Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Thru The Eyes Of Denny O'Neil Pt1
Transcript
- 0:01Hi, everybody, Welcome back. It's word Balloon the Comic Conversation Show John
- 0:06Centris. Here we look back at a fantastic conversation I had with the late
- 0:10great Denny O'Neill. We lost Denny back in twenty twenty, and this conversation
- 0:16happened in twenty eighteen. It was Denny's birthday this weekend. He would have
- 0:21been eighty five years old, and I remain a fan. He was really
- 0:27one of the first writers going back to the early seventies that I really took
- 0:31notice of and could tell the difference between a Denny O'Neill script and some of
- 0:36the old guard that was still part of the Bronze Age of DC. You're
- 0:40gonna hear a lot of Bronze Age and Silver Age stories from Denny as the
- 0:44writer of great things like hard traveling Heroes and the great Batman Rayshot Ghul story.
- 0:51Although I'd like to point out that Denny pronounces it rossaw Gol, and
- 0:57really, up until Batman began, I always pronounced it as Roza Goal,
- 1:02and in fact, I know the Batman adam Ani series also called him Rosa
- 1:06Goual. But whatever. They adapted that great story by Denny and Neil Adams,
- 1:11and it really is a standout for the animated series. I'm sure you
- 1:15agree this is a two parter because it was a nice, leighty conversation.
- 1:19Denny was recuperating from a really bad auto accident. He had a really tough
- 1:26couple of last decades in his life. He had a heart condition and got
- 1:30just tossed around the backseat of a car with a car accident. But thank
- 1:38god, Larry O'Neil reached out to me and said, Dad's just kind of
- 1:42sitting looking at the walls and board. You did a great conversation with him
- 1:47a few years back. Would you be interested in talking to him again?
- 1:49Of course I would. I had three amazing conversations with Denny before his passing,
- 1:53and it means a lot to me that I got to connect with one
- 1:57of my favorite writers. And Batman edited and I'm sure you feel the same
- 2:00way. The great Danny O'Neil looking back at the DC Universe through his eyes
- 2:06Parts one and two on today's word below. Word Ballain is brought to you
- 2:09by Alex ross Art dot com. Alex is a good friend of the show
- 2:14and I am honored that he aligns himself with word Balloon and good lord,
- 2:20we all love his iconic art, whether it's for DC Marvel things like Bonnie
- 2:24Python, the Monkeys, David Bowie, so many other great license things the
- 2:29Beatles. If you go to Alex rossart dot com, you will find great
- 2:34value for your dollar, whether you can spring for something like original cover art
- 2:42or pages to lithos and posters. Every price point you can imagine, you
- 2:49will find something and a beautiful image from Alex ross Art dot com. Word
- 2:53Balloon is also presented by my listeners, the League of word Balloon Listeners.
- 2:58The help that I get via contributions from Patreon, Patreon dot com slash word
- 3:05Balloon. You hear the entertainment that I provide from word Balloon every day that
- 3:08I do a new episode. I am very fortunate to have the great creators
- 3:15of comics and pop culture willing to come on and give you great entertainment.
- 3:20I hope you will consider making an actual cash contribution via Patreon, even on
- 3:25dollar a month. But really, if word Balloon is worth the price of
- 3:30a comic book a month to you, it would be greatly appreciated if you
- 3:34slide that extra money you would put on an issue of a comic book to
- 3:38word Balloon via Patreon, Patreon dot com slash word Balloon. Thank you,
- 3:44League of word Balloon listeners. If you're ready, we'll dive in. Welcome
- 3:50back, Denny O'Neil to word Balloon. As I was just telling you off
- 3:53the air, it's a pleasure to have you back, and I appreciate your
- 3:57clarity of memory and your stories. How are things going in terms of last
- 4:01time we spoke, you had released your semi autobiography half fiction, half true
- 4:08tales. And how's the response been that that took is the best kept secret
- 4:14since the Invaders of Normandy. Oh man, I'm assuming you're going to have
- 4:17the autobiography with you for terrific content for people to buy and sign. I
- 4:23hope, I guess I am. They only gave me ten comps, and
- 4:32I pretty much gave all those away, so I bought fifteen more copies.
- 4:38I do have some copies. Great. I don't know what to do about
- 4:43that book. I don't know even what I think about it. If you
- 4:47want to save yourself five years worth of psychotherapy, write an autobiographical novel.
- 4:55Because the feedback I have gotten people remember things. I didn't even know about
- 5:03because I did them in blackouts, and a lot of them are pretty bad
- 5:08and pretty ugly. Ah, But I had no memory of them until I
- 5:15get reminded, and then I realized, God, I could I was a
- 5:20prick, it could have been a monster. Yeah. And then facing those
- 5:24kind of you know, past behavior and stuff. Yeah, that's got to
- 5:29be humbling, or is it? Because again, these are memories that were
- 5:32blank that they are kind of surprising, and I don't know how how do
- 5:38you process that? You face them? And my ex girlfriend has filled in
- 5:44a lot of blanks to my brother Day and my brother Tom filled in a
- 5:50lot of the blanks. It was worse than I thought. I don't quite
- 6:00know how I got through that without really damaging myself, but I did.
