Latest / The So What? / So Far, So Good
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the so-what podcast, in which politically-economic analysts J.B.
- 0:10Landman discusses the issues up-a-most in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on J.B.'s website jblandman.co.za
- 0:21I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:27This conversation, accompanies. is newsletter dated 19 September 2024 and titled
- 0:34So far so good.
- 0:36focusing on the G.N.U. the Government of National Unity.
- 0:41It's now two and a half months.
- 0:43Is it going to last?
- 0:45It certainly looks like it's so far and I say that because the first red line for the Government
- 0:51of National Unity was the so-called BELA Act, Basic. Education Law Amendment Act.
- 0:58The D.A. as well as the Freedom Front Plus made it clear before they joined the Government
- 1:02of National Unity that this is a red line for them.
- 1:06That if the President signs the bill then they will leave, Lantzelle was really was
- 1:10suffocated about that but also John Steenhuysen.
- 1:12Well, the President did sign it and nobody left.
- 1:16The President did play a clever card. He delayed the bringing into operation of clauses
- 1:24four and five of the bowl which are the two contentious clauses.
- 1:28And he said he would delay that for three months to enable a political process, political
- 1:33discussions between various parties and stakeholders to try and resolve the issue.
- 1:38That was a good move and we must now see what happens in the next three months.
- 1:42Let's just play out the scenarios if a political compromise is reached and well then
- 1:48great, then the problem is resolved.
- 1:50If it is not reached then the matter will go to the constitutional court.
- 1:54I think that's a fairly certain assumption.
- 1:57And if the court says these clauses are not valid, well of course then they won't come
- 2:01into force and effect and the matter is settled.
- 2:04If the constitutional court says no, all this is fine, there is no constitutional problem
- 2:08with it.
- 2:09Well then then that's the story and the parties who have committed themselves to the constitution
- 2:15cannot then walk away because the constitutional court gave ruling that they don't like.
- 2:20So I think we're over that red line.
- 2:22The second red line of courses in H.I.
- 2:25But the President has already made it abundantly clear on several occasions that he wants
- 2:30to see talks and negotiations around that.
- 2:33So I would expect in the next year or two, significant political movement around this,
- 2:40around in H.I.
- 2:41And that will probably remove that from the red line list as well.
- 2:45I see that there are some commentators who say that this process was the President signing
- 2:51a bill which then becomes an act.
- 2:56But holding back on some elements of it that it clouds the legislative process.
- 3:03Well, yes and no.
- 3:06But it enhances the legislative process and has since the Judeal with critical problem
- 3:11areas.
- 3:12Take for example the electricity regulations amendment bill which the President signed earlier.
- 3:18They also suspended the clause because the local government association has indicated that
- 3:23they will take that particular clause on review to the constitutional court.
- 3:28And the President said, well, okay, then let's not in acted.
- 3:31Let's hold back and see if we can find a compromise.
- 3:34I think that is the intelligent and wise way of dealing with it.
- 3:38What's the purpose of RAM running something through and signing it if people are in
- 3:42any case going to take it to court and you've got a whole aggressive contestation around
- 3:47it.
- 3:48I think it's better to try and find a political solution.
- 3:51First of the day, Andy A and C have cut people loose.
- 3:55How did they happen and why?
- 3:57Well, the day has cut loose two people.
- 4:04The one was John Siennace and Chief of Staff, which you appointed and then very shortly after
- 4:07asked him to resign as well as a member of Parliament that has been highlighted.
- 4:14That is made range of offensive remarks over the long time, long period.
- 4:19And he was expelled from the party.
- 4:21He lost his membership and therefore he also lost his parliamentary seat.
- 4:26I think what we see in that case is it's okay to have strong views and articulate them
- 4:33strongly and so forth, but they're not really in line in tandem with the spirit of a government
- 4:40of national unity.
- 4:41So the day I judged it wisely to cut them loose.
- 4:46I think that tells you something about the impact that the president is having.
- 4:49On the other side, we saw that Czikotwa who resigned as a member of the Government because
- 4:54he was charged, then surprisingly came back as a member of Parliament and now he's resigned
- 5:01from that as well.
- 5:02And I think once again what we see is that he's realizing if you are seen countering to people
- 5:12with a record and people that are charged, you're going to pay an electoral price.
- 5:15So they cut that loose as in loose as well.
- 5:18And I think what it indicates is people appreciate that the body politic has changed.
- 5:23You cannot just do what you want and stick to your position and then the rest.
- 5:28You've got to behave in a way which reinforces the model.
