Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #14 - Election 2024 Preview Part 4 - US House, Governor, State Legislature
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:06Today is election 2024 preview part 4.
- 0:10Last episode, we went over the competitive US senate races, including one I think that has
- 0:16the potential to be an upset, though I don't necessarily think it will be, in Maryland.
- 0:21Today, though, is going to be focused on competitive US house and gubernatorial races as
- 0:27well as state legislatures that could potentially flip majority party control.
- 0:32Now there's a lot more competitive US house elections this year than the ones I'm going to
- 0:39cover.
- 0:39There's just too many to have any sort of real depth on, but the ones I'm going to cover are
- 0:47because they have the potential to impact and be impacted by a competitive race for president
- 0:54or competitive race for the US senate.
- 0:57So let's get into it.
- 1:00So some of the high highlighted stats that you're gonna see here is and that neither
- 1:05facets I use to measure competitiveness in the previous episodes or at least shine light on
- 1:11why people think they're gonna be competitive.
- 1:14So is it an open seat, or is it an or is there an incumbent, somebody who's already there and
- 1:19is running for reelection?
- 1:21The electoral history.
- 1:22Now there's only been one congressional election under these new redistricted lines
- 1:27because every 10 years after the census, congressional lines always get redrawn.
- 1:33So you gotta be careful about comparing electoral history before then, so we'll just
- 1:38really focus on what happened in 2022.
- 1:42And, also, you have to be careful comparing midterm election results to presidential
- 1:47election results.
- 1:48These are different, who pea a lot of people who vote in presidential elections do not vote
- 1:54in midterms.
- 1:55The people who vote in midterms probably are gonna vote in presidential elections as long as
- 2:00they're able to to.
- 2:01There's not something stopping them, for whatever reason.
- 2:06So you do have to be careful with that kind of comparison, but we'll we'll still use it just
- 2:15to give a get a little bit of a sense of how competitive things are.
- 2:20Possibility of impacting other key elections, like I said, if it could impacts the presidency
- 2:26or the u or US senate race.
- 2:29Now the higher ballot races tend to have more of an impact on the lower ballot than the other
- 2:35way around, but it it can have some effects going the opposite direction.
- 2:40Voter registration numbers by party, if a state tracks that, and it tracks it by congressional
- 2:45district, and it's easy to get a hold of.
- 2:49And election forecast from 6 forecasting organizations.
- 2:53We actually use these in the episode about US senate.
- 2:57So that is CNalysis, c n a l y s I s, took political report, inside elections, Larry
- 3:07Sabato's crystal ball, split tickets, and elections daily.
- 3:12Now let's get into the specific US house races.
- 3:17Like I said, too many to cover, but here are some of the key races to watch for, and we
- 3:22can't spend too much time on this.
- 3:24But some of the states with competitive districts that are not highlighted here include
- 3:29California, Colorado, Iowa, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Washington, and
- 3:36Virginia.
- 3:37And you might see a couple of those states and think, wait a minute.
- 3:40Why are how are those states having competitive congressional elections?
- 3:43Aren't those very Republican, or are those very Democrat?
- 3:48Even in a state like a New York or a California, which are very Democratic states,
- 3:53you'll still have pockets here and there where it's actually a lot of Republican voters.
- 4:00So you may have some of these congressional districts where even if the state as a whole is
- 4:04dominated by democrats, there are a bunch more republicans.
- 4:08And the same way with states where republicans dominate, there are gonna be pockets of
- 4:13democrats where republicans can't break into either.
- 4:17First up is Alaska's at large district.
- 4:20So there's population is so small that Alaska only gets one US house rep.
- 4:28Open seat versus incumbent.
- 4:29There's an incumbent.
- 4:30Her name is Mary Peltola.
- 4:32She was appointed in September 2022 following the death of longtime representative Don Young
- 4:37who had been there for 40 something years.
- 4:42Now candidates, there's gonna be 4 in the general election.
- 4:45This was set up due to the top 4 primary being passed by Alaska voters in 2020.
- 4:50In 2020, there was a ballot measure where it was a top 4 primary, so it was actually the top
- 4:574 vote getters go on to the general election.
- 5:00And then the general election gets decided by ranked choice voting.
