Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / Students Don’t Care Anymore… Now What? (Teacher Burnout, Student Engagement & End-of-Year Reality)
Transcript
- Ilana: If you've said, ⁓ just thought, students care anymore, you're not And honestly, you're wrong. But also not the truth. Because I think what looks like caring... is usually something else. It's not laziness and even though I know it feels like defiance, it really isn't defiance. ⁓ certainly isn't a reflection ⁓ your teaching skills or who you are as a teacher. But really just think, ⁓ like, let's it. have we misread the students ⁓ showing us? ⁓ if we are misreading it, then our responses will always make it worse because we're to the behavior but not the underlying issues. So. you know, it's April, it's the last term, everyone's quite squirrely, there's a lot going on So today I think it's really good idea to unpack what's ⁓ really going on when students out this time of year. more importantly, ⁓ what you can do about it burning yourself out more. This isn't gonna be adding to your play. You don't need to think, ⁓ my gosh, I'm already so stressed out. I'm already too exhausted to go to work. I cannot handle doing another thing. That's not what this is about, but talk about it. ⁓ Hi, my name is Alana Huffer. I am an inclusive education teacher and I've been a teacher for 16 years. And this is my way of trying to create community when so much of our community gets taken away. Because even though we're working in buildings with 30 or more people in it, we are siloed away and it is becoming increasingly individualized and... Yeah, I just really want to create a community for all of us. know, collaboration time has been slashed completely. one has time to do things before or after school. Our lunches are usually taken up and we don't have enough prep. So ⁓ is where that I hope we can talk about what's really going on in our classrooms ⁓ get advice. Thank you for all your emails. This episode is a direct result of the many emails that I've been getting, so please continue sending me emails pedagogically speaking, pod gmail.com, because I really love it. Okay, what you are seeing right now. name it. Right classrooms feel I think it's difficult ⁓ to grasp because think, okay, term one was really, really hard ⁓ and you put so much groundwork and you got all of your systems in place, your management strategies were on point, you had the transitions going well, the routines were there, everything, you made all those great connections with your students. ⁓ And even though some days were hard, you were able to kind of rely on those systems that you put in place ⁓ through. Then term two, seems it's going to be easy. It's only a 10 week term ⁓ and everything falls apart. And so you're reaching for those ⁓ routines ⁓ making everything's really tight ⁓ so you can continue on. And then you think term three, that's the best term. We're outside so much, there's field trips, lots of outdoor learning, lots of great learning opportunities for students. then it turns ⁓ a little bit of a mess, doesn't it? ⁓ Students are coming in very dysregulated, everything's high, routines are gone because maybe you're doing a field trip or it's a half-day field trip or you're going outside or you're buddying up with someone or you're doing this. There's middle school transitions or even high school transitions, there's lots going on. ⁓ And ⁓ yeah, classrooms are feeling different ⁓ and are now starting to see less effort. more, don't know, ⁓ avoidance, more ⁓ more ⁓ more emotions, ⁓ shall we it? And I think of the most frustrating parts right now is that these are the students that you know are capable. ⁓ You know, these necessarily the students where ⁓ you understand those principles for their behaviors and how they are and so you've managed to create those relationships with them based on how they come to class and the different ways they can come to class. These are now students that you know are capable of maybe they haven't done this before they haven't done it all year or they haven't done it since September and now all of a sudden they ⁓ engaged in the year and now ⁓ haha not even gonna start they're not initiating that task. They're not trying. So you go, so you do, you know, you do everything perfectly. You go through what the whole assignment, whatever it is, you it up on the board, you do most of it with them, you show them how to do it, ⁓ you what it should look like when it's done, ⁓ you've the visuals, you've done everything, and now you're going and you're checking on the students that you know need check-ins, ⁓ and of sudden the students ⁓ that have this thing going haven't started yet, they're just sitting back. and they're not trying. And I'm finding the not, the initiating task, that is tricky, but the not trying thing is actually really bothering me right now personally with the students that I work with it just feels like, it really for me feels like we're back in September ⁓ I've got these students that are just like, I'm afraid of being wrong whatever it is. And so they are not trying. even yesterday had a talk with a student. was like, ⁓ you know, I, ⁓ I expect this from you because you're so capable and the work you do is so amazing and I love the insights that you have. Like, let's get this started, you know, and I'm trying to motivate and it did, I can honestly tell you it didn't work. 38 minutes, I got two sentences from the student who's normally, you know, in less than that. So ⁓ it's really hard because they're not trying. and they're not showing that they care. then our natural response can be like, ⁓ don't they care anymore? But this is the shift I think we need. We need to remember that it's not that they don't care. I think really what it is, they can't access caring ⁓ right And that's different. That's a completely different problem. So what's actually going on? Well, let's get real about this time of year. Students are carrying cognitive fatigue. It's been eight grueling months of learning and quite the learning arc as well, going from what they knew or didn't know in September to all of the things they've learned and not just academically, but social, and, you know, different ⁓ learning happens in different places. and it's different parts of learning which really