Latest / Dharma Lab / DL Ep.11: Meditation Apps - The Impacts on Brain Health to Gut Health
Transcript
- 0:00One of the kind of sobering issues in all of this that I am
- 0:05frequently reminded of
- 0:07is that there are certain kinds of interventions where the
- 0:12impact may not be seen
- 0:14SPEAKER_00: until some time has elapsed.
- 0:16SPEAKER_01: I mean, sometimes it's more than a decade or two later, right?
- 0:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 0:19SPEAKER_00: extreme cases.
- 0:20SPEAKER_00: There's a famous series of studies that was done by Mark Greenberg,
- 0:26and he developed interventions for adolescents who were at risk
- 0:29for substance
- 0:30SPEAKER_00: abuse.
- 0:31SPEAKER_00: And many of these were also contemplative-based interventions.
- 0:35SPEAKER_00: And in some of that work, they did not see any
- 0:39SPEAKER_00: immediate effect of the intervention.
- 0:43SPEAKER_00: But fortunately, they follow these people.
- 0:45SPEAKER_00: And in some cases,
- 0:46SPEAKER_00: they did not see the effects emerge until five or seven years later,
- 0:51SPEAKER_00: which is kind of remarkable.
- 0:54SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 0:55SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 0:56SPEAKER_00: right now,
- 0:57SPEAKER_00: Simon,
- 0:58you can tell us what the longest follow-up has been of any
- 1:01study with a meditation
- 1:03SPEAKER_00: app,
- 1:04SPEAKER_00: probably less than a year.
- 1:05SPEAKER_02: I think it's probably a year or less.
- 1:07SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:08SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:09SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 1:11SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:11one of the cool things about the use of the meditation app in
- 1:16research is that we
- 1:17have the potential to track the use of the app beyond the
- 1:22period of the formal
- 1:24SPEAKER_00: study.
- 1:25SPEAKER_00: And so we can know through the back end data,
- 1:29SPEAKER_00: so to speak,
- 1:30SPEAKER_00: how much people are engaged with it after the study has ended.
- 1:33SPEAKER_00: And we can also track the longer term effects in principle.
- 1:40And so that's something that really I think we'll see more of
- 1:43in the future.
- 1:54SPEAKER_01: Hello, gentlemen.
- 1:55SPEAKER_01: Welcome to another episode of DARPA Lab and everybody here listening.
- 1:59SPEAKER_01: We're here with our dear friend and colleague and brilliant scientist,
- 2:04SPEAKER_01: Simon Goldberg,
- 2:05SPEAKER_01: who just published a really,
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: really interesting article on meditation apps and,
- 2:09SPEAKER_01: in fact,
- 2:09is one of the leading scientists on the planet studying the use
- 2:14of meditation apps
- 2:15SPEAKER_01: and how effective they are.
- 2:17SPEAKER_01: So we're very excited to be here to have this conversation.
- 2:21SPEAKER_01: And as I was thinking about the backdrop for this,
- 2:24I was just reminded of some of my deep dives into the more
- 2:30traditional side of
- 2:31meditation traditions and reading about these accounts of
- 2:35people crossing over the
- 2:37SPEAKER_01: Himalayas
- 2:38SPEAKER_01: in some cases at great risk to their physical health,
- 2:43SPEAKER_01: a tremendous amount of time and energy just to learn to meditate,
- 2:46SPEAKER_01: just to encounter meditation teachers and get instructions.
- 2:51And then you fast forward now to the 21st century and you
- 2:54literally can download an
- 2:56SPEAKER_01: app and within five seconds with pretty much zero friction,
- 3:00SPEAKER_01: be learning from some of the greatest meditation teachers on the planet.
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: So it's just a completely different ball game.
- 3:07SPEAKER_01: than what has happened historically with these traditions.
- 3:11SPEAKER_01: And it's beautiful.
- 3:12SPEAKER_01: It's wonderful.
- 3:13It's amazing that everybody in the world or most people in the
- 3:17world have access to
- 3:17SPEAKER_01: these kinds of things now.
- 3:19But it's also changed the whole way that this happens in pretty
- 3:23fundamental ways.
- 3:25SPEAKER_01: So why don't we just kick this off with just some opening thoughts?
- 3:27SPEAKER_01: I'd love to hear from each of you.
- 3:29SPEAKER_01: And of course, I can chime in a little bit.
- 3:31SPEAKER_01: Just your opening thoughts about where we're at,
- 3:34SPEAKER_01: not only with scientific research in this area,
- 3:38but just the whole idea of how these ancient meditative
- 3:41traditions are being passed
- 3:44SPEAKER_01: down in the modern world.
- 3:45SPEAKER_01: So maybe,
- 3:46SPEAKER_01: Simon,
- 3:46we can just start with you and just any kind of opening
- 3:49thoughts you might have or
- 3:50SPEAKER_01: reflections before we dive into some of the science.
- 3:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah, thank you, Corden.
- 3:54SPEAKER_02: Thank you both for having me.
- 3:57SPEAKER_02: It's really fun to be here.
- 4:00SPEAKER_02: I love that reminder of sort of how this used to work.
- 4:04SPEAKER_02: And for me,
- 4:05I learned to meditate from Thich Nhat Hanh books when I was 20
- 4:10years old and I was
- 4:11SPEAKER_02: in rural North Carolina.
- 4:13SPEAKER_02: And I would get these books and then go and sit out in the forest.
- 4:16SPEAKER_02: And so for me, there's something...
- 4:20I think there's a resonant element to this sort of self-guided
- 4:24possibility,
- 4:25SPEAKER_02: at least for getting started,
- 4:26that makes me less skeptical of the potential of these tools
- 4:32because the practices
- 4:33SPEAKER_02: themselves have so much potency.
- 4:34SPEAKER_02: And if people are able to connect with them,
- 4:37I think a lot can be learned just from very relatively little
- 4:42instruction or even
- 4:43relatively little personalized instruction to begin with if
- 4:45someone's really
- 4:46SPEAKER_02: interested in exploring them.
- 4:49I have lots to say on the kind of status of the research and
- 4:52where some of this is going.
- 4:53SPEAKER_02: But in general, I'm super enthusiastic about it.
- 4:56And I think digital health is obviously a major part of the
- 5:01future of mental health.
- 5:02And I think meditation is maybe one of the very best techniques
- 5:06to be delivered that way.
- 5:09SPEAKER_01: What do you think, Richie?
- 5:10SPEAKER_01: What's what's your opening take on this topic?
- 5:12SPEAKER_00: Well, thank you, Simon.
- 5:14SPEAKER_00: And it's great to have you here on Dharma Lab.
- 5:17SPEAKER_00: You know, I reflect on just the role of technology in general and.
- 5:25SPEAKER_00: Our teacher court,
- 5:27SPEAKER_00: Mingyur Rinpoche,
- 5:29SPEAKER_00: has an enormous online presence,
- 5:32and people benefit all over the world from material that is
- 5:39available easily
- 5:41SPEAKER_00: online.
- 5:42You can go to the Dalai Lama website and find a plethora of
- 5:47material that is available.
- 5:50SPEAKER_00: 20 years ago, none of this existed.
- 5:54SPEAKER_00: And it has made Dharma available in a way that has democratized,
- 6:02SPEAKER_00: really,
- 6:04Dharma and allowed it to spread in ways that I don't think any
- 6:10of us really dreamt
- 6:12SPEAKER_00: would be possible 20 years ago.
- 6:15SPEAKER_00: So I think, you know, I kind of come down on...
- 6:22the side of believing that technology has an important role to
- 6:29play and has really
- 6:31SPEAKER_00: helped to bring these teachings out in a very wide and
- 6:41SPEAKER_00: equitable kind of way.
- 6:43SPEAKER_00: Of course,
- 6:43SPEAKER_00: there's a downside,
- 6:46SPEAKER_00: and that's not unexpected,
- 6:51SPEAKER_00: and I think that we need to be sensitive to it.
- 6:56SPEAKER_00: But one of the
- 6:58SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 6:59one of the things that I always remind myself of is that with
- 7:04digital technology,
- 7:06we can harness the very best teachers in the world that
- 7:12otherwise may be difficult
- 7:14SPEAKER_00: to have access to in person and have those teachings be available.
- 7:23SPEAKER_00: I think that,
- 7:24SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 7:24from my experience as a practitioner and being in the presence
- 7:28of great meditation
- 7:32SPEAKER_00: teachers,
- 7:33SPEAKER_00: there's no question that something is lost.
- 7:36SPEAKER_00: It's not the same as being in person.
- 7:43SPEAKER_00: But, you know, I think that it is...