- 6:06And I don't know why some people are able to turn that corner and other
- 6:13people aren't. I didn't plan for the novel I wrote to be as much
- 6:17about drinking as it was. But if you're trying to write about that time
- 6:27in the history of comics and you're trying to do it from one viewpoint,
- 6:34it's very hard. I mean, without completely making the whole thing up out
- 6:43of whole colost it's very hard to not acknowledge those things. So oh,
- 6:50forty percent of the way through the book, I said, well, this
- 6:55is a battle, it's not worth fighting. I will simply tell the story
- 7:00mostly ordered Goose. I wonder if when you were writing things like that famous
- 7:08Green Lantern, Green Arrow story about Speedy's addiction, how much of it you
- 7:15know? Were you in a place that you could, you know, write
- 7:19about that kind of addiction, and were you in denial of your own issues,
- 7:26or you know, where was it in the in the context of your
- 7:30drinking. Did it inform that story at all? It probably did. There
- 7:38is a couple of panels very early on in the continuity in which they mentioned
- 7:46that alcoholism is another form of addiction. I was at a point where I
- 7:54was getting drunk five or sixth ninth a week, and I don't know,
- 7:58I was violent and ugly a lot of that time, but nobody was calling
- 8:07me an alcohol again. My mother went to her grave without putting my name
- 8:13in the words alcohol in the same sentence. And what years were these?
- 8:16What decades were these that this was happening? This is mostly the seventies.
- 8:22Wow, I mean the novel started out as something very different than what had
- 8:28ended up as and what I wanted to do was tell the story of how
- 8:35comics came of age. Yeah, my son was twisting one arm, and
- 8:46I guess Mary's friend was twisting the other, and they kept saying you should
- 8:50like your story, and I objected to that, but I finally agreed if
- 8:56I could combine it with a fantasy and not have any of my self imposed
- 9:09rules, it would be an interesting thing to try. It's writing a novel
- 9:13the way we were taught, and college novels are written, and they're mostly
- 9:20not written that way. But you know, sit down, wait for the
- 9:24angel of inspiration to ride on your shoulder and whisper in your ear, and
- 9:30then make it up and to go along. I've written about ten novels.
- 9:37Only two did I make up because I was going along, And one,
- 9:41if I had my way, every single copy of that book in the world
- 9:46would vanish, would suddenly evaporate it because I certainly don't want anybody to read
- 9:52it who hasn't already, and it does have my name on the cover.
- 9:58That was well, it was a pretty easy job to do, and I
- 10:05did have the experience of writing a novel, writing a science fiction novel.
- 10:13When that was completed and published, I realized I am now a science fiction
- 10:20write. I have published a book that has been marketed as science fiction,
- 10:26and I don't know what an atom is. So I tried to fill in
- 10:33that huge gap in my education. I mean, I went to Saint Luis
- 10:39Juan. If you were an English major, you didn't take any science courses.
- 10:43You weren't allowed to, Okay, But it occurred to me, and
- 10:48I was right that anybody who lives in our time, in our error should
- 10:54know some science, especially if you're going to presume to write about it.
- 11:00So there was a book called One Who Tree Infinity that was a popularization of
- 11:07Einstein's theory, and that book was a huge help and good start. And
- 11:13then now I've got probably one hundred college courses on discs cross the room there,
- 11:20and maybe twenty twenty five percent of them have to do with science and
- 11:26math. I still can't do math, but I find science fascinating. There's
- 11:35an item in the Gannette Papers this morning about how our galaxy ate another galaxy.
- 11:43Wow, yeah, I mean I find that stuff really cool. Sure,
- 11:48prior to that exploration of science, do you feel that your writing was
- 11:54more space opera. Then in terms of science fiction, well, no,
- 12:01I didn't think about it doing much. I'm One of the secrets of being
- 12:07a professional writer of the time that I am is don't burn yourself with being
- 12:16an author, or don't carry into the job a lot of expectations. If
- 12:22I can get an editor and say we need this by the twenty fifth,
- 12:26it has to be seventy five thousand words, and that gives me some problems
- 12:35to solve. Okay, I know I can solve problem. I don't operate
- 12:41the way my son does. He is very scrupulous about getting every syllable right.
- 12:48I'm not. I think it's a job. And if I start thinking
- 12:54about, well, i'm competing with Alfred Bester here, I'm competing with Isaac
- 12:58Asimov, I'll be paralyzed. I'm not as good as those people. I
- 13:03never will be, or never was. So if I think about it,
- 13:09the way is to think about newspaper work, the press, thinking he's going
- 13:15to press the red button at ten o'clock. My story has to be on
- 13:18there on the press. Yet that I can handle. When I have a
- 13:22book to write, I do simple long division. I can do that much.
- 13:28Now beyond that, I'm lost. But if I have one hundred days
- 13:35to do this and it has to be one hundred thousand words, that's how
- 13:39long I've got. That's how much I have to do every day. In
- 13:43the first hardcover I was in a bad car crash in the middle of writing
- 13:48it. This was Batman of Retires, the first really major cantinaity we did.
- 13:58Nightfall was called and I had to kind of alter my message. For
- 14:07three weeks, I couldn't write or do any work, but we made it.
- 14:11Charlie Customer and I spent at the last weekend sitting in my bedroom in
- 14:20Brooklyn going over the manuscript and editing it there, and then it had to
- 14:30be on the presses by noon Monday. This was Friday. Charley and I
- 14:33spent the weekend editing that book and we made the deadline. Charlie gets huge
- 14:45thanks. He was one is one of the best editors I've ever had,
- 14:50and the book was given. All the handicaffs that there were in getting the
- 14:56thing done, one of which was we knew we were we're going to do
- 15:00this novelization, and I didn't know that there was going to be any DBC
- 15:05adaptation, but I knew that there would be comic books and other stuff and
- 15:09the deadline would be non negotiable. But I said, I'm writing two or
- 15:16three comic books a month, I'm editing a franchise. There are only twenty
- 15:24four hours in the day. I can't I can't manage this. So just
- 15:28isn't enough time. And Mary Franz said, if you let somebody else do
- 15:35this, you'll never forgive yourself. And I said, well, you know,
- 15:41when you put it life out, you're absolutely right. So every Saturday
- 15:48morning, Mary Pram and I would get in the car and go out to
- 15:50the end of Brooklyn to a shopping mall meet Charlie Tutchman. I would give
- 15:56in the work I had done in the past six days. He edited as
- 16:02he went along, and then as I said, we did the final rewrights
- 16:07and edits really under the gun. Mary fran bring hand cookies and coffee every
- 16:14five or six hours, and we got through it. I am delighted that
- 16:18I had that experience, and I never want to do anything like that again.
