Latest / Surrounded / 1 MAGA Republican vs 20 Far-Left Democrats (ft Dave Rubin) | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00Hey listeners,
- 0:00just want to remind you,
- 0:01we have episodes of the pod coming out
- 0:03every Sunday,
- 0:04so please consider subscribing
- 0:06wherever you get your podcasts.
- 0:08Thank you for your support.
- 0:10You're arguing that things economically were better under Joe Biden
- 0:14at the end of his administration.
- 0:15Absolutely.
- 0:15So can you give me an example of how,
- 0:17yeah,
- 0:17GDP growth was better off.
- 0:18Real median wage growth is better off.
- 0:20Inflation was better off at the end of his administration.
- 0:22Unemployment was better off at the end of his administration with
- 0:24the worst year of job growth in the past 4 years,
- 0:26just this last year under Trump's administration was the Rubin report,
- 0:29did that also accept
- 0:31Russian money?
- 0:31What show did I do for Russia?
- 0:33I'm not saying I did a show for Russia.
- 0:34I'm saying Russia saw you as a did I do.
- 0:36Who could easily say the talking points that benefited them.
- 0:39But what law is stopping you from doing anything that that another person cannot do?
- 0:43Laws are not protecting trans people.
- 0:45If they were,
- 0:45trans people would not be disproportionately unemployed,
- 0:48unhoused.
- 0:48What would you,
- 0:49what would you like?
- 0:50What would you like the law to do for you?
- 0:52Again,
- 0:52the,
- 0:52the law,
- 0:53the law can guarantee equality.
- 0:56It can't guarantee protection,
- 0:57right?
- 0:58So yes,
- 0:58it certainly can.
- 0:59So has wokeness pushed America past the breaking point?
- 1:02Or is the progressive movement
- 1:04the only answer to MAGA?
- 1:06I'm John Regalado,
- 1:07and from Jubilee Media this is Surrounded,
- 1:09where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 1:12Today we're unpacking what it means to be far left,
- 1:15the backlash to wokeness,
- 1:17and what your vote stands for in the upcoming midterm election.
- 1:21I'm here with our featured guest,
- 1:22conservative commentator Dave Rubin.
- 1:24Welcome.
- 1:25It's good to be here.
- 1:26Are y'all ready to debate,
- 1:27Dave?
- 1:29Let's begin.
- 1:30I'm Dave Rubin of the Ruben Report,
- 1:32and today I'm surrounded by the far left.
- 1:39My first surrounded claim is that wokeism did
- 1:41more damage to America than Trump ever did.
- 1:44All right,
- 1:45if you would like to debate this claim,
- 1:46please get to the center in 321.
- 1:51He's quick.
- 1:52He's quick.
- 1:53I am.
- 1:54So I find it interesting that you think wokeanism's done
- 1:56so much damage to America as opposed to Donald Trump.
- 1:59Wokeism did not kick 17 million Americans
- 2:01off of their health insurance through Medicaid.
- 2:03Wokeism didn't start a disastrous war with Iran
- 2:05that has now led to inflation outpacing,
- 2:08uh,
- 2:08wage growth.
- 2:09Woke.
- 2:10hasn't,
- 2:10uh,
- 2:11ripped up institutions or attempted even to destroy free speech,
- 2:15even by your standards because,
- 2:16uh,
- 2:17Ronald Reagan appointed judge,
- 2:18uh,
- 2:19ruled that the Trump administration was violating
- 2:20the First Amendment by attempting to deport,
- 2:23arrest,
- 2:23and detain
- 2:24students and faculty members on college campuses for protesting for Palestine.
- 2:28Um,
- 2:28wokeism
- 2:29to me it doesn't have,
- 2:31doesn't even have,
- 2:32uh,
- 2:32remotely as disastrous as a track record as Donald Trump.
- 2:35Well,
- 2:35how would you define wokeism,
- 2:36I guess we should start with,
- 2:37I think wokeism is a pejorative term
- 2:39that's used to describe left-wing cultural politics,
- 2:42right?
- 2:42And,
- 2:42and what do you think left-wing cultural politics are?
- 2:44I'd say left wing cultural politics include,
- 2:48uh,
- 2:48just the broad,
- 2:50um,
- 2:50broad attitudes towards social justice,
- 2:52especially for minority groups,
- 2:54um,
- 2:55that have faced,
- 2:55uh,
- 2:55personal.
- 2:56in various ways.
- 2:57OK,
- 2:57so I think the simplest way to define wokeism is basically
- 3:01collectivism on steroids,
- 3:03and usually as it applies to race
- 3:06and gender,
- 3:06meaning that you should be judged based on the color,
- 3:09you actually should be judged based on the color of your skin
- 3:12and your sexuality and your gender and a whole bunch
- 3:14of immutable characteristics and depending on where those fall
- 3:18on the left's kind of hierarchy of importance,
- 3:21that's kind of how you can parse out where people should be and how important.
- 3:23Important their ideas are.
- 3:25So even assuming your characterization to be an accurate,
- 3:28accurate characterization,
- 3:29which I don't necessarily take,
- 3:30can you give me,
- 3:31we're gonna,
- 3:31we're gonna have a lot of trouble getting
- 3:33can you actually demonstrate that wokeism has,
- 3:35for example,
- 3:36skyrocketed inflation out to outpace wage growth the way that
- 3:40Donald Trump's war of aggression on Iran has done?
- 3:42Can you,
- 3:43can you demonstrate that wokeism has violated
- 3:44the First Amendment by arresting students and
- 3:46faculty members on college campuses?
- 3:48OK,
- 3:48well,
- 3:49yes,
- 3:49I can.
- 3:50So let's start.
- 3:50Well,
- 3:51first off,
- 3:51the.
- 3:51The disastrous war,
- 3:53the quote unquote disastrous war that you're talking about,
- 3:54you're talking about a 40 day
- 3:56military operation that stopped an apocalyptic regime from getting a nuclear
- 4:00bomb and exporting terrorism throughout the world that we're in a,
- 4:04we're now in a,
- 4:04uh,
- 4:05we're now in an economic embargo of them,
- 4:07right?
- 4:08We've
- 4:08basically done a blockade of the Strait of Hormuz.
- 4:11So to say it's a disastrous war,
- 4:13we've done we did lose,
- 4:14hang on,
- 4:14hang on,
- 4:14we did,
- 4:15we did lose 13,
- 4:16we did lose 13 of our soldiers,
- 4:18and that is.
- 4:20Uh,
- 4:20but,
- 4:21well,
- 4:21things happen in war,
- 4:22right?
- 4:23Things,
- 4:24yeah,
- 4:24yeah,
- 4:24well,
- 4:25things do happen in war.
- 4:26You,
- 4:26wait,
- 4:26wait,
- 4:26you can laugh at that.
- 4:27Hold on,
- 4:27hold on,
- 4:28listen,
- 4:28you want to talk?
- 4:29No,
- 4:29I agree,
- 4:29I agree,
- 4:30but that's why war should be a last option.
- 4:32Uh,
- 4:33why did,
- 4:33why did,
- 4:34if,
- 4:34if,
- 4:35if Donald Trump wanted to prevent the Islamic
- 4:36Republic of Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon,
- 4:39he could have just stuck with the Iran nuclear deal that he ripped up.
- 4:42Iran did not,
- 4:43Iran did not enrich past the 2,
- 4:45the 3.67.
- 4:46Wait.
- 4:47The rich past the 3.67% agreed upon in the JCPOA.
- 4:50They,
- 4:51they only got to 60% after Donald Trump left that deal and then started doing,
- 4:55um,
- 4:56uh,
- 4:56aggressive actions.
- 4:56I must say I,
- 4:57I'm,
- 4:57I'm impressed with your talking points.
- 4:59You've got impressive talking points and you memorized them well.
- 5:02They're not correct,
- 5:02but I am impressed.
- 5:04Uh,
- 5:04first off,
- 5:05first off,
- 5:05the Iranians admitted in the negotiations right
- 5:08before the war started that they were enriching
- 5:10past what they were allowed to.
- 5:11That's,
- 5:12that's number one.
- 5:12Number two,
- 5:13you also have to go on the assumption.
- 5:14You also have to hold on,
- 5:15hold on,
- 5:15hold on,
- 5:16hold on,
- 5:17hold on.
- 5:17You also have,
- 5:18you also,
- 5:18you,
- 5:19you also,
- 5:19you also have to go on the assumption
- 5:21or acceptance that can you
- 5:24agree,
- 5:25can you agree or verify their claims?
- 5:27It's one thing to say,
- 5:27oh,
- 5:28this is what we're doing,
- 5:28this is what
- 5:29we are agreed to,
- 5:30etc.
- 5:30but you have to be able to verify that.
- 5:32And the idea that we have people on the ground
- 5:34or the UN or some third party
- 5:36organization that can verify what they're actually doing
- 5:38with underground nuclear sites and a whole bunch of other things is,
- 5:41is,
- 5:41I would say quite.
- 5:42A leap of faith,
- 5:43right?
- 5:44You want to trust but verify.
- 5:45Can I respond to that?
- 5:46Sure.
- 5:46So the IAEA and,
- 5:48and US intelligence said that Iran did not enrich past the 3.67%
- 5:53prior to Donald Trump ripping up and stepping out of the Iran nuclear deal
- 5:57in,
- 5:57uh,
- 5:58in,
- 5:58I believe it was 2017,
- 5:592018 when he did that.
- 6:01So,
- 6:01so,
- 6:02so yeah,
- 6:02in these negotiations because Donald Trump ripped up the Iran nuclear deal to,
- 6:07to begin with,
- 6:08that's the only reason why let's try it differently.
- 6:10I'll try it a different way.
- 6:11The IAEA assessments agree with me,
- 6:13and Tulsi Gabbard,
- 6:15our Director of National Intelligence,
- 6:16testified in front of Congress
- 6:18last year,
- 6:19and according to the entire intelligence community,
- 6:21Iran did not have a nuclear weapons program.
- 6:24OK,
- 6:25that they didn't have a nuclear weapons program.
- 6:27They were enriching past the point that they were allowed to for civilian use.
- 6:30Everyone knows that.
- 6:31But,
- 6:31but allow me,
- 6:32do you allow me the weaponization process is different than
- 6:35do you think the Iranian regime before this war.
- 6:38The Iranian regime that has oppressed the people of Iran for 40 years.
- 6:41Uh,
- 6:42do you think that was a good regime?
- 6:43Would you say that was a good government?
- 6:44Would you like to live under those people?
- 6:45Were they progressive in any way?
- 6:46Do they hold any of the values that
- 6:48any of you guys hold?
- 6:50No,
- 6:50but we don't just,
- 6:51we,
- 6:51we don't just start wars on countries whose politics we disagree with or,
- 6:54or,
- 6:55or who are oppressive to their own people.
- 6:56We're actually,
- 6:57uh,
- 6:57an ally to Saudi Arabia,
- 6:59uh,
- 7:00and Mohammad bin Salman ripped up that I agree with.
- 7:02You don't,
- 7:03you don't,
- 7:03you don't do that.
- 7:04OK,
- 7:05we got,
- 7:05we got something.
- 7:06All right,
- 7:06we got we got Israel that has committed gross human rights violations in Gaza.
- 7:12I'm shocked that Israel came up.
- 7:13Uh,
- 7:14Israel,
- 7:14the only place that has any of the progressive values that any of you guys share.
- 7:19Really?
- 7:20Wait,
- 7:20this is actually,
- 7:21wait,
- 7:21this is perfect.
- 7:22This is perfect because one of the things that you told me at the beginning
- 7:24of this conversation was that wokeism was judging
- 7:27people based on characteristics and collective thought.
- 7:30Israel is literally centered around
- 7:32the prioritization.
- 7:33Of the Jewish people
- 7:35as a as a matter,
- 7:36as a matter of policy,
- 7:38that is literally collectivist thought.
- 7:40So you must hate Israel too.
- 7:41You must,
- 7:42you must think that that's the ultimate,
- 7:44that's the ultimate let me ask you form of collective identity,
- 7:47right?
- 7:48How many Muslim countries are there?
- 7:49How many Muslim,
- 7:50so you're just pivoting.
- 7:51No,
- 7:51no,
- 7:51no,
- 7:51I'm going to answer is Israel communist?
- 7:53How many Muslim countries are there?
- 7:55I'm sure there are a lot of Muslim countries because there are,
- 7:57there are a lot more Muslims than
- 7:58than Jews.
- 7:59Yeah,
- 7:59well,
- 7:59just a ballpark,
- 8:00how many Muslim countries are there?
- 8:01I,
- 8:02I would probably maybe say like let's say
- 8:05between 10 to 20 maybe.
- 8:06All right,
- 8:06you're,
- 8:07you're,
- 8:07you're off by about 40.
- 8:08There's about 52 or 53 Muslim countries
- 8:11in any of those countries.
- 8:12How's it going for minorities,
- 8:14women,
- 8:15gays,
- 8:15Christians,
- 8:16Jews?
- 8:17Yeah,
- 8:17I,
- 8:17I,
- 8:17I,
- 8:18I can say that other nations,
- 8:19it's extraordinarily repressive,
- 8:21but I like I said,
- 8:22wait,
- 8:22we gotta pause there.
- 8:23We gotta pause there.
- 8:24You've been voted out by the majority.
- 8:26Please return to your seat.
- 8:28It's been fun.
- 8:30Dave,
- 8:31right,
- 8:31hi,
- 8:31good to meet you.
- 8:32I'm actually a big fan.
- 8:33I've been watching you since,
- 8:33like,
- 8:34all the way back in the Sam Harris era,
- 8:36and then I remember you softening me up.
- 8:38No,
- 8:38you brought on like,
- 8:39uh,
- 8:39Steven Mollahue,
- 8:40like the white nationalists,
- 8:41and I was like,
- 8:41this guy just loves ideas.
- 8:43He just loves all different types of ideas.
- 8:45I love that.
- 8:46Um,
- 8:47but yeah,
- 8:47just wanted to talk right now specifically about the
- 8:49difference between progressive values and the MAGA coalition.
- 8:53It seems to me that all of the ills that are
- 8:55attributed to wokeism are typically things that people find annoying,
- 8:58so people being overly,
- 9:00you know,
- 9:01policey about their pronoun usage or,
- 9:02or talking about specific groups that might seem extremely marginalized.
- 9:06That's what I typically hear from the right.
- 9:07I don't hear like a degradation of like
- 9:09society unless it's the far theocratic right,
- 9:11and I don't think that you ascribe to that.
- 9:12Would you call yourself a theocrat?
- 9:14I mean,
- 9:14I wrote the best selling book on classical liberalism,
- 9:17so it's funny,
- 9:18I get called a conservative all the time.
- 9:19I,
- 9:20I
- 9:20actually happen to be a liberal in the truest sense,
- 9:23in the truest sense of liberal.
- 9:24You should unfortunately,
- 9:25and well,
- 9:26well,
- 9:26I,
- 9:27progressives are not liberal as a general rule of thought,
- 9:29yeah,
- 9:30yeah,
- 9:30for me,
- 9:30I just feel like that type of like annoyance that wokeism
- 9:33presents to the world is a lot less dangerous than like,
- 9:36I don't know,
- 9:36the coalition that you're a part of that like
- 9:38condemns people for having children when they're in gay marriages.
- 9:41Or says things like,
- 9:42you know,
- 9:43people that are
- 9:44of particular sexual orientations don't deserve the same equal rights.
- 9:47Would you say that that's something that's,
- 9:49well,
- 9:49dangerous a coalition is gonna have all sorts of people in it.
- 9:52So it's like MAGA,
- 9:53if we were talking about ideological diversity,
- 9:54yeah,
- 9:55if we were talking about what MAGA is,
- 9:56what I like about MAGA actually is that it's not a specific
- 10:00set of you have to believe this exact set,
- 10:03right?
- 10:04You have to believe these some people in MAGA can
- 10:06believe like gay couples can have kids and others.
- 10:08Believe like that's degeneracy and those people need to be jailed.
- 10:11Well,
- 10:11those are like the difference of ideas.
- 10:12Well,
- 10:12actually,
- 10:13the tough answer to that is yes,
- 10:15as long as you're not trying to
- 10:17litigate someone's life.
- 10:19I am around a lot of conservatives all
- 10:21the time and I particularly Christian conservatives,
- 10:23let's say
- 10:24they generally are not for gay marriage.
- 10:27By the way,
- 10:27there's not one mosque in the United States that performs gay marriages,
- 10:30which is worth noting.
- 10:31Why are you so focused on Muslims today?
- 10:32Why I'm,
- 10:33I'm just,
- 10:34I'm just giving you,
- 10:34I'm just giving you a fact,
- 10:36um.
- 10:37But what I have found consistently,
- 10:38you know,
- 10:39Donald Trump was the first incoming first-time
- 10:41president that was for gay marriage.
- 10:43Barack,
- 10:44Barack Obama was not for gay marriage when he first came in.
- 10:47So,
- 10:48so what I would say is the MAGA movement,
- 10:50I mean,
- 10:50look,
- 10:50Scott Besson,
- 10:51who's the Treasury Secretary,
- 10:53is married to a man and has kids.
- 10:54Peter Thiel is married to a man and has kids.
- 10:56Douglas Murray is one of the greatest voices we have in conservatism,
- 10:59happens to be gay.
- 11:00Um,
- 11:01I,
- 11:01I don't,
- 11:02for the most part,
- 11:03people on the right.
- 11:05Actually believe in individual rights and don't really care,
- 11:07but that doesn't mean that's,
- 11:08that's but that doesn't mean that doesn't mean that everyone
- 11:10has to have the same religious perspective on everything.
- 11:13But you've been around the block for a long time and just like you alluded to in 2016,
- 11:16Trump held up a flag that said LGBTQ for Trump.
- 11:19He was asked in a CBS interview,
- 11:20would you let Caitlyn Jenner use the bathroom that she wants to in your hotels?
- 11:24He said,
- 11:24absolutely.
- 11:24He didn't have a problem.
- 11:25He gave,
- 11:26he actually gave a better answer than that.
- 11:27He said,
- 11:27I'm a hotel builder.
- 11:28If you told me I had to build one bathroom,
- 11:30that would be fine with me.
- 11:30I think it's a great answer.
- 11:31But that's what's crazy is that evolution has
- 11:33changed so much to the current MAGA movement.
- 11:35The MAGA movement today,
- 11:37Donald Trump would absolutely not say that somebody could
- 11:39use the bathroom aligned with their gender identity.
- 11:41He specifically banned that,
- 11:43and not just that,
- 11:44but he's also just called for a,
- 11:46uh,
- 11:46he specifically wrote an executive order that classifies far leftist
- 11:49groups like pro-transgender groups as a danger to the country,
- 11:53which
- 11:54often
- 11:54the,
- 11:54the entire
- 11:55military can go after.
- 11:57That is insane.
- 11:58That is absolutely viable.
- 11:59of people's individual rights.
- 12:00All right,
- 12:00so you want to talk about the trans issue sort of broadly.
- 12:02I just,
- 12:03I want to talk about the MAGA coalition I that can claim to be what Idividual liberty,
- 12:07yet wants to police the way that people express what are they doing that also wants
- 12:10to police people's bodies that want to go
- 12:12after people specifically because of their ethnicity.
- 12:14None of that.
- 12:14OK,
- 12:15so Donald Trump is in the middle of his second term.
- 12:17Gay marriage is here.
- 12:18It's passed.
- 12:19It's a just cause.
- 12:20I believe in individual,
- 12:21wait,
- 12:21you're friends with Michael Knowles,
- 12:22right?
- 12:23Yeah,
- 12:23yeah.
- 12:24So what,
- 12:24what's that coalition again called?
- 12:25I think it's like.
- 12:26Less equal that's trying to actually get rid
- 12:28of Obergefell and overturn gay marriage rights.
- 12:31Does that not concern you?
- 12:32I've,
- 12:32well,
- 12:32first off,
- 12:32I've never heard of that specific organization,
- 12:34but what I can tell you,
- 12:35you're friends with them.
- 12:37Michael is part of,
- 12:38I don't,
- 12:38I just don't know what you're talking about,
- 12:39but what I would look it up right now what I would say less than no,
- 12:42and it's Lila Rose,
- 12:43Michael Knowles,
- 12:44I think it's,
- 12:44uh,
- 12:45what's that guy's name at the Daily Wire,
- 12:46the Head one?
- 12:46But
- 12:47OK,
- 12:47but that,
- 12:47that's not Donald Trump.
- 12:48I understand they want to go away.
- 12:50No,
- 12:50no,
- 12:50no,
- 12:50no,
- 12:50that's not Donald Trump.
- 12:51That's not the head of the party.
- 12:52I have friends.