- 5:34There are also other parties in the G&U, apart from the ANC and the DA and some of them have
- 5:40or had before the elections, even more radical positions, our new Minister of Land Affairs
- 5:47comes from the PAC.
- 5:49How's that playing out?
- 5:50Playing out very well and you're quite right.
- 5:53The PAC is well known for the stand-on-land matters, for they meet a kind of a red line.
- 5:59I'm using the description.
- 6:01That's not what they said.
- 6:02But restoring land to the previously dispossessed is a very very important part of the PAC
- 6:08tradition and philosophy.
- 6:10Now the leader of that party is the Minister of Land Affairs.
- 6:13So one could expect fireworks or speak.
- 6:17What he said was he made an early speech, early in his tenure and he said that at some
- 6:23stage the country must have an adult conversation around exploration and then he moved
- 6:28on and he said in the meantime, there is low hanging fruit that can be harvested.
- 6:34What is the low hanging fruit that they had in mind?
- 6:37He highlighted two.
- 6:38The first one is fishing out title deeds to beneficiaries.
- 6:42People look at land and people look at houses.
- 6:45They have them title deeds, so there is no question about their legal ownership.
- 6:49And secondly he said that the government has got to speed up the process of land restitution.
- 6:53We people have put in claims and those claims are not being resolved yet.
- 6:57Now land restitution is of course a program which is particularly specifically mandated
- 7:03by the constitution.
- 7:04So it must be done anyway.
- 7:06And I think it's two very sensible, sensible proposals, two very sensible low hanging fruit
- 7:12so to speak.
- 7:13So there again you can see that it's not about slow-consistive solutions.
- 7:18And I think for that one must commend him and he probably wouldn't have taken that position
- 7:22if he wasn't in the government.
- 7:24It seems to me that this also gives us a kind of answer to something that people said before
- 7:31which is, oh this part is going to get that position so they will now put into practice
- 7:38their specific policies.
- 7:41Now we see that that doesn't happen.
- 7:44They have to work as a unit.
- 7:46You can only put in place or push forward the policies of the government of national unity,
- 7:51not of your party.
- 7:52If your party is for example in favor of the death penalty.
- 7:56Well that's an easy one, it's against the constitution so that's easy but even politically
- 8:02the majority of parties in the G and U doesn't want the death penalty.
- 8:06So you can't get on your high horse and start planting it.
- 8:09You've got to take the line of the government of national unity and by definition that
- 8:13is a kind of a moderate in the middle line.
- 8:15Yeah you're quite right.
- 8:16Party cannot pursue their own positions.
- 8:20They have to pursue their own positions within the framework of the big government of
- 8:25national unity.
- 8:26What do you think motivates a party to stay in the G and U even when this tension and disagreement?
- 8:33Well you know if you inside the tent then you can help to move things along.
- 8:37You can help to change things.
- 8:39Maybe even only in theory and only on the margin but at least you can do that.
- 8:45So it's much nicer to be in the scrum and to push forward and try and capture the ball
- 8:52than what it is to just stand on the sidelines and shout.
- 8:55The thing that's number one.
- 8:56Number two, the party is gain visibility when you are the minister or the deputy minister
- 9:01of something and you move around and immediately attracts you and so on.
- 9:06It's visibility not just for you but also for your party and thirdly the perks, the benefits.
- 9:13So people are not going to move away or walk away voluntarily from the perks, from the
- 9:17visibility and from that feeling of being part of the scrum.
- 9:22They will stay.
- 9:24All of this sounds like good news by cutting the pictures.
- 9:28There's a bit different.
- 9:29Absolutely.
- 9:30The cutting is the outlier.
- 9:31It's the one place where the idea of a government real government of national unity has not
- 9:37taken place yet.
- 9:38We see that in the province, provincial government but we also see it in the Joe Berg, Johannesburg
- 9:44and Tuany Metros.
- 9:46That's a great disappointment.
- 9:48It's also a great missed opportunity.
- 9:50I think both the provincial government and the metro governments will be much stronger if
- 9:56you can involve the biggest and second and third biggest parties in the government rely
- 10:02on their expertise and ability and work together to improve conditions.
- 10:07So Rudau will have to see what extent the ANC will pay a price for this approach because
- 10:14they had the one driving it.
- 10:15The local government elections of 2020-26 is only about 26 months away.
- 10:19It's not a long time.
- 10:21If you're thinking about the next 26 months, you'll be able to improve substantially over
- 10:26the next 26 months.
- 10:27If you serve as the delivery and the quality of administration and so on, do not even
- 10:32do not improve substantially.
- 10:34I think the ANC will pay an electroprisse.
- 10:38But how it is certainly the outlier to the national picture.
