerical technicality that
- 2:08:39the law was hindered. It just breaks your heart because even if the allegations
- 2:08:45against Natalia are accurate, this is a human being. Yeah, and now
- 2:08:50he's found not guilty. Hate certain listeners, Natalia Grace the docum menory on
- 2:09:01Max. Let's watch the deliberation process. One hundred percent of the jurors,
- 2:09:05one hundred percent definitely believed that Michael Burnett was guilty of abandoning her. But
- 2:09:15because the judge was very, very clear on what we had to follow,
- 2:09:20people were just like, oh, we have to go not guilty. Ah,
- 2:09:24and that was the okay. So this is great. We're hearing from
- 2:09:28one of the jurors and she's saying that everyone, all of us knew that
- 2:09:35he was guilty, but because of the law, in what we're being asked
- 2:09:39to rule on, we have to rule not guilty. We're not saying he's
- 2:09:43innocent, but we have to say that the prosecution didn't demonstrate without a reasonable
- 2:09:48doubt that the defendant actually did these things. That says something, right.
- 2:09:54I'm glad to hear that, because if the juror said the whole prosecution was
- 2:10:00ridiculous, there was no evidence they were just going after him for no reason,
- 2:10:03because you know, when you're a juror, you don't. You have
- 2:10:05no distractions. You have no phone, there's no computer, You're just you're
- 2:10:09just staring and listening to all the all the witnesses and hearing all the accounts.
- 2:10:13It says something that at least what she's saying is all the other jury,
- 2:10:16all the other jurors agreed. Now it's her story. This is pretty
- 2:10:20edited, you know, it's edited a lot. They're chopping things up,
- 2:10:24so I hope that they're not misrepresenting what she was basically saying. But so
- 2:10:30she's saying that they all believe that he was guilty of neglect. I think,
- 2:10:33meaning, yeah, you should have been there to help her or housed
- 2:10:39her. Right, that's not okay. Just think about the tragedy if all
- 2:10:45this is true for Natalia, just abandonment. Oh. We also saw an
- 2:10:50interview with the biological mother. The biological mother said that when she gave birth
- 2:10:56to Natalia in two thousand and three or two thousand and four, it was
- 2:11:00a very difficult birth, and then the doctor came to her and said,
- 2:11:03you shouldn't bring Natalia home with you because there's a lot of medical problems,
- 2:11:09and you also owe us one hundred thousand dollars for the birth, and you
- 2:11:15don't have much money at all. I think she's a single parents, I'm
- 2:11:18not sure. And you already have a child at home, another daughter,
- 2:11:22so you shouldn't take this child home with you. And then she said okay
- 2:11:31and left because she couldn't afford to pay the bill, and she's being advised
- 2:11:37that she needs to do this and it'll be the financial ruin of her and
- 2:11:41her family, and she's got to think about her other kid. And then
- 2:11:45later she had another kid who she still has. Sounded like or that she
- 2:11:48raised herself. She was crying about the loss of Natalia. But it's hard
- 2:11:56to know, because someone in that position could spin the tale a little bit
- 2:12:03to exonerate herself make herself look better. But that is more likely the case.
- 2:12:09It's not common that people will, you know, even if the child
- 2:12:13has a disability. It's really rare that a parent will just say, yeah,
- 2:12:18I don't want the kid. That's a very difficult thing to do,
- 2:12:22and or it takes a very particular kind of person. And those things are
- 2:12:28they're just not common. They happen, you know, you hear the stories,
- 2:12:31but what you don't hear in the news are all millions of other stories
- 2:12:35in which that doesn't happen. You know, you hear the times when it
- 2:12:37does, so you know it does happen. And I for a time reviewed
- 2:12:43a fair amount of literature on phenomena that are associated with this, uh,
- 2:12:48you know, abandoning a child soon after birth. You know you hear the
- 2:12:54stories about. I won't go to DNA for the stories. So the way
- 2:12:58that it was being told kind of by the twin sister was that the biological
- 2:13:03bomb just discarded the kid. But you know, you can imagine there being
- 2:13:07some bad blood between them. It seemed like there was, so it could
- 2:13:11be spun in a certain way. So it's hard to know, but it
- 2:13:16is possible that the biological mom had a regardless the child, Talia was abandoned,
- 2:13:22well abandoned, taken in some ways from the mom, and then apparently
- 2:13:28another family was tasked with raising Natalia. Was this like a foster home or
- 2:13:33an actual loving adoptive home. I mean, you can have loving foster parents
- 2:13:37too, but it's a different kind of relationship with a foster parent, meaning
- 2:13:41that foster parents at least, typically they don't invest that much as much emotional
- 2:13:46energy because they expect to only have the child for a temporary period of time.
- 2:13:54Now, sometimes foster parents can be extremely loving, even more loving than
- 2:13:58many adoptive parents. So I don't know. But then we hear from the
- 2:14:01twin that that you know anyway, So it's just heartbreaking. I think,
- 2:14:05you know, all that pain and agony and trump and of course, if
- 2:14:09we also believe the accounts of our behavior, you see results of that trauma.
- 2:14:13Then she gets to this family in New Hampshire. They are trying to
- 2:14:16pawn her off, trying to get money for her, and then she finds
- 2:14:20this family in Indiana with Michael and Christine, and pretty quickly, I'm imagining
- 2:14:26Christine is doing her abusive thing if we believe those accounts, and either Michael
- 2:14:33is going along with the abuse or he's being abusive himself. I don't know.
- 2:14:37The older brothers are being tasked with abusing Natalia as well. I mean,
- 2:14:41it's just horrific. Natalia presents her own problematic behaviors that don't help,
- 2:14:46right, she might have been that way anyway, you know, Just imagine
- 2:14:50you're like, I'm thirteen and your adoptive mom is just grilling you. And
- 2:14:56I guess that does paint that mature differently too, that the account. I
- 2:15:03think even Jacob said this, but definitely Michael did that. The mom Christine
- 2:15:07was just adamant about tell me who you are, you know, tell me
- 2:15:11who you really are, how old you really are? Seemingly possibly, I
- 2:15:16guess, because Christine at that point was determined to get rid of her and
- 2:15:20knew that she couldn't unless she had some technicality, some way out of it.
- 2:15:24And one of the technicalities she could use is, well, she's actually
- 2:15:28an adult, and so she was trying to get her to say something so
- 2:15:33she could find something out. Maybe Christine legit believed she was an adult,
- 2:15:39or she just was trying to manufacture it. I don't know. Then,
- 2:15:41you know, it's all the wall and the and the abuse, and the
- 2:15:46you're in in the bed and the countless other things. Those are just tip
- 2:15:48of the iceberg things, I'm sure I'm guessing. Then she gets put in
- 2:15:54an apartment and left alone. The parents just drop off food every once in
- 2:15:58a while, and she's lonely, and she's trying to for the first time
- 2:16:03in her life trying to socialize with a bunch of randos, and she has
- 2:16:07seemingly reactive attachment into scriminat attachment. So she's just like wandering into homes because
- 2:16:13developmentally she could be like a two year old. And if you had a
- 2:16:16two year old who was just left in a neighborhood, that's it wouldn't be
- 2:16:20unusual for a two year old to do right just like, well, I
- 2:16:22guess I'll just wander into this house. Hopefully some will take care of me.
- 2:16:26That creeps everyone out. She also has reports of her having tendencies to
- 2:16:31want to sexually abuse younger boys, evidence that she was sexually abused. You
- 2:16:37ask, particularly children who will perpetrate sexual abuse on other children. You know,
- 2:16:43my co host Embardo will talk about how when he was sexually abused when
- 2:16:46he was five, extensively by his thirteen year old female babysitter, you know,
- 2:16:52a number of incidents, and then he tells stories about how afterwards,
- 2:16:56a year later, a couple years later, he would fully perpetrate on other
- 2:17:03people. But he would do things thinking, well, that's what you do.
- 2:17:07You know, he would just reach down someone's pants as a way to
- 2:17:09try to connect because that's what was being shown to him, and he at
- 2:17:15no point during the decision process to do those things was thinking, ha ha
- 2:17:18ha, I'm going to get these people. It was just like an urge.
- 2:17:24It's just like, wasn't this what you're supposed to do? And so
- 2:17:26that manifested over a lot of years, and so she might have been doing
- 2:17:33so if she's a child right now. Children can perpetrate and knowingly perpetrate.
- 2:17:41There are sadistics I've worked with them that the extreme ones are are particular,
- 2:17:48not common, but they often do have extensive abandonment and trauma histories, So
- 2:17:54who knows what's going on there, But it's hard to hold a thirteen year
- 2:18:00accountable, like fully accountable for those kinds of behaviors when they've been through all
- 2:18:07that, right, and then she's kind of gaslit or brainwashed into telling everyone
- 2:18:13that she wants to kill people, and that pushes people away. Then the
- 2:18:20parents really kind of turn on her. You know, there's those videos of
- 2:18:22the dad going over to the house and filming her while they're talking, either
- 2:18:30because Christine told him to do that or because he's just against her, or
- 2:18:35he's recording because he wants to get evidence in case there are charges brought up,
- 2:18:41you know, and it's just heartbreaking. It's heartbreaking, and then she
- 2:18:46is genuinely abandoned and neglected. Yet again, years later they go to court
- 2:18:52and based on a technicality, the justice system finds the parents are not guilty.
- 2:18:58Now we haven't heard Christine. Is there a trial. I plan on
- 2:19:03looking it up. If I'm assuming we're going to hear about it. That
- 2:19:05seems like a huge miscarriage of justice. We felt that Michael Barnett had really
- 2:19:11gotten away with abandoning and neglecting his child, and none of us spelt good
- 2:19:16about that. And to me, the solution isn't to go after these I
- 2:19:22mean, in this case, maybe go after the parents. But if we
- 2:19:26actually want justice, if we actually want to reduce the risk of this happening
- 2:19:31in the future, there is a solution to actually fixing problems like this.
- 2:19:37If ten years ago or fifteen years ago in Indiana, the legislatures in Indiana,
- 2:19:43if they had allocated funds or raised levy taxes, or raised property tax
- 2:19:50or something to pay for a very strong program to have these kinds of services
- 2:19:56that not only would be for these kinds of families, but all all sorts
- 2:20:00of families. Then, in my opinion, this situation might not have ever
- 2:20:05happened. It might have been in this direction. You know, divorce might
- 2:20:09have happened. There might have been some parenting problems for sure, and Natalia
- 2:20:16might have still had some behavior problems, but the end of the story would
- 2:20:20be so much different. You know, I've seen that before, and just
- 2:20:24think about that, that we can fix this. You know, that's what
- 2:20:26I think if when aliens come to Earth, if they're not already flying around
- 2:20:31in an invisible spaceship in the sky and looking down on us there in my
- 2:20:37fantasy world, they're wondering this question, why are you doing this to yourself?