- 12:54Friend,
- 12:54well,
- 12:54first off,
- 12:54Michael and I are friends,
- 12:55but there is a cap on our friendship.
- 12:57There actually is friends with someone who doesn't want you to be in love,
- 12:59my man.
- 12:59He,
- 13:00he doesn't want me to be in love.
- 13:01He's had dinner at my house with his wife.
- 13:03My husband cooked for him.
- 13:04That's against God.
- 13:05So I want to have a word with him,
- 13:06but no,
- 13:06no,
- 13:06no,
- 13:07no,
- 13:07but think about,
- 13:08think about what you're saying.
- 13:09I get it.
- 13:09No,
- 13:09no,
- 13:09no,
- 13:09think about what he's saying.
- 13:10But what I want your name.
- 13:11Wait,
- 13:11wait,
- 13:11wait,
- 13:11wait,
- 13:11wait,
- 13:12hold on,
- 13:12champ.
- 13:12Hold on,
- 13:12champ.
- 13:13You know,
- 13:13in your,
- 13:14in your world of how tolerant you are showing me you are,
- 13:17you're actually showing a remarkable amount
- 13:19of intolerance because although I don't.
- 13:21Know the group that you're talking about.
- 13:22Michael Knowles as a human being has been to
- 13:25my house and my husband has cooked him lamb,
- 13:28and we have enjoyed evenings together
- 13:30and shared personal moments and all of those things.
- 13:32Now,
- 13:33do we agree
- 13:34on absolutely everything?
- 13:36Of course the answer to that is no.
- 13:38And if Michael
- 13:39was Michael or anyone else was trying to lead some
- 13:43organization that was going to go against my civil rights,
- 13:45well,
- 13:45that is where obviously we would have.
- 13:48Our difference of opinion,
- 13:49of course,
- 13:50but,
- 13:50but I also,
- 13:51but I also,
- 13:51but I also respect,
- 13:52but I also respect people's religious beliefs.
- 13:55They're allowed to have their religious beliefs.
- 13:56Their rigid religious beliefs are not allowed to legislate
- 13:59my life.
- 14:00This is all very separate from the trans thing,
- 14:01which obviously I sense is gonna come up a few
- 14:04more times.
- 14:04I'll just say real quick,
- 14:05like,
- 14:06I'm not trying to come after you.
- 14:07I believe that you should have the full liberty to have the family of your choice.
- 14:10But what I will say is I'm glad Michael treats
- 14:12you with respect individually when you guys are together,
- 14:15but.
- 14:15He goes in front of his platform and says that a video of two
- 14:18gay men having a child is the most disgusting thing that he's ever seen,
- 14:22which is a quote.
- 14:22You can look up the tweet.
- 14:23Michael said that that child is in one of
- 14:25the most dangerous situations he can think of,
- 14:27which is crazy to think of all the
- 14:28abusive parents that actually live in this society,
- 14:31regardless of sexual orientation,
- 14:32and you're gonna look at a happy family and say this is disgusting.
- 14:35That should feel like a violation.
- 14:37OK,
- 14:37so I didn't see that video,
- 14:38but if what you're asking me is if do I agree with,
- 14:42if,
- 14:42let's just say.
- 14:42You said is true.
- 14:44Do I agree with Michael's,
- 14:45uh,
- 14:46point on that?
- 14:47Of course the answer is no.
- 14:48But that is I,
- 14:49I,
- 14:49no,
- 14:49no,
- 14:49no,
- 14:50no,
- 14:50no,
- 14:50no,
- 14:50no,
- 14:51no,
- 14:51no,
- 14:51no,
- 14:51no,
- 14:51that's no ideology,
- 14:52no,
- 14:52that's not the coal.
- 14:53No,
- 14:53that's not the coal.
- 14:54No,
- 14:54that's not the coalition.
- 14:55You're the administration,
- 14:56you're taking a very specific person and you're saying a small specific.
- 15:00Oh,
- 15:00absolutely,
- 15:00yes,
- 15:01it is,
- 15:01yes.
- 15:01Oh,
- 15:01it is.
- 15:02I go,
- 15:03no,
- 15:03that's completely absurd.
- 15:04That's completely absurd.
- 15:05It's completely absurd.
- 15:06We got to pause there.
- 15:07You've been voted out by the majority.
- 15:09Please return to your seat.
- 15:11I want to go to your prompt in a second,
- 15:12but I just wanted to address,
- 15:13so I actually come from a Christian background.
- 15:15I spend a lot of my career debating Christian nationalists,
- 15:17and even the nicest
- 15:20Christian nationalists,
- 15:21they do want to take your rights.
- 15:22I,
- 15:22I spend a lot of time talking to these people,
- 15:24even the really nice ones,
- 15:25so
- 15:26I just wanna be.
- 15:27Careful,
- 15:27and I guess I wanna say like I remember when you posted about having your kids
- 15:31on Twitter,
- 15:31which congratulations,
- 15:33um,
- 15:34the comments were
- 15:36horrifying.
- 15:37I don't know if you remember,
- 15:37but it was
- 15:38Christian nationalists and Republicans
- 15:41tearing you and your husband down for having a child.
- 15:44Well,
- 15:44you should also note there was a lot of love.
- 15:46There was an awful lot of love from an awful lot of
- 15:48conservatives and liberals and people across the board and everything else.
- 15:51The,
- 15:51the
- 15:52way the internet operates
- 15:53is people only focus on the negative.
- 15:55So
- 15:55was there a whole bunch of nasty comments?
- 15:58Was there a whole bunch of nasty,
- 16:00what's.
- 16:00Honest,
- 16:01let's just be honest.
- 16:02Which side supports for that,
- 16:04if you're asking me about for that specific post,
- 16:06it was no,
- 16:07for that specific post,
- 16:08it was mostly people on the right,
- 16:09for sure.
- 16:10It was who were attacking him.
- 16:11Yeah,
- 16:12I,
- 16:12I fully acknowledge that.
- 16:13Absolutely.
- 16:1499% of the hate that I get.
- 16:17is from people that are in this circle.
- 16:20So it's definitely not for being gay.
- 16:23No,
- 16:23no,
- 16:23for supporting going back to the prompt,
- 16:24no,
- 16:24no,
- 16:24no,
- 16:25no,
- 16:25it's for supporting not for being gay like the authoritarian desiring,
- 16:30probably demented old man.
- 16:32So going back to the prompt of wokeism,
- 16:34it seems like you defined it as intersectionality.
- 16:37Um,
- 16:38some collectivization
- 16:40based on demographic,
- 16:41yeah,
- 16:42yeah,
- 16:42we could basically so wokeism is intersectionality.
- 16:44It is a,
- 16:46well,
- 16:46intersectionality is a piece of wokeism if you're going to group people
- 16:50on these immutable characteristics and then you decide based on this,
- 16:54we've got to put black people up here,
- 16:55we've got to put white guys down here,
- 16:57gays are going to be of the straights,
- 16:58trans will be above the gays,
- 16:59you know,
- 17:00you have this endless hierarchy.
- 17:01Policy harms have happened.
- 17:03I mean,
- 17:04quite literally the easiest one would be college admissions.
- 17:07I mean,
- 17:07we know that Harvard and other colleges were discriminating against
- 17:11mostly white and Asian students
- 17:14because they were there,
- 17:15they wanted more diversity
- 17:18and they were allowing students of color with lesser grades to get in.
- 17:22I,
- 17:23as a general rule,
- 17:24I worried about universities who's cutting their funding.
- 17:28Do you agree?
- 17:28Do you agree that that happened?
- 17:31Uh,
- 17:31to some degree,
- 17:31I think it was overblown to a
- 17:32large degree because affirmative action basically ended,
- 17:35I think,
- 17:35in the early 2000s,
- 17:36right?
- 17:36A lot of these issues were clamped down on pretty quickly.
- 17:39And the issue is that when you look at
- 17:41the reason why corporate,
- 17:42I mean,
- 17:42you could look at corporations.
- 17:43I mean,
- 17:43all these corporations that have their DEI stickers.
- 17:45I was just on a Delta flight,
- 17:47they still have their DEI sticker on there.
- 17:49DEI is not inherently a bad thing.
- 17:51Why would.
- 17:51Diversity ever be a problem for anyone?
- 17:53Well,
- 17:53diversity in and of itself is not a problem,
- 17:55but if you say we are going to inclusion,
- 17:57we are going to hire people and we are going to factor in all of
- 18:01these immutable characteristics inherently by saying we're
- 18:03going to elevate one group of people,
- 18:05you are going to have to discriminate against another
- 18:07group of people have that actually is racism.
- 18:10Do you have and a bigotry,
- 18:12unique experience based on your gayness that other people will never have.
- 18:16I'm sorry,
- 18:17does your gayness give you insight into certain experiences that other people.
- 18:20Simply will not have because they're not gay.
- 18:22Well,
- 18:22I suppose as a gay person,
- 18:23I do have experiences that some people don't have.
- 18:26And you probably have knowledge.
- 18:27That was and experience catch that.
- 18:29I did get the,
- 18:30you got that.
- 18:30I mean,
- 18:30lots of people do all causes of crazy sex.
- 18:32Yeah.
- 18:33But the issue is that
- 18:34what we're talking about here when we come to diversity.
- 18:36But I wouldn't want that to anything,
- 18:37I wouldn't want that to have anything to do with me being hired.
- 18:40Sure,
- 18:40but it's really hard to compare.
- 18:42So,
- 18:42sir,
- 18:42let's say I grant you all of the woke harms.
- 18:44The issue is that it didn't take us to Iran.
- 18:46It didn't kill schoolgirls.
- 18:48It didn't.
- 18:49Uh,
- 18:50right now,
- 18:50crush with the FCC and kick multiple people off of,
- 18:54uh,
- 18:54off of air and threatened to pull things.
- 18:55It's not burning books in Florida.
- 18:57Who's been kicked off air?
- 18:58Jimmy Kimmel got kicked off of air.
- 18:59ABC was regularly under threat for,
- 19:01uh,
- 19:02doing these things.
- 19:02The FCC president FCC president came out after Trump called him
- 19:07and said that we can't have these type of things.
- 19:09They crushed James Tallarico,
- 19:11but this has happened over and over again.
- 19:13There are books being burned.
- 19:14Trico.
- 19:14James Tallarico is the nominee right now.
- 19:16They crushed his appearance.
- 19:18What do you mean they crushed the FCC wouldn't allow his appearance.
- 19:21I,
- 19:21I don't know what you're talking about.
- 19:22I have literally no idea what you're talking about.
- 19:24I gotta pause there.
- 19:25I think you're talking about Colbert's show,
- 19:27but um,
- 19:28you've been voted out by the majority.
- 19:30How's it going,
- 19:30Dave?
- 19:31Quick,
- 19:31how you doing?
- 19:31How you doing?
- 19:32So I just quickly wanted to recognize,
- 19:34I love this,
- 19:35by the way,
- 19:35you have a very unconventional household,
- 19:37and wokeism has brought you that household,
- 19:39right,
- 19:39to have
- 19:40to live with your husband,
- 19:41to have your two children,
- 19:42we conceived through surrogacy,
- 19:43and I appreciate that wokeism didn't bring that equal rights,
- 19:46equal rights.
- 19:46So wokeism is,
- 19:48as I define it as I do it personally,
- 19:50is looking to expand on already existing,
- 19:52um,
- 19:53civil liberties,
- 19:53right,
- 19:54to ensure that hold on,
- 19:55to ensure America practices.
- 19:57What it preaches equal protections,
- 19:59inclusion of everybody,
- 20:00democracy,
- 20:00etc.
- 20:01so it's not a policy prescription,
- 20:02it's a social
- 20:04prescription.
- 20:04Donald Trump is president.
- 20:06He's the head of the executive branch.
- 20:08He has a trifecta,
- 20:09a judiciary
- 20:10that's on his side.
- 20:11Donald Trump's violent.
- 20:12Donald Trump's destroying the pillars of America democracy,
- 20:15negative rights,
- 20:16the rule of law,
- 20:17our Constitution.
- 20:18The list
- 20:19goes on and on.
- 20:20So I'm just curious to see
- 20:21what institutional damage has wokeism done.
- 20:24And
- 20:25sure,
- 20:25if you want to engage with Trump being violent,
- 20:26that'd be nice.
- 20:27Well,
- 20:27I mean,
- 20:27I just don't agree with anything you said there,
- 20:30period.
- 20:30First off,
- 20:31wokeism,
- 20:31wokeism isn't what led to say,
- 20:34gay marriage.
- 20:35What led to gay marriage is a fight for equality under the law.
- 20:39If you believe that heterosexual marriage,
- 20:41that an adult should be able to engage in any sort of contract with another adult,
- 20:45then that has to be equal.
- 20:46That's what equal protection,
- 20:47which you just mentioned,
- 20:49is,
- 20:49and that's actually what the decision was based on.
- 20:51So that was not wokeism.
- 20:53That was the promise of America,
- 20:55which is the promise of individual rights
- 20:57and equal opportunity.
- 20:59Uh,
- 20:59as for a few of the other things that you said there,
- 21:01again,
- 21:02I mean if we could do that,
- 21:03you want to do the Iran thing again.
- 21:04No,
- 21:04I said Donald Trump is violent.
- 21:06Yeah,
- 21:06so Donald Trump is violent in,
- 21:07in what sense?
- 21:08Yeah,
- 21:08so I also want to mention you,
- 21:10the reason why you left the left,
- 21:12correct me if I'm wrong,
- 21:13is because you believe progressives were turning to authoritarianism.
- 21:15Am I,
- 21:16am I correct there?
- 21:16I mean,
- 21:16there was,
- 21:17that was your prayer said.
- 21:18I can't deny it.
- 21:19Settle down,
- 21:20Jim.
- 21:20There was,
- 21:20there was a panopoly of reasons that I did.
- 21:22That's one of them,
- 21:23correct?
- 21:23Yeah.
- 21:23Do you think it's authoritarian for the President of the United States to call
- 21:26for the death of 6 active members of the legislature for making a video
- 21:30that is totally fine and legal?
- 21:31It's interesting.
- 21:32Oh,
- 21:32well,
- 21:32first off,
- 21:33you're talking about the video where they basically Mark Kelly and several
- 21:36of these guys were basically saying if you're in the military,
- 21:38you can,
- 21:39uh,
- 21:39you can go against,
- 21:40you know,
- 21:40Trump and all those things.
- 21:42Well,
- 21:42first off,
- 21:42there are some legal
- 21:43actual
- 21:44reasons that.
- 21:45Perhaps you should not,
- 21:46as a former member of the military,
- 21:48be telling the punishment for making videos is death.
- 21:50I forgot.
- 21:51I'm sorry.
- 21:51Did anyone hang up,
- 21:52hang up.
- 21:52George Washington,
- 21:53did anyone get put to death?
- 21:54Did any?
- 21:55Does it matter?
- 21:55The president of the United States is actively calling
- 21:58for the death of members of the legislature is,
- 22:00is are you in trouble?
- 22:01Is anyone,
- 22:02are you trouble with that?
- 22:03You're missing the difference.
- 22:04No,
- 22:04you're saying Donald Trump,
- 22:06no,
- 22:06no,
- 22:06hold on.
- 22:07Let's just understand the prompt here.
- 22:08You said wokeism has done more damage than Donald Trump ever done.
- 22:11So can you tell me a single.
- 22:12Time wokeism is,
- 22:14but he's doing something remotely similar,
- 22:16remotely similar as Donald Trump
- 22:18being slightly sarcastic.
- 22:20I can give you damage.
- 22:21Let me,
- 22:21let me explain.
- 22:22I can give you the damage.
- 22:23Hold on,
- 22:23hold on,
- 22:23hold on,
- 22:24hold on.
- 22:24Listen,
- 22:24let me explain something to you.
- 22:25Donald Trump,
- 22:26all you need to know about for any one of you guys that think that
- 22:28Donald Trump's coming for you because you're gay
- 22:30or you're trans or something like that,
- 22:32or you're black or anything else,
- 22:34might I recommend you just read Art of the Deal,
- 22:37which Donald Trump wrote about 40 years ago.
- 22:39It's.
- 22:39He's just discussing his activities throughout the week,
- 22:41you can dismiss it.
- 22:42You can dismiss it,
- 22:43but Donald Trump gave you his playbook 40+ years ago.
- 22:4740+ years ago,
- 22:48he gave you the playbook on how he negotiates.
- 22:51He leads with crazy this is irrelevant to what I'm currently talking about,
- 22:53right?
- 22:53No,
- 22:53it's completely.
- 22:54You asked me about damage.
- 22:55I can give you examples,
- 22:56but you don't want them because you know you're going to get fried.
- 22:57No,
- 22:58no,
- 22:58no,
- 22:58that is the truth.
- 23:00Donald Trump tried to rewrite the Constitution
- 23:01via executive order with Executive Order 14,160,
- 23:05and it was followed up
- 23:06by 1.
- 23:0641601 where they use this to target
- 23:10individuals for pro-Palestinian speech like Mahmoud Khalilil,
- 23:13and this was already ruled upon by the way.
- 23:14I'm sure you know about this,
- 23:16correct?
- 23:16OK,
- 23:17but you try to rewrite the constitution,
- 23:18the executive order.
- 23:18Can the president do that?
- 23:19There is a the president do that?
- 23:21Hold on.
- 23:21There is a difference between exercising free speech.
- 23:24There's a difference between exercising free speech
- 23:26and closing down a campus and not letting students get,
- 23:29you're,
- 23:30you're an interesting character.
- 23:31Yeah,
- 23:31yeah,
- 23:31yeah,
- 23:32no,
- 23:32you seem nice,
- 23:33um.
- 23:34There's a difference between exercising free speech,
- 23:36which I will always defend your free speech,
- 23:38no matter how noxious it is,
- 23:39and closing and closing down campuses.
- 23:42No,
- 23:42they weren't,
- 23:43no.
- 23:43Mahmoud Khalil and all of these masked,
- 23:45he was deported with no cause and it's literally in the,
- 23:48in the documents of the case.
- 23:49Well,
- 23:49first off,
- 23:49Marco Rubio has illustrated the point many,
- 23:52many times.
- 23:52If you're here on a green card or a student visa or anything else,
- 23:55you don't,
- 23:56you don't have the exact same protections that you don't,
- 23:58you don't.
- 23:59Congress shall make no law.
- 24:00What?
- 24:01No,
- 24:03yeah,
- 24:03for people,
- 24:04for people that are citizens of the United States of America.
- 24:07What's the precedent?
- 24:08Wait,
- 24:08wait a minute,
- 24:09wait a minute,
- 24:09wait a minute.
- 24:09Nothing.
- 24:10So Donald Trump tried to sign an
- 24:11executive order rewriting the birthright citizenship clause
- 24:14of the 14th Amendment.
- 24:15Where'd he get this power?
- 24:17Let me ask you something.
- 24:17Do you think,
- 24:18is it,
- 24:18is it authoritarian?
- 24:19Let me act on a self-granted authority?
- 24:21Hold on,
- 24:21hold on,
- 24:22hold on,
- 24:22is it?
- 24:22Can you answer my question?
- 24:23Hold on.
- 24:23You're not going to.
- 24:24You gotta let me chat here for a sec.
- 24:26Listen,
- 24:26listen,
- 24:26listen.
- 24:27Let me ask you something.
- 24:28Let's try it this way.
- 24:29So let's say you and your girlfriend went on vacation,
- 24:31Bora Bora.
- 24:32You show up to the most beautiful place on earth,
- 24:34and she's 7 months pregnant and she
- 24:36then gives birth in Bora Bora.
- 24:37You think your child should be a citizen of French Polynesia Bora Bora,
- 24:41and you think,
- 24:42and you think that just solely principle.
- 24:43And I'm sorry,
- 24:44the president cannot defy it because he doesn't like it.
- 24:46That's how our country works,
- 24:47and that is an example of damage to America.
- 24:49Fight it in the courts.
- 24:50You can fight it in the courts.
- 24:52He doesn't like the courts.
- 24:53He ignores them.
- 24:53Prior to the Alien Enemies Act removals,
- 24:55Emile Bove,
- 24:56we're,
- 24:56we're out of time.
- 24:56We got to stop there.
- 24:57OK,
- 24:58got you.
- 24:58My next surrounding claim is if you still vote for Democrats in 2026,
- 25:02you're voting for broken cities,
- 25:04broken schools,
- 25:04and broken borders.
- 25:06If you would like to debate this claim,
- 25:07get to the chair in 321.
- 25:14Hey,
- 25:14how are you,
- 25:15Santana?
- 25:16So,
- 25:17uh,
- 25:18can you explain a little bit about what you mean,
- 25:20broken cities,
- 25:21broken schools,
- 25:21broken borders?