- 10:42You say the ANC, but in 20 it's actually a which is making the trouble.
- 10:49Yeah, quite right.
- 10:50And I think they will probably pay a price.
- 10:53I think Action A said that much worse than what they thought they would in the election.
- 10:57So they are already weaker.
- 10:59Maybe this is a kind of a desperate play from them.
- 11:02I don't know.
- 11:03But I can't imagine that that's the kind of thing that the people who voted for Action A
- 11:07say want them to do.
- 11:10So yes, I think they will also pay a price.
- 11:12They're not part of the GNU are they?
- 11:14No, they're not.
- 11:15He's been very with several seven machabas with very the separatists that he will not work with the ANC.
- 11:20And now he's working with the ANC in Toronto.
- 11:25So much for promises.
- 11:29What can the rail that you and you?
- 11:32Well if we look back at our own history and the experience of the government of National
- 11:37Unity that we had after 1994 for two years, it is quite clear that the biggest danger,
- 11:44the biggest risk, is inside the political party itself.
- 11:48In the sense that those people in the political party who is not in the executive, who is not
- 11:53a minister or a deputy minister, start attacking the colleagues who are in the executive
- 11:58and say, why didn't you do this?
- 12:01Why did you agree to that?
- 12:02Why did you support that?
- 12:04You know, you can hear the accusatory tone coming through.
- 12:07That played a role in the collapse of the government of National Unity after 94.
- 12:15People in that government told me that.
- 12:18So I think that is the big danger here.
- 12:20That people in ANC are saying to the ANC leaders, guys, what are you doing here?
- 12:25You are going to fall and people in the day will say, guys, what are you doing here?
- 12:29You're going to fall.
- 12:30So you've got to keep your own people not under control, but you have to bring your own
- 12:35people along, I think that's the important point.
- 12:38And that's where the internal party managers, like Fakili Mubalula, in ANC and Helen Zelle,
- 12:44in the day where they play a very, very important role.
- 12:48They did this their responsibility not just to look after the party, which is of course what
- 12:52they must do, but they must also help and carry the government of National Unity.
- 12:57Those internal party managers have got a very important job.
- 13:01And let's see how they conduct themselves over the next year or two.
- 13:07A major criticism of the G&U is that it means that we now have 10 more cabinet members,
- 13:14cabinet members, then we had before and that it's very costly.
- 13:19Yes, that is the criticism.
- 13:20We have two more cabinet ministers.
- 13:22We used to have 28 day now, 30.
- 13:25We have eight more deputy ministers.
- 13:27They used to be 35, then now 43.
- 13:29So you've got a total of 10 more.
- 13:32And so yes, on the first sound, it sounds as if that's really expensive on the first
- 13:37yearing.
- 13:39But let's just look at the picture from the other side, what did we get in return for
- 13:43the 10?
- 13:44Well, we got 21 people who are not from the ANC now in the executive.
- 13:50We got 12 people from the DA who is now in the executive.
- 13:54In exchange for the 10, if you want to look at that way, we also have four people from
- 13:58the IFP now in the executive.
- 14:01And then you have people from a range of other parties like Good, Al-Jama and so on who
- 14:06now are sitting in the executive.
- 14:08So now you have to ask yourself a simple question.
- 14:11These new people that have come in with new energy, with diversity, with a different perspective
- 14:16from life and so on, are they making the government stronger a weeker?
- 14:20I think they make the government stronger.
- 14:23They bring new ideas, they bring different approaches.
- 14:25Am I happy to pay for that? We've seen extra cabinet ministers, I'm certainly very happy
- 14:30to do that.
- 14:31I would much rather have a bigger cabinet that is more diverse and have more new
- 14:35comers than just the same old, same old that we used to have.
- 14:41What will be the real taste of this government?
- 14:44If we when we look back in five years time, how will we judge it?
- 14:49I think the most important test would be what the government has achieved, looking back what
- 14:56it has achieved in bringing down poverty, unemployment and inequality.
- 15:01Those those three things poverty, unemployment and inequality are by far the biggest problems
- 15:07in South Africa.
- 15:09And you're not going to solve other problems if you don't solve those problems.
- 15:13So the government of national unity will be in my view, will be judged by that.
- 15:18Now is that possible?
- 15:20Well, as you know, we are now in the 11th year, 2020, 4 is the 11th year.
- 15:26So we've had more than a decade with the population grew faster than the economy.
- 15:32The economy grew at about one and a bit per cent.
- 15:37The population is growing at 1.5, 1.6 per cent.
- 15:41So you're going backwards all the time.
- 15:43You're creating new jobs.
