Latest / Microsoft Cloud IT Pro Podcast / Episode 363 – Hibernation is for more than bears
Transcript
- 0:03- Welcome to episode 363
- 0:06of the Microsoft Cloud IT Pro Podcast
- 0:09recorded live on November 30th, 2023.
- 0:12This is a show about Microsoft 365
- 0:14and Azure from the perspective of it pros
- 0:17and end users where we discuss a topic or recent news
- 0:20and how it relates to you.
- 0:22It's wintertime in the us.
- 0:23So this week we figured we'd talk about hibernation only
- 0:26instead of animals.
- 0:28It's a new feature coming to virtual machines. That's right.
- 0:31You can now hibernate some VMs to save a few bucks instead
- 0:34of deprovisioning them.
- 0:36We also discuss a feature going away
- 0:38as Microsoft has officially announced the end
- 0:41of SharePoint atoms.
- 0:42Finally, as we're in this holiday season,
- 0:45we're once again raising money for girls who code.
- 0:47Check out the link in the show notes
- 0:49to join us in our second annual campaign
- 0:51to support the organization.
- 0:55I know you don't watch football,
- 0:56but I watched Michigan beat Ohio State over the Thanksgiving
- 1:00weekend here in the US and thoroughly enjoyed it.
- 1:02So I'm sorry to any Ohio State fans that listen
- 1:05to the podcast , but
- 1:06- Should let me know.
- 1:07I would've worn my sports ball shirt today.
- 1:09But uh, yeah, no sports ball shirt,
- 1:11- No sports ball.
- 1:12Well we don't need to talk about sports ball.
- 1:14We can talk about other stuff today.
- 1:17Do you have one you wanna start with?
- 1:18You highlighted some things. I've got some things.
- 1:20We have some ignite to e stuff.
- 1:23We have some AI stuff that
- 1:26apparently is blown up on LinkedIn
- 1:27and everybody's been playing with.
- 1:29Now. Where should we start , Mr. Scott? Yeah,
- 1:32- Let's do some uh, newsy stuff.
- 1:35I think. I think I have a couple. Okay.
- 1:37One of these is a pre-post during Ignite announcement.
- 1:41I, I don't even know when these things fall
- 1:43at this point anymore.
- 1:44It's all over the place for me.
- 1:47That being said, VM hibernation, did you see this one? I
- 1:51- Did have seen it in Azure portal.
- 1:53I haven't used it. I think this was ignite
- 1:55because I think we like mentioned,
- 1:57hey this is out there on the Ignite episode.
- 1:59We just did but we spent no time talking about it
- 2:02'cause I don't really remember much about it.
- 2:04Yeah, but hibernating virtual machines, this is not like
- 2:08before you could shut down
- 2:09and not deprovisioned,
- 2:10you could deprovision a virtual machine
- 2:12whether you got built or not.
- 2:13Now we have a hibernating, a virtual machine. Yeah,
- 2:16- I think this is a good capability
- 2:20to bring forward.
- 2:22There's a couple dimensions here.
- 2:24One is you just need to save money on your compute always.
- 2:28I think all of us are in this mode
- 2:31and I've certainly got to the model
- 2:33of more ephemeral compute in everything I do.
- 2:36Like I find myself constantly these days like spinning up
- 2:40and deleting Databricks clusters, Kubernetes clusters, like
- 2:44all the things, it's all become very ephemeral to me.
- 2:47Even potentially things that should be living
- 2:50and be online more than they should be.
- 2:52So I'm fully on board with the servers, this cattle thing
- 2:55and the ephemeral nature of compute to save money.
- 3:00And then like you said in the past,
- 3:01it's been shut down your virtual machines to save money
- 3:04or delete your virtual machine,
- 3:06delete your VM profile which effectively shuts it down,
- 3:10but then maybe do something like retain the disks to keep it
- 3:13around so you still have the OSS
- 3:14and data diss and things like that.
- 3:16So that's all well and good,
- 3:18but that is not the same as hibernation, which lets you
- 3:22not only shut the VM down to save money
- 3:25but also suspend the memory for that virtual machine to disc
- 3:30so that when you come back from a hibernation event just
- 3:33like you would in VMware or HyperV
- 3:35or any other hypervisor that's out there,
- 3:38effectively your full kit comes back online just as was.
- 3:42And that's really what this capability is.
- 3:44This is fully deallocate your compute so
- 3:48that you're shutting down your VM to save money effectively.
- 3:51Like it's a location
- 3:53but it's an extra mode to de location that allows you to
- 3:58persist that virtual machine's memory
- 4:00and suspend it fully down to disc
- 4:03so you retain not only the discs for your virtual machines.
- 4:06So things like your data discs and your OSS disc, all that.
- 4:09You also retain the memory for the state that you were in.
- 4:14But again, this is just like,
- 4:16it's not some nifty new capability.
- 4:17This is in, I don't know, every hypervisor
- 4:20that's out there today.
- 4:23It's just this is now a native Azure capability.
- 4:28It's a little wonky I think at least in this first
- 4:32iteration when it comes to things like support for
- 4:36what can be hibernated and what can't be hibernated.
- 4:38So that's in a couple dimensions.
- 4:40One is things like operating systems.
- 4:43So if you go and look and,
- 4:45and this is all in preview is not
- 4:46production, blah blah blah.
- 4:48That whole disc that that whole disclaimer.