- 25:22Sure,
- 25:23well,
- 25:23broken cities,
- 25:24I would basically,
- 25:25you can boil it down to crime and drug use,
- 25:27and I can tell you,
- 25:28having been in here in Los Angeles for the last
- 25:3136 hours,
- 25:32I've seen more homeless people,
- 25:34more drug use,
- 25:35um,
- 25:36more
- 25:37urban decay
- 25:38than.
- 25:39I've seen in the last 5 years combined living,
- 25:41living in Florida.
- 25:42Florida
- 25:43in terms of schools,
- 25:44it's basically brainwashing kids and teaching them what to
- 25:47think instead of teaching them how to think.
- 25:50Uh,
- 25:50and then what was the third one in terms of,
- 25:52oh,
- 25:52well,
- 25:52borders is the easiest one.
- 25:53I mean,
- 25:54under the Biden administration we let in somewhere,
- 25:56we don't even know what the actual number is,
- 25:58but somewhere between 16 to 20 million
- 26:00illegals.
- 26:02If Donald Trump did quite literally nothing else in his presidency,
- 26:06just getting control of the border,
- 26:08I would say would be good enough because you don't have
- 26:10a country if you don't know who is in it.
- 26:12OK,
- 26:13all three of your claims are wrong.
- 26:14Pick which one you want to be proved wrong on.
- 26:18Let's do borders.
- 26:19Perfect.
- 26:19OK.
- 26:20Donald Trump is absolutely the worst president on the border.
- 26:22First and foremost,
- 26:23you can talk about the Langford Bill,
- 26:24which was a piece of legislation which would have strengthened our borders,
- 26:27but Donald Trump had that legislation shot down.
- 26:29He also,
- 26:30wait,
- 26:30wait,
- 26:30wait.
- 26:30So were the borders open under Obama?
- 26:33No,
- 26:33let's,
- 26:33or under Biden.
- 26:34Let's try,
- 26:35let's try that.
- 26:35The borders were not open.
- 26:37So,
- 26:37so we did not
- 26:38that he passed to open the borders.
- 26:39No,
- 26:39it's not about a piece of legislation.
- 26:40It's about quite literally open borders without legislation.
- 26:43You just let people through,
- 26:44which is exactly what.
- 26:45There's no one standing at the borders.
- 26:47Everybody just come right in.
- 26:48In many cases,
- 26:49yes,
- 26:49actually.
- 26:49In many,
- 26:50in many cases,
- 26:51they were quite literally moving barbed wire fence.
- 26:53Our guys.
- 26:54There,
- 26:55there are videos of it.
- 26:56Have you ever seen the video of Bobby?
- 26:57Have you ever seen,
- 26:58have you ever seen the video of Bobby Kennedy when he was running as a Democrat
- 27:02standing at the border?
- 27:03He was still a Democrat.
- 27:04Wait,
- 27:04you're talking about the same one that sniffed coke
- 27:06off off a toilet seat and emitted it recently.
- 27:09Wait,
- 27:09the same one that actually took a dead bear and dropped it in Central Park.
- 27:13The same one that actually chopped the head off a whale,
- 27:15you're citing RFK Junior.
- 27:17Yes,
- 27:17I am citing RFK Junior.
- 27:18No,
- 27:18no,
- 27:18no,
- 27:18I don't hear who's,
- 27:19who's running HHS right now,
- 27:21which he shouldn't be,
- 27:22but that's fine.
- 27:22Listen,
- 27:23when you talk about,
- 27:24do you,
- 27:24how many people do you think came in under Biden?
- 27:26Let's see if we're even operating on the same plane.
- 27:28The acceptable number is about 10 million.
- 27:30OK,
- 27:30so you,
- 27:30OK,
- 27:31all right,
- 27:31fair enough.
- 27:31So I'll,
- 27:32I'll grant you that.
- 27:32They say it could be anywhere.
- 27:33I think I've heard 16 to 20 million,
- 27:35but let's say it's 10.
- 27:36Do you think that's good or fair or just or how a country can operate?
- 27:40I think that when you create instability throughout the world
- 27:43and then you also tell people that your country's open,
- 27:45then you create an actual quote unquote border crisis.
- 27:47Think about this,
- 27:48so what,
- 27:48what instability was Joe Joe Biden causing?
- 27:51What was Barack Obama's nickname?
- 27:53Barry.
- 27:54Deporter in chief
- 27:56Barack Obama had a negative immigration rate.
- 27:58That means that he deported more people than he let into the country.
- 28:01So you,
- 28:02so you're for deportation.
- 28:03So we can say that there wasn't a border crisis under,
- 28:05um,
- 28:05Obama,
- 28:06right?
- 28:06The border crisis was significantly worse under,
- 28:08under Biden.
- 28:09But,
- 28:09but under Obama,
- 28:11was there a crisis?
- 28:12Biden,
- 28:13Barack Obama did yes or no.
- 28:15Barack Obama,
- 28:16no,
- 28:16Barack Obama did deport,
- 28:17I think,
- 28:18more people than Donald Trump.
- 28:19Yeah,
- 28:20I wish Donald Trump was deporting more people.
- 28:21I agree.
- 28:22So you're saying there was a crisis under Biden.
- 28:24Yes,
- 28:25OK,
- 28:25of course,
- 28:25but no crisis under Obama.
- 28:27No,
- 28:27I didn't say that.
- 28:28He was deporting,
- 28:29yes or no?
- 28:29Yes or no.
- 28:31Wait,
- 28:31hold on,
- 28:31we can,
- 28:32let's do,
- 28:32let's do Biden had a negative deportation rate.
- 28:35Let's do Biden
- 28:36and Trump.
- 28:38Biden and Trump.
- 28:38Let's do the last two administrations.
- 28:39the question,
- 28:40yes or no.
- 28:41I am for anyone that will close borders and I'll say no.
- 28:44I'll say no.
- 28:45That's fine.
- 28:46So if there wasn't a crisis under Obama
- 28:48and there was a crisis under Biden.
- 28:50What happened in between those two administrations?
- 28:52Was there something that happened?
- 28:54Wait,
- 28:54are you blaming Donald Trump for,
- 28:56for Joe Biden's border?
- 28:58No,
- 28:58what I'm blaming Donald Trump for is when he's actually campaigning for president
- 29:02and he's going around and to any news organization that will let him speak
- 29:06and telling everyone that the border's open,
- 29:08they're wide open,
- 29:08come on in,
- 29:09come on in.
- 29:10And he actually created
- 29:12something that wasn't there.
- 29:13So
- 29:14when,
- 29:14wait,
- 29:15you're blaming people.
- 29:16Coming to this country illegally,
- 29:17you're blaming Donald Trump.
- 29:18Donald Trump,
- 29:19who really only appeared because of borders,
- 29:22right?
- 29:22Build a wall.
- 29:22There wasn't a border issue.
- 29:23That's what it wasn't a border issue when he said that,
- 29:26right?
- 29:26But then when there was,
- 29:28we,
- 29:28we've always,
- 29:28no,
- 29:28no,
- 29:29no,
- 29:29no,
- 29:29we've always had a,
- 29:30we've always had a completely porous border.
- 29:32That,
- 29:32that is,
- 29:32we had a negative deportation rate under Obama.
- 29:35He created the actual desire for people to come here
- 29:37because he told the lie that the borders was open.
- 29:39Wait a minute,
- 29:39but why?
- 29:40But if America,
- 29:41if America's.
- 29:42America is a racist,
- 29:43evil capitalist country.
- 29:45Why would these people want to come here?
- 29:47Because it's still better than the country that they're in,
- 29:49because the United States America is pretty good stabilizing other countries.
- 29:53CIA,
- 29:54our CIA keeps destabilizing other countries and overthrowing other countries.
- 29:57So we're doing that right now.
- 29:59Wait,
- 29:59wait,
- 29:59so who did Barack Obama destabilize that
- 30:02then Donald Trump allowed into the country?
- 30:03The point being is our country has a history of destabilization.
- 30:07That doesn't matter if it's.
- 30:08Hold on.
- 30:08So who did Barack?
- 30:09Well,
- 30:10I'm,
- 30:10I'm just playing your game here.
- 30:11So who,
- 30:12hey,
- 30:12I'm just playing your game,
- 30:13man created the need for people to come here
- 30:16and
- 30:17there was no crisis,
- 30:18then Donald Trump not only created it,
- 30:20but he didn't handle it.
- 30:21I,
- 30:21I'm sorry,
- 30:21man.
- 30:22Nothing,
- 30:22nothing you're saying is making sense here.
- 30:24What you want Donald Trump,
- 30:25we gotta pause there.
- 30:26You've voted.
- 30:26What,
- 30:27what,
- 30:27what country did Barack Obama destabilize that caused
- 30:30people to come here under Donald Trump?
- 30:33I guess you'll never know.
- 30:34OK,
- 30:35you've been voted out,
- 30:36Richard.
- 30:38Hey,
- 30:38how are you?
- 30:39Hello,
- 30:40um,
- 30:40so,
- 30:41oh,
- 30:41my name is Maeby.
- 30:42Nice to meet you,
- 30:43Dave.
- 30:43Good to meet you.
- 30:43Uh,
- 30:44so I myself am a Democrat.
- 30:45I'm actually running for state senate here in California.
- 30:48Uh,
- 30:48I would argue that I am
- 30:50about as far left as you can get as a Democrat,
- 30:53and I'm critical of the Democratic Party because
- 30:55I actually don't think they're left enough.
- 30:57If we're gonna talk about broken cities,
- 30:59uh,
- 30:59here we are.
- 30:59Los Angeles,
- 31:00Los Angeles is not a broken city.
- 31:02I live here.
- 31:03I feel safe walking down the streets,
- 31:05uh,
- 31:05as an openly trans non-binary person,
- 31:07as somebody who does drag,
- 31:08uh,
- 31:09this is not a broken city.
- 31:10It is unaffordable in many ways,
- 31:12but that is the case across the rest of the United States.
- 31:15And if we're gonna talk about
- 31:17broken cities,
- 31:18we actually need to talk about broken.
- 31:19States,
- 31:20uh,
- 31:208 out of the 10 poorest states
- 31:22in the United States are Republican controlled,
- 31:25and the majority of states that are the wealthiest states
- 31:28are democratically controlled,
- 31:30and these are actually donor states to Republican states,
- 31:34and the irony is that Republicans
- 31:36are against welfare except when it comes to funding their states.
- 31:40OK.
- 31:41Well,
- 31:41first off,
- 31:42first off,
- 31:42I would say I'm very glad that as a trans person you feel safe here,
- 31:45you should feel safe,
- 31:46and I treat anyone that treats me with respect,
- 31:48you're gonna get respect out of me.
- 31:49So I appreciate that and I'm glad to hear it.
- 31:50I assume you've been to West Hollywood,
- 31:52right?
- 31:52I have,
- 31:52I used to live in West Hollywood,
- 31:54pretty close to the Abbey,
- 31:55uh,
- 31:56and I left about 6,
- 31:57I,
- 31:57well,
- 31:58I moved to the valley before that,
- 31:59but I lived there for about 6 years.
- 32:01And
- 32:02the 6 years that I lived there from about 2013 to 2019.
- 32:05It was pretty clean and it was pretty safe and there
- 32:08weren't drug addicts and homeless people all over the place.
- 32:10I spent the last two days there in West Hollywood.
- 32:13That's the hotel I'm staying at is there.
- 32:14There are drug addicts and homeless people
- 32:17everywhere,
- 32:18everywhere.
- 32:18You,
- 32:18you would acknowledge that is the case,
- 32:20yes,
- 32:20I would acknowledge that,
- 32:21but I would also acknowledge that there are plenty
- 32:23of housed people who are also drug addicts,
- 32:25and they never seem to be the problem.
- 32:26It's only when they're existing in poverty,
- 32:28abject poverty outside,
- 32:29that you have to witness it,
- 32:31that it becomes.
- 32:31A problem.
- 32:32The issue is not that these people are dangerous.
- 32:34The mythology around people experiencing homelessness
- 32:37is that they are dangerous.
- 32:38The reality is that unhoused people are more likely to be victims
- 32:42of violent crime than perpetrators.
- 32:43All right,
- 32:44so listen,
- 32:44I can,
- 32:45I can actually get on board some of what you're saying here.
- 32:47Now there's a couple issues here because one of,
- 32:49one of them is not just about violence.
- 32:51If you are going to create the conditions,
- 32:54the economic conditions or whatever you want to call it,
- 32:55that's going to allow for these people.
- 32:57To be out on the streets,
- 32:58would you want to walk a baby in a carriage down that block as these people are there?
- 33:02I don't think you would.
- 33:03I would because I don't,
- 33:05I,
- 33:05I,
- 33:05I have,
- 33:05I don't know the last time I've heard of an unhoused person attacking a baby,
- 33:10and these are,
- 33:10you know what,
- 33:10I,
- 33:11I would,
- 33:11I would say if you,
- 33:12no,
- 33:12it's not fear mongering.
- 33:13If you if you were a young mother and you were pushing a
- 33:15carriage and there were a bunch of people who clearly were on,
- 33:19well,
- 33:19now they have super meth or whatever it is,
- 33:21meth,
- 33:22but it,
- 33:22but it is real.
- 33:23It is a real thing.
- 33:24It is a real thing
- 33:25that are on any of these drugs,
- 33:26you would not want to push a carriage down that block,
- 33:28but it's not exactly just about violence.
- 33:30I told you I would actually feel comfortable with that.
- 33:32OK,
- 33:32so you would,
- 33:33you would most people,
- 33:34I,
- 33:34I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that most,
- 33:36most parents would not be comfortable with that,
- 33:38but it's not just about that.
- 33:40I would also say
- 33:41if you spend any time in,
- 33:42well,
- 33:43Hollywood's become a total disaster too,
- 33:44but if you,
- 33:45if you go down Melrose,
- 33:46you go down to these places that were once thriving.
- 33:49The store everywhere,
- 33:50the stores are closed.
- 33:52There are not,
- 33:52there are not shoppers,
- 33:54but it's because of the,
- 33:55it's because of the economic conditions.
- 33:57Exactly.
- 33:57That's a part of the economic conditions.
- 33:58So what we need is economic equity.
- 34:00No,
- 34:00no,
- 34:00no,
- 34:00no,
- 34:01no,
- 34:01no,
- 34:01no,
- 34:01no.
- 34:01But who's been running makers?
- 34:02But Democrats have been running this city forever.
- 34:05Democrats have been running the state of California forever
- 34:07Republicans who are running to represent the city wait,
- 34:09wait,
- 34:09including Spencer Pratt,
- 34:11is not coming in to build housing for all the
- 34:12issues that there is not enough housing in Los Angeles,
- 34:15but it's not about the number of people experiencing homelessness.
- 34:17Yes,
- 34:17it is because on.
- 34:18It's not a housing issue.
- 34:19It's not a housing issue.
- 34:20You could give drug addicts all the beds and homes that there are,
- 34:23and it will not work.
- 34:25It will not work.
- 34:26If you told me that what you were
- 34:27trying to do was figure out truly functional programs
- 34:30that would help these people get off drugs
- 34:32and they could actually work,
- 34:34like universal healthcare,
- 34:35I could get on some of that.
- 34:36No,
- 34:36but just saying universal healthcare,
- 34:37and we're going to give healthcare to everybody.
- 34:39Well,
- 34:39you haven't given me,
- 34:40you haven't given me a moment to speak and retort.
- 34:42So what I want to say is that
- 34:44on any given night in Los Angeles,
- 34:46in LA County,
- 34:46there are more than 72,000.
- 34:47People experiencing homelessness in LA City.
- 34:50There are more than 43 Democrats 43,000 people.
- 34:52Let me finish.
- 34:54There are more than 43,000 people experiencing homelessness,
- 34:56yet there are only about 16,000 interim housing shelter beds.
- 35:00Meanwhile,
- 35:01there are more than 250,000 vacant units.
- 35:03Here's the thing.
- 35:04Democrats,
- 35:04what I'm saying is your argument that Democrats have not funded,
- 35:07is your argument that Democrats have
- 35:09not funded homeless policies because they've,
- 35:11my argument is that Republicans are not going to fund it either.
- 35:14They're just going to criminalize our neighbors experiencing poverty,
- 35:16and we can.
- 35:17Not criminalize their neighbors experiencing homelessness
- 35:19just because they are poor,
- 35:21but you seem more angry at Republicans who've had nothing to do with this.
- 35:24Republicans have literally no influence in this city or in this state.
- 35:27So
- 35:27even if I could grant you some,
- 35:29but they have said what they want to do,
- 35:30which is,
- 35:31which is come in and criminalize people who are living poor in public,
- 35:34and that is not going to solve the problem.
- 35:36That is going to shuffle the problem
- 35:37down the street.
- 35:38It's going to create more incarceration.
- 35:39You're angry at the state of California.
- 35:41You seem angry at people that aren't in power and haven't
- 35:44been in power here in decades than the people who are.
- 35:46Actually in power.
- 35:47If you're,
- 35:47if you're angry,
- 35:48be angry about,
- 35:49but if you're angry at somebody,
- 35:50be angry at Gavin Newsom.
- 35:51Gavin Newsom,
- 35:52when he was mayor of San Francisco,
- 35:54had his,
- 35:55what,
- 35:5510 year plan to end homelessness in San Francisco.
- 35:58I am sure I don't have to tell you about the drug
- 36:00and homelessness problem in San Francisco
- 36:02actually have is permanent supportive housing.
- 36:04We do not have enough permanent housing wraparound services.
- 36:07OK,
- 36:07so we can't just criminalize people.
- 36:08So we have people jail.
- 36:09No,
- 36:09no,
- 36:09no,
- 36:10no.
- 36:10So we have a fundamental difference on what you can do for these people.
- 36:12I don't think that if you take a bunch of drug addicts and just give them beds.
- 36:16That that's going to solve anything.
- 36:17I think it's going to prolong it for the most part.
- 36:19OK,
- 36:20so we have a fundamental difference there.
- 36:21That,
- 36:21that's just fine.
- 36:22But what I would say is aim your anger that you would
- 36:24probably do drugs if you lived on the street as well.
- 36:26Aim your anger,
- 36:27aim your anger at the people who have been in charge.
- 36:31Your anger should not be at Spencer.
- 36:32My anger is at the duopoly,
- 36:33which is both Democrats and Republicans,
- 36:35but it's not a duopoly here.
- 36:37It's not a duopoly here.
- 36:39Here in Los Angeles,
- 36:39which is we got to pause.
- 36:40Karen.
- 36:41You've been voted out by the majority.
- 36:42Please return to your seat.
- 36:43Thanks,
- 36:43Dave.
- 36:44Yeah,
- 36:44thank you.
- 36:46Hi Eric,
- 36:47how are you?
- 36:47Good,
- 36:47how are you?
- 36:48Good,
- 36:48good.
- 36:48Uh,
- 36:49so I really want to ground this conversation more in what I
- 36:51believe is the greatest damage that's happening right now in America,
- 36:54which is the affordability problem,
- 36:55and I think that there's no one who has exacerbated that more.
- 36:59Than Donald Trump and mega Republicans,
- 37:01we can talk about cities specifically,
- 37:02but I'd like to just talk about the nation as a whole.
- 37:05If you look,
- 37:05I was previously an economics teacher for 12th grade,
- 37:08and if you look at the three primary indicators of how the economy is doing
- 37:12GDP,
- 37:12the labor,
- 37:13uh,
- 37:14market,
- 37:14and,
- 37:15uh,
- 37:15inflation,
- 37:16all three of those are indicating that the economy is going in a downhill direction.
- 37:20And that's also validated by
- 37:21a recent poll.
- 37:2273% of people in America are saying that the economy is in poor condition.
- 37:27Now if you look at the primary things that the Trump administration has done,
- 37:31taking away people's healthcare in one big beautiful bill,
- 37:34the war in Iran,
- 37:35which has raised gas prices,
- 37:36that's really the thing that is making
- 37:38everyone really feel like,
- 37:39oh,
- 37:39affordability,
- 37:40I need to choose between gas and groceries.
- 37:42This is the big,
- 37:43big problem that we're experiencing.
- 37:45So I don't think that going more in a Republican
- 37:47direction is necessarily going to be helpful for that,
- 37:49um,
- 37:49because we're seeing that
- 37:51Donald Trump ran on a platform of making the economy better.
- 37:54He appealed to people,
- 37:55the populace,
- 37:56of saying,
- 37:57listen,
- 37:58I understand the struggle.
- 37:59They pointed the finger at immigrants,
- 38:00at trans people,
- 38:01LGBTQ people,
- 38:02but then he made it worse.