- 7:50SPEAKER_00: nevertheless very helpful,
- 7:52SPEAKER_00: can really help relieve suffering,
- 7:55can also help to introduce people and give them a glimpse of
- 8:00what these experiences
- 8:01SPEAKER_00: are like.
- 8:02And for those people who are really passionate about it and who
- 8:07really connect to
- 8:08SPEAKER_00: these teachings,
- 8:09SPEAKER_00: it will inspire them.
- 8:11And maybe they'll have an opportunity to have in-person
- 8:15teachings,
- 8:16which may be
- 8:19may add to the value that they might have derived from an app
- 8:24or from other kinds
- 8:25SPEAKER_00: of technology.
- 8:29SPEAKER_00: So I think it's all part of this larger mandala, if you will.
- 8:35SPEAKER_00: And I do feel strongly that if we're going to scale well-being and I want
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: certainly think that the majority of our viewers would agree,
- 8:51SPEAKER_00: and beyond our viewers,
- 8:53SPEAKER_00: that the world really critically needs this.
- 8:55SPEAKER_00: I think technology is going to need to be part of the solution.
- 9:00SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I 100% agree.
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: And Simon,
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: your opening comment just about how you learned to meditate,
- 9:05SPEAKER_01: it reminded me of my own journey as well,
- 9:08SPEAKER_01: because it's true.
- 9:09SPEAKER_01: I wasn't using a meditation app.
- 9:11SPEAKER_01: Obviously,
- 9:11SPEAKER_01: this was in the early 1990s when I started meditating,
- 9:14SPEAKER_01: so it was not yet even a thing.
- 9:18SPEAKER_01: But like you, I had no teacher.
- 9:22SPEAKER_01: I had no community.
- 9:23SPEAKER_01: I meditated purely from reading books for seven years or so,
- 9:30SPEAKER_01: seven,
- 9:30SPEAKER_01: eight,
- 9:30SPEAKER_01: six,
- 9:30SPEAKER_01: seven,
- 9:30SPEAKER_01: eight years,
- 9:31SPEAKER_01: somewhere around in that range.
- 9:33SPEAKER_01: And from that point of view,
- 9:34I would say what we get from apps now relative to books is
- 9:37probably a much richer
- 9:38SPEAKER_01: experience than what I had in those early days.
- 9:41SPEAKER_01: And despite not having a teacher and not having a community,
- 9:45SPEAKER_01: I didn't even have any friends who meditated.
- 9:47I'm sure those of who watched other Dharma Lab episodes might
- 9:50remember my comment
- 9:52SPEAKER_01: that one of my friends accused me of joining a cult,
- 9:55which I always thought was so amusing because I didn't have any
- 9:58other friends in
- 9:59SPEAKER_01: the cult with me,
- 9:59SPEAKER_01: which it felt like just the loneliest cult in history.
- 10:02SPEAKER_01: But in any case,
- 10:05It just shows that you can actually do life-changing things
- 10:08without all of that,
- 10:08which isn't to say having a teacher in a community isn't
- 10:11incredibly helpful,
- 10:13but there are unique things you get from technology and from
- 10:16apps that actually you
- 10:17SPEAKER_01: don't get.
- 10:18SPEAKER_01: So for me,
- 10:18SPEAKER_01: it's not an either or,
- 10:19SPEAKER_01: it's just different and maybe each has something unique to contribute.
- 10:24SPEAKER_01: But now the science,
- 10:25SPEAKER_01: there's a lot of data on this,
- 10:26SPEAKER_01: so maybe we can just dive into a very basic question,
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: which is whether or not they even work,
- 10:31SPEAKER_01: and what do we know about how effective they are?
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: Maybe a follow-up question after we get through that.
- 10:37SPEAKER_01: How effective are they relative to more traditional modes of learning?
- 10:41SPEAKER_01: So what do we know at this point, and how definitive is the science?
- 10:46SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I'm happy to share my thoughts on that.
- 10:48Another framing that just came to mind in this conversation was
- 10:51that maybe people
- 10:52SPEAKER_02: are getting the Dharma from the apps and you can get that from the book,
- 10:55but the sort of Buddha experience and Sangha experiences might
- 10:59be harder to access.
- 11:00Although you measured therapeutic alliance and that could be a
- 11:05Buddha-ish relational quality.
- 11:07SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 11:08SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 11:09SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's...
- 11:10Anyways,
- 11:10there are stories of people getting enlightened from hearing
- 11:13texts.
- 11:14SPEAKER_02: I mean, the textual tradition is quite rich, right?
- 11:17SPEAKER_02: And has been around for a long time.
- 11:18SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 11:20SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 11:21SPEAKER_02: so my sense,
- 11:23and I've been involved a little bit in some of the
- 11:25meta-analytic work where
- 11:26meta-analysis being a research technique and a data analysis
- 11:30technique where you
- 11:31SPEAKER_02: combine results from lots of studies.
- 11:33SPEAKER_02: I always like to compare it to Yelp reviews,
- 11:35where you get a star rating that is some estimate of the
- 11:39effectiveness of an app or
- 11:41SPEAKER_02: the deliciousness of a restaurant.
- 11:44SPEAKER_02: And yeah,
- 11:45There are now dozens of trials that have been done on these
- 11:49meditation apps for
- 11:50SPEAKER_02: various outcomes.
- 11:52SPEAKER_02: And my sense of the literature is that they're clearly beneficial,
- 11:57SPEAKER_02: but only to a modest degree,
- 11:59SPEAKER_02: to a large extent.
- 12:00And this is on common mental health symptoms,
- 12:03things like depression,
- 12:04anxiety,
- 12:05and stress.
- 12:05We regularly see effects that psychologists would define in the
- 12:10sort of small magnitude range.
- 12:13But this is from often very light touch interventions or very
- 12:18kind of minimal
- 12:18SPEAKER_02: dosage interventions.
- 12:20SPEAKER_01: And what is a minimal like when you say minimal dosage?
- 12:23SPEAKER_01: Give me a sense of what you actually mean.
- 12:25SPEAKER_02: So in a lot of our trials and some of our effects are in those ranges.
- 12:29SPEAKER_02: Sometimes our effects have been bigger.
- 12:31I'm happy to share more details from the work that we've all
- 12:33done together.
- 12:33SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 12:35But someone might use a meditation app,
- 12:38say,
- 12:38for 12 days or an average of five minutes a day.
- 12:43SPEAKER_02: So relatively,
- 12:44SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 12:45SPEAKER_02: in the span of the meditative traditions,
- 12:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 12:48SPEAKER_02: a few sittings in some cases could,
- 12:52SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 12:53SPEAKER_02: be longer than that.
- 12:55SPEAKER_00: So,
- 12:57SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 12:57what do we know about the comparative effectiveness with regard
- 13:02to in-person
- 13:05SPEAKER_00: training?
- 13:06SPEAKER_02: So, there haven't been a lot of studies that have done that comparison.
- 13:09A lot of these app studies are done in large samples,
- 13:13which makes,
- 13:14you know,
- 13:14you can do...
- 13:16a large intervention when it's a digital intervention but they
- 13:18rarely have direct
- 13:19comparisons with in-person interventions if we look at the the
- 13:24effect sizes side by
- 13:25so the yelp rating side by side they're certainly bigger in
- 13:29in-person so just to
- 13:31put numbers around them for the apps they tend to be 0.2 to 0.3
- 13:35for depression and
- 13:36anxiety and for in-person they tend to be in the sort of 0.5 to
- 13:400.7 or 8 so quite a
- 13:42SPEAKER_02: bit larger maybe twice as large
- 13:44SPEAKER_02: for most of the in-person interventions.
- 13:47SPEAKER_00: And,
- 13:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 13:48SPEAKER_00: it's my sense,
- 13:49SPEAKER_00: but correct me if I'm wrong about this,
- 13:52it's my sense that in some sense that's really comparing apples
- 13:56to oranges because
- 13:58the duration of the training for in-person is typically much
- 14:03longer on average than
- 14:05SPEAKER_00: it is for the apps.
- 14:08Is there any comparison at all that's been done where the
- 14:12durations are matched?
- 14:14SPEAKER_02: I don't think so.
- 14:15SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 14:15there's a whole internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy
- 14:18literature that's a lot
- 14:19older than meditation apps is one of the kind of early digital
- 14:23mental health
- 14:23SPEAKER_02: implementations.
- 14:25SPEAKER_02: And my sense,
- 14:26SPEAKER_02: my read of that literature is that when they are doing those head-to-head
- 14:29SPEAKER_02: comparisons,
- 14:31between digital and non-digital in the sort of general mental
- 14:35health space,
- 14:36SPEAKER_02: you can get more equivalence between the two of them,
- 14:40even in relatively minimal guided versions of some of those
- 14:43interventions.
- 14:43SPEAKER_02: So there's certainly digital implementations that can be quite potent.