- 16:25I bought a computer. I bought a laptop computer. I hadn't used
- 16:30any computers up to that point, but driving to Saint Louis, we both
- 16:37got sleeping. Mary frown and I. After lunch, I had been driving,
- 16:42and I told her, you've got to take You've got to do this.
- 16:45I can't keep my eyes open. He said, I can't either.
- 16:49I'll tell you what you drive for the first hour and then I'll take it.
- 16:55We hit a wall doing seventy in the middle of that hour. So
- 17:02we spent Christmas Day in an intensive care award in a little mountaintown in Pennsylvania.
- 17:10Jesus and understand, I had the book about forty percent. The car,
- 17:18I'm told by people who saw the accident, flipped over three times and
- 17:22the computer was loose in the backseat. So we got put into an intensive
- 17:30care award and the doctor asked what he could do for me, and I
- 17:34said, go out to wherever the what's left of the car is and get
- 17:41my computer. The computer was fine, no glitches. I should have written
- 17:47Apple a thank you letter, because did that as a heartcover. And we
- 17:57knew it was going to be a big deal. In fact, we sort
- 18:00of set out to do a big deal Batman Protect. What I didn't know
- 18:07was that over across Fate Carrider Mike Carlin was doing something very similar with Superman,
- 18:17same thing. He dies, yes, comes back. So I eventually
- 18:22went to Paul and said, why didn't you tell me that Mike was doing
- 18:27this, because we have two stories going at the same time. We're getting
- 18:34one year's benefit out of this. We could have gotten two years. And
- 18:38he said, no, I did that deliberately because we want to tell the
- 18:45fans, hey, look at these things. Stuff is really happening over there,
- 18:48all over the place. Yeah. I don't know if he was right
- 18:52or wrong, but he did have. As always with Paul, he has
- 18:56reasons and they're generally good. One. It piqued my interest. I mean,
- 19:02I was certainly reading both stories, and that's interesting because I thought that
- 19:07Nightfall almost was inspired by the Superman Doomsday and Death of Superman story. So
- 19:15that's interesting in that typical way that sometimes it's just in the it's in the
- 19:21atmosphere, and you guys independently were both thinking along the same lines. That's
- 19:26pretty interesting. And I don't think a lot of people knew that pretty amazing.
- 19:30No, I'm sure that a lot of people thought I zood it,
- 19:33But I was following in my footsteps, and if you know how publishing worked,
- 19:41it was impossible for me to fall in follow in his footsteps because we
- 19:45had the same lead time, we had the same deadline. Sure, Wow,
- 19:52Nightfall really was I think a terrific story, and wasn't in response to
- 19:59the things that were happening at Image and those more extreme superheroes that you know,
- 20:06those guys that left Marvel were doing on their own. Now I knew
- 20:12about those guys. Image sent their whole company up to drop in on DC
- 20:22and make a visit, and at least I and I think some of my
- 20:27colleagues thought, well, they're, you know, coming to make peace with
- 20:33us, and that they were telling us they were going into competition with us,
- 20:38which they did very successfully per few years. But what happened with us
- 20:45is I guess my primary concern was always storytelling, and I realized that I
- 20:56had the freedom to do a two thousand word story with a character who,
- 21:03it has been estimated, would be recognized by eighty percent of the people on
- 21:10the planet. And I thought, this is a rare gift they are giving
- 21:15me as a storyteller. I can actually do this. I don't know if
- 21:22we can bring it off, but I know that nobody will stop me from
- 21:26trying so we had done the Robin Guy's story, and I thought that sends
- 21:36a message to the readers, with the loyal readers, that we are not
- 21:44about killing Batman. So we were at a retreat very close to where I'm
- 21:51sitting. I didn't know about Nayak, but it's crossed the river from Terrytown,
- 21:57and we realized, if we're going to kill make the world think that
- 22:02Batman instead, there's a pretty big step to take. I better get permissions.
- 22:07So either one of my assistants or I call New York every ninety minutes
- 22:11or so and explain what we were going to do, and said, you
- 22:17know, it's not too late. We've plotted the next six months, but
- 22:21it's not too late to change. Is it going to be any problem with
- 22:25this? Tell me? And I got all the go aheads I needed.
- 22:29So cut to three months later and we're into the story and I'm crossing a
- 22:36lobby from the building at the building where DC had its headquarters, and I
- 22:42run into an executive who tells me I have to bring Batman back to life.
- 22:48And I tried to explain, well, if nobody reads any Batman this
- 22:53year and they pick it up any year, they won't know that anything has
- 22:57happened. We're going to put all pieces back where you would like them to
- 23:02be. Didn't make any difference. So I had to compromise a story by
- 23:07inventing that subplot where Batman disguises himself as a British detective. As a writer
- 23:17who gave me the challenge, can I do British a convincing British accent in
- 23:26cold print? That compromised the story pretty badly. And my guests, based
- 23:38only on experience with that world, is that the people we were calling during
- 23:45the retreat did not bother to ask their superiors if it was okay to do
- 23:52this. So for the guys in the real big offices, this was a
- 23:57bad shock to them. Batman instead Batman is worth billions. Well, yeah,
- 24:06this is in the midst of the of the movies obviously, and I'm
- 24:11sure things were. I mean, sales certainly hadn't dropped as I understood it,
- 24:15or maybe they did, I don't know. So what was your work?