- 5:03So you say, this is the candidate I want most, 1.
- 5:06Canada wants second most, 2, 3rd, 4th.
- 5:11And somebody has to get a majority vote.
- 5:13Now if somebody does not get a majority vote, the lowest vote getter gets knocked out, and
- 5:18then they start counting the 2nd place votes.
- 5:21And if somebody still hasn't reached a majority then, then the last place voter gets knocked
- 5:26out, and then who has a majority after the first, out of the 1st and second place voters
- 5:32from that round.
- 5:33So we can go to 3 rounds, but they that's why they also sometimes call it instant runoff
- 5:38voting.
- 5:38Voters don't have to come back, but they have to number who they want to be elected from most
- 5:48to least.
- 5:49And then at the end, whoever gets a majority after several rounds, once they start knocking
- 5:55out people lower, that person is the one who wins, the one who gets the majority at the end
- 6:00there.
- 6:02So Mary Palzola is the democrat.
- 6:04Nicholas Begich is a republican.
- 6:06He's a member of the Begich Alaskan political family who's been around for a very long time,
- 6:12although they're actually mostly democrats.
- 6:15Mary Polsola has served on a native council tribal court, and I don't wanna say the name of
- 6:19this tribe because I don't wanna butcher it and offend anybody just in case.
- 6:25But, she's also worked as a lobbyist and is the executive director of an intertribal fish
- 6:30commission.
- 6:30So even before she was appointed, she was pretty well known in Alaska politics.
- 6:39John Howe is an Alaskan Independence Party candidate.
- 6:44He's worked various labor jobs, and and then there's Eric Hafner, who's also a democrat.
- 6:50I couldn't find much professional background, but he's currently in federal prison.
- 6:54Now you're might be wondering about Howe and Hafner, why they're there.
- 7:00They only received several 100 votes each, and the only reason they are there in the general
- 7:05is because Republicans, Nancy Dahlstrom and Matthew Salisbury dropped out.
- 7:09Now Salisbury is also somebody who only got several 100 votes.
- 7:15Dahlstrom actually was competitive, but she decided to drop out.
- 7:20So there's probably not gonna be really any support for those 2 either.
- 7:25It's pretty much just Peltola and Begich.
- 7:29Recent election history.
- 7:30So Peltola, she was appointed in in 2022, but she had to run-in that election after only a
- 7:37few months.
- 7:38Her 2022 victory was the 1st year of Alaska's system of a top four primary and ranked choice
- 7:44general election.
- 7:46Heltola won after 3 rounds of a runoff from that ranked choice general election.
- 7:54She defeated Republicans Sarah Palin and Nick Begich, which Nick Begich is is running again.
- 8:01Sarah Palin, you may remember, she is a former governor and was also the vice presidential
- 8:05running mate to John McCain in his 2008 presidential campaign.
- 8:10Voter registration statistics as of October 3, 2024, there's a 146,000 Republicans, 75,000
- 8:17Democrats, 85,000 nonpartisan, and 273,000 undeclared.
- 8:22And for Alaska, an undeclared means they are registered to vote, and they haven't made any
- 8:28declarations whatsoever about who they support.
- 8:31They haven't even said that they're nonpartisan.
- 8:32They're just basically registered to vote, and that's it.
- 8:35Nonpartisan, they actually say specifically, I want to be nonpartisan.
- 8:40Now how could it impact other races?
- 8:43Well, it could impact the presidency.
- 8:45Not the way you think, though.
- 8:47It's pretty safe to say that the state as a whole is going to vote Republican.
- 8:51It almost always does.
- 8:53I think one time it voted Democrat back, I wanna say, in 1968.
- 8:58I don't remember for certain, but the way it could affect the presidency so there is a way
- 9:07for the electoral college to become a tie at 269 to 269.
- 9:12Very unlikely, but possible.
- 9:15And if that happens, remember, you gotta get a majority of the electoral college to get
- 9:20elected.
- 9:21If it's a tie between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump, the election then gets decided by the
- 9:26state's US house delegations, not each individual US house representative, but each
- 9:31state's delegation.