- 14:47SPEAKER_02: And some of those interventions,
- 14:48SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 14:48the manualized forms of cognitive behavioral therapy have very
- 14:52clear skills,
- 14:53SPEAKER_02: say,
- 14:54SPEAKER_02: for cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia,
- 14:57SPEAKER_02: has a very specific plan.
- 14:59And so you might have a few meetings with a coach kind of
- 15:01helping you implement the
- 15:02SPEAKER_02: plan,
- 15:03SPEAKER_02: but it's very oriented to the skills.
- 15:04And some of those treatments really seem like a great fit for
- 15:08that digital
- 15:10SPEAKER_02: implementation,
- 15:10SPEAKER_02: either self-guided or minimally guided kinds of implementations.
- 15:14SPEAKER_02: And the effects from those are super promising.
- 15:16SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 15:17SPEAKER_01: it's interesting to me because it's,
- 15:20SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:20SPEAKER_01: from a scientific point of view,
- 15:21SPEAKER_01: you want to get the interventions as matched as you can.
- 15:24SPEAKER_01: But from another point of view,
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: if you just look at,
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: like,
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: how this plays out in the real world,
- 15:28SPEAKER_01: they're clearly just different.
- 15:30Like,
- 15:30you would never – you would go to a class or to a retreat and
- 15:34you would –
- 15:35expect to do it for hours I mean you wouldn't expect to go in
- 15:37and you spend 10
- 15:39minutes or 15 minutes a day and then you leave nobody would do
- 15:42that nor would you
- 15:43expect to do an app and sit on the phone for 90 minutes and
- 15:46listen like you just
- 15:46like that would never equally never happen so yeah but it does
- 15:50make it obviously
- 15:51difficult to compare the other thing that's kind of shocking to
- 15:54me about this is
- 15:55SPEAKER_01: is,
- 15:56SPEAKER_01: again,
- 15:57SPEAKER_01: we tend to design these around the constraints of how science happens,
- 16:02not necessarily how we think of like the normal time course of
- 16:06the meditative
- 16:06SPEAKER_01: process.
- 16:07You know,
- 16:07when I think of my own my own journey,
- 16:09I don't know how it was for you guys.
- 16:11SPEAKER_01: I started reading books.
- 16:12SPEAKER_01: I got really excited.
- 16:13SPEAKER_01: And you guys both know me.
- 16:14SPEAKER_01: I'm kind of a fanatic about anything I do.
- 16:17SPEAKER_01: But even as a,
- 16:17SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 16:18SPEAKER_01: being fanatic about this stuff,
- 16:20SPEAKER_01: it took me a while to get a regular practice going.
- 16:23SPEAKER_01: I had like a year of like on and off again,
- 16:25SPEAKER_01: even even though intellectually I was very interested.
- 16:29And then I took a class and I started paying a lot more money
- 16:33and I was still just
- 16:34SPEAKER_01: totally meditating or not.
- 16:35SPEAKER_01: I paid a lot of money for that class.
- 16:37SPEAKER_01: And that, I think, motivated me to kind of get more out of it.
- 16:40So I still was practicing on my own,
- 16:42but I started doing it regularly at that point.
- 16:44SPEAKER_01: I did twice a day for 20 minutes.
- 16:47And I would say it was after like six months that I really felt
- 16:50like my life had changed.
- 16:51SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 16:51SPEAKER_01: Like dramatically.
- 16:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: But if I look at that whole time course,
- 16:55SPEAKER_01: that's probably two years,
- 16:57SPEAKER_01: at least a year and a half of kind of starts and fits and ups and downs.
- 17:02SPEAKER_01: And,
- 17:02SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 17:03SPEAKER_01: we typically look at,
- 17:04SPEAKER_01: like you said,
- 17:04SPEAKER_01: maybe it's two weeks or a month,
- 17:07SPEAKER_01: and then we have a follow-up for,
- 17:08SPEAKER_01: if we're lucky,
- 17:09SPEAKER_01: three to six months.
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 17:11SPEAKER_01: So it's like, who said that you should see a lot of benefits in that?
- 17:15SPEAKER_01: Like nobody said that, but it's yet it's how science occurs.
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: So to me,
- 17:18it's almost amazing that actually we see the results that we do
- 17:21in a relatively
- 17:22SPEAKER_01: short time period.
- 17:23Because a lot of,
- 17:24you know,
- 17:24the traditions would say like,
- 17:25it's like exercise.
- 17:27SPEAKER_01: Of course,
- 17:27SPEAKER_01: you could look at it from a short point of view,
- 17:29SPEAKER_01: but really you need to sustain these practices.
- 17:32They should be,
- 17:34you know,
- 17:34you need to kind of maintain them to really derive the
- 17:36benefits.
- 17:38SPEAKER_01: And I just want to...
- 17:39SPEAKER_00: Along those lines,
- 17:40SPEAKER_00: I'm curious,
- 17:41what is the longest duration of time that a meditation app has
- 17:47been studied?
- 17:49SPEAKER_01: That's a good question.
- 17:50SPEAKER_01: The longest follow-up?
- 17:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 17:53SPEAKER_01: Or even the longest active intervention.
- 17:55SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's really what I... I've never seen anything over a month.
- 17:58SPEAKER_01: Have you guys?
- 17:59There are eight-week versions of things that are out there,
- 18:02I'm pretty sure.
- 18:02SPEAKER_00: We published ourselves one.
- 18:04SPEAKER_00: That's true.
- 18:05SPEAKER_02: We are very sure.
- 18:06SPEAKER_02: That's right.
- 18:07SPEAKER_02: We did.
- 18:09SPEAKER_01: I'm probably a co-author on that paper.
- 18:10SPEAKER_01: I should know that.
- 18:11SPEAKER_01: You probably are.
- 18:12SPEAKER_01: Wow.
- 18:15But it's true,
- 18:15a lot of the follow-ups are,
- 18:16I mean,
- 18:17we have data from a five-month follow-up.
- 18:20SPEAKER_02: I mean, it's a huge problem in the field, really, for not understanding.
- 18:23SPEAKER_02: To me,
- 18:25SPEAKER_02: a bigger issue that I think speaks to your point,
- 18:28SPEAKER_02: Court,
- 18:28SPEAKER_02: is that our measures are super crude.
- 18:32SPEAKER_02: Anxiety and depression typically means something like the GAT,
- 18:35SPEAKER_02: the generalized anxiety seven or the patient health questionnaire nine.
- 18:39SPEAKER_02: And it's very crude.
- 18:40It's not,
- 18:41I'm sure,
- 18:41getting...
- 18:42Could you just say a little bit for people who are listening?
- 18:45SPEAKER_01: We have these questionnaires.
- 18:46SPEAKER_01: What's the common question?
- 18:48SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: What are some items?
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 18:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 18:50SPEAKER_02: so I could pull it right up,
- 18:53SPEAKER_02: but I won't do that because so in the depression measure,
- 18:57SPEAKER_02: it'd be a measure of what's called anhedonia.
- 19:00SPEAKER_02: So a lack of pleasure, interest in things that you typically enjoy.
- 19:03SPEAKER_02: And you're rating it over the last two weeks,
- 19:06SPEAKER_02: saying whether it's happening,
- 19:07SPEAKER_02: not at all or to all of the time.
- 19:10SPEAKER_02: And then on the anxiety measures,
- 19:12it would be things like feeling keyed up or having sleep
- 19:15difficulties would be some
- 19:17SPEAKER_02: of the cardinal symptoms of generalized anxiety.
- 19:19SPEAKER_02: Basically like short questionnaires.
- 19:21SPEAKER_01: Yeah, short questionnaires.
- 19:22SPEAKER_01: Symptoms related to depression and anxiety.
- 19:25SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 19:25And we've studied relational,
- 19:27you know,
- 19:27how your relationships might have changed.
- 19:29But a lot of these things,
- 19:31certainly the deep end of the pool can be quite subtle.
- 19:34And and we don't have good measures of a lot of the kinds of
- 19:38transformations.
- 19:39SPEAKER_02: I'm sure that happens to people as they deepen in their practice.
- 19:42SPEAKER_02: Hmm.
- 19:45SPEAKER_01: So what would you say,
- 19:48SPEAKER_01: so you talked about the effect sizes,
- 19:49which is just like how much change is occurring in a given
- 19:52period of time.
- 19:54Not surprising that it's larger for doing like more traditional
- 19:57in-person course.
- 19:59SPEAKER_01: Of course,
- 20:00SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 20:00SPEAKER_01: if you do that,
- 20:01SPEAKER_01: typically,
- 20:02SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 20:02SPEAKER_01: what's a typical mindfulness-based stress reduction course?