- 4:50But if you go and look at the operating systems
- 4:54that are supported, it's everything on the Windows side,
- 4:56windows 10, windows 11, server 2019,
- 5:00server 20, 20 22, all that kind of stuff is there.
- 5:03That's all good. Linux is a little hairier.
- 5:07I think it's a little spottier. So there's Ubuntu and Dian.
- 5:10There's no support for RL today.
- 5:13I imagine that's gotta be on the roadmap someplace is
- 5:17bringing things like Red Hat Enterprise Linux over to
- 5:20that list of things.
- 5:22And I imagine, hey it's preview that all comes into time
- 5:26as they iterate on the preview
- 5:27and uh, get ready
- 5:28to hit general availability, all that good kind of stuff.
- 5:31So the first one is hey go to go check the docs
- 5:35and see what's going on there.
- 5:37Does this work for what you needed to do
- 5:38with the operating systems that you have?
- 5:41And then the other piece of it is
- 5:43it's only supported on a couple
- 5:45of different virtual machine sizes
- 5:48and only up to it has a a ceiling for the amount of RAM
- 5:53that's allocated to that VM size
- 5:56that it's gonna let you actually go
- 5:57ahead and hibernate through.
- 5:59So it's DASV fives, D-A-D-V-S,
- 6:03V fives, DS V fives and DDSV fives.
- 6:08Anything up to 32 gigs of RAM can be hibernated today.
- 6:11So if you happen to be running on something that says,
- 6:14say goes to 64 gigs of ram, well sorry
- 6:17that one can't be hibernated today.
- 6:20Again, I imagine that gets fixed over time
- 6:24as they get closer to ga.
- 6:27Okay, that's all all ready to go there.
- 6:29- Well and I imagine
- 6:31that there's maybe some technical limitations there
- 6:33because it does say when you're looking through this too,
- 6:37that when you hibernate a vm
- 6:40it signals the VMs operating system to perform a suspend
- 6:44to disc action in the memory contents
- 6:47of the VM are stored in the OSS disc
- 6:50and what these OSS disks are only 128 gigs.
- 6:53I imagine once you start getting up into 64 gigs of RAM
- 6:57and 128 gigs of ram, some of those,
- 7:00what if there's not enough room on the OSS disc for your
- 7:05amount of memory or even I'm curiously it
- 7:08- Is a consideration if
- 7:10- You install apps like some people, let's face it,
- 7:14you should add data disks
- 7:15and install your apps on the data dis.
- 7:16But if you're doing things like IIS
- 7:18and you have it sitting on the OSS disk
- 7:21and your IS logs start ramping up, like I would be curious
- 7:25to try to fill up an OSS disk
- 7:26and then try to hibernate one with 32 gigs of RAM
- 7:29with 10 gigs free on the OSS DIS and see what happens.
- 7:32Because I like to try to break stuff.
- 7:35- the other fun thing that happens here,
- 7:38and this is always, it's always fun to read
- 7:40between the lines to see like why
- 7:42they do these kinds of things.
- 7:43So why bring VM hibernation this late in the game?
- 7:47You would think hey it's been hyper V under the hood
- 7:50effectively for a long time.
- 7:52Now that's a native capability.
- 7:54Like why hold it back , you
- 7:57and I with our little virtual machines, like just going
- 7:59around one Z, two Z um,
- 8:01or even a customer that has a fleet of 10,000 VMs
- 8:05might not be the largest of the large
- 8:08that move the needle when it comes to how much it costs to
- 8:13actually run your service and put things forward.
- 8:15So if you look at this announcement
- 8:16and when it came out, you go
- 8:18and Google binging DuckDuckGo
- 8:20for all the other compute services that rely
- 8:24on Azure compute and deliver compute as a service to you.
- 8:29For example, dev box,
- 8:31we've talked about dev box in the past,
- 8:33Azure Virtual Desktop.
- 8:34We've talked about A VD in the past.
- 8:37At the same time that this announcement came out,
- 8:39a VD dev box
- 8:41and a bunch of these other ones,
- 8:42Citrix has a big deployment on top of Azure VMs.
- 8:46They all came out and said, Hey guess what?
- 8:49Our virtual desktop services all now support hibernation
- 8:52- .
- 8:53- Oh, oh, okay. I see why that's really there.
- 8:56It's maybe not there for us as mere mortals.
- 8:58Hey it's a nice to have
- 8:59and it's a good consideration for us now that it is there.
- 9:02But I think for the most part it's really there
- 9:04to support the desktop as a service provider kind
- 9:08of stuff that's out there.
- 9:09And that could certainly help you in your environments.
- 9:11Like I know you do a VD deployments with your customers.
- 9:14Yep. And potentially that's something
- 9:16that they're interested in along the way. Yeah,
- 9:19- I'm absolutely gonna look at this.
- 9:20Again, one of our deployments, we would run into one
- 9:24of those VM sizes
- 9:25'cause we're doing a VM with 128 gigs of ram.
- 9:28We're trying to cram a bunch
- 9:29of people on one rather than a bunch of small ones
- 9:32with a few people on it.
- 9:33But some of those smaller deployments,
- 9:36this is absolutely interesting.
- 9:38There's some times too, I even use VMs
- 9:40for different client stuff where it would be nice to deposit
- 9:44and be able to come back with that memory state versus
- 9:48shut it down, lose everything
- 9:51and like stuff I'm working on,
- 9:53I have just stuff up in visual studio code.