- 24:18Do you mind revealing what your original story plan was? Were you planning
- 24:23to after killing Batman, revive him or did you want him to stay dead
- 24:29and have John Paul Valley or Dick Grayson, someone else taking over the mantle.
- 24:34Well, we we live in the real world, and I knew I
- 24:37would not get away with permanently killing Batman, but I thought I could get
- 24:42away with having him off stakes for you. So that was really what we're
- 24:49going to do. Batman goes off. I hadn't plotted at that far.
- 24:55One of the basic disagreements I had with my crew was they wanted to plot
- 25:00every beat at the retreats, and I wanted to get know what the big
- 25:06events for the next six months are and let's give our writers some elbow room
- 25:11to come up with better ideas. So we're going to bring Bruce Layne back,
- 25:18probably more or less as he was brought back eventually, though one of
- 25:23my freelance writers had some uncharitable things to say about curing somebody by laying on
- 25:34the hands. It's since been done on television series. But we were going
- 25:41I was going to replace Batman with John Paul Valley for a year and then
- 25:52maybe kill off Asrael and everything would be as it was. Almost. When
- 26:03we were almost at the end, they asked me to do Asrael as a
- 26:11hero and as a monthly book. Well again, it was if I let
- 26:18somebody else do this, I'll never forgive myself. But he was conceived as
- 26:25a villain, right, So I don't know. I have very mixed feelings
- 26:32about the series. I think maybe the middle run, the middle third was
- 26:37pretty weak and the rest of it was probably okay. I never read published
- 26:45material, and that's not an exception. They did do another Asrael series and
- 26:55neglected to pay me for that, and I decided not to make a fuss
- 26:59about that. Wow, but yeah, that's love. They are now they
- 27:03are now obligated to pay us for anselar use of stuff we've created, which
- 27:10is a huge step forward from say, ten years ago. That's great to
- 27:15hear. And I know you mentioned that last time, like they're using Leslie
- 27:18Tompkins in Gotham, and I'm glad that you're being compensated for that. I
- 27:25just talked to Jerry Ordway and he was telling me about how a Supergirl was
- 27:30using Kat Grant and that, you know, was he was being compensated.
- 27:33So no, that's that's great to hear it. God, I mean,
- 27:37jeez, man, the the the additions to the Batman House, if you
- 27:41put it in architecture terms, that you made over these decades and stuff.
- 27:45Absolutely, man, I hope you're getting fade and I'm I'm glad to hear
- 27:48that it has gotten better. And I understand that, as you told me
- 27:52in our last conversation, that Howard Chickens lawyer has been pretty instrumental in kind
- 27:59of make do all that stuff happen. Am I correct. Yeah, He's
- 28:03a very good man and a very I mean a very nice man and a
- 28:07very good lawyer. And he when the need for a lawyer arose in my
- 28:15life, I had the indispensable Larry call around. I said, see if
- 28:22you can find me who the best lawyer for comic books is, and he
- 28:27came up with Harris Millard, who was amazingly cooperative and very generous. He
- 28:33could have charged me two or three times what he did. So yeah,
- 28:40Harris, I've had occasionally calling once or twice since. Well. In the
- 28:49novel, the hero of the novel was originally Captain Power. Yes, yes,
- 28:56and I had Harris look up Captain Power and he said, well,
- 29:00there are three Captain Powers who are actually under copyright. Probably nobody will make
- 29:08a fuss, but they could if they wanted to. So that's why we
- 29:12changed it, but Harris didn't. I mean, he just did that as
- 29:15a favor to me. Yeah, I can find that out. That's excellent.
- 29:19Yeah, man, very cool. I will really good news happened when
- 29:26we went to see Batman Versus Superman, and we looked at that. Well,
- 29:33when I heard that they were making that, I thought, are they
- 29:37aware of what they've left themselves in foots? This is I mean, these
- 29:41characters have never belonged in the same universe. It's an accident of publishing history
- 29:49that they are yo. But it's not a good idea because one guy juggled
- 29:56sons and one guy can mention Chris probably five hundred pounds and swim real fast
- 30:03and stuff. But they they're not the same kind of character. The mythology
- 30:08is real different. But we thought at the at the beginning credits of that
- 30:18movie Batman co created by Bob Kane and Bill Finger. So when we got
- 30:25home, we know, or I know Bill Finger's granddaughter a little bit.
- 30:30I've been on panels with her and I had her phone number. So Mary's
- 30:36name. Caldern when we got home said, how did you Denny never was
- 30:41able to put your grandfather's name on anything that had to do with Batman.
- 30:48Was this a one time lonely thing? And althea said no, we actually
- 30:53won, finally won a lawsuit and from now on the name Bill Finger will
- 31:00be any anytimes to the name Batman will see Bill Finger. Bob Kane's name
- 31:07is still on it, and he had virtually nothing to do with the characters
- 31:11as we know it. But at least Alcia, I mean Bill died I'm
- 31:18told broke and probably drinking too much. But my one evening when was very
- 31:25drunk. Wow. But Althia at least his granddaughter will live comfortably. One
- 31:34of the when I went out to visit the set, one of the time
- 31:41Warner checkutives told me that every time we do a Batman movie, I write
- 31:47a seven figure check for Bob Kain. Wow. So like in the mid
- 31:52fifties being paid for Batman probably didn't a mount too much. But those movies
- 32:00have made billions with a B of course and a little a little surprised loom
- 32:08or us. Yeah, absolutely most of them. Certainly most of them did
- 32:15well. Alas heard, I don't count schackers contributed unders. I think a
- 32:23lot of fans agree with you on that did now well. Apparently agrees.