- 20:07SPEAKER_01: I think you meet two hours a day, two hours a week for eight weeks.
- 20:11SPEAKER_01: And then you have kind of a half day retreat, I think is the standard.
- 20:14SPEAKER_01: If you add up the hours, that's a lot.
- 20:17SPEAKER_00: 30 hours total.
- 20:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah, 30 hours total.
- 20:21And whereas we've seen with the Healthy Minds app,
- 20:24four to five minutes a day for a month.
- 20:27SPEAKER_01: So, of course, you can do the math there and it's dramatically different.
- 20:30SPEAKER_01: I mean, kind of astronomically different in terms of the time commitment.
- 20:34SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 20:37SPEAKER_01: So what could people expect?
- 20:39I mean,
- 20:39when you say small to moderate effect sizes,
- 20:42in real world terms,
- 20:44what does that mean?
- 20:45SPEAKER_01: If somebody's saying like, hey, is this worth my time?
- 20:47SPEAKER_01: It might be a little...
- 20:50SPEAKER_01: less than motivating to say like,
- 20:51SPEAKER_01: ah,
- 20:52SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 20:52SPEAKER_01: it's a small,
- 20:53SPEAKER_01: like,
- 20:53SPEAKER_01: what does it really mean in real world terms?
- 20:56SPEAKER_02: I haven't done this exact translation,
- 20:57but I think Dan Harris estimating 10% is probably a good mental
- 21:01benchmark at least.
- 21:03SPEAKER_02: You might get 10% happier.
- 21:06SPEAKER_02: We should convert that and see how close he was.
- 21:09SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 21:10SPEAKER_01: Richie, what would you say?
- 21:13What's the scientific case for meditation apps for somebody
- 21:16who's just wondering
- 21:17SPEAKER_01: whether they should go that route?
- 21:20SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, I think that one of the things that...
- 21:27SPEAKER_00: doesn't often get communicated in the popular media,
- 21:31SPEAKER_00: and even is not so clear in scientific papers,
- 21:35SPEAKER_00: is kind of the dirty laundry of these studies,
- 21:40SPEAKER_00: which is that there's huge variation among people in how these apps work.
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: So some people show really big effect sizes, right?
- 21:51SPEAKER_00: And other people's show small to no change.
- 21:58SPEAKER_00: So there's a lot of variability.
- 22:00And I think that is there any just to drill down on that very
- 22:05specific point.
- 22:06Do we know what what's predictive of whether or not people
- 22:09benefit from it?
- 22:10SPEAKER_02: I have a thought on this.
- 22:11SPEAKER_02: I think this will be useful for your viewers or your listeners.
- 22:15SPEAKER_02: Those who ruminate more benefit more.
- 22:19SPEAKER_01: And we've seen that.
- 22:20SPEAKER_02: Others have seen that.
- 22:21SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 22:22SPEAKER_01: I mean, it seems like across many studies...
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: actually even beyond the meditation app space,
- 22:28SPEAKER_01: is that actually where we're struggling more,
- 22:30SPEAKER_01: we have the most room to grow,
- 22:32SPEAKER_01: actually.
- 22:32And so you tend to see where it's kind of counterintuitive
- 22:35because sometimes you
- 22:36SPEAKER_01: might think like,
- 22:37SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 22:37SPEAKER_01: I need to be in a good mental space to do this.
- 22:39SPEAKER_01: But actually,
- 22:39SPEAKER_01: it seems like in a lot of different domains and interventions,
- 22:43SPEAKER_01: it's actually,
- 22:44SPEAKER_01: no,
- 22:44SPEAKER_01: when you're really struggling,
- 22:45SPEAKER_01: that's where we have the most to gain.
- 22:46SPEAKER_01: It seems like that.
- 22:48SPEAKER_00: We've seen that very consistently.
- 22:49SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 22:51both in our laboratory work with biological measures and also
- 22:56in the work that
- 22:58SPEAKER_00: we've done more recently with our app-based interventions,
- 23:02that people who start off having more difficulty and showing
- 23:08more distress are the
- 23:11SPEAKER_00: ones who show the larger benefit.
- 23:13SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 23:14SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 23:16So that's maybe a good segue into the study that we've all been
- 23:22involved with.
- 23:23SPEAKER_01: But Simon,
- 23:23SPEAKER_01: you've been the lead in,
- 23:25which is specifically with people who have clinical levels of
- 23:28depression and
- 23:29SPEAKER_01: anxiety.
- 23:29SPEAKER_01: We internally call it the Be Well study.
- 23:34SPEAKER_01: We still haven't published anything on this,
- 23:37SPEAKER_01: but is there any sneak preview you can give of what we're...
- 23:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 23:41SPEAKER_01: Very specifically.
- 23:42SPEAKER_01: I mean, this is with the Healthy Minds app.
- 23:44SPEAKER_01: which our listeners would have heard us reference many times over.
- 23:48SPEAKER_01: But yeah,
- 23:48SPEAKER_01: what,
- 23:48SPEAKER_01: what's,
- 23:49SPEAKER_01: what,
- 23:49SPEAKER_01: what,
- 23:49SPEAKER_01: what's the,
- 23:50SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: the,
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: the sneak preview on your,
- 23:53SPEAKER_01: your work there.
- 23:54SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 23:54SPEAKER_02: And I w I want to tag it back to,
- 23:56SPEAKER_02: um,
- 23:57SPEAKER_02: some of the questions that we're having around kind of,
- 24:00SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 24:01key ingredients and also this question of dosage that I know
- 24:04we're all interested
- 24:05SPEAKER_02: in.
- 24:06SPEAKER_02: Cause,
- 24:06SPEAKER_02: um,
- 24:07SPEAKER_02: this study,
- 24:07this be well study had two versions of the healthy minds app
- 24:10that were compared one
- 24:12SPEAKER_02: that had,
- 24:13SPEAKER_02: um,
- 24:14SPEAKER_02: meditation practices and then the learns,
- 24:15SPEAKER_02: the sort of well-being,
- 24:16SPEAKER_02: psychoeducation,
- 24:17SPEAKER_02: science,
- 24:17SPEAKER_02: psychoeducation,
- 24:18SPEAKER_02: and then one that just had the psychoeducational elements to it.
- 24:22SPEAKER_02: And then there was a usual care control condition.
- 24:24And we saw very clearly that both versions of the app actually
- 24:28were quite effective
- 24:29SPEAKER_02: relative to the usual care.
- 24:31SPEAKER_02: So just that, I think, is a super fascinating data point.
- 24:35SPEAKER_02: And we saw that across many measures.
- 24:36You could just put this in terms that we've discussed in
- 24:38previous episodes.
- 24:40this is like the view like the part where you're just learning
- 24:43you're not doing any
- 24:44meditation like that's the the psycho education part that that
- 24:48you mentioned simon
- 24:49and this goes back to actually we've been discussing this for
- 24:51more than a decade i
- 24:52think richie actually i remember sitting at your breakfast
- 24:54table very soon after i
- 24:56got to madison and we were talking about like how we could
- 24:58dissect kind of this you
- 25:01know disentangle view meditation application and simon is one
- 25:04of the first
- 25:04SPEAKER_01: scientists to actually look at this
- 25:06SPEAKER_01: in a really rigorous way.
- 25:08SPEAKER_01: So there's like the part where it's just the view.
- 25:11SPEAKER_01: You're just learning and shifting your perspective,
- 25:13SPEAKER_01: not necessarily doing any formal meditation practice.
- 25:16SPEAKER_01: And then the other one,
- 25:17SPEAKER_01: which is the more traditional version of the Healthy Minds program,
- 25:20SPEAKER_01: is both those together.
- 25:21You have some learning components,
- 25:23some short lessons,
- 25:23and then you have practices.
- 25:26SPEAKER_01: And then,
- 25:26SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 25:26SPEAKER_01: there's the third element of daily life application,
- 25:28which is yet another dimension that we're all super geekily
- 25:32interested in.
- 25:35I think it's important for viewers to appreciate in this
- 25:39particular study that
- 25:40SPEAKER_00: we're talking about that in this so-called view condition,
- 25:45SPEAKER_00: the participants were doing no meditation,
- 25:48SPEAKER_00: zero meditation.
- 25:50SPEAKER_00: So there's absolutely no meditation.
- 25:52SPEAKER_01: They're basically just listening to stuff like this, actually.
- 25:55SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 25:56They're listening to us just talk about the science of
- 25:58well-being and human
- 25:59SPEAKER_01: flourishing and some of the underlying principles.
- 26:01SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 26:02SPEAKER_01: It's not all that different in a way.
- 26:05SPEAKER_00: And,
- 26:05SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 26:05SPEAKER_00: and Simon,
- 26:06maybe it would be helpful for viewers for you to share some of
- 26:09the key findings
- 26:10SPEAKER_00: when you compare the view group to the regular meditation group.