- 38:03I don't think a lot of people were expecting that,
- 38:05oh,
- 38:06you know,
- 38:06the economy could actually go in a worse direction.
- 38:08So I just wanna say again,
- 38:10I,
- 38:10I think there's been a certain theme that I,
- 38:11I obviously.
- 38:12I disagree with a little bit of the premise there,
- 38:14but I can,
- 38:14I can basically get on board what you said there.
- 38:16Look,
- 38:16if you want to create the conditions for economic success,
- 38:19what I think you have to do is you have to lower taxes literally for everybody,
- 38:24and you have to eliminate as much regulation as possible,
- 38:26right?
- 38:27When we see a massive exodus right now,
- 38:29we'll use New York as an example.
- 38:31Since Mamdami has taken over,
- 38:33they have,
- 38:33they have lost trillions of dollars
- 38:36in tax revenue,
- 38:37right?
- 38:37So the guy wants to fund big government programs and.
- 38:39What he's saying is I want to tax these people more
- 38:42and then he is causing them to leave.
- 38:44That is what people are going to do in a free society,
- 38:46right?
- 38:46We have states' rights
- 38:47and in Florida say we have no state income tax,
- 38:50we have low regulation.
- 38:51We create the conditions
- 38:53for economic boom and that's what we're getting right now.
- 38:55It's not,
- 38:56it's not a coincidence
- 38:57that massive corporations,
- 39:00and if you look at nothing else,
- 39:01if you look at nothing else between blue and red right now,
- 39:04do you know how many people since COVID have moved to Florida?
- 39:07I want to touch on what you're talking about,
- 39:09because I don't know the answer to that,
- 39:10but I can't say,
- 39:11OK,
- 39:11I'm not trying to,
- 39:12I'm not trying,
- 39:12I'm not trying to get you.
- 39:13I'm not trying to get you.
- 39:14So 2.3 million people
- 39:16have moved to Florida since COVID,
- 39:18right?
- 39:18And it was largely because of COVID,
- 39:20and then there were economic opportunities.
- 39:21Now it's because there's a huge
- 39:23boom down there and there's lower taxes and DeSantis
- 39:25is trying to get rid of property taxes,
- 39:26etc.
- 39:27etc.
- 39:28You know how many people have left California
- 39:30since COVID?
- 39:31Well,
- 39:31I
- 39:32again,
- 39:32I'm not trying to get you billionaires who wouldn't leave California
- 39:34if there was a proposed billionaire tax in the percent,
- 39:36but the billionaires less than 5%.
- 39:38But the billionaires are the billionaires that the billionaires will leave.
- 39:42But the billionaires are,
- 39:43the billionaires are leaving.
- 39:44Peter Thiel left,
- 39:45uh,
- 39:45Elon Musk left.
- 39:46Um,
- 39:47we can like
- 39:48look at Ken Griffin.
- 39:49What does just in the just in the last pause.
- 39:51Well,
- 39:51if you want to pause there,
- 39:52you've been voted out by the media.
- 39:53Yeah,
- 39:53if you want their money,
- 39:54they're going to take it.
- 39:55All right,
- 39:55I sorry.
- 39:55Thanks.
- 39:56Hi,
- 39:56Kian,
- 39:56nice to meet you.
- 39:57Hi,
- 39:57good to meet you.
- 39:57Um,
- 39:58I want to talk on broken schools.
- 40:00You mentioned that you think,
- 40:02um,
- 40:02schools are teaching kids what to think,
- 40:04not how to think.
- 40:05I just finished my student teaching program today.
- 40:08I'm getting my teacher certificate like right now.
- 40:10Um,
- 40:11thank you.
- 40:12Everything we talk about in my program,
- 40:15every piece of what you guys would probably
- 40:17consider to be like woke critical race theory
- 40:20has been so beneficial for me in my
- 40:22student teaching and connecting with our students.
- 40:24Taking,
- 40:25yeah,
- 40:25give me an example.
- 40:25Yeah,
- 40:26taking students' backgrounds into account when I am planning my lessons,
- 40:30making it actually engaging for them
- 40:32is like the step one if you want to teach.
- 40:34Them anything because the students can you give me an act like an actual example?
- 40:37I'm,
- 40:37I'm for sure,
- 40:39um,
- 40:39like I have noticed a lot of my students are specifically concerned
- 40:42about like money and being able to make money in the future.
- 40:46So when we're reading Romeo and Juliet,
- 40:48we talk about,
- 40:50um,
- 40:50the class,
- 40:51the class,
- 40:52um,
- 40:52like dynamics at play in that play
- 40:55because that's something they're interested in.
- 40:57So when I talk about that,
- 40:58they can buy in and they can actually do that.
- 41:01This is something that the right would look at and say is.
- 41:04Like
- 41:05CRT,
- 41:06you're just like looking at them because
- 41:07they're from like poor economic backgrounds,
- 41:09so they're doing all this.
- 41:10Well,
- 41:10you haven't,
- 41:11you haven't,
- 41:11you,
- 41:11but you haven't mentioned anything related to race.
- 41:13I,
- 41:13I don't have,
- 41:13I don't have an inherent problem with what you just described right there.
- 41:16I don't see how that's CRT.
- 41:17We're not trying to teach people
- 41:19what to think.
- 41:20We're teaching them how to think
- 41:21and that,
- 41:22and the way to do that is by getting them engaged,
- 41:25and
- 41:25I think we see this in that all the top states are all blue states.
- 41:29All the top states for education are all blue states.
- 41:32Florida's,
- 41:32yeah.
- 41:33Florida is number 1 in higher education without question.
- 41:35I mean,
- 41:35you check the US,
- 41:36check US News World Report.
- 41:38Yeah,
- 41:38I'm pretty sure Florida's top 3.
- 41:40We'd,
- 41:41we'd have to check,
- 41:42check,
- 41:42check US News World Report.
- 41:43We,
- 41:43we can,
- 41:44we can fact check it,
- 41:45yeah,
- 41:45yeah,
- 41:45yeah,
- 41:46yeah,
- 41:46yeah.
- 41:46What I would say my basic situation when it comes to education
- 41:50is we should have school choice.
- 41:51We should have charter schools.
- 41:52We should have public schools.
- 41:53We should have private schools.
- 41:54You shouldn't necessarily,
- 41:56uh,
- 41:56be stuck in a failing school just because of your zip code.
- 42:00I'm glad you want to have as much choice as possible.
- 42:02Within the system and then it creates,
- 42:03it also creates uh competition.
- 42:05I also look,
- 42:06we have a huge,
- 42:06I'm sorry,
- 42:07I gotta cut you off.
- 42:07Private and charter schools are not more inclusive.
- 42:10Do you know what the average cost of,
- 42:11I didn't say,
- 42:12I didn't say anything about inclusive.
- 42:14You said you don't want people to get stuck.
- 42:15I don't want people.
- 42:16I want,
- 42:16I want there to be should be inclusive.
- 42:18Well,
- 42:18it depends what you mean by inclusive.
- 42:19So I think that everyone should have similar opportunities,
- 42:22and the way to do that is not with school choice.
- 42:24School choice.
- 42:24So you want,
- 42:25you want state-run,
- 42:27no competition.
- 42:27I think having public schools is the best way to get the most amount.
- 42:31Of people and if we make
- 42:32public education good
- 42:34and we actually,
- 42:35well,
- 42:35that's resources that's a hell of a I know,
- 42:37but that's well,
- 42:37who's in school choice is what guts that.
- 42:39But if,
- 42:39but if you want wait,
- 42:40school choice,
- 42:41yes,
- 42:42where do you think the funding goes with school choice?
- 42:44It comes from public education to go to private and charter schools.
- 42:48So I would have as many charter schools as possible,
- 42:50as many private schools as possible.
- 42:52I would encourage home.
- 42:52So you want to,
- 42:53I would encourage eliminate
- 42:55public schooling.
- 42:56I think actually you could over time.
- 42:57I think you could,
- 42:58but I'm not calling for that today.
- 43:00You.
- 43:00Can I tell you what I really want?
- 43:02Can I tell you what I really want?
- 43:03So might I,
- 43:03might I recommend those have always been state,
- 43:05but,
- 43:05but it has always been state run,
- 43:06and how do you think that's working out?
- 43:08I think it was working out really great until we started gutting our funding.
- 43:11If we look at class sizes right now,
- 43:13can I talk about class sizes?
- 43:14My teacher,
- 43:15um,
- 43:15my mentor teacher has class sizes of up to 40 students in her classes.
- 43:19So I would that is not sustainable.
- 43:21If we put more funding in,
- 43:22we can hire more teachers for those public schools to get class sizes down,
- 43:25which is the number one thing.
- 43:26So if we have lower class sizes,
- 43:28wait,
- 43:28let me finish this.
- 43:29You think if we just put.
- 43:29More money into these things.
- 43:30I think if we hire more teachers,
- 43:32if we hire more teachers,
- 43:34then we have lower class sizes.
- 43:35Teachers like myself can individualize our curriculum.
- 43:38We can take individual students
- 43:40into account in our lesson planning,
- 43:42which is something I do because I was lucky enough
- 43:44to have a small class size,
- 43:45but other classes don't have that,
- 43:47so it's not possible.
- 43:48You,
- 43:48you would be quite a good teacher,
- 43:49likely in a pod or at a charter school or at something where it would be more.
- 43:53I'd be a good teacher anywhere,
- 43:54I promise you.
- 43:55We got a pause there.
- 43:56We got a pause there.
- 43:57You've been voted out by the majority.
- 43:59Thank you.
- 44:01Nice to meet you.
- 44:02Hi,
- 44:02how are you?
- 44:03All right,
- 44:03good.
- 44:03What is one main metric that Donald Trump has made better off since he got in office?
- 44:07Like an example would be GDP,
- 44:08unemployment,
- 44:09inflation,
- 44:10etc.
- 44:10Well,
- 44:11right now,
- 44:11first off,
- 44:12the big,
- 44:12beautiful bill was just passed last year,
- 44:14and it's kicking in now,
- 44:15right?
- 44:16It's kicking in now.
- 44:17OK,
- 44:18so we are,
- 44:19see,
- 44:19we're going to now see results of that,
- 44:20like,
- 44:21even the tariffs.
- 44:22All right,
- 44:22so let's do tariffs.
- 44:23Are you for or against tariffs?
- 44:24I'm against the universal tariffs.
- 44:26So what's the main metric that he made better off?
- 44:28What?
- 44:28What's the main metric that he made better off?
- 44:30GDP,
- 44:30unemployment,
- 44:30inflation?
- 44:31Do you have any idea?
- 44:33Listen.
- 44:36Listen,
- 44:37I don't think you do.
- 44:38Do you think,
- 44:38hold on.
- 44:39So
- 44:39you're arguing that things economically were better under
- 44:42Joe Biden at the end of his administration.
- 44:44Absolutely.
- 44:44So can you give me an example of how?
- 44:46Yeah,
- 44:46GDP growth was better off,
- 44:47real median wage growth is better off.
- 44:49Inflation was better off at the end of his administration,
- 44:51unemployment was better off at the end of his administration.
- 44:53With the worst year of job growth in the past four years,
- 44:55just this last year under Trump's administration,
- 44:57the inflation 3.8% year over year since Trump got in office.
- 45:01We're seeing all of those economic indicators become worse off.
- 45:03Can you tell me anything that he's done to make it better off?
- 45:05You say it's broken for Democrats.
- 45:06It sounds like it's broken right now under Trump.
- 45:08Have you looked at the stock market?
- 45:10It's worse off in terms of growth in 2025 as compared to 2024.
- 45:13If you look at Dow Jones and,
- 45:14uh,
- 45:14S&P 500.
- 45:15They're both up quite a bit right now,
- 45:17but lower rate lower and doing quite well,
- 45:20you know.
- 45:20Things don't happen overnight.
- 45:21So Donald Trump,
- 45:22for example,
- 45:23things don't,
- 45:23that's true.
- 45:24That's true.
- 45:24There's a,
- 45:25there's reality.
- 45:26There's actual reality.
- 45:26Like you put policies into place and they don't just kick in the next day,
- 45:30right?
- 45:30Donald Trump,
- 45:31a year and a half,
- 45:31Donald Trump said,
- 45:32Donald Trump said when the tariff,
- 45:33he said in a year prices would be down 50% for electricity.
- 45:37Are they?
- 45:37Right now,
- 45:37hold on.
- 45:38Donald Trump,
- 45:38when,
- 45:39when he brought in the idea of tariffs,
- 45:41would you agree that for the last
- 45:434 decades we have had completely lopsided trade deals
- 45:46with all of these countries where they're tariffing
- 45:48and taxing our products that go to them,
- 45:50and they're getting sweet deals when they sell to the American public?
- 45:53Do you think that's a fair?
- 45:54Didn't Trump address that with the USMCA,
- 45:56but he went against that when he didn't extend it
- 45:58through the context of his new trade agreement because he
- 46:00wanted to place tariffs on all of them again,
- 46:02and his tariffs that he's placing on
- 46:03are destroying our relationships with countries.
- 46:04Around the world,
- 46:05it's,
- 46:07it's costing you say destroying,
- 46:07when you say destroying it's costing,
- 46:09it's costing consumers here in this country.
- 46:10A Federal Reserve report just came out
- 46:12indicated that we'd be below pre-pandemic levels
- 46:14of inflation if Donald Trump never imposed the tariffs in the first place,
- 46:16meaning we'd be able to bring down interest rates and we'll be
- 46:18able to increase investment within our economy and bring more jobs back.
- 46:21Hold on.
- 46:22When you say destroying our relationships with other countries,
- 46:25well,
- 46:25other countries were getting sweet deals,
- 46:27right?
- 46:28If
- 46:29Canada,
- 46:29which was charging crazy taxes and Tariffs on our products that were going to them,
- 46:34and we were basically charging nothing back.
- 46:35How can we sell to their market?
- 46:37So,
- 46:37if they're upset with us,
- 46:39right?
- 46:39So China is a little upset with right now.
- 46:41We're upset with us.
- 46:42We're trying to get fairer deals.
- 46:44Canada,
- 46:44obviously under Carney is upset with us because we're trying to get fairer deals.
- 46:48Donald Trump is trying to reset things.
- 46:50We were basically the world's piggy bank for the last,
- 46:53it's really
- 46:53basically post World War II,
- 46:55and Donald Trump is trying to reverse that so that we will have fairer deals.
- 46:59If you told me that it was just 0 across the board
- 47:02and there were no tariffs going any which way,
- 47:03I could completely get on board with that.
- 47:05But as long as countries are going to treat us unfairly,
- 47:08often while we foot the bill
- 47:09for their defense or a series of other things
- 47:11and we give them foreign aid and everything else,
- 47:13well then we
- 47:14should have equal
- 47:16playing field going both directions.
- 47:18What better deal did he get?
- 47:19What?
- 47:19What better deal did he get?
- 47:21What do you mean?
- 47:21Several countries have already come back and we've name any
- 47:23of the conditions that made the trade better off.
- 47:25Give me the specifics.
- 47:27Canada,
- 47:28I think they had something like a 60%
- 47:30tariff on cheese,
- 47:31literally on cheese
- 47:33that was being sold from America,
- 47:35from Wisconsin
- 47:36to Canada,
- 47:37and that basically is zero right now.
- 47:39That's one,
- 47:39that's one little example.
- 47:41I think it's zero right now,
- 47:42so that's a targeted tariff,
- 47:43not a universal tariff.
- 47:44Can you name one country that had a universal tariff on us?
- 47:47I think there are several countries that,
- 47:49I think there,
- 47:50I think there are several countries that did.
- 47:51Honestly,
- 47:52I'm not sure,
- 47:52but I think there are several countries that did that
- 47:54that zero,
- 47:55that that zeroed out the tariffs.
- 47:56I,
- 47:57I think Argentina did,
- 47:58if I'm not mistaken.
- 47:58I think Israel did.
- 47:59I think a few other countries did.
- 48:00Why don't we put a proportional tariff on them the same that
- 48:03they put on us so that we can negotiate that down?
- 48:05It doesn't seem like Trump's looking for that.
- 48:06What do you mean that
- 48:07that's what,
- 48:07what,
- 48:08that's exactly what Trump did.
- 48:09Let me just clarify,
- 48:09the tariffs are being paid by our consumers,
- 48:12so Trump.
- 48:12While trying to get his deals is making inflation go up
- 48:15and making it worse off for you at the grocery store,
- 48:17worse off for you at the gas pump,
- 48:18worse off for you when you're trying to buy a house.
- 48:21So can you,
- 48:21again,
- 48:21like you could mention before,
- 48:22can you name one metric that Trump's be better off
- 48:24since he got off the premise of what you're saying,
- 48:26because do you think we should just have
- 48:28free trade with everybody without any penalization like libertarian.
- 48:33Don't you want free trade?
- 48:33No,
- 48:34that's what I'm saying.
- 48:35So I,
- 48:35so I think you're agreeing with me what Donald Trump is.
- 48:37He hasn't overall decreased tariffs.
- 48:39He's tried.
- 48:39The Supreme Court did more to decrease tariffs than he did.
- 48:42It doesn't happen overnight.
- 48:43It doesn't happen overnight.
- 48:44They're negotiating these things.
- 48:45Have we done anything in his office yet?
- 48:47Yes,
- 48:47what?
- 48:48Yes,
- 48:48talk.
- 48:48Scott Besson every day is negotiating
- 48:51with these other countries.
- 48:53You,
- 48:53you think that I think the negotiations are worse off with the JCPOA.
- 48:55We have less political concessions right now than
- 48:57we had a decade ago under the JCPOA.
- 48:59So tell me,
- 48:59what political concessions have we got with the
- 49:00war with Iran since Trump started it?
- 49:03Well,
- 49:03right now Iran literally exports no oil.
- 49:06Every day they are losing $500 million.
- 49:08So what you can do over time
- 49:10is you have a military adventure which we had 40 days,
- 49:13which we took out their air force and their,
- 49:16uh,
- 49:16their entire navy and everything else.
- 49:19And now we completely control their economy.
- 49:21What's and the political concession since the beginning of the war.
- 49:23What's,
- 49:24what's the political concession from Iran since the beginning of the war,
- 49:27well,
- 49:28we're in the,
- 49:28we're having.
- 49:29Negotiations with them right now and we haven't gotten anything.
- 49:31We're having negotiations with them right now,
- 49:33so nothing.
- 49:34Well,
- 49:34we're in a negotiation.
- 49:35We've been in a war for 2.5 months now.
- 49:37We got no political concession for 2.5 months.
- 49:39How long do you think a decade ago we had,
- 49:41we had a limitation in terms of them enriching uranium to
- 49:433.7% that was going to be in place until 2030.
- 49:46It would still be in place to this day.
- 49:47We started the JCPOA.
- 49:49We started with this.
- 49:50They admitted they were,
- 49:51they were enriching past that point.
- 49:53Steve for the JCPOA,
- 49:54Steve Witkoff said.
- 49:55The day 2 or 3 days before the war
- 49:58started that they admitted they were enriching more.
- 50:00Also you pulled out of the agreement and you also
- 50:02have no strike that we made a year ago.
- 50:04You also had,
- 50:04they haven't been building up.
- 50:05You also have to go on the assumption DNI.
- 50:07Why is it that,
- 50:08why is it that,
- 50:09why is it that you believe,
- 50:10why would you believe
- 50:12the Iranian theocratic regime?
- 50:14Why would you believe that they are doing right?
- 50:16That's the Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard,
- 50:18appointed by Donald Trump.
- 50:19So explain to me why you don't believe her.
- 50:21Listen,
- 50:22Marco Rubio,
- 50:23Marco,
- 50:24Marco,
- 50:25Marco,
- 50:25hold on.
- 50:26Why don't you believe the entire US intelligence Committee?
- 50:28Why do you think they're all lying?
- 50:29So
- 50:29are you saying that Donald Trump just
- 50:31ignored the entire US intelligence committee?
- 50:33No,
- 50:34that's what he did.
- 50:34No,
- 50:34he didn't.
- 50:35That's it.
- 50:36That's OK.
- 50:36So that's an interesting disconnect that we have.
- 50:38I mean,
- 50:38Marco,
- 50:38why did they contradict each other?
- 50:39Marco Rubio very clearly laid out what was going on here.
- 50:42And by the way,
- 50:43Donald,
- 50:43Donald Trump and Trump.
- 50:45Donald Trump and every president for the last 40 years
- 50:47has said that Iran will not get a nuclear bomb,
- 50:49right?
- 50:49Every president has said that.
- 50:51Joe Biden said no.
- 50:52Remember,
- 50:53Kamala Harris said no or don't,
- 50:55right?
- 50:55did it to a greater extent.
- 50:56Why didn't you address that point again?