- 9:33Each state delegation equals one vote, and Peltella, since she's the only representative
- 9:39for Alaska, she would decide her state's vote.
- 9:41And whichever candidate wins a majority of those state delegations votes wins the
- 9:46election, and that's what's called a contingent election.
- 9:50I talked more about that in one of my earliest episodes of the podcast, but hasn't happened
- 9:56for quite some time.
- 9:59But who knows?
- 10:00Maybe we'll see it around this time.
- 10:03Arizona's first district.
- 10:04Open seat versus incumbent?
- 10:06Well, it is an incumbent.
- 10:08Republican David Schweickart has been in office since winning in 2010, but he's had to change
- 10:13district several times due to redistricting.
- 10:15He is running up against Amish Shah, the democrat.
- 10:19Recent election history, so partisan competition for the district has become much
- 10:25tougher following this latest round of redistricting.
- 10:28Schweickart only won by 0.8 percentage points in 2022.
- 10:33And voter registration statistics, as of October 2024, 203,000 Republicans, 144,000
- 10:40Democrats, several thousand with minor affiliations, and 171,000 other.
- 10:46I'm I'm guessing other is just their catchall term for an independent.
- 10:53Every state has different definitions of what exactly in in independent is or how they call
- 11:01independence.
- 11:01I might call nonpartisan, unaffiliated, unenrolled, other, something like that.
- 11:07Other races it could potentially impact, well, Arizona is a battleground for the presidency,
- 11:13so it could impact the presidency because of the, competitiveness of Arizona as a whole.
- 11:20It's a battleground state.
- 11:22Although, as I say, it will be more likely to affect this district than the other way around,
- 11:26but might have some little impact.
- 11:30Every little bit counts when you have such a competitive state like Arizona.
- 11:35And, also, there's the effect on the possibility of a contingent election.
- 11:38If this district and the 6th district of Arizona flip to democrats and the other par
- 11:46other seats stay with the same party, then the majority of the delegation would become
- 11:51democrat.
- 11:52It would be 5 democrats and then 4 republicans.
- 11:56So another potential impact on contingent elections.
- 12:01And all 6 forecasters highlighted here have called it a toss-up except for inside
- 12:05elections, which rates it ever so slightly toward strike Schweickart, excuse me, what
- 12:12inside elections calls a tilt Republican race.
- 12:15Arizona 6th, open seat versus incumbent, incumbent representative, Republican Juan
- 12:21Siskamani.
- 12:22He won in 2022.
- 12:23He is going up against Kirsten Engel, a Democrat.
- 12:26There's also a green candidate and a writing candidate.
- 12:29Recent election history is that this is actually a rematch of 2022 because Siskamani
- 12:34faced Engel before in 2022, winning by 1 and a half percentage points.
- 12:40Voter registration statistics as of October 2024, 194,000 Republicans, 165,000 Democrats,
- 12:48several thousand with minor affiliations, and 174 k other.
- 12:54And as with Arizona's 1st district can have a big impact on what happens at the presidential
- 13:00level, whether as it gets flipped to democrats and then if a contingent election happens and
- 13:07the delegation becomes majority democrat, or even if it doesn't become a contingent election
- 13:15might be enough to swing the electoral college vote towards either Kamala Harris or Donald
- 13:21Trump.
- 13:22Maine's second district.
- 13:24This is currently held by incumbent Democrat Jared Golden.
- 13:27He first won the seat in the 2018 election and held on to it even after redistricting.
- 13:32So there's 3 candidates in this election.
- 13:34One of them is a write in, and it's a ranked choice election.
- 13:38But due to there being only 2 major candidates, it's unlikely that this goes past one round of
- 13:44voting because of that write in.
- 13:46So there's Jared Golden, the democrat, and then there is the republican Austin Cario.
- 13:51Recent election history, Golden won in 2022 by 6.2 points.
- 13:56Now here's interesting little bit of trivia for you.
- 14:00He beats Republican Bruce Poliquin after 2 rounds of the ranked choice format.
- 14:04Now Poliquin was actually the incumbent that Golden beat in 2018 to get his seat in the
- 14:10first place, and that 2018 election was the 1st congressional race in US history that was
- 14:16decided by ranked choice voting.