- 9:55Yeah I save it, I can close it all down, reopen it all.
- 9:58But sometimes it's like just suspend it.
- 10:00- I very much want this for the EVD instances
- 10:05that I get access to through my employer.
- 10:08'cause I, so one of the things
- 10:09that happens in the environment I work in is I can either do
- 10:13my work from employer
- 10:15provided device where it's all MD MD and ready to go.
- 10:18Or in the cases where I'm not, I,
- 10:21I don't have access to an MDM device.
- 10:23Last week here in the US was Thanksgiving,
- 10:25most of us were on vacation.
- 10:27Like I was up in the mountains completely disconnected.
- 10:29Like I didn't take anything other than my personal laptop
- 10:32and an iPad with me, neither of which are md md.
- 10:35So if I had wanted or had a need to do anything at work
- 10:38that way I claimed there was an escalation
- 10:40and I got called in, I wouldn't have been able
- 10:42to do anything unless I could do it through a VD.
- 10:45And in those instances I would very much want like my A VD
- 10:48instances to be suspendable as well.
- 10:50'cause once I'm in one of those sessions
- 10:52and I think it's one
- 10:53of the things like once I've started debugging a thing,
- 10:55like I've got Outlook open, I've got VS code open,
- 10:58I've got Edge open
- 11:00and I've got a bunch of very specifically CUSTO queries
- 11:03or something like that up and running
- 11:05or I'm in like one of the internal
- 11:07telemetry portals or something.
- 11:08I just want all that stuff back.
- 11:09Especially when I get back to work mode and
- 11:12and can log in again.
- 11:14I'm hoping they light it up for us.
- 11:15- Yeah. I'm curious too,
- 11:16you mentioned why not have it right away since it's all on
- 11:18Hyper V but another aspect of this too
- 11:21that I'm curious about is I don't believe,
- 11:26does HyperV suspend to the OSS disc
- 11:29or does it still keep stuff in memory?
- 11:32I feel like when I've used it before
- 11:34and it's been a long time
- 11:36to be fair since I've done HyperV on a physical VM
- 11:38or a physical machine,
- 11:40I feel like even though when I suspend it
- 11:42that machine is still taking up the same amount of memory
- 11:45and it's actually storing the suspended memory
- 11:47and memory versus suspended memory copied
- 11:50and retrieved from the OS disc.
- 11:52I wonder if there's some additional technology updates
- 11:56that kind of went out on the backend to support that.
- 11:58- There might be. I think it's an interesting
- 12:00choice design choice to go with hibernating the
- 12:04by compressing that memory
- 12:05and putting it into the OSS disc versus just side curing it
- 12:08and having it off to the side.
- 12:10And I don't know why that choice was made.
- 12:13Like maybe there's some underlying limitation in, it'd have
- 12:17to be both Windows and Linux, right?
- 12:19'cause it's supported across the board.
- 12:21I don't know what drives those. Like who knows?
- 12:23There's maybe some weird technical limitation.
- 12:25Maybe it's an a cost saving measure for customers like it,
- 12:29it certainly takes away the variability and cost.
- 12:32'cause in many cases you're already paying a fixed
- 12:34size for your discs.
- 12:35Like you're paying for what your provision not what you use.
- 12:38So if you're already paying for 128 gigs then it's a
- 12:41solid cost for you.
- 12:43It's easier for you to project and manage
- 12:45and for you as a customer
- 12:46to control your kind of cogs, right?
- 12:49Your costs of services and what that looks like.
- 12:51I think that all potentially makes sense there and it
- 12:55and is a good like forcing function
- 12:58to, to get it over that way.
- 12:59But yeah, interesting design choice. I
- 13:01- Wonder if it has to do too with, you don't know where
- 13:03that's gonna spin back up, right?
- 13:04Because if you hibernate it
- 13:06and you're deprovisioning it from
- 13:08or locating resources, when you go to un hibernate it,
- 13:12wake it back up, it could spin up in an entirely different
- 13:15rack, an entirely different data center within the region.
- 13:18And if it's in a separate sidecar storage, you'd have
- 13:21to keep track of all that together. You would,
- 13:23- There could be latency there.
- 13:25I imagine there's a way to pull it off, right?
- 13:26Especially in the world of managed disks where Microsoft
- 13:31is hosting the storage account and the VHD for you.
- 13:34They know where all that stuff lives and
- 13:36and they've already got that mapping in place.
- 13:38There's probably some weird trade off in there between cost
- 13:43complexity, friction for customers, friction
- 13:46as a service provider on the Azure side just to light up
- 13:50that capability and keep it going
- 13:52and make sure that it's robust
- 13:53and it works the way you want it to.
- 13:55All that kind of stuff.
- 13:56- So it's not taking a bunch of, I can see cost too.
- 13:59'cause you talk about like 32 gigs of ram.
- 14:01Let's say you suspend a hundred thousand virtual machines.
- 14:05If you're spinning that up in some sidecar blob storage
- 14:07that's going into your storage Scott.
- 14:09And yes I imagine it, I, we don't think of it as much
- 14:14but at that type of scale that could be a lot
- 14:16of extra storage versus to your point,
- 14:19just putting it in OSS disk that's already been
- 14:22planned on provisioned.
- 14:23You're paying for it.
