Latest / Film And Whiskey / Zodiac / Rebel Small Batch Reserve Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2007, director David Fincher and star Jake Gyllenhaal gave
- 0:05the world an excruciating examination into the unsolved
- 0:09Zodiac murders. In 2024, we try a new release
- 0:13from one of our favorite brands. The film is.
- 0:16Zodiac the whiskey is Rebel Small Batch Reserve.
- 0:20And we'll review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:25podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:45podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:48glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:51I'm Brad G. And this week we are looking at
- 0:53David Fincher's 2007 masterpiece Question Mark Zodiac.
- 1:00Now, Brad, we literally just got on the horn with each other.
- 1:04And usually when we start, you know, our pre recording spiel
- 1:07with each other, catching up on life or whatever, we make vague
- 1:11mention of our general thoughts on the movie or where we might
- 1:15want to take the episode. No such luck today.
- 1:18We just said screw it, let's jump on and see what happens.
- 1:21And it's. An.
- 1:22Unsolved mystery. Listen, dude, I am waiting with
- 1:25bated breath to hear what you thought of the movie because
- 1:28you've never seen it before. I've been telling you for years
- 1:30to watch it. I've also been telling you maybe
- 1:33I should set expectations for you when you watch it.
- 1:36I have my reasons for that. But even before we dive into
- 1:40Brad's initial thoughts on the movie, I just want to make note
- 1:44of how rare an occurrence it is for Bob to come in completely
- 1:48blind to an episode. The way I am right now, this is
- 1:51new territory. Yeah, and and like, the perfect
- 1:54movie to match that with. Like this is truly an
- 1:58opportunity to surprise you with my deep, heavy breathing.
- 2:03Well, yeah, listen man, I I edit the episodes.
- 2:05I know all about your heavy breathing and mine I take.
- 2:08I basically gasp between every every sentence.
- 2:11And I think that once again, that's appropriate for the movie
- 2:14that we're reviewing today. So folks, welcome into the
- 2:16podcast. If this is your first time
- 2:18joining us, welcome into film in Whiskey.
- 2:21This season. What we're doing is we're
- 2:22looking at films from the last 20 years and we're asking the
- 2:25question, does this film deserve to be considered a modern
- 2:29classic? Now, Bob, I have to point out
- 2:32the fact we did not do that last week.
- 2:35Yes, we have some Skyfall. We have some housekeeping to do
- 2:38today because yes, we forgot to actually answer the question.
- 2:42Does Skyfall belong in the conversation of modern classics?
- 2:46I vote yes. Where do you vote?
- 2:49I vote I'm going to abstain. I think.
- 2:54I think I need to see the movie. I, I need to see a little more
- 2:59from this season to see, you know what my gauge of a modern
- 3:03classic is. Because as it stands right now,
- 3:06I think I would lean no. But you know, if, if there's a
- 3:10lot of average movies from here on out, I I, I could be
- 3:13convinced that Skyfall is a modern map.
- 3:17And I don't think that we only need to consider this pool of
- 3:19movies either, you know, we've watched a ton of movies from
- 3:22this century or, you know, since 2005, wherever we're starting
- 3:25this endeavor that yes, I would consider No Country for Old Men
- 3:30and There Will Be Blood and whatever, a modern classic.
- 3:32So I think even among that group, I vote yes for Skyfall.
- 3:37I vote no, all right? It's not a modern classic.
- 3:42All right, so let's talk about modern classics.
- 3:44We've identified this list of 32 movies that we're looking at
- 3:47this season by whether or not they met the criteria for four
- 3:51categories. Is it in the IMDb top 250?
- 3:54Is it in the letterbox top 250? Did it make $100 million?
- 3:58Was it nominated for Best Picture?
- 4:01And as we kind of went down the list of movies that hit all four
- 4:05movies that hit three, of the four movies that only hit two or
- 4:07one, we kind of got to the point where we had a bigger pool of
- 4:11movies that only checked like one or two boxes.
- 4:13And then Brad and I kind of just drafted them amongst each other.
- 4:16And this was one that I wanted to make sure made it in because
- 4:20when this movie came out, Brad, it was a huge flop.
- 4:23It did not make very much money at the box office at all and it
- 4:27got kind of screwed on awards contention, and we'll get into
- 4:29that later. But this was one that Bob kind
- 4:32of shoehorned in and Brad, you'll have yours that you shoot
- 4:35shoehorn in as well. This was definitely a Bob book
- 4:38pick. Yeah, and it, it feels like a
- 4:40Bob book. Pick it.
- 4:42It feels like a film that you would be quite enamoured with.
- 4:46Oh, why do you say that? Because I'm a serial killer.
- 4:50I I you're making the connections, Bob, not me.
- 4:54I'm just speculating if I were to talk to anybody about it.
- 5:00Well, let's do this. I would like to hear what
- 5:03connections you find from me to this movie.
- 5:05But in order to do that, let's get a sense of what the movie
- 5:08is, and let's get into our first segment of the day, which we
- 5:11call Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 5:13movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 5:17ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 5:21Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 5:24show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 5:27just seen, often for the first time.
- 5:30Brad, this was your first time with Zodiac, correct?
- 5:32It sure was. And you watched it.
- 5:34I have to say I'm, I'm impressed.
- 5:36You watched it in one sitting starting at about 9:30 in the
- 5:39morning. So this was like, you know, pour
- 5:42yourself a cup of coffee, start your morning off right with a
- 5:45David Fincher meticulous investigation movie.
- 5:49I'm, I'm very impressed. I do think this will be one of
- 5:52the easier, Brad explains for the season.
- 5:54But I'm giving you, as always, 60 seconds.
- 5:57Spoil this movie for us, Brad, and then we'll talk about it
- 5:59some more. One minute and go.
- 6:02Zodiac is a film about the Zodiac Killer of the 1960s and
- 6:0870s. It follows the journey of a San
- 6:11Francisco chronicler I believe is the newspaper.
- 6:15The Chronicle, yeah. The The Chronicle, I apologize.
- 6:19A cartoonist who works for the Chronicle that becomes obsessed
- 6:23with finding the killer in the late 70s through the 80s and
- 6:27eventually writes a book on it. Fun fact, they never actually
- 6:32find the Zodiac Killer even though everybody's pretty sure
- 6:36that they know who who done it. Boom, Zodiac, Zodiac.
- 6:41Now Brad, I have already sensing some thoughts from you.
- 6:46I'll let you tease them out yourself.
- 6:48But I do want to hear, you know, you said this seems like a Bob
- 6:51book movie. What do we mean by that?
- 6:53Because you're right. But I'd I'd like to hear how I
- 6:55landed on that list for you. I think that it is incredibly
- 7:01meticulously shot and fastly paced.
- 7:06Like you move from scene to scene really quickly and you
- 7:10don't have to sit very long with each idea as you rush through
- 7:14this movie. And I it just has the the look
- 7:20of a movie that Bob would love, like the color palette of the
- 7:25film, the acting style of the actors.
- 7:29I'm guessing that Robert Downey Junior was your like least
- 7:33favorite performance of all the main people.
- 7:35Sure was. Yep, you are on to it man.
- 7:37Dude, I, you know how there's times where you tell me that my
- 7:42tasting notes are just perfect and there's nothing you have to
- 7:45add. That's kind of how I feel about
- 7:47this movie. But yeah, I I think that this
- 7:52has all of the things that Bob is going to look for in a movie,
- 7:57and I think that this movie is not good.