- 2:20:43You have experts that are telling you how to fix these problems, but
- 2:20:48you don't do what the experts say. You just yell at the television at
- 2:20:54a documentary, and then you move on with your life. Do you care
- 2:20:58or do you not care? People care about each other. They act like
- 2:21:03they care, and I think they do care, But why don't they take
- 2:21:05action? And in line with that caring? You know, if someone falls
- 2:21:11down, your neighbor falls down, they're carrying groceries, you go over there
- 2:21:16and you help them, or you at least care to you ask them.
- 2:21:18You know, you're a human being. You feel bad. It's easy,
- 2:21:22it's linear, it's it's something you can do. Your child is crying,
- 2:21:26you go to them, right, It's just it's easy. But when it
- 2:21:28comes to systems and taxes and politics and pundits and power structure and corporations and
- 2:21:37special interest were lost. The prosecutor then decided right then and there to let
- 2:21:43me know that she has now subpoened me to testify against your mommy. Okay,
- 2:21:48Well, I was wondering about that. I was wondering if they were
- 2:21:52doing the trial at the same time. It didn't sound like it. So
- 2:21:54it sounds like there's a there's another trial. My brother away. You don't
- 2:21:58have to feel bad, he said, even if you kissed her, I
- 2:22:00need to know. But you're not going to get in trouble, I think,
- 2:22:01is what he said. And I said, no, I'm never okay,
- 2:22:05So they're going back to the fella who purportedly had an affair with Christine,
- 2:22:13you know the Facebook messages and the member size conversation. And now he's
- 2:22:20saying that the police were asking him if he got together with Natalia and the
- 2:22:26investigator saying, look, even if you kissed Natalia, it's no big deal.
- 2:22:30You're not going to be prosecuted. And he's saying, no been intimate
- 2:22:35with a little person ever in my entire life. I know that. So
- 2:22:39now I know that I never that this is not somebody I met and forgot
- 2:22:43about. And I had met Christine and Jacob when I was on the road.
- 2:22:46I don't know how the officer, the detective got my name other than
- 2:22:52maybe or he saw on the message where Christine tried to set me up.
- 2:22:54Okay, so now we're seeing and I think we can believe these texts that
- 2:23:00Christine was texting Freddy that guy, I want to fix you up on a
- 2:23:05night out with Natalia. Wow. Wow Wow. So what is this August
- 2:23:13twenty twelve, so she would have been nine or eight years old. This
- 2:23:20is before she even moving into an apartment, right, But that was the
- 2:23:26year that the judge had determined that she was twenty two and not eight or
- 2:23:35nine at the time. But still, even if we believe that Christine thought
- 2:23:43that Natalia was twenty two, do we think that Christine would, as a
- 2:23:50mother try to be tender for her own daughter. I don't know, or
- 2:23:58I guess the way that people I think would interpret this, which might be
- 2:24:03the top hypothesis, is that, well, what would be the motivation?
- 2:24:07Because if we don't think that Christine was trying to help Natalia, you know,
- 2:24:13because it's hard to imagine this being in a mother's head, but well,
- 2:24:18I want my adult daughter to have a good time, so I'm gonna
- 2:24:22look because I think she reached out to him. She reached out to Freddy.
- 2:24:28Christine right reached out to Freddy. So we don't believe that then,
- 2:24:31was she trying to get Natalia abused, like that was the intent? She's
- 2:24:37that psychopathic, I've seen that before. Or Christine wanted to take part in
- 2:24:43it. I've seen that before too, Or she was trying to set Natalia
- 2:24:50up as evidence of like, look she's an adult, look what she's doing,
- 2:24:54or something like that. I don't know, but my goodness, what
- 2:24:56are we seeing? The details this story are in a few years they need
- 2:25:05to make a whole other, longer documentary and gather more information because every one
- 2:25:09of these details's like what, Okay, So I took a break and visited
- 2:25:16with my wife, and I got her watching this thing. Every time we
- 2:25:22see each other, like did you see that? Oh my god, like
- 2:25:26that thing? Oh my god? Yeah, this is and this is season
- 2:25:28one because I think there's still more to the story, so I guess we'll
- 2:25:33get to season two whether but I didn't take the bait now reply from me.
- 2:25:39I just am like, oh, give me shivers to think that anybody
- 2:25:43would even remotely do that. I don't go there, and I think that
- 2:25:46people do go there need to have their balls chopped off. It just really
- 2:25:50is disgusting. Now it raises this question. I hate to do this,
- 2:25:54but is there some evidence that Freddy was into that sort of thing or one
- 2:26:00or did do that. That's right because but because it seems weird that a
- 2:26:07mother would just randomly go I don't know. I mean, something is seriously
- 2:26:16wrong. I don't know what is wrong, but something is seriously wrong.
- 2:26:24She tried to send Italia up with Freddy Gill. There's something else that Freddy
- 2:26:31told us, Michael, that's a very serious accusation about you. I think
- 2:26:37it's our obligation to show you this. Okay, So apparently they informed him
- 2:26:41that there were texts saying that she and Freddie confirm this, that Christine was
- 2:26:50trying to set Natalia up with Freddie Gill when when she was when Natalia would
- 2:26:56have been eight or something, and he seems flabbergasted by that. Maybe he
- 2:27:05knew, maybe he didn't. I don't know. And now they're about to
- 2:27:07tell him something about allegations against Is this when we're gonna hear because we saw
- 2:27:11that. I can't remember what it was with some reference to how Talia would
- 2:27:18proposition him or something. I'm not gonna pay attention. I truly don't care.
- 2:27:24I gotta be honest. My thoughts are I'm apprecious. And now I'm
- 2:27:28thinking, so the sexual abuse that is possibly there for Natalia given the behaviors
- 2:27:35we saw when she was living in the apartment, did it not happen when
- 2:27:39she was prior to being in their house? Did it happen when they were
- 2:27:43in the house? Did something happen? Who knows? Obviously possibility? And
- 2:27:48was that text from Christine evidence of what was going on there? That the
- 2:27:54because golly, oh, it's just it's just too much to imagine. But
- 2:28:01did Christine was this a pattern? Was she sex trafficking her own adopted daughter?
- 2:28:09I mean, my god, no, it's just let's not told me
- 2:28:15in a series of messages, Natalia ruined her life in so many ways.
- 2:28:20Christine basically said that Natalia no guys, MIC's off. Look, I don't
- 2:28:30want to talk about this part at Yeah, well they didn't show us.
- 2:28:33I don't know why they didn't show us. It sounded like they're hitting in
- 2:28:39a direction like what I was suspecting. But that's just speculation. All when
- 2:28:48I testify in the trial of Christian Barnett, I'm going to be doing the
- 2:28:52right thing, telling the truth. I guess I'll see you guys in court.
- 2:29:01So we're at the end of the episode, so I guess this is
- 2:29:03a teaser for season two. So we don't know what he was going to
- 2:29:07say. It could be what I was speculating, it might not be,
- 2:29:11And even if it was stated by him, it's just something that Christine said.
- 2:29:16And given everything else we heard about Christine, can we believe something that
- 2:29:22Christine would say as Christine apparently is trying to set Freddie up with Natalia,
- 2:29:31And even if she thought that Natalia was an adults, A lot of questions
- 2:29:35there, and so it's just hard to know, or is it pointing in
- 2:29:43a legitimate direction? Is there other evidence that Michael was abusing her, was
- 2:29:52abusing Natalia. You know, it's possible. It's not unheard of. Of
- 2:29:56course, the things that Christine and Michael had said that I've done is a
- 2:30:01lie. It was all copied off the movie Orphan. Ukrainian Girl, Russian
- 2:30:07Girl. Check Orphan. Check all this crazy stuff, standing at the end
- 2:30:13of the bed with a knife. Check. That's why I want to do
- 2:30:18this. I saw during the first season of the documentary a reference to this
- 2:30:24movie. But I don't watch horror movies. It's not my thing. Sorry
- 2:30:28to all you horror fans out there. I love things that are horror ish,
- 2:30:33like the movie which I love that movie, or Midsummer I love that
- 2:30:37movie. That kind of thing, you know, it's sort of like horror,
- 2:30:39but not the kind of quintessential horror I imagine. Orphan is like kind
- 2:30:45of more quintessential horror. Anyway, So I heard that. But I've recently
- 2:30:50been learning from some of y'all and others that there's a serious allegation or a
- 2:30:56serious speculation that the parent saw the movie Orphan in two thousand and nine and
- 2:31:03then attempted to recreate it by finding a child from Russia or Ukraine who fits
- 2:31:11the bill and then proceeded to create a whole storyline a bunch of lies or
- 2:31:16manipulating the child into exhibiting some of the behaviors. And I find that to
- 2:31:22be fantastical. It's possible, and this story has a lot of fantastical claims
- 2:31:28and facts, so it's possible, but it doesn't seem likely to me.