- 15:45At the end of 2023, we had as many jobs as we had before covered struck in 2020.
- 15:53So that's something to celebrate, but what happened in 2021, 2022, 2023?
- 15:58Well, three to four million new people enter the labour market.
- 16:02So your unemployment goes up.
- 16:04You've got the same number of jobs, but the unemployment goes up.
- 16:07So you have to grow the economy faster than the population.
- 16:12It's a simple matter of mathematics or accounting.
- 16:15And these are tests.
- 16:17The government of national unity will have to get our economic growth rate to at least
- 16:223.5 per cent, double the rate of population growth.
- 16:27Then we can get somewhere.
- 16:28Now, the good news is that the Bureau of Economic Research at Stalingbars has done the
- 16:34work and they've published their findings.
- 16:36And basically, they say if the changes or the reform under Project Will and Laila are implemented
- 16:44in energy, in harbours, in railways, in water and so on, then we can achieve over the next
- 16:50two to three years, three and a half percent growth.
- 16:52That view of free and a half percent growth has since been confirmed by the governor of the
- 16:57bank of the Reserve Bank.
- 16:59And also by the epidemiolastrofinance.
- 17:02By the way, the epidemiolastrofinance, who is a very committed Will and Laila supporter, is also
- 17:07a leader of the ASACP.
- 17:10And they have again one of those wonderful paradoxes that you find only in South Africa.
- 17:15So I think it's quite possible the manufacturing survey was released by the BR and what
- 17:20they found was that politics as a constraint on manufacturing.
- 17:25Politics as a constraint on manufacturing is now the lowest level that it has been since
- 17:312012.
- 17:32And so that's a significant development.
- 17:35And what you also see with that is a sharp increase in manufacturing investment.
- 17:41We're talking manufacturing sectors specifically now.
- 17:44And that is without doubt good news.
- 17:46And then yesterday the consumer confidence index was released and that is also improved from
- 17:52what it was.
- 17:53Not as dramatically as manufacturing but it has improved.
- 17:57So the bottom line is I think the government of national unity is a confidence dividend
- 18:04coming out of it and that dividend is already spreading investment and hopefully will
- 18:08also spread consumers to take a slightly more optimistic note.
- 18:14And that builds well for the economic growth.
- 18:16So I think it is achievable but that will be the test.
- 18:19Can they get economic growth to a level substantially more than population growth and do something
- 18:25for poverty and employment in inequality?
- 18:28And that depends on the structural reforms contained in the Brazilian program.
- 18:33Now it is both simple and complicated simple in the sense that we don't have to do 55
- 18:39things.
- 18:40Simple in the sense that we don't have to go to the IMF for the World Bank.
- 18:42There's a home ground solution right here.
- 18:46But as reforms are of course not easy.
- 18:48Performing railways and reforming harbors is not easy process and completing the reforms in
- 18:54energy is also complicated.
- 18:56So in that sense it's complicated.
- 18:58But you know what you want to do, you know what you have to do is only the execution.
- 19:02That is complicated.
- 19:03So I think it's really doable.
- 19:06In summary, so what?
- 19:08Well I think the first so what is the development of national unity has survived its first
- 19:12red line.
- 19:13You may recall if you go back over news headlines of the last three months that when the government
- 19:19assumed they said, okay, right, the government is now formed but what about these two red
- 19:23lines?
- 19:24Bellar and NHI.
- 19:25Well we've now passed Bellar and on NHI the tone is already changing.
- 19:31So this expectation stroke fear that the government of national unity will just collapse
- 19:36simply has not materialized and I think that votes well for the stability of the government.
- 19:42I think secondly all the parties who are now currently in the government of national unity
- 19:51are operating in the middle.
- 19:53They're not operating on the flinges.
- 19:55They then bring the parties are the logical positions.
- 19:58And the list of the ideological positions are in line of the government of national unity.
- 20:03So the government is playing in the middle of the field, not on the left and not on the
- 20:07right.
- 20:08And that I think is a very strong class for the country.
- 20:12And we see that the improved confidence measures that I have for the fator.
- 20:16And I think the last so what is that this government, this government of national unity,
- 20:22is really presenting the base chance for South Africa to break out of this stagnation of
- 20:27the last decade.
- 20:29Basically from you can say from the time of the world cup we've been trading water for
- 20:34a decade, decade and a half.
- 20:36And I think this brings the real opportunity of changing that into a much more dynamic
- 20:41situation.
- 20:43Thank you for listening to the so-what podcast.
- 20:46If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating and please
- 20:51consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 20:55Also tell your friends.
- 20:57Remember you can find a written version of all japies content at jplandman.co.za