- 8:02Yeah, I, I kind of figured you were going to come in with with
- 8:06a similar vibe to that. And I want to set the stage
- 8:10today by saying this. The first time I saw Zodiac, I
- 8:15thought it was a not even just competently made, an
- 8:18extraordinarily well made movie that felt too long, a little
- 8:23shaggy and left me wondering like, what's what's the message
- 8:27here? Like what is the point of all
- 8:28this? And I think that Zodiac is one
- 8:31of those films that despite my my own opinion of it, there was
- 8:37something about the craft of the movie and it's kind of downward
- 8:41spiral of obsession, similar to a movie like Vertigo, I guess,
- 8:44which also San Francisco sent. But that kept me kind of like
- 8:49anytime I was just like perusing my shelf and feeling like, what
- 8:52should I throw on for a little bit, even if I only make it 45
- 8:55minutes in, be like, you know what, I kind of want to watch
- 8:57Zodiac again. I need to give that another
- 8:59chance. And it was never the, I have to
- 9:03give this a chance because it's Kubrick's 2001 and I have to
- 9:06like this movie. It was more just like, yeah, let
- 9:08me check that out again. And I've probably seen it in
- 9:11full maybe four times through now, but I've seen bits and
- 9:15pieces of it, I'd say maybe 10 times.
- 9:18And every single rewatch makes this movie richer and deeper and
- 9:23I appreciate it more. It kind of has the opposite
- 9:26effect of Fincher's other quote, UN quote masterpiece, The Social
- 9:29Network, where while that movie is big and flashy and Sorkin's
- 9:33dialogue is like right there for you to grab onto, I feel like
- 9:38repeat viewings of The Social Network has made me feel kind of
- 9:40like, yeah, like we got the point the first time, You know
- 9:44what I mean? Like, I it never gets to be a
- 9:46richer experience on rewatch for me.
- 9:48So all that to say, I kind of expected you to come in here
- 9:52much cooler on this than me, and not because of our particular
- 9:57differences in taste, but just because this was your first time
- 9:59with the movie. If this was your second, third
- 10:01time, I don't know if you'd like it better, but I think that I
- 10:05was kind of banking on you not being as all in on it as I am.
- 10:10Here's the problem, Bob. I I've said this a few times
- 10:13about other movies. The problem I have with this
- 10:16movie isn't that I don't like it, it's that I was really bored
- 10:21for two hours and 32 minutes. 35 minutes, however long it takes
- 10:26to get to the credits. I never found anything in this
- 10:31movie to actually be compelling. Oh, interesting.
- 10:34And and so like it like well made.
- 10:37I think the pacing is really well done, although it gets
- 10:40really tiring after a while to feel this sense of urgency that
- 10:46goes nowhere and ends up being just really boring.
- 10:51So it's it's kind of this like mixture of I think that Fincher
- 10:56wanted you to feel the pressure of this case building over the
- 11:00years, but all I felt like was that he was trying to kill me
- 11:04personally, with how long the film was, like, I die of old age
- 11:07before it was finished. So it's like, yeah, I just was
- 11:11really bored for 2 1/2 hours and then I wasn't and now I'm here.
- 11:16There you go all right, well, you as always, you are adding
- 11:20just a, a pleth, a wealth of analysis to this this podcast
- 11:25man, and I'm I'm joking, I'm being facetious.
- 11:28If you're bored, you're bored. I do want to interrogate, not
- 11:31even interrogate, investigate a little bit like.
- 11:34Why you? I was going to say I I have my
- 11:36rights. Yeah, you haven't.
- 11:37You haven't read me, my Miranda. Shining a spotlight on you,
- 11:40Where were you on the night of July 4th?
- 11:43So I think it's a kind of cast, a direction for this episode.
- 11:49I identified a couple movies that are like really obvious
- 11:53influences on this film and then also films that I think were
- 11:57influenced by this movie. But I want to start on the top
- 12:00with All the President's Men, which is one of the most famous
- 12:05newspaper movies ever made. And it's also an investigative,
- 12:08you know, it's about the Watergate scandal and how
- 12:11Bernstein and Woodward cracked that case.
- 12:13And it is just a meticulous recounting of all the leads they
- 12:18had to follow up on. You watch the procedural.
- 12:20It's not a police procedural, but it's a journalistic
- 12:22procedural. And it's a movie that I believe
- 12:25you. You've never seen, have you?
- 12:26What? What's the movie called?
- 12:29All the president's men. I have never heard of that film.
- 12:32Yeah. So this is this is a big problem
- 12:34because I think it's like, A, it's a classic film, and B, it
- 12:39is kind of like when we watched the movie Spotlight later this
- 12:42year, Spotlight was consistently referred to as like this
- 12:46generation's All the President's Men.
- 12:49And I kind of wish that we had watched both Spotlight and the
- 12:56Denis Villeneuve movie Prisoners before this movie, because those
- 13:00are both kind of procedural dramas.
- 13:02One of them has Jake Gyllenhaal in it.
- 13:04One of them is about working at a newspaper.
- 13:06And I, I, I can't wait till we get to those movies so we can
- 13:09kind of call back to Zodiac and start comparing and contrasting.
- 13:13But I think part of the reason that you may have been bored by
- 13:15this movie is that we've never really done a procedural movie
- 13:19on this podcast, especially not set inside of a newsroom.
- 13:23I mean, I think that I, I guess I don't know if it would count
- 13:28in the exact same way, but I'm curious if you would consider
- 13:32goodnight and good luck kind of a procedural newsroom like.
- 13:39Maybe a little bit, yeah. Especially in the pacing of it
- 13:41'cause that movie had that kind of like not even slow pace, but
- 13:44just like almost documentary vibe where they're just
- 13:47documenting each step of the process.
- 13:49That's that's fair. Yeah, and I very much so like
- 13:53that movie. I would also call Vertigo a
- 13:56procedural drama. The the way he goes about
- 13:59solving that mystery feels very procedural, you know, like he's
- 14:03just kind of walking through a garden following this lady
- 14:06around. So I, I think both of those
- 14:08could fit in that category. And fun fact, I think I gave a
- 14:1310 out of 10 to both of those. Yeah, you're right.
- 14:15We've done a couple that I would say if not like a perfect
- 14:19example like you're saying, they're at least tangentially
- 14:21related to the genre. So is the problem more that it's
- 14:25hard to sustain that type of narrative over 2 1/2 hours?
- 14:31I I think that's definitely one of the issues.
- 14:33OK, well, let's go in on those issues a little bit like so.
- 14:36We've identified the form, the form of the movie as part of the
- 14:41problem. What else did you just not jive
- 14:43with here? I I mean Jake Gyllenhaal doesn't
- 14:46know how to act in this movie. I like he has.
- 14:51The I love it when you come in with incredibly spicy takes, but
- 14:55you don't say like, you don't preface it with like, I've got
- 14:58some thoughts. You're just like, this is
- 14:59objective fact. Jake Gyllenhaal doesn't know how
- 15:02to act. You don't know it in like, I
- 15:05think that this is a bad performance.
- 15:07It's in this film. He forgot how to act.
- 15:11Yeah, 'cause he has the exact same face every single scene of
- 15:15the movie except for when he gets a little bit scared in that
- 15:17guy's basement. Like he like he's, he's afraid
- 15:22for one scene and he's like kind of earnest and blank stare the
- 15:29rest of the film. And I like, I just think his
- 15:34performance, which is supposed to carry the movie is so boring
- 15:40and he he doesn't have any ability to draw others to him.