- 14:18Now other races that it could impact could impact the presidency because while it is not
- 14:24expected to be a competitive state overall, it's likely to vote for Kamala Harris as a
- 14:30whole.
- 14:31That specific district's electoral vote is up for grabs, and that is because Maine is one of
- 14:37the 2 states that is not winner take all for the presidency.
- 14:41So whoever wins a majority of the state's overall vote gets 2 electoral votes, but each
- 14:47congressional district also gets their own electoral vote.
- 14:51So there is a way for Donald Trump to take one electoral vote out of Maine while the rest of
- 14:58Maine and their electoral votes goes to Kamala Harris.
- 15:04Again, unlikely that one electoral vote swings the election, but it might.
- 15:11And amongst the 6 election forecasters that we're highlighting here, this is universally
- 15:15considered a toss-up.
- 15:17Michigan's 7th district.
- 15:19This one is actually an open seat because it's being vacated by Democrat Alyssa Slotkin who is
- 15:24running for US senate now.
- 15:26Being an open seat that, generally speaking, inherently makes a seat more competitive than
- 15:31if there's an incumbent.
- 15:33Maybe not always, but a lot of times it does because of that incumbency advantage that
- 15:38incumbents enjoy a lot of the time.
- 15:41Candidates, this is there's Tom Barrett, republican, Curtis Hertel, democrat, and then
- 15:47there's also a libertarian candidate in the election as well.
- 15:50I couldn't really find any info on her.
- 15:52L Rachel Daly.
- 15:54Recent election history is that both Barrett and Daly ran in 2022, and Slotkin defeated
- 16:00Barrett by 5 point 4 points.
- 16:02A daily only got, like, 2% of the vote.
- 16:05Voter registration statistics, this state does not actually track voter registration by party
- 16:10because a lot of states don't.
- 16:12Most states do track it by party, but not every one of them does.
- 16:16And other races this could impact is the presidency, not only because it is a
- 16:21battleground state for the race, also that possibility of a contingent election.
- 16:27How this would come into play with a contingent election if Republicans flip this seat and all
- 16:33the other states seats, excuse me, stay with the same party, then that would be the
- 16:40delegation would be 7 Republicans and 6 Democrats.
- 16:44And as a result, it's probably gonna vote for Donald Trump in a contingent election with the
- 16:50majority Republican delegation.
- 16:53And amongst the 6 election forecasters that we are highlighting here, this seat is universally
- 16:58considered a toss-up.
- 17:00Montana's 1st district.
- 17:02This is currently held by incumbent Republican Ryan Zinke.
- 17:06Zinke is going up against Democrat Monica Tranell in a rematch of 2022.
- 17:12Then Zinke won by 3.1 points.
- 17:15Now Montana is one of those states that does not track voter registration by party, so we
- 17:20can't look exactly at the typical partisan leaning of the voters except for when it comes
- 17:27to election results.
- 17:28Now other races it could impact, probably not gonna impact the presidency because it's very
- 17:33likely to go to Trump.
- 17:34Although, since there's now 2 US house districts in Montana, if one's democrat, if
- 17:41one's republican, it'll be interesting to see how exactly they break that stalemate if we had
- 17:46a contingent election, but the US senate race might be affected.
- 17:50And that race we talked about in the previous episode, that one's expected to be close.
- 17:54That one's democrat Jon Tester, who's no stranger to competitive elections, but it'll be
- 18:00hard for him to win a 4th one in a row, and he's going up against Republican Tim Sheehy.
- 18:06All 6 forecasters see it as slightly favoring Zinke.
- 18:10Nebraska's 2nd district.
- 18:12So this one is currently held by incumbent Republican Don Bacon.
- 18:16He first won in 2016, and he's going up against Democrat Tony Vargas.
- 18:21And this is yet another instance where we have a rematch from 2022.
- 18:27Bacon defeated Vargas by 2.6 points in that election.
- 18:32Voter registration statistics as of October 1, 2024, there are a 157,000 Republicans, a
- 18:38143,000 Democrats, several thousand with minor labels.
- 18:42Usually, you'll just see only a few thousand with those minor labels, and a 104,000
- 18:48nonpartisan.