- 14:25There's not extra storage
- 14:27that's being consumed on the side because of it.
- 14:30Yeah it is. It's interesting. And
- 14:31- That's a consideration for you as a customer
- 14:33and I think Microsoft as a service provider, right?
- 14:35Like how do you plan for capacity in that world and
- 14:38and that level of variability.
- 14:40I don't know that you can in the current
- 14:42landscape and how things go.
- 14:44So yeah it makes sense if you peel back the curtain
- 14:46but I don't know, it's like you're a customer.
- 14:48I think you just need to know the way it works
- 14:51and understand that behavior
- 14:53versus understanding like hey here's like the underlying
- 14:56design decision behind it.
- 14:57- Design decisions are just fascinating to me.
- 15:00, that's stuff that interests me.
- 15:02You should, I need to go get a job at
- 15:04Microsoft just so I can.
- 15:05Yeah. See some design decisions
- 15:07- We make them every day trade offs abound.
- 15:11Yeah, I wish everybody could go
- 15:13and uh, I imagine especially like the folks
- 15:15who listen to this podcast like going
- 15:17and working for a hyperscaler in one
- 15:20of the hyperscale services.
- 15:22'cause not every service is a hyperscale
- 15:24service either, right?
- 15:25Like there, there's some that are small, there's some
- 15:27that are medium and there's some
- 15:29that are just like absolutely massive.
- 15:31Like I work in storage in Azure
- 15:33and that's a massive part of it.
- 15:36Compute ISS a big part. Networking's a big part.
- 15:38There's other smaller stuff out there.
- 15:40But like if you can go and work for a big one, whew.
- 15:43I lemme tell you, I've seen some stuff. I
- 15:46- Am sure I would.
- 15:47Again, I would love stories.
- 15:49I don't know that I want stories bad enough to come work
- 15:51for Microsoft yet .
- 15:52But we'll see. Do you feel
- 15:57overwhelmed by trying to manage your Office 365 environment?
- 16:00Are you facing unexpected issues
- 16:02that disrupt your company's productivity?
- 16:04Intelligent is here to help much like you take your car
- 16:07to the mechanic that has specialized knowledge on how
- 16:10to best keep your car running Intelligent helps you
- 16:13with your Microsoft Cloud environment
- 16:14because that's their expertise.
- 16:16Intelligent keeps up
- 16:17with the latest updates in the Microsoft cloud
- 16:19to help keep your business running
- 16:21smoothly and ahead of the curve.
- 16:22Whether you are a small organization
- 16:24with just a few users up to an organization
- 16:27of several thousand employees they want to partner with you
- 16:30to implement and administer your Microsoft Cloud technology,
- 16:34visit them at intelligent.com/podcast.
- 16:38That's I-N-T-E-L-L-I-G-I-N
- 16:42k.com/podcast For more information
- 16:46or to schedule a 30 minute call
- 16:48to get started with them today.
- 16:50Remember intelligent focuses on the Microsoft cloud
- 16:53so you can focus on your business.
- 16:57- So VM hibernation was mine. What do you got? What
- 16:59- Do I got man?
- 17:00I dunno which one to talk about.
- 17:01Let's talk about a small one first just
- 17:03'cause this one's kind of interesting.
- 17:05It's not the new tab. Remember when we talked a while back
- 17:09about Microsoft is gonna start transitioning everything
- 17:11to their own TD under cloud Microsoft?
- 17:15MM-Hmm the first one that I'm aware
- 17:17of is now out there your email if you want to go look for
- 17:22organizational email, this is not personal accounts yet.
- 17:26Personal accounts are still gonna be outlook.live.com But if
- 17:29you're using Microsoft 365, you wanna go check your email,
- 17:33you can now go to outlook.cloud.microsoft and it does work.
- 17:38I did try it. I don't think mail.office.com redirects
- 17:41to the cloud version yet.
- 17:43But if you were looking forward to using that cloud,
- 17:46do Microsoft go check out your outlook.
- 17:49- Interesting. I've been waiting to see when these are going
- 17:53to hit and this one's kind of funny
- 17:56'cause it's Outlook, all the things
- 17:59but the, IT does have a redirect in there
- 18:01for outlook.live.com
- 18:04and getting you over to your MSA kind of stuff.
- 18:09Yeah, I don't know, I don't have a ton
- 18:11of insight into the.microsoft TLD like I would
- 18:16expect you see that used in more places over time.
- 18:20Even outside like the M 365 stack. I
- 18:23- Would think so I think that's the plan. And
- 18:25- Azure land you see a lot of azure.net kinds of things
- 18:29or some variation of azure.net
- 18:32and I'll give you like azure star.net.
- 18:34So you've got like azure websites.net storage.azure.net,
- 18:39all those kinds of things exist out there
- 18:40'cause they have the Azure branding in there.
- 18:42So I don't know if someday you see a similar effort
- 18:45to come over to like do Microsoft for that stuff.
- 18:48It'd be interesting if that ever happened.
- 18:50- It would like if you'd have it Azure,
- 18:52I mean the root portal.
- 18:53If you had azure.cloud do Microsoft
- 18:56or I'm thinking it's gonna start the Microsoft 365 world.
- 18:59Like it wouldn't surprise me to start seeing onedrive.cloud,
- 19:03do Microsoft or onenote.cloud, do Microsoft.
- 19:07Some of those are probably also a little bit easier
- 19:11transition than maybe some of the other services.