- 50:58Again,
- 50:59you are going on the assumption that you can trust
- 51:01these random inspectors that are going into these places,
- 51:04literally,
- 51:05yeah,
- 51:06random inspectors.
- 51:07The IAEA is the International.
- 51:08Atomic energy with,
- 51:09with all due respect,
- 51:10I think that,
- 51:11I think that trusting some of these international things that they
- 51:13somehow have America's interests or the West's interests in mind,
- 51:16I think is a kind of faulty,
- 51:18uh,
- 51:18it's just a faulty premise,
- 51:19I would say the international actors that are lying,
- 51:22they don't actually do you have legitimate
- 51:23surveillance over their nuclear enrichment facilities?
- 51:25No,
- 51:25they don't.
- 51:26OK,
- 51:26they don't.
- 51:27They have,
- 51:27what do you mean they were buried,
- 51:28they were buried under,
- 51:29they were buried under mountains.
- 51:30They were buried underground.
- 51:34My next surrounded claim is that progressives
- 51:36push normal moderate Americans to the right.
- 51:39I'd like to debate this claim.
- 51:40Please get to the chair in 321.
- 51:48Hey,
- 51:48how are you?
- 51:50Nice to meet you.
- 51:51Good to meet you.
- 51:52So my
- 51:53argument here is that what progressives are doing are is opening up
- 51:57opportunities for people to reevaluate the way that they see politics,
- 52:00right?
- 52:01Progressives are arguing
- 52:02that more pocket power should be delivered
- 52:04to the average American.
- 52:06That is like one of the most,
- 52:07the foundational tenets of progressivism.
- 52:09I'm confused can you say what that what is more pocket power mean?
- 52:12OK,
- 52:12right,
- 52:12so
- 52:13this is the idea,
- 52:13right,
- 52:14that
- 52:14under our current system.
- 52:16We see that the majority of power as well as just like monetary control
- 52:21exists within people who own private property
- 52:23and to essentially
- 52:24uh
- 52:25decrease that gap,
- 52:26progressives want to give more power to those who are in the workplace.
- 52:30Do,
- 52:30do you not want people to own
- 52:31private property?
- 52:32Well,
- 52:33I'm definitely anti-capitalist,
- 52:34I would say so I would say that workers should own the means of production,
- 52:37right?
- 52:37Oh,
- 52:37so you're a communist.
- 52:38Yeah.
- 52:39Oh,
- 52:40interesting.
- 52:40Yeah,
- 52:40wow.
- 52:41I don't know what is communism?
- 52:42I haven't talked.
- 52:42To a real life communist in communist?
- 52:44Well,
- 52:44you want the you want the people to own the means of
- 52:48production and you don't seem to believe in the private property.
- 52:50The people who create value as in create the value of commodities should own
- 52:54the,
- 52:54the actual value that they create from that process.
- 52:57Yes.
- 52:58So my answer,
- 52:59if you want the people,
- 53:01everyone in this room
- 53:02and everyone in this country to have more,
- 53:04what I would want is that you would
- 53:07take less from them,
- 53:08so you tax.
- 53:09Everybody less
- 53:10you remove regulation.
- 53:12You create the conditions
- 53:13for competition and capitalism
- 53:16so that more people will have more of their money.
- 53:19I want you,
- 53:19I assume you work.
- 53:20Do you work?
- 53:21Do you pay taxes?
- 53:23I want you to keep more of your money.
- 53:24I don't know what you do.
- 53:25I don't know how much you earn.
- 53:26I,
- 53:27whatever it is you earn,
- 53:28I want you to have more of that money so
- 53:29that you can put that money back into the system.
- 53:31The majority of wealth in the system is,
- 53:33is owned by 1% of the population.
- 53:35And you understand that,
- 53:35right?
- 53:36And where does that wealth come from?
- 53:37Wait,
- 53:371% of the population.
- 53:38Do you know how much percent they pay in taxes?
- 53:40That 1%?
- 53:41Not nearly enough because the majority of their,
- 53:43because the majority of their wealth comes from,
- 53:44it's 47%.
- 53:46Hold on,
- 53:46hold on.
- 53:47So 1% of the population pay 47%.
- 53:50Do you accept that?
- 53:51Yeah.
- 53:51So what would be their fair share percent of that,
- 53:54what would be their fair share their actual wealth that they own that again,
- 53:57majority of these lineages of power and ownership,
- 54:00what would be their fair share.
- 54:01What would be their accumulation of what,
- 54:04what would be their fair share?
- 54:05I would say that
- 54:06the fact that they own
- 54:08so much%,
- 54:08you're not letting me 47% in taxes.
- 54:11Here's my problem.
- 54:12You're not letting me finish the point,
- 54:13so we can't get from point A to B.
- 54:14Do you understand that?
- 54:15OK,
- 54:15cool.
- 54:16If you accept that 1% there's not gonna be a fair share
- 54:18when their wealth is coming from the back ends of colonialism,
- 54:22so that's not gonna work.
- 54:23OK,
- 54:23we're gonna,
- 54:23we gotta pause there.
- 54:24We're gonna reset.
- 54:25Please return to your seat.
- 54:26You've been voted out.
- 54:29He's back.
- 54:29All right,
- 54:30good to see you again,
- 54:31Dave.
- 54:31Nice to see you.
- 54:32It's interesting to point to like 5 anecdotal examples as like
- 54:35an overall consensus on where the American people are moving.
- 54:38Well,
- 54:38I think they they qualify more as anecdote,
- 54:40more than anecdotal in that Tulsi Gabbard was a Democrat member of Congress.
- 54:44Bobby Kennedy is a Kennedy,
- 54:45which is a standard bearer for a Democrat.
- 54:48Do you think Bobby Kennedy is also in alignment with most of his family?
- 54:51Would you say that they would concur that he's a representative of the Kennedy?
- 54:54I don't know.
- 54:54I don't know about most.
- 54:55I know some don't like.
- 54:56Most,
- 54:56most don't like it,
- 54:57especially those that are the most vocal and still participate in politics.
- 54:59He's the we can move from that of talking about people like Joe Rogan,
- 55:03Bill Maher.
- 55:03These are people that thrive off of clicks and popularity.
- 55:06What's more clickbaity than I left the left?
- 55:08So many people get that,
- 55:10not just because they're getting a whole new audience in order to capitulate to,
- 55:14but there's also like,
- 55:15you think there's also like a lot of like,
- 55:16hold on,
- 55:16there's a lot of like oligarchic money too that
- 55:19like that's can incentivize people to change their worldview,
- 55:22like Russian money.
- 55:23Hold on,
- 55:23hold on.
- 55:23That's like for people like Tim Poole or like was the Ruben report,
- 55:27did that also accept
- 55:28Russian money
- 55:29from Tenne?
- 55:30All right,
- 55:30we could,
- 55:30I'm more than happy to talk about that.
- 55:32But just very quickly to impugn Joe's motives that at the day before the election,
- 55:36he suddenly said,
- 55:36I'm going to vote for,
- 55:38uh,
- 55:38Donald Trump for financial or click motives when
- 55:40he's the largest podcaster in the world.
- 55:42That's what you just said.
- 55:42I'm not saying it's just that is,
- 55:43that is saying no,
- 55:44but that was indicative of people who rely on clicks.
- 55:46That is quite we can walk over Joe Rogan specifically.
- 55:48I think his brain broke during COVID.
- 55:50I'm gonna be honest,
- 55:51because he went from somebody who went from like a huge Bernie Sanders supporter,
- 55:54so pro single payer healthcare,
- 55:55ensuring that we're more diplomatic in our international.
- 55:57Do you think it's possibly he just evolved?
- 55:59Do you think it's possibly he just evolved to different points?
- 56:01All of those days?
- 56:02Do you think his brain broke?
- 56:03It's not possible that he just started thinking about things.
- 56:05All of those are political foundations,
- 56:07believing that the United States should not continue interventionalism,
- 56:10believing that universal healthcare should be a right to people.
- 56:13These are political foundations.
- 56:14You don't just switch your political foundations like that.
- 56:17Hold on.
- 56:18You find that people are bullying you or you're saying that that's too mean.
- 56:21It's not as I've a lot.
- 56:22It's not a right to someone else's labor.
- 56:24You have a right to,
- 56:25we can have a universal healthcare debate if you want,
- 56:27but I'm talking the overall why America shifted to the right.
- 56:30But I have to talk about the last person who debated.
- 56:32Most people feel like they can't get a leg up in this economy.
- 56:35And when you have a Democratic Party,
- 56:37this is where I'm pretty critical of Joe Biden.
- 56:38You're gonna love this.
- 56:39You ready?
- 56:40I think that the Biden administration and then the following Kamala Harris,
- 56:44uh.
- 56:44Presidential campaign,
- 56:46I don't think that they focus enough on
- 56:48what specifically needs to change in order for the average
- 56:50American to feel like their economic conditions are getting better.
- 56:53And while we can follow the metrics economically and inflation was going down,
- 56:56unemployment was lower,
- 56:58um,
- 56:58most people didn't feel that.
- 56:59And when you feel like your rent is burdening you,
- 57:0234% of Americans feel rent burdened,
- 57:03which is huge.
- 57:04When you feel like the grocery prices are continuing to go higher,
- 57:07you're gonna try to find an alternative.
- 57:08And when Donald Trump is saying,
- 57:10look,
- 57:10I'm gonna fix all of the problems.
- 57:12I'm gonna make sure everything's OK.
- 57:13Some people are like,
- 57:14Yeah,
- 57:15I wanna go ahead and go.
- 57:15Well,
- 57:15that's what politics is,
- 57:16right?
- 57:17Like it's a secular for you,
- 57:18but we're not saying that ideologically Americans are more right wing.
- 57:21Why do progressive ballot propositions pass even in red states Nebraska,
- 57:25Ohio?
- 57:25We could go over minimum wage increases.
- 57:27Yeah,
- 57:27I got you.
- 57:28I got you.
- 57:28You did a lot there.
- 57:29OK,
- 57:29let's answer something.
- 57:30So,
- 57:30OK,
- 57:30I'm trying.
- 57:31I'm trying.
- 57:31So first off,
- 57:33um,
- 57:34you wanna talk about the tenant thing?
- 57:35What do you want to talk about?
- 57:36Where,
- 57:36where do you want to go?
- 57:36I'll even give it to you.
- 57:37I'll give it to you.
- 57:38Where do you,
- 57:38where?
- 57:39You want to go?
- 57:39Yeah,
- 57:39yeah,
- 57:39why did you take Russian money,
- 57:41and so like you didn't know.
- 57:42I was,
- 57:42OK,
- 57:43so I was,
- 57:44uh,
- 57:45reached out to by Lauren Chen,
- 57:46who you might know as millennial,
- 57:47what's her name,
- 57:48post-millennial online or something roaming roaming,
- 57:51roaming millennial,
- 57:53and I've known her for about 10 years,
- 57:55and we were friendly over the years and we had
- 57:57agreements and disagreements and we were on each other's shows,
- 57:59and she contacted me a couple of years ago and said that she had
- 58:02some backers that she was talking to and she was
- 58:04starting a new network and they were talking to.
- 58:06All sorts of people.
- 58:07She mentioned
- 58:07Tim Poole.
- 58:08She mentioned a whole bunch of creators that you guys know and I'm sure
- 58:11love,
- 58:11but it was a,
- 58:12it was
- 58:13people all over the political aisle.
- 58:14She said they wanted to create a free speech network.
- 58:17I said to her,
- 58:17listen,
- 58:18I am extremely,
- 58:19extremely busy,
- 58:20but I would consider doing something for you as long as I 100% control it.
- 58:25You have no control over the content
- 58:27whatsoever.
- 58:29I'm going to ask for a ridiculous amount of money because I don't have time.
- 58:33And
- 58:35we'll see if we come up to come to your defense,
- 58:36I'm not gonna attribute you.
- 58:37Like,
- 58:38let's say you didn't know that,
- 58:39and I'm not trying to say that you were able to know that it was Russian money,
- 58:42but what I do think is interesting is that this anti-woke movement
- 58:45that just says woke a lot and calls it an ideology,
- 58:47it is so easy to be ideologically aligned that Russian propagandists are like,
- 58:50yes,
- 58:51these are our people.
- 58:52This is how we're gonna get the American people on board.
- 58:54That's more of like the issue.
- 58:55It's not really your fault.
- 58:56It's more so that like your whole ideology is like wokeness is bad.
- 58:59What,
- 59:00what,
- 59:01what show did I?
- 59:01Do for Russia.
- 59:03What?
- 59:03What show did I do for Russia?
- 59:04I'm not saying you did a show for Russia.
- 59:06I'm saying Russia saw you as a stooge who
- 59:08could easily say the talking points that benefited them.
- 59:10But do you understand?
- 59:11they gave me no talking points.
- 59:13I did a show.
- 59:14It was a call-in show.
- 59:15But here's,
- 59:16here's what we're missing,
- 59:17Dave,
- 59:17right?
- 59:18I'm not saying Russia gave you a script to say.
- 59:20I'm saying Russia's like,
- 59:21yes,
- 59:21this is our guy.
- 59:22If we fund him more and we get them more influence,
- 59:24he's gonna do it for us without even getting a script.
- 59:27Isn't that embarrassing?
- 59:29You did it.
- 59:29Without even getting instruction from them,
- 59:31it's a quite literal fantastical,
- 59:33uh,
- 59:34adventure that you just went on there,
- 59:36literally.
- 59:37What's the adventure?
- 59:37Literally I did a call-in show.
- 59:39Why would Russia choose?
- 59:40You don't even know.
- 59:41Do you,
- 59:41why would Russia choose you in?
- 59:42Hold on,
- 59:43you don't even know what I did.
- 59:44You don't even know what the tenant show that I did,
- 59:46do you?
- 59:46Did you ever watch it?
- 59:47Do you know the name of it?
- 59:47Do you know anything that I did?
- 59:49So you don't,
- 59:49so you quite literally have no idea what you're talking about.
- 59:51They just gave you money because they're altruistic.
- 59:53No,
- 59:54buddy,
- 59:54they're just like,
- 59:55we're thinking of giving it to,
- 59:56to Dave.
- 59:56No,
- 59:57because.
- 59:57No,
- 59:57well,
- 59:58first off,
- 59:58so just to be clear,
- 59:59you have literally no idea what you're talking about.
- 1:00:01You don't know the name of the show.
- 1:00:02You don't know the name of the show that I did.
- 1:00:03You don't know the name of the show that I did for them or
- 1:00:05what I need to know the specifics on a podcaster who takes Russian money.
- 1:00:09Oh my God,
- 1:00:09no,
- 1:00:11man.
- 1:00:11But Dave,
- 1:00:12Dave is trying to respond to you.
- 1:00:14Like,
- 1:00:14let's,
- 1:00:14let's hear his side of the story.
- 1:00:15He's,
- 1:00:16do you know not knowing anything.
- 1:00:17I know he took Russian money.
- 1:00:18Yeah,
- 1:00:18but you're,
- 1:00:19but he's also,
- 1:00:20we also like haven't heard his entire,
- 1:00:22I literally did a call-in show at first,
- 1:00:25so my.
- 1:00:25The audience just called me and asked questions,
- 1:00:27talked about sometimes we talked about basketball,
- 1:00:29we talked about video games.
- 1:00:30It had literally nothing to do with foreign policy.
- 1:00:32I don't think we did one show on Russia or anything else.
- 1:00:34And then we shifted the show.
- 1:00:36That was kind of boring to me,
- 1:00:37so I was like,
- 1:00:38my team,
- 1:00:395 minutes before we go live will pick viral videos,
- 1:00:42you know,
- 1:00:42woman throws hamburger at somebody at Wendy's and I'll respond to it.
- 1:00:46That's what we did.
- 1:00:46And then guess what happened after about 6 months
- 1:00:49of that because I controlled the entire thing.
- 1:00:51I didn't even know what the clips were before I was doing them.
- 1:00:54The deal was off.
- 1:00:55They didn't want to do it anymore because I did not do anything.
- 1:00:58Yeah.
- 1:00:58And also notice I'm not under federal indictment.
- 1:01:00I'm not sitting here with a lawyer or anything else.
- 1:01:02And as a matter of fact,
- 1:01:03Merrick Garland,
- 1:01:04who I'm no friend of,
- 1:01:06basically said that the influencers had nothing to do with this.
- 1:01:09And,
- 1:01:09and if you read the,
- 1:01:10yes,
- 1:01:11just a second.
- 1:01:11And if you read the indictment,
- 1:01:12I'm the one
- 1:01:13that got on the Zoom call with
- 1:01:16the backer to ask more questions about it and everything else.
- 1:01:19Yeah,
- 1:01:20Dave.
- 1:01:20Again,
- 1:01:21I'm not saying you were saying Russia is such a great country,
- 1:01:23everyone should love Vladimir Putin,
- 1:01:25and I get that your show might not even been political in nature.
- 1:01:28I know,
- 1:01:28but the fact,
- 1:01:29just to be clear,
- 1:01:29you didn't know the show,
- 1:01:30you didn't know the show or what I do.
- 1:01:32Yeah,
- 1:01:32yeah,
- 1:01:33I want,
- 1:01:33yeah,
- 1:01:34but the fact that they are building the social capital
- 1:01:37of the Rubin Report being larger in infrastructure is because,
- 1:01:41no,
- 1:01:41but you as an entity,
- 1:01:43Dave,
- 1:01:43they want to legitimize you more in the eyes
- 1:01:45of the viewers that they are trying to capture.
- 1:01:47That is the.
- 1:01:47Point of why Russia paid you specifically,
- 1:01:49they don't do it out of the kindness of their hearts.
- 1:01:51They didn't do it because they're like,
- 1:01:52Dave seems like a good guy.
- 1:01:53They did it because Dave's politics is advocating for
- 1:01:56cheerleading for Donald Trump policies regardless of any criticism.
- 1:02:00That is the point.
- 1:02:00Where is the case?
- 1:02:01What do you mean?
- 1:02:02Where's the case?
- 1:02:02Where's the case?
- 1:02:03Where's the case right now?
- 1:02:04Why am I even able to talk about it?
- 1:02:05Why don't I have a lawyer sitting here?
- 1:02:06Where,
- 1:02:06where is the?
- 1:02:07I'm not saying what you did was illegal in nature of the I'm just saying that.
- 1:02:09Well,
- 1:02:09hold on,
- 1:02:10there was a federal indictment.
- 1:02:11Wouldn't I be a little afraid to be talking about it right now?
- 1:02:14I'm not.
- 1:02:14Dave,
- 1:02:15I'm not claiming.
- 1:02:16I,
- 1:02:16I started this conversation.
- 1:02:18I started this conversation saying you might not
- 1:02:20even have known about the Russian money.
- 1:02:22I'm not trying to cast that blame on you.
- 1:02:23I'm just saying it's interesting that your show
- 1:02:25is so ideologically aligned with what Russia wants
- 1:02:28for the United States that they're going to give you money to continue to do it.
- 1:02:31That is the point.
- 1:02:32What is it that I do for,
- 1:02:33for Russia?
- 1:02:34Suck Donald Trump's dick without criticizing any bad thing that he does.
- 1:02:38All right,
- 1:02:38yeah,
- 1:02:38we,
- 1:02:38we gotta pause.
- 1:02:39May.
- 1:02:39You gotta go.
- 1:02:45I actually will agree with you that establishment
- 1:02:47Democrats have done a really terrible job of ensuring
- 1:02:51that their policies reflect what the people actually want.
- 1:02:53Most people want universal healthcare.
- 1:02:56Most people want free higher education so that they
- 1:02:59can actually get a job and move up.
- 1:03:02Most people will say that they would love for the rich to
- 1:03:05be taxed at the same rate that they used to be,
- 1:03:07closer towards the 90%,
- 1:03:11rather than taxing rather than.
- 1:03:11And taxing the rest of the population that can barely pay their rent.
- 1:03:16And then they're watching shows like yours,
- 1:03:19and they're hearing ideology more so than factual evidence,
- 1:03:23and they're saying,
- 1:03:23you know what,
- 1:03:24yeah,
- 1:03:24the Democrats,
- 1:03:25establishment Democrats haven't been doing much
- 1:03:27that they said that they were gonna do,
- 1:03:29so let me listen to this guy
- 1:03:32and
- 1:03:33everything you give is emotion and ideology,
- 1:03:35so yeah,
- 1:03:36sometimes people who don't have nearly as much.
- 1:03:39Thinking as they probably should
- 1:03:41are going to move to the right,
- 1:03:43but honestly,
- 1:03:44the base that's actually growing are the progressive base.
- 1:03:47Young voters are becoming much and much more progressive than they ever were.
- 1:03:53Why?