- 2:31:35That's such a huge thing to do. I mean, why would someone do
- 2:31:41that. They are much easier ways to get attention, if that's why they
- 2:31:45were doing it, right, So there's that. Now. Do people make
- 2:31:50bad decisions in life? Yeah, absolutely, But I've never heard of a
- 2:31:52case that was in that ballpark. Maybe one exists, but that'd be hard
- 2:31:58to believe. But possible, And this, that and a third. But
- 2:32:03then you're going to come into that apartment that y'all dropped me often and pretty
- 2:32:11much tried to murder me. I just want people to know. So I
- 2:32:16don't think we heard anything along those lines, because the first season didn't ask
- 2:32:22her her side of the story, So it sounds like she has some bomb
- 2:32:26to drop regarding an allegation that the parents tried to murder her. It's true,
- 2:32:33that I told everybody that I'm twenty two years old, but Christine literally
- 2:32:39trained me to lie. That's what makes it worse, the fact that it
- 2:32:46had to come from me and they could use that against me, like,
- 2:32:50oh, but you said it. Yeah. This is starting to look akin
- 2:32:54to something like Munchausen's by Proxy, right, where you have a parent who
- 2:33:03for some reason is getting the child to lie or present in a way that
- 2:33:11is a deception, whether it's with Munchausend getting a kid to act like with
- 2:33:18Gypsy Rose, that the mother forced Gypsy Rose to act like she couldn't walk,
- 2:33:24for example, in addition to a whole so I did a whole deep
- 2:33:26dive on that a while back. So if you want to listen to that
- 2:33:30or watch the documentary, it's pretty good. I think there's a new one
- 2:33:33that I haven't watched. But similar to that, you have a mother allegedly
- 2:33:39think wanting to get rid. That's my best guess is that the mother adopted
- 2:33:46Natalia, at least mostly in good faith. I can't know that. I
- 2:33:50don't think that's a popular opinion, but it would be unusual if it wasn't
- 2:33:56this, So at least that's just my top hypothesis there. So the mother
- 2:34:01adopted her in good faith and found that it was very difficult and also was
- 2:34:09seemingly again with the other allegations about the brother's behavior, she had no way
- 2:34:16of coping with this emotionally as a parent and started to become abusive and might
- 2:34:24have even felt bad about it, or at least alarmed, at least worried
- 2:34:28about the criminal implications if she were caught parenting Natalia. I don't know,
- 2:34:35there's a lot of guesses here, but at some point the mom wanted to
- 2:34:39get rid of her, and maybe Michael was involved in this too, But
- 2:34:43at least if we just think about the mom and then the mom's thinking,
- 2:34:46well how do I get rid of her? And maybe influenced by the movie
- 2:34:50Orphan I don't know, but probably just grasping its struss, you know,
- 2:34:54like the allegation regarding at the creamery the farm place with the electric fence,
- 2:35:00and it could have been that the mom just saw that as an opportunity,
- 2:35:05was you know, because they're being told the way the documentary told us,
- 2:35:09like you know, she's at the creamy with creamery with a family and the
- 2:35:15staff there saying okay, they're electric fences. You gotta be careful. Da
- 2:35:18da da, And from my knowledge, it doesn't kill humans. I grew
- 2:35:22up kind of in that direction. I grew up just outside of Seattle,
- 2:35:26and there were electric fences that we would urinate on. In the seventies,
- 2:35:35we didn't have Xbox, so we had to find some way to entertain ourselves.
- 2:35:39So it was either that or eating, you know, daring your friend
- 2:35:43to eat a slug or a worm or something. You know, so sometimes
- 2:35:48he did one, sometimes he did the other. I guess. We also
- 2:35:50would climb trees and fall out of them occasionally. Anyway, So you know,
- 2:35:56from my knowledge, I don't think they're designed to kill people. That
- 2:35:58would be kind of a hazard. You know, they're there to be strong
- 2:36:01enough to be painful when livestock bump into it, right, and they don't
- 2:36:05need to kill people. But anyway, So, but I could imagine the
- 2:36:11staff exaggerating just to make sure people stay away from it. It's like,
- 2:36:15it's no joke. Don't play around with it. You know, it could
- 2:36:16really seriously hurt you, might even kill you or something. Now, having
- 2:36:20said that, don't take my advice on that, I don't know, don't
- 2:36:24walk up to don't pee on electric fence just because I said that we dared
- 2:36:28our friends to do it. Maybe it does kill you. I don't know,
- 2:36:31but I'm guessing there are part conditions or something that could result in death.
- 2:36:39The point is that speculation. The mom here's that it says, ooh,
- 2:36:43opportunity and then says hey, the rest of the family go off,
- 2:36:48and then Christine and Natalia are sort of buy it. Natalia is saying I
- 2:36:54can't walk because my shoes are hurting, I'm bleeding or something. You know,
- 2:36:58that was santalias story. You know, we could imagine that Christine's like,
- 2:37:01Okay, what if I make a big scene and the staff come over
- 2:37:05and the police are called, and I'll say that she tried to kill me,
- 2:37:09and it at the very least, I can use this in an overall
- 2:37:13campaign to make a case that she's a danger and I can get rid of
- 2:37:16her. And then all that is to say that eventually she figures out it's
- 2:37:22all speculative that maybe a better campaign is if I brainwash the child to say
- 2:37:28a bunch of things constantly, and maybe that will help so I can get
- 2:37:33rid of her. Right And then they stumble upon the age thing and run
- 2:37:39with that and then that ends up working. So you could see how a
- 2:37:43parent who is struggling and has issues and maybe a compromised sense of empathy,
- 2:37:52and you can see how a parent like that might go down a road like
- 2:37:56that. Unfortunately, don't know what happened in that house. They tortured me.
- 2:38:07I was abused. Christine is the real monster. Michael is an accomplice
- 2:38:13to the monster. Okay, that's interesting phrasing. She's saying that Christine is
- 2:38:20the monster and Michael was an accomplice to the monster. Yeah, yeah,
- 2:38:26yeah, because he went along with everything that Christine said. And we could
- 2:38:33see that if it's true, which we can't know, at least that it's
- 2:38:37true enough what Michael was saying that he was abused and intimidated by Christine,
- 2:38:43that he was actually another victim and was going along with the parenting and maybe
- 2:38:52even perpetrated the abuse as well. But wouldn't have done that unless he was
- 2:38:56being coerced or controlled or or something that does happen. It's sometimes hard to
- 2:39:03picture that when it comes to men being in the victim role, but it
- 2:39:09absolutely happens, and we know that now. Could someone who was a legit
- 2:39:16accomplice to abuse of a child make an excuse by saying that they were a
- 2:39:22victim. Yeah, it's just one of those things that we might not ever
- 2:39:26know. We probably will never know. That's what I did. One time.
- 2:39:31Christine told me, She's like, I'm gonna show you what's going to
- 2:39:37feel like if you do something wrong. I'm a pepper spray you. Christine
- 2:39:45told me to keep my eyes open and it's just pepper spray. Yeah that
- 2:39:52Yeah, who knows. But given everything we heard from a lot of other
- 2:40:00sources, most notably Jacob, the oldest son, who didn't say anything like
- 2:40:05this, but did say did indicate some abusive behavior from Christine, and was
- 2:40:13heavily alluding to the fact that he was only talking about a small amount of
- 2:40:18what he had seen. We could imagine this being true. And yeah,
- 2:40:24yeah, I as a therapist, of course, have heard about countless accounts
- 2:40:30of abuse, both from adult clients telling me what they went through as children
- 2:40:35and from the children themselves having recently been through the abuse. And I've heard
- 2:40:41it from the abusive parents. You know. I would treat perpetrators and they
- 2:40:46would tell me eventually what they had done. Some perpetrators would say it with
- 2:40:52pride, So there was that. But after a while in this field,
- 2:40:56and if you work in the field you know this too, that you start
- 2:41:00to get a sense for a spectrum and these kinds of things, because on
- 2:41:05one hand, you're like, well, pepper spray, it's temporary, it's
- 2:41:09awful, but it's not like breaking an arm or causing unconsciousness. But it
- 2:41:16is the markers of that behavior. At least to me, on my spectrum,
- 2:41:22this is top twenty percent types of abuse that you could do to a
- 2:41:28child. It's calculated, it's emotional as well. You know, it's one
- 2:41:33thing for a parent to strike out at a child, like the older child
- 2:41:39is about to take the younger child's toy and the parent says no, you
- 2:41:46know, and strikes a child. That's not good. It's illegal to stop
- 2:41:48that. But as a child, there's a likelihood of like, oh,
- 2:41:52well, there's a cause and effect and it's not good that I was hit.
- 2:41:56But at least there's some logic to it. For this. This appears
- 2:42:01that Christine was saying, you will lie to the public and to authorities,
- 2:42:07and if you don't, then this is what I'm going to do to you
- 2:42:11and it's calm, And what it says is, you know, because like
- 2:42:16the parent who just strikes two minutes later, they might actually feel we're more
- 2:42:20so of the very least care and show care for the child. But when
- 2:42:24you have this kind of behavior as a child, it's rational to conclude this
- 2:42:28person does not love me, they might not be capable of loving anybody,
- 2:42:33and they're thinking of ways of how to harm me. That is a very
- 2:42:39very what do I say? It's unnerving and I couldn't do anything about it.
- 2:42:50She literally made me sit there for like ten minutes and so I can
- 2:42:58finally go wash out. Also, another detail that I think, in my
- 2:43:03opinion, lends to the credibility of the story is that if you were trying
- 2:43:09to gain sympathy, I think you would typically come up with a different lie.
- 2:43:15And even then it's still hurt. She didn't care. Yeah, And
- 2:43:20that's the kicker, like I was saying earlier, is that the parent just
- 2:43:26didn't care. Again, abuse is wrong, but if you have an overreactive
- 2:43:33parent who also loves the children and is occasionally abusive and also loves and is
- 2:43:41warm or shows love and preference for the child, at least most of the
- 2:43:46time, or at least some of even just some of the time. Then
- 2:43:48the child at least can bank on that. But to have a parent that
- 2:43:54might not care about you at all and is out to get at you is
- 2:44:01yeah, it's And then knowing where she came from before she even came to
- 2:44:07the family, you know, you just imagine the hopes that she had being
- 2:44:11adopted and thinking, Okay, maybe this is a family because the initial phase
- 2:44:16of their relationship was probably very positive, and you know, she's probably a
- 2:44:20little hesitant but hopeful. And then to have a parent like Christine would be,
- 2:44:26you know, would be the final nail on the coffin in a lot
- 2:44:28of ways. And so you could see someone just giving up. So I'm
- 2:44:31just going to get a knife, and I don't know, I'll just scare
- 2:44:35these people. Christine was going to push the envelope as far as she could
- 2:44:43to try to break Natalia. So Christine starts putting words in Natalia's mouth.
- 2:44:48This is what you tell people, this is what you say. So my
- 2:44:54skeptical mind is always trying to evaluate what I'm being told. And we have
- 2:45:00an edit, we have the noise and the music, and we have a
- 2:45:03legal expert who is hired by the documentarians I believe, who was not there.
- 2:45:09She has heard accounts, but she's stating it as if it's fact.