- 32:29Yeah, that's I heard him on Fresh Air, the NPR Interview show,
- 32:35and he and he and he talked about having to create scenes. They would
- 32:38bring him a toy prototype and say, we need a scene like this in
- 32:44Batman and Robin, And I think that kind of obviously contributed to the goofiness
- 32:50of the of the Clooney movie. Certainly the Kilmer movie also a little you
- 32:54know, not as great as you know, the two that Tim Burton did.
- 32:58But I you know, I thought I thought Val Kilmer did okay,
- 33:01you know, in spite of a lot of the zaniness, and you've got
- 33:04Jim Carrey as the Riddler, and man, what a waste of Tommy Lee
- 33:07Jones. Wouldn't it have been interesting? I'm sure you agree to see him
- 33:12really get into the you know, two faces literally of Harvey Dent and they
- 33:17and they you know, to play two like a joker. Wow. Wow,
- 33:25I mean he he played in the camp. Yeah, yeah, and
- 33:30they really barely got into that wonderful backstory of Harvey Dent, the district attorney
- 33:36that worked with Batman, and I even very quickly there was like a moment
- 33:39of clarity where Tommy Lee Jones is like you're right, Bruce. I you
- 33:43know, he tries to appeal to Harvey and for a second Harvey saye and
- 33:47talking to him, and it's like, oh, there's that relationship. But
- 33:51you know, that was like twenty seconds and and you know, like I
- 33:54said, a missed opportunity. So yeah, and then the dog won.
- 34:00The best part of the script, which I thought was at best mediocre,
- 34:06but it was a subplot which explains it gives Bruce Wayne and out he's been
- 34:15blaming himself for his parents' death and he finally he gets a book of information
- 34:22and he's not responsible for He thought that he made his parents vote to the
- 34:29theater that night, and it turns out that they delayed their theater sojourned for
- 34:36twenty four hours, so it wasn't his fault at all. I might quarrel
- 34:40with that as a Batman's storyteller, because I always thought that the symbolic avenging
- 34:47of the Wayne's death was part of the essence of the character. Nonetheless,
- 34:57that was a very well written subplot that answered questions, and they just cover
- 35:01it interesting. They left a couple of lines in that don't make any sense
- 35:06without a context support a man, but that is the movie biz, I
- 35:14hear you, man, I wonder, I I just and not to name
- 35:17drop, but for context. A couple months ago, I had a dinner
- 35:22with uh Mark Miller, uh and we were talking about Superman and the question
- 35:29of is is Superman kal l of Krypton or is he Clark Kent that learns
- 35:34he's kal El of Krypton and grows up with the Earth values and you know,
- 35:38Clark is the man? Superman is the guys? H and Mark's disagreement
- 35:45was, no, he is, you know, so smart being a Kryptonian
- 35:49that it's like almost like being raised by a colony of ants in terms of
- 35:52the intellectual difference of a Kryptonian and an earth Man. And I wondered regarding
- 35:58you know, I'm sure you've been hit with this question before. Is Batman
- 36:01the real man? Is Bruce Wayne a guys? Or is this a traumatized
- 36:07Bruce Wayne that you know is still you know at the end of the day,
- 36:12Uh, you know, a guy trying to do good. But you
- 36:15know what, what is your thought on the Batman versus Bruce Wayne? Guys?
- 36:20I think Bruce Wayne died with his and from then on, Batman ruth
- 36:30allowed that tragedy to shape this is life stasis he made so from in my
- 36:37mind I never got from any writer except myself. Befoll Bruce Wayne. I
- 36:45wanted. There has been, particularly with the movies, a tendency to make
- 36:51Bruce Wayne, you know this very smart, ruthless tycoon guy. I think
- 36:57he should have been well. I had a real life person that owned a
- 37:02magazine. I freelanced for a guy who was really a nice man, very
- 37:10inherited a vast fortune and kind of blew it by never being able to get
- 37:16his act together. My Bruce Wayne would be driving a Ferrari, but he'd
- 37:22have a dent in the front fender because he backed into hit something the first
- 37:28time he took it out, and he was totally dependent on his assistance,
- 37:35as I occasionally was, to get things done love life. I didn't think
- 37:42there would have been any room for a relationship. So in my private version,
- 37:52Gotham City is full of debutants who had date one date with Bruce Layne
- 37:57and said, oh, had I think he took me home at ten o'clock.
- 38:01He just wasn't feeling well. I couldn't see him as a lover and
- 38:08the information. I just got that he's he's making it with Catwoman. Well,
- 38:16the dynamic with Russi al Ghoul was he could never get it on with
- 38:22Talia, though clearly they were the only two people on the planet who were
- 38:27ideal for each other. But she had a daddy hang up and he had
- 38:32a criminal hang up, and she was a criminal, so he could never
- 38:37do that. I thought that added attention to the continuity that helped the story
- 38:44along. I understand. And what did you think when there's a couple of
- 38:47times when Steve Engelhardt created Silver Saint Cloud and we had the Laughing Fish story.
- 38:53You were you editing then or were you also? No? I was.
- 38:59I was a free that we're both writers of Batman. Okay, so,
- 39:04and Steve convinced the powers would be that, you know, he he
- 39:08was a hot writer. I never paid attention to things like who's hot,
- 39:15or there was a kind of picking arder. If you were the guy who
- 39:19wrote Superman, you were higher on the picking higher, and then you're a
- 39:22guy that wrote Powerman. But those things weren't part of some people's experience.