- 26:15SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 26:17SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 26:18SPEAKER_02: so both clearly have some potency to them,
- 26:21SPEAKER_02: but on our study's primary outcome,
- 26:25SPEAKER_02: so if a study is a roulette table,
- 26:27SPEAKER_02: this is where we put our chips,
- 26:29SPEAKER_02: was on this measure of depression that we were talking about earlier.
- 26:32And we see at the three-month follow-up that the group that had
- 26:36the meditation is
- 26:38SPEAKER_02: outperforming the group that just had the view.
- 26:40SPEAKER_02: So they're very similar.
- 26:41SPEAKER_01: They both benefit.
- 26:42SPEAKER_01: But they benefit more if they're doing both together.
- 26:45SPEAKER_02: Yep.
- 26:46And that effect is even more pronounced when you're comparing
- 26:50those who have higher
- 26:51SPEAKER_02: levels of depression.
- 26:52So that's where that kind of combination seems to be really
- 26:57important that having
- 26:58SPEAKER_02: the application opportunity works.
- 27:02SPEAKER_02: seems to be a really important part.
- 27:05SPEAKER_00: That's the meditation.
- 27:06SPEAKER_02: That's not the application.
- 27:07SPEAKER_02: It's the meditation.
- 27:09SPEAKER_00: What about right after the formal intervention ends at one month?
- 27:15SPEAKER_02: We don't see differences on the depression measure,
- 27:18SPEAKER_02: although I was just looking at these data yesterday.
- 27:21It seems like when we categorize people into clinically
- 27:24significant improvement or
- 27:26SPEAKER_02: not,
- 27:26SPEAKER_02: there is a higher rate of clinically significant improvement in the
- 27:31SPEAKER_02: the meditation group relative to the view-only group.
- 27:35SPEAKER_02: But I wouldn't trust that enough to come...
- 27:38We'll poke at that more to make sure that it survives all of
- 27:41the things we have to
- 27:43SPEAKER_02: do to the data.
- 27:44SPEAKER_02: But we also see different...
- 27:45SPEAKER_02: We see differentiation at the post,
- 27:48SPEAKER_02: after the four-week intervention,
- 27:50SPEAKER_02: and then at the three-month follow-up on our primary well-being measure,
- 27:54SPEAKER_02: which is a multidimensional measure of flourishing,
- 27:57SPEAKER_02: which assesses not just mental health symptoms,
- 27:59SPEAKER_02: but relationships and meaning and purpose and those sorts of things.
- 28:04SPEAKER_02: So we see a differentiation there.
- 28:07SPEAKER_02: That's not huge magnitude, but it's very clearly there.
- 28:11And what is it relative to,
- 28:12because there's also a waitlist control group in this study,
- 28:15right?
- 28:16Yeah,
- 28:16so they both kind of hit it out of the park relative to the
- 28:19waitlist.
- 28:20SPEAKER_02: The pictures really kind of tell the story very clearly.
- 28:24SPEAKER_02: They're certainly outperforming the waitlist.
- 28:26SPEAKER_01: And is there anything to say about the biological side of things?
- 28:29SPEAKER_01: Because that was another really unique part of this study.
- 28:31SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 28:33SPEAKER_01: to have not only such a rigorous study design with such a huge sample,
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: but also to be doing these biological measures is very,
- 28:41SPEAKER_01: very unique,
- 28:41SPEAKER_01: especially for an app,
- 28:42SPEAKER_01: a study of a mobile app like this.
- 28:44Maybe you could just share a little bit about what you guys did
- 28:47and what we found.
- 28:48SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 28:48yeah and richie can chime in too as our biologist in residence
- 28:53um so far it seems
- 28:54that there are effects from the meditation group of the
- 28:59meditation group relative
- 29:00to the usual care group um on an inflammatory biomarker called
- 29:04interleukin-6 which
- 29:06we measured through blood people gave us little drops of blood
- 29:08on a piece of paper
- 29:09SPEAKER_02: and we analyzed those and it seems that those in the meditation group
- 29:13SPEAKER_02: were lower in inflammation relative to the control group,
- 29:17SPEAKER_02: but not relative to the view-only group,
- 29:20SPEAKER_02: actually.
- 29:20SPEAKER_02: And then similarly,
- 29:22on a wide-ranging measure of changes in microbiome composition
- 29:30in stool samples,
- 29:31SPEAKER_02: we see that there are actually quite a large number of different genera,
- 29:37SPEAKER_02: I'm told,
- 29:37SPEAKER_02: that is the level of
- 29:41bacteria categorization that we're looking at differences on
- 29:43and it's quite amazing
- 29:44you see all of these differences that are popping up between
- 29:48the group that had the
- 29:49meditation and the group that was in the the usual care group
- 29:52that aren't there
- 29:53when you look at the view only versus the meditation group and
- 29:57they're right that
- 29:58it's like the it's something about gut permeability with like
- 30:03like leaky gut
- 30:03SPEAKER_01: syndrome and things like that things that my remembering right
- 30:08SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 30:09the changes were primarily in what's called the butyrate
- 30:13pathway that has as one of
- 30:17SPEAKER_00: its essential functions sealing of the gut lining,
- 30:21SPEAKER_00: which prevents leaky bowel syndrome and inflammatory bowel syndrome,
- 30:28SPEAKER_00: that kind of thing.
- 30:30SPEAKER_00: And so these findings are potentially very exciting in underscoring the
- 30:38the fact that training our mind in this way also appears to
- 30:44affect our bodies in
- 30:45SPEAKER_00: ways that may be beneficial for our physical health as well.
- 30:49SPEAKER_01: And such small amounts,
- 30:50because I assume we're still talking on the order of four to
- 30:52five minutes of
- 30:53SPEAKER_01: meditation a day.
- 30:54SPEAKER_01: That's right.
- 30:55SPEAKER_01: And you're seeing these effects,
- 30:56SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 30:57SPEAKER_01: in the body's inflammation response,
- 30:59SPEAKER_01: in the microbiome of the gut.
- 31:01SPEAKER_01: I mean, that's kind of remarkable.
- 31:02SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 31:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 31:05another set of findings that I think are super cool are that
- 31:10people seem to change
- 31:11SPEAKER_02: the way that they're talking.
- 31:12SPEAKER_02: So we have this video based,
- 31:14SPEAKER_02: it's called experience sampling task where someone shares how they're,
- 31:19SPEAKER_02: They share about an emotional experience,
- 31:21SPEAKER_02: positive or negative,
- 31:22SPEAKER_02: that happened in the last 24 hours.
- 31:24SPEAKER_02: And those in the meditation group,
- 31:26SPEAKER_02: again,
- 31:26SPEAKER_02: relative to the usual care,
- 31:27are using fewer negative affect-related words and fewer
- 31:31first-person pronouns.
- 31:33SPEAKER_02: So I, me, mine kinds of pronouns.
- 31:35SPEAKER_02: So this very implicit measure.
- 31:37SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 31:39SPEAKER_02: that I think is super cool.
- 31:40SPEAKER_02: And that was something in our roulette table,
- 31:42SPEAKER_02: thanks to Christy Wilson Mendenhall,
- 31:44SPEAKER_02: we put our chips on those two vocal or speech indicators and are seeing
- 31:50SPEAKER_02: differences.
- 31:50SPEAKER_02: But again, no differences versus the view only group.
- 31:55SPEAKER_02: I think it's super fascinating.
- 31:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah, this is amazing.
- 31:57SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's amazing.
- 31:58SPEAKER_01: And to me,
- 31:59SPEAKER_01: as I mentioned earlier,
- 32:00SPEAKER_01: what's most amazing is just how quickly we see that it's just,
- 32:04SPEAKER_01: it's such a tiny amount of practice people are doing.
- 32:06SPEAKER_01: And you're starting to see not only,
- 32:08SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 32:08SPEAKER_01: your mind is beginning to shift,
- 32:10SPEAKER_01: your perspective is beginning to change,
- 32:12SPEAKER_01: but your biology is beginning to change.
- 32:15I think we would all expect that you need to continue and
- 32:18maintain practicing to,
- 32:19SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 32:20SPEAKER_01: to continue not only hopefully to
- 32:22SPEAKER_01: to have further improvements and to maintain those improvements.
- 32:26So maybe we could talk briefly before we move on with the
- 32:29follow-up studies,
- 32:30SPEAKER_01: because both in this study and in other work,
- 32:32SPEAKER_01: we try to also track them over time,
- 32:34SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 32:34SPEAKER_01: for at least a few months,
- 32:36SPEAKER_01: if not six months in some cases.
- 32:38SPEAKER_01: And what is the data there?