- 2:45:13The mother told her to say this. We don't know anything. Is it
- 2:45:18likely? It seems likely, but we don't know. We just have to
- 2:45:22say I don't know. That's what makes these situations just so heartbreaking, because
- 2:45:28if we knew, then we could know what to do right. But if
- 2:45:31we don't know, then we just don't know. And that's why we need
- 2:45:37juries, and we need investigations, and we need people there so they can
- 2:45:43observe. There was little ID tag inside of her bag when we adopted her
- 2:45:50that had the original family's information on it. I have never met them in
- 2:45:54person. I have no idea why they would say they never met the Chikanes
- 2:46:00when they literally met them at the adoption agency. Like I remember how to
- 2:46:05wait for who knows how long while? Did you okay? Now, memories
- 2:46:11are weird for all these individuals, particularly for Natalia because she was very young
- 2:46:18and traumatized. And I haven't even talked about dissociation and associative identity disorder,
- 2:46:22which is a common occurrence with her background. So when you suffer from conditions
- 2:46:31related to or actually our dissociation. Then a hallmark is that your memories are
- 2:46:37compromised, maybe even altered severely. So there's that for Michael. You know,
- 2:46:43when you have a lot happening, it's sort of like for us in
- 2:46:46the pandemic, which was four years ago, almost exactly when it started.
- 2:46:50You know, there's so many things that happened, and you might be reminded
- 2:46:54of things like, oh, yeah, I totally forgot about that. Yeah,
- 2:46:58I remember when we all were desperate for toilet paper. I mean,
- 2:47:01actually I just remembered because in my head, I'm like, we weren't really
- 2:47:05impacted by that, but we were. I think there was a time in
- 2:47:09our house when Stacey and I were like, Okay, we've got two roles
- 2:47:13left and we don't know when we're going to get another one, so you
- 2:47:16know, start thinking of other options or conserve. You know, recycle were
- 2:47:22used, not just talking. And so when there's a lot of chaos,
- 2:47:28particularly when it's not a typical situation, and you know every day or every
- 2:47:31minute there's a there's a new drama, you know, which it sounds like
- 2:47:35that's what it was like. It all just you don't get a chance to
- 2:47:41download or vent and talk about it, so you can kind of lock in
- 2:47:45some memories and it just sort of breezes past you. So for the parents,
- 2:47:50their memory would absolutely be affected by that. Also, we have individuals
- 2:47:54that have motivated reasoning to remember in a certain way, whether it's subconscios or
- 2:48:00conscious. Also, I am assuming that Christine and Michael have trauma history themselves,
- 2:48:09which can lead to dissociation, but more commonly, it can just lead
- 2:48:13to a lot of memory distortions. To Connie's talk to the Barnettes, like
- 2:48:18that's literally like how I remember it, like Plaina's day. So well,
- 2:48:24she she could be remembering accurately, but you know, this was a long
- 2:48:33time ago for her and she was, according to my notes, four years
- 2:48:39old. You know, you could see someone blending some memories together. But
- 2:48:43I don't know how relevant this is exactly, because even if Michael is just
- 2:48:46flat out lying about not having ever met that Chaconi's I don't see how that
- 2:48:52really other than it just points to the fact that Michael might be at the
- 2:48:56very least an unreliable narrator. There was a lot of good memories there.
- 2:49:01But then as like after a while, I okay. She's talking about the
- 2:49:05first family she was adopted by in New Hampshire, the Jaconi's I believe is
- 2:49:11what they're called, and she is painting a picture of an ideal life with
- 2:49:18them. One time, me and the little boy hero, who were just
- 2:49:26playing, I landed on Bureau's arm wrong, and I just kept saying I'm
- 2:49:33sorry, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to hurt you. But then Gary
- 2:49:37came in and he just started yelling okay. Who knows it could have gone
- 2:49:43down the way she says. Of course, she was very young at the
- 2:49:48time, so her memories could have been altered, or she could be misremembering.
- 2:49:54There's also a possibility that she even knows in this moment as she's telling
- 2:49:58us story that this is not the entire truth, that she might have actually
- 2:50:05targeted the boy and hurt him, maybe seriously, maybe even more seriously than
- 2:50:09she's saying, and the parents did indeed suspect or even knew that she did
- 2:50:16it on purpose. I mean, given everything else we heard, that wouldn't
- 2:50:18be unusual. But it's possible that everything we heard was was a lie.
- 2:50:24But typically if you have a family that adopts a child. I think in
- 2:50:31the general public, if you're not in this world, I think, you
- 2:50:37know, if I was to ask the general public, you know, what
- 2:50:39percentage of adoptive parents are adopting in bad faith? They are adopting to abuse
- 2:50:45the child, or to neglect the child, or something like that. I
- 2:50:48imagine. I don't know, but my anecdotal sense is that people would put
- 2:50:52that out about like thirty to forty percent or something like that, maybe ten
- 2:50:54percent. And the fact is is that it's a very rare thing. I
- 2:50:58don't know the statistics off the top of my head, but I can't tell
- 2:51:03you. I've seen the research and anecdotally it's less than one percent. There's
- 2:51:07so many other ways, one as a if you're a person who wants to
- 2:51:11harm people, there's a lot easier. I mean, it's so hard to
- 2:51:15adopt a child. It costs a lot of money, it takes time,
- 2:51:20There's all these hoops you have to jump through. It's really really annoying,
- 2:51:24too annoying really, because every day that passes, children are left in need
- 2:51:31of adoption, and if they're in an orphanage, or in a foster home,
- 2:51:35or in another country where they're being passed around. Then that child is
- 2:51:41incurring a lot of trauma that isn't going to help anybody, particularly the kid,
- 2:51:45but also the adoptive parents. So it's really hard to adopt kids,
- 2:51:50and so on average, in all likelihood that Chaconi's did adopt her in good
- 2:51:54faith and are very altruistic people at least, you know, at least part
- 2:52:01of them is very altruistic. They also could be horrible people in addition to
- 2:52:03that, but you know, there's an altruism there, and they adopt her,
- 2:52:07and so for that family to be very motivated to get rid of her,
- 2:52:15so to speak, then there's a good chance that a lot of things
- 2:52:20happened that reversed their altruism. And given everything we heard, there's a pretty
- 2:52:26good chance, you know, I'd put my money down on the speculation,
- 2:52:31the hypothesis that she repeatedly exhibited behavior that was a danger to other people and
- 2:52:39a concern. So that's just now there's a possibility that that didn't happen.
- 2:52:43But you know, she's telling a story now, she might remember it this
- 2:52:48way, so she might not be lying technically. And then as he was
- 2:52:50walking away, I was crying, and I was mad, I said,
- 2:52:54I hate you. After that, Gary, I get like he didn't like
- 2:53:03me anymore, Like that's what I felt like. It felt like he hated
- 2:53:07me. And the other thing the think is that she is a very young
- 2:53:11child with some arrested development perhaps who is seeing the world through that primitive lens,
- 2:53:20if you will. I mean, most kids that age are going to
- 2:53:24be that way anyway, but you imagine she might be a little delayed in
- 2:53:26that way given our history, and we all understand that kids don't see the
- 2:53:31world objectively or as objectively as they could if they were older. Then one
- 2:53:39day I remember, and it's just funny how this documentary, the editors,
- 2:53:46the producers, it's manipulative because the first time in season one, when we
- 2:53:52were introduced to the new Hampshire family, they showed this really dark, foreboding
- 2:53:56driveway up to the house and they were playing the evil music. Because in
- 2:54:01that time of the documentary they were trying to make the Chacone seem like this
- 2:54:07this really mysterious, almost like a horror movie sort of family. But because
- 2:54:13they're trying now to depict the family as this great family and this ideal situation,
- 2:54:20they show us this image. So and this could literally not even be
- 2:54:26their house. It could just be an airbnb that they decided to film.
- 2:54:31So I just want to point that out. It's like there's a lot of
- 2:54:33that kind of manipulation in this documentary. And coming in my room, she
- 2:54:39told me, she was like, I'm not going to be your mom anymore,
- 2:54:43but I will always love you. Okay again, So her story,
- 2:54:46the narrative in terms of the edit is that she innocently accidentally hurt her brother
- 2:54:54and then the dad yelled at her and then they gave her away. Is
- 2:54:58that possible? Yes? Is it likely? No, this little girl is
- 2:55:03available for adoption. There were three little people. Now, I want to
- 2:55:07be clear. Do I support what that Chacone or Chacone family did. No,
- 2:55:15I don't know the circumstances. Is it possible that the New Hampshire family,
- 2:55:20the parents were way too quick to abandon Talia. Yeah, it is
- 2:55:26possible. You know, that does happen sometimes, So you know, I'm
- 2:55:28just saying that it's just hard to know what happened. Many many children,
- 2:55:37not just Jacob, and in each one of them, I see this little
- 2:55:41spark. Michael alleged that Christine thought she had turned Jacob into a genius,
- 2:55:50and so by adopting a special needs child, she could show that she could
- 2:55:56do this again. Yeah, well, so this individual as saying that,
- 2:56:00Michael said that he speculated that that was the motivation for Christine, which does
- 2:56:09hold up. It is coherent. There could be a lot of other reasons,
- 2:56:13some of which we might not be able to brainstorm, but that is
- 2:56:18interesting as a speculation. It does fit nicely into all the other allegations that
- 2:56:24are being presented to us. I mean, it doesn't fit super neatly,
- 2:56:28but it's a good piece of the puzzle because with the allegations it looks as
- 2:56:35though Christine has you know, I've been saying that when you I'll just say
- 2:56:41for myself, when I would treat perpetrators of child abuse that exhibited this degree
- 2:56:48of cruelty towards children, it wasn't because they had an anger management problem.
- 2:56:52It was because they had a personality problem as a result of early childhood relational
- 2:56:56trauma themselves, and their defense that they developed, perhaps early in life as
- 2:57:05the parent when they were young, was that they were going to compensate somehow.
- 2:57:09And one of the ways that personalities can compensate is by having an approach
- 2:57:13to life that says, I'm going to be the best at everything, and
- 2:57:18I'm going to signal that all the time, and I need everyone to see
- 2:57:22me as awesome, because then maybe that gives me some shred of worth and
- 2:57:26maybe I'll get a little bit more attention. I won't get all the attention
- 2:57:30in love, because they'll see me as this superior, elevated person, but
- 2:57:33that's better than nothing. And that's developed when they're very young. There's a
- 2:57:37lot of other things associated with it of perhaps being modeled very cruel behavior,
- 2:57:43maybe cruel parenting behavior, also impaired empathy and paired ability to know what other
- 2:57:50people are feeling, impaired ability to know what they're feeling. And then grow
- 2:57:56up and you get married and you start having kids and start to know what
- 2:57:58happened with her own kids, because we haven't heard much along those lines,
- 2:58:03but you know it's possible, even given this profile, this you know,
- 2:58:07heavily speculated profile, that her parenting of her biological kids were, you know,
- 2:58:13not one hundred percent optimal, but workable. And then she has this
- 2:58:20oldest child who is this super genius and they're getting a lot of media attention,
- 2:58:28and she's starting to feel like, oh, I can get some of
- 2:58:31that supply, that's some of that self esteem that worth that attention that I
- 2:58:39am always chasing, and I'll lean into it. I'll go to the interviews,
- 2:58:45and when I go to the interview, I will claim that he's a
- 2:58:50genius because of me. And not only that, but I work with a
- 2:58:54lot of kids, and I am very good, you know, And you
- 2:58:56can imagine that a lot of people, without any indication otherwise, would at
- 2:59:03the very least entertain those ideas, if not believe her, because they worked
- 2:59:07with they had some sort of foundation that worked with a lot of kids.