- 1:03:53Because again,
- 1:03:54most people,
- 1:03:55well,
- 1:03:55I agree,
- 1:03:55I agree with that,
- 1:03:56that a lot of,
- 1:03:57a lot of young people are very confused about what America is and what freedom is.
- 1:04:01Yeah,
- 1:04:01they are.
- 1:04:02So,
- 1:04:02so you want,
- 1:04:03so I mean we could just do a few of what you just said.
- 1:04:05So what,
- 1:04:05how much.
- 1:04:06money would you like to take
- 1:04:08from anyone,
- 1:04:09from anyone to get whatever policy you want?
- 1:04:11What is the number?
- 1:04:12How much money should anyone have
- 1:04:15that you want to take to get whatever it is that you want done
- 1:04:19done?
- 1:04:19Please give me a number.
- 1:04:19It's interesting that you're using the rhetoric of
- 1:04:21taking when we're literally talking about a state,
- 1:04:24a society that functions solely through making sure
- 1:04:28that most people have their basic needs met.
- 1:04:31So
- 1:04:32unfortunately establishment.
- 1:04:34Democrats have moved so towards the corporatist side that
- 1:04:36they have forgotten what the people actually want.
- 1:04:39So how much that's where how Elon Musk.
- 1:04:41All right,
- 1:04:42so let's use Elon rhetoric around I'm gonna take as
- 1:04:45much money as I can from the it is not,
- 1:04:47it's not,
- 1:04:47no,
- 1:04:48it is,
- 1:04:48of course it is.
- 1:04:49What do you mean if you don't give,
- 1:04:50if,
- 1:04:50if they say we're going to take it and it,
- 1:04:52and you don't give it,
- 1:04:53they're going to put you in jail,
- 1:04:54right?
- 1:04:55So it is taking if,
- 1:04:56if it is so benevolent,
- 1:04:58if you don't pay your taxes,
- 1:04:58you're going to jail if you,
- 1:05:00if it is so.
- 1:05:01Benevolent to do these things,
- 1:05:03then why don't more people do it?
- 1:05:05No,
- 1:05:05it's just part of being a person living in a country.
- 1:05:08Every country has taxes.
- 1:05:09So,
- 1:05:09so how much of Elon Musk's money would you like to take from him to do what?
- 1:05:13I would actually like for billionaires and the rich in general to
- 1:05:17pay the same amount that they were paying back in the 1950s.
- 1:05:21OK,
- 1:05:21so that's a rather radical position if you want in the 1950s,
- 1:05:26mostly it was Republicans that were you want.
- 1:05:28Give that money to the system and the government,
- 1:05:31which you don't seem to like very much,
- 1:05:32right?
- 1:05:32You're talking about corporate Democrats and,
- 1:05:34and you don't like the Republicans,
- 1:05:36but your solution seems to be,
- 1:05:37I will take more money
- 1:05:39and put it into the system to do what I want.
- 1:05:41What I would prefer to do is that what I would prefer to do is that you,
- 1:05:46you have a job,
- 1:05:48yeah,
- 1:05:48OK,
- 1:05:48so I would like you to keep more of your money.
- 1:05:50I want everyone again in this room to keep more of their money.
- 1:05:53You know what happens when rich people have more.
- 1:05:55Their money they hire more people they invest in more things
- 1:05:59so untrue it is crazy and that's what I'm saying.
- 1:06:02People like you will spit out this rhetoric and people who are
- 1:06:06living paycheck to paycheck and don't have nearly as much critical thinking.
- 1:06:09I gotta pause there.
- 1:06:10We're out of time.
- 1:06:11We're out of time.
- 1:06:12Yeah.
- 1:06:12My final surrounding claim is that the modern
- 1:06:14left cares more about ideology than reality.
- 1:06:17All right,
- 1:06:18if you would like to debate this prompt,
- 1:06:20get to the chair in 321.
- 1:06:25How's it going,
- 1:06:26Dave?
- 1:06:26All right,
- 1:06:27all right,
- 1:06:27all right,
- 1:06:28um,
- 1:06:29let's talk about reality.
- 1:06:30OK.
- 1:06:31Let's talk about three things that exist in reality climate change.
- 1:06:35Donald Trump lost the 2020 election,
- 1:06:37and vaccines out of COVID are effective and safe.
- 1:06:41Um,
- 1:06:41the right does not accept any of those things.
- 1:06:44Does Donald Trump accept the 2020 election results,
- 1:06:47and do Republicans broadly accept the 2020 election results still to this day?
- 1:06:50I think there's a lot of questions about.
- 1:06:52The 2020 election.
- 1:06:53Do they,
- 1:06:53do they,
- 1:06:54but does Donald Trump accept it?
- 1:06:55Does Donald Trump,
- 1:06:56I think he thinks something went,
- 1:06:58something went awry.
- 1:06:58So he does not accept it now.
- 1:07:00Did Donald Trump lose the 2020 election?
- 1:07:02I don't know.
- 1:07:03Well,
- 1:07:03well,
- 1:07:03no,
- 1:07:03no,
- 1:07:03I know.
- 1:07:04No,
- 1:07:04yeah,
- 1:07:05that's the truth.
- 1:07:05I know that.
- 1:07:05I know that he was not the president by the end of that,
- 1:07:08but I do know that in all the chaos of COVID and mail-in ballots and everything else,
- 1:07:12that somehow magically Joe Biden got something like
- 1:07:1420 million more votes than Barack Obama.
- 1:07:16That's a little bit
- 1:07:17curious.
- 1:07:18So all.
- 1:07:19And I was incredibly hot that election because voting was made easier.
- 1:07:22Oh,
- 1:07:22because voting was,
- 1:07:23well,
- 1:07:23you might think it has something to do if you are doing mail-in ballots.
- 1:07:26There might be a little more access to fraudulent,
- 1:07:28uh,
- 1:07:29abilities.
- 1:07:29You might think that,
- 1:07:30but you have to actually provide evidence to demonstrate.
- 1:07:33So I'm just skeptical.
- 1:07:34I'm just skeptical of it.
- 1:07:35I don't know.
- 1:07:36I don't know.
- 1:07:37I'm skeptical of it.
- 1:07:38OK,
- 1:07:38so yeah,
- 1:07:38just,
- 1:07:39I would,
- 1:07:39I would,
- 1:07:40uh,
- 1:07:40venture to say that a little skepticism is probably a good thing.
- 1:07:43Also,
- 1:07:43the COVID vaccines didn't work.
- 1:07:45I mean,
- 1:07:45that's,
- 1:07:45that's.
- 1:07:45Fact that is not that is a fact.
- 1:07:47That is,
- 1:07:47uh,
- 1:07:47if you got a COVID vaccine,
- 1:07:49could you get COVID?
- 1:07:51if you got a COVID,
- 1:07:52yes,
- 1:07:52yeah.
- 1:07:52Oh,
- 1:07:52you could transmit the claim would you transmit it?
- 1:07:55Joe the claim was never that transmission was at 0%.
- 1:07:58Joe Biden,
- 1:07:59Joe Biden,
- 1:08:00Joe Biden,
- 1:08:00hold on,
- 1:08:01hold on,
- 1:08:01hold on.
- 1:08:01Joe Biden.
- 1:08:02If you get the COVID vaccine,
- 1:08:04you will not get nor transmit COVID.
- 1:08:06That is what Joe Biden said,
- 1:08:07but that's not the claim Fauci said that that's not,
- 1:08:09that's not what the right claims about the COVID vaccine,
- 1:08:11like similar.
- 1:08:12Yourself,
- 1:08:12you said
- 1:08:13you,
- 1:08:13yes,
- 1:08:14we're talking about whether or not the right or the left accepts reality,
- 1:08:17correct?
- 1:08:17So the right claims that the,
- 1:08:19that the COVID vaccine is unsafe and ineffective.
- 1:08:21That's not true.
- 1:08:22It is true.
- 1:08:23No,
- 1:08:23the,
- 1:08:23the,
- 1:08:23that is true.
- 1:08:24Of the people who died from COVID,
- 1:08:26are the vast majority of them unvaccinated or vaccinated?
- 1:08:29Hold on,
- 1:08:29hold on.
- 1:08:29Do you know unvaccinated?
- 1:08:30I know,
- 1:08:31I know a young guy who's in his early twenties who never had any health.
- 1:08:34Wait,
- 1:08:34wait,
- 1:08:35wait,
- 1:08:35wait,
- 1:08:35he who had never had any health problems,
- 1:08:37young,
- 1:08:37healthy guy in his early twenties who.
- 1:08:39to get the COVID vaccine to go to college,
- 1:08:41and he now has myocarditis.
- 1:08:42Does that,
- 1:08:43does that interest you at all?
- 1:08:44Does that interest you?
- 1:08:45He had no reason to.
- 1:08:46He had no reason to get a vaccine that,
- 1:08:48that would stop him.
- 1:08:49It did not stop him from getting COVID,
- 1:08:51and he could still transmit COVID.
- 1:08:52We don't use anecdotes in science.
- 1:08:54This is a,
- 1:08:54let's,
- 1:08:54let's pull it back to reality,
- 1:08:56right?
- 1:08:56This is why science is so important.
- 1:08:57This is why you're not actually like science,
- 1:08:59we understand that anecdotes aren't a good
- 1:09:01tool to use when assessing scientific research.
- 1:09:04So you think the government.
- 1:09:06The government should have been allowed to force people to get a vaccine.
- 1:09:09That was you're rushing that was rushed through by
- 1:09:13Operation Warp Warp Speed,
- 1:09:13which was Donald Trump,
- 1:09:14a guy you don't seem to like very much,
- 1:09:16right?
- 1:09:16I,
- 1:09:17yeah,
- 1:09:17sure,
- 1:09:17but we're,
- 1:09:17we're pivoting.
- 1:09:19Yeah,
- 1:09:19yeah,
- 1:09:19we're sure.
- 1:09:20I,
- 1:09:20I'm OK with Operation Warp Speed.
- 1:09:21I can,
- 1:09:22I can.
- 1:09:22So you,
- 1:09:22the guy that you seem to be quite deranged
- 1:09:24about Donald Trump pushes through a vaccine very fast,
- 1:09:27and you're right,
- 1:09:28because I want to ensure that people are healthy.
- 1:09:30But I,
- 1:09:30but even though,
- 1:09:31even though the vaccine,
- 1:09:32the vaccine,
- 1:09:32what I don't like is the fact that.
- 1:09:34Republicans and
- 1:09:36especially like right-wing influencers downplayed the efficacy of vaccines
- 1:09:40and claimed that they were unsafe or ineffective,
- 1:09:42but they were unaffective.
- 1:09:43No,
- 1:09:44they weren't.
- 1:09:45So if it reduces,
- 1:09:46if,
- 1:09:46if it young healthy people had no reason if it reduces the rate of transmission,
- 1:09:51that,
- 1:09:52that is,
- 1:09:52that is literally what a vaccine is intended.
- 1:09:54We were sold,
- 1:09:55we were sold.
- 1:09:56The bill of goods that they sold us was that you would not get nor transmit COVID.
- 1:10:01That is the president of the United States.
- 1:10:03Words as he was forcing people to get that vaccine,
- 1:10:06if he said that,
- 1:10:06then I would agree that his assessment of it was,
- 1:10:09was,
- 1:10:09well,
- 1:10:09he's the president of the United States.
- 1:10:11Oh,
- 1:10:11you should have,
- 1:10:12you should,
- 1:10:12you should,
- 1:10:12do you think,
- 1:10:13wait,
- 1:10:13hold on,
- 1:10:13wait,
- 1:10:13wait,
- 1:10:14are you speaking of presidents,
- 1:10:15speaking of presidents of the United States,
- 1:10:16how about,
- 1:10:17how about Donald Trump in suggesting that
- 1:10:19people should drink bleach or do hydroxychloroquine?
- 1:10:22He's the president of the United States.
- 1:10:23Do you think that that was at all the bleach
- 1:10:25you think that was the bleach thing is a completely
- 1:10:27made up farce.
- 1:10:28The bleach,
- 1:10:29he didn't,
- 1:10:29yes,
- 1:10:29he told people to inject bleach.
- 1:10:30Have you seen it?
- 1:10:31The whole quote,
- 1:10:31you think he told people to inject bleach.
- 1:10:33He's like,
- 1:10:33really?
- 1:10:34Like that he suggested,
- 1:10:36he suggested that things like hydroxychloroquine
- 1:10:38were effective means of preventing COVID.
- 1:10:41They were not the case.
- 1:10:41There were all sorts of other treatments.
- 1:10:43There were monoclonal treatments.
- 1:10:44People did use HCQ.
- 1:10:45There were all sorts of things that people used other things,
- 1:10:48but that doesn't mean that it,
- 1:10:49that doesn't mean that the vaccine wasn't the most safe and effective means.
- 1:10:53Well,
- 1:10:53there used to be something,
- 1:10:54there used to be something called herd immunity.
- 1:10:56There used to be that young people would actually go outside and.
- 1:10:59Get sun and run around and do exercise and not be sitting inside playing
- 1:11:03video games all day and taking takeout food and getting fatter and everything else
- 1:11:06like you might want to encourage people to be healthy rather than
- 1:11:09take a largely experimental vaccine that turned out not to be a vaccine.
- 1:11:13It,
- 1:11:13it,
- 1:11:13it was,
- 1:11:15it was first of all,
- 1:11:15I don't know what you mean by not a vaccine.
- 1:11:17It's clearly a vaccine.
- 1:11:19It doesn't mean just because something is a vaccine doesn't mean you,
- 1:11:22it promote it's 0% transmissibility.
- 1:11:25OK,
- 1:11:25we gotta,
- 1:11:25we gotta pause there.
- 1:11:26You've been voted out.
- 1:11:27OK.
- 1:11:28Hi,
- 1:11:29hi,
- 1:11:29my name's Miriam.
- 1:11:30Nice to meet you
- 1:11:31so.
- 1:11:33I would just like to get into the fact
- 1:11:35that I think it's actually conservatives and Republicans who
- 1:11:38don't live in reality because in reality Trump is
- 1:11:40actually making it worse for people who claim they want
- 1:11:43affordability.
- 1:11:44Nothing in the Big Beautiful
- 1:11:46bill,
- 1:11:47uh,
- 1:11:47actually helps poor Americans.
- 1:11:49It actually increased their taxes and gave tax
- 1:11:51breaks to corporations and the ultra wealthy.
- 1:11:54Uh,
- 1:11:54so if we want to talk about who's not living in reality,
- 1:11:57I think it's the people who
- 1:11:58are poor but support Trump because they think that he likes them.
- 1:12:01Well,
- 1:12:02again,
- 1:12:02I think one of the consistent themes here is that we just have a fundamental
- 1:12:05difference on what makes an economy work and what I think makes an economy makes.
- 1:12:09No,
- 1:12:09so what I think makes an economy work is lower taxes for everybody.
- 1:12:13Did he,
- 1:12:13did he lower taxes for everybody,
- 1:12:15or did he actually increase taxes for the poor?
- 1:12:17He didn't increase taxes for the poor.
- 1:12:19You can actually go,
- 1:12:20you can.
- 1:12:20Actually go look at it.
- 1:12:21But if you are poor after the Big Beautiful Act,
- 1:12:24you're actually paying what do you mean by poor?
- 1:12:26What qualifies as poor?
- 1:12:27You make under a certain amount.
- 1:12:28Yeah,
- 1:12:29well,
- 1:12:29if you make under something like $50,000 you basically pay no taxes anyway.
- 1:12:32But if the argument you guys seem to keep coming around to the argument that if
- 1:12:36you could just take more from a certain set of people that we could solve all,
- 1:12:39I'm not even arguing that right now.
- 1:12:40I'm saying that Trump is not helping
- 1:12:42people
- 1:12:43at all.
- 1:12:43He's not giving tax breaks to them.
- 1:12:45He's giving tax breaks to the ultra wealthy.
- 1:12:47When he should be giving tax breaks to,
- 1:12:49you said everybody at least.
- 1:12:51Well,
- 1:12:51no,
- 1:12:52I'm saying if you want to be like logically consistent,
- 1:12:55then you would give tax breaks to everybody,
- 1:12:56but he's not doing that.
- 1:12:57He's only doing that with the poorest people pay virtually no tax.
- 1:13:01The poorest people pay virtually no tax,
- 1:13:02and again,
- 1:13:03the 1% pay 47%.
- 1:13:06So what percentage
- 1:13:07would you find acceptable?
- 1:13:08I really,
- 1:13:09I really mean that.
- 1:13:09I seem to not be able to get an answer.
- 1:13:11I don't want to get into the actual specifics,
- 1:13:13of course,
- 1:13:13of course.
- 1:13:14Because I'm here to actually say that,
- 1:13:16but OK,
- 1:13:17so Elon Musk,
- 1:13:17who's sending people to Mars,
- 1:13:19I think this is not relevant though.
- 1:13:21OK,
- 1:13:21this is not relevant to your prom.
- 1:13:23No,
- 1:13:23because you have to,
- 1:13:24because human flourishing is important.
- 1:13:26And when you take someone like Elon flourishing,
- 1:13:28yes,
- 1:13:29it is important who works for Elon Musk?
- 1:13:30Yeah,
- 1:13:30144,000 people.
- 1:13:32OK,
- 1:13:32so should those people also be getting tax breaks?
- 1:13:35Of course.
- 1:13:35Of course why aren't they under his policy?
- 1:13:37But what are you that they're not,
- 1:13:39but they are,
- 1:13:40but they're not.
- 1:13:40How many people do you think,
- 1:13:41how many people do you think Elon Musk pays that are making less than $50,000?
- 1:13:45I'm going to venture to say it's virtually nobody,
- 1:13:48virtually nobody at his companies that basically everybody's making under
- 1:13:51over $50.
- 1:13:52That means those people,
- 1:13:53almost everybody got a tax break or a tax rebate
- 1:13:57under Donald Trump.
- 1:13:58But even I implore everyone to look that up because I implore them,
- 1:14:02I implore them as well.
- 1:14:03I implore them as well.
- 1:14:04You've been voted out.
- 1:14:05You've been voted out.
- 1:14:08Hi,
- 1:14:09hi,
- 1:14:09how are you?
- 1:14:09Love the hair.
- 1:14:10I love the hair.
- 1:14:11Oh,
- 1:14:11thank you.
- 1:14:12Um,
- 1:14:13yeah,
- 1:14:13so I kind of just want to echo what everyone else has been saying.
- 1:14:16I do agree that the Republican Party,
- 1:14:18I feel like has been much
- 1:14:20more focused on ideology than reality and specifically,
- 1:14:23Trump made several campaign promises to his voters
- 1:14:27that he hasn't come through on,
- 1:14:29and yet we continue to hear you guys boolick him all the time.
- 1:14:33And it's very frustrating to me.
- 1:14:34The topic is the modern left cares more about ideology.
- 1:14:36Yeah,
- 1:14:37and I disagree with the claim.
- 1:14:38I think that the modern right cares more about ideology.
- 1:14:40I mean,
- 1:14:40what is it?
- 1:14:41Let's look at,
- 1:14:41OK,
- 1:14:42so let's look at some of the things that Trump,
- 1:14:43Trump ran on,
- 1:14:44right?
- 1:14:45He ran on an American first,
- 1:14:46America first campaign,
- 1:14:47and then he bombs Venezuela.
- 1:14:49Then he doesn't end the war in Israel,
- 1:14:51even though he promised he was going to do that.
- 1:14:52He starts a conflict is over.
- 1:14:55The war is over.
- 1:14:56No,
- 1:14:56it's,
- 1:14:56what do you mean very much there's a ceasefire.
- 1:14:58There's not one Israeli in Gaza.
- 1:15:00The hostages are home.
- 1:15:01There's a reconstruction.
- 1:15:01That is absolutely not true.
- 1:15:03That is fundamentally false.
- 1:15:05Wait,
- 1:15:05you're saying there there are hostages in Gaza right now and the war is continuing.
- 1:15:08The conflict has continued.
- 1:15:09Yes,
- 1:15:09there have continued to be bombs and moving they're bombing Gaza right now.
- 1:15:12That's what you're telling me.
- 1:15:13Yeah,
- 1:15:14yeah,
- 1:15:14yeah,
- 1:15:14that's not true.
- 1:15:15I mean,
- 1:15:15I know you get your news from Grok,
- 1:15:17but like this is a fact that is continuing to happen.
- 1:15:20So he promises to be America first,
- 1:15:22right?
- 1:15:22He doesn't end the,
- 1:15:23he doesn't end the war in Israel.
- 1:15:25He starts a war in Iran while simultaneously defunding the VA,
- 1:15:30right?