- 18:49Now other races, it could impact, just like with Maine, which is the other non winner take
- 18:57all state, could impact the presidency because while it's not a competitive state overall for
- 19:03president, that specific district's electoral vote should be up for grabs, though.
- 19:08The district lines are different from what they were in 2020, but the second congressional
- 19:12district went to Joe Biden in 2020, and election forecaster still rated as slightly
- 19:18favoring Democrats, in this case, Kamala Harris.
- 19:21So, again, single electoral vote, so it'd mean a big difference in this election.
- 19:26Still unlikely, but it could happen.
- 19:30Now as for those election forecasters that we were talking about before, they see this as
- 19:34slightly favoring Vargas, meaning it would be a flip, except for Cook Political Report, which
- 19:39has it as a toss-up.
- 19:41North Carolina's first district, This one is held by incumbent Democrat Donald Davis who won
- 19:47in 2022.
- 19:49These are all veterans of the US military who are running in this election.
- 19:54Donald Davis, captain of the US Air Force, Lori Bucat, the republican US army colonel, and Tom
- 19:59Bailey, the libertarian who served in Vietnam.
- 20:03Recent election history is that Davis defeated Republican business executive Sandy Smith by
- 20:084.8 points in 2022.
- 20:10Now this one could also impact the presidency in the event of a contingent election.
- 20:15Right now, there's an even number of Democrats and Republicans in North Carolina's
- 20:20congressional delegation or US house delegation with 7 a piece.
- 20:24So just one seat could flip how that congressional delegation would vote in a
- 20:30contingent election.
- 20:32And as for election forecast, most forecasters have this as slightly favoring Davis to hold on
- 20:37to the seat except for Cook Political Report and Elections Daily, which have it as a
- 20:41toss-up.
- 20:43Pennsylvania's 7th district.
- 20:45This one is held by incumbent Democrat Susan Wild.
- 20:49She first won in 2018.
- 20:52She exceeded Lisa Scheller, a republican, by 2 points in 2022.
- 20:59And the voter registration statistics of that district show 232,000 democrats, 208,000
- 21:06republicans, several 1,000 with minor affiliations, and then there's also 88,000 with
- 21:12no affiliation and 17,000 with other as their affiliation.
- 21:17And, again, could also have an impact on a contingent election.
- 21:21Right now, the congressional delegation, the US house delegation of Pennsylvania is slightly
- 21:26democratic, and if Republicans win just one seat and the rest of the states or rest of the
- 21:32seats, excuse me, stay with the same party, then it would become a republican majority
- 21:38delegation.
- 21:38And in a contingent election, it's undoubtedly going to vote for Donald Trump.
- 21:42And then if it stays democrat majority in a contingent election, it would undoubtedly vote
- 21:48for Kamala Harris.
- 21:50And then the last US house district that we're gonna look at is Pennsylvania's 8th.
- 21:54This one is held by Democrat Matt Cartwright who also first won in 2018.
- 22:00He defeated Republican Jim Bognett, I'm hope I'm saying that right, by 2.4 points in 2022.
- 22:07Voter registration statistics, latest week shows 231,000 Democrats, 209,000 Republicans,
- 22:13several 1,000 with minor affiliations, 67,000 with no affiliation, and then 14,000 designated
- 22:20as other.
- 22:23And just like with Pennsylvania's 7th district, it's a battleground state and could have a
- 22:29massive impact on the contingent election if we have contingent election.
- 22:35And as for election forecast, they all see this as a toss-up or slightly favoring part right.
- 22:42Now let's talk about competitive gubernatorial races or rather race.
- 22:46New Hampshire is easily the most competitive.
- 22:49Although election forecasters do see an outside chance for Republicans in North Carolina and
- 22:55Washington and then for Democrats in Indiana, probably not gonna happen, so we're gonna focus
- 22:59just on New Hampshire here because it is universally considered a toss-up.
- 23:04So this one is going to be open seat.
- 23:06Incumbent Republican, Chris Sununu, declined to seek reelection.
- 23:11He won 4 straight gubernatorial elections in Vermont and New Hampshire.
- 23:15They have 2 year terms for their governor as opposed to all the other states, which have 4
- 23:20year terms.