- 2:59:11I think that you know, kids had autism. Not sure, but and
- 2:59:16you know, it's hard to hate a parent that does that sort of thing,
- 2:59:18right, So you can imagine a lot of accolades, a lot of
- 2:59:22attention, a lot of like, oh my god, you're so awesome,
- 2:59:24and I've finally arrived. I finally have a way to get that attention that
- 2:59:31I have been seeking my whole life that I never got when I was young,
- 2:59:35and that attention equates to safety. And so then how do I continue
- 2:59:43going down that road? You know, I've already done it with one kid.
- 2:59:46You can imagine that she might turn to her other kids and maybe it
- 2:59:48didn't work out with that, who knows. And then she starts to work
- 2:59:52with the foundation, to work with kids that she barely knows, you know,
- 2:59:56because you'd only see them every once in a while. That's not really
- 2:59:58working on She's like, well, if if I adopt a kid, and
- 3:00:01maybe another part of her also wanted to spread love around and help someone,
- 3:00:05you know, those all these things can exist within one person. And then
- 3:00:11the adoption goes forward. But you know, a good portion of the motivation
- 3:00:15is this selfish motivation and dependent on the adopted child actually being some sort of
- 3:00:22genius or some sort of notable change, right, And I guess that would
- 3:00:26maybe lead the mom to want to adopt a child that was particularly in need.
- 3:00:31Okay, so then adopt the child and she starts to try to reform
- 3:00:37the child. You know, I guess it's sort of like my fair Lady
- 3:00:41situation, right, And it doesn't work well. In fact, there's a
- 3:00:46lot of behaviors presented that are very concerning. And this is interesting, I
- 3:00:52mean, just going with a lot, this is just a whole narrative I
- 3:00:54don't want to do with this documentary is fairly manipulative, to say, the
- 3:01:01music and the talking heads who are all just speaking hearsay and speculating, especially
- 3:01:07the legal expert. She just says things as if they're fact, when at
- 3:01:13least what we're being presented, it's not a fact. It's a possibility,
- 3:01:18but it's not a fact. At least in the initial phase of this second
- 3:01:20season, they seem to really be going after Michael, so they must have
- 3:01:24determined like, Okay, everyone hated her, so now we got it,
- 3:01:26or you know, you just imagine the producers having those conversations. But and
- 3:01:31there's not a lot to react to, frankly, because they're not really giving
- 3:01:33us any any data. It's just a lot of people saying speculations or Natalia
- 3:01:39telling stories about when she was four, so it could be true. And
- 3:01:45I don't fault Natalia for having an idea that she remembers things. You know,
- 3:01:50she might actually remember things. But anyway, getting back to my highly
- 3:01:56speculative story here, then it's not working out, which is terrifying. You
- 3:02:01know, to people with these personality disorders, they don't wake up in the
- 3:02:05morning and say he he he. I'm going to enact my personalize or their
- 3:02:09personality disorder, and their their reactivity is out of desperation. They are given
- 3:02:16their relational traumas. They've developed a schema that informs their the way they perceive
- 3:02:22things and thus the way they feel about things, and thus the way they
- 3:02:24react to things. So for them, the things you see that are problematic
- 3:02:31and harmful to other people, in all likelihood, it's coming from a legit
- 3:02:35terror that they're going through. Now they might not actually be in danger,
- 3:02:39but they feel like it's dangerous because of the schema and the lens they developed
- 3:02:43when they were growing up. And so this is all just telling a story.
- 3:02:46I have no idea if this true, but we could imagine a situation
- 3:02:50like this where it's like, oh no, I'm not going to be able
- 3:02:52to get my sense of superiority or my sense of specialness here because she's not
- 3:02:58easy, my fair lady. Not only that, but she has a lot
- 3:03:03of behavioral problems. And if that gets out, if that is known to
- 3:03:07people, then that will really and not only will I not gain any kind
- 3:03:15of specialness in the world, but I'll lose specialness. And I've worked so
- 3:03:18hard to get this amount of respect and compliments from people. And the more
- 3:03:26I say this, the more I kind of makes it. But you know,
- 3:03:28it's just speculation. And then she goes on this campaign she's obsessed with
- 3:03:33I need to find a way out of this, so I need to blame
- 3:03:37the kid, and so I start spreading rumors, I start making things up.
- 3:03:43I might even influence my husband to believe things, coerce him into remembering
- 3:03:46things. Who knows Michael's complicitness or brainwashedness. It's hard to say. Maybe
- 3:03:54we'll get some information as we before, but didn't imagine Christine or someone in
- 3:03:58her shoes with this supposed issue would think, Okay, I have to get
- 3:04:03out ahead of this, and one way to do that is to make her
- 3:04:09older so I can get rid of her. And also I can tell everyone
- 3:04:11that she's a con artist. So the fact that I didn't turn into a
- 3:04:15genius is not my fault because she's the evil one, and a lot of
- 3:04:20people with these personal disorders, they did have what one could call evil caregivers.
- 3:04:26So for some of these parents, they might be projecting, they might
- 3:04:30be displacing, transferring onto their kids. That does happen almost all the time
- 3:04:35really with all of us, but particularly people with personally source. And then
- 3:04:39you can imagine a person in this situation would then do everything that they could
- 3:04:45to make the kid actually tell others, because if it comes from her,
- 3:04:48then I'm off the hook, right And then you know, the coaching.
- 3:04:52And then as soon as you can get rid of the kid and the kid
- 3:04:54is in an apartment, then you know, so long person. Even though
- 3:05:01there's a thought in the mind a line of the kid, the person might
- 3:05:03actually be a nine year old child that I'm putting into an apartment. But
- 3:05:07you know, that's like Kryptonita can't be around that because that will scar my
- 3:05:13image. So I don't know, you know, what to do about that.
- 3:05:16And then I'm just moving on with my life and I'm just gonna focus
- 3:05:18on my oldest son, who is legit a genius. That kind of thing.
- 3:05:22You know, you can imagine that being a thing right as I say
- 3:05:26it out loud. It's possible. So Michael's speculation about that, of course,
- 3:05:31he would have seen a lot of things and heard a lot of things
- 3:05:35that would have informed that speculation. Of course, he's motivated given everything that's
- 3:05:41happening the divorce, the legal proceedings, the internet, all this hoopla around
- 3:05:46this family. He's motivated throw under the bus, so who knows. He
- 3:05:52alleged that when that didn't turn out just the way that Christine wanted, That's
- 3:05:56why Natalia didn't really sit into Christine's narrative. Christaine was writing a book,
- 3:06:05which was ultimately called The Spark, about the academic success of her oldest Okay,
- 3:06:11it's interesting, I mean it all kind of fits right in the interview
- 3:06:13on CNN, she was talking about a spark, So she's trying to make
- 3:06:20it about her right now, you know, maybe she has a legit things
- 3:06:22say my dog's whining that she actually was instrumental in helping to find that spark
- 3:06:30in her oldest child. It seems likely, honestly, or at least,
- 3:06:33that she was there to support her oldest son and help him in a lot
- 3:06:39of ways. You know, it seems absolutely possible. It would be weird
- 3:06:41if you had a successful kid in academia that didn't have supportive parents that were
- 3:06:48right there. But yeah, so you just imagine, you know, the
- 3:06:50book and a CNN interview and the language, the coining phrases, The Spark
- 3:06:56that kind of thing, writing a book which which was ultimately called The Spark,
- 3:07:01about the academic success of her oldest son, Jacob. So here's the
- 3:07:05timeline regarding the book the Burnettes Adoptedtalia. Okay, the book is called The
- 3:07:11Spark, a mother's story of nurturing genius. Yeah, talk about centering yourself
- 3:07:18at this story. And it's akin to the famous family vloggers who have been
- 3:07:26alleged or discovered to have exploited their children for their own narcissistic need. So
- 3:07:35yeah, but yeah, if I just heard this part of the story and
- 3:07:39not anything else, I wouldn't necessarily suspect Christine of doing something exploitative. You
- 3:07:46know, there's something wrong with writing a book and celebrating what you've done or
- 3:07:50spreading what you've learned or something like that. So but when you put it
- 3:07:54all together, especially the way they're presenting it, in twenty ten, Christine
- 3:07:58signs a book in twenty eleven, and the book is published in twenty thirteen.
- 3:08:03So this whole time that Natalia is part of the Barnett household, Christine
- 3:08:09is really working hard to maintain her image. Now, look, we know
- 3:08:13Christine was no stranger to making money off her kids. She has made a
- 3:08:18ton off of Jacob. Okay, highly speculative, but at the very least
- 3:08:24it gives us something to hold on to, because I have been wondering what
- 3:08:30is at least a part of the fuel that would cause these events to happen,
- 3:08:35the adoption to the abuse pretty quickly, and then just the full court
- 3:08:41press trying to make sure that everyone understands that she's a Natalie's a monster,
- 3:08:46and that she's an adult. In two thousand and nine, Jacob's Plays the
- 3:08:52daycare center that Christina and Michael Rand made over one hundred thousand dollars with the
- 3:08:58spark, she made at least a half a million dollars just on the book
- 3:09:01deal. And wow, yeah interesting. I mean it fills out that speculative
- 3:09:07story that your one, your career, your livelihood, your whole image depends
- 3:09:15on your image. But two, the fact that it even got to that
- 3:09:20point, right that now you know a parent who creates a foundation that helps
- 3:09:26people and is doing a lot of work for it and getting donations and maybe
- 3:09:33a book deal. You know, they're not evil necessarily, But if we
- 3:09:37go with the allegations against her, even just some of them, it's like,
- 3:09:41well, did she really care about Natalia or anybody? So, how
- 3:09:48does that make sense? And then you're looking for answers and this provides a
- 3:09:54potential answer. And so my point is that it fits into this narrative that
- 3:09:58we have the speculative narrative that she was driven not necessarily by actually trying to
- 3:10:05help the world and make the world a better place. At least that wasn't
- 3:10:07the primary drive. The primary drive was that she wants to be seen as
- 3:10:13special and interesting and she found an opportunity because she had a kid who was
- 3:10:18very good at math. That was an opportunity for her to capitalize on.