- 19:14- I think M 360 five's a good place to start with it.
- 19:16'cause that's where I think people really need the,
- 19:21they don't need the cognitive load
- 19:22of remembering all the variations in URLs
- 19:25that maybe like we put up
- 19:27with on the admin side or the tooling side. Exactly.
- 19:29- And if you know the product, if they can keep doing it
- 19:31with Outlook, word, Excel, OneDrive, SharePoint,
- 19:35well not SharePoint
- 19:37'cause that gets into the tenant level stuff.
- 19:38But yeah, just have all the products.cloud
- 19:41Microsoft could be nice.
- 19:42- That was the plan. I'm, I'm trying to remember,
- 19:44they didn't link in the article that you had,
- 19:46they didn't link back to the original announcement
- 19:48but I believe the original announcement was like a bunch
- 19:50of those properties were come under the fold
- 19:53of the Microsoft T ld.
- 19:55The other interesting thing about that
- 19:57and I I think it's another good call out
- 20:01and driver for customers as they get ready for this
- 20:04is there's lots of customers that are looking to
- 20:07disambiguate between their resources
- 20:10and Microsoft's resources.
- 20:12Say you go to download an asset from someplace, a lot
- 20:14of it today like might exist in a storage account.
- 20:17How do you know a storage account is a
- 20:19Microsoft storage account like a Microsoft
- 20:21managed storage account?
- 20:22Like you bootstrap office office does a bunch of stuff
- 20:25where it downloads assets from blob storage
- 20:27and how do you disambiguate
- 20:29and know that the blob storage account for
- 20:31that office thing is different than the one
- 20:33that's maybe in your tenant and your environment.
- 20:36Very hard to do like when every storage account is blob dot
- 20:39core windows.net today.
- 20:41But potentially easier in the future if that's all massed
- 20:43between oh Microsoft assets are
- 20:45behind the dot, Microsoft T ld.
- 20:47Go ahead and allow list those
- 20:49and then maybe you do something
- 20:50with your own stuff on the side. Yeah,
- 20:52- So - For those customers who are looking
- 20:53for either data exfiltration controls, they're just looking
- 20:58for that additional click stop
- 20:59of control in their environment, having a lockdown TLD
- 21:03that's unique to the service provider opens up a world
- 21:06of possibilities for you there as well.
- 21:08Makes the network admins happy and the security folks.
- 21:11- Yeah, so we like keeping network admins
- 21:13and security folks happy.
- 21:14Some of us do. Some of us. Yeah.
- 21:15Another news one, we should talk about this one
- 21:18because SharePoint is near and dear to both of our hearts.
- 21:22Scott and I had another one along the lines of this too.
- 21:25There were two things that got retired.
- 21:27One of them being the SharePoint ADD-in retirement in
- 21:31Microsoft 365.
- 21:33To be clear, this is not anything with
- 21:37SharePoint on-prem,
- 21:39SharePoint server on-premises can still
- 21:42do SharePoint, add-ins.
- 21:43We'll still have all of that.
- 21:45There are gonna be some things that impact it in terms
- 21:48of SharePoint add-ins from the Mark public marketplace.
- 21:52But SharePoint online SharePoint admins are going away.
- 21:56SharePoint framework is the way forward
- 21:58as I'm sure AC would've told you long ago,
- 22:01- Years and years ago.
- 22:04But now you're gonna be potentially, depending on
- 22:07how your deployments look like and
- 22:08and what things look like in your environment,
- 22:11you are gonna be forced into the framework path.
- 22:13And I think that's fine for some folks.
- 22:16Like when I see announcements like this, like one
- 22:18of the fun things to do is go out on like public forums like
- 22:21Stack Overflow, Reddit, all that kind of stuff
- 22:24and just see what people are latching
- 22:27onto and complaining about.
- 22:29And I saw a couple interesting ones on Redmond,
- 22:32on Redmond on Reddit rather where folks we're, oh
- 22:37crap, we've developed solutions in-house years ago
- 22:41and they've just been running and we
- 22:43don't have access to the code.
- 22:44We don't know what's going on
- 22:45and now that's all potentially going to break
- 22:48and have to go away from them.
- 22:50Or another one that I saw, it was somebody
- 22:51who like whatever add-in they had built was it was helping
- 22:56admins function in the environment like administrators
- 22:59of their SharePoint tenancy
- 23:02and whatever they were doing in that thing,
- 23:04they were all freaked out 'cause they're like,
- 23:05well we're all admins, we don't know.
- 23:07We don't even remember who built this thing years
- 23:09and years ago
- 23:10but like we depend on it every single day
- 23:12for our jobs and now what do we do?
- 23:15- It was, this is one of those
- 23:16that the writing has been on the wall of this for a while
- 23:19and they haven't been investing in the
- 23:21add-in framework for a while.
- 23:22But to your point, I'm in the same boat.
- 23:24I still go into clients and they're using old add-ins
- 23:27or old development things.
- 23:29And even this could go down another path to like even people
- 23:34that have built stuff for the SharePoint framework
- 23:37that never go back
- 23:38and bother updating their solutions
- 23:41to the more recent version of the SharePoint framework.
- 23:44And in the meantime Microsoft's making continual updates,
- 23:48continual improvements to SharePoint and
- 23:50before they know what they're running customizations built
- 23:52on the SharePoint framework that are three years old
- 23:55and stuff starts breaking
- 23:56and then you have to go in and fix it.
