Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️106 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 5th Oct.Water reverse osmosis Day1 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Today at the Coronalt public inquiry, we were back into water habitats, river crossings, peat, power lines, and cumulative effects. However, again and again, I noticed as the day went on that some fairly important parts of this proposal do not necessarily have to be completely worked out now. Did
- 1:17you know, according to the various consultants of the applicants' team; these not so inconsequential details can be designed and verified later, maybe even decided on site, monitored during operation, adjusted if necessary, or even dealt with through some future management plan. And perhaps, if
- 1:37you are talking about a standard development, there may be some leeway that things can reasonably be left until later, but as we all know, this is not an ordinary development. We're talking about a gold mine in The Sperrins because some of our most sensitive rivers and protective habitats, whose
- 1:56primary production is toxic waste, will have to be managed long after the gold has gone, and long after people making these promises have gone as well. The tone for the morning was probably set by Sean Tracy, who returned to the proposed reversed osmosis plant, called the RO plant. The RO plant is
- 2:17basically the mine's last major water filter before treated mine water is released into the environment, and it uses enormous pressure to force contaminated water through very fine membranes, separating cleaner water from concentrated waste streams. It is one of the last barriers between the mine
- 2:36water and the river, and Sean didn't tiptoe around any of this. He went straight into the design and particularly the specifications of the high-pressure concentrate pump, and his assessment was scathing. He described the design as amateurish and said there is no such thing as a fail-safe
- 2:54system. Sean's point was that if something goes wrong with a membrane, a seal, an end cap, or another critical component, the consequences could be disastrous and maybe even life-threatening for plant employees. He called it a ticking time bomb and said that one rupture could mean goodbye, pollen row burn, the
- 3:16SAC, and all the ecosystems associated with it. Sean went on to talk about the monitoring system. Conductivity probes can tell you something about the overall composition of the water, but Sean's argument was that they cannot identify every individual contaminant in real time. So an individual substance
- 3:37could potentially be elevated without the system providing the sort of instant warning that people might imagine when they hear the words continuous monitoring. The applicants' team, of course, took a very different view. We were treated to a marketing pitch for Ouro Technology from yet another
- 3:54consultant. As an aside, I'd dearly love to know how many consultants are on the applicants' team, as they seem to reproduce somewhere between inquiry sessions, every time you think you've met the full crew, another one appears from behind the paperwork. Anyways, getting back to the marketing pitch,
- 4:13reverse osmosis is established technology, and it seems their consultant has decades of experience with these plants, our ro is considered best available technique for this type of mine water treatment, and the system would have two treatment trains provided, providing redundancy. We were
- 4:33also told that the plant would be commissioned and performance tested on site, that the regulator would have to be satisfied before discharge was allowed, and that detailed design matters could be dealt with through that verification process. Now, given what we have heard over the past week about
- 4:52NIEA not having some of their most basic water parameters for receiving waters, you will forgive me if the words. The regulator will have to be satisfied. Do not quite provide the warm blanket of reassurance, though, or perhaps intended to. It is, after all, considerably easier to be satisfied when
- 5:12there are certain things you simply don't know.
- 5:16And that was where today's wider theme began to emerge for me, that mostly everything we talked about was consigned to be tested, verified, signed off later by regulators we do not trust, and a long way out of the sight of a public inquiry. Dr. Stephen Emerman then took that argument even further when he
- 5:37reminded us once again about the length of the operational life of the mine, and then that closure lasts in perpetuity. The present closure plan envisages continuing with reverse osmosis into the closure period, until the water can eventually be discharged untreated, or managed through some form of passive
- 6:00treatment, and the existing ponds, which are really reservoirs, we were told have the potential to become part of that passive treatment system. So that sounds all good. However, Steve's difficulty was with the word potential. Passive water treatment is not a case of leaving a few reservoirs behind
- 6:20after mining; it requires detailed design, testing, maintenance, and adjustment, and he could not see any detailed plans setting out how that was actually going to work. He asked, "What happens if 15 years into closure the water still requires active treatment? That closure plan is still
- 6:39conceptual, which Stephen said was unusual for a project that had progress this far beyond the feasibility study. I suppose we are going to have to accept that conceptual is yet another word for a plan that hasn't had the inconvenience of being planned yet. His criticism of the approach to reverse osmosis was
- 6:58equally straightforward, saying that Oro is commonly used, but it does not automatically demonstrate that it is suitable for every water chemistry, or indeed for every required discharge concentration. Depending on what has to be removed, other filtration stages may be required, and high levels
- 7:20of suspended solids can themselves cause problems for RO membranes. His description of the approach was essentially: we will use reverse osmosis and work out the required details later. And once that had been said, I started hearing many similar versions of that phrase throughout the remainder of the
- 7:40day. We moved into the river crossings and the exchanges with NAEA, where the commissioner was endeavouring to establish exactly what the final arrangements might be. At some of the river crossings, more than one construction method remains on the table, with the final choice apparently being
- 7:58made on site. I think this was referred to as a palette of options, which had me briefly daydreaming about someone standing on the river bank with a deluxe colour chart, directional drilling in soft sage, culvert replacement in natural hessian, and perhaps a daring splash of open channel
- 8:18cut for the features wall. The only slight difficulty is that we are not decorating the downstairs toilet. These are quite different engineering interventions involving protected water courses, potentially bringing damming, concrete, and heavy machinery into or alongside the river, and
- 8:37it would be useful to know which particular method they have chosen before they are standing on the river bank, ready to apply it. None the less, the commissioner kept pressing onwards. Whether the various options could have materially different effects and whether the alternatives had actually
- 8:54been assessed, the reassurance eventually was that the effects had been assessed and could be appropriately mitigated. Then Pete entered the discussion, and we heard another variation on the same approach. NIEA acknowledged that de-watering always remains a risk, and that what happens in theory and what
- 9:16happens in practice are not necessarily identical, which is why monitoring and active management become important? There was a particularly telling moment when the commissioner pointed out that by the time monitoring shows that something has gone wrong, the beat may already have been removed. The
- 9:35response was that vegetation, water levels, and subsidence can be monitored, and if problems emerge, habitat management and construction environmental management plans should contain measures capable of rectifying them. So, by this stage, we had detailed design to come later, verification later, some
- 9:55construction decisions to be made on site, monitoring during the work. And corrective measures if problems subsequently emerge. In ordinary language, I would call it suck it and see, and I begin to think we could almost have a separate column in the inquiry transcript headed things to be sorted out
- 10:15later. That is, if we had the luxury of an official inquiry transcript. So here's a list of things to do. The applicant has things to finalise later.