- 3:10:22Again, even if a parent did that, it wouldn't necessarily make them a
- 3:10:26bad parent, as long as they also had other parts of personalities that were
- 3:10:31helpful as a parent, like love and empathy and that kind of stuff.
- 3:10:33So it is interesting as a detail though. And then there were donations.
- 3:10:39That's enough to build an empire. There was also a movie deal in the
- 3:10:43works. Rosamund Pike was supposed to play Christie. Christine had a web presence
- 3:10:50of some kind where she was influencing people to pay her amounts of money.
- 3:10:56Wow. That Yeah, this is way bigger than I thought it was even
- 3:11:01when they first started talking about it. Yeah, wow, Right, you
- 3:11:05could see a huge motivation. And then if Natalia say was a challenge and
- 3:11:13you're on the up and up, then as a as an influencer, as
- 3:11:16an author, you think there would have been anything wrong with saying that,
- 3:11:20right, Like, you're not going to necessarily lose your quote unquote empire if
- 3:11:24you say, hey, you know, I'm learning a lot of new things
- 3:11:28and let me share with you, and I'm going to write another book about
- 3:11:31how difficult this sort of thing can be and how naive was about you know,
- 3:11:35you can still go down that road. But it looks as if,
- 3:11:41according to the narrative that were being shown, that she did not want to
- 3:11:45go down that road for fear of being seen as perhaps not perfect. Right.
- 3:11:50Instead, she had to eliminate the evidence. She had to destroy it.
- 3:11:54She had to burnt the whole thing down, this book that she wrote,
- 3:11:58a fraction of the earnings which were supposed to go to her, and
- 3:12:05because the like I'm a pretty big subject of the book, if I mean,
- 3:12:09I'm on the cover, So like there was a fraction of money that
- 3:12:13was supposed to go to me so well, I've already been over so many
- 3:12:18stories on this channel regarding this. I think is what he's getting at is
- 3:12:22he either got very little money or no money at very least not as much
- 3:12:28as what was promised to him. And that is a very common story.
- 3:12:33It goes back over one hundred years. It's why we have laws in Hollywood
- 3:12:37that protect children who are in TV shows and movies. There are no laws
- 3:12:43in the United States and maybe around the world that protect children from these kinds
- 3:12:46of situations where they're being used exploited, either in a book or on reality
- 3:12:54TV or on a family YouTube channel, and there need to be laws about
- 3:12:58that. Absolutely when you look at it, it's just a no brainer.
- 3:13:03And you know, like if you have a child actor ten year old boy
- 3:13:09in a movie, there are regulations and laws that put money aside for that
- 3:13:16ten year old. It goes into a trust and then when the ten year
- 3:13:18old is eighteen or something at some older age gets access to that money.
- 3:13:22Because there are so many stories and situations in which the children get none of
- 3:13:31the money and the parents or the step parents take take everything, which of
- 3:13:35course is not fair. And so we're seeing another example of that, which
- 3:13:39also lends itself to this speculative narrative that the documentary is pieced together that I'm
- 3:13:46elaborating on, because if you truly care about your children, you don't need
- 3:13:52a lot to tell you to share the you know, sure, you put
- 3:13:56it into a trust fund or something, but you don't promise and then not
- 3:14:01do it. He was you know, trusted with with you know, making
- 3:14:05sure that that money was spent appropriately, and you know that it was spent
- 3:14:13right. I didn't get a sent of it, so he didn't get any
- 3:14:16of it. Yeah, Yeah, And you know, Jacob comes across as
- 3:14:20a credible person, so of the people being interviewed that have first hand accounts
- 3:14:28of things, you know, Jacob is believable. So yeah, on the
- 3:14:33order of two hundred thousand that was supposed to go to me but didn't.
- 3:14:37Wow, that's a lot more than I even thought. So it sounds like
- 3:14:41with the book deal, six hundred thousand dollars or maybe some other situation,
- 3:14:46that a sizeable percentage. You know. In my head, I'm like,
- 3:14:50well, yeah, maybe it was a few thousand bucks, because you could
- 3:14:54see a parent saying, yeah, I'll give you some money, you know,
- 3:14:56and the parent thinking if I almost three thousand dollars to my kid,
- 3:15:01they're going to be their mind's gonna be blown by that. But two hundred
- 3:15:05grand and who knows. It's just speculation that with someone with the personality issue
- 3:15:13that I have been describing in front of others, they might want to be
- 3:15:16magnanimous and show how altruistic and awesome they are by promising it. But then
- 3:15:22when it comes time to actually enact to that promise, the person never actually
- 3:15:28intended on doing that. They were just saying that why didn't you leave?
- 3:15:31That's the best question ever I tried, And this is these answers aren't going
- 3:15:39to be what you're looking for to an agree. But I tried to leave
- 3:15:43her no less than ten times. I ended up in the hospital regularly over
- 3:15:48it. Why did you marry her? That's all the question. Okay,
- 3:15:54so they're having a conversation. By the way, I've been watching and not
- 3:15:56necessarily reacting, but I'll just spread Glynn. There's a lot of fluff in
- 3:16:01the second season, so there's not really a lot of reason to watch the
- 3:16:05scenes its entirety, but there have been a lot of scenes demonstrating that Natalia
- 3:16:11was a child, a young child when she was adopted. And it's boring
- 3:16:16because I feel like that was already known to us as an audience from the
- 3:16:24previous document. I mean, the quote to quote evidence that she was much
- 3:16:28older was spotty. Even when they were telling us, you know, like
- 3:16:33her forehead was big or that, you know, they would show these pictures
- 3:16:37of her taking selfies with like duck face, and the judge said that,
- 3:16:41well, if you stop growing, that means you're eighteen, and since she
- 3:16:45stopped growing four years ago, then that must mean she's twenty two what And
- 3:16:48so it seemed very questionable in the beginning, And then of course other evidence
- 3:16:54came out. So there's a lot of scenes where they were going over like
- 3:16:58dental records and everything, and and she's like, yeah, I think we
- 3:17:00all know that. But anyway, then there was evidence that Michael, even
- 3:17:07though he probably knew that Natalia was a young child, he continued to lie
- 3:17:15and say that she was an adult. So I don't know what that says.
- 3:17:18It could say that he So I'm starting to gravitate around a perspective that
- 3:17:24both of the parents are to blame and both of the parents are responsible.
- 3:17:28Christine is perhaps more responsible for more of the abuse and neglect, and that
- 3:17:37Michael in part was going along with it because he was abused maybe or coerced.
- 3:17:46And I'm guessing that prior to him even meeting Christine he has traumas that
- 3:17:52result in him trying to be a pleaser. I don't know that there's not
- 3:17:56a ton of evidence of that, but I could see that being the case.
- 3:18:00Often if you have an abusive person, especially if they have a long
- 3:18:03term relationship, the other person will be a pleaser or codependent or dependent or
- 3:18:09something. So if we go with the allegations that Christine is indeed to some
- 3:18:18degree abusive, if not as abusive as she appears to be, then it
- 3:18:22would be unusual if he didn't have the mirror image of that personality. So
- 3:18:28that doesn't let him off the hook, right If you are very people pleasing
- 3:18:33in a codependent or the opposite, if you're very dependent as an adult,
- 3:18:39that doesn't let you off the hook. If you are observing abuse to your
- 3:18:45children, especially if you're also doing it sometimes participating in it sometimes for sure.
- 3:18:50So there's that, And I don't even know if legally, if you
- 3:18:52were able to demonstrate that you were a victim of ongoing spousal abuse, if
- 3:18:58you would legally be left off the hook from that as well, morally might
- 3:19:03we let people have the hook? I think there are cases like that,
- 3:19:05as you know, it's similar to being in a cult where you're you're terrified,
- 3:19:11you've been broken down, you don't have any agency anymore. So there's
- 3:19:16that. But have has that been demonstrated to us sufficiently? I would say
- 3:19:20no. Is it possible that that was happening, Sure, but it's hard
- 3:19:24to know. But I'm gravitating toward the perspective that he might have also had
- 3:19:31a similar drive, maybe not nearly as much as Christine. This is all
- 3:19:35speculative, of course, but that he wanted that accolade to be seen as
- 3:19:41a wonderful parent that's perfect and saintly. And you know the fact that he
- 3:19:46in the beginning of the documentary is talking about how we had all the Lamborghinis
- 3:19:50and the nice cars, and the humongous house and five thousand square feet you
- 3:19:54know, just you know, can you have a Lamborghini and not be narcissistic?
- 3:19:58Sure? By it just all kind of potentially fits together, and that
- 3:20:03he had similar motivations around the adoption, he had similar hopes for his wife,
- 3:20:11you know, that he would be secondary to that, but wanted that
- 3:20:16as well, that that secondary shine of the light would go on him,
- 3:20:22and also wanted to get rid of Natalia when it was clear that Natalia wasn't
- 3:20:28gonna be a genius and might even be a you know, a bad mark
- 3:20:33in their parenting record. And from the stories that even Natalia tells, when
- 3:20:39push came to shove, he would help her. He would help Natalia,
- 3:20:45and that Christine, according to Natalia, was was just universally cold or abusive,
- 3:20:50whereas he at times would be warm or accommodating or helpful to her minimally
- 3:20:58at least in terms of the descriptions. That doesn't let him off the hook,
- 3:21:01right, But it does, by contrast, make him not as bad.
- 3:21:05So I'm sort of gravitating around a multi factoral reason as to why he
- 3:21:11did what appears to be what he did. Some of those factors absolutely hold
- 3:21:18him responsible but provide some explanation, and other factors might actually let him off
- 3:21:26the hook, depending on how you look at it. So there's that,
- 3:21:31and I think as he is talking to Natalia and he knows he's being filmed.
- 3:21:37I think he really wants some validation. I think the way that he
- 3:21:41talks, it's so off putting, you know, it comes across it's very
- 3:21:46fake and exaggerated, which doesn't help his credibility, it doesn't erase his credibility.
- 3:21:52I think actually a fair amount of time he is telling the truth.