- 32:40SPEAKER_01: Like how consistently...
- 32:42Do people retain the benefits that we see early on and do they
- 32:46tend to increase or decrease?
- 32:48SPEAKER_01: And is that just purely tied to whether or not they keep practicing?
- 32:51SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 32:51what do we know about like where it goes from there after you
- 32:53do the intervention
- 32:54SPEAKER_01: for a month or whatever it is?
- 32:57Yeah,
- 32:57the biological effects we only measured at baseline and the
- 32:59longest follow-up.
- 33:01SPEAKER_02: So those are the only time points.
- 33:02SPEAKER_02: The mental health benefits.
- 33:03SPEAKER_02: The mental health benefits.
- 33:04SPEAKER_00: Follow-up being about five months.
- 33:06SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 33:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 33:08SPEAKER_01: Okay,
- 33:08so those improvements are there five months later from just
- 33:11doing five minutes a
- 33:12SPEAKER_01: day for a month.
- 33:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 33:14SPEAKER_02: Amazing.
- 33:14And the mental health benefits for the flourishing and
- 33:17depression that we talked
- 33:18SPEAKER_02: about,
- 33:18SPEAKER_02: both of those get a little bit larger,
- 33:20SPEAKER_02: actually,
- 33:21SPEAKER_02: in that three-month follow-up period.
- 33:23SPEAKER_02: So we see more differentiation in the...
- 33:26SPEAKER_02: in the three-month follow-up period.
- 33:28We do see a little bit of evidence that how much people are
- 33:31practicing is related
- 33:35SPEAKER_02: to their improvement on depression.
- 33:37SPEAKER_02: The relationship isn't super strong,
- 33:40but it does seem that people who are using it more are those
- 33:45who are benefiting
- 33:45SPEAKER_02: more.
- 33:46And we see that,
- 33:47if I'm remembering correctly,
- 33:48when we combine all of their usage.
- 33:50SPEAKER_02: So during the four-week intervention period and the three-month follow-up
- 33:54SPEAKER_02: that that predicts their long-term effects.
- 33:58One of the kind of sobering issues in all of this that I am
- 34:04frequently reminded of
- 34:06is that there are certain kinds of interventions where the
- 34:10impact may not be seen
- 34:12SPEAKER_00: until some time has elapsed.
- 34:15SPEAKER_01: I mean, sometimes it's more than a decade or two later, right?
- 34:17SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's an extreme case.
- 34:19SPEAKER_00: There's a famous series of studies that was done by Mark Greenberg,
- 34:24SPEAKER_00: who is a prevention researcher.
- 34:28SPEAKER_00: did this work when he was at Penn State,
- 34:31and he developed interventions for adolescents who were at risk
- 34:34for substance
- 34:35SPEAKER_00: abuse.
- 34:36SPEAKER_00: And many of these were also contemplative-based interventions.
- 34:40And in some of that work,
- 34:43they did not see any immediate effect of the intervention.
- 34:49So that after just looking pre-post the intervention,
- 34:53there was no significant change.
- 34:57SPEAKER_00: that was produced.
- 34:59SPEAKER_00: But fortunately they follow these people.
- 35:01SPEAKER_00: And in some cases they did not see the effects emerge.
- 35:05SPEAKER_00: This was in a randomized controlled trial.
- 35:08SPEAKER_00: They did not see the effects emerge until five or seven years later,
- 35:12SPEAKER_00: which is kind of remarkable.
- 35:15SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 35:16SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 35:17SPEAKER_00: right now,
- 35:18SPEAKER_00: Simon,
- 35:19SPEAKER_00: please,
- 35:19you can tell us what the longest follow-up has been of any
- 35:23study with a meditation
- 35:26SPEAKER_00: app.
- 35:26SPEAKER_00: Probably less than a year.
- 35:28SPEAKER_02: I think it's probably a year or less.
- 35:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 35:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 35:32SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 35:32SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 35:33one of the cool things about the use of the meditation app in
- 35:38research is that we
- 35:39have the potential to track the use of the app beyond the
- 35:47period of the formal
- 35:48SPEAKER_00: study.
- 35:50SPEAKER_00: And so we can know through the back-end data,
- 35:53SPEAKER_00: so to speak,
- 35:54SPEAKER_00: how much people are engaged with it after the study has ended.
- 35:58SPEAKER_00: And we can also track the longer-term effects in principle.
- 36:05And so that's something that really I think we'll see more of
- 36:09in the future.
- 36:11You know,
- 36:11one of the things that's really interesting about this whole
- 36:14area is that
- 36:16SPEAKER_01: If you think about,
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: again,
- 36:18SPEAKER_01: a more traditional way of learning to meditate,
- 36:21SPEAKER_01: and here I'm not talking about ancient history traditional,
- 36:24SPEAKER_01: but like going to a class,
- 36:25SPEAKER_01: like going to mindfulness-based stress reduction,
- 36:28SPEAKER_01: is that typically you pay for it.
- 36:30SPEAKER_01: And even if you don't, you're expending personal time and energy.
- 36:34SPEAKER_01: Like you're getting,
- 36:35SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:36SPEAKER_01: you're hopping in a car or a bus or,
- 36:38SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:38SPEAKER_01: and you have to go somewhere,
- 36:40SPEAKER_01: you have to devote a lot of time.
- 36:41SPEAKER_01: Like there's some skin in the game, so to speak.
- 36:45One of the beautiful things about apps is just there's so
- 36:50little skin in the game.
- 36:50SPEAKER_01: You literally can download something.
- 36:52SPEAKER_01: It takes zero time.
- 36:54SPEAKER_01: Even the ones that do charge,
- 36:56usually there's a getting started thing that you can do for
- 36:59free for a week or 10
- 37:00SPEAKER_01: days.
- 37:01SPEAKER_01: And then if you do pay, it might be $7 or $10.
- 37:05SPEAKER_01: It's not like you're not paying hundreds of dollars.
- 37:07So on the one hand,
- 37:08it's wonderful that it's so easy for people to take those first
- 37:12steps.
- 37:13SPEAKER_01: But we also know,
- 37:14SPEAKER_01: and there's a lot of research on this,
- 37:16SPEAKER_01: it's a whole different area,
- 37:18that when you do either pay for something or you expend your
- 37:22own time and money and
- 37:24SPEAKER_01: energy in some other way,
- 37:25SPEAKER_01: your investment,
- 37:26SPEAKER_01: you're invested in it.
- 37:27SPEAKER_01: And so you tend to give it more, you tend to be more committed to it.
- 37:30And so it's a,
- 37:31you know,
- 37:32there's an interesting piece in this around engagement with the
- 37:35apps.
- 37:35SPEAKER_01: And that's another, some of the dirty laundry, you know, is that just...
- 37:41Compared to somebody who's paid $500 and is going to
- 37:44mindfulness-based stress
- 37:45SPEAKER_01: reduction,
- 37:46you compare that to a random person who just downloaded an app
- 37:50and didn't pay
- 37:51SPEAKER_01: anything.
- 37:52What's the likelihood that that one person is still meditating
- 37:55a month or two
- 37:56SPEAKER_01: months or six months later?
- 37:57SPEAKER_01: So maybe we could talk about that.
- 37:59SPEAKER_01: And then I'd love to talk about maybe kind of the forward-looking...
- 38:02side of this of what what's sort of exciting in the for future
- 38:06research and
- 38:06hopefully for kind of where the whole field is going but but
- 38:09maybe we could talk
- 38:10about engagement because that's i think it's for somebody who's
- 38:12using apps you just
- 38:14need to know it's going to be harder and there's probably
- 38:16things we can do to to
- 38:18set ourselves up for success because just the way the
- 38:21casualness of apps actually
- 38:23will work against us in that we don't have that commitment we
- 38:26don't have the skin
- 38:26SPEAKER_01: in the game
- 38:29SPEAKER_02: So, yeah, in the digital health space, they call it the hockey stick.
- 38:32SPEAKER_02: And this is the engagement,
- 38:34SPEAKER_02: the engagement metrics,
- 38:35SPEAKER_02: because it's really and it's in I mean,
- 38:37SPEAKER_02: it's in days for most,
- 38:40SPEAKER_02: probably most people.
- 38:41SPEAKER_02: And you'll see 30,
- 38:42SPEAKER_02: 30 days out,
- 38:43SPEAKER_02: maybe,
- 38:43SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 38:44a few percentage of people are still actively using most mental
- 38:47health apps that
- 38:47SPEAKER_02: get downloaded so that it's really,
- 38:49SPEAKER_02: really rapid decrease.
- 38:53SPEAKER_00: Do we know what the percentage of people who go through a two-month
- 39:00SPEAKER_00: mindfulness-based stress reduction course,
- 39:03what the percentage of those people are who are still
- 39:06meditating a year later?