- 15:45And that the way that Fincher shoots his date with the the
- 15:48girl that he ends up marrying that I don't even know what her
- 15:52name is because who gives a RIP about her?
- 15:54Like the, the way that he acts on that date is so ridiculous
- 16:01and boring and frustrating. And he doesn't like the, there's
- 16:08a lot of this movie that doesn't follow.
- 16:11Like, it doesn't follow in any semblance of the real world that
- 16:16those two human beings would get married based on what they have
- 16:20shown you in the film. And so I think it's like stuff
- 16:23like that that just frustrates me beyond any belief that it
- 16:28made it into the film. Like, give your character
- 16:31something other than this obsession to understand why
- 16:35things are happening in the world.
- 16:37But like, there's just so much happening that we have to get
- 16:40through. We have to rush through that.
- 16:43Meh. Joel Hall just kind of has to
- 16:45flow from 1 angstiness to the next.
- 16:49There are times where I'm thinking, as you're talking
- 16:54about, like, we have to fill 60 minutes of audio here, Brad.
- 16:58And I feel like we could just kind of call it here if we
- 17:01wanted to. Like, yeah, I think you said
- 17:04what you want to say. I now, again, we're not going to
- 17:07do that. But it's hard for me to think
- 17:10of, like, where to go because it sounds like literally nothing
- 17:13about this movie worked for you. Is that fair?
- 17:15I don't know if I would say nothing.
- 17:16Like I said, I I think that this is a competently made film like
- 17:20I think the cinematography works pretty well.
- 17:23I I think that the the lighting and the color of the film makes
- 17:28sense within the world of what Fincher is creating.
- 17:31I think that for me, there's not really any interesting
- 17:35characters and like the whole mystery of the film, like
- 17:39whodunit, like they, there's no question about it.
- 17:43Like once they show you Lee, there's no question that he's
- 17:47the guy who did it even after they get it wrong.
- 17:49So it's just kind of boring to watch them stumble around
- 17:54throughout the whole film. You said something a few minutes
- 17:58ago about how you have to give these characters more than just
- 18:01the obsession for the movie to work.
- 18:03And I'm wondering because you've obviously hit on the theme of
- 18:06the movie, which is like this all consuming obsession and its
- 18:10effect on people. Like it's it's as much about the
- 18:14killer and the killings as it is about the toll it took on the
- 18:17people that were investigating it and kind of the futility of
- 18:21that. Like it's AI don't want to say
- 18:22it's a downer of a movie, but I think if you're trying to crack
- 18:25the code of like, what's the message here?
- 18:27Fincher is really giving you a story to which there is no
- 18:32resolution. And I'm and I'm wondering like
- 18:36if he is trying to communicate that the obsession is the point
- 18:40of these characters and of this movie, what's a more successful
- 18:45way to portray that? I don't.
- 18:48I don't know if there's a more successful way to portray it.
- 18:50I'm just saying that it was very boring.
- 18:52Well, let's compare it to like Vertigo then.
- 18:54Like Vertigo is a movie about obsession, you know what I mean?
- 18:57Like, is it an obsession? I think is like the core theme
- 19:01of that movie too. Now, there's other stuff going
- 19:04on in the mechanics of the movie, not to distract you from
- 19:07the obsession, but to kind of just keep the wheels of the
- 19:09movie turning. And I guess that's what I'm
- 19:11asking. Like, is there just not enough
- 19:13other things going on to keep them the wheels turning for you?
- 19:16Or like, what about Vertigo and its themes work better than this
- 19:20movie's themes? I mean, I, I think part of it is
- 19:23just the fact that nobody ever stops talking in this movie that
- 19:27like the amount of information that is dumped on you, the
- 19:33audience. Like when you see date after
- 19:37date after date after date, it forces you to check out as an
- 19:42audience member. It's like, oh, he doesn't care
- 19:44about me, the audience member anymore.
- 19:46He's just trying to hurdle down these train tracks as fast as he
- 19:49can. And I have no ability as a
- 19:53audience member to keep up with the information being provided
- 19:58in a way that helps me make meaning of what's going on in
- 20:02the story. Whereas Vertigo moves at a nice
- 20:05slow pace so that you you the audience member.
- 20:10Are swept along in this mysterious story that is being
- 20:17crafted whereas Zodiac is just like, here's some more
- 20:20information kid, here's more information here's more
- 20:23information 47 years later there's more information and
- 20:26it's like I like I just lose interest when it's just slamming
- 20:31me over the head with a baseball bat over and over with
- 20:34information and names and numbers and dates and people
- 20:38and. Yeah, I I think do you?
- 20:40Want me to follow this? I think that we have to get you,
- 20:43and maybe we don't because it sounds like this is just not a
- 20:46genre that's gonna work for you. But I was just thinking like, we
- 20:49got to get you to watch more investigative, like journalistic
- 20:51movies like this, like All the President's Men, like Spotlight,
- 20:54'cause that's just, that's just the genre, I think.
- 20:57And I think that might be what you're kind of butting up
- 21:00against here a little. But it also sounds like this is
- 21:02the rare movie for you where the faster pace of the movie is a
- 21:07detriment to the film as opposed to a slower pace.
- 21:11Yeah, I I think that a faster paced film shouldn't last two
- 21:15hours and 37 minutes. Like there's there's no change
- 21:20in the pace either. Like if, if I'm if I am speaking
- 21:26and I never take a pause and I always speak at this exact thing
- 21:29over and over and over again. And I never stopped my cadence
- 21:32anything. I just keep talking at the same
- 21:34rate. People lose interest.
- 21:37Like you have to change the pace at which you speak for people to
- 21:41be interested in what you're saying.
- 21:43You go faster at times and slower at times.
- 21:46And Fincher just has this monotone, like 70% fast.
- 21:51Like, it's not like it's a Terrence Malick film where
- 21:55you're just like, seen, seen, seen, boom, boom, boom, cut,
- 21:57cut, cut. Like, like, it's not like this
- 21:59film is wildly fast-paced, but the entire movie is like between
- 22:0565 and 75% fast. And there's no change in the
- 22:10pace. And so, yeah, I'm going to lose
- 22:12interest. All right, here's the thing,
- 22:14Bob. I came in thinking I would give
- 22:15this like A7 7 1/2 and the more I talk the more I'm like, Oh no,
- 22:20I really, really didn't like this.
- 22:23Movie. That's crazy to me, man.
- 22:24Yeah. So I'm going to be under the
- 22:28operative assumption that your reaction to everything in this
- 22:33film was it was bad until you correct me.
- 22:36So I want to talk about the cast, but I also don't want to
- 22:39hear you repeatedly say everybody in the cast was bad.
- 22:42So why don't we just throw it to you and say who was good or who
- 22:47surprised you in this cast? I I was OK with Robert Downey
- 22:54Junior. Like I think he was fine.
- 22:57I think he was himself. And I like, at this point, I
- 23:02don't know if I've ever seen a movie where Robert Downey Junior
- 23:06wasn't just Robert Downey Junior.
- 23:09Like, is that fair? I mean, yeah, I've, I've seen a
- 23:12couple, but I know that the ones that we've watched, you
- 23:14definitely have not. Yeah, So I don't think he was
- 23:18bad. I don't think he was good.
- 23:20I think he was himself and wasn't like wildly interesting.
- 23:27I liked Mark Ruffalo decently well.