accesses all parts of their brain. So there's that cognitive fatigue, there's the emotional fatigue, there's social fatigue. ⁓ my gosh, how many kids right now do we know that have been friends all year that are now having fights at recess and people are crying. There's so much going on. and they've got behavioral fatigue as well. are having a hard time keeping everything in. And that's because they've been on, right? Like on for months, months. And for many of our students, especially those who need that extra support, whether it's learning support, EA support, or just those check-ins from you, that on has been a lot of masking. It's been, Coping, coping with the noise, the distractions, different things happening. It's been trying to keep up with everything, right? Like we all know the grind. Teachers feel the grind because we have to get through certain curriculum throughout the year. these students are trying to keep up and they're doing it, ⁓ they're treading water. And as soon, it's like, you know, they're trying to keep up. They get there. They understand the concept. You've done a great job. They've done a great job. But it's like there's a rest. ⁓ Boom, next I don't understand it. and then you work on getting them to understand how to apply the new concept and then they get it and boom right like so there's no there's no break for these students who are trying to keep up trying not to fail ⁓ we all know especially like as we get into like grade five six seven eight like they are trying not to stand ⁓ they're trying not to stand out I always find it so interesting when students, many younger students, like, I want glasses and I wish I had braces and I want to look different. And then all of a sudden it's like, I want to conform. So interesting. But like that takes an enormous amount of energy. And so, you know, happens in April, May, June, the system, ⁓ starting to And... When that happens, when everything is just too much and overwhelming, it's not like our students are saying, I'm experiencing cognitive overload and emotional exhaustion. mean, goodness gracious, I don't even know any adults that would say that, even if they're, exactly what they're feeling. know, students aren't saying, like what's actually going on, they might not even understand what's going on. They're saying, I don't care. Or they're showing you body language avoidance strategies, right? They're showing you that they're avoiding refusal, apathy, defiance. But we have to like shift it and understand that those are the symptoms, right? It's not the cause, it's the symptoms. There's an underlying cause there. And so I think the big mistake that we make when things are really going sideways that when we interpret it, and fair enough, we're tired too, ⁓ we're interpreting I don't care as disrespect, laziness, even a lack of motivation. Because when we think it's those things, then our response ⁓ we're going to put more pressure on the students. We're going to give the students consequences. If you don't have this finished, you're not going to gym. Which, by the way, can we all stop doing that, please? Gym is like, you to do gym. ⁓ One, we know movement matters. Get the anxiety out of your body. ⁓ But and most importantly, You wouldn't say that for science. Why are you saying that for gym? Do know what mean? Like, let the kids go to gym, let the kids go to recess. But you're putting pressure on the kids, consequences, more structure, more demands. And I do totally get it. That response does make sense if those were the causes and not just the behaviors we're seeing on the top. But it backfires, right? Because that student is already at capacity. They are done, they are filled up. They have been holding it in and holding it together for so long. to them, they're doing a good job. ⁓ you, what you're seeing ⁓ it's like, don't wanna do that. Or they're ripping up their paper, whatever, right? Like, they're showing you, I'm not doing that. And to you, that's extreme. ⁓ But to them, they're like, I've kept this going. And then they're ready to go to gym, they're ready to go to recess, and they get told no. Well. mean, what's happened in your classroom when that goes on, right? Adding does not motivation. It creates shutdown. So instead of, they're not trying, we need to ask, what's making it hard for them to try right now? And I think that question really changes everything. making it hard for this to try now? So let's talk about some realistic shifts. What you can actually do right now. Okay, what works right now? can tell you, don't go to Pinterest. That's not gonna help you. That's not gonna help you. It's perfect teaching, okay? ⁓ We some real ⁓ and sustainable shifts. first things lower. ⁓ the entry point, okay? Not the expectation, entry point. When students are overwhelmed, starting the hardest part, right? Because if they already think they can't do it, if they're already too exhausted, just starting the thing is hard. And like think about yourself too, right? Like I know me, sometimes starting things is very hard, and I'll write a list. Because then at least I can like figure that out. what is a list? It's chunking, right? I this much to do. That's overwhelming. I can't do it. But if I chunk it, which for me looks like a list, I can it all of a sudden. ⁓ So starting the hardest part. ⁓ Instead of complete this try write one Okay? Tell me your idea out loud. Circle where you would start. Okay? that's not, that is not lowering the bar, that is not settling, that is not changing the expectations. It's the barrier ⁓ to right? You are letting that student ⁓ access That the most important part. Okay, number two, make success immediate. Okay, so right now, students need to feel, I can do this, right? You need to the students feel, can do this, but like fast, immediately, ⁓ after 40 minutes, ⁓ after the whole assignment, ⁓ okay? And you're thinking, well, what does that look like? Just about it. Chunk tasks the tiny pieces, right? ⁓ How rewarding it for us as adults to have a list and like tell me if you do this too, you kind of down like, I've already finished these but I'm gonna put them on my list to check them off already. Feels good, doesn't it? ⁓ Okay? Give that satisfaction to the students. Chunk the task into tiny pieces. Let them check it off if that's what they