- 1:15:30So he's Sending people
- 1:15:32to go fight an unnecessary war
- 1:15:34while defunding the,
- 1:15:35like,
- 1:15:35the organization and the institution that helps those people.
- 1:15:38That's not America first at all.
- 1:15:40He promised he was gonna drain the swamp,
- 1:15:42and then he puts Kash Patel in,
- 1:15:43who's drunk at work.
- 1:15:44Then he puts Pam Bony in who's
- 1:15:46numpty,
- 1:15:47right?
- 1:15:47She ain't doing shit.
- 1:15:48Then he puts Christy Noam and her big booby boyfriend in,
- 1:15:51right?
- 1:15:51He didn't drain the swamp at all.
- 1:15:52He dumped raw sewage in the swamp.
- 1:15:54Like,
- 1:15:54he hasn't come through on any of his promises,
- 1:15:57and you continue to defend him.
- 1:15:58You are not accepting.
- 1:15:59Reality that Trump failed his voters.
- 1:16:03The topic here is the modern left cares more about ideology than reality.
- 1:16:07You're giving me,
- 1:16:08you're giving me the modern right cares more about ideology than reality,
- 1:16:10but that's not what the topic is.
- 1:16:12If you want to talk,
- 1:16:13if you want to talk about what my claim was,
- 1:16:14it's that the modern left,
- 1:16:15I am referencing your claim.
- 1:16:16You just don't want to interact with this because you know,
- 1:16:18you're going to lose.
- 1:16:19You know all these things.
- 1:16:20You don't want to say that I,
- 1:16:21I'll tell you what my claim is.
- 1:16:22The modern left,
- 1:16:23which cares more I heard about
- 1:16:25trans ideology,
- 1:16:27which cares more about racial ideology.
- 1:16:28No,
- 1:16:29you're trying to focus on the,
- 1:16:30you're trying to focus on your definition of progressivism.
- 1:16:34I'm going on what's on the paper.
- 1:16:35You're focusing on your definition of progressivism because you don't
- 1:16:38want to admit that Trump has failed his voters.
- 1:16:40Trump has failed his voters.
- 1:16:41He has not come through on his promises.
- 1:16:43I mean,
- 1:16:44he said,
- 1:16:45look,
- 1:16:45he said he was going to be tough on crime,
- 1:16:47especially immigrants,
- 1:16:47but he pardons the president of Honduras,
- 1:16:50who was literally in jail for smuggling 400 tons of cocaine
- 1:16:54into the US.
- 1:16:55He has not come through with his.
- 1:16:58I'm,
- 1:16:58I'm confused.
- 1:16:58So you want,
- 1:16:59you want the government,
- 1:17:00you want the government to be tougher on crime.
- 1:17:01Is that what you're telling me?
- 1:17:02You're,
- 1:17:02you're a lefty.
- 1:17:03You want a lefty.
- 1:17:04You're a lefty,
- 1:17:04and you want,
- 1:17:05so you want the government.
- 1:17:06I'm just looking at reality.
- 1:17:07The reality is Trump made a promise that he did not keep.
- 1:17:10His actions do not align with what he ran on.
- 1:17:13I,
- 1:17:13I actually wish Donald Trump was being harder on crime,
- 1:17:16and I,
- 1:17:17and I actually wish the fact that you've defended him for the last 3
- 1:17:19hours proves that you're not in touch with the reality of the situation.
- 1:17:22No,
- 1:17:23I wish he was doing more as it came to deportations.
- 1:17:25You can only do so.
- 1:17:26Many things at once.
- 1:17:27You don't get everything that you want all the time.
- 1:17:29You just defended Trump.
- 1:17:30You just defended Trump's deportation policy.
- 1:17:32So you wish he was doing more or you're defending it.
- 1:17:33What is it?
- 1:17:34No,
- 1:17:34I like the policy.
- 1:17:35I wish he was doing more.
- 1:17:36I wish he was doing more.
- 1:17:38The fact that you are continuing to support a president who
- 1:17:41has not come through on his party promises is delusion.
- 1:17:43No,
- 1:17:44it's not delusions.
- 1:17:44It is Donald Trump,
- 1:17:45as I said at the beginning,
- 1:17:46you sat here and defended Donald Trump for so long.
- 1:17:49If Donald Trump did nothing else other than close the borders,
- 1:17:52he has already
- 1:17:54done more than enough for the country.
- 1:17:55You,
- 1:17:56whoa,
- 1:17:56whoa,
- 1:17:56whoa,
- 1:17:56you think in 4 years a president's only responsibility is to close the borders.
- 1:18:00He's supposed to be running the free world.
- 1:18:02He's supposed to be running the entire country.
- 1:18:03That's all you care about is the border.
- 1:18:05If you have a what about healthcare?
- 1:18:07What about the national debt?
- 1:18:08He's increased the national debt by $2.5 trillion.
- 1:18:11You don't give a about that.
- 1:18:12If you have a slow,
- 1:18:13soft invasion of your country happening,
- 1:18:16then at the very least you can close the borders and start
- 1:18:19kicking out the people who are not supposed to be here,
- 1:18:21OK,
- 1:18:21but you just said the only thing that Trump did is close the.
- 1:18:25that would be an effective presidency to you if the only thing he did,
- 1:18:28no,
- 1:18:28I want him to do more.
- 1:18:29OK,
- 1:18:29so then why would you say that him
- 1:18:31closing the borders would be an effective presidency,
- 1:18:33I would stop if I was Donald Trump,
- 1:18:36because,
- 1:18:36because presidents have to do a lot of different things at once.
- 1:18:38You don't,
- 1:18:38OK,
- 1:18:39but you just said if he did one singular thing that,
- 1:18:42that would all that's a good president to you if,
- 1:18:44if really relative to where we were with Joe Biden,
- 1:18:47a lame duck presidency.
- 1:18:48If the only thing he can accomplish in 4 years is one thing,
- 1:18:51you want to have like a silly semantic argument,
- 1:18:53I think you.
- 1:18:53It's not a silly.
- 1:18:54I think you,
- 1:18:55I think,
- 1:18:55I think you understand.
- 1:18:56No,
- 1:18:57no,
- 1:18:57I think you understand the point that I'm making that
- 1:18:59in and of itself closing the border is by far
- 1:19:02the most important thing that had to happen.
- 1:19:04By
- 1:19:05far don't care.
- 1:19:06We had an invasion into this country,
- 1:19:0816 to 20 million people on top of the fact that we
- 1:19:11probably had at least 12 million illegals here in the first place.
- 1:19:14So you don't care.
- 1:19:14So we have about he just we have a billion dollars from Medicaid.
- 1:19:17You don't care that he defunded
- 1:19:18the EPA.
- 1:19:19You don't care that I don't fund the VA.
- 1:19:20I don't you don't care that he the EPA.
- 1:19:22But that's besides the point.
- 1:19:23None of those things.
- 1:19:24You don't care.
- 1:19:24It's just as long as he does immigration,
- 1:19:26you're happy.
- 1:19:26It's that's delusional.
- 1:19:27That is,
- 1:19:28you're not accepting the reality that is of the issues in this country.
- 1:19:31No,
- 1:19:31you,
- 1:19:31it's interesting.
- 1:19:32You guys all seem to hate the government and hate Donald Trump,
- 1:19:35but you love government programs.
- 1:19:36I don't understand.
- 1:19:37That seems to be the disconnect
- 1:19:39with progressives as a general programs when they
- 1:19:41are effective in supporting the needs of the
- 1:19:43might I might I offer that most of you guys who are in your twenties,
- 1:19:46you don't really understand how the world works.
- 1:19:48We got to pause here.
- 1:19:48We've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:19:50Please return to your seats.
- 1:19:51How are you doing?
- 1:19:53So your fundamental claim is that
- 1:19:55the left is more in touch with ideology than reality,
- 1:19:58right?
- 1:20:00Make America Great Again is an ideological claim that
- 1:20:02they are trying to make America great again.
- 1:20:05That is fundamentally incongruous with reality
- 1:20:08because Donald Trump is not making America great.
- 1:20:10He's attacking the fundamental fabric that makes America
- 1:20:14America.
- 1:20:15For example,
- 1:20:15birthright citizenship.
- 1:20:17One of the things that distinguishes us from other countries in the Western world,
- 1:20:20in first world countries,
- 1:20:21is that we have just solely.
- 1:20:23If someone is born here,
- 1:20:24they're an American.
- 1:20:25If someone believes in the ideals of America,
- 1:20:27they're an American.
- 1:20:28No,
- 1:20:28wait,
- 1:20:28wait,
- 1:20:28wait,
- 1:20:28but that's just not meanwhile,
- 1:20:29someone believes in the ideals of America,
- 1:20:31they're Americans.
- 1:20:32So if someone in Canada believes in the ideals of America,
- 1:20:34they're Americans.
- 1:20:35That's the great conservative thinker Ronald Reagan.
- 1:20:37There are millions of unknowing Americans.
- 1:20:39He actually,
- 1:20:40but they have to become American.
- 1:20:41The conservative ideology of the 1980s actually invited people into America
- 1:20:44that were going to work hard and build a better life,
- 1:20:46not people who tried to destroy America would agree
- 1:20:48that you have to come by removing those people.
- 1:20:49Well,
- 1:20:50first off,
- 1:20:50that's,
- 1:20:51you,
- 1:20:51you would agree that they have to come legally.
- 1:20:53I think that we need to reform our legal
- 1:20:55process so that people can come here legally effectively.
- 1:20:57Trump has actually shut down legal immigration
- 1:20:59more than he shut down illegal immigration,
- 1:21:01but more than the border,
- 1:21:02the border is completely closed.
- 1:21:03There are people that are waiting in line to get into the country.
- 1:21:06That's not true.
- 1:21:07Trump,
- 1:21:07Trump has sent back about 80,000 people.
- 1:21:10Over the course of the second administration,
- 1:21:11uh,
- 1:21:12Biden sent away 956,000.
- 1:21:14When it comes to border crossings,
- 1:21:16Biden stopped much more border crossings than Trump did.
- 1:21:18I'm not saying it's a good or bad thing.
- 1:21:19I'm just saying objectively speaking,
- 1:21:21on a per year basis,
- 1:21:22Biden stopped more border crossings than Trump.
- 1:21:24Anyone coming through the border right now?
- 1:21:27Yes,
- 1:21:27yes,
- 1:21:27they are.
- 1:21:28Yeah,
- 1:21:28what,
- 1:21:28what numbers are coming through?
- 1:21:29I mean,
- 1:21:29the borders,
- 1:21:30I don't know the exact number.
- 1:21:30The borders don't actually track that.
- 1:21:32We only track on borders,
- 1:21:33the borders are completely closed and they were wide open under Biden.
- 1:21:37But
- 1:21:37the Reagan comment that you just made is that ideologically someone,
- 1:21:41it's a beautiful thing about this country,
- 1:21:43which is interesting,
- 1:21:44which is that
- 1:21:45yes,
- 1:21:46anyone can become an American,
- 1:21:47but you don't become an American by believing in American ideals.
- 1:21:50You become an American
- 1:21:51by having a set of beliefs and then applying to become a citizen.
- 1:21:55And doing it lawfully and legally
- 1:21:57and that is completely not what we have had
- 1:22:00for the 4 years before Donald Trump.
- 1:22:01So to become an American,
- 1:22:02either you're born here or you immigrate here and then you get
- 1:22:05a legal residence and eventually from there you become a citizen.
- 1:22:08If that's the case and that's what we're respecting,
- 1:22:11why is Stephen Miller ordering 3500 deportations a day and then to do that,
- 1:22:15but the Trump administration here illegally?
- 1:22:17No,
- 1:22:19because Trump tried to remove temporary protected status of over 500,000 people.
- 1:22:22Who are here legally,
- 1:22:23so that they could reach the 3500
- 1:22:25mark.
- 1:22:26If someone is changing the law to make someone that has legal status illegal?
- 1:22:30Hold on,
- 1:22:30are you that's not coming after people who you're saying here legally.
- 1:22:32We're you're saying we're deporting legal,
- 1:22:35we're actually deporting citizens.
- 1:22:36We deported a 4 year old kid with lung cancer.
- 1:22:38We deported a 10 year old.
- 1:22:39You're talking about because the brain cancer.
- 1:22:41If you're talking about because the 10 year old kid with brain cancer,
- 1:22:44you're talking about because the father was illegal and
- 1:22:46they didn't want to break up the family.
- 1:22:47Was the kid an American citizen or not?
- 1:22:49By the.
- 1:22:50Law of the United States,
- 1:22:51if the kid was born here by birthright citizenship,
- 1:22:53then he was.
- 1:22:54But are you saying are they deporting an American citizen?
- 1:22:56Because they were deporting the father.
- 1:22:58Why are they made?
- 1:22:59The reality is that the kid is an American citizen.
- 1:23:01Why are you deporting an American citizen unless you are ignoring
- 1:23:03the material reality to separate the father from the child?
- 1:23:06No,
- 1:23:06but if they're receiving medical treatment,
- 1:23:08life saving medication in a first world country,
- 1:23:10granted one of the worst healthcare situations in a first world country,
- 1:23:13I think it'd be I just wanna make sure we're talking about the same case.
- 1:23:15So in this specific case,
- 1:23:16you,
- 1:23:16you grant that the father.
- 1:23:17It was illegal,
- 1:23:18right?
- 1:23:18We're talking about multiple cases.
- 1:23:20There's a 4 year old kid with lung cancer
- 1:23:21and a 10-year-old kid with brain cancer was illegal,
- 1:23:23correct?
- 1:23:23From my understanding,
- 1:23:24one of the parents was not documented,
- 1:23:26so they didn't want,
- 1:23:26so they didn't want to break up the family.
- 1:23:28I don't think you would want to do that,
- 1:23:29and I would want if they were acting in the best interests of the child,
- 1:23:32why were they withholding medication while they're in detention?
- 1:23:34We gotta pause here again.
- 1:23:36The father was illegal.
- 1:23:37They didn't want to break up the family.
- 1:23:38We gotta pause here.
- 1:23:39You've been voted out.
- 1:23:40OK.
- 1:23:40Listen,
- 1:23:40Dave,
- 1:23:40I'm gonna be honest,
- 1:23:41I'm a little tired,
- 1:23:42but I'm not the president,
- 1:23:42so I'm not gonna fall asleep.
- 1:23:43OK?
- 1:23:44Give me a second.
- 1:23:44Let me see.
- 1:23:46So
- 1:23:46I want to defend the Democratic Party because did you think that was funny?
- 1:23:50I thought it was absolutely hilarious,
- 1:23:51but let's slow down.
- 1:23:52First of all,
- 1:23:52I'm pretty sure you talked a lot of shit about Joe Biden,
- 1:23:54who's demented,
- 1:23:55but I don't want to talk about that.
- 1:23:56I want to defend
- 1:23:57the Democratic Party.
- 1:23:58Do you not think Joe Biden had cognitive problems?
- 1:24:00I'm joking.
- 1:24:01I'm joking.
- 1:24:02Hold on.
- 1:24:02I'm joking.
- 1:24:03OK.
- 1:24:04The Democratic Party,
- 1:24:05is,
- 1:24:05are you,
- 1:24:05are you an improv or something?
- 1:24:07I'm just curious.
- 1:24:07Can we lock in or just lock in?
- 1:24:09Listen,
- 1:24:10listen,
- 1:24:10I'm with you.
- 1:24:11I'm really,
- 1:24:11I'm trying to read what's going on here.
- 1:24:12The Democratic Party,
- 1:24:13the left is clearly receptive to the needs of
- 1:24:15the American people because it's shown in the elections.
- 1:24:17It's shown in the candidates
- 1:24:19that they're giving out.
- 1:24:20If you need Zoran Mamdani in New York,
- 1:24:21you'll get it.
- 1:24:21If you need Abigail Spamberger in Virginia,
- 1:24:23you'll get it.
- 1:24:23If you need James Salarico
- 1:24:25in Texas,
- 1:24:25Ossoff in Georgia,
- 1:24:27you're going to get it.
- 1:24:28But you know what party hasn't changed their mind?
- 1:24:30What party is so crazy that they will go back on their number.
- 1:24:33One campaign promise and say
- 1:24:35affordability is a hoax,
- 1:24:36it's MAGA,
- 1:24:36and it's evident
- 1:24:38that,
- 1:24:38hold on,
- 1:24:38a lot of people say Trump is stupid,
- 1:24:40and I think he's a little dumb,
- 1:24:41but I think he's also malicious.
- 1:24:43Reality is what Donald Trump makes,
- 1:24:45and a perfect example
- 1:24:46is
- 1:24:47his response to a tragedy.
- 1:24:48When Charlie Kirk was murdered
- 1:24:50hours before there was even a suspect in custody,
- 1:24:52Donald Trump blamed half of the electorate.
- 1:24:55Nancy Mace said the.
- 1:24:57Democrats
- 1:24:57own this.
- 1:24:59Van Norden
- 1:24:59said that it was the fake news media for peddling these radical points.
- 1:25:02You know what AOC said?
- 1:25:03This is a time that we need unity.
- 1:25:05This is a time we need to come together.
- 1:25:06We need to deal with political violence.
- 1:25:08The Republican Party MAGA uses death as a cudgel to justify the unjustifiable,
- 1:25:14and that is denying reality.
- 1:25:15That's making reality whatever you want it to be,
- 1:25:17and people like you
- 1:25:18are corrupted enough to spew it all over social media.
- 1:25:21Wow,
- 1:25:21yeah.
- 1:25:23I,
- 1:25:24I,
- 1:25:24yeah,
- 1:25:24I'll respond.
- 1:25:25out of all the people,
- 1:25:26I have to say you're the worst,
- 1:25:27like by far,
- 1:25:28because,
- 1:25:28because you're having a trouble,
- 1:25:29a lot of trouble responding to things I say.
- 1:25:31You,
- 1:25:31you honestly believe that there is a moral equivalence to the tone and
- 1:25:36tenor of what goes on the right versus what goes on the left.
- 1:25:38Did Hassan Piker,
- 1:25:40who is the number one influencer on the left,
- 1:25:42did he not just go on an interview?
- 1:25:45I'll give you two examples.
- 1:25:46He went on an interview a couple weeks ago
- 1:25:48and said that he understands why.
- 1:25:49Luigi Manjion killed Brian Thompson,
- 1:25:51the UnitedHealthcare CEO.
- 1:25:53When you guys open up that Pandora's box,
- 1:25:55guess what?
- 1:25:56There's a lot of people that don't like your ideology,
- 1:25:58and once you can kind of excuse violence,
- 1:26:00it's coming in every which way.
- 1:26:02And then it happened again in the New York Times interview that he did two weeks ago.
- 1:26:06He said the same thing.
- 1:26:06Well,
- 1:26:07Donald Trump,
- 1:26:07a lot of people don't like Donald Trump,
- 1:26:08so I can kind of understand why people might kill him.
- 1:26:11Once you guys do that,
- 1:26:12once you go past that red line.
- 1:26:16It literally ends the fabric of what this country
- 1:26:18is because we are allowed to have political disagreements.
- 1:26:21We have deep political disagreements.
- 1:26:23I would never
- 1:26:24tacitly endorse or pretend
- 1:26:27to condone someone if they tried to violently harm you or any of these people,
- 1:26:32but subtly on the left,
- 1:26:34that is being allowed and that is not,
- 1:26:36and that simply is not happening on the right.
- 1:26:38That simply is not happening.
- 1:26:39OK,
- 1:26:39we're gonna stop there
- 1:26:41because we're out of time.
- 1:26:44Dave,
- 1:26:44we are now at the final portion of the video.
- 1:26:47Please look around the room.
- 1:26:48Choose somebody who you haven't spoken to or who you want to speak to more.
- 1:26:51They will bring their own claim,
- 1:26:52and you'll debate for 10 minutes.
- 1:26:54Sure,
- 1:26:54I have to say first off,
- 1:26:55I,
- 1:26:55I thoroughly enjoyed this,
- 1:26:56believe it or not,
- 1:26:57uh,
- 1:26:57this is what it's,
- 1:26:57this is what it's all about,
- 1:26:58and we can agree to disagree.
- 1:26:59It's what my entire career and life have been about,
- 1:27:01so that's just fine.
- 1:27:02There was a.
- 1:27:03Some odd moments of uh of real tension and I could
- 1:27:06see some real hatred in a couple of the eyes,
- 1:27:07but two that I did not
- 1:27:09see it in were you
- 1:27:11and you.
- 1:27:11So this is a complete toss up with the two of you,
- 1:27:13but I actually,
- 1:27:14but I actually think our conversation was
- 1:27:16the most interesting and I think there's the
- 1:27:17most room to try to get something uh on the other side of this.
- 1:27:20So I'd love to bring you back up.