- 39:31And when I finally took over editing the franchise, I simply ignored Silver Saint
- 39:39Cloud. I thought it was a bad idea. I didn't think that Batman
- 39:45would fall in love with a debutante, so you didn't. We didn't have
- 39:51to write her out. We could just ignore. It. Was the same
- 39:53way with Batman's Child in that graphic novel of my I thought it was Yeah,
- 40:01I thought that was a terrible idea in terms of Batman storytelling. But
- 40:07I didn't have to write it out. I could, I explained to Mike,
- 40:10and we took a long walk around the lake in Hollywood, but I
- 40:17was not going to ever refer to that. And this is nothing against you,
- 40:22Mike. It's in my editorial opinion. It's not a good storytelling.
- 40:28Cope. I don't think Mike has ever forgiven me for that. But they
- 40:32have those characters back, and uh, that's now an official part of the
- 40:40continuity. That's right. Yeah, Damien is Yeah, Damien's part of the
- 40:45story now. And you have to remember that there is no lighter wrong in
- 40:51this, oh Man. That was my opinion of how the story and the
- 40:58mythos should play out. Doesn't mean I was right all along. It was
- 41:01my opinion and it was working. I understand absolutely, Man you know,
- 41:07you're known for some of your guidelines, if not rules, for writing Batman,
- 41:14and I know one of them, and I imagine it might dovetail into
- 41:16what you were saying earlier about Superman, and I want to explore that for
- 41:20a second. But one thing I know that you said was you didn't like
- 41:22Batman in Space, and that you would kind of, you know, shy
- 41:27away from those stories and stuff as much as you could. Sometimes there was
- 41:30a big event, and I suppose, you know, they expected the Batman
- 41:35comics to dovetail into an event. But it seemed again I only get my
- 41:39information from the fan magazines of the day, but it sounded like you weren't
- 41:44crazy about the idea of putting Batman in space. I thought it was a
- 41:47terrible idea in the same way it was a terrible idea of her eye as
- 41:52trying to put the spirit into space. They're not that kind of terror from
- 41:58this post. Let's think underpinnings for Batman. It's more Dracula than Percival or
- 42:08any of the King Arthur's men. Okay, I don't think those guys were
- 42:15thinking about this stuff with the left side of their brains. But in a
- 42:21way, Batman is brilliant because we are fascinated by darkness, and evil villains
- 42:27are almost always more interesting than heroes. Well, here you have that iconic
- 42:32iconography of the dark and in every culture that I know about except Chinese,
- 42:39that's our symbols of evil or reincarnated souls or stuff like that. So you
- 42:45have that iconography. When he's on our side. He's a good guy,
- 42:52So you had to take an ebit. Putting him in space makes it what
- 42:58I think of his science face, some light just not appropriate for the character
- 43:05as we were doing him. Then it doesn't mean that somebody will come along
- 43:09and ride a terrific Batman in space story. If it's happened, I haven't
- 43:15seen it. Well. And how often, again, based on what you
- 43:21said about the Batman Superman ideas, that they were kind of conflicting universes in
- 43:27the same publishing house, how often did Superman show up in your Batman stories?
- 43:32If ever, only when there was a crossover. And I never resisted
- 43:40participating in the crossover because that was city, you know, going in.
- 43:46It's not your ball and it's not true bat and your daddy doesn't own the
- 43:51part. Sure, something that is like that we had to participate in them.
- 44:00I was always able to hide and code that Batman occupied a little distant
- 44:04corner of the story and could do Batman like things and did not have to
- 44:09deal with ray guns and spaceships and aliens. Batman as a storytelling tool was
- 44:21flexible enough that we could get away with cheating like that once in a while,
- 44:25as long as I didn't have to do it every month. Understood,
- 44:30And again, like, what about the interpersonal relationship with Superman? How did
- 44:36you tackle it when it necessitated a conversation between Clark and Bruce. I didn't
- 44:45any like that scene. I don't remember. Well. Miller kind of answered
- 44:51that, sure, if I'm remembering my continuity Superman is Batman a piece of
- 44:59kryptonite? He says, if I ever go off the deep family USUS.
- 45:05I thought that was a good way to nod toward established continuity and still a
- 45:14duel with a logical story point. You know, I think that was John.
- 45:19I think that was John Byrne in Man of Steel that yeah, And
- 45:22I also wonder as John byrn came in that that period, because obviously you
- 45:29had Frank writing Batman Batman year one, and certainly before the Dark Knight returns.
- 45:35That was, you know, such a great elevator, you know,
- 45:37evolution of the character. And in the meantime, Berne was doing his thing
- 45:43with Man of Steel and you know, obviously rebooting Superman and kind of changing
- 45:47things around, stripping away a lot of that Mort Weisinger era and even Julie
- 45:52Schwartzeer obviously. So how did you know when when there was this newer Superman?
- 45:59Did you you know, did the character change at all for you from
- 46:02an editorial standpoint or a writing standpoint? Yeah? Oh yeah, by all
- 46:12mean yeah. And by the way, you know, we've already gone an
- 46:15hour, like am I am? Am? I taxing you? I don't
- 46:16want to You're not. I have nothing to do until tomorrow at two.
- 46:23Well, I've enjoyed the conversation, so please continue. But yeah, I
- 46:30resisted being involved with Superman on that first arose and my problem was basically what
- 46:42we do is fantasy melo drama. Essence, a melo drama is conflict.
- 46:50You have to have a worthy opponent for your zero. To have Superman go
- 46:58after pick pockets would be looted. Chris, Well, how do you keep
- 47:06contriving a problem for Superman? To solve. I mean, I did the
- 47:12Justice League for about a year and a half and that's where that problem arose.