like to do. Give them instant feedback and celebrate that they've started all... I see you started, that's great, whatever. just say something generic, make sure that it's specific for them, ⁓ please celebrate it, that's great. ⁓ just celebrate when they finish something. Celebrate they're started it. ⁓ Celebrate they keep going, okay? It's so important because that momentum ⁓ matters than the perfection. Once they it going, It'll be easier for them to keep going. Right? Once it's rolling, it'll keep rolling down the hill. But you gotta get it rolling. And third, sure that you're offering control without chaos, right? A lot of not caring is really just ⁓ a of control, students feeling like they've got no control. ⁓ And gonna get ⁓ more prevalent as we get closer and closer towards school ending. Because ⁓ even students don't necessarily have control at school, there are some parts of it that they can control. And they a lot of that when... ⁓ when this routine isn't here anymore. so ⁓ going to heighten a lot of students, ⁓ feeling of lack of control. So ⁓ can you give it back in small ways? Can ask them, do you want to write this up or do you want to type it? Do you to start with question one or question three? you want to work here ⁓ or did you to work at the table? ⁓ Or did you to work in the library because it's quieter? Right? Because like these aren't big changes and quite frankly they're not even, they're probably things you're already doing. But can we give these, can we to the students more often right now? You know? it really does restore their autonomy and their feeling of trust. ⁓ And also, we all know that autonomy really does fuel engagement, right? Think of yourself. When you feel like you are being treated as an autonomous professional, maybe with your Pro-D days or the way that you are teaching fractions, are engaged with that. And it's the same for students as well. Okay, so those three ⁓ I think are really important. that you can shift right now. So number one, lower the entry point, not the expectation. Two, make that success immediate. when they start, celebrate that they keep going. The celebrations don't need to come only at the end. And make sure you're offering the control, ⁓ obviously that chaos, okay? ⁓ Not changes, ⁓ but let them their autonomy. ⁓ Four, accept engagement. I know you're groaning, it's kind of why I recap the first three before I got to four. But really important, okay? Except partial engagement. Because full from every student all the time is unrealistic, especially in term three when there's already so much going on and the routines are bonkers, okay? So instead thinking they only did half, go with, ⁓ They did have is data if you need it ⁓ is certainly movement that's engagement ⁓ that's them listening to you. That's them ⁓ you something that you wanted that you needed protect possibly and honestly That's a win. So take the win. Take the win, okay? And I know it's the oldest cliche. Is the cup half full or half empty? Make it full. Okay, they did the work. They did the work. That's great. Okay? and you're all doing this. So stop it. taking it personally. This has nothing to do with ⁓ as a teacher. You are a fantastic teacher and you have proof ⁓ you have wonderful students who care about you ⁓ you've created an amazing community in your classroom. You are great. This has nothing to do with you and everything to do with the fact that we are getting close to the end of the year and everyone is exhausted. it like it personally. It hits the deepest because I know, I know. know that when students disengage, it feels like rejection. It feels like failure. it feels like I'm not doing enough. And if it feels like for you, I can't do this, I'm not meant to be a teacher or any of those things, stop right now. Absolutely, are meant to be a teacher. Absolutely, you can do this. You've proven you can do it. ⁓ ⁓ or May, depending on when this comes out. ⁓ been successfully doing this for eight months. You two months left. ⁓ In months, ⁓ it'll ⁓ summer okay? Summer holidays. ⁓ You've it. Understand that. That is successful. ⁓ You amazing. ⁓ You doing all of it. But the student's capacity right now, absolutely is not a reflection of your competence, okay? You can be an incredible teacher and still have students who cannot learning ⁓ this moment. Both can be true. We can hold both truths at once. ⁓ Life a paradox. And the sooner we understand that and accept it, the better. Okay, I think ready for the hard truth. ⁓ Here's the part no one really wants to say out loud, okay? You cannot make a student care. can create conditions, ⁓ can build relationships, ⁓ can absolutely and should be removing all barriers to learning, but cannot force engagement. And so I don't want you to try to do something and be like, I worked so hard on this and the students didn't even care, or I spent all this money on this and the students didn't even care. ⁓ You force engagement. And if you try, ⁓ you absolutely exhaust yourself. you will absolutely exhaust yourself and you will get upset. Okay? So, we are shifting the goal. The goal is gonna shift from make them care to it easier ⁓ them to reengage ⁓ they ⁓ ready. Make it easier for the students to reengage ⁓ the learning, the material, when they are ready. And that's a completely different type of teaching. Okay. It's been a lot. your classroom feels harder right now, if students feel checked out, If you're questioning whether what you're doing is enough, I need you to hear this, like through your ears, into your brain, into your heart. is not the moment where prove your worth ⁓ as teacher. You've done that already. You're amazing. This is moment ⁓ where you your energy. where you stay connected to your students keep the door open. Because, and remember this, even when it looks like they don't care, they're still watching. still noticing. And it matters. You not need to everything. You just need to stay human. You need to yourself in a system ⁓ that asks too of you a lot ⁓ from them. ⁓ And that, that's enough. so much for listening this week. I hope you have a great week ⁓ I hope you're able to take some of this ⁓ apply it to your ⁓ practice and to your life as a teacher. Remember more than enough. You're great. The students absolutely need you ⁓ and are rocking it. Talk to you later.