- 39:10SPEAKER_02: I think that's been studied a little bit.
- 39:11SPEAKER_02: I don't know offhand.
- 39:13SPEAKER_02: I mean, they're like the activation energy is so different.
- 39:17SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 39:18SPEAKER_02: there's the amount that you're paying,
- 39:19SPEAKER_02: but also court to your point to get myself to a class,
- 39:22SPEAKER_02: to sign up for a class.
- 39:24SPEAKER_02: Like I'm in such a-
- 39:29SPEAKER_01: Each one of those is like a cost in a way,
- 39:31SPEAKER_01: like you're sort of expending time and many and energy to do something.
- 39:35And by the time you even get to the class,
- 39:37you've done 20 steps and spend time.
- 39:40SPEAKER_01: So that's even before you've shown up for the first class.
- 39:42SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 39:43and my point is that even with that kind of investment that's
- 39:47required for
- 39:48SPEAKER_00: something like that,
- 39:49my sense is that the percentage of people meditating a year
- 39:53later is probably...
- 39:55SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 39:55SPEAKER_00: even then.
- 39:55SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's probably, yeah.
- 39:57SPEAKER_01: Because the truth is it's,
- 39:59SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 39:59SPEAKER_01: in fact,
- 40:00we found this a lot with the Healthy Minds program in the early
- 40:02days when we did
- 40:04SPEAKER_01: not the more kind of rigorous scientific research,
- 40:07but we were doing more design research just to try to see if it
- 40:10was working for
- 40:10SPEAKER_01: people and what they were saying.
- 40:13And we saw a lot of people falling away and kind of stopping
- 40:16using the app.
- 40:17This is right,
- 40:17you know,
- 40:18again,
- 40:18at the very beginning phases of development.
- 40:21SPEAKER_01: And what we heard universally,
- 40:22SPEAKER_01: almost to a person,
- 40:23SPEAKER_01: in fact,
- 40:23SPEAKER_01: I don't think we ever heard anything that was different than this.
- 40:27SPEAKER_01: was something to the effect of, I like it.
- 40:30SPEAKER_01: I feel better when I do it.
- 40:31SPEAKER_01: I want to do it.
- 40:32SPEAKER_01: I know it's good for me,
- 40:34SPEAKER_01: but I had a busy weekend and,
- 40:37SPEAKER_01: or I went on vacation and I forgot about it.
- 40:39Or I just,
- 40:40you know,
- 40:41I was sick for a few days and I lost,
- 40:43it just habit formation.
- 40:45SPEAKER_01: That was like the only thing.
- 40:46SPEAKER_01: It wasn't like they needed to be convinced they should do.
- 40:48SPEAKER_01: I mean, just like how we feel about diet and exercise.
- 40:51SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 40:52SPEAKER_01: You know, like we know it's good for us.
- 40:53SPEAKER_01: We know we feel better.
- 40:54SPEAKER_01: And yet it's just hard.
- 40:55SPEAKER_01: It's just hard to make a habit.
- 40:57SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 40:59SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 40:59SPEAKER_02: We've had a behavioral economist hanging out these past two weeks.
- 41:02SPEAKER_02: So this is he studies medication adherence.
- 41:04SPEAKER_02: And I guess this is forming habits is hard and lots of disciplines.
- 41:08SPEAKER_02: There are lots of health behavior.
- 41:10SPEAKER_02: I mean, to me, I'm not.
- 41:12completely troubled by that i think there's maybe something
- 41:16okay about being
- 41:19introduced to a technique having it in the back of your mind
- 41:22maybe hopefully having
- 41:24had some kind of potent sticky experiences and then when you
- 41:29know things hit the
- 41:30fan there's some part of you that remembers that there's a
- 41:34there's a way to work
- 41:35with this and maybe now is not the moment for it but suffering
- 41:38is going to come
- 41:40SPEAKER_02: And if you have some sense that there's something you can do about it,
- 41:43SPEAKER_02: I think even that can be really powerful for people.
- 41:46SPEAKER_02: It can be a gift for people.
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 41:49SPEAKER_01: And it's not a linear thing either.
- 41:50SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 41:50SPEAKER_01: really with any meaningful change that we make in our lives,
- 41:53SPEAKER_01: it's not as though we wake up one morning and we say,
- 41:56SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 41:57SPEAKER_01: I'm going to change my life in X way.
- 42:01SPEAKER_01: And then we just do it and it's done.
- 42:02SPEAKER_01: And we've now changed.
- 42:03SPEAKER_01: It's like, it's up, it's down.
- 42:04SPEAKER_01: We forget.
- 42:05SPEAKER_01: We're excited.
- 42:06SPEAKER_01: We're bored.
- 42:06SPEAKER_01: We kind of go through all of this.
- 42:08And that's that's just,
- 42:09you know,
- 42:10in Buddhist terms,
- 42:11we say that's the path like it's messy.
- 42:13SPEAKER_01: It's not linear.
- 42:14SPEAKER_01: It's messy.
- 42:15SPEAKER_01: You kind of need to design with the assumption of messiness,
- 42:19SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 42:20SPEAKER_01: where,
- 42:20SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 42:22and that's where it's still surprising to me that we see a
- 42:24signal in a month or six
- 42:27SPEAKER_01: months because it's because it is,
- 42:29SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 42:29SPEAKER_01: in a way,
- 42:30SPEAKER_01: the real promise of these things is long term.
- 42:34so that's the that's the cool thing so what's exciting going
- 42:37forward here we've got
- 42:38i mean we're sitting on some really really cool data you've
- 42:40you've mentioned some
- 42:42of it here i know i know all three of us are really interested
- 42:48in how we can
- 42:49leverage some of the new technologies ai and machine learning
- 42:52and um and there's
- 42:54even more cool stuff in the works but what what's what are you
- 42:58most excited about
- 42:59SPEAKER_01: maybe
- 43:00SPEAKER_01: Maybe we can start again with you,
- 43:01SPEAKER_01: Simon,
- 43:02SPEAKER_01: but Richie,
- 43:02I'd love to hear what you are most excited these days in this
- 43:07whole world.
- 43:08At the end of the paper that David Cresswell and I did that you
- 43:11mentioned at the
- 43:11SPEAKER_02: beginning,
- 43:12SPEAKER_02: we have a picture.
- 43:13SPEAKER_02: AI helped generate that picture, by the way.
- 43:16SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 43:17SPEAKER_02: Um,
- 43:17but it really sees these apps in this much broader network of
- 43:22other intervention
- 43:23SPEAKER_02: components.
- 43:24SPEAKER_02: And it really feels to me that we're at the very,
- 43:26SPEAKER_02: very beginning of,
- 43:28SPEAKER_02: um,
- 43:29SPEAKER_02: digital mental health interventions and meditation apps in particular.
- 43:33And there's really countless ways that we could imagine these
- 43:37evolving that could
- 43:39SPEAKER_02: really benefit people in the coming years.
- 43:41SPEAKER_02: So just an example I know we're talking about earlier.
- 43:42SPEAKER_02: Um, so I try to, uh,
- 43:45have my bike ride to work be a formal practice for me where i'm
- 43:49really using that
- 43:49as a as an active practice as you would say in the app and it's
- 43:53easy for me to
- 43:54forget that but wouldn't it be cool if there was some haptic
- 43:58signal that i could
- 43:59receive when i got on my bike when it knew based on my
- 44:02geolocation that i was going
- 44:03to be riding home and it would remind me maybe repeatedly maybe
- 44:06it even figures out
- 44:08SPEAKER_02: Somehow physiologically,
- 44:09SPEAKER_02: when I'm sort of losing,
- 44:12SPEAKER_02: losing concentration and has some reminder,
- 44:14SPEAKER_02: this is your practice.
- 44:15SPEAKER_02: Stay with this while you're here or sets a brief intention,
- 44:18SPEAKER_02: some sort of reflection to do during that time period.
- 44:22SPEAKER_02: And that's just one example.
- 44:22SPEAKER_02: Of course,
- 44:23SPEAKER_02: there's countless moments in the day and countless situations,
- 44:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 44:26during stressful events or relaxing events where that kind of
- 44:30integration could
- 44:30SPEAKER_02: happen.
- 44:32SPEAKER_02: Thankfully,
- 44:33SPEAKER_02: we're getting to run a study with a wearable,
- 44:35SPEAKER_02: kind of a second version of the Be Well study.
- 44:38SPEAKER_02: So we'll have electrodermal activity, hopefully, in that study.
- 44:41So we'll hopefully get much more of a sense of how people are
- 44:45physiologically being
- 44:46impacted by these practices that could guide those kinds of
- 44:49interventions in the
- 44:50SPEAKER_02: real world as the technology matures.