- 47:16When I did my fourth or fifth billion Invasion, I realized this,
- 47:22my creative tank is empty as far as this this character is concerned. Later
- 47:27rioters did a much better job than I did of making it makes sense and
- 47:31getting good stories out of it. But yeah, they to my mind,
- 47:37they did not belong in the same story. And if you if you have
- 47:44Superman, it depends on which era. But at his most powerful, he
- 47:50was God. He was juggling sons, he was able to search every room
- 47:55in the propolis. A second versay, do put that character in a believable
- 48:01conflict? He can do anything? Said, why doesn't he sell? Whatever
- 48:07problem it is in the second panel? You had to contrive answers to that
- 48:14if you were going to be consistent with the character. Back in the farties
- 48:19when they were creating this stuff, they didn't worry about that, and they
- 48:24shouldn't have. I mean, it was enough part of the problem. They
- 48:28had to solve a lot of them. Well, Jury, you mentioned Jury
- 48:35before, who became a pretty close friend of mine towards the end of his
- 48:39day. Great guy, and he did occasional script changes when he was,
- 48:47you know, a very young guy doing comics. But that was okay because
- 48:52nobody knew how to write comic books back then. And I the mistake I'm
- 48:59most often and I went into and I was teaching, was people ask things
- 49:05of the artists they can't deliver. So Garry had a natural gift as a
- 49:13storyteller, and he was a very good artist. And if some writer who
- 49:19had never written a comic book before asked for something that couldn't be accommodated in
- 49:27that very limited and artificial storytelling tool that was the comic book, Gerry could
- 49:39change it. I think that I've been written a few times. I deeply,
- 49:46deeply resented. It's one of the reasons I don't I don't read published
- 49:57work. And I made one a horrible's life mistake this Within the past year,
- 50:02I watched myself on television. I watched the public I don't normally do
- 50:08that because I don't like the way I look, but I watched the public
- 50:15television thing. Yeah, and that was a terrible mistake on my part because
- 50:22it was apparently I didn't have much to do with green lantern, Green Arrow,
- 50:27Apparently the artist wanted to draw a green lantern, so he got Julie
- 50:31Charts too, And then then Denny wrote a script. Wow. No,
- 50:36Denny wrote the script a long time before the artist was involved. Denny thought
- 50:42the script was going to be done by Gill Kenny. But it's nothing to
- 50:49get leathery about. But it is annoying. Well, let's set the record
- 50:52straight. Let's talk about that Greenland and Green Arrow run because I and it's
- 50:59I was thinking about how Siegel and Shuster very early on in Superman really had
- 51:06Superman attacking social justice issues. And I know there was a very early issue
- 51:10where it leaned out a slum and really kind of improved it and you know,
- 51:15after an evil mind owner. Yes, and of course the famous radio
- 51:21story of him going after the clan and and things like that. So and
- 51:25they are also on the radio and anti Semitics story, yes, very much
- 51:31so yes, so so yeah, tell me like was the first green Land
- 51:37and Green Arrow story about where that classic scene happens where the elderly black gentleman
- 51:43says, hey, you say, you know you save the orange skins,
- 51:45you save the purple skins. What are you doing for the black skins here
- 51:47on Earth. No that way. Neil did not only show the script,
- 51:55but I thought, that's among the three best panels ever in the history of
- 52:01comics. And one of the things that absolutely delights me is my favorite politician
- 52:08who turns out to be a huge comics fan and the only person I know
- 52:13who ever read all of Philip K. Dick. He use that as a
- 52:19campaign he rewrote the dial. Wow. That guy's name is Alan Grison.
- 52:25He is a Democratic congressman up currently up a reelection from Florida. And I
- 52:36got this Mary got took a phone call and she said, there's this congressman
- 52:44who wants to know if he can buy a coffee or drink or something.
- 52:50And I thought, well, okay, he probably wants my help with because
- 52:55he's going to do a campaign comic book. Oh. I arranged to meet
- 53:00the guy, and no, we didn't talk about politics. We talked about
- 53:05comic books. I gave him his five minute crash course in visual emeritive than
- 53:14in static images, and then he told me. We got on til K
- 53:19Dick and he told me that he had read all of til K Dicks and
- 53:22execuses. I could that's something like five thousand pages and I don't know anybody
- 53:29else who even tried to do that. Very cool. I'm looking him up.
- 53:32I want to make sure I think this is I think I know Alan
- 53:36Grayson. I think he's uh made himself known at times in Well's. He
- 53:43doesn't take corporate money. He's he's the real deal as far as I can
- 53:47tell. Yes, I don't think it's possible to be a major politician and
- 53:54remain unforrupted. But he's been on my for a two years now, and
- 54:01I get two or three mailing emails from him in a week. He looks
- 54:09like the real deal. And I said, you grew up in the Bronx.
- 54:14He was a street kid. Well, it seems to have been as
- 54:16strong as I remember seeing video clips of him. I know he was a
- 54:21strong proponent for you know, better healthcare and certainly was complaining about the Republican's
- 54:27answer. And I remember a famous quote of his of you know, the
- 54:30Republican solution is you get sick, you don't get elfcare, and you die.
- 54:34And that's how they saw healthcare issues. So no, I know exactly
- 54:37what you're talking about. And isn't it always great when you learn various people
- 54:42who are comic book people. And I certainly get a kick out of it
- 54:45when I hear not only celebrities but also again, yeah, Brad Meltzer,
- 54:50I forget which specific politician had green arrow in his office and as he was
- 54:58getting started with his green arrow and refer to uh, I think I believe
- 55:02he was a governor and and you know, and it certainly wasn't Jeb Bush.