- 23:21And he won in 2022 pretty handily against physician Democrat Tom German by 15 and a half
- 23:27points.
- 23:28But now that it's an open seat, it's gonna be a lot more competitive going forward.
- 23:34And the candidates here are Kelly Ayotte.
- 23:36She is a former US senator, and she narrowly lost reelection only by about 800 votes to
- 23:44current US senator Maggie Hassan.
- 23:47And then there's Democrat Joyce Craig, who's a former mayor of Manchester, New Hampshire and a
- 23:52former chair of the Manchester Board of School Committee, and then there's also a libertarian
- 23:58candidate.
- 23:59And as of September 30, 2024, there are 308,000 Republicans, 269,000 Democrats, and 318,000
- 24:08undeclared.
- 24:10Registered Republicans took over Democrats sometime between August November of 2023 and
- 24:15have shot way past them since.
- 24:17In fact, Republicans added 36,000 more voters between December 2023 March 2024.
- 24:2436,000 is not that much compared to really big states, but New Hampshire is not a big state.
- 24:29So that's a massive difference.
- 24:32As for other races it could impact, probably not gonna impact the presidency because that's
- 24:36expected to be pretty solidly democratic, but it could impact control of the state
- 24:42legislature, which we're gonna talk about in the next section.
- 24:46But all of the forecasters we've highlighted here have considered this a boss up.
- 24:50On one hand, clearly favored by experience running in a statewide election.
- 24:56She has a larger voter base to draw from, and she has much more money that she's that her
- 25:02campaign has raised and spent.
- 25:05But the state is also predicted to be very likely democrat for president, like we just
- 25:10said, and that could heavily impact the governor's race.
- 25:14So if it votes, it I mean, it's possible for the state to vote statewide democrat and then
- 25:19statewide republican.
- 25:20It has done it before with Chris and Nunu.
- 25:23But because of the leaning for presidency, you have to still consider how much that could
- 25:31impact the governor's race this time around as well.
- 25:35Now for our last section, state legislative chamber control.
- 25:40So this is looking at the likeliest potential for partisan control flips for overall
- 25:44chambers, not specific seats that are battlegrounds.
- 25:46There's way too many of those.
- 25:49There's thousands of seats that you'd have to sift through.
- 25:52Obviously, a lot of them are not gonna be very competitive, but there's still just too many of
- 25:56those.
- 25:56So we're just talking about chambers where majority party control is potentially up for
- 26:03grabs.
- 26:03Now other chambers that are not listed here might flip party control as well, but it's just
- 26:09less likely.
- 26:10Now, obviously, the state legislative chambers matter a great deal.
- 26:14A lot of people don't vote in them, but redistricting control belongs to many state
- 26:19legislatures.
- 26:20Now mandated redistricting following the US census is done now, but in the event that a
- 26:27congressional map or a state legislative map gets challenged in court and then it has to get
- 26:33redrawn, the majority party control of the state legislature is gonna be a big factor in
- 26:39how those lines get redrawn again.
- 26:43Also, candidates who win at these lower levels, they start to build up a, what do you call it,
- 26:47bench, sort of like in professional sports, NFL, MLB, NHL, NBA, where you have a bench or
- 26:55you have a farm system where you develop talent like a minor league level, whether it's, NFL,
- 27:04NBA.
- 27:04Well, end NFL doesn't really have the same kind of of deal as, like, an NBA, MLB, NHL, and you
- 27:12build up that bench for future congressional candidates to try to win.
- 27:17And they already have a little bit of experience running in an election.
- 27:21And then there's that more direct day to day impact on your daily lives as opposed to
- 27:26federal offices, though a little less than local offices.
- 27:28Those have the most impact on your day to day life.
- 27:32States listed here aren't necessarily guaranteed to flip, but they are the most
- 27:37likely to change majority party control.
- 27:40So first, we'll talk about Alaska, both the house and senate.
- 27:44This is a really unique situation.
- 27:46Alaska politics are pretty quirky.
- 27:48Republicans have majority control in both of the chambers when it comes to the number of
- 27:55legislators they have.
- 27:56They have more they have a majority of the house and the senate, but there are power
- 28:02sharing agreements in both chambers amongst republicans and democrats.