- 44:53SPEAKER_01: So cool.
- 44:54SPEAKER_01: What about you, Richie?
- 44:55SPEAKER_01: What's exciting in your world?
- 44:57SPEAKER_00: You know, three interrelated things.
- 44:59SPEAKER_00: One is that this technology,
- 45:02SPEAKER_00: and they're related to what Simon says,
- 45:03SPEAKER_00: this technology provides an opportunity for more personalized training.
- 45:09SPEAKER_00: And clearly, the data consistently show these very big opportunities
- 45:16SPEAKER_00: individual differences or variations in how people respond.
- 45:21SPEAKER_00: And we have the strong conjecture that if we could figure this out,
- 45:27it may be that there are different strategies that are more
- 45:31efficacious for
- 45:32SPEAKER_00: different kinds of people.
- 45:34SPEAKER_00: And so that's one really big
- 45:38SPEAKER_00: opportunity that I think is on the horizon.
- 45:41SPEAKER_00: The second is just-in-time intervention.
- 45:45SPEAKER_00: So although well-being and flourishing is largely thought of as a trait,
- 45:50there are variations in our mood and you can think of it as our
- 45:57well-being
- 45:57SPEAKER_00: throughout the day.
- 45:58SPEAKER_00: And for people that are vulnerable who are really suffering,
- 46:06SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 46:06SPEAKER_00: we're doing some work in the center these days that we're involved with,
- 46:12SPEAKER_00: both of us are involved with,
- 46:13that has to do with the prevention of suicide among people who
- 46:19are at potential
- 46:20SPEAKER_00: risk for suicide.
- 46:21Suicide is a really kind of snap judgment in a lot of people,
- 46:26and it's very important.
- 46:28SPEAKER_00: episodic and often happens quite spontaneously.
- 46:37So not like they're planning for weeks and weeks and then
- 46:41finally more or less just at the
- 46:44SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 46:44SPEAKER_00: there are some people who do that planning,
- 46:46SPEAKER_00: but there are other people for whom it's really more of an impulsive act.
- 46:51SPEAKER_00: And if we can figure out what the immediate precursors are,
- 46:56imagine a just-in-time intervention being delivered that may
- 47:00really be helpful.
- 47:02SPEAKER_00: It may have,
- 47:03SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 47:04SPEAKER_00: something to do with connection,
- 47:06SPEAKER_00: which may really be helpful in that moment.
- 47:12SPEAKER_00: And the third piece is...
- 47:18SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 47:20SPEAKER_00: going back to Mingyur Rinpoche,
- 47:22SPEAKER_00: he has developed a program for beginning meditators called Anytime,
- 47:30SPEAKER_00: Anywhere Meditation.
- 47:32SPEAKER_00: And I've kind of jokingly renamed it Every Time, Everywhere.
- 47:38SPEAKER_00: And it's kind of— That's the advanced.
- 47:41SPEAKER_01: You're in the advanced level.
- 47:42SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 47:44SPEAKER_00: I try to be.
- 47:47SPEAKER_00: But it's really how can we micro dose this stuff to have it available in,
- 47:54SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 47:54SPEAKER_00: in all the nooks and crannies of our everyday life.
- 47:57SPEAKER_00: And it's a big design problem,
- 48:01SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 48:01in terms of figuring out how to best provide those
- 48:05opportunities in ways that are
- 48:06SPEAKER_00: not annoying,
- 48:07SPEAKER_00: but actually are helpful.
- 48:09SPEAKER_00: But if we can figure that out,
- 48:11SPEAKER_00: we can be really sprinkling everyday lives with these invitations,
- 48:20SPEAKER_00: if you will,
- 48:20SPEAKER_00: that can really,
- 48:21SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 48:22SPEAKER_00: be tremendously beneficial.
- 48:24SPEAKER_00: And I think these are really the power of technology,
- 48:27SPEAKER_00: but we're not even close to harness at this point in time.
- 48:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 48:32SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I totally agree.
- 48:34And I think for that last point about micro dosing well-being
- 48:39is definitely for me,
- 48:40SPEAKER_01: I think there's just so much potential,
- 48:42SPEAKER_01: especially in our fast paced lives.
- 48:44SPEAKER_01: In fact,
- 48:44SPEAKER_01: I just remembered earlier today,
- 48:45SPEAKER_01: I had a meeting,
- 48:47SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 48:47SPEAKER_01: with a group of people and it was,
- 48:50SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 48:51SPEAKER_01: budgeting and planning.
- 48:52SPEAKER_01: I mean, very like not meditative stuff normally.
- 48:55SPEAKER_01: But we started the meeting with a little appreciation practice.
- 49:00And we just did it was just like 60 seconds of just the
- 49:04instruction was so simple.
- 49:05Just think of whatever comes to mind,
- 49:07anything that you appreciate or you're grateful for.
- 49:09SPEAKER_01: That was it.
- 49:10SPEAKER_01: Like it was just just bring to mind whatever that is.
- 49:13SPEAKER_01: And then after that, we said, oh, why don't we just each share?
- 49:15SPEAKER_01: Like, if you want, just share what you thought about.
- 49:17SPEAKER_01: So I shared,
- 49:18SPEAKER_01: I just thought of my son,
- 49:19SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:19SPEAKER_01: who's a 20-year-old in college and is going through a rough time.
- 49:24SPEAKER_01: And I just thought,
- 49:25SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 49:25SPEAKER_01: I just,
- 49:26SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:26SPEAKER_01: he can be a pain in the ass sometimes,
- 49:28SPEAKER_01: but I love him and I'm so grateful he's in my life.
- 49:30SPEAKER_01: I'm so happy he's my son.
- 49:31SPEAKER_01: I just thought that.
- 49:32SPEAKER_01: Hmm.
- 49:32SPEAKER_01: And my,
- 49:33SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:33SPEAKER_01: one of my colleagues was saying,
- 49:34SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 49:34SPEAKER_01: my my dog,
- 49:36SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:36SPEAKER_01: he's just unconditional love and,
- 49:38SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:39SPEAKER_01: and just and then we went into the like the budgeting stuff.
- 49:41But you could just see like just the energy was so different
- 49:45than if we had not done that.
- 49:46SPEAKER_01: And it literally took 90 seconds.
- 49:48SPEAKER_01: You know, I mean, it was it was this tiny little thing.
- 49:51SPEAKER_01: But I could you could just see for everybody in that meeting.
- 49:54SPEAKER_01: It was different.
- 49:54SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 49:55SPEAKER_01: Because there's sort of a spillover effect where,
- 49:58SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:58SPEAKER_01: like you were saying,
- 49:58SPEAKER_01: Richie,
- 49:59SPEAKER_01: it is like a little micro dose.
- 50:00SPEAKER_01: But then it.
- 50:01It has like a,
- 50:03you know,
- 50:04a derated kind of like a spillover effect that colors.
- 50:06SPEAKER_01: And if you just have a few of those moments throughout your day,
- 50:09SPEAKER_01: imagine that's like once or twice an hour.
- 50:11SPEAKER_01: You have just like a little thing like that.
- 50:14SPEAKER_01: Your life is different if you do that.
- 50:16SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 50:16SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 50:17SPEAKER_01: And you don't have to sit down and meditate.
- 50:18SPEAKER_01: You don't have to go to some retreat.
- 50:19SPEAKER_01: You don't have to really.
- 50:20SPEAKER_01: It's just the midst of your the flow of your everyday life.
- 50:24SPEAKER_01: It's kind of amazing.
- 50:25SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 50:25and I think one of the really important takeaways from this is
- 50:29that it's really
- 50:32SPEAKER_00: often easier than you think.
- 50:35And I think it really has to do with the fact that we are built
- 50:39to flourish and we
- 50:42SPEAKER_00: have all the ingredients intrinsically.
- 50:45SPEAKER_00: We just need to remind ourselves.
- 50:49of these qualities and sort of just nurture them and get them
- 50:52activated a little bit.
- 50:54SPEAKER_00: But once you do that, it really can come quite spontaneously.
- 51:00SPEAKER_01: Well, gentlemen, this has been a fantastic discussion.
- 51:04Something tells me this may not be the last time that,
- 51:07Simon,
- 51:07you join us.
- 51:08I have a feeling we're going to have an endless list of things
- 51:11we want to talk to you about.
- 51:12SPEAKER_01: So thank you so much for taking a little time.
- 51:15SPEAKER_01: And Richie,
- 51:16SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 51:16always an honor and privilege to have some time and
- 51:19conversation with you.
- 51:21SPEAKER_01: And for everybody listening and watching, thank you for tuning in.
- 51:24SPEAKER_01: And we will see you soon on another episode of Dharma Lab.