- 55:06That's his local governor tied Florida. But uh no, that's great,
- 55:10and I well, and I wanted to know. So when you when you
- 55:15suggested these stories to Julie Schwartz, I'm assuming and and you you guys were
- 55:21kind of putting more social justice in these stories. Was there a concern?
- 55:24Was there like, Hey, we don't want to you know, we're telling
- 55:25stories for twelve year olds. Why what you know? What are you doing
- 55:30putting putting these kinds of issues in stories? I wondered the same thing.
- 55:36So I talked to Julie a lot for the last year of his wife.
- 55:39I thought to remember that morning I was going in to teach class and he
- 55:46was coming in, would walk up and down the hall and stick his head
- 55:51and open doors and say, what are you doing to editors. So I
- 55:57don't think Julie bothered to ask permission. I want to ask him. Well,
- 56:02the conventional wisdom in the parties and fifties was you can't have continued stories
- 56:07because the newsstand distribution was so erratic that because I got Detective forty five,
- 56:15that doesn't mean I will be able to get Detective Party six. Yes,
- 56:22and yet he did a continued story once a year, and I said,
- 56:27how did you get away with that? And he said, I didn't ask,
- 56:30but nobody ever said anything. I think with Green Lantern, Green Arrow,
- 56:36he didn't see any need to share what we were doing with anyone.
- 56:43And so yeah, I mean if the genesis of that was my my weekly
- 56:49visit to DC and I do a terrible jewely schortz, Well my water,
- 56:55what have you got? And it was a very u buncular editor. And
- 57:04I had done a couple of things, one of them for him with social
- 57:10concerns near the center of the story, and I wanted to do more.
- 57:16I was genuinely concerned with what was going on in the world. So he
- 57:27said that they wanted he personally, I think, wanted to continue publishing Green
- 57:32Lantern, the science fiction elements of it must have appealed to him, but
- 57:39the sales did not justify continual publication, so he pretty much gave me a
- 57:45slave. I told him an idea or two I had. Then I went
- 57:51home and wrote the story, and then I wrote another one and another one,
- 57:57and at that point the first one was on the newsstand and we got
- 58:01noticed by reporters. The first story that appeared was in The Village Voice,
- 58:08a counterculture newspaper from Greenwich Village that was on my must reading. I Hear
- 58:15You Me Too? Was founded by Norman Mailer in a bar or used to
- 58:24frequent anyway. Uh uh. I think that somebody at the Voice saw this
- 58:36and thought there might be a story there and called the number that was in
- 58:40the telephone book for DC Comics. Maybe got a receptionist or an assistant editor,
- 58:47somebody who didn't know what we were doing, because Julie wasn't mentioned in
- 58:52the Village Voice piece, nor was I, nor was Neil. And I
- 58:59think they did what they were doing. That changed rapidly and drastically, and
- 59:05we found ourselves. I found myself being interviewed by Paris and television. There's
- 59:09an experience not many people have and we got invited to universities and we were
- 59:17something respectable. But I think that that came as aide surprise to the people
- 59:25in the Big office because comic books, you know, we don't have.
- 59:30I doubt that they read it. One of the real pluses in the Paul
- 59:36Levitt's column is he did read this stuff and he had opinions about it.
- 59:42But I don't think any of the executives bothered. And so this came as
- 59:47a surprise to him. But it came as a surprise that came an endorsement
- 59:52from there of New York City among other people. So they saw a bandwagon
- 59:58that could hop on and uh that may eventually wrote a Texas as far as
- 1:00:06he was the last liberal Republican mayor, that was that. John Lindsay,
- 1:00:14John John Lindsay, Yeah, yeah, no, I remember, yeah,
- 1:00:17and I and I've certainly seen my share a video of Mari Lindsay and everything.
- 1:00:22And of course kind of uh uh Batman television fans might know that there
- 1:00:27was a parody of him in the television show as well. Marilynd Ced I
- 1:00:31believe was how he was called. But you kind of if you if you
- 1:00:35knew your your history of politics. You knew who they were talking about back
- 1:00:38then. That's cool. And also I remember your your amazing issue of Greenland
- 1:00:45and Green Arrow where clearly, as at least from an artists standpoint, it
- 1:00:49was Spiro Agnew in the store in the story, and there was a little
- 1:00:52girl that that had a face very much like Richard Nixon's face. Yeah,
- 1:00:59no, wise, another sole point, because I didn't know that that cover
- 1:01:07was going to be done. The problem was it was that had nothing to
- 1:01:12do with the story, It had nothing to do with the continuity. You
- 1:01:16could certainly attack Agnew and Nixon, though at least one of my freelancers who's
- 1:01:23a conservative, said he found a defensive interesting. But at the time I
- 1:01:30thought it was so obvious that these guys are crooked and corrupt. There won't
- 1:01:36be any problem with this. Well, there are people who think that mixed
- 1:01:40it was a great president. But I resented that because what did it have
- 1:01:45to do with anything. It didn't have to make any political comment of its
- 1:01:51own, and it had nothing to do with the story. Interesting occasionly Julie,
- 1:01:57well, Julie would let things get by that I couldn't understand why he
- 1:02:02did. That was an example, I don't know that I would have located
- 1:02:07the cover had I been editing thing put understood, No, I understand.
- 1:02:16Okay, we're gonna stop there. I promise more great stuff in part two.
- 1:02:21You don't want to miss it, and thanks as always for supporting word
- 1:02:24balloon. Until next time. This is John saying, take it easy.
- 1:02:29Word bulloon is a copyright feature of Shaky Productions. Copyright twenty twenty four.