- 23:58And there's not always a straightforward path from
- 24:02what I've seen with some of these clients
- 24:03that I've come into where it's let's just go
- 24:06update this to the latest version
- 24:08- . Uh, so I think
- 24:09- It's still some of that caution. There's
- 24:12- No easy button for a migration here if you don't have an
- 24:15equivalent in the SharePoint framework.
- 24:17And let's be honest, it might not be possible for you
- 24:20to a straight one-to-one equivalent in the SharePoint
- 24:23framework without a heavy lift.
- 24:25So if you don't have that one-to-one option,
- 24:28there is no one-click migration, anything like that,
- 24:31like you really do have to start rationalizing
- 24:34and thinking through what
- 24:35that looks like for you along the way.
- 24:37So I feel really bad for the customers
- 24:40who are relying on add-ins in the marketplace
- 24:43and the marketplace is going away as well.
- 24:45And potentially those vendors
- 24:46that have been in the marketplace don't have
- 24:48equivalence in the SharePoint framework.
- 24:50If they do have equivalence,
- 24:51there's often not like a data migration path
- 24:54for you depending on how
- 24:55that solution was originally built.
- 24:57So there's all sorts of kind of wonkiness
- 25:01that comes along the way with this.
- 25:02And then there's another impact add-ins in the uh,
- 25:07SharePoint to add-ins also relied on
- 25:10access control services.
- 25:11Azure, Azure access control services.
- 25:14A-C-S-A-C-S is also being retired at the same time
- 25:19and basically on the same timeline.
- 25:22So even if you weren't using SharePoint ADD-ins,
- 25:24but for some reason you were using a CS
- 25:26for something else in your environment, that's another thing
- 25:29that now you gotta go figure out.
- 25:30And the replacement is enter id, which is not a
- 25:34straight one-to-one replacement either.
- 25:38Again, there's work here for you to do.
- 25:42I'm sympathetic to customers
- 25:45who can't come along for the ride.
- 25:47But at the same time, like this is part of the deal
- 25:49of cloud is that it is ever changing.
- 25:52I'm always telling my customers this, Hey,
- 25:54for all the time you're not spending managing servers
- 25:57now you're spending time managing the service
- 25:59and managing to the service
- 26:00and you should like, it's not like you're spending less time
- 26:03on it, you're just spending time in different places.
- 26:06And I see a lot of customers that don't treat it that way.
- 26:08They go, oh it's sas,
- 26:09it's evergreen, it's just gonna work forever.
- 26:11I'm like, yeah, that works until you customize it.
- 26:14But as soon as you go off the beaten path, you need to plan
- 26:18for your own success there.
- 26:19Like your own success is tied
- 26:21to the provider's success at that point.
- 26:23And you've gotta rationalize that
- 26:25and figure out what it looks like for you.
- 26:27So I'm hoping after years and years and
- 26:30and maybe this'll be another good example of it,
- 26:33those customers that haven't been planning for the future,
- 26:35you really do need to.
- 26:37- And one of the things, I get it, customers do need addeds.
- 26:40There's some benefit to add-ins.
- 26:41There's some good ones out there.
- 26:43I think this also speaks a little bit too,
- 26:45and not to tell you not to do development on SharePoint,
- 26:48but I think there's a lot of people sometimes developers,
- 26:53can I make fun of developers? Scott, your
- 26:54- Show have fun - Every okay good
- 26:57that treat every challenge they run into is SharePoint
- 27:00as a we need to fix it
- 27:02with development versus first looking to,
- 27:06there's stuff you can do outta the box.
- 27:09What can we do out of the box?
- 27:10And I think at one particular client that we helped
- 27:13with this, it was probably a year
- 27:15or two ago now, they had 25 different
- 27:19custom solutions built for their SharePoint intranet.
- 27:22And they were ones where it wasn't an add-in
- 27:26but they were on an old version of the SharePoint framework
- 27:28and stuff just kept breaking.
- 27:30So it was let's go in
- 27:31and update everything to the SharePoint
- 27:32framework or a new version.
- 27:34We started looking at it
- 27:35and we were able to cut down their, the number of SharePoint
- 27:40web parts, it's not add-ins
- 27:42but SharePoint framework customizations.
- 27:45We cut it down from whatever I said, 25, 26,
- 27:48maybe even 30 down to two
- 27:50and did everything else with the other 20 just
- 27:52doing out of the box stuff.
- 27:54Maybe it wasn't quite as pretty, it wasn't quite
- 27:58what they had before but it was pretty close
- 28:01and close enough that it wasn't worth trying to maintain all
- 28:06of this custom development work over the course of time.
- 28:09And I think that's the other thing that jumps out
- 28:11to me at this is when you're looking at SharePoint,
- 28:15you don't have to develop solutions for everything.
- 28:18Go look at some of the what can you do outta the box first
- 28:22and only would you absolutely have to go build web parts,
- 28:26go do custom development, that type of stuff.
- 28:28- That's been the case all along, right?
- 28:30You're paying Microsoft for SharePoint,
- 28:32you're not paying Microsoft to then go pay a bunch
- 28:35of developers or consultancy service providers.
- 28:40Anything would anything out there
- 28:42to then go ahead and give you what you need.