- 10:27NIEA has things to monitor and manage later. NIE has matters which appear to depend upon assessments or decisions further down the road. Meanwhile, the inquiry taking place now today is supposed to establish whether this development can proceed. There was another new important strand today, which could easily
- 10:49have disappeared among all the technical evidence, and that was the discussion around ordinary rural development. We have heard repeatedly about the existing pressures on these rivers, including septic tanks and one-off rural housing. Official assessments of the Onkalu catchment already recognise new
- 11:08housing as something that can add pressure to the river, particularly rural houses using individual septic tanks. In plain English, every new house can add a little more wastewater nutrients to the catchment, so when planners look at the health of the river, they have to consider the cumulative effect
- 11:26of future residential development, particularly because of the number of individual houses and their proximity to the river. That brings us into the cumulative assessment and environmental capacity of this catchment. The point made today was a very practical one. If there is only
- 11:44so much environmental headroom available within these river systems, decisions made about the mine do not exist in isolation from decisions about the future of the people who actually live here. Local development plans are supposed to provide for communities, including rural dwellings. So
- 12:04there's a real planning issue when the environmental capacity of the catchment is being discussed in the same breath as a major industrial development, with discharges continuing over decades. A young family wanting to build a house on family land may find itself being discussed as another septic tank and
- 12:22another cumulative pressure on the catchment, while an industrial gold mine is arguing that its own contribution can be accommodated because the predicted change is not significant, it comes down to this: you can choose to have a mine, or you can choose local housing development for your
- 12:38young people, but you cannot have both, and that brings me to the expression which had a very good outing today: not significant, or one of its many close relatives. Small changes are not significant. The risk is not significant. There are no residual significant environmental effects. There is
- 13:02no significant potential cumulative effect. My notes contain the word "significant" more than 26 times today, although not every one of those occasions came from the applicant or was used in exactly the same context. But it has certainly become one of the recurring expressions in this
- 13:20inquiry, quite a lot it seems can happen to a river without crossing the mysterious frontier into significance. There were moments during the day as well when mr. Beatty seemed particularly keen to keep matters moving, producing references and directing attention to the next piece of
- 13:38material with impressive efficiency. At one stage, when he was in again with yet another reference, I did begin to wonder whether he had been given custody of the time table for the afternoon. Perhaps he had somewhere to be, but behind the occasional entertainment of watching all this unfold,
- 13:55today's evidence again raises serious issues about the stage this project has actually reached because a public inquiry can only examine what is put in front of it. If important details are going to be designed after consent, if treatment systems are going to be adjusted after commissioning, if
- 14:18construction methods are going to be selected on site. If environmental problems are going to be picked up through monitoring and dealt with through management plans, and if long-term passive treatment of mine water remains conceptual, then a large amount of information is being placed
- 14:38beyond the reach at which this inquiry can examine the finished version, and that was today's reoccurring theme. Sean Tracy began the morning by challenging whether a critical piece of the water treatment system had actually been designed to do what has been claimed for. Steve Emermann took us forward into
- 14:58closure and showed. Showed just how much remains conceptual decades into the future. The river crossing discussion showed that some practical choices will be made when work is taking place. The peat discussion relied heavily on monitoring and intervention if problems develop. The cumulative effects
- 15:16evidence brought us back to the future housing development of communities already living within this catchment, and across much of it sat the familiar reassurance that the effects would not be significant.
- 15:28The difficulty with the suck it and see it approach is that it is a particularly unforgiving place to discover that something did not work quite as expected, because once you build the mine, you cannot unbuild it. The pollen row burn is already there, the unkilloo is already there, the protected habitats
- 15:46are already there, the peach is already there, and the communities who have lived in these valleys for generations are already there. They are what the plan has to work around now, not designed later after the mine is built, and I leave it there for the saving. See you all tomorrow. You've been
- 16:06listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation are available in the show notes.
- 16:26Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for
- 16:45listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.