- 3:21:56I can't know, but I think that there's a good possibility, you know,
- 3:22:01just because someone has historic behaviors. And you know, I've treated many
- 3:22:07histrionic people I specialize in personally sours, so I can tell you that they,
- 3:22:13especially when they're under the microscope, they will have a lot of this
- 3:22:18dramatic, over expressive way of talking. And if they're not particularly good at
- 3:22:24it, which not all of them are, they'll come across as though they're
- 3:22:28lying or they're greatly exaggerating almost all the time, and yet they're often telling
- 3:22:35the truth. So can they lie? Yeah, history onic people probably are
- 3:22:39more likely to lie. I haven't seen their research on that recently. But
- 3:22:41anyway, so he is now trying to explain to her. I think what
- 3:22:46he's looking for is, hey, I was a victim too. But I
- 3:22:50think what would be a better approach, especially to me as a viewer,
- 3:22:54would be if he said, look, I looking back, I did some
- 3:23:00bad things and I'm so sorry to you, Natalia. We never should I
- 3:23:05should have I should have stood up to Christine. I also did bad things
- 3:23:09myself, and I'm sorry. But as I say this, it's like,
- 3:23:13well, then he would go to prison potentially. So it's like, but
- 3:23:18I guess there's a version that he could say that would not implicate him criminally.
- 3:23:24So you know, something along those lines and say, you know to
- 3:23:28Natalia, because he hasn't. Really this isn't a meeting between two politicians.
- 3:23:33This is a meeting between an adoptive parent and a child that was absolutely thrown
- 3:23:37away in a very cruel way. So you just think that he would sit
- 3:23:41down and say, Natal, I just want to say from the outset that
- 3:23:45it looks like you were a kid, and I have to say I probably
- 3:23:50should have accepted that I at the time. I'll get into it, but
- 3:23:56I let you down. I was your I am your dad, and I
- 3:24:03should have protected you. I should have been a better parent. I know
- 3:24:07that now, and I'm just so, you know, just something like that,
- 3:24:09and then, because that's even if you go with the allegations that Natalia
- 3:24:16was highly problematic towards everybody in the home. She was a child, so
- 3:24:24it's like, you're the adult. So I think he would say something like
- 3:24:26that, and then he would say and I've done a lot of thinking.
- 3:24:30I've been through a lot of therapy, and I realized that I have problems
- 3:24:33with my personality that results in me deferring to other people a lot and living
- 3:24:39in a constant state of fear. And that's on me, and I guess
- 3:24:41my upbringing. So there's that problem that's all independent of everyone else. Now,
- 3:24:48the other part of this is that Christine we all know Da Da Da
- 3:24:50Da Da, and I was terrified of her, and over time it sort
- 3:24:56of broke me down to just be totally focused on on her. And you
- 3:25:01know, I'm not going to go into details because you're I don't think you
- 3:25:05need details. If you want details, I guess I could give some of
- 3:25:07them. But that doesn't let me off the hook, really, because I
- 3:25:11should have known better. I should have gone to therapy, I should have
- 3:25:15consulted with other people. You know, I have two eyes. I saw
- 3:25:18what was happening, and I didn't do anything, And you know that's on
- 3:25:22me, and frankly, I'm terribly ashamed about it and I can't sleep at
- 3:25:26night because of it. Yeah, something like that, I think my eyes
- 3:25:31would be I mean as I say that out loud. I often will do
- 3:25:33this kind of role play. It's like, you know, what would be
- 3:25:37something that I would hope I would say if I were in those shoes,
- 3:25:39or what would I like to see? And it always seems absurd as I'm
- 3:25:43saying it, because we almost never see these kinds of displays from people,
- 3:25:50whether it's an apology video or a documentary or a reality TV show. Sometimes
- 3:25:56we do, sometimes you do for sure. But anyway, so other things
- 3:26:01that we learned was that there was another family. There was a third family
- 3:26:05that was interested in adopting Natalia from the Checkcones or Chacones from New Hampshire,
- 3:26:13and they almost adopted her before the Barnetts did. But according to the legal
- 3:26:20expert, the Chacones found out about a CPS report that had been filed against
- 3:26:28them. The Chacones so presumably in New Hampshire, the local Child Protective Services
- 3:26:33reached out to the family and said, hey, we heard an allegation and
- 3:26:39the family suspected that the new family that wanted to adopt Natalia had actually made
- 3:26:46the CPS report, which is kind of a logical suspect, right, because
- 3:26:50you get it, especially if you have been protective of information getting out of
- 3:26:56your household, which I don't know if they had done, And now you
- 3:26:58send Natalia, and if Natalia was potentially prone to lying or manipulating people,
- 3:27:07and that's why you're actually wanting other people to adopt her, she is now
- 3:27:11staying with another family and lo and behold all of a sudden a CPS report.
- 3:27:15You know, it would be a logical suspect or logical suspicion. And
- 3:27:20the family said, no, we didn't call CPS. We don't what you're
- 3:27:24talking about. But Chacones were not necessarily convinced, apparently, and so they
- 3:27:28denied this other family the opportunity to adopt Natalia. And you just think if
- 3:27:35this other family, or you know, any of the families that were highly
- 3:27:41considering to adopt Natalia, if they had adopted Natalia, how things how different
- 3:27:46things would have been. Mike, Natalia had some behavioral problems, you know,
- 3:27:50could be probably honestly, but they wouldn't have been exacerbated and exaggerated and
- 3:27:58compounded by the abuse that allegedly the Barnett's committed against her. But I'm wondering
- 3:28:03if this is the main course of this second series, of this sit down
- 3:28:09between the two people, And I don't know how comfortable I am watching this,
- 3:28:13because this is something that I might be a part of as a therapist,
- 3:28:18and it's fairly intimate and fraught. Natalia has a big reason to hate
- 3:28:26him. Even if Natalia had a lot of behavior problems, it doesn't really
- 3:28:31matter. She was a kid and she was campaigned against pretty maliciously to make
- 3:28:37her into an adult and then kick her out. You know, even if
- 3:28:41he wasn't the ringleader of that all, he was an adult, he could
- 3:28:46have done something and not only did nothing about it, but he actually participated
- 3:28:50in it. So she has a lot of reason to be angry. He
- 3:28:54might have a lot of reason to try to make the case that he wasn't
- 3:29:00as responsible. Maybe he was only sort of responsible. But he thinks if
- 3:29:07I admit sort of responsibility, then people will think that I'm responsible for everything.
- 3:29:11But I'm not responsible for everything. He could also just be in complete
- 3:29:13denial of his responsibility. Why did you marry her. That's a whole question.
- 3:29:20Before you do that, let's respect God in this place. Okay.
- 3:29:26So that individual is Antoine Mans who is a reverend or a bishop and a
- 3:29:33religious leader, and he is the new adoptive parent of Natalia. I'm sorry,
- 3:29:41let's not use curse words. I know you probably you talk like this
- 3:29:45on a regular basis. Maybe, but we try to keep a clean environment,
- 3:29:50so this is really hard. I don't rest. We'll respects boundary no
- 3:29:56more than you asked Michael not to be himself. I don't. So then,
- 3:30:01Terrence, this other person talking off camera is his lawyer. Michael's lawyer,
- 3:30:07the lawyer that defended him during the criminal case in twenty twenty was the
- 3:30:13trial, I'm not sure. Twenty twenty three, I'm not sure. But
- 3:30:16so now we have advocates for both of them going going at each other.
- 3:30:20So the criticism to Michael is that he was swearing, and I actually I
- 3:30:24don't remember him swearing, but I'll take their word for it. And so
- 3:30:28he's jestizing him saying not to swear swearing. Plus, I was raised Christian,
- 3:30:37and swearing isn't you know, it's it's against culture. But to say
- 3:30:45a swear word isn't inherently, at least in the belief system that I had
- 3:30:50growing up. God isn't that sensitive. Let's put it that way. Don't
- 3:30:56Christian see your one? I he's his old man. You understand that God
- 3:31:05is in control. You understand that God is in control. So now these
- 3:31:09two randos are fighting and he's saying, I'm out of here. Yeah,
- 3:31:16yeah, I don't blame him. Honestly, it's like this, this is
- 3:31:20raising attention. It's already tense, it's already hard, so I see something
- 3:31:26happening. This is getting out of control. He might even have had urge
- 3:31:30to like be an intermediary, and then he's thinking, why why am I
- 3:31:35doing this? I don't know. It's also possible that he didn't know that
- 3:31:39Natalia was going to be hostile, at least kind of, and he's using
- 3:31:43this as an excuse to get out of it. I don't know. I
- 3:31:46try, I try, I try, I try, I try, I
- 3:31:52try, I try try. This is what we might call we can use
- 3:31:58this as a jumping off point for histrionic behavior. So when children are neglected
- 3:32:05and abused, there's a set of available defenses that children naturally gravitate towards either
- 3:32:13due to their own disposition or trial and error or modeling or something and one
- 3:32:20of the defenses. And sometimes it depends on the kind of abuse that's happening.
- 3:32:24But if you are being harmed and you're not being attended, you're not
- 3:32:30being given enough attention, then the child feels unloved. The child feels unsafe,
- 3:32:37because we seem to have evolved as a species to be highly driven towards
- 3:32:45having enough attuement and attention and love from our caregivers when we're very young,
- 3:32:50and it seems as though a mechanism to drive us to make sure that we
- 3:32:54want that and signal for it and make sure that we get it so that
- 3:32:58we can and stay alive, because you know, if we're not very noticeable
- 3:33:03to our parents, they might leave us behind and we might die. So
- 3:33:05apparently an evolved emotional response is that if I'm not getting attention as a child,
- 3:33:11and this is everybody, If I'm not getting attention as a child,
- 3:33:13I need to lean into I need to make myself more noticeable. I need
- 3:33:18to cry louder, or I need to be louder, or I need to
- 3:33:20tug at their pant leg it's pay attention. And the motivation isn't of just
- 3:33:26like mild interest. It's terror. It's fear. You know, you'll see
- 3:33:30it when your kids if you go around the corner. You know, I
- 3:33:33remember this. When I was a kid, I would fall asleep in the
- 3:33:39car. Still do sometimes as a passenger. And I remember I would fall
- 3:33:43asleep in the car at the age of three, and my family wouldn't want
- 3:33:48to wake me up because it's like I was taking a nap, so they'd
- 3:33:52go inside the house and I'd wake up in the car and the driveway by
- 3:33:54myself, and I would just start wailing. And part of it is just
- 3:33:58being in a crank mood when you wake up and just kind of disoriented,
- 3:34:01like why I'm in the car. I mean, I remember that happening at
- 3:34:03least once. And you know it's normal, right, we understand we're crying.