- 23:30I think he, I think he does a really good job of showing the
- 23:37toll that obsession takes on a person and the way that he tries
- 23:43to shut the case out, move on, try to be a healthy human being.
- 23:48I like that was the only character as written and as
- 23:52portrayed that I thought had like a healthy sense of
- 23:56development and movement. And, you know, he's willing to
- 24:01entertain it, but only to a certain point, you know, in the
- 24:04years that followed the killings way beyond the originals.
- 24:08So I like, I, I think that Ruffalo does a really good job
- 24:11of, of showing how freaking hard it would be to be the police
- 24:17officer. I, I think the moment when he
- 24:18looks at Gyllenhaal and says, like, you're a cartoonist, I'm a
- 24:24police officer, this is my job. This shouldn't be taking the
- 24:27toll on you that it is on me. Like great moment.
- 24:32I think for me, first of all, I have wanted you to be able to
- 24:38articulate why you didn't like this movie.
- 24:40I freaking love this movie. I think this movie is a is a
- 24:43absolute yes on the classic scale.
- 24:45For me, I think this is Fincher's best movie.
- 24:47Like, I'm just going to put it out there.
- 24:49We don't have to investigate that at all.
- 24:51Like, it's fine. I know we're at odds here.
- 24:53I do feel like I need to say I think this movie works perfectly
- 24:57and I think part of the reason it works perfectly is this cast.
- 25:01And it's not just it's almost like when you look at
- 25:05championship teams in the NBA, very rarely is it just like the
- 25:11Oklahoma City Thunder had Russell Westbrook and James
- 25:14Harden and Kevin Durant at the same time.
- 25:16Yes, they did, but there's a reason they didn't win the
- 25:19championship. Like their their bench didn't go
- 25:21deep enough, you know what I mean?
- 25:22And I think on a movie like this, it's all of the supporting
- 25:25players, and not even just supporting players, but like
- 25:283rd, 4th tier players. When you have, you know, Anthony
- 25:32Edwards playing Toski's sidekick and you have Philip Baker Hall
- 25:36playing the guy that analyzes the handwriting and you have
- 25:38Brian Cox show up for one scene as Melvin Belli, the guy that
- 25:42they're calling in on the air for.
- 25:44It's just like everybody in that zone is guys that I recognize
- 25:48from other movies. And it's like, oh that that's
- 25:51awesome that they came and did one day on a Fincher movie
- 25:53'cause it makes everybody in the movie that much better.
- 25:57And for me, I think that the unsung hero of the movie is John
- 26:02Carroll Lynch as Arthur Lee Allen, because we've seen him in
- 26:06other movies. Brad, he's a really good actor,
- 26:08and I can't ever shake him as the Zodiac Killer.
- 26:13Now that I've seen him as the Zodiac Killer, he's really
- 26:17creepy in this movie and he does a really good job.
- 26:20Yeah, I I think he does like almost too good of a job to the
- 26:25point where you like, you know that it's him the entire movie
- 26:29once they show you him. So like the the whole thrust of
- 26:33the tension is gone. But I'm with you that the scene
- 26:37of him at the plants where you know, wherever he works being
- 26:42interviewed by Gyllenhaal, his partner and I think the local
- 26:48Molinax maybe like incredible scene the.
- 26:54Editing the way that they keep cutting to the little like
- 26:57insert shots of the watch and everything else, the boots like
- 27:00it's, it's so well done. Yeah.
- 27:02And so I, I don't have anything else to say.
- 27:07Bob, he, he, he does great. He's a great performance.
- 27:10All right, so you've covered everyone in the cast that you
- 27:13like now, right? Which was basically Mark Ruffalo
- 27:16was pretty good. Yep, I liked Mark Ruffalo.
- 27:19I would say beyond pretty good. I think he was really solid.
- 27:23Is that a good? That's an upgrade.
- 27:27We need to start reviewing whiskeys like that man.
- 27:29Yeah, really solid. Brian Cox is Brian Cox, and he's
- 27:33fine. I don't understand.
- 27:36I don't know if I just missed something, but all of a sudden
- 27:38he's in the movie and then all of a sudden he's not.
- 27:41And I don't know who. Melvin it is I I don't know why
- 27:45he's there, but hey, that is that's a OK.
- 27:51I I think my struggle is all of the secondary characters in this
- 27:55movie are really solid. But as you were talking about
- 27:59the names, I don't I didn't recognize almost any of the
- 28:03secondary cast from anything else.
- 28:05I I recognize the Zodiac Killer, whatever his name is, but other
- 28:12than that I think I recognized Jake or no, not Gyllenhaal's
- 28:18wife. Mark Ruffalo's wife is from
- 28:23Parks and Rec. June Diane Raphael.
- 28:26Yeah. Yep, Yep.
- 28:27That's the that I recognize her. You did it, man.
- 28:31I did it. All right, so God, this is a
- 28:34fucking bummer. You didn't like this movie.
- 28:36I don't know where to go from here.
- 28:38Maybe it's time for us to go drink some whiskey and then
- 28:41we'll get into some fun stuff in the back half of the episode.
- 28:43What do you say? Let's get to it, Bob.
- 28:46I'm excited. Woo.
- 28:54All right, so today we are checking out Rebel Small Batch
- 28:58Reserve Bourbon. Now our history and love for
- 29:02Rebel Bourbon. Is well documented.
- 29:05Well documented, Bob. Almost as well documented as
- 29:08everything in this film. Very much so when they go into
- 29:12Vallejo and he he gives them the classic, all of these files,
- 29:17right, It's like. But no pens.
- 29:20Yeah, yeah. No pens, Bob.
- 29:21No, no pens. Only whiskey.
- 29:23All right, so small batch reserve is the latest release or
- 29:26one of the latest releases in the Rebel line from Lux Row.
- 29:30We love Lux Row, we love Rebel. They used to source it, they
- 29:34make it in house now. This is a small batch version
- 29:37that is 110 proof. So it's a slight bump up from
- 29:40the Rebel 100 that Brad and I love very much MSRP is around
- 29:45$30. You might you might be charged a
- 29:47little bit more depending on where you live.
- 29:49So this is still kind of in that low mid range bourbon.
- 29:54Like I wouldn't call this a budget bourbon anymore, but it's
- 29:58still cheaper than like a bottle of Elijah Craig, which is kind
- 30:00of where I start pricing mid range bourbons.
- 30:04So very affordable, Brad, I'm very excited to get into it.
- 30:08It's a non age stated bourbon. We don't know the mash bill,
- 30:10wink, wink. Let's dive in, man.
- 30:13Yeah, When I got into the nose on this, it had some really nice
- 30:17cherry tart notes. It's a little bit grain forward
- 30:23and I there's a little bit of spiciness here, some cinnamon
- 30:26notes that I thought were interesting.
- 30:28I think it's a decent nose. I'm going to give it a 7 1/2.
- 30:32Yeah, I'm a little bit lower than you.
- 30:34This was like, fine, but I think it's probably right in line with
- 30:39a Rebel 100 in terms of what you're getting on the nose.
- 30:42Pretty simple, but I can't shake the fact that it's $10 more
- 30:46expensive. It had a little bit of peanut
- 30:48butter and then there was like a slight kind of off dill pickle
- 30:53note, which we've gotten dill on Ryze before, but this is a
- 30:56weeded bourbon, so you really wouldn't expect to have dill on
- 30:59anything here. It threw me for a loop and I
- 31:03didn't like it that much. And so I, I dinged this for that
- 31:06note all the way down to a 7 out of 10.