- 28:06And then there's also a few independents in the state house that are part of those power
- 28:10sharing agreements.
- 28:12Alaska's US house seat is a battleground, and the effects of that might trickle down to these
- 28:16state legislative contests.
- 28:19Now everyone in the house is up for election, although only half of the senate is up for
- 28:23election, but the senate has 11 seats belonging to Republicans and 9 seats belonging to
- 28:28Democrats.
- 28:29In the state house, Republicans have 22 seats, Democrats have 13, there are 4 independents,
- 28:35and then one nonpartisan.
- 28:38And for that senate, at least one incumbent for both parties have the potential to lose their
- 28:44seat, which could be a massive deal for control of the senate since it's only an 11 to 9
- 28:51advantage for republicans.
- 28:53If republicans maintain their majority number or even expand, we'll have to see if they
- 28:59choose to maintain power sharing agreements with democrats.
- 29:02But as of right now, it seems like that might be the case.
- 29:08See analysis ratings because most of these forecasters don't actually rate state
- 29:13legislative state legislative chamber control.
- 29:18But see analysis, that's one that's one big thing that they do.
- 29:22In the house, they consider it a toss-up with republicans having a 55% chance of keeping the
- 29:27chamber and 10% chance of split chamber.
- 29:30And there's a also a couple of formulas that CNalysis uses.
- 29:37I don't know exactly what they how exactly they come up with these.
- 29:44They have what they call a classic and expanded.
- 29:47I'm going by unless I otherwise stated, I'm going by their classic formula.
- 29:53Now for the senate, they say it's a solid democrat rating, and, I don't don't really
- 29:59understand that rating.
- 30:00As they say, democrats have a one 100% chance of winning that chamber and that there are 15
- 30:06democrats right now, which isn't the case.
- 30:09Power share agreement might be still likely to hold, but there are still more self identified
- 30:13republicans, and there's a good chance that it might stay that way.
- 30:16So the 100% chance of winning doesn't really make sense to me, but maybe there's just
- 30:22something I'm missing.
- 30:23I'm not trying to say that they're wrong or anything like that.
- 30:25I mean, it's a it's a prediction.
- 30:27But, yeah, it it's I am a little little confused as to why exactly they are so sure
- 30:35about the Alaska senate.
- 30:37Arizona's house and senate.
- 30:39It's probably the hottest state for political junkies, and that's not just because of the dry
- 30:43heat.
- 30:44It's also competitive for president, US senate, several US house districts.
- 30:49And in Arizona, all state legislators are up for reelection every 2 years.
- 30:55So every single house rep, there's 60 of those, and then the 30 senate seats all up for
- 31:01reelection.
- 31:03And because the state is a battleground for president and for US senate and even a couple
- 31:08of US house races, those effects the effects of those races could trickle down into state
- 31:14legislative elections.
- 31:16Now when accounting for full state legislatures, no state's majority party control
- 31:21is as razor thin as Arizona's.
- 31:23There's in the house, there's 31 Republicans and 29 Democrats.
- 31:27In the senate, there's 16 Republicans and 14 Democrats.
- 31:31So if Republicans have a net loss of 1 seat in either chamber, that means Democrats come even
- 31:37with them in that chamber.
- 31:39And then if they win 2 seats, then they take control of that chamber.
- 31:45If democrats take both chambers, they'll have a trifecta in that state because democrat Katie
- 31:52Hobbs is the current governor.
- 31:54Democrats last won a majority in the state house in the 1964 election.
- 32:01And the state senate, that was in the 1990 election.
- 32:05Although in 2000, they split the chamber 15 to 15.
- 32:09So it's been a very long time since Democrats had control of one of those chambers and
- 32:15especially for the state house.
- 32:19But there has been a trend of a decreasing republican majority in both chambers for about
- 32:24the past decade.
- 32:26CN analysis ratings, house, it says, is a toss-up with republicans having a 49% chance of
- 32:32keeping the chamber and 11% chance of a split chamber.
- 32:37As for the senate, it actually rates it as a tilt democrat with democrats having a 45%
- 32:43chance of taking the chamber and an 18% chance of a split chamber.