- 28:44Like you decided to invest in the platform in the first
- 28:46place for a certain reason.
- 28:47Make sure you maximize that benefit
- 28:49before you go down the not so beaten path.
- 28:54- Yeah and I don't think we said this was going away.
- 28:57I don't think we announced any timelines.
- 28:59We should probably let people know. So SharePoint add-ins.
- 29:02- I'm not the one who announces the timelines. Microsoft is.
- 29:05- Okay. So Microsoft announced the timelines.
- 29:06We did not inform our listeners of the timelines.
- 29:08We just said it's going away.
- 29:10They are uninformed unless they read the article.
- 29:13November 21st or November 21st.
- 29:16November 1st, 2024.
- 29:19So a year from when we're recording this,
- 29:23ADDINS will stop working in new tenants.
- 29:26So if you go spin up a brand new tenant
- 29:27after November 1st of next year, 2024
- 29:31a CS will no longer work
- 29:33and SharePoint add-ins will no longer work SharePoint
- 29:36ADD-ins and a CS will stop working in
- 29:41current tenants as
- 29:43of April 2nd, 2026.
- 29:47So roughly two and a half years from now.
- 29:50I think that works out too. Mm-Hmm right ish.
- 29:54And then as of I'm losing my timelines. So
- 29:58- I think your next important one is July 1st, 2024.
- 30:02- Yes, that's what I missed. Which
- 30:03- Is when you will no longer be able to get new add-ins
- 30:09or, or you will not be no longer be able
- 30:11to purchase add-ins from the public marketplace.
- 30:14Well actually it's not very clear in the way they worded it.
- 30:16Uh, so ven vendors can't add new add-ins to the marketplace.
- 30:20I don't know. I don't understand. Basically if you're doing
- 30:22add-ins today, don't go buy any new ones
- 30:25like after today.
- 30:27That's good advice. Yes.
- 30:28Yeah, please don't go buy any new ones
- 30:30and then start coming up with your ramp-down plan.
- 30:33And I imagine for some of this,
- 30:35especially if you're on marketplace add-ins, you are going
- 30:38to have to wait for those vendors to announce their plans
- 30:42and hopefully their plans can line up with the
- 30:46Microsoft timelines for all this stuff.
- 30:48- Yep. And then that April 2nd, it was nice
- 30:51of them not to do this on April 1st.
- 30:53I wonder if that was intentional April 2nd,
- 30:55it's all going to go away.
- 30:57And they do say in here there's not gonna be
- 30:59an option to extend it.
- 31:00So unless Microsoft makes additional announcements like
- 31:03April 2nd, it all shuts down
- 31:05and you're hosed if you haven't made that transition off.
- 31:09But you have two and a half years to do it.
- 31:10So all kinds of time right Scott?
- 31:13- All kinds of time. I always love things like this
- 31:16'cause again there's all the knock-on effects that come in.
- 31:19So add-ins going away, a CS going away.
- 31:22There were multiple flavors of ADD-ins, like basically
- 31:26UI add-ins that you added that manipulated D UI
- 31:29and then there were hosted add-ins, which
- 31:33were the ones that used a CS in the middle
- 31:37as an auth framework provider hosted add-ins
- 31:40and I think officially is what they were called.
- 31:42But then those were hosted on their own units of compute
- 31:44and all that stuff that's out there.
- 31:46You gotta go figure all that out as well.
- 31:48like what's all the other stuff running in my
- 31:50environment that was actually potentially tied to
- 31:53this Add-in along the way,
- 31:56whether it came from the marketplace custom developed in
- 31:59your own tenant catalog, like whatever it happened to be.
- 32:01- Right? And this is another interesting call out.
- 32:03They call it out towards the bottom
- 32:05of the a CS documentation.
- 32:07I don't know that it's in Okay.
- 32:09They do have it in the SharePoint documentation too
- 32:12for people that forget.
- 32:14Project Online is built on top of SharePoint.
- 32:18So this also applies to anything project online related
- 32:22because SharePoint A are going away
- 32:26and could affect project online
- 32:28and a CS going away could also affect project online for any
- 32:33of those extensions that you built on top
- 32:36of SharePoint online slash project deadline.
- 32:40- I wonder what that means in context of
- 32:42what we talked about last week or the week
- 32:44before with the collapse, the unification
- 32:47of and all the things.
- 32:48So project coming over to play in
- 32:50and wasn't very clear what that looked like at the time.
- 32:53I wonder if some of that's driven by this too. It wouldn't
- 32:57- Surprise me if there's yeah, if project in
- 33:01and of itself, like not even custom stuff on top of project,
- 33:04but to your point like did Microsoft have some add-ins
- 33:09some stuff that they're using in Project online
- 33:12that is using the A CS and SharePoint ADD model
- 33:16and they were forced into this.
- 33:19- wouldn't surprise me or
- 33:20- In agreement with Microsoft on it.
- 33:22I don't know if they were forced or arms twisted
- 33:25or if this was a mutual decision,
- 33:28but I can see some stuff being there too.
- 33:30Yeah. Oh good times Scott.
- 33:33The ever-changing Cloud .
- 33:35Anything else you wanna talk about
- 33:36before we wrap up our Thursday recording?
- 33:39No, we have tomorrow too.
- 33:40Yeah, we're gonna record again tomorrow.
- 33:42Our, these holidays mess us up. Sometimes
- 33:44- We're gonna chat again in like less than 24 hours.