- 31:09When it comes to the taste, I liked it a lot.
- 31:12It was really viscous, super dark in terms of like the fruit
- 31:16that it was bringing up on my, you know, on my palate, lots of
- 31:19chocolate notes for me, definitely not as sweet as other
- 31:23Rebels were. And that again, it threw me for
- 31:25a loop because we've drank enough Rebel that I can tell
- 31:29what the flavor wheelhouse of Rebel is.
- 31:32Now, this wasn't that dark stone fruit, really heavy kind of dark
- 31:37notes. I gave it a 7 again, Brad.
- 31:39Yeah, I'm in a 7 1/2 on the flavor.
- 31:41I I think that the palate has some really nice mixture of like
- 31:46a cinnamony spice with the classic cherry and it, you're
- 31:51right, it gets into like a little bit of a cacao dark
- 31:55chocolate kind of vibe. I like, I I'm not crazy about
- 32:00it. I think it's pretty good though,
- 32:02I think. I think the finish drops off a
- 32:05little bit for me. It gets oaky and and much more
- 32:09grainy. That grain finally starts to
- 32:12come through a little stronger than I'd like.
- 32:15There's a little bit of a black pepper.
- 32:18The vanilla. There's like hints of vanilla
- 32:20for me, which I didn't get quite as much on the nose and the
- 32:23palate. 7 out of 10 on the finish. 7 as well.
- 32:28There's a just a little pop of cinnamon.
- 32:31I did get quite a bit of ethanol and usually the ethanol is
- 32:33present like on the front of the pallet or the mid pallet it it
- 32:37burned quite a bit and you could feel the 110 proof here.
- 32:41After that, the notes that were left behind were just really,
- 32:43really dark red wine. And I, you know, again, I didn't
- 32:47take good enough notes to pinpoint exactly what kind of
- 32:50wine it brought up. You know, whatever kind of wine
- 32:53you associate with the darkest red wine, go for it.
- 32:56So that's where I'm at on this one.
- 32:58It's a 7 out of 10 on the finish.
- 33:00And in terms of overall balance, all I wrote down was it's good.
- 33:04But this is far from my favorite in the rebel line.
- 33:07I gave it a 7 out of 10 again, Brad.
- 33:09So I was sevens pretty much across the board here on our
- 33:12first four categories. Yeah, I'm I'm not far off from
- 33:15you. I give it a 7 on balance as
- 33:18well. I think that there's some
- 33:21interesting things going on here, but it's not standing out
- 33:23enough to really make me love this whiskey.
- 33:27Now, I will say when you and I first tried this whiskey, which
- 33:30was down at the Kentucky Bourbon Festival about two months ago
- 33:33now, we took note that MSRP was $45.
- 33:39And I'm looking online and I don't see it that high anywhere.
- 33:42So I don't know if we just maybe they're raising the price and it
- 33:45hasn't really taken effect yet. I don't know.
- 33:48At $45.00, I was like, this is a 7 at best.
- 33:51I will say at $30, this is a much better value than I had
- 33:54originally taken note of. So I'm going to go ahead and up
- 33:57it to, I'll say 7 1/2 out of 10. I was going to go up to an 8,
- 34:01but I think it's just marginally better than that at a 7 1/2.
- 34:06Yeah, if you're getting this around the $35 mark, I'll give
- 34:11it a 7 1/2 as well. I think, Bob, I think this might
- 34:15be the first time we've ever had every single score be 7 or 7 1/2
- 34:22on a product. I.
- 34:23Mean this is like the quintessential average whiskey.
- 34:26See, that's funny because I always think of 7 1/2 as like
- 34:29when you I used to look at the movie reviews in the newspaper
- 34:33and they were on a four-star scale.
- 34:34So three stars was the like, OK, like this is worth my while.
- 34:38Two stars is average. That's 5 out of 10.
- 34:41And like, so I always think like, oh, this is like a 7 1/2
- 34:45whiskey. It's the three star movie.
- 34:47It's worth the money, it's worth your time.
- 34:49You're not going to regret it, but it's also not going to be
- 34:51like a life changing, memorable experience.
- 34:54And I kind of think of it that way.
- 34:55I wouldn't call it average. I think it's definitely above
- 34:57average, but it's the three star movie of the Rebel lineup.
- 35:02See your Your definition of average is off though, because
- 35:05the the grading scale you think of is like 99 to 100 is an A&A
- 35:10minus, so. I will have you know, I had
- 35:13multiple people contact me after that episode came out and tell
- 35:18me like I was on that scale all the way till high school or my
- 35:22high school used that scale. Like once again, Brad G thinks
- 35:26that his life experience is everyone's life experience.
- 35:30I Bob, I am 100% sure that the common experience is the 10
- 35:36point scale I like. I have so little doubt that that
- 35:40has been the reality for most people.
- 35:43Like whatever the off scale is, I'm telling you 75 or a 7.5 is
- 35:52an average grade because that's AC.
- 35:56All right, so Brad thinks it's a sea whiskey.
- 35:58I think it's like a bee whiskey. That's totally fine.
- 36:01What is your actual score? We're arguing about the smallest
- 36:03stuff today. 36.5. 36.5 So we're coming out to an average of a 36
- 36:09out of 50 or a 72 out of 100. It has just cleared the bar at
- 36:1435 where we start recommending to try a pour or to buy a
- 36:18bottle. I think I would do both, but
- 36:21it's like a soft recommend because IA pour of this is only
- 36:23going to cost you like 6 bucks. So you want to try it.
- 36:26It's worth 6 bucks to try. If you want to buy a bottle,
- 36:29it's worth $30 to just get a bottle.
- 36:31I just don't think that it is as good of a value, or maybe as
- 36:35good of a bourbon as Rebel 100. I I think I'd agree with that.
- 36:40The Rebel 100 still stands out. I I might, yeah, I might call it
- 36:45a better whiskey. Well, there you go all right
- 36:47folks, so it's a soft recommend on Rebel small batch.
- 36:50It is a firm recommendation once again on Rebel 100.
- 36:54Go find it, go buy it Rebel, we love you.
- 36:56We're going to try some more of your product again next week.
- 36:59Brad, what do you say we get back into this love fest we have
- 37:03going on today with the movie Zodiac?
- 37:06Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 37:12That was Rebel Small Batch a whiskey that we were in
- 37:17agreement on that it's decidedly decent.
- 37:20And we're basically in agreement that 2 Facts and a Falsehood is
- 37:24the greatest segment that any podcast has ever come up with.
- 37:28Woo. Hoo.
- 37:29Brad is going to try to stump your ball.
- 37:34All right. And what is wrong?
- 37:382 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 37:41the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 37:45the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 37:49Brad, I'm excited to see what you came up with today.
- 37:51I did do more research than normal today 'cause I wanted to
- 37:54talk about all the cool things I like about this movie.
- 37:57I have I realized very quickly I will get to mention very little
- 38:00of them, but hopefully it will come in Andy at 2 facts and a
- 38:05falsehood. I am writing A1 game win streak,
- 38:08but I think I'm six and one overall on the season.