- 3:34:09I was crying out of terror, out of fear. So, oh
- 3:34:11my god, And why do I feel it even though I know there are
- 3:34:15just a few feet away in the house. You know, It's like,
- 3:34:18but it just this drive to get that attention. And so when his children
- 3:34:22were not getting that attention and or we're being abused. Then we have this
- 3:34:26drive. It's fear based, just like terror. It's just utter terror,
- 3:34:31and the child is not getting their attention. One of the available defenses is
- 3:34:35to become very very noticeable, and this becomes neurological to the point where emotions
- 3:34:43are felt bigger. It's not drummed up. You know. The child doesn't
- 3:34:46invent or exaggerate their emotions. They might kind of at times, but over
- 3:34:50time the brain and the neurous system become oriented actually to feel emotions more acutely
- 3:34:58in a bigger way, in a more intense way, particularly if they're emotions
- 3:35:01that are related to garnering attention, like you're in danger, or you are
- 3:35:09telling a story, or you're happy. Just laughing, you know, can
- 3:35:13be a form of expression that can get attention from other people. And so
- 3:35:18for these kids, they learn somewhat consciously, but mostly unconsciously, and then
- 3:35:24it develops neurologically into feeling emotions bigger, and signaling emotions bigger, and just
- 3:35:31signaling in general. Even if they're just telling an unemotional story, they have
- 3:35:35to have like lots of noticeable communication styles. You know, they become very
- 3:35:41good at They could tell just the most boring story, but it will be
- 3:35:45very particularly if they're really good at it and they are smart enough to figure
- 3:35:48out how to develop this skill. And again it's mostly subconscious. They become
- 3:35:52extremely good storytellers and you'll be hearing them say just a regular story, just
- 3:35:58like, oh my god, this is so interesting. And when they're angry
- 3:36:01at you, they're very angry at you. When they're happy with you,
- 3:36:03they're very happy with you. There's also a bit of borderline in there as
- 3:36:07well, in that there's some all or nothing, there's some black and white,
- 3:36:11there's some I hate you, I love you kind of stuff happening.
- 3:36:16It's not the hallmark, but it does come along with it lack of a
- 3:36:18connection to self emotional regulation issues. It all, most perconise stores have these
- 3:36:24kinds of things, and so for the individual they when triggered in particular,
- 3:36:28they will have this extreme motivation to express themselves emotionally in a very dramatic,
- 3:36:35very over the top manner. And I don't know, I can't evaluate someone
- 3:36:41over the internet or on a TV show about a personality disorder, but this
- 3:36:46is one of the displays that would be indicative of historic personality sort and I've
- 3:36:50done whole deep dives on historyonic So just if you want to know what might
- 3:36:56look like in a situation like this, this is what it might look like.
- 3:37:00I try, I try, I try, I try, I try,
- 3:37:05I try. So you would think if he was wanting to leave,
- 3:37:09he would just walk out. But you also add to this of I'm suffering
- 3:37:15and you're fighting against me, you know, because the production they don't necessarily
- 3:37:18care about his feelings, because if as a human being, I would just
- 3:37:22let him go. This is this is rough. But you're a production crew
- 3:37:26and you're being paid to get footage, and you know, so you can
- 3:37:31fill the minutes of a documentary, and you have a boss that might get
- 3:37:35on your back if you just let him walk out the door. So you're
- 3:37:37going to do everything you can. Hey, you know, but you know
- 3:37:41you can't put hands on but you can use all your skills, you know.
- 3:37:43I've become aware that producers of reality TV slash documentaries they I'm guessing are
- 3:37:54hired partly on their demonstrated skill to be able to convince people to stay on
- 3:38:01camera and do things on camera. It's not just that they're good at developing
- 3:38:05questions or figuring out a place to shoot and how to communicate to the camera
- 3:38:11personnel, but actually how to influence the subjects. You know, So the
- 3:38:16producer's going against him and he's not getting validation, and he's also in a
- 3:38:22rough spot because he knows that, you know, this is a very shameful
- 3:38:26situation. I imagine that he does have a heart, and that a lot
- 3:38:33of shame is emerging for him in this moment. You know, he's trying
- 3:38:35to make a case that he was a victim as well, but he knows
- 3:38:39not everyone sees it that way, particularly Natalia, and he probably doesn't necessarily
- 3:38:43see it entirely that way himself either. So you know, there's a lot
- 3:38:46of emotions. I tried, I tried, and I think another personality arena
- 3:38:52that I have been wondering about him is what we might briefly call just people
- 3:38:58pleasing, we might call dependent. Also, there's overfunctioning and codependent, but
- 3:39:05at the very least a deferral to other people and desperately trying to please others.
- 3:39:11Maybe in addition to the histrionic defense, there was another defense of just
- 3:39:16trying to be as pleasing as possible and as helpful as possible and putting yourself
- 3:39:22aside. And so when you're being asked to do something, Hey, I
- 3:39:26want you to be in this documentary, you know, because that's another part
- 3:39:30of this. It's like, why did he agree to being the documentary to
- 3:39:33begin with? There's not a reason. He probably overall loses by being in
- 3:39:39the documentary, but he did it anyway. You know, Christine isn't in
- 3:39:43it because she probably figured it was not a good idea, you know,
- 3:39:48So for him to be asked to be in a documentary, he might just
- 3:39:52feel like, well, I want I'm used to doing what other people want
- 3:39:56me to do, which would fit well with an abusive person, if we
- 3:40:00believe that Christine was terribly abusive. And then he's being asked by the producer
- 3:40:03you know, hey, stay, and it really is a conflict for him,
- 3:40:07right There's this is a visceral reaction. He's having to get out of
- 3:40:13the door the producer, and then all these things come in and then the
- 3:40:16histrionic part comes in of just like you're not paying attention to me, and
- 3:40:20and that's what the experience was like for the one year old, two year
- 3:40:24old, three year old child, where it's you know, there's an anger
- 3:40:26in there sometimes obviously where you're not paying attention, you're not hearing me,
- 3:40:31and so you can imagine someone getting bigger and louder and repetitive. It's sort
- 3:40:37of like the way a child would speak, I want to go home.
- 3:40:39I want to go home. I want to go home. I want to
- 3:40:41go home. It's not the way an adult would speak, right, even
- 3:40:45if they were distressed. It's a it's an interesting presentation. God, why
- 3:40:54try, I try? I try, I try, I try. Why
- 3:41:01that's why? That's fry. Let me let me talk to you, Let
- 3:41:07me talk to you, Let me talk to you. Yeah, yeah,
- 3:41:13yeah. I just I've had clients like this family. I mean not exactly,
- 3:41:20but I've had clients like this, and I just feel not great about
- 3:41:28a documentary about them being shown to everyone. I feel like they need some
- 3:41:33talking head on this documentary, just say like, look, let's all look
- 3:41:39at the bigger picture here, or even ask questions about his childhood and his
- 3:41:45parents. Doesn't let him off the hook, but it, you know,
- 3:41:48provides some context around this. Also, there's been up to this point and
- 3:41:54almost think no discussion or extremely minimal discussion of how attachment works. And how
- 3:42:03early development works for someone like Natalia. You know the way this whole thing
- 3:42:07is playing out, and of course it works on the audience better if you
- 3:42:11if you have a scapegoat, right you have at first? You know,
- 3:42:15it's like, basically there's two chapters to the story. You have Natalia as
- 3:42:18a monster, like the movie Orphan. It's like, WHOA, how weird?
- 3:42:22Is that scary? It's like a horror movie. But really the parents
- 3:42:24are a monster and Talia is this innocent person. Oh my god, the
- 3:42:28parents are awful parents. I hate awful parents. And then you know that's
- 3:42:33it. You just walk away. But those those perspectives aren't typically the kinds
- 3:42:37of perspectives that clinicians and experts will have when they actually assess and help families,
- 3:42:43Like this is way more nuanced. So I don't know, I just
- 3:42:46I just feel bad for everybody, I guess, particularly Natalia. Come here
- 3:42:50for a second, No, I can't hear speak to you for a seconds.
- 3:42:58And then the person who caused this whole problem, and now Natalia,
- 3:43:05poor Natalia's has her hands over her face. So the fellas like, I
- 3:43:09want to talk to you. I mean, if he really wanted to help
- 3:43:13he could say, look, I'm sorry, I won't say anything anymore.
- 3:43:16Maybe that would help. But some sort of power play. What's going on?
- 3:43:22I got it? I got it, Mirke. We'll come here for
- 3:43:24a second. Man, I'm not here to degrade you. Hey, come
- 3:43:28here, I'm not here. God would not know what happened. Well yeah,
- 3:43:39yeah, this is starting to look more and more like reality TV and
- 3:43:43not a documentary. I mean, what's the difference. I suppose, But
- 3:43:48yeah, no, listen to me. If there was a god, he
- 3:43:52a lunny eyes, you would have he loves you. All I wanted was
- 3:44:00just to talk to him. Let me die. What what is he saying,
- 3:44:03let me die? You would have let me regard if there was a
- 3:44:09god, he would have let me die. Let me die? Is he
- 3:44:13referring to one of the suicide attempts he had? Is this another manipula or
- 3:44:18is this a manipulation to make people feel sorry for him? I don't know.
- 3:44:24Just let him go home. I'm not a fan of when people it
- 3:44:28feels paparazzi ish, right that you provoke, Like why did these other people
- 3:44:33have even have to be in the room. Why couldn't you just have a
- 3:44:37few production people, and then the subjects. Why did you know? They
- 3:44:43probably didn't predict this would happen, But you certainly don't have to follow them
- 3:44:46outside, let away from me. He shouldn't have talked to my dad that
- 3:44:50way. All my dad asked was that he didn't cuss, just have some
- 3:44:56My dad has the right to ask that, just like I. I don't
- 3:45:05understand. And all this is over Michael supposedly he swore. I don't even
- 3:45:13remember him swearing. I guess I could go back and watch, but he
- 3:45:18said a swear word as he was struggling. And all of this is because
- 3:45:24of that many great, yeah, yeah, and you know the pain of
- 3:45:35all these individuals, particularly in Talia, it's just a lifetime of pain.
- 3:45:39It sounds like things for the past few years have been going well with the
- 3:45:43man's family, which is just awesome. I am very happy about that.
- 3:45:50But just a lifetime of pain, just a lifetime of trauma and abandonment and
- 3:45:56mistreatment. Yeah, yeah, it's yeah. I I hope she's on the
- 3:46:05road to recovery. All right, Well, that does it for that episode.
- 3:46:07Everyone out there, please take care of herself because you deserve it,
- 3:46:11You really really do.