- 33:47So we'll talk more then.
- 33:49- Yeah, we save some stuff for that episode. All right.
- 33:53Go enjoy the rest of your nice cool Florida weather.
- 33:57There was frost on the roof the other morning, Scott.
- 34:00It felt so good outside. I
- 34:01- Know I've broken out all my fluffy sweatshirts
- 34:04and so it was
- 34:0647 Fahrenheit two days ago and so that was the day.
- 34:10There was like frost outside in the morning.
- 34:13I was freezing that day.
- 34:14I haven't turned the heat on in my house yet.
- 34:15I'm one of those people who like, I wait
- 34:17until the very last minute.
- 34:18Good for you. We all just, we bundle up around here.
- 34:21So I broke out all my fluffy sweatshirts and did all that
- 34:23and I was like, it was so cold.
- 34:25I had to go find like my little thin bird gloves, ,
- 34:28like my little underlayment gloves
- 34:29so I could take the dogs on a walk.
- 34:31And I, I did all that and then the next day I woke up
- 34:36and it was still cold, slept
- 34:38with the window open, all that kind of stuff.
- 34:39We broke out the extra big quilt and comforter.
- 34:42That's wonderful. And we did all that. And so I woke up
- 34:44and it was still cold so I went over to the closet,
- 34:48got dressed in the morning, put on my big fluffy sweatshirt
- 34:51and I walked around the house most of the day freezing.
- 34:53'cause once it gets cold, I don't turn the heat on
- 34:55so it stays cold inside the house too.
- 34:57And then I had to go to the grocery store and go shopping
- 35:00and I walked outside and it was like 65 Fahrenheit.
- 35:02I was like, oh no, what happened?
- 35:04And I had already walked out the door.
- 35:05I wasn't gonna turn around and change my whole outfit
- 35:07for the day, but I went
- 35:08to the grocery store dressed up like I've got thick boots on
- 35:13and a big fluffy sweatshirt.
- 35:15And I showed up at the grocery store
- 35:17and everybody's there in like shorts and a T-shirt.
- 35:19And I'm like, Hmm. Either they're tourists
- 35:22or yeah, they gotta be tourists. I, they're not,
- 35:24- I was gonna say tourists, like they're
- 35:26- Their blood's not thin enough yet.
- 35:27- No. Anybody in Florida,
- 35:29if it's under 70 Florida's bundle up.
- 35:31Like it's the middle of winter one.
- 35:33I don't know if it's 'cause everybody in Florida's cold
- 35:36or if it's because everybody in Florida wants an excuse
- 35:39to wear all their warm clothes
- 35:40and like 70 is that threshold where you can put up
- 35:43with it once it drops under 70. Part
- 35:45- Of it was I did need the excuse to wear the clothes.
- 35:48So like my wife bought me a bunch of new flannel shirts
- 35:50and things before we went on vacation for Thanksgiving.
- 35:52She's like, we're going to the mountains,
- 35:54we're gonna be in front of a fire.
- 35:55You need plaid and and flannel.
- 35:57And I was like, sure, whatever.
- 35:58Like it's cold up there, legitimately cold.
- 36:00So I came back and I washed everything.
- 36:02Now I've got all these flannel shirts.
- 36:04I'm like what am I gonna wear these down here? know.
- 36:07But yeah, we are officially into hopefully cold season.
- 36:11We'll see how long it sticks. I
- 36:12- Don't think it's supposed to stay too long.
- 36:14We're actually headed down to Disney this weekend
- 36:17and one of my kids was bummed out
- 36:19'cause it's supposed to be like 80 down in Disney.
- 36:21Yeah, it's a little south. I don't know about here.
- 36:24It's supposed to be up to 78 Friday.
- 36:27- Fun thing about living in Florida, we have two seasons.
- 36:29We have summer and we have summer light
- 36:31and we're like, so when I say we're making the transition
- 36:34to the cold season, we're making the transition
- 36:35to summer light maybe kind of sorta Yes
- 36:38and really not even now.
- 36:40Like it still gets into Yeah, the eighties and December.
- 36:43Yeah, we'll see. Usually like January, February you start
- 36:46to hit like that cold snap
- 36:48and when I say cold snap it's, ooh,
- 36:49it's 60 degrees every day. Rough.
- 36:52- And that's the high it does get down.
- 36:54I've woken up and had to scrape my windshield in Florida.
- 36:56Every once in a while you get a thin layer of ice.
- 36:58But yeah, Friday, tomorrow's Scott high of 78.
- 37:01So don't put on all your warm clothes tomorrow
- 37:04because it's gonna be a warm one-ish. Alright,
- 37:08- Noted.
- 37:09- Alright, well thanks.
- 37:09Now go enjoy your nice fluffy warm clothes for one more day
- 37:13before you have to go pack the ball away for a couple days
- 37:15and then you can get 'em out again by a week from now.
- 37:18- All right, sounds good. Thanks Ben.
- 37:19- Talk to you later. Scott, if you enjoyed the podcast,
- 37:24go leave us a five star rating in iTunes.
- 37:26It helps to get the word out
- 37:28so more it pros can learn about Office 365 and Azure.
- 37:32If you have any questions you want us to address on the show
- 37:35or feedback about the show, feel free
- 37:37to reach out via our website, Twitter, or Facebook.
- 37:40Thanks again for listening and have a great day.