- 38:11So let's see how I do today. Brad hit me with those two facts
- 38:15and a falsehood. Fact number one In one of the
- 38:17Zodiacs letters he muses on who would portray him in a film
- 38:22about him. In this film he is portrayed by
- 38:24three separate actors and in any shot featuring the Zodiac the
- 38:27actors faces are always out of focus or obscured, partially so
- 38:31that the Zodiac killer himself would not be portrayed by a
- 38:35visible or famous actor. Fact #2 Jake Gyllenhaal grew up
- 38:41with a fascination of the Zodiac killings, as his parents lived
- 38:45in California when they occurred and had told their children all
- 38:48about it when the book came out in 1989.
- 38:52Fact #3 The shooting script for the film was 200 pages long, and
- 38:57in order to prevent any problems with a link that such a long
- 39:00script might cause, director David Fincher decided to ask his
- 39:04cast members to speak faster. OK, I think #1 is like true just
- 39:10because I looked at the cast list and there's like 1 actor is
- 39:15listed as like Zodiac one and two, one is listed as Zodiac 3
- 39:18and 1 is listed as Zodiac four or something like that.
- 39:22So I think that's true. They they wanted it to be kind
- 39:24of this, everyone reminded you of each other.
- 39:27But you can project those rememberings onto somebody like
- 39:32a John Carroll Lynch later in the movie.
- 39:34So I think 1 is true. 2 sounds true to me as well.
- 39:38I'm gravitating towards 3 because I know that Fincher had
- 39:43final cut on this movie and this might be a good place to really
- 39:46briefly mention this. Brad, this movie was intended to
- 39:49be released at the end of O 6 for Oscar consideration.
- 39:53Fincher turned in a cut of the movie that was three hours and 8
- 39:56minutes long. And then Paramount was like you,
- 40:00you got to cut it down. But he had final cut and so he
- 40:04said OK, it's probably too long, let me cut some stuff out.
- 40:06He landed at 2 hours and 40 ish minutes and then said like
- 40:10that's it I'm not making another cut put it out.
- 40:12And Paramount was like, cool, we'll dump it in February or
- 40:15whatever. So it got it got no love from
- 40:18Paramount, partially resulting in the fact that it didn't do
- 40:22very well at the box office. And so anyway, all that to say,
- 40:26I'm gravitating towards 3 is the falsehood.
- 40:29Now, he may have told his actors to speak longer or to speak
- 40:32faster, but I also don't think he cared that much about the
- 40:35length of the movie 'cause he turned in a three hour cut.
- 40:39So my gut says #3 I may be wrong, but I'm going to roll
- 40:42with it. Brad #3 is the falsehood.
- 40:44Bob #3 is not the falsehood. Wow. #2 was our falsehood today.
- 40:51OK, is there any smidgen of truth in #2?
- 40:56I 100% made that up. Nice dude.
- 41:00Yeah, I did. I I I guess I don't know if this
- 41:04is true or not. I looked up where Jake
- 41:06Gyllenhaal is from and seeing that he was from Los Angeles,
- 41:10CA, I assumed that his parents lived there in the 60s and 70s
- 41:15since his dad is a screenwriter. So maybe it's true that they
- 41:21lived there, but other than that it it basically was 100% made.
- 41:25Up if we ever get famous enough that we can start going back
- 41:28through Brad's made-up things and asking the people involved
- 41:32if they actually happened. I want I I want retroactive
- 41:35points because like if there's a serial killer around you, you're
- 41:39going to be like, hey, mom and dad, tell me about this thing
- 41:42that you grew up with and they're probably going to tell
- 41:44you about it. So it it still seems plausible.
- 41:47You write it down when we interview Jake Gyllenhaal
- 41:50someday, you can ask him if his parents ever talked about the
- 41:54Zodiac Killer. That's the first question of the
- 41:56interview. There's no like, warming him up,
- 41:59getting on his good side, no. Now I will say I changed the
- 42:04date that the book came out because the book came out in
- 42:071986 and Gyllenhaal was in born in 1980.
- 42:11And I was like, well, if, if Bob knew that Gyllenhaal was born in
- 42:15like 80, then he's probably not going to think that the parents
- 42:17talked to him about it when he was 6.
- 42:20There you go. And so in the first eight weeks
- 42:23of our season here, Brad, I think this is episode #8 I am
- 42:276:00 and 2:00. Yeah, you're killing it.
- 42:30Now I will also say just like the Zodiac, 6:00 and 2:00 is a
- 42:3575%. So apparently according to you I
- 42:38am just doing average at. Apparent to the American grading
- 42:44system, you have a C. Because.
- 42:48If you had an 8 question test and you got 6 right, that's a
- 42:5375% Bob. So I would see your big red pen
- 42:57at the top that said see. And then also the comment.
- 42:59You're killing it just to confuse me.
- 43:02Yep. Awesome.
- 43:04All right, man, let's get back into talking about the movie a
- 43:06little bit. And I do want to talk about
- 43:07Fincher's craft because this is, I think there's only a few
- 43:12moments in the movie where Fincher is really showing off
- 43:15with the camera. There's a kind of very obviously
- 43:18CGI assisted shot where you're tracking a taxi cab around
- 43:23multiple corners from above. It's, you know, when the guy
- 43:25gets killed in the cab. And that's a very, like, look at
- 43:29the fun, sharp angles I can take with a camera.
- 43:32But for the most part, I'm more impressed at Fincher's restraint
- 43:36with the camera in this movie. It's still very precise, but I
- 43:40don't think there's as much showing off with the camera as
- 43:42there was in a movie like The Social Network.
- 43:45And correct me if I'm wrong, this is our third Fincher movie,
- 43:48right? We did Fight Club and Social
- 43:50Network and now this one. Yes, OK.
- 43:52Yeah, I don't think we've done any others.
- 43:55So talk to me a little bit, Brad, about like the
- 43:58Fincheriness of this movie. Does it seem like it belongs in
- 44:01his catalogue? How is it different in terms of
- 44:04the directorial flourishes from the other ones we've watched?
- 44:10I mean the The Social Network feels like the outlier of those
- 44:15three films. This one definitely has a a
- 44:20darkened color palette I guess I'd say.
- 44:24Like if you put a random still from those 3 movies in front of
- 44:28me, like chances are that this film and Fight Club are going to
- 44:35look very similar in my mind. Whereas Social Network has much
- 44:40less of a firm aesthetic. It's more of just like, hey,
- 44:44we're at Harvard and we're in, you know, California and it, it
- 44:48doesn't feel like it's as important to the film.
- 44:51Whereas this film, it's like, yeah, we're going to shoot this
- 44:54as a very dark green, grey, brown color palette that seems
- 45:00similar to Fight Club. I do think that the one shot
- 45:05that made a ton of sense to me that I was curious why he didn't
- 45:10do it more often throughout the film.
- 45:12Because most of the movie he just puts up a new date at the
- 45:18bottom of the screen. And that's that's the new date.
- 45:21We've moved forward. And sometimes he says, you know,
- 45:23four years later, three months later, two days later, the best
- 45:28way of communicating that was when he did the shot of the
- 45:32building, the the skyscraper being the timelapse incredible.
- 45:37It's like, oh, I know in general how long it would take to do
- 45:42that. It's probably a year or two
- 45:43later. That's incredible.
- 45:45I like, loved that shot very much.
- 45:49So didn't like the computer assisted taxi cab shot.
- 45:52It looked very fake to me. Yeah, well, that's also a
- 45:56function of this being 17 years old now, you know, which is
- 45:59crazy because I think that this movie didn't start catching on
- 46:02with the audience that doesn't appreciate it until a few years
- 46:05after the fact because it wasn't like it got nominated for zero
- 46:09Academy Awards, which to me is wild to you is probably like,
- 46:12yes, you are justified, Academy. Makes a lot of sense, this.