- 32:48So buckle up if you're in Arizona.
- 32:51Michigan state house, all 110 house seats are up for election.
- 32:56No senate elections this time, though.
- 32:58And the state is a battleground for president, so that's going to trickle down into these
- 33:02state house elections.
- 33:04And right now, Democrats have a 56 to 54 advantage over Republicans.
- 33:0956 Democrats, 54 Republicans.
- 33:11So a net gain of 1 to 2 seats for Republicans can make a huge difference.
- 33:15Democrats took control of the chamber following the 2022 election.
- 33:19And before then, Republicans had taken control in 2010 just like they did for a lot of state
- 33:25legislative chambers.
- 33:25In 2010, Republicans for state legislature had massive success around the country.
- 33:32And CNNalysis rates this as a toss-up with republicans having a 52% chance of winning the
- 33:38chamber and a 7% chance of a split chamber.
- 33:43New Hampshire state house and senate, All 400 state house seats and 24 state senate seats are
- 33:49up for election.
- 33:50Yes.
- 33:50You heard that right.
- 33:51400 state house seats.
- 33:54I don't know why they have such a massive state house, especially with how small the state is,
- 33:59but it is what it is.
- 34:01So like we said before, it is not competitive for president.
- 34:05The gubernatorial race is expected to be hotly contested.
- 34:08There's a republican advantage in both chambers, but there's not huge majorities.
- 34:12In the house, there's a 197 Republicans, a 191 Democrats, one other, and 11 vacancies, quite a
- 34:20few vacancies.
- 34:21And in the senate, there's 14 Republicans and 10 Democrats.
- 34:25Now the 2020 presidential election was quite unkind to democrat state legislators.
- 34:33In the 2018 election, they won 233 house seats.
- 34:37In 2020, they won a 187, so they had a loss of 46 seats, assuming that there weren't any
- 34:45vacancies or state or special state legislative elections between then.
- 34:51And in the state senate, in 2018, they had won 14 seats.
- 34:552020, they had won 10.
- 34:58CNL's ratings, house slightly favors Democrats with a 69% chance to win that chamber.
- 35:05And in the senate, it's a toss-up with 52% chance Republicans win the chamber and a 15%
- 35:12chance of a split.
- 35:14Pennsylvania's state house.
- 35:17State senate is pretty likely to stick with republican control, so we're not gonna discuss
- 35:21it here.
- 35:22May it might flip.
- 35:23It's one of those that could potentially flip, but probably won't.
- 35:27All 203 state house seats are up for election in Pennsylvania, and this is a rare instance
- 35:33where Democrats control 1 chamber and republic Republicans control the other chamber.
- 35:38Democrats have the house.
- 35:41Republicans have the senate.
- 35:43Now the state is a battleground for both president and US senate, so those are going to
- 35:50have some impact on the state legislative elections.
- 35:54Now democrats took a majority in the state house through special elections in 2023.
- 36:00They had lost it in the 2010 election just like they did for a lot of state legislative
- 36:06chambers that year.
- 36:07CNL's ratings have a 58% chance of Democrats keeping control of the chamber.
- 36:14And for the last state to cover, Wisconsin's state house or what they call the state
- 36:20assembly.
- 36:21State senate is pretty likely to stick with republican control, so it's not gonna be
- 36:25discussed here.
- 36:26Similar case to Pennsylvania.
- 36:28All 99 seats in the state house are up for election.
- 36:32Now this is another one of those states.
- 36:34That's a battleground for both president and the US senate, and the effects of those can
- 36:39trickle down into state legislative elections just like for several of these states that
- 36:43we've already talked about.
- 36:45And Republicans have had the majority in the chamber since the 2010 election just like we
- 36:50talked about before.
- 36:51One of those many state legislative chambers that year that saw huge Republican gains.
- 36:56And CNALYSIS rates it as a 64 to 68% chance to keep that chamber.
- 37:05And that's gonna do it for today's episode.
- 37:07As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 37:09Next episode, we'll talk about the big kahootah, the US presidential election.
- 37:14All my media, my Facebook, LinkedIn, Medium, and all that in the show notes below.
- 37:21But as always, thank you again for listening, and until next time, take care.