- 1:27:21Oh yes.
- 1:27:26My surrounded claim is trans rights are human rights.
- 1:27:29One of the first initiatives of Donald Trump in this current presidency,
- 1:27:33uh,
- 1:27:34he put forth
- 1:27:34an executive order,
- 1:27:36uh,
- 1:27:36essentially attempting to ban gender-affirming healthcare
- 1:27:40for people under 19 years of age.
- 1:27:42And when we say under 19 years of age,
- 1:27:44this also includes adults
- 1:27:46who are 18 years old who are old enough to go
- 1:27:49off and die in a war for oil imperialism in Israel,
- 1:27:52but they can't make their own healthcare decisions.
- 1:27:55OK,
- 1:27:56let's do this.
- 1:27:56I love how you guys have to get Israel into this thing.
- 1:27:58It's like Israel is the one place in the Middle
- 1:28:00East that you could go and you would be celebrated.
- 1:28:02I couldn't get married there.
- 1:28:03That's actually the truth.
- 1:28:04Well,
- 1:28:04they,
- 1:28:04yes,
- 1:28:05they are not perfect and no country is,
- 1:28:07but you would be treated equally and with respect,
- 1:28:09and they have the biggest LGBT pride parade.
- 1:28:11It's coming up in 2 weeks.
- 1:28:12You should probably go.
- 1:28:12You might find it quite interesting anyway.
- 1:28:14Um,
- 1:28:15as far as the,
- 1:28:15the claim,
- 1:28:16I 100% believe that trans rights are human rights
- 1:28:20or that trans people should be treated equally under the law law 100%.
- 1:28:23Now,
- 1:28:24so what your claim is,
- 1:28:25is about people that are under,
- 1:28:26let's say 19,
- 1:28:27right?
- 1:28:27Now that's a different thing.
- 1:28:28If you are going to
- 1:28:30chemically castrate a kid or if you are going to
- 1:28:33give them hormone blockers or a series of other things
- 1:28:35when they are 567,
- 1:28:3712,
- 1:28:37when they're in the middle of what wait,
- 1:28:39wait,
- 1:28:40wait,
- 1:28:40wait,
- 1:28:40wait,
- 1:28:40it is happening,
- 1:28:41it is happening.
- 1:28:42Or if you are going to
- 1:28:43literally have schools
- 1:28:45where they are calling a child by a different
- 1:28:47gender and a different name without alerting the parents,
- 1:28:49etc.
- 1:28:50etc.
- 1:28:50These things are happening.
- 1:28:52Then I am not for that.
- 1:28:53But,
- 1:28:54however,
- 1:28:54how,
- 1:28:54how old are you,
- 1:28:55if you don't mind me asking?
- 1:28:55Is that,
- 1:28:56can I,
- 1:28:56I'm.
- 1:28:57I ask a lady,
- 1:28:58see,
- 1:28:58I'll,
- 1:28:59I'll even use your pronouns because as long as you treat me with respect,
- 1:29:01I'll treat you with respect.
- 1:29:02I'm 3915,
- 1:29:03I'll be 40 this summer.
- 1:29:05And so,
- 1:29:05wait,
- 1:29:05wait,
- 1:29:06so let me say something.
- 1:29:06So I want you to be treated under the law with 100% equality.
- 1:29:12Every single thing.
- 1:29:13That
- 1:29:13I and everyone else in this country
- 1:29:15should be treated to,
- 1:29:16which is equality of opportunity and equality under law,
- 1:29:19you should be treated.
- 1:29:20I,
- 1:29:20I'm not that interested in talking about my sexuality.
- 1:29:22It's,
- 1:29:22it's actually
- 1:29:23a very unimportant part of my life in a weird way,
- 1:29:25and,
- 1:29:26and maybe that's
- 1:29:27because I'm,
- 1:29:27I'll be 50 next month,
- 1:29:28and,
- 1:29:29and as time goes by,
- 1:29:29you realize you just are who you are and you do the best you can in the world,
- 1:29:32right?
- 1:29:33And,
- 1:29:34but I understand feeling.
- 1:29:36I grew up in a time
- 1:29:37when there was no gay marriage,
- 1:29:38and I,
- 1:29:38and when I was a kid.
- 1:29:40For however confused I was or anything else,
- 1:29:42there was no,
- 1:29:42I never thought about the future because it wasn't even a thing.
- 1:29:45Like there was literally no future.
- 1:29:46And then,
- 1:29:47and then magic happened over time
- 1:29:49and we got equal rights.
- 1:29:51I've been married for,
- 1:29:53God,
- 1:29:53it's a long time now.
- 1:29:54I've been married for about 13 years.
- 1:29:55My husband and I have been together for 15 years.
- 1:29:57We're in a 100% monogamous relationship.
- 1:29:59We have two of the most incredible
- 1:30:00kids who I want to grow up with the most amount of respect and
- 1:30:03love and who are safe and cherished and all of those wonderful things,
- 1:30:06as I hope if you want,
- 1:30:07you,
- 1:30:07you will get in your life too.
- 1:30:09The reason I mention that
- 1:30:11is because
- 1:30:12the difference between equal rights for everybody,
- 1:30:16everybody,
- 1:30:17versus
- 1:30:18what you might do to a child are very different things.
- 1:30:21If there is a child
- 1:30:22who I,
- 1:30:23I suspect when you were a young kid,
- 1:30:24how old were you when you thought you were in the,
- 1:30:26in the,
- 1:30:27I was 5.
- 1:30:27I was 5 years old 5 years old.
- 1:30:29I realized that I was a trans person.
- 1:30:30OK,
- 1:30:31OK.
- 1:30:31I,
- 1:30:31I can,
- 1:30:32I can accept that.
- 1:30:33Can I also ask how old you were when you,
- 1:30:34um,
- 1:30:35realized that you were gay?
- 1:30:37I mean,
- 1:30:37I came out very late for a series of other reasons.
- 1:30:39Are you still gay?
- 1:30:41Only after 10:00 p.m.,
- 1:30:42so I don't know what time it is right now.
- 1:30:43Oh,
- 1:30:43look,
- 1:30:44I made him laugh.
- 1:30:44There you go.
- 1:30:45OK,
- 1:30:46wait,
- 1:30:46wait,
- 1:30:46I'm not,
- 1:30:46wait,
- 1:30:47hold on,
- 1:30:47I'm,
- 1:30:47I'm really,
- 1:30:48I think I'm granting you an awful lot here.
- 1:30:50Um,
- 1:30:51the,
- 1:30:51the only thing that I would say
- 1:30:53related to a 5 year old who
- 1:30:55is having gender dysphoria or whatever term you want to apply it to.
- 1:30:59Is that you should wait until
- 1:31:02the child can make those decisions properly for themselves,
- 1:31:05that your brain at 5
- 1:31:07was not developed enough to do it,
- 1:31:08and there was so much social pressure over the last couple of years
- 1:31:12to trans kids.
- 1:31:14Uh,
- 1:31:14Abigail Schreier wrote an incredible book about this,
- 1:31:16that a certain amount of it is a social contagion that is true.
- 1:31:20That is empirically true.
- 1:31:21I'm not saying it was you,
- 1:31:22right?
- 1:31:22I'm not.
- 1:31:23I'm friends with Blair White.
- 1:31:24I believe that Blair
- 1:31:25is,
- 1:31:26I believe that Blair was biologically a male
- 1:31:30and
- 1:31:31believes that she,
- 1:31:32and I will call her she because she treats
- 1:31:33me with respect and I'll treat her with respect,
- 1:31:35that she transitioned when the time was right.
- 1:31:38The issue for most people on the right
- 1:31:40is about the kids.
- 1:31:42I can tell you this,
- 1:31:42you know,
- 1:31:42it's funny because a lot of you tried to use my sexuality against me.
- 1:31:46Yeah,
- 1:31:46I'll get there.
- 1:31:47Listen.
- 1:31:47A lot of you tried to use my sexuality against me,
- 1:31:49and I can tell,
- 1:31:50and it's interesting because you guys also think sexuality is very important,
- 1:31:53right?
- 1:31:54So you would think I would I would have been afforded.
- 1:31:56As someone that travels in circles that you guys don't,
- 1:31:59I go to Republican things,
- 1:32:00and I,
- 1:32:01I have to traverse that a little bit,
- 1:32:02and it can be tricky at times,
- 1:32:04but I've shown Republicans that you can be a decent human being
- 1:32:07who,
- 1:32:08who can have a family and be monogamous.
- 1:32:10That,
- 1:32:10that job,
- 1:32:11I I really appreciate you being kind.
- 1:32:12We're,
- 1:32:13we're less than 5 now,
- 1:32:14and I have not really had a moment to speak.
- 1:32:15Yeah,
- 1:32:15so,
- 1:32:16so again,
- 1:32:16I'm just making the point between children and adults.
- 1:32:18I want you,
- 1:32:19and that's exactly what I'm gonna respond to right now.
- 1:32:21I appreciate your kindness.
- 1:32:22I appreciate you not misgendering me.
- 1:32:24I appreciate you treating me like I'm just a regular human being,
- 1:32:27and that's what trans people are.
- 1:32:28We're just regular human beings with the same
- 1:32:29struggles trying to get through this life,
- 1:32:32actually more struggles because we have this whole group of people
- 1:32:35who want to take away our rights.
- 1:32:36Uh,
- 1:32:37as somebody who's been an elected,
- 1:32:38can you let me finish,
- 1:32:39let me speak.
- 1:32:40But,
- 1:32:40but what I'm just I'm saying it right now as somebody
- 1:32:43who's been an elected official in Los Angeles since 2019,
- 1:32:46every single year I've seen
- 1:32:47more and more and more anti-LGBTQIA bills moving across the federal legislation.
- 1:32:52Legislature,
- 1:32:52uh,
- 1:32:53and across state legislatures all across the US and when I say anti-LGBTQIA bills,
- 1:32:57what I actually mean is anti-trans bills,
- 1:33:00bills that are trying to limit our existence in society,
- 1:33:02bills that are trying to limit,
- 1:33:04uh,
- 1:33:04how we can receive health care,
- 1:33:05how we can make our own autonomous healthcare decisions,
- 1:33:07how we can even participate in going to the bathroom.
- 1:33:10We all have to take a shit,
- 1:33:12and that is something we should be able
- 1:33:13to do freely and privately without somebody recording us
- 1:33:16in the bathroom and trying to make us go viral and make it seem like we are.
- 1:33:20Predators.
- 1:33:21Now you describe,
- 1:33:22uh,
- 1:33:22this idea of 5 year olds being chemically castrated.
- 1:33:26Here's the thing,
- 1:33:26uh,
- 1:33:27you cannot compare a 5 year old who is
- 1:33:29gonna perhaps socially transition and wants to go by,
- 1:33:32uh,
- 1:33:32a name that is opposite of the gender they were assigned at birth
- 1:33:35or want to wear clothes that are different.
- 1:33:375 year olds are not receiving any sort of medical transition,
- 1:33:41and so you say that they should wait,
- 1:33:43and that's true and that's exactly why
- 1:33:45puberty blockers are prescribed to,
- 1:33:47uh.
- 1:33:47Teenagers that are about to go through puberty,
- 1:33:50uh,
- 1:33:50and here's the issue.
- 1:33:51How old is that?
- 1:33:51Would you say?
- 1:33:52I would say anywhere from probably maybe like 1011,
- 1:33:5612,
- 1:33:57and here's the thing,
- 1:33:58but do you think puberty blockers have been to know the full,
- 1:34:00yes,
- 1:34:00I do,
- 1:34:01the full ramifications of what they're doing.
- 1:34:03Yes,
- 1:34:03a 10 year old puberty blockers,
- 1:34:05puberty blockers have been around for over 30 years.
- 1:34:08They've been prescribed to kids who are experiencing precocious puberty,
- 1:34:12and
- 1:34:12yet this has never been an issue for the rights.
- 1:34:15It is.
- 1:34:15Only an issue for the rights when somebody decides,
- 1:34:18oh,
- 1:34:18I'm,
- 1:34:19I'm trans and
- 1:34:20they together with their family and their physicians want to make that decision.
- 1:34:24They're not getting surgery
- 1:34:26at 10 years old.
- 1:34:27They're taking puberty blockers to make that decision
- 1:34:30over time with their family and their physicians.
- 1:34:32There is no reason why you or the president of the United States
- 1:34:35should be able to decide what is right for somebody's healthcare,
- 1:34:38for an individual,
- 1:34:39for somebody else's child,
- 1:34:40unless you are their doctor or their parents.
- 1:34:42OK,
- 1:34:43so.
- 1:34:44Listen,
- 1:34:46I have a couple of fundamental disagreements with that when it comes to minors,
- 1:34:51but the issue is about trans rights or human rights.
- 1:34:53So we can trans people are disproportionately unhoused,
- 1:34:56disproportionately experience housing discrimination,
- 1:34:59healthcare discrimination,
- 1:35:00if you,
- 1:35:01you on the books,
- 1:35:02we are,
- 1:35:02are legal,
- 1:35:03hold on,
- 1:35:03we are actually discriminate experiencing discrimination every
- 1:35:06single day in every realm of society.
- 1:35:08Yeah,
- 1:35:08you know,
- 1:35:08I've,
- 1:35:09I've experienced discrimination.
- 1:35:10I'm gonna guess almost everyone here in,
- 1:35:11in some way has something that they've been
- 1:35:13discriminated against or judged upon or something else.
- 1:35:15What you have in America
- 1:35:16is
- 1:35:17equal equality under the law and,
- 1:35:19and you have an opportunity to we don't
- 1:35:20when Republicans are trying to legislate against us,
- 1:35:23but tell me that,
- 1:35:24so you as an adult,
- 1:35:25what law is stopping you from doing anything that that another
- 1:35:29person cannot do that literally anyone in this room cannot do?
- 1:35:32See,
- 1:35:32this is the thing is you were trying to hide behind this idea of the law.
- 1:35:35No,
- 1:35:36but,
- 1:35:36but I mean that the reality is laws are not protecting trans people.
- 1:35:39If they were,
- 1:35:40trans people would not be disproportionately unemployed,
- 1:35:42unhoused.
- 1:35:43You,
- 1:35:43what would you like,
- 1:35:44what would you like the law to do for you?
- 1:35:46Again,
- 1:35:47the law,
- 1:35:47the law can guarantee equality.
- 1:35:50It can't guarantee protection,
- 1:35:52right?
- 1:35:52So yes,
- 1:35:53it certainly can.
- 1:35:54So what would you like the law to do for you?
- 1:35:56I would like the law to protect trans people,
- 1:35:59and it's not the law.
- 1:36:00Our legislators are actively legislating
- 1:36:04against us.
- 1:36:04Again,
- 1:36:05if there was a law,
- 1:36:06if you can point me to a law
- 1:36:08that was
- 1:36:09discriminating against trans adults,
- 1:36:11they can't get a.
- 1:36:11Job they can't whatever.
- 1:36:13Then of course I just I did at the beginning of this debate,
- 1:36:14Donald Trump is trying to ban gender affirming healthcare for people
- 1:36:18who are 18 years old about minors talking about minors.
- 1:36:2118 year olds aren't minors.
- 1:36:22They can go off and die in a war,
- 1:36:23but for some reason they can't make their
- 1:36:25own autonomous healthcare decisions according to Donald Trump.
- 1:36:28OK,
- 1:36:29listen,
- 1:36:30when we're talking about young people,
- 1:36:31it's a different thing.
- 1:36:32It's exactly,
- 1:36:33and these are not your young people.
- 1:36:34They're not his young people.
- 1:36:35These are no 5 year old is walking into a medical
- 1:36:39office and getting.
- 1:36:40Puberty blockers without the consent
- 1:36:42of their parents or their,
- 1:36:43but you,
- 1:36:44so you don't think there's any element of social contagion over the last 10 years.
- 1:36:47I don't.
- 1:36:47And even if there is,
- 1:36:48that's,
- 1:36:49that's OK because there's nothing wrong with being trans.
- 1:36:51And if somebody decides to de-transition,
- 1:36:53that's OK,
- 1:36:54but they can't tell everybody else that they're not allowed to transition.
- 1:36:56Again,
- 1:36:57I think we're sort of splitting hairs on this that we're,
- 1:36:59we're agreeing to disagree on,
- 1:37:02perhaps we're agreeing to disagree on the,
- 1:37:04uh,
- 1:37:04underage portion of it.
- 1:37:06But again,
- 1:37:06as it how many times have you seen.
- 1:37:08How many times have you seen people on the rights
- 1:37:11make fun of trans people because,
- 1:37:13uh,
- 1:37:13especially trans women because they look like a man.
- 1:37:15But,
- 1:37:16well,
- 1:37:16you know,
- 1:37:16but you're allowed,
- 1:37:17you know what prevents them by allowing them to go through
- 1:37:19puberty blockers and to make their own autonomous healthcare decisions.
- 1:37:22Yeah,
- 1:37:23but,
- 1:37:23OK,
- 1:37:24so have,
- 1:37:24have,
- 1:37:25have we whittled this down to some people make jokes about people?
- 1:37:28Do they do,
- 1:37:28they make jokes about people.
- 1:37:29They're not just joking,
- 1:37:30they're trying to legislate against our very existence.
- 1:37:33Your friend Michael Knowles at CPAC
- 1:37:35said that we need to eradicate.
- 1:37:37Transgenderism in society
- 1:37:39that is a direct threat to me,
- 1:37:40my neighbors,
- 1:37:41my friends and family.
- 1:37:42OK,
- 1:37:42I promise you this.
- 1:37:44I promise you this.
- 1:37:45If Michael Knowles or anyone else starts pushing for legislation
- 1:37:49that will jail you
- 1:37:51or stop you from getting a job
- 1:37:53or any of the other freedoms that we all enjoy,
- 1:37:56I promise you I will be on your side of that.
- 1:37:58So I can't wait to be on your show soon.
- 1:38:01All right then,
- 1:38:02there we go.
- 1:38:03Thanks for chatting,
- 1:38:03Dave.
- 1:38:04Yeah my pleasure.
- 1:38:07Tune in this Wednesday
- 1:38:09for a follow up conversation where I'll talk to some of the cast from
- 1:38:12this episode and we'll dig deeper into some of the moments that happened here.
- 1:38:15If you agree with Dave's prompts or you disagree,
- 1:38:17let us know in the comments and keep the discussion going there,
- 1:38:20but we just ask that you acknowledge the humanity of all the participants.
- 1:38:24Thank you for watching.
- 1:38:25We'll see you next time.
- 1:38:26I think that the disconnect between the online world
- 1:38:28and the real world is getting larger and larger
- 1:38:31and so that was why I kind of wanted to do this in the first place because I was like,
- 1:38:34you know,
- 1:38:34I exist in the online world.
- 1:38:36I talked to a lot of people
- 1:38:38uh that I enjoy talking to but it's hard to talk to lefties.
- 1:38:41I think Dave totally misses the ball in that he completely buys into
- 1:38:47Republican framing,
- 1:38:48especially.
- 1:38:48Economic issues
- 1:38:50and doesn't understand that things like
- 1:38:52government regulation are empirically shown to
- 1:38:56better the lives of uh the people that they intend to better.
- 1:38:59I think Dave um Olov was incredibly mediocre and I don't
- 1:39:04know if he's fallen victim to or he's willingfully doing this,
- 1:39:07but
- 1:39:08it's clear that he's either fallen victim to the MAGA agenda or the.
- 1:39:11Money and stability is too nice for him to ever actually change his position
- 1:39:14and really appeal to the needs and desires of the American people.
- 1:39:17The left does not want to concede to MAGA.
- 1:39:19Every single time you give them an inch,
- 1:39:20they take a mile.
- 1:39:22So I guess this pattern of them operating in
- 1:39:24bad faith has made it so our elected officials,
- 1:39:26a lot of people on social media,
- 1:39:27etc.
- 1:39:28are very hesitant
- 1:39:29to give them ground
- 1:39:31because who knows what they're going to do with it.
- 1:39:32But if these guys would just tone it.
- 1:39:34Down a little bit,
- 1:39:35they have no idea what conservatives think.
- 1:39:37They have no idea how generous and kind and decent most
- 1:39:41conservatives are and that they want the same things.
- 1:39:43At the end of Trump's second term,
- 1:39:46there may be a desire for something a little more normal,
- 1:39:49and I say that as a Trump supporter,
- 1:39:51right?
- 1:39:51Like
- 1:39:52I think he was,
- 1:39:53he was necessary.
- 1:39:54We needed him to break something that we all could kind of see.
- 1:39:57And I think there could be a moment after this when things
- 1:40:01start feeling a little more the way we thought politics were.
- 1:40:05Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:40:07your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:40:10And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:40:12subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.