- 46:16Is a very stacked year for movies.
- 46:17We've talked about 2007 as potentially the best year in the
- 46:2121st century for movies. So it gets shut out of the
- 46:24Oscars and it didn't make any money.
- 46:25And I think people slowly started to reclaim it.
- 46:29And so for me, I think about Zodiac and I'm like, Oh yeah,
- 46:32that movie's from like 2011, 2012, 2015.
- 46:35I I just think of it as a more recent movie.
- 46:38And it's getting close to its 20th anniversary here in a
- 46:41couple years. So there are certain things
- 46:44about the film that I'm like, Oh yeah.
- 46:45Like I can tell where Fincher used some CGI fireworks on 4th
- 46:49of July or whatever it might be. And they look a little cheesy
- 46:52now. So I have to, I have to agree
- 46:54with that. I wanted to talk about the
- 46:56Fincheriness of the movie though, because just a couple
- 47:00weeks ago we watched Parasite, a movie that I made mention of and
- 47:06said Hong Joon Ho is doing a David Fincher impression in
- 47:10terms of like the way he's using the camera in this movie, the
- 47:13way that it's like always mounted on a tripod, that
- 47:16there's a lot of like pans and they're very precise movements
- 47:20of the camera. Now that you've like watched
- 47:23Zodiac as just a general Fincher refresher, do you see it in
- 47:28Parasite I? Don't know if I do, partially
- 47:35because they're like there's two hours and 37 minutes worth of
- 47:40camera shots that I I don't know if I can pinpoint any specific
- 47:47way that he used the camera. Whereas, like, to me, Parasite
- 47:53stands out as one of the best uses of a camera that I've ever
- 47:57seen in a movie. Like it's so impersonal and it
- 48:02gives you such a detached view of what's going on.
- 48:06I don't like, I just don't know if I've seen that done in many
- 48:10other films. And I I certainly wouldn't say
- 48:14that that's true about Fincher here.
- 48:16I looking back as best as I can through the movie, I can't think
- 48:21of anything about this film that makes the camera work stand out
- 48:25to me. And I'm not saying that like
- 48:27negatively, like there's nothing negative about the camera work.
- 48:31I don't know if there's also anything that makes me go wow,
- 48:34what an incredible film to study camera work on.
- 48:38The more I watched this movie, the more I kind of kicked myself
- 48:41that we placed it so early in the season and we kind of put it
- 48:43around Halloween time and we got pushed back a couple weeks.
- 48:47So like now it's now it's our Thanksgiving movie.
- 48:49It gets spread but but I really think we should have watched a
- 48:54movie like Spotlight 1st. And I like Spotlight.
- 48:57I think it's a competently made movie, but like when you look at
- 49:01the look of that film, it's very flat.
- 49:03Like there's just not much of A palette there.
- 49:05They don't do a great job with the lighting of that film and
- 49:08it's kind of intentionally that way 'cause it's like it takes
- 49:10big and it takes place in a big fluorescent lit office building.
- 49:16This movie, I just think there's such a great depth with the
- 49:18shadows and the way they're playing with light and
- 49:19everything else. But I, I do want to go back to
- 49:21the Bong Joon Ho thing for a minute because I really do see
- 49:26it. I see that so much Fincher in
- 49:28that movie, you know, way more than in a movie like
- 49:30Snowpiercer. I just think that he's like
- 49:33really playing in the Fincher sandbox here.
- 49:37And I think it's also bolstered a little bit by the fact that in
- 49:41the Sight and Sound poll that just came out a couple years
- 49:44ago, and in the 2012 version of the Sight and Sound poll, Bong
- 49:47Joon Ho listed Zodiac as one of the 10 best films ever made.
- 49:50That was like one one of his picks.
- 49:53So I know for a fact this is like got to be an influence on
- 49:55the guy or he wouldn't be putting it in his top 10 there.
- 49:58I watched a great video essay right before we hopped on where
- 50:03the the guy that made the video was comparing this movie with
- 50:07another Bong Joon Ho movie called Memories of Murder.
- 50:10And I think the Fincher has just really kind of gotten his hooks
- 50:13into Bong Joon Ho. And it's really cool to see how
- 50:16the same themes and even sometimes the same way of using
- 50:18the camera can be applied in a Fincher movie and then half a
- 50:22world away in a Korean movie. I just, I thought it was a cool
- 50:26little pairing. It's not back-to-back weeks, but
- 50:29having Parasite followed by a Fincher movie and just kind of
- 50:32examining the darkness that's in the human psyche the way both of
- 50:36those guys do, I thought it was worth worth noting I.
- 50:40Was going to say, do you think that that is like Fincher's
- 50:43legacy as a film maker is that he's just a really dark
- 50:47director? I think he's AI think he's a
- 50:50pervert like and and and like, I mean that as positively as I
- 50:54can. But like you, you have you
- 50:57accused me of being hot take. I think that Jake Gyllenhaal
- 51:02isn't a good actor in this film. And then you just come out and
- 51:06call David Fincher a pervert. I think that he really likes in
- 51:10this video essay I was watching, he talked about the way he used
- 51:13the camera and he he said that he really likes an objective
- 51:16camera kind of to what you were saying.
- 51:18He said the way that I moved the camera.
- 51:20I want it to feel like whatever is happening is doomed to
- 51:25happen. And I really liked that because
- 51:28it's not just the way the camera kind of creeps around sometimes.
- 51:30It could be very precise, but that precision feels like
- 51:34mechanical sometimes, and it feels inhuman.
- 51:37And I think because of that, like, Fincher really likes being
- 51:41making you as an audience member, this helpless observer
- 51:46of wherever he's about to go. And he goes to some really sick
- 51:49psychological places in most of his movies.
- 51:52He loves plumbing the depths of twisted stories.
- 51:56You don't go into a Fincher movie and be like, you know,
- 51:59you're not going to get like step brothers, you know what I
- 52:01mean? Like, it's just it's never going
- 52:02to happen. That's what he's attracted to
- 52:04and it's, I think, more than any other filmmaker.
- 52:07Yes, I see Kubrick there. I see a lot of Hitchcock in
- 52:11Fincher in the way that he is really fascinated and kind of
- 52:15tickled by really dirty things, whether that's violence, whether
- 52:19that's murder or torture or sex, whatever it might be.
- 52:24He's he's voyeuristic in the same way that Hitchcock was, and
- 52:27I think that the way he uses the camera shows that.
- 52:30I think that's probably a fair take.
- 52:32I haven't seen enough Fincher to really dive into it, mostly
- 52:37because I like it. Surprises me that The Social
- 52:40Network is a Fincher film. Like how long has it been since
- 52:44you watched that one? Whatever, we watched it for the
- 52:47podcast. So like 3 or 4 years now
- 52:50probably. Yeah, OK, maybe I feel like it's
- 52:53more recent than that, but you know how fast time goes.
- 52:56I I think the thing for me with a director who focuses on
- 53:00hopeless dark themes, I I don't see the importance of making
- 53:09movies about darkness that don't have any point like that.
- 53:14They're just doesn't seem to me to be an importance of saying,
- 53:19hey, bad things happen without pointing towards and humans are
- 53:26courageous in the face of it or that you know, they, they will
- 53:30always find the light eventually or, you know, find some sort of
- 53:34message that is redemptive. I guess for me, when I look at
- 53:40the world I live in, I don't need super dark reminders of the
- 53:46brokenness of the world. I I see that in everyday life.
- 53:50Yeah, yeah. And I'm not saying that Fincher
- 53:52is my favorite film maker by any stretch.
- 53:54I I don't really, I don't get the perverse joy of watching
- 53:58these sick things happen the way a lot of Fincher fans do.
- 54:02And it's kind of my beef. We talked about this before with
- 54:04the Coen brothers too, like Hurley Cohen's they'll make a
- 54:08movie about like the weird chaotic nature of life, you
- 54:12know, like a movie that you hated.
- 54:13Like Raising Arizona is still like a light hearted examination
- 54:17of like the weird way chaos happens or O brother, where art
- 54:21thou. You know, they take a turn in
- 54:23the mid 2000s and now it's just like nothing has a point.
- 54:26Everything's nihilistic and their response to it is kind of
- 54:30just a shrug into the wind. Fincher's not really a shrug guy
- 54:34as much as he's just like, the world is fucked up.
- 54:37Check this out. You know what I mean?
- 54:39And, and I don't like either one of those things.
- 54:42I, I, I appreciate Fincher's craft and I like this movie more
- 54:46than most other Fincher movies because I don't feel him like,
- 54:51you know, getting his rocks off portraying stuff in this movie.
- 54:54I think it's more just like it's a movie about what dedication
- 54:59looks like and what precision is and how your your efforts might
- 55:04be futile in a world that doesn't care.
- 55:07And like, I think it's more affecting for me than a lot of
- 55:11his other stuff. Yeah, and it it kind of ends in
- 55:14a place where we all know who the killer is without know who
- 55:19knowing who the killer is. And I think that the fact that
- 55:23he had to follow real life events kind of gives it a light
- 55:31that he might not have in a lot of his other films.
- 55:35I think it's a good place for us to get into our last segment of
- 55:38the day, Brad, and it's a segment that we call Let's Make
- 55:40It a Double presented by Blackwood Distilling Co.
- 55:43We're near the end of the episodes of Things, listening to
- 55:47the film and Whiskey Show. Let's have another film with
- 55:49this one, even if it's struggling.
- 55:51It's the final segment of the day.
- 55:52Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 55:55part of the show where we pick a movie to pair.
- 55:57Pair up with this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 56:01Brad, I'll let you go first, man.
- 56:02I'm interested to see if you're going to try to pair this with
- 56:04something that you like better, or if you're just going to roll
- 56:07with let's just make it a double of two movies I don't like.
- 56:11I would say I could go with the Mark Ruffalo of it all and go
- 56:14with Eternal Sunshine. There you go.
- 56:18But I'm not going to do that. I am going to pair it with a
- 56:21movie I did like a lot that is also a procedural drama that I
- 56:26think freaking knocks it out of the park.
- 56:28I'm going to go with 1991's The Silence of the Lambs.
- 56:32The further we've gotten from watching that movie, The more I
- 56:35am very comfortable in thinking that that is a good, not great
- 56:38movie, and equally surprised at how much that movie has affected
- 56:43you. Like one of your very first
- 56:45Blu-ray purchases, a movie that you've mentioned many times, and
- 56:49have you returned to it since watching it?
- 56:51Bread. I haven't, it's been on my list
- 56:54of like these are there's like maybe 10 to 15 movies from the
- 56:58podcast history that the, the vault that we have accumulated
- 57:03that I really want to get back to, but I, I have not found the
- 57:07time yet. I'm trying to decide what I want
- 57:09to pair this with. I think All the President's Men
- 57:11is a good journalistic movie to pair it with.
- 57:14I think you could look at a movie I've I've brought up JFKA
- 57:17couple times. I think that was also an
- 57:19influence in terms of every movie where a character amasses
- 57:23a lot of information and then reveals it all in one big
- 57:27explosive scene at the end, takes its cues from JFK.
- 57:31So you could do that. I think I will pair it with
- 57:34Spotlight, which we're getting to later this season.
- 57:38And I now have a mission of like half that episode is going to be
- 57:44how is this better or worse than Zodiac, Brad, when we get to
- 57:49that? So we will be making it a
- 57:51double, a very long double, but we'll get to that later in the
- 57:54season. So for Brad, it is Silence of
- 57:56the Lambs. For me, it is Spotlight.
- 57:59And that was brought to you by Blackwood Distilling Co.
- 58:02No matter what movie you pick to pair up with this, you can
- 58:05always make it a double with Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 58:08If you go to bourbonoutfitters.com/film
- 58:11Whiskey, that's Bourbon outfitters.com slash film
- 58:14whiskey and buy a bottle of Blackwood, you get 5% off, which
- 58:18is a fantastic deal. Brad, because Blackwood's a
- 58:21luxury whiskey. It is worth every single dollar,
- 58:24but you'll get 5% off with our code film whiskey with an E at
- 58:28checkout. Brad.
- 58:29Let's get into some final scores here.
- 58:32I'll, I'll just without much comment.
- 58:34I don't think it's a 10. I do think it's a 9.5.
- 58:38It's my favorite Fincher movie. I think it's a freaking classic.
- 58:419 1/2 out of 10 for me. Man, you and the Last Jedi in
- 58:46nine and a halfs. I it is forever tarnished, Bob,
- 58:50forever tarnished. I think that I walked away from
- 58:56this movie thinking, eh, boring. Well, made 7 out of 10.
- 59:03I I've talked myself down, Bob, I think this is a 6 1/2.
- 59:07Wow. Well, that lands us at an
- 59:10average of an 8 out of 10, which is kind of exactly where this
- 59:13lands on letterbox instead of four point O out of five S, 8
- 59:16out of 10. Still a very good average for a
- 59:18movie. It sounds like this is a
- 59:20decisive no for you. The classic thing?
- 59:24Yeah, I know. This is not even, not even
- 59:28close. May maybe the furthest from
- 59:31being a modern classic. I was going to say this is your
- 59:33lowest score of the season so far.
- 59:36Yeah. So is this a worse movie than
- 59:39Ford V Ferrari and The Help? Yes.
- 59:43That's crazy. You're you are wrong.
- 59:44That's all there to do it. All right, so it's an 8 from us,
- 59:49but we want to know what you think.
- 59:50You can find us on any one of our social media channels.
- 59:53Who is right and who is wrong here?
- 59:55Tell us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at
- 59:59Film Whiskey. Or join the conversation on our
- 1:00:02Discord server. You can find a link to our
- 1:00:05server at the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:00:07Next week we are changing up our programming just a little bit.
- 1:00:10As you know, each year we do a special Thanksgiving episode
- 1:00:14called Hanksgiving. Instead of releasing that
- 1:00:16episode on Thanksgiving, we're we're going to put it out on
- 1:00:18Tuesday like a regular episode. So we'll be doing our Hanks
- 1:00:21Giving episode on his 2013 I think modern classic Captain
- 1:00:28Phillips and Brad gets to look at me and say I'm the captain
- 1:00:32now. I say you're already declaring
- 1:00:35it a modern classic. I think so.
- 1:00:37It's one of his best performances of the century for
- 1:00:39sure. OK.
- 1:00:40Well, I'm really excited to get into it, Bob.
- 1:00:42Is that a first time watch for you?
- 1:00:44It is wow. OK, so join us next week for
- 1:00:47Captain Phillips, but until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:00:50I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.